arxiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 feb 2003 - ihespreprints.ihes.fr › p03 › p03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[...

35

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

��� ��������� ������������������������� � �������������! "#���$� "#�$��� �%����

&('*),+.-%/�02123�45076�8:9;&<'*)=+>-?/A@B&<C$0EDF&<GF4H8JIK'*)�LF/NM7/NOPIQ&R1;LS6TGFC5&S0*4U8

VXWZY\[^]_[^`?[ aZbcYedTfg`?[^bhYjikl[m`ZaZbcY�n%oc]pbcW�[^]pqsrt`ZbcYu�v%wZx^y `?[^b�aZbUz|{sf x [ x bcY}?~�������<� ` x bcYX��Ym` x ���T��bh[m[^b#��� x fgWZocb.�

� ibh� x ]�b x��g��u

VXd�k|nZ���A� �u � �}

Page 2: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

arX

iv:h

ep-t

h/03

0219

1 v2

24

Feb

200

3

���������������� ���������������������������������� ���!"����#$ ������"�&%'���( ����$ ���)

*,+.-0/1/3254�*,6(-047698:4�*�;</�256=6=/1>?*,6=@0254�A7*

-047B C�@0>D>EC�>D@0+.2�8:4�*

��FHGJILKNM<%PORQTS'UVK5WRXZYH��FHGJILKNM,��[�I�UV\H[�]�S�W_^L`aX�YR��Mb]$MbcL[d�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHf�g$YX=h�iTj1k1l�mon�pNqVn�r<l�s�s$t5u_v�w�l(xy$pLp�z|{

^dmo{�}9k�~�{��Hqa�=hL��p���z|��y��V�DnV�emo{����R�a��{���z�qapLl��n��R�Jl����Vv����$t5u�l=�����a��{��R�`9k��� �����N�a�������dk1�'�Zp�z�qNp�hL��p���z|��y_�V�Ll<mon�pNqVn�r<l�s�s$t�w�u��$l�xy$pLp�z|{

g0hV�"j��Rl��y_� �Lp���p�y�����¡����a���V�Ll<¢��Vw�s5���R��l(¢£��{��Pqa�

¤¥K�¦§ILK¨UVK5F�cTFRK5©ªK5W'M|G�K5FH«aK�¬�S�I­cV\RK(«aS�F�®VKZ«�cV¯RILK1c°\P[�c²±(�&%�«aS�ILILK5³´[�cVMbS�Fµ¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FHU�M¶F�cV\RK�· ¸¹��UV¯§�¦PKNI�UVº$»d»:K5cVILM´«�¼'[�¯R¼�K�c°\RK5S�ILM¶KZU�[�ILKG�KZUL«aILMb½PKZG=½�º¾[�F0[�¯R¿$Mb³¶M|[�ILº�c�©(SeG�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³'«aS�F�¬�S�IL»0[�³$ÀHK5³´GcV\RK5S�ILºÁO�¤¥K�UVc°¯PG�ºÂGJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�FPU(S�¬�cV\RKe· ¸3�:UV¯§¦HK5I�UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«"¼'[�¯R¼�KecV\RK5S�ILºÃ½�ºÃ[�³¶³<¼'[�¯R¼�K5�M¶F_W�[�ILM´[�F�c�« \RMbI�[�³1S�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�U5O7¤¥Kë5[�³|«�¯§³´[�cVKdc°\RKĦH[�ILcVMbcVM¶S�Fo¬�¯§FH«ac°M¶S�FÅS�¬"c°\§Kd· ¸Æ��c°\§KNS�ILº�S�F@ g ©M¶c°\o[�¦§¦RILS�¦RILM|[�c°K5³¶º�c�©�M´UVcVKZG0½PS�¯RFHGR[�ILº0«aS�FHG�M¶cVMbS�FHU5O��§S�I(cV\RK�Ç=ÈL��É�cV\RK5S�ILº0©�MbcV\7MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHUÈËKNM¶cV\RK5I:F§S�FH«aS�»:»9¯RcL[�c°M¶W�K�Y�S�I:!µ��M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FHU5Y�GJKN¦PK5FHG�M¶FR¼oS�FÌcV\RK7«aS�FHUVc°IL¯P«�cVM¶S�FTÉ�cV\RKĦH[�ILc°M¶cVMbS�F¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�F�YR[�U(M¶ccV¯RILFHU1S�¯Rc5Y�\H[�U[ÍILK5¦RILKZUVKNF�cL[�c°M¶S�F0M¶FÃcVK5IL»0U1S�¬²cV\RKec°\§KNS�ILºdS�¬<¬�ILK5K"¬�K5IL»dMbS�FHU1S�F7[UV¦R\RK5ILK�Y'[�FHGd«aS�M¶FH«aM´G�KZU<©�MbcV\0cV\RK"cÊ[�¯§��¬�¯§FH«ac°M¶S�F�S�¬,cV\RKD��S_GR[ ³´[�cVcVM´«aK"\RM¶KNI�[�I�« \�ºÁO<Î"UVMbF§¼�cV\RM|U�ILKZUV¯R³¶c©(Kd¦RILS�W�K:cVSÏ[�³¶³1S�I�G�K5I�UDM¶FÐUVcVILM¶FR¼Ã³¶S'S�¦ÑK5¿'¦H[�FPUVMbS�F¥cV\H[�c=c°\§K0KaÒ£KZ«ac°M¶W�K0¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³"È|¬�S�IÓǾÈL��É©M¶cV\o[�³b³<«L\RM¶I�[�³,«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼'U&MbFP«�³¶¯HG�KZGPÉ1M´U�¼�M¶W�K5Fý�º0cV\RKe¬�ILK5K=K5FRK5IL¼�º0S�¬�c°\RK=cVS�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³­UVcVILMbFR¼9S�FÔ¾Õ X O7¤¥KÃUV\§S�©ÖcV\H[�c=cV\RK0¼�I�[�W'M¶cÊ[�cVMbS�FP[�³�G�KZUL«aK5FHGR[�F�cLUD¦R³|[�ºÏ[�FªM¶»d¦HS�ILcL[�F�cDI�×S�³bKdM¶FÅcV\RKd¼'[�¯R¼�KÀHK5³|GRUa �UVc°ILM¶FR¼d«�S�ILILKZUV¦PS�FHG�K5FH«aK�OD¤¥K�cV\RK5FoM|G�K5F�c°M�¬�ºÄc°\RM|UeUVc°ILM¶FR¼d©M¶c°\¥cV\RK=³¶MbcVc°³¶K0UVc°ILM¶FR¼d½PS�¯RFHG7cVScV\RK9ÀHW�K5½RI�[�FRK=©I�[�¦§¦HKZG�S�F¥c°\RKdc�©(S���UV¦R\§KNILK�O9¤¥KØ[�³|UVS7G�M´UL«a¯HULUµc°\RKdcV\RK5S�ILº7©M¶c°\Ù¬�¯RFHGR[�»dK5F�cÊ[�³»0[�c°cVK5I\�º'¦PK5IL»�¯R³¶cVMb¦R³¶K5cÊU5O

�§KN½§IL¯H[�ILº:�������

foÚ�ÛeÜÞÝ�ßaàZÝ"á5â­ßZãåä�Ý�Û�æLÝ&âèç�á�é=ê<ë�ì�í,îPï_ð9áZä�æLáNñ�ïHòZòaóZôZõZö�ï$÷�øåä�ä�ùúß

Page 3: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

��� 25476=@d8:B���Ծ6=2�8:4

�(\§K��S�³¶º��"I�[�[�³'S�¬HcV\RK(cV\RK5S�ILK5c°M|«5[�³'¦R\�º_UVM|«5UTM|U�c°\RK(F§S�FR¦HK5ILcV¯RIL½H[�cVMbW�K�c°\RK5S�ILºe©\RM|«L\eM¶FH«a³b¯HGJK¨U� ¯P[�F_cV¯R» ¼�I�[�W'M¶c�º�Y�UVS�»dK5cVMb»dKZU�«5[�³¶³bKZGÑ[�U:����c°\RK5S�ILº�¶���OÌ�(\§Këa¯RILILK5F_c=©�M´ULGJS�» [�ULUV¯R»dKZUec°\H[�ccV\RK5ILK�M|UDFRS7«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼Ã«aS�FHUVcÊ[�F�c5Y,[�FHG�©\H[�cVK5W�KNIe¦PKNILcV¯RIL½H[�cVM¶S�FocV\RK5S�ILº7M´U ¯HUVKZG¥G�K5¦HK5FHGRUµS�FÏcV\RK¦H[�ILcVM´«a¯R³|[�I�UVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�F7S�F§K=KN¿$¦H[�FHGRU"[�½PS�¯Rc5OD�(\RK=K5¿'¦P[�FHUVMbS�FĦH[�I�[�»dK5c°K5I"M|U"S�FRKeS�¬�c°\§K�¼�K5S�»dKNcVILM|««L\P[�I�[�«�cVK5ILM´UVcVM|«NU�S�¬(c°\§K:½P[�«L]'¼�ILS�¯§FHGTO���cDM´UµS�¬&UVS�»dK�M¶F�c°K5ILKZUVc"c°Sij¶S'S�]Ĭ�S�I=UVMb»d¦R³¶MúÀPK¨G7UVcVILM¶FR¼Ã[�FHGÀHK5³|G¥c°\§KNS�ILK5cVM´«9»dS_GJKN³|U5Y<©\§M´« \Ï\P[ZW�K0UVcVILMbFR¼Ä³¶S'S�¦ÑKN¿$¦H[�FHUVM¶S�F,Y<[�FHG�©\RK5ILKdc°\§KÃUVc°ILM¶FR¼7«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼«aS�FHUVcL[�F_c(\P[�U[=¼�K5S�»dK5c°ILM|«"M¶F�c°K5IL¦RILK5cL[�c°M¶S�F,O

�H����z|� �7�L}��'{���p�z|n�� z|����{�y����e���R��n��a�Q,[�IL¼�K�� ¼'[�¯R¼�K�c°\RK5S�ILM¶KZU�[�ILK(c°\§K»dS'UVc<¦HS�¦R¯§³´[�IZY�[�FHGÍc°\RK�»dS'UVc­K5³¶¯HUVM¶W�K(»:S�G�K5³´U²©M¶c°\0UVcVILMbFR¼

ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�F,Od��FªcV\RKd¼'[�¯R¼�K� �UVcVILMbFR¼ÄG�¯H[�³¶Mbc�º�� ���� ��1S�FRK�»0[�cL«L\RKZU c°\§KØ«aS�FRF§K¨«acVKZGª«aS�ILILKN³|[�cVMbS�F¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FPU(S�¬�cV\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILº0S�½HUVK5ILW�[�½§³bKZU1©M¶cV\7c°\RK=¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�FÓ¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FÄS�¬�c°\§K¾UVcVILMbF§¼�cV\RK5S�ILºM¶Fªc°\§K0½R¯R³¶]HO7�(\§KØ«a³¶S'UVKZGªUVc°ILM¶FR¼7G�¯H[�³1\H[�U X��� [�U=[7UVc°ILM¶FR¼o«aS�¯R¦R³¶M¶FR¼Â«aS�FHUVcL[�F�cNO7�"G�W�[�FP«�KZUeM¶FcV\RK�UVcV¯HG�M¶K¨U1S�¬<c°\§KDc�º'¦PK=�°�1UVc°ILM¶FR¼�«aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�À£«5[�cVMbS�FHU1S�F���[�³|[�½RMb����[�¯Ó»Ø[�F§Mú¬�S�³|GRU�³bKZGÓc°Sd[�FRS�c°\§KNI«a³´[�ULUÍS�¬D»:S�G�K5³´U5Y�©\RM|«L\ MbFÌcV\RKijbS�©��K5FRK5IL¼�ºo³¶Mb»dM¶c=ILKZG�¯H«aK0cVSo· ¸ �¥UV¯R¦PK5I�UVº'»d»dKNcVILM|«=¼'[�¯R¼�KcV\RK5S�ILMbKZU5YR©�MbcV\o[dFRS�W�K5³Tc�º'¦PK=S�¬�UVcVILMbF§¼:³¶S'S�¦7K5¿$¦H[�FHUVM¶S�F,O�"[�»dKN³¶º�YH«aK5ILcÊ[�M¶Fo«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼'U�� �ÍMbF7cV\RK³¶S�©���K5FRK5IL¼�º=KaÒTK¨«acVMbW�K=[�«ac°M¶S�F7[�ILK�¼�M¶W�K5F0½�º�cV\RKD¼�K5F�¯HU"!:¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�Fd¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�F0S�¬­cV\RKDcVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M|«N[�³¶³¶ºc�©�M´UVcVKZG7UVc°ILM¶FR¼dS�F#��[�³|[�½RM¶�$�1[�¯,O(�(\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�Ke¼�ILS�¯R¦7S�¬�c°\RKe· ¸ ��cV\RK5S�ILºÃG�S$KZU"FRS�c\P[ZW�Kec°SÓ½HKÇ=È$��Ée©M¶c°\¥³|[�IL¼�K%�¥O7��ceM´UeG�K5c°K5IL»dM¶FRKZGo½�º7cV\RKd¼�K5S�»:K5cVILºoS�¬&�([�³´[�½RM¶����[�¯o»0[�FRM�¬�S�³|G'�)(��O0�(\RKI�×S�³¶K�S�¬(KaÒ£KZ«ac°M¶W�K�UVcVILMbFR¼0«aS�¯R¦R³¶M¶FR¼dM´U�¦R³|[Zº�KZGĽ�ºÄc°\RK=W�K5WÄS�¬�cV\RK�¼�I�[�W'M¶¦R\RS�cVS�F0ÀPKN³|G7UVcVILKNF§¼�c°\*� #��Y©\§M´« \ÃM|U(¯HUV¯P[�³b³¶º:[�ULUV¯R»dKZGdcVSd½HK=«aS�FHUVcÊ[�F�c&� ���O

��F0cV\RM|U1¦H[�¦PKNI(©(KDUV\H[�³¶³PKN¿$¦R³|[�MbF0cV\H[�c(cV\RK5ILK"KN¿$M´UVcLU([=FP[�c°¯RI�[�³J¬�ILS�» cV\RKD¼'[�¯§¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILºd¦HS�M¶F�cS�¬�W$MbK5©?©[�ºocVS,+HKZUV\ªS�¯Rc=cV\RKZUVKëaS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼'U5Oo�(\RKÓM´G�KZ[�M´UecVS¥¦R¯Rcec°\RKÄcV\RK5S�ILºÏM¶FÅ[�FRS�F�cVILMbW$M´[�³¼�K5S�»dKNcVILM|«D½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFPGTY�©\RM|«L\7©(K=¦§ILK¨UVK5F�cV³bºÃGJK¨UL«aILM¶½HK�O-��S�FHUVM|G�K5I�[�F�ºÃQ S�ILK5F_c/.5��MbF�W�[�ILM|[�F�c1ÀHK5³´GcV\RK5S�ILº7MbF10¥G�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FHU5O9%'¯R¦§¦HS'UVK=cV\RKdc°\§KNS�ILºo«5[�F¥½PK:S�½§cÊ[�M¶FRKZG�½_º32e[�³¶¯4.Z[��52 ³¶KNM¶F7ILKZG�¯H«acVMbS�F¬�ILS�» UVS�»dK�c°\RK5S�ILº=M¶F6087Ù��G�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FHU5O,��F0[�GRGJMbcVMbS�F�Y'UV¯R¦R¦PS'UVK(c°\§K�cV\RK5S�ILº=M¶F�0�7ª�GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FHU\H[�Gd[e¼�³¶S�½H[�³HUVº'»d»dK5c°ILº=¼�ILS�¯§¦:9¥O1��S�© «aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�¬�º�cV\RK&0;7Å��G�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³$c°\RK5S�ILº9S�FÃ[�«aM¶I�«a³bK* X S�¬�«aM¶I�«�¯§»�¬�K5ILK5FH«aK&<�YP©M¶c°\o[Íc�©M|UVc5YHUVS�cV\H[�c�MbFļ�S�MbF§¼:[�ILS�¯RFHGÓcV\RK¾«aM¶I�«a³bK�Y�cV\RK¾UV¦P[�«�K5��cVMb»dK�@�=K5¿'¦PK5ILMbK5FH«aKZUD[0Q S�ILKNF�c/.=ILS�cÊ[�cVM¶S�F,YP½_º7[�FoK5³¶K5»:K5F�c"K5¿'¦=È$<?>"É�Y,[�FHG�MbF¥[�GRG�M¶c°M¶S�Fo[d¤ Mb³|UVS�Fo³¶MbF§K�M¶FcV\RK�¼�ILS�¯R¦#9¥Y,K5¿$¦�È�<Z-ÄÉ"M|UDcV¯RILFRKZG7S�F�O��(\RK9ILKZUV¯R³bcVM¶FR¼0cV\RK5S�ILºo«N[�F�½HKdFRS�©Ö«�S�FPUVM´G�K5ILKZGÄM¶FÏcV\RK<A@ � ³¶Mb»dM¶cNY�©�\RK5ILK(¬�S�I<ÀPFRMbcVK >-BL- ©(K1ÀHFHGÍKN¿$c°I�[=«aS�¯R¦§³bM¶FR¼'U�MbFdcV\RK 0J��GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³'Q,[�¼�I�[�FR¼�M|[�F,O�(\§M´U"M|U c°\RKd½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFPGÄ©(K:UV\H[�³¶³<KN¿$c°K5FHUVM¶W�K5³bº�¯HUVK�M¶F¥c°\§K�¦H[�¦PK5IZO:��S�ILK�UV¦HKZ«aMúÀT«N[�³¶³¶º7©(K:UV\H[�³¶³½PK�»dS'UVc°³¶ºÄMbF�cVKNILKZUVcVKZG7M¶FÏcV\RKͬ�S�¯RI�G�M¶»dKNFPUVMbS�FH[�³P· ¸ �Óc°\§KNS�ILM¶KZU5O=�(\RK5ºo[�³¶³²«5[�F¥½PK�W'M¶K5©(KZGo[�U

Page 4: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

G�M¶»dKNFPUVMbS�FH[�³�ILK¨GJ¯H«ac°M¶S�FHU S�¬�· ¸ �0UV¯PUVºÏ¼'[�¯§¼�K:cV\RK5S�ILM¶K¨U¾¬�ILS�» UVMb¿¥S�IeÀHW�KÃGJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FHU5O7�(\RK¼�³¶S�½H[�³,UVº'»d»dK5c°ILºd¼�ILS�¯R¦�9 M|U��1ǾÈ��$É�È�����UVº'»d»dKNcVILºRÉLO

�(\§K¨UVK=«aS�FHUVM|G�K5I�[�c°M¶S�FHU(³¶KZ[�G7cVS0¦PS�©(K5IV¬�¯R³�ILK¨UV¯§³bcLU"«�S�FP«�K5ILFRM¶FR¼dK5¿_[�«ac"FRS�FR��¦PKNILcV¯RIL½H[�cVM¶W�K¾«5[�³¶�«a¯R³|[�c°M¶S�FHU=M¶FÌcV\RKÂUV¯§¦HK5I�UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«9¼'[�¯R¼�K0cV\RK5S�ILMbKZU5OÌ��FѦH[�ILcVM´«a¯R³|[�IZY�S�FRK7[�ILILM¶W�K¨U=[�c9c°\§KÃcVKZ«L\R�FRM � ¯RKeS�¬�G�K5ILM¶W'M¶FR¼�KaÒTKZ«�cVM¶W�K�¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�c°M|[�³|U(S�¬�cV\RK · ¸ �0UV¯HUVºd¼'[�¯R¼�K=cV\RK5S�ILMbKZU&©M¶c°\�c°\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�K¼�ILS�¯R¦HUÍÇ=È$� X É���������ªÇ=È$� = É%�� DÈ˽H[�UVKZG¥S�F � ���� )���b�5����¶����5�¶�5��5�¶�5���Y,UVK5KÃ[�³´UVS�ILK5³´[�cVKZG¥©(S�IL]oM¶F�¶��(�5�¶�5#�5�¶�5����b�� ËÉÊO(��ILK5W'M¶S�¯HUV³bº�Y§c°\RKeKaÒ£KZ«acVMbW�K9³bS�©��K5FRK5IL¼�º0[�«�cVM¶S�Fo[�FHGÄc°\§K�«�S�ILILKZUV¦PS�FHG�M¶FR¼=¦RILK5¦PS��cVKNF�cVM´[�³������oÈ���É�©[�U(G�K5cVK5IL»:M¶FRKZG9¯HUVM¶FR¼�cV\RK�«aS�FHUVcVI�[�M¶F_cLU�S�¬,\RS�³bS�»dS�IL¦R\�º=[�FHGdK5³¶K¨«acVILS���»Ø[�¼�F§KNcVM|«G�¯H[�³¶M¶c�º3�b������b�5)��� �����O�Dz ���R������{�p�z|�9z|�Lp=z|����{�y����e���R��n��a�� FRK�S�¬cV\RK0¼�S'[�³|UDS�¬cV\RKd¦RILKZUVK5F�cD¦H[�¦PKNIeM|Uec°S7K5¿'cVK5FHG c°\RKd»dK5c°\§S_G�� �cVS7¼�KNc=cV\RK0«aS�ILILK5�³|[�c°M¶S�F7¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FHU"S�¬1· ¸ � qa�'z|��{�~ S�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U5Oe�(\RM|U"M|U"K � ¯RM¶W�[�³¶KNF�c"cVSÂUVS�³¶W'M¶FR¼d¬�S�IDcV\RK9K�ÒTKZ«ac°M¶W�K¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�c°M|[�³RS�¬,cV\RK�· ¸ �DcV\RK5S�ILº�©�\RS'UVK»dM|«aILS'UL«�S�¦§M´«1¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³,È�UVK5K%�¶�����¬�S�I�M¶F�c°ILS�G�¯H«acVMbS�FM¶F0· ¸ �9UV¯HUVºRÉ�M|U�¼�MbW�K5FĽ_º��

�����Ù¸�� �Z��I�! ^ 7#"%$& � $&(')*�+ X, �- ��I�! */. &10 ÈL�2�´��É

©\§KNILK435 ¸ÖÈ 5 X B 5 ^ B����6��É(³´[�½PK5³­[�³¶³,¦PS'ULUVMb½§³bKD¼'[�¯§¼�KN��M¶F�W�[�ILM´[�F�c1¦HS�³¶º'F§S�»:M|[�³|U1MbF7cV\RK�[�GZ®VS�M¶F�cM¶¼�¼'UÀHK5³|G7!ÐÈËFRS�cVKcV\H[�c8�9�;: X : �;:=<=<><�UV\RM�¬�cÊU8� ��ÉLO�QTK5c?3@ ¸3ÈÊ��BL� BL� B����6��ÉLYBAC35 Aå¸ED * 5 * Y�[�FHGF35HG 3@ ¸ID * - 5 * O

��F�S�I�G�K5I"¬�S�IDcV\RK�cV\RK5S�ILºoG�KaÀHFRKZG7½�ºªÈL��O´��É�c°S7[ZW�S�M|G7W�[�FRM´UV\§MbFR¼dS�¬(c°\§K:UVKZ«aS�FHG¥G�K5ILMbW�[�cVM¶W�K¨US�¬�¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³£[�c�³´[�IL¼�K9È � ¯H[�UVM´«a³|[�ULUVM´«5[�³ËÉ�W�[�³¶¯RKZU(S�¬�c°\§K¾�M¶¼�¼'U1ÀHK5³|G

J !LKNMPOQ�7RTSUOWV ^ XZY\[^] ÈL�2� �$É[�FHGeFRS�c<cVS"IL¯RF=MbF�cVSDUVc°ILS�FR¼D«aS�¯R¦R³¶M¶FR¼�UVM¶FR¼�¯R³|[�ILMbc�ºÁY5cV\RK«aS�¯R¦R³¶M¶FR¼'U�� $& UV\RS�¯R³|G ½HK(cVILKZ[�c°KZG ¬�S�IL»0[�³b³¶º�O� FRKëaS�¯R³|GÅ[�³|UVSo©(S�ILILºª[�½PS�¯Rc=c°\§KÃFRS�F§ILKNF§S�IL»Ø[�³¶M .¨[�½§Mb³úc�º7S�¬µcV\RKĦHK5ILcV¯RIL½H[�cVMbS�F ÈÊ��O|��ÉÊOÌ�&\RM´UÍM´U[�«ac°¯P[�³b³¶ºÌFRS�c7UVSRY¦RILS�W'M|G�KZGÌcV\RK¥«�S�F�®V¯R¼'[�c°K¥¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³ � M|U0]�K5¦Rcëa³|[�ULUVM´«5[�³ � � ��I ! ^ O �(\RK[�«ac°M¶S�F7M|U(FRSd³¶S�FR¼�K5IILKZ[�³�Y�\§S�©(K5W�K5IZY�c°\§K�KaÒTK¨«acVMbW�K�GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FHU�S�¬1c°\RK ÀHK5³|GRU�! [�FPG ! ½PKZ«aS�»:K=�[�FHGÄ��Y�c°\§KNILK5½�ºD®V¯HUVcVMú¬�º$MbFR¼0[�FÄMbFJÀHFRM¶c°KDF�¯R»9½HK5I1S�¬�c°K5IL»0U1MbFªÈL��O|��ÉÊO

¤¥K�UV\§S�¯R³´GeF§S�c°K1c°\P[�c²«a³|[�ULUVM´«5[�³¶³bº c°\RK5ILK[�ILK1ILK5³´[�cVMbS�FPUT½PKNc�©(KNK5F9c°\RKGJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�FPUT¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°KZG½�ºÏG�K5ILM¶W�[�cVMbW�KZUe©�O IZO cNO_� $& Y<©\§M´« \ªS�ILMb¼�M¶FH[�cVK�M¶FªcV\RKd¬�[�«ac=c°\P[�c=c°\RK5ILKÃ[�ILKd¦PS�³bº$FRS�»dM´[�³�ILKN³|[�cVMbS�FHU½PKNc�©(KNK5F¹cV\RKÏUVM¶FR¼�³¶KN��cVI�[�«aK7S�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U0��I9! * ¬�S�I`-ba � [�FHG c°\§Ko»�¯§³bcVMb¦§³bK5��c°I�[�«aKÄS�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U5O¤ \§KNF¥M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU"[�ILK=M¶FH«a³b¯HGJK¨G�c°\§K¨UVKd«a³´[�ULUVM|«5[�³,ILK5³´[�cVM¶S�FHUD[�ILK�»dS�G�MúÀPK¨G O���c�UVK5K5»0UD«aS�F�W�KNF§MbK5F�c

Page 5: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

cVS0]�K5KN¦o[�³¶³8� $& [�U"M¶FHG�K5¦PK5FHG�K5F�c«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼'U5O(�(\§K�«�³|[�ULUVM|«N[�³T¦§ILKN¦PS�cVKNF�cVM´[�³�c°\§KNF�S�½HK5º�U�[�G§G�MbcVM¶S�FH[�³«aS�FHUVcVI�[�MbF�cLU��,cV\RK �Ä��M¶FHG�K5¦PK5FHG�K5F�c�FRS�F§��³¶M¶FRKZ[�I(S�FRKZU��

�� � $& � ��� ¸ � =� � $&�� ���6� � � $&�� � ��� B 35 ¸ 35 X 7Q���6� 35 = ÈL�2� �$É[�FHGÓc°\§K �Ä��G�K5¦PKNFPG�K5F_c1³¶MbFRKZ[�I�S�FRKZU��

"$&�� $&�� $� + � = È��¾��É� $& �� � $& � ��� ¸ � B 0�aÌ� ÈL�2� (�É

�(\§K � ¯P[�F_cV¯R» KaÒTK¨«acVMbW�KÓ¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F_cVM|[�³­S�½PK5º_UeM¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FÏ«aS�ILILKZ«ac°KZG¥«aS�FHUVcVI�[�MbF�cLU �¶�5���Y,©�\RM´« \o©(KM¶»:¦§³bM|«aMbcV³bº0G�K5cVK5IL»:M¶FRK"M¶FÃcV\RM|U¦P[�¦HK5IZO

��n��§��{'q¨���V���a�=p�(\§K�«�S�FPUVc°I�[�M¶F�cÊU�S�¬(\RS�³bS�»dS�IL¦R\�ºÃ[�FPG7K5³bKZ«acVILS���»0[�¼�FRK5cVM´«=GJ¯H[�³bM¶c�º7[�ILK=¦HS�©(K5IV¬�¯R³<K5FRS�¯R¼�\ocVS

G�K5cVKNIL»dM¶FRKDcV\RK=KaÒ£KZ«acVMbW�K=³¶S�©���KNF§KNIL¼�º9¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³ �����ÌÈ�UVK5K6�b�5��ËÉÊY§¯R¦7cVSÃ[dG�MúÒTK5S�»dS�IL¦R\RM|UV»ES�¬cV\RK0«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼'U�� $& Y�M�O K�Od¯R¦¥c°So«aS�F�cÊ[�«acec°K5IL»0U5Od��FªS�I�G�K5IDcVSÄÀH¿ocV\RKd¦RILKZ«aM´UVK=»0[�¦R¦§MbFR¼Ó½HK5c�©(K5K5FcV\RK"»:M|«aILS'UL«aS�¦RM´«�«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼'U&È�©�\RM´« \d©(Kµ[�³|UVS�«5[�³b³��Vc°M¶»dK¨U���Y$M¶FÃ[�«5«�S�I�G§[�FH«aK©M¶cV\0c°\§K�cVK5IL»dMbFRS�³¶S�¼�º[�G�S�¦RcVKZG9MbFdM¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�½R³¶K�UVº_UVcVK5»0UaÉ­[�FHG9c°\§K�»0[�«aILS'UL«aS�¦RM|«1S�FRKZU5Y'S�FRK�FRK5KZGRU�»dS�ILK�ILK�ÀPFRKZG�»dK5cV\RS_GRUÈ�UVKNK �b�5�� ¬�S�IDcV\RK:G�M|UL«a¯HULUVM¶S�FÃS�¬�cV\RKd«�S�F�cL[�«ac�cVK5IL»0UD[�FHGÄcV\RK5MbIDILK5³|[�c°M¶S�FocVS0cV\RK�cVS�¦PS�³bS�¼�ºÄS�¬�cV\RK«aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�À£«5[�c°M¶S�FHU9S�¬�cV\RK7»dS_G�¯§³bM"UV¦H[�«aK¨UaÉLO �"Ud©(KoUV\H[�³¶³K5¿'¦§³´[�M¶F M¶FÌc°\§M´Ud¦P[�¦HK5IZY(cV\RKoG�M¶ILKZ«�cM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�Fë5[�³´«a¯R³¶¯HU&M´U&¦HS�©(K5IV¬�¯R³HK5FRS�¯§¼�\ÃcVS:UVS�³¶W�K"¬�S�I;� ��� �

� ��� È��4B � $& É�¸*� ��� È���� � ��É 7 " $& � $&�� $& È���É 7 " $& : $� � $& � $��� $& $� È���É 7Q����� ÈL�2� #$É©\§KNILK

� $& È���É1¸ � ')*�+ X, �- ��I ! * . &10 � M ÈL�2� �$É

©\§Mb³¶K � $& $� [�ILK1cV\RK(K5¿'¦PK¨«acL[�c°M¶S�FdW�[�³¶¯RKZU,S�¬Pc°\RK«aS�F�cL[�«�c<cVK5IL»ØU�½PK5c�©(K5KNF � $& [�FPG � $� �b�5���� �R���� �����O

��y�{�~Pp�����z|� �Ó�Ë�R��n���z��Lp¤¥KÂUV\P[�³b³([�IL¼�¯RK0cV\H[�cdc°\§Kü�K5FRK5I�[�³¶M .5KZG¥M¶FÌc°\RM|U=©[�º¥¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³DÈÊ��OÞ#$ÉLY(©\RM|«L\ÑM|U�[�³|UVSÏ[

¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶FR¼e¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FÃS�¬<c°\RKe«�S�ILILK5³|[�c°S�I�U�S�¬²« \RM¶I�[�³HS�½HUVK5ILW�[�½§³bKZU5Y$M´U1K5FH«aS_GJK¨GÓM¶FÃ[�«aK5ILcÊ[�M¶F7UVc°ILM¶FR¼�º¦H[�ILcVMbcVM¶S�FĬ�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�F,O(¤¥K�UV\H[�³¶³­GJKN»dS�FHUVcVI�[�cVKDc°\P[�c�cV\RK=¼�K5FRK5I�[�cVMbFR¼Í¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�F�S�¬²cV\RK=K5¿'¦PKZ«acÊ[�cVMbS�FW�[�³¶¯RKZUDS�¬cV\RK0«L\§MbI�[�³<S�½HUVK5ILW�[�½R³¶KZU"M¶FÏcV\RK0UV¦PK¨«aM|[�³<· ¸E�7UV¯R¦HK5IL¼�I�[�W'M¶c�ºÄ½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHG7[�ILKd¼�MbW�K5F½�ºocV\RK0K5¿'¦PS�FRK5F�c°M|[�³1S�¬�cV\RKÃ[�³¶³b��¼�K5F�¯HU"¦H[�ILcVMbcVM¶S�F¥¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FªS�¬"c°\§K0c°S�¦PS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³(UVc°ILM¶FR¼RO7�RS�I=cV\RK

