blake taylor
TRANSCRIPT
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 1/22
Blake and Thomas TaylorAuthor(s): Frederick E. PierceSource: PMLA, Vol. 43, No. 4 (Dec., 1928), pp. 1121-1141Published by: Modern Language AssociationStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/457606 .
Accessed: 21/09/2014 20:19
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
.
Modern Language Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to PMLA.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 2/22
LXIII
BLAKE AND THOMAS TAYLOR
THE mystical
philosophical
(or
pseudo-philosophical)
ten-
dencies
of
the
English
romantic
movement
probably
owed
a
good
deal
to
Thomas
Taylor.
From
the
publication
of
Cowper's
Task and
Burns'
Kilmarnock
poems
to
the
death
of
Shelley
and
Byron, Taylor
poured
out an
unceasing
stream
of
commentaries
and translations
elucidating
for
England
the doctrines
of
Plato
and
the
Neo-Platonists.
To be
sure,
his works had
very
limited
sale,
and
most
of one edition
was locked
up
for a lifetime
in
the
archives
of
the
rich nobleman
who financed
its
publication.
But
no man
could
so much and
receive
as
many
comments
as
he
did
without
having
a
definite effect.
Perhaps
his influence
worked more
strongly
on
William
Blake
than
on
any
other
poet.
They
were
strict
contemporaries,
Blake
being
about
a
year
the
elder;
and it is
probable,
though
not
certain,
that
they
knew each other
personally.
Whether
they
did
or not, the dates of their publications interlock so consistently,
and
the
Neo-Platonism
of
the
poet
so
consistently
develops
just
behind that
of
the
scholar,
that some form
of
influence
seems
almost
unquestionable.
Both were
mystics living
in
London:
both
knew
Flaxman,
Tom
Paine,
and other
common
friends;
directly
or
indirectly
there
must have been
some
transferring
of
ideas.1
In this
connection
a
dated
table
of
publications
is
illuminating.
The following list, though by no means complete,2 gives the more
important
works
of
both authors.
TAYLOR
BLAKE
1783. Poetical
Sketches
printed.
(nothing
mystical)
1787.
Hymns
of
Orpheus,
nd
sec-
tion
from
Plotinus
on
The Beauti-
ful.
1788-89.
Philosophical
nd Math-
1789.
Songs
of
Innocence
en-
ematicalCommentariesfProclus. graved.
1
Some
of
the more
obvious
likenesses
between
Taylor
and
Blake
have
been
pointed
out
by
Professor
Damon n
his
William
Blake.
2
For a
very
full
list
of
Taylor's
works
see Thomas
Taylor,
the
Platonist,
List
of
Original
Works
and
Translations,
repared
or
Newberry
Library
by
Ruth
Balch
of the
Library
Staff,
Chicago,
1917.
1121
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 3/22
Blake
and
Thomas
Taylor
TAYLOR
1790
or
1791.
Dissertation on
Eleusinian
and
Bacchic
mysteries.
1792.
Philosophical
and
Mathe-
matical Commentaries f
Proclus
(edition
n
Yale
Library).
1793.
Plato's
Cratylus, Phaedo,
Parmenidesand Timaeus.
1793.
Sallust on
the Gods and the
World.
1794. Five
books
of Plotinus
(in-
cluding
that on the descent
of
the
soul).
1804.
The Works
of Plato.
BLAKE
1789. Book of Thel engraved.
1793 ff.
Marriage
Hell
engraved.
of Heaven
and
1793. Visions of
Daughters
of
Albion
engraved.
1794. Books of Urizen
engraved.
1794.
Songs
of
Experience
en-
graved.
1797
ff.
The Four
Zoas
written.
1804
ff. Milton
engraved.
1804
ff.
Jerusalem
engraved.
Any
one
reading
these
books
in
chronological
sequence
will see
Blake's
Neo-Platonism
steadily
increasing
in
proportion
to what
he couldhaveamassed from
Taylor.
In some cases there may have
been other sources3
available,
in
some
there
certainly
were
not;
but for
all cases
under
discussion
Taylor
was
a
possible
source,
sometimes, apparently,
the
only
one.
Even
where
Blake could
have
drawn
from
other
writers,
it
seems
improbable
that he
did.
For
example,
the
creation
of
Urizen
in
The
Book
of
Urizen
shows
a marked likeness
to the creation
of man
in
Plato's
Timaeus.4
Taylor's
translation
of
the Timaeus was not the
only
version in
existence; but it is rather striking that it had appeared so shortly
before Blake's
poem.
A
comparison
of
Taylor's
translation
will
show how
direct
the
borrowing
from
Plato
was:
Blake's Book
of
Urizen194-205.
"Restless
urn'd
he
Immortal,
enchain'd,
Heavingdolorous,anguish'd,
unbearable;
Till
a
roof,
shaggy,
wild,
enclos'd
In
an orb
his fountain
of
thought.
In
a
horrible,
dreamful
slumber,
Like the linked infernal
chain,
A
vast
Spine
writh'd
n
torment
Upon
the
winds,
shooting
pain'd
31
have
made,
not
an exhaustive
earch,
but a
reasonably
horough
ne,
without
inding
uch
sources.
4
Firstnoticed
y
Professor
amon.
1122
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 4/22
Frederick E.
Pierce
Ribs,
like a
bending cavern;
And
bones of solidness
roze
Over all his
nerves of
joy."
Plato's Timaeus
Taylor's
rans. ed. of
1793,p.
525)5
"Employing
herefore
his
nature
of
bone,
he fashioned ike
one
work-
ing
with
a wheel
a
bony
sphere,
and
placed
it round the
brain;
eaving
a
narrow
passage
in
the
sphere
itself. And
besides
this,
forming
certain
vertebrae
rom
bone about
the marrowof
the neck and
back,
he extended
them
like
hinges,
commencing
rom the head
and
proceeding hrough
he
whole
cavity
of the
body.
And
thus he
preserved
ll the
seed,
by
fortifying
it
round
about with
a
stony
vestment."
Taylor's
works
are
so
rare
and
so
widely
scattered that
no
scholar has
yet
essayed
the Herculean
task
of
mastering
them all.
We
have
examined
those
obtainable,
and
among
them
found
five
which show
many
likenesses
to
Blake and
may
throw
some
light
on his
meaning.
The first is
The
Eleusinian
and Bacchic
Mysteries
in
the third
edition of
1875,
which
is
practically
a
reprint
of
the
first.6
This
is a small work.
The
second
is
The
Philosophical
and
Mathematical
Commentaries
of
Proclus
in
two
volumes,
London,
1792. It has the same title as the 1788-89 work, which we have
not
been able
to
examine.7
The
1792
edition
contains
long
dis-
cussions
on
Neo-Platonism
by Taylor,
brief
lives
of
Plotinus,
Porphyry,
Iamblicus,
and
Proclus,
the
commentaries
of Proclus
on
Euclid,
Proclus's
Theological
Elements,
etc.
