b to k π - yonsei universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_b2kpi... ·...

71
C. S. Kim (Yonsei Univ.) Collaboration with Chuan-Hung Cheng, Sechul Oh, J.H. Jeon, Y.W. Yoon ® B K 1) Is there any puzzle of new physics in decays? 2) Possible new physics from decays : Unparticle, Leptophobic Z’ ® B K ® B K 1 2010-10-18

Upload: others

Post on 23-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

C. S. Kim (Yonsei Univ.)Collaboration with Chuan-Hung Cheng, Sechul Oh, J.H. Jeon, Y.W. Yoon

®B K

1) Is there any puzzle of new physicsin decays?

2) Possible new physics from decays : Unparticle, Leptophobic Z’

®B K®B K

12010-10-18

Page 2: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-18 2

Page 3: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-18

+

+

3

Page 4: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-18 4

Page 5: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

B Kπ Puzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009

Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217

At March 2007Rc = 1.11 ± 0.07Rn = 0.97 ± 0.07

5 2010-10-18

Page 6: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

CP Asymmetries - HFAG March 2009

0

0 0( ) ( ) 0.14 0.03

(sin2 ) (sin2 ) 0.35 0.21S

CP CP

ccsK

B K B K

® ®

B Kπ Puzzle

6 2010-10-18

Page 7: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Quark Diagram Approach in B Kπ

Amplitude parameterization

0

0

0

0 0 0

( )

2 ( )

2

CEW

CEW EW

EW

A B K

A B K

A B K

A B K

®

®

®

®

with re-definition of 1 13 3

C CEW EW

CEW

®

®

7 2010-10-18

Page 8: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-188

Page 9: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-189

Page 10: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1810

Page 11: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1811

Page 12: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1812

Page 13: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1813

Page 14: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1814

Page 15: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Quark Diagram Approach in B Kπ

* *tb ts tc ub us uc tc ucV V V V

2 4

Hierarchy between the parameters

tc

EW,

CEW,

uc,

1

23

bk m2 2/

cu tu| / |

uc tc| / |

Buras, Fleischer

PLB. 341. 379 (1995)

uc u c

tct c

W

G m k G m k

E x G m kM

2

2

( , , ) ( , , )2( ) ln ( , , )3

b

km

2

2

1 14 2

uc

tc

0.2 0.4

Mishima, Yoshikawa

PRD. 70. 094024 (2004)C

EW| |

15 2010-10-18

Page 16: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Final form A B K A P0 0 ®

, ,Cuc EWP P A

T C EWi i i i i iT C EWA B K A e P r e e r e e r e

00 0 1 12

®

Ti i iTA B K A e P r e e 0 (1 )

®

C EWi i i iC EWA B K A e P r e e r e

000 0 0 00 1 12

®

We Neglect We set the strong phase of P to be zero all phase is relative to it We hold 7 unknown parameters We use value given by other analysis are real and positive, are phases of their amplitude

, , , , , ,T C EW T C EWP r r rδδδγ

ijA ij

Quark Diagram Approach in B Kπ

EWtc T C EW

tc tc tc

P r r r, , ,

16 2010-10-18

Page 17: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1817

Page 18: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1818

Page 19: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1819

Page 20: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1820

Page 21: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1821

Page 22: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2010-10-1822

Page 23: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Re-parameterization Invariance

We assume NP comes into PEW part (or C part)

sin( ) sin( )sin( ) sin( )

i i ie e e

For any phase

We can choose arbitrary at will, for any given

Botella, Silva 2005

N N N NN N N N N

i i i i ir r re e e e e

sin sin( )2 2 sin 2 sin

Absorbed into C Absorbed into EW

φ

,θη φ

0

Re-Parameterization Invariance

23 2010-10-18

Page 24: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

NP term is absorbed into SM term

C EN N

N

W

C EWN

i i iC EW

i i i

N i i

N Nii

C EN N

Wi

A A P r e e r e

P r e e r e

r

re

e e

r e e

0 00 1,21 )2 sin sin

sin sin(

CMC

NMN

i N iC C

ir ee r e r sin

sin

EWMW

NEM i

E

NN

W EWiir ee r e r

sin( )

sin

CMEW

MM iC

ME

i iWP e e er r 1

2

Re-Parameterization Invariance

24 2010-10-18

Page 25: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Original Form does not change