Page 6: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

�$Ç=ÈÊ��É �ªcV\RK5S�ILºÌcV\RKÏG�¯P[�³�UVcVILMbFR¼ ³bM¶W�KZUdS�F Õ X È�����»dS�G�K5³�ÉLOÖ�,S ¦RILS�W�KÄcV\RM´UØ©(KoUV\H[�³b³"¯HUVK7cV\RKILKZ«aKNF�cDILKZUV¯R³¶cLU"S�¬&�eO � ]�S�¯RFR]�S�W7[�FHG ��OT��[�FPG�\H[�ILM¶¦H[�FHG�KD©�\RSÄILKN³|[�cVK¨G�cV\RK�¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�F7¬�¯§FH«ac°M¶S�FS�¬�c°\§K�cVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M|«N[�³,UVcVILM¶FR¼=S�F¥Ô¾Õ X ©�MbcV\7cV\RKDcL[�¯R�ˬ�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FÄS�¬²cV\RK=��S_GR[ͳ´[�cVc°M|«aK�\§MbK5I�[�I�«L\�º�O<�(\RKK5¿'¦RILKZULUVM¶S�FÃS�¬1c°\RKe¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶FR¼9¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�F7S�¬1c°\RK=«L\§MbI�[�³TS�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U�cV\RILS�¯R¼�\Äc°\RK=cL[�¯R�ˬ�¯RFH«acVMbS�FPU(S�¬[�FÄMbF�cVKN¼�I�[�½§³bK�UVº�UVc°K5»?M|U[dUVcVI�[�Mb¼�\�c�¬�S�IL©[�I�G9¼�KNF§KNI�[�³¶M .¨[�cVM¶S�F0S�¬�c°\RKeK5¿'¦PK5ILMb»dK5F�cÊ[�³¶³bºd©(K5³¶³b��]'F§S�©�FILK5³´[�cVM¶S�F=½HK5c�©(K5K5F=c°\§K%'K5M¶½HK5IL¼���¤ M¶cVc°K5F=¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�c°M|[�³|U,[�FHG � ¯H[�UVM´«a³|[�ULUVM´«5[�³�cL[�¯R�ˬ�¯RFH«acVMbS�FHU � ����PÈ�UVK5K[�³|UVS � ��(��[�FHG�ILKa¬�K5ILK5FH«aK¨Uµc°\RK5ILK5M¶FTÉÊO=�§S�IDcV\RK�cL[�¯R�ˬ�¯RFH«acVMbS�F�¼�MbW$MbFR¼Óc°\RK9¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶FR¼d¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�F7¬�S�IcV\RK�«aS�ILILK5³´[�cVS�I�U�S�¬�«L\RM¶I�[�³RS�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U1©(K"©M¶³¶³H¦RILKZUVK5F�c�[ÍFH[�cV¯RI�[�³RILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�FdM¶F0c°K5IL»0U1S�¬,¬�ILK5K¬�K5IL»dMbS�FRM|«�S�I�½HS'UVS�F§M´«(UVº�UVc°K5»7O,¤¥K�c°\RM¶FR]ec°\§M´U<M|U�[DUV¯§½HUVcÊ[�F�cVM´[�³�UVc°K5¦9c°S�©[�I�GRU�c°\§K¯RFHGJKNI�UVcL[�FHG�M¶FR¼cV\RK�¦§\_º�UVM´«5[�³PS�ILMb¼�M¶F0S�¬�cV\RK�ILKZUV¯R³¶cLU1S�¬8� �����O� FRK�»0[�º0cV\RMbF§]ÃcV\H[�cDcV\RM|UILKZUV¯R³¶cM|U"º�K5cD[�FRS�cV\RK5I�K5¿�[�»:¦§³bK=S�¬�cV\RK=³¶S_«5[�³<»dMbILILS�I"UVº'»d»dKNcVILº�)(��O"¤¥K�UV\RS�¯R³|G7UVcVILK¨ULU�\RK5ILKec°\P[�cDMbc"M|U"½�º0FRS0»dKZ[�FHU�S�½�W'M¶S�¯HU5O"��FHG�K5KZGTYH[ئHS�©(K5IV¬�¯R³,»dK5c°\§S_G7cVSK5»�½PKZG7· ¸E�ļ'[�¯R¼�K9c°\RK5S�ILM¶KZUDM¶F�c°S7UVc°ILM¶FR¼Äc°\§KNS�ILº7M|U ½_º¥«aS�FHUVM´GJKNILM¶FR¼dc�º$¦HK0�V�DUVc°ILM¶FR¼ÄS�F¥³bS�«N[�³��[�³|[�½RM¶����[�¯7»0[�FRMú¬�S�³|GRU5OD��³¶»:S'UVcD[�³¶³<S�¬�cV\RK=ILKZUV¯R³¶cÊU"S�½§cÊ[�M¶FRKZGÄMbF�c°\§M´U"©[�º7«N[�F�½HK9W'M¶K5©(K¨G�[�UD[G�K5¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶S�F=S�¬HcV\RK(cV\RK5S�ILº�©�\RM´« \=K5¿'M|UVcÊU�¬�S�I�¼�³bS�½H[�³�Y�«aS�»d¦H[�«ac ��[�³|[�½RM¶�$�1[�¯=»Ø[�F§Mú¬�S�³|GRU5O,��F=S�cV\RK5I©(S�I�GRU5Y�S�FRK�[�ULUV¯§»:KZUPcV\H[�c<c°\§K(¼'[�¯R¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILº=G�KZ«�S�¯§¦R³bKZU£¬�ILS�»3¼�I�[�W'M¶c�ºD[�FHGeK5¿_«aM¶c°KZG�UVcVILM¶FR¼"»:S�G�KZU5Y©\§KNF c°\RK���[�³|[�½RMb����[�¯¥M|U=[�½HS�¯§c=c°SoG�K5W�K5³¶S�¦HKÃUVS�»dK0UVM¶FR¼�¯R³|[�ILMbc�º�Y,[�FPG¥c°\§K0¼�³bS�½P[�³�UVc°IL¯P«�cV¯RILKdS�¬��[�³|[�½RM¶����[�¯oM|U"FRS�cDILK5³¶K5W�[�F�c ��½R¯RcDM¶FocV\RM|UD©[�ºÄS�FRK:«5[�FRFRS�c ILK¨[�³¶³¶ºÂG�M|UL«a¯HULU"cV\RK�\§Mb¼�\RK5I �([�UVMb»dM¶IG�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHU1ÈL��O´��ÉLO��S�©(K5W�K5IZY�c°\RK(»0[�M¶F�«a³´[�M¶»ÖM´U�cV\RK5ILK1�,cV\RK¦§ILKN¦PS�cVKNF�cVM´[�³$S�¬HcV\RK¼'[�¯R¼�K1cV\RK5S�ILºÁY[�U"©(K5³¶³­[�U"cV\RK=\RM¶¼�\RK5ID«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼'U8� � Y£[�ILK=¼�M¶W�K5Fo½�º0cV\RK�cVS�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³­UVcVILMbFR¼Ä[�»:¦§³bM¶c°¯PG�KZU(S�FocV\RK³¶S_«5[�³ �([�³´[�½RM¶����[�¯,O

�ˬ,cV\RKD³¶S_«5[�³ ��[�³|[�½RMb����[�¯dM|U(«5[�F0½HK W'M¶KN©(KZG0[�U([=GJKN¼�K5FRK5I�[�cVMbS�FdS�¬<c°\RKD«aS�»d¦H[�«ac��([�³´[�½§Mb����[�¯cV\RK5F7S�FRK¾UVM¶»d¦R³¶º0cÊ[�]�KZU�cV\RK=³bM¶»dMbc(S�¬1c°\RK=«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHGJMbFR¼=cVS�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³²UVcVILM¶FR¼:[�»d¦R³¶MbcV¯HG�KZU È�KaÒTK¨«a�cVMbW�K5³¶ºÂ[�³¶³,M¶ILILK5³bK5W�[�F�c�2��[�\R³bK5I"«�³|[�ULUVKZU�MbFÄc°\§K����»dS_GJKN³<[�ILK¾UVK5F�ccVSdMbFJÀHFRM¶c�º�YR[�FHGÄc°\§K=©(S�IL³´GRUV\§KNK5cM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU"G�S0FRS�c ]'FRS�© [�½PS�¯RcDcV\RK5» �T\RS�©(K5W�KNIZYPS�FRK=\P[�U"c°SÄILK5FRS�IL»0[�³bM .5K�cV\RK .NK5ILS0M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FUVKZ«ac°S�I"³¶KNW�K5³�c°K5IL»ÄÉÊO���F7c°\§M´U"«5[�UVK�S�F§K¾«5[�F,Y§MbF7¦RILM¶FH«aM¶¦R³bK�Y$cÊ[�]�K=cV\RKe»dMbILILS�I(cV\RK5S�ILº�YRcV\RK�±1��»:S�G�K5³S�Fo[0G�¯P[�³ ��[�³|[�½RM¶����[�¯7»0[�FRMú¬�S�³|GTYR[�FHG�c°ILºÄcVS0¦HK5IV¬�S�IL» c°\§K�[�FH[�³bS�¼�S�¯PUG�K5¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶S�F7cV\RK5ILK�� (��YcV\RM´Ue©[�ºoK5W�K5Fª³¶KZ[�GRUec°SoUVS�»dKdK � ¯H[�cVM¶S�FHUeS�F1� ��� U6� ��#��O7�S�©(KNW�K5IZY�c°\§KÃUVMbcV¯H[�cVMbS�F \RK5ILK:M|UeUVc°M¶³b³¯RFHUL[�cVM|U�¬�[�«�cVS�ILº�O��§S�IDcV\RK=¼�³bS�½P[�³ �([�³´[�½§Mb����[�¯��ÞU�c°\§K�©\§S�³bK�UV¯R» D � � ���� ^ � ^ M´UµM´G�K5F�cVMúÀHKZGÄ©�MbcV\cV\RKd³bS�¼'[�ILM¶c°\§» S�¬c°\RKd¦H[�ILcVM¶c°M¶S�F�¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�F¥S�¬c°\§K:KaÒTKZ«�cVM¶W�K ��«a³¶S'UVKZGÏUVcVILM¶FR¼0ÀPKN³|G�c°\§KNS�ILº ���ocV\RK2 S_GR[�M¶I�[��V%'¦HK5FH«aK5IDcV\RK5S�ILº'� �����S�FªcV\RK0±1��UVM´G�K ��[�³|[�½RM¶�$�1[�¯Ï»0[�FRM�¬�S�³|GTO0��S�c°\RM¶FR¼ÄS�¬�cV\RM|U�UVS�ILceM´U]'F§S�©�F0¬�S�I�c°\RK=G�K5¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶S�FHU(«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FPG�MbF§¼�cVSd³bS�«N[�³"��[�³|[�½RM¶�$�1[�¯�� U�S�FÄc°\RK=����UVM´G�K�O� ¯RID«�S�F�cVILMb½§¯Rc°M¶S�FÄc°SÄc°\§K:UV¯R½�®VK¨«ac"M|U"c°\§K=M´G�K5F�cVMúÀ£«5[�cVMbS�F7S�¬(cV\RK�[�FH[�³¶S�¼�¯RK�S�¬(cV\RK%2 S_GR[�M¶I�[��%'¦PK5FH«aKNI�c°\RK5S�ILº�Y�[�c�³bKZ[�UVc�M¶F�cV\RKDUV¦PK¨«aM�À£«(«aS�F�c°K5¿'c1©(K(¬�S�«a¯HU�S�F9MbFdcV\RM|U�¦H[�¦PK5IZO­�&\RM|U<M´U5Yå©(K�«a³´[�M¶»7Y

(

Page 7: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

cV\RK�¬�ILKNK�¬�K5IL»dMbS�F§M´« È�S�I�¬�ILK5K�½PS'UVS�FRM|«�É­cV\RK5S�ILº�S�F0[ ��MbK5»0[�FRFdUV¯RIV¬�[�«aK�È�[�U(UV¦R\RK5ILK(¬�S�I�ǾÈL��É�¼'[�¯R¼�K¼�ILS�¯R¦TÉLY$©M¶c°\oUVS�»dK�UV¦PKZ«�M�À£«��¹��½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHG9cV¯RILFRKZG0S�F�O

�7S�ILK5S�W�K5IZY�©(K"\H[�W�K�[�³|UVS=UVS�»:K5cV\RM¶FR¼DFRK5© S�FdcV\RKD����UVM|G�K�O���c1M´U�S�¬­«aS�¯RI�UVKF§S�c�cV\RK�ÀHI�UVc�cVMb»dK©\§KNFÑcV\RKÃ�P[�FRS7W�[�ILM¶KNcVM¶K¨U9[�¦R¦PK¨[�I=M¶FÑc°\RKÄ«�S�F�cVK5¿'c�S�¬"³bS�«5[�³(»:M¶ILILS�I=UVº'»d»dKNcVILº�OÏ�S�©(K5W�KNIZY<cV\RKcVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³,UVcVILMbF§¼�[�»:¦§³bM¶c°¯PG�KZU5Y_«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FPG�MbF§¼Dc°SdcV\RKD³¶S_«5[�³ �([�³´[�½§Mb����[�¯0G�S9FRS�c�«aS�M¶FH«aM´G�K"©�MbcV\cV\RS'UVK�¬�S�I��P[�FRSRYZK5W�K5F�M�¬Rc°\§K[�«�cV¯H[�³$©(S�IL³´GRUV\§KNK5cTM¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU ³´[�FHGeS�F��P[�FRS"UV¯R½�W�[�ILMbK5c�º"M¶F=c°\§K(³bS�«N[�³��[�³|[�½RM¶����[�¯,O,�§S�I�K5¿_[�»d¦R³¶K�Y�cV\RK�ILK¨UVS�³¶W�KZG=«aS�FRMú¬�S�³|GeM|U<c°\§K � È��=��É�� � È��¾��ÉT½R¯§FHG�³¶K�S�W�K5I(Ô¾Õ X Y�[�³b³©(S�IL³|GRUV\RK5K5c­M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FHU²³´[�FHG9M¶FÄÔ¾Õ X ÈË©\§M´« \:M|U1�H[�FRS�ÉLY�º�K5c1c°\RK"cVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M|«N[�³PUVc°ILM¶FR¼�[�»d¦R³¶MbcV¯HG�K�M´U[�ÒTK¨«acVKZG0½�º�cV\RK;.5K5ILS=»:S�G�KZU1S�¬,c°\§K"¬�K5IL»:M¶S�FHU5Y�«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHGJMbFR¼ c°S9c°\RK"FRS�IL»0[�³HGJMbILKZ«ac°M¶S�FHU5O<�(\RKZUVK.5K5ILS�»dS_G�KZU1»0[�]�K"c°\§K�«aS�F_cVILM¶½R¯RcVMbS�FHU�S�¬²[�³¶³P¦HS'UVM¶c°M¶W�KD¼�\RS'UVc1F�¯R»�½PK5I�S�½PUVKNILW�[�½R³bKZU�S�¬­cVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M|«N[�³UVcVILMbFR¼9S�FÂ�P[�FRS=W�[�F§M´UV\Ä©\RK5F7�H[�F§S�M|U(K5»�½PKZGRG�KZGdM¶F_cVS6�([�³´[�½§Mb����[�¯,O

��F0S�¯§I�«5[�UVK�Y�\RS�©(KNW�K5IZY�©(K"¼�K5c(³¶MbcVK5I�[�³b³¶º:UVcVILMbF§¼'U�S�F7Ô=Õ X O��(\RM|U1»dS_G�K5³PM´U1»9¯H«L\9ILM´« \RK5I�cV\RK5FcV\RKÃUVcVILMbFR¼'UeS�FÑ«�S�F§Mú¬�S�³|GTO¥��FŦP[�ILc°M|«a¯R³´[�IZY<[�U=©(K0UV\RS�©�Y<cV\RK0¼�I�[�W'M¶cL[�c°M¶S�FH[�³(G�KZUL«�K5FHG§[�F_cLUeS�¬�cV\RK2��[�\R³bK5I«a³|[�ULU(S�¬(Ô¾Õ X [�ILK=G�¯H[�³PcVS:cV\RKe\RM¶¼�\RK5I;��[�UVM¶»:M¶I�U1M¶FÃcV\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�KDcV\RK5S�ILºÁO

��c1¼�S'KZU1©M¶cV\RS�¯Rc(UL[Zº$MbFR¼ c°\H[�c(K5»9½HKZGRG�M¶FR¼DS�¯§I�¦RM|«ac°¯§ILKM¶F:cV\RKD¼�K5FRK5I�[�³HUVcVS�ILº=S�¬,³¶S_«5[�³H»dM¶ILILS�IUVº'»d»dK5c°ILºe©M¶³¶³_½PK(½PKNF§K�ÀT«�M|[�³$¬�S�I�½PS�c°\,O���F�¦H[�ILcVM´«a¯R³|[�IZY � �����K5¿'¦R³|[�MbFPU<\RS�©ªc°\§KcVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³RUVcVILMbFR¼[�»d¦R³¶MbcV¯HG�KZU"[�ILM´UVK=[�U"cV\RK�¦§\_º�UVM´«5[�³,UVcVILMbF§¼Ã[�»d¦R³bM¶cV¯HG�KZU(©�MbcV\¥c°\RK=M¶FHUVK5ILcVMbS�F7S�¬�?!æPS�©(K5I�U�S�¬�cV\RKUV¯R¼�I�[Ó¤¥KNº$³(»�¯R³¶cVMb¦R³¶K5c�� Y�cV\RKdW�KNILcVK5¿¥S�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U ¬�S�I�� KaÒTK¨«acVMbW�K5³¶ºªc�©�M´UVcVMbF§¼7c°\RKÓ©(S�IL³´GRUV\§KNK5ccV\RK5S�ILºÁO<¤¥K"«�³|[�M¶»EcV\H[�c�cV\RK�c°S�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³HUVcVILMbFR¼ ©M¶c°\0cV\RK�¼�I�[ZW$MbcL[�c°M¶S�FH[�³RG�KZUL«aK5FHGR[�F�cÊU&È�©�\RM´« \:[�ILK«aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«ac°KZG=©�MbcV\�cV\RK�\RK5³b¦9S�¬£cV\RK(ÀPKN³|GRU<S�¬Pc°S�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³R¼�I�[�W'M¶c�ºRÉT\H[�W�KG�M¶ILK¨«ac�[�FHG9«�³¶KZ[�I�¦R\�º_UVM|«5[�³»dKZ[�FRMbF§¼:S�F�c°\§K�¼'[�¯R¼�K=cV\RK5S�ILºÂUVM|G�K�OD¤¥KdG�S0FRS�c"]'F§S�©Ö[�cDcV\RK=»dS�»:K5F�c\§S�©.c°SÄK5»�½PKZGÄc°\RK5»M¶FÃcV\RK ¬�I�[�»:K5©(S�IL]9S�¬8� �����O�S�©(K5W�K5I©(K�UV\H[�³¶³T»0[�]�K�[�UV¯§¼�¼�K¨UVcVM¶S�F,O

� � �å{��Rz�5{���z|n��ªnV�¾�Ë�R� �å{��R����(\§K=¦H[�¦HK5IeM´UµS�IL¼'[�FRM .5KZGo[�U�¬�S�³b³¶S�©"U5O=�(\RKdUVK¨«acVMbS�F¥�ÃGJM´UL«a¯HULUVKZU�MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FÏ«5[�³´«a¯R³¶¯HU�M¶FÏcV\RK

· ¸ �DUV¯HUVºe¼'[�¯R¼�K1c°\§KNS�ILM¶KZU5Y�½PS�c°\ͬ�ILS�»3cV\RK¦§\_º�UVM´«5[�³$¦HS�M¶F�c­S�¬PW'M¶KN©eY_[�FPGe©M¶c°\9c°\RK�K5»:¦§\H[�UVM´U S�FM¶cÊU�»0[�c°\RK5»0[�cVM´«5[�³_[�UV¦PKZ«acÊU5Y$ILK5³´[�cVKZG=cVS�cV\RKK � ¯RMbW�[�ILM´[�F�c�«aS�\RS�»dS�³bS�¼�ºeS�¬£cV\RK(»dS_GJ¯R³bMRUV¦H[�«aKZU5O<�(\RKK � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM|[�F�c�»dK5c°\§S_GRU ³bKZ[�G¥cVS7cV\RK0K5W�[�³¶¯H[�c°M¶S�FªS�¬cV\RK0M¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³|UDS�FRK9K5FH«aS�¯RF�c°K5I�U MbFªcV\RKd¼'[�¯R¼�KcV\RK5S�ILºÁO1�"U�[ÍILKZUV¯R³bc(S�F§K�[�ILILMbW�KZU�[�ccV\RKD¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶FR¼Í¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FÄS�¬²cV\RKeK5¿'¦PK¨«acL[�c°M¶S�FoW�[�³b¯RKZU&S�¬²cV\RK«L\§MbI�[�³�S�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�U5Y�©�\RM´« \�M|U�K5¿$¦RILKZULUVK¨Gd[�U1[D¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�F9¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FdS�¬­[e«�K5ILcL[�MbF0[�¯R¿$Mb³¶M|[�ILº�UVcÊ[�cVM´UVcVM|«N[�³»dS_G�K5³�S�F¥cV\RK���S�¯RFR¼7G�M´[�¼�I�[�»0U5Oe�(\RKdUVK¨«acVMbS�Fª�ÄUV¦HKZ«aM�ÀHKZUDcV\RKZUVK�ILKZUV¯R³¶cÊU�¬�S�I�cV\RKd¼'[�¯R¼�K=¼�ILS�¯R¦Ç=ÈÊ��É�[�FHG�K5¿'¦§³´[�M¶FHU c°\RK5M¶I=MbF�cVK5IL¦RILK5cÊ[�cVMbS�F�¬�ILS�» cV\RKd¦HS�M¶F�c�S�¬W$MbK5© S�¬c°\RKd³¶MbcVcV³bKÃUVcVILM¶FR¼0cV\RK5S�ILºÁO�(\§M´U0UVKZ«acVMbS�F [�³|UVSªMbF�cVILS_G�¯P«�KZUdcV\RK�¬�S�IL»Ø[�³¶M|UV» S�¬=¬�ILK5K7¬�K5IL»dM¶S�FHU9©\RM|«L\¹[�ILKoW�K5ILºÌK�Ó«aM¶K5F_cdM¶F¦H[�« ]�[�¼�MbF§¼�cV\RK�UV¯R»0U1S�W�K5I"¦H[�ILcVMbcVM¶S�FHU5O��&\RK¾UVKZ«acVMbS�F (0M|G�K5F�c°M�ÀHKZU1cV\RK=¦H[�ILcVMbcVMbS�FÓ¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�F7©�MbcV\o[UVM¶»:¦§³bKD«aS�ILILK5³´[�cVS�IS�¬�¬�ILKNK ¬�K5IL»dMbS�FHU5O

#

Page 8: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

� � · ¸ �Ä6��7>e8:@��u_�|s��Ø��{�y����e���R��n��a�0�L��{�~úz�5{���z|n���p

¤¥KoUVcÊ[�ILcdS�¯RIdK5¿'¦PS'UVM¶c°M¶S�F ©�MbcV\Ìc°\§KÏ«5[�UVK7S�¬�¦R¯RILKÓ· ¸ � UV¯R¦HK5I�UVº$»:»dK5cVILM´« �1[�FR¼����7M¶³b³|UcV\RK5S�ILºÃ©�MbcV\7c°\§K=¼'[�¯R¼�K�¼�ILS�¯§¦¥Ç¾È���É�[�FHGÄM¶cÊUµ»Ø[�¿$Mb»0[�³TcVS�IL¯HU"6 ¸ÖǾÈL��É � O"�(\RK ÀHK5³|G7«�S�F�cVK5F_cS�¬�c°\§K=c°\RK5S�ILº0M|U(¼�M¶W�K5F7½�º0c°\§K�W�KZ«ac°S�I"»9¯R³bcVM¶¦R³bK5c5Y�©\RS'UVK=«aS�»d¦HS�FRK5F�cLU([�ILK/�1cV\RK=«�S�»d¦R³¶K5¿ÃUL«5[�³´[�I� Y<c�©(S7¼�³¶¯RM¶S�FHU�� Y� Y�e¸ ��BL� ��.¸ ��BL�7cV\RK5MbI�«aS�F�®V¯R¼'[�cVKZU � �� Y Y�[�FHG¥cV\RK0¼'[�¯R¼�K9ÀHK5³|G���� �Ï[�³b³ÀHK5³|GRU�MbF7cV\RK:[�G�®VS�MbF�cILK5¦RILKZUVK5F�cÊ[�cVM¶S�FÃS�¬Ç=È���ÉÊO=�(\§K�[�«�cVM¶S�F7M´U"¼�M¶W�K5F7½�ºÃcV\RK=M¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�³,S�W�K5I�cV\RKUV¯R¦PK5I�UV¦H[�«aK/� ������� g�� , ��� g�� �ÄÈ��9É 7���� g � �ÄÈ �9É . È����´��É©\§KNILK � Y� Y� ¸ ��BL� � �d¸ ��BL�ª[�ILKÄcV\RKo«L\RM¶I�[�³&�"I�[�ULUV»0[�FRFÅ«aS'S�I�GJMbFH[�cVKZU9S�F cV\RKoUV¯R¦PKNI�UV¦P[�«�K�Y� ¸ � 7 � �;7 � �"! 7 �6����M|U�c°\RK�· ¸ �eW�KZ«ac°S�IUV¯§¦HK5IVÀHK5³|GTY�[�FHG �EM|U�cV\RK"¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³,È˳bS�«N[�³¶³¶ºÁY[ \RS�³bS�»dS�IL¦R\§M´«�¼'[�¯R¼�KM¶F�W�[�ILM|[�F_c�¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�F:S�¬ � ÉLO ��³|[�ULUVM|«N[�³RUV¯R¦PK5I�UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|« ��[�FR¼����7M¶³¶³´U�cV\RK5S�ILº\H[�U

�ÄÈ � É�¸I�9�Z��I � ^ È���� �$É©\§KNILK � ��M|U"[0«aS�»d¦R³bK5¿Ã«aS�FHUVcL[�F�cNY�©�\RS'UVKeILK¨[�³<[�FHGÄM¶»Ø[�¼�M¶FH[�ILºd¦H[�ILcLU(¼�M¶W�K�cV\RK=cV\RK5cÊ[Ó[�FR¼�³bK=[�FHGcV\RK�M¶F�W�K5I�UVKµU � ¯H[�ILKDS�¬<c°\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�K�«aS�¯R¦§³bM¶FR¼�ILKZUV¦PKZ«�cVM¶W�KN³¶º �

� �D¸$# ��&% 7 ('%(�! ^� B È���� �$ÉcV\RK�UV¯R½PUL«�ILM¶¦Rc,� ILK5»:M¶FHGRU ¯HU<cV\H[�c�cV\RKZUVK[�ILK(½H[�ILK � ¯P[�F_cVM¶c°M¶KZU5YÁGJK�ÀPFRKZG=[�c�UVS�»dK(\RMb¼�\=K5FRK5IL¼�º=UL«5[�³bK) ��� O���c�M´U²©(KN³¶³¶��]$FRS�©F�cV\H[�c<· ¸ � ¼'[�¯R¼�K(cV\RK5S�ILº=\H[�U�[ »dS_G�¯R³¶MRUV¦H[�«aKS�¬TW�[�«a¯H[�Y'« \H[�I�[�«ac°K5ILM .NKZG½�ºDcV\RK(K5¿'¦PK¨«acL[�c°M¶S�FdW�[�³¶¯RK�S�¬Pc°\RK«aS�»d¦R³¶K5¿�UL«5[�³´[�I � MbF=cV\RK[�GZ®VS�M¶F�c,ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F�cÊ[�cVMbS�F�O � F§K�«5[�F=¦R¯RcJ � K�¸E�+*-,D¸�./� V�È�69ÉLYHG�¯§K�cVSdc°\RKe¦PS�c°K5F�c°M|[�³,cVK5IL»Æ��I � � B � ^ M¶F7c°\RK=[�«ac°M¶S�F7S�¬�c°\§K�cV\RK5S�ILº�O�¤¥K[�ILK�UVcV¯HG�º$MbF§¼�cV\RK"¼'[�¯R¼�KcV\RK5S�ILº=S�FÃ��¯H«a³bM|G�KZ[�F:UV¦P[�«�K"@ g Y_[�FPG�M¶»d¦HS'UVK�c°\§K�½PS�¯RFHG§[�ILº¾«aS�FHG�M¶cVMbS�F� È � É&@ �§YT¬�S�I � @ 0 O:��cDM´Ue[�³|UVSëaS�F_W�K5FRM¶K5F�c�cVSo[�«5«aS�»:¦P[�F_ºÄcV\RK=ÀH¿$MbF§¼ÃS�¬(c°\§KØ[�UVº$»d¦Rc°S�cVM|«NUS�¬�cV\RKÃ�M¶¼�¼'U ÀHK5³´GÙ½_º�c°\§KdÀH¿'M¶FR¼7cV\RKÃ[�³¶³bS�©(KZG�¼'[�¯R¼�K0cVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHU"cVSÏ[�¦R¦§ILS'[�«L\¥¯RFRM¶c�ºÏ[�cM¶F�ÀHFRM¶c�º�O

�(\§K"· ¸ �9¼'[�¯R¼�Kec°\§KNS�ILºÓMbFÓ¬�S�¯RI�GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FHU1M´U�[dG�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³PILK¨GJ¯H«ac°M¶S�FÃS�¬�cV\RK · ¸ �ÀHW�KoG�M¶»dK5FHUVMbS�FP[�³�cV\RK5S�ILº�O �(\RKij´[�cVcVKNIÓc°\RK5S�ILºÑFRK5KZGRUd[�F ¯R³¶c°I�[�W'M¶S�³¶KNcd«aS�»:¦§³bK5cVMbS�FÌcVSª½PK7©(KN³¶³¶�G�KaÀHFRKZGTO��S�©(K5W�KNIZYRUVS�»dK�¬�KZ[�c°¯§ILK¨U�S�¬<MbcLU�³bS�©��K5FRK5IL¼�º�½PK5\H[ZW$MbS�¯§I[�ILKDILS�½R¯HUVc � � �O

��Fd¦H[�ILcVM´«a¯R³|[�IZY�c°\§KKaÒ£KZ«acVMbW�KD¼'[�¯§¼�K�«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼DIL¯RFHU<½PKZ«5[�¯HUVKS�¬Tc°\§K�S�F§KN��³¶S'S�¦9W�[�«a¯R¯R»E¦PS�³|[�IL�M .¨[�cVM¶S�F7½_ºÄcV\RK�±(�(%0¦P[�ILc°M|«a³bKZU5O"�(\RKZUVKe¦H[�ILc°M|«a³bKZU"[�ILKe¤ ��½HS'UVS�FPUDÈè¬�S�IDFRS�FH[�½PK5³bM|[�F7c°\§KNS�ILº§ÉÊY§¬�S�¯RI

Page 9: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

G�M¶»dKNFPUVMbS�FH[�³�M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FHU5Y�W$MbK5©(KZG�[�U�UVS�³¶M¶c°S�FHU²MbFÍÀHW�KG�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³$c°\RK5S�ILº�Y�[�FHG=cV\RK�½HS�¯RFPG�UVcL[�c°KZUcV\RK5ILKNS�¬°O

