attendee questionnaire name affiliation/status area of study/research for each of these subjects:...
TRANSCRIPT
-
Attendee questionnaireNameAffiliation/statusArea of study/researchFor each of these subjects:Linguistics (Optimality Theory)Computation (connectionism/neural networks)Philosophy (symbolic/connectionist debate)Psychology (infant phonology)please indicate your relative level ofinterest (for these lectures) [1 = least, 5 = most]background [1 = none, 5 = expert]Thank you
-
Optimality in Cognition and GrammarPaul SmolenskyCognitive Science DepartmentJohns Hopkins University
-
Optimality in Cognition and GrammarPaul Smolensky Cognitive Science Department, Johns Hopkins University
Plan of lecturesCognitive architectureSymbols and neuronsSymbols in neural networksOptimization in neural networksOptimization in grammar I: HG OTOptimization in grammar II: OTOT in neural networks
-
Cognitive architectureCentral dogma of cognitive science:Cognition is computationBut what type of computation?What exactly is computation, and what work must it do in cognitive science?
-
ComputationFunctions, cognitivePixels objects locations [low- to high-level vision]Sound stream word string [phonetics + ]Word string parse tree [syntax]Underlying form surface form [phonology]petit copain: /ptit + kop/ [p.ti.ko.p]petit ami: /ptit + ami/ [p.ti.ta.mi]Reduction of complex procedures for evaluating functions to combinations of primitive operationsComputational architecture: Operations: primitives + combinatorsData
-
Symbolic ComputationComputational architecture: Operations: primitives + combinatorsData The Pure Symbolic Architecture (PSA)Data: strings, (binary) trees, graphs, OperationsPrimitivesConcatenate (string, tree) = consFirst-member(string); left-subtree(tree) = ex0 CombinatorsComposition: f(x) =def g(h(x)))IF(x = A) THEN ELSE
-
PassiveFew leaders are admired by George admire(George, few leaders)(s) = cons(ex1(ex0(ex1(s))), cons(ex1(ex1(ex1(s))), ex0(s))) But for cognition, need a reduction to a very different computational architecture
-
The cognitive architecture: The connectionist hypothesisRepresentations: Distributed activation patternsPrimitive operations (e.g.)Multiplication of activations by synaptic weightsSummation of weighted activation valuesNon-linear transfer functions Combination: Massive parallelism PDP ComputationAt the lowest computational level of the mind/brain
-
Criticism of PDP (e.g., neuroscientists)
Much too simple Misguided. Relevant complaint: Much too complex Target of computational reduction must be within the scope of neural computation. Confusion between two questions
-
The cognitive questionfor neuroscienceWhat is the function of each component of the nervous system? Our question is quite different.
-
The neural question for cognitive science
How are complex cognitive functions computed by a mass of numerical processors like neuronseach very simple, slow, and imprecise relative to the components that have traditionally been used to construct powerful, general-purpose computational systems? How does the structure arise that enables such a medium to achieve cognitive computation?
-
The ICS HypothesisThe Integrated Connectionist/Symbolic Cognitive Architecture (ICS)In higher cognitive domains, representations and fuctions are well approximated by symbolic computationThe Connectionist Hypothesis is correctThus, cognitive theory must supply a computational reduction of symbolic functions to PDP computation
-
PassiveNet
-
The ICS IsomorphismTensor product representationsTensorial networks
-
Within-level compositionalityW =Wcons0[Wex1Wex0Wex1] + Wcons1[Wcons0(Wex1Wex1Wex1)+Wcons1(Wex0)](s) = cons(ex1(ex0(ex1(s))), cons(ex1(ex1(ex1(s))), ex0(s))) Between-level reduction
-
Levels
-
The ICS Architecturedog+sAdgz
RepresentationGrammar G Function Algorithm AConstraints: NOCODAoptimal: optimal:Activation PatternConnection WeightsHarmony OptimizationSpreading Activation
Chart6
0.031250.031250.031250.03125
-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125
-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125
0.031250.031250.031250.03125
-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125
0.031250.031250.031250.03125
0.031250.031250.031250.03125
-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (X B)
Sheet1
X' = X+X* = XTr0*r1*u0*u1*
r01111u00.50.50.50.5
r11-11-1u10.5-0.50.5-0.5
X'*Y'*A'*B'*
X11110.250.250.250.25X'0.250.250.250.25
Y1-11-10.25-0.250.25-0.25Y'0.25-0.250.25-0.25
A11-1-10.250.25-0.25-0.25A'0.250.25-0.25-0.25
B1-1-110.25-0.25-0.250.25B'0.25-0.25-0.250.25
(X'xu0)*0.1250.1250.1250.125(X'xu1)*0.1250.1250.1250.125
0.1250.1250.1250.125-0.125-0.125-0.125-0.125
(Y'xu0)*0.125-0.1250.125-0.125(Y'xu1)*0.125-0.1250.125-0.125
0.125-0.1250.125-0.125-0.1250.125-0.1250.125
(A'xu0)*0.1250.125-0.125-0.125(A'xu1)*0.1250.125-0.125-0.125
0.1250.125-0.125-0.125-0.125-0.1250.1250.125
(B'xu0)*0.125-0.125-0.1250.125(B'xu1)*0.125-0.125-0.1250.125
0.125-0.125-0.1250.125-0.1250.1250.125-0.125
(X'xu0)*0.1250.1250.1250.1250.1250.1250.1250.125
(Y'xu0)*0.125-0.1250.125-0.1250.125-0.1250.125-0.125
(A'xu0)*0.1250.125-0.125-0.1250.1250.125-0.125-0.125
(B'xu0)*0.125-0.125-0.1250.1250.125-0.125-0.1250.125
(X'xu1)*0.1250.1250.1250.125-0.125-0.125-0.125-0.125
(Y'xu1)*0.125-0.1250.125-0.125-0.1250.125-0.1250.125
(A'xu1)*0.1250.125-0.125-0.125-0.125-0.1250.1250.125
(B'xu1)*0.125-0.125-0.1250.125-0.1250.1250.125-0.125
Axr011-1-1Axr011-1-111-1-1
11-1-1
Bxr01-1-11Bxr01-1-111-1-11
1-1-11
Axr111-1-1Axr111-1-1-1-111
-1-111
Bxr11-1-11Bxr11-1-11-111-1
-111-1
a=X+Axr0111111-1-111-1-1
Wa0.250.250.250.250.250-0.25000.250-0.25
a'Wa2
W(0,1)0.1250-0.12500000
000000.1250-0.125
0.1250-0.12500000
000000.1250-0.125
X'(A'xu0)*0.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.03125X A B0.06250-0.0625000.06250-0.0625
0.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.06250-0.0625000.06250-0.0625
0.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.06250-0.0625000.06250-0.0625
0.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.06250-0.0625000.06250-0.0625
X'(B'xu1)*0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125
0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125
0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125
0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125
Y'(B'xu0)*0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.03125Y B A0.06250-0.062500-0.062500.0625
-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.062500.0625000.06250-0.0625
0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.06250-0.062500-0.062500.0625
-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.062500.0625000.06250-0.0625
Y'(A'xu1)*0.031250.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125
-0.03125-0.031250.031250.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.03125
0.031250.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.03125-0.031250.031250.03125
-0.03125-0.031250.031250.031250.031250.03125-0.03125-0.03125
11111111
22222222
33333333
44444444
55555555
66666666
77777777
88888888
99999999
1010101010101010
1111111111111111
1212121212121212
12345678
123456789101112
U1U2U3U4U10U20U30U40U11U21U31U41
X111100000000
Y1-11-100000000
A11-1-100000000
B1-1-1100000000
A 000011-1-111-1-1
B 00001-1-111-1-11
A000011-1-1-1-111
B 00001-1-11-111-1
AB000020-20020-2
BA000020-200-202
XAB111120-20020-2
YBA1-11-120-200-202
111111111111
222222222222
333333333333
444444444444
555555555555
666666666666
777777777777
888888888888
999999999999
101010101010101010101010
111111111111111111111111
121212121212121212121212
123456789101112
Sheet1
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W (Total)
Sheet2
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(X --> A --)
Sheet3
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(X --> -- B)
Sheet3 (2)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(Y --> B --)
Sheet3 (3)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(Y --> -- A)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(Y --> -- A)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(Y --> B --)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(X --> -- B)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W(X --> A --)
Depth-1 units
Weight
Depth-0 units
W (Total)
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (X A B, Y B A)
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (X A )
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (X B)
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (Y B )
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (Y A)
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (X A B)
1
2
3
4
Depth-1 Units
Weight
Depth-0 Units
W (Y B A)
X
Y
A
B
A
B
A
B
AB
BA
XAB
YBA
X
A
A
A
AB
XAB
X
Y
A
B
A
B
A
B
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (X A B, Y B A)
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (X A B)
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (Y B A)
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (X B)
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (Y B )
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (X A )
Depth-1 Units
Depth-0 Units
W (Y A)
YBA
XAB
BA
AB
B
A
B
A
B
A
Y
X
Units
Representations
tTHa(0) -- #1#2#3#4a(1) -- #5#6#7#8#9#10#11#12[Wa](0)[Wa](1)p(0)p(1)Update n
00.00110000020-20020-20.50.50.50.5000000000.51249739650.51249739650.51249739650.51249739650.50.50.50.50.50.50.50.56
10.0019.990000020-20020-20.50.50.50.5000000000.51250990120.51250990120.51250990120.51250990120.50.50.50.50.50.50.50.58
dtepsilon
0.051X1111
X'0.250.250.250.25
iterationtHa(0) -- #1#2#3#4a(1) -- #5#6#7#8#9#10#11#12[Wa](0)[Wa](1)
00000020-20020-20.50.50.50.500000000
10.0500.0250.0250.0250.02520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.006250-0.00625000.006250-0.00625
