beyondcompetencies ispi 4-6-08beyond competencies— managing employee and organization capability...
TRANSCRIPT
Beyond Competencies—
Managing Employee and Organization Capability
Peter R. Hybert20 Danada Square West, #102Wheaton, IL 60187ph: 630.682.1649web: www.prhconsulting.com
ISPI ConferenceApril 6, 2008
PRH Consulting, Inc.
leveraging knowleveraging know--how for performance!how for performance!
PRH Consulting, Inc.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 1All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
Beyond Competencies—
Managing Employee and Organization Capability
ISPI International Conference April 6, 2008
leveraging knowleveraging know--how for performance!how for performance!
PRH Consulting, Inc.
20 Danada Square West, #102Wheaton, IL 60187phone: 630.682.1649web: www.prhconsulting.com
PRH Consulting, Inc.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 1
Overview: We Can Do a Better Job with Employee Capability…And We Should
“It is not necessary to change. Survival is not mandatory.”W. Edwards Deming
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 2All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 2
The Opportunity
Premises
1. Companies spend a great deal of effort trying to build, manage, and improve employee and organization capability
2. Currently, internal organizations work independently
3. As a result of Item 2, deliverables are not integrated, there is redundant work, and there are gaps.
4. There are opportunities to eliminate waste, improve productivity, and deliver increased benefits to the organization.
Success Factors—How We Can Realize the Opportunity
1. Use a common/sharedanalysis methodology
2. Create an integrated solutionset for the business
3. Develop/use a common data management and storage taxonomy
4. Grow communities of knowledge and practice
The key to the above is the framework of capabilities that connects needs to solutions
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 3
Session Objectives
By the end…you will be able to
Describe workforce capability from a general business leadership perspectiveSummarize where current methods for managing capability fall shortDescribe a model for linking work process, capability, and rolesDescribe how various strategies for managing capability (e.g., assessment, qualification, training, performance support) can be integrated across an organization
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 3All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 4
SITUATION: Many Stakeholders, Mostly Unsatisfied
“Your most unhappy customers are your greatest source of learning.”
Bill Gates
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 5
What We Want is Clear…
Leaders need to know what the capability of their organization is and needs to be
Employees need to know what capabilities they need to develop for advancement
HR needs to know what capabilities are needed so they can recruit for and retain them
“Capability Providers” (e.g., performance consultants, trainers) need to know what capabilities exist and are needed so they can develop them
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 4All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 6
What We Have Can be Unclear…
Perfo
rman
ce
Appra
isal
Role Profiles
Kno
wledg
e
Man
agem
ent
Skill DictionaryTraining
Career Maps
Competency M
odels
Curriculum
Learning Objects
Corp In
itiativ
es
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 7
The Opportunity: Alignment
“Honest disagreement is often a good sign of progress.”Ghandi
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 5All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 8
Aligning Around Capability Requirements
Capability Requirements
CapabilityRequirements
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Role Definition
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Role Definition
Content and Support Development and Maintenance
Content and Support Development and Maintenance
Job/Role DefinitionsJob/Role Definitions
Career/Development PathsCareer/Development Paths
Organizational Capability PlanningOrganizational Capability Planning
Individual Capability Assessment and Development Planning
Individual Capability Assessment and Development Planning
TRAINING, OTHERS
HR
Recruiting & SelectionRecruiting & Selection
Qualification AdminQualification Admin
WORK PROCESSES
LEADERSHIP
©2006 PRH Consulting Inc.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 9
Example Capability Model
Manufacturing Management—Capability Model Information Confidential and Proprietary to PRH Consulting Inc. 2008Design © 2002 PRH Consulting Inc. Wheaton, IL. USA(630) 682-1649
PharmaceuticalsPharmaceuticals
ManagementManagement CAPABILITY MODEL – v08/06/08
1st Line Supervisor1st Line SupervisorP E R F O R M A N C E C A P A B I L I T I E S
S U P P O R T I N G C A P A B I L I T I E S
Implement site- and externally-driven process changesEtc.Leading
Change
Managing Relationships
with Key Stakeholders
Interface with internal stakeholders (e.g., other work centers)Operations
Planning & Management
On request, provide input to production planEtc.
On request, participate in an emergency management team
Participate in emergency management responses and drills as needed
Recognize need for and implement emergency management (e.g., “command and control”) in your area
Managing Emergencies
Strategic Planning
On request, provide input to a long-range plan
Etc.