The
third and
fourth. books
are
the
Cratylus,
etc.
and
the
Sallust,
both
read
in
the
1793
editions.
The fifth is The Works
of
Plato
in
the
vast,
five
volume
edition
of
1804. These
books
appeared just
as the
mystical
tendency in Blake's poetry was beginning to be obvious. We have
no
positive proof
that
he read
them;
but
it
seems
highly
im-
probable
that a
poet
so
eager
to
explore
mystic
thought
would
have left
such works
unperused,
and there
are
various
similar
passages
which
sound
as
if
the
poet
had
borrowed
material
from
the
scholar.
We
give
these
passages
below.
They
are
presented,
in
the
first
place,
as
evidence
that
Blake
probably
read
Taylor.
But,
much
more
important
than
that, they
are
brought together
in an effort
to
elucidate
Blake's
meaning.
Either
from
Taylor
or elsewhere
6
About
three-fourths
hrough
the
dialogue.
The likeness
was mentioned
by
Professor
Damon
in his
William
Blake.
6
I
have
compared
all
quoted
passages
with
the
anonymous
and
dateless
irst
edition
in
the
Boston
Public
Library
(Amsterdam
d.).
7
Miss
Balch
lists
a
copy
as
in
the
British
Museum.
1123
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 5/22
Blake
and
Thomas
Taylor
he must have
acquired
Neo-Platonic
ideas;
and a
great
deal in
his poetry which once seemed unintelligible nonsense can now be
explained
as
a modern
adaptation
of" ancient and once
highly
respected
systems
of
thought.
For our
text
of
Blake
we
have
used
Sampson's
ed. of
the shorter
poems8
(1913)
and
Sloss and Wallis's
edition9
of the
longer
works.
I
Blake's Jerusalem
(12, 61-13,
12)
"And
the North Gate of
Golgonooza
oward
Generation
Has four sculptur'dBulls terriblebeforethe Gate of iron ....
The
South,
a
golden
Gate,
has four
Lions, terrible,Living
....
The
Western
Gate,
fourfold,
s
clos'd; having
four Cherubim
...
The Eastern
Gate,
fourfold;
errible
and
deadly
its ornaments."
Commentaries
of
Proclus
(II,
279):
"But there
are two
gates:
one
towards the
north
gives
entrance
to
mortals
descending;
ut
the othertowards
he
south
which s more
divine,
is
impervious
to
mankind;
and alone
affords
a
passage
to
ascending
immortals."
The Cratylus, tc., 1793 (pp. 396-397):
"He
asserts,
therefore,
hat
this lowest
order
of
daemons
always
con-
tends
with
souls
in
their ascent and
descent,
especially
western
daemons
for,
according
o
the
Egyptians,
the
west
is accommodated
o
daemons
of
this
description."
II
Blake's
Jerusalem
53,
1-2):
"But
Los,
who
is
the Vehicular
Form
of
strong
Urthona,
Wept
vehemently
over Albion."
Commentariesof Proclus (II, 434, note):
"The
reader
must
observe that
these
vehicles
or divine
bodies,
the
first
participants
of their
correspondent
ouls,
are
no
other
than those
vehicles,
so
beautifully
described
by
Synesius."
(II,
435):
"Every
soul
possesses
an
eternal
body,
which is
the
first
participant
of
its
nature.
Hence
the
cause
of
every
particular
oul,
and
consequently
of its
vehicle,
is
immovable,
and on
this
account
super-mundane."
III
Blake's
adviceto a disciplewas: "Cultivate magination
o
the
point
of
vision."
His
wife
complained,
hat,
though
a
good
husband,
he was
too often
away
in
"eternity."
8
The
Poetical
Works
of
William
Blake,
ed.
by
John
Sampson,
London,
Oxford
Univ.
Press,
1913.
9 The
Prophetic
Writings
of
William
Blake,
ed.
by
D.
J.
Sloss
and
J.
P.
R.
Wallis,
Oxford,
1926.
1124
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 6/22
Frederick E.
Pierce
A similar attitude is found
in The
Commentaries
(I,
cxxviii):
"But
after the multitude belonging to souls, betake yourself to intellect, and the
intellectual
kingdoms,
that
you
may possess
the
unity
of
things.
There
remain
in
contemplation
of
a
nature ever
abiding
in
eternity,
of life
ever
flourishing,
intelligence
ever
vigilant,
to which no
perfection
of
being
is
wanting,
and which does not desire the chariot of
time,
for the
full
energy
of
its
essence."
Again
(II,
244):
"For
as he
who desires to know
in-
telligible essence,
then
only
perceives
what is above
sense,
when
he
possesses
no
image
of
a
sensible
object:
so he who desires to
contemplate
a
nature
superior
to
intelligible
essence,
will
enjoy
the ineffable
vision,
if
he
neglects everything intelligible,
while
merged
in
the most
profound
and
delightful
of all
contemplations." (II, 351,
note):
"So
that he
who
contracts the
difference, subsisting
in
things
which
are
many,
into
one
life
alone,
and
contemplates
an
unceasing
sameness of
energy,
never
passing
its
intelligence,
or
life,
from one
thing
into
another,
but
ever
abiding
in
the
same manner
in
itself,
far
remote
from all
distance; he,
I
say,
who
beholds
all
these,
contemplates
eternity, viewing
life
ever
possessing
a
present
whole,
where all
things
abide
together
in
sameness,
without the
order of first
and
last,
and
are
comprehended
in
an
indivisible
bond."
The
Cratylus, etc.,
1793
(p.
282):
"Eternity
is
nothing
else than
an
illumination
proceeding
from the
unity
connected
with
being."
IV
Blake
uses
the
word
"shadow"
repeatedly.
Numerous
examples
are
given
by
Sloss and
Wallis
(II,
222-225).
According
to
these
editors,
"The
symbol
is
used
in
reference to
matters
of
the
phenomenal
universe which
persist
because
they
are 'shadows' of the realities
in
the
spiritual
world."
InTaylor's
Commentaries
of
Proclus
wefind the
word used often
in
the
same
way (I,
xxviii):
"But we
cannot, by any
means,
attain to the
appre-
hension
of the
fifth,
unless
we have been first
accurately
conversant
with
the
rest;
for
from our
imperfect
condition we are
compelled
to rise from
difference to
identity,
from
multitude
to
unity,
and
from shadow to
substance."
(I, xxix):
"Because
we
speak
with
those,
who
are alone
con-
versant with
shadows,
and
are on this
account
derided
by
them,
when
they
find
that
our fifth
does
not, by any means,
accord
with material
resemblances,
which
they
consider as the
only
realities."
