ashraestandard18911hour4slidesperpage

8/4/2019 ASHRAEStandard18911hour4slidesperpage

1/17

The (Proposed) ASHRAEThe (Proposed) ASHRAE

Standard 189.1Standard 189.1

HighHigh--Performance,Performance,Green BuildingsGreen Buildings

Tom Lawrence, Ph.D. P.E., LEEDTom Lawrence, Ph.D. P.E., LEED--APAP

[email protected]@engr.uga.edu

44

ASHRAE Standard 189.1ASHRAE Standard 189.1

Overview of proposed ASHRAE StandardOverview of proposed ASHRAE Standard

189.1 for189.1 forHighHigh--Performance, GreenPerformance, Green

BuildingsBuildings

-- What is it?What is it?

-- Why have it?Why have it?

-- StatusStatus

-- HighlightsHighlights

55

ASHRAEASHRAEs More Active Role ins More Active Role in

Sustainable DesignSustainable Design

Sustainability PolicySustainability Policy What Standard 189.1 is:What Standard 189.1 is:

-- a standarda standard

-- applies to all buildings except lowapplies to all buildings except low--rise residentialrise residentialbuildings (same as ASHRAE Std 90.1)buildings (same as ASHRAE Std 90.1)

-- intended for adoption into model building codesintended for adoption into model building codes

What Standard 189.1 is not:What Standard 189.1 is not:

-- notnot a design guidea design guide

-- notnot a rating systema rating systemEven if not adopted by local authorities,this Standard is an indication of future trends

Standard 189.1: IntentStandard 189.1: Intent


2/17

Standard 189.1: Relation to OtherStandard 189.1: Relation to Other

ASHRAE StandardsASHRAE Standards

Adapt, withmodifications

Adapt,with minor

modifications

Adapt

62.1 (current version)90.1 (current version)

90.1 (current version)

55 (current version)

88

Why is this Needed?Why is this Needed?

Localities are beginning to adoptLocalities are beginning to adoptgreengreen

buildingbuildingas a requirementas a requirement

-- LEED certification (to some level)LEED certification (to some level)

-- Others are more vagueOthers are more vague

Intended to fill a gap in evolving buildingIntended to fill a gap in evolving building

codescodes

ASHRAE partnership with USGBC, IESNA,ASHRAE partnership with USGBC, IESNA,

and will be submitted for ANSI approvaland will be submitted for ANSI approval

99

Organization and What it CoversOrganization and What it Covers

Similar to other ASHRAE standards and LEEDSimilar to other ASHRAE standards and LEED

and Plans for Operation

MandatoryMandatory

PrescriptivePrescriptive

PerformancePerformance

1010

The purpose of this standard is to provideThe purpose of this standard is to provide

minimum requirements for theminimum requirements for the siting, design,siting, design,

construction, and plans for operationconstruction, and plans for operationof highof high

performance, green buildings to:performance, green buildings to:(a)(a) balancebalanceenvironmental responsibility,environmental responsibility,

resource efficiency, occupant comfort and wellresource efficiency, occupant comfort and well

being, and community sensitivity, andbeing, and community sensitivity, and

(b)(b) support the goal of development thatsupport the goal of development that

meets the needs of the present w ithoutmeets the needs of the present w ithout

compromisingcompromisingthe ability of future generationsthe ability of future generationsto meet their own needs.to meet their own needs.