If there is NP

M MC C

M MEW E

C SM C SM

EW EWSM SMWr

r

r

r

( ) , ( )

,

A B K A P0 0 ®

MCT

MEWM i

EWi i i i

TM i

CA B K A e P r e r e re ee 00 0 1 1

2 ®

Ti i iTA B K A e P r e e 0 (1 )

®

MEW

MCM i M i

C Ei

WiA B K A e erP ee r

000 0 0 00 1 12

®

Analytic re-Solution (CSK, S Oh, Y Yoon, PLB665(2008)231)

25 2010-10-18

Page 26: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

P Br 0

CPT

CP

T CP T

RRA R

r R

2

2

sin2 1cot 1 1 1( ) cos 2 sin

(1 cot cot ) 1

Step 1 - , ,T TP rδ

Ti i iTA e P r e e (1 )

A P 0

Analytic Solution

T T T

CP T T

R r r

R r

21 2 cos cos

2 sin sin

B

B

R

0

0 0.90 0.05

T

T

P

r

(49.9 1.1)eV

0.14 0.07

20 11

reject

26 2010-10-18

Page 27: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Step 2 -

A A P xA P x

A A P xA P x

2 20 00 2 200

00

2 20 00 2 200

00

2 2ArcCos2 2

2 2ArcCos2 2

00 00,αα

T

T

i i i i iT

i i i i iT

A e A e P r e e xe

A e A e P r e e xe

0 00

0 00

0 00

0 00

2 (2 )

2 (2 )

Analytic Solution

x0A

00A

0A

00A

Two-fold ambiguity occurs.2 X 2 = 4 fold ambiguities in tatal.

27 2010-10-18

Page 28: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Step 3 - , , ,M MEW EW

M MC Crδ rδ

MEW

ME

MC

MC

W

y y yy

y y yy

y yy y

y yy y

r

r

2 2

2 2

1 cos( )sin 2

1 cos(2 )sin 2

cos cosArcTansin sin

cos( ) cos( )ArcTansin( ) sin( )

MEC

M

W

MEW

M

C

M iEW

M iE

M iC

M iC

i

W

i i

i i i

Ae e yePAe e y

rr e

r e

e

r e eP

00

00

00

00

2 1

2 1

Analytic Solution

y

yM

EWr

M iγCr e

γ γ

No discrete ambiguity

28 2010-10-18

Page 29: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Analytic Solution 4 different solutions for

We reject “Case 3” due to large prediction The SM estimate

0sKπS

0.12 0.039 , 61 , 22EW C C EWr rδδ

, , ,M MEW EW

M MC Crδ rδ

SKS 0 =0.33 0.21(data)

Case 2: Large C Case 4: Large EW

29 2010-10-18

Page 30: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Analytic Solution Step 4 - solutions for NP term

CMC

NMN

i N iC C

ir ee r e r sin

sin

EWMW

NEM i

E

NN

W EWiir ee r e r

sin( )

sin

4 Equations VS 7 unknowns - , , , , , ,N N NC EW C EWr rδδrφδ

30 2010-10-18

Page 31: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Additional Inputs a) Additional inputs from Flavor SU(3) Sym.

From B ππ decays

HFAG March 2007

Assuming no NP in B ππ

31 2010-10-18

Page 32: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Additional inputs from Flavor SU(3) Sym. B ππ parameterization

T C

T

C

i i i i

i i i

i i i

A B Te e Ce e

A B Te e Pe

A B Ce e Pe

®

®

®

0

0

0 0

2 ( )

( ) ( )

2 ( ) ( )

with 5 parameters

T C

P

Chisq-fitting with 5 measurements3 – Br, ( ),CP ππAππS

0 0 0.33CP 0.31( )=0.36 (data)

us

ud

VC CV

(3.8 0.4)eV

EW T Ci i iEW T C

b

c cr e r e r ec c R

9 10

21 2

3 1 ( )2

C C

EW EW

r

r

( , ) (0.076 0.008, 12 15 )

( , ) ( 0.14 0.04, 9 10 )

Gronau, Pirjol, Yan (1999)

Additional Inputs

32 2010-10-18

Page 33: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

b) Additional inputs from PQCD result

Li, Mishima, Sanda, PRD72, 114005 (2005)

C C

EW EW

r

r

( , ) (0.039, 61 )

( , ) (0.12, 22 )

Additional Inputs

33 2010-10-18

Page 34: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Solution for NP term with additional inputs

MC C C

MEW EW EW

i M i iC C C

i M i iEW EW EW

r e r e r e

r e r e r e

NC C

NC

NEW

NCN

rr

r r

or

sinsin( )sin

sin

NC

NEW

Ni N i

C

Ni N i

EW

r e r e

r e r e

sinsin

sin( )sin

Defining

With inputs from SU(3) sym. With inputs from PQCD results

Cases 2&4 are suitable and consistent each other between two methods.