Provide input to the team vision/purpose
Production Management and Process Improvement
Assess exceptions (e.g., process adjustments, deviations, or changes)Resolve and/or negotiate solutions with up/downstream stakeholdersEtc.
Collect data for operational performance metrics for your area
Production Planning and Scheduling
Manage work group capacity and throughput Manage employee qualification and training
Translate the production plan into a work plan and schedule for your areaMonitor the flow of work between your work group and internal suppliers/customers
O N G O I N G
Develop a succession plan for your work groupSelect and develop employees for work group(from internal and external candidates) Etc.
Etc.Etc.Etc.
Coach and provide performance feedback to direct reports and other employees
Managing People
Etc.Design and implement recognition systems for your work group
Managing Facilities
Maintain reliable equipment Etc.Etc.
Business Skills
Etc.
QualityLeadership Models
Budgeting and AccountingEtc. Etc.
Etc.Team CommunicationsProblem-Solving
Etc.
RxP Leadership Behaviors
Etc.Etc.
Personal Skills and Values
Absence/Attendance Compensation/Merit Development PlanningEtc.Etc.Etc.Etc.
Confidentiality/ Intellectual Property
HR Policies/ Processes
Assessment & Coaching
Implementing Change
Decision-Making
Facilitation/ Teaching
Team Development
Delegation
Business / Management
Motivating Others
Management/ Leadership Skills
External Regulatory Processes
Health, Safety, Environment
Quality Systems
RxP Compliance Policies and Procedures
Regulatory
Process Capability Supply Chain
Business PlanningInformation systems
RxP Business Processes & Tools
Applied Science Engineering
Chemistry
Microbiology
Statistics/Math
BiotechnologyPharmaceutics
Product Manufacturing Processes
Production Processes, e.g.,
Your Product
-Manufacturing-Granulation-Tablet Filling-Packaging
Equipment, e.g.,-Lab-Production
Pharmaceutical Industry
Drug Development StagesCompetitive Landscape
-RxP-Your Product/FunctionValue Chain
-Healthcare Marketplace
Manufacturing Organization/Network
Materials Management
Etc.Etc.
Etc.
HRAccounting/Finance
LegalEtc.
Maintenance
Quality
Manufacturing ScienceEngineering
Production
Utilities/Facilities
Process Automation
LEADERSHIP/ INTERPERSONALINDUSTRY/ DISCIPLINECOMPANY-SPECIFIC
P L A N N I N GThe top section defines the job performance.
The bottom section defines the knowledge, skills, etc. needed to perform the job.
Man
ufac
turin
g M
anag
emen
t—C
apab
ility
Mod
el
Info
rmat
ion
Con
fiden
tial a
nd P
ropr
ieta
ry to
PRH
Con
sulti
ng In
c. 2
008
Des
ign
©20
02 P
RH C
onsu
lting
Inc.
W
heat
on, I
L. U
SA(6
30) 6
82-1
649
Phar
mac
eutic
als
Phar
mac
eutic
als
Man
agem
ent
Man
agem
ent C
APA
BILI
TY M
ODE
L –
v08/
06/0
8
1st L
ine
Supe
rviso
r1s
t Lin
e Su
perv
isor
P E
R F
O R
M A
N C
EC
A P
A B
I L
I T I
E S
S U
P P
O R
T I N
GC
A P
A B
I L
I T I
E S
Impl
emen
t site
-and
ext
erna
lly-
driv
en p
roce
ss c
hang
esEt
c.Le
adin
g C
hang
e
Man
agin
g Re
latio
nshi
ps
with
Key
St
akeh
olde
rs
Inte
rface
with
inte
rnal
st
akeh
olde
rs (e
.g.,
othe
r wor
k ce
nter
s)O
pera
tions
Pl
anni
ng &
M
anag
emen
t
On
requ
est,
prov
ide
inpu
t to
prod
uctio
n pl
anEt
c.
On
requ
est,
parti
cipa
te in
an
emer
genc
y m
anag
emen
t tea
m
Parti
cipa
te in
em
erge
ncy
man
agem
ent r
espo
nses
and
dr
ills a
s ne
eded
Reco
gnize
nee
d fo
r and
im
plem
ent e
mer
genc
y m
anag
emen
t (e.
g., “
com
man
d an
d co
ntro
l”) in
you
r are
a
Man
agin
g Em
erge
ncie
s
Stra
tegi
c Pl
anni
ng
On
requ
est,
prov
ide
inpu
t to
a lo
ng-r
ange
pla
n
Etc.
