astrrobiology lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/abl8.pdf · the interstellar medium – the cradle of...

52
Astrobiology Lesson 8 Discussion

Upload: others

Post on 30-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Astrobiology

Lesson8Discussion

Page 2: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Astrobiologyinanutshell

AcompletecourseinAstrobiologydealswiththefollowingitems:

-  Ancientideas,Copernicanrevolu?on,Enlightenmentvsreligion-  LifebeyondtheEarth,-  LifeinthesolarsystemvslifeintheUniverseasawhole.-  Fundamentalques?onsconcerningtheoriginandevolu?onoflife

onEarthandtheimplica?onsforlifeintheUniverse -  WhereandhowdowesearchforlifeoutsidetheEarth?-  IntelligentLife(SETI)

Butmostimportant:Whyshouldwebeinterestedin“LifeintheUniverse?”AOerall,WealreadyknowthatlifeexistintheUniverse!Sowhatisthebigdeal?(Actualquote)

Page 3: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Well....

•  Dowehaveneighbors?Itisinteres?ngifsomebodylivesacrossthehallway....

•  WedonotknowhowlifearoseonEarth....•  Wasitaneasyprocess–andthereforealikelyoutcomeofthecondi?ons?

•  Orwasitadifficultprocess–andthereforeunlikelytohappen

•  Astrobiologyisanewscience–thisishowitestablishitself?

Page 4: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

ArewealoneintheUniverse?

Page 5: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

The birth of the belief in other worlds

“Thereareinfiniteworldsbothlikeandunlikethisworldofours…withlifelikaandunlike”Epicurus(c300BC)

“…falseanddamnable…”G.Galiliei(born1564)

“Therearecountlesssunsandcountlessearthsallrota?ngaroundtheirsunsinexactlythesamewayasthesevenplanetsofoursystem…ThecountlessworldsintheuniversearenoworseandnolessinhabitedthanourEarth”GiordanoBruno,1584inDeL'infinitoUniversoEMondi

ButAristotelearguedthatthiswasNOTthecase

Page 6: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Today

•  “Some?mesIthinktheUniverseisfulloflifeandsome?mesIdonot.Eitherwayisequallyamazing”–ArthurC.Clarke

•  “Theremustbebillionsandbillionsofworldswherelifearose.Some?mesIthinkthereisanEncyclopediaGalac?caouttherewhichwehavenotyetbecomepartof....”–CarlSagan

Page 7: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Thishasledtotheaskingof‘BigQues?ons’like....

“WhatistheuniquenessofourownEarth?”

“Arewe(lifeforms)alone?”

“Whatisourpast&future?”-Theforma?onofplanets-Theevolu?onofplanetarysystems

Page 8: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Cosmic Vision is centered around four Grand Themes: 1.  What are the conditions for planet formation and

the emergence of life?

•  From gas and dust to stars and planets

•  From exo-planets to biomarkers

•  Life and habitability in the Solar System

2.  How does the Solar system work?

3.  What are the Fundamental Physical Laws of the Universe?

4.  How did the Universe originate and what is it made of?

Page 9: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Cosmic Vision is centered around four Grand Themes: 1.  What are the conditions for planet formation and

the emergence of life?

•  From gas and dust to stars and planets

•  From exo-planets to biomarkers

•  Life and habitability in the Solar System

2.  How does the Solar system work?

3.  What are the Fundamental Physical Laws of the Universe?

4.  How did the Universe originate and what is it made of?

First: In-depth analysis of terrestrial planets. Next: Understanding the conditions for star & planet formation, and the origin of life. Later: Census of Earth-sized planets, exploration of Jupiter’s moon Europa. Finally: Image terrestrial exoplanet.

Therealisa?onthatforthefirst?meinhistorywecandomorethanspeculate

Page 10: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

LifebeyondtheEarth?

•  Thereisagreatgeneralinterestintheques?on:–  Viz.Films,TV,UFO’s,PersistentrumoursaboutArea51,etc.

