APEC Project Completion ReportSECTION A: Project profile

Project number & title: CTI 04 2015A – Promoting SMEs’ Integration into Global Value Chains in IT/Electronics

Project time period: March 2015 to December 2015 Date submitted: 2015-12-18

Committee / WG / Fora: CTI

Project Overseer Name / Organization / Economy: Jin Kim, Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, Korea

SECTION B: Project report and reflection

1. Project description: In 3-4 sentences, please describe the project and its main objectives.

The project was designed to raise the understanding and awareness of Global Value Chain (GVCs) in IT/Electronics industry. Activities of the project include sectoral PPP Forum, GVC Workshop, and a progress report. By disseminating best practices and policy recommendations brought up from the activities, this project seeks to contribute to facilitate SMEs’ integration into GVC which can be directed to benefiting both SMEs and MNCs with a goal of supporting sustainable and inclusive economic growth and prosperity in the Asia-Pacific region.

2. Meeting objectives: Describe how the project met each of its proposed objectives. Please outline any challenges you may have encountered in delivering the activity.

This project is a direct response to the objective of SME development including access to regional and global market and the other is Activities outlined in the GVCs Blueprint. The main objectives of the meetings are:1) To support implementation of the GVCs Blueprint to increase the knowledge of GVCs among the participants and to create a network in which GVCs development can be actively formulated.

2) To facilitate SMEs’ integration into GVCs in major industries by building their capacity for sustainable and inclusive growth through forums and workshops specifically responding to needs of regional SMEs.

3) To develop recommendations and build support for the promotion of GVCs by providing and sharing related information through progress reports focusing on APEC's shared goal of promoting ‘balanced and inclusive growth’ of SMEs through GVC participation.

Specific objectives listed in the project proposal have been fully met by (1) collecting and sharing inputs as well as creating networks among the SMEs and MNCs for partnership through operation of four times of sectoral PPP Forum (May 2015, Korea), (2) holding GVC Workshop to better understand GVCs in IT/Electronics sector and build the capacity of the SMEs participating in GVC by (September 2015, Korea), and (3) sharing outcomes and results of the PPP Forum and GVC Workshop by developing a progress report.

3. Evaluation: Describe the process undertaken to evaluate the project upon completion. (e.g. evaluation through participant surveys, peer reviews of outputs, assessments against indicators, statistics demonstrating use of outputs etc.). Provide analysis of results of evaluations conducted and where possible include information on impacts on gender. Evaluation data needs to be included as an appendix.

To ensure comprehensive evaluation of the progress and achievement of the project, a participant survey has performed using a set of direct and indirect indicators as following.

4. Output indicators: Describe the main project outputs below. This may include workshops, tools, research papers, reports, recommendations, best practices, action plans.

The output includes PPP Forum, Workshop and Progress Report which will identify priority issues and appropriate policy recommendations to facilitate SMEs into GVCs. Detailed outputs are as described in the following table. The table shows quantitative outputs of the project have been delivered as planned in overall including the number of events, participants, attending economies, etc. .Indicators(Edit or Insert rows as needed)

# planned # actual Details or notes

# workshops / events 5 5 Four PPP Forum and one GVC workshop# participants (M/F) 163 163 See in Appendix 1

# economies attending 11+ 10 Korea, China, Chile, Indonesia, Mexico, Peru,Vietnam, Philippines, Chinese Taipei, Thailand

# speakers engaged 6 6 For GVC Workshop# other organizations engaged

3 3Non-APEC participating organizations including International Trade Center, OECD, and International Council for Small Business

# publications distributed 1 1 A progress report will be submitted in Jan 2016# recommendations agreed on n/a

Other: n/a

In the four PPP forum, four different sub-sectors within IT/Electronics industry GVC have been separately covered to present to enhance understanding of the global value chains and provide ideas for policy improvement. Moreover, by providing a clearer view of perspectives concerning global value chains as discussed in each PPP forum, the GVC workshop provided a better understanding of challenges and shortcomings in SMEs participation of GVCs. The workshop was open to a wider range of participants from both public and private sectors in APEC economies with the purpose of sharing issues and case studies raised by the PPP forum and perspectives of some key APEC economies. The workshop sought to raise greater awareness of participants on SMEs’ participation of GVCs.

