atrt review berkman final report 20oct10 en

8/3/2019 Atrt Review Berkman Final Report 20oct10 En

1/143

!

!

!

"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"55!! "&!3&-212&-2&'!627*28 !!

!"#$%&!'()*+,!

!!!!-.,*/(+!012!0131!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!


2/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4,*!%!/+*%7!+%$E(!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+92!#$.&57#$E!)+#>%,(!9(.,*+!%.,*+9!%$7!E&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!59(+9G!:,!%&9*!+(.(#>(9!#$)5,2!%7>#.(!%$7!9*C(,#C(9!)+(995+(!D+*C!E*>(+$C($,9G!:;4#&6!*$!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!)5/.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!,*!D*9,(+!%..*5$,%/#,6G!!

!

D"#/.A):).A).,#E)>9)?#&=#F%-.2:-%).01#-.A#500&@.,-'9(9,1#-,#/4566## 52#:-%,#&=#-#(-%9)?#:%&0)223#=-0@(,1#-.A#%)2)-%07)%2#=%&*#,7)#G)%8*-.#4).,)%#=&%#/.,)%.),#H#+&09),1#7->)#,-8).#&.#,7)#07-(().#(?!8(%C!N48'8OG!8B#9!+(9(%+.B!+()*+,!#$D*+C9!,B(!?*+J!*D!,B(!48'82!?B#.B!#9!.B%+E(7!?#,B!%99(99#$E!:;4


3/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(!%..*5$,%/#,6!,B+*5EB!,B(9(!,B+((!C(.B%$#9C9G !

!

K"#L9.A9.(%&9!%!B#EB&6!.*C)&(U!)#.,5+(!?#,B!C%$6!#$,(+%.,#$E!>%+#%/&(9!,B%,!C%J(!D%.,ID#$7#$E!.B%&&($E#$E!%$7!%&9*!+($7(+!9#C)&(!9*&5,#*$9!#C)*99#/&(G!X#,B!,B#9!.*C)&(U#,6!#$!C#$72!%$7!+(D(++#$E!,*!,B(!C%#$!,(U,!*D!,B(!+()*+,!D*+!%!C*+(!E+%$5&%+!%$%&69#92!,B(!D#$7#$E9!%$7!%99(99C($,9!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!.%$!/(!.*$7($9(7!%9!D*&&*?9G!!

/4566I2#:)%=&%*-.0)#%))%-((#,%-M)0,&%1#9.#,792#%)#(?!%&9*!9B*?9!%!)(+>%9#>(!)(+.(),#*$!%C*$E!>%+#*59!9,%J(B*&7(+9!,B%,!,B(6!%+(!$*,!S/(#$E!B(%+7T!/6!,B(!:;4%$7!,**&9!*D!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!8B#9!+()*+,L9!%$%&69#9!#7($,#D#(9!,B(!)*,($,#%&!D*+!#C)+*>(C($,!#$!9*.#,#$E!)5/.!#$)5,M!95CC%+#F#$E2!%EE+(E%,#$E!%$7!%.J$*?&(7E#$E!)5/.!.*$,+#/5,#*$9M!.&%+#D6#$E!B*?!)5/.!#$)5,!#9!+(D&(.,(7!#$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EM!%$7!($B%$.#$E!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!#$,(+%.,#*$9G!!

/4566I2#


4/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;49.-9(-'()#-.A#)O:)%9*).,-,9&.#?9,7#-::%&-07)2#-.A#,&&(2#?7)%)# =)-29'()"#+)>)%-(#&=#,7)#%)0&**).A-,9&.2#-%)#-9*)A#-,#9*:%&>9.#(?!]%$(&!N:']O!)+*.(99G!

Q(>(+%&!*D!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%77+(99!:;4]+*)*9(7!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!,B#9!.%,(E*+6!#$>*&>(!7#9.&*95+(!)*.#(9!%$7!7*.5C($,!B%$7$E!)+%.,#.(9M!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%/*5,!/%9($(!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!)5/.!.*CC($,!)(+#*79M!,B(!+(H5(9,!D*+!C*+(!(U).#,!%$7!7(,%#&(7!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!D*+!7(.#9#*$9!/6!,B(![*%+7M!,+%$9)%+($.6!+(E%+7#$E![*%+7I9,%DD!#$,(+%.,#*$9M!%$7!#C)+*>(C($,9!*D!,B(!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!/(,?(($![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((!N^4;OG!

"*&&*?#$E!,B(!)+*)*9(7!(>*&5,#*$%+6!%))+*%.B2!D5,5+(!:;4(!#C)+*>(7!,B(!9,%,59!H5*2!%$7!?B(,B(+!


5/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4


6/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;42*("0?%!

D2/)2/'!E%/F2/' 2!&'22*("0?%!

L+*72/!B$$-2&$%@H 3%&'22*("0?%!

M2&-,!;2+'N2/C! >")(2'%E"/"#'*D"'%#)$%J",,2@/D(+%M$.(/2'?%82#'$%P":I"'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%6$)2/'!O(/*0C! E"/"#'*D%7('"*02'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%


7/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#(?!(DD*+,G!!

!


8/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

VB%&6I,(*%'0(*(+#0(2) BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB!

UB%;2'+2'#0"%C2."')#)*" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB!

;G!' WQW4';K!j PWQ8:-

3[=!W9Y!3;;A9;!"5"PY;3;!"5R!R3;4A;;3L5 ===========================================================!

4G!8 '4+"*(


9/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4Q"W35B!?6L49;;9; ============= ZU !

"??95R3]!9^!.D9!R5;>496.!?6L?L;"P ================================================================!

!

!


10/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(+$%$.(G!W%.B!95/9(.,#*$!#$,+*75.(9!,B(!#995(92!95CC%+#F(9!,B(!D%.,5%&!*/9(+>%,#*$9!59(7!#$!,B(!%$%&69#92!%$7!7#9.599(9!,B(!%+(%9!7(9(+>#$E!D5+,B(+!%,,($,#*$2!,B($!)+*>#7(9!%!.*$.#9(!%+,#.5&%,#*$!*D!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!8B(![*%+7!^*>(+$%$.(!9(.,#*$!#$.&57(9!%$%&69#92!7#9.599#*$!%$7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!+(&%,(7!,*!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!%$7!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((!N^4;OG!

!


11/143

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

8B(!48'8!#$#,#%,(7!#,9!+(>#(?!*$!4)+#&!302!0131 _!%$7!9(&(.,(7!D%.5&,6!%$7!+(9(%+.B(+9!%,!,B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!D*+!:$,(+$(,!m!Q*.#(,6!%,!K%+>%+7!P$#>(+9#,6!N+(D(++(7!,*!%9!,B(!S[(+JC%$!,(%CTO!,*!%.,!%9!#$7()($7($,!(U)(+,9G ` !8B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!?%9!%9J(7!/6!,B(!48'8!,*!)+*>#7(!#,9!*?$!%$%&69#9!D*.59#$E!*$!,B(!)+*>#9#*$9!*D!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;2!/%9(7!*$!)+#C%+6!%$7!9(.*$7%+6!+(9(%+.B2!#$.&57#$E!%!9(+#(9!*D!.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!#$,(+>#(?92!%$7!,*!95/C#,!%$!

#$7()($7($,!9(,!*D!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!#$!%..*+7%$.(!?#,B!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,!*D!45E59,!`2!0131!/(,?(($!,B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!%$7!:;4


12/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#9*+6![*%+7!e(C/(+!%$7!Q($#*+!'(9(%+.B(+!X($76!Q(&,F(+!#9!%!+()+(9($,%,#>(!*D!,B(!#*59&6!?*+J(7!?#,B!:;4($5(!D*+!(%+&6!C((,#$E9!%$7Z)+#*+!,*!,B(!D*+C%,#*$!*D!:;4*&>(C($,!#$!,B#9!+(9)(.,!?#,B!:;4


13/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4)%.-.0)##

]%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;!#9!%#C(7!%,!($95+#$E!S%..*5$,%/#,62!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!,B(!#$,(+(9,9!*D!E&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!59(+9T!%$7!9(,9!,B(!D+%C(!*D!+(D(+($.(!D*+!,B#9!+()*+,G!XB#&(!,B(!%+(%9!*D!+(>#(?!%+(!D5+,B(+!9)(.#D#(7!#$!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!N%o7O!*D!,B(!4*;2!$*!.*C)+(B($9#>(!7(D#$#,#*$9!*D!,B(!J(6!.*$.(),9! #**26)0#I(,(0? !%$7!0'#)/+#'")*? !%+(!)+*>#7(7G!4$6!+(>#(?!*D!:;4


14/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4 ;2'+2'#0"%#)$%,"1#,%#**26)0#I(,(0? 2!?B#.B!.*>(+9!,B(!*/E%,#*$9!,B%,!:;4 '0(*(+#0()1%*2::6)(0?%#**26)0#I(,(0? 2!?B#.B!($95+(9!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!%$7!(U(.5,#>(!)(+D*+C!D5$.,#*$9!#$!$(!?#,B!,B(!?#9B(9!%$7!(U)(.,%,#*$9!*D!,B(!:;44.+*99!,B(9(!%+(%92!:;4

)+%.,#.(92!%$7!,B(!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!!

:$!)%+%&&(&!,*!:;4(+%&!*,B(+!D+%C(?*+J9!D*+!%..*5$,%/#,62!)+*>#7#$E!%77#,#*$%&2!.*C)&(C($,%+62!%$7!9*C(,#C(9!.*C)(,#$E!)(+9)(.,#>(9G 33![5#&7#$E!5)*$!(%+(+!%$%&69(92!,B(!>%+#*59!7#C($9#*$9!*D!%..*5$,%/#,6!%9!%))(7!,*!:;4 T'#)/+#'")*? !%9!%!D5$7%C($,%&!7#C($9#*$!*D!%..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!%$!#$9,+5C($,!D*+!%99(99#$E!:;4 !(#I(,(0? !#$!,B(!9($9(!*D!.*$9(H5($.(9!,B%,!C%6!9,(C!D+*C!#$%))+*)+#%,(!%.,#*$9!/6!:;4

8B(!D#+9,!,B+((!)+*.(75+%&!C(.B%$#9C9!%+(!?(&&I(9,%/B(7!(&(C($,9!*D!:;4


15/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(+$C($,%&!($,#,#(92!>%+#*59!*/9(+>(+9!B%>(!%E+((7!,B%,!,B(!)5/.!9(.,*+!)+*>#7(9!59(D5&!C*7(&9!D*+!(>%&5%,#$E!:;4(&*)(7!%.,#>(!#$D*+C%,#*$!)*.#(9!,*!($95+(!7#+(.,!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!?#,B!9,%J(B*&7(+!.*$9,#,5($.#(9G!!

[5#&7#$E!5)*$!,B#9!%$%&6,#.%&!D+%C(?*+J2!,B+((!,6)(9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!C(.B%$#9C9!.%$!/(!7#9,#$E5#9B(7=!!


16/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4


17/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#9#/#,6!%$7!,+%.(%/#,6!*D!%$!#$7#>#75%&!#$)5,!D+*C!S($7!,*!($7T!ND+*C!#$#,#%&!#$)5,!,*!+(&(>%$,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!*+!:;4#75%&L9!#$)5,!,*!)5/.!.*CC($,9!*+!D*+5C92!*+!#$7#+(.,&62!>#%!,B(!.B%$$(&9!*DD(+(7!/6!,B(!7#DD(+($,!/*7#(9!,B%,!D((7!#$,*!,B(![*%+7L9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!

)+*.(99(9G!;*$D+*$,#$E!)(+.(),#*$9!*D!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!,B%,!,B(6!%+(!$*,!%.,5%&&6!S/(#$E!B(%+7T!#9!D5$7%C($,%&!,*!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!)5/.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!%$7!,*!,B(#+!#$,(+9(.,#*$!?#,B!(DD(.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#,6G!

!

P"#4&%:&%-,)#S&>)%.-.0)###

]%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;!C%J(9!9(>(+%&!+(D(+($.(9!,B%,!%+(!/(9,!95/95C(7!5$7(+!,B(!5C/+(&&%!,(+C!S.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(GT!^*>(+$%$.(!*D!:;4(+9(!9(,!*D!D5$.,#*$%&!%.,#>#,#(92!+%$E#$E!D+*C!9,+#.,&6!,(.B$#.%&!%.,#>#,#(9!,*!,B(!%C/#,#*59!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!(DD*+,!,*!9((J!.*$9($959!*$!)*.6!H5(9,#*$9!*D!E&*/%&!+(&(>%$.(G!:D!.*$9#7(+(7!9()%+%,(&62!(%.B!*D!

,B(!%.,#>#,#(9!5$7(+,%J($!%,!:;4#,#(9!%$7!,B(#+!E*>(+$%$.(!5$7(+!*$(!D+%C(?*+J!%$7!%77+(99!,B(!%99*.#%,(7!,+%7(*DD9G!R(.#9#*$9!%$7!9,+5.,5+(9!%,!:;4(!,B(!B#EB(9,!9,%$7%+79!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#,62!?B#&(!*)(+%,#$E!?#,B#$!,B(!&(E%&!+(9,+#.,#*$9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!:;4(+!,B(!%.,#*$9!*D!:;4


18/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4


19/143

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

#C)*+,%$,!95))&(C($,%+6!D%.,5%&!/%9#9!D*+!,B#9!+()*+,!/(.%59(!,B(6!.*$>(6!*/9(+>%,#*$9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!)(+.(),#*$!%$7!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$!*D!:;4#(?9!?(+(!.*$75.,(7!*$!,B(!.*$7#,#*$!*D!.*$D#7($,#%,6M!#$!,B(!.%9(!*D!,B(!H5(9,#*$$%#+(9!,*!^4;!C(C/(+92!+(9)*$7($,9!?(+(!%9J(7!,*!9)(.#D6!?B(,B(+!,B(6!?#9B(7!,B(#+!%$9?(+9!,*!+(C%#$!.*$D#7($,#%&G!4&&!:;4#9*+!,*!,B(!]+(9#7($,2!R($#9(!e#.B(&G!:;4


20/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

!"#F7)#/.,%&A@0,9&.#&=#6)?#(&*)C($,G!!

8B(!)+*)*9(7!)+*.(99!B%9!/(($!D+%5EB,!?#,B!.*$,+*>(+962!#$.&57#$E!.+#,#.#9C9!*>(+!#,9!7(&%692!?B(,B(+!:;4($!(U#9,G!;+#,#.9!B%>(!%&9*!+%#9(7!%!$5C/(+!*D!9)(.#D#.!95/9,%$,#>(!#995(92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!WU)+(99#*$!*D!:$,(+(9,!)+*)*9%&2!,+%7(C%+J!)+*,(.,#*$2!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((2!,B(!)+*)*9(7!C*+%,6!%$7!)5/.!

