art 39 amor art 42 bailon persons
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
1/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
THIRD DIVISION
G.R. No. !"#$ %eb&ua&' !( )##"
%E*ICIT+S +MOR,C+T+*+N( Petitione&(-s.COURT O% +PPE+*S( M+NI*+( OR*+NDO . C+T+*+Nan/ MEROPE E. R+G+N0+( Respon/ents.
D E C I S I O N
1N+RES,S+NTI+GO( 2.3
This petition fo& &e-ie4 assails the Decision of the Cou&t of +ppeals in C+,G.R. CV No. !$5"6 /ate/ +u7ust !( )##8( 4hich&e-e&se/ the Decision) of the Re7ional T&ial Cou&t 9RTC: of Da7upan Cit'( &anch 88( in Ci-il Case No. D,#!;!( /ecla&in7the
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
2/56
%u&nish copies of this Decision to +tt'. Napoleon . +&enas( 2&.an/ +tt'. Nolan E-an7elista.
SO ORDERED.#
Respon/ents appeale/ the /ecision to the Cou&t of +ppeals(4hich &e-e&se/ the /ecision of the RTC( thus3
@HERE%ORE( p&ee4ise DISMISS Ci-il Case No. D,#!;!( RTC( &anch 88( Da7upan Cit'. No costs.
SO ORDERED.
+fte& the
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
3/56
natu&ali=ation an/ /i-o&ce.
The Cou&t of +ppeals the&efo&e ha/ no basis 4hen it hel/3
In li7ht of the alle7ations of %elicitas co
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
4/56
pe&sonalit' to inAui&e into the
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
5/56
Republic of the Philippines
SUPREME COURTManila
THIRD DIVISION
G.R. No. 94053 March 17, 1993
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitione&(-s.GREGORIO NOLSCO, &espon/ent.
The Solicitor General for plaintiff-appellee.
@a&loo G. Ca&/enal fo& &espon/ent.
R E S O * U T I O N
FELICINO, J.:
On 6 +u7ust $55( &espon/ent G&e7o&io Nolasco file/ befo&e the
Re7ional T&ial Cou&t of +ntiAue( &anch #( a petition fo& the/ecla&ation of p&esue&( in-o>in7 +&ticle 8 of the %a
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
6/56
assist the Solicito&,Gene&al in the instant case. The Republica&7ue/( fi&st( that Nolasco /i/ not possess a F4ell,foun/e/ belief that the absent spouse 4as al&ea/' /ea/(F ! an/ secon/( Nolascos
atte
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
7/56
!( $5"( as ae& Nolasco( 4ithout p&e?u/ice to
he& &eappea&ance. 4
The Republic appeale/ to the Cou&t of +ppeals conten/in7 thatthe t&ial cou&t e&&e/ in /ecla&in7 2anet Monica Pa&>e& p&esu
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
8/56
absentee is still aliveB o& the absentee is generally considered tobe dead an/believed to be so by the spouse present ( o& is presumed dead un/e& +&ticle ;$# an/ ;$ of the Ci-il Co/e. 9
The %a
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
9/56
In the case at ba&( the Cou&t consi/e&s that the in-esti7ation
alle7e/l' con/ucte/ b' &espon/ent in his attee&s 4he&eabouts is too s>etch' to fo&< the basis of a &easonable o& 4ell,foun/e/ belief that she 4as al&ea/'/ea/. @hen he a&&i-e/ in San 2ose( +ntiAue afte& lea&nin7 of 2anet Monicas /epa&tu&e( instea/ of see>in7 the help of localautho&ities o& of the &itish Eno4 the 7eo7&aphical /iffe&ence bet4een *on/on an/*i-e&pool( fo& a hus( e-e&' ti
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
10/56
ci&cu
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
11/56
not sub'ect to stipulation( ecept that
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
12/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
%IRST DIVISION
G.R. No. *,8;$#6 Ma' ;#( $5;
SER+%I+ G. TO*ENTINO( petitione&(
-s.HON. EDG+RDO *. P+R+S( M+RI+ C*EMENTE an/ THE*OC+* CIVI* REGISTR+R O% P+OMONG( U*+C+N(&espon/ents.
+
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
13/56
Cou&t( upon +
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
14/56
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
15/56
Dapucanta( Dula' +ssociates fo& petitione&.
Si7uion Re'na( Montecillo an/ On7sia>o *a4 Office fo& p&i-ate
&espon/ent.
P+R+S( 2.3
In an action 9%ae/ fo& the/ecla&ation of Nullit' of his ati( Met&o Manila: 4ith he&ein petitione& *ilia Oli-a @ie7el
9*ilia( fo& sho&t( an/ /efen/ant the&ein: on the 7&oun/ of *ilias p&e-ious eistin7
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
16/56
as a of
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
17/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
EN +NC
G.R. No. *,6;!8) +p&il 6( $55
*EONI*O C. DON+TO( petitione&s(-s.HON. +RTEMON D. *UN+( PRESIDING 2UDGE( COURTO% %IRST INST+NCE O% M+NII+( R+NCH II HON.2OSE %*+MINI+NO( CIT1 %ISC+* O% M+NI*+B P+0 .
++1+N( &espon/ents.*eopol/o P. Dela Rosa fo& petitione&.
E
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
18/56
cha&acte&.
