8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

1/35

FACILITIES SERVICES DIVISION-BUILTAND CHARTER SCHOOL-BUILT SCHOOLS

A PRESENTATION TO THE

LOS ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICTSCHOOL CONSTRUCTION BOND CITIZENSOVERSIGHT COMMITTEE

Thomas A. Rubin, BOC ConsultantOctober 20, 2010

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

2/35

Schools Compared

New High Schools placed into service in 2007,2008, and 2009Seven Charter High Schools, all Green Dot

(Animo) Data provided by California CharterSchools Association, from Green DotFive FSD-Built (all FSD-Built High Schoolsplaced into service in this period)

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

3/35

Green Dot Schools

Animo Locke TechAnimo Pat BrownAnimo Ralph Bunche

Animo South Los AngelesAnimo VeniceAnimo Watts (formerly known as Watts 2)Oscar De La Hoya Animo

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

4/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

5/35

FSD-Build Schools

Central Los Angeles Area New High School #9(450 North Grand)Edward R. Roybal Learning Center (1200 West

Colton Street)Felicitas and Gonzalo Mendez Learning Center(1200 Plaza del Sol)

Helen Bernstein High School (1309 NorthWilton Place)West Adams Preparatory School (1500 WestWashington Blvd)

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

6/35

Statistics

Charter FSD %Capacity (Seats) 4,116 10,071 245%Square Feet 314,875 1,147,112 364%

Cost $101.2M $889.8M 880%Square Feet/Student 77 114 149%Cost/Square Foot $321 $776 241%Cost/Unit of Capacity $24,580 $88,356 359%

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

7/35

Animo Locke Tech High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

8/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

9/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

10/35

Animo Pat Brown High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

11/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

12/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

13/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

14/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

15/35

Animo Ralph Bunche High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

16/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

17/35

Animo South Los Angeles High Schools

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

18/35

Animo Venice High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

19/35

Animo Watts High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

20/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

21/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

22/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

23/35

Oscar De La Hoya Animo High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

24/35

Central Los Angeles Area New HS #9

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

25/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

26/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

27/35

West Adams Preparatory High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

28/35

Helen Bernstein High School

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

29/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

30/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

31/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

32/35

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

33/35

C. Board Policy

i. Project Stabilization Agreement (See A.v.) ---ii. Joint Use/Extended (see A.vii.) ---iii. Design Consistent with the Community

and Public Art 1-3%iv. Small Learning Community/Small Schools 0-3%v. Enhanced Relocation Policy (see B.i.) ---vi. A-G Curriculum 0-3%vii. Enhanced Environmental Clearance (see A.x.) ---viii. Greenness and Building Friendliness 4-5%ix. Audit and Oversight (see A-.ix) ---

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

34/35

Summary

Direct comparisons are easy to do, but very difficultto do fairlyThe Charter Schools are simple, basic designs and

executions designed to produce workable schools,quickly, at a reasonable cost with minimal externalconstraintsFSD-Build Schools are larger, with more designfeatures, the products of detailed externalrequirements, massive public outreach, and thepolitical process to be more than just schools

8/8/2019 BOC Conventional and Charter Schools 10 20 10

35/35