The progress report brought together the results of the PPP forum as well as the workshop to identify the necessary steps and developments in penetrating the SMEs participation of GVCs. The report mainly aimed to benefit both the public and private sector. As for SMEs, the report will provide practical ways and strategies to overcome challenges they may face in participating in GVCs. In the progress report, a set of best practice cases were identified to examine broader and innovative ways of approaching GVCs but also those who are less familiar with GVCs will have a better understanding of various elements and issues related to the concept of SMEs’ integration into GVCs. To benefit the policy makers of APEC economies in practical decision making on GVC-related issues, the progress report also provided actionable recommendations and implications to modify or establish new approaches in SME and GVC-related policies.

5. Outcomes: Describe any specific medium-term changes to policy, processes or behaviour that can be attributed to result from this activity. Please include details on: What indicators were used to measure medium-term impact? (Example indicators: type/number of

policies/ regulations/processes changed, % of businesses conforming to new standards, change in sector’s commercial activity, # individual action plans developed, # agencies using resource or tools etc.)

Monitoring plans in place and proposed indicators to measure impacts, including any impacts on gender. Please summarise relevant information.

The activities implemented under this project can be attributed to bring potential medium-term impacts that can lead to practical changes such as improved government policy in APEC economies to facilitate SMEs’ participation in GVCs. This is partly enabled by the project’s contribution to enhance awareness and understanding of policy makers and businesses on global value chains in IT/Electronics industry. Overall, the project will change the way participants perceive GVCs and the way they implement and execute strategies and policies related to GVCs. The impact can be assessed by number of action plans that individually or collectively developed by any APEC economies in response to the policy recommendations or other information provided by the project.

Monitoring mechanism and indicators for measuring the medium-term impacts can be proposed and developed by further initiatives under the priority areas of APEC, mainly MSME globalization and modernization. The ongoing works to develop an APEC MSME Globalization Index or APEC TiVA Database are expected to provide effective ways for monitoring and measurement of the project’s midterm impacts.

6. Participants (compulsory for events): Must be gender-aggregated. May be included as appendix.

Economy(Insert rows as needed) # male # female Details

Korea 81 62 See appendix 1

China 2 2Vietnam 2Mexico 3Chile 2Indonesia 1Peru 1Thailand 1Philippines 1 1Chinese Taipei 1 1Other 2Total 97 66

Comments: What was the approach undertaken for participant nomination/selection and targeting? Please provide details. What follow-up actions are expected? How will participants/beneficiaries continue to be engaged and supported to progress this work?

Each economy was invited to nominate participants to discuss their own opinion. Experts and speakers were chosen by their work experiences or research background pertinent to the subject matter. General information including background of the project, draft agenda, and travel information about the workshop and PPP forum was distributed to help nomination of the participants. Gender representativeness was also considered for nomination.

7. Key findings: Describe 1-3 examples of key findings, challenges or success stories arising from the project (e.g. research or case studies results, policy recommendations, roadblocks to progress on an issue, impacts on gender).

The following examples are presented as a part of key findings and lessons learnt from the GVC workshop under the work plan of the project.

In the key note presentation titled “The Importance of SMEs’ Participation in the Global IT/Electronics Value Chain in APEC and Economies Worldwide”, it was noted about Korea that the economy has successfully globalized itself in export-led expansion. However, many evidence and analysis suggest there are still greater growth potential for the economy and SMEs when strategies to facilitate SMEs participation in global value chains by increasing foreign direct investment share. (Ki-Chan Kim, President, International Council for Small Business)

SMEs face a wide range of issues for their decision making in integration into global value chains. They are required to addressing domestic supply issues by sourcing them abroad, in developing economies, subcontracting low or medium-value work to global suppliers to focus on value addition, accessing new growth markets in developing economies and contributing to economic and social development in the economies. It is recommended for SMEs when optimize location to utilize World Bank Location Readiness Index: DIY Supplier Analysis which can assist SMEs’ decision making by providing detailed information such as cost, infrastructure, business and living environment, country risk, industry maturity.(Dr. Anders Aeroe, Director, Division of Market Development, International Trade Center)

A presentation titled “Strategic Positioning of SMEs in GVC - A Case of Chinese Market “ identified current status in Chinese SMEs’ global value chain participation and proposed strategic points for improving infrastructure by location factors of GVC to provide better foundation for GVC development, promoting intermediate and advanced technology industries’ creative activities by protecting intellectual property, necessary to form a union between manufacturing industry and MNCs to make optimized industrial clusters. (Zhan Xi, Guanzhou University, China)

Next steps: Describe any planned follow-up steps or projects, such as workshops, post-activity evaluations, or research to assess the impact of this activity. How will the indicators from Question 5 be tracked? How will this activity inform any future APEC activities?

