biodiesel fuels, issues trends challenges
DESCRIPTION
- Petroleum Background - Needs of Petroleum Industry - Schematic of Petroleum Refining - Foundational Technology: Distillation - Diesel Engines Pollute the Air - Diesel Engines Here for Long Term - Needs of Biodiesel Industry - Biodiesel Background - Enter Biodiesel - Growing Biodiesel Feedstock: Canola and Mustard oil seed crops - Biodiesel Raw Materials - Biofuels: Production Methods - Biofuels Production: Reaction Mechanism - The Biodiesel Reaction - Transesterification Reaction - Base Catalyzed Esterification of Oils - Biofuels Production: Process Flowsheet - Biodiesel Fractionation Processes - Conventional Biodiesel Fractionation Technologies - Foundational Technology: Urea Clathration - Urea-biodiesel clathration - Differential Processing Biodiesel Properties - Biodiesel: Fuel Quality for Diesel Engines - Biodiesel B100 Properties - Cold Flow Properties - Important Biodiesel Parameters - Production Process Highlights - Biodiesel Production: Challenges - Biodiesel: Economics - Biodiesel ApplicationsTRANSCRIPT
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Biodiesel Fuel Issues, Trends and Challenges
By Gerard B. Hawkins Executive Director RENALT ENERGY
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Petroleum Background
Geologically mined non-renewable resource Complex mixture of mainly hydrocarbon structures (alkane / alkene, aromatics, wide range of molecular weights, C4-C100+) Multiple sources differing in composition (geographical, contaminants)
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Needs of Petroleum Industry
Unusable in original state (viscous, black gunk), low cost Must be able to handle differing feedstocks and produce consistent products Needed processing technology to make useful differentiated products, e.g. gasoline, diesel, kerosene, chemical feedstocks, etc. Current issues are economic and political
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Schematic of Petroleum Refining
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Foundational Technology: Distillation
www.renaltenergy.com
Diesel Engines Pollute the Air Diesel exhaust is toxic and carcinogenic 20,000 Americans die each year from lung disease
from diesel exhaust particulates 400,000 Americans suffer from asthma and lung
disease related to diesel exhaust; problem acute in West Oakland, BayView
Diesel exhaust is even more of a problem in congested cities with older diesels
Sulfur oxides in exhaust lead to acid rain Environmental Justice projects in SF…
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Diesel Engines Here for Long Term Diesel engines are still one of the most reliable,
energy efficient & powerful propulsion systems; long engine life
New diesel engine technologies & regulations will reduce exhaust emissions dramatically; plus new after-treatment
Diesel-Electric hybrids do help reduce impact; electric buses have decades of success on the steep hills of SF
CNG buses in widespread use but problems persist However, the diesel fuel remains toxic to workers &
the public as volatile flammable liquid; threat to groundwater
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Diesel Engines Here for Long Term
2/3 of our petroleum is imported now; jobs/trade balance
Diesel fuel production at refineries in the western states cannot keep up with the demand – opportunity for biofuel
The long-term sustainability of non-renewable petroleum fuel is a real issue for the US and developing countries
The rising price of diesel fuel is promoting alternative fuel
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Needs of Biodiesel Industry
Useful existing feedstock (oil), high cost Quality control; Must be able to handle differing feedstocks and produce consistent products Needed processing technology to make differentiated products, e.g. cold flow products Major current issue is product performance with respect to cold weather
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Biodiesel Background
Biologically produced renewable resource Hydrocarbon-like ester structures (mainly alkane/alkene structures, relatively narrow molecular weight distribution (C12-C20) Multiple sources differing in composition (plant/animal/microbial, few contaminants)
www.renaltenergy.com
Enter Biodiesel A diesel displacement fuel made from plant oils,
animal tallow or recycled cooking oils through a chemical process to remove glycerin and yield methyl or ethyl esters optimized for combustion
Renewable, agriculturally produced alternative fuel to displace imported petroleum; similar price
Biodiesel itself is non-toxic, non-flammable and non-volatile, making it safer to handle & store
Biodiesel contains little sulfur and no aromatics When blended with petroleum diesel or burned as a
pure fuel, biodiesel can significantly reduce diesel engine exhaust PM, CO, HC, S & toxics
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Growing Biodiesel Feedstock: Canola and Mustard oil seed crops
Rotation crops for wheat farmers in CA, Eastern Washington, Oregon, Idaho, NV
High oil yield strains yield 100-150 gallons of biodiesel per acre (double yield of soy)
Dry farmed and drought tolerant crops Plant debris contributes nitrogen to soil Glucosinolate in plant and meal is an organic
fungicide, pesticide & herbicide -reduces costs for farmer; added benefits
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel Raw Materials Oil or Fat Alcohol Soybean, Canola Methanol Corn, Safflower Ethanol (rare) Mustard, Cottonseed Sunflower Catalyst Palm, Coconut Sodium or potassium
Jatropha, Castor bean Hydroxide Beef tallow, pork lard, poultry fat Used cooking oils & grease, FOG
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biofuels: Production Methods
Biodiesel Production Methods •Base catalyzed transesterification of oil •Direct acid catalyzed transesterification of oil •Convert oils into fatty acids and then to biodiesel
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biofuels Production: Reaction Mechanism Base catalyzed Esterification reaction CH2OCOR''„ CH2OH R'''COOR CHOCOR'' + 3 ROH Catalyst CHOH + R''COOR CH2OCOR„ CH2OH R'COOR (100 lbs) (10 lbs) (10 lbs) (100 lbs) Oil or Fat Alcohol (excess) Glycerin Biodiesel (Triglyceride)
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
The Biodiesel Reaction
Vegetable Oil or Animal Fat (100 lbs.)