��So«5[�³´«a¯R³|[�c°KdcV\RK0KaÒTK¨«acVMbW�KÄ«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼'U ©(KdFRK5K¨GÙc°S�]'FRS�©EcV\RK0»9¯R³bcVM¶¦R³bM|«aMbcVM¶K¨U5Y c°\RKÓ»Ø[�ULUVKZU5Y«L\P[�IL¼�K¨U5Y([�FHGÑcV\RKoUV¦RM¶FHU9S�¬�cV\RKo±(�&%ª¦H[�ILc°M|«a³bKZU9¦RILKZUVK5F�c�M¶F cV\RKoUV¦HKZ«acVIL¯R» S�¬ec°\RK7cV\RK5S�ILº � )��O�(\§M´Ue«5[�Fª½HK0G�S�F§KÁY�M¶Fª¦RILM¶FH«aMb¦R³¶K�YT½�ºo«5[�ILK�¬�¯§³ � ¯H[�F�c°M .Z[�c°M¶S�F¥S�¬c°\RKd»dS_GJ¯R³bM1UV¦H[�«aK:S�¬�«aS�³¶³bKZ«acVMbW�K«aS'S�I�G�M¶FH[�cVKZU"S�¬c°\§K:UVS�³¶MbcVS�FÏUVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�FHUÍÈ�©�\RM´« \ª[�ILKe¬�S�¯RI¾GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³,¼'[�¯R¼�K9MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHUaÉÊO=��S�©UV¯R¦R¦PS'UVKcV\RK"cV\RK5S�ILº�M|U(«�S�»d¦H[�«acVMúÀPK¨G9S�FÃ[=«aM¶I�«a³bK�O��(\§KNFÓc°\RK"S�FRK5��³¶S'S�¦dKaÒ£KZ«acS�¬­[e¼�M¶W�K5F0¦H[�ILcVM´«a³¶K«aS�FHUVM|UVcÊU�S�¬²[e½R¯§³b]9c°K5IL»7Y'¦§ILK¨UVK5F�c�M¶F0cV\RK"ÀHW�KDG�M¶»dKNFPUVMbS�FH[�³�cV\RK5S�ILº�YR[�FHGd[=FRK5©ÌÀPFRMbcVK5��UVM .5KKaÒTKZ«�c5Y\H[�W'M¶FR¼DcVS�G�Se©M¶c°\0cV\RK�³bS$S�¦HU�©�I�[�¦R¦RM¶FR¼DcV\RK�«aM¶I�«a³bK"M¶FØUV¦P[�«�K5��cVMb»dK � )��O��ˬ,M¶F0[�GRG�M¶c°M¶S�F�©(K�ILS�cÊ[�cVKZGcV\RKFRS�FP«�S�»d¦H[�«ac�¦P[�ILc­S�¬,cV\RK"UV¦H[�«aKN��cVMb»dK(M¶Fd¼�S�MbFR¼=[�ILS�¯RFHGecV\RKD«aMbI�«a³¶K�Y�c°\§KNFdcV\RK³¶S'S�¦PU�©�I�[�¦R¦RM¶FR¼cV\RK�«aMbI�«a³¶K"©(S�¯R³´G9\H[�W�KcVS�½PK"³bS�«5[�³bM .5K¨GÓFRKZ[�I1c°\RK S�ILMb¼�M¶FdMbF0cV\RKDUV¦H[�«aK5��c°M¶»dKÁO��&\RM|U�³¶S_«5[�³¶M .Z[�cVMbS�FÄM´U[�c�cV\RKD«aS�ILK(S�¬£cV\RK"»dKNcV\RS�G=©(K�[�ILK�K5»:¦§³bS�º'M¶FR¼RO,��cLU�»Ø[�cV\RK5»0[�c°M|«5[�³�Mb»d¦R³¶K5»:K5F�cL[�c°M¶S�F=M´U1G�M|UL«a¯HULUVKZGM¶FÃcV\RKeFRK5¿'c�UVKZ«acVMbS�F,O

�(\§K�«�S�F�cVILMb½§¯Rc°M¶S�FÄS�¬�c°\§K:±(�&%æH[�ILcVM´«a³¶KZUcVS0IL¯RF§FRMbF§¼�S�¬(c°\RK=KaÒTKZ«�cVM¶W�K:«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼'UG�K5¦PKNFPGRU5YS�¬�«aS�¯RI�UVK�Y<S�FÅcV\RK5MbI9»0[�ULUVK¨U5Y�UV¦§MbFHU5Y�[�FPGÅ« \H[�IL¼�KZU6� )��Oª�(\RKļ�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶FR¼Ä¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FÅS�¬�[�³¶³(c°\RKZUVKKaÒ£KZ«acVMbW�K=«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼'U(«5[�F7½PKDM|G�K5F_cVM�ÀHKZG0©�MbcV\ÃcV\RK=UV¯R¦PKNI�UVº$»d»:K5cVILM´«&MbFPG�K5¿'��³bM¶]�K � ¯H[�F�c°M¶c�º

��I��eÈ��DÉ�� V �� � V ��� �� V �� ��©\§KNILK=+ M|U�c°\RK=¼�K5FRK5I�[�cVS�I"S�¬�c°\§K�QTS�ILK5F�c .=ILS�cL[�c°M¶S�FHU5YP2eM´U�cV\RK=¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°S�I"S�¬�cV\RK?����UVº'»d»dKNcVILºILS�cL[�c°M¶S�FHU5Y�[�FPG1<7M|U=cV\RKëaM¶I�«�¯§»�¬�K5ILK5FH«aKdS�¬Dc°\RKÓÀR¬�cV\ЫaM¶I�«a³bK�OªÎ�FHG�K5I:«aK5ILcL[�MbFÌ«aS�FHG�M¶c°M¶S�FHUeS�F*>[�FHGÑ- c°\§M´U9cVI�[�«�KÄ\H[�U9UVS�»:KÄUV¯R¦HK5I�UVº$»:»dK5cVILºÏ©�\RM|«L\Ì[�³b³¶S�©"Uec°S¥K5W�[�³¶¯H[�cVK7Mbc5OÌ��FÌc°\§KæRILS�«aK¨ULUS�FRK0¼�K5cLUdUVS�»:KdM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³|UeS�W�K5I=cV\RKûdS�G�¯R³¶M�UV¦H[�«aK0S�¬"MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FÅ«aS�³b³¶KZ«�cVM¶W�K«aS'S�I�GJMbFH[�cVKZU5Y�[�UeM¶F� �1��5� ��)�5� ������b�5����b�����OÅ��c�M|U�cVSªcV\RKZUVKÃM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³|U=cV\H[�cdS�FRK7[�¦R¦R³¶MbKZU=cV\RK7K � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�c=³bS�«5[�³bM .Z[�c°M¶S�FcVK¨« \RFRM � ¯RKZU5YRG�KZUL«aILM¶½HKZGd½PK5³bS�©�O

±1Ka¬�S�ILK=©(K�G�M|UL«�¯PULUcV\RKZUVK=M¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�³´U�©(K�UV\RS�¯§³´GÄ«aS�FH«a³b¯HGJK=S�¯RIDG�M´UL«a¯HULUVM¶S�FÄS�¬�cV\RK=ILKZG�¯H«acVMbS�FS�¬�cV\RKeÀHW�K�G�M¶»dK5FHUVMbS�FP[�³Tc°\RK5S�ILº7G�S�©F7cVSd¬�S�¯RI�G�M¶»dK5FHUVMbS�FPU5O��"«acV¯H[�³b³¶º�YT©(K�UV\H[�³¶³,½PK=K5W�KNF�»dS�ILK¼�K5FRK5I�[�³�YR[�FPG0G�M|UL«�¯PULU1c°\RKeILKZG�¯H«acVMbS�FÓ¬�ILS�»?UVMb¿ÃGJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FHU5O� FRK�«5[�FÃ[�ILILM¶W�K[�c�cV\RKDUVK5c°¯§¦0©(K�UV\H[�³¶³R¯HUVK�½�º�³¶Mú¬�cVMbF§¼�cV\RK"c°\§KNS�ILº9c°Se· ¸ ÈL��BÊ�$É�UVM¶¿:GJMb»dK5FR�UVM¶S�FH[�³�cV\RK5S�ILºÁY1[�FHG�c°\§KNFÌ«aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�¬�º'M¶FR¼7S�FÅ[�c�©(S���c°S�IL¯HUµ©M¶c°\Ñc°\§K0c�©M|UVcVK¨GÙ½HS�¯RFPGR[�ILºo«aS�FHG�M¶�cVMbS�FHU"È�[�³¶S�FR¼=½HS�cV\ � [�FPG � «aº_«a³bKZUaÉLYRUV¯H«L\dcV\H[�c([�U1©(K�¼�S�[�ILS�¯§FHGd[eFRS�FR��«aS�F_cVI�[�«acÊ[�½§³bK�³bS$S�¦�� O5 � 7����dY$c°\§KUV¦H[�«aKN��cVMb»dK([�FHG=cV\RK1ÀHK5³|GRU�S�¬£cV\RK(¼'[�¯R¼�K(cV\RK5S�ILº=«L\H[�IL¼�KZGe¯RFHGJKNI<cV\RK ����UVº'»d»dKNcVILº¼�ILS�¯R¦7��Ç=È��$É � [�ILK�ILS�cL[�cVK¨Ge½�ºDcV\RK1K5³bK5»dK5F_c�È V Y�� & M � ��� ��� B V Y�� & M � ��� � � B V Y�� & M � ��� � � É�*F�1ǾÈ��$É�� ��1ǾÈ��$É � �?�1ǾÈ��$É � ¸I��� � 5 È (�É �?�1ǾÈ��$É � O���F:S�cV\RK5I1©(S�I�GRU5Y�©(K�«aS�»d¦H[�«acVMú¬�º9c°\RKDUVM¶¿�G�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³

Page 10: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

· ¸ �"UV¯HUVº9¼'[�¯R¼�K"c°\RK5S�ILºdS�F0cV\RK"»0[�FRMú¬�S�³|Gd©�MbcV\0cV\RKDcVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�º06 ^ �:@ g ©�MbcV\ÃcV\RKD»dK5cVILM´«"[�FHGcV\RK ����UVº'»d»dK5c°ILº9¼'[�¯R¼�K"ÀHK5³|G0¤ Mb³|UVS�FijbM¶FRK1�

��� ^ ¸ < ^ ���&� �;7 È � � � 7�> �� � � ���$ÉÊÈ � � � 7 > �� � � � �$É B- M ¸3È�> � � ���-7 > � � � �$É�� M� � B ) ¸ ��BL� BL� B/(4B �9¸3��BL� BL� È���� (�É

M¶cM|U«aS�F�W�KNF§MbK5F�c�cVS0«aS�»�½RM¶FRK�� X : ^ [�FHG�� X : ^ M¶F�c°S9c�©(S:«aS�»d¦R³¶KN¿d¦H[�I�[�»dK5cVKNI�U X : ^ � X �� ^ ¸ ��È�� X 7 ��� X É�B X 7� ^ ¸ ��È�� ^ 7 � � ^ É È���� #$É�(\§K�[�F�c°M|UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«�»Ø[�cVILM|«�KZU8>&B > [�ILKD¼�M¶W�K5Fý�º �

> � � ¸ ���� X � ��� X � � �� � � ^� � �� ^ �

���� B > � � ¸ ��

�� X � �� X � � �� � � ^� � � ^ �

���� È���� �$É

��F=cV\RK(³¶Mb»dM¶c <A@ ��©(K1¼�K5c,¬�S�¯§I²GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³�¼'[�¯§¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILº�O,¤¥K«aS�¯R³|G�[�³|UVS"cÊ[�]�K(cV\RK1³bM¶»dMbc�c°SDcV\RKÀHW�K=G�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³RcV\RK5S�ILº�YR½�ºÃ«aS�FHUVM|G�K5ILMbF§¼=c°\RK=G�K5¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°KecVS�IL¯HU6 ^ O1¤¥K=FRS�c°KeM¶FæH[�ULUVM¶FR¼9c°\H[�ccV\RKD«�S�»d¦R³¶K5¿:UVcVIL¯H«ac°¯§ILKS�¬,cV\RK"c°S�IL¯HU16 ^ «aS�¯R³|G9½HK"]�K5¦Rc�ÀHFRM¶c°K�O��&\RKILKZUV¯R³¶cVMbFR¼ ¬�S�¯RI(G�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³cV\RK5S�ILºÂÈè¬�S�I"¼'[�¯R¼�KD¼�ILS�¯R¦`��Ç=È��$ÉVÉ�M|U(ILK5³|[�c°KZGÓc°SdcV\RKec°\RK5S�ILºdS�¬�c°\§K�UVS���«N[�³¶³¶K¨GÄ����UVcVILM¶FR¼'U � �R���� �����O�(\§K7MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FÌ«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVMbS�FPU=cVSªc°\§Ko«�S�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�F ¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FHU9S�¬�cV\RKo«L\§MbI�[�³(S�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U9M¶FÌc°\RM|UcV\RK5S�ILºo[�ILK�ILK5³´[�cVKZG7cVS7c°\§K�K5³b³¶M¶¦Rc°M|«=¼�K5FRK5I�[dS�¬cV\RK9MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�F�»dS_G�¯R³¶M�UV¦H[�«aK�� ����1[�FHGo«aS�¯R³|G�½HKUV¯R»d»dKZG0¯R¦�YR¼�M¶W'M¶FR¼0ILM|UVK�cVS0cV\RKd%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼���¤ M¶c°cVK5Fo«�¯§ILW�K¨U&¬�S�IDcV\RKZUVK=cV\RK5S�ILMbKZU5O"S�©(K5W�K5IZYRM¶F7c°\RM|U¦H[�¦PK5I�©(K=UV\H[�³¶³TFRK5MbcV\RK5IDG�M|UL«�¯PULU(K5³b³¶M¶¦Rc°M|«�YRFRS�I"cVILMb¼�S�F§S�»:K5cVILM´«µ³bM¶»dMbcLU5YRK5W�K5F7c°\§S�¯R¼�\7c°\§KNºÄ³¶K¨[�GÄcVSM¶F_cVK5ILKZUVc°M¶FR¼=M¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�½R³¶K�UVº_UVcVK5»ØU&� ��(��O

�(\§K�[�«�cVM¶S�FoS�¬�cV\RKe¬�S�¯RI�GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³HcV\RK5S�ILºÄMbF�c°\RK=³¶M¶»:M¶c&< @ �dM|U"FRS�c"cV\H[�c"S�¬�cV\RK=¦R¯§ILKUV¯R¦PK5I�UVº'»d»dKNcVILM|«;��[�FR¼����7M¶³¶³´U�cV\RK5S�ILºÃS�F¥@ g YH½§¯Rc"I�[�c°\RK5IDM|UD[0GJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F7S�¬1MbcD½�º0cV\RK >DY >(�G�K5¦PKNFPG�K5F_c(cVK5IL»0U5O<¤ÏK=UV\H[�³¶³H©�ILMbcVK=G�S�©�F0\RK5ILKDS�FR³¶ºdc°\§K�cVK5IL»ØU&©M¶c°\7½PS'UVS�FRM|«&ÀHK5³´GRU�[�c # �D¸ ����(È$>µÉ ����� ¸ � �

�?! ^� �,I� X^ ! ^� � 7 È � � � �#> �� � � ! � � ÉLÈ�� � � � > �� � � ! � � É 7 � � B � ^�� È���� �É��cÄM´U7[�»9¯HUVM¶FR¼¥c°\H[�cÄcV\RM´U7GJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F¹«5[�F ½HKªG�KZUL«aILM¶½HKZG [�U7[ÌUV¯§¦HK5I�UV¦H[�«aK5��G�K5¦HK5FHG�K5F�c�½P[�ILK«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼?�9�1� � ��È � B � � ) ��� É�¸E� �ÁÈ ) ��� É 7 > �"� 7�> � � > � � � � � � È����>�$ɤ¥K:[�ILK9¼�S�MbFR¼Óc°SoUVcV¯HG�ºÄc°\§KØ«aS�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�F7¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FHU"S�¬«L\RM¶I�[�³<S�½HUVK5ILW�[�½R³¶K¨U5O=�&\RKZUVK=S�½HUVK5ILW�[�½R³¶K¨U[�ILK�¼'[�¯§¼�K:M¶F�W�[�ILM|[�F_c"\RS�³¶S�»dS�IL¦R\RM|«"¬�¯§FH«ac°M¶S�FHU S�¬c°\RK0UV¯R¦PK5IVÀHK5³´G �dO! "M¶KN©(KZG¥[�Ue[Ó¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�F¥S�FcV\RK¾UV¯§¦HK5I�UV¦H[�«aK�Y'K5W�K5ILº0UV¯H«L\ÄS�½HUVK5ILW�[�½R³¶K � «5[�FýPK=G�KZ«�S�»d¦PS'UVKZGB�

� � �dÈ � B � É�<¸ � � � � 7 � �ËX � � 7Q���6��7 � �bg � � g È���� )$É�

Page 11: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

�(\§K�«�S�»d¦PS�FRK5F�c � �bg � «N[�F�½HK=¯PUVK¨G�c°S7G�Ka¬�S�IL» c°\RKd[�«ac°M¶S�FoS�¬�cV\RK9c°\RK5S�ILº�YPc°\§M´UDGJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F�M´UK � ¯RM¶W�[�³¶K5F_c�c°S9c°\§K¾[�GRGJMbcVMbS�FÄS�¬ � c°SdcV\RK�½P[�ILKD¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³�O

�(\§K:F§M´«aKd¦RILS�¦PKNILc�ºoS�¬cV\RKëL\§MbI�[�³�S�½PUVKNILW�[�½R³bKZU M´UecV\RK0M¶FHG�K5¦PK5FHG�K5FH«aKdS�¬c°\RK5M¶I�«aS�ILILKN³|[�cVMbS�F¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FPU0S�¬=c°\§KÙ[�F�cVMb��« \RMbI�[�³"G�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHUdS�¬�cV\RKocV\RK5S�ILº�Y"MbF¹¦H[�ILcVM|«�¯§³´[�I0S�¬ � � X O ¤¥KÏ«5[�F,YcV\RK5ILK�¬�S�ILK�YR«aS�FHUVM|G�K5I(c°\§K�³¶Mb»dM¶c � � @ 0 O���FÄc°\§M´U&³bM¶»dMbc(cV\RKec°K5IL»4�

� ��� ! � ^M¶FocV\RK:[�«acVMbS�F�³bS�«N[�³¶M .NKZU c°\§K=¦H[�c°\¥M¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³,S�F�cVS0cV\RK�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�Fo«aS�F�ÀH¼�¯RI�[�cVM¶S�FHU5OD�(\RK=ILKZUV¯R³¶cVMbFR¼M¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�F0»dKZ[�UV¯RILK�«5[�FýPK=«N[�³|«a¯R³|[�c°KZG � ¯RM¶c°KeK5¿'¦R³¶M|«�M¶cV³bºÃ[�FPG0cV\RK ÀHFH[�³TM¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�³£«5[�³|«a¯R³´[�cVKZGTO�¤¥KUV\H[�³¶³,G�M|UL«�¯PULU�cV\RM|U�UV\§S�ILc°³¶º�O

��S�©¹©(KD©[�F�c(cVSd¦H[�¯HUVKDcVS0G�M´UL«a¯HULU�S�cV\RK5I�¦§\_º�UVM´«5[�³PILKZ[�³bM .Z[�c°M¶S�FHU1S�¬�S�¯RI(· ¸ �9c°\§KNS�ILM¶KZU5O

u_��u_�µ�H����z|� �Ó���R��n��a�0�L��{�~úz�5{���z|n���p

�(\§K(· ¸ � c°\RK5S�ILºd«N[�F0[�ILM|UVK�[�U1[D³¶S�©ÌKNF§KNIL¼�º9³bM¶»dMbc�S�¬£cV\RK"c°\§KNS�ILº9S�F0[�UVcL[�«L]9S�¬­!"��½RI�[�FRKZUM¶FÃc�º$¦HKe�°�1¼'[�¯R¼�K"cV\RK5S�ILº�O�� UVcL[�«L]0S�¬ � ¦H[�I�[�³¶³¶KN³T!D�ͽRI�[�FRKZU1MbF7�V��±ÌcV\RK5S�ILºdMbF +£[�c@ X :�� «5[�ILILM¶K¨U· ¸(=UV¯R¦HK5I�UVº$»:»dK5cVILM´«"��[�FR¼����7M¶³¶³´U�cV\RK5S�ILº�� ��#��O�� UVcL[�«L]9S�¬£¦H[�I�[�³¶³¶KN³R!;(e½RI�[�FRKZU<M¶F:�V��� cV\RK5S�ILºM¶F#+£[�c�@ X :�� «5[�ILILMbKZUµ· ¸?�oUV¯R¦PK5I�UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«A��[�FR¼����7M¶³¶³´U c°\§KNS�ILº�MbFÙÀHW�KÃG�M¶»dKNFPUVMbS�FHU5O0Î�¦PS�F«aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�À£«5[�c°M¶S�FªS�FÌ[7«aMbI�«a³¶K0c°\§K0³´[�cVcVKNI9c°\§KNS�ILº¥ILKZG�¯H«aKZUecVSocV\RKd¬�S�IL»dK5I=MbFÑc°\§K0³bM¶»dMbceS�¬ .5K5ILSI�[�G�M¶¯HU5O

��S�© «aS�FHUVM|G�K5I(c°\§K¾UVcL[�«L]0S�¬ � !;(d½RI�[�FRKZU1MbFÄcV\RK�¼�K5S�»dK5c°ILºÄ* X �Ø@ X :�� ©M¶c°\7cV\RKD»dK5cVILM´«2���� ^ ¸ � � � � � � 7�< ^ ��� ^ 7 ��� ^ 7(A �� X 7 �� X ����A ^ 7(A �� ^ � �� ^ ����A ^ È����´�5�$É

�K5ILK � � G�K5FRS�cVK�cV\RKD«aS'S�I�G�M¶FH[�cVKZU1S�F0c°\§Kµ��MbF§]�S�©"UV]'MHUV¦H[�«aK"@ X : ` Y��ÙM´U�c°\§KD¦HK5ILM¶S_G�M|«"«aS'S�I�G�M¶FH[�cVKS�F�cV\RK«aM¶I�«�³¶K(S�¬,«�M¶I�«a¯R»9¬�K5ILKNFP«�K�<�Y��eM|U<[DILKZ[�³$c°I�[�FHUVW�K5I�UVK(G�M¶ILK¨«acVMbS�F�Y�� X [�FPG�� ^ [�ILK(c°\RK(\§S�³bS�»dS�IL�¦R\RM|««aS$S�I�G�MbFP[�c°KZU1S�Fdc°\§KDILK5»Ø[�M¶FRM¶FR¼=Ô ^ O��(\RK"©(S�IL³|G�W�S�³¶¯R»dK(S�¬,c°\RK"½RI�[�F§K¨U�M|U�* X ��@ X : ` Y$©\RM|«L\M|U(³¶S_«5[�c°KZGÄ[�c � X ¸�� ^ ¸ ��YR[�FHG��9¸�����Y���¸3��B������ B��¥O���S�¼�K5c°\RK5I�©M¶c°\0cV\RKe¤ M¶³´UVS�FÓ³bS$S�¦ÃK5M¶¼�KNF§�W�[�³¶¯RKZU V Y�� � B������ B V Y���� [�ILS�¯RFPG¥* X ��� �ÞU"¬�S�IL» � «aS�»:¦§³bK5¿7»dS_G�¯§³bM�� X B������ B�� � Y,¦P[�I�[�»:K5cVK5ILM .5M¶FR¼cV\RK�»dS�G�¯R³¶M£UV¦H[�«aKDS�¬�W�[�«a¯H[�O1��FÄc°\RKe³¶Mb»dM¶c�<A@ �Íc°\§K � «aS�»d¦R³bK5¿d»dS_G�¯§³bMP³bS$S'UVK�¦PK5ILMbS�G�M|«�M¶c�º�O

��c=M|UeKZ[�UVºocVSÏ«L\§K¨« ]ocV\H[�c=cV\RK0©(S�IL³|G�W�S�³b¯§»:K=cV\RK5S�ILºo\P[�U · ¸ ��UV¯HUVº�Y,©�MbcV\Ñc°\RKd»0[�ULUVM¶W�K\�º'¦PK5IL»�¯R³¶c°M¶¦R³¶K5c�M¶FªcV\RK0[�GZ®VS�M¶F_ceILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�F,Od�(\§M´U ILKZ[�³bM .Z[�c°M¶S�FªM|U��&��GJ¯H[�³�cVS7c°\RKÄUVcÊ[�FHG§[�I�GILKZ[�³bM .Z[�c°M¶S�FÄ©M¶c°\Äc°\§K¾� %_#9½RI�[�FRKZUA� ���� ^ O(��S�c°KecV\H[�c"c°\RKe½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFHGÄÈ���O (�É1M´U"UVM¶»dMb³|[�I(c°S7È���O´�5�$É

X�� á5ñ<ÝLàZÝ�çLï�á�ÛåÝä��åá�ø�Ü! 9ã'Ý"ßañ²ß�ç�Ý(á5â#"��åÝ%$'á�ä�ä�ùúã�ùÞÜÞù&"('dá5â)�åáZÜÞá�é"á�ç*$���ùÞæDßZÛåá�éDß5Ü&',+^.-/-0"��'ßZÛ�1Zä1ð2+�31á�ø�4ZÜúß5ä1â|á�ç5"6��ÝùÞÜÞÜúø'é"ùúÛ$ß�"�ùúÛ�47 �ùÞä�æ�ø�ä�ä�ùÞá�Ûdá�Û8"���ùÞä/$'á�ù Û"9+

)

Page 12: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

½R¯Rc"cV\RK�!"��½RI�[�FRKZU�[�ILK=³bS�«N[�cVKZG¥G�MúÒTK5ILK5F_cV³¶ºÁY§©\RM|«L\7³¶KZ[�GRU�c°SÄW�K5ILºÃM¶F�c°K5ILKZUVcVMbFR¼9¼�K5S�»:K5cVILMbKZU"¯§¦HS�F�(��G�¯P[�³bM¶c°M¶KZU([�FHGÓ³bM�¬�cÊU&c°S0����cV\RK5S�ILº3� � �Y�©\§M´« \æRILS�W'M|G�KD[�FRS�cV\RK5I¯HUVKa¬�¯R³PM¶FHUVMb¼�\�c5O

�S�©(K5W�K5IZY�M¶FdS�¯RI�UVcVS�ILº=©(K"©[�F�c�c°S�[�FP[�³bº .NK�c°\§K�¦§¯RILK(· ¸ �eUV¯R¦PKNI�UVº$»d»:K5cVILM´« �1[�FR¼����7M¶³b³|UcV\RK5S�ILºÁOD�&\RM|U�«5[�F�½HK�[�« \RMbK5W�KZGĽ�ºÃcL[�]'M¶FR¼�� @ 0 ³¶Mb»dM¶cNYP[�cDc°\§K�UL[�»:KecVMb»dK=cL[�]'M¶FR¼0cV\RK=©(KZ[�]UVcVILMbFR¼D«aS�¯R¦R³¶M¶FR¼³¶Mb»dM¶cNO��&\RK1ILK¨UV¯§³bcVMbF§¼�½§I�[�FRK�«aS�F�ÀP¼�¯RI�[�c°M¶S�F=«N[�F=½PK�GJK¨UL«aILM¶½HKZG ¯HUVM¶FR¼"c�©(S"¦H[�I�[�³b³¶K5³� %_#ĽRI�[�FRKZUD[�FPG � ! (ýRI�[�F§K:UV¯HUV¦PK5FHG�KZG7½PK5c�©(K5KNF¥cV\RK5»7Y­[�U MbF� �����Y�S�IZY,[�³¶c°K5ILFH[�cVM¶W�KN³¶º�Y­[�Ue[UVcL[�«L]0S�¬ � !D�ÄÈè¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³ËÉ�½RI�[�FRKZU(UVcV¯H«L]Ä[�ccV\RK�Ô ^���� ^ UVMbFR¼�¯§³´[�ILM¶c�º�Y_[�U�M¶F � �1���O��&\RKeILKN³|[�cVMbS�F½PKNc�©(KNK5FÌcV\RKZUVKÃc�©(So¦RM|«ac°¯RILKZUÍM´U9cV\RILS�¯R¼�\Ñc°\RK7�(��G�¯P[�³bM¶c�º¥S�¬Dc°\RKÄILKZUVS�³bW�KZG Ô ^ ��� ^ UVM¶FR¼�¯R³|[�ILMbc�º�O�(\§K(¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³R!D�e½RI�[�F§K¨U�½R³¶S�©Ì¯R¦�M¶F�c°S=!D# ½RI�[�FRKZU<©I�[�¦§¦RMbF§¼µ[ FRS�FR��«aS�F�c°I�[�«acL[�½R³¶K�c�©(S���UV¦R\§KNILK�O�(\§KILKZUVS�³bW�KZGdUV¦H[�«aK����NÕ X \P[�U�[ÍǾÈL��É�M|UVS�»:K5cVILº�Y�©M¶c°\dc�©(S ÀH¿$K¨GئHS�M¶F�cÊU(ÈËcV\RKD�S�ILcV\Ã[�FHGÓ%'S�¯§c°\¦PS�³bKZU<S�¬HcV\RK(FRS�F§��«aS�F�cVI�[�«�cL[�½R³¶K�c�©(S���UV¦R\RK5ILK�ÉLO,Î�¦HS�Fd�(��G�¯H[�³¶Mbc�ºDc°\§K¨UVK(cV¯RILF9MbF�cVS�c�©(S�� %_#"½RI�[�FRKZU5O�(\§K�!D#9½RI�[�FRKZU(G�¯H[�³¶M .NK c°S0!;(9½RI�[�FRKZUUV¯HUV¦PK5FHG�KZG9½HK5c�©(K5K5Fo� %_# �ÞU5O

�(\§KDMbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FÃKaÒTK¨«acLU�MbF7cV\RM|U(cV\RK5S�ILºÃ[�ILK�G�¯RK c°S0cV\RK ¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³,!=ÈË����É�M¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU5Y$©\RM|«L\½RM¶FHG�c°S7cV\RKd¬�I�[�«acVMbS�FP[�³�!D�ĽRI�[�FRKZU5Y�MbF c°\RK0�V��±EGJK¨UL«aILM¶¦RcVMbS�F,O0�&\RK �V©(S�IL³´GJW�S�³b¯R»dK �9c°\§KNS�ILº�S�FcV\RKZUVK¾!=ÈË����É�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU1M|U(cV\RK=UV¯R¦HK5I�UVº$»:»dK5cVILM´«�»0[�c°ILM¶¿dMbF�cVK5¼�I�[�³�Y�©�\RM´« \é(KeG�KZUL«�ILM¶½PKD©M¶c°\7cV\RK\RK5³¶¦ÅS�¬D��! �� «�S�FPUVc°IL¯H«acVMbS�F ½HK5³¶S�©eOª��FÌc°\§KÃ�°���?¦RM|«ac°¯§ILK0c°\§KÃM¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FªKaÒTK¨«acLUd[�ILKÃG�¯RK0cVS��¯H«a³bM|G�KZ[�FÃ!D�9½RI�[�FRKZU5Y$©\RM|«L\ �V¦RILS�¦H[�¼'[�cVK��ͽHK5c�©(K5K5FÄc�©(S:� %_#9½RI�[�FRKZU5O

�(\§KÂ�V��± ¦RM|«ac°¯§ILKé�MbcV\ cV\RKĬ�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³�½RI�[�FRKZU�«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FPGRU=cVSªcV\RK7»dKNcVILM|«oÈ˽HKa¬�S�ILK3> M´UcV¯RILFRKZG0S�F É � ��� ^ ¸ � � � � � � 7 ����� �'7 ��� ^� ��� � È����´����É

�(\§K¾UVM¶FR¼�¯R³|[�ILMbc�ºÃÔ ^ ��� ^ \H[�U�ÀHW�K=»dS_G�¯R³¶MTM¶FÏ�V��± UVcVILMbFR¼9c°\§KNS�ILº��(cV\RK=c°\§ILKNK=¦P[�I�[�»:K5cVK5I�U(S�¬cV\RKd¼�KNS�»dK5cVILM´«ÍILK¨UVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�F¥S�¬cV\RK0UVMbF§¼�¯R³´[�ILM¶c�º�Y,[�FHG�cV\RK +H¯R¿$K¨U S�¬cV\RK0�D%��D%¥[�FHG � � ���ˬ�S�IL»0UcV\RILS�¯R¼�\7cV\RK=c�©(S���«aº_«a³bK=©�\RM|«L\o[�¦R¦PKZ[�I�U�[�¬�cVK5ID½R³¶S�©�¯R¦,O"�(\RK=³|[�cVc°K5I�U"©�\RM´« \o[�ILK=ILKZUV¦HS�FHUVM¶½R³¶K"¬�S�IcV\RK�¼'[�¯§¼�K�«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼'U1S�FÄcV\RKD¬�I�[�«acVMbS�FP[�³,!D�=½RI�[�F§K¨U&� ��)���

� �D¸ �� �� � � 7�� ���� ��

�� � � � � È����´�5�$É

� ¯RI�«aS�F�®VKZ«ac°¯RILK�M´U�cV\H[�c�cV¯RILFRM¶FR¼DS�FÓc°\RK�\RM¶¼�\RK5I��([�UVMb»dM¶I�U5Y'È�[�FHG9¼�I�[ZW$MbcL[�c°M¶S�FH[�³HGJK¨UL«aK5FHGR[�F�cLUS�F¹c°\§KÙGJ¯H[�³D«�³¶S'UVKZG¹UVc°ILM¶FR¼ÅUVM|G�K�É:«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHG§U�cVS [ �V\RS�³bS�»dS�IL¦R\§M´«Ó©[ZW�K ��Y�©\RK5ILK � � UVcL[�ILcÊU\RS�³¶S�»dS�IL¦R\RM|«N[�³¶³¶º�G�K5¦HK5FHGÓS�F �eO1�(\RM|U(M|U(]$FRS�©�FÃcVSd½HKe[:UVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�FÓS�¬��V��±¹UV¯R¼�I�[�� ('���O

¤¥K0UV\H[�³b³�ILKNcV¯RILFªcVS7cV\RKd¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³1½RI�[�FRK9¦RM´«acV¯RILKd³´[�cVK5I=S�F,O4��Mb¼�\�cDFRS�©E³¶K5c=¯HU »:K5F�cVMbS�F[�FRS�cV\RK5I�UVcVILMbFR¼�º7KaÒTKZ«�c5O0±1º7cV¯RILFRM¶FR¼0S�F¥c°\§K:«aS�FHUVcL[�F_ce�D%��D%o±1�ËÀHK5³|GÏ[�³¶S�FR¼0cV\RKd©(S�IL³|G�W�S�³b¯§»:KS�¬cV\RK:!D����½RI�[�F§K¨Uµ©(K:G�Ka¬�S�IL» cV\RK0UV¯R¦HK5IL����[�FR¼�����Mb³¶³´U&S�Fª@ g cVS7c°\§KØUV¯§¦HK5IL����[�FR¼����7M¶³¶³´U&S�FÏcV\RK