Prov
ide
inpu
t to
the
team
vi
sion/
purp
ose
Prod
uctio
n M
anag
emen
t and
Pr
oces
s Im
prov
emen
tA
sses
s ex
cept
ions
(e.g
., pr
oces
s ad
just
men
ts,
devi
atio
ns, o
r cha
nges
)Re
solv
e an
d/or
neg
otia
te s
olut
ions
with
up
/dow
nstre
am s
take
hold
ers
Etc.
Col
lect
dat
a fo
r ope
ratio
nal p
erfo
rman
ce
met
rics
for y
our a
rea
Prod
uctio
n Pl
anni
ng a
nd S
ched
ulin
g
Man
age
wor
k gr
oup
capa
city
and
thro
ughp
ut
Man
age
empl
oyee
qua
lific
atio
n an
d tra
inin
g
Tran
slate
the
prod
uctio
n pl
an in
to a
wor
k pl
an a
nd
sche
dule
for y
our a
rea
Mon
itor t
he fl
ow o
f wor
k be
twee
n yo
ur w
ork
grou
p an
d in
tern
al su
pplie
rs/c
usto
mer
s
O N
G O
I N
G
Deve
lop
a su
cces
sion
plan
for y
our w
ork
grou
pSe
lect
and
dev
elop
em
ploy
ees
for w
ork
grou
p(fro
m in
tern
al a
nd e
xter
nal c
andi
date
s)Et
c.Et
c.Et
c.Et
c.
Coa
ch a
nd p
rovi
de p
erfo
rman
ce fe
edba
ck to
dire
ct
repo
rts a
nd o
ther
em
ploy
ees
Man
agin
g Pe
ople
Etc.
Desig
n an
d im
plem
ent r
ecog
nitio
n sy
stem
s fo
r you
r wor
k gr
oup
Man
agin
g Fa
cilit
ies
Mai
ntai
n re
liabl
e eq
uipm
ent
Etc.
Etc.
Busin
ess
Skills
Etc.
Qua
lity
Lead
ersh
ip M
odel
s
Budg
etin
g an
d A
ccou
ntin
gEt
c.Et
c.Et
c.Te
am C
omm
unic
atio
nsPr
oble
m-S
olvi
ng
Etc.
RxP
Lead
ersh
ip B
ehav
iors
Etc.
Etc.
Pers
onal
Ski
lls a
nd
Valu
es
Abs
ence
/Atte
ndan
ce
Com
pens
atio
n/M
erit
Deve
lopm
ent P
lann
ing
Etc.
Etc.
Etc.
Etc.
Con
fiden
tialit
y/ In
telle
ctua
l Pr
oper
ty
HR P
olic
ies/
Pro
cess
es
Ass
essm
ent &
Coa
chin
g
Impl
emen
ting
Cha
nge
Deci
sion-
Mak
ing
Faci
litat
ion/
Teac
hing
Team
Dev
elop
men
t
Dele
gatio
n
Busin
ess /
Man
agem
ent
Mot
ivat
ing
Oth
ers
Man
agem
ent/
Le
ader
ship
Ski
lls
Exte
rnal
Reg
ulat
ory
Proc
esse
s
Heal
th, S
afet
y, E
nviro
nmen
t
Qua
lity
Syst
ems
RxP
Com
plia
nce
Polic
ies
and
Proc
edur
es
Regu
lato
ry
Proc
ess
Cap
abilit
y Su
pply
Cha
in
Busin
ess
Plan
ning
Info
rmat
ion
syst
ems
RxP
Busin
ess
Proc
esse
s & To
ols
App
lied
Scie
nce
Engi
neer
ing
Che
mist
ry
Mic
robi
olog
y
Stat
istic
s/M
ath
Biot
echn
olog
y
Phar
mac
eutic
s
Prod
uct M
anuf
actu
ring
Proc
esse
s
Prod
uctio
n Pr
oces
ses,
e.g.