Section 2Section 2 -- PurposePurpose


3/17


4/17

1515

ChallengesChallenges

Using normative (code) languageUsing normative (code) language

Determining the stringency for aDetermining the stringency for a

minimumminimumstandardstandard

Identifying standards or regulations to citeIdentifying standards or regulations to cite(could not reference guidelines)(could not reference guidelines)

Prescribing universal strategiesPrescribing universal strategies(requirements for all, not a menu)(requirements for all, not a menu)

Coordination with other initiativesCoordination with other initiatives Creating something that is enforceableCreating something that is enforceable

1616

Ind irect Benefits of Establishing BaselineIndirect Benefits of Establishing Baseline

More certainty for manufacturersMore certainty for manufacturers

-- Will develop and provide next generationWill develop and provide next generation

products if a market is known to existproducts if a market is known to exist

Benefits to existing buildingsBenefits to existing buildings

-- Suppliers will stock better performingSuppliers will stock better performing

products as they become availableproducts as they become available

1717

Potential Users of Std. 189.1Potent ial Users of Std. 189.1

Organizations with green building ratingOrganizations with green building rating

systems (LEED, Green Building Initiative)systems (LEED, Green Building Initiative)

Developers:Developers:

individual projectsindividual projects

Corporations:Corporations: corporate ownedcorporate owned

Universities:Universities: campus buildingscampus buildings

States/provinces/municipalities:States/provinces/municipalities:

-- their own buildingstheir own buildings

-- basis for incentivesbasis for incentives

-- private construction, through reference inprivate construction, through reference in

local codeslocal codes

1818

x.1:x.1: ScopeScope

x.2:x.2: ComplianceCompliance

x.3:x.3: MandatoryMandatory(required for all projects)(required for all projects)

x.4:x.4: PrescriptivePrescriptive optionoption

(simple option, minimal choices,(simple option, minimal choices,

very few calculations)very few calculations)

x.5:x.5: PerformancePerformance optionoption

(more sophisticated, flexibility, but(more sophisticated, flexibility, butmore effort)more effort)

Standard 189.1 Basic StructureStandard 189 .1 Basic Structure

For Each Section


5/17

1919

Highlights of Standard 189.1Highlights of Standard 189.1

Chapter 5Chapter 5 -- Sites:Sites:

Discourages unmitigated spraw lDiscourages unmitigated spraw l Prohibited development activityProhibited development activity

-- Flood plains, wetlands, fish and wildlifeFlood plains, wetlands, fish and wildlifehabitathabitat

Other areas that are addressed:Other areas that are addressed:-- Amount of impervious surface areaAmount of impervious surface area [max of[max of

60% of total site to be impervious]60% of total site to be impervious]-- Urban heat islandUrban heat island [shaded or higher solar[shaded or higher solarreflective index materials]reflective index materials]

-- LightLightpollutionpollutionlimitationslimitations2020

Mandatory P rovisionsMandatory P rovisions

Heat island effectHeat island effect-- Site hardscape:Site hardscape:

to be shaded, be SRIto be shaded, be SRI29, or porous pavers29, or porous pavers

-- Wall:Wall:to be shaded up toto be shaded up to20 feet above grade20 feet above grade

-- Roofs:Roofs:to be SRI 78 (lowto be SRI 78 (low--slope)/29 (steepslope)/29 (steep--slope) or cool roofslope) or cool roof

Sustainable SitesSustainable Sites

Definition: SRI

Standard black = 0; standard white = 1

2222

Confusion of Heat Island w ithConfusion of Heat Island w ith

Building Heat GainsBuilding Heat Gains

Two separate issues!Two separate issues!

-- Heat IslandHeat Island

-- Building heat gainBuilding heat gain

AAcool roofcool roofis just one of the potential strategiesis just one of the potential strategies

for reducing heat gain to a building structurefor reducing heat gain to a building structure

The Heat Island effect is a Siteissue (Section 5); heat gainto a building (and how fast it enters the buildin g) isprimarily an Energyissue (Section 7)


6/17

2323

Mandatory P rovisionsMandatory P rovisions

Reduction ofReduction ofl ight pollutionlight pollution

-- Outdoor lightingOutdoor lighting

trespass:trespass:

limits onlimits on

horizontal andhorizontal and

vertical luxvertical lux


2424

Prescriptive Path forPrescriptive Path for

ComplianceCompliance Site DevelopmentSite Development

-- All sites:All sites:Min. 40% of area to beMin. 40% of area to beeffective pervious surface (vegetation, greeneffective pervious surface (vegetation, greenroof, porous pavers)roof, porous pavers)

