atomius caninius...let's review dalton's theory in light of current scientific knowledge....
TRANSCRIPT
atomiuscaninius
the reporter with anose for sciencenews
BB Y RACHEL, COLIN, AND LUCY
it's all for science! i'mrisking my life to take thistime machine back to the
beginning of atomic theory.
after muchresearch, i
can share thesecret of
wheretheoriesabout theatom came
from.
my theoryabout atoms.
now to ace reporter, atomiuscaninius. what do you have for
us, AC?
hello, democritus.thanks for
meeting with me.
here i am in 460 BCE greece.the concept of the atom was
introduced by philosopher,democritus.
call medemmy! as i
was saying tosocrates theother night, ilove to talkabout atoms!
can you expandon your ideas?
what arethese atoms
like?
well, atoms in solids aresmall and pointed, andliquid atoms are large
and round.
hmmm. whatobservationsdid you do tocome up withyour theory? observations?
who am i?aristotle? oh,
wait, hehasn't beenborn yet. i
just thoughtabout it. it'sonly logical.
you're verywelcome.andremember tostay cheerful.it's the secret
to a long,happy life.
how did demmy's theories holdup over time? of course,scientists may make a
discovery tomorrow thatchanges everything!
to sum up. I'll give demmy's theorya b+. it's amazing that he got somuch right, but since he didn't have
any evidence, ithink he was justlucky! back to you, tiffany.
hanks for theinsightfulreport, ac.
what's next inthis series?
thank you forspeaking toour viewersabout the
atom.
I'M HEADED TO LONDON IN1803, AN EXCITING TIME AND
PLACE FOR SCIENTIFICDISCOVERIES,
WHEW! I MADE IT SAFEAND SOUND! WE'RE
MEETING JOHN DALTON, ACHEMIST WHO DEVELOPED
HIS OWN THEORY OFATOMIC STRUCTURE.
SORRY TOBOTHER YOU, DR.DALTON. WHATCAUSED YOURINTEREST INATOMS?
WHAT DID THATTELL YOU ABOUT
ATOMS?
THAT ATOMS OF DIFFERENTGASES MUST BE
DIFFERENT SIZES. I DEDUCEDTHAT ATOMS COMBINE AND
SEPARATE FROM EACHOTHER IN CHEMICAL
REACTIONS.
INTERESTING.SO YOUR IDEASCAME FROM
OBSERVING GASATOMS?
OH NO! NOBODY CAN SEEAN ATOM. THEY'RE TOO
SMALL! I MADE INFERENCESABOUT ATOMS FROM MY
MEASUREMENTS OF GASESAND MIXTURES.
I'M INTERESTED INFRANKLIN AND
ELECTRICITY, BUTWITHOUT LAVOISIER'S
WORK ONMEASURING THECOMPOSITION OFCOMPOUNDS, ICOULDN'T HAVEDEVELOPED MY
THEORY.
AS A METEOROLOGIST,I WONDERED HOW
WATER VAPOR AND AIRSHARED SPACE. I
EXPERIMENTED WITHMEASURING MIXTURESOF GASES AND THEIR
PROPERTIES.
I SEE. WHO ISYOUR
GREATESTSCIENTIFIC
INFLUENCE?
let's reviewdalton'stheory inlight ofcurrentscientificknowledge.
so, what grade should wegive dalton? let's give himan A because he based hisideas on experiments. He did
great considering hecouldn't see what he was
studying!
that is just fascinating, AC. Ican't wait for the final
installment of your exposé onthe structure of the atom.
now we're going to hear from ernestrutherford, a scientist born in newzealand, who worked in canada and
england. He made his discovery aboutthe atom in 1899. This time our
scientist is the time traveler. goodluck, ernie!
what a great opportunity tovisit the 21st century! willthere be robots? will i beable to watch plays andlisten to music in my own
home?
thank you forjoining us. ihope your
journey wascomfortable.
just fine, thankyou. i'm veryexcited to
share my ideaswith your
scientists andlearn what theyhave discovered.
i understand youare speaking to
the nationalassociation ofscientists thisafternoon. whatelse will you dowhile you are
here?
as you cansee,
Thomson'sview of the
atom,the plumpudding model,
was apositively
charged soupwith negativecorpuscles,now calledelectrons.
i had a problem. iwanted to base myideas on evidence,
but i couldn'tobserve atomsdirectly. could idraw conclusionsfrom their traces,though, i wondered.
i shot alpha particles throughgold foil and saw that most
particles passed straight through,but a few deflected at sharp
angles.
i'll visitlaboratories.i understand i
won'tremember myexperienceshere, but i'llenjoy themwhile i can!
thank you for inviting me here todayto discuss atoms. i'm also eager tolearn about those devices you call
smartphones!
i concludedthat atomsare mostlyspace and
most of theirmass is in apositivelychargednucleus
surrounded byelectrons.
did you haveany help from
otherscientists onthis project?
are there anyquestions?
yes, of course. hansgeiger and ernest
marsden conducted theexperiment in mylaboratory in
manchester, and i builtmy ideas on thomson's
theory.
well, our timetogether isover. thankyou for the
visit, and goodluck on yourreturn trip!
it's been apleasure and
anenlighteningexperience!
thank you forthe
opportunity.
this concludes my report onthe history of theories on
atomic structure. nextweek, an investigative
report on why helium makesyou talk funny!
rutherford gets an a+! hisexperiment was ingenious, andhis conclusions were mostly
correct.
so how doesrotherford's
theorymeasure up?