8/6/2019 BIM_CMM_v1.9

1/6

Interactive Building Information Model Maturity Model

As of: 07/21/2011

TODAY: July 21, 2011 40745

NIBS 2007 The Interactive BIM Capability Maturity ModelArea of Interest Weighted Importance Choose your perceived maturity level Credit

Data Richness 84% Expanded Data Set 1.7

Life-cycle Views 84% No Complete Project Phase 0.8

Change Management 90% Initiation 1.8

Roles or Disciplines 90% Two Roles Partially Supported 2.7

Business Process 91% Separate Processes Not Integrated 0.9

Timeliness/ Response 91% Most Response Info manually re-collected - Slow 0.9Delivery Method 92% Network Access w/ Basic IA 2.8

Graphical Information 93% NCS 2D Non-Intelligent As Designed 2.8

Spatial Capability 94% Not Spatially Located 0.9

Information Accuracy 95% Initial Ground Truth 1.9

Interoperability/ IFC Support 96% Forced Interoperability 1.9

Credit Sum 19.2

Maturity Level Not Certified

ADMINISTRATION Points Required for Certification Levels

0 39082 Low High Not Certified

39814.00 40178.00 40 49.9 Minimum BIM

50 69.9 Certified

70 79.9 Silver

80 89.9 Gold

90 100 Platinum

Remaining Points Required For: Certified 30.9

Hyperlinks:

Interactive Maturity Model

Area of Interest Weighting Flowchart

Tabular Maturity Model

Category Descriptions

Matrix Definitions

8/6/2019 BIM_CMM_v1.9

2/6

Areas of Interest Chart

Data Richness

Life-cycle Views

Change Management

Roles or Disciplines

Business Process

Timeliness/ ResponseDelivery Method

Graphical Information

Spatial Capability

Information Accuracy

Interoperability/ IFC Support

0.0

2.0

4.0

1.7

0.8 1.8

2.70.9

0.9

2.8

2.8

0.9

1.9

1.9

Areas of Interest and their Respective Credits

8/6/2019 BIM_CMM_v1.9

3/6

Area of Interest Weighting

Interoperability/IFC SupportWeight: 96%

Information AccuracyWeight: 95%

Spatial CapabilityWeight: 94%

Graphical InformationWeight: 93%

Delivery Method

Weight: 92%

Timeliness/ResponseWeight: 91%Business Process

Weight: 91%

Change ManagementWeight: 90%

Roles or DisciplinesWeight: 90%

Data RichnessWeight: 84%

Lifecycle ViewsWeight: 84%

8/6/2019 BIM_CMM_v1.9

4/6

Tabular BIM Capability Maturity Model 5/30/2006

Maturity Level

1 Basic Core Data No Interoperability

2 Aware of CM

3

4

5

6

7

8 Add Financial

9 4D - Add Time

10

NIBS 2007

AData Richness

BLife-cycle Views

CRoles Or

Disciplines

GChange

Management

DBusinessprocess

F Timeliness/Response

EDeliveryMethod

HGraphical

Information

I SpatialCapability

JInformationAccuracy

KInteroperability/ IFC

Support

No CompleteProject Phase

No Single RoleFully Supported

No CMCapability

SeparateProcesses Not

Integrated

Most ResponseInfo manually re-collected - Slow

Single PointAccess No IA

Primarily Text -No Technical

Graphics

Not SpatiallyLocated

No GroundTruth

Expanded DataSet

Planning &Design

Only One RoleSupported

Few BusProcessesCollect Info

Most ResponseInfo manually re-

collected

Single PointAccess w/Limited IA

2D Non-Intelligent As

Designed

Basic SpatialLocation

Initial GroundTruth

ForcedInteroperability

Enhanced Data

Set

Add

Construction/Supply

Two Roles

PartiallySupported

Aware of CM

and Root CauseAnalysis

Some Bus

ProcessCollect Info

Data Calls Not In

BIM But MostOther Data Is

Network

Access w/Basic IA

NCS 2D Non-

Intelligent AsDesigned

Spatially

Located

Limited

Ground Truth -Int Spaces

Limited

Interoperability

Data Plus SomeInformation

IncludesConstruction/

Supply

Two Roles FullySupported

Aware CM, RCAand Feedback

Most BusProcessesCollect Info

LimitedResponse Info

Available In BIM

NetworkAccess w/

Full IA

NCS 2DIntelligent As

Designed

Located w/Limited Info

Sharing

Full GroundTruth - IntSpaces

Limited InfoTransfers Between

COTS

Data PlusExpandedInformation

IncludesConstr/Supply &

Fabrication

Partial Plan,Design&Constr

Supported

ImplementingCM

All BusinessProcess(BP)Collect Info

Most ResponseInfo Available In

BIM

Limited WebEnabledServices

NCS 2DIntelligent As-

Builts

Spatiallylocated

w/Metadata

LimitedGround Truth -

Int & Ext

Most Info TransfersBetween COTS

Data w/LimitedAuthoritativeInformation

Add LimitedOperations &

Warranty

Plan, Design &ConstructionSupported

Initial CMprocess

implemented

Few BPCollect &

Maintain Info

All ResponseInfo Available In

BIM

Full WebEnabledServices

NCS 2DIntelligent And

Current

Spatiallylocated w/Full

Info Share

Full GroundTruth - Int And

Ext

Full Info TransfersBetween COTS

Data w/ MostlyAuthoritativeInformation

IncludesOperations &

Warranty

Partial Ops &SustainmentSupported

CM process inplace and earlyimplementation

Some BPCollect &

Maintain Info

All ResponseInfo From BIM &

Timely

Full WebEnabled

Services w/IA

3D - IntelligentGraphics

Part of alimited GIS

Limited CompAreas &

Ground Truth

Limited Info UsesIFC's For

Interoperability

CompletelyAuthoritativeInformation

Operations &SustainmentSupported

CM and RCAcapability

implemented

All BP Collect& Maintain Info

Limited RealTime Access

From BIM

Web EnabledServices -

Secure

3D - CurrentAnd Intelligent

Part of a morecomplete GIS

Full ComputedAreas &

Ground Truth

Expanded InfoUses IFC's ForInteroperability

LimitedKnowledge

Management

Full Facility Life-cycle Collection

All Facility Life-Cycle RolesSupported

Businessprocesses aresustained by

CM using RCAand Feedback

loops

Some BPCollect&MaintIn Real Time

Full Real TimeAccess From

BIM

NetcentricSOA BasedCAC Access

Integrated intoa complete

GIS

Comp GTw/LimitedMetrics

Most Info UsesIFC's For

Interoperability

Full KnowledgeManagement

SupportsExternal Efforts

Internal andExternal Roles

Supported

Businessprocesses are

routinelysustained byCM, RCA and

Feedback loops

All BPCollect&MaintIn Real Time

Real TimeAccess w/ Live

Feeds

NetcentricSOA Role

Based CAC

nD - Time &Cost

Integrated intoGIS w/ FullInfo Flow

ComputedGround Truthw/Full Metrics

All Info Uses IFC'sFor Interoperability

8/6/2019 BIM_CMM_v1.9

5/6

Capability Maturity Model Category Descriptions

Weight Title Description Hyperlinks:

1.1 Data Richness

1.1 Life-cycle Views

1.2 Roles Or Disciplines

1.2 Change Management

1.3 Business process

1.3 Timeliness/ Response

1.4 Delivery Method

1.5 Graphical Information

1.6 Spatial Capability

1.7 Information Accuracy

1.8 Interoperability/ IFC Support

Identifies the completeness of the building Information Model from initially very few pieces of

unrelated data to the point of it becoming valuable information and ultimately corporate knowledgeabout a facility Interactive Maturity Model

Views refer to the phases of the project and identifying how many phases are to be covered by theBIM. One would start as individual stove pipes of information and then begin linking thosetogether and taking advantage of information gathered by the authoritative source of theinformation. This category has high cost reduction, high value implications based on theelimination of duplicative data gathering. The goal would be to support functions outside thetraditional facility management roles, such as first responders.

Area of Interest Weighting Flowchart

Roles refer to the players involved in the business process and how the information flows. This isalso critical to reducing the cost of data re-collection. Disciplines are often involved in more thanone view as either a provider or consumer of information. Our goal is to involve both internal andexternal roles as both providers and consumers of the same information so that data does nothave to be re-created and that the authoritative source is the true provider of the information.

Tabular Maturity Model

Change Management identifies a methodology used to change business processes that have

been developed by an organization. If a business process is found to be flawed on in need ofimprovement, one institutes a root cause analysis of the problem and then adjusts the businessprocess based on that analysis. Since this is related to the following item, business processes itshould come after it.

Category Descriptions

The business process defines how business is accomplished. If the data and information isgathered as part of the business process then data gathering is a no cost requirement. If data isgathered as a separate process then the data will likely not be accurate. The goal is to have databoth collected and maintained in a real time environment, so as physical changes are made theyare reflected for others to access in their portion of the business process.