Determining NP parameters

34 2010-10-18

Page 35: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Dependance on Dependance on SKS 0

Discussions

35 2010-10-18

Page 36: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Due to the Re-parameterization Invariance(RI) the NP terms absorbed into the SM terms and in pair.

In order to extract NP parameters we need at least 3 additional inputs.

We could pin down each hadronic parameter under four-fold discrete ambiguity using analytic method. And also NP parameter for given additional inputs

Results shows that there should be quitelarge NP contribution with maximal weak phase

Summary

EWC P

36 2010-10-18

Page 37: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

in mixing and B→(π, K)π decays

Collaboration with Chuan-Hung Chen and Yeo-Woong Yoon

PLB671(2009)250

37

BB

2010-10-18

Page 38: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle Physics Georgi, PRL. 98. 221601 (2007)

field with IR fixed pointscale Invarant

at ( 1 TeV) scale physicsM

1smk

O OM

dimensional transmulation

at scale of

can not be described by ordinary particle

☞ Unparticle stuffBanks, Zaks, NPB.196.189(1982)

Interaction with the SM particle:

d d

smk

CO O

M

Matching onto Unparticle operator

: scaling dimension of Unparticle Op.d38 2010-10-18

Page 39: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle Physics

p d d q q qp

44 4 2 0 0 2 2 2

311

(2 ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )( )(2 )

n nj n

j j j njj

d pP p p p A P P P

The vacuum matrix element

rp

4

†2 24

0| (0) |0 | 0| (0)| | ( )(2 )

i p xd pO O e O P P

should scale with dimension , by virtue of scale invariance. Therefore,2d

22 2 0 2 2| 0| (0)| | ( ) ( ) ( )( ) ,ddO P P A P P Pr q q

This characterizes the unparticle phase space.And, it resembles the phase space for n massless particles

pp

5/2

2

16 ( 1 / 2)(2 ) ( 1) (2 )n n

nA

n nWhere,

39 2010-10-18

Page 40: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle PhysicsGeorgi’s proporsal:

Identifying

5/2

2

( 1 / 2)16(2 ) ( 1) (2 )d d

dA

d dpp

,n dA A n d

“ Unparticle with scaling dimension ”d

“ Fractional number of invisible particles ”d

40 2010-10-18

Page 41: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle PhysicsBecause of scale invariance, The Unparticle propagator is

422 2

10| ( ( ) (0)|0

2sin( ) ( )d iip x

d

A p pd xe T O x O i g e

d p p

m nfm n mn

p

It carries CP conserving phase ( 2)df p

The Effective Lagrangian for the interaction with vector Unparticle is

5 51 1(1 ) (1 )q q q qL R

d d

C Cq qO q qOm m

m mg g g g

Georgi, PLB 650:275(2007), Cheung et al, PRL.99:051803(2007)

41 2010-10-18

Page 42: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Mixing Constraintsb

q

q

b

t

t

W

tbV

*tqV

W,d sB,d sB

q

b

b

q

bqC bqC,d sB ,d sB

,12q SM

,12q

Containing Weak Phase

From CKM Factor

Containing Strong Phase

From unparticle propagator

12

, ,12 12

q

q SM q

BB

42 2010-10-18

Page 43: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2 2

, ,2 * 212 0 122

( ) ( ) | |12

SMq

qq q

B iq SM q SMF WBB B tq tb t

G mm f B V V S x e fh

p

Lattice QCD results for the Non-perturbative parameters.