•  Butalsoscien?stsareinterestedforanumberofreasons:– WedonotreallyknowhowlifearoseontheEarth– WedonotknowwhattheroleoflifeintheUniverseis– Wedonotknowmanyoftheevolu?onarystagesonEarth

•  ItisclearthatthediscoveryofanykindoflifeoutsidetheEarthwouldhaveanenormousimpact

Page 11: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

LifebeyondtheEarth?

•  Sowhatarewegoingtolookfor:–  TheintelligentlifeportrayedinfilmslikeStartrek?Orourselves?

–  Giraffes,PlatypusorHamsters?–  Simpleonecellularlifelikethatinhabi?ngourEarthformostofitshistory?~4Gyrs

•  Alloftheabove–ThehistoryoflifeonourEarthmakesthatclear.Modeledonourownexperience

•  Caveat:Somehowwewillhavetoaddresstheques?onthatlifecouldbeverydifferent(Oblivion)

Page 12: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Astrobiology

•  SoAstrobiologyisthestudyoftheorigin,evolu?on,distribu?onandfutureoflifeinthewholeUniverse

•  Howcanitbeaddressed?–  BystudytheeventsthattookplaceontheEarth,bysearchingforsignsoflifeontheplanetsintheSolarSystem,bysearchingintherestoftheUniverse

–  ByusingcrossdisciplinarymethodsincludingeverythingfromgeophysicstoSETI

Page 13: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Astrobiologyisanewscience-howdoesitestablishitself?

Page 14: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Astrobiology

•  Byclarifying,eventually,oneofthegreatques?ons:ArewealoneintheUniverse?

�Bydemonstra?ngitsvaluetounderstandlifeonEarthanditsevolu?on

� Bydemonstra?nghowwecanunderstandthepastandfutureevolu?onoftheSolarSystem

Page 15: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

LifebeyondtheEarth?

•  ButtheissuesarecenteredwhenconsideringlifeontheEarthitselfanditsorigin

•  WedonotknowwhenorhowlifearoseonEarth•  Weknowverylikleabouttheevolu?onoflifeforthefirst~4Gyrs

•  WedonotknowwhyaOer~4Gyrwehadthe“CambrianExplosion”leadingtoallphylathatexistonEarthtoday

Page 16: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Howcansciencehelpusanswerthefundamentalques?onsconcerningwherelife

comesfromandhowitisformed?

Page 17: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

FirstweconsiderlifeontheEarth?

•  Threeimportantques?ons:•  Whatislife?•  WhendidlifebeginontheEarth?•  AndhowdidlifeariseontheEarth?

Page 18: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Whatislife(Clausius,1865)

•  Clausiusformulatedthefirsttwolawsofthermodynamics

•  1:TheenergyoftheUniverseisconstant•  2:Theentropy(degreeofdisorder)oftheUniversetendstoamaximum

•  Boltzmanspeculated:“Thegeneralstrugglefortheexistenceofanimatebeingsisnotastruggleforrawmaterials,norforenergy,butfornega4veentropy,availablebythetransi?onofenergyfromthehotSuntothecoldEarth

Page 19: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

WhatislifeSchrödinger’sparadox(1944)

•  Inaworldgovernedbythe2ndlawofthermodynamicsisolatedsystemsareexpectedtotendtoastateofmaximumdisorder.

•  Lifeapproachesandmaintainsahighlyorderedstate–doesthisviolatethe2ndLaw.Aparadox?

•  Lifeisnotanisolatedsystemènoparadox.Whynot?•  Theincreaseoforderinsideanorganismiscompensated

morethanenoughbytheincreaseindisorderoutsidethisorganism.Thehighlyorderedstate,issustainedbycausinganetincreaseindisorderintheUniverse.

