HO

MEL

AN

D S

ECU

RIT

Y:C

YBER

-SEC

UR

ITY

AT

THE

LOC

AL

LEVE

LK

irk B

aile

y, C

ISSP

, CIS

MC

ISO

, UW

Erni

e H

ayde

n, C

ISSP

CIS

O, P

ort o

f Sea

ttle

HO

W B

IG IS

TH

E JO

B?

WH

AT

IS IN

VOLV

ED (T

HE

SCO

PE O

F IT

)?

WH

AT

AR

E TH

E TO

UG

H C

HA

LLEN

GES

?

WH

AT

DO

ES T

HE

FUTU

RE

LOO

K L

IKE?

U.S

. CR

ITIC

AL

INFR

AST

RU

CTU

RE

SOM

E R

ELA

TED

FA

CTS

�FO

R C

ON

TEXT

HO

W B

IG?

300

INLA

ND

// C

OST

AL

POR

TS

87,0

00LO

CA

LITI

ES //

JU

RIS

TIC

TIO

NS

80,0

00D

AM

S

2,80

0EL

ECTR

ICA

L PO

WER

PLA

NTS

104

CO

MM

ERC

IAL

NU

CLE

AR

PO

WER

PLA

NTS

2,00

0,00

0M

ILES

OF

PIPE

LIN

ES

2,25

0,00

0,00

0M

ILES

OF

TELE

CO

MM

UN

ICA

TIO

N C

AB

LES

1,80

0FE

DER

AL

WA

TER

RES

ERVO

IRS

1,60

0M

UN

ICIP

AL

WA

STEW

ATE

R F

AC

ILIT

IES

5,00

0PU

BLI

C A

IRPO

RTS

120,

000

MIL

ES O

F M

AJO

R R

AIL

RO

AD

S

5,80

0R

EGIS

TER

ED H

OSP

ITA

LS

66,0

00C

HEM

ICA

L PL

AN

TS (H

AZA

RD

OU

S M

ATE

RIA

LS)

460

SKYS

CR

APE

RS

26,6

00FD

IC IN

SUR

ED F

INA

NC

IAL

INST

ITU

TIO

NS

1,91

2,00

0FA

RM

S

87,0

00FO

OD

PR

OC

ESSI

NG

PLA

NTS

SEA

TTLE

�S

SLIC

E O

F TH

E PI

E�

�16

0,00

0JO

BS

GEN

ERA

TED

IN

TH

E R

EGIO

N

�$5

.5 B

ILLI

ON

PAYR

OLL

�$1

2 B

ILLI

ON

REV

ENU

E

�$6

60 M

ILLI

ON

STA

TE &

LO

CA

L TA

X G

ENER

ATI

ON

DIV

ERSE

INFR

AST

RU

CTU

RE

AN

DSE

RVI

CES

AIR

POR

T, S

EAPO

RT,

FIS

HIN

G T

ERM

INA

L,

PAR

KS

& R

ECR

EATI

ON

FA

CIL

ITIE

S

POLI

CE,

FIR

E &

EM

S SE

RVI

CES

SE

A-T

AC

INTE

RN

ATI

ON

AL

AIR

PO

RT

SE

A-T

AC

INTE

RN

ATI

ON

AL

AIR

PO

RT

�182

AC

RES

�ON

-DO

CK

RA

IL

�3 B

ERTH

S

�5 C

ON

TAIN

IER

CR

AN

E

�182

AC

RES

�ON

-DO

CK

RA

IL

�3 B

ERTH

S

�5 C

ON

TAIN

IER

CR

AN

E

APL

AN

ZDL

Col

umbu

s Li

nes

FESC

O

Hyu

ndai

Mae

rsk-

Seal

and

MO

L

P& O

Ned

lloyd

Ltd

.

Wes

twoo

d Sh

ippi

ng L

ines

APL

AN

ZDL

Col

umbu

s Li

nes

FESC

O

Hyu

ndai

Mae

rsk-

Seal

and

MO

L

P& O

Ned

lloyd

Ltd

.