*+7(+!9,%$7%+7!D*+!*/Y(.,#*$9!,*!$(?!E8VR92!%$7!>(+,#.%&!#$,(E+%,#*$G!

D"#F7)#"OOO#C&*-9.#4-2)#-.A#/4566#C)0929&.NQ-89.


21/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#(?!#$!011lZ,B(!D#+9,!95.B!+(H5(9,!,*!/(!B(%+7!/(D*+(!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&!N:']O!#$!:;4#(?!]%$(&!N:']O2!%$7!N0O!,B(!#$,(+%.,#*$!/(,?(($!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((!N^4;O!%$7!,B(!:;4

K"#F7)#C6+N4VEF#$%&:&2-(#

:;4#(?9!?#,B!,B(!R#(?!*D!,B(9(!C%,(+#%&9!95EE(9,9!,B+((!J(6!#995(9!5$7(+&6#$E!,B(!.*$,+*>(+96=!N3O!,B(!C(+#,9!%$7!.&%+#,6!*D!:;4


22/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#(?!]%$(&2!%$7!Q5))*+,#$E!-+E%$#F%,#*$92!%9!?(&&!%9!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(![6&%?9!7(D#$(!,B(!#$,(+D%.(9!%C*$E!,B(9(!/*7#(9G!!

&'2*"$6'#,%(//6"/ =!4$%&6,#.%&&6!7#9,#$.,!D+*C!9,+5.,5+%&!#995(9!%+(!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!)+*.(75+(9!?#,B#$!%!E#>($!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!D+%C(?*+JG!:995(9!#$!,B#9!.%,(E*+6!#$.&57(!.*$.(+$9!%/*5,!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!?#,B#$!%!E#>($!9,+5.,5+(!N(GEG2!.&%+#,62!,#C($(992!*+!)+(7#.,%/#,6!*D!7(.#9#*$9O!%$7!?B($!%$7!B*?!#$D*+C%,#*$!D&*?92!%$7!%,!?B%,!H5%,62!/(,?(($!,B(!7#DD(+($,!:;4

#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!7#9.&*95+(!+(H5(9,9!#9!%$*,B(+G!! >6I/0#)0(."%(//6"/]% 4!,B#+7!.%,(E*+6!*D!#995(9!.*$.(+$9!,B(!95/9,%$.(!*D!:;4

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

+(>#(?(72!,B(6!$((7!,*!/(!%77+(99(7!#$!%))+*)+#%,(!?%692!D*+!(U%C)&(2!/6!/%&%$.#$E!#$D*+C%,#*$!%96CC(,+#(9!#$!.%9(!*D!SC(+(T!)(+.(),#*$!#995(92!+(E%+7&(99!*D!,B(#+!95/9,%$,#>(!C(+#,9G!!

!


23/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#*59!9(.,#*$!,B+*5EB!,B(!&($9!*D!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;2!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!.&59,(+!C%,+#U!(C(+E(9=!

! ;'/%#'%/(+! ?/$#2-%/(+! ;%)0'(&'*72!!

./(&01(/2,!!N.+*99I9(.,#*$%&O=!4*;!kG3!!

8+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,9! :$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!! WU(C),#*$9!! :$D*+C%,#*$!7(9#E$!

N%.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6O!?%)+*#!?(/'*#*1('*$&C!#$.&57#$E!)5/.!#$)5,!C(.B%$#9C9!!N.+*99I9(.,#*$%&O=!4*;!kG3!%$7!kG3N.O!!

:$.*+)*+%,#$E!)5/.!#$)5,!#$,*!:;4 #(?!

*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!!

8+%$9)%+($.6!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!

[*%+7IQ,%DD!#$,(+%.,#*$! R(D#$#,#*$!*D!^4;!

%7>#.(! [*%+7I^4;!#$,(+%.,#*$!!

-P8Q:RW!-"!Q;-]W!-"!'Wi:WX!

!

8B(!D*&&*?#$E!9(.,#*$!%77+(99(9!%&&!*D!,B(9(!J(6!#995(92!9,%+,#$E!?#,B!,B(!.+*99I9(.,#*$%&!,B(C%,#.!%+(%9!%9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;Z,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!)5/.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!N#$.&57#$E!)5/.!#$)5,!C(.B%$#9C9OZD*&&*?(7!/6!C*+(!9)(.#D#.!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*![*%+7!E*>(+$%$.(!%$7!+*&(!*D!,B(!^4;!%9!9)(.#D#(7!#$!kG3!N%o/O!*D!,B(!4*;G!!

!


24/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4


25/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4-,9&.2#-.A#E)0&**).A-,9&.2#

T=V!3&I$/

:;4(+!01!7#DD(+($,!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!)5/.&6!%>%#&%/&(!#$D*+C%,#*$!%+(!,(7!#$!,B(!R*.5C($,%+6!:$D*+C%,#*$!R#9.&*95+(!]*.6!NR:R]OG0` !:$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!:;4(&2!D*+!(U%C)&(!/6!D%#$E!,*!9,%,(!.&(%+&6!#,9!E*%&9!%$7!)+#*+#,#(9%$7!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!/(B#$7!C%Y*+![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!:$,(+>#(?((9!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!.&(%+2!+(E5&%+!)+*E+(99!+()*+,9!9,%,#$E!?B%,!7(.#9#*$9!B%>(!/(($!C%7(!%$7!?B62!?B%,!,B(!5).*C#$E!)+#*+#,#(9!%+(2!%$7!?B%,!:;4

:;4(+%&!.B%$E(9!B%>(!9#$.(!/(($!#$,+*75.(72!#$.&57#$E!9(%+.B!D5$.,#*$%,6!%$7!'QQ!D((79!%$7!%!+(7(9#E$!*D!,B(!9#,(L9!D+*$,!)%E(G!:$!b5$(!011k2!:;4(%&(7!)&%$9!D*+!%!D5&&!+(7(9#E$!*$!#,9!/&*E2!#$.&57#$E!9.+(($9B*,92!+(95&,9!D+*C!,B(!95+>(62!%$7!%$!#$7()($7($,!9#,(!%57#,G 0l !!8B#9!+(7(9#E$!B%9!$*,!6(,!/(($!#C)&(C($,(72!/5,!#9!9,#&&!%!)+#*+#,6!#,(C!*$!,B(!:;4(!(U)(+#C($,(7!?#,B!%!?#J#!D*+C%,!,B%,!#$.&57(9!S9(%+.B%/&(!?#J#!)%E(9!,*!)+*>#7(!,B(!)5/.!?#,B!(%96I,*I%..(99!#$D*+C%,#*$!*$!(>(+6!95/9,%$,#>(!+(9*&5,#*$!%))+*>(7!/6!,B(![*%+7!*D!R#+(.,*+9GT0k !!4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?((92!,B#9!)+*.(99!?#&&!9**$!/(!.*C)&(,(7G!8B(!?#J#!.5++($,&6!)+(9($,9![*%+7!+(9*&5,#*$9!D+*C!011k!/6!.%,(E*+6!N(GEG2!E8VR9!*+!47C#$#9,+%,#*$!m![57E(,O2!,B*5EB!#,!#9!$*,!(7#,%/&(!*+!#$,(+%.,#>(2!.*$,+%+6!,*!?B%,!*$(!C#EB,!(U)(.,!D+*C!%!?#J#!N,B(!?#J#!+(D(+($.(9!%$!S477!;*CC($,T!/*U!,B%,!%))(%+9!,*!/(!C#99#$EOG!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

8B(!+(>#(?!*D!)*.#(9!%$7!)+%.,#.(9!7(C*$9,+%,(9!,B%,!:;4#7#$E!7*.5C($,9!%9!,9!*D!$J9!*$!#,9!?(/9#,(2!?#,B!$%>#E%,#*$!,**&9!95.B!%9!,*)#.%&!.&59,(+92!J(6?*+792!%$7!9(%+.BG!Q5.B!#$D*+C%,#*$!7(9#E$!.B*#.(9!B%>(!%$!


26/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4$6!C(C/(+!*D!,B(!)5/.!C%6!+(H5(9,!#$D*+C%,#*$!,B%,!#9!$*,!C%7(!)5/.&6!%>%#&%/&(!N)%99#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6OG!8B(9(!+(H5(9,9!%+(!(C/(77(7!#$!%!9)(.#%&!)+*.(75+(!9(,!D*+,B!#$!:;4


27/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(!/(($!D#&(7!9#$.(!,B(!C(.B%$#9C!B%9!/(($!#$,+*75.(72!7(9)#,(!%$(.7*,%&!(>#7($.(!,B%,!95EE(9,9!%!&%+E(+!$5C/(+!*D!()#(?!%))(%&!)+*.(75+(9!%+(!*$&6!%>%#&%/&(!,*!)(+9*$9!?B*!B%>(!/(($!SC%,(+#%&&6!%DD(.,(7T!/6!%$!%7>(+9(!7(.#9#*$G!N8B#9!+(D(+($.(!&(%79!,*!%!)+*/&(C!#$!#$,(+)+(,#$E!?B%,!#9!C(%$,!/6!SC%,(+#%&&6!%DD(.,(72T!(9)(.#%&&6!#$!,B(!EB,!*D!4+,#.&(!:i!Q(.,#*$!0G3!*D!,B(![6&%?9!>(+959!Q(.,#*$!0G02!?B#.B!9,%,(9!C*+(!E($(+%&&6!,B%,!,B*9(!?B*!SB%>(!/(($!%7>(+9(&6!%DD(.,(7!/6T!%$!:;4

c-d!62#$


28/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(+2!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!(U(C),#*$!)*.#(9!&(%79!,*!9(>(+%&!.*$.(+$92!#$.&57#$E!.*$.(+$9!+(&%,(7!,*!9)(.#D#.!(U(C),#*$9!%$7!,B(!/+*%7$(99!*D!%!S.%,.BI%&&T!,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!9(,!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$9!#9!,(7!#$!,B(!R:R]!5$7(+!,B(!,#,&(!SR(D#$(7!;*$7#,#*$9!D*+!:;4


29/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

#(?2!,B(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,!9B*5&7!/(!)5/B(7!#$!,B(!4$$5%&!'()*+,G!:$!%77#,#*$2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!95EE(9,9!,B%,!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!7%,%!/(!+(&(%9(7!%9!)%+,!*D!,B(!R%9B/*%+7p:;4


30/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(+9#,6!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,!%,!%&&!&(>(&9!*D!)*.6!7(>(&*)C($,!%$7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EGT\k !4+,#.&(!:::!+(H5#+(9!:;4


31/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#7(!59(D5&!%$%&*E9!,*!7+%?!5)*$G`1 !-)($!#$$*>%,#*$!,(+%,5+(!%$7!)+#$.#)&(9!%&9*!)+*>#7(!59(D5&!D+%C(?*+J9M!?B#&(!,B(+(!%+(!/*,B!/($(D#,9!%$7!,+%7(I*DD9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!)5/.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!(DD(.,#>(!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+%.,#.(9!.%$!.*$D(+!&(E#,#C%.6!*$!%$7!95))*+,!D*+!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9!%$7!+(95&,92!#D!)%+,#.#)%$,9!D((&!,B(6!B%>(!/(($!D%#+&6!B(%+7G`3 !!!!

e%$6!*D!*5+!J(6!D#$7#$E9!D+*C!/*,B!,B(!.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!,B(!#$,(+>#(?9!D*.59!*$!7#+(.,!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!.*CC5$#,6!+()+(9($,%,#*$2!95.B!%9!#$)5,!,*!)5/.!.*CC($,9!%$7!)5/.!D*+5C9G!K*?(>(+2!,B(9(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%&9*!B%>(!+(&(>%$.(!D*+!S#$7#+(.,!+()+(9($,%,#*$TZ%$!#$7#>#75%&L9!#$)5,!>#%!,B(!>%+#*59!95))*+,#$E!%$7!%7>#9*+6!/*7#(9Z%$7!#$!)%+,#.5&%+2!,B+*5EB!9,%J(B*&7(+!E+*5)9!#$!,B(!^


32/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4-,9&.2#-.A#E)0&**).A-,9&.2#

T=V!9+*#*'*&@!?%)+*#!3&1%'!

c(d!300%20!

:995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!>*&5C(2!9,+5.,5+(2!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!:;4#E%,#*$O!*D!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!C(.B%$#9C9!.%$!%&9*!)+(>($,!)5/.!#$)5,G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

49!$*,(7!%/*>(2!:;4#(?((9!#$7#.%,(7!,B%,!,B(!$(?!E8VR!)+*.(99!B%9!/(($!9#E$#D#.%$,&6!C*+(!.*$95&,%,#>(!,B%$!)+(>#*59!:;4

*D!,B(!;W-G`0

!;*$9#7(+%/&(!)+*E+(99!B%9!/(($!C%7(!,*!#C)+*>(!+(C*,(!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!*),#*$9!D*+!/*,B!)5/.!D*+5C9!%$7!*,B(+!C((,#$E9!>#%!.B%,!+**C9!%$7!>(!%57#*!D((79G`\ !! !

R(9)#,(!,B(9(!%7>%$.(92!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!:;4#(?((9!%&9*!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!:;4(C($,T=!,B*9(!?B*!C%6!/(!#$,(+(9,(7!#$!*$(!%9)(.,!*D!:;4*&>(7G!:$!+(D&(.,#$E!*$!B#9!,(+C!%9!:;4

477#,#*$%&!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!)5/.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!C59,!D*.59!*$!&*?(+#$E!,B(!/%++#(+9!D*+!.*$9,+5.,#>(!.*$,+#/5,#*$9!,*!:;4(+9(!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!C%6!/(!%77+(99(7!/6!(9,%/B#$E!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,#C#$E2!9,+5.,5+(2!%$7!*5,+(%.BG!8B(9(!$((7!$*,!/(!(UB%59,#>(G!'%,B(+2!,B(6!?*5&7!)+(9($,!9*C(!9($9(!*D!%!.*$9#9,($,!/%9($(!N*>(+%+.B#$E!,#C(D+%C(!D*+!,B(!)+*.(99M!.B%$$(&9!*D!7#9,+#/5,#*$M!

)+*,*.*&9!D*+!.*CC($,!95CC%+#F%,#*$M!%>%#&%/#,6!*D!,+%$9&%,#*$9O!%$7!9*C(!C($5!*D!*),#*$9!N(GEG2!)*99#/&(!,**&92!)(+B%)9!,%#&*+(7!,*!,B(!,6)(!%$7!5+E($.6!*D!,B(!7(.#9#*$OG!8B(!.*$7#,#*$9!*+!7#DD(+($,!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!)*.6!7(.#9#*$9!,B%,!C#EB,!?%++%$,!)5/.!#$)5,!C#EB,!%&9*!/(!7#DD(+($,#%,(7G`` !