0 0.0030.023 0.002: 0.215 0.019 0.245 0.021

( ) : 0.244 0.026 0.295 0.036

d sd sB BB Bf B f B

JLQCD

HP JL QCD

The values for the SM mixing amplitudes

, ,12 12

0.20 1 10.26

1 1

2| | 2| |

: 0.75 ps 16.4 2.8 ps

( ) : 0.97 0.29 ps 23.8 5.9 ps

d SM s SM

JLQCD

HP JL QCD

22 45.2 5.7 , 2 2.3 0.2SM SMd sf b f l h

Mixing ConstraintsBB

43 2010-10-18

Page 44: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Current Experimental data (HFAG)1

1

(0.507 0.004) ps 43 2

(17.77 0.12) psd d

s

M

M

f

CDF, PRL. 97. 242003 (2006)

d dB BStrongly constraining on the mixing

122| |qqM

Especially on phases of ,

12d

: 130 180 , ( ) : 132 12d dJLQCD HP JL QCDf f

Mixing ConstraintsBB

44 2010-10-18

Page 45: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

2 2

, 2 2 2 212 2 2

4 5 10 14( ) ( ) ( )

3 6 3 6q q

qq q

B Bq qb qb qb qbBB B L R L R

m mC p m f B C C C C

p p

determine the phase of

22 2 22

( ) ,2sin ( )

id

d d

A eC q

d p

f

p

( 2)df p

2( )C q ,

12q

Therefore (HP+JL)QCD can not give the right value of scaling dimension d

JLQCD allows all value of d

We choose JLQCD case and set 1.5d

Mixing ConstraintsBB

45 2010-10-18

Page 46: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Constraints on unparticle mixing amplitudes from experimental data

, 1 , 112 122| | 0.25 0.26 ps 2| | 7.6 6.6 psd s

Mixing ConstraintsBB

are strongly constrained as 4 4 3| | 3.1 10 , 3.5 10 | | 1.4 10 ,db db sb sb

L R L RC C C C

, ,db db sb sbL R L RC C C C

46 2010-10-18

Page 47: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle contribution in B→(π, K)π decays

The SM decay amplitudes

The recent PQCD result for the SM parameters

47 2010-10-18

Page 48: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle contribution in B→(π, K)π decays

Effective Hamiltonian for

2( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )qb qb q q q qL V A R V A L V A R V AC q C qb C qb C q q C q q

b qq q ®

Unparticle contribution in decays

2 2 2 ,1 0

2 2 2 ,1 0

( ) ( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( )

i j

i j

i j BB dec

i j B KK B K dec

A B C q f m F m a

A B K C q f m F m a

p p pp p

p p

p p

p

®

®

2 2 21 2( ),B B bq m m m q mp

2 2

1 2

2 2

1 2

,( ) ( )

,( ) ( )

b u d b d d

K KK K

b u s b d s

m mr r

m m m m m m

m mr r

m m m m m m

p pp p

48 2010-10-18

Page 49: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle contribution in B→(π, K)π decays

Unparticle Parameters:

,

, , , (

)

, , ,

db db sb sbL R L R

uu uu dd ddL R L R

d

C C C C Strong constraints

from mixing

C C C C

4 4 4 51.5 10 , 2.3 10 , 5.8 10 , 9.3 10

3.9, 12.4, 3.7, 12.2

db db sb sbL R L R

uu uu uu uuL R L R

C C C C

C C C C

We set

2cPerform minimum analysis for 8 free parameters with

16 experimental data of decays.

Free

parameters

( , )B Kp p®

The fitted values are

( ) ( ) ( )SMA B f A B f A B f® ® ®

c 2 4.6, . . 8d o f

1TeV, 1.5d

49 2010-10-18

Page 50: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Unparticle contribution in B→(π, K)π decays

The unparticle contribution with fitted values of the parameters

Chisq is

Much

Reduced

( w/o : without Unparticle contribution )

50 2010-10-18

Page 51: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Summary We searched Unparticle contribution in mixing and

decays

mixing could give strong constraints on unparticle

parameters. The scaling dimension also can be constrained

when more precise estimation of the SM mixing amplitude is

provided.

The Unparticle contribution could successfully resolve the

discrepancy between theory and data for the

decays, such as and

( , )B Kp p®

, ,d s d sB B

d

, ,d s d sB B

( , )B Kp p®0 0( ), ( )d CP dBr B A Bp p p p ® ® 0( )CP dA B K p®

51 2010-10-18

Page 52: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

in mixing and B→(π, K)π decays

Collaboration with S. W. Baek and J. H. Jeon

PLB664(2008)84

52

BB

2010-10-18

Page 53: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Leptophobic Z’ - does not couple to SM leptons - introduced to explain the Rb-Rc puzzle at LEP and

anomalous high-ET jet cross section at CDF - by introducing the superstring inspired models,

i.e., E6 or Flipped SU(5)

