are 309 – chapter 3 administrative law & procedure · pdf fileexercising three...
TRANSCRIPT
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 1
Slide 3-1
ARE 309- Environmental Law
Chapter 3
Administrative Law & Procedure
Slide 3-2
Major Topics
1. Overview2. Administrative Agencies3. Rulemaking4. Enforcement5. Adjudication6. Agency Organization
Slide 3-3
Topic 1. Overview
• Definition of Administrative Law
• Why it is important to Environmental Law
• Eight characteristics of Administrative Law
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 2
Slide 3-4
Definition of Administrative Law
• The procedures governing how the executive branch carries out and enforce substantive statutes and regulations
• Administrative proceeding take place before an administrative body as distinguished from proceedings in court
Slide 3-5
Why Administrative Law and Procedures Are Important
• 80% to 90% of disputes concerning environmental laws and regulations involve administrative law issues
• Rulemaking• Issuance of permits• Assessment of civil penalties for violations
Slide 3-6
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
1. Agency rules have the force and effect of law
2. There is a right to contest any agency action
Before the Agency Court
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 3
Slide 3-7
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
3. Administrative agencies have no inherent or residual authority
• Legislature must grant them specific authority
Slide 3-8
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
4. Administrative agencies must act in accordance with the statute, their own rules, regulations, and procedures
• Example: permitting landfill
Slide 3-9
Permitting Landfill Case
• Anson County Citizens Against Chemical Toxins In Underground Storage v NC-DENR– http://oahnt.oah.state.nc.us/decisions/2001/pdf/ehr/EHR000938.pd
f
• Issue: Did the Agency follow the law in reviewing the compliance history of the permit applicant ?
• Held: No
• Result: Permit was denied
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 4
Slide 3-10
HoldingThe Division’s failed to act as required by law or rule in reviewing the history of environmental compliance of the permit applicant for the following reasons:
a. The Division failed to make any effort to look behind the data submitted by the applicant or to gather any of its own data. A citizen using the Internet, Ms. Lee, was able to rather easily come up with numerous violations committed by the applicant that were neither submitted by the applicant nor otherwise obtained by the Division.
b. Incredibly, the Division failed to contact for further information any of the State or Federal authorities that had cited the applicant or that had prosecuted the applicant for criminal violations, relying solely instead on brief, self-serving summaries of the violations compiled by the applicant.
c. The Division very nearly disregarded violations outside North Carolina, with no rational explanation for having done so, especially with regard to a large, multinational corporate applicant that does most of its business outside North Carolina. The statute does not limit the review to violations in North Carolina;
Slide 3-11
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
5. Agency actions may not be arbitrary and capricious
• There must be an explanation, but it may be one of many possible explanations
Slide 3-12
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
6. An agency’s interpretation of its own regulations and statutes will generally be granted deference
• Courts are reluctant to substitute their interpretation for that of the agency
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 5
Slide 3-13
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
7. Agency decisions may be contested by the affected party and in some cases by third parties
Slide 3-14
Eight Characteristics of Administrative Law
8. On appeal, courts generally uphold agency actions
Slide 3-15
Major Topics
1. Overview2. Administrative Agencies3. Rulemaking4. Enforcement5. Adjudication6. Agency Organization
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 6
Slide 3-16
Topic 2. Administrative Agencies
• What Are They
• What Do They Do
• What Are Their Limits
Slide 3-17
Administrative AgenciesWhat Are they
• Any body created by a legislative branch to carry out specific duties authorized by statute– Examples:
• Federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)• NC Department of Environment and Natural
Resources (DENR)• Environmental Management Commission (EMC)
Slide 3-18
Administrative AgenciesWhat they do
• Three Major Functions of Agencies:– Rulemaking [quasi-legislative]
• Write the regulations
– Enforcement [executive]• Enforce the regulations they write
– Adjudication [quasi-judicial]• Adjudicate disputes over application of the rules
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 7
Slide 3-19
Administrative AgenciesExercising Three Functions of Government
• Sometimes Referred to “Fourth Branch of Government”
• Why?
• Is this accurate ?
Slide 3-20
Administrative AgenciesWhat Are Their Limits
• Courts can review their actions– Was it arbitrary and capricious standard
• Executive Branch can review their actions– Administrative Law Judges
• Can the Legislative Branch review their actions ?
Slide 3-21
Administrative AgenciesLegislative Review & Controls
• Federal Agencies– Rules Subject to override under
Congressional Review Act• Example: Federal Ergonomics Standard (2001)
• North Carolina– Rules Subject to legislative override under
Administrative Procedures Act
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 8
Slide 3-22
Congressional Review Act
• Agencies must submit all new rules to Congress
• Congress has 60 session days to review and possibly reject agency rules
• Special expedited procedures limit debate in the House and ban a Senate filibuster
• If the motion to disapprove passes in both the House and Senate, and is then signed by the President, the rule essentially disappears
Slide 3-23
Rules Sent to Congress Under the Congressional Review Act
• Fact: Between April 1, 1996 and March 13, 2001: 21,653 rules were submitted to Congress for review.
• Fact: Number of rules disapproved by Congress = 1.