The PO will ensure the sustainability of the project with a different set of follow-up activities such as continuation of holding the PPP Forum and utilization dissemination of the progress report. Keeping the PPP Forum will provide for valuable experiences and lessons to both the private sector and government sector helping them develop long-term policy solutions. The progress report, being an integrated output of the PPP Forum and GVC Workshop, will be made available for application in other industries and sectors as well. Specifically, the progress report will be developed further and incorporated into the final synthesizing report of the Phase 2 in 2016. The final comprehensive report will incorporate all the outputs from five GVC sectors such as automotives, textile, healthcare and agribusiness. Phase 2 will focus on how to effectively integrate progresses made in the five sectoral GVC work stream. While addressing key problems in each of the sector GVC, Phase 2 will also focus on cross-cutting issues policy recommendations with general applicability. In Phase 2, it will be important to bring different types of cases with diverse backgrounds that will benefit all the APEC economies including developing economies.

8. Feedback for the Secretariat: Do you have suggestions for more effective support by APEC fora or the Secretariat? Any assessment of consultants, experts or other stakeholders to share? The Secretariat examines feedback trends to identify ways to improve our systems.

The APEC Secretariat has been quite helpful and informative during the preparation and implementation of the project and they responded to questions and emails promptly. Their guidance on preparation of materials and templates were also useful.

SECTION C: Budget

Attach a detailed breakdown of the APEC- provided project budget, including: Planned costs: (using most recently approved budget figures) $95,500 Actual expenditures Variance notes: An explanation of any budget line under- or over-spent by 20% or more.

The total amount of APEC funding spent than originally planned. Rather, the amount of self-funding expenditure increased after rearranging of the overall budget planning. Some of the speakers planned to be provided with an honorarium from APEC funding source were willing to deliver their lecture/session for free. Cost-saving was also possible in travel expenditure due to participants from some of the travel-eligible economies. Some participants adjusted their airfare lower than the original budgeting.

SECTION D: Appendices

Please attach the following documentation to the report as required. Note that the participant contact list is a mandatory requirement for all Project Completion Reports.

Appendices Notes Participant contact list: contact info, gender, job titles (mandatory) Appendix 1 Experts / consultants list: contact info, job titles, roles, gender Appendix 1 Event Agenda Appendix 2 Reports, websites or resources created: links or soft copies To be submitted Jan 2016 Post activity survey or other evaluation data (raw and/or aggregated) Appendix 3

Other information or resourcesFOR APEC SECRETARIAT USE ONLY APEC comments: Were APEC project guidelines followed? Could the project have been managed more effectively or easily by the PO?

Appendix 1

Speakers and Participants Info ListProject No.

Name of Symposium

Date

Venue city & Economy

: CTI 04/15A

: Promoting SMEs’ Integration into Global Value Chains in IT/Electronics

: 2015-05-08(1st PPP Forum), 201506-02(2nd PPP Forum), 2015-07-03(3rd PPP Forum), 2015-08-20(4th PPP Forum), 2015-09-24(GVC Workshop)

: Seoul, Korea

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Discussant(Forum1) Yong-suk Lee M Korea AT&C Director 010-2925-2344

Discussant(Forum1) Jin-pyo Hong M Korea Hi-K Telecom Representative j28403025@hiktelecom.com

Discussant(Forum1) Sung-ryong Ahn M Korea HiTec Representative 010-6878-1379

031-371-9400

Discussant(Forum1) Woo-sung Lee M Korea STEPI Head, Global Policy Research Center 044-287-2121

010-9068-2803

Discussant(Forum1) Joonho Lee M Korea KOSBI Senior Researcher johlee@kosbi.re.kr

Discussant(Forum1) Hong-suk Kim M Korea INNOBIZ

Association

Head, Strategy Department byjung@kisdi.re.kr

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Discussant(Forum1) Hae-sik Jeong M Korea NIPA Chief, Technology of Information and

Telecommunictaion Center

042-612-8214

Discussant(Forum1) Ki-Chan Kim M Korea Catholic University of

Korea,

Professor kckim@catholic.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum1) Joonkoo Lee M Korea Hanyang University Professor joonklee@hanyang.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum1) Gye-soo Lee M Korea Convergence Policy