+ Methanol or
Ethanol (10 lbs.)
Biodiesel (100 lbs.)
+ Glycerine (10 lbs.)
+ catalyst (hydroxide)
Combining Yields
www.renaltenergy.com
Transesterification Reaction
H O H - C - O - C - CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH3 O H - C - O - C - (CH2)7 -CH = CH(CH2)7 CH3 + 3 H3 - C -OH ---------------> + -OH O Methanol Catalyst H - C - O - C - (CH2)7 -CH = CHCH2 CH = CH(CH2)4 CH3 H Triglyceride
Vegetable / Soybean Oil
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel = Methyl esters of Tryglyceride fatty acid chains
H O H - C - OH CH3 - O - C - (CH2)16 CH3 Methyl Stearate (saturated ester) O H - C - OH + CH3 - O - C - (CH2)7 -CH = CH(CH2)7 CH3 Methyl Oleate (mono-unsaturated ester) O H - C - OH CH3 - O - C - (CH2)7 -CH = CHCH2 CH = CH(CH2)4 CH3 H Methyl Linoleate (di-unsaturated ester) Glycerin Biodiesel Methyl Esters
Catalyst- Mixing
Methanol
Catalyst
Transesterification Vegetable Oils, Used
Cooking Oil, Animal Fats
Neutralization Phase Separation Re-neutralization Methanol- Recovery
Purification Methanol- Recovery
Quality Control
Glycerin Purification
Neutralizing Acid
Crude Biodiesel
Methyl Ester
Crude Glycerin
Pharmaceutical Glycerin
Recycled Methanol
If desired
Biodiesel Production Process
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biofuels Production: Process Flowsheet
Base Catalyzed Esterification of Oils
Source: Lurgi Process
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Biodiesel Fractionation Processes
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Historical comparison between development of petroleum/biodiesel fuel processing – Technologies to create multiple fuel products Description of new biodiesel fractionation process Opportunities/Applications
Overview
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Conventional Biodiesel Fractionation Technologies
1. Thermal fractionation (with or without solvent): Crystallization/filtration process, very low yields, long process time, high losses due to co-crystallization / inclusion
Solvent crystallization gives higher yields, but requires significant refrigeration/very low temperatures
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Conventional Biodiesel Fractionation Technologies
2. Adsorption/Chromatographic, Liquid-Liquid extraction techniques Require multiple solvents, expensive processing components, energy intensive
High cost, low selectivity, unsuitable for large scale processing
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Conventional Biodiesel Fractionation Technologies
3. Lipase catalysis Relies on the selectivity of certain lipases to hydrolyze only the unsaturates
High selectivity but very low yields, process time runs into days
Extremely expensive
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Urea-biodiesel clathration
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Foundational Technology: Urea Clathration
Scalable/robust, based on alkene structure, energy efficient www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Biodiesel Standard Process
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Biodiesel Fractionation Process
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Urea is only additional component, which is 100% recycled
Only additional major equipment is mixing tank/centrifuge (some additional tankage)
Only added energy input is for added methanol evaporation (if any)
Differential Processing
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Can be integrated into existing/new biodiesel processing plants Scalable, robust, simple process Estimated differential costs 5-10 cents/gal
Differential Processing
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Differential Processing
Usable with any biodiesel feedstock or blend, e.g. soybean oil, canola, palm oil, coconut oil, lard, waste restaurant fat, etc. Controllable product properties based on Alkane / alkene composition, carbon chain Length
Yields will depend on feedstock Composition Serial/staged fractionation is possible to obtain multiple products
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel: Fuel Quality for Diesel Engines
•ASTM Specification for B100 for Blending has been developed (D6751) • Changes being considered to improve quality •Attempts are being made to address stability and compatibility with newer diesel technology concerns of engine manufacturers • Additional research required to define and test for stability • Lack of data relating stability and deposit formation in engine
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel B100 Properties Ultra low Sulfur (typically < 8 ppm) No Aromatics (& low PAH emission) High Cetane (> 52, improved ignition) High Lubricity (even 1% restores ULSD lubricity) Biodegradable (soil, marine, aquatic ecosystems) Non-Toxic (but harmful to aquatic habitats) Non-volatile (< 2 mm Hg vapor pressure) Non-flammable (Flash Point > 300 Deg F) Solvent action of fuel on seals, gaskets, tank liners Must meet ASTM 6751 specifications or problems