Slide 3-24
Congressional Review Act• The Senate voted to repeal the OSHA Ergonomics
rule on March 6, 2001, by a vote of 56 to 44. A day later on March 7, 2001, the House of Representatives voted to repeal the final rule by a vote of 223 to 206.
• President Bush signed the Resolution for Disapproval on March 20, 2001 effectively repealing the OSHA Ergonomics program Final Rule.
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 9
Slide 3-25
Major Topics
1. Overview2. Administrative Agencies3. Rulemaking4. Enforcement5. Adjudication6. Agency Organization
Slide 3-26
Topic 3. Rulemaking
• What is a rule• Economic impact of rules• Types of rules• How a rule is adopted
– Federal procedure– NC procedure
Slide 3-27
RulemakingWhat is a rule
• Any agency regulation, standard or statement of general applicability that implements or interprets a statute or that describes the procedure or practice requirements of an agency
• Rule = Regulation
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 10
Slide 3-28
The Number of Federal Regulations Is Increasing at A Record Rate
Slide 3-29
Major Federal Rule
• Defined: Rules that will have an annual effect on the economy of more than $100 million.
Slide 3-30
Major Rules
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 11
Slide 3-31
The Growth Of Federal Regulations• The Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), an
annual listing of executive agency regulations published in the Federal Register, includes all regulations now in effect
• In 1970, the CFR filled 114 volumes with a total of 54,834 pages
• In 1998, the CFR filled 201 volumes with a total of 134,723 pages; it occupies 19 feet of shelf space.
Slide 3-32
Lots of Regulations =Big Regulatory Bureaucracy
• In fiscal year (FY) 2000• 54 federal departments and agencies• Over 130,000 federal employees• Will spend over $18.7 billion• Writing and enforcing federal
regulations.
Slide 3-33
Environmental Regulations Account For 1/3 of All Federal Regulatory Costs
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 12
Slide 3-34
The Cost of Federal Regulations
• Estimates of how much federal regulation will cost in FY 2000 range from $200 billion to more than $700 billion
• About $6,800 per year for each American family
Slide 3-35
RulemakingThree Basic Types of Rulemaking
• Permanent Rules– “Notice & Comment”
• Temporary Rules (North Carolina)
• Exempt– General policy statements– Interpretations
Slide 3-36
RulemakingHow a rule is adopted (generic process)
• Publish notice of proposed rule• Solicit public comment
– written– public hearings
• Publish text of final rule• Establish effective date• Establish way to challenge the rule
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 13
Slide 3-37
RulemakingAdopting a Federal rule
See Course Material
“Federal Rulemaking Process
A Clean Air Act Example”
Eight Step Process
Slide 3-38
RulemakingAdopting a Federal rule
• How long does this all take?
Slide 3-39
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule
• A bit more complicated than Federal
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 14
Slide 3-40
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule
• A 10 step process for permanent rules
• As specified in: – North Carolina Administrative Procedure Act
(APA)– N.C.G.S. Chapter 150B
• See Class Material
Slide 3-41
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule-(Steps 1-3)
• Step 1: Publish notice of rule making proceedings in North Carolina Register– Published 1st and 15th of each month
• Step 2: Allow at least 60 days for public comment
• Step 3: Agency prepares fiscal note– if state $ or local gov’t $ involved– if “substantial economic impact” ($5M)
Slide 3-42
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule -(Steps 4-6)
• Step 4: Publish text of proposed rule in North Carolina Register
• Step 5: Mail notice of proposed rule to official “mailing list”
• Step 6: Holding a public hearing– if requested– if Agency wants to
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 15
Slide 3-43
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule -(Steps 7-8)
• Step 7: Accept written comments on proposed rule
• Step 8: Adopt final rule w/i 12 months– if same as proposed rule
• text is NOT published in NCR– if “substantially different”
• republish text and accept written comment for 30 days
Slide 3-44
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule -(Step 9)
• Step 9: Submit rule to Rules Review Commission (“RRC”)– Approve the rule– Reject the rule
• no statutory authority• unclear or ambiguous• not reasonably necessary• adopted by improper procedure
Slide 3-45
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule -(Step 10)
• Step 10: Establish the effective date of the rule.– If RRC objects to the rule
• Rule does not go into effect/; send back to Agency
– If RRC approves the rule• Rule goes to the NC General Assembly
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 16
Slide 3-46
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule -(Step 10+)
• At the NCGS the rule does not go into effect until the earlier of:
– the 31st legislative day or the day of adjournment of the next regular session of the General Assembly that begins at least 25 days after the RRC approves a rule
– Unless, prior to that date, a bill is introduced disapproving the rule
Slide 3-47
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule
• So how long does it take to adopt a permanent rule in North Carolina??
• What do you do it you need a rule sooner?
