asher introduction to taj mahal

Upload: devyani-vj

Post on 07-Jul-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    1/19

    An Introduction to the Taj Mahal

    Catherine B. Asher 

    The Taj Mahal is without doubt India’s most famous monument (Fig. 1).

    Fig. 1. The Taj Mahal. Photo by Rachita Jain

     Annually, thousands of Indian and international tourists come to visit this white marble tomb

    placed in a spectacular garden complex. The Taj is attractive to tourists for various reasons: it is

    one of the greatest monuments in the world, one of its Seven Wonders, is associated with

    eternal love and is one of India’s greatest assets. Few, having experienced the tomb and its

    garden, leave unimpressed, for the dazzling white of the mausoleum’s marble whose color

    changes subtly as the earth turns, the absolute symmetry of the architectural design, as well as

    the sheer scale of the massive complex leave most in awe. On a more factual note, this

    impressive site was built by the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan (r. 1628 !58) after the death of his

    favorite wife, Mumtaz Mahal, in 1631. Most of the complex was built between 1632 and 1647/8.

     Although repairs, restorations and even changes, especially in the plantation of the garden,

    have transpired over the last 350 years, the overall complex remains consistent with Shah

    Jahan’s original vision.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    2/19

    The Mughals and Shah Jahan

    The first Mughal, Babur, traced his lineage from both the Mongol Genghis Khan (d. 1227) and

    the great Central Asian warlord, Timur (d. 1405), whose 15th-century successors produced art

    and architecture that became the gold standard of artistic creation in the Persian speaking

    world. Babur defeated the last independent Muslim ruler of north India in 1526. He only ruled for

    four years but introduced into the subcontinent, the Timurid tradition of ordered and regular

    gardens, in which the land was divided by water channels and pools. While such gardens,

    known as charbagh or four part gardens, are usually considered paradises on earth, for Babur 

    and his successors, these gardens had a political meaning, that is, they were considered as

    visual metaphors for the Mughals’ ability to order and rule a land and people that Babur

    considered to be chaotic and unruly.

    Babur’s son and successor, Humayun, did little to enhance Mughal authority, and for a 15-year

    period was forced to flee India, being able to return in 1555 and reclaim the Mughal throne.

    Humayun died a year later and was succeeded by his son, Akbar, who ruled for nearly 50 years

    (1556 !1605). Under Akbar’s long reign, the empire was enlarged and consolidated to cover 

    most of the northern subcontinent reaching to the Deccan. Rather than punish Rajput princes

    and others whose territory Akbar enfolded into the Mughal empire, Akbar included these

    defeated elite into his own administrative and military system. He ensured loyalty from these

    newcomers by often marrying their daughters. Further stabilizing the new empire, currency and

    modes of taxation were standardized. Policies promoting tolerance among India’s various

    religious communities were adopted. As Akbar’s empire grew, he added forts and palaces

    across the land as a visual reminder of his ever increasing authority and power. Among his first

    architectural projects was the tomb he provided for his father, Humayun, which served as an

    important model for the future Taj Mahal (Fig. 2).

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    3/19

    Fig. 2. Humayun's Tomb, West Facade, Delhi. Photo by Mehreen Chida-Razvi

    Upon Akbar’s death in 1605, his son Jahangir ascended the throne, ruling until his death in

    1627. The empire he inherited was strong, stable and wealthy, and Jahangir made few

    significant changes to policies and practices established by Akbar. Jahangir continued to build,

    although he is better known for his passion for painted albums and manuscripts as well as for

    his careful observations of nature. Military campaigns were not undertaken by the emperor but

    rather by his highly competent son, Khurram, the future Shah Jahan. Prince Khurram was the

    favored heir, until the early 1620s when Jahangir’s powerful wife, Nur Jahan, began to promote

    another of Jahangir’s sons to be next in line for the throne. Khurram rebelled and established a

    counter-court; but within a year after Jahangir’s death, this prince proclaimed himself emperor,

    assuming a title that his father had given him after a successful military campaign, Shah Jahan,

    ‘King of the World’.