XB#&(!:;4%,#>(!$(?!,**&9!D*+!)5/.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!#$.&57#$E!>%+#*59!9*.#%&!C(7#%!%$7!95+>(6!7*.5C($,92!,*!7%,(!,B(6!B%>(!$*,!/(($!?#7(&6!,(9,(7G!e5&,#)&(!#$,(+>#(?((9!.*CC($,(7!*$!,B(!)*,($,#%&!*D!,B+(%7(7!9,+%#$9!*D!7#%&*E5(2!?B#.B!?*5&7!


33/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(!/%9($(!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!)5/.!.*CC($,!)(+#*79G!R#DD(+($,#%,(!/(,?(($!,B(!)5/.!#$)5,!+(H5#+(C($,9!D*+!7#DD(+($,!,6)(9!*D!:;4

W$95+(!,B%,!,B(+(!#9!%7(H5%,(!.**+7#$%,#*$!/6!:;4

Q*.#,!)5/.!#$)5,!%$7!9,+5.,5+(!.*CC($,!)(+#*79!?#,B!,**&9!,B%,!/(,,(+!D*9,(+!7#%&*E5(!

%C*$E!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!?#,B!,B(!:;4(&*)!.*$>(+9%,#*$9!/(,?(($!#$7#>#75%&92!,B(#+!.*$9,#,5($.#(92!,B(!9,%DD2!%$7!5&,#C%,(&6!,B(![*%+7G!

;*$,#$5(!,*!#C)+*>(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!,*!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$!:;4

;*$,#$5(!,*!#C)+*>(!,B(!H5%,6!%$7!,#C(&6!)5/.%,#*$!*D!,+%$9&%,#*$9!*D!+(&(>%$,!C%,(+#%&9!%$7!.*CC($,9G!WU)&*+(!C(,B*79!*D!($E%E#$E!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!>*&5$,((+9!#$!,+%$9&%,#*$G!

!

T=T!"@@/2@('*&@!(&-!6201$&-*&@!'$!?%)+*#!3&1%'!

c(d!300%20!

:;4#75%&!.*CC($,9!C%6!/(!C*+(!59(D5&!*+!#C)&(C($,%/&(!,B%$!.*CC*$!>#(?)*#$,9G!Q(.*$72!,B(!>*&5C(2!&($E,B!%$7!H5%,6!*D!)5/.!.*CC($,9!>%+6!?#&7&6G!"5+,B(+C*+(2!9*C(!.*CC($,9!%+(!95/C#,,(7!,*!,B(!#$.*++(.,!D*+5CM!.*CC($,9!,B%,!?*5&7!/(,,(+!95#,!,*)#.I9)(.#D#.!D*+5C9!ND*+!(U%C)&(2!


34/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(+%&!,+%7(C%+J!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!C%6!.*5$,!%9!C5&,#)&(!#$7#>#75%&!.*CC($,92!?B#&(!%!D*+C!&(,,(+!9#E$(7!/6!C5&,#)&(!#$7#>#75%&9!C%6!*$&6!.*5$,!%9!%!9#$E&(!.*CC($,OG!Q*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!/((>(!%$%&69(9!*D!)5/.!.*CC($,9!?(+(!*>(+9#C)D#(7G!! !

R(9)#,(!,B(9(!7#DD#.5&,#(92!9(>(+%&!*D!,B*9(!#$,(+>#(?(7!)*#$,(7!,*!,B(!C%+J(7!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!#$.*+)*+%,#$E!)5/.!#$)5,!%$7!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!:;4(&*)#$E!

%$7!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!/%9($(!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,B(!)+*.(99!.%$!B(&)!9,+($E,B($!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!,B(!D#$%&!%$%&69#9G!^5#7($(92!C*+(!7(D#$(7!,(C)&%,(92!%$7!(U).#,!.B%$$(&9!D*+!)5/.!#$)5,!.%$!B(&)!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!,*!/(!.&(%+!*$!,B(!D&*?!*D!,B(#+!.*$,+#/5,#*$9G!

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p%$%&69#9!7*.5C($,9!%+(!9,+5.,5+(7!/6!.%,(E*+#(9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!7#DD(+($,!)+*)*9%&92!#$!*+7(+!,*!7(>(&*)!%C($7C($,9!,*!,B(!R4^G!Q(.,#*$9!*D!,B(!R4^!,B%,!B%>(!/(($!.B%$E(7!#$!+(9)*$9(!,*!.*CC($,9!%+(!$*,(7!#$!,B(!D**,$*,(9G!Q#C#&%+!*),#*$9!.*5&7!/(!,%#&*+(7!%..*+7#$E!,B(!)%+,#.5&%+!*/Y(.,#>(9!*D!,B(!)*.6!7(>(&*)C($,!)+*.(99!#$!H5(9,#*$G!!

c-d!62#$


35/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4


36/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(C($,9!#$!,B(!(U#9,#$E!.B%$$(&9!%$7!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!.+*99!.*CC5$#,6!7(/(+%,#*$92!/*,B!D*+C%&!%$7!#$D*+C%&2!%+(!9,#&&!$((7(7!%,!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!$((7!D*+!/(,,(+!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(!%,!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!%+*9(!C5&,#)&(!,#C(9!#$!,B(!#$,(+>#(?9G!:$,(+>#(?((9!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!)*.6!7(>(&*)C($,!7(&%69!*D,($!9,(C!D+*C!.%9(9!?B(+(!7#DD(+($,!E+*5)9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4#(?!*D!,B(9(!#$,(+>#(?((92!(%+&6!#$,(+%.,#*$!/(,?(($!,B(9(!E+*5)9!&(%79!,*!C*+(!(DD#.#($,!)*.6!7(>(&*)C($,!%$7!#9!C*+(!.*$75.#>(!,*!.*$9($959!%$7!/+*%7(+!#$.&59#*$G!

Q*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!E+*5)9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4*.%,(7!D*+!C*+(!.*CC5$#,6I?#7(!7#9.599#*$!/(D*+(!7*.5C($,9!%+(!)5/B(72!#$!*+7(+!,*!)+(>($,!,B#9!&%,(+!S)#$EI)*$ET!(DD(.,G!

:$!9*C(!#$9,%$.(92!:;4#(?((9!)*#$,(7!,*!,B#9!E+*5)!%9!%!)*9#,#>(!(U%C)&(!*D!7#%&*E5(!/(,?(($!>%+#*59!E+*5)9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4(!%!)+*/&(C!.%59(7!/6!%!&%.J!*D!95DD#.#($,!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(!(%+(+!#$!,B(!7(>(&*)C($,!*D!,B(!$(?!E8VR!)+*E+%CG!!c#d!R*0#%00*$

4!&%.J!*D!95DD#.#($,!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7(/(+%,#*$!%,!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!)*.6!7#9.599#*$9!C%6!.%59(!7(&%69!/6!)+(>($,#$E!>%+#*59!9,%J(B*&7(+9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4


37/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

W$.*5+%E(!:;4(92!7#9.599#*$92!%$7!7(/(+%,#*$9G!WU)&*+(!

(U).#, !)*.#(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!,+#EE(+#$E!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7(/(+%,#*$!%C*$E!:;4#7(2!,B(!C%$6!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!%$7!9,%J(B*&7(+!E+*5)9!#$>*&>(72!,B(!E&*/%&!$%,5+(!*D!#,9!.B%+E(2!,B(!7(9#+(!

,*!+(,%#$!,B(!.*$9($95%&!/%9#9!*D!#,9!E*>(+$%$.(2!%$7!,B(!,($9#*$9!%$7!C#99#*$!.*$D.,9!#$B(+($,!?#,B#$!:;4(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#,6!C59,!%&9*!,%J(!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(!$((7!,*!C%J(!9*5$7!7(.#9#*$9!#$!%$!(DD#.#($,!%$7!,#C(&6!C%$$(+G!!

4,!,B(!B(%+,!*D!#,9!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!.B%&&($E(!#9!,B(!D%.,!,B%,!:;4(!*D!E&*/%&!#$,(+(9,9G!:;4

/*,,*CI5)!.*$9($95%&!C*7(&G!8B#9!#C)(9!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!C59,!/(!#$!,B(!)*9#,#*$!,*!D5&&6!5$7(+9,%$72!#$,(+)+(,2!%$7!%.,!#$!%..*+7%$.(!?#,B!,B(!#$,(+(9,9!%$7!)+(D(+($.(9!*D!,B(!:;4


38/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4-,9&.2#-.A#E)0&**).A-,9&.2#

T=V!E$(/-!#$

;*$.(+$9!?(+(!(U)+(99(7!#$!#$,(+>#(?9!?B(,B(+!,B(!)+*)(+!+%$E(!*D!9J#&&9!?(+(!%7(H5%,(&6!

+()+(9($,(7!*$!,B(![*%+7G!Q5/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!(U)+(99(7!,B(!7(9#+(!D*+!S/+*%7(+!/59#$(99!(U)(+,#9(!%$7!E($7(+!7#>(+9#,6T!#$!,B(![*%+7G!]5/.!95/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!#$7#.%,(!,B%,!9*C(!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!D((&!,B%,!%,!&(%9,!.(+,%#$!%9)(.,9!*D!,B(![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!)+*.(992!D*+!#$9,%$.(!?#,B!+(E%+7!,*!9(&(.,#*$!.+#,(+#%!59(72!%+(!$*,!,+%$9)%+($,!($*5EBM!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!,B(!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!7(.#9#*$9!*D!,B(!(!%9!,B(6!.*5&7!/(G!!


39/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(!(9,%/B(7![*%+7!7(>(&*)C($,!.*CC#,,((9G!4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?((92!:;4,%J($!D#+9,!9,()9!#$,*!,B#9!7#+(.,#*$!N(GEG2!?#,B!9)(.#%&!,+%#$#$E!9(99#*$9!*$!)%+,#.5&%+!#995(9!D*+![*%+7!C(C/(+9!/%9(7!*$!95+>(6I/%9(7!9(&D!(>%&5%,#*$OG!!

c-d!62#$


40/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

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

,B#9!)(+.(#>(7!9#,5%,#*$G!

:$!.*$,+%9,2!9*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!.*$9#7(+!,B(!E8VR!.%9(!%$!(U%C)&(!*D!+(.($,!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!,B(!D&*?!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!D+*C!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!,*!9,%DD!,*![*%+72!)%+,#.5&%+&6!?#,B!+(9)(.,!,*!B*?!)5/.!.*CC($,9!*$!,B(!E8VR!)+*.(99!%+(!95CC%+#F(7!%$7!)%99(7!,*!,B(!:;4


41/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(C($,9!;*CC#,,((G a_ !

]+#*+!+()*+,9!%$7!#$,(+>#(?!+(9)*$9(9!B%>(!B#EBEB,(7!,B(!#995(9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!%!7(C%$7#$E!?*+J!&*%7!D*+!,B(![*%+7!%&*$E!?#,B!,B(!.B%&&($E(9!*D!9(,,#$E!)+#*+#,#(9!%C*$E!C%$6!7#9)%+%,(!%.,#>#,#(9Ga` !!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

8B(!#995(!%77+(99(7!#$!,B#9!9(.,#*$!D*.59(9!*$!,B(!7#9,+#/5,#*$!*D!%E($7%I9(,,#$E!%$7!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!+(9)*$9#/#,6!/(,?(($!:;45$7(+9,**7!%$7!,%J($!#$,*!%..*5$,!#$!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!!

8B(!H5(9,#*$!*D!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!+(&%,#*$9B#)Z%$7!(DD(.,#>(!#$,(+%.,#*$Z/(,?(($!9,%DD!%$7![*%+7!#9!%!H5(9,#*$!,B%,!.B%&&($E(9!C%$6!*+E%$#F%,#*$9G!:$!C*9,!.*+)*+%,#*$9!*D!%$6!9#F(2!,B(!9,%DD!B%9!%$!#C)*+,%$,2!%$7!*D,($!)+(7*C#$%$,2!+*&(!/*,B!#$!,B(!7%6I,*I7%6!C%$%E(C($,!*D!,B(!*+E%$#F%,#*$!%$7!#$!9(,,#$E!#,9!&%+E(+!%E($7%G!:$!,B(!D*+I)+*D#,!9)B(+(2!,B#9!#$.+(%9(7!)*?(+!*D!,B(!(U(.5,#>(!9,%DD!B%9!/(.*C(!%..(),(72!,*!,B(!(U,($,!,B%,!,B(! M:"'(*#)%!#@%-)/0(060"%&'()*(+,"/%2


42/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

;*$,#$5(!,*!9,+($E,B($!,B(!.%)%.#,6!*D!,B(![*%+7!,*!)+*%.,#>(&6!%$7!>#9#/&6!9,((+!:;4

477+(99!.*$.(+$9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!%C*5$,!%$7!(DD(.,#>($(99!*D!,#C(!9)($,!/6![*%+7!C(C/(+9!*$!+(&(>%$,!D%.,ID#$7#$E2!7(/(+%,#*$2!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!%$7!*>(+9#EB,!%.,#>#,#(9G!!

:$.+(%9(!,B(!&(>(&!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!9,%DDI[*%+7!#$,(+%.,#*$9!,*!D5+,B(+!#$.+(%9(!)(+D*+C%$.(!%$7!%77+(99!)(+.(),#*$!#995(9!+(E%+7#$E!)*,($,#%&!9,%DD!.%),5+(G!

T=\!./(&01(/2,!$I!-2#*0*$&!(!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!?#,B*5,!)+*)(+&6!,%J#$E!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(#+!#$)5,!%$7!,B(+(D*+(!?#,B*5,!.*$9#7(+#$E!,B(!D5&&!9(,!*D!+(&(>%$,!D%.,9G!e5&,#)&(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!#$)5,!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!B%>(!$*,!+(9*&>(7!,B(!)(+.(),#*$9!,B%,!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%+(!$*,!/(#$E!D%#+&6!+()+(9($,(7G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

R(9)#,(!+(.($,!9,()9!,%J($!,*!#$.+(%9(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%/*5,![*%+7!)+*.(99(92!C%$6!#$,(+>#(?((9!+()*+,(7!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99!#9!*)%H5(!%$7!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!D*+!7(.#9#*$9!$*,!

D5&&6!%+,#.5&%,(7G!XB#&(!,B(!C#$5,(9!*D![*%+7!C((,#$E!%+(!)5/B(7!*$!,B(!:;4#7(!95DD#.#($,!7(,%#&G!Q5/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!$*,!,+%$9)%+($,=!S7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!?#,B*5,!%$6*$(!/(#$E!%?%+(!*D!,B(!&*E#.!59(7!,*!%++#>(!%,!,B(C!%$7!(U)&%$%,#*$9!*D!7(.#9#*$92!#D!%$62!%+(!#$%7(H5%,(GTal !