�5�

Page 13: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

FRS�FH«aS�»d»�¯§cÊ[�cVMbW�K(@ g � � (H���� ('����)('���O � F9c°\§K©(S�IL³|G�W�S�³b¯§»:K1S�¬Tc°\RK"!=ÈË� ��É�MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU,cV\RK"FRS�FH«aS�»d�»�¯§cÊ[�cVMbW$Mbc�ºo[�«�cLUe[�U�[Ä�H[�º�K5c°����³¶³¶MbS�¦PS�¯R³¶S'U(cVKNIL»7Y,GJK�¬�S�IL»dM¶FR¼dc°\§KØ�"!D"� K � ¯P[�c°M¶S�FHU � (�(��� ('#���)('���Y[�FHGÓILKZUVS�³bW$MbFR¼=cV\RK=UVMbF§¼�¯R³´[�ILM¶cVMbKZU1S�¬�c°\§K�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�F0»dS_GJ¯R³bMTUV¦H[�«aK�YH[�U&MbF1� (� �O�¤¥K=UV\H[�³¶³H¯HUVK c°\RM|UG�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�F7[�U[9c°KZ« \RFRM|«N[�³�c°S$S�³�YPUVSd©(K¾UV\H[�³¶³TFRS�c"G�KZUL«�ILM¶½PKDMbc�MbF7»9¯H«L\ÄG�K5cÊ[�M¶³�O(�&\RK�F§K¨«aKZULUL[�ILºILKa¬�K5ILKNFP«�KZU�«N[�FĽPKD¬�S�¯RFPG0M¶F �)('���O

�(c<cV\RM|U�¦PS�MbF�c<©(K(ILK5»0[�IL]Dc°\P[�c�K5W�KNFͬ�S�I � ¸3�(cV\RK�MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU,[�ILK(¦RILKZUVK5F�c­M¶F�cV\RK!"��½RI�[�F§K¦RM|«ac°¯RILK�O��&\RK5ºo½PKZ«�S�»dK9W'M|UVMb½R³¶K=M¶FÏcV\RK9¼'[�¯R¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILº7©\RK5F¥FRS�FH«aS�»d»�¯§cÊ[�cVMbW$Mbc�ºÃM|U"cV¯RILFRKZG�S�F,O��K5»Ø[�IL]�[�½R³bº�Y<cV\RK7[�«�cV¯H[�³(W�[�³¶¯RK0S�¬"c°\§KÃFRS�FP«�S�»d»9¯RcÊ[�cVM¶W'M¶c�ºo¦H[�I�[�»dK5cVKNI � G�S'KZUÍFRS�c�[�Ò£KZ«ac�cV\RKK5¿'¦PKZ«�cL[�cVMbS�F7W�[�³¶¯RKZU�S�¬�c°\RKe«L\RM¶I�[�³HS�½PUVKNILW�[�½R³bKZU5Y$c°\�¯HU�UVMb»d¦R³¶M�¬�º'M¶FR¼=S�¯RI³¶M�¬�KDK5FRS�IL»dS�¯HUV³bº�O

%'SÓ¬�[�I�©(Kd¦RILKZUVK5F�c°KZG�c°\RK0!"��½RI�[�F§K=ILK¨[�³¶M .¨[�cVM¶S�FÏS�¬(· ¸ �ÓcV\RK5S�ILºÁO0�&\RK5ILK�K5¿'M|UVcLU=[�FRS�c°\§KNI¯HUVKa¬�¯R³DILKZ[�³¶M .Z[�cVMbS�F�Y"W'M|[ѳbS�«N[�³ ��[�³|[�½RMb����[�¯¹»0[�FRM�¬�S�³´G§U3� (��O?�(\§M´UÓILKZ[�³bM .Z[�c°M¶S�F,YD[�UÓ©(KÙ[�³¶ILKZ[�G�ºK5¿'¦R³|[�M¶FRKZG�M¶Fdc°\§K�M¶F�c°ILS�G�¯H«acVMbS�F9M´U�¯HUVKa¬�¯R³RM¶FdILKN³|[�cVMbFR¼ecV\RK¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³RcVS=cV\RK"c°S�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³HUVcVILMbFR¼[�»d¦R³¶MbcV¯HG�KZU5O¥�ˬ�cV\RKÄc°\RK5S�ILº¥M|U=K5»�½PKZGRG�KZG¥M¶FÅcV\RK7�°��� UVcVILMbFR¼7S�Fѳ¶S_«5[�³&�([�³´[�½RM¶����[�¯,Y<cV\RK5FÅcV\RKM¶F_cVK5ILKZUVc°M¶FR¼0¦R\�º�UVM´«5U"«aS�»:KZU�¬�ILS�» cV\RK9©(S�IL³´GRUV\§KNK5c�MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU5YH©�I�[�¦R¦RM¶FR¼0UVS�»dK�����«aº�«�³¶KZU"M¶FÏcV\RK��[�³|[�½RM¶����[�¯,O<��F0cV\RKD»dMbILILS�I(�V��± G�KZUL«aILM¶¦Rc°M¶S�FdS�FRK"¼�K5cÊU�[�UVcVILMbFR¼e©M¶cV\RS�¯Rc(©(S�IL³|GRUV\RK5K5c�MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVMbF§¼�cVSÃcV\RK�¦§ILKN¦PS�cVKNF�cVM´[�³�YH[�FPG7KaÒ£KZ«acVMbW�K5³¶º7ILK¨GJ¯H«aMbFR¼dcVSÃUVS�»dKeÀHK5³´GÄcV\RK5S�ILº�O��&\RM´U�ÀHK5³´GcV\RK5S�ILºoM|Ue]'FRS�©F¥M¶Fªc°\§KØ«5[�UVKdS�¬�¼�³¶S�½H[�³��([�³´[�½§Mb����[�¯,O0±1¯§c=MbceM´UeF§S�c�]$FRS�©�FªK5¿'¦R³¶M|«�M¶cV³bº�MbFªcV\RK«5[�UVK�S�¬(³bS�«5[�³���[�³|[�½RM¶�$�1[�¯,O��"UD©(KdUV\H[�³¶³²UV\§S�©eYHM¶c=«N[�F¥½PK:UVS�»dK5c°M¶»dKZU"M´GJKNF�cVMúÀPK¨G�©M¶c°\¥cV\RK=¬�ILK5K¬�K5IL»dMbS�F0cV\RK5S�ILº0S�F7[�¯R¿'M¶³¶M´[�ILº���MbK5»0[�FRFÃUV¯§IV¬�[�«�K9È�« ¬°O �)( ��ËÉÊO��K5³´[�cVMbS�F�c°SÄcV\RK�¼�K5S�»dK5c°ILM|«5[�³­K5FR¼�M¶FRK5K5ILMbF§¼ � (�<M|UD[�³|UVSïHUVKa¬�¯R³<M¶Fo»0[�]'M¶FR¼Ã«aS�F�cL[�«�c ½HK5c�©(K5K5FS�¯RI�>&��GJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�Fª[�FHG cV\RKÃUV¯R¼�I�[Ó½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHGRU ©M¶cV\ż�I�[�W'M¶¦R\RS�cVS�F�ÀHK5³´GªUVcVILK5FR¼�cV\,OÏ��FHG�K5KZGTYS�¯RID«aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«ac°M¶S�F7MbF�W�S�³¶W�KZG7[d³bM�¬�c"c°SÓÀHW�K=S�IDUVM¶¿ÂG�M¶»dK5FHUVMbS�FPU5O��&\RKeÀHI�UVc�«5[�UVK=K5»�½PKZGRU�KZ[�UVMb³¶ºÃcVS�V���ÆUVcVILM¶FR¼ocV\RK5S�ILº¥©\RK5ILK0cV\RM|U:«aS�ILILKZUV¦PS�FHGRU c°S¥cV\RKó¶M�¬�c�cVSÏ�7��cV\RK5S�ILº�Oª�,SªUVK5K0cV\RKÄ©\RS�³¶KÃUVM¶¿G�M¶»dKNFPUVMbS�FH[�³�¦RM|«ac°¯§ILK¾È���O (�É�S�FRKDUV\RS�¯R³|G�¯PUVKµ�V��± ³´[�FR¼�¯P[�¼�Kµ[�FPGdc°\§K�³¶M�¬�c(c°Sd�<��c°\RK5S�ILº0ÈËS�FRKD\H[�U1cVSUVK5c > ¸ ��YRcV\RS�¯R¼�\ ÉÊO

QTK5cD¯PUD«aS�FHUVM´GJKNI"cV\RK=ÀPW�K�G�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³T³¶Mú¬�c5Oe¤ÏK9\H[�W�K��7��c°\§KNS�ILºÄS�FocV\RK7���a��¬�S�³|GÄ©M¶cV\ÏcV\RK»dK5c°ILM|«2�

��� ^ ¸ È � � � 7�> �� � � ���1É ^ 7�< ^ ��� ^ 7 ��� ^ ��� È����´�5�$É�K5ILKo©(KÏ[�ULUV¯§»:K�Y&¬�S�IÂUVM¶»d¦R³¶M´«aM¶c�º�Y(c°\P[�c X ¸ �� ^ YDUVSÅcV\H[�c�> ¸ > ¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°KZUÄ[�F(�1ǾÈ��$ÉILS�cL[�c°M¶S�F,Y<cV\_¯PUD¦RILKZUVK5ILW'M¶FR¼Ä\H[�³�¬S�¬�UV¯HUVº�OÂ��S�©E³¶K5c=¯HUeILKZG�¯H«aK�S�FªcV\RKëaM¶I�«a³bKÄ* X [�FHG¥M¶F_cVK5IL¦RILK5c

���

Page 14: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

cV\RKýP[�«L]'¼�ILS�¯§FHGÌÈ���O´�5�$ÉeMbFÑc°\§KÃc�º$¦HK7�V��� UVc°ILM¶FR¼ROªÎ"UVM¶FR¼'�¶��©(KÃ[�ILILM¶W�KÃ[�c9c°\RKÓ¬�S�³¶³bS�©M¶FR¼o�V���½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFHG �

! � ¸���< ^ 7 � > G � � ^������ � � M�� ¸ �

< ^ 7 � > G � � ^ >�� � � � � � ���� ^ X � ¸ � < ^ 7 � > G � � ^ � < ^ � � ^ 7�> �� > � � � ^ � � ^�� �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� 77 < ^ 7�� > G � � ^ ��� ^ � �

È����´��(�É

©\§KNILK"cV\RKD¼�I�[�W'M¶¦R\RS�cVS�FÄǾÈL��É<ÀHK5³´GØM´U1cV¯RILFRKZGdS�F,O��&\RK��V��� UVcVILMbF§¼�«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼e½HKZ«aS�»dKZU(UVc°ILS�FR¼�[�c� @ 0 O1�S�©(K5W�K5IZY'cV\RKeKaÒ£KZ«ac°M¶W�K=«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼9MbFÄc°\§K¾«5[�³|«�¯§³´[�cVMbS�FPU1S�¬ � � M|U�� O*! � � �'� � � M � � ^ O���< ^ 7 � > G � � ^�� �� @ � B � @ 0 È����´�5#$É

u_�|��� � y�� ��n5{�~� ¯RI(¯R³¶c°M¶»0[�c°KD¼�S'[�³�M´U&c°\§K�«5[�³´«a¯R³|[�c°M¶S�FÄS�¬²cV\RKe¦H[�ILcVMbcVMbS�FÓ¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�F��È^� $& � �4B�>"É1¸ ���

� ' � + M � ! � � �+���6���2V � � � � È����´�5�$ÉS�¬Tc°\RK&· ¸ ��UV¯PUVº�¼'[�¯R¼�K(cV\RK5S�ILº=©M¶cV\Ø[�³¶³�c°\§K\RM¶¼�\RK5I�«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbF§¼'U�ÈL��O|��É,S�Fdc°\RK�½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHGdÈ���O (�É©M¶cV\7c°\RK ÀH¿$K¨G7[�UVº$»d¦Rc°S�cVM|«NU&S�¬�c°\RK��M¶¼�¼'U1ÀHK5³|G7[�cM¶F�ÀHFRM¶FRM¶c�º�O<¤¥K=¯HUVKDcV\RKD¬�[�«ac"cV\H[�ccV\RK=«L\RM¶I�[�³G�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHU�[�ILK=FRS�cDUVKNFPUVMbcVMbW�KecVSÃcV\RK�[�F�c°M¶��«L\RM¶I�[�³T¦H[�I�[�»dK5c°K5I�U È�¯R¦�c°SÓ\RS�³bS�»dS�IL¦R\§M´«D[�F§S�»Ø[�³¶º�)(')��ÉLOd¤¥K:cL[�]�Kdc°\§K:³¶M¶»:M¶c � ��@ 0 Y�[�FHG�cV\RK�¦H[�ILcVM¶c°M¶S�F�¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�F¥½HKZ«aS�»dKZUec°\RK0UV¯R» S�W�K5I�cV\RKM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FëL\P[�IL¼�K¨U�S�¬­cV\RKDM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³|U1S�W�K5I(cV\RKD»dS_GJ¯R³bMPUV¦H[�«aK¨U�� S�¬­M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU�S�¬�c°\RK »:KZ[�UV¯RILK�YS�½RcL[�MbF§K¨Gѽ�ºÑc°\§KoG�K5W�KN³¶S�¦RM¶FR¼¥c°\§K7¦H[�c°\ MbF�cVK5¼�I�[�³(¦HK5ILcV¯RIL½H[�cVMbS�FÌK5¿'¦P[�FHUVMbS�F [�ILS�¯§FHGªM¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FUVS�³¶¯Rc°M¶S�FHU5O� F cV\RKoS�cV\RK5IÃ\P[�FHGTY�Mú¬=©(K7cÊ[�]�K¥M¶FHUVcVK¨[�G [ª³¶S�©��K5FRK5IL¼�ºÅ³¶Mb»dM¶cNY�cV\RM´UÓ«N[�³|«a¯R³|[�c°M¶S�F UV\RS�¯R³|GILKZG�¯H«aKdc°S�c°\P[�c=S�¬�³¶S�©���K5FRK5IL¼�º�K�ÒTKZ«ac°M¶W�KÃ[�«ac°M¶S�F,Oo��FÅcV\RKÃUVcL[�FHGR[�I�G %'K5M¶½HK5IL¼���¤ M¶c°cVK5FÅUVcVS�ILºÏcV\RK³¶S�©���K5FRK5IL¼�º0cV\RK5S�ILº7M|UD«L\H[�I�[�«acVK5ILM .5KZG7½�ºÄc°\RKd«aS�»:¦§³bK5¿'M�ÀHKZG7K5FRK5IL¼�º7UL«5[�³bK�S(O ) ��� V ^ X2Y\[^] � ����� � O¤¥K�F§S�©¹ILKZ«5[�³b³�È���O>�$ÉLO���FÃS�¯RI"UVK5c°¯R¦ÄcV\RK�³¶S�©��K5FRK5IL¼�º:UL«5[�³bK M´U È � B � É���G�K5¦PK5FHG�K5F�c6�

S"È � B � É1¸ ) ��� V ^ X2Y [^] ��� : ��� ����� � ¸ESLV ^ X2Y ��� � � �� � � � � � È����´���É��KZ[�I � ¸ �DM¶c�M|U�ÀHFRM¶cVKÁYå©\RM¶³bK[�c � @ 0 cV\RKcV\RK5S�ILºe½HKZ«aS�»dK¨U²MbF�ÀPFRMbcVK5³bºe©(KZ[�]'³¶º�«aS�¯R¦R³¶K¨G O,¤ MbcV\È���O>�$É1MbFÄ»dMbFHGØ©(K¾«5[�FÄK¨[�UVM¶³¶º:ILK5³|[�c°KecV\RK�¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�Fd¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FÃcVSdc°\RKe¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�c°M|[�³�ÈL��O #$ÉLÈ�« ¬°O&�� �É �

� ¸ ���� �"! K5¿'¦ � � g � � g � � Y & � ! È���� � $& � S"È � B � ÉVÉ 7 �'z ���R���7�����az|�Z{���z|���Lp ¸¸ K5¿$¦ � X ^ � � Y & � ! È��4B � $& � S�É 7$#=È� X B� ^ É � È����´���$É

�5�

Page 15: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

©\§KNILK � Y & � ! M|UDcV\RK0UV¯R» S�¬�[�³¶³�M¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FÏ«aS�ILILKZ«ac°M¶S�FHU c°S7cV\RKd¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³�Y�[�FHG0� �� �"! M|UDcV\RKILKZUV¯R³¶cS�¬�cV\RK�¦PK5ILc°¯§IL½H[�c°M¶W�K=«N[�³|«a¯R³|[�c°M¶S�F7S�FocV\RK�>(��½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFPGTO�(\§K�«�S�ILILKZ«acVMbS�FHU&MbF X : ^ «�S�»dK¬�ILS�» c°\RKeM¶¼�FRS�ILKZGÄ\RMb¼�\§KNI"G�K5ILMbW�[�c°M¶W�K�cVK5IL»0U5O�(\RKe¦PKNILcV¯RIL½H[�cVM¶W�K�¦H[�ILc�M´U�¼�M¶W�K5F7½_ºÓc°\RK=S�F§KN��³¶S'S�¦«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVMbS�FÙ¬�ILS�» ¤ ��½HS'UVS�FHU5Y�[�UÍ©(K5³b³[�UÍFRS�FR��.5KNILS7»dS�G�KZUeS�¬µcV\RK7[�½HK5³¶M´[�F ¦R\RS�cVS�FHU5O ��KZ«5[�³b³cV\H[�cM¶F0cV\RK >&��½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHG9S�FRK�«5[�FÄMbF�cVKN¼�I�[�cVK"S�¯Rc�[�³¶³TFRS�FR��.5K5ILS�»dS�G�KZU5YR[�U�> ³bM�¬�cLU[�³¶³T»Ø[�ULUV³¶KZULUÀHK5³|GRU5O(±1K¨«5[�¯HUVKeS�¬�c°\§K�ILKZG�¯H«aKZGÄUV¯R¦HK5I�UVº$»:»dK5cVILº:cV\RK=G�K5c°K5IL»dM¶FH[�F�cÊU(G�SdFRS�c � ¯RM¶cVK�«N[�FP«�K5³�O(�(\RKUVM¶»:¦§³bKZUVc1©[ZºdcVSØ«5[�³|«a¯R³´[�cVKec°\RK5»?M|U(cVSd¼�S�cVSdc°\RKe½H[�UVM|U1S�¬�UV¦R\RK5ILM´«5[�³P\H[�IL»dS�FRM|«NU��

��� � O "Y : �N: Y : ��� X � � �Y � Y � � Y XX � � X^ � Y XX � � X^ B ��B � ¸3��B��6��� �� FR³bºdcV\RKec°S�¦7UV¦RM¶FæRILS�®VK¨«acVMbS�FPU(«�S�F�cVILMb½§¯Rc°K�Y�¼�M¶W'M¶FR¼�ILM|UVK"c°S �

� �� �"! ¸ )�\: � � Y : ��� X� È^� � � � � 7 X È � � ��É 7 ^ È�� � ��É°É È����´�5)$É

cVMb»dKZUDcV\RKd«�S�F�®V¯R¼'[�c°KdcVK5IL»ÂY ©\RM|«L\¥G�K5¦HK5FHGRU S�F �RO9¤¥KØUV\P[�³b³<¯R³¶c°M¶»0[�c°K5³¶º7cÊ[�]�K ��@ 0 Y�UVSé(KM¶¼�FRS�ILKdc°\RM|UecVKNIL»�� [�c�[�F_º�I�[�c°K�Y�Mbc�«5[�FH«aK5³´UeS�¯§c=MbFªcV\RKëaS�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�F¥¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FPUeS�¬�cV\RK0«L\RM¶I�[�³S�½HUVK5ILW�[�½R³¶KZUdOÌ�(\RK7UVº'»9½HS�³� � M¶F¹È���O|�5)$É�»dKZ[�FHU=cV\H[�c9c°\RK7«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVMbS�F S�¬µcV\RK�.5KNILS¥»dS_GJK¨U��¸ �oY �<¸�9¸ �&c°S=cV\RK�¦RILS_G�¯P«�c�M´U<S�»dM¶c°cVKZGTO<¤¥KDUV\H[�³b³R[�³¶©[Zº�U<¯RFHGJKNI�UVcL[�FHGdÈ���O´�5)$É<M¶F�cV\RKDUVKNFPUVKS�¬�����ILK5¼�¯R³|[�ILM .Z[�cVMbS�F,O��(¬�cVK5I"ILKN¼�¯§³´[�ILM .Z[�c°M¶S�F0S�FRK�«5[�Fo[�FH[�³¶º'cVM|«N[�³¶³¶ºØ«aS�F�cVMbF�¯RK"cVS� X 7 ^ ¸¹��O

��FÓ¬�[�«acNYJ¬�S�I� X ¸ �� ^ ¸ �� S�FRK=«N[�FÄK5¿'¦H[�FPGB���È�� $& � � B�>"É1¸ K5¿'¦� � '"� + � �� ^ � ^ � � È^� � �

$& � S�É�� È���� ���$É�(\§K�\RM¶¼�\RK5I �V¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�c°M|[�³|U�� � � ©�Mb³¶³TcV¯RILFÃS�¯§c³|[�c°K5I"c°Sd½PK�ILK5³|[�c°KZGÄcVSdc°\RKe\RM¶¼�\RK5I(¼�K5F_¯PUUVcVILMbFR¼[�»d¦R³¶MbcV¯HG�KZU5O

u_�Þ�R�µhÊ��p���{��R��n��¥�0��{�p�y��L�

�"U"©M¶³¶³­½PK=\RS�¦PKa¬�¯R³b³¶º7«�³¶KZ[�ID½�º0cV\RK�K5FHGÄS�¬(c°\§K¨UVK�«aS�»dM¶FR¼0UVK¨«acVMbS�FPU5YHcV\RKe· ¸3�dM¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�F»dKZ[�UV¯RILK7È�cVS�¼�K5c°\RK5Id©M¶cV\Ìc°\RKÄS�½HUVK5ILW�[�½R³¶KZU � Éec°I�[�FHUV³|[�cVK¨UÍc°S¥cV\RK7A0��K � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM|[�F�c�«�S�\§S�»:S�³¶S�¼�º«a³´[�ULU8>�ÑS�¬ � O��&\RK�«aS�ILILK5³´[�cVM¶S�Fd¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FÄMbFÄcV\RK�¼'[�¯§¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILº0½PKZ«�S�»dKZUUVM¶»d¦R³¶º�cV\RKDM¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�³

J � K�¸ ��� >� È���� �R��É�(\§K�¼�ILS�¯R¦�A [�«acÊU"M¶F7cV\RK�M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FÄ»dS_G�¯R³¶M,UV¦H[�«aKe½_ºÓILS�cÊ[�cVMbF§¼:cV\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�KeS�ILMbK5F�cÊ[�cVM¶S�FÃS�¬�cV\RKM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU,[�c�MbF�ÀPFRMbc�º�È�M¶F�S�cV\RK5I�©(S�I�GRU5Y�� M|U,cV\RK � ¯RS�c°M¶K5F�c­S�¬TcV\RKUV¦H[�«aK(S�¬£[�F�c°M¶��UVK5³ú¬���G�¯H[�³�¼'[�¯R¼�K

�5�

Page 16: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

ÀHK5³|GRU�½_ºÓc°\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�Kec°I�[�FPU�¬�S�IL»Ø[�cVM¶S�FHU[�¦R¦§ILS'[�«L\RM¶FR¼=M|G�K5F_cVM¶c�ºÃ[�cM¶F�ÀHF§Mbc�º§É ` O %'¯H« \ÃM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³|U«5[�F½PK�«aS�»:¦§¯Rc°KZGÓ¯HUVM¶FR¼=³bS�«5[�³bM .Z[�c°M¶S�F,O���FĦR³|[�MbF0©(S�I�G§U1Mbc(»dKZ[�FHU1cV\H[�ccV\RK5ILK�[�ILKD¼�M¶W�K5F0½�º:cV\RK=UV¯R»0US�W�KNI c°\RKeÀP¿'KZG�¦HS�M¶F�cÊU"S�¬1c°\RKd[�«ac°M¶S�F¥S�¬�c°\§K�S�FRK5��¦H[�I�[�»dK5c°ILM|«�UV¯§½R¼�ILS�¯R¦ÄKN¿$¦,È��N��ÉLY�� *ª@�YTS�¬�AoO�(\§K¾«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVM¶S�F0S�¬�K¨[�« \0ÀP¿'KZGĦHS�M¶F�c�� * � È�[�ULUV¯R»dMbFR¼=M¶cM|U�M´UVS�³|[�cVK¨GÄ[�FHG � M´U�UV»:S$S�c°\o[�ccV\RM´U&¦HS�M¶F�c�É1M´U&¼�MbW�K5FĽ�º:cV\RKeI�[�c°M¶S �

���¥¸ > � ��� � � � A� È � � É ��� � � � A� È���� ���$É

©\§KNILK�� � � � G�K5FRS�cVKZU9c°\RK7UL«5[�³´[�Id«aS�»:¦PS�FRK5F�c=S�¬Dc°\RK7M¶FR\RS�»dS�¼�K5FRK5S�¯HUeG�M�Ò£K5ILK5F�c°M|[�³1¬�S�IL» «aS�ILILK5�UV¦PS�FHG�M¶FR¼DcVS=c°\RK"K � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�c�GJMúÒTK5ILKNF�cVM´[�³$¬�S�IL» ��Y_[�FPG È � � É<M´U�cV\RK"K � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM´[�F�c��1\RK5ILFd¦HS�³¶º'�FRS�»dM|[�³�S�¬ � � Oª��c�M|U�G�KaÀHFRKZGª[�U¾¬�S�³b³¶S�©�U5Oª�"U � � M|UdA0��K � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�cNY<©�MbcV\ÌILKZUV¦HKZ«ac=cVSÏcV\RK»0[�¿'M¶»0[�³HcVS�IL¯HU6 M¶cUV¦R³¶MbcLU[�U�[:GJMbILKZ«acUV¯R» S�¬�c°\RKe³¶MbFRK ½R¯RFHG�³¶KZU5Y

� � ¸�� Y . YS�FÌ©\§M´« \ ,o[�«acLU�©�MbcV\ UVS�»dKé(K5M¶¼�\�c � Y È�[¥³¶MbFRKZ[�Iͬ�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FÌS�F�,�ÉÊO �(\RKÄK � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM|[�F_c ��\RK5ILF¦PS�³bº$FRS�»dM´[�³PM´U�G�KaÀHFRKZGÄUVMb»d¦R³¶º�½�º �

È � � É �� T¸ ) Y È X È . Y É 7 � Y È��PÉLÉ` ì��åÝ�Ý���ø�ùÞà5ßZç�ùúßZÛ"æLá��á�é"á�Ü á 4,'0æLÜúß5ä�ä�ÝLäDßZç�ݵç�Ý $'ç�ÝLä�Ý�Û"�Ý dñ�ù&"���"���Ý ��ÝLÜ!$dá5â5"���Ý"Ý���ø�ùÞàNßZç�ù ß�Û"(â|á�ç�é"ä +

ì��åÝLä�Ý0ßZç�Ý=â�ø'Ûåæ�"�ùÞá�Û�äeá�Û��ªñ�ù&"�� "���Ý=à5ß5Üúø�ÝLä�ùúÛ "��åÝ �Ýd÷ �$ßZé æLá�é $�ÜÞÝ��¥á5â�� +ªë�Ûoß � �ù&"�ùÞá�Û§ï5"���ÝLä�Ýâ�ø'Û�æ�"�ù á�Û�äßZç�ÝDç�Ý���ø�ùúç�Ý "�á�ã$Ý�����Ý���ø�ùÞàNß�ç�ùúßZÛ"�ïRù + Ý,+ "���Ý "���ÝDß, ���áZùúÛ"(ß5æ�"�ùÞá�Ûdá¨â��Eá�Û��7é"ø�ä "1æLá�éDé"ø�"�Ýñ�ù&"���"��åÝ�ß5æ�"�ù á�Û�á¨â��Öá�Û "��åÝ% �ù RÝ�ç�Ý�Û"�ùúß5ܧâ´á�ç�é"ä1á�Û!� +,ì ��Ý% �ù RÝ�ç�Ý�Û"�ùúß5ܧâ|á�ç�é"ä1á�Û�� �'ßaàZÝß �Ý�4�ç�ÝLÝ,+ì��åÝ=Ý��Áøåù à5ßZç�ùúßZÛ"Íâ´á�ç�é"ä�ßZç�Ýdã�ù� 4�ç�ß �Ý Rê9ã'2"��åÝ �Ý�4�ç�ÝLÝ�"�á5â "6��Ýeâ|á�ç�é á�Û#� ßZÛ� �ã' "��åÝ �Ý�4�ç�ÝLÝ%$á5â5"���Ý"â�ø'Ûåæ�"�ùÞá�Ûdá�Û&�#+�ì ��ÝDÝ���ø�ùÞàNß�ç�ùúßZÛ" �ù RÝ�ç�Ý�Û"�ùúß5Ü�ç�ß5ùÞä�ÝLäDã'�á�Û�Ý "���Ý æLá�é"ã�ùúÛ'ß�"�ù á�Û'"�(oô)$eá5â5"���ÝLä�Ý �Ý�4�ç�ÝLÝLä +"ì���Ý"Ý���ø�ùÞàNßZç�ù ß�Û"�æLá��á�é"á�Ü á 4,'dù ä 4�ç�ß, åÝ 0ã' "��åù ä(æLá�é�ãåùúÛ'ß�"�ùÞá�ÛÓá�ÛåÜ ',+"ì���øåä�ï'ñ ��Ý�Ûdñ<Ý"ä�$$Ý�ß,1á5â�ßÓç�Ý $'ç�ÝLä�Ý�Û"°ß�"�ùÞàZÝ9á5â "��åÝ=Ý��Áøåù à5ßZç�ùúßZÛ"eæLá ��á�é"áZÜÞá,4,'7æLÜúß5ä�äaï<ù "eéDß9'Âã$Ý 4ZùÞàZÝ�Û�ã'ÃßZÛÄùúÛ��åá�é"á,4ZÝ�ÛåÝLá�ø�ä �ù RÝ�ç�Ý�Û"�ùúß5ÜPâ|á�ç�é á�Û!�?ê

*,+'-,./�0 �2143 576 "8:9<;>=@? .