Matrix Definitions

While some information is more static than other information it all changes and up to the minuteaccuracy may be critical in emergency situations. The closer to accurate real time information youcan be the better quality the decisions that are made. Some of those decisions may be life savingin nature.

Data delivery is also critical to success. If data is only available on one machine then sharing cannot occur other than by email or hard copy. In a structured networked environment if informationis centrally stored or accessible then some sharing will occur. If the model is a systems orientedarchitecture (SOA) in a web enabled environment the nentcentricity will occur and information willbe available in a controlled environment to the appropriate players. Information assurance mustbe engineered into all phases.

Often the starting point is a non-graphical environment. The advent of graphics helps paint aclearer picture for all involved. As standards are applied then information can begin to flow as theprovider and receiver must have the same standards in place. As 3D images come into play moreconsumers of the information will have a common view and a higher level of understanding willoccur. As time and cost are added then the interfaces can be expanded significantly.

Understanding where something is in space is significant to many information interfaces and therichness of the information. Energy calculations must know where the heat gains will come from,first responders need to know where water supplies and utility cutoffs are located in relation to thefacility.

Having a way to ensure that information remains accurate Is only possible through somemathematical ground truth capability. Having a mathematical product will also allow for bettermanagement by supporting difficult to game metrics. These numbers can be used for occupancy,information collection completeness and overall inventory calculations.

Our ultimate goal is to ensure interoperability of information. Getting accurate information to theparty requiring the information. There are many ways to achieve this, however the most effectiveis to use a standards based approach to ensure that information is a form that it can be sharedand products are available that can read that standard for of information.

8/6/2019 BIM_CMM_v1.9

6/6

Maturity Level Data R ichness Life-cycle Views Roles Or Disciplines Business process Delivery Method Timeliness/ Response Change Management Graphical I

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

Choose this selectionwhen you haveestablished a BIM, buthave only very basic datato load

Data is gathered as it isavailable but no singlephase is authoritative norcomplete

Roles apply to peoplesjobs and at this level noones role is fullysupported through theBIM

Business processes arenot defined and thereforenot used to storeinformation in the BIM

The BIM is onlyaccessible from a singleworkstation and has noinformation assurancebuilt-in

Information is re-collectedwhen needed to respondto a question - theprocess is slow and un-automated and has to bere-invented each time aquestion is asked

No change managementprocess awareness isevident nor has beenimplemented in theorganization.

There are nothe BIM - onl

As you become moreadvanced additional datawill be available and beentered. This is still earlyin the maturity

Since basic initial data iscollected during planningand design this is typicallythe first phase to be madeavailable, but this can beany phase such as

construction also

Roles apply to peoplesjobs and at this levelthere is one persons rolethat is fully supportedthrough the BIM

Few business processesare designed to collectinformation to maintainthe BIM in theorganization

The BIM is not on anetwork but there iscontrol over who canaccess the BIM

Most of the informationneeded to respond to aquestion must becollected to respond tothe question howeverthere is awareness of

how to obtain theinformation

There is an earlyawareness of the needfor business processdefinition and changemanagement in theorganization although

implementation is not yetinitiated

2D drawings the BIM but tinteraction winformation - were not devthe NCS

At this point you arebeginning to be at a pointwhere you come to themodel for basic data andthere truly somethingthere

An additional phase isavailable, typicallyconstruction, however thetwo phases do notnecessarily need to belinked

Roles apply to peoplesjobs and at this levelthere are at least twopeoples roles that arepartially supportedthrough the BIM but theystill do have to go to otherproducts to accomplishtheir jobs

Some businessprocesses are designedto collect information tomaintain the BIM in theorganization

The BIM is on a networkand there is basicpassword control overdata entry and retrieval

Most information is in theBIM however manyresponses to data callsinvolve collection of datawhich is then store in theBIM

Early implementation ofbusiness processdefinition is underwayand there is an earlyawareness of the needfor business processdefinition and there is anawareness of changemanagement and theneed for root causeanalysis in theorganization

The drawingsdeveloped ware still non-iand not objec

This is the first stagewhen data is turned intoinformation

A third phase is addedalthough information doesnot have to be flowing, itis assumed that some is

Roles apply to peoplesjobs and at this levelthere are at least twopeoples roles that arefully supported throughthe BIM in that they donot have to go to otherproducts to accomplishtheir jobs

Most business processesare designed to collectinformation to maintainthe BIM in theorganization

The BIM is on a networkand there is control overdata entry and retrieval

Information is stored inthe BIM and many datacalls can be answeredwith information that isalready in the BIM

Business processes arein place and there is anunderstanding of the fullchange managementrequirement to includeroot cause analysis andimplementation of afeedback loop.