(I,
lxxxix):
"Since,
then,
there
is a
long
gradation
of
beings, proceeding
from
the first
being,
even to formless matter, which is nothing more than the dark shadow of
essence."
(I,
45, note):
"But
I
call
images
in
the
first
place,
shadows."
(II,
214):
"However,
though
the real
person
of
theology
was not
the
object
of
vulgar
inspection,
her shadow at
least was
beheld
by
the
be-
nighted
multitude,
and
became
the
subject
of
ridiculous
opinions,
and
idle
investigation."
(II, 227):
"It
is
one
thing
to
be modest
and another
to
be meek:
for
the
former is
the
shadow
attendant
on
genius."
1125
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 7/22
Blake
and
Thomas
Taylor
V
Blake's Preface to Milton:
"The Stolen and
Perverted
Writings
of
Homer
&
Ovid,
of
Plato
&
Cicero."
Taylor's
Commentaries
of
Proclus
(II,
216):
"We
are informed
by
Numenius,
the
Pythogorean,
that
Plato's suc-
cessors,
Speusippus,
Zenocrates,
and
Polemo, perverted
his
dogmata,
and
almost
entirely changed
the whole of his
philosophy."
VI
Blake
repeatedly
uses
"non-entity"
as
equivalent
to
delusion,
the
state of Ulro.
(See
Sloss and
Wallis, II,
239).
There is a
similar use
in The
Commentaries
of
Proclus.
(I, xxxi):
"On
the
former
system,
she is
on a
level
with the
most
degraded
natures,
the
receptacle
of
material
species,
and the
spectator
of
delusion and
non-
entity." (II, 348,
note):
"Body,
and
its
properties,
belong
to
the
region
of
non-entity."
(II, 349,
note):
"Whatever
becomes
corporeal
in
an
eminent
degree,
as
falling
fast into
non-entity,
has but
little
power
of
recalling
itself into one."
Cratylus, etc.,
1793
(p.
430):
"From
thence
they
verge
downwards
and extend to
perfect
non-entity,
or
the
last of
things-that is,
to
matter
itself."
VII
Blake's
"black water"
of Jerusalem
4.
10
is
explained
by
Professor
Damon'?
as
materialism-the
Sea of
Time and
Space.
But
how did
Blake
come
to
use that
peculiar
symbolism?
In
The
Commentaries
(II,
230)
occurs
the
phrase:
"By
which
we
may
safely
pass through
the
night
of
oblivion over the
dark
and
stormy
ocean of matter."
And
again
(II,
234):
"To shun the bitter stream of sanguine life." (II, 283): "The Stoics
assert that the sun
is
nourished
by
the exhalation
of
the
sea;
the moon
from
the effluvia
of fountains and
rivers;
but
the stars
from
the exhalation
of the earth ..... It is
necessary
therefore
that
souls,
whether
they
are
corporeal
or
incorporeal,
while
they
attract
bodies,
must
verge
to humid-
ity,
and be
incorporated
with
humid
natures, especially
such
souls,
as
from their
material
inclinations
ought
to
be united
with
blood,
and con-
fined
in
humid bodies as
in
a
watery
tegument."
(II,
294):
"Again,
according
to
Plato,
the
deep,
the
sea,
and a
tempest
are so
many
symbols
of the constitution of matter."
Eleusinian and Bacchic
Mysteries (p.
12):
"'The
Egyptians,'
says
Simplicius,
'called
matter,
which
they
symbolically
denominated
water,
the
dregs
or
sediment of the
first
life'."
The
Cratylus,
etc.,
1793
(p.
132):
"A
fish,
from its
residence
in
the
sea,
represents
a
life
merged
in
generation."
10
S.
F.
Damon,
William
Blake,
1924,
p.
435.
1126
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 8/22
Frederick E.
Pierce
1127
VIII
Blake's Jerusalem, 59, 26-48:
"And
one
Daughter
of
Los sat at
the
fiery Reel,
&
another
Sat at the
shining Loom,
with
her sisters
attending
round:
Terrible their
distress,
& their sorrow
cannot be
utter'd.
And another
Daughter
of Los sat at
the
Spinning
Wheel:
Endless their
labour,
with
bitter
food,
void of
sleep:
Tho'
hungry,
they
labour:
they
rouze
themselves, anxious,
Hour after hour
labouring
at the
whirling
Wheel ....
Other
Daughters
of
Los,
labouring
at Looms
less
fine,
Create the Silk-worm & the Spider & the Catterpillar
To
assist
in
their most
grievous
work of
pity
&
compassion.
And others
Create the
wooly
Lamb and
the
downy
Fowl."
Commentaries
of
Proclus
(II,
284):
"What
symbol
is more
proper
to souls
descending
into
generation,
and
the
tenacious
vestment
of
body,
than as the
poet says,
'Nymphs
weaving
on
stony
beams
purple
garments
wonderful
to
behold?' ....
The
purple
garments
plainly
appear
to
be the flesh with which we are
invested. ....
Thus
according
to
Orpheus, Proserpine,
who
presides
over
everything generated from seed, is represented weaving a web."
IX
In Blake's Jerusalem one
of the sons of
Albion
is named
Hyle.
Blake
may
have
got
this word from
Henry
More's
Psychozoia
of the seventeenth
century,
where
Hyle
is an
allegorical
character. But he
may
also
have
got
it
from
Taylor.
(Commentaries
of Proclus, II,
287,
note):
"But it
is
this
hyle
or matter which
composes
all
that
body
of the
world
which
we
everywhere
perceive
adorned with
impressions
of
forms."
Eleusinian and
Bacchic
Mysteries (23):
"Blessed thrice blessed
who,
with
winged
speed,
From
Hyle's
dread
voracious
barking
flies."
Sallust
(p. 124):
"The
raging uproar
lulls
Of
dire-resounding Hyle's
mighty
flood."
Sallust
(p.
136):
"And
lest
deep-merged
in
Hyle's
stormy
mire,
Her
powers
reluctant
suffer
tortures dire."
Sallust
(p.
155):
"And from Hyle's stormy main,
To her
father back
again,
To her
true immortal
goal
Lead
my
wand'ring,
weary
soul."
Sallust
(p. 157):
"Fraudful
Hyle
here
prepares
Me to
plunge
through magic
snares."
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 9/22
Blake
and Thomas
Taylor
x
Blake's Visions of the Daughtersof Albion, 89-94:
"Tell
me
where
dwell
the
thoughts
forgotten
till
thou call
them forth?
Tell me where dwell
the
joys
of
old,
&
where
the
ancient
loves,
And
when will
they
renew
again,
&
the
night
of
oblivion
past,
That
I
might
traverse times &
spaces
far
remote,
and
bring
Comforts into a
present
sorrow
and a
night
of
pain?