Slide 3-48
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina rule
• For one of six reasons
• Agency can by-pass permanent ruling making process
• Adopt Temporary Rules
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 17
Slide 3-49
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina Temporary Rule
• Allowed in six situations– serious & unforeseen threat to public health,
safety, or welfare– effective date of new state or federal law– recent change in federal or state budgetary policy– federal regulation– court order– State Medical Facilities Plan
Slide 3-50
RulemakingAdopting a North Carolina Temporary Rule
• Step1: Agency prepares a finding of need– citing one of the 6 statutory factors
• Step 2: Agency submits finding to “Codifier of Rules”
• Step 3: Codifier has one business day to review finding of need
• Step 4: Publishes the rule in North Carolina Register with immediate effective date
Slide 3-51
• How, When and Where you can challenge a rule differ:– Federal rules– State rules
• Many federal rules are litigated• Most state rules are not litigated
RulemakingJudicial Review of Rules
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 18
Slide 3-52
RulemakingChallenging Federal Rules
• Which Court:– Varies with the individual law [Examples]
• Time for Appeal– Varies with the individual law– Generally 60-90 days after publication in FR
• Standard of Review– Deference to Agency– Unless rule is “arbitrary and capricious”
Slide 3-53
RulemakingChallenging North Carolina Rules
• No direct route to court for permanent rules
• Two options – Wait until the DENR enforces the rule
• Raise the validity of the rule as a defense
– Ask for Declaratory Ruling from the Agency
Slide 3-54
RulemakingChallenging North Carolina Rules
• Declaratory Ruling– Petition to Agency– Asking the Agency to declare its rule
invalid• Agency’s Decision on Declaratory
Ruling may be appealed – To Superior Court
• Wake County or• County of residency
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 19
Slide 3-55
RulemakingJudicial Standard of Review
• Review of the written record of rulemaking
• To determine if there is “some evidence” for Agency’s actions
• “Arbitrary & Capricious”
• Court will not substitute its judgment for the agency
• Agency’s generally win!
Slide 3-56
Major Topics
1. Overview2. Administrative Agencies3. Rulemaking4. Enforcement5. Adjudication6. Agency Organization
Slide 3-57
Agency EnforcementAgency Powers
• Power to enter you facility• Power to investigate violations• Power to assess civil penalties of up to
$25,000/day/violation• Power to issue orders
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 20
Slide 3-58
Agency EnforcementAgency Powers
Civil Penalties Are On Line
http://www.enr.state.nc.us/novs/dwq.htm
Slide 3-59
Major Topics
1. Overview2. Administrative Agencies3. Rulemaking4. Enforcement5. Adjudication6. Agency Organization
Slide 3-60
Agency AdjudicationAppealing Agency Actions Against You
• Civil penalties– $25,000 per day per violation
• Permits– new– renewals
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 21
Slide 3-61
Agency AdjudicationAppealing Agency Actions Against You
• Federal and State procedures differ• Federal--Governed by Federal APA
– 5 USC Section 500 et al• State--Governed by State APA
– NCGS Chapter 150B
Slide 3-62
Agency AdjudicationAppealing North Carolina Actions
• Notice of Violation (“NOV”)• Complaint/Order/Permit Issued• 30-60 day later you must:
– pay or accept permit– ask for remission– contest the action at Office of
Administrative Hearings (“OAH”)
Slide 3-63
Basic Steps In NC Administrative Appeals
Step 3: Settlement of Case With AgencyLegal & Technical Types Work Out Mutually Acceptable Solution
Step 2: File Notice To Contest Agency Action:****Time Limited *****Usually within 30 days
Step 1: Agency ActionPermit Issuance
orCivil Penalty Assessment
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 22
Slide 3-64
Step 8: Appeal to Court SystemReview of written record only
Step 7: Final Order of Agency
Step 6: Appeal to Agency Administrator or BoardReview of written record created by ALJ
Step 5: Initial Decision of Administrative Law Judge
Step 4: Hearing Before Administrative Law JudgeTrial type proceeding
Basic Steps In NC Administrative Appeals
Slide 3-65
The Truth About Administrative Appeals
• NC Contested Case Statistics [1989-1998]
• ALJ rules for the Agency---75%– Agency reverses ALJ in 1 % of these
cases
• ALJ rules for the petitioner ---25 %– Agency reveres ALJ in 90% of these
cases
Slide 3-66
The Truth
Petitioner has about a 3% chance of winning its appeal at the administrative level
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 23
Slide 3-67
Agency AdjudicationPermitting
• Complete Application• Draft Permit• Public Comment/Hearing• Final Permit Decision• Administrative Appeal• Hearing• Final Agency Action
Slide 3-68
Who Can Appeal A Permit ?
OperatingPermit
The Facility Third Parties
Citizens
Other Agencies
Competitors
Slide 3-69
Major Topics
1. Overview2. Administrative Agencies3. Rulemaking4. Enforcement5. Adjudication6. Agency Organization
ARE 309 – Chapter 3Administrative Law & Procedure
© 2003 J.M. Kuszaj Chapter 3 – Page 24
Slide 3-70
Agency OrganizationMajor Environmental Agencies
• Federal– Environmental Protection Agency
• Headquarters• Regional Offices
• North Carolina– Department of Environment and Natural
Resources (“DENR”)• Central Office• Regional Offices
Slide 3-71
Agency OrganizationGenerally By Program Area
Air
WaterWaste
Toxics
CERCLA
Slide 3-72
Agency OrganizationFederal EPA Regions
North Carolina is in Region 4