•  ThecomplexityonEarthcausedbyliferequiresenergymostlyprovidedbytheSunandsupernova(radioac?vity)èincreasesentropymorethanlifediminishit

Page 20: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

WhatislifeSchrödinger’sparadox(1944)

•  Soweliveincloseconnec?onwiththeUniverseandnotseparatefromitinanyway

•  LaterwewillseethisagainwhendiscussingphotosynthesesandhowthisconnectlifeonEarthwiththeSun

•  IstheUniverseintendedforlife?ThisisabigissueinCosmology

•  ParallelUniverseswithdifferentnaturallaws(aninfiniteamount)solvethisissue

Page 21: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Abriefhistoryoflife

•  AlllifeonEarthisprobablyrelatedandgoesbacktoa“firstcell”~4Gyrsago

•  Theoldestfossilsareprobably(thestromatolites)simpleone-cellularwithnonucleus(~3.5Gyr).Procaryotes

•  2Gyrscellswithanucleusevolved.Eucaryotes•  Mul?cellularlifeareknownfrom650–542Myrsago.The

firstsignsarefossilisedtracksofwormlikelife•  542MyrCambrianexplosion(TheBurgessshale)•  Organismswithshellsand(exo-)skeletonsappear•  FirstVertebrates(488-416MyragoOrdovicium),Jawlessfish

Page 22: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Abriefhistoryoflife

•  Firstplantsonlandnotlaterthan444-416Myrago(Silur)•  Firstfrogs416-359Myrago(Devon)•  Firstmammals251-200Myrago(Trias)•  Firstprimates(endofCretaceus)66Myrago•  Separa?ngfromourcousins(Chimpanzees)7-6Myrago•  HomoErectus~1Myr–143Kyrago•  HomoHeidelbergiensis(thebrightestofthelot),

Neanderthalensis,Denisovans800Kyr–40Kyr•  HomoSapiens200Kyr-.....

Page 23: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Observations of forming stars demonstrate that this happens in dense clouds of atomic and molecular gas observed in the Milky way and other galaxies

Inordertohavelife,wefirstneedaplanet

Page 24: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Observa?onsshowforma?ononbothgalac?c

Stars, planets and the Interstellar Medium (ISM)

andintergalac?cscales

Page 25: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

As far as we know, life must begin with complex organic molecules

The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?)

Such molecules can form on a planetary surface but also in interstellar space

~ 10% of the (visible) mass of the Galaxy consist of gas and dust between the stars and half of this mass is in molecular form

Significant amounts of this gas is found in dense clouds and these are the precursors of stars and planets

Page 26: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Stars and planets thus form embedded in a gas consisting partly of organic molecules – i.e. Molecules built with Carbon atoms

The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?)

Molecules similar to nucleotides, fatty acids, carbohydrates and amino acids

è Prebiotic molecules are found all over the universe

But processes forming interstellar molecules are different from those occurring on the Earth

Page 27: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?)

Buckminster-Fullerene C60 Crab supernova remnant (1054 A.D.), creating heavy elements, ejecting them into interstellar medium

Page 28: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Starsforminclusters

•  Mostmolecularcloudscontainbetween104and>106solarmassesofgas.

•  Thereisthusenoughtoformalargeamountofstarsineachcloud

Page 29: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

In the interstellar gas are found Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs). Consist only of Carbon and Hydrogen in multiple rings

The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?)

It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through hydrogenation, oxygenation and hydroxylation è Organics

è Formation of amino acids and nucleotids è may form è Proteins and DNA respectively

But most important è ISM leads to Stars and planets

We know about 145 different molecules that have been detected (almost exclusively in the micro wave region – mm and sub-mm λ) in the interstellar medium

Page 30: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  Firststeptowardslifewastheforma?onoftheEarth•  Condi?onsonEarthatforma?onareimportanttotrytoformapictureofhowlifefirstappeared

•  Thestar?ngpointwasadensemolecularcloudconsis?ngofgasanddust

•  Rela?velyhighdensity•  Rota?ng–containingangularmomentum•  Contrac?ng–conver?ngpoten?alenergytokine?cenergy