-- Greenfield sites:Greenfield sites:Min. 20% of area native or adapted plantsMin. 20% of area native or adapted plants


2525

Mandatory ProvisionsMandatory Provisions

Site water useSite water use: bio: bio--diverse plantings,diverse plantings,

hydrozoning, & smart irrigation controllershydrozoning, & smart irrigation controllers

Chapter 6Chapter 6 Water Use EfficiencyWater Use Efficiency

2626

Mandatory ProvisionsMandatory Provisions

Building water useBuilding water use::

((6.3.2.1)6.3.2.1) plumbing fixtures & fittings perplumbing fixtures & fittings per

U.S. EPA WaterSense or ASME StandardsU.S. EPA WaterSense or ASME Standards

((6.3.2.2)6.3.2.2) appliances per U.S. EPAappliances per U.S. EPA

EnergyStar, with water use factor for publicEnergyStar, with water use factor for public

access appliancesaccess appliances



7/17

2727

Mandatory P rovisions (ContMandatory P rovisions (Cont d)d)

HVAC Systems (HVAC Systems (6.3.2.3)6.3.2.3) ::

-- Once through cooling prohibitedOnce through cooling prohibited

-- Cooling tower makeup and blowdownCooling tower makeup and blowdown

meters, efficient drift eliminatorsmeters, efficient drift eliminators

-- Condensate collection from units > 19 kWCondensate collection from units > 19 kW

(65,000 Btu/hr)(65,000 Btu/hr)


2828

Performance OptionPerformance Option

Site water use reductionSite water use reduction ::

proposed potable water for irrigationproposed potable water for irrigation< 35% of baseline evapotranspiration< 35% of baseline evapotranspiration

Building useBuilding use::

Proposed use < [mandatory+ prescriptive]Proposed use < [mandatory+ prescriptive]


2929

Highlights for Energy (Chapter 7)Highlights for Energy (Chapter 7)

EnergyEnergy -- General:General:

Goal is 30% less than Standard 90.1Goal is 30% less than Standard 90.1--20072007

INCLUDING PROCESS LOADSINCLUDING PROCESS LOADS

Appendix G from Standard 90.1 isAppendix G from Standard 90.1 is

incorporated as aincorporated as a Normative AppendixNormative Appendix

Metering for verificationMetering for verification

Peak load reductionPeak load reduction

Other areas increase stringency beyondOther areas increase stringency beyondStandard 90.1Standard 90.1

Green Buildings Overview,Green Buildings Overview,

Standard 189Standard 189 -- 3030

ASHRAE Energy GoalsASHRAE Energy Goals

2010 2015 2020 2025 2030

36000

Year

Energy(kBtu/yr)

ASHRAE BOD Goal


Standard 189Standard 189

AEDGAEDG

Energy Reduction Proposal409,000 kJ/m-yr

Btu/ft-yr


8/17

3131


Mandatory Requirements:Mandatory Requirements:

-- OnOn--site renewable power (site renewable power (7.3.2)7.3.2)1% of service overcurrent rating1% of service overcurrent rating

-- ExceptionsExceptions

-- solar hot water heating with 100%solar hot water heating with 100%

total usetotal use oror peak capacity = 2.5%peak capacity = 2.5%

of service overcurrent ratingof service overcurrent rating

-- By 10% improvement in energyBy 10% improvement in energyefficiency plus COefficiency plus CO2e2e reductionreduction

80%80%

2.0%2.0%

RevisedRevised

in ISCin ISC

3232


EnergyEnergy Mandatory continued:Mandatory continued:

Remote or automatic reading metersRemote or automatic reading meters

((7.3.3)7.3.3) criteria based on sizecriteria based on size

-- Energy sources (Table 7.3.3Energy sources (Table 7.3.3--1)1)