    Shah Jahan ruled for 30 years, continuously promoting himself as a semi-divine ruler who was

    fully cognizant of the value of the visual to achieve these ends (Fig. 3).

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    4/19

    Fig. 3. Shah Jahan on a Globe

    Both his portraiture, which often depicted him literally as King of the World as he stands on a

    globe, and his highly symbolic architecture were intended to showcase him as belonging to a

    lineage of great rulers.1 Shah Jahan likened himself to the just king Solomon, something his

    Ottoman predecessor had done some 100 years earlier. The impression is of an aloof, perhaps

    even arrogant ruler, but historical sources indicate a more human side of this Mughal emperor.

    Prince Khurram married Arjumand Banu Begum, later to bear the title of Mumtaz Mahal, in 1612

    after a five-year engagement, and she became his constant companion, even accompanying

    him on all his military campaigns until her death in 1631. Women had long had a major role in

    1Ebba Koch, Mughal Art and Imperial Ideology: Collected Essays (New Delhi: Oxford University Press,

    2001).

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    5/19

    the outcome of Mughal politics. For example, Akbar often sought the council of his mother, but

    as we have in this case of Akbar’s mother, it was more often the council of senior female elites

    that could make or break relationships.2  Jahangir’s powerful wife, Nur Jahan, was a notable

    exception, for she was in many ways the de facto ruler, not a behind-the-scene Queen Mother,

    as her aging husband’s health deteriorated. Similarly, Mumtaz Mahal, a niece of Nur Jahan, had

    great influence over her husband, although we do not know specific examples. Chronicles

    reveal that although Shah Jahan had two other wives, Mumtaz Mahal remained his soulmate

    throughout their 19 year marriage.3 During this time Mumtaz Mahal gave birth to 14 children,

    half of whom survived. But shortly after delivering her last child, she became extremely weak,

    called for her husband and died. The devastated emperor went into mourning, not interacting

    with his court for a good week and then, for the next two years, continuously grieved.4 In the

    meantime the queen was buried temporarily in a garden in Burhanpur, the city in the Deccan

    where she had died; six months later her body was interred and moved to Agra at a site chosen

    for her mausoleum, the Taj Mahal, which was the result of an exchange of land from a high-

    ranking noble.5 Shah Jahan long outlived his wife, dying in 1666. The last eight years of his life,

    however, were not spent as an active emperor, but rather by 1658 he had been deposed by one

    of his sons, Aurangzeb. He was imprisoned in his Agra fort, overlooking the Taj Mahal, until his

    death, whereupon he was interred next to Mumtaz Mahal.

    The Tradition of Mughal Funereal Architecture

    Following the Timurid tradition, the Mughals were great patrons of the arts including painting,

    architecture and luxury arts such as jade carving, textile production, jewelry, metal objects,

    military paraphernalia and more. The other contemporary Muslim dynasties of this time, the

    Ottomans of Turkey and the Safavids of Iran also engaged in similar production and

    consumption to prove their elite status. But the Mughals, more than any other Islamic house,

    engaged in the construction of tombs, particularly during the late 16th, through 17th centuries, a

    2

    Ruby Lal, Domesticity and Power in the Early Mughal World  (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2005), 121-36, 205 !07.3

    Ebba Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal and the Riverfront Gardens of Agra (London: Thames andHudson, 2006), 18. This is the most up-to-date scholarly study of the Taj Mahal and should be consultedto enrich and enhance this brief introductory essay.4

    Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal , 20, W.E. Begley and Z.A. Desai, Taj Mahal: The Illumined Tomb, an Anthology of Seventeenth-century Mughal and European Documentary Sources (Cambridge, MA. and

    Seattle: Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture and University of Washington Press, 1989), 29 !39.5