Page 31: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  Theaccre?nggasformedadiskofvaryingcomposi?on•  Forma?onofclumps•  Metalrichelementsformedgrainsofiron,nickel,refractorymaterialsininnerpart

•  Grainsconsis?ngoficesfurtheroutbeyond‘snowline’•  Metalsoriginateinstellarwindofredgiantstarsandin

supernovaexplosions•  Supernovamaybepartofprocessstar?ngcollapseofdenseISMclouds

•  TheSunbecamehokerandhoker•  Highdensity•  Rota?ng–containingangularmomentum•  Contrac?ng–conver?ngpoten?alenergytokine?cenergy

Page 32: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  AngularmomentumandEnergywasconserved•  Fasterrota?on•  Highertemperature•  Concentra?ontocenter(99.8%ofmass)èForma?onoftheSun

•  TheSunwasnowaT-Tauristar.Variable.Finally,contrac?onèdensityandtemperatureinthecenterarehighenoughfornuclearreac?onstobegin.

•  Largeamountsofenergyreleased•  Contrac?onbalancedbyreleaseofnuclearenergyHèHe•  Sunbecomesstableandthesolarsurfacebecomescooler(~25%coolerthantoday)è“faintyoungSun”.

•  TheSolarradia?onbecomeseventuallystrongerbecausetheSun(itscore)becomesmorecompressedandhokerasthecenterisfilledwithHe

Page 33: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  Theclumpsinthesurroundingdisknowformtheplanets.•  Clumpsmergeandcontractgrainsèpebblesèbouldersèplanetesimalsèplanets

•  TheEarthnowbecameveryhot(1000K?)throughcontrac?onandsolarradia?on

•  Toohightemperatureforicesandothervola?lesatEarth’sdistancefromtheyoungSun

•  EarthandinnerplanetsforminaregionwithFe,Ni,simpleminerals(refrac?ve)asSiOandMgOçèJustasmallfrac?onofgasdiskmass

•  Furtherout(beyondthe“snowline”)planetsformfromH,He,Ne,H2O,moleculeswithC,Nformlargerplanets(moregaseousmaterialpresent)

Page 34: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  Timeframeafew?mes107years(?)•  Manymoreplanetsformed–someejected,somemergedwiththeSun?

•  Dynamicalinterac?onbetweenlargeplanets•  Voidsandlargeaggregatesofsmallplanetesimalsinteractandcollide

•  E.g.The“Nicemodel”•  TheNicemodelisascenarioforthedynamicalevolu?onof

theearlySolarSystem•  Itsuggeststhatthemigra?onofthegiantplanetsfroma

morecompactarrangementaOerthedissipa?onofthegasinthesystemleadeventuallytothecurrentconfigura?onwhichisstableofmanybillionsofyears

Page 35: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  TheNicemodel•  FormulatedbyMorbidelli,Leavisonandco-workers(2006)

•  Dynamicalcalcula?onsexplainhistoricaleventslike

•  theLateHeavyBombardment(+800Myr),•  ThechangeofplacesofNeptuneandUranus(+1Gyr)•  theforma?onoftheOortcloud•  Theforma?onoftheKuiper-Edgeworthbelt•  Theforma?onoftheJupiterandNeptuneTrojans•  Theforma?onofthetrans-NeptunianObjects(Pluto,etc)

Page 36: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  TheNicemodel

Simulation showing the outer planets and planetesimal belt: a) early configuration, before Jupiter and Saturn reach a 2:1 resonance; b) scattering of planetesimals into the inner Solar System after the orbital shift of Neptune (dark blue) and Uranus (light blue); c) after ejection of planetesimals by planets

Page 37: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  Theforma?onofEarth’sMoon•  TheMoonisthoughttohaveformednearly4.57billionyearsago,not

longaOerEarth•  ThereareseveralhypothesesbutmostacceptedisthattheMoonformed

fromdebrisoftheimpactonEarthbyaMarssizedbody

This has been observed recently in the case of HD172555

Page 38: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theforma?onoftheSunandPlanetsintheSolarSystem

