boumedienne v bush

8/13/2019 Boumedienne v Bush

1/25

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

BOUMEDIENE ETAL. v. BUSH, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES,et al.

CERTIORARITOTHEUNITEDSTATESCOURTOFAPPEALSFORTHEDISTRICT

OFCOLUMBIACIRCUIT

Argued December , !""#$Dec%ded &u'e (!, !"")*N+. "-((.*I' t/e Aut/+r%0at%+' 1+r U2e +1 M%l%tar3 F+rce 4AUMF5, C+'gre22 em6+7eredt/e Pre2%de't 8t+ u2e all 'ece22ar3 a'd a66r+6r%ate 1+rce aga%'2t t/+2e 9 /edeterm%'e2 6la''ed, aut/+r%0ed, c+mm%tted, +r a%ded t/e terr+r%2t attac:2 9 +'Se6tember ((, !""(.; I'Hamdi


2/25

!. Pet%t%+'er2 /a


3/25

c+'tra2t t+ %t2 2%g'%1%ca't d%2cu22%+' +1 6ract%cal barr%er2 t+ t/e ru''%'g +1 t/e7r%tG a'd 4K5 %1 t/e >+


4/25

acc+mm+dat%'g t/e 'ece22%t3 1+r 1act1%'d%'g t/at 7%ll ar%2e %' 2+me ca2e2 b3all+7%'g t/e a66ellate @udge +r &u2t%ce t+ tra'21er t/e ca2e t+ a d%2tr%ct c+urt.See !!=(4b5. H+7e


5/25

+6%'%+', %' 7/%c/ >INSBUR>a'd BREER, &&., @+%'ed. ROBERTS, C. &., 1%led ad%22e't%'g +6%'%+', %' 7/%c/ SCALIA, THOMAS,a'd ALITO, &&., @+%'ed. SCALIA,&., 1%led a d%22e't%'g +6%'%+', %' 7/%c/ ROBERTS, C. &., a'd THOMASa'd ALITO,&&., @+%'ed.

N%&e!

** T+get/er 7%t/ N+. "-((, Al Oda/, Net Fr%e'd +1 Al Oda/, et al. INSBUR>"#d &USTICEBREER%(#,+%#+rr(#-.

I @+%' t/e C+urt2 +6%'%+' %' %t2 e't%ret3 a'd add t/%2a1ter7+rd +'l3 t+ em6/a2%0e t7+ t/%'g2 +'e m%g/t +ua'ta'am+ Ba3, 8t+ determ%'e t/e legal%t3 +1 t/eEecut%


6/25


7/25

T/e 6+l%t%cal bra'c/e2 created a t7+J6art, c+llateral re


8/25

4u+t%'g Burton


9/25

reu%reme't2 %de't%1%ed b3 t/e 6lural%t3 %'Hamdi,; ante, at K, t/e C+urt6r+ceed2 t+ d%2m%22 t/e tr%bu'al 6r+ceed%'g2 a2 '+ m+re t/a' a 2u26ect met/+du2ed b3 t/e Eecut%+


10/25

1r+m a /abea2 c+urt u'der !!=(."d., at !, K=. T/at 6r+ce22 c+'2%2ted +1 t/er%g/t t+ 8rece%++


11/25

re (amashita, K!# U. S. (, ) 4(=5 48T/e c+urt2 ma3 %'u%re 7/et/er t/edete't%+' c+m6la%'ed +1 %2 7%t/%' t/e aut/+r%t3 +1 t/+2e deta%'%'g t/e 6et%t%+'er.I1 t/e m%l%tar3 tr%bu'al2 /a


12/25

A2 t+ cla22%1%ed %'1+rmat%+', 7/%le deta%'ee2 are '+t 6erm%tted acce22 t+ %tt/em2el


13/25

c+me t+ 6a22 a2 '+ re


14/25

T/e S+l%c%t+r >e'eral c+'cede2 t/at remed%al aut/+r%t3 +1 2+me 2+rt mu2t be%m6l%ed %' t/e 2tatute, g%


15/25

d+'e, e'd u6 l++:%'g a great deal l%:e t/e DTA re


16/25

T/e C+urt 7+'der2 7/at m%g/t /a66e' %1 t/e deta%'ee 6ut2 1+r7ard 'e7mater%al e


17/25

2u%c%de b+mb%'g aga%'2t Ira% 2+ld%er2 %' M+2ul, Ira. See /%te, EJ>ua'ta'am+ Deta%'ee &+%'ed Ira Su%c%de Attac:, a2/%'gt+' P+2t, Ma3 ),!""), 6. A().