    Begley and Desai, Taj Mahal , 169 !71.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    6/19

    timeframe that is roughly concurrent with the construction of the Taj Mahal. Tomb construction

    had been practiced in the subcontinent at least as early as the 10th century in what is today

    Pakistan, where Muslims had assumed political authority in the eighth century. Once Muslim

    rulers established themselves in central north India by the beginning of the 13th century,

    mausolea were built for rulers and their elite. Since the Mughals controlled a vast amount of

    territory, increasing numbers of elite were required for the military and administration, but all the

    same why are there so many extant Mughal tombs? Ebba Koch has suggested that tomb

    construction may essentially be a form of estate planning.6 That is, tombs in Mughal India,

    always set in gardens, were exempt from the customary requirement that land must revert to the

    state upon the landholder’s death. While many tombs intended for the elite survive, it is the

    imperial Mughal mausolea that attract the most attention.

    The first major Mughal imperial tomb complex was the one provided by Akbar for his father,

    Humayun, in Delhi close to the shrine of an important Muslim saint, Nizamuddin Auliya, and the

    then Mughal fort today known as the Purana Qila (Fig. 2). Humayun’s tomb was completed in

    1571 and designed by a father-son team from Bukhara trained in both structural and landscape

    architecture. This large domed structure is a Baghdadi octagon, that is, an octagon with four

    alternating long and short sides. It sits on a high plinth in the middle of a charbagh garden. In

    overall scale, design and garden plan, the structure belongs to the Timurid tradition. The interior

    too, consisting of a central chamber surrounded by eight smaller rooms in a plan known as

    hasht bihisht or eight paradise is also Timurid in inspiration. The use of red sandstone as the

    structure’s veneer, detailed with white marble trim is part of a longstanding tradition in north

    Indian architecture, particularly in buildings associated with Muslim patrons. Placing the tomb in

    a garden setting is probably a Mughal innovation. The garden can be read on two levels, one as

    an earthly paradise and the other as a symbol of political control as introduced by Babur.

    Following Timurid tradition, Humayun’s tomb was probably designed as a Mughal dynastic

    tomb; although no other emperor was buried there, a number of royal elite later were interred in

    Humayun’s tomb.

    When Akbar died in 1605, Jahangir commenced his tomb complex on the outskirts of Agra,

    today known as Sikandra, but then called Bihishtabad, meaning the ‘Abode of Paradise’ (Fig. 4).

     

    6Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal , 28.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    7/19

    Fig. 4. Akbar's tomb at Sikandra. Photo by Rachita Jain

    Like Humayun’s tomb and later the Taj Mahal, Akbar’s tomb is also set in a walled garden

    complex with waterways that divide the complex into four main units. The tomb, though, as well

    as the tomb later built for Jahangir in Lahore, has no dome, but its upper terrace is left open, to

    conform to a passage in the tomb’s inscription: ‘May [Akbar’s] soul shine like the rays of the sun

    and the moon in the light of God’.7 An element in common with the Taj Mahal is the accessible

    underground crypt where the royal deceased are interred, for in the Muslim tradition the dead

    are to be buried six feet beneath the ground. The cenotaphs marking other floors would mirror

    the actual ones below ground. All imperial Mughal tombs have elaborate entrance gates, and

     Akbar’s tomb is no exception. Two features of its gate reappear at the Taj Mahal. One feature is

    the four white marble minarets that mark the corners of the entrance; at both Jahangir’s tomb

    and the Taj Mahal, similar minarets will be placed not on the entrance, but at each corner of the

    plinth. A second feature is the long inscription which embellishes both sides of the gate. This is

    a Persian poem especially written for this monument and designed by the calligrapher ‘Abd al-

    Haqq Shirizi, who was honored with the title Amanat Khan. The poem praises the deceased

    emperor, Akbar, and the patron, Jahangir, but ends with verses inviting the visitor to enter the

    gardens of paradise.8  While imperial Mughal gardens, especially those associated with tombs,

    7Edmund W. Smith, Akbar’s Tomb, Sikandarah, near Agra, Archaeological Survey of India, New Imperial

    Series, 35 (Allahabad: F. Luker, Superintendent Government Press, 1909), 35.8

    Smith, Akbar’s Tomb, 30 !35.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    8/19

    are generally associated with visions of paradise, this poem on the complex’s entrance gate

    makes this reference clear.