20.10.10.048750.048750.048750.0487520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.01218750-0.0121875000.01218750-0.0121875
30.150.1950.07131250.07131250.07131250.071312520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.0178281250-0.017828125000.0178281250-0.017828125
40.20.285250.0927468750.0927468750.0927468750.09274687520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.02318671880-0.0231867188000.02318671880-0.0231867188
50.250.37098750.11310953120.11310953120.11310953120.113109531220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.02827738280-0.0282773828000.02827738280-0.0282773828
60.30.4524381250.13245405470.13245405470.13245405470.132454054720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.03311351370-0.0331135137000.03311351370-0.0331135137
70.350.52981621880.1508313520.1508313520.1508313520.15083135220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.0377078380-0.037707838000.0377078380-0.037707838
80.40.60332540780.16828978440.16828978440.16828978440.168289784420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.04207244610-0.0420724461000.04207244610-0.0420724461
90.450.67315913740.18487529510.18487529510.18487529510.184875295120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.04621882380-0.0462188238000.04621882380-0.0462188238
100.50.73950118060.20063153040.20063153040.20063153040.200631530420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.05015788260-0.0501578826000.05015788260-0.0501578826
110.550.80252612150.21559995390.21559995390.21559995390.215599953920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.05389998850-0.0538999885000.05389998850-0.0538999885
120.60.86239981540.22981995620.22981995620.22981995620.229819956220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.0574549890-0.057454989000.0574549890-0.057454989
130.650.91927982470.24332895840.24332895840.24332895840.243328958420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.06083223960-0.0608322396000.06083223960-0.0608322396
140.70.97331583340.25616251040.25616251040.25616251040.256162510420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.06404062760-0.0640406276000.06404062760-0.0640406276
150.751.02465004180.26835438490.26835438490.26835438490.268354384920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.06708859620-0.0670885962000.06708859620-0.0670885962
160.81.07341753970.27993666570.27993666570.27993666570.279936665720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.06998416640-0.0699841664000.06998416640-0.0699841664
170.851.11974666270.29093983240.29093983240.29093983240.290939832420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.07273495810-0.0727349581000.07273495810-0.0727349581
180.91.16375932960.30139284080.30139284080.30139284080.301392840820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.07534821020-0.0753482102000.07534821020-0.0753482102
190.951.20557136310.31132319870.31132319870.31132319870.311323198720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.07783079970-0.0778307997000.07783079970-0.0778307997
2011.24529279490.32075703880.32075703880.32075703880.320757038820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.08018925970-0.0801892597000.08018925970-0.0801892597
211.051.28302815520.32971918690.32971918690.32971918690.329719186920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.08242979670-0.0824297967000.08242979670-0.0824297967
221.11.31887674740.33823322750.33823322750.33823322750.338233227520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.08455830690-0.0845583069000.08455830690-0.0845583069
231.151.35293291010.34632156610.34632156610.34632156610.346321566120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.08658039150-0.0865803915000.08658039150-0.0865803915
241.21.38528626450.35400548780.35400548780.35400548780.354005487820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.0885013720-0.088501372000.0885013720-0.088501372
251.251.41602195130.36130521340.36130521340.36130521340.361305213420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09032630340-0.0903263034000.09032630340-0.0903263034
261.31.44522085380.36823995280.36823995280.36823995280.368239952820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09205998820-0.0920599882000.09205998820-0.0920599882
271.351.47295981110.37482795510.37482795510.37482795510.374827955120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09370698880-0.0937069888000.09370698880-0.0937069888
281.41.49931182050.38108655740.38108655740.38108655740.381086557420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09527163930-0.0952716393000.09527163930-0.0952716393
291.451.52434622950.38703222950.38703222950.38703222950.387032229520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09675805740-0.0967580574000.09675805740-0.0967580574
301.51.5481289180.3926806180.3926806180.3926806180.39268061820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09817015450-0.0981701545000.09817015450-0.0981701545
311.551.57072247210.39804658710.39804658710.39804658710.398046587120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.09951164680-0.0995116468000.09951164680-0.0995116468
321.61.59218634850.40314425780.40314425780.40314425780.403144257820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10078606440-0.1007860644000.10078606440-0.1007860644
331.651.61257703110.40798704490.40798704490.40798704490.407987044920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10199676120-0.1019967612000.10199676120-0.1019967612
341.71.63194817950.41258769260.41258769260.41258769260.412587692620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10314692320-0.1031469232000.10314692320-0.1031469232
351.751.65035077060.4169583080.4169583080.4169583080.41695830820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1042395770-0.104239577000.1042395770-0.104239577
361.81.6678332320.42111039260.42111039260.42111039260.421110392620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10527759820-0.1052775982000.10527759820-0.1052775982
371.851.68444157040.4250548730.4250548730.4250548730.42505487320-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10626371820-0.1062637182000.10626371820-0.1062637182
381.91.70021949190.42880212930.42880212930.42880212930.428802129320-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10720053230-0.1072005323000.10720053230-0.1072005323
391.951.71520851730.43236202290.43236202290.43236202290.432362022920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10809050570-0.1080905057000.10809050570-0.1080905057
4021.72944809140.43574392170.43574392170.43574392170.435743921720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10893598040-0.1089359804000.10893598040-0.1089359804
412.051.74297568690.43895672560.43895672560.43895672560.438956725620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.10973918140-0.1097391814000.10973918140-0.1097391814
422.11.75582690250.44200888930.44200888930.44200888930.442008889320-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11050222230-0.1105022223000.11050222230-0.1105022223
432.151.76803555740.44490844490.44490844490.44490844490.444908444920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11122711120-0.1112271112000.11122711120-0.1112271112
442.21.77963377950.44766302260.44766302260.44766302260.447663022620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11191575570-0.1119157557000.11191575570-0.1119157557
452.251.79065209060.45027987150.45027987150.45027987150.450279871520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11256996790-0.1125699679000.11256996790-0.1125699679
462.31.8011194860.45276587790.45276587790.45276587790.452765877920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11319146950-0.1131914695000.11319146950-0.1131914695
472.351.81106351170.4551275840.4551275840.4551275840.45512758420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1137818960-0.113781896000.1137818960-0.113781896
482.41.82051033610.45737120480.45737120480.45737120480.457371204820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11434280120-0.1143428012000.11434280120-0.1143428012
492.451.82948481930.45950264460.45950264460.45950264460.459502644620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11487566110-0.1148756611000.11487566110-0.1148756611
502.51.83801057840.46152751240.46152751240.46152751240.461527512420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11538187810-0.1153818781000.11538187810-0.1153818781
512.551.84611004940.46345113670.46345113670.46345113670.463451136720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11586278420-0.1158627842000.11586278420-0.1158627842
522.61.8538045470.46527857990.46527857990.46527857990.465278579920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1163196450-0.116319645000.1163196450-0.116319645
532.651.86111431960.46701465090.46701465090.46701465090.467014650920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11675366270-0.1167536627000.11675366270-0.1167536627
542.71.86805860360.46866391840.46866391840.46866391840.468663918420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11716597960-0.1171659796000.11716597960-0.1171659796
552.751.87465567350.47023072240.47023072240.47023072240.470230722420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11755768060-0.1175576806000.11755768060-0.1175576806
562.81.88092288980.47171918630.47171918630.47171918630.471719186320-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11792979660-0.1179297966000.11792979660-0.1179297966
572.851.88687674530.4731332270.4731332270.4731332270.47313322720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11828330680-0.1182833068000.11828330680-0.1182833068
582.91.8925329080.47447656570.47447656570.47447656570.474476565720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11861914140-0.1186191414000.11861914140-0.1186191414