Wes

twoo

d Sh

ippi

ng L

ines

TER

MIN

AL

5

�196

AC

RES

�ON

-DO

CK

RA

IL

�5 B

ERTH

S

�8 C

ON

TAIN

ER C

RA

NES

�196

AC

RES

�ON

-DO

CK

RA

IL

�5 B

ERTH

S

�8 C

ON

TAIN

ER C

RA

NES

CO

SCO

Chi

na S

hipp

ing

Col

umbu

s Li

neH

apag

Lloy

dK

-Lin

eLy

kes

Line

Mar

uba

Line

Mat

son

Nav

igat

ion

NYK

Nor

asia

/CSA

VO

OC

LP

& O

Ned

lloyd

Ltd

.TM

MYa

ng M

ing

Line ZIM

CO

SCO

Chi

na S

hipp

ing

Col

umbu

s Li

neH

apag

Lloy

dK

-Lin

eLy

kes

Line

Mar

uba

Line

Mat

son

Nav

igat

ion

NYK

Nor

asia

/CSA

VO

OC

LP

& O

Ned

lloyd

Ltd

.TM

MYa

ng M

ing

Line ZIM

TER

MIN

AL

18

BNSF

SIG

Yar

dBN

SF S

IG Y

ard

Han

jin

CO

SCO

K-L

ine

Yang

Min

g

Han

jin

CO

SCO

K-L

ine

Yang

Min

g

TER

MIN

AL

46

TER

MIN

AL

91

Valu

e of

Tra

de$2

3.8

Bill

ion

Impo

rts:

$18

.5B

Expo

rts:

$5.

3B

Valu

e of

Tra

de$2

3.8

Bill

ion

Impo

rts:

$18

.5B

Expo

rts:

$5.

3B

199

9

6

7,0

00

200

1:

5

8

17

0,0

00

200

3:

1

00

4

00,0

00

200

4:

1

50

5

60,0

00

200

5:

1

70

6

50,0

00

Ves

sels

P

ax

CR

UIS

E SH

IPS

GR

AIN

TER

MIN

AL

FISH

ERM

AN

S� T

ERM

INA

LPU

BLI

C A

CC

ESS

REC

REA

TIO

NA

L M

AR

INIA

S

INFR

AST

RU

CTU

RE

INTE

R-D

EPEN

DEN

CIE

S

�PO

WER

�SE

ATT

LE C

ITY

LIG

HT

// PU

GET

SO

UN

D E

NER

GY

�SE

WER

�C

ITY

OF

SEA

TTLE

// K

ING

CO

UN

TY

�W

ATE

R�

SEA

TTLE

PU

BLI

C U

TILI

TIES

// L

OC

AL

WA

TER

DIS

TRIC

TS

�TE

LEC

OM

MU

NIC

ATI

ON

S�

QW

EST

// A

T&T

(Cel

l) //

NEX

TEL

(Cel

l) //

VER

IZO

N�

WES

TON

BU

ILD

ING

// F

ISH

ER P

LAZA

�C

ITY

OF

SEA

TTLE

FIB

ER A

ND

STR

EET

RIG

HT

OF

WA

YS

�80

0 M

Hz

// 91

1�

PUB

LIC

SA

FETY

�

POLI

CE

// F

IRE

// E

MER

GEN

CY

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

(EM

S)

�TR

AN

SPO

RTA

TIO

N�

HIG

HW

AYS

: I-5

// I-

90 //

I-40

5 //

520

�VI

AD

UC

T //

US-

99

�C

ITY

SUR

FAC

E ST

REE

TS a

nd B

RID

GES

�C

ITY

TRA

FFIC

CO

NTR

OL

SYST

EMS

�PI

PELI

NES

�W

ATE

R: S

EATT

LE P

UB

LIC

UTI

LITI

ES &

LO

CA

L D

ISTs

�A

VIA

TIO

N F

UEL

TR

AN

SPO

RT:

OLY

MPI

C P

IPEL

INE

�N

ATU

RA

L G

AS:

PU

GET

SO

UN

D E

NER

GY

�R

AIL

RO

AD

S�

BN

SF //

UN

ION

PA

CIF

IC�

BA

NK

ING

// F

INA

NC

E�

FED

. RES

ERVE

// B

of A

// W

AM

U //

BA

NK

OF

CA

L.

�IN

FOR

MA

TIO

N S

YSTE

MS

THE

BIG

CO

MB

INED

CYB

ER P

ICTU

RE

�14

,000

+ D

ESK

TOPS

and

LA

PTO

PS�

2,50

0+ S

ERVE

RS

�15

00+

NET

WO

RK

PER

IPH

ERA

LS (p

rinte

rs, f

ax)

�4,

500+

RA

DIO

S (a

ll ty

pes)

�3,

000?

PD

As

// TR

EOS

// B

LAC

KB

ERR

IES

�18

,000

+ T

ELEP

HO

NES

(des

k an

d ce

ll)�

5,00

0? M

ILES

of F

IBER

and

CA

BLE

�10

0+U

NIQ

UE

or S

PEC

IALI

ZED

INFO

. SYS

TEM

S

PRO

TEC

TIN

G C

RIT

ICA

L SE

RVI

CES

LI

KE

PUB

LIC

SA

FETY

OR

PO

WER

AN

D W

ATE

R S

UPP

LIES

IS V

ERY

DIF

FER

ENT

THA

N S

IMPL

Y PR

OTE

CTI

NG

C

OM

PUTE

RS,

NET

WO

RK

S,A

ND

DA

TA F

RO

M H

AR

M.

