benchmarking - massey universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/manuscripts/powerp_maccormick.… ·...

11
Benchmarking Rotorua Lakes

Upload: others

Post on 25-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Benchmarking

Rotorua Lakes

Page 2: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Rule 11

• Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided:

1. Farmers supply benchmarking information

2. Discharges remain below benchmarked level

• Caps discharges to 2001-2004 levels, but does not achieve water quality target

• Applies to five lakes

Page 3: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Where?

Page 4: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Benchmarking Objectives

1. Prevent further intensification

2. Give the best estimates of agricultural discharges to the lakes

3. Educate and raise awareness

4. Provide a baseline for compliance at the property level

Page 5: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Benchmarking Method

• Benchmarked area defined by surface water catchment

• Physical parameters provided by GIS and LiDAR analysis

• Combination of data and user discretion

• Protocols developed as required

• Utilised Council staff and local farm consultants

Page 6: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

How is the benchmark used?

• Banks • Valuers • Purchasers

• Rotorua District Council (subdivisions, tradeable development rights?)

• Bay of Plenty Regional Council (land use change agreements)

Page 7: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Issues

Page 8: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

The Future…

• Proposed Regional Policy Statement requires Rotorua N discharges to reduce to 435 tonnes – about a 50% reduction from current agricultural losses

• New rules are being developed for Lake Rotorua with stakeholder consultation

• Measurement, allocation and reduction options all under consideration

• Incentive fund will assist farmers with compliance

Page 9: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply
Page 10: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply
Page 11: Benchmarking - Massey Universityflrc.massey.ac.nz/workshops/13/Manuscripts/PowerP_MacCormick.… · Rule 11 •Diffuse discharge of N and P is permitted provided: 1. Farmers supply

Issues • Determination of catchment boundaries - LiDAR • Method of defining block slopes – LiDAR • Historical aerial photography invaluable • Soil information/soil testing (do we pursue accuracy or

find alternative approach) • Co-ordination with Waikato Regional Council required to

control all discharges into Lake Rotorua • Knowledge and capacity of rural professionals • GIS linkages to Overseer • Quantifying unmeasured losses (CSA’s)