P&io& to the /ate set fo& the t&ial on the
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
19/56
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
20/56
Pu&suant to the /oct&ine /iscusse/ in *an/icho -s. Relo-a( petitione& Donato cannot appl' the &ule on p&e?u/icial Auestionssince a case fo& annul
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
21/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
EN +NC
+.M. No. );8$ 2ul' ;( $$)
DOROTH1 . TERRE( co
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
22/56
$5( co
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
23/56
co
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
24/56
9Ehibit DB tsn( 2ul' "( $5!( p. )8:B she li>e4ise file/ acase fo& bi7a
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
25/56
the co
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
26/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
%IRST DIVISION
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
27/56
G.R. No. #$868 2une 8( $$8
2OSE C. SERMONI+( petitione&(-s.HON. COURT O% +PPE+*S( Ele-enth Di-ision( HON.DEOGR+CI+S %E*I0+RDO( P&esi/in7 2u/7e( Re7ional T&ialCou&t of Pasi7( &. 6( an/ 2OSEPH SINS+1( &espon/ents.
uasha( +spe&illa( +ncheta( Pea an/ Nolasco fo& petitione&.
Ponciano *. Escua/&a fo& p&i-ate &espon/ent.
E**OSI**O( 2.3
i7a
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
28/56
cont&act 4as &e7iste&e/. %o& this &eason( the co&&espon/in7info&es issue 4ith the Falle7e/ conceal
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
29/56
const&ue/ libe&all' in fa-o& of the accuse/. To co
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
30/56
s to &e-e&se the/ecision /ate/ Octobe& )( $$$ of the Cou&t of +ppeals inC+,G.R. CR No. )#"##( 4hich affi&
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
31/56
The facts of this case( as foun/ b' the cou&t a Auo( a&e asfollo4s3
+ppellant *ucio Mo&i7o an/ *ucia a&&ete 4e&e boa&/
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
32/56
9": Months of P&ision Co&&eccional as
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
33/56
Petitione&
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
34/56
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
35/56
The fi&st ele
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
36/56
SO ORDERED.
Puno( 9Chai&ete/ asCi-il Case No. #,)#8. On 2ul' 5( )##;( the RTC of
Muntinlupa( &anch )6!( &en/e&e/ an +
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
37/56
That on o& about 2anua&' )8( $5;( in the Municipalit' of SanPe/&o( P&o-ince of *a7una( Philippines( an/ 4ithin the ?u&is/iction of this Hono&able Cou&t( the sai/ accuse/ /i/ thenan/ the&e 4illfull'( unla4full' an/ feloniousl' cont&act a secon/
o& subseAuent
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
38/56
@he&efo&e( the O&/e& of +u7ust ;( )##" is &econsi/e&e/ an/ setasi/e. *et a ne4 one be ente&e/ Auashin7 the info&
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
39/56
bein7 its statuto&' counsel in all appeale/ c&i
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
40/56
initio on 8 +p&il )##; b' &anch )6! of the Re7ional T&ialCou&t of Muntinlupa Cit'. The sai/ /ecision 4as ne-e& appeale/( an/ beca of. In othe& 4o&/s( the&e 4as onl' one
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
41/56
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
42/56
In Ma&bella,obis -. obis( the Cou&t pointe/ out the /an7e& of not enfo&cin7 the p&o-isions of +&ticle 8# of the %ae an/ eat it too. Othe&4ise( all that ana/-entu&ous bi7a
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
43/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
THIRD DIVISION
G.R. No. ;!8!" +p&il !( )###
+NTONI+ +RM+S 1 C+*ISTERIO( petitione&(-s.M+RIETT+ C+*ISTERIO( &espon/ent.
VITUG( 2.3
On )8 +p&il $$)( Teo/o&ico Caliste&io /ie/ intestate( lea-in7se-e&al pa&cels of lan/ 4ith an esti
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
44/56
sole hei& of the estate of Teo/o&ico Caliste&io ' Cacabelos.
Respon/ent Ma&ietta appeale/ the /ecision of the t&ial cou&t tothe Cou&t of +ppeals( fo&
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
45/56
+ppeals &e-e&sin7 an/ settin7 asi/e the /ecision of the t&ialcou&t is not in acco&/ 4ith the la4 o& 4ith the applicable/ecisions of this Hono&able Cou&t. 8
It is e-i/ent that the basic issue focuses on the -ali/it' of thees of the natu&e of f&au/( a b&each of a>no4n /ut' th&ou7h so
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
46/56
spouse of the cont&actin7 pa&t'
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
47/56
Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT
Manila
THIRD DIVISION
G.R. No. !6686 Ma&ch )8( )##!
SOCI+* SECURIT1 S1STEM( Petitione&(-s.TERESIT+ 2+RUE VD+. DE +I*ON( Respon/ent.
D E C I S I O N
C+RPIO MOR+*ES(2.3
The Cou&t of +ppeals Decision /ate/ 2une );( )##8) an/Resolution /ate/ Septe
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
48/56
' O&/e& of Dece
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
49/56
acco&/in7 to the o&/e& of p&efe&ence p&o-i/e/ un/e& the la4(afte& the a
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
50/56
Respon/ent thus file/ a petition)" a7ainst the SSS befo&e theSSC fo& the &esto&ation to he& of he& entitle
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
51/56
/ecease/
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
52/56
basis alone of its o4n in-esti7ation an/ /ecla&e that the /ecisionof the RTC /ecla&in7 one to be p&esu
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
53/56
The SSS sub
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
54/56
he& p&esu
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
55/56
-
8/19/2019 Art 39 Amor Art 42 Bailon Persons
56/56