T/e2e, m%'d 3+u, 7ere deta%'ee2 7/+m the militar! /ad c+'cluded 7ere '+te'em3 c+mbata't2. T/e%r retur' t+ t/e :%ll %llu2trate2 t/e %'cred%ble d%11%cult3 +1a22e22%'g 7/+ %2 a'd 7/+ %2 '+t a' e'em3 c+mbata't %' a 1+re%g' t/eater +1+6erat%+'2 7/ere t/e e'


18/25

c+urt +1 la7 +6erat%'g u'der a 7r%tte' C+'2t%tut%+', +ur r+le %2 t+ determ%'e7/et/er t/ere %2 a c+'1l%ct bet7ee' t/at Clau2e a'd t/e M%l%tar3 C+mm%22%+'2Act. A c+'1l%ct ar%2e2 +'l3 %1 t/e Su26e'2%+' Clau2e 6re2ererma'3. T/e3 /ad bee' ca6tured %' C/%'a, a'd a'

Amer%ca' m%l%tar3 c+mm%22%+' 2%tt%'g t/ere /ad c+'erma'32 2urre'der."d., at #-#.

L%:e t/e 6et%t%+'er2 /ere, t/e >erma'2 cla%med t/at t/e%r dete't%+'2


19/25

@ur%2d%ct%+'. N+t/%'g %' t/e tet +1 t/e C+'2t%tut%+' ete'd2 2uc/ a r%g/t, '+rd+e2 a'3t/%'g %' +ur 2tatute2.;"d., at #).

&u2t%ce &ac:2+' t/e' elab+rated +' t/e /%2t+r%cal 2c+6e +1 t/e 7r%t

8T/e al%e', t+ 7/+m t/e U'%ted State2 /a2 bee' trad%t%+'all3 /+26%table, /a2

bee' acc+rded a ge'er+u2 a'd a2ce'd%'g 2cale +1 r%g/t2 a2 /e %'crea2e2 /%2%de't%t3 7%t/ +ur 2+c%et39 .

8But, %' ete'd%'g c+'2t%tut%+'al 6r+tect%+'2 be3+'d t/e c%t%0e'r3, t/e C+urt/a2 bee' at 6a%'2 t+ 6+%'t +ut t/at %t 7a2 t/e al%e'2 6re2e'ce 7%t/%' %t2terr%t+r%al @ur%2d%ct%+' t/at ga


20/25

T/e C+urt al2+ rea2+'2 t/atEisentragermu2t be read a2 a 81u'ct%+'al;+6%'%+' becau2e +1 +ur 6r%+r dec%2%+'2 %' t/e I'2ular Ca2e2. See ante, at !-!.It c%te2 +ur 2tateme't %' Bal+a#


21/25

7ar cr%me2 are 7%t/+ut @ud%c%al remed3, all e'em3 c+mbata't2 deta%'ed dur%'ga 7ar, at lea2t %'2+1ar a2 t/e3 are c+'1%'ed %' a' area a7a3 1r+m t/e battle1%eld+


22/25

It %2 e't%rel3 clear t/at, at E'gl%2/ c+mm+' la7, t/e 7r%t +1 /abea2 c+r6u2 d%d'+t ete'd be3+'d t/e 2+


23/25

Sc+tla'd a'd +t/er 81+re%g' d+m%'%+'2.; Co%le,supra, at ), # E'g. Re6., at-"". T/e 7r%t d%d '+t ru' t+ Sc+tla'd becau2e, e


24/25

&ac:2+'2 +6%'%+' 1+r t/e C+urt %' Johnson


25/25

deta%'ee2 2tatu2 a2 a 2ub@ect 7a2 mater%al t+ t/e re2+lut%+' +1 t/e ca2e,; =!U. S., at "=.

7T/e C+urt al2+ argue2 t/at t/e 1act t/at t/e 7r%t c+uld ru' t+ Irela'd, e

boumedienne v bush

Documents