,
Your
Pro
duct
-Man
ufac
turin
g-G
ranu
latio
n-T
able
t Filli
ng-P
acka
ging
Equi
pmen
t, e.
g.,
-Lab
-Pro
duct
ion
Phar
mac
eutic
al
Indu
stry
Drug
Dev
elop
men
t Sta
ges
Com
petit
ive
Land
scap
e-R
xP-Y
our P
rodu
ct/F
unct
ion
Valu
e C
hain
-Hea
lthca
re M
arke
tpla
ce
Man
ufac
turin
g O
rgan
izatio
n/N
etw
ork
Mat
eria
ls M
anag
emen
t
Etc.
Etc.
Etc.
HR Acc
ount
ing/
Fina
nce
Lega
lEt
c.
Mai
nten
ance
Qua
lity
Man
ufac
turin
g Sc
ienc
eEn
gine
erin
g
Prod
uctio
n
Utili
ties/
Faci
litie
s
Proc
ess
Aut
omat
ion
LEA
DERS
HIP/
INTE
RPER
SON
AL
INDU
STRY
/ DI
SCIP
LIN
EC
OM
PAN
Y-SP
ECIF
IC
P L
A N
N I
N G
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 6All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 10
Success Factors: Necessary Technologies
Analysis11 Integrated Solution Set22
Data-Management33 Communities44
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 11
Technology Analysis
“Frame by frame. Death by drowning in your own analysis.”
Adrian Belew
11
Analysis consists of taking apart and examining something to find patterns, the internal logic, so you can better understand it.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 7All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 12
Greeting and IntroGreeting and Intro SecuritySecurity Explore
Initial Needs
Explore Initial
NeedsPropose SolutionsPropose Solutions
Enter OrderEnter Order
Steps/Tasks Output
Security Policy
Account #, Password
Handling Objections/ Questions
Two-handed typing
Navigating Accounts
Account RecordsKnowledge
Item
Information Item
Skill Item
Pre-requisite Knowledge/ Skills
Skill Item
Knowledge Item
The Elements of Performance—Remember the Learning Hierarchy?
Performance
Supporting Capabilities
Pre-Requisites
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 13
All information describing performance, including outputs, tasks, and measures can be categorized as “the work.”
In addition, there are “supportingsupporting knowledge/ skills/ characteristics/ values” (what you need in your behavioral repertoire to do the work).
Key Principle: Performance vs. Supporting Capabilities
Greeting and IntroGreeting and Intro PreliminaryPreliminary
Explore Initial
Needs
Explore Initial
Needs
Identify Actionable
Issues
Identify Actionable
Issues
Summarize Next Steps and Close
Summarize Next Steps and Close
Other NeedsOther Needs
N
Sales SkillsTechnical
Knowledge
Customer Industry
KnowledgeEtc.
Related to the specific job/role.
More likely to be “shareable.”
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 8All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 14
Practice: Performance vs. Supporting
• Policy about credit for returns• Clarify the caller’s initial question• How to navigate the customer account
data systems
Customer Service Agent
• Competitive product capabilities• How to use the CAD system• Materials characteristics (e.g., melting
point)• Design a cruise control switch
Engineer
• Sterile environment practices• Suturing skills• Executing a specific procedure (e.g.,
angioplasty)• Principles of malpractice claims
Doctor
SupportingPerformanceExample CapabilitiesRole
“Litmus Test” Questions• Are you on the payroll to do this?• Is it something you do or something you use to do
something else?
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 15
Capabilities Needed
Technical SkillsProbably Unique to Company—Must Be Learned at Company
•Computer system•ACD system•Etc.
Product KnowledgeUnique to Company—Must Be Learned at Company
•Product A•Service B•Etc.
Customer Service SkillsUnique to Role—Must Be Learned in Equivalent or Actual Role
• Participant calling for information
• Angry participant complaint• Impaired participant (e.g.,
hard of hearing, confused)• Ex-spouse of participant
requesting information• Etc.
Traits/CharacteristicsUnique to Individual—Must Be Part of Selection Criteria
•Energetic•Patient•Able to multi-task•Etc.
Process/Task PerformanceUnique to Role at Company—Must Be Learned at Company
•Greet callers•Access account data•Provide information•Etc.
(Company) Industry Knowledge Unique to Industry—May Be “Selected For” or Learned at Company
•Legal/regulatory•Standards•Marketplace•Etc.