5�A 8:BC�D A =@BC 0 ôFE ô�ô)1

ñ �åÝ�ç�Ý D A =@BC ùÞäTß �åá�é"á,4�Ý�Û�ÝLá�øåä åÝ�4�ç�ÝLÝ4$�$$áZÜ&'ÁÛåá�é"ùúß5Ü�á�ÛG�#+Hì �'ßZÛ�1Zä "�á�"��åÝLùúçPÝ��Áøåù à5ßZç�ùúßZÛåæLÝ�ä°øåæ ��âèø$Û�æ�"�ùÞá�Ûåä5oßZç�Ý(ø'Û�ùH��ø�ÝLÜ&' �Ý�"�Ý�ç�éµù ÛåÝ �ã' "��åÝLù ç²àNß5Üúø�ÝLä�á�Û�I 0 ñ ��Ý�ç�Ý "��åÝ�á�ÛåÜ&'�ß, � åù&"�ùÞá�Û'ß5Ü�æLá�Ûåä "°ç�ߨù Û"<ùÞä�ùúÛ�àNß�ç�ùúßZÛ�æLÝø'Û� �Ý�ç "6��Ý!J0Ý�'�Ü 4�ç�á�ø�$�ç�ÝLK_ÝLæ�"�ù á�Û�äM1�+ON�á0ÜÞÝ�"¾øåäQPR�Âß�Û7ÝLÜÞÝ�é"Ý�Û"!S + I +oì��åÝ=àNß5ÜúøåÝ:á¨âUT4VXW�Y�Z�ùÞä¾ß�Ûá�ç åùúÛ'ßZç ' åù JÝ�ç�Ý�Û"�ùúß5ÜRâ|á�ç�é á�Û[� ßZÛ� eù "�ä(ù Û"�Ý�4�ç�ß5ÜRæ�ß�Û:ã$Ý�æLá�Û�àZÝ�Û"�ùÞá�Û$ß5ÜÞÜ '7 �ÝLPRÛ�Ý �+

��(

Page 17: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

��\_º�UVM´«aM|UVcÊU9[�ILKd¬�[�»dMb³¶M|[�I=©M¶c°\ÌcV\RK7!"¯RM|UVc°K5IL»0[�[�c°���KZ«L]$»Ø[�F§F � #���1¬�S�IL»9¯R³|[�K0³bM¶]�KoÈ���O ���$ÉeMbFÌcV\RK«aS�F�c°K5¿'c<S�¬Hc�©(S���GJMb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³ �1[�FR¼����7M¶³b³|UTcV\RK5S�ILº:� #R���YÁ[�FPGeMbF0È˦HK5IL\H[�¦PU,³¶KZULU�]'FRS�©FTÉPc°\§K«�S�F�cVK5¿'cS�¬µUVM¶¼�»0[7»dS_GJKN³|U6� #����Oª��FÑS�I�G�K5I=cVSϦ§ILS_«aK5K¨GÙ©(KÃFRK5KZG c°S¥«N[�³|«a¯R³|[�c°K0cV\RKÄF�¯R»dKNI�[�cVS�I=[�FHGªcV\RKG�K5FRS�»dM¶FH[�c°S�I(S�¬(È���OÞ���$É�[�FPG0cVS0UV¯R»?S�W�KNI(cV\RKe¦HS�M¶F�cÊU ��O�y��R�R~|� p�n������ez|��p���{��R��n��o�9nN��y�~úz�p��'{'qa�

�K5ILK0©(KdILK¨«5[�³¶³UVS�»dKØUVcL[�FHGR[�I�G¥«aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«ac°M¶S�FHU5Oo�&\RK0¦RILS�½§³bK5» «aS�FHUVM|G�K5ILKZG�\RK5ILK0M´U=[�½PUVS��³¶¯Rc°K5³¶ºÃc�º'¦RM|«5[�³,M¶FocV\RK�UVS�³bM¶cVS�F7¦R\�º_UVM|«NU5O � FRK ÀHFHG§UUVS�»dK�»dS�G�¯R³¶M­UV¦H[�«aKeS�¬�UVS�³b¯§c°M¶S�FHUDÈ�«aS�³b³¶KZ«ac°M¶W�K«aS'S�I�G�M¶FH[�cVKZUaÉ�©\§M´« \oUV\RS�¯R³|G0½PK � ¯H[�F�cVM .5KZGTO"�(\RK�UV¯§¦HK5I�UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«�c°\§KNS�ILM¶KZU�³bKZ[�G7cVSÃUV¯R¦PK5I�UVº'»d�»dK5c°ILM|« � ¯H[�F�cV¯R» »dK¨« \H[�FRM|«5U"S�FªcV\RKd»:S�G�¯R³¶M�UV¦H[�«aKZU5O0�ˬ�cV\RKd¼'[�¯R¼�KdUVº'»d»dKNcVILºoM|U ¦RILKZUVKNF�cDcV\RK«aS�³b³¶KZ«ac°M¶W�K«aS'S�I�G�M¶FH[�cVK¨U<[�ILK(G�KaÀHFRKZGe©M¶cV\�cV\RK(\RK5³b¦=S�¬TUVS�»:K1¼'[�¯R¼�K1ÀH¿$MbF§¼�¦§ILS_«aKZG�¯RILK�YZ©�\RM´« \=³bKZ[�GRUcVS:cV\RK=«aS�»:¦§³bM|«5[�c°M¶S�FHU(G�KZUL«aILMb½PKZGd½PKN³¶S�©�O6X� ������� ,%� ������� ������� ����� ���� � ��� � �(\RKecÊ[�F§¼�KNF�c"UV¦H[�«aK�cVS0cV\RK=MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FûdS_GJ¯R³bM,UV¦P[�«�K �[�c=cV\RK0¦PS�MbF�c � «5[�FѽHKÃGJK¨UL«aILM¶½HKZG¥[�U ¬�S�³¶³bS�©�U5O7��M´« ]Ù[ļ'[�¯§¼�KdÀHK5³´G � ©\RM|«L\ª«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FPGRUDcVS� * � Y ! È�� É1¸ ��O���F_ºec�©(S�UV¯P«L\:« \RS�M|«�KZU�GJMúÒTK5I­½�º=[D¼'[�¯§¼�K(c°I�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F�O,��S�©Ì«aS�FHUVM´GJKNIG�Ka¬�S�IL»dMbF§¼ � � � @ � 7 � �UVSdc°\P[�c�cV\RK=FRK5©.¼'[�¯R¼�K ÀHK5³´G7[�³|UVSdS�½HK5º_Uµc°\RK=M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FÄK � ¯H[�cVMbS�F ! È�� 7 � � É(¸3��O���F7S�cV\RK5I©(S�I�GRU5Y � � S�½PKNº�U(cV\RKe³bM¶FRKZ[�IK � ¯P[�c°M¶S�FHU��

� � � � ¸ �� �� � � ¸ � È���� ��(�É©\§KNILK"cV\RK�ÀHI�UVc1K � ¯H[�cVMbS�F0M|U1cV\RK"³bM¶FRKZ[�ILM .5KZGd[�F�c°M¶��UVKN³�¬���G�¯H[�³¶Mbc�º�K � ¯P[�c°M¶S�F,Y$©\RM¶³bK"cV\RK�UVKZ«aS�FHG9M´U1cV\RK¼'[�¯R¼�K�« \RS�M|«�K�Y�c°S"¦RILS�®VKZ«acTS�¯Rc�c°\RK1cVILMbW$M´[�³'G�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�FHU � �IO � ��� O�QTK5c�¯HU,« \RS'S'UVK�UVS�»dK�½P[�UVM´UPM¶FcV\RKDÈ|ÀPFRMbcVK5��G�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³ËÉ_W�KZ«ac°S�I1UV¦H[�«aK�S�¬£UVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�FPUTcVS�È���OÞ��(�É � � � ¸E���� � � � � � Y�©\§KNILKH���ÌS�½PK5ºÈ���O ��(�ÉLY­[�FPGTYTUL[Zº�Y,[�ILK9S�ILc°\RS�F§S�IL»Ø[�³�©�O IZO c"cVSÃcV\RKdFH[�cV¯RI�[�³,»dK5cVILM´« J � � A � � K����! � � �#"%$ � � ¸� � � Y .8B'& ¸ ��B������ BÊGJMb» � OE��S�© UV¯R¦§¦HS'UVK7©(K�\H[ZW�Ko[Ù¬�[�»dMb³¶ºÌS�¬=MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�F ¼'[�¯R¼�KÄÀHK5³|GRU5Y¦H[�I�[�»dK5c°K5ILM .5K¨G9½�º�cV\RKD¦PS�M¶F_cLU1S�¬ � ����RÈ � � �7ÉLYR©�\RK5ILK � *7@dg B�� * � O�Q KNc�¯HU(G�M�Ò£K5ILK5F�c°M|[�cVK���:©eO IZO c(cV\RK�»dS�G�¯R³¶M ��O��1³bKZ[�IL³¶ºÁY�S�F§K�«5[�FÃK5¿'¦P[�FHGB�

� �� � � ¸E� � � � � 7 � � � � È���� ��#$É�(\§Kµ«aS�»d¦PKNFPUL[�c°M¶FR¼=¼'[�¯R¼�K"cVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHU � � c°S�¼�K5cV\RK5I©�MbcV\ ���RÈ ��É<¬�S�IL»?[�«aS�FRFRKZ«ac°M¶S�F �.¸���RÈ � � ��É � � � 7 � � � � � MbF¥cV\RKdI�[�FR] � W�KZ«acVS�I�½R¯§FHG�³¶K)(ÑS�W�K5I � �o@ g Od� »Ø[�cV\RK5»0[�c°M|«5[�³b³¶º

�5#

Page 18: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

S�ILM¶KNF�cVKZGÌILKZ[�G�K5I0©(S�¯R³|GÌS�½�®VK¨«ac7[�cÃcV\RM|Ud¦PS�MbF�c5YD[�U0M¶c z¶pÏr&��~�~ú�����Rn�r�� cV\H[�c0¯RFRM¶W�K5I�UL[�³"½R¯RFHG�³¶KZUcVS�¼�KNcV\RK5I<©M¶c°\d[�FRM´«aK(«aS�FRFRKZ«ac°M¶S�FHU,GJS�F§S�c­K5¿$M´UVc�S�W�K5I<c°\§K�«aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�ÀHKZGe»dS_G�¯§³bM'UV¦H[�«aKZU5O�¤ÏK(UV\H[�³¶³FRS�c�¦H[Zºe[�c°cVK5F_cVM¶S�F=c°S"cV\RKZUVKDÈ|¬�¯R³¶³¶º�®V¯HUVcaÉHILK5»0[�IL]_U5Y�[�U�K5W�K5F�c°¯H[�³¶³¶º�cV\RK5ILK1M´U<[�©[Zºe[�ILS�¯RFHGTOT¤¥K�ÀHFHGM¶c�»dS�ILK=UVc°I�[�M¶¼�\�c�¬�S�IL©[�I�GØc°S0K5¿$¦R³´[�M¶FocV\RM¶FR¼'U"[�U�Mú¬�UV¯P«L\7S�½_®VKZ«acLU"K5¿'M|UVc°KZG7S�W�K5I"c°\RK�«aS�»d¦H[�«acVMúÀHKZG»dS_G�¯§³bMHUV¦P[�«�K"S�¬,M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5O<QTK5c �0G�K5FRS�c°K"cV\RKD¦RILS�®VK¨«acVMbS�F � ��@ g @ � O1%$¯R¦R¦PS'UVK©(K"]'FRS�©K5W�K5ILº'cV\RMbF§¼Ã[�½HS�¯§c (<O9S�©.©(S�¯R³´G�©(K=ILKZ«�S�FPUVc°IL¯H«ac � � ¬�ILS�» c°\RK5ILK � ¤¥K9]'FRS�© [�³¶ILKZ[�G�ºÄc°\H[�ccV\RK=cÊ[�F§¼�KNF�c"UV¦H[�«aKDc°S � [�cD[9¦PS�MbF�c � M´U"UV¦H[�F§FRKZGd½�º0c°\§K�UVS�³b¯RcVM¶S�FHU(cVS7È���OÞ��(�ÉÊO"��c"M|U(¦R³|[�MbF7cVSM|G�K5F_cVM�¬�º:cV\RKZUVK=UVS�³b¯RcVM¶S�FHU1©M¶c°\ÄcV\RK¾«aS�\RS�»dS�³¶S�¼�ºdS�¬²cV\RK��&c°M¶º'[�\R�V%'M¶FR¼�K5I«aS�»:¦§³bK5¿ �

� ��@ > � È�@ g É�� � � @ > X È�@ g É�� � ��@ > ^ : È�@ g É�� � ��@ � È���� ���$É©\§KNILKecV\RKeÀHI�UVcF§S�FR��c°ILM¶W'M|[�³­[�ILILS�©¹M´U�cV\RK=MbFJÀHFRM¶c°KZUVM¶»Ø[�³T¼'[�¯§¼�K=c°I�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F � ���@ � � � [�FHGcV\RK�UVKZ«�S�FPGÄMbc � � �@ � � � �eO"�(\H[�F§]_U�c°S ! � ¸3�9cV\RM|UM|U�MbFPG�K5K¨G7[d«aS�»d¦R³¶KN¿PYPM�O K�O � � � � ¸ ��O�(\§K�UV¦H[�«aKZU�>;=�� � «5[�FĽHKeW'M¶K5©(K¨GÄ[�U(cV\RKe½R¯RFHGJ³bKZU1S�W�KNI � �Ã@ g Y�K�O ¼RO<¬�S�IDA ¸ Ç=È$��É

> = È�@ g É�� � ¸ (� ( � ��S = � � @ g È���� � �É�"KNF§KNILM|«5[�³b³¶ºÑc°\RK¥«aS�»:¦§³bK5¿ È���O ���$É�\P[�UdS�FR³¶º'9 X «aS�\RS�»dS�³bS�¼�º�O ¤ÏKª[�ILK7cV\�¯HUd³¶K¨G c°SÑM|G�K5F_cVM�¬�º2 ��«a³|[�ULUVKZU�� � � ¸ 9 X �19 � �19 ^ OC � �� � ��� � � � B � � � � � �� � � ��� � ¤¥K=UV\H[�³¶³TFRK5K¨GÓc�©(Sd»dS�ILKDFH[�cV¯RI�[�³P½R¯RFHG�³¶KZU(S�W�K5I � O��"U �M|UG�KaÀHFRKZGd½�º9c°\RK � ¯§S�c°M¶K5F_c(©eO IZO c5O<c°\RK ¼�ILS�¯R¦0S�¬­¼'[�¯§¼�KDc°I�[�FPU�¬�S�IL»Ø[�cVM¶S�FHU5Y�c°ILM¶W'M|[�³,[�c(MbFJÀHFRM¶c�º�Y'©(K\H[�W�K�[9½R¯RFHGJ³bK�� S�W�K5I � ©\§S'UVK"ÀH½PKNI�M´U�cV\RK ÀH½HK5I�S�¬²cV\RKeS�ILMb¼�M¶FH[�³�ǾÈ���ɽR¯§FHG�³¶KDS�W�K5I"@ g [�cM¶F�ÀHFRM¶c�º�O­��FRS�cV\RK5I(M¶»:¦PS�ILcL[�F_c�½R¯RFHG�³¶K(M|U1c°\RK"½R¯§FHG�³¶K�� S�¬­!"M¶I�[�«8.NK5ILS=»dS_GJK¨U5O<��cLU�ÀH½PKNI(S�W�K5I�cV\RK¦PS�MbF�c � * � M|U(cV\RK�UV¦P[�«�K S�¬²F§S�IL»Ø[�³¶M .¨[�½§³bK"UVS�³b¯RcVM¶S�FHU1c°S9c°\§K¾!"M¶I�[�«"K � ¯P[�c°M¶S�FÃM¶FÓ¬�¯RFHGR[�»dK5F�cÊ[�³ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�FdM¶FÃcV\RKD½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFPG�S�¬<c°\§K�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�Fd¼'[�¯R¼�K"ÀHK5³|GTY�«�S�ILILKZUV¦PS�FHG�M¶FR¼ec°S ��O���FÃcV\RK³|[�FR¼�¯H[�¼�KDS�¬ 2D��cV\RK5S�ILºÁY

� ¸ ³bM¶»��� '( A �

�.¸ � � (È���� �1�$É

�(\§K�¦R¯HUV\�¬�S�IL©[�I�G � � M´U�G�KaÀHFRKZG \RK5ILK�MbF . ^ UVK5FHUVK�O­��Fe©\P[�cP¬�S�³b³¶S�©"UT©(K�UV\P[�³b³�FRK5KZGDM¶cÊU�K � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�c[�FH[�³¶S�¼�¯RK�O­�²MbFH[�³¶³¶ºÁYå³bK5cH���ÏG�K5FRS�cVKcV\RK"½R¯RFHG�³¶KZU�S�¬,¦HS'UVM¶c°M¶W�K�[�FPG=FRK5¼'[�cVMbW�KD«L\§MbI�[�³¶Mbc�º¾UV¦RM¶FRS�I�U�S�W�KNI@ g O?�(\§K¨UVK�½R¯RFHGJ³bKZUd[�ILKocVILMbW$M´[�³ c°S�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³b³¶º�O?�S�©(K5W�K5I0cV\RK5º [�ILKoF§S�F_cVILM¶W'M|[�³µ[�UÓ½R¯RFPG�³bKZU5YK � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM|[�F�c(©M¶c°\ÄILKZUV¦HKZ«accVSdc°\RKe¼�ILS�¯R¦0S�¬�ILS�cL[�c°M¶S�FHU1S�¬�@ g O

�5�

Page 19: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

@ � � � , ����� � �� ��� � � �� � � ��� � ¤¥K�[�ILILMbW�K=[�c"c°\RKͬ�S�³b³¶S�©M¶FR¼�ILK5³|[�c°M¶S�FÏ[�»dS�FR¼dcV\RK=W'M¶ILc°¯P[�³,½R¯RF§�G�³¶KZU��

(�¸ � � � � È � �U� É� � ¸ � � � È (� ( � É È���� ��)$É

�(\§K« \RMbI�[�³(S�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U � $& ©(K7G�M|UL«a¯HULUVKZGªM¶FÅcV\RK7M¶F�c°ILS�G�¯H«ac°M¶S�FÑFRS�©?[�ILKÄMbFÌS�F§KN��cVS���S�FRKëaS�ILILK5�UV¦PS�FHG�K5FH«aK7©M¶c°\ c°\§KÏ«L\P[�I�[�«�cVK5ILM´UVcVM|«Ã«a³|[�ULUVK¨U9S�¬=c°\§KªÇ=È$��Éd½R¯RFHGJ³bKZU5O � «aS�F�W�K5FRM¶KNF�c9½H[�UVM´U9M¶FcV\RK0UV¦H[�«aK�S�¬�UV¯H« \Ï«a³´[�ULUVKZU M´U ¼�M¶W�KNF¥½�º7cV\RK0UV]�KN© %�«L\�¯RI"¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FHU5YT³|[�½HK5³¶K¨G�½�º7cV\RKd¦H[�ILc°M¶cVMbS�FHU�0¸ È � X�� � ^�� ����� � � � �$É �

��� � ¸ !µKNc�� � ��� Y ��� È���� ���$É��FRS�cV\RK5I½H[�UVM|U(M|U(³|[�½HK5³¶KZG0½�º9ÀHFRM¶c°KeUVK � ¯RK5FH«aKZU 5 X B 5 ^ B��6��� B 5 = S�¬­FRS�FR��FRK5¼'[�cVMbW�K MbF�cVKN¼�K5I�U��

� $& ¸ ) ' *�+ X È � * É &10 È���� �R��É��c�M´U&c°\RM|U(½P[�UVM´U&c°\H[�c(©(Ke¯HUVKZGÓMbF¥ÈÊ��O|��ÉLO

�{'qa�d��n �R�'�Zp�z�qV{�~����~ú��p�(\§Kµ«aS�FH«a³¶¯HUVM¶S�F�S�¬,S�¯RI(UVS�»dKN©�\H[�c�¬�S�IL»Ø[�³PG�M´UL«a¯HULUVM¶S�F=M|U([�¦R¦RILS'[�«L\§MbFR¼RO��(\RK"M¶»:¦PS�ILcL[�FH«aKS�¬

(�MbFÄcV\RK5S�ILKNcVM|«N[�³�¦R\�º_UVM|«5U1M´U�®V¯HUVc°M�ÀHKZGÓ½_ºdcV\RK ¬�S�³b³¶S�©�MbF§¼=M´G�K5F�cVMúÀ£«5[�cVMbS�F ���I�! * ¸ � * È (�É 7� � B6������� È���� ���$É

È�[�U7[ÅUV¯R¦PK5IVÀHK5³´G£ÉÊY"©�\RK5ILK� � B6�������ªG�K5FRS�c°K¥M¶ILILK5³bK5W�[�F�cÃUV¯R¦PK5I�UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«ÄW�[�ILM|[�c°M¶S�FHU5O?�(\§M´UÓM´U®V¯HUVcVMúÀPK¨GÓ½�ºdc°\RK=UVcVI�[�Mb¼�\�c�¬�S�IL©[�I�G:[�FP[�³bº�UVM´U&S�¬²cV\RKeMbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�F�.5K5ILS�»dS_GJK¨U5O1��FĦH[�ILc°M|«a¯R³|[�IZY�¯R¦ÃcVSM¶ILILKN³¶K5W�[�F�c� � B6�������0c°K5IL»0UDS�F§K�ÀPFHGRU"M¶FªcV\RKd½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHG7S�¬(cV\RK0M¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�Fo¼'[�¯R¼�KÍÀHK5³´G �EcV\RK¬�K5IL»dMbS�FRM|«8.5KNILSd»dS_GJK¨U�� � Y� O � �/: � Y � ���� �[�FHGÓc°\§K�K5¿'¦§ILK¨ULUVM¶S�Fd¬�S�I�c°\RK=�Mb¼�¼'U�ÀHK5³´G

!̸ �� �

� � � B $ � � � � � �©\§KNILK � � � � �� � � YP©\RM|«L\ÄM|G�K5F_cVM�ÀHKZU(M¶c�©�MbcV\7cV\RK�«a¯RILW�[�cV¯RILK�c�©(S���¬�S�IL» S�F7c°\RKe»dS_G�¯§³bM,UV¦H[�«aK� O���F0¬�[�«ac5YRcVS�¼�KNcV\RK5I"©M¶c°\ � � [�FHG ! � cV\RK5ºÃ«aS�»�½§MbFRK"M¶F�c°Sd[�«a¯RILW�[�cV¯RILK"¬�S�IL»?S�F � �Ã@ g �

!#7�� � 7 ! � � ^ ¸ �1¯RILW�[�cV¯RILK �cV\RK5ILKN½�ºD®V¯HUVM�¬�º'M¶FR¼ÃÈ���OÞ���$ÉÊO

��

Page 20: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

¤¥K�UV\H[�³¶³T¦RILKZUVK5F_c1cV\RK�K5¿$¦R³bM|«aMbc&¬�S�IL»�¯R³|[ ¬�S�IcV\RKe³bS�«5[�³bM .5K¨G � * Y -o¸ � BZ��BÊ� B������R½PK5³bS�©�Ox�n���{���z|n��R{�~<p������Ó������z��Lp

�(\§K=ÀH¿$K¨GÙ¦HS�M¶F�cÊU S�¬�cV\RKd¼�ILS�¯R¦ÑA [�ILK�cV\RKd¦PS�MbF�cV��³¶M¶]�K=MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU5O:�&\RK5ºÏG�SÄFRS�c ¬�S�IL» [FRM|«aK�M|UVS�³|[�c°KZG0UVK5c(S�¬,¦PS�MbF�cLU5O��7S�ILK5S�W�K5IZY�cV\RK�UV¦P[�«�K"S�¬,¦PS�MbF�cV��³bM¶]�K"MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU<M´U1F§S�FR��«�S�»d¦H[�«ac5Y'[�UcV\RK5ºØ«5[�F0IL¯§FØ[�©[�º�cVS�M¶F�ÀHFRM¶c�º�O � FRKD«5[�F,Y$MbF0¦§ILMbFH«aM¶¦R³¶KÁYå¼�KNc[�ILS�¯§FHG9c°\RM|U(G�M ë�¯§³bc�º=½�ºd«N[�ILKa¬�¯R³¶³¶º[�FH[�³¶º .5M¶FR¼ÃcV\RK0«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVMbS�F�S�¬c°\§M´UeUVMbF§¼�¯R³´[�I ³bS�«�¯PUDM¶F¥c°\RKdM¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�F¥»dS_G�¯R³¶M�UV¦H[�«aK �¶�5#��Y�½R¯RcS�FRK�«5[�F7¼�K5c»dS�ILKDM¶F�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�FÃ[�FPGÃUL[�W�K�UVS�»dKDcVMb»dKD½�º0K5»d¦R³¶S�º$MbFR¼=º�K5c"[�FRS�c°\§KNI"UVº'»d»dK5c°ILºdS�¬cV\RKd¦RILS�½R³¶KN»7O=�(\§K:UVº'»d»dK5c°ILº7M¶F � ¯RKZUVcVMbS�F¥M|U"cV\RKdILS�cÊ[�cVMbS�FPU"S�¬c°\§K:UV¦H[�«aK5��c°M¶»dK:@ g Od��[�»dK5³¶ºÁY³¶KNcd¯HU9©(S�IL]ªK � ¯RMbW�[�ILM´[�F�cV³bºÑ©M¶c°\ÌILKZUV¦PKZ«�cdcVS#��� � 5 È (�ÉLO ��FÌc°\§KoUV¯R¦HK5I�UVº$»:»dK5cVILM´«9ÀPKN³|GÑcV\RK5S�ILº³|[�FR¼�¯H[�¼�KM¶c1»:KZ[�FHU²c°\H[�c1©(K"¦R³|[�«�K�S�¯RI1c°\RK5S�ILº=M¶F0[eFRS�FR��c°ILM¶W'M|[�³RUV¯R¦PKNIL¼�I�[�W'M¶c�ºe½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHGTY�©�MbcV\[dFRS�F§��cVILM¶W'M|[�³,W�K5W7S�¬�[Ó¼�I�[ZW$Mb¦R\§S�c°S�FÓÀHK5³´G�UVc°ILK5FR¼�cV\,Oe��I�[�«acVM´«5[�³¶³bºÄc°\§M´U"»dKZ[�FHU�cV\H[�cD©(K=cV¯RILF7S�FcV\RK >&��GJK�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F�GJK¨UL«aILM¶½HKZGeM¶Fdc°\RK�½HK5¼�M¶FRFRM¶FR¼"S�¬£cV\RM|U�«L\P[�¦Rc°K5IZO<��Fdc°\§K�«aS�F�c°K5¿'c�S�¬£K � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�c«aS�\RS�»dS�³bS�¼�ºeS�¬Tc°\RK�»dS_G�¯R³¶MRUV¦H[�«aK(S�¬£M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FHU5Y�M¶F�cV\RK�«5[�UVK�S�¬£c�©(SeG�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³_UVM¶¼�»0["»dS_G�K5³�YcV\RK�M|G�KZ[=cVSdK5»:¦§³bS�º�cV\RKeILS�cÊ[�cVMbS�FP[�³,UVº'»d»dKNcVILM¶K¨U1S�¬�cV\RKe©(S�IL³´GRUV\§KNK5c1©[�U(¦R¯§I�UV¯RKZG�M¶F1� #����O

u_�|v����D� ��m qVn���p�����yRq5��z|n����S�¼�K5cD[9\H[�FHG�³¶KDS�FÄc°\RKZUVK ÀH¿'KZGĦPS�MbF�cUVK5cLU�[�FPG0cVSë5[�³´«a¯R³|[�cVK�cV\RK=«L\H[�I�[�«acVKNILM|UVcVM´«"F�¯R»9½HK5I�U

S�¬cV\RK0W�[�ILM¶S�¯HU ½R¯RFHG�³¶KZUD©(K9\H[�W�KØGJK�ÀPFRKZGÏ[�½PS�W�KÁY<©(KdFRK5KZG�c°S�ILK5»:M¶FHG�[Ĭ�K5©Ö¬�[�«acLU�[�½PS�¯Rc�cV\RK[�«ac°¯P[�³,«�S�FPUVc°IL¯H«acVMbS�FÄS�¬ � Y�c°\§K¾UVS���«5[�³b³¶KZG0�"!D"� «aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«ac°M¶S�F � #�(��� (� �O���FÄc°\RM|U«aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«acVMbS�FS�FRK�UVcL[�ILcÊU�©�MbcV\oc�©(S0�K5IL»dMbcVM´[�F�W�KZ«�cVS�I�UV¦H[�«aKZU � [�FHG �ÆÈËMbcDM|U�FRS�cD[�«5«�M|G�K5F�cÊ[�³�c°\P[�cD©(K�³|[�½PKN³cV\RK5»ÆM¶F7c°\§K�UL[�»:K ©[ZºÃ[�U"UVS�»dKeS�¬²cV\RK=½R¯§FHG�³¶K¨U�[�½HS�W�K�ÉÊO � FRKecV\RK5Fo³¶S'S�]_U&¬�S�I�¬�S�¯RID�K5IL»:M¶cVM´[�FS�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�U�� � ��� @ ��Y ) ¸Æ��BL� BL� B/(Â[�FHG�c�©(SÄ«�S�»d¦R³¶K5¿7S�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U � � � � @ ��Y ¸Æ��BL�È�[�FHG ���� ¸ � f� � � @ �3ÉLY�©\§M´« \«5[�FĽHK=«aS�»�½RM¶FRKZGdM¶F_cVS:[9UVK � ¯RK5FH«aK1�

� @ � �#� ��@ � � � �#� @ � È���� ���$É©\§KNILK c°\RKeFRS�FR��cVILMbW$M´[�³P»0[�¦ÃM|U(¼�M¶W�K5Fý�º��

� ¸�� ��� � � ��(\§K���! �� K � ¯H[�cVM¶S�FoILK � ¯RM¶ILKZU�c°\H[�c���� «�S�»d»9¯Rc°KZU�©M¶cV\ocV\RK���[�¯R³¶M,»0[�cVILM´«aKZU � �Â[�«acVMbFR¼dM¶F� OÏ��FÑ[�GRG�M¶c°M¶S�F,Y<S�FRKdILK � ¯RM¶ILKZUec°\P[�c���� \H[�U=[7»0[�¿$Mb»0[�³1I�[�FR]HO7�(\§K0»dS_G�¯R³¶M(UV¦H[�«aK � M´UcV\RK5F7M´G�K5F�cVMúÀHKZGd©�MbcV\7cV\RK¾UV¦P[�«�K S�¬�UV¯P«L\� B �ïR¦Äc°SdcV\RK=[�«�cVM¶S�F7S�¬²cV\RKe¼�ILS�¯R¦�Ç¾È ��É1S�¬²¯§FRMbcL[�ILºcVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHU�MbF ��O��&\RK¼�ILS�¯R¦ÓÇ¾È �.É�[�«�cLU�S�F � ½�º=c°\§KFH[�cV¯RI�[�³H[�«acVMbS�F,Y$G�KZUL«�K5FHGJMbFR¼µ¬�ILS�»cV\H[�c=S�F�� È� [�ILK:F§KN¯§c°I�[�³ËÉÊO��(\RK0¼�ILS�¯§¦���� � 5 È (�É�[�«acLU=S�F$� ½�ºoILS�cL[�c°M¶FR¼�� M¶Fªc°\§K0W�KZ«�cVS�IILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�F0[�FHG �ÄMbFÓc°\RKe[�¦R¦RILS�¦RILM|[�c°K"«L\RM¶I�[�³TUV¦RMbF§S�I�ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F�cÊ[�cVMbS�F�O­�§ILS�» c°\RM|U�¬�S�IL»0[�³bM|UV»S�FRK�«5[�F7K5¿'cVI�[�«accV\RKeKN¿$¦RILKZULUVMbS�FPU<¬�S�I"cV\RK��1\RK5ILFëL\P[�I�[�«�cVK5IS�¬<c°\RKe¯RFRM¶W�K5I�UL[�³H½§¯RFHG�³¶K�O

���

Page 21: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

u_�����µ���°�5��{�� ���Hz�q5��y��L�Ll({ ��{�z|��(\§K��! �� «aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«acVMbS�F=½PKZ«�S�»dKZU<W�K5ILºeFH[�c°¯§I�[�³_©�\RK5F�cV\RK(¼'[�¯R¼�K(cV\RK5S�ILº=M´U²ILK¨[�³¶M .NKZGe©�MbcV\

cV\RK=\RK5³b¦�S�¬�!"��½RI�[�FRKZU5O"�(\RK�UV¦P[�«�K � M´U�cV\RK6�1\H[�FR����[�cVS�FÂUV¦H[�«aKe¬�S�IDcV\RK�!=ÈË����É(½RI�[�FRKZUeYT©\RM¶³¶K� M´Uµc°\RK ��\H[�F§����[�c°S�F7UV¦H[�«aKe¬�S�IDcV\RK�!D�Ó½RI�[�FRKZU5O��&\RK=»0[�c°ILM|«aKZU�� [�ILK=cV\RK�¼�ILS�¯§FHGÃUVcL[�cVK¨U S�¬cV\RK:È��=��B �=��É�UVcVILM¶FR¼'U5Y'©�\RM¶³bK�� � B � �M [�ILK c°\RS'UVKeS�¬È �=��BL�$ÉÊY�È�� B��=��ÉÊO1�(\RK=�"!D"� K � ¯H[�cVM¶S�FHU[�ILKcV\RK�«aS�FHG�M¶c°M¶S�FHU&¬�S�ID¯RF�½RILS�]�K5F7UV¯HUVº�O��&\RK5MbIDUVS�³¶¯Rc°M¶S�FHU"G�KZUL«aILMb½PKec°\RK��M¶¼�¼'U"½RI�[�FH« \ÃS�¬1c°\RKd!=ÈË� ��ÉM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FªcV\RK5S�ILº g �&\RKÃ!=ÈË����ÉDMbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU�[�³|UVSo«5[�ILILºÙ[Ä»9¯R³¶c°M¶¦R³¶KNceILKZUV¦HS�FPUVMb½R³¶K=¬�S�I9c°\§K7Ç¾È ��É�V¼'[�¯R¼�K �9¼�ILS�¯R¦,O1��F7¦H[�ILcVM´«a¯R³|[�IZY � ¯H[�F�c°M .Z[�c°M¶S�F7S�¬È �=��B��¾��ÉUVcVILMbF§¼'U1MbFo[�GRGJMbcVMbS�FÄcVS � ¼�MbW�KZU�ILM|UVKcVSÃ[9»Ø[�cVILM¶¿ � M¶F7c°\RK�[�G�®VS�MbF�c(S�¬Ç=È �9ÉÊYP©�\RM´« \7ILK5¦RILKZUVKNF�cLU1c°\§K=»:S�cVM¶S�F7S�¬�!=ÈË� ��É(M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU1M¶FcV\RK¾GJMbILKZ«ac°M¶S�FHU5Y$c°I�[�FPUVW�KNI�UVK"cVS0!D�=½RI�[�F§K¨U5O

u_�Ët��µhÊ��p���{��R��n��¥�0��{�p�y��L� l��L�a�Zz¶p�z|�V���¤¥KDFRS�©¹©ILM¶c°K=[�FÃK5¿$¦RILKZULUVMbS�Fd¬�S�I�c°\§K�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�F0»dKZ[�UV¯RILK"MbF7cVK5IL»0U1S�¬²cV\RKe»0[�c°ILM|«aK¨U�� B �£O

