appendix c: letter from mnrf to mr. eade dated april 14 ...appendix c: letter from mnrf to mr. eade...

50
List of Appendices Appendix A: Excerpts of comments Appendix B: Email from Watay Power to Wildlands League dated February 27, 2018 Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated July 7, 2016 Appendix E: MNRF letter to MECP dated July 19, 2018

Upload: others

Post on 08-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

List of Appendices

Appendix A: Excerpts of comments

Appendix B: Email from Watay Power to Wildlands League dated February 27, 2018

Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016

Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated July 7, 2016

Appendix E: MNRF letter to MECP dated July 19, 2018

Page 2: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

APPENDIX A 

Page 3: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

Excerpts from the Ministry Review of the New Transmission Line to Pickle Lake Environmental

Assessment (August 2018)

Comment ID Comments

Commenter: Mishkeegogamang First Nation Source: Wataynikaneyap Power Environmental Assessment Report for the Phase 1 New Transmission Line to Pickle Lake Project: Indigenous Community or Group Comments (August 2018), Table 4

MISH-05 By opening up a separate geographic area, it would absolutely result in excessive hunting and poaching by non-community members. This is an issue because men, women, children and elders rely on hunting to put food on the table. If these areas are now opened up for anyone to hunt, it would reduce the ability of the community to hunt and put nutritional food on the table. Also it would be impossible to police that vast area by the OPP and/or MNR conservation officers

MISH-07 Another major concern identified by our membership if Watay’s preferred route proceeds, especially because of the need for over 80km of new access roads/trails as discussed above, would be the troubling if not decimating impacts on our Caribou. You need to know that what the Watay EA Consultants have concluded regarding Caribou is not accurate. It is the view of our Elders and those who continue to live off the land, that a transmission line and parallel access road would entirely upset the balance of nature within that area, including within the Far North area. That is where there is significant Caribou habitat…Although it is accurate to say that there are very few of our members who presently hunt Caribou, regardless, the Caribou are there for a significant purpose, both to provide the balance in nature and to perpetuate its spiritual importance to our people. We therefore fully support the independent findings of the study by the Wildlands League, which convincingly concludes the Caribou would be decimated if there was a new access corridor constructed from Dinorwic to Pickle Lake. It would appear that Watay’s EA consultants have determined this study has no significance. We respectfully disagree.

Commenter: Ojibway Nation of Saugeen Source: Wataynikaneyap Power Environmental Assessment Report for the Phase 1 New Transmission Line to Pickle Lake Project: Indigenous Community or Group Comments (August 2018), Table 6

SAUG-06 …In contrast, an access road from Dinorwic to Pickle Lake would provide newaccess to previously inaccessible lakes, rivers and habitat, which would attract countless poachers, tourists and others who want to access our traditional lands for their own interests. We can’t understand why serious consideration would be given to a new corridor of approximately 340 kilometers, which would obviously increase disturbance, when there is already a corridor in existence, and where as a result, even a new access road adjacent to Highway 599 would cause minimal disturbance.

SAUG-08 We also remain extremely disturbed that Watay EA consultants have not taken seriously the adverse impacts to our Caribou that roam through our territory along the proposed Dinorwic alignment. It is very unusual that Caribou are found along Highway 599, but it is common knowledge amongst our people that the Caribou’s habitat is situated in the precise location where Watay’s proposed transmission line and access road are to be located.

Page 4: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

Caribou are a Species at Risk and our Caribou continue to have enormous spiritual significance to our people and to our ecosystem. It would be tragic to proceed with the Dinorwic routing knowing full well there has been the recent study by the Wildlands League that cautions against such an initiative.

Commenter: Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry Source: Environmental Assessment Report for the Phase 1 New Transmission Line to Pickle Lake Project Government Review Team (GRT) Comments on the Final EA Report August 2018), Table 11

MNRF-COV-11 Consultation The EA does not demonstrate that there has been adequate Aboriginal consultation to support MNRF permitting and authorizations as it does not fully address the details of the project components. It is possible that Aboriginal values and rights could be impacted by the project components that are not fully discussed within the EA…It is unclear whether the concerns identified and brought forward by Mishkeegogamang have been considered, addressed or responded to within the EA. Furthermore, the EA needs to better reflect consultation and coordination with other land users. More information is needed to demonstrate how impacts to and feedback from the forest industry, aggregate operators and other stakeholders are considered. Additional information is needed with regard to how activities will be coordinated with forest industry to minimize project impacts.

MNRF comment 49551

Nowhere in the EA and its conclusions is it apparent to the reader what the real implications of the proposed transmission corridors will be for caribou. Focusing the impacts assessment on the right of way (ROW) and then teased apart into habitat category type, seasonality, ranges, collars etc. confuses the reader and diverts attention away from documenting the sum impact of the project on woodland caribou.

MNRF-COV-01 Data, Analysis and Conclusions In MNRF’s opinion the Final EA does not contain sufficient information to confirm that MNRF’s specific jurisdictional mandate, legislative requirements or interests have been adequately identified. The information in the Final EA does not address areas of MNRF mandate at the appropriate level of detail. The EA remains too high level and found to contain discrepancies, thus impacting conclusions.