592.951.89790626260.47575273740.47575273740.47575273740.475752737420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11893818430-0.1189381843000.11893818430-0.1189381843
6031.90301094950.47696510050.47696510050.47696510050.476965100520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11924127510-0.1192412751000.11924127510-0.1192412751
613.051.9078604020.47811684550.47811684550.47811684550.478116845520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11952921140-0.1195292114000.11952921140-0.1195292114
623.11.91246738190.47921100320.47921100320.47921100320.479211003220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.11980275080-0.1198027508000.11980275080-0.1198027508
633.151.91684401280.4802504530.4802504530.4802504530.48025045320-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12006261330-0.1200626133000.12006261330-0.1200626133
643.21.92100181220.48123793040.48123793040.48123793040.481237930420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12030948260-0.1203094826000.12030948260-0.1203094826
653.251.92495172160.48217603390.48217603390.48217603390.482176033920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12054400850-0.1205440085000.12054400850-0.1205440085
663.31.92870413550.48306723220.48306723220.48306723220.483067232220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1207668080-0.120766808000.1207668080-0.120766808
673.351.93226892870.48391387060.48391387060.48391387060.483913870620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12097846760-0.1209784676000.12097846760-0.1209784676
683.41.93565548230.4847181770.4847181770.4847181770.48471817720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12117954430-0.1211795443000.12117954430-0.1211795443
693.451.93887270820.48548226820.48548226820.48548226820.485482268220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1213705670-0.121370567000.1213705670-0.121370567
703.51.94192907280.48620815480.48620815480.48620815480.486208154820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12155203870-0.1215520387000.12155203870-0.1215520387
713.551.94483261910.4868977470.4868977470.4868977470.48689774720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12172443680-0.1217244368000.12172443680-0.1217244368
723.61.94759098820.48755285970.48755285970.48755285970.487552859720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12188821490-0.1218882149000.12188821490-0.1218882149
733.651.95021143880.48817521670.48817521670.48817521670.488175216720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12204380420-0.1220438042000.12204380420-0.1220438042
743.71.95270086680.48876645590.48876645590.48876645590.488766455920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1221916140-0.122191614000.1221916140-0.122191614
753.751.95506582350.48932813310.48932813310.48932813310.489328133120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12233203330-0.1223320333000.12233203330-0.1223320333
763.81.95731253230.48986172640.48986172640.48986172640.489861726420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12246543160-0.1224654316000.12246543160-0.1224654316
773.851.95944690570.49036864010.49036864010.49036864010.490368640120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.122592160-0.12259216000.122592160-0.12259216
783.91.96147456040.49085020810.49085020810.49085020810.490850208120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1227125520-0.122712552000.1227125520-0.122712552
793.951.96340083240.49130769770.49130769770.49130769770.491307697720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12282692440-0.1228269244000.12282692440-0.1228269244
8041.96523079080.49174231280.49174231280.49174231280.491742312820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12293557820-0.1229355782000.12293557820-0.1229355782
814.051.96696925120.49215519720.49215519720.49215519720.492155197220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12303879930-0.1230387993000.12303879930-0.1230387993
824.11.96862078870.49254743730.49254743730.49254743730.492547437320-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12313685930-0.1231368593000.12313685930-0.1231368593
834.151.97018974920.49292006540.49292006540.49292006540.492920065420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12323001640-0.1232300164000.12323001640-0.1232300164
844.21.97168026180.49327406220.49327406220.49327406220.493274062220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12331851550-0.1233185155000.12331851550-0.1233185155
854.251.97309624870.49361035910.49361035910.49361035910.493610359120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12340258980-0.1234025898000.12340258980-0.1234025898
864.31.97444143630.49392984110.49392984110.49392984110.493929841120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12348246030-0.1234824603000.12348246030-0.1234824603
874.351.97571936440.49423334910.49423334910.49423334910.494233349120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12355833730-0.1235583373000.12355833730-0.1235583373
884.41.97693339620.49452168160.49452168160.49452168160.494521681620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12363042040-0.1236304204000.12363042040-0.1236304204
894.451.97808672640.49479559750.49479559750.49479559750.494795597520-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12369889940-0.1236988994000.12369889940-0.1236988994
904.51.97918239010.49505581760.49505581760.49505581760.495055817620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12376395440-0.1237639544000.12376395440-0.1237639544
914.551.98022327060.49530302680.49530302680.49530302680.495303026820-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12382575670-0.1238257567000.12382575670-0.1238257567
924.61.98121210710.49553787540.49553787540.49553787540.495537875420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12388446890-0.1238844689000.12388446890-0.1238844689
934.651.98215150170.49576098170.49576098170.49576098170.495760981720-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12394024540-0.1239402454000.12394024540-0.1239402454
944.71.98304392660.49597293260.49597293260.49597293260.495972932620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12399323310-0.1239932331000.12399323310-0.1239932331
954.751.98389173030.49617428590.49617428590.49617428590.496174285920-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12404357150-0.1240435715000.12404357150-0.1240435715
964.81.98469714380.49636557160.49636557160.49636557160.496365571620-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12409139290-0.1240913929000.12409139290-0.1240913929
974.851.98546228660.49654729310.49654729310.49654729310.496547293120-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12413682330-0.1241368233000.12413682330-0.1241368233
984.91.98618917230.49671992840.49671992840.49671992840.496719928420-20020-20.50.50.50.50.12417998210-0.1241799821000.12417998210-0.1241799821
994.951.98687971360.4968839320.4968839320.4968839320.49688393220-20020-20.50.50.50.50.1242209830-0.124220983000.1242209830-0.124220983
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
H
a
Time
X
-
Processing I: ActivationComputational neuroscience
Key sourcesHopfield 1982, 1984Cohen and Grossberg 1983Hinton and Sejnowski 1983, 1986Smolensky 1983, 1986Geman and Geman 1984 Golden 1986, 1988
-
Processing I: ActivationProcessing spreading activation is optimization: Harmony maximization
Chart4
000
0.20190762310.15313704760.16125
0.29375879590.1985962140.163846875
0.34237528730.20308326370.1658332266
0.37363255790.1923633110.1676250155
0.39756885460.17636963770.1692421028
0.41809600490.15891422560.1707015241
0.4367550540.14144314370.1720186518
0.45416879370.12448883970.1732073596
0.47060358220.10823173380.1742801684
0.48618668670.09271734640.1752483783
0.50099039930.07794020960.1761221877
0.51506462540.06387626150.1769108007
0.52844954250.05049531920.177622524
0.54118054760.03776585140.1782648542
0.55329022040.02565677310.1788445572
0.56480912970.01413809380.1793677392
0.57576619020.00318112210.1798399109
0.5861888435-0.00724149680.1802660459
0.5961031683-0.01715580830.1806506328
0.605533962-0.02658659680.1809977224
0.614504809-0.03555744190.1813109708
0.6230381421-0.04409077420.1815936774
0.6311552994-0.05220793120.1818488202
0.6388765782-0.05992920990.1820790866
0.6462212858-0.06727391740.1822869019
0.6532077877-0.07426041930.1824744553
0.6598535539-0.08090618550.1826437222
0.6661752022-0.08722783380.1827964856
0.6721885402-0.09324117170.1829343546
0.6779086041-0.09896123570.1830587813
0.6833496973-0.10440232890.1831710765
0.6885254252-0.10957805680.1832724228
0.6934487299-0.11450136150.1833638879
0.6981319222-0.11918455380.1834464352
0.7025867125-0.12363934410.1835209341
0.7068242401-0.12787687170.1835881693
0.7108551011-0.13190773260.1836488491
0.7146893746-0.13574200620.1837036126
0.7183366484-0.139389280.1837530367
0.7218060426-0.14285867420.183797642
0.7251062324-0.1461588640.1838378982
0.7282454701-0.14929810170.1838742294
0.7312316053-0.15228423690.1839070184
0.734072105-0.15512473660.1839366104
0.7367740719-0.15782670350.1839633172
0.7393442623-0.16039689390.1839874201
0.7417891031-0.16284173470.1840091729
0.7441147076-0.16516733910.1840288049
0.746326891-0.16737952250.1840465227
0.7484311849-0.16948381650.1840625131
0.7504328512-0.17148548280.1840769444
0.7523368951-0.17338952670.1840899686
0.7541480777-0.17520070930.184101723
0.7558709278-0.17692355940.1841123313
0.7575097536-0.17856238520.1841219053
0.7590686529-0.18012128450.1841305459
0.7605515238-0.18160415540.184138344
0.7619620742-0.18301470580.1841453817
0.7633038312-0.18435646280.1841517333
0.76458015-0.18563278160.1841574657
0.765794222-0.18684685360.1841626391
0.766949083-0.18800171460.1841673081
0.7680476208-0.18910025240.1841715219
0.7690925822-0.19014521380.1841753248
0.7700865803-0.19113921190.1841787569
