armed forces tribunal, principal bench, new...
TRANSCRIPT
1
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 01-04-2019
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 1 (Ground Floor)
HON'BLE THE CHAIRPERSON
CORAM:
HON'BLE LT. GEN. PHILIP CAMPOSE
S. No. Case No. Parties Name
For Admission
Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
101. OA 146/2019 with MA 562/2019 & 937/2019
IC-57396N Lt Col Anjan Kumar Sinha V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
102. OA 235/2019 No 1525034 Ex Nk Ajaib Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian Mr. Avdhesh Kumar Singh
103. OA 304/2019 Ex SDR CDT Rohit Kumar (No 16129541F) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Ajit Kakkar Mr. S P Sharma
104. OA 311/2019 with MA 1013/2019
IC-54491P Lt Col Rajiv Narain Sharma V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh Mr. Tarunvir Singh Khehar
105. OA 479/2019 Ex Seaman 1 Manoj Baghel (No 213951 B) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh
None
2
For Orders 201. OA 1769/2018
with MA 1012/2019
No 6935914K Hav SHT Pradeep Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian Mr JS Rawat
202. OA 1888/2018 No 3191911Y Hav Ram Phal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajesh Nandal Mr. J S Rawat
203. MA 1949/2018 in OA 825/2017
No 14255775L Hony Nb Sub Vijendra Singh Dagar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Sant Ram Ms. Jyotsna Kaushik
204. OA 62/2019 Cpl Sandeep Kumar (No 744905G) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Mr. Prabodh Kumar
205. OA 209/2019
IC-41196N Maj Gen Sudhakar Jee V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh Mr. Anil Gautam
206. MA 750/2019 in OA 1735/2017
IC-32867L Lt Col (TS) AS Malik (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. Anil Srivastava Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
207. MA 865/2019 in OA 551/2017
Ic-38305 Maj Gen K K Sinha (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Harish V Shankar
208. MA 1028/2019 in OA 364/2017
IC-36611A Maj Adarsh Kumar Sharma (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. AK Srivastava Dr. Vijendra Singh Mahndiyan
3
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 01-04-2019
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 2 (Ground Floor) CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV CHACHRA Note : There shall be no passover in first three cases.
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
For Admission 1. OA 1883/2018 No. 14819393N Nk Keti Bhogeswar
Rao V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh Mr. Prabodh Kumar
2. OA 183/2019 No. 9098856M Hav Ved Parkash V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh Mr. J S Rawat
3. OA 192/2019 No 6396882L Hav/SKT Kumar B V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh & Abhishek Singh Mr. S R Swain
4. OA 265/2019 Maj Abhishek Raheja (IC-69477A) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Anand Kumar Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
For Execution 5. MA 383/2019
in OA 182/2016
Rolly Gandhi W/o Late Wg Cdr Manish Gandhi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Mr. Avdhesh Kumar Singh
4
For Hearing 6. TA 3/2015
with MA 615/2019 (CWJC 4813/1996
Lt. Col. Harjit Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr IS Singh Mr Anil Gautam
7. OA 230/2017 with MA 181/2017
Col Vikram Chauhan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. I S Singh & Abhishek Singh Mr. Shyam Narayan
8. OA 544/2018 with MA 395/2018, 1847/2018 & 548/2019
Hav Kuldeep Singh (Retd (No 10315501-N) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh Mr Prabodh Kumar
9. OA 1296/2018 with MA 2253/2018
IC-49695-X Col Atul Dimri V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajendra Kumar Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
10. OA 1469/2018 with MA 1489/2018 & 2281/2018
JC-412924N Sub Maj/Clk (SD) Kuldip Singh (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey Ms. Jyotsana Kaushik
11. OA 1684/2018 with MA 1833/2018 & 402/2019
IC-52861-L Col M S Prakash V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh Mr. Anil Gautam
12. OA 34/2019 Wg Cdr Apurba Kumar Gayan (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Mr. Sarita Rajan
13 MA 574/2019 & MA 575/2019 in OA 1653/2016
JC-761543P Sub/M Tech 'B' Veh Kumaravelu V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Arvind Patel
5 14. MA 618/2019
& MA 619/2019 in OA 771/2016
Hav (Clerk) Rakesh Kumar V/s UOI & Ors
Mr Indra Sen Singh & Abhishek Singh Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
Regular hearing matters List 1 1. OA (Appeal)
1922/2018 With MA 2125/2018
N. 4576674M Hav Sham Das D Thru his wife Mrs. Raji R Nair V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Anand Kumar Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
2. OA 1388/2018 Ex Brig Amit Kumar Chatterjee (IC-48355H) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
3. OA 489/2010 with MA 1399/2018 (TA 36/2012 (RB Kolkata)
Ex. Lt. Col. Prawin Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S. S. Pandey Mr Anil Gautam
4. TA 9/2015 with TA 35/2015 (RB Chandigarh)
