ateneo law journal . legal concept of terrorism under ... · rig/as act, 4 7 ateneo l.j. 571...

24
822 ATENEO LAW JOURNAL courts, the limitation of the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus to those involved in rebellion or invasion, and the requirement that those detained during the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus must be charged in court within three days have been repealed. 1 l4 Instead, there will be an interim Parliament composed of the incumbent Senators and Congressmen, at least one-third of the Cabinet Members with portfolio, and thirty persons to be appointed by President Gloria Macapagal- Arroyo.1J5 The interim Prime Minister and the Cabinet will be under the direction and of President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo. 1 J6 President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo will be the President, Head of State, and Head of Governme,nt.ll7 \ It behooves every Filipino to resist this attempt to restore authoritarianism with every legal weapon. The nightmarish experience of the nation during the dark days of the I973 Constitution brings to mind the warning of Justice Calixto Zaldivar in his separate opinion in the case of ]avel/ana, when he quoted a dissenting opinion of Justice George Sutherland, '[t)he saddest epitaph which can be carved in memory of a vanished liberty is that it was lost because its pos<essors failed to forth a saving hand while yet there was time.' 1 J 8 134· ld. art. IX § 8. 135. Id. art. XX§ 136. Id. art. XX § I 2. I37·Id. m. XX§ 13. IJS.Javellana v. Commission on Elections, 50 SCRA JO, 309 (1973) (citing The Associated Press v. National Labor Relations Board, 301 U.S. 103, 141 (1937)). ."" Legal Concept of Terrorism under International Law and Its Application to Philippine Municipal Law Secifrey M. Candelaria* Ve1'11 M. de Guzman** Ivy D. Patdu*** I. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 824 * '84 LL.B. Ateneo de Manila University School of Law; LL.M. University of British Columbia (1990). The Author is the Associate Dean for Student Affairs and a professorial lecmrer on Constitutional Law, Pubic International Law, Law Review, International Economic Law, Children's Rights Law, and Indigenous Peoples' Rights at the Ateneo de Manila University School o.f Law. He is also a Member of the GRP (Government of the Republic of the Phlhppmes) Panel for talkn;:ith the CPP/NPA/NDF (Communist Party of the Repubhc of the Philippines/New ·People's Army/National Democratic Front); Head of the Research and Linkages Office and the Department of Special Areas of Concern of the Philippine Judicial Academy, Supreme Court of the Philippines; Head of the Children's Rights and Indigenous People's Desk, Ateneo Human Rights Center; and President of the CASA/GAL Foundation of the Philippines, Inc. The Author's previous works published in the Joumal indud-o The Rights if ; 11 International Law, 46 ATENEO L.J. 273 (2001); lntrodunng the lndrgenous Peoples Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization <?f the Asia-Pacific Ewnomic Conference (APEC) and the Individual Action Plans in International Law, 44 ATENEO L.J. 405 (2000); and The IMF and the Philippines: A11atomy of a Third World Debt, 36 ATENEO L.J. 18 (1992). He is also co-author of Testing Constituti01,al Waters: Balancing State Power, Economic Development and Respect for Human 51 ATE.NEO L.J. 1 (2ou6); Courr.< and Social Context Theory: Philippine Judicial as Appi1ed to Vulnerable Sectors, 50 ATENEO L.J. 823 (2006); and The P/1ilippines a11d tl1e ConventiOI7 (ll1 tire Rights of the Clrild: Evaluating Compliance with Respect to Intemational Sra<1dards for Procedural Rulc•s Involving Children, 49 A TEN EO L.J. 1016 (2005). ** 'o3 A.B. and '07 J.D., Ateneo de Manila University; Member, Board ofEclit(!l'rs ;mel Executive Committee, Ateneo Law Journal. She was the Lead Editor for Vol. 5 r, issue number 3 and Vol. 50, issue number 4. Her previous work published in the Journal includes: A Play with Words: B. P. Big. 88o and the Calibra:ed Preemptive Rcspouse Policy, 51 ATENEO L.J. 185 (2oo6). She is also co-aut':-:or ot i\!ledrallon: A Fall<Jrable Resolrrtian to Family Dispute Settlemmt, 51 ATENEO L.J. 762 (2006). *** 'o2 M.D. University of the Philippines; 'o9 J.D. cand., Ateneo Je Manila Univers;ty School of La,;,; Member, Board of Editors, .LawJoumaL She won Jrcl place for her Essay Judicial I111der the DuvJde Watch lil a National Essay Writing Contest for Law Students (Supreme Comt, zoos). Citr· '" 51 ATENEO L.J. (2007).

