Band Janta Party Band Janta Party Band Janta Party Band Janta Party –––– Gujarat’s Gujarat’s Gujarat’s Gujarat’s Shaming, Polluting, India Shining Shaming, Polluting, India Shining Shaming, Polluting, India Shining Shaming, Polluting, India Shining February23, 2013

In attached three pages Clippings from Gujarat budget document – first page reports Indian GDP Quadrupled since 2004-12, more than doubled in Net GDP at constant prices and per capita GDP in real term more than doubled. But in Gujarat as given in the annexure even as Value of Factory production was up 25.54%, number of factories up 36.63% yet Net Value Additions declined 0.64% in just one year 2009-10 to 2010-11. THIS IS NOT GOOD GOVERNANCE BUT CONNIVANCE IN LOOT. I HAD EARLIER REPORTED HOW GUJARAT EXTENDED TAX BENEFITS TO FOREIGN OWNED ESSAR ENERGY AS AN EXAMPLE THAT CONTRIBUTED PRACTICALLY NOTHING AS SALARY AND DIVIDEND TO GUJARAT BUT POLLUTION. Can we believe Gujarat FactoCan we believe Gujarat FactoCan we believe Gujarat FactoCan we believe Gujarat Factory sector GDP contribution is barely Rs. 89448 ry sector GDP contribution is barely Rs. 89448 ry sector GDP contribution is barely Rs. 89448 ry sector GDP contribution is barely Rs. 89448 crorecrorecrorecrore in in in in 2010-11---- $16b over 10 years of Narendra Modi Raj when Gujjus Remit $16b over 10 years of Narendra Modi Raj when Gujjus Remit $16b over 10 years of Narendra Modi Raj when Gujjus Remit $16b over 10 years of Narendra Modi Raj when Gujjus Remit more than $20b annually to Gujarat? more than $20b annually to Gujarat? more than $20b annually to Gujarat? more than $20b annually to Gujarat? Foreign remittances kept services sector alive but main thrust of Gujarat was always Industry and Vibrant Gujarat Summits focused on Industries. Had it been USA or Any Developed Country Band Janta Party (BJP) would have been put in jail for 10-20 years for Fabricating Data for Political Purpose and Loot. In document downloaded from Vibrant Gujarat2013 site – Industry Stats - just before Elections, Gujarat reported 34860 No of Registered Factories out of that 24453 were working.

Year No. of Regd. Factories

No. of working factories

workers employed

2009 34860 (32%) 24453 (70%)) 1257957 But in SER2013 released this week data shows 15576 No of Factories in Gujarat 2009-10 that it claims had gone up 36% to 21282 but actual Net Value Additions had declined by 0.64%. There can’t be any Worse Forging of Government data anywhere in the world. 4.184.184.184.18 The number of factories have increased from 15576 in 2009-10 to 21282 in 2010-11(P), showing a growth of 36.63 percent over the previous year. The net value added by factory sector in the State has decreased from Rs.90028 crore in 2009-10 to Rs. 89448 crore in 2010-11(P), showing a reduction of 0.64 percent over the previous year. Most Polluting: - Even more Horrifying Rs.89,448 crores of Net Value Added but 71% consists of most polluting Companies - Mfg. of Coke Refined Petroleum Products & Nuclear Fuel, Mfg. of Chemical & Chemical Products, Mfg. of Basic metals, Mfg. of other non-metallic mineral products. This implies around Rs.26,000 crores Net Value Addition by less polluting industries this too doesn’t include any High Tech production but for some Foreign Plants.

So factories in Gujarat contribute just $5b Net Value Additions of Medium Polluting Industry Production and in per capita terms less than $83. For over 12 years Band Janta Party is projecting Narendra Modi as PM for 2014 and entire political party like a Band Company is fully active celebrating VICTORY in advance for FABRICATED GROWTH. We need qualified people to run India and Indian Industries. Gujarat is Shaming and Polluting, India Shining in spite of BJP Sabotage. Had Gujarat been an Independent Nation it would have been totally Bankrupt by now reduced to Ethiopia or Somalia level. Ravinder Singh Progressindia008@yahoo.com My Earlier Message - Modi’s Vibrant Gujarat Flop Show, 10,407 (30%) Sick Factories - Excl.(C) This is enough to Puncture Modi Campaign as 30% or for every Two Working Factories, One in Gujarat are sick and Modi did nothing to revive them. Modi registered 8404 Factories but increase in number of number of Working Factories was just 4029 (48%). FOR EVERY ONE FACTORY REGISTERED AND WORKING BY MODI MORE THAN ONE FACTORY WAS SHUT DOWN OR BECAME SICK. It was easy to REVIVE sick units than finance new projects. Data provided by Gujarat government indicates in two import Factory Data fixed capital as Gujarat share of India was BEST PHASE of Gujarat growth trajectory and since Modi arrived it declined. http://ic.gujarat.gov.in/pdf/INDUSTRIES-IN-GUJARAT-2010.pdf Indicators as % of India 1990-91 2000-01 2008-09 Fixed Capital 9.8% 18.04% 16.32% Output Value 10.20% 13.81% 15.52% Net Value Added 8.57% 11.74% 11.45% Table 28 Is important – Fixed Capital and Value Added by Gujarat were 18.04% and 11.74% in 2001 that were down to 16.32% and 11.45% in 2009. Table 28 Continued – Here growth is compared since 1960.

In 1990-91 to 2000-01 decade Factory Growth Was Double of National Average – Fixed Capital 9.8% Table 29 Is Important – P-66 Figures in bracket is Growth rate

Year No. of Regd. Factories

No. of working factories

workers employed

1990 16820 14513 (86%) 747569 2000 26454 (57%) 20424 (77%) 866720 2009 34860 (32%) 24453 (70%)) 1257957

SSI – MSME SSI units registration declined from 14761 in 1998-99 to 12168 in Oct06 to July10.

Table 10 in above Annual SSI registration was 14761 in 1998-99 was reduced to 10955 in 2005-06. Table 13 admits Failure of Gujarat to promote SMEs. Between October02 2006 to July31 2010 four years total registration of SSI was just 12168 – Micro Units registration in these years was 49186 and medium industries 504. In table 15 Micro Small and Medium industries contributed 859272 jobs but in this Medium Industries contributed just 55457 jobs just 6.5%. Modi created 5 lakh factory jobs in over 10 years for over 100 lakh population growth. But neglect of Textiles, MSMEs, Poor Implementation of Irrigation projects resulted in average growth – - that enriched few Adanis or Ambanis.

Job numbers Swelled after Micro Units like roadside welder or mechanic were included in the MSME sectors. Ravinder Singh Progressindia008@yahoo.com September10, 2012

ANNEXURE – I Page 2 INDUSTRIES 2.15 According to the provisional result of Annual Survey of Industries 2011, total number of factories in the state increased from 15576 in 2009-10 to 21282 in 2010-11 which shows that the race of industrialization has been very rapid in the state in the recent past. As a result of rapid industrialization a value of the factories production increased from 643 thousand crore in 2009-10 to 807 thousand crore in

2010-11 at current prices recording an increase of more than 25 percent. At the same time the fix capital generated by the factories increase from around 240 thousand crore to 272 thousand crore reflecting an increase of more than 13 percent. However after taking into account the input cost and depreciations the net value added by the factories sector decreased marginally from around 90 thousand crore in 2009-10 to around 89 thousand crore in 2010-11.