The drawingsare intelligenrecognizes itwith propertieare as designas built

The data is beginning tobe accepted asauthoritative and theprimary source

A forth phase of thefacility lifecycle is addedand some information isflowing

Peoples jobs in planningand design are fullysupported through theBIM in that they do nothave to go to otherproducts to accomplishtheir jobs

All business processesare designed to collectinformation as they areperformed

The BIM is in a limitedweb environment typicallyfound in a single officeenvironment, IA is not inplace to control data entryor retrieval

A significant portion of theresponse informationrelated to a facility isstored in the BIM

Business processes arein place and theorganization has begunimplementing changemanagement procedures

The drawingsare intelligenrecognizes itwith propertieare as built bcurrent

Some metadata is storedand information istypically best available

An additional phase isadded and clearlyinformation is flowing tooperations from thedesign and constructionphases

Peoples jobs in planning,design and constructionare fully supportedthrough the BIM in thatthey do not have to go toother products toaccomplish their jobs

All business processesare designed to collectinformation as they areperformed but few arecapable of maintaininginformation in the BIM

The BIM is web enabledbut IA is not in placealthough there is somecontrol to access of theinformation. Thisenvironment would befound in a singleoffice/company

Responses to data callsrelated to the facility areprimarily stored in the BIM

Business processes arein place and early changemanagement processesare identifying changes,but no process is in placeto make changes

The drawingsare intelligenrecognizes itwith propertieare current

Most users rely oninformation as reliableand authoritative, littleadditional data checkingis required

Information collectedduring earlier phases isflowing to operations andsustainment

Peoples jobs in planning,design, construction arefully supported andoperations andsustainment are partiallysupported through the

BIM in that they do nothave to go to other

All business processesare designed to collectinformation as they areperformed and some arecapable of maintaininginformation in the BIM

The BIM is in a webenvironment so multiplepeople can operate on itand there is role based IAmanually controlled

All emergency responseinformation is in the BIMand that is considered theprimary source ofaccurate information

Early implementation ofchange management isin place and someprocesses are beingmaintained through a rootcause analysis process.

The drawingsobject basedintelligence

The information hasmetadata and is theauthoritative source

A cost model is supportedand costs are linked tothe information related toal phases. Lifecyclecosting can be performed

Peoples jobs in planning,design, construction andoperations andsustainment are fullysupported through theBIM in that they do nothave to go to otherproducts to accomplishtheir jobs

All business processesare designed to collectinformation as they areperformed and all arecapable of maintaininginformation in the BIM

The BIM is in a webenabled environment andis considered secure. It isnot in a SOA

Information stored in aBIM is available real timeand although not from alive feed processes are inplace to maintain itsaccuracy

Implementation of achange managementprocess is in place and isbeginning to beexercised, but is not fullyendorsed by allparticipants

The drawingsobject basedprocess in plathem current

Limited KnowledgeManagement implies thatKM strategies are in placeand authoritativeinformation is beginningto be linked

All phases of the lifecycleare supported andinformation is flowingbetween phases

All facility related jobsthroughout the lifecycle ofthe facility rely solely onthe BIM to accomplishtheir jobs

All business processesare designed to collectand some maintain datain real time

The BIM is in a netcentricweb environment and isserved up as a service ina service orientedarchitecture and CACenabled but roles must bemanaged manually

The information is storedin a BIM and is currentenough to be a reliablesource for information inan emergency

The change managementprocesses are in place,but is not a efficientprocess and changestypically take more than48 hours

Time phasingadded to the that one can historical as wable to projecfuture

Full KnowledgeManagement implies arobust data richenvironment with virtuallyall authoritativeinformation is loaded andlinked together

External information islinked into the model andanalysis can beperformed on the entireecosystem of the facilitythroughout its life

All facility related jobsboth internal and externalto the organization relysolely on the BIM toaccomplish their jobs

All business processesare designed to collectand maintain data in realtime

The BIM is in a netcentricweb environment and isserved up as a service ina service orientedarchitecture with rolebased CAC enabled toenter and accessinformation

Information is continuallyupdated and availablefrom live feeds tosensors. Responses toquestions are almostimmediate and areaccurate and relational

A mature and fullyoperational changemanagement process isin place and processeschanges areimplemented within 48hours

The drawing BIM are intellobject basedtime and cost