Where
goest thou,
O
thought?
to what
remote land
is
thy flight?"
Commentaries
of Proclus,
II,
230:
"The
mathematical
sciences are
indeed
the
proper
means of
acquiring
wisdom, but they ought never to be considered as its end. They are the
bridge
as it
were
between
sense
and
intellect
by
which we
may
safely
pass
through
the
night
of
oblivion over the
dark and
stormy
ocean of
matter,
to
the lucid
regions
of the
intelligible
world;
and he who
is desirous of
returning
to
his true
country
will
speedily pass
over
this
bridge,
without
making
any
needless
delays
in
his
passage."
(II,
276):
"The
mathematical
science; by
whose
assistance,
we first
recognize
the
glimmerings
of
truth,
and discover the
dawning
beams
of
intellect
emerging,
as it
were,
from the
night
of
oblivion."
XI
With the
main
thesis
of Blake's
Songs
of
Innocence and
Experience
compare
the
following
(Commentaries
of
Proclus, I,
ci):
"But
in
the
third
place,
being
elevated
to
supernal
natures,
and
judging
these to be
alone
true, they
affirm themselves to
be
ignorant
of
all
they formerly
imagined
themselves to
know;
in which
degree
Socrates
professed
to
find
himself,
when he
said,
this
one
thing
I
know,
that
I
know
nothing;
an
ignorance
preferable
to
all the
knowledge gained
by
the
most
unwearied
experimental enquiries."
XII
Blake
uses
"generation"
in
the Neo-Platonic sense
as
meaning
birth
into material
life,
putting
on
the
garment
of
flesh.
For
examples
see
Sloss
and
Wallis,
II,
162-163.
Similarly
the
Commentaries
of
Proclus
(I,
xci)
read:
"For
true
being,
according
to
the
Platonists,
is
without
generation,
because
it
has
an
infinite
power
of
being totally
present
at the
same
time:
and
body
is said
to be
generated,
because
it
always
possesses
in
itself
an
infinite
flowing
power,
which it cannot at once
totally
receive."
XIII
Blake's
Jerusalem,
38,
16-21:
"Mutual in
one
another's love and wrath
all
renewing,
We
live as
One
Man:
for,
contracting
our
infinite
senses,
We
behold
multitude; or, expanding,
we
behold
as
one,
1128
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 10/22
Frederick
E. Pierce
As
One Man all the
Universal
Family;
and that
One
Man
We call Jesus the Christ: and he in us and we in him
Live
in
perfect
harmony
in
Eden,
the land
of
life."
Commentaries
of
Proclus
(I,
x):
"Will it
not, therefore,
be
proper,
in the first
place,
to
enquire,
with
the
great
Plotinus,
whether
multitude is not a
departure
and
distance
from
one,
so that
infinity
itself
is a
separation
from
unity
in the
extreme,
because it
is
no other than innumerable
multitude;
that on this
account
it
becomes
evil;
and
that
we
contract a similar nature when
departing
from intellectual
unity,
we
are divided
by
sensible multitude."
XIV
Blake's
peculiar
use
of
the word
"Spectre"
to
represent
"the
reasoning
power"
with
its false
picture
of
life,
is
well
known.
Examples
can be
found
in
Sloss and Wallis
(II,
226-233).
The word occurs
in
a
sense
resembling
Blake's
in
The Commentaries
(I,
53):
"For the
conjectural
power
knows
the
spectres
of sensible
forms,
while
they
are beheld
in
water and
other
bodies,
which
perspicuously
represent
their
image."
XV
Blake repeatedly uses the figure of the "Wine-press," often with great
lack
of clearness. See Sloss
and
Wallis, II,
254-256.
At
times,
at
least,
he
may
have had in mind
the
following
passage
from
The
Eleusinian and Bacchic
Mysteries
(p.
144):
"The
pressing
of
grapes
is as evident
a
symbol
of
dispersion
as the
tearing
of
wool;
and
this circumstance was doubtless one
principal
reason
why
grapes
were
consecrated
to Bacchus:
for
a
grape,
previous
to its
pressure, aptly
repre-
sents that which
is collected
into
one;
and
when
it
is
pressed
into
juice,
it
no
less
aptly
represents
the
diffusion of that which
was
before
collected
and entire."
XVI
Repeatedly
in
Jerusalem Blake
speaks
of
the
starry
wheels of
Albion's
sons, meaning
apparently,
mistaken
systems
of
thought.
An
example
is Jerusalem
5,
3-5:
"Cambridge
&
Oxford
&
London
Are driven
among
the
starry
Wheels,
rent
away
and
dissipated
In
Chasms
&
Abysses
of Sorrow."
Compare
The
Eleusinian
and
Bacchic
Mysteries
(p.
142):
"In the first place, then, with respect to the wheel, since Dionysus,
as
we have
already
explained,
is the
mundane
intellect,
and
intellect is of
an
elevating
and
convertive
nature,
nothing
can
be
a
more
apt
symbol
of
intellectual
action than a wheel
or
sphere."
Also Sallust
(p.
34):
"But of the bodies
contained
in
the
world,
some
imitate
intellect,
and revolve
in
a
circle;
but
others
soul,
and are moved
in
a
right
line."
1129
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 11/22
1130
Blake and
Thomas
Taylor
XVII
The Four Zoas (end of Night V):
"The Woes of
Urizen,
shut
up
in
the
deep
dens of Urthona
....
I
will
arise, explore
these
dens,
and
find that
deep
pulsation
That shakes
my
caverns
with
strong
shudders:
perhaps
this
is the
night
Of
Prophecy,
and
Luvah
hath
burst
his
way
from Enitharmon."
Eleusinian
and
Bacchic
Mysteries (pp.
103-104):
"The reader
may
observe
how
Proserpina,
being represented
as
con-
fined in the dark recess
of a
prison
and
bound
with
fetters,
confirms
the
explanation of the fable here given as symbolical of the descent of the
soul ....
What emblem
can more
beautifully
represent
the evolutions
and
outgoings
of an intellectual
nature
into the
regions
of sense than
the
wanderings
of Ceres
by
the
light
of torches
through
the
darkness of
night,
and
continuing
the
pursuit
still she
proceeds
into the
depths
of Hades
itself?"
XVIII1
Visions
of
the
Daughters of
Albion-Argument:
"I
pluck6d
Leutha's
flower,
And I rose up from the vale;
But the
terrible
thunders
tore
My virgin
mantle
in
twain."
Eleusinian
and
Bacchic
Mysteries
(p.
99):
"Proserpina,
therefore,
or the
soul,
at the
very
instant
of her descent
into
matter,
is,
with
the
utmost
propriety,
represented
as
eagerly engaged
in
plucking
this fatal
flower;
for her faculties
at
this
period
are
entirely
occupied
with
a
life
divided about
the
fluctuating
condition
of
body.