Research Center For

Future Internet

Head of the Department newkslee@daum.net

Discussant(Forum2) Kyeong-ho Lee M Korea East Mob Co-Founder lkh205@gmail.com,

lkh205@estmob.com

Discussant(Forum2) Ki-hong Jeong M Korea Wemade

Entertainment

Deputy Head, Strategy Department jkh9336@wemade.com

Discussant(Forum2) Hyong-joo Lee M Korea INICIS Strategy Department realist2hj@gmail.com,

realist@inicis.com

Discussant(Forum2) Hong-ryeol Kang M Korea KISDI Senior Researcher hongyol@kisdi.re.kr

Discussant(Forum2) Eun-hee Ji F Korea SPRI Senior Researcher ehj524@spri.kr

Discussant(Forum2) Kyeong Lee M Korea KISED Head, Global Startup&Enterpreneur Team

Discussant(Forum2) Bong-Kyu Lee M Korea Yonsei University Professor bglee@yonsei.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum2) Kwang-ho Park M Korea Hanyang University Professor oobepark@hanyang.ac.kr

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Discussant(Forum2) Joon-soo Yoon M Korea Hanyang University Professor ceo@mncpartner.co.kr

Discussant(Forum3) Sung-sik Hwang M Korea SKC Solmics Chief Researcher 010-9077-8154

Discussant(Forum3) Jung-sik Woo M Korea Wonik IPS Director 010-4860-6255

Discussant(Forum3) Jong-woo Lee M Korea Global Zeus Representative jonglee@globalzeus.com

Discussant(Forum3) Ki-hyeon Ahn M Korea KSIA Director khahn@ksia.or.kr

Discussant(Forum3) Sung-soo Han M Korea ETRI Director, Indutrial Strategy Team sshan@etri.re.kr

Discussant(Forum3) Yong-ho Song M Korea Hanyang University Professor yhsong@hanyang.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum3) Jong-il Kim M Korea Dongguk University Professor jongil@dongguk.edu

Discussant(Forum3) Hye-jung Hyon F Korea Kyung-HeeUniversity Professor hjhyun@khu.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum3) Dong-yoon Oh M Korea Dong-ah University Professor ohdy@dau.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum3) Bong-Goul Jeon M Korea University Of Seoul Professor

Discussant(Forum4) Yang-hee Park M Korea Samsung Electronics Section Chief, Home Appliances yhpark3@gmail.com

Discussant(Forum4) Jae-Kwan Jeong M Korea KEA Head, Electronics Industrial Policy Department ipr@gokea.org

Discussant(Forum4) Hyun-jeongKim F Korea KASHI Section Chief enjoy@kashi.or.kr

Discussant(Forum4) Kyeong-sook Lee F Korea KIET Researcher ekslee@kiet.re.kr

Discussant(Forum4) Myeong-ho Choi M Korea KT

Economics&Manage

ment Research

Institute

Researcher myoungho.choi@kt.com

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Discussant(Forum4) Beom-suk Ko M Korea Dongyang Mirae

University

Professor bsko58@dongyang.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum4) Yong-wook Jun M Korea Sejong University Vice-president junywk@sejong.ac.kr

Discussant(Forum4) Ju-kwon Kim M Korea Konkuk University Professor zkkim@konkuk.ac.kr

Speaker(Workshop) Nguyen Viet Khoi M Viet Nam Vietnam National

University

Professor khoivnu@gmail.com

Speaker(Workshop) Zhanxi F China Guangzhou

University of China

Professor Zhanxi@naver.com

Speaker(Workshop) Seunggun Cha M Korea ZEUS Deputy head of department sgcha@globalzeus.com

Speaker(Workshop) Anders Aeroe M Swiss International Trade

Center

Director aeroe@intracen.org

Expert(Workshop) Keijian Gu M China Renmin University of

China

Professor gukj@ruc.edu.cn

Expert(Workshop) Oscar F. Contreras M Mexico El Colegio de la

Frontera Norte in

Tijuana

Professor ocontre@colef.mx

Expert(Workshop) Norihko Yamano M OECD OECD Administrator norihko.yamano@oecd.org