¤¥K�¯HUVK=cV\RKe¬�[�«acec°\H[�c � M´Uµc°\RK � ¯RS�cVM¶KNF�c"S�¬[dW�[�ILM¶KNc�º7¼�MbW�K5Fo½�º7UVS�»dK=K � ¯H[�cVMbS�FHUµMbF¥[dW�KZ«�cVS�IUV¦H[�«aK0½�ºª[oUVº$»:»dK5cVILºo¼�ILS�¯R¦,O¥QTK5c9¯HU=G�KZUL«aILMb½PK0[o¼�K5FRK5I�[�³(«aS�FHUVc°IL¯P«�cVM¶S�F¥¬�S�I�cV\RK0M¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�cVMbS�FcV\RK5S�ILº:S�W�K5I�UV¯H« \ÂUV¦P[�«�KZU5O

��½HUVcVI�[�«�cV³¶ºÁY�¼�M¶W�K5F�[DUV¦H[�«aK�� ©M¶c°\�«aS$S�I�G�MbFP[�c°KZU � � Y�©(K1ILKN¦§ILK¨UVK5F�cTcV\RK(K5¿'cVKNILM¶S�I�G�M�ÒTKNILK5F�cVM´[�³|U� � � ½_º � � O�%'¯R¦R¦PS'UVK�YZM¶F:[�GRG�M¶cVMbS�F,Y�c°\P[�c­©(K1\H[�W�K�["UVº$»:»dK5cVILºD¼�ILS�¯R¦��o[�«ac°M¶FR¼"S�F��7Y�cV\RK[�«ac°M¶S�F½PKNM¶FR¼0¼�K5FRK5I�[�cVKZGo½�ºÄc°\§K�W�KZ«ac°S�I ÀHK5³´G§U � �M Y��7¸?��B��6��� BLG�M¶»��&O¾��S�ILK5S�W�K5IZYR©(K9©[�F�c�cVSÄMb»d¦PS'UVKUVS�»dK=K � ¯H[�cVMbS�FPU ) � È � É"¸ ��Y � ¸ ��B����6� B 5 O=¤¥K:[�ULUV¯§»:KecV\RKZUVK�K � ¯H[�cVM¶S�FHU"cVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»ÆM¶FªUVS�»dKILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�F0S�¬��(Y�M�O K�O

) � È ! G � É�¸ � È !PÉ � � ) � È � É� ¯RI¯R³¶cVMb»0[�cVKD¼�S'[�³TM´U&c°S0G�KaÀHF§KDMbF�cVK5¼�I�[�c°M¶S�F0cV\RK5S�ILº0S�W�K5I;�� ¸ ) X È��$É � �

¤¥K"MbF�cVILS_G�¯H«aK"cV\RK&2DS'U/.5¯R³R»9¯R³¶c°M¶¦R³¶KNc � B�9 � Y_[�FHGØc°\RK�¬�K5IL»dMbS�F§M´«&¼'[�¯R¼�K�ÀH¿'M¶FR¼=»�¯§³bcVMb¦§³bK5c�����B � YcVS�¼�KNcV\RK5Id©M¶c°\ÌcV\RKĽHS'UVS�F§M´«0[�F�cVMb¼�\§S'UVc � �Å[�³b³�c°\§ILKNKÄM¶FÅcV\RK7[�GZ®VS�MbF�c=S�¬ �(OÌ�(\§KÃK � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�cG�M�Ò£K5ILK5F�c°M|[�³ �ØF§S�FR��³bM¶FRKZ[�IL³bº=ILKZ[�³¶M .5KZGÄUV¯HUVº0[�«�cLU"[�U1¬�S�³¶³bS�©�U��

� � � ¸ � � B � � � ¸ ��M È � É � M

�� � ¸9 � B �&9 � ¸3È �BM�É �� � M �� � ¸���B ���d¸ � � B �

È���� ��(�Ég ì§á�éDß,1¨Ý "��åùÞä,ä "°ß "�Ý�é"Ý�Û"�ä<ÜÞù&"�Ý�ç�ß5ÜÞÜ!' "°ç�ø�Ý�á�ÛåÝ�ä��åá�ø�Ü! "æLá�Ûåä�ù! �Ý�ç53(ô �(3���ä '�ä "�Ý�é ùúÛ�ä "�Ý�ß, eá5â 3 0 �°ò 1��(3��

0 "�áeß�à�áZù! �á� ��ä6��ÝLÜÞÜTä "°ç�ùúÛ�4¾ßZé $�ÜÞù&"°ø� åÝLä�ï_ß�Û� "6��ÝÛ�á�Û ��Ý���ù ä*"�Ý�Û�æLÝDá¨â­é"á $ø�ÜÞùPä�$'ß5æLÝLä1á5â,à5ß5æ�ø'ß ùúÛ "6��ÝXP�ÝLÜ! "��åÝLá�ç�ùÞÝLä(ÜÞÝLä�ä/"���Ý�ÛÍùúÛ "6�'ç�ÝLÝ �ùúé"Ý�Û�ä�ù á�Û�äM1�+

�5)

Page 22: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

%'¯R¦§¦HS'UVK�Y�MbFÌ[�GRG�M¶c°M¶S�F,Y�c°\P[�c=S�F � ©(K0\P[ZW�K0[ �<��M¶F_W�[�ILM´[�F�cD»dK5c°ILM|« ! � � Oo�&\RK5Fªc°\§K �L[�«ac°M¶S�F �ILKZ[�GRU��

� ¸ � � ! � � � �M � M � � 7 � � � B � 7 � � ) � � ¸¸*! � � � � È � É � � È � É 7#! � � � �M � M � � 7 � � � ��� � � � È � É/77 � � B � ^ 7 � ��B � �-7���9 � ) � È � É 7 � � � � ) � � �

È���� ��#$É�(\§K �VMbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�F �e»dK¨[�UV¯§ILKDM´U��

� �S�³�� � � � � �� � 9 � � � � � � V �� È���� ���$É�(\§KÃ[�«ac°¯H[�³1M¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FÅ«5[�³´«a¯R³¶¯HUeM¶F�W�S�³bW�KZU c�©(S7c�º'¦PKZU=S�¬"MbF�cVKN¼�I�[�³|U ³bM¶]�KoÈ���O ���$ÉLOÏ�&\RK9ÀHI�UVc=c�º$¦HK«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHG§U,cVSec°\RK"¼'[�¯R¼�K(¼�ILS�¯§¦HU��(O<�(\RK"UV¦H[�«aK � M¶F�cV\RM´U1«5[�UVKM|U�cV\RK"UV¦H[�«aK(S�¬­[�³b³�¼'[�¯R¼�K&ÀHK5³´GRUS�F7@ g YRcV\RK�¼�ILS�¯§¦ �ªM|U(cV\RKe¼�ILS�¯R¦0S�¬�[�³¶³T¼'[�¯R¼�KDcVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�FHU5Y�©�\RM´« \Ã[�ILKDK � ¯P[�³,cVS:¯§FRMbc�ºØ[�cM¶F�ÀHFRM¶c�º�O��(\RK K � ¯H[�cVMbS�FHU ) � ¸ �d[�ILKDcV\RK=[�F�c°M¶��UVKN³�¬���G�¯H[�³¶Mbc�º=K � ¯H[�cVMbS�FHU ! ¸ ��O

�(\§K�UVKZ«�S�FPGdc�º'¦PKeS�¬­M¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�³´U(«aS�ILILKZUV¦PS�FHG9c°S � ¸ � �:cV\RKe»dS_G�¯R³¶MTUV¦H[�«aK�S�¬�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5Y[�FHG � ½PK5MbF§¼ocV\RK0¼�³¶S�½H[�³UVº'»d»dK5c°ILº�¼�ILS�¯R¦,O¥��FÅS�¯§I:«5[�UVK0M¶c�M|Uec°\RKĦRILS�G�¯H«ac=S�¬�cV\RKļ�ILS�¯R¦ªS�¬¼�³¶S�½H[�³,¼'[�¯R¼�K=cVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�FHU�Ç=È���ɵ[�FHG�c°\§K=¼�ILS�¯R¦7S�¬�UV¦H[�«aK5��c°M¶»dK�ILS�cL[�c°M¶S�FHU � #¾È (�ÉÊOe��FocV\RK«5[�UVK�S�¬�¼�³¶S�½H[�³,UVº'»d»dK5c°ILºd¼�ILS�¯R¦ÄS�FRK=G�S'KZU&FRS�cM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�cVK�S�W�K5I ��B � B � O(�7S�ILK5S�W�KNIZY$M¶cM|UKZ[�UVº0cVSUVK5K�cV\H[�cec°\RKdM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³(È���OÞ���$É"©M¶c°\ ��¸E��Y � ��[�IL½§MbcVI�[�ILº�YT½R¯Rc�«aS�»d»�¯§c°M¶FR¼0©�MbcV\ � UVcVMb³¶³�\H[�Ue[¬�K5IL»dMbS�FRM|«=UVº'»d»dK5c°ILº �=O0�(\§K:M¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³�[�«ac°¯P[�³b³¶ºÏG�K5¦PK5FHGRU"S�FR³¶ºoS�F¥cV\RK0«aS�F�®V¯R¼'[�«aºo«a³´[�ULU S�¬ � O�§S�I(c°\RKe¼�³¶S�½H[�³T¼�ILS�¯R¦7Ç=È$��É��4� #¾È (�É�M¶c»dKZ[�FHU1cV\H[�c©(Ke«N[�Fo[�ULUV¯§»:K1�

� ¸ G�M|[�¼RÈ^� X B����6�?B � � É � ���� X � ��� X � � �� � � ^� � �� ^ �

� �� È���� � �É

�(\§Ko»0[�¿'M¶»0[�³�cVS�IL¯HUdS�¬�� #¾È (�ÉØ«aS�M¶FH«aM´GJK¨UØ©M¶c°\¹cV\H[�c0S�¬�[ÌÇ=È��$ÉÃUV¯§½R¼�ILS�¯R¦ÑS�¬�� #=È (�É9©\RM|«L\¦RILKZUVK5ILW�KZU�UVS�»dK0«aS�»:¦§³bK5¿ÏUVcVIL¯H«acV¯RILKdS�FÐ@ g O¥��FªcV\RKd¬�S�³¶³bS�©M¶FR¼7©(K0UV\H[�³¶³�S�F§³bº¥¦RILKZUVK5ILW�K0Ç=È��$ÉLO�(\§KĬ�KNIL»dM¶S�FRM|«ÃUVº$»:»dK5cVILº�� [�³b³¶S�©"U9c°SÅ«5[�³|«a¯R³´[�cVKªÈ���O ���$É=½�ºÅcL[�]'M¶FR¼ � @ 0 O ��F cV\RM|U:«5[�UVKcV\RK¾UL[�G§G�³bKe¦PS�MbF�c[�¦R¦RILS�¿'M¶»0[�c°M¶S�F0©(S�¯R³|GÓ³bS�«N[�³¶M .NK=cV\RKeMbF�cVK5¼�I�[�³TS�F_cVSdc°\§K=W'M|«�M¶FRM¶c�º0S�¬�cV\RK=¦HS�M¶F�cÊU� * �7Y�©�\RK5ILK ��È � É�¸ ��O���FÄcV\RM´U&©[ZºdS�FRK=[�ILILM¶W�K¨U1¦§ILK¨«aM|UVK5³bº0[�cDÈ���O ���$ÉLO

�<M¶FH[�³¶³bº�Y1S�FRKÄKNFP«�S�¯§F_cVK5I�U9º�KNc0[�FRS�cV\RK5IdILK5¦RILKZUVKNF�cL[�c°M¶S�F ¬�S�IoÈ���OÞ���$ÉLY(©\RK5ILK � M´U9ILK5¦R³|[�«�KZG½�ºocV\RK0UV¦H[�«aKdS�¬�[�³b³1»0[�c°ILM|«aK¨U � B �TY��¹M´UecV\RKd¦RILS�G�¯H«ac�S�¬cV\RK �V¼'[�¯R¼�Kd¼�ILS�¯R¦ ��Ç=È$0PÉLY�[�FHG¥cV\RK¼�³¶S�½H[�³,¼�ILS�¯R¦¥Ç=È���É��oÇ=È��$ÉLY,UVS0cV\H[�cDS�F§K�M¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�cVK¨UµS�W�K5I"c°\§K � B � B �Ä»9¯R³bcVM¶¦R³bK5c&¬�S�I=ǾÈ�0PÉLO��"U[7ILKZUV¯R³¶c5Y�cV\RKÃK � ¯H[�c°M¶S�FHU ) � ¸ �o[�ILKÓc°\RK7�"!D"� K � ¯H[�cVM¶S�FHU�� #�(��Y�S�IZY�»dS�ILK0¦RILKZ«aM|UVKN³¶º�Y<c°\§KNM¶IFRS�FH«aS�»d»�¯§cÊ[�cVMbW�KDG�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�cVMbS�F1� ('���YR©�\RK5Fé(K=UVcV¯HG�º0cV\RKeILK¨UVS�³¶W�KZG0»dS�G�¯R³¶M,UV¦H[�«aK:ÈËMbc�M´U"[�c�c°\RM|U

���

Page 23: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

¦PS�MbF�c=cV\H[�c�� #¾È (�É�ILKZG�¯P«�KZUecVSÑǾÈ��$É°ÉLOÌ�(\RKZUVKÄK � ¯H[�cVMbS�FPU=cVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL» M¶FÅcV\RK¥È�[�G�®VS�MbF�c5Y�cVILMb¦R³¶K5cNYUVM¶FR¼�³bK5caÉ�S�¬(ǾÈ�0PÉ �7Ç=È��$É �7Ç=È$��ÉLO

�§S�IÏG�K5cL[�Mb³|U7cV\RKÌILKZ[�G�K5IoM|U�KNFP«�S�¯§I�[�¼�K¨G c°S3«aS�FHUV¯§³bc�� #�#�5� #����� # �� #1���� #�)�5�¶�5#��Ye[�U�©(KN³¶³�[�U� #���5� ����5� #����� �R���� #�(��� #���5�¶����$�¶�5���O

��F¥©\P[�cD¬�S�³¶³bS�©�U ©(K:UVK5c X ¸ �� ^ ¸ �� O0��S�c°K�Y�c°\H[�cecV\RM´Ue��³´[�FH« ]Ï«aS�FHUVcL[�F�cD\H[�U FRS�c°\§MbFR¼cVSÃG�S0©�MbcV\ocV\RK:«aS�¯R¦§³bM¶FR¼:«aS�FHUVcL[�F�c"S�¬�c°\§K=¼'[�¯R¼�K=c°\§KNS�ILº�YP©\§KNILK=M¶cD[�¦R¦PK¨[�I�U"[�U"cV\RK=¦H[�I�[�»dK5cVKNIS�¬cV\RK�¼�K5S�»dK5c°ILM|«=½H[�« ]'¼�ILS�¯RFPGªÈ���O (�ÉLO0��c=«�S�ILILKZUV¦PS�FHGRU�\RS�©(K5W�KNI KN¿�[�«ac°³¶º¥c°SÄc°\§K:³¶S'S�¦ª«aS�¯RF�cVMbFR¼M¶FÃcV\RK=G�¯H[�³,UVcVILMbFR¼=cV\RK5S�ILº�YR©�\RMb³¶KDcV\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�KDcV\RK5S�ILºØ��³|[�FH«L]0«aS�FHUVcL[�F_c(M¶F7UVc°ILM¶FR¼�cV\RK5S�ILº0¦RM|«ac°¯§ILK[�ILM|UVK¨Ue[�Ue[ r�n���~ú��pL�R�L�a� ¦H[�I�[�»dK5cVKNIZY�[�«N«aS�I�G�M¶FR¼Äc°S7cV\RKdILK5³´[�cVM¶S�Fª½HK5c�©(K5K5F¥c°\§K0©(S�IL³´GJ��UV\§KNK5cD[�FHG¼'[�¯R¼�KDcV\RK5S�ILº0M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5Y'GJK¨UL«aILM¶½HKZGÓ½HK5³¶S�©eO

u_�����7��n���� ��~ú{���z|n��9��y_�Pq5��z|n���p¾nV�e���R�=qa�'z|��{�~<n��R����{���n��Lp��S�© ©(Ko[�ILKÃILKZ[�G�ºÑc°SÑ[�c°cL[�«L]Ñc°\§Ko«�S�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�FѬ�¯RFH«acVMbS�F ÈL��OÞ#$ÉÊO �<M¶I�UVc�S�¬�[�³¶³�Y&¯HUVMbF§¼ÏcV\RK

¯RF�½RILS�]�K5F UV¯R¦PK5I�«L\H[�IL¼�KZU9S�FRKÏ[�IL¼�¯§K¨UØc°\H[�cÓc°\RM|UÄ«�S�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�F̬�¯§FH«ac°M¶S�F¹M´UÓMbFPG�K5¦HK5FHG�K5F�c�S�¬�cV\RK«aS'K�ëaMbK5F�cM¶F0¬�ILS�F�c(S�¬�cV\RKDcVKNIL» A ! A ^ 7Q������©\RM|«L\ÄM|U � B6�������'O��&\RK5ILKa¬�S�ILKÁY�S�F§K�«5[�Fü�SdcVS:cV\RK©(KZ[�]D«�S�¯§¦R³bM¶FR¼(ILK5¼�M¶»:K�È�©�MbcV\�cV\RK1c°\§KNcL["[�FR¼�³¶K²[�¦§¦RILS�¦RILM|[�c°K5³¶º�[�GZ®V¯HUVcVKZGTY�UVS�c°\P[�c��9�1M|UPÀHFRM¶cVKÁY�©\RM¶³¶K� �A@ 0 É�M¶Fé�\RM|«L\7ÈÊ��OÞ#$É�M|U(UL[�cV¯RI�[�c°KZGd½�ºdM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU�È�« ¬°O&� #�#�ËÉ���FÃcV\RM|U1³bM¶»dMbc(cV\RK�GJK¨UL«aK5FHGR[�F�cLUS�¬�c°\§K�«L\RM¶I�[�³TS�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�U1½PK¨«aS�»dKec°\RK ��\RK5ILF7«�³|[�ULUVKZU1S�¬�c°\RKe¯RFRM¶W�K5I�UL[�³H½§¯RFHG�³¶K�Y �VM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�cVK¨G �dÈ�M¶FcV\RKDK � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM|[�F�cUVKNFPUVK�ÉLY$S�W�K5I�@ g O1�KNILK M´U&c°\RK cÊ[�½R³¶KDS�¬<K � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM´[�F�c(M¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�³|U � #����È�« ¬°O�È���O|���$É°É �

� � > �¶g � ¸ > � � � È��$É X ^ È���� �1�$ɤ¥K¾UV\§S�¯R³´GØc°\RK5FÄMbF�cVK5¼�I�[�c°KDcV\RKZUVK=«�³|[�ULUVKZU(S�W�K5I � O�±1¯Rc�c°\RK5F7[�¼'[�MbF�Y�©(KD¯HUVKDK � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�c(³bS�«5[�³b�M .¨[�cVM¶S�F,YTcV\RM´Uµc°M¶»dK=S�FÏcV\RKÍÀH¿'KZG7¦PS�M¶F_cLU"M¶F � O=�(\§K¨UVKeÀP¿'KZG�¦HS�M¶F�cÊUD[�ILK=³|[�½PKN³¶KZG7½�ºÄ¦H[�ILc°M¶cVMbS�FHU� O��&\RK�«5[�³|«�¯§³´[�cVMbS�FÓS�¬­cV\RKDK5¿'¦PKZ«�cL[�cVMbS�F7W�[�³¶¯RKZU1S�¬­cV\RK�« \RM¶I�[�³HS�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U�½HKZ«aS�»dKZU(K � ¯RM¶W�[�³¶K5F_c(cVScV\RK�«5[�³´«a¯R³|[�cVMbS�FdS�¬­cV\RK"K5¿'¦PKZ«�cL[�cVMbS�FÄW�[�³¶¯RKZU1S�¬­S�¬­UVS�»dK"S�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U�M¶F0cV\RKDUVcÊ[�cVM´UVcVM|«N[�³T»dKZ«L\P[�FRM´«5[�³»dS_G�K5³�Y1©\RK5ILKÄc°\RK7cV\RK7½H[�UVM|«ÓW�[�ILM´[�½§³bKZU�[�ILKÄcV\RK3�Ä��c°¯R¦§³bKZU9S�¬�¦H[�ILcVMbcVM¶S�FHU5Y � X B������ B � � Y(©�\RK5ILK� ��¸?È�0 � X � 0 � ^ � 0 � ` � ���6��0 � &�� a'0 � &�� X ¸ �H�����úÉ�O9��FocV\RM|U�UVcL[�c°M|UVcVM´«5[�³�»dS_GJKN³�YTcV\RK�S�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I� � � �* ¸ X* ��I�! * M¶FÃcV\RKe¼'[�¯R¼�KDcV\RK5S�ILº:cVI�[�FHUV³|[�c°KZU&c°SdcV\RK�S�¦PK5I�[�c°S�IeÈ^� �T¸ ���� �|É �� * � 3� P¸ �� *- ��"� + X

� � *� 7 '" Y + X È � � 7�0 � Y ����7 ��É * �ÌÈ � � 7�0 � Y ����É * �ÌÈ � � 7 �����É * 7 È � ������É * ��¸��� ���������� �- "

� : Y�� ÈLÈ^� � 7 �� È$0 � Y 7 �����ÉVÉ * �ÌÈ � � 7 �� È�0 � Y ����ÉVÉ *��È���� ��)$É

�R�

Page 24: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

�(\§M´UdK5¿$¦RILKZULUVMbS�FÑM´UØ»:S'UVc0UVM¶»d¦R³bºÑ«N[�³|«a¯R³|[�c°KZG̯PUVMbFR¼ c°\RKo!ÍÈ�����É�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FÌ»0[�c°ILM¶¿Ñ»:S�G�K5³��= �OÎ"UVMbF§¼ÃÈ���O ��)$É1S�FRK�«5[�F7©ILM¶c°K1�

� � È (�É�¸ � � È �.É�7 � � È ��ÉLÈ V��� ^ �UV �� ^ É ^©\§KNILK � � È �.É�¸ D � V M � YT[�FHG � � È �=É�¸ ��I V � S�F7cV\RK ÀH¿'KZG7¦PS�M¶F_cUVK5c5O ��KZ«5[�³b³�c°\P[�c�\§KNILK � M´UcV\RK�»0[�cVILMb¿dM¶FÃcV\RK=!=ÈË� ��É1»0[�c°ILM¶¿d»:S�G�K5³�Y�©�\RM¶³bK !ÌM|U5YR[�U(½PKa¬�S�ILKÁY§c°\§KDÀHK5³|GdS�Fo!D�ͽRI�[�FRK�O

�"MbW�K5FÄc°\RK=UVM¶FR¼�³bK5��cVI�[�«�K S�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U � * ©(KD½R¯RM¶³´GÄ[�IL½RM¶c°I�[�ILº9¼'[�¯R¼�K5��MbF�W�[�ILM|[�F�c�S�¦HK5I�[�cVS�I�U � $&[�UeM¶FÐÈL��O|��ÉÊY(ÈL��O �$ÉLO7�&¬�c°K5I�cV\H[�ceS�FRK0«5[�FªMbF�cVK5¼�I�[�c°K9c°\RK5M¶Ie· ¸ �7G�KZUL«aK5FHGR[�F�cLU � �¶g �$& ¯HUVM¶FR¼ÃcV\RKcL[�½R³bKeS�¬­K � ¯RMbW�[�ILM´[�F�c(M¶F_cVK5¼�I�[�³´U"È���OÞ�1�$ÉÊO

��cÄM´UÓ¯HUVKa¬�¯R³"cVSÌILK¨«5[�³¶³D\RK5ILKocV\RKª!"��½RI�[�FRK7M¶F�c°K5IL¦RILK5cL[�c°M¶S�F S�¬=cV\RK¥¦H[�ILc°M¶cVMbS�FHU � O?��F¹c°\RM|U¦RM|«ac°¯RILK�Y�c°\§K7¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³D!D����½RI�[�FRKZUd[�ILKoUVK5¦H[�I�[�cVK¨G MbF c°\§K�� GJMbILKZ«ac°M¶S�F,Y[�FPG [�ILKo³¶S_«5[�cVKZG [�c� ¸ � � Y �<¸E��B6����� B��¥O"�,SdcV\RK � � c°\o!D�ؽRI�[�FRK 0 � ¸ D Y 0 � Y !=È�����É1MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU[�ILK=[�c°cL[�«L\RKZGTO���FcV\RK�F§S�FH«aS�»:»9¯RcL[�c°M¶W�K"c°\RK5S�ILºd©M¶cV\7c°\RK FRS�FH«aS�»d»�¯RcL[�c°M¶W'M¶c�º9¦H[�I�[�»dKNcVK5I � Y

� �PX B �R^ H¸ � �R` B �Jg P¸ � �cV\RKZUVK�!=È�����É(M¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU[�ILKe³¶S_«5[�c°KZG�FRKZ[�I"c°\§K=S�ILMb¼�M¶FÏÈ � X B�� ^ ÉHO ��YP©\§KNILK � X ¸ � X 7 � � ^ B�� ^ ¸� ` 7 � � g Oª!µMúÒTK5ILKNF�c=¦H[�ILcVM¶c°M¶S�FHU=«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHG�cVS¥c°\RKÄG�MúÒTK5ILK5F_c�����G�M¶»dK5FHUVMbS�FP[�³ �LUV¯§½R»0[�FRMú¬�S�³|GRU��ÈËMbFªcV\RK0[�³¶¼�KN½§I�[�M´«Í¼�KNS�»dK5cVILºÏUVK5FHUVK�ÉS�¬DÔ ^ OÃ�ˬ"©(K:G�K5FRS�cVKd½_º�� ��c°\RK0[�³¶¼�K5½RI�[0S�¬\§S�³bS�»dS�IL¦R\RM|«¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FPUÃÈ˦PS�³bº$FRS�»dM´[�³|UaÉDS�F¹Ô ^ ©�\RM´« \ÅW�[�FRM´UV\ÌS�FÌcV\RK7!=ÈË� ��É=M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5Y1UVc°¯H« ]ªcVSªc°\§K � � cV\!D����½RI�[�FRK�Y�cV\RK5FÄMbc(«5[�FýPKDM|G�K5F_cVM�ÀHKZG�©�MbcV\0cV\RKDM|G�KZ[�³HM¶F0cV\RKDILM¶FR¼=S�¬,¦PS�³bº$FRS�»dM´[�³|U(Ô6� � X B�� ^ TUV¯H«L\cV\H[�ccV\RK � ¯RS�cVMbK5F�c"Ô:� � X B�� ^ � � �HM|UUV¦P[�FRFRKZGd½�º0cV\RKD»dS�FRS�»dM´[�³|U� Y XX � � X^ B ��� ��� 0 � Y�D[�¯R¼�Kdc°\RK5S�ILº�¼�KNF§KNI�[�cVM¶FR¼0¬�¯§FH«ac°M¶S�FªS�¬cV\RK0«�S�ILILK5³|[�c°S�I�U S�¬cV\RK0«L\RM¶I�[�³�S�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�U ½HKZ«aS�»dK¨UecV\RKUVcL[�c°M|UVc°M|«5[�³»dS_GJKN³(¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�F ¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�FÑ©M¶c°\ [�³¶³(c°\§KÃM¶F�c°K5¼�I�[�cVK¨G S�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�U � � � �bg �$& [�GRG�KZGªcVScV\RK�"[�»:M¶³¶c°S�FRM|[�F,O"��F7S�cV\RK5ID©(S�I�GRU5Y�©(K�UV¯R» S�W�K5I"cV\RK=¦H[�ILcVMbcVMbS�FPU� � ���9¸ 0 � Y ��cV\RK�±1S�³ .5»0[�FRF©(K5Mb¼�\�cLU�KN¿$¦ ��� X�� � D $& � $& � $& � YT[�FHG7cV\RK=»dKZ[�UV¯RILKeS�F7c°\RK9¦H[�ILcVMbcVMbS�FPU(M|U"¼�MbW�K5F�½_ºÓc°\RKdU � ¯H[�ILKeS�¬cV\RK�ILK5¼�¯R³|[�ILM .NKZG0GJM´UL«aILK5c°M .5KZG �[�FHG�K5IL»dS�FHG�KDG�K5cVK5IL»:M¶FH[�F�c��

) $ ¸ )

� � Y ��+ � � � � È � � Y � � � ��É� � Y ¸E� � 7 �� È$0 � Y ����É�B È���� ('�$É

�(\§K¦RILS�G�¯H«ac<MbFÄÈ���O ('�$É,M|U<cÊ[�]�K5FdS�W�KNI1[�³b³�¦H[�M¶I�U1È(� ��É �¸3È � �§ÉT©\RM|«L\9M´U�UV\RS�ILc�¬�S�I 'È(���¸ �7É��VS�IÈ(��¸�,B ���¸�RÉ�� �Í[�FPGë5[�FĽHKe¯RFHG�K5I�UVcVS'S�Gd©M¶c°\7cV\RKe\RK5³b¦ÄS�¬ ����ILKN¼�¯§³´[�ILM .Z[�c°M¶S�F��

) $ ¸ KN¿$¦

�� � ���� ���È���É � '� �F�X� � X "

� � Y ��+ � � � � V ! � � � � ����� ����� � + ��� È���� (H��É

�(\§K�UV¯R»?M¶FÏÈ���O (H��É�M|UG�KaÀHFRKZGÓ½�ºØ[�FP[�³bM¶c�º_« «�S�F�cVMbF�¯H[�cVM¶S�F,O

���

Page 25: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

� � -��9>D/�25-04 6��7>e8:@ ����|s���� ~úz|����~è�"p����az|� �0�Ë�'{��qVn�y�~ú�

��S�©ÖUV¯R¦R¦PS'UVK=©(K�cL[�]�K%� ¸ ��O���F�c°\§K�¦R¯RILKe· ¸ �Ó¼'[�¯R¼�K=cV\RK5S�ILº7c°\RM|U"M|UDF§S�cDc°\§K�»dS'UVcM¶F_cVK5ILKZUVc°M¶FR¼�«5[�UVK�Y�UVMbFP«�K1FRK5M¶c°\RK5I�¦HK5ILcV¯RIL½H[�cVMbW�K�Y�FRS�I,F§S�FR��¦HK5ILcV¯RIL½H[�cVMbW�K�«aS�ILILKZ«�cVM¶S�FHU<[�Ò£KZ«ac<c°\RK1³¶S�©��K5FRK5IL¼�º�¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³�O���»0[�¼�MbF§KÁYåc°\RK5F,Y�cV\H[�c1©(KDK5»�½PKZG�cV\RK � ¸ �&· ¸ �ecV\RK5S�ILº�M¶F0cV\RKDcV\RK5S�ILº©M¶cV\ÃM¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5O � F§KD¦HS'ULUVM¶½RM¶³bM¶c�º=M|U(cV\RKDFRS�FP«�S�»d»9¯RcÊ[�cVM¶W�K ¼'[�¯§¼�KDc°\§KNS�ILº�Y�[�FRS�cV\RK5I(¦HS'ULUVM¶½RM¶³bM¶c�ºM|U�cV\RK�c°\RK5S�ILºªS�F c°\§Ko!"��½RI�[�FRK�Y1KÁO ¼RO ¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³"!D����½RI�[�FRK7[�c:cV\RKo�"!D����UVMbFR¼�¯§³´[�ILM¶c�º�Y�S�I0cV\RK!D#$ �� %_#"½§I�[�FRK�©�I�[�¦R¦RM¶FR¼D[DÕ X M¶F�� � O���F9c°\§M´U�UVK5cV¯R¦=cV\RKcV\RK5S�ILº�\P[�U,F§S�FR��¦HK5ILcV¯RIL½H[�cVMbW�K1KaÒ£KZ«acÊU5Y«aS�»dMbFR¼Ó¬�ILS�» FRS�FH«aS�»d»�¯RcL[�cVMbW�K MbFHUVcL[�F�c°S�FPU5YTS�Ie¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³(!=È�����É"½RI�[�FRKZU5Y�S�I=c°\RKÓ©(S�IL³´GRUV\§KNK5cM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FHU�S�¬�!��=UVcVILMbF§¼'U"½HS�¯§FHG7cVSÂ! #�Y,S�IDcV\RK9KN³¶K5»dKNF�cL[�ILºoUVc°ILM¶FR¼0©(S�IL³|GRUV\RK5K5cM¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FHU�M¶FcV\RK"½H[�«L]$¼�ILS�¯RFHG=S�¬­� %_# ½RI�[�FRK�Y�S�I[�F �. ^ È � É­cVI�[�FHU�¬�S�IL»ÖcV\RK5ILK5S�¬°O���FdK5MbcV\RK5I«5[�UVK�Y�©(KDUV\H[�³b³§¼�KNccV\RK�M¶FHUVcL[�F�c°S�FëaS�F�cVILMb½R¯§c°M¶S�FHU1cVS�cV\RK�KaÒTKZ«�cVM¶W�K=¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F_cVM|[�³�O�Q KNc�¯HU«5[�³|«a¯R³´[�cVKDcV\RK5»7O