After
this,
Pluto,
forcing
his
passage
through
the
earth,
seizes
on
Proserpina."
XIX
Blake
repeatedly
speaks
of the
union or reunion
of the
soul
with the
body
as
"death" and of
people
absorbed
in
material affairs
as
"dead."
Examples
may
be
found
in Sloss and
Wallis,
II,
147.
Eleusinian and
Bacchic
Mysteries
(p.
5):
"That
the
soul, indeed,
till
purified
by
philosophy,
suffers death
through
its
union
with the
body,
was
obvious
to the
philologist
Macrobius
....
The
death
of
the
soul
was
nothing
more
than
a
profound
union with
the
ruinous
bonds
of
the
body."
XX
Jerusalem
(33, 35-34,
11):
"Vala
replied
in
clouds
of
tears,
Albion's
garment
embracing:
'I was
a
City
&
a
Temple
built
by
Albion's
Children.
11
Pointed
out
by
Professor
Damon.
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 12/22
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 13/22
Blake
and Thomas
Taylor
being
laid
asleep,
as it
were,
were
only engaged
in
the delusions of
dreams'."
Blake,
as
the context shows felt
more
compassion
than
Ficinus
for
the
dreamers
of
dreams,
but was
equally
clear
that their
attitude was not
one for
a
noble
soul.
XXIII
The
symbolism
of
Urizen's book of brass
may
be clearer
in
the
light
of
the
following passage:
Cratylus, etc.,
1793
(p.
132):
"Brass,
from its
resisting
nature,
is
an
apt
emblem
of
body,
and con-
sequently
of the realms
of
generation,
in which
body
predominates."
XXIV
Blake's
pairing
off
of
male
and
female
symbolic
figures might
easily
have
received an
impetus
from
the
following
passage:
Cratylus, etc.,
1793
(p.
43,
note):
"It is
necessary
to
observe,
that
this
mutual communication of
energies
among
the
gods
was called
by
ancient
theologists
lpos
y7<los,
a
sacred
marriage;
concerning
which
Proclus .... remarks
as follows:
....
'Theologists at one time considered this communion of the
gods,
in
divinities co-ordinate with
each
other;
and then
they
called it
the
marriage
of
Jupiter
and
Juno,
of
Heaven and
Earth,
of Saturn
and
Rhea.
But at
another time
they
considered
it
as
subsisting
between subordinate
and
superior
divinities;
and
then
they
called it
the
marriage
of
Jupiter
and
Ceres. But at
another
time,
on
the
contrary,
they
beheld
it
as
subsisting
between
superior
and
subordinate
divinities;
and
then
they
called
it
the
marriage
of
Jupiter
and
Proserpine
....
It is
necessary
to understand
the
idiom
of
each,
and to transfer a
conjunction
of this
kind from the
gods, to the communion of ideas with each other'."
XXV
Blake's
character
Enion,
the venerable Earth
Mother,
whose
name
suggests
a
derivation from the Latin
Ens,
resembles the Neo-Platonic
conception
of
Vesta.
Cratylus, etc.,
1793
(p.
41,
note):
"The
goddess
Vesta has a
manifest
agreement
with
essence,
because
she
preserves
the
being
of
things
in
a state
of
purity,
and
contains
the
summits of the wholes from which the universe consists. For being is the
most ancient of
all
things,
after the first
cause,
who
is
truly
superessential;
and
Earth,
which
among
mundane divinities
is
Vesta,
is
said
by
Plato,
in
the
Timaeus,
to be the most ancient of all the
gods
in
heaven.....
Hence
every
thing
which is
stable,
immutable,
and
which
always
subsists
in
the same
manner,
descends to
all mundane
natures
from
this
super-
celestial
Vesta."
1132
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 14/22
Frederick
E.
Pierce
XXVI
Blake's hostile, or at least distrustful, attitude toward Nature might
easily
have
been
inspired
by Taylor's
Introduction to the Timaeus.
Cratylus,
etc.,
1793
(p.
375):
"With
respect
to the
term
nature,
which is
differently
defined
by
different
philosophers,
it is
necessary
to inform the
reader,
that Plato does
not consider either matter
or
material
form,
or
body,
or natural
powers,
as
worthy
to be
called
nature; though
nature has been thus denominated
by
others.
Nor does
he think
proper
to
call
it
soul;
but
establishing
its
essence between
soul and
corporeal powers,
he
considers it as inferior to
the former through its being divided about bodies, and its incapacity of
conversion
to
itself,
but
as
surpassing
the latter
through
its
containing
the
reasons
of all
things,
and
generating
and
vivifying
every part
of the
visible
world. For nature
verges
toward
bodies,
and
is
inseparable
from
their
fluctuating
empire."
XXVII
Taylor,
like
Blake,
uses the word
"abyss"
to
symbolize
matter
or
materialism:
Sallust (p. 128):
"Nor e'er
remember
in
the
dark
abyss
The
splendid
palace
of their
sire sublime."
XXVIII
Blake's
Book
of
Ahania
(Ch.
V):
"The
lamenting
voice
of
Ahania,
Weeping upon
the Void
And round the
Tree of
Fuzon,
Distant
in
solitary
night,
Her voice was heard, but no form
Had
she;
but her tears from
clouds
Eternal
fell
round
the
Tree.
And
the voice
cried:
'Ah
Urizen Love
Flower
of the
morning
I
weep
on
the
verge
Of
Nonentity -how
wide
the
Abyss
Between
Ahania and thee'
...."
Taylor's
Sallust
(pp.
165-166) (To Vesta):
"While
on
Hyle's stormy sea,
Wide I roam in search of thee,
Graciously
thine
arm
extend,
And
my
soul
from all
defend:....
And soon cut the fatal folds
Through
which
guileful
nature holds
Me
indignant
from
thy
sight
Exil'd
in
the realms
of
night,
1133
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 15/22
Blake
and
Thomas
Taylor
From
my
father's
bosom
torn,
Wand'ring weary and forlorn,
That
my
soul with
rapid
wing,
From
Oblivion's coast
may
spring,
May
once more
triumphant
gain
Truth's
immortal,
shining plain."
XXIX
In 1793
Blake
engraved
The
Visions
of
the
Daughters
of
Albion
and
named
the
villain of the
poem
Bromion.
In
the
same
year
Taylor
published
his
Sallust, etc., containing
the
line,
"Jove
all-seeing,
Bromius
strong."
The
epithet
Bromius
was,
of
course,
common in
Greek
mythology;
but
the
coincidence
in
dates
seems
worth
recording.