Moderator(Workshop) Park TaeHo M Korea Seoul National

University

Professor thbark@snu.ac.kr

Moderator(Workshop) YoungHan Kim M Korea SungKyunKwan

University

Professor kimyh@skku.edu

Participant(Workshop) José Antonio Yanes

Azoños

M Mexico The General

Coordination

Adviser inadem.josey@inadem.gob.mx

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Of Planning,

Evaluation and

Following ,National

Institute of the

Entrepreneur

Participant(Workshop) Juan Godínez M Mexico Regional and

Sectorial

Development,

National Institute of

the Entrepreneur

Deputy Director juan.godinez@inadem.gob.mx

Participant(Workshop) Poltak Ambarita M Indonesia Logistic

Development

Cooperation,

Ministry of Trade of

Indonesia

Deputy Director poltak.ambarita@kemendag.go.id

Participant(Workshop) Indra Maulana Putra M Indonesia Logistic

Development

Cooperation,

Ministry of Trade of

Indonesia

Senior Staff indra.mp@gmail.com

Participant(Workshop) Diana Arana F Peru Technical Institute of

Production- ITP,

APEC Peru

Research specialist daranda@itp.gob.pe

Participant(Workshop) Thanakrit

Luangasnathip

M Thailand Ministry of

Commerce

Trade Officer(professional level) thanakrit@moc.go.th

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Ran Li F China Policy Research

Department, Ministry

of Commerce

Senior Staff Member liran@mofcom.gov.cn

Participant(Workshop) Songsong Zhu M China Policy Research

Department, Ministry

of Commerce

Senior Staff Member zhusongsong@mofcom.gov.cn

Participant(Workshop) Alfredo Azancot M Chile ProChile Department Head of Industries aazancot@prochile.gob.cl

Participant(Workshop) Raissa Faminial F Philippines Bureau of

International Trade

Relations,

Department of Trade

and Industry

Analyst raissafaminial@dti.gov.ph

Participant(Workshop) Anthony B. Rivera M Philippines Department of Trade

and Industry-export

marketing bereau

Director aaabr@yahoo.com

Participant(Workshop) Hyeon-kwon Kim M Korea KSA Senior Researcher, National Standards Coordinator

Bureau

prokhk@nate.com

Participant(Workshop) Seong-wook Lee M Korea Excion Representative yisuksy@excionglobal.com

Participant(Workshop) Joo-Hyeon Moon M Korea Global Zeus Section Chief, Innovation Team mjh@globalzeus.com

Participant(Workshop) Young-taek Choi M Korea KSA Senior Researcher, National Standards Coordinator

Bureau

yandy0928@ksa.or.kr

Participant(Workshop) Mi-ok Lee F Korea Samsung Electronics Assistant Manager miok9170.lee@samsung.co

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

m

Participant(Workshop) Yeon-Joo Choi F Korea Samsung Electronics Member of Staff younju.choi@samsung.com

Participant(Workshop) Mi-Hyang Kim F Korea Samsung Electronics Manufacturing Innovation Team 2 mh1457.kim@samsung.com

Participant(Workshop) Hyeon-jeong Jang F Korea SeongHwa Assistant Manager hjjang@seonghwa.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Eun-jeong Shin F Korea Samsung Corning

Precision Materials

Co

Assistant Manager, PTI Group ej143.shin@samsung.com

Participant(Workshop) Dong-young Kim M Korea KDI Researcher kimdy@kdi.re.kr

Participant(Workshop) Yang-paeng Kim M Korea KIET Researcher, Department of Focused Industries 010-8696-4354

Participant(Workshop) Miae Jo F Korea ServeOne Assistant Manager minelife@serveone.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Jong-young Yoon M Korea Hansol E&G Vice-president

hansoleng88@naver.com

Participant(Workshop) Chih-chien Lin F Chinese

Taipei

Taiwan Trade

Center, Seoul

Deputy Director cclin@taitra.org.tw

Participant(Workshop) Suil Park M Korea INNOBIZ

Association

Researcher vrtopia@naver.com

Participant(Workshop) Patricio Parraguez M Chile The Embassy of

Chile in Korea

pparraguez@prochile.gob.cl

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Herbert C.C. Lin M Chinese

Taipei

Taipei Mission in

Korea

First Secretary, Economic Division cclin@moea.gov.tw

Participant(Workshop) Yoon-hee Choi F Korea KEA Director, Convergence Planning Team ian@gokea.org

Participant(Workshop) Seri Lee F Korea CJ CheilJedang Assistant Manager, Technology Management