43/143

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

:$!,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$IE%,B(+#$E!)B%9(!*D!%!7(.#9#*$2!,+%$9)%+($.6!*$!C%,(+#%&9!95/C#,,(72!E($(+%,(72!%$7!.*$95&,(7!#9!7(9#+%/&(G!e%J#$E!95.B!C%,(+#%&9!)5/.!.%$!B(&)!,*!)+*>*J(!,B(!)+*>#9#*$!*D!D5+,B(+!C%,(+#%&9!,B%,!C#EB,!*,B(+?#9(!/(!*>(+&**J(7G!"%.,IE%,B(+#$E!B(%+#$E9!#$!&(E#9&%,#>(!%$7!*,B(+!)*.6!.*$,(U,9!%+(!,6)#.%&&6!*)($!,*!,B(!)5/.G!!

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

)*9#,#*$9!%$7!,B59!C%J(!)*9#,#>(!*5,.*C(9!&(99!J(&6!,*!*..5+G!-$!,B(!*,B(+!B%$72!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!C%6!/(!959)#.#*59!,B%,!,B(6!B%>(!/(($!S9*&7!*5,T!#$!%!.*C)+*C#9(!,B%,!*..5+9!#$!%$!*)%H5(!D%9B#*$G!8B#9!959)#.#*$!.%$!/(!&(99($(7!/6!,B(!.&(%+!($5$.#%,#*$!*D!+(%9*$9!D*+!%!7(.#9#*$!)*9,!D%.,*!%$7!/6!95DD#.#($,!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!($E%E(C($,!/6!,B(![*%+7!#$!,B(!5)ID+*$,!)+*.(992!9*!,B%,!,B(+(!#9!%$!%995+%$.(!,B%,!,B(!&*9#$E!%+E5C($,9!%$7!#$D*+C%,#*$!?(+(!#$!D%.,!B(%+7!%$7!C(%$#$ED5&&6!.*$9#7(+(7G!!


44/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

[(,,(+!7($(%,(!%+(%9!*D!B#EB2!C(7#5C2!%$7!C#,(7!7#9.&*95+(!*D![*%+7!#$)5,92!7(/(+%,#*$92!%$7!7(.#9#*$92!%$7!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!D*+!(%.BG!!

]+*>#7(!7(,%#&(7!(U)&%$%,#*$9!*D!,B(!+(%9*$9!D*+!,%J#$E!>%+#*59!7(.#9#*$92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!C%$$(+!#$!?B#.B!(U)(+,!*)#$#*$!%$7!.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,!%+(!D%.,*+(7!#$,*!,B(9(!7(.#9#*$9G!'(9)(.,D5&&6!+(.%)#,5&%,#$E!,B(!&*9#$E!%+E5C($,9!C%6!/(!59(D5&G!

T=`!3&-212&-2&'!627*28!

B2&2/(+!4$&0*-2/('*$&0!

:;4($5(9!D*+!+(>#(?!*D![*%+7!%$7!9,%DD!7(.#9#*$9=!,B(!-C/579C%$2!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,92!%$7!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&!N:']OG h0 !8*!>%+6#$E!7(E+((92!(%.B!C(.B%$#9C!#9!%#C(7!%,!#$.+(%9#$E!:;4(!$*,!/(($!#$>*J(7G h_ !8B(9(!C(.B%$#9C9!7*!$*,!D*&&*?!%!9)(.#D#.!B#(+%+.B6!*+!9(H5($.(!*D!%.,#>%,#*$M!#$!)+%.,#.(2!B*?(>(+2!,B(6!#$,(+%.,!?#,B!(%.B!*,B(+!%$7!C%6!/(!#$,(+)+(,(7!%9!%$!S(9.%&%,#*$!C*7(&GT!

8B(!:']!)+*.(99!#$!)%+,#.5&%+!?%9!(U).#,&6!#$,+*75.(7!,*!#$.+(%9(!:;4#(?9!B%>(!/(($!(U)+(99(7!%9!,*!?B%,!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!+%,#*$%&(!*D!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!#9!%$7!?B%,!J#$7!*D!%..*5$,%/#,6!#,!)+*>#7(9!,*!?B*CG!8B(!7#9%E+((C($,!%/*5,!,B(!)%+,#.5&%+!+*&(!,B%,!,B(!:']!7*(9!*+!9B*5&7!)&%6!?#,B#$!7#DD(+($,!,B(*+#(9!*D!%..*5$,%/#,6h` !B%9!,+%$9&%,(7!#$,*!)+%.,#.%&!#995(9!,B%,!95+D%.(7!#$!,B(!C%,(+#%&9!+(>#(?92!


45/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(!)+*)*9%&9!D*+!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!)+*.(99(9!B%>(!/(($!)5,!D*+,BG!-$(!)+*)*9%&!?*5&7!#$9,#,5,(!%!.*CC5$#,6!+(I>*,(!C(.B%$#9CG!4$*,B(+!)+*)*9%&!?*5&7!.+(%,(!%!/#$7#$E!%+/#,+%,#*$!+(E#C(!?#,B!%$!#$7()($7($,!9,%$7#$E!)%$(&!,B%,!?*5&7!9(+>(!%9!%!C(.B%$#9C!,*!*>(+,5+$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$92!#$.&57#$E!%!)+*>#9#*$!,B%,!?*5&7!*DD(+!,B#+7!)%+,#(92!95.B!%9!+(E#9,+%$,92!9,%$7#$EGha !:,!#9!*5,9#7(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!,*!(U)&*+(!#$!7(,%#&!,B(!C(+#,9!%$7!7(C(+#,9!*D!,B(9(!+(9)(.,#>(!)+*)*9%&9G![%9(7!*$!,B(!7(,%#&(7!(U)&*+%,#*$!*D!,B(!GUUU!.%9(!+(>#(?!)+*.(99!%9!+(H5(9,(7!#$!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!D*.59(7!*$!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!(U#9,#$E!:']!)+*.(992!?#,B!%$!(6(!,*?%+79!,B(!-C/579C%$!%$7!,B(!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,!)+*.(75+(9!%9!%>($5(9!D*+!(%+&6I9,%E(!7#9)5,(!)+(>($,#*$!%$7!+(9*&5,#*$G!

c(d!300%20!

8B(!:']!)+*.(99!#$!,B(!GUUU!.%9(Z,B(!D#+9,!%$72!,*!7%,(2!*$&6!.%9(!#$!?B#.B!,B(!:']!B%9!/(($!

(C)&*6(7ZB%9!+%#9(7!.*$.(+$9!%/*5,!,B(!.*9,!%$7!%..(99#/#,6!*D!,B(!)+*.(99!%$7!#,9!5,#,6!%9!%$!%..*5$,%/#,6!C(.B%$#9CG!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

Q(>(+%&!#$,(+>#(?((9!#$7#.%,(7!,B%,!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!.%$!/(!.*$9#7(+(7!%!95..(992!#$!,B%,!#,!)+*C),(7!%!+(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!*D!,B(!.%9(2!.*C)(&&(7!:;4(+9!B%>(!#$7#.%,(7!,B%,!,B(!GUUU!.%9(!+(>(%&(7!%!$5C/(+!*D!7#DD#.5&,#(9!%$7!C#,%,#*$9!#$!,B(!:']2!#$.&57#$E!#,9!.*9,$(992!%!&%.J!*D!.&(%+!)+*.(75+(92!%$7!,B(!)+*/%/&(!7#DD#.5&,6!*D!(C)&*6#$E!,B(!:']!/6!$*$.*CC(+.#%&!#$,(+(9,9G!:$,(+>#(?((9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!,B(!.*9,2!#$%..(99#/#,62!%$7!$*$/#$7#$E!$%,5+(!*D!,B(!+5$E9!*D!,B(!:']!9#E$#D#.%$,&6!+(75.(!,B(!J(B**7!,B%,!7#9)5,%$,9Z(>($!.*CC(+.#%&!7#9)5,%$,9!?#,B!%7(H5%,(!+(9*5+.(9Z?#&&!,5+$!,*!,B(!:']!%9!%!C(%$9!*D!+(9*&>#$E!,B(#+!7#9)5,(9G!'%,B(+2!#$,(+>#(?((9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!#,!?*5&7!/(!)+(D(+%/&(!,*!)+*.((7!7#+(.,&6!,*!,#E%,#*$!#$!;%D*+$#%!.*5+,9G!:,!B%9!/(($!%+E5(7!,B%,!,B#9!9,%,(!*D!%DD%#+9!D5+,B(+!+(75.(9!,B(!59(D5&$(99!*D!,B(!:']!%9!%$!%..*5$,%/#,6!C(.B%$#9C2!)&%.(9!D5+,B(+!/5+7($9!N#$!,(+C9!*D!,#C(2!+(9*5+.(92!)5/.!#C%E(2!%$7!9*!D*+,BO!*$!%&&!)%+,#(9!#$>*&>(72!%$7!+(75.(9!,B(!%..(99#/#,6!*D!%))+*)+#%,(!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!)+*.(99(9!,*!$*$IPQ!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!

:$!EB,!*D!,B(!:']L9!D#$7#$E!#$!:;e!>G!:;4


46/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(&6!B#EB!D*+!.(+,%#$!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!R(9)#,(!,B(!D%.,!,B%,!95.B!%$!*/9(+>%,#*$!#9!.5++($,&6!/%9(7!*$!*$&6!*$(!%)).%,#*$!*D!,B(!:']!)+*.(992!#,!#9!%7>#9%/&(!,*!.&%+#D6!#,9!9.*)(!%$72!#D!$(.(99%+62!,*!.*$9#7(+!%!&(99!/5+7($9*C(!%$7!.*9,&6!%&,(+$%,#>(G!!

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e*+(!)+*C#9#$E2!D+*C!/*,B!&(E%&!%$7!$*+C%,#>(!)(+9)(.,#>(92!%+(!)+*)*9%&9!D*+!/#$7#$E!%+/#,+%,#*$I/%9(7!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C9!,B%,!%+(!$%++*?(+!#$!,(+C9!*D!,B(#+!9.*)(!*D!+(>#(?M!,B(!7(,%#&(7!(>%&5%,#*$!*D!95.B!)+*)*9%&92!B*?(>(+2!#9!*5,9#7(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+()*+,G!8B%,!/(#$E!9%#72!,B(!$*$I/#$7#$E!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C9!?#,B#$!,B(!.5++($,!9,+5.,5+(!.%$!/(!C%7(!C*+(!(DD(.,#>(!/6!

B%>#$E!,B(![*%+7!C%J(!%!.5&,5+%&!%$7!)+*.(75+%&!.*CC#,C($,!,*!B(%+#$E!#,!*5,!%$7!7(%$E!?#,B!#,!9(+#*59&6G!!

8B(!&(E%&!%$7!)+%.,#.%&!C#,%,#*$9!*$!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!B#EBEB,!,B(!#C)*+,%$.(!*D!"5%#)0"!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!;+(%,#$E!C*+(!+*/59,!%$7!/(,,(+I7(D#$(7!)+*.(99(9!5)!D+*$,!D*+!)*.6!%$7!*,B(+!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E2!%&*$E!,B(!$(9!7#9.599(7!%,!Q(.,#*$!:i!;G0G\N.O!%/*>(2!?#&&!+(75.(!,B(!$((7!D*+!/%.JI($7!+(>#(?G!R#9)5,(!%>*#7%$.(!#9!E($(+%&&6!/(,,(+!,B%$! "5%+2/0 !7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$G!XB(+(!7#9)5,(9!(C(+E(2!#,!#9!%7>#9%/&(!,*!%77+(99!,B(C!%,!,B(!(%+(9,!)*99#/&(!9,%E(!%$7!,*!($.*5+%E(!%&,(+$%,#>(!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!C(.B%$#9C9ZD*+!#$9,%$.(2!.*$.#%,#*$2!$(E*,#%,#*$2!%$7!C(7#%,#*$Z,*!C#$#C#F(!,B(!(9.%&%,#*$!*D!7#9)5,(9!,*!,B(!)*#$,!?B(+(!%$!:']!B(%+#$E!?*5&7!/(!$((7(7G!:$!,B#9!.*$,(U,2!#,!#9!%7>#9%/&(!,*!#C)+*>(!,B(!)5/.L9!)(+.(),#*$!*D!,B(!

>%+#*59!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!C(.B%$#9C92!,*!9,+($E,B($!,B(!-C/579C%$L9!+*&(2!%$7!(U)%$7!,B(!E+*5$79!*$!?B#.B!%!7#9)5,%$,!.%$!#$#,#%,(!%!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,G!

c-d!62#$(7!%,!%!C*+(!95CC%+6!&(>(&G!


47/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

c(d!300%20!:,!#9!5$.&(%+!?B%,!,6)(9!*D!^4;!#$)5,9!.*$9,#,5,(!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$9!%$7!?B%,!%+(!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!.B%$$(&9!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!D*+!95/C#,,#$E!^4;!#$)5,!,*!,B(![*%+7G!8B(!^4;!%$7!,B(![*%+7!7*!$*,!B%>(!C5,5%&!7(D#$#,#*$9!D*+!,B(9(!,(+C9!%$7!7*!$*,!%E+((!*$!%..(),%/&(!C(,B*79!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!,B(9(!#$)5,9G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

4..*+7#$E!,*!,B(!:;4#.(!*$!,B(!%.,#>#,#(9!*D!:;4


48/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(!,B%,!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$9!.%$!/(!95/C#,,(7!,B+*5EB!%!>%+#(,6!*D!C(%$92!#$.&57#$E!(IC%#&2!&(,,(+92!#$I)(+9*$!/+#(D#$E9!%,!)5/.!%$7!)+#>%,(!Y*#$,!C((,#$E92!%$7!;*CC5$#H5f9G!"*+!(U%C)&(2!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B(!E8VR!.%9(2!,B(!^4;!9,%,(7!#,9!)*9#,#*$!*$!,B(!59(!*D!E(*E+%)B#.!$%C(9!%9!,*)I&(>(&!7*C%#$9!#$!9(>($!9()%+%,(!;*CC5$#H5f9!%$7!,?*!&(,,(+9!,*!,B(![*%+7!/(,?(($!-.,*/(+!011h!%$7!e%+.B!0131G!g(,2!*,B(+!#$,(+>#(?((9!9,%,(7!,B%,!9*C(![*%+7!C(C/(+9!/((>(!,B%,!,B(!^4;L9!>#(?!*D!B*?!%7>#.(!%$7!*)#$#*$!.%$!/(!.*CC5$#.%,(7!#9!*>(+&6!(U)%$9#>(!%$7!,B%,!%7>#.(!9B*5&7!*$&6!.*C(!D+*C!,B(!^4;!;B%#+!#$!?+#,,($!D*+CG!:$,(+>#(?((9!%&9*!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!#9!*..%9#*$%&&6!/+#(D(7!/6!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!