0.7710321005-0.19208473210.1841818545
0.7719315072-0.19298413870.18418465
0.7727870492-0.19383968080.1841871729
0.773600866-0.19465349760.1841894499
0.7743749925-0.19542762410.1841915048
0.7751113644-0.1961639960.1841933594
0.775811823-0.19686445460.1841950332
0.7764781198-0.19753075140.1841965438
0.777111921-0.19816455260.1841979071
0.7777148113-0.19876744290.1841991374
0.7782882983-0.19934092990.1842002479
0.778833816-0.19988644760.18420125
0.7793527285-0.20040536010.1842021544
0.7798463333-0.20089896490.1842029707
0.7803158648-0.20136849630.1842037074
0.7807624969-0.20181512850.1842043722
0.7811873465-0.20223997810.1842049722
0.781591476-0.20264410750.1842055138
0.7819758958-0.20302852740.1842060025
0.7823415673-0.20339419880.1842064436
0.7826894047-0.20374203630.1842068416
0.7830202779-0.20407290950.1842072009
0.7833350143-0.20438764580.1842075251
0.7836344007-0.20468703230.1842078177
0.7839191859-0.20497181750.1842080818
0.784190082-0.20524271360.1842083202
0.7844477663-0.20550039790.1842085353
0.7846928832-0.20574551480.1842087294
0.7849260457-0.20597867720.1842089046
0.7851478366-0.20620046820.1842090627
0.7853588107-0.20641144230.1842092054
0.7855594954-0.2066121270.1842093342
0.7857503927-0.20680302430.1842094504
0.7859319797-0.20698461130.1842095553
a1
a2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
H
Time
Competitive Net
Sheet1
TimeInput 1Input 2Inhibdelta-tA1A1-exactA2A2-exactH
00.60.50.90.500000
10.60.50.90.50.30.20190762310.250.15313704760.16125
20.60.50.90.50.33750.29375879590.240.1985962140.163846875
30.60.50.90.50.360750.34237528730.2181250.20308326370.1658332266
40.60.50.90.50.382218750.37363255790.1967250.1923633110.1676250155
50.60.50.90.50.4025831250.39756885460.17636406250.17636963770.1692421028
60.60.50.90.50.42192773440.41809600490.1570196250.15891422560.1707015241
70.60.50.90.50.44030503590.4367550540.1386423320.14144314370.1720186518
80.60.50.90.50.45776346860.45416879370.12118389980.12448883970.1732073596
90.60.50.90.50.47434897930.47060358220.10459838910.10823173380.1742801684
100.60.50.90.50.49010521460.48618668670.08884215380.09271734640.1752483783
110.60.50.90.50.50507363810.50099039930.07387373030.07794020960.1761221877
120.60.50.90.50.51929364040.51506462540.0596537280.06387626150.1769108007
130.60.50.90.50.53280264260.52844954250.04614472590.05049531920.177622524
140.60.50.90.50.54563619470.54118054760.03331117380.03776585140.1782648542
150.60.50.90.50.55782806910.55329022040.02111929930.02565677310.1788445572
160.60.50.90.50.56941034990.56480912970.00953701850.01413809380.1793677392
170.60.50.90.50.58041351660.5757661902-0.00146614820.00318112210.1798399109
180.60.50.90.50.5908665250.5861888435-0.0119191566-0.00724149680.1802660459
190.60.50.90.50.60079688290.5961031683-0.0218495145-0.01715580830.1806506328
200.60.50.90.50.6102307230.605533962-0.0312833546-0.02658659680.1809977224
210.60.50.90.50.61919287110.614504809-0.0402455026-0.03555744190.1813109708
220.60.50.90.50.62770691170.6230381421-0.0487595433-0.04409077420.1815936774
230.60.50.90.50.63579525030.6311552994-0.0568478819-0.05220793120.1818488202
240.60.50.90.50.6434791720.6388765782-0.0645318036-0.05992920990.1820790866
250.60.50.90.50.65077889760.6462212858-0.0718315292-0.06727391740.1822869019
260.60.50.90.50.6577136370.6532077877-0.0787662686-0.07426041930.1824744553
270.60.50.90.50.66430163930.6598535539-0.0853542709-0.08090618550.1826437222
280.60.50.90.50.67056024160.6661752022-0.0916128732-0.08722783380.1827964856
290.60.50.90.50.67650591370.6721885402-0.0975585453-0.09324117170.1829343546
300.60.50.90.50.68215430220.6779086041-0.1032069338-0.09896123570.1830587813
310.60.50.90.50.68752027130.6833496973-0.1085729029-0.10440232890.1831710765
320.60.50.90.50.6926179420.6885254252-0.1136705736-0.10957805680.1832724228
330.60.50.90.50.69746072910.6934487299-0.1185133607-0.11450136150.1833638879
340.60.50.90.50.70206137680.6981319222-0.1231140084-0.11918455380.1834464352
350.60.50.90.50.70643199220.7025867125-0.1274846238-0.12363934410.1835209341
360.60.50.90.50.71058407680.7068242401-0.1316367084-0.12787687170.1835881693
370.60.50.90.50.71452855720.7108551011-0.1355811888-0.13190773260.1836488491
380.60.50.90.50.71827581350.7146893746-0.1393284451-0.13574200620.1837036126
390.60.50.90.50.72183570710.7183366484-0.1428883386-0.139389280.1837530367
400.60.50.90.50.72521760590.7218060426-0.1462702375-0.14285867420.183797642
410.60.50.90.50.72843040980.7251062324-0.1494830414-0.1461588640.1838378982
420.60.50.90.50.73148257360.7282454701-0.1525352051-0.14929810170.1838742294
430.60.50.90.50.73438212910.7312316053-0.1554347607-0.15228423690.1839070184
440.60.50.90.50.73713670680.734072105-0.1581893384-0.15512473660.1839366104
450.60.50.90.50.73975355570.7367740719-0.1608061873-0.15782670350.1839633172
460.60.50.90.50.74223956210.7393442623-0.1632921937-0.16039689390.1839874201
470.60.50.90.50.74460126820.7417891031-0.1656538998-0.16284173470.1840091729
480.60.50.90.50.7468448890.7441147076-0.1678975206-0.16516733910.1840288049
490.60.50.90.50.74897632880.746326891-0.1700289604-0.16737952250.1840465227
500.60.50.90.50.75100119660.7484311849-0.1720538282-0.16948381650.1840625131
510.60.50.90.50.7529248210.7504328512-0.1739774525-0.17148548280.1840769444
520.60.50.90.50.75475226410.7523368951-0.1758048957-0.17338952670.1840899686
530.60.50.90.50.75648833510.7541480777-0.1775409667-0.17520070930.184101723
540.60.50.90.50.75813760260.7558709278-0.1791902342-0.17692355940.1841123313
550.60.50.90.50.75970440670.7575097536-0.1807570382-0.17856238520.1841219053
560.60.50.90.50.76119287050.7590686529-0.1822455021-0.18012128450.1841305459
570.60.50.90.50.76260691120.7605515238-0.1836595428-0.18160415540.184138344
580.60.50.90.50.76395024990.7619620742-0.1850028814-0.18301470580.1841453817
590.60.50.90.50.76522642160.7633038312-0.1862790532-0.18435646280.1841517333
600.60.50.90.50.76643878470.76458015-0.1874914163-0.18563278160.1841574657
610.60.50.90.50.76759052970.765794222-0.1886431613-0.18684685360.1841626391
620.60.50.90.50.76868468740.766949083-0.189737319-0.18800171460.1841673081
630.60.50.90.50.76972413730.7680476208-0.1907767688-0.18910025240.1841715219
640.60.50.90.50.77071161460.7690925822-0.1917642462-0.19014521380.1841753248
650.60.50.90.50.77164971810.7700865803-0.1927023497-0.19113921190.1841787569
660.60.50.90.50.77254091640.7710321005-0.193593548-0.19208473210.1841818545
670.60.50.90.50.77338755480.7719315072-0.1944401864-0.19298413870.18418465
680.60.50.90.50.77419186130.7727870492-0.1952444928-0.19383968080.1841871729
690.60.50.90.50.77495595240.773600866-0.196008584-0.19465349760.1841894499
700.60.50.90.50.7756818390.7743749925-0.1967344706-0.19542762410.1841915048
710.60.50.90.50.77637143130.7751113644-0.1974240628-0.1961639960.1841933594
720.60.50.90.50.77702654390.775811823-0.1980791755-0.19686445460.1841950332
730.60.50.90.50.77764890090.7764781198-0.1987015325-0.19753075140.1841965438
740.60.50.90.50.77824014010.777111921-0.1992927717-0.19816455260.1841979071
750.60.50.90.50.77880181730.7777148113-0.1998544489-0.19876744290.1841991374
760.60.50.90.50.77933541060.7782882983-0.2003880422-0.19934092990.1842002479
770.60.50.90.50.77984232430.778833816-0.2008949559-0.19988644760.18420125
780.60.50.90.50.78032389230.7793527285-0.2013765239-0.20040536010.1842021544
790.60.50.90.50.78078138190.7798463333-0.2018340135-0.20089896490.1842029707
800.60.50.90.50.7812159970.7803158648-0.2022686286-0.20136849630.1842037074
810.60.50.90.50.78162888140.7807624969-0.202681513-0.20181512850.1842043722
820.60.50.90.50.78202112150.7811873465-0.2030737531-0.20223997810.1842049722
830.60.50.90.50.78239374970.781591476-0.2034463812-0.20264410750.1842055138
840.60.50.90.50.78274774640.7819758958-0.203800378-0.20302852740.1842060025
850.60.50.90.50.78308404330.7823415673-0.2041366749-0.20339419880.1842064436
860.60.50.90.50.78340352530.7826894047-0.2044561569-0.20374203630.1842068416
870.60.50.90.50.78370703330.7830202779-0.2047596648-0.20407290950.1842072009
880.60.50.90.50.78399536580.7833350143-0.2050479974-0.20438764580.1842075251
890.60.50.90.50.78426928170.7836344007-0.2053219133-0.20468703230.1842078177
900.60.50.90.50.78452950190.7839191859-0.2055821334-0.20497181750.1842080818
910.60.50.90.50.7847767110.784190082-0.2058293426-0.20524271360.1842083202
920.60.50.90.50.78501155960.7844477663-0.2060641912-0.20550039790.1842085353
930.60.50.90.50.78523466590.7846928832-0.2062872974-0.20574551480.1842087294
940.60.50.90.50.78544661680.7849260457-0.2064992484-0.20597867720.1842089046
950.60.50.90.50.78564797020.7851478366-0.2067006017-0.20620046820.1842090627
960.60.50.90.50.78583925590.7853588107-0.2068918874-0.20641144230.1842092054
970.60.50.90.50.78602097730.7855594954-0.2070736089-0.2066121270.1842093342
980.60.50.90.50.78619361260.7857503927-0.2072462442-0.20680302430.1842094504
990.60.50.90.50.78635761620.7859319797-0.2074102478-0.20698461130.1842095553
Sheet1
A1
A2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
Time
Sheet2
A2-exact
a1 (i1 = 0.6)
a2 (i2 = 0.5)
Competitive Net
Sheet3
a1
a2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
H
Time
Competitive Net
012345678910
000104090160250360490640810100
1112151101171261371501651821101
2425282132202292402532682852104
393103133183253343453583733903109
4164174204254324414524654804974116
52552652953454155056157458951065125
636637640645652661672685610061176136
749750753758765774785798711371307149
86486586887388088981008113812881458164
981982985990997910691179130914591629181
1010010101101041010910116101251013610149101641018110200