XXX
The
hint
of the
falls of Urizen
and
Los
may
be
found in
Taylor's
Sallust
(p.
159):
"Staggering
and
oppress'd
with
sleep,
Thro' dark
Hyle's stormy deep,
Headlong
borne with
forceful
sway,
And
unconscious
of
the
way,
Far
I
fell,
mid
dire
uproar,
Till I
touch'd
this
gloomy
shore.
But
my soul,
now
rous'd
by
thee,
And
enabled
truth
to
see,
Scorns
her
fetters,
and
aspires,
Borne on
wings
of
pure desires,
To
thy
meadows full of
light,
Fill'd
with
fountains of
delight.
Arbiter
of
mental
life,
Thro'
these realms of
endless
strife,
Thro' earth's dark
Tartarian
tomb,
May thy
light my steps illume;
And
disclose the
arduous
way
To
the coasts of mental
day."
XXXI
Blake's Jerusalem (31, 15-16):
"Till he
came to old
Stratford &
thence
to
Stepney
&
the
Isle
Of
Leutha's
Dogs."
Sallust
(p.
127,
note):
"For
evil
daemons,
as I
have shown
in
my
Dissertation
on
the
Mysteries,
appear
in
the
shape
of
dogs."
Sallust
(p.
157):
1134
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 16/22
Frederick E. Pierce
"Daemons from
my
life
expel,
That
in
matter's
darkness
dwell;
Noxious to the human
race,
Dogs
of
hell, terrific,
base."
XXXII
Blake's
general
attitude
in
telling
his obscure
philosophic myths
might
easily
have been
inspired
by Taylor.
Sallust
(p.
10):
"As
the
gods
impart
the
goods
of sensible natures
in
common
to
all
things, but the goods resulting from intelligibles to the wise alone, so
fables
assert
to all men that there
are
gods;
but
who
they
are,
and of
what
kind,
they
alone manifest to such
as are
capable
of
so
exalted
a
knowledge.
In fables
too,
the
energies
of the
gods
are
imitated;
for the
world
may
very
properly
be called a
fable,
since
bodies,
and the
corporeal
possessions
which it
contains,
are
apparent,
but
souls
and intellects are
occult and
invisible.
Besides,
to inform
all men of the
truth
concerning
the
gods,
produces
contempt
in
the
unwise,
from
their
incapacity
of
learning,
and
negligence
in
the
studious;
but
concealing
truth
in
fables,
prevents
the
contempt
of the
former,
and
compels
the latter
to
philosophize.
But
you
will ask
why
adulteries,
thefts,
paternal
bonds,
and
other
unworthy
actions
are celebrated
in
fables?
Nor
is
this
unworthy
of
admiration,
that where
there
is
an
apparent absurdity,
the soul
immediately
conceiving
these
discourses
to
be
concealments, may
understand
that
the
truth which
they
contain is to be involved
in
profound
and occult silence."
XXXIII
Sloss
and Wallis
(II,
194)
in
discussing
the sons of
Los,
say
that one
class
of them
were "never
generated,"
a
phrase
of
Blake's which
"eludes
interpretation."
But it
does
not
elude
interpretation
after
one
has
read
Taylor's
Sallust
(p.
5):
"The essences
of the
gods
are neither
generated;
for eternal
natures
are
without
generation;
and
those
beings
are eternal
who
possess
a first
power,
and
are
naturally
void
of
passivity."
XXXIV
Blake's
Jerusalem
(27,
35-36):
"Albion gave his deadly groan,
And
all
the Atlantic Mountains
shook."
Cratylus, etc.,
1793
(p.
399),
Introduction
to Timaeus:
"According
to the
saying
of
Heraclitus,
he
who
passes
through
a
very
profound region
will
arrive at the
Atlantic
mountain,
whose
magnitude
is
such,
according
to the
relation
of
the
Aethiopian
historians,
that
it
touches
the
aether,
and casts a shadow
of five
thousand
stadia
in
extent."
1135
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 17/22
Blake
and
Thomas
Taylor
XXXV
In Blake's Milton, p. 32 (and reproduced there in the Quaritch ed. of
1893)
is
a
diagram
by
Blake of a vast
egg.
It
contains the names of
Adam
and
Satan,
surrounded
by
the four
intersecting
circles of the Four
Zoas.
Apparently
it
is Blake's chart of that
mental universe
through
which
Milton took his course.
This
may
have been
suggested by
the
Cratylus
of
1793
(p.
286):
"Time
is
symbolically
placed
for
the one
principle
of
the
universe;
but aether
and
chaos,
for the two
posterior
to
this one: and
being,
simply
considered,
is
represented
under the
symbol
of an
egg."
And
five or six
pages later: "The egg itself is heaven: from the bursting of which into
two
parts,
the sections are said to
have become heaven and earth."
This chart
of
Blake's was his
drawing
of
what he called
"the
mundane
shell." The
phrase
was
probably
suggested
by Taylor's
work,
for,
though
its exact form does
not
appear
there,
the
adjective
"mundane" is con-
stantly
used
in
ways
that would
suggest
it. We
quote
a few
examples:
Cratylus,
etc.
(p. 56,
note):
"mundane
gods"-"mundane
natures"
(p. 61,
note):
"mundane subsistence"-"mundane
intellect"-"mundane
soul";
(p.
63,
note):
"mundane
establishment"-"mundane
concerns";
(p. 70, note): "mundane idiom"; (p. 372): "mundane animal."
(p.
372)
(Introduction
to
Timaeus):
"The
whole mundane animal too is connected
together,
according
to
the united
comprehension
which subsists
in
the
intelligible
world;
and
the
parts
which it
contains
are distributed so
as to harmonize with the
whole,
both such as are
corporeal
and such as are vital. For
partial
souls are
introduced into
its
spacious receptacle,
are
placed
about the
mundane
gods,
and become mundane
through
the luciform vehicles with which
they
are connected."
Sallust
(p. 133, note) speaks
of
"the mundane order."
Sallust
(p.
156):
"Of the mundane
gods
the
king."
Sallust
(p.
162):
"Thy power exempt
from mundane forms
we see."
XXXVI
The
following passage
from Blake's
Four
Zoas
(IX,
478-482)
may
be
simply
a bit of
idyllic
poetry:
"And
on
the
river's
margin
she
ungirded
her
golden girdle;
She stood
in
the river & view'd
herself
within
the
wat'ry
glass,
And
her
bright
hair was wet with the
waters.
She
rose
up
from
the
river,
And
as
she
rose,
her
Eyes
were
open'd
to the
world
of
waters:
She saw Tharmas
sitting
upon
the rocks beside the
wavy
Sea."