¤¥K�UV\H[�³¶³£UV³¶M¶¼�\_cV³¶ºØ« \H[�FR¼�K"cV\RK�F§S�cÊ[�cVMbS�Fج�S�IcV\RK�cVM¶»:KZUL� $& [�U(M¶FÃcV\RM|U(«N[�UVKecV\RK5ILKDM´U1F§S�FRK5KZGcVSØGJM´UVM¶FR¼�¯RM|UV\d½HK5c�©(K5K5FÂ��I�! * [�FHG�È��,I�!�É * O�¤¥K�UVK5c6�

" $& � $&(')*�+ X� * &10È -�É &10 ¸ '"*�+ X � *

� *� XÈ -�7 ��É�� È����´��É

[�FHGÄ«aS�FHUVM´GJKNI(cV\RKe¦H[�ILcVMbcVMbS�Fج�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�Fo[�U[¾¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FÄS�¬�c°\RKecVMb»dKZUX� * O�<M¶I�UVcNY$³¶KNc�¯HU(F§S�c(c°¯RILFÄS�ÒÏcV\RKe\RM¶¼�\RK5I(S�I�G�K5I;��[�UVM¶»:M¶I�U5O<�(\RK5F,Y�©(K�[�ILKecVS:«5[�³´«a¯R³|[�cVK/�

V ! ��� ��� � "

) V ! � È���� �$Ék({�����z|��z|n���p¾{��§�0�L���H�L� pZ���R��{���z|n���p

�"U�Mbc�M´U�©(K5³b³¶��]'FRS�©F�Y'cV\RKe¦H[�ILc°M¶cVMbS�FHU � ¸ È�0 X � 0 ^ � 0 ` � �6��� 0 & É�[�ILKeMbF7S�FRK5��cVS���S�F§K�«aS�IL�ILKZUV¦HS�FPG�K5FH«aK�©�MbcV\7c°\§K�M¶ILILK¨GJ¯H«aMb½R³¶KDILK5¦RILKZUVK5F�cÊ[�cVMbS�FPU � S�¬1c°\RKdUVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«"¼�ILS�¯R¦ � = Y 0ĸ A � A O�7S�ILK5S�W�K5IZY'M¶FÃcV\RK=«5[�UVK � ¸Ö��Y�S�FRK�¼�K5cLU1¬�ILS�» È���O ('�$É �

) ¸ ') Y + � �� È�0 Y �10 � 7�� ����É�� È � ����É

[�FHGÓ¯HUVM¶FR¼�cV\RK=ILK5³´[�cVM¶S�FýPK5c�©(K5KNF7¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�FHU � [�FPG���S�¯RFR¼dG�M´[�¼�I�[�»0U � YR©\§S'UVK � � cV\7ILS�©.«�S�F§�cL[�MbFHUA0 Y aÖ�Ó½HS�¿'KZU5Y(� � ��� 5 «aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHGJMbFR¼dcVSÃcV\RKdM¶ILILK¨GJ¯H«aMb½R³¶KeILKN¦§ILK¨UVK5F�cL[�c°M¶S�F�� S�¬cV\RK

���

Page 26: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

UVº'»d»dK5c°ILM|«(¼�ILS�¯§¦ � = È�[�FHGdcVS�cV\RKDM¶ILILKZG�¯H«aM¶½R³bK(ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F�cÊ[�cVM¶S�F�� S�¬­cV\RK"¼�ILS�¯R¦ÄǾÈ��� ÉÊY$¬�S�I[�F�º�� � 5 ÉÊY§c°\§M´U�«N[�FĽPK�ILK5©ILM¶cVc°K5F7[�U) ¸ È �=��É = �� &)Y�� � È �� È�0 Y �10 � 7�� ����ÉVÉ &)Y + X

��� = � & Y È$0 Y 7 5 ����É��� ^ ¸ È �=��É =�� G�M¶» �

�� = 0 �� ^©\§KNILK ©(KDK5»:¦§³bS�ºdc°\RKeIL¯R³¶K � � � � X � � � � ^ � <=<=<X � ^ � ` <><=< � � � � X � � � � ^ � <=<>< ¸ X��� O1K5FH«aK

) ¸ , G�M¶» � 0 �

. ^ È�� �� ^ É =�(\§K�UV¯R»d»0[�c°M¶S�F0S�W�KNI � M´U&c°ILM¶W'M|[�³Tc°\P[�FR]_U&c°S0±1¯RILFHUVM|G�K �ÞU�cV\RK5S�ILK5»ÂYR[�FPG0©(K�«aS�FH«a³¶¯HG�K1�

� ¸ K5¿$¦ � � ��� ^

, � X � ^� 7#V ! � . È���� �$ɤ¥KÏUVK5K¥c°\P[�c0c°\§Kϼ'[�¯§¼�K7c°\RK5S�ILºÌ¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³DS�IÓc°\RK�¬�ILK5KoK5FRK5IL¼�ºÌS�¬=S�¯RIÃUVcL[�c°M|UVcVM´«5[�³e»:S�G�K5³«aS�MbFP«�M|G�KZU(©�MbcV\Äc°\RK �"ILS�»:S�W'��¤ MbcVc°K5F0¦§ILKN¦PS�cVKNF�cVM´[�³TS�¬�cV\RK=Õ X c°S�¦PS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³,UVM¶¼�»Ø[e»dS�G�K5³�O

�{'qa�d��nµ����{'q5��z|n��R{�~��5��{��T� p�(c�c°\§M´U&¦HS�M¶F�c(c°\RKµ¬�[�MbI � ¯RKZUVcVMbS�FÄM´U���©\RK5ILKDcV\RM|UÕ X «5[�»dK"¬�ILS�» � �&¬�c°K5ID[�³¶³�Y�M¶FÂ[�³¶³T¦R\�º_UVM|«5[�³

[�¦R¦R³¶M|«N[�cVM¶S�FHU�S�¬�c°\§K=c°S�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³�UVc°ILM¶FR¼'U�c°\§K=cÊ[�IL¼�K5c�UV¦H[�«aK�UV\RS�¯§³´GÓ½HKd[���[�³|[�½RM¶����[�¯7»0[�FRMú¬�S�³|GTY[�FHGdÕ X M´U1G�KaÀHFRM¶cVKN³¶º�F§S�c�c°\§KDS�FRK�O � F§K�«5[�F0M¶»Ø[�¼�M¶FRK�c°\RK"cVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M|«N[�³PUVc°ILM¶FR¼eS�FÃ[D³¶S_«5[�³ ��[�³|[�½RM¶���[�¯,Y$©\§M´« \:M|U([eILKZUVS�³bW�KZGd«aS�FRM�¬�S�³´GTY$M�O K�O�[ecVS�cÊ[�³,UV¦H[�«aK"S�¬,cV\RK � È��=��É � � È��¾��É<½R¯RFHGJ³bK�S�W�K5IÕ X O� FRKD«N[�FÄcV\RK5FÃcV¯RILF0cV\RK�UVS���«5[�³b³¶KZGdc�©�M´UVcVKZGd»0[�ULUVK¨U ) X B ) ^ Y�S�IZY�»dS�ILK�»0[�cV\RK5»0[�c°M|«5[�³b³¶º:UV¦PKZ[�]'M¶FR¼RYK � ¯RM¶W�[�ILM|[�F�c¦H[�I�[�»dK5c°K5I�U&©M¶c°\7ILKZUV¦PK¨«ac�c°S0cV\RK=ILS�cL[�c°M¶S�FHU&S�¬�c°\§KeÀH½HK5I�S�¬�c°\§K=W�K¨«acVS�I"½R¯RFHG�³¶K�O(��FcV\RK�³¶M¶»:M¶c ) X : ^ @ �9cV\RK¾UVM¶¼�»0[=»dS_GJKN³TM|U(³¶S_«5[�³¶M .5KZGÄS�F�c°SdcV\RKe»Ø[�¦PU1MbF�cVSØÕ X ¦RILS�¦HK5IZO1��U(cV\RM|UcV\RK©[�º=c°S9KN»9½HKZG9S�¯RI1»dS_G�K5³RM¶F0[ ¬�¯R³b³¶� +HKZG�¼�KZG�UVcVILMbF§¼¾«aS�»d¦H[�«ac°M�À£«5[�cVMbS�F � ¤¥K�G�S�¯R½§c�Mbc1M|U�cV\RKD«5[�UVKÁO�"[�c°\§KNIZYå©(KcV\RMbF§]=c°\RK"¦RILS�¦PK5I�»dS_G�K5³HUV\§S�¯R³´GͽHK"cV\H[�c�S�¬,³¶MbcVcV³bKDUVcVILMbFR¼ c°\RK5S�ILº � ����H«aS�»d¦H[�«acV�M�ÀHKZGÄS�FÏÕ X OD��FHG�K5KZGTYPcV\RK�G�M|UL«�¯PULUVMbS�FÄMbF�c°\§K=½HK5¼�M¶FRFRM¶FR¼dS�¬�c°\§M´UDUVKZ«acVMbS�F¥UV¯R¼�¼�KZUVcÊU"[dILKZ[�³¶M .Z[�cVMbS�FS�¬Dc°\§KÂ[�½PK5³bM|[�Fż'[�¯§¼�KÃcV\RK5S�ILºª©M¶cV\ÅM¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHUͽ_º¥»dKZ[�FHU=S�¬DcV\RK7!D#�½RI�[�FRK0©�I�[�¦R¦RM¶FR¼o[oÕ XM¶FHUVM´GJK�cV\RK0��¼�¯H« \RM¶��"[�FHUVS�FoUV¦P[�«�K � � Õ X Y<©�\RM´« \¥M´U c°\§K0ILKZUVS�³b¯RcVM¶S�FoS�¬cV\RKÄÔ ^���� ^ UVM¶FR¼�¯R³|[�ILMbc�º�O�(\§K7©I�[�¦R¦PKZGÅ!D#Ù½RI�[�FRKÄM´Ud[¥½R³¶S�©FR��¯R¦ ¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³�! �o½§I�[�FRKÂUVcV¯H« ]Ð[�cdcV\RKoUVMbF§¼�¯R³´[�ILM¶c�º�O ��cUV¯R¦R¦PS�ILcLU�[�F¥· ¸ �ļ'[�¯R¼�Kdc°\§KNS�ILº�©M¶c°\Ñ[7UVMbFR¼�³¶K0[�½HK5³¶M´[�F¥W�KZ«ac°S�I=»9¯R³¶c°M¶¦R³¶KNc5OÃ��FÅ[�GRG�M¶c°M¶S�F,Y�Mbc\H[�U1M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5Y�«aS�»:M¶FR¼e¬�ILS�» ¬�I�[�«ac°M¶S�FH[�³T!=ÈË� ��É�½§I�[�FRKZU5Y'S�IZY�[�¬�c°K5I�ILK¨UVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�F�Y_!�� UVc°ILM¶FR¼=©(S�IL³|G��UV\RK5K5c�M¶FHUVcL[�F_cVS�FHU5O¥�(\RKZUVK7[�ILK0½PS�¯RFHG c°S¥cV\RKÂ! #o½§I�[�FRKd©(S�IL³´G�W�S�³¶¯R»dK�OÏ�&¬�cVK5I7%'��G�¯H[�³¶Mbc�ºÏ[�FHG[�¦R¦RILS�¦§ILM´[�cVK�GJK¨«aS�¯R¦§³bM¶FR¼"³bM¶»dMbcLU<cV\RKZUVKcV¯RILF�M¶F�c°SecV\RK�UVS���«5[�³b³¶KZG ~úz|����~|�1p����az|� ��p Y$S�¬£©�\RM|«L\�W�K5ILº=³¶MbcVcV³bKM|Ue]'FRS�©F,O¥��Fª¦P[�ILc°M|«a¯R³´[�IZY<»9¯H«L\ªG�K5½H[�cVK0©[�U=G�K5W�S�cVKZGªcVSocV\RK0M|ULUV¯RKdS�¬�cV\RK0cV¯RFH[�½R³¶K0«aS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼«aS�FHUVcL[�F_c(M¶FÄc°\RKZUVKec°\§KNS�ILM¶KZU5O � ¯§I(ILK¨UV¯§³bcLUUVcVILS�FR¼�³¶ºØUV¯§¼�¼�K¨UVc(UV¯H« \Â[ͦHS'ULUVM¶½RM¶³bM¶c�º�O

��(

Page 27: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

����u_�µ¢£�L�L�1�Z���a��z|n���p

��S�©Ö³¶K5cD¯HU"cV¯RILF¥S�FocV\RK9\RMb¼�\§KNI S�I�G�K5I ��[�UVM¶»dMbI�U�M¶FÏcV\RK9¼'[�¯R¼�K=c°\§KNS�ILº�O���SÓ¬�[�«aMb³¶MbcL[�cVK:cV\RK«5[�³´«a¯R³¶¯HU&Mbc"M|U«aS�F�W�KNF§MbK5F�c(c°SÓMbF�cVILS_G�¯H«aKDcV\RK ¬�S�IL»0[�³bM|UV» S�¬�¬�ILK5KD¬�K5IL»dMbS�FPU5O���S�FPUVM´G�K5I�c°\RKecV\RK5S�ILºS�¬�[�UVM¶FR¼�³¶K"¬�ILK5K¾«aS�»d¦R³¶KN¿9¬�K5IL»dMbS�FÓS�FÂ[9c�©(S���UV¦R\RK5ILK1� ���� � � O�¤ÏK=«5[�FÃK5¿$¦H[�FHGB�

� È �$É1¸ "� � �� X^

� � � �� , ���� . X^ B�� È �$É1¸ "

� � �� X^�� ��� � , ���� . X^

� � B �� � �e¸ � � �È���� (�É

�(\§K"¬�K5IL»:M¶S�FRM|«D�§S_«L]0UV¦H[�«aKDM|U«aS�FHUVcVIL¯H«acVK¨GÓ©M¶cV\7c°\RK \RK5³b¦ÄS�¬�c°\RK=«L\P[�IL¼�K � W�[�«a¯R¯R»ÆUVcL[�cVK�� �A � K1¸ ��� �� ��� � � ��� �� ������ � A � K�¸¹� B < a ��� � A � K�¸¹� B <� � È���� #$É

��ceM´Ue[�³|UVS«aS�F�W�K5FRMbK5F�c"c°S7¯PUVK�cV\RKd½H[�UVM´UµS�¬c°\RK0UVS���«5[�³b³¶KZG7¦H[�ILcVM¶c°M¶S�FªUVcÊ[�cVKZU�È�UVK5KÁY<K�O ¼RO3� ������ ��(��ÉLO�§S�I(K¨[�« \æP[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�F � ¸3È�0 X � 0 ^ � �����úÉ1©(KDMbF�cVILS_G�¯P«�K c°\RKeUVcÊ[�cVK1�

A � � � K1¸ ��� �� = � ��� �� = � ����� È���� �$É� FRK�G�KaÀHFRKZU&c°\RK9Ç=ÈÊ��É(«�¯§ILILKNF�c([�U��

-�¸ ���� � ��¸ "& � � - & � & ����- & ¸ "� � & �� � � & �� � "

�� & � & �� �� �È���� �É

��KZ«N[�³¶³TcV\RK�½PS'UVS�FRM .Z[�c°M¶S�F0IL¯R³¶KZU��� ¸ � V Y � � B �� ¸ � V Y � � B -�¸ � � � È����>�$É

[�FHGÄ[=¯HUVKa¬�¯R³P¬�[�«ac&¬�ILS�» Ç¾È ��¥É1¼�ILS�¯R¦Äc°\RK5S�ILº���cV\RK"¬�[�»dS�¯HU(¤¥K5º'³<«aS�ILILK¨UV¦PS�FHG�K5FH«aKDUVcL[�c°KZU(cV\H[�cÈ�Ô �� É�� = ¸ �

: + = � � � È���� )$É��� Û'�� ùÞä 4Zá�á� Íâ´á�ç�ã'øåù Ü! åù Û�4 "���Ý(ä6$'ß5æLÝ,+

��#

Page 28: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

[�U � = �¥Ç=È ��ÙÉ�ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F�cÊ[�cVM¶S�F,O���S�©Ö³bK5c9Ç ¸EG�M|[�¼ ��� X B6����� B�� �� � ½PKØ[�Ç=È ��ÙÉ»0[�c°ILM¶¿HOd�(\RK5FS�FRK0«5[�F¥K¨[�UVM¶³¶ºÏUV\RS�©3¯PUVMbFR¼Ä¤¥K5º'³(«L\H[�I�[�«acVKNI ¬�S�IL»�¯§³´[�YT[�FHG�cV\RK0UVcÊ[�FHG§[�I�Go½PS'UVS�FRM .Z[�c°M¶S�FoIL¯R³¶KZU5YcV\H[�c6�

�,I�����Ç ¸ J �� � � A � V Y D �� �� � � �� � � � � V Y �� � � � � � A � K�B È����´�5�$É�§ILS�» cV\RM|U1¬�S�IL»9¯R³´[eS�F§K�G�K5ILMbW�KZU��

V 0 � �� A � K�¸ "G�M¶» � �� = 0 �

A � � � K È����´����É� � 25476=>eAÃ@0-��9/�> *(�7*,6=>D+ -047B Ô=Õ X *,2�AÃ+3- +Ö8:BÄ>D/

�(\§K�M¶»d¦HS�ILcL[�FH«aK�S�¬Pc°\RK1¬�K5IL»dM¶S�FHUTM|UR®V¯HUVcVMúÀPK¨Ge½�ºDcV\RK1¬�S�³¶³bS�©M¶FR¼DUVcL[�c°K5»dK5F_c5O<�(\RK(¼�K5FRK5I�[�cVMbFR¼¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FÄ©M¶cV\7c°¯RILF§K¨GØS�FÃ\RM¶¼�\RK5I&�([�UVMb»dM¶I�U�K � ¯H[�³´U&c°SdcV\RK=«�S�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�Fd¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�F��

� ¸ J � A V 0 �� K5¿'¦ � '"� + X � � � � � X � V 0 � �� A � K È ( �´��É

�K5ILK/�'"� + X � � � � ��¸ '"� + X

��� 7 ���� � �

È � 7 ��^ É � X �ÑÈ � � ��^ É � X�� È ( � �$É

[�FHG� � X ¸ �

�� � �� È �� �0É � � � B � ¸ � ��� È ( � �$É

�ˬTS�FR³¶º!� X �¸ � cV\RK�«aS�ILILK5³´[�cVS�IÈ (RO´��É�M´U�c°ILM¶W'M|[�³¶³bº=«aS�»:¦§¯Rc°KZG9[�FHG9¼�MbW�KZU(È���O �$É<©M¶cV\ �d¸ �� � O��§ILS�»«aS�»d¦H[�ILM´UVS�F7S�¬�È (RO|��É©M¶c°\ c°\RK9ILKZUV¯R³bcLU S�¬-� �����S�FRK9¼�KNcLUecV\H[�cD¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°M¶FR¼Ó¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�FÌÈ (RO´��ÉLY­[�Ue[¬�¯RFH«acVMbS�F9S�¬,c°M¶»dKZU � � � M´U1["cL[�¯R�ˬ�¯RFH«acVMbS�FdS�¬Tc°\RK"��S_GR[ ³´[�cVcVM´«aK\§MbK5I�[�I�«L\�º�O,��S�cVK�cV\H[�c�cV\RK&¬�KNIL»dM¶S�FRM|«»0[�c°ILM¶¿�K5³¶K5»:K5F�c"È (RO|��É�M´U1W�K5ILº9»�¯H« \ØGJMúÒTK5ILKNF�c�¬�ILS�»EcV\RK�UVcL[�FHGR[�I�G9ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�Fͬ�S�IcV\RKD�,S�GR[cL[�¯R�ˬ�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�F1� ��#��O(��F7S�¯RI�«5[�UVKec°\§K �Vc°M¶»dK¨U��9[�ILK¾«aS�¯R¦§³bKZGÓc°S0cV\RKe¤ ��¼�K5FRK5I�[�c°S�I�U5Y�©�\RM¶³bKD¯PUV¯H[�³b³¶ºcV\RK5ºÃ«aS�¯R¦R³¶KDc°SdcV\RK=«�S�»d¦PS�FRK5F�cÊU1S�¬�cV\RK=Ç=ÈÊ��É«a¯RILILK5F�cNO

�(\§K=¬�ILK5K=¬�K5IL»dMbS�F§M´«ÍILKN¦§ILK¨UVK5F�cL[�c°M¶S�FªÈ (RO|��É"M´U ¯HUVKa¬�¯R³�M¶FªUVKNW�K5I�[�³<ILKZUV¦HKZ«acLU5O � FRK9S�¬�cV\RK5» M´UcV\RKdILKN»0[�IL]�[�½§³bKe»0[�¦R¦RM¶FR¼0S�¬(c°\RKd¼'[�¯R¼�K9c°\§KNS�ILºo«aS�ILILK5³|[�c°M¶S�F7¬�¯RFP«�cVM¶S�FÏcVS7cV\RK:[�»d¦R³¶MbcV¯HG�KZU"S�¬[ÈËc°S�¦PS�³bS�¼�M|«5[�³Rc�º$¦HKD� É­UVcVILMbFR¼RYå¦RILS�¦H[�¼'[�cVMbFR¼"S�FÄÔ¾Õ X O���FPG�K5K¨G Y�¯HUVM¶FR¼"c°\RK"ILKZUV¯R³¶cÊU²S�¬"� ����TÈ�UVK5KD[�³´UVS� �����É�S�FRK=«5[�FÂUV\§S�©¹cV\H[�c6�� K5¿'¦ � � '"*�+ X � * � �¶g �*� X���� ��� ��������� �� ��M;: �� ¸ KN¿$¦ '"� + � �� ^ � ^ J J KN¿$¦ ����� � G � 7 '"� + X � � � � � X È �É K K � � "!$# ��

È ( � (�É���

Page 29: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

��c�M|U�c°K5»d¦RcVMbFR¼ecVS¾UV¦PKZ«�¯§³´[�cVKcV\H[�c�[eUVMb»dM¶³´[�I�ILKN³|[�cVMbS�F9\RS�³´G§U�¬�S�I�FRS�FH[�½PK5³bM|[�F�¼'[�¯§¼�KcV\RK5S�ILMbKZU5O<�(\RK³¶K�¬�c<\H[�FPG=UVM´G�K�S�¬­È (RO (�ÉTM´U�]$FRS�©�FD¬�S�I�c°\RK1¼'[�¯R¼�K1¼�ILS�¯R¦9ǾÈ���É�ÈË©(K1K¨ULUVK5F�cVM´[�³¶³bºeG�KZUL«�ILM¶½PK¨G M¶c­½�ºDcV\RK¬�S�IL»�¯§³´[�K"È���OÞ��)$ÉLÈ���O ('�$ÉÊY�UVK5K�[�³|UVS:�� ËÉ,½R¯Rc<cV\RK"ILMb¼�\�c,\P[�FHG�UVM|G�KM|U<FRS�c5Y�[�³bcV\RS�¯R¼�\9c°\RK5ILK[�ILK"UVc°ILS�FR¼M¶FHG�M|«N[�cVM¶S�FHUTcV\H[�c�cV\RK1¬�ILK5K1¬�K5IL»:M¶S�F=ILK5¦RILKZUVK5F_cL[�cVMbS�F=[�FHGeILK5³´[�cVM¶S�F=c°SDcV\RK"Ô=Õ X UVMb¼�»0[�»dS_G�K5³'\§S�³´GRUM¶F�cV\RM|U,«5[�UVK�cVS'S�� � �O<��FRS�cV\RK5I­[�¦R¦R³¶M|«N[�cVM¶S�F�S�¬,È (RO´��ÉPM´U c°\RK(«5[�³´«a¯R³|[�cVMbS�FeS�¬Rc°\RK1K5¿'¦PKZ«�cL[�cVMbS�F=W�[�³¶¯RKZUS�¬ � * Oo�&\RM|UeKN¿$K5I�«�M|UVK0M|UeMbF�cVK5ILK¨UVcVM¶FR¼ÃM¶FÑILKN³|[�cVMbS�F¥cVSocV\RK0ILKZ«aKNF�ce»0[�c°ILM¶¿¥»:S�G�K5³� Z¼'[�¯§¼�K�cV\RK5S�ILº«aS�ILILKZUV¦HS�FHGJKNFP«�K"S�¬ �eOR!"M ®V]'¼�I�[�[�¬²[�FPG �"O �[�¬�[ � �1���Y�©\RM|«L\ĦRILKZG�M|«acÊU5Y�[�«5«�S�I�GJMbFR¼=cVS3� ��)���

J ��I � * K�¸ � * ���� B �-7 S ^ �� ¸ � � È � É�¸ � � 7 � X � � X 7 � ^ � � ^ 7Q�6����7 � � È ( � #$É� ¯§MbcVK0M¶FÙ[�¼�ILK5K5»dK5F_ce©M¶cV\ªc°\§K�¬�S�IL»9¯R³|[�K=¬�ILS�» � �����Y<S�½RcÊ[�M¶FRKZG�MbF c°\RK0«aS�F�c°K5¿$c=S�¬�cV\RKÄ%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼��¤ M¶cVc°K5F7cV\RK5S�ILºÁO

��SëaS�»d¦R¯RcVK=c°\RK9K5¿'¦PK¨«acL[�c°M¶S�FªW�[�³¶¯RKZU S�¬ � * MbF�S�¯RI�[�¦R¦RILS'[�« \ªÈ|¬�S�I � ¸?��ÉMbceUV¯ ë�KZU"cVS«5[�³´«a¯R³|[�cVK � �� ^ X� � ! 0 � � � [�c � ^ ¸ � ` ¸ ���6�§¸ �d[�FHGÄcV\RK5FoUVK5FHG �� @ �ÃÈ�[�U � ��)�<G�M|G0FRS�c�³bS$S�]Â[�ccV\RK�K � ¯RMbW�[�ILM´[�FH«aKD©�MbcV\ÄILK¨UV¦PKZ«accVS:cV\RK=UV¦H[�«aK5��cVM¶»:K"ILS�cL[�c°M¶S�FHUaÉ �

J � * K M;: �D¸¸ ³bM¶»�� � � �� * J � A V �� � � �� � � � � � �� � È�� 7 X^ É

* �ÌÈ�� � X^ É* � � � V �� �� � � �� � � � � � A � KJ � A V �� � � �� � � � V � �� � � �� � � � � � A � K ¸

¸ , �-7 �;7 S ^� . * ����S ^ ¸(V ! � B �ظ �� �

È ( � �$É

cV\RK�³|[�UVc(ILK5³´[�cVM¶S�FæRILS�W�KZGd½�ºd½HS'UVS�FRM .Z[�c°M¶S�F,O��&\RM´U&ILK5¦RILS_G�¯P«�KZU"È (RO #$É�¬�S�I � ¸ ��O�(\§KocVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³�UVcVILM¶FR¼ªS�F.Ô¾Õ X [�«�cV¯H[�³¶³bºÌ\P[�U0K5W�K5F¹»:S�ILK7S�½PUVKNILW�[�½R³bKZUdcV\RK5F¹c°\§KÏS�F§K¨U

¦RILKZUVK5F�c°KZGeM¶FÃÈ (RO (�ÉLO���FHG�K5KZGTY�©(K[�ILK(»dM´ULUVM¶FR¼"[�³b³�cV\RK¼�I�[�W'M¶cÊ[�cVM¶S�FH[�³_G�KZUL«aK5FHGR[�F�cLUTS�¬Tc°\RK(¦§¯RFH«ac°¯§ILKS�¦PKNI�[�cVS�I�� = È � É B�0 a ��O ¤¥Ko«aS�F�®VKZ«ac°¯RILK�Y�c°\P[�c0c°\§KNM¶Id¼'[�¯R¼�K7cV\RK5S�ILº G�¯H[�³�Y�½�ºÌ[�FH[�³¶S�¼�ºÅ©�MbcV\�"GP%R ��(���Ì«aS�ILILK¨UV¦PS�FHG�K5FH«aK ������Y$M|U�cV\RK�UV\RM�¬�c�S�¬,W�K5W_U1S�¬,cV\RKDS�¦PK5I�[�c°S�I�U1��I � * Y$¬�S�I � * X È � ÉÊO1�RS�I-¹¸ �Í©(KØ[�ILK9cÊ[�³¶]'M¶FR¼o[�½PS�¯Rc=UV\RMú¬�cVM¶FR¼ �§Y<c°\§K:W�K5W�S�¬ � O0�(\RM|UDM|U MbFHGJKNKZG�cV\RK0«N[�UVK�OÓ¤ \RK5Fª[�³b³cV\RKZUVKëaS�¯R¦R³¶MbFR¼'Ue[�ILK0cL[�]�K5FÅM¶F�c°So[�«5«aS�¯RF�c=©(Kd©(S�¯R³´GÙKN¿$¦HKZ«ac�cVSªUVK5K:cV\RKÓ¬�¯R³¶³�c�©(S���G�M¶»dK5FHUVMbS�FP[�³��S_GR[ͳ´[�cVcVM´«aK=\RM¶K5I�[�I�«L\�º�� ��#��O

Page 30: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

� � 6��7>e8:@ ��� 256�� +.-D6=6=>D@

��FdcV\RM´U(UVKZ«acVMbS�Fd©(KDUV\H[�³¶³HG�M|UL«�¯PULU<c°\§KNS�ILº9©M¶c°\Ó»Ø[�cVcVKNI1M¶F0c°\§K¬�¯§FHGR[�»dK5F_cL[�³�ILK5¦RILKZUVKNF�cL[�c°M¶S�F,O¤¥K�UV\H[�³¶³£[�¼'[�M¶F7«�S�FPUVM´G�K5I(S�FR³¶º0Ç=ÈL��É&«5[�UVK�Y�½R¯Rc[�U([�½PS�W�KD©(K�UV\H[�³¶³H½PK�Y�MbFļ�K5FRK5I�[�³�Y$M¶F_cVK5ILKZUVc°KZGdM¶FcV¯RILFRM¶FR¼=S�FÃ\§Mb¼�\RK5I-��[�UVM¶»:M¶I�U5O

v��|s������Ã{��R�Óu'� ���~ú�0�Ë�R��n��a��(\§Ke¬�[�»:S�¯PU�«aS�FHGJMbcVMbS�F7S�¬([�UVº'»d¦RcVS�c°M|« ¬�ILK5K¨GJS�»ÂY���� � �����NYPMú¬1KN¿$c°I�[�¦PS�³|[�c°KZG7cVSÄc°\RK�«5[�UVK

���1¸ �(UV¯R¼�¼�KZUVcLU,cV\H[�c�©(K(«aS�¯R³|G�[�GRGe¯R¦9c°S c�©(S"¬�¯RFHG§[�»:K5F�cL[�³'\�º'¦PK5IL»�¯R³¶c°M¶¦R³¶K5cÊU5OT��c�M|U<[�UVcVI�[�M¶¼�\_cV�¬�S�IL©[�I�G9K5¿'K5I�«aM´UVK"cVS=KN¿$c°K5FHGÓcV\RK"ÀH¿$K¨GئHS�M¶F�c�«5[�³|«�¯§³b¯HU�cVS=MbFH«aS�IL¦PS�I�[�c°K"cV\RK"KaÒ£KZ«ac(S�¬­cV\RKD«L\H[�IL¼�KZG»0[�c°cVK5IZO�QTK5c(¯HU1½RILM¶K�+Hº=ILK5»dMbFHG9cV\RK"Mb»d¦PS�ILcÊ[�F�c�UVcVK5¦HU5O1%'¯HUVº=K � ¯H[�c°M¶S�FHU1M¶F0cV\RK"¦RILKZUVKNFP«�K�S�¬­»0[�cV�cVKNI"\�º'¦PK5IL»�¯R³¶cVMb¦R³¶K5c � ¸ÖÈ �� B ��É«L\P[�FR¼�KD¬�ILS�» ! ¸¹�dc°S ! 7 � � � ¸ ��Y � � � ¸ ��O(�(\RK»dS_G�¯§³bM�UV¦H[�«aK�S�¬�UVS�³¶¯RcVMbS�FPUcVS7cV\RKZUVK�K � ¯H[�cVM¶S�FHUD³¶S'S�]�UeFRKZ[�I � ¸ �Ó³bS�«�¯PU�[�Ue[0W�KZ«acVS�I�½R¯§FHG�³¶KS�W�KNI � �0cV\RKDM¶FHUVcÊ[�F�cVS�FûdS�G�¯R³¶M�Y$©\RS'UVKµÀH½HK5I�M´U&c°\RKecV\RK�½§¯RFHG�³¶K"S�¬�!µMbI�[�«;.5K5ILS�»dS�G�KZU5O