49440 …Woodland caribou are already demonstrating avoidance of Hwy 599. It is moreacceptable to construct a new permanent linear disturbance that parallels an existing permanent linear disturbance (Hwy 599) that is already acting as a barrier from an ecological integrity perspective. The risk to woodland caribou is low because Hwy 599 is already acting as a barrier. The construction of a new permanent linear disturbance adjacent to a permanent linear disturbance that is not acting as barrier is potentially a high risk for woodland caribou. This may cause or create a barrier to woodland caribou that did not exist previously and will impact ecological integrity.

49434 …OMNRF, Obishikokaang Resources Corporation and Resolute Forest productsmet with representatives from Wataynikaneyap in October 2017 at the request

Page 5: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

of MNRF due to the suggested deficiencies in the Sustainable Forest License Holder consultations. Obishikokaang Resources Corporation and Resolute Forest Products requested information about the caribou disturbance (buffered effect) within each range and Forest Management Unit because this has an impact on wood supply levels. MNRF…requested this information as well. The final EA does not contain this information for the proposed routes.

Page 6: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

APPENDIX B 

Page 7: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 8: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

APPENDIX C 

Page 9: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 10: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 11: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 12: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 13: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 14: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 15: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 16: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 17: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 18: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 19: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 20: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 21: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 22: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 23: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 24: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 25: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 26: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 27: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 28: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 29: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 30: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

APPENDIX D 

Page 31: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� �������������� � �� ���������������� ���������� �� ��!�"���� �#�$��%�� ���& �'������(��)�*��+����, ��+�� ������-�� ���(���$��$�� ��� ���� ��.��������������+���� ��� ����$$����&�)����& �/���(��0�� (�$�1�. �� !1!�"/���(��0�� (�$#�1&�� ���* .�2������������ �� ����1��0� � �0 �1��3 ���"�& �1��3 ��#�)���� %� .!��2& �$��$�� ��� ���� ����� ��� ����$$����&�����+� ���& ��� ���)���������)����)�������������)����& �.��������������+� )) ������� ��� ��!��4��� �$��� �����& �$��$������$$����&�$��%�� ���(����� �������$�����5�����6���& �'*,-�$��%�� ���& ���� ���� �� ��7+����� !�2&���� ������+���+���� ��&�.�/���(��0�� (�$�.���������$���� �'*,-�7+����� �����& �������+� )) ������� ��� ��!�89:� ��;<������=�>��??�??���=��@@���AB�/���(��0�� (�$�����$$�(��7���������� ������ ��� ����$$����&�)������� ����7��������� ���������+���7�.��������������+!�2& ��$$����&�+� ����� ��� ��� ��$����������� ��+� � �����������������$� �������$������������ ���!���� ��� ��� ��$�������� �������+� ���)������� ������&����� �+� �������� ����& ���7��)����� ��)�� ���+��� )) ��������&������� �������������� $� � ����& �0 (�$��$ ��� ���)��& ����� ������&����&�+���� �$��� �� �!�-���.�����) ����� ������& ���� ��� ��� ��$��������� �)C�+�������7����� ����7�����(� )) ���% �$�$+�������!��' ��+� � ��������������� $� � ���$��$ ��� ���)��& � �%����� ����&�������� �+� ������&����� ��D ��&��7 ����������� ����E����� ��� ��� ��$������������ ����7)+��.�(!�' ��+� � ����������������(�� ��&����� ��D ���&��+7&�F+��������% ����F+�������% �� ������ $ ����7�����& ��%������ ���)��������!�' ��+� � ��������������)���.�����) �����+� �&��������%���������(�"F+�����(�����F+����(#��&��������������+�����"�����7 � ����������� ���%��(#�������+�%�%�������� $���+�����!�2& �7�����)��& �G�����+�G��� �%������1����)������������������� �.��&�/���(��0�� (�$E��� )���������)��& ���� ��� ��� ��$�����)���������+�����&�.���7��)����� ��)���$�����.����� �� � ���� �!�H�������(���& ��&� �$�����$� ��)����& �,��7 �'���7 � ���1����(�� )� ���/���(��0�� (�$E��� ��+� � �������������!�������& ���)�����������+�� ���� ���)� ���(��& �'*,-�.����� �+� ������& � �%����� �������� ��� ���"I�#����� ����� ��& � J�����7����������������$��%�� ����� J��)���$� ������7��& ����� � ����������+�+����% � )) ����)�����& �1��3 �������$� %��+��� J�����7������ �������(�)�� � ��� �� % ��$� ���!���0 (����+�$��������/���(��0�� (�$E��������(���������$���� ��& � ���)�����������+�� ������&����& (�.����� ��%������ �)���+� ����� ����6�����&��$���������+����������)��& �I�!�-���������� ��(���������& � ����7��������$�� �����)��& �I���/���(��0�� (�$�.���������$���� �� %��+�� ���������+����& �� F+ �� ��K'*,-����� ���L������������� ��K'*,-�����������L�"$!���C����'*,-�� �� ����� ���$�����5�����6#�+�� ���& �� � %����� ��+� � �������������!�2& �K'*,-����� ���L�)���������+�&�����������������+�"�$ �� ��$��� �����#��� �������� ���.��&�/���(��0�� (�$E���� ���)� ��� ��+� � ���������������)�&��������%���������(��&�������

� =���������� �'���&�����, 7������1���� ��"'*,-#� ��=��M+�(�N�����6�AA�H� $& ��G��0�����M+������ ���������M�&��, ���"/���(��0�� (�$�1�. �� !1!#�O������� ��I�� � @��P�A=��Q9���R�N���C��� C��5C2'CSR�@B�?��8���T�=���?�<??<���><���=��@<AU>��>�U��@��P�A=�V���?@��?��=�����O���A����������@@���AB�O���T���>����A��<W���OO�A=?��??�??���=���

��� X�M+�(�N�����6�1��3 ���*�!���R�N���C��� C��5C2'CSR�2�X��������� �'���&�����, 7������1���� ��"'*,-#� �YZ� ��

Page 32: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� ������������� ���� ��������������������������� ���������������������������������� ���������� ������� ������� �������� ���� !"�#���������������� ����� ��������������� ���������� �$������$�� ������ ���%��������������#&�������'� !"���� ����(����� �� ��$��� �����)������� �����#� ���*�� ��)����������$���)�$�� ���������������� ��������� ������������ ����+�)�� ��$������$�� ������ ������������ �������� ��������$�� ����������������� �� ��������� �� �������������� � ���������� ����������� ��������� �� �������������������������� ��������� ����������� �����#� ��� � ����,�� ���������������������������������������� ������ �������$���������������)������������$�� ������� ����� �� ���������� ��������)����� ���������$�� ������� �������������%����������-��� �����)���������)������������ ���������� ���&��!� ����� �����'� !"���� ����(����� �� �� ����� ����������,�� ����� �������� �������� ������� ���������$�� ������� ������������#��)� �����������������$$���������#�.� ����+�������#������������� �� ���� !"/������� ������ �� ���������������� ��������$�� ������

0� �1�2����3��4567�8��,�� � ���69:9396�-�;<=-59>-��-?:���1�;�������������������!�)������8�������%� !"&� 4@A� ��

Page 33: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� � ���������������� ����������� ����������������������������������� ��������� ����������������������� ��������� ���������������� ������!"#$%&#&%'(�#))())*(+&�,()-.%/%+0�123�#+�#-&%'%&3�%)�4.545)(,�&5�5--".�%+�#�0%'(+�.#+0(�12(.(�&2(�-5+,%&%5+�*#3�+5&�/(�)"66%-%(+&�&5�)")&#%+�-#.%/5"�5.�*#3�/(�"+-(.&#%+�&5�)")&#%+�-#.%/5"7� 8�95&�,%.(-&$3�$%+:(,�&5�4.545)(,�#44.5#-2�8�;2%)�.(<"%.(*(+&�%)�5"&)%,(�&2(�)-54(�56�&2(�-#.%/5"�#))())*(+&�)(-&%5+7�;2(�0"%,#+-(�#44(#.)�&5�/(�$%+:(,�&5�&2(�.#&%5+#$(�65.�&2(�%,(+&%6%-#&%5+�56�&2(�#$&(.+#&(�-5..%,5.)7�;2(�%,(+&%6%-#&%5+�56�&2(�-5..%,5.)�1#)�,%)-"))(,�%+�=(-&%5+�>7?7?7@�A,(+&%6%-#&%5+�56�;.#+)*%))%5+�B5..%,5.�C4&%5+)�#+,�D$&(.+#&%'()�%+�&2(�D*(+,(,�;(.*)�56�E(6(.(+-(F�12%-2�1#)�#44.5'(,�/3�&2(�GCHBB7��8�D)�)&#&(,�%+�=(-&%5+�I7J�D))())*(+&�#+,�H'#$"#&%5+�56�&2(�D*(+,(,�;5EF�#�6%+#$�-5..%,5.�.5"&%+0�#+#$3)%)�1%$$�/(�-5*4$(&(,�&2#&�-5+)%,(.)�#$$�,%)-%4$%+()F�%+-$",%+0�155,$#+,�-#.%/5"7�8�;2%)�4.545)(,�%+,%-#&5.�1%$$�/(�+5&�%+-5.45.#&(,�%+&5�&2(�155,$#+,�-#.%/5"�#))())*(+&F�/"&�.#&%5+#$(�65.�&2(�K.5L(-&�1%$$�/(�.(%&(.#&(,�1%&2%+�&2(�HD7�8�95+(��

� � M���N������ �O��������������P�N�M�!"#+&%&#&%'(�#))())*(+&�,()-.%/%+0�-2#+0(�%+�5'(.#$$�-"*"$#&%'(�,%)&"./#+-(�#&�&2(�.#+0(�$('($�#)�#�.()"$&�56�&2(�#-&%'%&37��D))())*(+&�56�251�-2#+0(�%+�,%)&"./#+-(�-#")(,�/3�#-&%'%&3�*#3�45&(+&%#$$3�%*4#-&�-#.%/5"�454"$#&%5+�)%Q(�#+,�&.(+,�#&�&2(�.#+0(�$('($7� 8�R)(�B=;S,(.%'(,�)&#&%)&%-)�&5�.(45.&�-2#+0(�%+�5'(.#$$�-"*"$#&%'(�,%)&"./#+-(�#&�&2(�.#+0(�$('($��8�T%)-"))�&2(�%*4$%-#&%5+)�56�-2#+0(�%+�,%)&"./#+-(�$('($)�5+�&2(�454"$#&%5+�0.51&2�.#&(�")%+0�&2(�.($#&%5+)2%4�,('($54(,�/3�H+'%.5+*(+&�B#+#,#�U?J@@V�#+,�")(,�/3�G9EW�U?J@XV7���� �������Y�,%)&"./#+-(�)&#&%)&%-)�1%$$�/(�0(+(.#&(,�/3�&2(�B=;7�A6�B=;�%)�+5&�#'#%$#/$(F�Z#&#3+%:#+(3#4�1%$$�-#$-"$#&(�-2#+0(�%+�,%)&"./#+-(�)&#&%)&%-)�/#)(,�5+�HB�U?J@@V�*(&25,)�#+,�#'#%$#/$(�,%)&"./#+-(�%+'(+&5.3�,#&#7� 8�[#/%&#&�#'#%$#/%$%&3�U%7(7F�<"#+&%&3�#+,�<"#$%&3V���8�=".'%'#$�#+,�.(4.5,"-&%5+����M��������\�����]����������������� � ��� �O�����!"#+&%&#&%'(�#))())*(+&�,()-.%/%+0�&2(�#*5"+&�56�5'(.$#4�/(&1((+�&2(�4.545)#$�#+,�(%)&%+0�#+,�4$#++(,�,%)&"./#+-()7�D))())*(+&�56�251�-2#+0(�-#+�%*4#-&�454"$#&%5+�)%Q(�#+,�&.(+,7� 8�R)(�B=;�,(.%'(,�)&#&%)&%-)�&5�<"#+&%63�&2(�#*5"+&�U:*V�#+,�4.545.&%5+�U_V�56�K.5L(-&�&2#&�5'(.$#4)�1%&2�(%)&%+0�#+,�4$#++(,�,%)&"./#+-()7�8�B#$-"$#&(�$(+0&2�U:*V�#+,�,(+)%&3�U:*:*?V�56�(%)&%+0�,%)&"./#+-(�,(+)%&3�#+,�<"#+&%63�4(.-(+&�-2#+0(�%+�$%+(#.�6(#&".(�,(+)%&3�#)�#�.()"$&�56�&2(�4.5L(-&7���� �������Y�B=;�1%$$�/(�#'#%$#/$(7�A6�B=;�%)�+5&�#'#%$#/$(F�Z#&#3+%:#+(3#4�1%$$�")(�%+65.*#&%5+�5+�(%)&%+0�,%)&"./#+-(�U6.5*�a#+,�A+65.*#&%5+�C+&#.%5�#+,�%+65.*#&%5+V�#+,�4$#++(,�,%)&"./#+-()�6.5*�#'#%$#/$(�%+65.*#&%5+�&5�-#$-"$#&(�#*5"+&�U:*V�#+,�4.545.&%5+�U_V�56�K.5L(-&�&2#&�5'(.$#4)�1%&2�(%)&%+0�#+,�4$#++(,�,%)&"./#+-()7�8�[#/%&#&�#'#%$#/%$%&3�U%7(7F�<"#+&%&3�#+,�<"#$%&3V��8�[#/%&#&�,%)&.%/"&%5+�U%7(7F�#..#+0(*(+&�#+,�-5++(-&%'%&3V��8�=".'%'#$�#+,�.(4.5,"-&%5+�

T#&(b�c"$3�dF�?J@>�K.5L(-&�957�@efede@�S�gDaSJeXS;GShf�;5b�g%$$%#++(�G#.)2#$$F�E(0%5+#$�K$#++(.�UG9EWV� fI� ��

Page 34: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� � ���������������� ����������� ����������������������������������� ��������� ����������������������� ��������� �������!�"�������� ����� �������������#$%&'�()*%+)+�$+)+%$+%,$�-./&0�%&�+(1�234�516.5+$7�+(1�65.6.&1&+�$(./80�01$,5%*1�(.9�+(1%5�65.6.$10�),+%:%+;�,()&'1$�+(1�)<./&+�)&0�)55)&'1<1&+�.-�$/%+)*81�9%&+15�)&0�51-/'1�()*%+)+�)+�+(1�5)&'1�81:18=�>$$1$$<1&+�.-�(.9�,()&'1�,)&�%<6),+�6.6/8)+%.&�$%?1�)&0�+51&0=� @�#$1�234A015%:10�$+)+%$+%,$�+.�516.5+B�C�)51)�.-�9%&+15�)&0�51-/'1�()*%+)+�):)%8)*81�%&�+(1�5)&'1�)&0�(.9�+(.$1�)<./&+$�,.<6)51�+.�+(1�3DEF�C�)51)�.-�9%&+15�)&0�51-/'1�()*%+)+�)--1,+10�%&�+(1�5)&'1�)&0�(.9�51<)%&%&'�)<./&+$�,.<6)51�+.�+(1�3DEF�@�#$1�234A015%:10�<)6$�+.�0%$,/$$B�C�,()&'1�%&�)55)&'1<1&+�.-�9%&+15�)&0�51-/'1�()*%+)+�)$�)�51$/8+�.-�+(1�65.G1,+=���� �������H�234�9%88�*1�):)%8)*817�)&0�0%'%+)8�-%81$�.-�9%&+15�)&0�51-/'1�()*%+)+�9%88�*1�65.:%010=�I-�+(1�234�%$�&.+�):)%8)*817�J)+);&%K)&1;)6�9%88�)668;�+(1�,.&:1&+%.&)8�*.51)8�<.018�LM8K%1�1+�)8=�NOPQR�+.�%01&+%-;�9%&+15�)&0�51-/'1�()*%+)+�*)$10�.&�SDI�)&0�T&+)5%.�U)&0�2.:15�0)+)=�3DEF�$+)+%$+%,$�9%88�*1�1V+5),+10�-5.<�+(1�T&+)5%.�U)&0$,)61�4..8=�@�W)*%+)+�):)%8)*%8%+;�L%=1=7�X/)&+%+;�)&0�X/)8%+;R��� ��@�W)*%+)+�0%$+5%*/+%.&�L%=1=7�)55)&'1<1&+�)&0�,.&&1,+%:%+;R�@�3/5:%:)8�)&0�5165.0/,+%.&����������YH�!�������������������Z��������� ��� �����������!�"����[�����������������[�\��]�Z������ �������� ��� �"��������������Y�!�"������� �����������!�"����[�����������������[�\��]�Z������ ������ � �_������Y�����������������Z�#$1�+(1�aWb�<)66%&'�)&0�%&-.5<)+%.&�):)%8)*81�+(5./'(�UIT�+.�01+15<%&1�+(1�&/<*15�.-�)&0�+.+)8�)<./&+�.-�(%'(�/$1�)51)$�9(%,(�9%88�.:158)6�9%+(�+(1�65.G1,+�)51)�L%=1=7�)<./&+�.-�+(%$�()*%+)+�+()+�9%88�*1�8.$+�$(./80�+(1�65.6.$)8�65.,110�%&�+()+�8.,)+%.&R=�2.<6)51�+(1�)<./&+�.-�(%'(�/$1�)51)$�%<6),+10�+.�+(1�+.+)8�)<./&+�):)%8)*81�%&�+(1�5)&'1=�b%$,/$$�%<6),+$�+.�,)5%*./�6.6/8)+%.&�$%?1�)&0�+51&0�)$�)�51$/8+�.-�,()&'1$=����>&)8;?1�+(1�&/<*15�.-�E/5$15;�>51)$7�J%&+15�#$15�>51)$�)&0�45):18�2.55%0.5$�9%+(%&�PO�K<�.-�+(1%5�65.6.$)87�)&0�01$,5%*1�+(1�)&+%,%6)+10�%<6),+$�+.�-/&,+%.&c/$1-/8&1$$�.-�+(1$1�-1)+/51$�)$�)�51$/8+�.-�+(1�65.G1,+=�

@�#$1�0%'%+)8�aWb�<)66%&'�-%81$�+.B�C�,)8,/8)+1�&/<*157�)51)7�)&0�65.6.5+%.&�.-�&/5$15;�()*%+)+7�9%&+15�/$1�()*%+)+7�)&0�+5):18�,.55%0.5$�0%51,+8;�)--1,+10�*;�+(1�d5.G1,+�C�%01&+%-;�(%'(�/$1�)51)$�9%+(%&�PO�K<�.-�+(1�d5.G1,+�)&0�0%$,/$$�6.+1&+%)8�,()&'1�+.�518)+%:1�X/)8%+;�.-�+(.$1�()*%+)+$�@�d5.0/,1�<)6$�.-�(%'(�/$1�)51)$�+.�X/)8%+)+%:18;�01$,5%*1�+(1�,()&'1�%&�)55)&'1<1&+�)&0�,.&&1,+%:%+;�.-�(%'(�/$1�)51)$=�@�b%$,/$$�+(1�-/&,+%.&�)&0�%<6.5+)&,1�.-�(%'(�/$1�)51)$�)&0�6.+1&+%)8�%<68%,)+%.&�.-�%<6),+$�+.�+(.$1�()*%+)+$���� �������H�0%'%+)8�-%81$�.-�+(1�aWb�<)66%&'�9%88�*1�):)%8)*81=�I-�aWb�<)66%&'�%$�&.+�):)%8)*817�%+�9%88�*1�65.0/,10�+(5./'(�)�<.018�01:18.610�*;�J)+);&%K)&1;)6�/$%&'�S.51$+�D1$./5,1�I&:1&+.5;�)&0�1V%$+%&'�6/*8%,8;�):)%8)*81�0)+)=���@�W)*%+)+�):)%8)*%8%+;�L%=1=7�X/)&+%+;�)&0�X/)8%+;R������@�W)*%+)+�0%$+5%*/+%.&�L%=1=7�)55)&'1<1&+�)&0�,.&&1,+%:%+;R��@�3/5:%:)8�)&0�5165.0/,+%.&�

b)+1B�e/8;�f7�NOPg�d5.G1,+�E.=�PhihfhP�A�a>UAOhQA4jAFi�4.B�a%88%)&&1�j)5$()887�D1'%.&)8�d8)&&15�LjEDSR� Qck� ��

Page 35: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� � ���������������� ����������� ����������������������������������� ��������� ����������������������� ��������� ����������������!�"�#����$�%������&��������������� �'()�*+,�-.//012�34�56.13078�39)�343.:�.-4613�47�;.3)24<8�=�9.>03.3?�@90A9�@0::�>)�B0<)A3:8�0-/.A3)BC�;4-/.<)�39)�.-4613�47�().(41.:�<.12)�.<).(�0-/.A3)B�34�39)�343.:�.-4613�.D.0:.>:)�01�39)�<.12)C�� E�'()�B0203.:�*+,�-.//012�70:)(�34F�G�A.:A6:.3)�.<).�.1B�/<4/4<3041�47�().(41.:�.77)A3)B�>8�39)�H<4I)A3�E�H<4B6A)�-./(�47�().(41.:�<.12)(�34�56.:03.30D):8�B)(A<0>)�39)�A9.12)�01�.<<.12)-)13�.1B�A411)A30D038�47�().(41.:�<.12)(C�E�,0(A6((�39)�761A3041�.1B�0-/4<3.1A)�47�().(41.:�<.12)(�.1B�/43)130.:�0-/:0A.3041�47�0-/.A3(�34�394()�9.>03.3(C���� �������$�B0203.:�70:)(�47�39)�*+,�-.//012�@0::�>)�.D.0:.>:)C�J7�*+,�-.//012�0(�143�.D.0:.>:)?�03�@0::�>)�/<4B6A)B�39<4629�.�-4B):�B)D):4/)B�>8�K.3.810L.1)8./�6(012�M4<)(3�N)(46<A)�J1D)134<8�.1B�)O0(3012�/6>:0A:8�.D.0:.>:)�B.3.C���E�+.>03.3�.D.0:.>0:038�P0C)C?�56.13038�.1B�56.:038Q��E�+.>03.3�B0(3<0>63041�P0C)C?�.<<.12)-)13�.1B�A411)A30D038Q��E�R6<D0D.:�.1B�<)/<4B6A3041�����������S�"�#������������������������������������������� �'()�*+,�-.//012�34�56.13078�39)�343.:�.-4613�47�;.3)24<8�T�9.>03.3?�@90A9�@0::�>)�B0<)A3:8�0-/.A3)B�>8�39)�/<4/4(.:C� E�'()�B0203.:�*+,�-.//012�70:)(�34F�G�A.:A6:.3)�.<).�.1B�/<4/4<3041�47�;.3)24<8�T�9.>03.3�.77)A3)B�>8�39)�H<4I)A3�E�H<4B6A)�-./(�47�;.3)24<8�T�9.>03.3�34�56.:03.30D):8�B)(A<0>)�39)�A9.12)�01�.<<.12)-)13�.1B�A411)A30D038�47�().(41.:�<.12)(C�E�,0(A6((�39)�761A3041�.1B�0-/4<3.1A)�47�;.3)24<8�T�9.>03.3�.1B�/43)130.:�0-/:0A.3041�47�0-/.A3(�34�394()�9.>03.3(C���� �������$�B0203.:�70:)(�47�39)�*+,�-.//012�@0::�>)�.D.0:.>:)C�J7�*+,�-.//012�0(�143�.D.0:.>:)?�03�@0::�>)�/<4B6A)B�39<4629�.�-4B):�B)D):4/)B�>8�K.3.810L.1)8./�6(012�M4<)(3�N)(46<A)�J1D)134<8�.1B�)O0(3012�/6>:0A:8�.D.0:.>:)�B.3.C���E�+.>03.3�.D.0:.>0:038�P0C)C?�56.13038�.1B�56.:038Q���E�+.>03.3�B0(3<0>63041�P0C)C?�.<<.12)-)13�.1B�A411)A30D038Q��E�R6<D0D.:�.1B�<)/<4B6A3041������ ����&������&���� �����������������������������U�U�V���� &�����&&������W��������� �� ����������� ����'(012�A.<0>46�4>()<D.3041�0174<-.3041�.1B�B)(A<0>012�.18�1)@�3<.1(/4<3.3041�A4<<0B4<(�P<4.B(?�3<.0:(Q�.((4A0.3)B�@039�39)�/<4I)A3�4<�.130A0/.3)B�01A<).()B�6()�47�)O0(3012�<4.B(X3<.0:(?�39)�/<4/41)13�(946:B�B)(A<0>)�.18�/43)130.:�01A<).()(�01�A.<0>46�-4<3.:038�B6)�34�D)90A6:.<�A4::0(041(�4<�01A<).()B�9613012�/<)((6<)�39.3�-.8�4AA6<�.(�.�<)(6:3�47�39)�/<4I)A3C� E�Y03)<.36<)�<)D0)@�.1B�(6--.<8�47�-0302.3041�74<�39)�H<4I)A3?�.1B�56.:03.30D)�B0(A6((041�47�/43)130.:�0-/.A3(�34�A.<0>46C� E�R6<D0D.:�.1B�<)/<4B6A3041��� �����������&���� ������������� ��&��������������� �������������� � �����&�� ��������������� ���� �������Z�&V��W�#����W����U���� ��������� ���������&�[�������� ��[� ���������U�U�#����Z����U�,)(A<0/3041�47�94@�39)�.A30D038�-.8�01A<).()�/43)130.:�/<)B.34<�.A30D038�>8�B0(A6((012�94@�39)�.A30D038�-.8�<)(6:3�01�A41D)<(041�47�9.>03.3�39.3�0(�-4<)�/<4B6A30D)�74<�/<)B.34<(�P>).<(�.1B�@4:D)(Q\�39)<)74<)�<)(6:3012�01�9029)<�/4/6:.3041�B)1(030)(�47�39)()�(/)A0)(C� E�Y03)<.36<)�<)D0)@�.1B�(6--.<8�47�-0302.3041�.1B�>)(3�-.1.2)-)13�/<.A30A)(�74<�39)�H<4I)A3?�.1B�56.:03.30D)�B0(A6((041�47�/43)130.:�0-/.A3(�34�A.<0>46C� E�R6<D0D.:�.1B�<)/<4B6A3041�

,.3)F�]6:8�?�=_a�H<4I)A3�b4C�cTcc�d�*eYd_cfdghdiT�g4F�*0::0.11)�h.<(9.::?�N)2041.:�H:.11)<�PhbNMQ� cXj� ��

Page 36: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� � ���������������� ����������� ����������������������������������� ��������� ����������������������� ��������� ��������� �������������� ������������� ��� �!�������"�"�#����$��� � $�%�!�������$��#&��������'()*+�,-.)/01�0/(2.3-4)0*�)*50.6-4)0*�-*7�,0*()72.)*+�4892(�05�(2*(0.8�7)(41./-*,2(�4:-4�6-8�/2�-((0,)-427�;)4:�4:2).�-,4)3)48�-*7�4:2�4)6)*+�05�4:2).�-,4)3)48<�4:2�9.090*2*4�(:01=7�>1-=)4-4)32=8�72(,.)/2�4:2�-*4),)9-427�)69-,4(�40�,-.)/01�712�40�(2*(0.8�7)(41./-*,2�?2@+@<�,:-*+2(�)*�9:8()0=0+8�-*7�/2:-3)01.�4:-4�-552,4�50.-+)*+�-*7�.29.071,4)0*A@� B�C)42.-41.2�.23)2;�-*7�(166-.8�05�6)4)+-4)0*�50.�4:2�D.0E2,4<�-*7�>1-=)4-4)32�7)(,1(()0*�05�9042*4)-=�)69-,4(�40�,-.)/01@� B�F1.3)3-=�-*7�.29.071,4)0*�������������G���������%� ������������������H#����I)(,1((�>1-*4)4-4)32=8�4:2�-601*4�05�-.2-�;)4:)*�60(-),�/=0,J?(A�4:-4�)(�/2)*+�4-J2*�19�/8�4:2�9.090(-=<�-*7�>1-=)4-4)32=8�72(,.)/2�)69-,4(�4:-4�.2603)*+�4:)(�-.2-�5.06�4:2�60(-),�/=0,J?(A�;)==�:-32�0*�4:2�IKLF�032.�4)62�-*7�0*�4:2�-/)=)48�05�4:2�50.2(4�092.-40.�40�6224�0/E2,4)32(<�)*7),-40.(�-*7�72().-/=2�-*7�4-.+24�=232=(�50.�9.03)()0*�05�,-.)/01�:-/)4-4�032.�4)62@� B�'(2�KFM�72.)327�(4-4)(4),(�40N�O�)72*4)58�*16/2.�-*7�-.2-�05�IKLF�90=8+0*(�4:-4�032.=-9�;)4:�4:2�D.0E2,4�O�7)(,1((�.2(1=4(�)*�.2=-4)0*�40�4:2�2552,4(�0*�4:2�-((2((62*4�2*790)*4�50.�,-.)/01��B�M:2�-((2((62*4�05�,:-*+2(�)*�60(-),�/=0,J(�-*7�IKLF�5.06�4:2�D.0E2,4�)*�.2=-4)0*�40�6224)*+�0/E2,4)32(<�)*7),-40.(<�72().-/=2�=232=(�-*7�4-.+24�=232=(�05�-99=),-/=2�PQD(�-.2�*04�,0690*2*4(�05�4:2�2552,4(�-((2((62*4�0*�,-.)/01�50.�4:2�D.0E2,4@�R4�)(�-((1627�4:-4�4:2�4-.+24�=232=(�05�4:2�PQD(�:-32�-=.2-78�/22*�)*,0.90.-427�)*40�4:2�IKLF<�;:),:�;)==�/2�-�,0690*2*4�05�4:2�-((2((62*4�0*�2552,4(�40�;007=-*7�,-.)/01@��B�K0(4�-((0,)-427�;)4:�9042*4)-=�PQD�.23)()0*(�;)==�*04�/2�-((2((27��B�S/E2,4)32(�05�4:2�PQD(�;)==�/2�,0*()72.27�)*�4:2�72(,.)94)0*�05�4:2�-((2((62*4�2*790)*4�50.�,-.)/01@���� �������T�7)+)4-=�5)=2(�05�4:2�IKLF�;)==�/2�-3-)=-/=2�3)-�4:2�KFM<�50.�6-9�,.2-4)0*@�R5�4:2�KFM�)(�*04�-3-)=-/=2<�7)+)4-=�5)=2(�05�4:2�IKLF�50.�-==�PQD(�4:-4�032.=-9�;)4:�4:2�D.0E2,4�;)==�/2�9.03)727�7).2,4=8�5.06�50.2(4.8�,069-*)2(�-4�=2-(4�U�60*4:(�/250.2�(1/6)(()0*�05�4:2�VW@���B�L-/)4-4�-3-)=-/)=)48�?)@2@<�>1-*4)48�-*7�>1-=)48A��B�L-/)4-4�7)(4.)/14)0*�?)@2@<�-..-*+262*4�-*7�,0**2,4)3)48A�

I-42N�X1=8�Y<�Z[\U�D.0E2,4�]0@�\_Y\��aWC[bMQc_�M0N�a)==)-**2�Q-.(:-==<�d2+)0*-=�D=-**2.�?Q]dPA� Uef� ��

Page 37: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

� � ���������������� ����������� ����������������������������������� ��������� ����������������������� ��������� �������������������!�������"� ����#�����#�����!���$��������� ������������������ ��������$����!��%�� ����&�#��������%&��$��� �������������� �����'��� �%�� ����&#������'%&���()*+,-.)�/0)10),�2,�321�10)�4,25)+1�/-66�-748+1�10)�2.5)+1-9)*�:2,�10)�;),9-<�=+262>-+86�?23)�@;=?A�-3�/0-+0�10)�4,25)+1�-*�4,242*)<�12�2++B,C�()*+,-41-23�2:�+231)31�-3�10)�4,21)+1)<�8,)8*�7838>)7)31�<-,)+1-23�,)681)<�12�+8,-.2BD+8,-.2B�08.-181�83<�EB86-181-9)�<-*+B**-23�2:�02/�4,25)+1�-*�2,�-*�321�+23*-*1)31�/-10�10)�7838>)7)31�<-,)+1-23C�()*+,-41-23�2:�<-,)+1-23�-3�;FGH*�,)681)<�12�+8,-.2BD+8,-.2B�08.-181�83<�EB86-181-9)�<-*+B**-23�2:�02/�4,25)+1�-*�2,�-*�321�+23*-*1)31�/-10�10)*)�8,)8�*4)+-:-+�426-+-)*�83<�<-,)+1-23�/-10-3�10)7C�()*+,-41-23�2:�<-,)+1-23�-3�;IFGH*�,)681)<�12�+8,-.2BD+8,-.2B�08.-181�83<�EB86-181-9)�<-*+B**-23�2:�02/�4,25)+1�-*�2,�-*�321�+23*-*1)31�/-10�10)*)�8,)8�*4)+-:-+�426-+-)*�83<�<-,)+1-23�/-10-3�10)7C�J�K0)*)�-3<-+812,*�/-66�321�.)�-3+2,42,81)<�-312�10)�+8,-.2B�8**)**7)31�.)+8B*)�+23*-*1)3+L�/-10�*181)<�2.5)+1-9)*�-*�321�-3<-+81-9)�2:�7)8*B,)8.6)�+083>)�-3�)39-,237)3186�+23<-1-23*�1081�+2B6<�6)8<�12�8�+083>)�-3�10)�+8,-.2BM*�8**)**7)31�)3<42-31C�� J�N23)�

N21)*O�8A�P,27�QNRP�@STUVAC�;IFGH�W�;277B3-1L�I8*)<�F83<�G*)�H683X�;=P�W�;),9-<�=+262>-+86�P,87)/2,YX�;FGH�W�;,2/3�F83<�G*)�H26-+-)*X�;ZK�W�+8,-.2B�*+,))3-3>�1226X�(;[Z�W�<L387-+�+8,-.2B�08.-181�*+0)<B6)X�PQH*�W�P2,)*1�Q838>)7)31�H683X�PR\�W�P2,)*1�R)*2B,+)�\39)312,LX�][(�W�>)3),86�08.-181�<)*+,-41-23�:2,�10)�/22<683<�+8,-.2B�@QNR�STU.AX�\R_R*�W�-31)>,81)<�,83>)�8**)**7)31�,)42,1*X�Q =;;�W�Q-3-*1,L�2:�=39-,237)31�83<�;6-781)�;083>)X�ZRNa�W�Z-7B681)<�R83>)�2:�N81B,86�a8,-8.-6-1LC����(81)O�bB6L�cd�STUV�H,25)+1�N2C�UeeceU�f�]_FfTegfKQfa�K2O�]-66-833)�Q8,*0866d�R)>-2386�H6833),�@QNRPA� cDh� ��

Page 38: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated

APPENDIX E 

Page 39: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 40: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 41: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 42: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 43: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 44: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 45: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 46: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 47: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 48: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 49: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated
Page 50: Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14 ...Appendix C: Letter from MNRF to Mr. Eade dated April 14, 2016 Appendix D: Allan Eade Memo to Gillianne Marshall (MNRF) dated