Example: Call Center Agent
Performance
Supporting Supporting
Supporting
Supporting
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 9All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 16
Example: Section of Engineer Capability List
Raw analysis data has to eventually be converted to an organized set of capabilities.
Qualification Catalog
04 Tools/Equipment/Machinery04.01 Tools/Equipment/Machinery (General)04.02 Analysis/Design Tools04.03 Requirements Tracing Tools04.04 Defect Tracking Tools04.05 Configuration Management Tools04.06 Loaders04.07 Software Development Tools04.08 Hardware Development Tools
04.08.01 Mechanical Design/Development04.08.02 Electrical Design/Development
04.08.02.01 DSP Tools04.08.02.02 Viewdraw04.08.02.03 View Sim04.08.02.04 Mentor Graphics
Category
Parent2nd Level
Individual Qualification Items
Parent1st Level
User assesses his/her
capability at this level
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 17
Activity: You Own a Cleaner/Laundry Business!
Diagram of the business
Worksheet
Three to four other participants and your imaginations
Supporting Materials:
Break a simple performance into capabilities
Identify as either “performance” or “supporting”
Classify supporting capabilities
Purpose:
The Clothes Pin
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 10All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 18
Activity: The Business
You are the majority stockholder of a privately held laundry/ cleaning business. Overall, revenue is $2.6M/yr.
Central Plant• Services
- Customer service- Laundry and pressing- Dry cleaning- Drapery cleaning- Fur storage
• Labor: Mostly full-time• Hours:
- Open to public from 6:30am to 8pm, M-Sat
- Operations 24 hours
Storefront (x3)• Services
- Laundry and pressing- Customer service
• Labor: Mix of part-time and full-time
• Hours: - Open to public from
6:30am to 8pm, M-Sat- Operations 24 hours
Clothes may be processed at either location, depending on workload and type of processing
The Clothes Pin
The Clothes Pin
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 19
Activity: Your (Business) Goal
You would like to deliver consistent customer service at all locations and be able to move employees from site to site as needed. For that to work, you will need to be more systematic about the way you manage the capabilities of your workers.
Your first priority is customer service. Your current situation includes the following:The cash register/ order processing system at the plant is different (more complex and newer) than at the three sites.Sites 1 and 2 use the same equipment. Site 3 uses an older system that is mostly manual. (You purchased the third site last year from a competitor that retired.)Most of your labor at Site 2 are students from a nearby college. However, the majority of your labor force is made up of late/ middle-age, lower education workers. Many speak only minimal English.
You decide to analyze the process for receiving an order, from greeting the customer to transferring the order to operations. (This includes entering the order, sorting and bagging the clothes, and tagging the bag. The order is transferred when the bag is dropped in the “in” basket and the order is forwarded in the system.)
The Clothes Pin
The Clothes Pin
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 11All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 20
PRH Consulting Inc.PRH Consulting Inc.20 Danada Square West, #10220 Danada Square West, #102Wheaton, IL 60187Wheaton, IL 60187phone:phone: 630.682.1649630.682.1649web:web: www.prhconsulting.comwww.prhconsulting.comleveraging know-how for performance! ISPI 08_Beyond Competencies Contents © 2008 PRH Consulting Inc.
Performance—Customer Service
T A S K S
Sub-
Task
sSu
ppor
ting
Cap
abili
ties
O U T P U T (S)
• Tools• Software
• Procedures• Reference Docs Prompt/Job Aid
Resource Icon Key
Coach/Expert• asd ;kerj• ke ikjf l kl l \• m3o, eoc.• oe3.f04 ,;;• .merp kekf
• asd ;kerj• ke ikjf l kl l \• m3o, eoc.• oe3.f04 ,;;• .merp kekf
• asd ;ke rj• ke i kj f l k ll \• m 3o , e oc .• oe 3. f04 , ;;• .m erp ke kf
• asd ;ke rj• ke i kj f l k ll \• m 3o , e oc .• oe 3. f04 , ;;• .m erp ke kf
• Training• Qualification
DO
USE
Activity: Your (Activity) Goal
Work in groups of four to six people.
Break the customer service work into a set of capabilities. Go into as much (or as little) detail as you need to be able to
The Clothes Pin
The Clothes Pin
Identify process steps and job tasks.
Tip: Don’t worry about getting the supporting capabilities organized or linked to the performance at this point.