Innovation Team

sallian@cj.net

Participant(Workshop) Jeong-hoon Lee M Korea Soulbrain Assistant Manager lgh@sbi.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hyunah Seo F Korea CJ CheilJedang Section Chief hyunahseo@cj.net

Participant(Workshop) Kyunghee Yoo F Korea CJ CheilJedang Section Chief youkh@cj.net

Participant(Workshop) Hyeong-suk Song M Korea Union Corporation Director Hs.song@union21.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Jin-hee Lee F Korea LSIS Member of Staff hermosa@lscns.com

Participant(Workshop) Yeon-im Jeong F Korea BC Card Assistant Manager, C&C Center skyjyi3@hanmail.net

Participant(Workshop) Ji-sun Choi F Korea ADT Caps Assistant Manager jschoi1@caps.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Misoo Kim F Korea BC Card Director mskim@bcline.com

Participant(Workshop) Eunho Shin M Korea Canon Korea

Business

Manager, Development Strategy Team ehshin@canon-bs.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Im-jo Choi M Korea Canon Korea

Business

Director, Business Development Strategy Team ijchoi@canon-bs.co.kr

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Jin-hwa Lee F Korea Handok Assistant Manager JinHwa.lee@handok.com

Participant(Workshop) Suyeon Kim F Korea BMW Korea Management Team sooyoun.kim@bmw.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Inhee Song F Korea BC Card Deputy Director ihsong@bccard.com

Participant(Workshop) Sang-hyeon Jeon M Korea LS Mtron Director, Technology Management Team shjeon@lsmtron.com

Participant(Workshop) Jung-kyu Ahn M Korea LS Mtron Senior Researcher, Technology Management Team seifert@lsmtron.com

Participant(Workshop) Han-kwon Ryu M Korea LS Mtron Director, Technology Management Team hangwon.ryu@lsmtron.com

Participant(Workshop) Hoyoung Jeong M Korea LS Mtron Assistant Manager, Technology Management Team jhyoung@lsmtron.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) So-hyun Kim F Korea Hyundai Heavy

Electronics

Member of Staff, Marine Technology Planning

Team

sohyun@hhi.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hyeon-hwa Kim F Korea C&M Teleworks Head of the Department kh2425@hanmail.net

Participant(Workshop) Bomi Ahn F Korea C&M Teleworks Member of Staff spring5252@hanmail.net

Participant(Workshop) Suyeon Choi F Korea Lotte World

Aquarium

Member of Staff 119hd@lotte.net

Participant(Workshop) Sung-ah Im F Korea Menna Tech Korea Representative sungah.lim@mannatechkorea.com

Participant(Workshop) Seong-yeop Lee M Korea Seoul Milk Deputy Director, Research& Planning Team mammary@seoulmilk.co.kr

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Young-sik Ha M Korea Seoul Milk Director, Research& Planning Team ysha@seoulmilk.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Dong-yeop Lee M Korea Doosan Infracore Assistant Manager, Research&Planning Team dongyeop.lee@doosan.com

Participant(Workshop) Suyeon Jeon F Korea C&M Teleworks Assistant Manager junsy73@cnm.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hwa-sook Jeong F Korea C&M Teleworks Director gkdis114@cnm.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Kyeong-mi Ha F Korea Byucksan Head of the Department hkmi@bsco.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Sooyoung Choi F Korea CJ CGV Manager wings0048@hotmail.com

Participant(Workshop) Hye-kyeong Ko F Korea CJ CGV Assistant Manager koya@cj.net

Participant(Workshop) Hyeon-joo Jeong F Korea CJ CheilJedang Director, SCM Strategy Team hyunju_jung@cj.net

Participant(Workshop) Won-suk Lee M Korea A&D Engineering Senior Researcher, CMS Research Institute lws0922@adeng.com

Participant(Workshop) Myeong-soo Kim M Korea Hanhwa Techwin Senior Researcher, Development Planning firehigh.kim@hanwha.com

Participant(Workshop) Eui-yea Hwang F Korea Hanhwa Techwin Senior Researcher, Development Planning uiyee.hwang@hanwha.com

Participant(Workshop) Byeong-ki Nam M Korea Hansol Chemical Director, Electronics Material Team bknam@hansol.com