IF Y

OU

TH

INK

BEI

NG

A S

UPE

R G

EEK

O

R A

NET

WO

RK

SPE

CIA

LIST

IS E

NO

UG

H�

YOU

WIL

L FA

IL A

ND

A

ND

PEO

PLE

WIL

L B

E H

AR

MED

.

Tech

nolo

gy

Secu

rity

Info

rmat

ion

Secu

rity

�Fi

rew

alls

�In

trus

ion

Det

ectio

n

�N

etw

ork

Secu

rity

�Vi

ruse

s, W

orm

s,C

rimew

are

�Sy

stem

Har

deni

ng

�En

cryp

tion

�En

gine

erin

g

Tech

nolo

gy

Prob

lem

s

�R

isk

Man

agem

ent

�In

telle

ctua

l Pro

pert

y

�B

usin

ess

/ Fin

anci

alIn

tegr

ity

�R

egul

ator

y C

ompl

ianc

e

�O

rgan

ized

Cyb

er-C

rime

�In

dust

rial E

spio

nage

�Pr

ivac

y

�Fo

rens

ics

& In

vest

igat

ions

Business

Problems

Cha

rt B

ased

on

Forr

este

r, A

pril

2005

Critical Security

Problems

Stra

tegi

cSe

curit

y

�Te

rror

ism

�R

egio

nal I

nter

ests

�N

atio

n St

ate

Inte

rest

s

�In

telli

genc

e

�Ac

tive

Def

ense

Con

tinuu

m

�Pr

ofes

sion

al A

llian

ces

�Po

litic

s

�St

rate

gies

and

Tac

tics

SEC

UR

ITY

PRO

FESS

ION

EXP

ERTI

SE L

EVEL

S

R E

S E

A R

C H

�In

the

wor

ld o

f net

wor

ked

com

pute

rs e

very

soc

iopa

th is

you

nei

ghbo

r.�-D

an G

eer,

Chi

ef S

cien

tist ,

Ver

dasy

s

SEC

UR

ITY

PRO

FFES

ION

ALS

NEE

D T

O K

NO

WTH

E W

HO

, WH

AT,

WH

ERE

AN

D W

HY

BEH

IND

ALL

TH

E FR

UST

RA

TIN

G, M

ISER

AB

LE A

ND

H

AR

MFU

L ST

UFF

TO

FIG

UR

E O

UT

HO

WTO

DEA

L W

ITH

IT A

LL.

A N

ETW

OR

K O

F TR

UST

THE

NEE

D F

OR

INTE

LLIG

ENC

E

A N

ETW

OR

K O

F TR

UST

YOU

HA

VE T

O R

EMA

IN H

UM

BLE

AN

D K

NO

W Y

OU

R L

IMIT

S�

AN

D K

NO

W E

VER

YON

E W

HO

CA

N H

ELP

YOU

.

IS T

HER

E A

N E

ASY

FO

RM

ULA

?

THE

VULN

ERA

BIL

ITIE

S

SEA

TTLE

RA

NK

S H

IGH

AS

A T

AR

GET

INSU

RA

NC

E SE

RVI

CES

OFF

ICE

(NEW

JER

SEY)

Terr

oris

m R

isk

Insu

ranc

e A

ct o

f 200

2In

dem

nific

atio

n fo

r Ins

uran

ce C

ompa

nies

for l

osse

s du

e to

terr

oris

m

1ST

TIE

R (

100X

MO

RE

LIK

ELY

TO

BE

ATT

AC

KE

D):

New

Yor

k, W

ashi

ngto

n D

C, S

an F

ranc

isco

, Chi

cago

2nd

TIE

R (2

0X M

OR

E L

IKE

LY T

O B

E A

TTA

CK

ED

):S

eattl

e, L

os A

ngel

es, H

oust

on, P

hila

delp

hia,

Bos

ton

Tons

of C

riter

ia in

clud

ing:

geog

raph

ical

loca

tion,

ec

onom

ic im

porta

nce,

acc

essi

bilit

y as

targ

et (p

ort c

ity),

icon

ic b

uild

ings

and

bus

ines

ses,

infra

stru

ctur

e si

tes,

sp

orts

ven

ues,

inte

llige

nce

indi

cato

rs, a

nd �g

ut fe

el.�

Cyb

er-b

ased

Ter

roris

t Thr

eats

:A

naly

sis

for

The

City

of S

eattl

e, a

nd

The

Stat

e of

Was

hing

ton

Prep

ared

by:

K

irk C

. Bai

ley,

CIS

SP, C

ISM

CIS

O, C

ity o

f Sea

ttle

Confidential

(Disc

losur

e Pro

tectio

n pro

vided

unde

r WA S

tate R

CWs)

A N

ETW

OR

K O

F TR

UST

...an

d ot

her s

tuff

RA

PID

LY G

RO

WIN

G T

HR

EAT

SPEC

TRU

MC

RIM

INA

L EL

EMEN

TS A

RE

AC

TIVE

LY F

INA

NC

ING

AN

D

WO

RK

ING

TO

CO

NTR

OL

MA

LWA

RE

DEV

ELO

PMEN

T A

ND

DEL

IVER

Y SY

STEM

S.