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jan-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization

822 ATENEO LAW JOURNAL

courts, the limitation of the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus to those involved in rebellion or invasion, and the requirement that those detained during the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus must be charged in court within three days have been repealed. 1l4

Instead, there will be an interim Parliament composed of the incumbent Senators and Congressmen, at least one-third of the Cabinet Members with portfolio, and thirty persons to be appointed by President Gloria Macapagal­Arroyo.1J5

The interim Prime Minister and the Cabinet will be under the direction and sup't~rvision of President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo. 1 J6 President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo will be the President, Head of State, and Head of Governme,nt.ll7

\ It ther~fore behooves every Filipino to resist this attempt to restore

authoritarianism with every legal weapon.

The nightmarish experience of the nation during the dark days of the I973 Constitution brings to mind the warning of Justice Calixto Zaldivar in his separate opinion in the case of ]avel/ana, when he quoted a dissenting opinion of Justice George Sutherland, '[t)he saddest epitaph which can be carved in memory of a vanished liberty is that it was lost because its pos<essors failed to str~tch forth a saving hand while yet there was time.'1J8

134· ld. art. IX § 8.

135. Id. art. XX§ 9· 136. Id. art. XX § I 2.

I37·Id. m. XX§ 13.

IJS.Javellana v. Commission on Elections, 50 SCRA JO, 309 (1973) (citing The Associated Press v. National Labor Relations Board, 301 U.S. 103, 141 (1937)).

."" Legal Concept of Terrorism under

International Law and Its Application to Philippine Municipal Law Secifrey M. Candelaria* Ve1'11 M. de Guzman** Ivy D. Patdu***

I. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 824

* '84 LL.B. Ateneo de Manila University School of Law; LL.M. University of British Columbia (1990). The Author is the Associate Dean for Student Affairs and a professorial lecmrer on Constitutional Law, Pubic International Law, Politi~al Law Review, International Economic Law, Children's Rights Law, and Indigenous Peoples' Rights at the Ateneo de Manila University School o.f Law. He is also a Member of the GRP (Government of the Republic of the Phlhppmes) Ne~otJatmg Panel for talkn;:ith the CPP/NPA/NDF (Communist Party of the Repubhc of the Philippines/New ·People's Army/National Democratic Front); Head of the Research and Linkages Office and the Department of Special Areas of Concern of the Philippine Judicial Academy, Supreme Court of the Philippines; Head of the Children's Rights and Indigenous People's Desk, Ateneo Human Rights Center; and President of the CASA/GAL Foundation of the Philippines, Inc. The Author's previous works published in the Joumal indud-o The Rights if Indigeno~s Cormnunitie~ ;11 International Law, 46 ATENEO L.J. 273 (2001); lntrodunng the lndrgenous Peoples Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization <?f the Asia-Pacific Ewnomic Conference (APEC) and the Individual Action Plans in International Law, 44

ATENEO L.J. 405 (2000); and The IMF and the Philippines: A11atomy of a Third World Debt, 36 ATENEO L.J. 18 (1992). He is also co-author of Testing Constituti01,al Waters: Balancing State Power, Economic Development and Respect for Human R(~hts, 51 ATE.NEO L.J. 1 (2ou6); Courr.< and Social Context Theory: Philippine Judicial R~form as Appi1ed to Vulnerable Sectors, 50 ATENEO L.J. 823 (2006); and The P/1ilippines a11d tl1e ConventiOI7 (ll1 tire Rights of the Clrild: Evaluating Compliance with Respect to Intemational Sra<1dards for Procedural Rulc•s Involving Children, 49 A TEN EO L.J. 1016 (2005).

** 'o3 A.B. and '07 J.D., Ateneo de Manila University; Member, Board ofEclit(!l'rs ;mel Executive Committee, Ateneo Law Journal. She was the Lead Editor for Vol. 5 r, issue number 3 and Vol. 50, issue number 4. Her previous work published in the Journal includes: A Play with Words: B. P. Big. 88o and the Calibra:ed Preemptive Rcspouse Policy, 51 ATENEO L.J. 185 (2oo6). She is also co-aut':-:or ot i\!ledrallon: A Fall<Jrable Resolrrtian to Family Dispute Settlemmt, 51 ATENEO L.J. 762 (2006).

*** 'o2 M.D. University of the Philippines; 'o9 J.D. cand., Ateneo Je Manila Univers;ty School of La,;,; Member, Board of Editors, At~neo .LawJoumaL She won Jrcl place for her Essay Judicial R~forms I111der the DuvJde Watch lil a National Essay Writing Contest for Law Students (Supreme Comt, zoos).

Citr· '" 51 ATENEO L.J. 8~3 (2007).

Page 2: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 3: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 4: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 5: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 6: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 7: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 8: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 9: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 10: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 11: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 12: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 13: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 14: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 15: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 16: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 17: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 18: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 19: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 20: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 21: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 22: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 23: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization
Page 24: ATENEO LAW JOURNAL . Legal Concept of Terrorism under ... · Rig/as Act, 4 7 ATENEO L.J. 571 (2002); The Legal Characterization