75+#$E!C((,#$E9M!B*?(>(+2!#,!?%9!5$.&(%+!#D!95.B!/+#(D#$E9!?(+(!#$,($7(7!,*!9(+>(!%9!%$!*DD#.#%&!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!*D!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$Gl0 !!!

8B+*5EB*5,!011_o011h2!?B#&(!,B(!GUUU!98VR!%)).%,#*$!?%9!)($7#$E!/(D*+(!,B(![*%+72!9(>(+%&!C(C/(+9!*D!,B(!^4;2!#$.&57#$E!,B(!^4;!;B%#+2!9($,!7#+(.,!.*++(9)*$7($.(!,*!,B(![*%+7!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!.%9(Gl\ !!Q*C(!&(,,(+9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!%)).%,#*$!%$7!*,B(+9!#$,#C%,(7!,B%,!,B(![*%+7L9!%.,#*$9!?(+(!#$.*$9#9,($,!?#,B!)+#*+!^4;!%7>#.(2![6&%?9!)+*.(75+(92!*+!B%7!$*,!6(,!/(($!%7(H5%,(&6!%77+(99(7!/6!,B(!^4;2!%$7!+(H5(9,(7!(U)&%$%,#*$!*D!%.,#*$9Gl_ !!8B+*5EB*5,!,B#9!,#C(!)(+#*72!,B(!^4;!#995(7!C5&,#)&(!;*CC5$#H5f9!,B%,!)+*>#7(7!>%+#*59!D*+C9!*D!D((7/%.J!,*!,B(![*%+7!*$!,B(!GUUU!%)).%,#*$Gl` !!:$,(+>#(?((9!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(!.*$D.,#$E!$%,5+(!*D!,B(!&(,,(+9!/6!,B(!^4;!#9!)+*/&(C%,#.2!%9!,B(!.%)%.#,6!*D!,B(!?+#,(+!?%9!$*,!.&(%+&6!7(D#$(7!N#G(G2!?B(,B(+!#,!

?%9!?+#,,($!*$!/(B%&D!*D!,B(!^4;!*+!%9!%$!#$7#>#75%&!C(C/(+!*D!,B(!^4;OG!:$,(+>#(?((9!?(+(!5$.(+,%#$!B*?!,B(![*%+7!>#(?(7!,B(9(!#$,(+%.,#*$92!%$7!?B(,B(+!,B(![6&%?9!+(H5#+(7!%$!*DD#.#%&![*%+7!+(9)*$9(G!:$!9(>(+%&!.%9(92!,B(!^4;!C(C/(+9!?(+(!7#99%,#9D#(7!?#,B!+(9)*$9(9!+(.(#>(7G!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

:,!#9!.&(%+!,B(+(!%+(!7#9.+()%$.#(9!/(,?(($!B*?!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;!#$,(+)+(,!,B(!:;4#.(!,*!,B(![*%+7!%+(!.*$,(9,(7G!:$!%77#,#*$!,*!&%.J#$E!%!)+(.#9(!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!,B(!,(+C!S%7>#.(2T!,B(![6&%?9!59(!S*)#$#*$T!%$7!S.*CC($,T!#$!%!C%$$(+!,B%,!#C)(9!,B(!,(+C9!%+(!#$,(+.B%$E(%/&(G!:,!#9!5$.&(%+!?B(,B(+!,B(9(!,(+C9!?(+(!#$,($7(7!,*!/(!#7($,#.%&!%$7!%))&6!,*!%$!(H5%&!9.*)(!*D!95/Y(.,!C%,,(+G!!

8B(![6&%?9!7*!$*,!7(9.+#/(!,B(!C(,B*79!/6!?B#.B!,B(!^4;!#9!)(+C#,,(7!,*!95/C#,!#,9!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$!,*!,B(![*%+7G!:,!#9!%&9*!5$.&(%+!?B#.B!C(,B*79!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!,+#EE(+!,B(![*%+7L9!*/E%,#*$9!#$!,B(![6&%?9!,*!,%J(!,B(!^4;L9!%7>#.(!#$,*!%..*5$,2!,*!)+*>#7(!$*,#.(!%$7!(U)&%$%,#*$!,*!,B(!^4;!?B($!,B(![*%+7!7(.$(9!,*!D*&&*?!^4;!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$2!%$7!,*!?*+J!?#,B!,B(!^4;!,*!.*C(!,*!%!C5,5%&&6!9%,#9D%.,*+6!.*C)+*C#9(G 86!!!


49/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

:$!.&*9(!.*$95&,%,#*$!?#,B!,B(!^4;2!.&%+#D6!?B%,!.*$9,#,5,(9!^4;!S%7>#.(T!*+!S*)#$#*$T!%$7!.&%+#D6!,B(!C*9,!(DD(.,#>(!.B%$$(&9!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!D*+!95/C#,,#$E!^4;!%7>#.(!,*!,B(![*%+7G!!

!

T=_=T!!E$(/->B"4!3&'2/(#'*$&!

c(d!300%20!

;*CC5$#.%,#*$!/(,?(($!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;!#9!$*,!%&?%69!9,+*$E2!,#C(&62!*+!(DD#.#($,G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!:;4

:$!.%9(9!?B(+(!,B(!^4;!#995(9!%7>#.( lk !,*!,B(![*%+72!+(E%+7&(99!*D!?B(,B(+!95.B!%7>#.(!#9!

+(H5(9,(72!,B(!%7>#.(!C59,!/(!S75&6!,%J($!#$,*!%..*5$,2!/*,B!#$!,B(!D*+C5&%,#*$!%$7!%7*),#*$!*D!)*.#(9T!/6!,B(![*%+7Gk1 !!:D!,B(![*%+7!S7(,(+C#$(9!,*!,%J(!%$!%.,#*$!,B%,!#9!#$.*$9#9,($,!?#,B!,B(!t^4;L9u!%7>#.(T!,B(![*%+7!C59,!S9,%,(!,B(!+(%9*$9!?B6!#,!7(.#7(7!$*,!,*!D*&&*?!,B%,!%7>#.(T!%$7!,+6!,*!D#$7!%!SC5,5%&&6!%..(),%/&(!9*&5,#*$GTk3 !!:D!$*!9*&5,#*$!#9!D*5$72!,B(![*%+7!#9!+(H5#+(7!,*!9,%,(!,B(!+(%9*$9!?B6!,B(!^4;!%7>#.(!?%9!$*,!D*&&*?(7!#$!#,9!D#$%&!7(.#9#*$Gk0 !

8B(!^4;!%))*#$,9!%!S$*$I>*,#$E!%#9*$!,*!,B(!:;4#7(7!,*!,B(C!G!G!G!D*+!,B(!)5+)*9(!*D!.*$95&,#$E!?#,B!,B(#+!+(9)(.,#>(!.*CC#,,((!*+!*+E%$#F%,#*$GTk` !!Q*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!*..%9#*$%&&6!/+#(D9!

,B(![*%+7!*$!#995(9!*D!.*$.(+$!,*!^4;!C(C/(+9!%$7!,B%,!,B(+(!#9!%!E($(+%&!(U)(.,%,#*$!,B%,!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!/+#(D9!^4;!C(C/(+9!*$!)($7#$E!#995(9!/(D*+(!,B(![*%+72!(U.(),!#$!#$9,%$.(9!?B(+(!.*$D#7($,#%,6!#9!+(H5#+(7G!8B(!^4;!B%9!.*$9#9,($,&6!%))*#$,(7!,B(!^4;!;B%#+!%9!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7Gka !

:$,(+>#(?((9!C%7(!.&(%+!,B%,!,B(!C%Y*+#,6!*D![*%+7!C(C/(+9!/((>(!)+(9($.(!*D!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!75+#$E![*%+7!C((,#$E9!#9!95DD#.#($,!,*!)5,!,B(!^4;!*$!S$*,#.(T!*D!)+*)*9%&9!,B%,!+%#9(!)5/.!)*.6!#995(9!%9!#9!+(H5#+(7!#$!,B(![6&%?9Gkh !!K*?(>(+2!*,B(+!#$,(+>#(?((9!$*,(7!,B%,!^4;!


50/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#$E!,#C(&6!$*,#.(!*D!)($7#$E!)+*)*9%&9!%&9*!%))(%+9!,*!/(!%$!%+(%!$((7#$E!)+*.(75+%&!%$7!95/9,%$,#>(!#C)+*>(C($,9G!8B(!^4;L9!+()(%,(7!;*CC5$#H5f9!*$!,B(!59(!*D!E(*E+%)B#.!$%C(9!%9!,*)I&(>(&!

7*C%#$9!#$7#.%,(!#,!B%7!$*,!+(.(#>(7!%!95DD#.#($,!+(9)*$9(!D+*C!,B(![*%+7!*$!,B#9!#995(G!

8B(!+(9)*$9#/#,#(9!*D!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!%+(!%C/#E5*59G!8B(![6&%?9!7*!$*,!9)(.#D6!,B(!)+*%.,#>(!+(9)*$9#/#,#(9!*D!,B(!V#%#9*$9!/(6*$7!/(#$E!S>*&5$,((+9T!?#,B!,B(!%/#,6!,*!S%,,($7![*%+7!C((,#$E92!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$![*%+7!7#9.599#*$9!%$7!7(/(+%,#*$9T!%$7!%..(99!SC%,(+#%&9GT311 !!:,!9((C9!J(&6!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;L9!7#DD(+#$E!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$9!*D!V#%#9*$!+(9)*$9#/#,#(9!C%6!5$7(+(!9*C(!*D!,B(!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!)+*/&(C9!#7($,#D#(7!%/*>(G!

c-d!62#$#9(!%$7!*/9(+>(!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!,#C(&6![*%+7!+(9)*$9(9!,*!^4;!95/C#99#*$9G!R(,(+C#$(!?B(,B(+!,B(![*%+7!%$7!^4;!?*5&7!/($(D#,!D+*C!C*+(!D+(H5($,!Y*#$,!C((,#$E9G!;&%+#D6!+*&(9!%$7!+(9)*$9#/#,#(9!#$!.*CC5$#.%,#$E![*%+7!+(H5(9,9!D*+!^4;!%7>#.(2!#$.&57#$E!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!#$!,B#9!)+*.(99G!

!


51/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4(7!D*+!,B(!4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!'(>#(?2T!4)+#&!302!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p+(>#(?I3I%)).%,#*$9I($GB,CG!\ !:;4#(?!8(%CZQ(&(.,#*$!*D!:$7()($7($,!WU)(+,!%$7!P)7%,(!*$!48'8!'(>#(?2T!45E59,!312!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I31%5E31I($GB,CG!!a!:;4#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$pB%+>%+7I9(+>#.(9I%E+((C($,I1`%5E31I($G)7DG!h!Q((2!(GEG2!b*$%,B%$!n#,,+%#$G!r:;4(7!"(/+5%+6!3`2!011l2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p,+%$9)%+($.6p%..,I,+%$9ID+%C(?*+J9I)+#$.#)&(9I31Y%$1lG)7DG!!3l !e#&,*$!e5(&&(+2!S:;4(+$%$.(!]+*Y(.,2!(C/(+!3a2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#$,(+$(,E*>(+$%$.(G*+Ep)7Dp:;4(+9#*$9G!!


52/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4%#&%/&(2T!-;MGG%8,212!"(/+5%+6!3a2!01312!B,,)=pp/&*EG#.%$$G*+Ep0131p10p+(C*,(I)%+,#.#)%,#*$ID*+I$%#+*/#I7(,%#&9I%>%#&%/&(pG!_a !:;4%+7![59#$(99!Q.B**&!]+(992!011aOG!`0 !:;4


53/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p#$7(UI*DI)5/.I.*CC($,9I01%5E31I($G)7DG!`l !Q((!'*9(&&(!VG!X#99&(+2!S;*5+,I;*$$(.,(7!e(7#%,#*$!:$!^($(+%&!;#>#&!;%9(9=!XB%,!X(!d$*?!D+*C!WC)#+#.%&!'(9(%+.B2T![D(2%>0#0"%N26')#,%2)%7(/+60"%E"/2,60(2)!3h!N0110O2!a_3oak1G!X#99&(+!.*$.&57(9!,B%,!)(*)&(!D(&,!,B%,!S,B(6!B%7!%$!*))*+,5$#,6!,*!,(&&!,B(#+!9#7(!*D!,B(!9,*+62!,B(6!)%+,#.#)%,(7!%.,#>(&6!#$!,B(!)+*.(992!,B(6!B%7!.*$9#7(+%/&(!#$)5,!#$!7(,(+C#$#$E!,B(!*5,.*C(!*D!,B(!7#9)5,(!%$7!,B(6!?(+(!$*,!)+(99(7!/6!,B(!C(7#%,*+!*+!*,B(+9!,*!9(,,&(GT!Q((!%&9*!]%,+#.J!"#(&72!(,!%&G2!S:$,(E+%,#$E!e(7#%,#*$!#$!V%$7!P9(!R(.#9#*$!e%J#$E2T!;*$9($959![5#&7#$E!:$9,#,5,(2!b%$5%+6!01312!\lG!"#(&7!