��c�«5[�Fd½PK�UV\RS�©F9c°\H[�c�c°\RK�MbFPUVcÊ[�F�cVS�F�»dKZ[�UV¯RILK�¼�K5cLU([�F�K5¿'cVI�[µ¬�[�«�cVS�I(©\§M´« \=c°\RK"K � ¯§MbW�[�ILM|[�F�c��¯R³bK5I"«�³|[�ULU�S�¬�cV\RM´U�½R¯§FHG�³¶KÁO(�&\RK�³¶S_«5[�³¶M .Z[�cVMbS�FĬ�S�IL»9¯R³|[�K�UVc°M¶³¶³,©(S�IL]HY§½R¯Rc�FRS�©¹KZ[�«L\7¦P[�ILc°M¶c°M¶S�F �\H[�U=[�F¥K5¿'cVI�[7©(K5M¶¼�\_c �= �O7�(\RK0«aS�F�c°ILM¶½R¯RcVMbS�F�S�¬�cV\RK9ÀH¿'KZG¥¦PS�M¶F_cecVSocV\RKd¦H[�c°\ MbF�cVKN¼�I�[�³�MbFªcV\RK¦RILKZUVK5FH«aKDS�¬­cV\RKe»0[�c°cVK5IÀPKN³|GRU1M|UDÈ���O ('�$É1»�¯R³¶cVMb¦R³¶M¶K¨Gؽ_ºdcV\RKeKN¿$c°I�[ͬ�[�«acVS�I;�

�) È��4B �7É1¸����� � ! È��4B ��É � ^)� + X ')Y + X È��A7 ����7 �� ÈÊ� ����ÉVÉ �����ZÈ��&7 ���;7 �� È�0 Y ����ÉVÉ È�#��´��É

©\§KNILK

� �� � ! È^� B���É1¸ )� ')Y + X �

, �A7 �����

7 ���� . O K5¿'¦ � '� GR�� "�

V ! � M ��� �UVM¶FR\ ^ � �� !^ �

¸

¸ "�

� È^� 7 ���'É ^� �� ^ ³¶S�¼RÈ��A7 ���É 7 �

�5� ³¶S�¼RÈ^� 7 ��$É 7 "� X

� ^ ��?!£È��?! �ª�$É , ���A7 ���

. ^ � ^ �È�#�� �$É

�(\§KD½HS'UVS�F§M .Z[�cVMbS�FÄIL¯R³¶K�È���O|�5�$É�³¶KZ[�GRU1cVS:cV\RK ¬�S�³b³¶S�©M¶FR¼e¬�S�IL»�¯R³|[��� Y & � ! ¸ � V Y �� � �� �

� ' � V Y���

���X � V D � ! ����� � V Y � �� � ��X � V Y �� � �� �

� � � � È�#�� �$É��c(«5[�F0½HKDUV\RS�©F9c°\P[�c�cV\RK�¬�¯R³¶³H¦H[�ILcVM¶c°M¶S�F9¬�¯RFH«ac°M¶S�F � �� � ! � Y & � ! [�³´UVSe\H[�U1[ ����� MbF�cVKNIL¦§ILKNcL[��

cVMbS�F,YR[�FPGÃ[�³|UVS�S�½PK5º_U"��S_GR[ͳ´[�cVc°M|«aK�K � ¯H[�c°M¶S�FHU5O�¤ÏKeUV\H[�³b³,GJM´UL«a¯HULU1cV\RM|U(M¶FÂ[ͬ�¯RcV¯RILKD¦R¯§½R³bM|«5[�c°M¶S�F,O

�1�

Page 31: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

v���u_�µx��~ú{���z|n��¥��n�����n��0�a���az�qd��� ��z|�T�L���az|� �

��S�©¹³¶K5c¯HU&c°¯RILFÄS�ÒocV\RK�\§Mb¼�\RK5I-��[�UVM¶»:M¶I�U5O,�&\RK5FÏÈ�#�O �$ÉLÈ�#�O´��É(³¶K¨[�GÓcVS

�L�D¸ X^ � X � ^ � � X � ^ ³bS�¼RÈL� � V ! � É 7 "�X^ È �-7 ���É ^ ³¶S�¼�È��A7 ����É

� X ¸��5� ³¶S�¼RÈ^�A7 � X ÉÊÈ��A7 � ^ É

� � ¸ � ^ ��?!£È��?! �ª�$É " � �� ^ � ^

È��A7 ��$É ^ � ^

È�#�� (�É

¤¥K�ILK5»0[�IL]dc°\P[�c�È�#�O (�É1M´U"[9³bM¶»dMbc(S�¬1c°\RK=[�³¶³b��¼�K5F�¯HU1c°S�¦PS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³,UVcVILMbFR¼9¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³TMbF7cV\RK¼�K5S�»dKNcVILºÃG�KZUL«aILM¶½HKZGÓMbF���_���È��²Mb¼RO|�5��YH� � O"È 'O ��(�ÉVÉÊO"�(\§K¾UV¦PKZ«�M�À£« ³bM¶»dMbc(M|U�c°SdcL[�]�KeÀHI�UVcX� X BL� ^ B ! �M¶FocV\RK5MbIDF§S�cÊ[�cVMbS�F�c°S�.5K5ILSRY,[�U � �0¸ � È��A7 ���'É�B ! � ¸ � �� Y � @ ��YP©\§Mb³¶K � < � ÈËc°\§KNM¶IDFRS�cL[�cVMbS�FTɸ � X ÈËS�¯RI"FRS�cÊ[�cVM¶S�FTÉ�M´U&ÀHF§MbcVK�O��(\§K�¦RILK5¦PS�c°K5F�cVM´[�³ ��_��,[�«ac°¯H[�³¶³¶ºÃG�KZUL«aILMb½PKZU(cV\RKDÀPW�K�G�M¶»:K5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³UV¯HUVº0¼'[�¯§¼�K=c°\RK5S�ILº7«aS�»:¦P[�«�cVM�ÀHKZGÄS�FÏ[0«aM¶I�«�³¶K=S�¬�«aM¶I�«�¯§»�¬�K5ILK5FH«aK � O��&\RK=³¶Mb»dM¶c � @ �0[�«ac°¯H[�³¶³¶ºcL[�]�K¨U�¯HU&c°SdcV\RKe¬�S�¯RI"G�Mb»dK5FHUVM¶S�FH[�³RcV\RK5S�ILº�YR©\§M´« \ÃM|U(©�\H[�c©(Ke©(K5ILK�UVc°¯PG�º'M¶FR¼�M¶F7cV\RM´U&¦H[�¦PKNIZO(��cM|U«a³bKZ[�IZY$¬�ILS�» ��_���È��<M¶¼RO|�5��«ZÉ�cV\H[�c�c°\RKe¼�K5S�»dKNcVILº0«aS�ILILK¨UV¦PS�FHGRU�cVS:cV\RK=Ç=ÈL��É�¼'[�¯§¼�KDc°\§KNS�ILºd©�MbcV\c�©(Sͬ�¯RFHGR[�»dK5F�cÊ[�³P\�º'¦PKNIL»9¯R³¶c°M¶¦R³¶KNcLU�È�c�©(S0!"��½RI�[�F§K¨U1¦§¯R³b³¶M¶FR¼=S�FÃcV\RK=UVM´GJK¨UaÉLO� ¯RI�ILKZUV¯R³¶cLU�[�ILK�Y$\RS�©(K5W�K5IZY'UVcVILS�FR¼�K5IZO���FHG�K5KZGTY�©(K"©(K5ILKD[�½R³¶K�cVS:«5[�³|«a¯R³´[�cVK"c°\§KD¦RILK5¦HS�cVK5F�c°M|[�³[�FHG � � �ÞU(©�MbcV\7[�IL½RMbcVI�[�ILºd\RM¶¼�\RK5I;��[�UVM¶»:M¶I�U�c°¯RILF§K¨GÓS�F,O1��FÃcV\RKe³bM¶»dMbc

� X B � ^ @ 0B V ! � @ � ÈËS�¯RIFRS�cL[�cVMbS�FTÉ�B UVS�cV\H[�c S ^ ¸ � X � ^ V ! � ¸(V�� � M|U1ÀHFRM¶cVKÈ�#�� #$É

©(Ko¼�K5cĽH[�«L]ÌcV\RK¥¦R¯RILK¥Ç=ÈL��É0c°\RK5S�ILº�Y"©\§M´« \ ©(K¥M´GJKNF�cVMúÀPK¨G ©M¶c°\¹cV\RK¥c°S�¦PS�³¶S�¼�M´«5[�³�UVcVILMbF§¼ªS�FÕ X È (RO (�ÉÊO ��S�cVKocV\H[�cdc°\§M´U9©[�U9FRS�c:Õ X K5»9½HKZGRG�KZG MbF�cVS ��[�³|[�½RMb����[�¯�Y�[�U9M¶FÌc°\§K7³´[�cVc°K5Ië5[�UVKFRS�¼�I�[ZW$MbcL[�c°M¶S�FH[�³G�KZUL«aK5FHGR[�F�cLUDK5W�K5I0UV\RS�©(KZG¥¯§¦,O¥¤¥KÃ[�ILKó¶KZGTY�cV\RK5ILKa¬�S�ILK�Y�cVSÏcV\RK7«aS�FH«a³b¯HUVM¶S�F,YcV\H[�cDcV\RK�cVS�¦HS�³¶S�¼�M|«N[�³�UVcVILMbF§¼0S�FocV\RK�¼�K5S�»dK5c°ILºÄS�¬�<Mb¼RO|�5�9S�¬-��_��<\H[�UD[ÄG�Ka¬�S�IL»0[�c°M¶S�F,YH[�³¶³¶S�©�MbFR¼¼�I�[�W'M¶cÊ[�cVMbS�FP[�³�G�KZUL«aK5FHGR[�F�cÊU5Y([�FHG +PS�©�MbFR¼RY1M¶F cV\RK7³¶Mb»dM¶cÂÈ�#�OÞ#$ɾcVSÑc°\RK7¦§¯RILKÂÕ X »dS�G�K5³�O �&\RM´U¬�[�UL«aMbFP[�c°M¶FR¼�¦§ILK¨GJM´«acVMbS�FëaK5ILcL[�MbFR³¶º0G�KZUVK5ILW�K¨U�¬�¯RILcV\RK5I�UVcV¯HG�º�O

�"qa���Rn�r�~|��� �����Ó���R�ËpN��"� [�«L]$FRS�©�³bKZG�¼�KZU�¯HUVKa¬�¯R³dG�M´UL«a¯HULUVM¶S�FHUÄ©�MbcV\ �eO=±1K5IL]�S�W$Mbc/.�YÄ%HO �1\RK5IL]'M|U5Y:�eO ��M¶W�K5F�cÊ[�³�Y

!=O8�"ILS'ULU5Y�ªO�2 S�F_cLUVK5W'M|«L\,Y �¾O(�7S$S�ILK�Y��eO�<S�³¶º'[�]�S�WHY(�eO"%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RY"%HO�%'\H[�cL[�UV\�W'M¶³bM�Y��O1¤ M¶c°�cVKNF�Y ��O 1[�¬�[�YH[�FHGÓKZUV¦HKZ«aM´[�³¶³¶ºÃ�eO � ]�S�¯RFR]�S�WHO��"� M|U(¼�I�[�cVKa¬�¯R³,cVS���¯Rc°¼�K5I�U(Î�FRM¶W�K5I�UVMbc�º�YR��FPUVc°M¶c°¯§c°K¬�S�I(��GJW�[�FH«aKZG0%$c°¯HGJºÁY 2e[ZW$³bMR��FHUVcVM¶c°¯RcVK�¬�S�I��&\RK5S�ILK5c°M|«5[�³J��\�º_UVM|«5U5Y'[�FHG �1³´[�º��o[�cV\RK5»0[�c°M|«5[�³H��FHUVcVM¶�cV¯Rc°Ke¬�S�IDUV¯R¦§¦HS�ILc"[�FHGÄ\RS'UV¦RM¶cÊ[�³¶M¶c�º0G�¯RILM¶FR¼�cV\RK=¦RILK5¦H[�I�[�cVMbS�FÓS�¬�c°\§K=»Ø[�F�¯HUL«aILM¶¦Rc5O�� %_QÑ[�FHG7�"�

��)

Page 32: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

[�ILKe¼�I�[�c°Ka¬�¯R³TcVS0��"�(%d¬�S�I"\RS'UV¦RM¶cL[�³bM¶c�º�YR�"� [�«L]$FRS�©�³bKZG�¼�KZU([�³|UVS�cV\RK�UV¯R¦R¦PS�ILc1S�¬�c°\§K¾�1«aS�³bK=��S�IL�»0[�³bKÓ%'¯R¦PK5ILMbK5¯RILK�Y �(���D%o[�FHG�cV\RK:��[�¿o��³|[�FH« ]Â��FPUVc°M¶c°¯§c°Kͬ�S�I¾��[�c°\RK5»0[�cVM´«5U ©\RK5ILK=cV\RM´U ©(S�IL]©[�Ue«�S�»d¦R³¶K5c°KZGTO���KZUVK¨[�I�« \o©[�U ¦H[�ILcVM´[�³¶³bºoUV¯§¦R¦HS�ILcVKZG7½�º�������� ¼�I�[�F�cÊU �R�a���R�a������#�( �7È�� %_Q<ÉLY�R�a���R�a������#���)�È��"�¥É�[�FHGd�R�a���R�a������#�(')=È��"� É�[�FPGd½�º=c°\RKe���"�­� %�¼�I�[�F�c�)�)���#�)��dÈ�� %_Qo[�FHGÓ���ÙÉÊO

���

Page 33: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

@ ��� ��� � � � ���

�¶��E��O�¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�#����R�5��(� ��E�eOR�<S�³¶º'[�]�S�WPY�\RK5¦R��c°\T �) _���5������Yå\RK5¦R��c°\T �)1����)���# � ����HOR��[�³´G§[�«�K5FH[�Y$\RK5¦R��cV\T �) _���5����� �

%HO��"¯R½HUVK5IZY��LO42D³¶K5½H[�FRS�WHYR�eOR�<S�³¶º'[�]�S�WPY�\RK5¦R��c°\ �)1�����R�5��) ���O�¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1�����R�5#��

�)(� %HO42e[�c .�YR�eO 2 ³¶KN»d»7Y ��O 1[�¬�[�Y�\RK5¦R��c°\T �)�����)�����)� #�E�ªOT±1K5I�UV\H[�GRUV]$º�YT%HO ��KZ«aS�cVc°M�YT�O � S�¼�¯RILM�Y �"O �[�¬�[�Y ��S�»d»7O ��[�c°\,OP��\�º�U5O ��� � ÈL�5)�)�(�É&�R����Y

��¯H«a³�OR��\�º_U5O � ��� � ÈL�5)�)��$É�� �) ��LO���F�c°S�FRM|[�G�M|U5YZ�O �D[ZW�[�Y 29O�%HO��"[�I�[�M¶F,Y�� O/�eO��<[Zº$³bS�IZYZ��¯H«a³�O���\�º_U5O � � � � ÈÊ�5)�)�(�É(�5����Y���¯H«a³�O��\_º�U5O � � � � ÈÊ�5)�)�#$ÉD�5��)

� �� ��O 1[�¬�[�YR\RK5¦R��cV\T ������1�R��('��� E�eOR��KN]$I�[�UVS�WPYR\RK5¦R��cV\T ��������R�5�R�� ��E�eORQTS'UVK5WHY �¾OP�7S$S�ILKÁY��eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHYP%HOP%$\H[�cÊ[�UV\�W$Mb³¶M�Y$\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�#���)R�5#R�� )�E�eOR��KN]$I�[�UVS�WPYR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�����)��R�5)��

�eORQ,[�©ILK5FH«aK�YR�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHY�\RK5¦R��cV\T �) ���������#�¶�5��E�eORQTS'UVK5WHYP�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHYP%HOP%'\P[�cÊ[�UV\�W'M¶³¶M�Y$\RK5¦R��c°\ �) _�����5�1��Y'\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1���R�5���R��¶���� �=OR�7S'S�ILK�YR�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHYP%POP%'\H[�cL[�UV\_W$Mb³¶M�Y'\RK5¦R��cV\T �) _�5����(H��¶�5�� �=OR�7S'S�ILK�YR�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHYP%POP%'\H[�cL[�UV\_W$Mb³¶M�Y'\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1����������#�¶�5��E�eORQTS'UVK5WHYP�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHYP%HOP%'\P[�cÊ[�UV\�W'M¶³¶M�Y$\RK5¦R��c°\ �)�)��1������(RY'\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�)R���5��)�)�¶��(�E�eOD!"S�ILK5º�YD�DO��HOD�S�³b³¶S�©(S'S_G Y =O 2 \RS�.5K�YD�ªOD��[�c°cVM´U5Y"\§KN¦§��cV\T ���������������Y[�FPG ILKa¬�K5ILK5FH«aK¨U

cV\RK5ILKNM¶F�¶�5#�E�DOR�S�³¶³bS�©(S'S�GTY�\RK5¦R��cV\T ������R�5� �#�Y'\§KN¦§��cV\T ��������R�5) �¶�5��EÎeOR±1IL¯4. .5SRYH�(O��R¯P«�M¶cVSRY��HOÞ�(OR�7S�I�[�³¶KZU5Y_�eOR�<[�F4.5MbF§M�Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T ����R�����5�1� �

!=OÞ±1K5³b³¶M´UL[�M�YT�(OÞ�R¯H«aM¶c°SRYT�eOÞ�­[�F .NM¶FRM�Y �=O ��I�[�W�[�¼�³bM¶FRM�YR\RK5¦R��cV\T ��������R���5��YP\RK5¦R��c°\ ���������� ���YH\§KN¦§�cV\T ������1������#

�¶�� �eOR�<³¶¯R»dKÁY��eOR�<S�¼�\RS'ULUVM|[�F,Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T ������1�R���� ��eOR�<³¶¯R»dKÁY��eOR�<S�¼�\RS'ULUVM|[�F,Y'eOT%$c°S�I�« \,Y'\§KN¦§��cV\T ��R���5����('��Y$\RK5¦R��c°\ ��R���5���R����¶����E�eOP%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RYR�O�¤ MbcVcVKNF�YH\§KN¦§��cV\T �)�('� ��1� 'Y�\§KN¦§��cV\T �)�('�1����)�)�¶�5)�E�eOP%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RY�\RK5¦R��c°\ �)�('�1���R�5�� ����E�eO42D³¶K5»d»ÂY�¤.ORQTK5I�«L\§KÁYP%POR�(\RK5M|UVKNF�YP%HO ��[�FR]$MbK5³¶S�©�M´«�.�Y�\RK5¦R��c°\ �)�(H���5��( ���

�<OR��IL¼�º'ILKZU5YR�eOR�H[�I�[�¼�¼�M�Y$\RK5¦R��c°\T �)�(H���5��# ���eOR"[�FH[�F�ºÁY �=O � .�Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�#���#�� (

� �R�� �=OR�7S'S�ILK�YR��O�¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\§KN¦§��cV\T �) ���)R�5)��� ����E�eO �"S�I�UV]'º�Y���O$�o[�I�UV\H[�]�S�WHY���O$�7M¶ILS�FRS�WPY��eO��7S�ILS�.5S�WPY���¯H«a³�O ��\�º_U5O � � �� ÈL�5)�)1�$É­��)���� _�5��Y

\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1��������� �R�

Page 34: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

� ����E�eO �"S�I�UV]'º�Y,� O 2 ILM´« \RK5W�K5IZY£�eOÞ�o[�I�UV\H[�]�S�WHYT�eOÞ�7M¶ILS�FRS�Wo[�FPGÏ�eOÞ�7S�ILS�.5S�WHY,��\�º_U5O,Q KNcVc5O � � � �ÈL�5)�)�#$É ('��� ��\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�#���#�����#�O

� ��(�E�eO��o[�I�UV\H[�]�S�WHY �a%'K5M¶½HK5IL¼���¤ M¶c°cVK5FÐ�&\RK5S�ILºª[�FHGÅ��F_cVK5¼�I�[�½R³¶KÃ%$º_UVcVKN»0U5Y ��� n��a~ú�¥�£q5z��a�R��z ��qal�Hz|� �å{��ån�� ����s�w�w�w�� ��L��F�cVKN¼�I�[�½§Mb³¶Mbc�º �<�(\RK�%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼���¤ M¶c°cVK5F [�FHGѤ \RM¶cV\H[�» � � ¯H[�cVMbS�FPU���Y���GRU5O1eO�±1I�[�G�K5F [�FHG�LO42 ILM´« \RK5W�K5IZY �(n�����n��¥{��R�Ó��L��{'qa���Ëu_������� O

� ��#�E�eO42D³¶K5»d»ÂYR��O��H[�UV³¶S�©eY�\RK5¦R��c°\T �)�)�������('�� ����E�ªOR±1K5I�UV\H[�G§UV]'º�YR%PO���KZ«aS�c°cVM�YPeO � S�¼�¯RILM�Y ��O �[�¬�[�Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�����)R��('�� � E�eOP%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RY�\RK5¦R��c°\ �)����1�R������ �1�� %HO��1K¨«aS�cVc°M�YHQ�O �"MbI�[�I�GJKN³¶³¶SRY'��\�º�U5O Q KNcVc5O ��� � �?ÈL�5)1���$É���)� ��)�E�eOP%'»dMb³¶¼'[�Y ��[�GTOÞ�<M .�O � � ÈÊ�5)1���$ÉLYH�R�5#����R���� ���� %HOP%'K5cV\RM�YR�ªOP%'cVK5ILF,Y�\RK5¦R��c°\ �) ���#���('�� �R����HOR�eOR��MbFH[�\P[�F,Y_!ÍOH��K5»:KZUL« \H[�FHUV]'º�Y ��O �[�¬�[�YP�eO �<O§¤Ù[�ILF§KNIZY$\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1�����R�5�1� �

�DOR��¼�¯H« \RM�Y 29OP%_[�]�[�M�YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �������������#�Y'\§KN¦§��cV\T ����R���5�R�5�� ���� � O��µ[�FRS�IZY$\RK5¦R��cV\T �)���� ���)���Y'\§KN¦§��cV\T �)����1�R�5�1�� ����EQ�OR±([�¯§³bM¶K5¯,YR�eOHQTS'UVK5WPYR��OP��KN]$I�[�UVS�WPY�\RK5¦R��c°\ �) �� _�� (� ��(�E�eOR�o[�I�UV\H[�]�S�WHY��eOH��MbILS�FRS�WHY$\RK5¦R��cV\T �) _�����5#�� �

eO�±1I�[�G�K5F,Y��eO'��[�I�UV\H[�]�S�WPYZ�eOÁ��MbILS�F§S�WPY��eO��7S�ILS�.5S�WPYZ\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1�R�5��� Z��YZ\§KN¦§��cV\T �)�)���������# ��DOR��¼�¯H« \RM�Y�eO 2e[�FRFRSRY$\RK5¦R��c°\ �������#����1� �eOR±1I�[�G�K5F,YR�eOH��[�I�UV\H[�]�S�WPY�\RK5¦R��cV\T �������)������ �eOR±1I�[�G�K5F,YR�eO �"S�I�UV]'º�YR�eO � G�KZULUV]'M¶M�Y� =O ��¯R½RcLUVS�WHY$\RK5¦R��c°\T ��R�������5����� ���O ��UL[�]$M�Y��PO ��IL³¶M´« \,Y =O =O 2D\§S�.NK�YR��O �²S�¦R¦RM¶c .�Y �=Oú%$\H[�G�»dM�Y �=Oú%$\RMbIL»0[�F,Yå\RK5¦R��c°\T ��R���5�R���1� ��DOR�S�³¶³bS�©(S'S�GTY�\RK5¦R��cV\T ��������R�5��#

� ��#�E��O�¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�#R�5�R�5#��� ����E��O�¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �) ����R�5���� � %HO��1\RK5IL]'M|U5Y4�=OH��S'S�ILK�YR�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHY�M¶FæRILS�¼�ILKZULU� �1��E!=O ���O�!"M|[�«�S�F§K¨UL«a¯,YR� OR!"S�¯R¼�³|[�U5Y��PO �"S�»dM´U5Y$\RK5¦R��c°\ �) _�5�������� ��)�E�eORQ,[�©ILK5FH«aK�YR�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHY���O 1[�¬�[�YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1�������R�5#�)('��E�LO42 ³bK5½H[�F§S�WPY_�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHY�\§KN¦§��cV\T �)�)R���5��)�� �

�HOR�²S�³´« \RMbFPUV]'M�Y�\RK5¦R��c°\ ����R�����5)���)(H��E�eO���S�FRF§K¨U5YR� OR!"S�¯R¼�³|[�U5Y_�eO %_«L\�©[�I�.�Y �_"�1��� � � ÈÊ�5)�)1�$É�������)('��E�eOP%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RYR�O�¤ MbcVcVKNF�YH\§KN¦§��cV\T �)�)��1�R��('��Y ��"���� � �ÈL�5)�)�)$ɲ������)('��E�eO���S�FRF§K¨U5Y �L��S�FH«aS�»d»�¯§cÊ[�cVMbW�K"¼�K5S�»dK5c°ILº ��YR��«5[�G�K5»dM|«���ILKZULU"ÈÊ�5)�)�(�É�)(�(� � O��\H[�ILS�F�ºÁY(� O±1K5IL]�S'S�.�Y�eOD%$KNM¶½PKNIL¼RY&\RK5¦R��c°\T �) _�5�R����'Y1�"G�WHO"�(\RK5S�IZO(�o[�cV\,O��\�º_U5O �

ÈL�5)�)1�$ɵ���5)����5#���)('#� � O���\H[�ILS�F�º�YD�ªOD±1K5IL]�S'S�.�Y9%HO 2e[�«L\§IL¯,Y��eO9%'K5M¶½HK5IL¼RYD��O=%'M¶³bW�K5I�UVcVK5MbF,Y"\§KN¦§��cV\T �) �� �� �)�Y

�"G�WHOR�&\RK5S�IZOR�o[�cV\,OR��\_º�U5O � ÈL�5)�)1�$ɵ��( �����5# �)('��E�eOR��KN]$I�[�UVS�WPYH�eOP%HOP%_« \�©[�I�.ÁY$\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1���������1��Y4�1S�»d»ÂOÞ�o[�cV\,O'��\�º_U5O � ��ÈL�5)�)1�$É��1��)

���

Page 35: arXiv:hep-th/0302191 v2 24 Feb 2003 - IHESpreprints.ihes.fr › P03 › P03-09.pdf · m¶c°\o[ ¦§¦rils ¦rilm|[ c°k5³¶º c©m´uvcvkzg0½ps ¯rfhgr[ ilº0«as fhg m¶cvmbs

�)(� EeOR�"[�]�[Z®VM¶»Ø[�Y��LQTKZ«ac°¯§ILK¨U&S�FÂ�M¶³b½PK5ILcD%_« \RK5»dK¨U1S�¬��<S�M¶F�cÊU1S�F�%'¯RIV¬�[�«aKZU�� ��"�¥%0Î�FRMbW�K5I�UVM¶c�º0QTKZ«ac°¯§ILK=%'K5ILMbKZU5Y,�5)�)�)�YR�V%�±(�3��� ���R�������5)�#�����)�O

�)( �� �eOR!"M ®V]'¼�I�[�[�¬°Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�����)�������)(')�E�eORQTS'UVK5WHYP�eOH��K5]'I�[�UVS�WHY�M¶FæRILS�¼�ILKZULU� #�����HO��POR!"¯RM|UVc°K5IL»0[�[�c5Y4�=O �POR�K¨« ]'»0[�F,YR��F�W�K5F�cNOR��[�c°\�O � �ÈÊ�5)1���$É(��#�) �

�ªOR�&c°M¶º'[�\,Y �eOR±1S�cVcNYP�,S�¦PS�³¶S�¼�º � � ��So��ÈL�5)1��(�ɵ�� #R��E��O�¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)�����('�1���� #���E�ªO42 S�F�cÊUVK5W$M´« \,Y'\§KN¦§��cV\T �)�('��#�����#� #���E�eO���M¶W�K5F�cÊ[�³�YR[�³b¼���¼�K5S�»Ä �)����������R�� #�(�E�ªOR�&c°M¶º'[�\,Y =OH!µILMbF�¬�K5³|GTY���OP�MbcL«L\RM¶F,Y ��¯�OR�o[�FRM¶F,Y���\�º_U5ORQ K5c°c5O � � - ÈL�5) Z�$ɵ����#� #�#� =OR��S�W$Mb]�S�WHYP�ªOP%'\RM�¬�»0[�F,Y���O 1[�MbFHUV\�cVK5MbF,Y� =O �H[�]$\H[�ILS�WPYR��\�º�U5O Q KNcVc5O � � �?ÈL�5)1��)$ɵ�5���� #���E�eOP%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RYR��\�º�U5O Q KNcVc5O � ��� �?ÈL�5)1�1�$É �#� # E�eOR!"S�ILK5º�YH�DO��POR�S�³b³¶S�©(S$S_GTY =O ¾O42 \RS�.5K�YR�ªOP�<OR�o[�cVc°M|U5Y�\RK5¦R��c°\ ��������������� #1��E�eOR!"S�ILK5º�Y =O =O�2D\RS�.5K�YR�ªOÞ�<O��o[�cVc°M|U5YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �) �������� 'Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T �) ��1�������� #�)�E�eOR!"S�ILK5º�Y =O =O�2D\RS�.5K�YR�ªOÞ�<O��o[�cVc°M|U5YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �)���� ������� ���� �=OR��³¶³bM¶FR¼'UVIL¯HG Y�%HOÞ��O�%'cVILS�»d»:K�Y���F�W�K5F_c5O��o[�cV\,O � ÈL�5)1� �É���('������#�� �

Q�O�� �S�cVcÊ« \RK�YH�o[�cV\,OR�eO¶O � � � ÈÊ�5)�)��$ÉD�5)�������� � �R��E�ªOR�&c°M¶º'[�\,Y��=OP%'K5¼'[�³�YR��FRF�O�S�¬���[�c°\�O � ÈL�5)��1�$É�#��R�� ����E�eORQTS'UVK5WHY �¾OP�7S$S�ILKÁY§%HO %'\H[�cL[�UV\_W$Mb³¶M�Y�\RK5¦R��c°\ �) �� ���#�� �

�eOP%'K5Mb½PK5IL¼RY�\RK5¦R��c°\ �) ���#����R�� ����E�eO � ]�S�¯§FR]�S�WPY �eOP��[�FHG�\H[�ILM¶¦H[�FHG$K�Y�»0[�cV\,O � �� ������ �������Y$»0[�c°\�O � �� �������('����#� ��(�E�§S�I[�FÃK5¿_«aK5³¶³bK5F�cILK5W'M¶K5© UVKNK�Y§KÁO ¼ROP%HO42 \H[�I�«L\§KNWPY'\§KN¦§��cV\T �)1�R�5����)R�� ��#� 29ORÎK5FRSRY429OH�<[�]�[�UL[�]$M�YR�"G�WPOT%'cV¯HG�M¶KZU1MbF7��¯RILK��o[�cV\,O � ÈL�5)1��(�ɵ�� ����E�DOR��¼�¯H« \RM�Y 29ORS�ILM�Y���O �V%HO��"MbS�F§¼RY�\RK5¦R��c°\T �)�����#�����# �

�DOR��¼�¯H« \RM�Y§%HO ��[�F§¼RY�\RK5¦R��c°\T �)�('� _�5��(���DOR��¼�¯H« \RM�Y�eO 2e[�FRFRSRY$\RK5¦R��c°\ �)�('��('��#��

� � E�eOR��KN]$I�[�UVS�WPYH�eO � ]�S�¯RFR]�S�WHY$MbF7¦RILS�¼�ILKZULU� �1�� �eOR!"M ®V]'¼�I�[�[�¬°Y���O 1[�¬�[�YR\RK5¦R��cV\T �����������#�#�Y'\§KN¦§��cV\T ������ _�5����Y$\RK5¦R��c°\ ������1����( � ��eOR!"M ®V]'¼�I�[�[�¬°YP%HO��"¯R]�S�WHY =O 2e[�.Z[�]�S�WPY���O �[�¬�[�Y§\RK5¦R��c°\T ����R�5�����1� ��eOR!"M ®V]'¼�I�[�[�¬°YR�ªO��"ILM|UL[�IL¯,Y4�"ORQ,[�»7Y���O �[�¬�[�YR!=O �H[�FRS�F,Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T ����R���5�R����

�ªOR��¼'[�FH[�¼�M|«�YR�ªOR��[�ILMbFRSRY��eO 2 ³bK5»d»7Y4�"O �[�¬�[�YR\§KN¦§��cV\T ����R���5��)1� ��eOR!"M ®V]'¼�I�[�[�¬°YR�eOH��K5Mbc/.5]�K�Y ��O �[�¬�[�Y�\RK5¦R��cV\T ����R�����5)�(� ��)�E�(O��([�«L\H[�.5SRY��ªOR!"S�¯R¼�³|[�U5YR�eOT%'K5M¶½HK5IL¼RY��O§¤ M¶c°cVK5F,YR\§KN¦§��cV\T ����R������������� =OR±([�³´[�UV¯§½RI�[�»0[�FRM´[�F�Y'�<O42DI�[�¯PU5Y_�eOHQ�[Z©�ILK5FH«aKÁY$\RK5¦R��cV\T �)1����#R��_���_��E�ªOR��¼'[�FH[�¼�M|«�YR�ªOR��[�ILM��FRSRY ��O 1[�¬�[�YR\RK5¦R��cV\T ��������R�5��(

���