Participant(Workshop) Donghoon Kang M Korea KT&G Research

Institute

Head of the Research Institute 20100058@kgc.co.kr

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Jiyeon Yoo F Korea GS Caltex Assistant Manager 02-2005-6166

Participant(Workshop) Yoonhwa Lee F Korea GS Caltex Head, Efficient Energy Team yhl2821@gscaltex.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hanwoong Lee M Korea Hanhwa Techwin Senior Researcher, SS Business Development

Team

hanwung.yi@hanwha.com

Participant(Workshop) Jae-kyeong Lee M Korea Lee Jae-kyeong

Studio

Representative

Participant(Workshop) Jeonghan Kim M Korea Lee Jae-kyeong

Studio

Assistant Manager

Participant(Workshop) Soohee Shin F Korea Lee Jae-kyeong

Studio

Assistant Manager

Participant(Workshop) Jeonghee Lee F Korea Digital Science Representative, Planning Team

Participant(Workshop) Jeongsoo Kim M Korea Digital Science Head, R&D

Participant(Workshop) Bongkyu Kim M Korea Konai Research

Institute

Section Head bgkim@konai.com

Participant(Workshop) Woojin Oh M Korea Konai Research

Institute

Head of the Department wjoh@konai@com

Participant(Workshop) Youngjoo Kim M Korea Namyang

Construction

Assistant Manager narangna626@hanmail.net

Participant(Workshop) Mira Jin F Korea GS TeleService Member of Staff 010-2491-1190

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Younghee Kim F Korea GS TeleService Assistant Manager tmkyh@gshs.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Nak-jung Kwon M Korea Macrogen Researcher, Clinical Diagnostics Division asper76@macrogen.com

Participant(Workshop) Eunyoung Lee F Korea Nongshim

Engineering

Assistant Manager ley8812@yahoo.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Yoon-kyeong Kim F Korea Broadband CS Assistant Manager yoonykim@hanaro.com

Participant(Workshop) Soon-im Ji F Korea KTIS Assistant Manager jssn@ekois.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Mijin Cho F Korea LG Display Executive mijinjo@lgdisplay.com

Participant(Workshop) Sunmi Im F Korea LG Electronics Deputy Director, HA Management Team sunmi.lim@lge.com

Participant(Workshop) Kiho Yoon M Korea Canon Korea

Business Solution

Researcher, Techonolgy Research Institute khyun@canon-bs.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hong-kook Kim M Korea Canon Korea

Business Solution

Researcher, Techonolgy Research Institute hkkim7@canon-bs.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Minjung Seo F Korea Kumho Electronics Research Assistant, Technology Management

Team

031-379-4435

Participant(Workshop) Won-kyeong Yeom M Korea Kumho Tire Assistant Manager 02-6303-8112

Participant(Workshop) Jinha Choi F Korea Inzi Controls Senior Researcher, Research Planning Team truesummer@inzi.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Sunyong Ahn F Korea Korloy Director, R&D Institute sunyong@korloy.com

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Young-heum Kim M Korea Korloy Head, R&D Institute yhkim@korloy.com

Participant(Workshop) Heeyeoung Kang F Korea Semes Senior, Semiconductor Equipment Team nahy.kang@semes.com

Participant(Workshop) Jayoung Kim F Korea Gaia Global Assistant Manager 055-269-31143

Participant(Workshop) Jungmin Kim M Korea Eagon Assistant Manager, Quality Development Team nicekim@eagon.com

Participant(Workshop) Jiyoung Shin F Korea BIFIDO Assistant Manager, Quality Management Team bifido033@paran.com

Participant(Workshop) Young-ae Kim F Korea SajoHP Deputy Director, Research Institute young@hanmail.net

Participant(Workshop) Bong-chan Kim M Korea SajoHP Deputy Director, Research Institute a1600@sajo.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hye-sung Kwon M Korea Daesang Director, Innovative Planning Team suwae@daesang.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Eunju Bae F Korea LG Housys Assistant Manager, Innovation Promotion Team ejbae@lghausys.com

Participant(Workshop) Hana Kim F Korea OCI Assistant Manager 02-727-9295

Participant(Workshop) Miyeon Baek F Korea S&T Daewoo Assistant Manager 051-509-2114

Participant(Workshop) Seulki Kang F Korea SK E&S Member of Staff skkang@skens.com

Participant(Workshop) Younghee Lee F Korea Konai Head, Technology Research Institute leeyh@konai.co.kr