D#$79!,B%,!C(7#%,#*$!)%+,#.#)%$,9!B%7!%!S?#&$E$(99!,*!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$!C(7#%,#*$!7(9)#,(!#$7#.%,#*$9!/6!C%$6!,B%,!,B(#+!C*9,!+(.($,!(U)(+#($.(!?#,B!C(7#%,#*$!7#7!$*,!+(95&,!#$!%$!%E+((C($,!,B%,!9%,#9D#(7!,B(CGT!`k !:;4#(?!]%$(&OG!h\ !:;4(!4..*5$,%/#,62T!b5&6!0h2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I0hY5&1kI($GB,CG!:$,(+>#(?((9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!%!>%+#(,6!*D!%77#,#*$%&!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!.*$.(),!*D!%$!#$7()($7($,!Y57#.#%+6!/*76!,%9J(7!?#,B!B(%+#$E!%$7!(>%&5%,#$E!%+E5C($,9!%/*5,!,B(!:;4


54/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4($9,%C!,*!]%5&!8?*C(62!(C/(+!0\2!011`2!:;41`GB,CM!%$7!](,(+!n%$E&!,*!i#$,!;(+D2!e%+.B!3h2!011`2!:;4(+w;*CC5$#H5(G)7DM!^4;2!S^4;!;*CC5$#H5fZX(&$E,*$2T!e%+.B!0l2!011a2!B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep969,(CpD#&(9p^4;w0`wX(&$E,*$w;*CC5$#H5(G)7DM!^4;2!S^4;!;*CC5$#H5fZV#9/*$2T!e%+.B!0l2!011h2!B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep969,(CpD#&(9p^4;w0lwV#9/*$w;*CC5$#H5(G)7DG!la !:;4!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NBOG!ll !:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!aG3N.OG!lk !49!7#9.599(7!#$!,B(!)+(>#*59!9(.,#*$2!,B(!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!S%7>#.(T!#9!$*,!)+(.#9(&6!7(D#$(7!#$!,B(![6&%?92!%$7!#$!9*C(!C#,(7!.%9(9!,B#9!,(+C!#9!59(7!#$,(+.B%$E(%/&6!?#,B!S*)#$#*$GT!!"*+!,B(!)5+)*9(9!*D!,B#9!9(.,#*$2!,B#9!+()*+,!59(9!,B(!,(+C!S%7>#.(T!,*!($.*C)%99!/*,B!%7>#.(!%$7!*)#$#*$!%9!#$,($7(7!#$!,B(![6&%?9G!!k1 !:;4%&B*!V*)(9!,*!e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#2!Q(),(C/(+!a2!011`2!:;4


55/143

4..*5$,%/#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4


56/143

!""#$%&'()*)&+,'%-,./'%01'/2%"+,'&,34!556,!%,3%-212%-2%&,728)29 ,

, :;;,1$(*)",0$(?)00)#%0,>/#?,@'%$'/+,ABBC,,@$%2,DE=,ABDB,)%,#/-2/,,)-2%&)>+,?')%,'/2'0,#>,"#%"2/%,2F1/2002-,(+,8'/)#$0,0&'G2H#*-2/0,'%-,"/2'&)#%,#>,',&2%&'&)82,)00$20,?'1,&H'&,)%>#/?0,&H2,>'"&I>)%-)%J,1/#"200,K2LJL=,&H2,-/'>&)%J,#>,'%,)%&2/8)29,M$20&)#%%')/2=,

022,(2*#9NL,, 3%)&)'*,/28)29,#>,02*2"&2-,'"'-2?)",'/&)"*20,'%-,0"H#*'/*+,

9#/G0=,1*$0,&H2,"/2'&)#%,#>,'%,)%)&)'*,'%%#&'&2-,()(*)#J/'1H+,&H'&,)%>#/?0=,(#&H,-)/2"&*+,#/,)%-)/2"&*+=,&H2,&2'?O0,9#/G,'0,)&,/2*'&20,,&H2,/28)29,1/#"200L,

P%J'J2-,)%,&H2,"#**2"&)#%,#>,',/21/202%&'&)82,0'?1*2,#>,?'&2/)'*0,K)%"*$-)%J=,>#/,2F'?1*2=,34!55,1$(*)"'&)#%0=,)%-212%-2%&,/21#/&0,'%-,/28)290=,'%-,1$(*)","#??2%&0N,&H'&,2%'(*2,',(#&?I$1,'%-,1/#(*2?I#/)2%&2-,'%'*+0)0L,

Q/'>&2-,)%&2/8)29,M$20&)#%%')/20,/2*'&2-,,&H2,&H/22,"'02,0&$-)20L

,

!$JL,AE=,ABDB,R/#J/200,721#/&6, Q/'>&,3%&2/8)29,R/#"#*,'%-,

S$20&)#%%')/20,, Q/'>&,R$(*)",3%1$&,T2?#, Q/'>&,U#/G)%J,V+1#&H2020, R/2*)?)%'/+,!%%#&'&2-,

W)(*)#J/'1H+, X22-('"G,#%,!.7.,Y$/82+,,

&H2,4#??$%)&+,,

!$JL,DZ=,ABDB6,,!.7.,?22&)%J,

!$JL,A[=,\B=,ABDB6,,!.7.,W2)])%J,9#/G0H#1,

Y21&,Z=,ABDB6,,!.7.,?22&)%J,


57/143

!""#$%&'()*)&+,'%-,./'%01'/2%"+,'&,34!556,!%,3%-212%-2%&,728)29 ,

, :;2,"#%&2D&,#?,&>2,E2)F)%B,G22&)%BH,

I20)B%2-,',9/)&&2%,@$20&)#%%')/2,&>'&,)0,012")?)"'**+,

B2'/2-,'/-0,J!4,G2G(2/0H, 4/2'&)%B,"$0G)K2-,@$20&)#%%')/20L('02-,#%,012")?)",'/2'0,#?,2D12/&)02,#/,2D12/)2%"2L?#/,%#%M0&'??,G2G(2/0H,

I)0&/)($&2-,0&'??,'%-,J!4,@$20&)#%%')/20H, I282*#12-,"/)&2/)',?#/,)%&2/8)2922,%#G)%'&)#%0,'%-,

0>'/2-,',*)0&,#?,1/#1#02-,)%&2/8)29220,9)&>,&>2,!.7.H,

4#%-$"&2-,#82/,NO,)%&2/8)290H, 728)292-,'%-,"#GG2%&2-,#%,&>2,PJ,&2G1*'&2,

-282*#12-,(+,&>2,!.7.H, 728)292-,'%-,"#GG2%&2-,#%,&>2,-/'?&,)00$20,

1'12/0,1/21'/2-,(+,&>2,!.7.Q0,PJ0H, I2?)%2-,&>2,)%&2/?'"20,(2&922%,&>2,E2/CG'%,&2'G,

'%-,&>2,!.7.Q0,PJ0,9)&>)%,&>2,?22-('"C,#%,&>2,/2"2)82-,PJ,-/'?&,)00$20,1'12/0,RPJ,STA,UA,'%-,NVH,

W/21'/2-,',G2G#/'%-$G,#%,&/'%01'/2%"+,)00$20H,

W/21'/2-,',-/'?&,"'02,0&$-+,#%,&>2,)%&/#-$"&)#%,#?,%29,B.XI0H,,

Y21&H,TZA,UOTO6,,[)-&2/G,721#/&6, \22-('"C,#%,&>2,!.7.Q0,P#/C)%B,

J/#$1,.2G1*'&2, \22-('"C,#%,300$20,721#/&0,(+,&>2,

!.7.Q0,P#/C)%B,J/#$10,

I/'?&,X)0&,#?,W/#1#02-,3%&2/8)29220, 728)02-,3%&2/8)29,W/#"#*,'%-,]$20&)#%%')/20,?#/,Y&'??,'%-,&>2,J!4,

I/'?&,4'02,Y&$-+,#%,&>2,3%&/#-$"&)#%,#?,529,B.XI0,

I/'?&,./'%01'/2%"+,[2G#/'%-$G,Y21&H,ZOA,UOTO6,,I/'?&,4'02,0&$-)206,

.>2,)%&/#-$"&)#%,#?,%29,B.XI0A,012")?)"'**+A,&>2,^D1/200)#%,#?,3%&2/20&,1/#1#0'*A,&>2,3G1*2G2%&'&)#%,72"#GG2%-'&)#%,.2'GA,&>2,/#*2,#?,&>2,J#82/%G2%&'*,!-8)0#/+,4#GG)&&22,RJ!4VA,'%-,82/&)"'*,)%&2B/'&)#%,

.>2,HDDD,M*282*,-#G')%A,012")?)"'**+A,&>2,/28)29,1/#"200,R3%-212%-2%&,728)29,W'%2*V,'%-,

)%&2/'"&)#%,(2&922%,&>2,J!4,'%-,&>2,E#'/-,

.>2,I5YM4^7.,1/#1#0'*,

Y21&H,TNA,UOTO6,!.7.,G22&)%B,

Y21&,UOA,UOTO6,,!.7.,G22&)%B,

Y21&H,U_A,UOTO6,,

!.7.,G22&)%B,,


58/143

!""#$%&'()*)&+,'%-,./'%01'/2%"+,'&,34!556,!%,3%-212%-2%&,728)29 ,

, :;


59/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;!-*82/02!B/$%1!$@!0'(C2?$+-2/0!(&-!2D12/'0!9?$!?(82!)22&!*&'2/8*292-!-%/*&B!'?2!#$%/02!$@!$%/!(&(+,0*0E!.?202!*&'2/8*290!1/$8*-2!(&!*A1$/'(&'!0%11+2A2&'(+!0$%/#2!$@!*&@$/A('*$&!)2#(%02!'?2,!#$&82,!$)02/8('*$&0!/2B(/-*&B!'?2!12/#21'*$&!(&-!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$@!34"55!-2#*0*$&0!),!'?2!)/$(-2/!#$AA%&*',>!*&!(--*'*$&!'$!#$&@*/A*&B!'?2!@(#'0!$@!2(#?!#(02E!.?2!0'('2A2&'0!$@!*&'2/8*29220!-$!&$'!/2@+2#'!'?2!$1*&*$&0!$/!#$+%0*$&0!$@!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(AE!!

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

X?*+2!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!?(0!A(-2!282/,!2@@$/'!'$!/2A$82!@(#'%(+!*&(##%/(#*20>!*'!-$20!&$'!(''20'!'$!'?2!(##%/(#,!$@!'?2!$)02/8('*$&0!$@@2/2-!),!*&'2/8*29220E!

!"#$%&'$()*%+#+,+-)

3&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!),!'2+21?$&2!),!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!%0*&B!W%20'*$&&(*/20!#%0'$A*Y2-!@$/!'?2!*&-*8*-%(+!*&'2/8*2922E!4$&0*-2/()+2!+('*'%-2!9(0!$@@2/2-!'$!*&'2/8*29220!'$!(++$9!'?2A!'$!2D1+$/2!'$1*#0!(&-!*00%20!'?('!'?2,!@2+'!92/2!/2+28(&'!(&-!*A1$/'(&'!'$!'?2!F2/CA(&!42&'2/!0'%-,E!.?2!*&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!$&!'?2!#$&-*'*$&!$@!#$&@*-2&'*(+*',E!4$A1/2?2&0*82!&$'20!92/2!'(C2&!-%/*&B!'?2!*&'2/8*290!(&-!0%)02W%2&'+,!0%AA(/*Y2-!@$/!'?2!/202(/#?!'2(AE!.?2!

&(A20!$@!'?2!*&'2/8*29220!?(82!)22&!/2A$82-!@/$A!'?2!&$'20!(&-!0%AA(/*20E!!

.?%0!@(/>!34"55!0'(@@!*&'2/8*290!?(82!'(C2&!1+(#2!(0!(!'9$T0'21!1/$#200>!9*'?!'?2!$11$/'%&*',!'$!1/$8*-2!9/*''2&!/201$&020!'$!$%/!#%0'$A*Y2-!W%20'*$&&(*/20>!@$++$92-!),!(!1?$&2!#(++!9*'?!'?2!F2/CA(&!42&'2/!'2(A>!-20*B&2-!'$!#+(/*@,>!9?2/2!&2#200(/,>!0$A2!$@!'?2!9/*''2&!(&092/0!(&-!'$!-*B!-2212/!*&'$!9/*''2&!/201$&020E!3&!'?2!#(02!$@!'?2!P"4>!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!'$$C!(!)/$(-T)(02-!(11/$(#?!),!-*0'/*)%'*&B!(!9/*''2&!W%20'*$&&(*/2>!9*'?!'?2!(*A!$@!@$++$9*&B!%1!-*/2#'+,>!9?2/2!1$00*)+2>!9*'?!1(/'*#%+(/!A2A)2/0!9?$!A(,!?(82!?(-!A$/2!0%)0'(&'*(+!*&8$+82A2&'!*&!'?2!#(020E!

"++!34"55!0'(@@!*&'2/8*290!(&-!9/*''2&!/201$&020!'$!W%20'*$&&(*/20!?(82!)22&!#$$/-*&('2-!),!34"55Z0!"-8*0$/!'$!'?2![/20*-2&'>!R2&*02!\*#?2+E!.?2!/201$&020!'$!'?2!W%20'*$&&(*/20!92/2!

#$++2#'2-!(&-!(BB/2B('2-!),!34"55!1/*$/!'$!0%)A*00*$&!'$!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(AE!34"55Z0!P2&2/(+!4$%&02+>!]$?&!]2@@/2,>!?(0!(''2&-2-!'?2!1?$&2!*&'2/8*290!9*'?!34"55!0'(@@!A2A)2/0!('!?*0!/2W%20'E!

!"#$%&'$().$-$,#'+")

G$/!2(#?!#(02!0'%-,>!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!*-2&'*@*2-!#/*'2/*(!),!9?*#?!'$!02+2#'!*&'2/8*29220!^@$/!@%/'?2/!-2'(*+0>!022!'?2!_H2+2#'*$&!4/*'2/*(!(&-![/$1$02-!3&'2/8*29220`!A2A$!*&!'?2!\*-'2/A!


60/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;


61/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;%&2!$?!@


62/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;

"#$#%!!&'()*+(',!-'./*0/1.2#############################################################################

"#$#$!!-./*2/1(4!5.'!6(4101.78!9.2)70/###################################################################

"#$#"!!;*07'1/?../[email protected]*!;0(412A ##########################################################

"#$#B!!&CD!D*+(2)!(2)!E0.2.+10!F2(4?>!!AMN7AJJ3F5!FO!35.A7AJ.! N7FNFJ"B ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????!

>?R!!. 7"SA@"7T! 3JJKAJ!"5S!.HA! 3@NBA@A5.".3F5! 7 A4F@@A5S".3F5! . A"@ ???????????????????????????????????????????!

>?C!!. HA!7 FBA!FO!.HA!I FGA75@A5."B! " SG3JF7U! 4 F@@3..AA ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????!

"#G#%!!H*.A'(IJ10!K(+*8 ############################################################################

"#G#$!!EMI'*881.2!.5!N2/*'*8/!-'.I.8(4##################################################################

"#G#"!!PQ*'('0J12A!N887*8 ##########################################################################

>?; !!. HA!@F7"B3.U!"5S! NKWB34!F 7SA7! J ."5S"7S ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????!

>?P!!GA7.34"B! 35.AI7".3F5 ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????!

>?V!!35.A75".3F5"B3XAS! S F@"35! 5 "@AJ ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????!


63/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;

3&!>#'$)2/!/D(&*U('*$&!FZ5H>JT!?*&(+*U2-!(!+*0'!$?!1$+*#,!/2#$CC2&-('*$&0!$&!'E2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!&29!D.QG0AV!*&!+*&2!9*'E!34"55@0!0'('2-!#$CC*'C2&'!'$!B*&'/$-%#*&D!(&-!1/$C$'*&D!#$C12'*'*$&!*&!'E2!/2D*0'/('*$&!$?!-$C(*&!&(C20!9E2/2!1/(#'*#()+2!(&-!)2&2?*#*(+!*&!'E2!1%)+*#!*&'2/20'LI; !!.E2!34"55!S$(/-!(11/$82-!'E202!/2#$CC2&-('*$&0!*&![%&2!/D(&*U('*$&!(&-!'E2!4$%&'/,!4$-2!5(C20!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&J!'E('!-282+$1!(&-!/2#$CC2&-!1$+*#*20!'$!'E2!34"55!S$(/-L!e(#E!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&!(+0$!(11$*&'0!'9$!8$'*&D!C2C)2/0!'$!'E2!S$(/-L!V!Z5H>A!Bf*&(+!721$/'!K!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!529!Z2&2/*#!.$1KQ282+!G$C(*&0AI!"%D%0'!OA!