But if this
passage
has a
symbolic
meaning,
it
may
be
explained
by
the
following
excerpt
from The
Works
of
Plato
(II,
514):
"For,
as if
some one
standing
on the
margin
of
a river should behold
the
image
and form of
himself
in
the
floating stream,
he indeed
will
pre-
1136
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 18/22
Frederick
E.
Pierce
serve
his face
unchanged,
but the stream
being
all-variously
moved
will
change the image.
....
After
the same manner
the
soul, beholding
the
image
of
herself
in
body,
borne
along
in the river of
generation,
and
variously disposed
at different
times, through
inward
passions
and
ex-
ternal
impulses,
is
indeed herself
impassive,
but
thinks that
she
suffers,
and,
being
ignorant
of,
and
mistaking
her
image
for,
herself,
is
disturbed,
astonished,
and
perplexed."
XXVII
Blake's
Milton
(16,
21-26):
"The
Mundane
Shell
is a
vast Concave
Earth,
an immense
Harden'd shadow of all
things upon
our
Vegetated
Earth,
Enlarg'd
into dimension
&
deform'd
into
indefinite
space
In
Twenty-seven
Heavens
and
all
their
Hells,
with Chaos
And
Ancient
Night
&
Purgatory.
It is a cavernous
Earth
Of
labyrinthine intricacy, twenty-seven
folds
of
opakeness."
Blake's
Jerusalem
(75,
10):
"And these the names
of the
Twenty-seven
Heavens
&
their
Churches:"
Works
of
Plato
(II,
629):
"But
Timaeus,
in
what
he here
says,
converting
things
last to
such
as
are
first,
and the terminations of the soul to its summit establishes this
to be
octuple,
and
that
twenty-seventimes,
the
first." Also on the
pre-
ceding
page
Taylor
has
the
footnote:
"Let
it be
remembered
that the first
numbers
of
the
soul
are,
as
we have
observed
in
the
Introduction
to this
Dialogue,
1, 2, 3,
4,
9,
8,
27."
These
passages
are
part
of a discussion
on
the
mystic properties
of
numbers,
which
might
easily
have left
with Blake
the
impression
that
27
was
the
supreme
Platonic
number,
as
3
was the
supreme
number
of
the Trinitarians.
XXXVIII
Blake's Jerusalem
(98,
7-8):
"At the
clangor
of
the Arrows of Intellect
The innumerable
Chariots of
the
Almighty appear'd
in
Heaven."
Works
of
Plato'3
(II, 283):
"Intellect,
possessing
its life
in
eternity,
and
in
an essence
ever
in
energy,
and
fixing
all its
intelligence
collectively
in
itself,
is
perfectly
divine."
(II,
475,
note): "Intellect, therefore,
is
alone
unconquerable;
but
science and scientific
reasoning
are
vanquished
by intellect,
according
to the knowledge of being." (V, 523, note): "His [Apollo's] emission of
arrows is
the
symbol
of
his
destroying everything
inordinate,
wandering,
and immoderate
in
the
world."
13
Quotations
hroughout
his
essay
from The
Works
of
Plato
are
almost
wholly
from
Taylor's
vast
mass
of
editorial
matter,
not from the Platonic
dialogues
themselves.
1137
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 19/22
1138
Blake and Thomas
Taylor
XXXIX
Blake's Milton (23, 72):
"Time is the
mercy
of
Eternity."
Works
of
Plato
(II,
279):
"Time
is the
image
of
eternity."
XL
Blake's
Four Zoas
(IX,
616-619):
"The
feast
was
spread
in
the
bright
South,
&
the
Eternal
Man
Sat at the feast
rejoicing,
&
the wine
of
Eternity
Was serv'd round by the flames of Luvah all day & all the night.
And
many
Eternal Men sat
at the
golden
feast."
Works
of
Plato
(II, 578,
note):
"According
to the
theology
of
Plato,
there
is
not one
father
of
the
universe
only,
one
providence,
and
one divine
law,
but
many
fathers
subordinate
to
the one
first father."
XLI
With
the
wanderings
of
Blake's
Urizen
in The
Four
Zoas,
Night
VI
compare Worksof Plato (II, 506, note): "But the fourth and last genus is
that which
abundantly
wanders,
which descends
as
far
as to
Tartarus,
and is
again
excited
from
its dark
profundities,
evolving
all-various
forms
of
life,
employing
various
manners,
and at
different
times
different
passions.
It
also obtains various
forms
of
animals,
daemoniacal,
human,
irrational,
but
is
at
the same
time corrected
by
Justice,
returns from
earth
to
heaven,
and is
circularly
led
from matter
to
intellect,
according
to
certain
orderly
periods
of wholes."
XLII
For Blake's
use of the
symbolic
"veil
of
Vala"
see
Sloss
and
Wallis,
II,
251.
The
conception
may
have
been
suggested
by
such
passages
as the
following
in The
Works
of
Plato:
(I,
520),
"The
veil of
Minerva
is
an
emblem
of
that
one
life
or nature
of the
universe,
which the
goddess
weaves
by
those intellectual vital
powers
which she
contains."
(II,
487,
note):
"Hence
soul'4
is said ....
to extend
itself
to
the extremities
of
heaven,
as
vivifying
it on
all
sides;
and
to
invest
the
universe
as
with a
veil,
as
possessing powers
exempt
from divisible
bulk."
Cratylus, etc., 1793 (p. xvi):
"Men
who
are
ignorantly
called
men
of
learning....
who,
like
Homer's
mice,
impiously
nibble
the veil of
Wisdom,
and
would
willingly
destroy
the
work
of her
celestial
hands."
14
Remember
hat
"soul" is
used
here in
the Neo-Platonic
ense
as
something
inferior
o
intellect.
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 20/22
Frederick
E. Pierce
XLIII
Blake's Songs of Innocence ("Night")15:
"When
wolves and
tigers
howl
for
prey,
They pitying
stand
and
weep."
Works
of
Plato
(I,
501):
"Why
therefore should
you
wonder that
many according
to
life
are
wolves,
many
are
swine,
and
many
are invested
with
some other
form of
irrational animals?"
XLIV
Blake's
Jerusalem
(opening):
"Of the Sleep of Ulro and of the
passage through
Eternal Death and
of the
awaking
to
Eternal
Life."
Works
of
Plato
(I,
493):
"As
they
advance
however
in
perfection,
are
excited
from
body,
and
collect their
powers
from
matter,
they
become
more
prolific,
and
more
inventive of the
things
about
which
they
were before
unprolific
and
dubious,
through
the
sluggishness
and
privation
of life
proceeding
from
matter,
and
the
sleep
of
generation." (Invert
the order
of
one
of the
above
sentences,
and
you
find
both
running parallel
in
thought
throughout.)
Worksof Plato (II, 459):
"As this
introduction
and
the
following
translations
were the result
of
no moderate
labour
and
perseverance,
I
earnestly hope they
may
be
the
means
of
awakening
some
few at least
from
the
sleep of
oblivion."