-- Key systems (Table 7.3.3Key systems (Table 7.3.3--2)2)

Meters communicate to central recordingMeters communicate to central recording

systemsystem


3333

Metering Thresholds:Metering Thresholds: May beMay beRevisedRevised

in ISCin ISC

3434

Prescriptive Option (General)Prescriptive Option (General)

Target is to comply withTarget is to comply withStandard 90.1Standard 90.1--20072007

plusplus 30% savings30% savings

Standard 189.1 buildsStandard 189.1 buildsfrom 90.1from 90.1--20072007



9/17

3535


Prescriptive Option (Continued)Prescriptive Option (Continued)

Prescriptive Option:Prescriptive Option:

-- Lower lighting power density (90%), expandLower lighting power density (90%), expandoccupancy sensor controloccupancy sensor control

-- Increased requirement for economizers andIncreased requirement for economizers andvariable speed controlsvariable speed controls

-- SHGC , East & West window area combinationSHGC , East & West window area combinationlimits for climate zones 1limits for climate zones 1--4 (west only in 54 (west only in 5--6)6)

3636

Prescriptive Option (Building Envelope)Prescriptive Option (Building Envelope)

Section 7.4.2 generally has more stringentSection 7.4.2 generally has more stringent

requirements for building enveloperequirements for building envelope Replaces Table 5.5Replaces Table 5.5--1 thru 8 on building1 thru 8 on building

envelope in 90.1, for example:envelope in 90.1, for example:

Highlights for Energy (Chapter 7)Highlights for Energy (Chapter 7)((7.4.2 a )7.4.2 a )

May beMay be

RevisedRevised

in ISCin ISC

3737


Example comparisons:Example comparisons:

More stringent SHGCMore stringent SHGC


Example:Example:

Climate zone 3Climate zone 3 Std 90.1 Std 189.1Std 90.1 Std 189.1

Insulation above deck RInsulation above deck R--1515 RR--2525

Example for 10Example for 10 --40% window area:40% window area:

Climate zone 5Climate zone 5

Std. 90.1: 0.39 (0.49 north)Std. 90.1: 0.39 (0.49 north)Std. 189 .1: 0.35 all orientat ionsStd. 189 .1: 0.35 all orientat ions

((7.4.2 a )7.4.2 a )

3838


Vertical fenestrationVertical fenestration 0.5

((7.4.2 e)7.4.2 e)

-- Permanent projections: west, east & southPermanent projections: west, east & south

-- Climate zones 1Climate zones 1--55



10/17

3939

Prescriptive Option (Mechanical)Prescripti ve Option (Mechanical)

Higher equipmentHigher equipment

efficienciesefficiencies

More pipe/duct insulationMore pipe/duct insulation

Fan power allowance 10% lessFan power allowance 10% less

Unoccupied hotel/motel rooms to haveUnoccupied hotel/motel rooms to have

autoauto--shutoffshutoff


4040

Prescriptive Option (Lighting)Prescriptive Option (Lighting)

Interior lighting power to be 10% lessInterior lighting power to be 10% less

than ASHRAE Standard 90.1than ASHRAE Standard 90.1

Occupancy sensorOccupancy sensor

controlscontrols

AutoAuto--controlscontrols

for lighting infor lighting in

daylight zonesdaylight zones


7.4.3 HVAC


Adapt, withmodifications

General Concept:Base on Standard 90.1, butmodify to gain improvedenergy performance overcode minimum standards


4242

7.4.3 HVAC7.4.3 HVAC

Brief mention of modifications to Std. 90.1Brief mention of modifications to Std. 90.1

-- 7.4.3 (a)7.4.3 (a) Expanded air economizerExpanded air economizer

requirementrequirement

-- 7.4.3 (b)7.4.3 (b) Minimum equipment efficiencyMinimum equipment efficiency

-- 7.4.3 (c)7.4.3 (c) Motorized dampers exceptionMotorized dampers exception

-- 7.4.3 (d)7.4.3 (d) Lowers DCV occupancy thresholdLowers DCV occupancy threshold