    Paradise, in Islam, is the reward for the true believer on the Day of Judgment. Sufis, mystically

    inclined holy men, were believed to be among those to surely find a place in paradise. The

    tombs of important Sufi saints, most notably the tombs of the Chishti saints, Moinuddin in Ajmer 

    and Nizamuddin Auliya in Delhi, were made of white marble and had associations with sanctity

    and purity. Over time, structures made predominately of white marble were made for the use of

    the emperor and his immediate family, but not for others. Jahangir’s queen Nur Jahan

    constructed a white marble tomb that was richly inlaid with multi-colored stones for her mother

    who died in 1621 and her father who died shortly afterward. Nur Jahan’s father was Shah

    Jahan’s finance minister and very close to Jahangir, but not of royal blood. Thus the tomb’s

    appearance as pure white marble from a distance that changes to one of multiple colors as one

    comes nearer is probably a reflection of the mother’s and father’s elite but not royal status.

     Although the tomb was built for husband and wife, it is known as the tomb of Itimad-ud-Daula,

    after the father’s official title. The tomb, completed in 1626-8, like other imperial Mughal

    mausolea, sits in the center of a walled charbagh and its ground floor adheres to the hasht

    bihisht plan. The second story, consisting of a central chamber enclosed with exquisitely carved

    screens, is capped by a truncated pyramidal vault. Each corner of the plinth is marked by a

    short minaret. While the complex is smaller than any tomb intended for an emperor, its inlaid

    décor gives the structure an unprecedented elegance. Not surprisingly, floral and geometric

    designs are found, but more innovative are the images of cypress trees, fruit and slender-

    necked vessels for nectar inlaid into the white marble surface. This imagery, drawn from

    classical Persian poetry and the Quran, is intended to place the complex in a paradisiacal

    setting.

    The Taj Mahal

    The white marble domed structure that best represents the Mughal fascination with the imagery

    of paradise in a funereal setting is the Taj Mahal. While today the Taj Mahal and its garden

    complex appear to sit alone along Agra’s Yamuna riverfront, in fact it was one of many—

    admittedly the largest—of garden complexes built by Mughal elite that lined the river’s banks. 9

     

    9Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal , 24 !31.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    9/19

    The Taj complex though was the only one that spanned both sides of the river. On the south

    side was the mausoleum and its garden, while across from it was the Mahtab/Mehtab Bagh,

    Moonlight Garden, with its reflecting pool.

    Most visitors to the Taj Mahal think of the marble tomb and its garden as the complex, but there

    is much more, for this massive complex was almost a city within the city of Agra, then the

    Mughal capital and known officially as Akbarabad (Figs. 5, 6 and 7 from Ebba Koch).

    Fig. 5. Site Plan of the Taj Complex by Ebba Koch

     

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    10/19

    Fig. 6. The first plan of the Taj Complex, by Thomas & William Daniel. Courtesy Ebba Koch

    Fig.7. Satellite Image of Taj Complex. Courtesy Ebba Koch

    We can roughly divide the complex into four areas: an area for four main markets known today

    as Taj Ganj, the forecourt into the tomb’s main garden; the tomb and other buildings in the main

    garden, and the Mahtab Bagh across the river. Taj Ganj held at each of its four corners, large

    enclosed markets with multiple shops whose goods were praised by Persian panegyrists and

    near contemporary European travelers. While the gates of Taj Ganj still survive, much of the

    original construction has been replaced or remodeled to serve the needs of backpackers and

    locals. The forecourt is a spacious area before the entrance into the tomb‘s garden with a

    double row of shops radiating from the east and west entrances, the income of which helped

    maintain the complex. Two corners of the forecourt hold small uninscribed tombs, while the

    other two corners served as residential quarters for the complex’s attendants.