64/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;!

M>! N(00!28(+%('*$&0!*+%-*&B6!

28(+%('*$&!$A!'@2!/2O%20'2-!0'/*&B!E'$!-2'2/?*&2!'@('!*'!P*0!&$'!+*Q2+,!'$!#(%02!02#%/*',!$/!0'()*+*',!1/$)+2?0!*&!'@2!D5RSLT!

0#/22&*&B!A$/!0'/*&B!0*?*+(/*',J!*+%-*&B!1/$)+2?0!#(%02-!),!P0*?*+(/*',!'$!2U*0'*&B!.CD0!$/!/202/82-!&(?20ST!

0#/22&*&B!$A!'@2!(11+*#(&'!E'$!-2'2/?*&2!P9@2'@2/!'@2!(11+*#(&'!@(0!'@2!/2O%*0*'2!'2#@&*#(+J!$12/('*$&(+!(&-!A*&(*(+!#(1()*+*'*20!'$!$12/('2!(!/2B*0'/,SLT!(&-!

(!)(#QB/$%&-!#@2#Q!A$/!'@2!$12/('$/!(&-!Q2,!?2?)2/0>!

K>! 3A!(11+*#()+2J!0%AA*#*2&'+,!(--/200!(&,!$)V2#'*$&0!?(-2!$&!'@2!B/$%&-0!$A!P0'/*&B!#$&A%0*$&J!+2B(+!/*B@'0J!?$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!(&-W$/!#$??%&*',>S!

;>! X&-2/B$!(!MKY-(,!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!12/*$->!Z>! N(00!(!02#$&-(/,![U'2&-2-![8(+%('*$&!*A!'@2!(11+*#('*$&!-$20!&$'!?22'!'@2!#/*'2/*(!A$/!

'@2!*&*'*(+!28(+%('*$&>!

H>! ./(&0*'*$&!'$!-2+2B('*$&6!4$?1+2'2!(!/2B*0'/,!(B/22?2&'!9*'@!34"55!(&-!1(00!(!02/*20!$A!'2#@&*#(+!'20'0>H!

5$'!(++!$A!'@202!0'210!(/2!&2#200(/,!A$/!(++!(11+*#(&'0J!(&-!(++!$A!'@202!0'210!(/2!0%)V2#'!'$!#@(&B2!)2A$/2!'@2!1/$#200!*0!A*&(+*\2-!(&-!'@2!B.CD!1/$B/(?!*0!A$/?(++,!+(%@2->!.@2!A$%/'@!82/0*$&!$A!'@2!D"]!*++%0'/('20!'@2!1/$#200!(0!A$++$906!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

H!34"55J!PD/(A'!"11+*#(&'!]%*-2)$$QJ!^2/0*$&!MJS!_(,!*#(&&>$/BW2&W'$1*#0W&29YB'+-0W-/(A'Y/A1Y#+2(&Y`H?(,GIY2&>1-A>!


65/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;


66/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;!'?2!@5A!&(B2!01(#2!*0!(&'*C#$B12'*'*82!$/!'?('!'?2!1/$#200!*0!)2*&D!?2+-!%1!),!(!>29!1$92/>%+!8$*#20!'?('!-$!&$'!/21/202&'!'?2!9*-2/!34"55!#$BB%&*',E FF!

!"#$%&'()&*($

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

"'!'?2!U#'$)2/!KLLQ!34"55!B22'*&D!*&!A2$%+N!34"55!>(#2-!#/*'*#*0B!>/$B!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'0!9?$!#+(*B2-N!V'?2!'*B2'()+2!?(0&G'!0+*112-N!)%'!?(0!)22&!()(&-$&2-W!(&-!*B1+$/2-!34"55!'$!VX%0'!1*#I!(!-('2EW!VY2G/2!+$0*&D!>(*'?!*&!'?*0!1/$#200!(0!92!022!-2+(,!(>'2/!-2+(,!(>'2/!-2+(,NW!0(*-!$&2EFZ!!3&'2/8*29220!0%DD20'2-!'?('!'?202!-2+(,0!B(,!)2!-%2!'$!'?2!*&>+%2!$>!1$92/>%+!0'(I2?$+-2/0!9?$!(/2!>%&-(B2&'(++,!$11$02-!'$!'?2!9*-201/2(-!2S1(&0*$&!$>!'?2!-$B(*&!&(B2!

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`!'?2!3[4!?(0!%/D2-!'?2!+*B*'('*$&!$>!'?*0!2S1(&0*$&EF; !!3&!*'0!J%&2!KLLQ!4$BB%&*a%b!'$!'?2!c$(/-N!'?2!O"4!(+0$!0'/2002-!V'?2!&22-!>$/!B$/2!2>>2#'*82!1/$'2#'*$&!>$/!*&'2++2#'%(+!1/$12/',!/*D?'0W!9?*+2!0'('*&D!*'0!0%11$/'!>$/!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!&29!D.H@0EF_!!

U'?2/!*&'2/8*29220!>2+'!'?2!-2+(,0!B(,!)2!-%2!'$!'?2!$82/C#$&0*-2/('*$&!$>!1%)+*#!*&1%'!$/!'$!'?2!c$(/-G0!*&-2#*0*82&200!9?2&!>(#2-!),!(!+(#I!$>!1%)+*#!#$&02&0%0E!.?202!#$BB2&'('$/0!-20#/*)2-!>/%0'/('*$&!('!022*&D!*00%20!'?('!?(-!)22&!12/#2*82-!$/!282&!2S1+*#*'+,!B(/I2-!(0!#+$02-!0%)02a%2&'+,!/2$12&2-E!A%#?!*00%20!*+%-2!'?2!B$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!0'(&-(/-!>$/!D$82/&B2&'(+!$)X2#'*$&0!'$!&29!D.H@0N!9?*#?!9(0!-2)('2-!9*'?*&!'?2!O5AUN!*&02/'2-!*&'$!'?2!>*/0'!82/0*$&!$>!'?2!@"ON!(&-!+('2/!(+'2/2-!*&!/201$&02!'$!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!\'?202!(+'2/('*$&0!(&-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

FF!"&-/29!"++2B(&N!V529!D.H@!.*B2+*&2!A+*10N!R/%0'/('*$&!c$*+0!U82/!*&!A2$%+NW!!"#$%&'($#)'*%+) N!U#'$)2/!K;N!KLLQN!?''16dd-$B(*&&(B29*/2E#$BdKLLQdFLdK;d&29CD'+-C'*B2+*&2C0+*10C>/%0'/('*$&C)$*+0C$82/C*&C02$%+dE!!FK!34"55N!V529!D.H@![/$D/(B6!Y?('!I*&-!$>!*&'2/&2'!-$!,$%!9(&'e!NW!J%&2!KTN!KLLMN!

?''16dd1(/E*#(&&E$/Dd>*+20d1(/*0dc""f3&'/$f529O.H@0f[(/*0fKTJ%&LME1->E!FT!34"55N!V529!D.H@![/$D/(B!g1-('2NW!^(,!TFN!KLLQN!?''16dd999E*#(&&E$/Dd2&d(&&$%B2&'0d(&&$%B2&'CL_B(,LQC2&E?'BE!FZ!34"55N!V529!D.H@!U82/8*296!34"55!^22'*&DN!A2$%+N!h$/2(NW!U#'$)2/!K;N!KLLQN!?''16dd02+E*#(&&E$/DdB22'*&D0d02$%+KLLQd'/(&0#/*1'C&29CD'+-0C1/$D/(BC$82/8*29CK;$#'LQC2&E'S'E!F


67/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;

'=2!*&*'*(+!/2(0$&*&>!)2=*&-!'=2!0'(&-(/-!(/2!-20#/*)2-!*&!'9$!2?1+(&('$/,!@2@$/(&-(!1%)+*0=2-!),!34"55!*&!A#'$)2/!BCCD!(&-!E(,!BCCF GDHIGF!!3&!'=2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!'$!'=2!'=*/-!82/0*$&!$J!'=2!K"LM!1%)+*0=2-!*&!A#'$)2/!BCCFM!34"55!N/20*-2&'!7$-!O2#P0'/$@!+*0'0!Q28(+%('*$&!#/*'2/*(M!-*01%'2!/20$+%'*$&!0'(&-(/-0!(&-!1/$#2-%/20M!(&-!#$&'2&'*$&!/20$+%'*$&!1/$#2-%/20R!(0!)2*&>!(@$&>!'=2!(/2(0!Q9=2/2!'=2!1/$#200!$J!#$&'*&%$%0!*'2/('*$&!(&-!#$@@%&*',!J22-)(#P!*0!2002&'*(++,!

#$@1+2'2IRBC

!!S$9282/M!*&!*'0!E(/#=!BCGC!4$@@%&*T%U0!'$!'=2!O$(/-M!'=2!L$82/&@2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$@@*''22!VL"4H!0'('2-!'=('!*'!Q)2+*282W-X!'=*0!*'2@!0=$%+-!&$'!)2!+*0'2-!$&!'=2!Y#+$02-!*'2@0Z!+*0'!9*'=!/2012#'!'$!'=2!&29!>.[K!1/$#200MR!(/>%2-!'=('!'=2!0'(&-(/-!9(0!*&(11/$1/*('2M!(&-!/2T%20'2-!@$/2!-2'(*+!J/$@!34"55!0'(JJ!$&!=$9!'=2!0'(&-(/-!9$%+-!)2!*@1+2@2&'2-I BG!

A'=2/!*&'2/8*29220!2?1/2002-!#$/&0!'=('!),!1/$#22-*&>!9*'=!*@1+2@2&'('*$&!$J!'=2!L5\A!/2#$@@2&-('*$&0!)2J$/2!'=$/$%>=+,!/201$&-*&>!'$!#$@@%&*',!#$/&0!$82/!'=2!&2#200*',!J$/!(!>.[K!2?1(&0*$&]9=*#=!9$%+-!*+%-2!(!'=$/$%>=!2#$&$@*#!(&(+,0*0!(&-!-2@$&0'/('*&>!'=2!#(1()*+*',!$J!'=2!/$$'!'$!0#(+2!0%##200J%++,]34"55!=(0!#/2('2-!#$&'/$82/0*20!'=('!#$%+-!=(82!)22&!(8$*-2-I BB!

3&!$'=2/!*&'2/8*290M!*'!9(0!0%>>20'2-!'=('!'=2!-2+(,0!(/2!(!&2#200(/,!1(/'!$J!'=2!)$''$@^%1M!@%+'*^0'(P2=$+-2/!(11/$(#=!'$!9=*#=!34"55!*0!#$@@*''2-I B_!!

!"#$$%&'()*)+,-./$0112(13$

O(02-!$&!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'0!$&!'=2!J*/0'!82/0*$&!$J!'=2!K/(J'!"11+*#(&'!L%*-2)$$PM!34"55!*-2&'*J*2-!J$%/!QA82/(/#=*&>!300%20R!/2+('2-!'$!'=2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$J!&29!>.[K06!GH!./(-2@(/P!N/$'2#'*$&`!BH!N$'2&'*(+!J$/!E(+*#*$%0!4$&-%#'`!_H!\2#%/*',!(&-!\'()*+*',a7$$'!b$&2!\#(+*&>`!(&-!cH!.[K!K2@(&-!(&-!d#$&$@*#!"&(+,0*0I Bc!

!"#"4$$5)*6(7*)8$9):;(+;-:.$

3&!/201$&02!'$!'/(-2@(/P^/2+('2-!#$/&0!/(*02-!*&!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'0!$&!'=2!J*/0'!-/(J'!$J!'=2!K"LM!34"55!1+2->2-!'$!-*0#%00!'/(-2@(/P!*00%20!0'2@@*&>!J/$@!'=2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$J!&29!>.[K0!Q9*'=!(++!/2+28(&'!1(/'*20R!(&-!9*'=!3&'2++2#'%(+!N/$12/',!$/>(&*e('*$&0!(/$%&-!'=2!9$/+-I!A&!E(/#=!;M!BCCFM!'=2!34"55!O$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!-*/2#'!'=2!L5\AZ0!3&'2++2#'%(+!N/$12/',!4$&0'*'%2,M!*&!#$&f%'*$&!9*'=!34"55!0'(JJM!'$!J$/@!(&!3@1+2@2&'('*$&!72#$@@2&-('*$&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GD!34"55M!Q529!>.[K!N/$>/(@!d?1+(&('$/,!E2@$/(&-%@6!E$/(+*',!(&-!N%)+*#!A/-2/!A)f2#'*$&!4$&0*-2/('*$&0!*&!529!>.[K0MR!A#'$)2/!BFM!BCCDM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a@$/(+*',^1%)+*#^$/-2/^-/(J'^BF$#'CD^2&I1-J`!34"55M!Q529!>.[K!N/$>/(@!d?1+(&('$/,!E2@$/(&-%@6!\'(&-(/-0!J$/!E$/(+*',!(&-!N%)+*#!A/-2/!7202(/#=MR!E(,!_CM!BCCFM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a@$/(+*',^1%)+*#^$/-2/^_C@(,CF^2&I1-JI!GF!3&'2/8*290M!\21'2@)2/!BCGCI!BC!34"55M!QK/(J'!"11+*#(&'!L%*-2)$$PM!g2/0*$&!_MR!A#'$)2/!cM!BCCFM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a-/(J'^/J1^#+2(&^Cc$#'CF^2&I1-JI!BG!QL"4!4$@@%&*T%U]5(*/$)*MR!E(/#=!GCM!BCGCM!=''16aa>(#I*#(&&I$/>a0,0'2@aJ*+20a5(*/$)*h4$@@%&*T%2I1-JI!BB!3&'2/8*290M!\21'2@)2/!BCGCI!B_!3&'2/8*290M!\21'2@)2/!BCGCI!Bc!34"55M!Q529!>.[K!K/(J'!"11+*#(&'!L%*-2)$$P6!"&(+,0*0!$J!N%)+*#!4$@@2&'Mi!j2)/%(/,!GDM!BCCFM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a(>8G^(&(+,0*0^1%)+*#^#$@@2&'0^GDJ2)CF^2&I1-JI!


68/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;!?37.@!'$!(--/200!'/(-2>(/A!#$/&0B CD!E$/!(--*'*$&(+!*&F$/>('*$&!$&!'G2!37.H!1+2(02!022!02#'*$&!IBI!$F!'G*0!/21$/'B!