SER

IOU

S C

RIM

INA

LS A

RE

NO

W S

EEK

ING

CO

NTR

OL

OF

BO

TNET

S A

ND

IMPR

OVI

NG

HO

W T

HEY

CO

VER

TH

EIR

TR

AC

KS

AN

D F

OIL

INVE

STIG

ATI

ON

S.

THE

NEW

CR

IMIN

AL

AC

TIVI

TIES

AN

D IN

VEST

MEN

TS A

RE

PRO

DU

CIN

G �

CR

IMEW

AR

E� W

ITH

BET

TER

TA

RG

ETIN

G,

PAYL

OA

D A

ND

DEL

IVER

Y SY

STEM

S.

IT A

LL M

EAN

S TH

AT

�ZER

O D

AY�

EVE

NTS

AR

E M

OR

E LI

KEL

Y W

ITH

EVE

N W

OR

SE IM

PLIC

ATI

ON

S TH

AN

IM

AG

INED

BEF

OR

E.

A N

ETW

OR

K O

F TR

UST

A V

IEW

OF

A S

MA

LL P

OR

TIO

N O

F O

RG

AN

IZED

CYB

ER-C

RIM

EA

ND

GEO

GR

APH

Y O

F EV

OLV

ING

�C

RIM

EWA

RE�

CYB

ER-C

RIM

EG

AN

GS

PHIS

HIN

G G

RO

UPS

(PG

s)PR

OFI

LED

AN

D T

RA

CK

ED

BY

AN

TI-P

HIS

HIN

G W

OR

K G

RO

UP

CO

DER

S FO

R H

IRE

SOM

E C

OD

ERS

AR

EFL

AMB

OYA

NT

INTH

E O

NLI

NE

UN

DER

GR

OU

DA

ND

TH

EIR

ON

LIN

E C

OM

MEN

TS

AR

E M

ON

ITO

RED

.

TERRORISM?

A N

ETW

OR

K O

F TR

UST

WH

AT

AR

E TH

EY D

OIN

G?

HER

OIN

CO

CA

INE

MET

HM

AR

IJU

AN

A

PRES

CR

IPTI

ON

D

RU

GS

POR

NH

UM

AN

TR

AFF

ICK

ING

CH

ILD

POR

NSL

AVE

RY

PRO

STIT

UTI

ON

STO

CK

FR

AU

D&

SH

AR

EM

AN

IPU

LATI

ON

ELEC

TRO

NIC

THEF

T &

FR

AU

D�C

RIM

EWA

RE�

MAL

ICIO

US

CO

DE

TEC

HN

ICA

L EX

PLO

ITS

BO

TNET

SSP

AMSO

CIA

L EN

GIN

EER

ING

FEE

SCAM

S

ID T

HEF

T

CR

EDIT

FR

AU

D

ELEC

TRO

NIC

EXTO

RTI

ON

INFO

RM

ATIO

NTH

EFT

& S

ALE

S

ILLE

GA

L D

RU

GS

ILLE

GA

L W

EAPO

NS

IND

UST

RIA

LES

PIO

NA

GE

SOFT

WA

RE

PIR

AC

Y

MO

NEY

LA

UN

DER

ING

&

MO

VEM

ENT

= TR

AD

ITIO

NA

L IN

TER

NA

TIO

NA

L C

RIM

E

�In

tern

atio

nal E

xerc

ises

�U

S /

Can

ada

�To

pOff2

�Li

vew

ire

�Bl

ueC

asca

des

II

�Vu

lner

abili

ty E

xerc

ises

�C

ity o

f Sea

ttle�

s �A

LKI�

�Po

rt of

Sea

ttle

Loss

of P

ier 6

9 E

vent

Tabl

etop

Exe

rcis

es U

nder

scor

e C

ritic

ality

of

Cyb

er-Is

sues

THIN

GS

TO T

HIN

K A

BO

UT

IFYO

U W

AN

T TO

BE

AC

YBER

-SEC

UR

ITY

PRO

FESS

ION

AL

The

Hot

Sea

t

Impa

ct o

n P

eopl

es� L

ives

Bac

kgro

und

Che

cks

// Y

our P

rivac

y

The

Adv

ersa

ry