result with precipitations, contaminants & failures
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel Properties Properties ASTM Standard-D6751 • Reaction completion • Glycerin removal • Catalyst removal • Free fatty acids removal
Ester Viscosity mm²/s
Cetane No. ΔHg kJ/kg
Tflash
°C
CP °C
PP °C
Methyl 4.08 46.2 39,800 191 2 -1 Ethyl 4.41 48.2 40,000 174 1 -4 Isopropyl 52.6 – – -9 -12 N-Butyl 5.24 51.7 40,700 185 -3 -7 No. 2 Diesel 2.39 45.8 45,200 78 -19 -23
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Cold Flow Properties:
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Biodiesel quality depends on feedstock
www.renaltenergy.com
Important Biodiesel Parameters
Complete Reaction to >97% conversion to avoid partially reacted glycerides remaining in fuel
Removal of Glycerin (gums engine valves) Removal of Catalyst (caustic hydroxide) Removal of Alcohol (flash point issues) Absence of Free Fatty Acids or Soaps
Should be insured via ASTM D 6751 [New revisions coming including oxidation stability]
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Production Process Highlights Most transesterification reactions achieve 97-99%
conversion of oils & fats to esters Co-product glcyerin & unreacted reagents are
largely removed by gravity or centrifugation; traces can remain in fuel
Methanol is flashed off and recovered Water washes remove last traces of catalyst,
methanol, glycerin and soaps Final polishing steps essential to remove traces of
oils, mono-, di-, tri-glycerides & glycerin to achieve ASTM spec B100
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel Production: Challenges
• Glycerol Utilization - Better utilization of glycerin • Improve Esterification - Processing steps • Fuel to diesel engine specifications - Minimize impurities
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Biodiesel: Production vs Capacity
Biodiesel Specification ASTM 6751
Property ASTM Method Limits Units Flash Point 93 130 min. degree C Water & Sediment 2709 0.05 max. vol.% Carbon Residue 4530 0.05 max. wt. % (100% sample)
Sulfated Ash 874 0.02 max. wt. % Kin. Viscosity, 40C 445 1.9 - 6.0 mm²/sec. Sulfur 5453 0.05 max. wt. % Cetane 613 47 min. Cloud Point 2500 By Customer degree C Copper Corrosion 130 No. 3 max. Acid Number 664 0.80 max. mg KOH/g Free Glycerin 6854 0.020 wt. % Total Glycerin 6854 0.240 wt. % Phosphorous 4951 10 max ppm Distillation, T90 AET 1160 360 max degree C
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
ASTM D6751 Highlights
Acid number – for degrading, oxidized fuel Flashpoint – for residual methanol Water & sediment – fuel fouling, deposits Sulfated ash – for residual catalyst Total glycerin – for incomplete conversion, detects
residual mono, di and tri glycerides Free glycerin – inadequate fuel washing New ASTM updates will include specs for Na+, K+ and oxidation stability
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel: Economics
Assumptions • Plant size: 60 million gallons • Feedstock cost: 80% • 7.5 lbs feedstock/gallon biodiesel • Operating cost (excluding feedstock): $0.42/gallon • Credit for glycerin and other by-products: $0.05/gallon
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
Biodiesel: Economics Net operating profit= Revenues –Operating cost (excluding capital and other fixed costs )
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
How can Biodiesel be used? In low levels with petrodiesel ULSD (B2 - B5) to
restore the lubricity after hydrotreatment that removes the sulfur and lubricating compounds
As a blending stock with regular diesel (B20) As a pure fuel (“Neat” or B100 in niche markets)
primarily in CA and among biodiesel enthusiasts
In all diesel engines, with no conversion for blends of 20% or less; Check fuel tanks
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Applications Summer/winter diesel fuel blend stocks
Aviation jet fuel
Solvents
Chemical feedstocks (enhanced reactivity)
Future research on catalytic cracking/reforming/alkylation/cyclization
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Summary
Description of a novel simple fractionation process for biodiesel fuels Low energy, environmentally benign, low cost, robust /scalable, compatible with existing/new biodiesel synthesis plants
www.renaltenergy.com
RENALT ENERGY Renewable and Alternative Energy for the New Millennium
Summary
Usable with variety of feedstocks (plant, animal, microbial lipids) Controllable cold temperature properties suitable for ground, aviation fuels; also potential chemical feedstocks
www.renaltenergy.com