-- 7.4.3 (e)7.4.3 (e) Duct sealing level A everywhereDuct sealing level A everywhere

-- 7.4.3 (f)7.4.3 (f) Expanded economizer requirementExpanded economizer requirement

-- 7.4.3 (g)7.4.3 (g) Zone reheatZone reheat-- 7.4.3 (h)7.4.3 (h) Fan power limitation 10% lowerFan power limitation 10% lower

-- 7.4.3 (i)7.4.3 (i)Added partAdded part--load fan power limitsload fan power limits


11/17

4343

7.4.3 HVAC7.4.3 HVAC

Brief mention of modifications to Std. 90.1Brief mention of modifications to Std. 90.1

(Continued)(Continued)

-- 7.4.3 (j)7.4.3 (j) Lowered pump power thresholdLowered pump power threshold

-- 7.4.3 (k)7.4.3 (k) Expand energy recovery reqExpand energy recovery reqtt

-- 7.4.3 (l)7.4.3 (l) Kitchen hoods add variable speedKitchen hoods add variable speed

-- 7.4.3 (m and n)7.4.3 (m and n) Minimum duct and pipeMinimum duct and pipe

insulation increased (Tables Cinsulation increased (Tables C--16, 17 and 18)16, 17 and 18)

-- 7.4.3 (o)7.4.3 (o)Added pipe sizing/flow limitationAdded pipe sizing/flow limitation

-- 7.4.3 (p)7.4.3 (p) Unoccupied hotel/motel guestUnoccupied hotel/motel guest

roomsrooms

4444


Performance Based Option:Performance Based Option:

Demonstrated equivalent performance inDemonstrated equivalent performance inbothboth energyenergyandand COCO22 equivalentequivalent

compared to if using the Prescriptive pathcompared to if using the Prescriptive path

ProposedProposed Mandatory +Mandatory +Prescriptive PathPrescriptive Path

Using Appendix DUsing Appendix DPerformance OptionPerformance Optionfor Energy Efficiencyfor Energy Efficiency

4545 4646


Performance Based Option:Performance Based Option:

COCO22 equivalentequivalent compared to buildingcompared to building

designed to the Prescriptive pathdesigned to the Prescriptive path

NationalNational

(U.S.)(U.S.)

basedbased

numbersnumbers


12/17

4747

Indoor Environmental Quality (Indoor Environmental Quality ( 8)8)

Mandatory Key Items toMandatory Key Items to

ASHRAE members:ASHRAE members:-- Outdoor airflowOutdoor airflow

-- Tobacco smoke controlTobacco smoke control

-- Outdoor air monitoringOutdoor air monitoring

Refers to and modifies

4848

Indoor Environmental QualityIndoor Environmental Quality

8.3.1 M inimum IAQ8.3.1 M inimum IAQ

1.3 times Standard 62 .11.3 times Standard 62 .1--2004 outdoor2004 outdoorairflow for offices and classroomsairflow for offices and classrooms(climate zone and other exceptions)(climate zone and other exceptions)-- Climate zones 1A and 2AClimate zones 1A and 2A

-- Offices zones 6,7,8 w ithout heat recoveryOffices zones 6,7,8 w ithout heat recovery

-- NonNon--attainment air quality areasattainment air quality areas

-- Design according to IAQ procedureDesign according to IAQ procedure

NonNon--attainment PMattainment PM 2.52.5 MERV 13 filtersMERV 13 filters

4949

Example, and discussion on additionaloutdoor airflow requirement

5050


8.3.28.3.2

Environmental Tobacco SmokeEnvironmental Tobacco Smoke

ControlControl-- No smok ing inside, w ith signageNo smok ing inside, w ith signage