A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.5A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.4A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.3A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.2A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.1A1A2I1I2Inhib0A1A2I1I2Inhib0.1A1A2I1I2Inhib0.2A1A2I1I2Inhib0.3A1A2I1I2Inhib0.4A1A2I1I2Inhib0.5A1A2I1I2Inhib0.6A1A2I1I2Inhib0.7A1A2I1I2Inhib0.8A1A2I1I2Inhib0.9A1A2I1I2Inhib1
-0.5-0.50.60.50.9-1.025-0.5-0.40.60.50.9-0.885-0.5-0.30.60.50.9-0.755-0.5-0.20.60.50.9-0.635-0.5-0.10.60.50.9-0.525-0.500.60.50.9-0.425-0.50.10.60.50.9-0.335-0.50.20.60.50.9-0.255-0.50.30.60.50.9-0.185-0.50.40.60.50.9-0.125-0.50.50.60.50.9-0.075-0.50.60.60.50.9-0.035-0.50.70.60.50.9-0.005-0.50.80.60.50.90.015-0.50.90.60.50.90.025-0.510.60.50.90.025
-0.4-0.50.60.50.9-0.875-0.4-0.40.60.50.9-0.744-0.4-0.30.60.50.9-0.623-0.4-0.20.60.50.9-0.512-0.4-0.10.60.50.9-0.411-0.400.60.50.9-0.32-0.40.10.60.50.9-0.239-0.40.20.60.50.9-0.168-0.40.30.60.50.9-0.107-0.40.40.60.50.9-0.056-0.40.50.60.50.9-0.015-0.40.60.60.50.90.016-0.40.70.60.50.90.037-0.40.80.60.50.90.048-0.40.90.60.50.90.049-0.410.60.50.90.04
-0.3-0.50.60.50.9-0.735-0.3-0.40.60.50.9-0.613-0.3-0.30.60.50.9-0.501-0.3-0.20.60.50.9-0.399-0.3-0.10.60.50.9-0.307-0.300.60.50.9-0.225-0.30.10.60.50.9-0.153-0.30.20.60.50.9-0.091-0.30.30.60.50.9-0.039-0.30.40.60.50.90.003-0.30.50.60.50.90.035-0.30.60.60.50.90.057-0.30.70.60.50.90.069-0.30.80.60.50.90.071-0.30.90.60.50.90.063-0.310.60.50.90.045
-0.2-0.50.60.50.9-0.605-0.2-0.40.60.50.9-0.492-0.2-0.30.60.50.9-0.389-0.2-0.20.60.50.9-0.296-0.2-0.10.60.50.9-0.213-0.200.60.50.9-0.14-0.20.10.60.50.9-0.077-0.20.20.60.50.9-0.024-0.20.30.60.50.90.019-0.20.40.60.50.90.052-0.20.50.60.50.90.075-0.20.60.60.50.90.088-0.20.70.60.50.90.091-0.20.80.60.50.90.084-0.20.90.60.50.90.067-0.210.60.50.90.04
-0.1-0.50.60.50.9-0.485-0.1-0.40.60.50.9-0.381-0.1-0.30.60.50.9-0.287-0.1-0.20.60.50.9-0.203-0.1-0.10.60.50.9-0.129-0.100.60.50.9-0.065-0.10.10.60.50.9-0.011-0.10.20.60.50.90.033-0.10.30.60.50.90.067-0.10.40.60.50.90.091-0.10.50.60.50.90.105-0.10.60.60.50.90.109-0.10.70.60.50.90.103-0.10.80.60.50.90.087-0.10.90.60.50.90.061-0.110.60.50.90.025
0-0.50.60.50.9-0.3750-0.40.60.50.9-0.280-0.30.60.50.9-0.1950-0.20.60.50.9-0.120-0.10.60.50.9-0.055000.60.50.9000.10.60.50.90.04500.20.60.50.90.0800.30.60.50.90.10500.40.60.50.90.1200.50.60.50.90.12500.60.60.50.90.1200.70.60.50.90.10500.80.60.50.90.0800.90.60.50.90.045010.60.50.90
0.1-0.50.60.50.9-0.2750.1-0.40.60.50.9-0.1890.1-0.30.60.50.9-0.1130.1-0.20.60.50.9-0.0470.1-0.10.60.50.90.0090.100.60.50.90.0550.10.10.60.50.90.0910.10.20.60.50.90.1170.10.30.60.50.90.1330.10.40.60.50.90.1390.10.50.60.50.90.1350.10.60.60.50.90.1210.10.70.60.50.90.0970.10.80.60.50.90.0630.10.90.60.50.90.0190.110.60.50.9-0.035
0.2-0.50.60.50.9-0.1850.2-0.40.60.50.9-0.1080.2-0.30.60.50.9-0.0410.2-0.20.60.50.90.0160.2-0.10.60.50.90.0630.200.60.50.90.10.20.10.60.50.90.1270.20.20.60.50.90.1440.20.30.60.50.90.1510.20.40.60.50.90.1480.20.50.60.50.90.1350.20.60.60.50.90.1120.20.70.60.50.90.0790.20.80.60.50.90.0360.20.90.60.50.9-0.0170.210.60.50.9-0.08
0.3-0.50.60.50.9-0.1050.3-0.40.60.50.9-0.0370.3-0.30.60.50.90.0210.3-0.20.60.50.90.0690.3-0.10.60.50.90.1070.300.60.50.90.1350.30.10.60.50.90.1530.30.20.60.50.90.1610.30.30.60.50.90.1590.30.40.60.50.90.1470.30.50.60.50.90.1250.30.60.60.50.90.0930.30.70.60.50.90.0510.30.80.60.50.9-0.0010.30.90.60.50.9-0.0630.310.60.50.9-0.135
0.4-0.50.60.50.9-0.0350.4-0.40.60.50.90.0240.4-0.30.60.50.90.0730.4-0.20.60.50.90.1120.4-0.10.60.50.90.1410.400.60.50.90.160.40.10.60.50.90.1690.40.20.60.50.90.1680.40.30.60.50.90.1570.40.40.60.50.90.1360.40.50.60.50.90.1050.40.60.60.50.90.0640.40.70.60.50.90.0130.40.80.60.50.9-0.0480.40.90.60.50.9-0.1190.410.60.50.9-0.2
0.5-0.50.60.50.90.0250.5-0.40.60.50.90.0750.5-0.30.60.50.90.1150.5-0.20.60.50.90.1450.5-0.10.60.50.90.1650.500.60.50.90.1750.50.10.60.50.90.1750.50.20.60.50.90.1650.50.30.60.50.90.1450.50.40.60.50.90.1150.50.50.60.50.90.0750.50.60.60.50.90.0250.50.70.60.50.9-0.0350.50.80.60.50.9-0.1050.50.90.60.50.9-0.1850.510.60.50.9-0.275
0.6-0.50.60.50.90.0750.6-0.40.60.50.90.1160.6-0.30.60.50.90.1470.6-0.20.60.50.90.1680.6-0.10.60.50.90.1790.600.60.50.90.180.60.10.60.50.90.1710.60.20.60.50.90.1520.60.30.60.50.90.1230.60.40.60.50.90.0840.60.50.60.50.90.0350.60.60.60.50.9-0.0240.60.70.60.50.9-0.0930.60.80.60.50.9-0.1720.60.90.60.50.9-0.2610.610.60.50.9-0.36
0.7-0.50.60.50.90.1150.7-0.40.60.50.90.1470.7-0.30.60.50.90.1690.7-0.20.60.50.90.1810.7-0.10.60.50.90.1830.700.60.50.90.1750.70.10.60.50.90.1570.70.20.60.50.90.1290.70.30.60.50.90.0910.70.40.60.50.90.0430.70.50.60.50.9-0.0150.70.60.60.50.9-0.0830.70.70.60.50.9-0.1610.70.80.60.50.9-0.2490.70.90.60.50.9-0.3470.710.60.50.9-0.455
0.8-0.50.60.50.90.1450.8-0.40.60.50.90.1680.8-0.30.60.50.90.1810.8-0.20.60.50.90.1840.8-0.10.60.50.90.1770.800.60.50.90.160.80.10.60.50.90.1330.80.20.60.50.90.0960.80.30.60.50.90.0490.80.40.60.50.9-0.0080.80.50.60.50.9-0.0750.80.60.60.50.9-0.1520.80.70.60.50.9-0.2390.80.80.60.50.9-0.3360.80.90.60.50.9-0.4430.810.60.50.9-0.56
0.9-0.50.60.50.90.1650.9-0.40.60.50.90.1790.9-0.30.60.50.90.1830.9-0.20.60.50.90.1770.9-0.10.60.50.90.1610.900.60.50.90.1350.90.10.60.50.90.0990.90.20.60.50.90.0530.90.30.60.50.9-0.0030.90.40.60.50.9-0.0690.90.50.60.50.9-0.1450.90.60.60.50.9-0.2310.90.70.60.50.9-0.3270.90.80.60.50.9-0.4330.90.90.60.50.9-0.5490.910.60.50.9-0.675
1-0.50.60.50.90.1751-0.40.60.50.90.181-0.30.60.50.90.1751-0.20.60.50.90.161-0.10.60.50.90.135100.60.50.90.110.10.60.50.90.05510.20.60.50.9-010.30.60.50.9-0.06510.40.60.50.9-0.1410.50.60.50.9-0.22510.60.60.50.9-0.3210.70.60.50.9-0.42510.80.60.50.9-0.5410.90.60.50.9-0.665110.60.50.9-0.8
-0.5
-0.4
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
a2
Harmony
a1
Competitive Net
MBD00079BEA.unknown
Chart5
00
0.20190762310.1531370476
0.29375879590.198596214
0.34237528730.2030832637
0.37363255790.192363311
0.39756885460.1763696377
0.41809600490.1589142256
0.4367550540.1414431437
0.45416879370.1244888397
0.47060358220.1082317338
0.48618668670.0927173464
0.50099039930.0779402096
0.51506462540.0638762615
0.52844954250.0504953192
0.54118054760.0377658514
0.55329022040.0256567731
0.56480912970.0141380938
0.57576619020.0031811221
0.5861888435-0.0072414968
0.5961031683-0.0171558083
0.605533962-0.0265865968
0.614504809-0.0355574419
0.6230381421-0.0440907742
0.6311552994-0.0522079312
0.6388765782-0.0599292099
0.6462212858-0.0672739174
0.6532077877-0.0742604193
0.6598535539-0.0809061855
0.6661752022-0.0872278338
0.6721885402-0.0932411717
0.6779086041-0.0989612357
0.6833496973-0.1044023289
0.6885254252-0.1095780568
0.6934487299-0.1145013615
0.6981319222-0.1191845538
0.7025867125-0.1236393441
0.7068242401-0.1278768717
0.7108551011-0.1319077326
0.7146893746-0.1357420062
0.7183366484-0.13938928
0.7218060426-0.1428586742
0.7251062324-0.146158864
0.7282454701-0.1492981017
0.7312316053-0.1522842369
0.734072105-0.1551247366
0.7367740719-0.1578267035
0.7393442623-0.1603968939
0.7417891031-0.1628417347
0.7441147076-0.1651673391
0.746326891-0.1673795225
0.7484311849-0.1694838165
0.7504328512-0.1714854828
0.7523368951-0.1733895267
0.7541480777-0.1752007093
0.7558709278-0.1769235594
0.7575097536-0.1785623852
0.7590686529-0.1801212845
0.7605515238-0.1816041554
0.7619620742-0.1830147058
0.7633038312-0.1843564628
0.76458015-0.1856327816
0.765794222-0.1868468536
0.766949083-0.1880017146
0.7680476208-0.1891002524
0.7690925822-0.1901452138
0.7700865803-0.1911392119
0.7710321005-0.1920847321
0.7719315072-0.1929841387
0.7727870492-0.1938396808
0.773600866-0.1946534976
0.7743749925-0.1954276241
0.7751113644-0.196163996
0.775811823-0.1968644546
0.7764781198-0.1975307514
0.777111921-0.1981645526
0.7777148113-0.1987674429
0.7782882983-0.1993409299
0.778833816-0.1998864476
0.7793527285-0.2004053601
0.7798463333-0.2008989649
0.7803158648-0.2013684963
0.7807624969-0.2018151285
0.7811873465-0.2022399781
0.781591476-0.2026441075
0.7819758958-0.2030285274
0.7823415673-0.2033941988
0.7826894047-0.2037420363
0.7830202779-0.2040729095
0.7833350143-0.2043876458
0.7836344007-0.2046870323
0.7839191859-0.2049718175
0.784190082-0.2052427136
0.7844477663-0.2055003979
0.7846928832-0.2057455148
0.7849260457-0.2059786772
0.7851478366-0.2062004682
0.7853588107-0.2064114423
0.7855594954-0.206612127
0.7857503927-0.2068030243
0.7859319797-0.2069846113
a1
a2
A1-exact
A2-exact
Time
Competitive Net
Sheet1
TimeInput 1Input 2Inhibdelta-tA1A1-exactA2A2-exactH
00.60.50.90.500000
10.60.50.90.50.30.20190762310.250.15313704760.16125
20.60.50.90.50.33750.29375879590.240.1985962140.163846875
30.60.50.90.50.360750.34237528730.2181250.20308326370.1658332266
40.60.50.90.50.382218750.37363255790.1967250.1923633110.1676250155
50.60.50.90.50.4025831250.39756885460.17636406250.17636963770.1692421028
60.60.50.90.50.42192773440.41809600490.1570196250.15891422560.1707015241
70.60.50.90.50.44030503590.4367550540.1386423320.14144314370.1720186518
80.60.50.90.50.45776346860.45416879370.12118389980.12448883970.1732073596
90.60.50.90.50.47434897930.47060358220.10459838910.10823173380.1742801684
100.60.50.90.50.49010521460.48618668670.08884215380.09271734640.1752483783
110.60.50.90.50.50507363810.50099039930.07387373030.07794020960.1761221877
120.60.50.90.50.51929364040.51506462540.0596537280.06387626150.1769108007
130.60.50.90.50.53280264260.52844954250.04614472590.05049531920.177622524
140.60.50.90.50.54563619470.54118054760.03331117380.03776585140.1782648542
150.60.50.90.50.55782806910.55329022040.02111929930.02565677310.1788445572
160.60.50.90.50.56941034990.56480912970.00953701850.01413809380.1793677392
170.60.50.90.50.58041351660.5757661902-0.00146614820.00318112210.1798399109
180.60.50.90.50.5908665250.5861888435-0.0119191566-0.00724149680.1802660459
190.60.50.90.50.60079688290.5961031683-0.0218495145-0.01715580830.1806506328
200.60.50.90.50.6102307230.605533962-0.0312833546-0.02658659680.1809977224
210.60.50.90.50.61919287110.614504809-0.0402455026-0.03555744190.1813109708
220.60.50.90.50.62770691170.6230381421-0.0487595433-0.04409077420.1815936774
230.60.50.90.50.63579525030.6311552994-0.0568478819-0.05220793120.1818488202
240.60.50.90.50.6434791720.6388765782-0.0645318036-0.05992920990.1820790866
250.60.50.90.50.65077889760.6462212858-0.0718315292-0.06727391740.1822869019
260.60.50.90.50.6577136370.6532077877-0.0787662686-0.07426041930.1824744553
270.60.50.90.50.66430163930.6598535539-0.0853542709-0.08090618550.1826437222
280.60.50.90.50.67056024160.6661752022-0.0916128732-0.08722783380.1827964856
290.60.50.90.50.67650591370.6721885402-0.0975585453-0.09324117170.1829343546
300.60.50.90.50.68215430220.6779086041-0.1032069338-0.09896123570.1830587813
310.60.50.90.50.68752027130.6833496973-0.1085729029-0.10440232890.1831710765
320.60.50.90.50.6926179420.6885254252-0.1136705736-0.10957805680.1832724228
330.60.50.90.50.69746072910.6934487299-0.1185133607-0.11450136150.1833638879
340.60.50.90.50.70206137680.6981319222-0.1231140084-0.11918455380.1834464352
350.60.50.90.50.70643199220.7025867125-0.1274846238-0.12363934410.1835209341
360.60.50.90.50.71058407680.7068242401-0.1316367084-0.12787687170.1835881693
370.60.50.90.50.71452855720.7108551011-0.1355811888-0.13190773260.1836488491
380.60.50.90.50.71827581350.7146893746-0.1393284451-0.13574200620.1837036126
390.60.50.90.50.72183570710.7183366484-0.1428883386-0.139389280.1837530367
400.60.50.90.50.72521760590.7218060426-0.1462702375-0.14285867420.183797642
410.60.50.90.50.72843040980.7251062324-0.1494830414-0.1461588640.1838378982
420.60.50.90.50.73148257360.7282454701-0.1525352051-0.14929810170.1838742294
430.60.50.90.50.73438212910.7312316053-0.1554347607-0.15228423690.1839070184
440.60.50.90.50.73713670680.734072105-0.1581893384-0.15512473660.1839366104
450.60.50.90.50.73975355570.7367740719-0.1608061873-0.15782670350.1839633172
460.60.50.90.50.74223956210.7393442623-0.1632921937-0.16039689390.1839874201
470.60.50.90.50.74460126820.7417891031-0.1656538998-0.16284173470.1840091729
480.60.50.90.50.7468448890.7441147076-0.1678975206-0.16516733910.1840288049
490.60.50.90.50.74897632880.746326891-0.1700289604-0.16737952250.1840465227
500.60.50.90.50.75100119660.7484311849-0.1720538282-0.16948381650.1840625131
510.60.50.90.50.7529248210.7504328512-0.1739774525-0.17148548280.1840769444
520.60.50.90.50.75475226410.7523368951-0.1758048957-0.17338952670.1840899686
530.60.50.90.50.75648833510.7541480777-0.1775409667-0.17520070930.184101723
540.60.50.90.50.75813760260.7558709278-0.1791902342-0.17692355940.1841123313
550.60.50.90.50.75970440670.7575097536-0.1807570382-0.17856238520.1841219053
560.60.50.90.50.76119287050.7590686529-0.1822455021-0.18012128450.1841305459
570.60.50.90.50.76260691120.7605515238-0.1836595428-0.18160415540.184138344
580.60.50.90.50.76395024990.7619620742-0.1850028814-0.18301470580.1841453817
590.60.50.90.50.76522642160.7633038312-0.1862790532-0.18435646280.1841517333
600.60.50.90.50.76643878470.76458015-0.1874914163-0.18563278160.1841574657
610.60.50.90.50.76759052970.765794222-0.1886431613-0.18684685360.1841626391
620.60.50.90.50.76868468740.766949083-0.189737319-0.18800171460.1841673081
630.60.50.90.50.76972413730.7680476208-0.1907767688-0.18910025240.1841715219
640.60.50.90.50.77071161460.7690925822-0.1917642462-0.19014521380.1841753248
650.60.50.90.50.77164971810.7700865803-0.1927023497-0.19113921190.1841787569
660.60.50.90.50.77254091640.7710321005-0.193593548-0.19208473210.1841818545
670.60.50.90.50.77338755480.7719315072-0.1944401864-0.19298413870.18418465
680.60.50.90.50.77419186130.7727870492-0.1952444928-0.19383968080.1841871729
690.60.50.90.50.77495595240.773600866-0.196008584-0.19465349760.1841894499
700.60.50.90.50.7756818390.7743749925-0.1967344706-0.19542762410.1841915048
710.60.50.90.50.77637143130.7751113644-0.1974240628-0.1961639960.1841933594
720.60.50.90.50.77702654390.775811823-0.1980791755-0.19686445460.1841950332
730.60.50.90.50.77764890090.7764781198-0.1987015325-0.19753075140.1841965438
740.60.50.90.50.77824014010.777111921-0.1992927717-0.19816455260.1841979071
750.60.50.90.50.77880181730.7777148113-0.1998544489-0.19876744290.1841991374
760.60.50.90.50.77933541060.7782882983-0.2003880422-0.19934092990.1842002479
770.60.50.90.50.77984232430.778833816-0.2008949559-0.19988644760.18420125
780.60.50.90.50.78032389230.7793527285-0.2013765239-0.20040536010.1842021544
790.60.50.90.50.78078138190.7798463333-0.2018340135-0.20089896490.1842029707
800.60.50.90.50.7812159970.7803158648-0.2022686286-0.20136849630.1842037074
810.60.50.90.50.78162888140.7807624969-0.202681513-0.20181512850.1842043722
820.60.50.90.50.78202112150.7811873465-0.2030737531-0.20223997810.1842049722
830.60.50.90.50.78239374970.781591476-0.2034463812-0.20264410750.1842055138
840.60.50.90.50.78274774640.7819758958-0.203800378-0.20302852740.1842060025
850.60.50.90.50.78308404330.7823415673-0.2041366749-0.20339419880.1842064436
860.60.50.90.50.78340352530.7826894047-0.2044561569-0.20374203630.1842068416
870.60.50.90.50.78370703330.7830202779-0.2047596648-0.20407290950.1842072009
880.60.50.90.50.78399536580.7833350143-0.2050479974-0.20438764580.1842075251
890.60.50.90.50.78426928170.7836344007-0.2053219133-0.20468703230.1842078177
900.60.50.90.50.78452950190.7839191859-0.2055821334-0.20497181750.1842080818
910.60.50.90.50.7847767110.784190082-0.2058293426-0.20524271360.1842083202
920.60.50.90.50.78501155960.7844477663-0.2060641912-0.20550039790.1842085353
930.60.50.90.50.78523466590.7846928832-0.2062872974-0.20574551480.1842087294
940.60.50.90.50.78544661680.7849260457-0.2064992484-0.20597867720.1842089046
950.60.50.90.50.78564797020.7851478366-0.2067006017-0.20620046820.1842090627
960.60.50.90.50.78583925590.7853588107-0.2068918874-0.20641144230.1842092054
970.60.50.90.50.78602097730.7855594954-0.2070736089-0.2066121270.1842093342
980.60.50.90.50.78619361260.7857503927-0.2072462442-0.20680302430.1842094504
990.60.50.90.50.78635761620.7859319797-0.2074102478-0.20698461130.1842095553
Sheet1
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
A1
A2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
Time
Sheet2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
A2-exact
a1 (i1 = 0.6)
a2 (i2 = 0.5)
Competitive Net
Sheet3
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
a1
a2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
H
Time
Competitive Net
012345678910
000104090160250360490640810100
1112151101171261371501651821101
2425282132202292402532682852104
393103133183253343453583733903109
4164174204254324414524654804974116
52552652953454155056157458951065125
636637640645652661672685610061176136
749750753758765774785798711371307149
86486586887388088981008113812881458164
981982985990997910691179130914591629181
1010010101101041010910116101251013610149101641018110200
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.5A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.4A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.3A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.2A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.1A1A2I1I2Inhib0A1A2I1I2Inhib0.1A1A2I1I2Inhib0.2A1A2I1I2Inhib0.3A1A2I1I2Inhib0.4A1A2I1I2Inhib0.5A1A2I1I2Inhib0.6A1A2I1I2Inhib0.7A1A2I1I2Inhib0.8A1A2I1I2Inhib0.9A1A2I1I2Inhib1
-0.5-0.50.60.50.9-1.025-0.5-0.40.60.50.9-0.885-0.5-0.30.60.50.9-0.755-0.5-0.20.60.50.9-0.635-0.5-0.10.60.50.9-0.525-0.500.60.50.9-0.425-0.50.10.60.50.9-0.335-0.50.20.60.50.9-0.255-0.50.30.60.50.9-0.185-0.50.40.60.50.9-0.125-0.50.50.60.50.9-0.075-0.50.60.60.50.9-0.035-0.50.70.60.50.9-0.005-0.50.80.60.50.90.015-0.50.90.60.50.90.025-0.510.60.50.90.025
-0.4-0.50.60.50.9-0.875-0.4-0.40.60.50.9-0.744-0.4-0.30.60.50.9-0.623-0.4-0.20.60.50.9-0.512-0.4-0.10.60.50.9-0.411-0.400.60.50.9-0.32-0.40.10.60.50.9-0.239-0.40.20.60.50.9-0.168-0.40.30.60.50.9-0.107-0.40.40.60.50.9-0.056-0.40.50.60.50.9-0.015-0.40.60.60.50.90.016-0.40.70.60.50.90.037-0.40.80.60.50.90.048-0.40.90.60.50.90.049-0.410.60.50.90.04
-0.3-0.50.60.50.9-0.735-0.3-0.40.60.50.9-0.613-0.3-0.30.60.50.9-0.501-0.3-0.20.60.50.9-0.399-0.3-0.10.60.50.9-0.307-0.300.60.50.9-0.225-0.30.10.60.50.9-0.153-0.30.20.60.50.9-0.091-0.30.30.60.50.9-0.039-0.30.40.60.50.90.003-0.30.50.60.50.90.035-0.30.60.60.50.90.057-0.30.70.60.50.90.069-0.30.80.60.50.90.071-0.30.90.60.50.90.063-0.310.60.50.90.045
-0.2-0.50.60.50.9-0.605-0.2-0.40.60.50.9-0.492-0.2-0.30.60.50.9-0.389-0.2-0.20.60.50.9-0.296-0.2-0.10.60.50.9-0.213-0.200.60.50.9-0.14-0.20.10.60.50.9-0.077-0.20.20.60.50.9-0.024-0.20.30.60.50.90.019-0.20.40.60.50.90.052-0.20.50.60.50.90.075-0.20.60.60.50.90.088-0.20.70.60.50.90.091-0.20.80.60.50.90.084-0.20.90.60.50.90.067-0.210.60.50.90.04
-0.1-0.50.60.50.9-0.485-0.1-0.40.60.50.9-0.381-0.1-0.30.60.50.9-0.287-0.1-0.20.60.50.9-0.203-0.1-0.10.60.50.9-0.129-0.100.60.50.9-0.065-0.10.10.60.50.9-0.011-0.10.20.60.50.90.033-0.10.30.60.50.90.067-0.10.40.60.50.90.091-0.10.50.60.50.90.105-0.10.60.60.50.90.109-0.10.70.60.50.90.103-0.10.80.60.50.90.087-0.10.90.60.50.90.061-0.110.60.50.90.025
0-0.50.60.50.9-0.3750-0.40.60.50.9-0.280-0.30.60.50.9-0.1950-0.20.60.50.9-0.120-0.10.60.50.9-0.055000.60.50.9000.10.60.50.90.04500.20.60.50.90.0800.30.60.50.90.10500.40.60.50.90.1200.50.60.50.90.12500.60.60.50.90.1200.70.60.50.90.10500.80.60.50.90.0800.90.60.50.90.045010.60.50.90
0.1-0.50.60.50.9-0.2750.1-0.40.60.50.9-0.1890.1-0.30.60.50.9-0.1130.1-0.20.60.50.9-0.0470.1-0.10.60.50.90.0090.100.60.50.90.0550.10.10.60.50.90.0910.10.20.60.50.90.1170.10.30.60.50.90.1330.10.40.60.50.90.1390.10.50.60.50.90.1350.10.60.60.50.90.1210.10.70.60.50.90.0970.10.80.60.50.90.0630.10.90.60.50.90.0190.110.60.50.9-0.035
0.2-0.50.60.50.9-0.1850.2-0.40.60.50.9-0.1080.2-0.30.60.50.9-0.0410.2-0.20.60.50.90.0160.2-0.10.60.50.90.0630.200.60.50.90.10.20.10.60.50.90.1270.20.20.60.50.90.1440.20.30.60.50.90.1510.20.40.60.50.90.1480.20.50.60.50.90.1350.20.60.60.50.90.1120.20.70.60.50.90.0790.20.80.60.50.90.0360.20.90.60.50.9-0.0170.210.60.50.9-0.08
0.3-0.50.60.50.9-0.1050.3-0.40.60.50.9-0.0370.3-0.30.60.50.90.0210.3-0.20.60.50.90.0690.3-0.10.60.50.90.1070.300.60.50.90.1350.30.10.60.50.90.1530.30.20.60.50.90.1610.30.30.60.50.90.1590.30.40.60.50.90.1470.30.50.60.50.90.1250.30.60.60.50.90.0930.30.70.60.50.90.0510.30.80.60.50.9-0.0010.30.90.60.50.9-0.0630.310.60.50.9-0.135
0.4-0.50.60.50.9-0.0350.4-0.40.60.50.90.0240.4-0.30.60.50.90.0730.4-0.20.60.50.90.1120.4-0.10.60.50.90.1410.400.60.50.90.160.40.10.60.50.90.1690.40.20.60.50.90.1680.40.30.60.50.90.1570.40.40.60.50.90.1360.40.50.60.50.90.1050.40.60.60.50.90.0640.40.70.60.50.90.0130.40.80.60.50.9-0.0480.40.90.60.50.9-0.1190.410.60.50.9-0.2
0.5-0.50.60.50.90.0250.5-0.40.60.50.90.0750.5-0.30.60.50.90.1150.5-0.20.60.50.90.1450.5-0.10.60.50.90.1650.500.60.50.90.1750.50.10.60.50.90.1750.50.20.60.50.90.1650.50.30.60.50.90.1450.50.40.60.50.90.1150.50.50.60.50.90.0750.50.60.60.50.90.0250.50.70.60.50.9-0.0350.50.80.60.50.9-0.1050.50.90.60.50.9-0.1850.510.60.50.9-0.275
0.6-0.50.60.50.90.0750.6-0.40.60.50.90.1160.6-0.30.60.50.90.1470.6-0.20.60.50.90.1680.6-0.10.60.50.90.1790.600.60.50.90.180.60.10.60.50.90.1710.60.20.60.50.90.1520.60.30.60.50.90.1230.60.40.60.50.90.0840.60.50.60.50.90.0350.60.60.60.50.9-0.0240.60.70.60.50.9-0.0930.60.80.60.50.9-0.1720.60.90.60.50.9-0.2610.610.60.50.9-0.36
0.7-0.50.60.50.90.1150.7-0.40.60.50.90.1470.7-0.30.60.50.90.1690.7-0.20.60.50.90.1810.7-0.10.60.50.90.1830.700.60.50.90.1750.70.10.60.50.90.1570.70.20.60.50.90.1290.70.30.60.50.90.0910.70.40.60.50.90.0430.70.50.60.50.9-0.0150.70.60.60.50.9-0.0830.70.70.60.50.9-0.1610.70.80.60.50.9-0.2490.70.90.60.50.9-0.3470.710.60.50.9-0.455
0.8-0.50.60.50.90.1450.8-0.40.60.50.90.1680.8-0.30.60.50.90.1810.8-0.20.60.50.90.1840.8-0.10.60.50.90.1770.800.60.50.90.160.80.10.60.50.90.1330.80.20.60.50.90.0960.80.30.60.50.90.0490.80.40.60.50.9-0.0080.80.50.60.50.9-0.0750.80.60.60.50.9-0.1520.80.70.60.50.9-0.2390.80.80.60.50.9-0.3360.80.90.60.50.9-0.4430.810.60.50.9-0.56
0.9-0.50.60.50.90.1650.9-0.40.60.50.90.1790.9-0.30.60.50.90.1830.9-0.20.60.50.90.1770.9-0.10.60.50.90.1610.900.60.50.90.1350.90.10.60.50.90.0990.90.20.60.50.90.0530.90.30.60.50.9-0.0030.90.40.60.50.9-0.0690.90.50.60.50.9-0.1450.90.60.60.50.9-0.2310.90.70.60.50.9-0.3270.90.80.60.50.9-0.4330.90.90.60.50.9-0.5490.910.60.50.9-0.675
1-0.50.60.50.90.1751-0.40.60.50.90.181-0.30.60.50.90.1751-0.20.60.50.90.161-0.10.60.50.90.135100.60.50.90.110.10.60.50.90.05510.20.60.50.9-010.30.60.50.9-0.06510.40.60.50.9-0.1410.50.60.50.9-0.22510.60.60.50.9-0.3210.70.60.50.9-0.42510.80.60.50.9-0.5410.90.60.50.9-0.665110.60.50.9-0.8
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
-0.5
-0.4
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
a2
Harmony
a1
Competitive Net
MBD00079BEA.unknown
Chart5
00
0.20190762310.1531370476
0.29375879590.198596214
0.34237528730.2030832637
0.37363255790.192363311
0.39756885460.1763696377
0.41809600490.1589142256
0.4367550540.1414431437
0.45416879370.1244888397
0.47060358220.1082317338
0.48618668670.0927173464
0.50099039930.0779402096
0.51506462540.0638762615
0.52844954250.0504953192
0.54118054760.0377658514
0.55329022040.0256567731
0.56480912970.0141380938
0.57576619020.0031811221
0.5861888435-0.0072414968
0.5961031683-0.0171558083
0.605533962-0.0265865968
0.614504809-0.0355574419
0.6230381421-0.0440907742
0.6311552994-0.0522079312
0.6388765782-0.0599292099
0.6462212858-0.0672739174
0.6532077877-0.0742604193
0.6598535539-0.0809061855
0.6661752022-0.0872278338
0.6721885402-0.0932411717
0.6779086041-0.0989612357
0.6833496973-0.1044023289
0.6885254252-0.1095780568
0.6934487299-0.1145013615
0.6981319222-0.1191845538
0.7025867125-0.1236393441
0.7068242401-0.1278768717
0.7108551011-0.1319077326
0.7146893746-0.1357420062
0.7183366484-0.13938928
0.7218060426-0.1428586742
0.7251062324-0.146158864
0.7282454701-0.1492981017
0.7312316053-0.1522842369
0.734072105-0.1551247366
0.7367740719-0.1578267035
0.7393442623-0.1603968939
0.7417891031-0.1628417347
0.7441147076-0.1651673391
0.746326891-0.1673795225
0.7484311849-0.1694838165
0.7504328512-0.1714854828
0.7523368951-0.1733895267
0.7541480777-0.1752007093
0.7558709278-0.1769235594
0.7575097536-0.1785623852
0.7590686529-0.1801212845
0.7605515238-0.1816041554
0.7619620742-0.1830147058
0.7633038312-0.1843564628
0.76458015-0.1856327816
0.765794222-0.1868468536
0.766949083-0.1880017146
0.7680476208-0.1891002524
0.7690925822-0.1901452138
0.7700865803-0.1911392119
0.7710321005-0.1920847321
0.7719315072-0.1929841387
0.7727870492-0.1938396808
0.773600866-0.1946534976
0.7743749925-0.1954276241
0.7751113644-0.196163996
0.775811823-0.1968644546
0.7764781198-0.1975307514
0.777111921-0.1981645526
0.7777148113-0.1987674429
0.7782882983-0.1993409299
0.778833816-0.1998864476
0.7793527285-0.2004053601
0.7798463333-0.2008989649
0.7803158648-0.2013684963
0.7807624969-0.2018151285
0.7811873465-0.2022399781
0.781591476-0.2026441075
0.7819758958-0.2030285274
0.7823415673-0.2033941988
0.7826894047-0.2037420363
0.7830202779-0.2040729095
0.7833350143-0.2043876458
0.7836344007-0.2046870323
0.7839191859-0.2049718175
0.784190082-0.2052427136
0.7844477663-0.2055003979
0.7846928832-0.2057455148
0.7849260457-0.2059786772
0.7851478366-0.2062004682
0.7853588107-0.2064114423
0.7855594954-0.206612127
0.7857503927-0.2068030243
0.7859319797-0.2069846113
a1
a2
A1-exact
A2-exact
Time
Competitive Net
Sheet1
TimeInput 1Input 2Inhibdelta-tA1A1-exactA2A2-exactH
00.60.50.90.500000
10.60.50.90.50.30.20190762310.250.15313704760.16125
20.60.50.90.50.33750.29375879590.240.1985962140.163846875
30.60.50.90.50.360750.34237528730.2181250.20308326370.1658332266
40.60.50.90.50.382218750.37363255790.1967250.1923633110.1676250155
50.60.50.90.50.4025831250.39756885460.17636406250.17636963770.1692421028
60.60.50.90.50.42192773440.41809600490.1570196250.15891422560.1707015241
70.60.50.90.50.44030503590.4367550540.1386423320.14144314370.1720186518
80.60.50.90.50.45776346860.45416879370.12118389980.12448883970.1732073596
90.60.50.90.50.47434897930.47060358220.10459838910.10823173380.1742801684
100.60.50.90.50.49010521460.48618668670.08884215380.09271734640.1752483783
110.60.50.90.50.50507363810.50099039930.07387373030.07794020960.1761221877
120.60.50.90.50.51929364040.51506462540.0596537280.06387626150.1769108007
130.60.50.90.50.53280264260.52844954250.04614472590.05049531920.177622524
140.60.50.90.50.54563619470.54118054760.03331117380.03776585140.1782648542
150.60.50.90.50.55782806910.55329022040.02111929930.02565677310.1788445572
160.60.50.90.50.56941034990.56480912970.00953701850.01413809380.1793677392
170.60.50.90.50.58041351660.5757661902-0.00146614820.00318112210.1798399109
180.60.50.90.50.5908665250.5861888435-0.0119191566-0.00724149680.1802660459
190.60.50.90.50.60079688290.5961031683-0.0218495145-0.01715580830.1806506328
200.60.50.90.50.6102307230.605533962-0.0312833546-0.02658659680.1809977224
210.60.50.90.50.61919287110.614504809-0.0402455026-0.03555744190.1813109708
220.60.50.90.50.62770691170.6230381421-0.0487595433-0.04409077420.1815936774
230.60.50.90.50.63579525030.6311552994-0.0568478819-0.05220793120.1818488202
240.60.50.90.50.6434791720.6388765782-0.0645318036-0.05992920990.1820790866
250.60.50.90.50.65077889760.6462212858-0.0718315292-0.06727391740.1822869019
260.60.50.90.50.6577136370.6532077877-0.0787662686-0.07426041930.1824744553
270.60.50.90.50.66430163930.6598535539-0.0853542709-0.08090618550.1826437222
280.60.50.90.50.67056024160.6661752022-0.0916128732-0.08722783380.1827964856
290.60.50.90.50.67650591370.6721885402-0.0975585453-0.09324117170.1829343546
300.60.50.90.50.68215430220.6779086041-0.1032069338-0.09896123570.1830587813
310.60.50.90.50.68752027130.6833496973-0.1085729029-0.10440232890.1831710765
320.60.50.90.50.6926179420.6885254252-0.1136705736-0.10957805680.1832724228
330.60.50.90.50.69746072910.6934487299-0.1185133607-0.11450136150.1833638879
340.60.50.90.50.70206137680.6981319222-0.1231140084-0.11918455380.1834464352
350.60.50.90.50.70643199220.7025867125-0.1274846238-0.12363934410.1835209341
360.60.50.90.50.71058407680.7068242401-0.1316367084-0.12787687170.1835881693
370.60.50.90.50.71452855720.7108551011-0.1355811888-0.13190773260.1836488491
380.60.50.90.50.71827581350.7146893746-0.1393284451-0.13574200620.1837036126
390.60.50.90.50.72183570710.7183366484-0.1428883386-0.139389280.1837530367
400.60.50.90.50.72521760590.7218060426-0.1462702375-0.14285867420.183797642
410.60.50.90.50.72843040980.7251062324-0.1494830414-0.1461588640.1838378982
420.60.50.90.50.73148257360.7282454701-0.1525352051-0.14929810170.1838742294
430.60.50.90.50.73438212910.7312316053-0.1554347607-0.15228423690.1839070184
440.60.50.90.50.73713670680.734072105-0.1581893384-0.15512473660.1839366104
450.60.50.90.50.73975355570.7367740719-0.1608061873-0.15782670350.1839633172
460.60.50.90.50.74223956210.7393442623-0.1632921937-0.16039689390.1839874201
470.60.50.90.50.74460126820.7417891031-0.1656538998-0.16284173470.1840091729
480.60.50.90.50.7468448890.7441147076-0.1678975206-0.16516733910.1840288049
490.60.50.90.50.74897632880.746326891-0.1700289604-0.16737952250.1840465227
500.60.50.90.50.75100119660.7484311849-0.1720538282-0.16948381650.1840625131
510.60.50.90.50.7529248210.7504328512-0.1739774525-0.17148548280.1840769444
520.60.50.90.50.75475226410.7523368951-0.1758048957-0.17338952670.1840899686
530.60.50.90.50.75648833510.7541480777-0.1775409667-0.17520070930.184101723
540.60.50.90.50.75813760260.7558709278-0.1791902342-0.17692355940.1841123313
550.60.50.90.50.75970440670.7575097536-0.1807570382-0.17856238520.1841219053
560.60.50.90.50.76119287050.7590686529-0.1822455021-0.18012128450.1841305459
570.60.50.90.50.76260691120.7605515238-0.1836595428-0.18160415540.184138344
580.60.50.90.50.76395024990.7619620742-0.1850028814-0.18301470580.1841453817
590.60.50.90.50.76522642160.7633038312-0.1862790532-0.18435646280.1841517333
600.60.50.90.50.76643878470.76458015-0.1874914163-0.18563278160.1841574657
610.60.50.90.50.76759052970.765794222-0.1886431613-0.18684685360.1841626391
620.60.50.90.50.76868468740.766949083-0.189737319-0.18800171460.1841673081
630.60.50.90.50.76972413730.7680476208-0.1907767688-0.18910025240.1841715219
640.60.50.90.50.77071161460.7690925822-0.1917642462-0.19014521380.1841753248
650.60.50.90.50.77164971810.7700865803-0.1927023497-0.19113921190.1841787569
660.60.50.90.50.77254091640.7710321005-0.193593548-0.19208473210.1841818545
670.60.50.90.50.77338755480.7719315072-0.1944401864-0.19298413870.18418465
680.60.50.90.50.77419186130.7727870492-0.1952444928-0.19383968080.1841871729
690.60.50.90.50.77495595240.773600866-0.196008584-0.19465349760.1841894499
700.60.50.90.50.7756818390.7743749925-0.1967344706-0.19542762410.1841915048
710.60.50.90.50.77637143130.7751113644-0.1974240628-0.1961639960.1841933594
720.60.50.90.50.77702654390.775811823-0.1980791755-0.19686445460.1841950332
730.60.50.90.50.77764890090.7764781198-0.1987015325-0.19753075140.1841965438
740.60.50.90.50.77824014010.777111921-0.1992927717-0.19816455260.1841979071
750.60.50.90.50.77880181730.7777148113-0.1998544489-0.19876744290.1841991374
760.60.50.90.50.77933541060.7782882983-0.2003880422-0.19934092990.1842002479
770.60.50.90.50.77984232430.778833816-0.2008949559-0.19988644760.18420125
780.60.50.90.50.78032389230.7793527285-0.2013765239-0.20040536010.1842021544
790.60.50.90.50.78078138190.7798463333-0.2018340135-0.20089896490.1842029707
800.60.50.90.50.7812159970.7803158648-0.2022686286-0.20136849630.1842037074
810.60.50.90.50.78162888140.7807624969-0.202681513-0.20181512850.1842043722
820.60.50.90.50.78202112150.7811873465-0.2030737531-0.20223997810.1842049722
830.60.50.90.50.78239374970.781591476-0.2034463812-0.20264410750.1842055138
840.60.50.90.50.78274774640.7819758958-0.203800378-0.20302852740.1842060025
850.60.50.90.50.78308404330.7823415673-0.2041366749-0.20339419880.1842064436
860.60.50.90.50.78340352530.7826894047-0.2044561569-0.20374203630.1842068416
870.60.50.90.50.78370703330.7830202779-0.2047596648-0.20407290950.1842072009
880.60.50.90.50.78399536580.7833350143-0.2050479974-0.20438764580.1842075251
890.60.50.90.50.78426928170.7836344007-0.2053219133-0.20468703230.1842078177
900.60.50.90.50.78452950190.7839191859-0.2055821334-0.20497181750.1842080818
910.60.50.90.50.7847767110.784190082-0.2058293426-0.20524271360.1842083202
920.60.50.90.50.78501155960.7844477663-0.2060641912-0.20550039790.1842085353
930.60.50.90.50.78523466590.7846928832-0.2062872974-0.20574551480.1842087294
940.60.50.90.50.78544661680.7849260457-0.2064992484-0.20597867720.1842089046
950.60.50.90.50.78564797020.7851478366-0.2067006017-0.20620046820.1842090627
960.60.50.90.50.78583925590.7853588107-0.2068918874-0.20641144230.1842092054
970.60.50.90.50.78602097730.7855594954-0.2070736089-0.2066121270.1842093342
980.60.50.90.50.78619361260.7857503927-0.2072462442-0.20680302430.1842094504
990.60.50.90.50.78635761620.7859319797-0.2074102478-0.20698461130.1842095553
Sheet1
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
A1
A2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
Time
Sheet2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
A2-exact
a1 (i1 = 0.6)
a2 (i2 = 0.5)
Competitive Net
Sheet3
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
a1
a2
H
A1-exact
A2-exact
H
Time
Competitive Net
012345678910
000104090160250360490640810100
1112151101171261371501651821101
2425282132202292402532682852104
393103133183253343453583733903109
4164174204254324414524654804974116
52552652953454155056157458951065125
636637640645652661672685610061176136
749750753758765774785798711371307149
86486586887388088981008113812881458164
981982985990997910691179130914591629181
1010010101101041010910116101251013610149101641018110200
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
00000000000
A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.5A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.4A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.3A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.2A1A2I1I2Inhib-0.1A1A2I1I2Inhib0A1A2I1I2Inhib0.1A1A2I1I2Inhib0.2A1A2I1I2Inhib0.3A1A2I1I2Inhib0.4A1A2I1I2Inhib0.5A1A2I1I2Inhib0.6A1A2I1I2Inhib0.7A1A2I1I2Inhib0.8A1A2I1I2Inhib0.9A1A2I1I2Inhib1
-0.5-0.50.60.50.9-1.025-0.5-0.40.60.50.9-0.885-0.5-0.30.60.50.9-0.755-0.5-0.20.60.50.9-0.635-0.5-0.10.60.50.9-0.525-0.500.60.50.9-0.425-0.50.10.60.50.9-0.335-0.50.20.60.50.9-0.255-0.50.30.60.50.9-0.185-0.50.40.60.50.9-0.125-0.50.50.60.50.9-0.075-0.50.60.60.50.9-0.035-0.50.70.60.50.9-0.005-0.50.80.60.50.90.015-0.50.90.60.50.90.025-0.510.60.50.90.025
-0.4-0.50.60.50.9-0.875-0.4-0.40.60.50.9-0.744-0.4-0.30.60.50.9-0.623-0.4-0.20.60.50.9-0.512-0.4-0.10.60.50.9-0.411-0.400.60.50.9-0.32-0.40.10.60.50.9-0.239-0.40.20.60.50.9-0.168-0.40.30.60.50.9-0.107-0.40.40.60.50.9-0.056-0.40.50.60.50.9-0.015-0.40.60.60.50.90.016-0.40.70.60.50.90.037-0.40.80.60.50.90.048-0.40.90.60.50.90.049-0.410.60.50.90.04
-0.3-0.50.60.50.9-0.735-0.3-0.40.60.50.9-0.613-0.3-0.30.60.50.9-0.501-0.3-0.20.60.50.9-0.399-0.3-0.10.60.50.9-0.307-0.300.60.50.9-0.225-0.30.10.60.50.9-0.153-0.30.20.60.50.9-0.091-0.30.30.60.50.9-0.039-0.30.40.60.50.90.003-0.30.50.60.50.90.035-0.30.60.60.50.90.057-0.30.70.60.50.90.069-0.30.80.60.50.90.071-0.30.90.60.50.90.063-0.310.60.50.90.045
-0.2-0.50.60.50.9-0.605-0.2-0.40.60.50.9-0.492-0.2-0.30.60.50.9-0.389-0.2-0.20.60.50.9-0.296-0.2-0.10.60.50.9-0.213-0.200.60.50.9-0.14-0.20.10.60.50.9-0.077-0.20.20.60.50.9-0.024-0.20.30.60.50.90.019-0.20.40.60.50.90.052-0.20.50.60.50.90.075-0.20.60.60.50.90.088-0.20.70.60.50.90.091-0.20.80.60.50.90.084-0.20.90.60.50.90.067-0.210.60.50.90.04
-0.1-0.50.60.50.9-0.485-0.1-0.40.60.50.9-0.381-0.1-0.30.60.50.9-0.287-0.1-0.20.60.50.9-0.203-0.1-0.10.60.50.9-0.129-0.100.60.50.9-0.065-0.10.10.60.50.9-0.011-0.10.20.60.50.90.033-0.10.30.60.50.90.067-0.10.40.60.50.90.091-0.10.50.60.50.90.105-0.10.60.60.50.90.109-0.10.70.60.50.90.103-0.10.80.60.50.90.087-0.10.90.60.50.90.061-0.110.60.50.90.025
0-0.50.60.50.9-0.3750-0.40.60.50.9-0.280-0.30.60.50.9-0.1950-0.20.60.50.9-0.120-0.10.60.50.9-0.055000.60.50.9000.10.60.50.90.04500.20.60.50.90.0800.30.60.50.90.10500.40.60.50.90.1200.50.60.50.90.12500.60.60.50.90.1200.70.60.50.90.10500.80.60.50.90.0800.90.60.50.90.045010.60.50.90
0.1-0.50.60.50.9-0.2750.1-0.40.60.50.9-0.1890.1-0.30.60.50.9-0.1130.1-0.20.60.50.9-0.0470.1-0.10.60.50.90.0090.100.60.50.90.0550.10.10.60.50.90.0910.10.20.60.50.90.1170.10.30.60.50.90.1330.10.40.60.50.90.1390.10.50.60.50.90.1350.10.60.60.50.90.1210.10.70.60.50.90.0970.10.80.60.50.90.0630.10.90.60.50.90.0190.110.60.50.9-0.035
0.2-0.50.60.50.9-0.1850.2-0.40.60.50.9-0.1080.2-0.30.60.50.9-0.0410.2-0.20.60.50.90.0160.2-0.10.60.50.90.0630.200.60.50.90.10.20.10.60.50.90.1270.20.20.60.50.90.1440.20.30.60.50.90.1510.20.40.60.50.90.1480.20.50.60.50.90.1350.20.60.60.50.90.1120.20.70.60.50.90.0790.20.80.60.50.90.0360.20.90.60.50.9-0.0170.210.60.50.9-0.08
0.3-0.50.60.50.9-0.1050.3-0.40.60.50.9-0.0370.3-0.30.60.50.90.0210.3-0.20.60.50.90.0690.3-0.10.60.50.90.1070.300.60.50.90.1350.30.10.60.50.90.1530.30.20.60.50.90.1610.30.30.60.50.90.1590.30.40.60.50.90.1470.30.50.60.50.90.1250.30.60.60.50.90.0930.30.70.60.50.90.0510.30.80.60.50.9-0.0010.30.90.60.50.9-0.0630.310.60.50.9-0.135
0.4-0.50.60.50.9-0.0350.4-0.40.60.50.90.0240.4-0.30.60.50.90.0730.4-0.20.60.50.90.1120.4-0.10.60.50.90.1410.400.60.50.90.160.40.10.60.50.90.1690.40.20.60.50.90.1680.40.30.60.50.90.1570.40.40.60.50.90.1360.40.50.60.50.90.1050.40.60.60.50.90.0640.40.70.60.50.90.0130.40.80.60.50.9-0.0480.40.90.60.50.9-0.1190.410.60.50.9-0.2
0.5-0.50.60.50.90.0250.5-0.40.60.50.90.0750.5-0.30.60.50.90.1150.5-0.20.60.50.90.1450.5-0.10.60.50.90.1650.500.60.50.90.1750.50.10.60.50.90.1750.50.20.60.50.90.1650.50.30.60.50.90.1450.50.40.60.50.90.1150.50.50.60.50.90.0750.50.60.60.50.90.0250.50.70.60.50.9-0.0350.50.80.60.50.9-0.1050.50.90.60.50.9-0.1850.510.60.50.9-0.275
0.6-0.50.60.50.90.0750.6-0.40.60.50.90.1160.6-0.30.60.50.90.1470.6-0.20.60.50.90.1680.6-0.10.60.50.90.1790.600.60.50.90.180.60.10.60.50.90.1710.60.20.60.50.90.1520.60.30.60.50.90.1230.60.40.60.50.90.0840.60.50.60.50.90.0350.60.60.60.50.9-0.0240.60.70.60.50.9-0.0930.60.80.60.50.9-0.1720.60.90.60.50.9-0.2610.610.60.50.9-0.36
0.7-0.50.60.50.90.1150.7-0.40.60.50.90.1470.7-0.30.60.50.90.1690.7-0.20.60.50.90.1810.7-0.10.60.50.90.1830.700.60.50.90.1750.70.10.60.50.90.1570.70.20.60.50.90.1290.70.30.60.50.90.0910.70.40.60.50.90.0430.70.50.60.50.9-0.0150.70.60.60.50.9-0.0830.70.70.60.50.9-0.1610.70.80.60.50.9-0.2490.70.90.60.50.9-0.3470.710.60.50.9-0.455
0.8-0.50.60.50.90.1450.8-0.40.60.50.90.1680.8-0.30.60.50.90.1810.8-0.20.60.50.90.1840.8-0.10.60.50.90.1770.800.60.50.90.160.80.10.60.50.90.1330.80.20.60.50.90.0960.80.30.60.50.90.0490.80.40.60.50.9-0.0080.80.50.60.50.9-0.0750.80.60.60.50.9-0.1520.80.70.60.50.9-0.2390.80.80.60.50.9-0.3360.80.90.60.50.9-0.4430.810.60.50.9-0.56
0.9-0.50.60.50.90.1650.9-0.40.60.50.90.1790.9-0.30.60.50.90.1830.9-0.20.60.50.90.1770.9-0.10.60.50.90.1610.900.60.50.90.1350.90.10.60.50.90.0990.90.20.60.50.90.0530.90.30.60.50.9-0.0030.90.40.60.50.9-0.0690.90.50.60.50.9-0.1450.90.60.60.50.9-0.2310.90.70.60.50.9-0.3270.90.80.60.50.9-0.4330.90.90.60.50.9-0.5490.910.60.50.9-0.675
1-0.50.60.50.90.1751-0.40.60.50.90.181-0.30.60.50.90.1751-0.20.60.50.90.161-0.10.60.50.90.135100.60.50.90.110.10.60.50.90.05510.20.60.50.9-010.30.60.50.9-0.06510.40.60.50.9-0.1410.50.60.50.9-0.22510.60.60.50.9-0.3210.70.60.50.9-0.42510.80.60.50.9-0.5410.90.60.50.9-0.665110.60.50.9-0.8
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000
0000000000000000