Classification Name Gender Economy Organization Designation Email/Phone

Participant(Workshop) Kiyeon Lee M Korea Konai Section Chief, Innovative Strategy Team kylee@konai.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Dooman Kim M Korea Ksys Representative dmkim@kau.ac.kr

Participant(Workshop) Mijung Shin F Korea SK Innovation Researcher Assistant, Battery Manufacturing

Department

m.shin@sk.com

Participant(Workshop) Jungdoo Kim M Korea Seo-young Advisor kormpt@naver.com

Participant(Workshop) Soomin Kim F Korea STX Chief, Management Team 02-316-9986

Participant(Workshop) Hee-cheol Kim M Korea Crucial Tec Director, R&D Group 1 hckim@crucialtec.com

Participant(Workshop) Suil Kim M Korea Crucial Tec Section Chief, R&D Planning

Participant(Workshop) Sunyoung Kim F Korea Kefico Assistant Manager, R&D sunyoung.kim@kefico.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Hye-kyeong Choi F Korea Samsung SDS Assistant Manager 070-7015-6417

Participant(Workshop) Ae-young Sung F Korea CNG HiTech Member of Staff sung@cnghitech.com

Participant(Workshop) Kyeong-kook Kim M Korea KETEP Senior, Technology Management Team enpower@ketep.re.kr

Participant(Workshop) Jaehan Jeon M Korea Hyundai Mobis Researcher, Intelligent Vehicle Research Team jhjeon1@mobis.co.kr

Participant(Workshop) Eunjeong Seo F Korea STS

Semiconductor&Tele

communication

Member of Staff ejseo@bokwang.com

Appendix 2

Time Event Speaker/DiscussantOpening session 09:00~09:30 Registration 　

09:30~09:40 Introduction/Overview of Workshop Jin-YoungOhVice-President, KMAC

09:40~09:50 Opening Taehee WooAssistant Secretary, Minisrty of Trade, Industry&Engergy

09:50~10:30 "The Importance on SMEs' Participation of Global IT/Electronics Values Chain in APEC Economies and Worldwide"

Ki-ChanKimPresident, ISCB

　 10:30~10:45 Coffee Break 　Session1:Necessity of SME Participation and Strategic Positioning of SMEs in GVC

10:45~11:30 "Facilitating SMEs' Participation in Emerging Market of APEC region"

Nguyen Viet KhoiVietnam National University

11:30~12:15 "Strategic Positioning of SMEs in GVCs─A Case of Chinese Market"

ZhanxiProfessor, Guangzhou University of China

12:15~12:55 "Do Small and Medium Enterprises Gain from Global Production Networks?"

Hae-Jung HyunAssociate Professor, KyungHee University

　 12:55~14:00 Luncheon 　Session2:Cooperation Strategies for Development of GVCs

14:00~14:45 "GVC Participation and Establishment of Global Cluster"

Anders AeroeDirector, International Trade Center

14:45~15:25 "M&A Strategy as A New Way of GVC Participation"

Seunggun ChaTeam Leader, Global Zeus

　 15:25~16:00 Break 　Discussion session

16:00~16:05 Introduction of Topics and Panels Moderator: YoungHan KimProfessor, SungKyunKwan University

16:05~16:40 Discussion A"Challenges and Strategy in SMEs Participation of Global Value Chain─Best Practices for Participation In Global Value Chain"

Panel 1: Keijian GuProfessor, Renmin University of ChinaPanel 2: Oscar F. ContrerasResearch Professor, Departamento de Estudios Sociales El Colegiode la Frontera Norte Tijuana

Panel 3: JoonKu LeeProfessor, Hanyang University

Panel4:Lee JoonhoDirector, KOSBI

16:40~17:00 Q&A/ Discussion with Audiences 　17:00~17:10 Wrap-up 　16:00~16:05 Introduction of Topics and Panels Moderator: Tae-Ho Bark

Professor, Seoul National University

16:05~16:40 DiscussionB:"Creating a New Platform and the Future of Global Value Chain"

Panel 1: SongSong ZhuSenior Staff Member, Ministry of CommercePanel 2: Jae-Kwan JungDirector, KEA

Panel 3: Seunggun ChaTeam Leader, Global ZeusPanel 4: Norihiko YamanoAdministrator, OECD

16:40~17:00 Q&A/ Discussion with Audiences 　17:00~17:10 Wrap-up