Identify the supporting capabilities needed to perform the process steps and job tasks.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 12All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 22
Technology Integrated Solution Set
“For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled. ”
Richard Feynman
22
Solutions are specific ways of meeting a need—more than one will often work but there are always trade-offs.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 23
Overall System View
Capability Requirements
CapabilityRequirements
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Role Definition
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Role Definition
Content and Support Development and Maintenance
Content and Support Development and Maintenance
Job/Role DefinitionsJob/Role Definitions
Career/Development PathsCareer/Development Paths
Organizational Capability PlanningOrganizational Capability Planning
Individual Capability Assessment and Development Planning
Individual Capability Assessment and Development Planning
TRAINING, OTHERS
HR
Recruiting & SelectionRecruiting & Selection
Qualification AdminQualification Admin
WORK PROCESSES
LEADERSHIP
©2006 PRH Consulting Inc.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 13All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 24
Start from Capability Requirements…
…then design an integrated set of solutions.
Requirements
•Capability A•Subcap 1•Subcap 2•Subcap 3
•Capability B•Subcap 1•Subcap 2•Subcap 3
•Etc.
Capability-Related Interventions
Capability-Related Objects
A
B
C
D
M
N
O
P
CC
DD
EE
FF
KK
LL
MM
NN
SS
TT
UU
VV
WW
XX
YY
ZZ
Career Path
Training
Qualification Test(s)
Selection Instruments
Knowledge Management
Career Path
Training
Qualification Test(s)
Selection Instruments
Knowledge Management
Capability-Related Interventions
…OR define a library of components that can be shared across the organization.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 25
Activity Part 2: You Still Own a Cleaner/Laundry Business!
Starter capability model diagram
Four to six other participants and your imaginations
Supporting Materials:
Consolidate/ clarify capabilities for communication
Distill wording/ consolidate to manageable level of detail
Identifying categories to help with communication and sharing
Purpose:
The Clothes Pin
The Clothes Pin
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 14All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 26
Technology Data-Management and Storage Taxonomies
33
“Not afraid?? You will be…You will be.”
Yoda
An effective approach requires an intuitive interface (for the user) but the ability to handle the necessary complexity.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 27
Capability Requirements
CapabilityRequirements
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Role Definition
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Business Processes
Role Definition
Content and Support Development and Maintenance
Content and Support Development and Maintenance
Job/Role DefinitionsJob/Role Definitions
Career/Development PathsCareer/Development Paths
Organizational Capability PlanningOrganizational Capability Planning
Individual Capability Assessment and Development Planning
Individual Capability Assessment and Development Planning
TRAINING, OTHERS
HR
Recruiting & SelectionRecruiting & Selection
Qualification AdminQualification Admin
WORK PROCESSES
LEADERSHIP
©2006 PRH Consulting Inc.
Overall System View
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 15All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 28
Key: Managing Lots of Small Components
From the “Supplier” Perspective
From the Business User Perspective
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z
AA
BB
CC
DD
EE
FF
GG
HH
II
JJ
KK
LL
MM
NN
OO
PP
RR
SS
TT
UU
VV
WW
XX
YY
ZZ
Org 1, Role 1 Org 2, Role 1
A J R Q
DD
QQ W AA GG OO
WW
AA
EE
AA
GG
EE
AA
GG
A L R
Interpersonal Technical Legal/Regulatory Etc.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 29
“Complex” and “Complicated” are Two Different Things
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 16All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 30
There are basic components in a number of disciplines.
Cooking uses recipes…
Manufacturing uses the Bill of Materials…
Chemistry uses the Periodic Table…
Taxomony
“Categories, which designate rank in a hierarchy, and taxa(plural for taxon), which designates named groupings of organisms, are thus two very different kinds of phenomena.
Controversy usually reigns supreme [emphasis added]over whether or not a particular group is truly distinct enough to be a new taxon. If it is a new taxon, taxonomists then determine which category the taxon will be placed in…”
Taxomony
“Categories, which designate rank in a hierarchy, and taxa(plural for taxon), which designates named groupings of organisms, are thus two very different kinds of phenomena.
Controversy usually reigns supreme [emphasis added]over whether or not a particular group is truly distinct enough to be a new taxon. If it is a new taxon, taxonomists then determine which category the taxon will be placed in…”
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 31
What Would a “Human Performance Capability Taxonomy” Look Like?