Sqn Ldr Ravi Goel V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Amjid Maqbool Mr KK Tyagi
5. OA (Appeal) 333/2015
Lt Cdr Mahesh V Birajdar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. D J Singh Mr Harish V Shankar
6. OA (Appeal) 455/2015 with MA 486/2015 & 487/2015
Ex Sep Uday Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey Mr Anil Gautam
7. MA 1501/2018 in OA (Appeal) 460/2016
No. 14413656X Ex Hav (GD) Lokendra Singh Thru his Father Mr. Deshraj Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Avdhesh Kumar
8. MA 1502/2018 in OA (Appeal) 163/2017
No. 15155622H Ex Gnr Upnil Kumar Thru his wife Ankan Sharma V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
6 9. MA 1503/2018
in OA (Appeal) 569/2015
No. 14435695W Ex Nk (TA) Sunil Kumar Thru his wife Smt. Suman Lata V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Anil Gautam
10. MA 1504/2018 in OA (Appeal) 228/2017
No. 14431609H Ex Hav (GD) Sarabjeet Singh Thru his brother Gagandeep Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
11 MA 1505/2018 in OA (Appeal) 162/2017
No. 15137452F Ex Hav (TA) Tapas Ranjan Rout Thru his father Dhaneswar Raut V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
12 MA 1506/2018 in OA (Appeal) 462/2016
No. 15156180F Ex L/Nk (Opr) Amresh Kumar Tiwari Thru his brother Ashutosh Kumar Tiwari V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr JS Rawat
13 MA 1507/2018 in OA (Appeal) 1015/2017
No. 15116695Y Ex Hav (DMT) Naseer Mohammed Thru his wife Smt. Patasi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
14 MA 1508/2018 in OA (Appeal) 867/2017
No. 15180736Y Ex Gnr (GD) Bikramjit Singh Thru his father Sh. Shukhwinder Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
15 OA (Appeal) 1263/2018 with MA 1205/2018
No 15151563K Ex L/Nk Naryan Swami V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey Mr SR Swain
Regular hearing matters List 2 1. OA 509/2014
Ex Carporal D.S. Khan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr CK Sharma Mr JS Rawat
WITH
2. OA 558/2014
Ex Carporal Manish Sinha V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr CK Sharma
Mr SD Windlesh
7 3. OA 277/2015
with MA 724/2017
Sub M/Tech Opto Gurjeet Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey Mr Ashok Chaitanya
4. OA 283/2015 with MA 1061/2015
Hav Jaswant Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh Dr Vijendra Singh Mahndiyan
5. OA 308/2015
Brig A Umar Farook V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr IS Singh & Abhishek Singh Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with Mr Arvind Patel
THIS BENCH WILL NOT ASSEMBLE TODAY CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE LT. GEN. PHILIP CAMPOSE
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
For Hearing 1. MA 711/2019
in OA (Appeal) 1130/2015
No. 14438710L Ex L/Nk (Washerman) Anish Kumar Bundele (In the matter of Ex Hav (GD) Satyendra Kumar Singh & Ors.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey Mr. Harish V Shankar
8
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 01-04-2019
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 3 (First Floor) CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SUNITA GUPTA HON'BLE LT. GEN. GAUTAM MOORTHY
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
For Judgement 1. OA 931/2016 Sgt Naresh Kumar Sharma (Retd)
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. C K Sharma & Gaurav sharma Mr Arvind Patel
For Admission 2. OA 359/2019 Col Sanjay Singh (Retd) (IC 43586P)
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Virender Singh Kadian Mr. Arvind Patel
3. OA 363/2019 with MA 905/2019
Ex Cpl Nishant Kumar (No 903409 R) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Virender Singh Kadian Mr. Harish V Shankar and Ms. Rati Varma
4. OA 372/2019 with MA 916/2019
No. 13937405-Y Ex Hav (Hony Nb Sub) Birham Pal Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Virender Singh Kadian Mr. Ashok Chaitanya
5. OA 416/2019 Ex Cfn Babu KK (No 14675909) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajendra Kumar
None
9 6. OA 417/2019 Lt Col Kuldip Singh (Retd) (IC 49683
H) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajendra Kumar
None
7. OA 447/2019 with MA 1006/2019
Ex LNk Yashwant Singh (No 4084174 F) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Virender Singh Kadian
None
8. OA 448/2019 with MA 1007/2019
Ex L/Nk Manoj Kumar Sharma (No 15612851 H) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Praveen Kumar
None
9. OA 449/2019 Ex Sgt Vijay Kumar (No 777122F) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Virender Singh Kadian
None
10. OA 450/2019 Brig ST Rangarajan (Retd) (IC 24672 L) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Balaji Subramanian & Ishant Banerjee
None
11. OA 454/2019 with MA 1015/2019
No 4056269L Ex Rfn Sate Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajesh Nandal
None
12. OA 455/2019 with MA 1016/2019
No. 43215-M Col Sanjeev Kumar Singh (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar
None
13. OA 456/2019 with MA 1017/2019
Ex Sgt Amit Kumar (No 791095) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ved Prakash