•  Intheouterreachesofthesolarsystemlargenumbersofsmallbodies(totalmassisratherlow)areformedandprobablyejectedhalfwaytotheneareststars(Oortcloud,containingprimoridalmaker)

•  ThesebodiesconsistofH,He,H2OandCH4.•  Therightenvironmenttoformpre-bio?ccompoundswithO,CandN

67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Page 39: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Theevolu?onoftheyoungEarth

•  TheyoungEarthwasbuiltbyminerals(fromdustgrains).•  Originallyitwasveryhotonthesurface(~1000K)buteventuallythe

gravita?onalcontrac?onalongwiththeheatfromradioac?veheavymetalsheatedthecentralparts

•  Thesebecameelas?candeventuallyfluidsuchasitistoday.AllheavyelementschieflyFeandNisanktothecenterandformedacoreèIncreasedthetemperature.

•  Con?nentalplatesmayhaveformedearly(solidrockfloa?ngonanelas?cmedium)

•  Remnantsoftheforma?onoftheSolarSystemcollidedregularlywiththeplanetsandbroughtsubstancesthatdidnotexistoriginallyinourpartofthesolarsystem(WaterandCarboniccompounds)

Page 40: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Further(possible)evolu?onoftheyoungEarth

•  PartoftheancientEarthwouldhavebeendisruptedbytheimpactcrea?ngtheMoonwhichshouldhavecausedmel?ngofoneortwolargeareas.Presentcomposi?ondoesnotmatchcompletemel?nganditishardtocompletelymeltandmixhugerockmasses

•  However,afairfrac?onofmaterialshouldhavebeenvaporizedbythisimpact,crea?ngarockvaporatmospherearoundtheyoungplanet.Therockvaporwouldhavecondensedwithintwothousandyears,leavingbehindhotvola?leswhichprobablyresultedinaheavyCO2atmospherewithHandH2O

•  Liquidwateroceansexisteddespitethesurfacetemperatureof230°CbecauseoftheatmosphericpressureoftheheavyCO2atmosphere(60bar)

•  Ascoolingcon?nued,subduc?onanddissolvinginoceanwaterremovedmostCO

Page 41: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Geological?ming

•  Howcanwedatethestagesintheearlyevolu?onofourplanet?•  Mainlyusingradioac?ves.MostlytheUranium-Leadchainofdecay•  TheUranium-Leadradiometricda?ngschemetodayèanerrormarginin

rocksthat<twoMyrin21/2Gyr•  TherearenorocksonEartholderthan3.8Gyr.Butwhenoneanalyse

Zircon(ZrSiO4crystals)adifferentresultemerges.ZrincorporatesUinitscrystalsbutrejectlead

•  Twochains:1)from238Uto206Pb,withahalf-lifeof4.47Gyrsand2)from235Uto207Pb,withahalf-lifeof704millionyears.

•  ThisgivesanageoftheEarth’sZrcrystalsof4.4Gyrs•  TheMoonislesschangedthantheEarthè4.57Gyrwhichissimilarto

meteoritesorigina?ngintheasteroidbelt

Page 42: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Geological?ming

•  WethereforedividetheearlyphasesoftheEarth’shistoryinto•  1.Hadeanfromthebeginningun?l~3.8Gyr•  2.TheArcheanfrom3.8Gyrun?l~2.4Gyr•  TheLunarlandingsinthe1970:?esbroughtin-situmeasurementsofthe

Moon.Itwasfoundthatthe“Mare”thelargelavaplainsontheMoonwereallformedbyheavycollisions~4Gyrsago.Theconclusionwasthatanumberofbodies>100kmindiametercollidedwiththeMoonduringthisepoch(seetheNicemodelforexplana?on)

•  TheEarth,beingbigger,musthavebeenhitmuchmoreandeachcollisionislargeenoughsothatmostoftherockssurfaceoftheearthwouldhavemeltedoreventurnedintogas.MostofthewatermusthaveturnedintosteamèTheimplica?onsforlifeifithasformedalreadyarenotgood.