!"#"#$$%&'()'*+,$-&.$/+,*0*&12$3&)410'$

3&!E2)/%(/,!CJJKH!34"55!1/$>*02-!'$!L(#'*82+,!0$+*#*'MN!F22-)(#AO!$&!'G2!1$'2&'*(+!F$/!>(+*#*$%0!

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

!"#"!$$5(01.*'6$+)4$5'+7*,*'689&&'$:&)($50+,*);$

.G2!34"55!]$(/-!-2+2P('2-!9$/A!$&!'G2!02#%/*',!(&-!0'()*+*',!*00%2!'$!'G2!R2#%/*',!(&-!R'()*+*',!

"-8*0$/,!4$>>*''22!(&-!'G2!7$$'!R2/82/!R,0'2>!"-8*0$/,!4$>>*''22H!9G*#G!^$*&'+,!#$&-%#'2-!(!0'%-,!(&(+,_*&P!'G2!*>1(#'!$F!'G2!1/$1$02-!P.[Q!2V1(&0*$&!$&!02#%/*',!(&-!0'()*+*',!9*'G*&!'G2!Q5R!/$$'!02/82/!0,0'2>B!"!/21$/'!$&!/$$'!0#(+*&P!9(0!1%)+*0G2-!$&!"%P%0'!IUH!CJJKS!(!0'%-,!$&!/$$'!_$&2!(%P>2&'('*$&!(&-!*>1(#'!(&(+,0*0!F$++$92-!$&!R21'2>)2/!U?',"'(&",7*09''

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

CD!34"55H!L"-$1'2-!]$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!b!\2V*#$Hc!\(/#G!;H!CJJKH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d>*&%'20d/20$+%'*$&0TJ;>(/JKBG'>B!C; !34"55H!L529!P.[Q!Q/(F'!"11+*#(&'!Y%*-2)$$A6!"&(+,0*0!$F!a%)+*#!4$>>2&'Hc!E2)/%(/,!UWH!CJJKH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d'$1*#0d&29TP'+-0d(P8UT(&(+,0*0T1%)+*#T#$>>2&'0TUWF2)JKT2&B1-FB!C1$/(/,!gV12/'!"-8*0$/,!Y/$%10!E$/>2-!$&!529!P.[Q!\(+*#*$%0!4$&-%#'!3&*'*('*820Hc!Q2#2>)2/!IH!CJJKH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d(&&$%>2&'0d(&&$%>2&'TJI-2#JKT2&BG'>B!CK!34"55H!L\*'*P('*&P!\(+*#*$%0!4$&-%#'!*&!529!P.[QbX$&2!E*+2!"##200!(&-!Z*PG!R2#%/*',!X$&2!.[QHc!E2)/%(/,!CCH!CJUJH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d(&&$%>2&'0d(&&$%>2&'TCCF2)UJT2&BG'>B!IJ !34"55H!LR2#%/*',!(&-!R'()*+*',6!7$$'!X$&2!R#(+*&PHc!G''106dd0'B*#(&&B$/Pd&29TP'+-T$82/(/#G*&PT*00%20d*&-2VB#P*e02#%/*',f(&-f0'()*+*',f/$$'f_$&2f0#(+*&PB!


69/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;!'?2!@$(/-!0'('2-!'?('!*'0!-2#*0*$&!'$!#(++!A$/!(&!*&-212&-2&'!0'%-,!9(0!B$'*8('2-!),!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!C#$/&*&D!#$B12'*'*$&E/2+('2-!*00%20!0%#?!(0!-*AA2/2&'*(+!1/*#*&DF!9*'?!/2012#'!'$!1/$1$02-!&29!/2D*0'/,!(D/22B2&'0!)2'922&!34"55!(&-!'?2!$12/('$/0!$A!'?2!G)*H>!G*&A$!(&-!G$/D!/2D*0'/*20>!9?*#?!?(-!)22&!1$0'2-!A$/!#$BB2&'!*&!I%+,!JKK;GLJ !

3&!(!M2#2B)2/!N!JKK!*+%-*&D!'?2!5('*$&(+!"00$#*('*$&!$A!V(&%A(#'%/2/0>LW!".X.> LY!(&-!'?2!3&'2/&2'!4$BB2/#2!4$(+*'*$& L; !(+0$!2T1/2002-!#$/&0!'?('!34"55!?(-!&$'!,2'!A*++2-!*'0!$)+*D('*$&!'$!#$&-%#'!(!'?$/$%D?!2#$&$B*#!0'%-,!1/*$/!'$!/2+2(0*&D!'?2!M"UG LZ!!!

S$B2!*&'2/8*29220!(+0$!2T1/2002-!#$/&0!'?('!'?*0!(&(+,0*0!0'*++!/2B(*&0!'$!)2!0('*0A(#'$/*+,!#$&-%#'2->!9?*+2!$'?2/0!)2+*282-!'?2!2#$&$B*#!0'%-*20!34"55!?(0!#$BB*00*$&2-!?(82!)22&!?2+1A%+!*&!*&A$/B*&D!'?2!-2)('2!$82/!82/'*#(+!*&'2D/('*$&!)2'922&!/2D*0'/*20!(&-!/2D*0'/(/0![A$/!B$/2!*&A$/B('*$&!$&!'?*0!-2)('2>!022!C\2/'*#(+!3&'2D/('*$&F!)2+$9]G L

3&!V(/#?!JKK^>!34"55!/2+2(02-!'9$!0'%-*20!),!R&*82/0*',!$A!4?*#(D$!2#$&$B*0'!M2&&*0!4(/+'$&>!$&2!$&!'?2!*B1(#'!$A!D._M0!$&!#$&0%B2/!92+A(/2!(&-!$&2!$&!'?2!1$00*)*+*',!$A!1/*#2!#(10!$&!'?2!1/*#20!#?(/D2-!),!&29!D._M!/2D*0'/*20!A$/!02#$&-!+282+!-$B(*&0G!3&!'?202!0'%-*20>!4(/+'$&!#$+%-2-!'?('!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$A!&29!D._M0!9$%+-!C*B1/$82!#$&0%B2/!92+A(/2!),!A(#*+*'('*&D!2&'/,!(&-!#/2('*&D!&29!#$B12'*'*$&GGGG!.?2!+*`2+,!2AA2#'!$A!34"55O0!1/$1$0(+!*0!'$!*/2(02!$%'1%'>!+$92/!1/*#2!(&-!*/2(02!*&&$8('*$&GF!a2!(+0$!0'('2-!'?('!1/*#2!#(10!$&!&29!._M0!92/2!C%&&2#200(/,F!(&-!'?('!*B1$0*&D!1/*#2!#(10!B(,!?(/B!'?2!B(/`2'1+(#2!),!1+(#*&D!+*B*'0!$&!'?2!1/*#*&D!A+2T*)*+*',!$A!&29!/2D*0'/*20!9*'?$%'!1/$8*-*&D!B(&,!)2&2A*'0!'$!/2D*0'/(&'0GL^!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LN!34"55>!C"-$1'2-!720$+%'*$&0!A/$B!34"55!@$(/-!V22'*&D>b!Q#'$)2/!N!JKK;>!?''16cc999G*#(&&G$/Dc2&cB*&%'20c/20$+%'*$&0EN!C_2''2/!'$!4?(*/B(&!M2&D('2E.?/%0?>b!M2#2B)2/!N!JKK!?''16cc999G*#(&&G$/Dc#$//201$&-2c)(`2/E'$E-2&D('2E'?/%0?ENb!M2#2B)2/!NY>!JKK!?''16ccA$/%BG*#(&&G$/Dc+*0'0cD'+-ED%*-2c-$#85^UILeV4-G-$#G!L; !3&'2/&2'!4$BB2/#2!4$(+*'*$&>!C4$BB2&'0!$&!'?2!529!D._M!d/$D/(B!(&-!d/$#200>b!M2#2B)2/!NY>!JKK!?''16ccA$/%BG*#(&&G$/Dc+*0'0cD'+-ED%*-2c1-A9*@H77)RN"G1-AG!LZ!V*#?(2+!d(+(D2>!C34"55!O0!P#$&$B*#!721$/'06!f*&-*&D!'?2!V*00*&D!d*2#20!'$!'?2!d%HH+2>b!?.,4.)(("@1%3($,& !YGW>!"1/*+!JKK^>!?''16cc1(12/0G00/&G#$Bc0$+LcM2+*82/,G#ABcSS75j3MNW^W;ZNj#$-2ZY^ZYZG1-Ak()0'/(#'*-lNW^W;ZNXB*/*-lNG!L


70/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;!2#$&$E*#!(&-!#$E12'*'*$&!*E1(#'0N!$>!'?2!&[email protected]!1/$@/(E!*&!'?/22!4$EE%&*W%_0!'$!'?2!]$(/-!(&-!(!021(/('2!+2''2/!'$!`2'2/!I2&@('2D.?/%0?G!3&!Y%+,!XHH!I*/2#'$/0!1(002-!(!/20$+%'*$&!0'('*&@!'?('!K34"55!?(0!,2'!'$!#$EE*00*$&!'?2!*&-212&-2&'A!#$E1/2?2&0*82!2#$&$E*#!0'%-,!$>!'?2!-$E(*&!&(E2!/2@*0'/('*$&!E(/P2'!#(++2-!>$/!),!*'0!]$(/-!$>!I*/2#'$/0!*&!XHH;N!(&-!'?('A!K(##$/-*&@+,A!34"55!?(0!-2E$&0'/('2-!&$!(-2W%('2!2#$&$E*#!$/!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!a%0'*>*#('*$&!>$/!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!&[email protected]!!

3&!b21'2E)2/!XHH!'?2!R&*'2-!b'('20!c$%02!$>!721/202&'('*820V!Y%-*#*(/,!4$EE*''22A!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!7$-!]2#P0'/$E!0'('*&@!'?('!K'?2!$&+,!2#$&$E*#!a%0'*>*#('*$&!1%'!>$/'?!'?%0!>(/!?(0!)22&!(&!34"55D#$E*00*$&2-!/21$/'!'?('!?(0!)22&!9*-2+,!#/*'*#*F2-!>$/!>(*+*&@!'$!*+%-2!2E1*/*#(+!-('(!$/!(&(+,0*0N!(&-!(0P*&@!9?2'?2/!34"55!*&'2&-2-!'$!>$++$9!'?/$%@?!$&!*'0!#$EE*'E2&'!'$!#(//,!$%'!(&!2#$&$E*#!0'%-,G BC!]2#P0'/$E!/201$&-2-!),!1$*&'*&@!'$!'?2!'9$!/21$/'0!),!4(/+'$&!(&-!(&!d#'$)2/!XHHe!0'%-,!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2@/('*$&!),!47"!3&'2/&('*$&(+G!c2!0'('2-!'?('!Kf82&!9*'?!9?('!(112(/0!'$!)2!'?2!#$E12++*&@!)2&2>*'0!$>!#$E12'*'*$&A!34"55V0!#$EE*'E2&'!'$!$12&!(&-!'/(&01(/2&'!1/$#20020!/2W%*/20!>%/'?2/!(#'*$&!$&!34"55V0!1(/'N!(&-!-2#+(/2-!'?('!34"55!9$%+-!K/2'(*&!2#$&$E*0'0!'$!/28*29!(&-!0%EE(/*F2!9$/P!'$!-('2!/2@(/-*&@!'?2!#$0'0!(&-!)2&2>*'0!$>!&[email protected](&-!'?2&!28(+%('2!9?2'?2/!(--*'*$&(+!0'%-,!*0!/2W%*/2-GN B; !

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BH!34"55A!KL#$E12'*'*$&@D1/*#*&@D1/2+*EM!4?/$&$+$@*#(+!3&-2ZAN!?''16gg>$/%EG*#(&&G$/@g+*0'0g#$E12'*'*$&D1/*#*&@D1/2+*EgG!BQ!"&-/29!"++2E(&&A!K34"55!72+2(020!.9$!VJ?*'29(0?V!721$/'0!'$!I2>2&-!*'0!`$0*'*$&0!$&!&[email protected]! !"#$%&'($#)'*%+) A!S(/#?!CA!XHH


71/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

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

3&!'>*0!/$%&-!$?!1%)+*#!#$EE2&'0F!0%11$/'2/0!$?!(&!@C3!E$-2+!*+%-2-!(!&%E)2/!$?!3&'2/&2'!E(/V2'*&J!#$E1(&*20F!.NO!#$&0%+'*&J!?*/E0F!02+?I*-2&'*?*2-!1$'2&'*(+!J.NO!(11+*#(&'0!B*+%-*&J!)%0*&200!(&-!#*8*+!0$#*2',!$/J(&*[('*$&0DF!(&-!\$O(--,P!.>2,!(/J%2-!*'!9$%+-!V*#VI0'(/'!'>2!(11+*#('*$&!1/$#200!(&-!2&0%/2!'>('!$&+,!02/*$%0!(11+*#(&'0!92/2!*&8$+82-P!]$'2&'*(+!J.NO!(11+*#(&'!M'21>2&!7%0V$90V*T0!#$EE2&'!*0!',1*#(+!$?!'>2!02&'*E2&'0!2A1/2002-!),!@C3!1/$1$&2&'06!

!"#$%&'($")*$")+,-./,+$-&0",-1",//+'2$"'3",-0".&+$$-")*,)"*$%/."$-.4+$",%%",//%5&,-).",+$".$+5'4.6"25,7%$6",-1"#$%%85-)$-)5'-$19":$.)+5&)5-;")*$"+'4-1")'")*'.$"#*'"*,2$"/,+)5&5/,)$1"5-")*$"3'+(,%"('!'>2!'(/J2'!*0PH!QU!34"55F!G"-$1'2-!R$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!c!M2$%+FH!C#'$)2/!Y''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&a(&&$%E2&'0a(&&$%E2&'IWW&$8'EP!ZW!34"55F!G@A1/200*$&0!$?!3&'2/20'!*&!529!J.NO0FH!>''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&a1%)+*#I#$EE2&'a1%)+*#I#$EE2&'IK


72/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

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

! Y%11$/'2/0!$G!'F2!G22B!9F*#F!*+%-2-!@(&,!02+G[*-2&'*G*2-!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'0B!)2+*282-!*'!9$%+-!2GG2#'*82+,!1/282&'!&$&[02/*$%0!1/$1$0(+0N!.F2,!(+0$!&$'2-!'F('!'F2!KLLBDDD!H>3!G22!9$%+-!)2!(11+*2-!'$!'F2!K


73/143

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;2!1/$#200C!.>$02!9>$!#(&&$'!(AA$/-!'>2!?@3!A22!+*D2+,!#(&&$'!(AA$/-!'$!(11+,!A$/!$/!B(&(E2!(!.FGH!'>2,!(/E%2-C!

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

! R/$1$&2&'0H

atrt review berkman final report 20oct10 en

Documents