Extra neutral U(1) gauge boson, Z’ - has been considered one of the extensions of the SM - motivated by

String-inspired GUTs (J.L.Hewett, T.G.Rizzo, M.Cvetic, P.Langacker, etc)

Dynamical symmetry breaking models (G.Buchalla, G.Burdman, etc)

Extra dimension models (M.Masip, A.Pomarol)

Little higgs models (N.Arkani-Hamed, A.G.Cohen, T.Han, etc)

53 2010-10-18

Page 54: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

6 E GUTs comes from heterotic superstring ( ) was the natural anomaly free choice for a GUT group after

SO(10) could have several intermediate mass breaking scales

Maximal breakings of E6 :

If we consider the following breaking chain

U(1)’ can be a linear combination of 1. two U(1)s [ (1) ' (1) sin (1) cos , (5)

2. three U(1)s [ (5)

] ambiguity of embeddings, ]U U U Flipped SU

Flipped SU Maψ χθ θ= −

+

3

1. (10) (1)2. [ (3)]3. (2) (6)

SO USU

SU SU

× ×

54 2010-10-18

Page 55: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

directly SU(5) → SM : SU(5) (Geogri-Glashow)

SU(5)XU(1)χ → SM : Flipped SU(5) (S.M.Barr,1982)

Flipped SU(5) is a different breaking pattern of SO(10)

(5) : (10, ) { , } (5, ) { , } (1, ) { }

(1) ' (1) sin (1) cos

1 3 5, 2 2 2

c c c c cGGSU F Q u L d l

U U U

e f

ψ χ

ν

θ θ

• = = − = = =

• = −

=

(5)

Flipped (5) : (10, ) { , } (5, ) { , } (1, ) { }

1 3 5, 2 2 2

/ 2 (1) (1) ( 1/ 5)

c c c c c

SU

SU F Q d L u l ef

Y U U χ

ν

α β α β

• = = − = = =

=

= + = = −

Leptophobic Z’ does not couple to multiplet(f) and singlet(lc)

55 2010-10-18

Page 56: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

(5)Leptophobic Z in stringy flipped SU′

5

(1) '

: SU(5) U(1) SO(10) SU(4) U(1)Uobservable hidden

Gauge group• × × × ×

(J.L Lopez, D.V. Nanopoulos, and K.J.Yuan (NPB399,654(1993))

56 2010-10-18

Page 57: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Neutral Current Interaction−

57 2010-10-18

Page 58: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Experimental result

Lattice QCD result

1%less than

27%about

58 2010-10-18

Page 59: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Experimental results

PQCD results

~ 4.3%~ 4.7%~ 3.1%

~ 6.1%

1 σ

59 2010-10-18

Page 60: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Experimental results

PQCD results

2 σ

60 2010-10-18

Page 61: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Experimental results

PQCD results

2 σ

61 2010-10-18

Page 62: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

0 0 S S MixingB B−

, , '12 12/s SM s ZR M M=

RG

62 2010-10-18

Page 63: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

B K decaysπ→

Leptophobic Z’ contributions

63 2010-10-18

Page 64: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

64 2010-10-18

Page 65: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

65 2010-10-18

Page 66: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

66 2010-10-18

Page 67: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

67 2010-10-18

Page 68: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

68 2010-10-18

Page 69: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

Stringy leptophobic Z’ can possibly explain the apparent deviations from the SM predictions in the B→πK decays

This is phenomenologically interesting because

- The new Z’ coupling is generation dependent and can generate FC- The FCNC couplings allow large CP violation- The couplings also violate the isospin symmetry and can give large

contributions to the EW penguins (PEW and PCEW )

69 2010-10-18

Page 70: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

70 2010-10-18

Page 71: B to K π - Yonsei Universitykimcs.yonsei.ac.kr/sub_pages/seminar/harbin2010/3_B2Kpi... · 2015-11-17 · B KπPuzzle Branching Ratios - HFAG March 2009 Fleischer Hep-ph/0701217 At

,1) of the fields ( , , ) can be interchanged with those of ( , , )c c c cQ L d H h Sϕ χ ν

2) The pairs ( , ) and ( , ) are interchanged : Flpped SU(5)c c c cu e d ν

3) We can consider the interchange of both (1) and (2) simutaneously

71 2010-10-18