•  Theseinterpreta?onsarenottotallyaccepted!•  Whatisclearisthatrocksdatedat3.8Gyrsdemonstratethatthe

collisionsceasedthen.

Page 43: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

StructureoftheyoungEarth

TheearlyphasesoftheEarthwasviolentevenwhenthebombardmenthadceasedMajor movements in the crust, tectonics, as well as severe volcanic activity

Large amounts of radioactivity è heating + contraction + latent heat left from the merger of the planetesimals. + the bombardment

This led to a stratification that remains to this day

Crust (~ 35km – thinner under the oceans, thicker under land) + Mantle (3000km) consisting of MgO+ Core (Fe+Ni) down to 6400km

Under the mantle is the Magma which is liquid

Volcanic activity takes place at the border between different tectonic plates, where magma can reach the surface

Page 44: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Tectonicplates

Page 45: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

TracesofearlylifeonEarth

•  WecannotreallyexpecttofindtracesofthefirstlifeonEarthsinceitwasverysimpleandprimi?veandourplanethavebeenre-cycled

•  Earlyevolu?onappear,however,tohaveproducedmicroorganismsthatusedSunlightgavetracesinthefossilrecordthatcanbefoundaOer3Gyr.

•  CyanobacteriaformedveryearlyanddominatedtheEarthforatleast1Gyr.TheyproducedfreeoxygenandthuschangedtheEarth’satmosphere

•  SomeresearchersclaimthatfossiltracesofStromatolitesexistthatare3500millionyearsold.Thesearecoloniesofcyanobacteriawhichproducemineralisedmatsthats?llexist

Fossilised stromatolite

Page 46: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

EarlyLifeontheEarth?–Whatdoweknow

•  TheEarthformedabout4.54Gyrago•  Earliestundisputed(almost)signsoflifearefossilmicrobialmats(Stromatolites)from3.48Gyr(Australia)

•  Biogenic(?)Graphiteinsedimentary?3.7GyroldrocksinGreenland

•  Twootherstudiesfindsigns(fromfossil12C/13Cra?os)from4.25and4.4Gyr

•  èLifearoseEarly?Implica?ons?

Page 47: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

TheatmosphereoftheyoungEarth

•  AOerthenuclearreac?onslitofinsidetheSunitsluminosity,LO,dropped.Observa?onsofT-TauristarsindicatetheLOmayhavegonedownby25-35%

•  TheZirconeanalysisindicateearlyliquidwaterontheEarthèamuchdenseratmospherewith“greenhousegases”(CO,CH4)

•  Theatmosphereprobablyoriginatedinplanetesimals/cometsfallingdownontoEarth,butalsooutgassing(volcanos)sincesuchcomponentsmusthavebeenpartoftheforma?onèHcombiningwithO,C,NèH2O,CH4,NH3

•  Thisisareducingatmospherewithcompletelydifferentproper?esthaninourpresentatmospherewhichisoxidizing.

•  Reducingatmospheredoesnotformoxides(e.g.RustwithFe),C+HdoesnotexplodebutinsteadformCH4.

•  HistolighttostayintheEarth’satmosphere.H2OandNH3aredissociatedbyUVlightandtheHescapestospacewhichleadstoanatmospheredominatedbyN(78.09%today),(+20.95%O,0.93%Ar,0.039%CO2).

Page 48: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

DifferencesbetweenayoungEarthandayoungVenus

•  Thetwoplanetsareverysimilarinsizeandincomposi?onbutVenushasatemperature~600K,whiletheEarthisbetween273Kand370K(average287.3Kin2013).