     

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    11/19

    The dominant feature of the forecourt is the stunning entrance gate located in the center of the

    north wall that leads to the main garden complex (Figs. 8a and 8b).

    Fig. 8a & 8b. The Great Gate, Darwaza-i-Rauza. Photo by Rachita Jain

    This large arched gate, faced with red sandstone, recalls the entrance to Akbar’s tomb (Fig. 9),

    but chattri s (small domed kiosks) mark each corner not the minarets found on Akbar’s tomb.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    12/19

    The entrance gates to both Akbar’s tomb and the Taj Mahal bear inscriptions designed by the

    same calligrapher, Amanat Khan. While those on Akbar’s tomb were in Persian, the inscriptions

    on the Taj Mahal’s entrance gate are drawn from the Quran and are thus in Arabic. The theme

    of each is similar, for they invite the believer to enter paradise.10 

    Fig. 9.The Entrance Gate to Akbar's Tomb at Sikandra. Photo by Rachita Jain

    Passing through the entrance gate the white marble mausoleum set at the end of this first

    garden dominates the skyline. Between the entrance and the tomb is the long rectangulargarden divided into four quadrants by wide waterways that meet at a central pool that

    contemporary texts equate with al-Kausar,11 a Quranic chapter which likens God’s generosity to

    a pool of abundance. Known in contemporary texts as the ‘paradise-like garden’,12 its name

    matches the invitation inscribed on the entrance gate. Although we do not know exactly how this

    garden was planted, it is likely that flowers such as marigolds, roses and poppies, fruit and

    shade trees including cypress, associated with the beloved in Persian poetry, graced this one.

    The tomb is placed centrally on a high plinth at the garden’s end overlooking the river. To keep

    the plinth and its components from sliding into the river, wells were sunk into the ground andthen filled with stone and iron.13  At the plinth’s west end is a large mosque faced with red

    10Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal , 128. For all the Quranic inscriptions, see Begley and Desai, Taj Mahal ,

    195 !231.11

    Begley and Desai, Taj Mahal , 80.12

    Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal, 137.13

    Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal, 96.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    13/19

    sandstone and white marble trim surmounted by three marble faced domes. It is still used by

     Agra’s Muslim community today for Friday congregational prayer. On the east is a building

    identical in appearance, providing symmetry and balance. At each corner of the plinth,

    connected to the mosque and its counterpart, are red sandstone towers. Although not

    accessible to the public today, the north towers would have provided good river views, while

    others contained a well, latrines and other rooms.

    The centrally placed tomb sits on a marble platform atop the riverfront plinth. Each of the

    corners is marked by a tall slender minaret. The tomb, like Humayun’s tomb, is a Baghdadi

    octagon, and its interior is a more sophisticated version of the hasht bihisht  plan used at

    Humayun’s tomb.

    Four types of decoration dominate the mausoleum: the white marble facing procured from the

    quarries at Makrana about 365 kilometers away; the bands of inscriptions embellishing the

    exterior and interior; the carved floral motifs on both the tomb’s interior and exterior dado; and

    the pietra dura inlay on the imperial cenotaphs and their surrounding screen. Marble as the

    main facing material, not just for decorative motifs, as noted earlier, was associated with the

    tombs of saints and over time with royalty; moreover, marble absorbs light and changes color

    with each change of the day, and since, in the Muslim tradition, God’s presence is often

    associated with light, the tomb takes on spiritual overtones (Fig. 10).

    Fig. 10. The Taj Mahal from the South. Photo by Rachita Jain

     

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    14/19

    Underscoring the spiritual are the 25 Quranic inscriptions that appear on the complex. These

    further develop the theme of paradise as promised for the faithful on the Day of Judgment

    expressed on the great entrance. Amanat Khan had crafted the text so that all the letters look to

    the viewer as if they are the same size but, in fact, he has rendered those portions distant from

    the ground in a larger format. Not only would the inscriptions be seen, but also, in the 17th

    century, the melodic chanting of the tomb’s Quranic readers would reverberate throughout the

    tomb as they prayed for the deceased queen’s soul.