None
For Orders 14. MA 1032/2019
in OA 500/2016
Capt Hemendra Kumar Singh (Retd) (SS-39418) V/s UOI & Ors
Ms Archana Ramesh Mr. S R Swain
10 For Hearing 15. OA 132/2018 JC-143849X Ex-Subedar (Hony. Sub.
Maj.) Sher Singh Yadav V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Sangeeta Tomar Mr Ashok Chaitanya
16. OA 252/2018 with MA 169/2018
No. 120523T Ex LRO (SPL) Kranthi Kumar Barla V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. O S Punia Mr Arvind Patel
17. OA 377/2018 with MA 234/2018
JC-339626M Sub Rajvir Singh (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh
18. OA 684/2018 No 14228748X Ex Sigmn E Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh Mr SP Sharma
19. OA 995/2018 No 178742-H Ex Chief ART Yashpal Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Ved Prakash Mr. Arvind Patel
20. OA 1436/2018 with MA 1450/2018 & 2066/2018
Ex Sgt Emandi AR Ajay Kumar (No 765880) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kandian Mr. Prabodh Kumar
21. OA 1010/2015 Ex MWO Ayodhya Mishra V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr SP Sharma
22. OA 570/2016 Sub Mewa Lal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. N K Ghai Mr YP Singh for R 1-3, Ms Anjali Vohra for R-4
23. OA 1167/2016 with MA 841/2019
Smt. Lochanabai Babarao Kamble V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr. S R Swain
11
24 OA 1290/2016 Ex Rect Darshan Singh Negi V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Pallavi Awasthi Mr Prabodh Kumar
25. OA 1340/2016 with MA 1008/2016
Ex-Ear/App Ashwani Kumar Tyagi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar Mr Shyam Narayan
26. OA 1687/2016 Capt Anil Kumar Malhotra (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Aditya Singh Puar Ms Barkha Babbar
27. OA 180/2017 Lt Col Arun Kumar Sarma (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. A S Puar Mr Arvind Patel
28. OA 727/2018 with MA 597/2018 & 2247/2018
Ex MCPO-I (Hony SLT) Ram Kishore V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar Mr. J S Yadav
29. OA 787/2018 with MA 660/2018
Ex CPO Pradeep Kumar Verma (No 112563) & Ors. V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar Mr VS Tomar
30. OA 994/2018 with MA 2218/2018
HFO (Retd) Shiv Om V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar Mr. Shyam Narayan
31. OA 732/2015 with MA 781/2015
Capt. Ajay Kumar Gulati (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh Mr SP Sharma for R 1,2 & 4 Ms Anjali Vohra for R-3
12 32. OA 812/2015
with MA 842/2015
Ex Sep Ghasi Ram V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Archana Ramesh Mr Arvind Patel
33. OA 358/2016 Ex Hav (Clk ) Anuja Kumar Nayak V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Anil Srivastava & Association Mr SD Windlesh
34. OA 956/2016 Ex Sep Naginder Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. N K Ghai Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh
35. OA 1375/2016 Col Jaswant Singh Labana (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr Ashok Chaitanya
36. OA 477/2017 Ex Sub Ramkant Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr. S R Swain
37. OA 805/2017 with MA 902/2018
Ex Sgt Satyendra Prasad V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Yogesh Kumar Dr. V S Mahndiyan
38. OA 786/2018 with MA 429/2019
Smt Savita Singh W/o Late Wg Cdr AD Singh (19480G) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Ajit Kakkar Mr. J S Rawat
For Final Hearing 39. OA 1623/2016 Maj Gen Bipin Bakshi
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ankit Swarup & Tanya Swarup Mr Anil Gautam
13 40. OA 841/2017
with MA 660/2017 & 759/2019
Sandeep Ex Chera V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Sukhjinder Singh Ms Barkha Babbar
THIS BENCH WILL NOT ASSEMBLE TODAY CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SUNITA GUPTA HON'BLE LT. GEN. PHILIP CAMPOSE
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
Part Heard 1. TA 439/2009
Writ Petition No. 1069/1997
Lt Cdr Prahlad Kr. Varshney V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Ajai Bhalla Mr Harish V Shankar
Note : The Cause List is also available at www.aftdelhi.nic.in ,www.aftpbba.in