It would describe content vs. type (e.g., rather than “concepts” it would contain the actual intended concepts)Organized in a way that fits the business (e.g., roles, technologies, functions, processes)Can be “rolled up” or “drilled down” but, ultimately able to go to small components (like Bill of Materials)Discrete, definable, specific—can be developed independentlyRelational—some are subordinate to one or many others
Capability: Ability to “do stuff”—kind of like objectivesCapability: Ability to “do stuff”—kind of like objectives
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 17All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 32
Example: Engineer Performance
“Assignable Chunk”
Tasks/ Components
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 33
Example Supporting Capabilities: Engineer
Certain capabilities support the performance of tasks
02.01.03 Computer interfaces (I/O)02.01.03.01 RS232/423
02.01.03.02 Interconnect board design
02.01.03.03 Bus technology
02.01.03.04 Fiber optics
02.01.03.05 Digital I/O
The capability for each in this category may be• Knowledge of what it is• Knowledge of how it works• Knowledge of its strengths and
limitations• Information sources for more detail
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 18All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 34
Technology Communities of Knowledge and Practice
“In the great cult of behavior, knowledge is given the place of honor—knowledge for its own sake.”
Thomas Gilbert
44
To build, implement, and improve integrated solutions requires cross-functional participation and ownership.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 35
What Type of Communities Do We Need?
Providers
Leadership/champions to • Support the integration• “Referee” difficult
decisions
Cross-functional teams to • Analyze work, • Define the capabilities• Design solution elements
“Subject area” liaisons
End-Users
“Subject area owners” to provide know-how and content to provider teams on performance and/or supporting capability areas
Application users (i.e., managers and individual contributors)
Leaders/champions
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 19All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 36
So What? Potential Next Steps
“Sooner or later, every good idea degenerates into work.”
Peter Drucker
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 37
How to Make This Work Without Trying to “Boil the Ocean”
Set up the structure—create prototypes of• The various deliverables (e.g., career path, capability
model, etc.)• Simple data management plan
Find toward a manageable “end to end” application (or even a focused pilot)
Expand to other areas on a strategic need basis
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 20All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 38
Summary and Q & A
The business needs capable performersCompetencies, skill dictionaries, and training curriculum alone are too static or unstructured to meet the business need—things change constantlyInstead of continuous churn
• Analyze work down to the components of capability• Construct an integrated HR solution set based on the
components of capability• Build and manage the components of the system to keep
them in alignment with the design
Plan for upcoming business changes to get ahead of the impact on capability requirements
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 39
For More Information . . .
Contact See Also
Peter R. HybertPRH Consulting, Inc.20 Danada Square West, #102Wheaton, IL 60187phone: 630.682.1649email: [email protected]: www.prhconsulting.com
Articles available on the website (or by request)
• Systems that Help People Get Work Done*• Give the Customer What He Meant to Ask
For (published in Performance Improvement, Vol. 40, #9)*
• Training versus Non-training Solutions• Performance-Based Training is (a Little)
Harder to Do• Simulations for Corporate Training• Curriculum architecture design for retail site
managers • Qualification system for engineers• And more…
* Available here as supplies last. Other topics also available.
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 21All rights reserved. May not be reproduced or published without express written consent of the author.
Beyond Competencies—Managing Employee and Organization CapabilityISPI Conference
April 6, 2008
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 40
Session Presenter
Peter R. Hybert
Pete has been in the human performance improvement field since 1984 and has been a consultant since 1989.
His clients include many Fortune 500 firms. He has analyzed, designed, and developed training and development for almost every type of business function and process.
Pete is the author of more than twenty articles and has presented more than twenty times at international conferences and local chapters of ISPI, ASQ, and ASTD. He has also served as the chairperson for ISPI’s Awards of Excellence Committee and a President of the Chicago Chapter of ISPI.
Analyzed over 100 jobs and work processes
Designed over 40 modular curriculum architectures and developed over 50 training and performance support solutions
Designed, developed, and implemented qualification systems and instruments for engineers, technicians, validation specialists, project managers, and service engineers
Designed, developed, and implemented performance-based competency systems, including assessment tools, coaching tools, and links to curriculum
©2008 PRH Consulting, Inc. Page 41
Session Close
Please remember toPlease remember tofill out a session evaluation form!fill out a session evaluation form!