XLV
Blake's
["To
Thomas
Butts"]'6:
"With
my
inward
eye,
'tis an old man
grey,
With
my
outward,
a Thistle across
my
way."
Works of P7lato I, 66, note):
"But
sometimes
one
herb,
or
one
stone,
is sufficient to
a
divine
opera-
tion.
Thus,
a thistle
is sufficient to
procure
the sudden
appearance
of
some
superior
power."
XLVI
Blake's Four
Zoas
(V,
164-165):
"Nor
all
the
power
of
Luvah's
Bulls,
Tho
they
each
morning
drag
the
unwilling
Sun out
of the
deep."
Works
of
Plato
(IV,
449,
note):
"But
they
say
that the moon
is drawn
by
two
bulls."
15
This
was
written
before
The
Works
of
Platowas even
planned.
But
the
like-
ness
may
represent
ome common
ource,
now
lost,
and so
help
to
interpret
Blake.
16
According
o
Sampson
(Poetical
Works
of
Wm.
Blake,
p.
187 of 1913
ed.),
this
was
writtensome
two
years
beforeTheWorks
of
Plato
appeared.
But there
s
the
possibility
of
personal
contact between Blake and
Taylor.
1139
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 21/22
Blake
and
Thomas
Taylor
XLVII
For Blake's use of the "polypus" see Sloss and Wallis, II, 207. In
The Works
of
Plato
(III,
478),
the editor translates
a
passage
from "The
Banquet"
as
follows:
"So that
every
one
of
us
at
present
is
but the
tally
of
a
human
creature;
which
has
been cut
like a
polypus,
and
out of
one
made
two."
Of
this
passage
the
editor
says
in
the footnote:
"Under this
difficulty
of
ascertaining
what
animal
is meant
by
the
/'TTrra
mentioned
here
by Plato,
we
have
translated
it
a
polypus,
because
the
wonderful
property
ascribed here
to the
,Vrlrra
s the same
with
that
in
the
polypus,
which a few
years
since
afforded
great
entertainment
to
the
virtuosi
in
many parts of Europe."
XLVIII
Blake's
Jerusalem
(99,
1-4):
"All
Human
Forms
identified,
even
Tree, Metal,
Earth,
&
Stone;
all
Human
Forms
identified, living, going
forth
&
returning-wearied
Into
the
Planetary
lives of
Years,
Months,
Days
&
Hours;
reposing,
And
then
Awaking
into his Bosom
in
the
Life
of
Immortality."
Works
of
Plato
(I, 64,
note):
"Hence we
may
behold
the sun
and
moon
in
the
earth,
but
according
to a terrene
quality;
but in the celestial
regions,
all
plants,
and
stones,
and
animals, possessing
an intellectual
life
according
to
a celestial
nature."
XLIX
Blake's
Jerusalem
(p.
77):
"Is the
Holy
Ghost
any
other than an
Intellectual
Fountain?"
Works
of
Plato
(I,
Ixxxiii):
"That vast
whole of
wholes,
in
which
all other
wholes are
centered
and
rooted,
and which is
no other
than
the
principle
of
all
principles,
and the fountain of deity itself."
L
Blake's
Songs of
Experience'7:
"Ah
Sunflower
weary
of
time,
Who countest
the
steps
of the
sun;
Seeking
after
the
sweet
golden
clime,
Where
the traveller's
journey
is
done."
Works
of
Plato
(I, 64,
note):
"Hence the
sun-flower,
as far
as it is
able,
moves
in
a
circular
dance
toward the
sun;
so
that,
if
any
one could
hear the
pulsation
made
by
its
circuit
in
the
air,
he
would
perceive
something
composed
by
a
sound
of
this
kind,
in
honour of
its
king,
such
as
a
plant
is
capable
of
framing."
17
The
Songs
of
Experience ppeared
en
years
before
The Works
of
Plato.
But
there
is
the
possibility
hat
Blake
knew
Taylor
personally,
and
got
ideas
from
him
long
before
they appeared
n
print.
1140
This content downloaded from 66.171.203.86 on Sun, 21 Sep 2014 20:19:25 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8/10/2019 Blake Taylor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blake-taylor 22/22
Frederick E. Pierce
LI
Blake's Jerusalem (p. 77):
"I
give
you
the end of
a
golden
string;
Only
wind it into a
ball,
It
will
lead
you
in at
Heaven's
gate,
Built
in
Jerusalem's
wall."
Works
of
Plato
(I,
lvix):
"Having
thus
taken
a
general
survey
of
the
great
world,
and descended
from
the
intelligible
to the sensible
universe,
let us
still, adhering
to
that
golden
chainl8 which is bound round the summit
of
Olympus,
and
from
which all things are suspended, descend to the microcosm man." Ibid.
(I,
lxxxvii):
"By
these
men
[Plotinus,
Porphyry, Iamblichus,
etc.],
who
were
truly
links
of the
golden
chain
of
deity,
all
that
is
sublime,
all
that
is
mystic
in
the doctrines
of Plato .... was freed from
its
obscurity
and
unfolded into
the most
pleasing
and admirable
light."
(If
Blake
had this
passage
in
mind
in
the above
stanza,
he would
be
referring
to himself
as
the last link
in
the
golden
chain of
Neo-Platonic thinkers. This
belief
is
strengthened
by
the
following
passage:
Works
of
Plato
(I,
xc):
"Por-
phyry
being
let down
to
men like a mercurial
chain,
through
his various
erudition,
unfolded
everything
into
perspicuity
and
purity."
Such
is
the evidence. It
probably
shows
that
Blake read these
particular
works of
Taylor. But,
more
important
than
that,
it
shows
that much
of
his
thought
was drawn
in
some
way
from
Neo-
Platonic sources
and
can
be
given
a
dignified
and
poetical
inter-
pretation
in
the
light
of
Neo-Platonic
teaching.
FREDERICK
E.
PIERCE
Yale
University
18
The
phrase
"golden
chain"
s
found
in
Homer
and
Milton,
but neitheruses
it
to
symbolize
a
continuous
ystem
of
thought.
Since Prof.
Lowes,
n his Road
o
Xanadu,
has shown
that
Coleridge
read
Taylor enthusiastically,
he
following
quotation
from
Coleridge's
rose may
be
in
point:
"From the
time
of Honorius
to
the
destruction
of
Constantinople
... there was
a continued
succession
of
individual
ntellects;
he
golden
chainwas
never
wholly
broken, hough
he
connect-
ing
linkswereoften of
baser
metal"
(The
Complete
Works
f
Samuel
Taylor
Coleridge,
ed.
by
Prof.
Shedd,
New
York, 1853,
IV, 30.)
1141