-- No smoking w ithin 25 feet of entrance,No smoking w ithin 25 feet of entrance,

outdoor air intakes or operable windowsoutdoor air intakes or operable windows


13/17

5151


Indoor Environmental Quality:Indoor Environmental Quality:

Mandatory:Mandatory: 8.3.3 Outdoor Air Monitoring8.3.3 Outdoor Air Mon itoring

-- COCO22 monitoring for systems servingmonitoring for systems serving

densely occupied spaces (lowerdensely occupied spaces (lower

threshold forthreshold for densely occupieddensely occupied

than Std. 90.1than Std. 90.1--2007)2007)

-- NonNon--densely occupied spaces monitor outdoordensely occupied spaces monitor outdoorairflow toairflow to 15% of15% ofdesign minimumdesign minimum

outdoor airflow rateoutdoor airflow rate

BeingBeing

RevisedRevised

in ISCin ISC5252


Other Mandatory:Other Mandatory:

Thermal ComfortThermal Comfort-- Comply withComply with

ASHRAE Std 55ASHRAE Std 55

Mat systems atMat systems at

building entrancesbuilding entrances

Acoustical designAcoustical design

for envelope (soundfor envelope (soundtransmission ratingtransmission rating

criteria)criteria)

5353

Other Mandatory:Other Mandatory:

Minimum MERV 8Minimum MERV 8

filtration upstreamfiltration upstreamof cooling coilsof cooling coils

(revises 62.1)(revises 62.1)

Daylighting byDaylighting by

toplighting fortoplighting for

large open spaceslarge open spaces


5454

Indoor Environmental Quality (Ch 8)Indoor Environmental Quality (Ch 8)

Mandatory:Mandatory:

Thermal ComfortThermal Comfort

-- Comply withComply withASHRAE Std 55ASHRAE Std 55

Mat systems atMat systems at

building entrancesbuilding entrances


14/17

5555

Prescriptive Option (Prescriptive Option (8.4)8.4)::

Side daylightingSide daylighting-- Offices and classroomsOffices and classrooms

-- Minimum effective aperture of windowsMinimum effective aperture of windows

-- Minimum visible reflectance of interiorMinimum visible reflectance of interior

surfacessurfaces

-- Exceptions forExceptions fordark roomsdark rooms,,

facades closely adjacent tofacades closely adjacent toother buildingsother buildings


5656

Prescriptive Option (ContPrescriptive Option (Contdd))::

Office space shading, with projections orOffice space shading, with projections orother techniquesother techniques

Low emitting materialsLow emitting materials

-- Adhesives and sealantsAdhesives and sealants

-- Paints and coatingsPaints and coatings

-- Floor covering materialsFloor covering materials

-- Composite wood and agrifiber productsComposite wood and agrifiber products


5757

Performance Option (Performance Option (8.5)8.5)::

Daylighting simulationDaylighting simulation

-- All regularly occupied spacesAll regularly occupied spaces-- Minimum illuminance target:Minimum illuminance target:

300 lux (30 fc) on work surfaces,300 lux (30 fc) on work surfaces,4.5 m (15 ft) from facade, noon equinox4.5 m (15 ft) from facade, noon equinox

-- Direct sunlight on workplane < 20% ofDirect sunlight on workplane < 20% ofoccupied hours on equinox dayoccupied hours on equinox day

Modeling to show compliance withModeling to show compliance withCalifornia CA/DHS/EHLB/RCalifornia CA/DHS/EHLB/R--7174 (low7174 (lowemitting materials)emitting materials)


May beMay be

RevisedRevised

in ISCin ISC

5858

BuildingBuilding s Impact on Atmosphere,s Impact on Atmosphere,

Materials and Resources (Materials and Resources ( 9)9)

Mandatory Items Key to ASHRAE:Mandatory Items Key to ASHRAE:

CFC, other refrigerant restrictionsCFC, other refrigerant restrictions

-- No CFCsNo CFCs-- Global warm ing and ozone depletionGlobal warm ing and ozone depletion

potentia l balancepotentia l balance

LCGWP = Life cycle global warmingLCGWP = Life cycle global warming

LCODP = Life cycle ozone depletionLCODP = Life cycle ozone depletion

Units: kg CFC11/ kW-yrlb CFC11/ ton-yr


15/17

5959



Refrigerant restrictions (Continued):Refrigerant restrictions (Continued):

GWPGWPrr = global warm ing potential= global warming potential

0 to 12,000 kg CO0 to 12,000 kg CO22/ kg refrigerant/ kg refrigerant

ODPODPrr = ozone depletion potential= ozone depletion potential

0 to 0.2 kg CO0 to 0 .2 kg CO22/ kg refrigerant/ kg refrigerantLr= Leak rateMr= End of life refrigerant lossRc= Charge

6060



Refrigerant restrictions (Continued):Refrigerant restrictions (Continued):

Exception:Exception:

Small HVAC units, coolersSmall HVAC units, coolers

w ith < 0 .5 lb refrigerant chargew ith < 0.5 lb refrigerant charge

Life Cycle Assessment (Performance)Life Cycle Assessment (Performance)

-- Must include operating energy consumptionMust include operating energy consumption

-- LCA to includeLCA to include allall of these impact categories:of these impact categories:

land use, resource use, climate change,land use, resource use, climate change,

ozone layer depletion, human healthozone layer depletion, human health

effects, ecotoxicity, smog, acidification,effects, ecotoxicity, smog, acidification,

eutrophicationeutrophication

-- show 5% gain in two categories for theshow 5% gain in two categories for thebuildingbuilding



6262

1010 -- Construction and Operation PlansConstruction and Operation P lans

Mandatory:Mandatory:

Full commissioning for projectsFull commissioning for projects

> 5,000 ft> 5,000 ft

-- HVAC, building envelope, lighting, irrigation,HVAC, building envelope, lighting, irrigation,

plumbing, domestic water, renewable energyplumbing, domestic water, renewable energy

Addition of monitoring equipment forAddition of monitoring equipment for

measurement and verification, M&V plansmeasurement and verification, M&V plans

-- water, energy and IAQwater, energy and IAQ

-- M&V plans in placeM&V plans in place-- certification of lamp and ballast recyclingcertification of lamp and ballast recycling


16/17

6363

1010 -- Construction and Operation P lansConstruction and Operation Plans

10.3.3.3 Energy Efficiency10.3.3.3 Energy Efficiency

Two compliance pathsTwo compliance paths

-- Comparison to CBECSComparison to CBECSbenchmark 12benchmark 12--1818

months aftermonths after

occupancyoccupancy

-- Energy simulationEnergy simulation

Done every 3 yearsDone every 3 years

6464

1010 -- Construction and Operation PlansConstruction and Operation P lans

10.3.3.4 Indoor Environmental Quality10.3.3.4 Indoor Environmental Quality

If CO2 monitoring, determine maximumIf CO2 monitoring, determine maximum

allowableallowable action levelaction levelper Standard 62.1 forper Standard 62.1 forthat zone typethat zone type

For outdoor air flow, monitor and react ifFor outdoor air flow, monitor and react if

flow


17/17

FURTHER INFORMATIONFURTHER INFORMATION

Information on ASHRAE standards:Information on ASHRAE standards:

www.ashrae.orgwww.ashrae.org then followthen followStandardsStandards, includes listserv for, includes listserv for


Information on USGBC programs:Information on USGBC programs:

www.usgbc.orgwww.usgbc.org

Information on IESNA programs:Information on IESNA programs:www.iesna.orgwww.iesna.org

6868

Thank you!Thank you!

Comments, questions, concerns, adviceComments, questions, concerns, advice

Dr. Tom Lawrence, P.E., LEEDDr. Tom Lawrence, P.E., LEED--APAP

[email protected]@engr.uga.edu

ashraestandard18911hour4slidesperpage

Documents