    In addition to inscriptions addressing paradise, are floral motifs rendered in marble along the

    interior and exterior lower wall. These flowers had a political meaning as well, for Mughal

    chroniclers and poets used floral imagery and metaphors to refer to members of the royal

    family, calling Shah Jahan himself, ‘the spring of the flower garden of justice and generosity’.14

    These floral patterns are carved in highly naturalistic way, only upon careful reflection is it

    apparent that the leaves and flowers do not belong to any living plant. Rather these are flora

    that could only exist in God’s realm, that is, paradise. Similar floral motifs are found on the two

    imperial cenotaphs placed centrally on the main interior chamber. These are not carved in high

    relief, but are made of semi-precious stones, predominately red in color, inlaid into the marble.

    The cenotaphs are surrounded by an octagonal marble screen also inlaid with similar colored

    stones, replacing the original enameled gold one, as during his lifetime Shah Jahan was worried

    the gold would attract looters (Fig. 11).

     

    14Koch, The Complete Taj Mahal, 223 !24.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    15/19

    Fig. 11. Tomb Chamber and Inlaid Marble Screen surrounding the Cenotaphs. Copyright ASI

    The Mahtab Bagh is placed directly opposite the Taj Mahal on the river’s north bank (Figs. 12a

    and 12b).

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    16/19

    Fig. 12a. The Mahtab Bagh as viewed from the Taj Mahal. Photo by Rachita Jain

    Fig. 12b. The view of the Taj Mahal, Mihman Khana and the mosque from the Mahtab Bagh. Photo by

    Rachita Jain

    The garden with its large reflecting pool was known from Mughal times, but silting caused by

    continuous flooding covered the pool and it was essentially forgotten. Instead a fictitious

    account of a second Taj Mahal, this one to have been built in black stone, that was first

    mentioned by a late 17th-century European merchant, spread like wildfire and was perpetuated

    over time. Excavations by the Archaeological Survey of India in the 1990s unearthed the original

    Mughal garden squashing the myth of the black Taj.

    The tomb complex was commenced six months after the queen’s death and by June 1632, the

    first anniversary of her death, known as ‘urs, that is, the marriage of her soul with God, was

    commemorated in solemn ceremonies involving prayer and the distribution of largess to the

    needy. Court historians used the occasion of the annual ‘urs to indicate progress towards the

    complex’s completion. Europeans too wrote about the stages of construction, although it

    appears their observations were made from a distance, not the result of having examined the

    site first-hand.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    17/19

    Today the Taj Mahal complex is a world heritage tourist site. Anyone who can afford the

    entrance fee can visit the site. However this was not the case during Mughal times. Only those

    close to the royal family had access to the tomb garden. While many may have arrived on

    roads, Shah Jahan preferred to visit the tomb on a boat and would enter the complex via water

    gates, now closed, on the great plinth. Few Europeans prior to the 18th century set foot in the

    complex. An exception was Francois Bernier, a French physician who had access to the royal

    family later in the 17th century, who was allowed to enter the Taj’s grounds, although he was

    denied access to the tomb itself on the grounds that he was not a Muslim.15

    When Shah Jahan died in 1666 after being imprisoned by his son and successor, Aurangzeb,

    for eight years, he was buried in the Taj Mahal next to his wife. The question is: was this always

    his intention? Texts are silent on this issue, but one of the Taj Mahal’s official names, Rauza-i-

    Munavvara, ‘the Illumined Tomb’, an epithet shared with the Prophet Muhammad's tomb in

    Medina, suggests that Shah Jahan always intended the Taj Mahal to be his tomb as well. He

    wished history to remember him, like the Prophet Muhammad, to conform to the Islamic

    theological concept of a Perfect Man. It would seem unlikely that the queen’s tomb would have

    been given the same name as the Prophet’s tomb, since he was a man, unless Shah Jahan

    saw it as his final resting place as well.