–  TheblackbodytemperatureofEarthis254Kor-19degreesC.ITisthegreenhouseeffectthatkeepEarthfrombeingasnowballagain

•  ThecurrentdensityofVenusatmosphereis90?meshigherthantheEarth’s

•  Theiratmosphereswereverylikelysimilartostartoutwith....ButVenuswasalwayshokerthantheEarthèVenuslostmoreofitswaterandthereforenevergotplatetectonics.TheHescapedandOreactedwithCH4andformedCO2whichmadetheplanethoker.AllitsCistodayintheatmosphere

•  OnEarthmostoftheCO2formedinthiswayisdissolvedintotheoceans,andtogetherwithCagoesoutofsolu?onascarbonates.

Page 49: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

StanleyMiller’sexperiment

•  A.Oparin(1894-1980)suggestedin1920:?esthatareducingatmospherewithHandhydrogenatedmoleculestogetherwithelectricdischargesandUvradia?onèchemicalreac?onsimportantforthechemistryoflife.

•  HaroldUrey(1893-1981,Nobelprizein1934,discoveryofD)suggestedanexperimenttohisstudentStanleyMiller(1930-2007)whichhecarriedoutin1953

•  Hecreatedreducingatmospheresinthelabandpassedelectricdischargesthroughit

•  AOerafewdayshefoundsomeblackgoointhetestvessel:–  Aspar?cacidandButyricacid–nosurprisesthere.–  Thesecondmostcommonsubstance,however,wasglycinthesimplestaminoacid–  Andnumber4wasalaninanotherimportantaminoacid+somemoreaminoacidsin

significantamounts

And amino acids are the building blocks of proteins! è Biochemestry!

Page 50: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

StanleyMiller’sexperiment

•  ProblemisofcoursethatwealreadyfoundthattheEarthwouldloseitsH,H2andrapidlygetanatmosphereofN2andCO2whichdoesnotallowtheresultsofMiller’sexperiment

•  Millercon?nuedtoworkfortherestofhislifeandotherideashavebeentested:

–  MethaneejectedfromvolcanosintoaCO2richatmospheregivessomeaminoacidsbutnotinsuchgreatamounts

–  Moderncalcula?onsindicatethattheEarthwouldhavebeenlosingitsHmuchslowerthanpreviouslysuggestedèLifecouldhavehad?metostart

•  Areducingatmosphereandcoldseas/oceansseemtobeastar?ngpointforcrea?nganenvironmentintowhichthebuildingblocksoflifecouldhavebeenformed.AlotofCH4isalsorequiredplussuitableenergysources

•  Comparedtootheralterna?vesincludingthepresentEarth,thesecondi?onscouldbesearchedforaroundexoplanetswithadvancedinstrumentsanditwouldhelpiftheplanetwaslargerthantheEarth(moreHandH2isretained)èSuperEarth

Page 51: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

HowdidthefirstlifeariseonEarth?

•  Summary:Itisatleastpossiblethatthecondi?onsofMiller’sexperiment,togetherwithcoldoceansofH2Ocouldhaveexistedforasignificant?me

Page 52: Astrrobiology Lesson 8mackie/astrobio/files/ABL8.pdf · The Interstellar medium – the cradle of Planets and life(?) It has been observed that PAH’s in space transform through

Lifeoritsbuildingblocksarrivingfromspace?

•  TheMurchisonmeteoritefellindaylightoverMurchison,Victoria,Australiaon28/91969.Itwaswidelyobservedasafireball,breakingintoatleast3fragmentsasitwasobservedandanimpacttremorwasfelt

•  100kgofmasswascollectedinfragmentsofupto7kgoveranareaof13km2includingoneinsideabarn

•  Over15aminoacidsplusahostofotherorganiccomponentshavebeeniden?fied.AmountsaresimilartothosefoundintheMillerexperiment

•  Sofarnoorganiccompoundshavebeenretrievedfromacomet,butobserva?onsofHalley’sandothercometshavedemonstratedthepresenceofcarboniccompoundssuchashydrogencyanideandformaldehyde.Alsoadenine,oneofthebasesinnucleicacids(likeDNA)wasseeninHalley

•  Injustafewweeks,ESAwillreleasedatafromalaboratorylandedonthecomet67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko