automatically generated pdf from existing images. · 2019-08-12 · this is to inform that all...
TRANSCRIPT
GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGALJUDICIAI- DEPARTMENT
IAIRITERS' BUILDINGS, KOLKATA - 1
No. 1218 Sl Dated, Kolkata, the 27rh June, 2016
To
The Managing Directorw.B.r.D.c.
Subiect : Ease Of Doinr Business (EoDBl
Sir,
As discussed in the meeting on 24.06.2016, with Hon'ble Minister-in-Charge,
Commerce & lndustries Department, Chief Secretary and other Departmental Secretaries, I
am enclosing the copy of
1) Order and supporting documents relating to filling up of vacancies at the Distrjct
Courts/Commercial Courts (point No. 330 of EODB)
2) Template relating to model commercial contracts (point No. 335 of EODB).
You are requested to upload a copy of the said orders in your website as part of
EODB - for the time being.
Yours sincerely,
GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGAT
JUDICIAL DEPARTMENT
WRITERS, BUILDINGS, KOLKATA - 1
No. 1217 S.l Dated, Kolkata, the 27th June, 2016
ToThe Managing Oirectorw.B.t.D.c.
subiect : Ease of Doine Business {EoDBl
Sir,
As discussed in the meeting oi 24.06.2076, with Hon'ble Minister-in-Charge,
Commerce & lndustries Department, Chief Secretary and other Departmental Secretaries,
this is to inform that all vacancies of the District Courts/Commercial Courts are filled up.
A copy of the judgements of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of "Malik Mazhar
sultan and Anr - Vs - UP, PsC & ors", Civil Appeal No 1867 of 2006 and other related
documenls are also enclosed in suppon.
You are requested to upload a copy of the said judgement and other related
documents in your website as part of EODB - for the time bein8.
j
Government of West BengalJudicial Department
Writers' Buildinss, Kolkata_1.
No. 1694-tlJ D/1M -0|/14(pt.) Dated:Kotkata,the 2"d April,201,6
From; Shri Paban Kumar MondalSecretary to the Government of West Bengal
To : The Registrar (Judicial Service)High Court, Appellate Side, Calcutta,Kolkata-1
Ref : Your letter No.5107-4 Dt.08.10.2015 & 502-4 Dt.05.02.2015
Sub: Particulars in respect of 52 successful candidates appointed in thecadre of Civil Judge (Junior Division) on the basis of the results ofw.B.J.S.E 2014.
Sir,
With reference to the above, lam to send herewith the particularsshowing the names & addresses, qualificatjons, Dates of Birth, reservationstatus etc. ln respect of 52 successful candidates appointed in the cadre of CivilJudge (Junior Division) on the basis of the results of W.B.J.S.E, 2014 and dulyappointed by this Depa rtment.
Elelq: As stated above.
Yours faithfully
+_ _9I' utlusecretary to the coverlment of w{tiAI"e"r
d\L
sc/sT/NAME &AODRESS
r,ts. nnsil xesuer, p/o. LATE sK HAslvIAT,2ND FLooR,
u-nj-rnaielr carlcul,v slo. ssir olrrvlcstru calculv, s+70'
r.c. a,rnrnlrt noeo, oeKsHINESWAR, P O. _ DAKSIIINESWAR'
Dlsr. - NoRrH 2 4-PARGAI!4!LP]!:7 0Qq? 6
r',rTserrentre oes, oTo IMARGoPAL DAs, DEBIGARH No l
rl-.lrne snantre, o7o.5IIRI RAMESH SHARMA, 6, RAI
MATHURA NATII CHOWDHURY STREI]T, AABANAGAR,
KUrrGHAr, NORrll 24-PARCANA!l!q!!q14:70!!!6- rMs. tab-antre cnarre-nlrgD/o snru PRAsANTA
B,A,1,1,8(HON5) 04.02.1990
31,07.1990
o1.10.1986
27.06.19E6
11.07.0988
15,10,1985
13.11.19E5
B.A,L.I,B(HONS),
B.A,L,L,B{HONS},
B.A, L.L.B
B.A,t.r.8(HoNS),
SAMNI, MADEYAMGRAM, P,O' . MADHYAMGRAM, DIST.
NORTH 24-PARGAN4q4qlKATA - 700 l2c.l-rs. sevelreNl cttouoHURY, D/O. SHRI UTTAII't clIouDIIURY, B.A, t.L.B(rloN5)
3/1/C, UKILAEAD ROAD, P.O - AERHAMPORE, DIST.
MURSHIDABAD, PIN . 742I01,
B.A,1.1.8(HONS) 07.10.1989
25.06.1990
8.A, t.1,8(HON5) 09.12,1988
& P,O, ' BURRABAZAR, KOL 7-
trn- sour.evies, s/o. snnr serlxel oes, x_el7r, xunt-onant B A,L L B 0l'07 1988
ROAD, P.S.. NADIAL, P,O.. BARTALA, DIST' . SOIJTH Z4'
B.A,L.I.B{HO'!S),
CHATTIRIEE, 18,A, VIVEKANANDA ROAD, P,O'. NABAGRAM,
Dlsr. - HoocHLY, PIN - 712246.ttls-. ttnerrtvrot, o7o. RAvl SHANI(AR TRIVEDI, 3K
RUPCHAND ROYSTREET,4TH FLOOR, NEAR BURRABAZAR, P'S'
tr4i. elutr cuexnesoRrY, s/o. sHRI BARUN cHAKRAB0RTY
VILL.AANBANIA(RAMKRISHNASARANI) NEARCHOWMATHA,
VIVEXANANDA PARK KAMDAIIARI, P,O.. GARIA, S,D, ' ALIPORE,
BHATTACHARYA, 254, SUtsODH PARX, FLAT NO,2A, P'O, & P'S'
BANSDRONI, KOLKATA. 70O O70,
t-
t
!4. - HABM, NoRrH 24-PARG4l!es, !!L?11_?!1. -.= , -. .:- - I
Ms. SEULI Roy, D/o. sHRI CHANDI CHARAN RoY, c/o. cHANDI B-Sc, L.L.SM5,5!ULr RuY, u/u rnK L/u lrrdrPiCHARAN ROY, BALITIKURI, CHAKPATI.A, P,O, BAKULTALA,DIST
- HOWRAH, PIN - 711113-I al"L.r.e{rons),
L,L.M11
\7
1l
MS, NILAN'ANA BANDYOPADTIYAY, D/O, SHRI DIPANT(AR
e-a,L.L.e(xol!s)
BANDYOPADHYAY, VILL 'ABASBARI, P,O, & P'S. ' TAMLUK DIST'
PIIRBA MEDINIPUR, PIN . 721636,MS, SUMANASAHA ROY, D/O, SHRI PRABIRSAHA ROY,8A, B.A,t.L.BlHONS)
AHAR LAL DUTTA LANE, P,O,. ULTADANGA, KOL- 67'
MS, SUMITA DEB ROY, D/O, LATE BIMALENDU DEB ROY, VILL
13.0E.1988
29.06.1989
, IALPAIGURI, PIN. 735209,DAMDIM, P,O, . DAMDIM, S,D, & P,S,. MALBAZAR, DIST.
M5. xorl pna5iidi, plo-sn2,,tJtrxuMAR PRADIIAN, v-sala, B.A,t.r.8(HONS),
DIST, . SOUTH 24'PARCANAs, KOLKATA 84.
rvrs serenupe rov, olo3nnr nsuoxxn.lov, oo-tz/r, B A,L L B(HoNs)
DESBANDHUNAGAR" BACUIATI, KOI-KATA, P,O, .
DESBANDHUNAGAR, DIST. NORTH 24'PARCANAS, PIN '700059.
MS, NABANITANANDY, D/O. SHRI DEBAARATA NANDY,l NO'
PALLYSREE COLONY, S.K. DEV ROAD, E,P, 136, PATIPUKURSREEBHUMI, S,D, ' BIDHANNAGAR, DIST,. NORTH 24'
,g,r-L-e(Botlst
28.11.1986
ls.oo.rgag
02.10.19E4
19.11-1984
04.11.1984
!2.07.1987
18.05.1987
12.01.1990
12.0s.1989
wrs-enasuve oev, o7o. sHRt sUNIL KR. D[Y, 25l3, BHARAll 8.1,5, L,L.B
ROAD, B.ZONE, Dt'RGAPUR - 5, P O. . A-ZONE, DIST' - BtJRDWAN,
PIN - 713205. g.A,L.L.B 15.02.19E918
19
I
t Z4.PAMs. rasnrue pltvrtu, D/o. MD. NURUL IIAQUI,26K, KusrlA a.A,l.L,a 16.01,1990
ROAD, P.S.-KAMYA, P.O. - TILIALA, KOL'39.20 MS. BISAKHA CHAUD}IURY, D/O. SHRI KUNAL CHAUDXURY, ' LA,L.L.B{HoNs) 12.04.1987
KOLKATA. TOO 123,
BLOCK X, TLAT.26, S.M, NAGAR HOUSING ESTATI', P,O'.
SARXARPOOL, DIST, . SOUTH 24'PARGANAS, (OLXATA 7OO
CNAKRABORTY. BABUPABA, VILL + P,O,. SONAMUKHI, S.D, .mn. erUlpeftl CnernABORTY, S/O. SATYA NARAYANARAYAN M.S(, L.L M
,IUKHI, S.D,.
BISTINIJPUR, DIST,. BANKURA, PIN.7Z22O7' I
-lri. surnesese, nlo.lltrS,lne, oo x' roeo, lrlcecul,r, B A,L.L.B(HoNs),
Un. SetlllttlOv pel, S/O SHRI DEBABMTA PAL, 9A, PANPARA
FIFTH LANE, P,O,. TALPUKUR, BARRACKPORE, DIST' - NORTH
HOWRAH . 8, P.O. NETAIIGARH, S.D, . HOWnAH SADAR, P'S. L.L'M
POLEGHAT, P.O, - DAKSHIN IAGADDAL, P,S' ' SONARPUR, S'D
rrD I ArruA^rri J.u _rrvtr
l.r LUAH, DIST. - HOWRAH, PIN-7 t 1 I 08 l
Mn. susHeotp MlrRAto. stlru eleotp xn ulrne,zzo tc B.a,L L B{HONs),
KHAN ROAD, LAKEVIEW, P,O,. MANKUNDU, S'D,. L.T'M
CHANDERNAGORE,IIOOGHLY, PIN 712139.
MS. ytsMtN ARA KHATUN, o7o. ttnsitr'l elt uolutt vtlr _ B A,L L
MS. AMRITA BANER]EE, D/O, SUBRATA KUMAR BANIRIEE, B.A,L.t.B(HON5),
B,A,L,L.B
AMAR BASU SAMNI, RAM MANDIR, P,O, BURRABAZAR,
23, 30.07.1988
6
K0LKATA 7oooo7. I
- =
]vsstruxil irwrrswtroErrrr iepeswr, r j, I A,L L B(HoNsl 13 01 1990
IOGENDRANATH GHOSAL ROAD, P'O.' ARIADAHA, KOLKATA'700 057
r,,rT nar,rl,enl x,isnver, p-lo.t,e....rr arlroo xn. sen, cTo nerlt I i s r' r'L a za.or.rgag J5AII, RAJBARI BINAY PALLY, NEAR SADHU BABA ASHRAM, P,O, '
seNirrvrxrretr, aolrut, otsl:qltBluM, PIN - 79121! ^- -^ -^;: - ^D.,^\,ili1#jiil*iffi^q"-#i;ii-rcr..i7o iai'e uu reztnur g'r,L isiHoNs) o1'1o leEe oBc (A)
rueui Iuult-tcx, t, i.x. cHosH RoAD, P.o. ' BELGACHIA,
XOLKATA . 7OO 037'ltssurvlrepe utrrrn, olo. r'laou,u orelo r'lrrrrn, a a,L L'B 23 06'1989 ll a
'r,ror,ro8eM" p-+, l"Iorl;uiEL evruur, oul't oum, r'o -
MR. MD, JONNY UL HAQUE MULLILK, 5/U ,A I L MU,IAZIDUL' r,qoui uur,r-rcx, r, iK. GHosH RoAD, P.o.' BELGACHIA,
XOLKATA . 7OO 037'MS. SURYATAPA MITTIR, O7O. UaOU,U CnelO t'ltfff& a A'L L'B 23 06'1989 N A
I
'r,ror,ro8eM" p-+, l"Iorl;uiEl evruur, oul't oum, r'o - L
MOTUHEEL, P,S,. DUM DUM, DI5T, ' NORTII z4-PARGANAS,KOLXA rA _ 700 074
M5. RITwTKA MoHANTA. D/o. RANIAN MollANTn, rl,ti llo ze, g'a,L t_BGotlsi zs os rgeg - N a
+
__-,.t""lttII
16.10.1e83 oBc (B) I
DlsT. DAR'EELING, PtN - 73400S44 Ms. NAtMUs sAlar, o/o. Mn. egous settin, z plLxHe'l,r
FIRST LANE, 1ST FLOOR. P.O, . HOWR.AH, P,S, . GOIIIBARI,HOWRAX 711 101.
sOUTII24 P RCANAS, KOLXATA 7OO 137. ir..rn. snrDIP BirreV, 5/O. atltt oluax]tt u,{LL^v, a_r/:s' B A,L.L.B(HONS], 1l'08'1986
KALYANI, P.O, & P,S, - KALYANI, S,D. ' XALYANI, DI5T. - NADIA, L.T,M
PIN ,741235.6.A,L,L.B{HONS),
B.A,!.t.8(HON5) 10.09.1989
B.A,L.L.8{HON5), 04.041947l-,1.M
DIST, B NKURA, PIN .722140,
us. srrrlclre nov, o7o surl nenesu ctt. iov, ztlo mrrt, B.a,L.L.8(HoN5) 27 02'1!188
SEVOI( ROAD, IYOTINAGAR (NEAR ULKAMAT ) AINAY
CHOUDHURY SABAN I, HOUSE NO- 52, SILIGURI, P,O.. SEVOKE
ROAD, P.S. BHAKTINAGAR, DIST. -'ALPAIGURl, Pl!:73!q01trttJntrosu xn. stanMA, S/o. SHRl arr.alBllusHAI\I SHARMA,
QR NO, 127(A), RLY, SOUTH COLONY, NIP, P,O, ' AIIAKTINACAR,)rsT. ' IALPAIGURI, Pllll -734007.
rus. nrinvirnne, o7o. xAILAsH srNGlI RESTDTNcATlI. No 452,NAYA BAZAR, W/NO 8, IAGDEOBHAWAN, I ST !'LOOR, SILICURI,
oBC (A)
t of rtE tB,Ls AfnCEtS iPtuInED U r E CAtfrE OF C'.r u& DIln) olt |HE &ES(0LT O?rt',$ EX-'l ', 2o',1
XAMALA APARTMENT, 8.1, NORTHERN PARX, P.O -
BANSDRONI, KOLKATA - 7OO 07O,
M5. pnenrnane seNenlEE, D/o. TARUN BANtRIEE, 53/7,MAJLISH ARA ROAD, P,O, . BEIIALA, SOUTII 24'PARGANAS,
KOLK TA - 700 04l.r'TSJEgE PENVTTN, U/O, LATE MOIIAMMED YA5IN,81A/1,TOPSIA ROAD, 2ND IILOOR, P,O, . TILIALA, XOLKATA ' 39,
MS. ANANYA CHATTERIEE, D/O,IITEN CHATTER'EE, HATTALA
RoAD, P.orjlurylvEs!!4Br9r!L:!uE!!4[f Ir! :z]!!14MS, SANIUKT BIIATTACIIARYA, D/O. DR, SUDIPTA
BHATTACHARYA, Z411A, GARCHA TIRST I,ANE, P'O, 'BALLYGUNGE, KOLIGTA ' 7OO 019.
MR. SK.IATAR ALI, S/O. SK, IALIL, VILL . IIENTALKIIALIDAI{SHINPAR.A, P.O,. IIENTALKHALI, P,S,. MAIIESIITALA, DIST,
u-. vozlle r.aue, o7o. ltR. PEMA LAMA, SUNRISE scHooL,HARSING HATTA, P,O, . LEAONG, DIST. - DAR'EELING, PIN '
714105.us. sauare oes, o7o. sHRI SAMBHU DAS,7Ol3' ALIPORII
ROAD, P,O,. ALIPORE, KOLKATA. TOO 027,
MR. rAPAS LAHA. S/O. SUrt OUnCe SAlXen lau,r' nrKHATRA, SRI RAMKRISHNA SARANI, P O. + P.S. + S.D. ' KHATM,
lri. Ltot Lau Mex,rrrrs flossAlN, s/o. KADAM RAsUL MoLLAH,
MR, MD, SAMIM AUIM, S/O. MD. SHAH ALAM, 127, B.C, ROAD,
B484E4Z & S.p.4 SEI. - BURpWAN, PIN -lla10lMR, ABDUL HOQUE, S/O EMAMUL HOQUE, BELCHORIA R.P
HOUSING ESTATE, BLOCK NO, N.1/S, P.O, & P,S,. BELGHORIA,
DIST,' NORTH 24 PGS,, PIN- 7OOO56,
rvrnJesvANGbonlcEsrrinia,s/:o.rawltcrercavisrs.r'a,iANGEL LODGE, CHOTA xAK IIIOPv{, DARJEELINC, PIN ' 734 101' ]
ns. seiinata oes,blo. snru alnori oes, cTo lorol
rs
,g
,OJ
31
fz
33
14
35
47
tM.A, L,t,M, M,B,A
S,A,L.L,B(HONS),
B.A,rra(HoN5),
' B.A,L.L.BIHON5), 04.10 1988
B.A,L.!.8(HON5) 04.04.1990
27.12.1988
07.101986
04.02.,.985
it5
,tf 5.C
r'E
5.7
rl5C
a.a,t.t.s
S.A,L,I,B 12.01 1983 osc (A)-
-t4sl 4.5c., L.La 25.12.19a2,li oBc(A) Illls.clIl] oBc(a)
I
l 59, GOLAM HOSSAIN SARDAR LAN[, P,O, SIIIBPUR, DISTIIOWRAH, P]N 711 IO2
MR, BINOD VISIIWAXARMA, S/O, SIIRI CUNGESTIWAR B.A(HONs),!-r.B 11.07.1984
VISHWAKARMA, PURE IAMAAD COLLIERY, P,O, - BAHULA, S'D' -
I)IIRCAPIIR PIN. 713322,
46
B.A(HON5),l.L.B 04.08,1987
B'4, L. L.b )3 Oar tggri o'c (A)
a.a1roNs1,r.l.e 02.04.1984
I
ST
S,T
50
si
4!qE!llqlgElc!orA 44usseonala oes, o7o. sHRI aMoD DAs, C/O LOTON s a,r-r."(Ho^rs) --] olE.reao f s.c
MALqKAR, P.O. + VILL _ CHOGOMALI, NIRANIAN NACAR, P.S _
BHAKTINACAR, DIST, . IALPAIGIJRI, PIN 7340061lr-reoeN ouxee, o7o. NARt DUKPA, RAti4PURIA BUsrY, P.o.
TANDAH, P.S, - RANGI-I RANGLIOT, DI5T. DAR]EELINC, PIN
g.l,t.t.g(ttottls) 14.01.1987
t734222.
Ms. eunrte pner'lertcK, D/o. AMAR Pn-lMANIcK, t4/12A'BtaEN ROY ROAD [EAST), P.O. - BARISHA. DIST. - 50UTH 24
s.com,,L,t,B
--i
03.10.1980
lTlPARGANAS, PIN . 7OO O0II,
48
All @mmunrcahns shoutdNomber Dale I Subt€ctpEvi)]rs corcspond$@a&ressed lo lhe Se.@iary
From
To
t i 2466.2266,05,46i 1540
&ln. {05Diecr 2466{622Far :€1-$246&0992
& PUBLIC SER\/ICE COllll]vlISSION, llllEST BENGAL161.A, S. P, MUKHERJEE ROAD, KOLKATA -7OO 026
xe. A - 201 p.s.s. 1a1
Sri P. C. Sit,Secretary, Public Service Commjssion, West Bengal.
: The Secretary to (he Govt. oi West Bengdl,Judicial Department,Writers' Eurldings. Btock-t, 1'r Ftoor,Kolkata - 700 001
rolkata, thel[J,aay,20r5
Sub. : Revjsed allotment of qualified candidates for appointment in the w.B. Judiciat Serviceon the results of W.e. .Judicial Service Examinaiibn,ZO14.
Ref. : Your deoartment,s letterNo. 15This office letter No. A 169 pSC lAl dt.29.L2.2014.
Sir,
. lam directed to refer to your department,s letter No.1599J/JD//1M-01/14(pt) dt. 16.04.2015 on thesubje.t noted above and to state that on the basis of your depanment;i Lquisition to,- fiffing up 52(fifty two)IUR 35, SC- 05, ST 03, BC(A)- 05 & Bc(B), o4l vacancies the commission'haf prepared a setect tist of 117candidates sent earlier quaJified on the results of the west Bengal Judicial servrce Examination, 2014.lam funher to state that Commission initially recommended G2 (38 cteared and 24 anticjpated)candldates for fi,ing up against 64 (39 cleared and 25 anticipated) ;ul"*,"1 Ja",no offi.e tetrer No. A_169_PSC(A) dt. 29.12.2014 from the aforesaid select tist. Now in response i" ,*. O"p"ur"*,, .equest for sendingrecommendation for revised alotmenr against 52 IUR- 35, sC,05, ST,03, gC(;)- 05 & BC(B)_ O4l confirmedvacancies vide tetter No. 1599 JrDl/1M,01/14{p0 dt. 16.04.2015 the commrsion recommends 52 [uR- 35,sc
.05' sr- 03, BC(A)- 05 & 8C(B)- O4r candidares aSainst 52 confirmed/ creareJvacancies in canceflation of itsearlier recommendation vide retter No. A-169-psc(A) dt. 29.12 2014. The name, have been arranSed in orderof merits.
The original applications and other aonnected papers of the above 52 candidates stated in the enclosedlist (except at sr' No 48 in the encroserr rist) have .rready o""n t"nt to vo, ,ia" this office retter No. 4-169,PsC(A) dt 29 12 2014 The same in respect of the remainrng candidates may be sent oack to this office at anearly date. The originar appri.ation and other.onnected pap;rs in respect or'tne .anaioate at sr. No. 48 in theenclosed list are enclosed.
The Appointing authority is requested that before offering appointment the eritibirity ofthe candidatesmay be verafied. For this purpose the statements of the .andidai;s made in the appti.ation reSarding dateof binh, educational qualiri.ations, caste etc. may be veriried with reference to the valid o/ginal ceniric.teso, the candidates. rt is arso requested to have the .".t" .",ri;;;";';; th" candidates verified as p€iprovision of the west Bengar schedured caste a scneautea rriues 1ii"",];*ii-".r Act, 1994 and e6twhireS.heduled Castes and Tribes Welfare Depanment (now BCW O"p"n,nunt)- O,Ou, No, 261-IVEC/MR.103/94 dated 06'04'199s and 6320-BcwMa'errro aated 2a;9.2;-i; iilpiotocrapr, "na
,irnature ol thecandidates in the applications may also be veriried,Any discrepancy may kindry be communicated to the commission immediately berore offeringappointment.I am to request you again that befoJe offering appointment the intetrity of the candidaie(s) who ir /are already employed by the Govt. ot west_Bengal, may b€ verifi€d Uy ttre a-ppointing authority. ln case th€report in resped ot any candidate(s) is / are unsaiisfacto,y ;"1' ;; ;ij;l","(s) is / are consider€dunsuirable ,or appointment(s) on grounds of integrity the matte; m"y i" ,ur"rr"i o** ,o the commission.The candadates have not been medically examined nor have their uni"a"o"n,, been verified by theCommission. Appropriate actron in this regard may be made Uy ttre appolntingauttrority.The Commissron may be rnformed early of the uction taken on the reaorn'n'"nOution.An acknowledgement of re(erpt of the letter wttn its encfosure ls ielueliea.
'
Yours faithfulty,
PnSecretary l'l'tEnclo:As above
Enctosure to tetter No. A - 2o 1 p.s.c. (a) dated 5 & May,2o15
List of candidates recommended for appointment against confirmed/ cleared vacancies in theWest Benpal Judiclal Service on the results of the West Eenpal Judicial Service Examination. 2014.
Sl. No. Roll Name Position in order of Merit
1 0100916 ARSHI HASMATIBC.A] 1" in the Select List{alloned against unrese ed vacancy)
2 0101575 DEBAYAN GANGULY 2'd in the Select List
3 0101293 SAPTAMtTA DASlBC,El 3'o in the Select List(allotted arainst un.e5erued vacancv)
0101351 SAYANTANICHOUOHURY 4rh in the Select tist5 01013s3 NEHA SHARMA 5th in the select tist
6 0100281 NABANITA CHATTERJEE 6th in the Select List
1 0100933 RIHA TRIVEDI 7'h in the select List
8 0100936 SOURAV OAS 8'h in the select List
9 0100367 AMIT CHAKRAEORTY grh in the select List
10 0101324 SEU LI ROY lorh in the Select List
11. 0101305 NILANJANA SANOYOPADHYAY 11r" in the Select List
t2 0100328 SUMANA SAHA ROY 12ri in the Select List
13 0100502 SUMITA DEB ROY 13'h in the select List
l4 0100101 KOYEL PRADHAN 14th in the Select List
15 0100129 SATARUPA ROY 1srh in the Select l-ist
16 0101344 NABANITA NANDY 15(h in the select tist71 0100938 ANASUYA DtY 17rh in the Select List
18 0101515 SAMIIINIOY PAL 18th in the Select List
19 0100323 NASRINA PARVEEN 191^ in the Select List
20 0100179 EISHA(HA CHAUDHURY 2orh in the Select List
21 0100905 ARINDAM CHAKRABORTY 21'r in the Select l-ist
22 0701171 SUNITA SAHA 22^d in the select List
21 0100269 SUBHADIP I\,1ITRA 23'd in the select List
24 0101176 YESMIN ARA KHATUN 24'h in the Select List
25 0101437 ARUNIMA BHATTACHARYA 25rh in the 5elect List
26 0100303 AMRITA BANERIEE 26rh in the Select List
21 0100312 SHUKTITAPASWI 27th in the Select List
28 010008s RANIANI KASHYAP 28r'in the Select Lrst
29 010158s MD JONNY UL HAQUE MULLlC( (8C.A) 29'^ in the Select l-ist(allotted aga nn unreserued vacancy)
30 0101186 SURYATAPA MITIER 3O1h in the Select l-ist
31 0101300 RITWIKA MOHANTA 31irin the Select l-ist
32 0101317 PRARTHANA BANEfuEE 32"d in the select List
33 0100308 zEEA PERVEEN (8C-A) 33'd in the Select List(allotted asainn u6.ererved vacancv)
34 0101116 ANANYA CHATTER,]€€ 34rh in the Select List
35 0101131 SANJUKTA BHATTACHARYA 35th in the Select List
36 0100228 s( rAFAR ALt (BC-A) 45'h in the Select List
37 0100906 sRrDrP BALLAV (8C,8) 52"d in the Select tist38 0200018 YOZNA LAMA (5T) 53'd in the Select List
39 0100306 SAMATA DAS (BC.B) 55rh in the Select List
40 0100904 TAPAS LAHA (BC B) 56th in the Select List
Contd...Page 2
I
-2-
,#l')''Public Service Commission,
West Eengal.
Sl. No. Roll no, Name Position in order of Merit
47 0101569 SANGTTA ROY (SC) 69" in the select List
42 0101974 SANTOSH KUMAR SHARMA (SC) 79'h in the sel€ct List
43 0100893 RUBY SINHA (BC B) 85'n in the select List
A4 0101965 NA.tMUS SAsAR (BC-A) 86'n in the select List
45 0101595 MOLLAH MAHATAE HOSSA]N (BC.A) 88ri in the select List
46 0101653 BINOD VISHWAKARMA (SC) 89'h in ihe Select tist
41 0101040 MO SAMIM AL,AM (BC-A) 9o'h in the Select List
49,' 0101527 ABDUL HOQUE (BC A) 93'd in the Select List
49 0200014 ]ABYANG OORJEE SHERPA (ST) 94rh in the Select List
50 0101778 SADHANA DAS (SC) g7'h in the select List
/57 0200023 PEDEN DUKPA (5T) 98ih in the Select List
52 0101732 AMRITA PRAMANICK (SC) looth in the select List
, DEBI PROSAD DEY
, 4t.rcrntn IUD\CIAL SERVTCE)tl {rc,, aou RT, C,4ICUTTA
I'. \
Most Urg€ntBy Sp€cial Messcnger
3, Esplanacic \VtstKolkata-Z)0 001Phone : (033) 2243 5085
(033) 2254 804sTele/Fax: (033) 22.13 9306Mobile : (033) 8697742i30
t\
No-ll98-A.
ToThe Secrelar! to the Goverument of West Bengal,Judiciol Deparlmenl,hiters' Buildings,Kolkota - 700 001.
Doled. Colcutto, the l 3th Motch, 20 1 5.
Sub. ConJirnitg vacancJ.in the botic.\tlre of Civil Julge (Ju,tior Division)/JudicialMagislrulelfu appoihtnult lrot , the West Be gtl Ju(liciat Service Exauinalion-_2!U.
Sir.
*tonunoLhtttJ in the rct^td cuth.e :rrL,nyrh
li)u o( reqrcltel k' proceel u.L\rdirgh ut \t)w ! tt.
lour\ liithfully.
a|_..--ADchi Protrl Dey \)
Rcgistr$ (J udicinl Sen'ie)
u^.
I.t,/
zc"\\ CQ+'- &.d5r€arTijr
*/\,,"
K*"S'
ITEM NO.27 COURT NO.1 SECTION XI
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
CIVIL APPEAL NO.1867 OF 2006
MALIK MAZHAR SULTAN AND ANR. Appellant (s)
VERSUS
U.P. PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION & ORS. Respondent(s)
(With appln(s) for exemption from filing O.T., clarification of
court's order dated 03/04/2006 and office report)
With Civil Appeal No.1868 of 2006
(With office report)
Civil Appeal No.1869 of 2006
(With office report)
Civil Appeal No.1870 of 2006
(With office report)
Civil Appeal No.1871 of 2006
(With office report)
Civil Appeal No.1872 of 2006
(With office report)
[For Final Directions]
Date: 04/01/2007 These matters were called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.K. THAKKER
For Appellant(s)
In CA 1867/2006: Mr. Ejaz Maqbool,Adv.
Mr. Vikash Singh,Adv.
Ms. Taruna Singh,Adv.
Mr. Abhijeet Sinha,Adv.
In CA 1872/2006: Mr. Shail Kumar Dwivedi,Adv.
In CA 1868-71/2006: Mr. C.D. Singh,Adv.
Mr. Merusagar Samantaray,Adv.
Mr. M.K. Singh,Adv.
For Respondent(s) Mr. Lakshmi Raman Singh,Adv.
Mr. Debasis Misra,Adv.
Mr. Dharmendra Kumar Sinha,Adv.
...2/-
- 2 -
Mr. Arvind Kumar Tiwary,Adv.
Mr. Ranjan Dwivedi,Adv.
For Allahabad High Mr. Ashok K. Srivastava,Adv.
Court: Mr. Shaiwal Srivastava,Adv.
Mr. K.K. Mohan,Adv.
For M.P. High Court: Mr. C.D. Singh,Adv.
Mr. Merusagar Samantaray,Adv.
For Uttar Pradesh: Dr. R.G. Padia,Sr.Adv.
Mr. Pradeep Misra,Adv.
Mr. T. Mahipal,Adv.
Mr. Kamlendra Mishra,Adv.
Mr. Prakash Kumar Singh,Adv.
Mr. S. Chandra Shekhar,Adv.
For High Court of Mr. Janaranjan Das,Adv.
Orissa: Mr. Swetaketu Mishra,Adv.
For Bombay High Court: Mr. Aniruddha P. Mayee,Adv.
Mr. Sanjeev Kumar Choudhary,Adv.
Mr. Sanjay Visen,Adv.
For Gujarat: Ms. Hemantika Wahi,Adv.
Ms. Pinky Behera,Adv.
For Tripura: Mr. Gopal Singh,Adv.
Mr. Rituraj Biswas,Adv.
Mr. Nishakant Pandey,Adv.
For Bihar: Mr. Gopal Singh,Adv.
Mr. Nishakant Pandey,Adv.
For West Bengal: Mr. Bhaskar P. Gupta,Sr.Adv.
Mr. Tara Chandra Sharma,Adv.
Ms. Neelam Sharma,Adv.
For Himachal Pradesh: Mr. J.S. Attri,AAG.
Mr. Vivek Singh,Adv.
For Arunachal Pradesh: Mr. Anil Shrivastav,Adv.
Ms. Smita Shankar,Adv.
For Assam: Mr. Riku Sarma,Adv.
for M/s. Corporate Law Group,Advs.
For Gauhati High Court: Mr. Vijay Hansaria,Sr.Adv.
Mr. P.I. Jose,Adv.
Mr. Anupam Mishra,Adv.
Ms. Sneha Kalita,Adv.
Ms. Deepti,Adv.
...3/-
- 3 -
For Tamil Nadu and Mr. V.G. Pragasam,Adv.
Pondicherry: Mr. S. Vallinayagam,Adv.
For Mizoram: Mr. K.N. Madhusoodhanan,Adv.
Mr. R. Sathish,Adv.
For Goa: Ms. A. Subhashini,Adv.
For Manipur: Mr. Kh. Nobin Singh,Adv.
Mr. S. Biswajit Meitei,Adv.
Mr. David Rao,Adv.
Mr. Prashant Chaudhary,Adv.
For Jammu & Kashmir: Mr. Altaf H. Naiyak,AG
Mr. Anis Suhrawardy,Adv.
For Chhattisgarh: Mr. Rajesh Srivastava,Adv.
Ms. Suparna Srivastava,Ad.
Ms. Pooja Matlani,Adv.
For Rajasthan High Mr. Sunil K. Jain,Adv.
Court: Mr. S. Borthakur,Adv.
For Punjab: Ms. Avneet Toor,Adv.
Mr. Sanjay Jain,Adv.
for Mr. Arun Kumar Sinha,Adv.
For Rajasthan: Mr. Aruneshwar Gupta,AAG.
Mr. Naveen Kumar Singh,Adv.
Mr. Mukul Sood,Adv.
Mr. Shashwat Gupta,Adv.
Ms. Shikha Tandon,Adv.
Mr. J.K. Bhatia,Adv.
Mr. R.S. Jena,Adv.
Mr. Siddharth Panda,Adv.
For Sikkim and Mr. A. Mariarputham,Adv.
Delhi High Court: Ms. Aruna Mathur,Adv.
for Arputham, Aruna & Co.,Advs.
For Meghalaya: Mr. Ranjan Mukherjee,Adv.
Mr. S.C. Ghosh,Adv.
For Uttaranchal: Ms. Rachana Srivastava,AAG.
For Karnataka: Mr. Sanjay R. Hegde,Adv.
Mr. Anil K. Mishra,Adv.
Mr. Vikrant Yadav,Adv.
Mr. Sashidhar,Adv.
For Kerala: Mr. G. Prakash,Adv.
Ms. Beena Prakash,Adv.
For Nagaland: Mr. U. Hazarika,Adv.
Mr. Satya Mitra,Adv.
Ms. Sumita Hazarika,Adv.
...4/-
- 4 -
For Madhya Pradesh: Mr. Vikrant Singh Bais,Adv.
Mr. B.S. Banthia,Adv.
For N.C.T. of Delhi: Mr. R. Mohan,ASG.
Mr. S.W.A. Qadri,Adv.
Mr. R.C. Kathia,Adv.
Mr. D.S. Mahra,Adv.
For U.Ts.: Mr. R. Mohan,ASG.
Mr. S.W.A. Qadri,Adv.
Ms. Vandana Bhandari Gugnani,Adv.
Mr. D.S. Mahra,Adv.
For Maharashtra: Mr. S.S. Shinde,Adv.
Mr. V.N. Raghupathy,Adv.
For M/o Law & Justice: Mr. S.W.A. Qadri,Adv.
Mr. P. Parmeswaran,Adv.
For State of Haryana: Mr. Manjit Singh,Adv.
Mr. Harikesh Singh,Adv.
Mr. T.V. George,Adv.
For Punjab & Haryana Mr. Nidhesh Gupta,Adv.
High Court: Mr. Vinod Shukla,Adv.
Mr. Deepak Goel,Adv
Ms. S. Janani,Adv.
For Sikkim High Court: Mr. Vishnu Sharma,Adv.
For Andhra Pradesh: Ms. D. Bharathi Reddy,Adv.
Mr. P. Vinay Kumar,Adv.
Ms. Sneha Bhaskaran,Adv.
Mr. P.H. Parekh,Adv.
Mr. Sameer Parekh,Adv.
Mr. Ajay K. Jha,Adv.
Ms. Sonali Basu Parekh,Adv.
Mr. Deeksha Rai,Adv.
For Calcutta High Mr. Jaideep Gupta,Sr.Adv.
Court: Mr. Raja Chatterjee,Adv.
Mr. Sachin Das,Adv.
Mr. G.S. Chatterjee,Adv.
For Himachal Pradesh: Mr. J.S. Attri,Addl.Adv.Genl.
Mr. Vivek Singh Attri,Adv.
Mr. B.S. Jain,Adv.
Mr. Ajay Veer Singh,Adv.
Dr. (Mrs.) Vipin Gupta,Adv.
Mr. Sandeep S. Tiwari,Adv.
...5/-
- 5 -
Mr. Arvind Kumar Tiwary,Adv.
Mr. Radhe Shyam Sharma,Adv.
Mr. Ranjan Dwivedi,Adv.
UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following
O R D E R
It was about five years' back that this Court directed
that existing vacancies in the subordinate courts, at all levels,
should be filled, if possible, latest by 31st March, 2003, in all
the States. This direction is contained in the judgement
reported in All India Judges Association vs. Union of India
(2002 (4) S.C.C. 247). It has been noticed that an independent
and efficient judicial system is one of the basic structure of our
Constitution. If sufficient number of judges are not appointed,
justice would not be available to the people thereby
undermining the basic structure. The judicial system has been
facing the problem arising out of delay in dispensation of
justice for which one of the major cause is insufficient number
of judges when compared to either the large number of cases
pending or in relation to the average judge-population ratio
going by the number of judges available in various other
democracies in the world. In this light, it becomes all the more
necessary to take all possible steps to ensure that vacancies in
the courts are timely filled.
Mr. Vijay Hansaria, learned amicus curiae, in the
written submission, has pointed out that according to the
figures given by the News Letter issued by this
Court for the period January-March, 2006, there were 2730
posts vacant in the subordinate judiciary in the country as only
11,682 judges actually were serving out of the approved
strength of 14,402 judges, i.e., on an average, about twenty per
cent existing posts were lying vacant.
6 -
In this matter, by judgement and order dated 3rd
April, 2006, it was observed that it is absolutely necessary to
evolve a mechanism to speedily determine and fill vacancies of
judges at all levels. For this purpose, timely steps are required
to be taken for determination of vacancies, issue of
advertisement, conducting examinations, interviews, declaration
of final results and issue of order of appointment. It was
further directed that for all these above and other steps, it is
necessary to provide to fix time schedule so that the system
works automatically and there is no delay in filling up of the
vacancies. The dates for taking up these steps can be provided
for on the pattern similar to filling of vacancies in some other
services. Adherence to strict time schedule can help in ensuring
timely filling of vacancies. In this view, all the State
Governments, Union Territories and/or High Courts were
directed to give suggestions regarding the time schedule to be
fixed so that every year vacancies that may occur are filled.
This Court also requested Mr. Vijay Hansaria, senior advocate,
to assist the court.
Considering the suggestions that have been given by
the State Governments, the learned amicus curiae submitted
written submissions, which were considered by this Court on
27th November, 2006. On the said date of hearing, it was
directed that the written submissions of the learned amicus
curiae along with the proposed suggestion as to time schedule
be sent to the State Governments/Union Territories and High
Courts so that their response/suggestions can also be taken into
consideration. Some of the State Governments and High Courts
have responded to the directions dated 27th November, 2006.
Mr. Vijay Hansaria has made additional submission having
regard to the responses received from the State Governments,
Union Territories and the High Courts pursuant to the order
dated 27th November, 2006.
7 -
Before we issue general directions and the time
schedule to be adhered to for filling vacancies that may arise in
subordinate courts and district courts, it is necessary to note
that selections are required to be conducted by the concerned
authorities as per the existing Judicial Service Rules in the
respective States/Union Territories. We may, however, note
that, progressively, the concerned authorities would consider,
discuss and eventually may arrive at a consensus that the
selection process be conducted by the High Court itself or by
Public Service Commission under the control and supervision of
the High Court. In this regard, considerable progress has
already been made. Reference can be made to the decision
taken in a Conference held between the Chief Justices and Chief
Ministers, minutes whereof show that in some of the States,
selection of subordinate judicial officers at all levels of civil
judges is already being made by the High Courts. Some States,
where selection is still being made by the Public Service
Commission, were agreeable to entrust the selection to the High
Courts whereas Chief Ministers/Ministers of Himachal
Pradesh, West Bengal, Punjab and Kerala were of the view
that the present system may continue but the decision taken
jointly was that in the said States [Himachal Pradesh, West
Bengal, Punjab and Kerala] setting up of question papers and
evaluation of answer sheets be entrusted to the High Court.
Further decision taken was that in other States where selection
of subordinate judicial officers is not being done by the High
Courts, such selection be entrusted to the High Courts by
amending relevant Rules. In this connection, with the affidavit
filed on behalf of the Calcutta High Court, a copy of the letter
dated 15th September, 2006, addressed by the Registrar General
of the said Court to the Secretary,
- 8 -
Judicial Department, Government of West Bengal, has also
been annexed. That letter refers to the aforesaid decision taken
in the Conference of Chief Ministers and Chief Justices held on
11th March, 2006 requesting the State Government for effecting
suitable amendment in the recruitment rules in terms of the
decision in the Conference above-referred. At this stage,
however, these are not the issues for our consideration. As
already indicated, the selection is to be conducted by authorities
empowered to do so as per the existing Rules.
Though no submission was made by any learned
counsel appearing for any State Government that the
constitution of selection committee by the Chief Justice of the
High Court to monitor the timely appointment of judges at
subordinate/district level would amount to interference with
the independent functioning of the State Public Service
Commission, but some State Governments in their responses
have indicated so. In view of what we have already noted about
the appointments to be made in accordance with the respective
Judicial Services Rules in the States, the apprehension of
interference seems to be wholly misplaced. A Committee
constituted by the Chief Justice of the High Court to ensure that
the vacancies are timely filled and the problem of delay in
dispensation of justice is tackled to some extent under no
circumstances be said to be interference with the independent
functioning of the authorities under the Rules or of
independent functioning of the State Public Service
Commission.
For filling up of vacancies in the cadre of District
Judges, accepting the proposal to which none has objected,
except in the manner hereinafter noticed, we direct as under:
- 9 -
A. For filling of vacancies in the cadre of District Judge
in respect of
(a) twenty five per cent vacancies to be filled by direct
recruitment from the Bar; and
(b) twenty five per cent by promotion through limited
competitive examination of Civil Judges (Senior Division) not
having less than five years of qualifying service.
S. Description Date
No.
1. Number of vacancies to be notified by 31st March
the High Court.
Vacancies to be calculated including
a] existing vacancies
b] future vacancies that may arise
within one year due to retirement.
c] future vacancies that may arise due
to elevation to the High Court, death
or otherwise, say ten per cent of the
number of posts.
d] Vacancies arising due to
deputation of judicial officers to
other department may be considered
as temporary vacancy.
2. Advertisement inviting applications 15th April
from eligible candidates
3. Last date for receipt of application 30th April
4. Publication of list of eligible 15th May
applicants
List may be put on the website
5. Despatch/issue of admit cards to the 16th May to 15th
eligible applicants June
6. Written Examination 30th June
Written examination may be
a] objective questions with multiple
choice which can be scrutinized by
the computer; and
b] subjective/narrative
S. Description Date
No.
7. Declaration of result of written 16th August
examination
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the newspaper
b] The ratio of 1 : 3 of the available
vacancies to the successful candidates
be maintained.
8. Viva Voce 1st to 7th
September
9. Declaration of final select list and 15th September
communication to the appointing
authority
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the newspaper
b] Select list be published in order of
merit and should be double the
number of vacancies notified.
c] Select list shall be valid till the
next select list is published.
10. Issue of appointment letter by the 30th September
competent authority for all existing
vacant posts as on date
11. Last date for joining 31st October
B. For filling of vacancies in the cadre of District Judge
in respect of fifty per cent vacancies to be filled by promotion.
S. Description Date
No.
1. Number of vacancies to be notified by 31st March
the High Court.
Vacancies to be calculated including
a] existing vacancies
b] future vacancies that may arise
within one year due to retirement.
c] future vacancies that may arise due
to elevation to the High Court, death
or otherwise, say ten per cent of the
number of posts.
2. Publication of list of eligible officers 15th May
a] The list may be put on the website
b] Zone of consideration should be
1 : 3 of the number of vacancies
S. Description Date
No.
3. Receipt of judgments from the 30th May
eligible officers
4. Viva Voce 15th to 31st July
Criteria
a] ACR for last five years;
b] Evaluation of judgments
furnished; and
c] Performance in the oral interview
5. Declaration of final select list and 31st August
communication to the appointing
authority
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the newspaper
b] Select list be published in order of
merit and should be double the
number of vacancies notified.
6. Issue of appointment letter by the 30th September
competent authority for all existing
vacant posts as on date
7. Last date for joining 31st October
C. For filling of vacancies in the cadre of Civil Judge
(Senior Division) to be filled by promotion.
S. Description Date
No.
1. Number of vacancies to be notified by 31st March
the High Court.
Vacancies to be calculated including
a] existing vacancies
b] future vacancies that may arise
within one year due to retirement.
c] future vacancies that may arise due
to promotion, death or otherwise, say
ten per cent of the number of posts.
2. Publication of list of eligible officers 15th May
a] The list may be put on the website
b] Zone of consideration should be
1 : 3 of the number of vacancies
3. Receipt of judgments from the 30th May
eligible officers
S. Description Date
No.
4. Viva Voce 1st to 16th August
Criteria
a] ACR for last five years;
b] Evaluation of Judgments
furnished; and
c] Performance in the oral interview
5. Declaration of final select list and 15th September
communication to the appointing
authority
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the newspaper
b] Select list be published in order of
merit and should be double the
number of vacancies notified.
6. Issue of appointment letter by the 30th September
competent authority for all existing
vacant posts as on date
7. Last date for joining 31st October
D. For appointment to the posts of Civil Judge (Junior
Division) by direct recruitment.
S. Description Date
No.
1. Number of vacancies to be notified by 15th January
the High Court.
Vacancies to be calculated including
a] existing vacancies
b] future vacancies that may arise
within one year due to retirement.
c] future vacancies that may arise due
to promotion, death or otherwise, say
ten per cent of the number of posts.
2. Advertisement inviting applications 1st February
from eligible candidates
3. Last date for receipt of application 1st March
4. Publication of list of eligible 2nd April
applicants
The list may be put on the website
5. Despatch/issue of admit cards to the 2nd to 30th April
eligible applicants
S. Description Date
No.
6. Preliminary written examination 15th May
Objective questions with multiple
choice which can be scrutinized by
computer
7. Declaration of result of preliminary 15th June
written examination
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the Newspaper
b] The ratio of 1 : 10 of the available
vacancies to the successful candidates
be maintained
8. Final Written examination 15th July
Subjective/narrative
9. Declaration of result of final written 30th August
examination
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the Newspaper
b] The ratio of 1 : 3 of the available
vacancies to the successful candidates
be maintained
c] Dates of interview of the successful
candidates may be put on the internet
which can be printed by the
candidates and no separate
intimation of the date of interview
need be sent.
10. Viva Voce 1st to 15th
October
11. Declaration of final select list and 1st November
communication to the appointing
authority
a] Result may be put on the website
and also published in the newspaper
b] Select list be published in order of
merit and should be double the
number of vacancies notified.
12. Issue of appointment letter by the 1st December
competent authority for all existing
vacant posts as on date
13. Last date for joining 2nd January of
the following
year
These directions would not be applicable to the
judiciary in the Sikkim High Court in view of a very small cadre
of judiciary in that State.
We request the Chief Justice of each High Court to
constitute a committee of two or three judges to monitor and
oversee that timely selection and appointment of judicial
officers is made. The Chief Justice is further requested to
constitute a special
- 15 -
cell in the name of `Selection and Appointment' in the High
Court or under such other name as the learned Chief Justice
may be consider proper with an officer of the rank of Registrar
for assisting the Committee and the Chief Justice for complying
with the aforesaid time schedule.
The Registrar of the aforesaid selection and
appointment committee shall send to the Registrar General of
this Court by 31st January every year report as regards the
filling up of vacancies with copies to Minister for Law and
Justice in the Central Government and the Law Minister of the
concerned State. The Registrar would also bring it to the
notice of the Committee and the Chief Justice any deviation
from the time schedule.
Insofar as the State of Bihar is concerned, the Patna
High Court has suggested that due to feasibility of floods, the
time schedule between June and November is not feasible and
that the time schedule of one year may be modified so as to
complete the selection process from December to June in the
said State. Learned counsel for the State Government and the
Public Service Commission has supported the view-point of the
High Court. Accordingly, the High Court can suitably, after
consulting with the Public Service Commission and the State
Government, amend the aforesaid time schedule. The amended
time schedule be filed in this Court.
Insofar as Delhi is concerned, it has been stated that
entire selection process is conducted by the High Court and
examination is held twice in a year for the Delhi Judicial
Service. The High Court may, accordingly, amend the aforesaid
time schedule so as to conduct the selection process twice in a
year and the revised time schedule shall be placed on the record
of this case. For the present, the Delhi High Court is permitted
three months' time for publication of final result after the
written examination.
- 16 -
The appointment letters shall be issued by the State
Government within one month of receipt of the
recommendations from the respective High Court/State Public
Service Commission.
The select list prepared for all categories of officials
shall be valid till the next select list is published.
We further direct that ten per cent of unforeseen
vacancies would be in respect of sanctioned posts and not
vacancies occurring in a particular year.
List of candidates eligible to appear in the
examination and final list shall also be published in the local
newspaper and be personally intimated to the officers, in
addition to the same being placed on the website.
The High Courts/State Governments/Union
Territories shall be at liberty to apply to this Court for
variation in the time schedule in case of any difficulty having
regard to the peculiar geographical and climatic conditions in
the State or other relevant
consideration. However, till such time a different time schedule
is permitted, the aforesaid time schedule shall be adhered to
and appointments made accordingly.
We place on record our appreciation for the assistance
rendered by Mr. Vijay Hansaria, learned amicus curiae.
For further directions, list the matter after four
months.
[ T.I. Rajput ] [ V.P. Tyagi ]
A.R.-cum-P.S. Assistant Registrar