    No aspect of this complex was left to chance. Every measurement was carefully recorded in

    historical chronicles, and clearly the tomb and garden complex were designed by someone with

    an extraordinary vision. We know from contemporary texts the names of a number of architects

    who were engaged in the construction of Shah Jahan’s numerous building projects, many of

    them built concurrently with the Taj Mahal, but these same chronicles are silent on the architect

    of the Taj Mahal. Only the calligrapher, Amanat Khan, is named. Clearly architects and

    engineers worked on the massive complex, but by leaving these players anonymous, it is the

    patron, Shah Jahan, whose role is highlighted.

    15Francois Bernier, Travels in the Mogul Empire, A.D. 1656-1668 , trans. & annotated Archibald

    Constable, 2nd

    ed., Rev. Vincent A. Smith (London: Humphrey Milford and Oxford University Press, 1916),298.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    18/19

     

    Selected Bibliography

     Asher, Catherine B. The Architecture of Mughal India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,

    1992.

    ———. ‘Multiple Memories: Lives of the Taj Mahal’. Crossing Cultures: Conflict/Migration/

    Convergence. Ed. Jaynie Anderson. Melbourne: University of Melbourne Press, 2008. 614 !20.

    ———. India before Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.

    Begley, Wayne E. ‘Amanat Khan and the Calligraphy on the Taj Mahal’. Kunst des Orients 12

    (1978-79): 5 !39.

    Begley, Wayne E. and Z.A. Desai. Taj Mahal: the Illumined Tomb: An Anthology of

    Seventeenth-Century Mughal and European Documentary Sources. Cambridge, MA. and

    Seattle: Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture and University of Washington Press, 1989.

    Bernier, Francois. Travels in the Mogul Empire, A.D. 1656-1668 . Trans. & annotated Archibald

    Constable. 2nd ed. Rev. Vincent A. Smith. London: Humphrey Milford and Oxford University

    Press, 1916.

    Koch, Ebba. Mughal Architecture: An Outline of Its History and Development, 1526 ! 1858 .

    Munich: Prestel, 1991.

    ———. Mughal Art and Imperial Ideology: Collected Essays. Delhi: Oxford University

    Press, 2001.

    ———. The Complete Taj Mahal and the Riverfront Gardens of Agra. London: Thames and

    Hudson, 2006.

    ———. ‘The Taj Mahal: Architecture, Symbolism and Urban Significance’. Muqarnas 22 (2005):

    138-49.

  • 8/18/2019 Asher Introduction to Taj Mahal

    19/19

    Lal, Ruby. Domesticity and Power in the Early Mughal World . Cambridge: Cambridge University

    Press, 2005.

    Lowry, Glenn D. ‘Humayun’s Tomb: Form, Function and Meaning in Early Mughal Architecture’.

    Muqarnas 4 (1987): 133-48.

    Pal, Pratapaditya, Janice Leoshko, Joseph M. Dye III, Stephen Markel. The Romance of the Taj

    Mahal . Los Angeles and London: Los Angeles County Museum of Art and Thames and Hudson,

    1989.

    Richards, John F. The Mughal Empire. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993.

    Ruggles, D. Fairchild. ‘Humayun’s Tomb and Garden: Typologies and Visual Order’. Gardens in

    the Time of the Great Mughal Empires: Theory and Vision. Ed. Attilio Petruccioli. Leiden: Brill,

    1997. 173 !86.

    Smith, Edmund W. Akbar’s Tomb, Sikandarah, near Agra. Archaeological Survey of India, New

    Imperial Series, 35. Allahabad: F. Luker, Superintendent Government Press, 1909.

    Tillotson, Giles. Taj Mahal . New Delhi: Penguin Books, 2008.