bristol city council jon wellington, mark weston, lucy ... · paula o'rourke, steve pearce,...

Bristol City CouncilMinutes of the Full Council

19 March 2019 at 6.00 pm

Members Present:-Councillors: Mayor Marvin Rees, Peter Abraham, Donald Alexander, Lesley Alexander, Nicola Beech, Nicola Bowden-Jones, Harriet Bradley, Mark Brain, Charlie Bolton, Tom Brook, Fabian Breckels, Tony Carey, Barry Clark, Jos Clark, Stephen Clarke, Harriet Clough, Eleanor Combley, Asher Craig, Chris Davies, Carla Denyer, Kye Dudd, Richard Eddy, Jude English, Martin Fodor, Helen Godwin, Geoff Gollop, John Goulandris, Fi Hance, Margaret Hickman, Claire Hiscott, Helen Holland, Gary Hopkins, Chris Jackson, Hibaq Jama, Carole Johnson, Steve Jones, Anna Keen, Tim Kent, Gill Kirk, Cleo Lake, Mike Langley, Jeff Lovell, Brenda Massey, Olly Mead, Matt Melias, Graham Morris, Anthony Negus, Paula O'Rourke, Steve Pearce, Celia Phipps, Ruth Pickersgill, Kevin Quartley, Liz Radford, Jo Sergeant, Afzal Shah, Steve Smith, Paul Smith, Clive Stevens, Jerome Thomas, Mhairi Threlfall, Estella Tincknell, Jon Wellington, Mark Weston, Lucy Whittle and Mark Wright

Aldermen in Attendance:-Royston Griffey, John McLaren, Aurthur Massey, Christopher Orlik, Brian Price, Stephen Williams, Rosalie Walker.

1. Welcome, Introductions and Safety Information

The Lord Mayor welcomed all attendees to the meeting, and made a safety announcement in relation to the fire/emergency evacuation procedure.

2. Apologies for Absence

Apologies were received from Councillors Bradshaw, Khan, Mike Davies and Windows.

3. Minutes of the Previous Meeting

On the motion of the Lord Mayor, seconded by Councillor Hance, it was

RESOLVED: That the minutes of the meeting of the Full Council held on the 26 February 2019 be confirmed as correct record and signed by the Lord Mayor.

Public Document Pack

[email protected]

4. Declarations of Interest

The following interests were declared with reference to item 11, Motion 2: Councillor Sergeant – spouse is an employee of the Brunel Pension Partnership. Councillor Langley – a retired employee of FirstBus Councillor Kent highlighted that a number of Councillors were members of the Avon Pension Fund

either as former officers or as Councillors.

5. Lord Mayor's Business

A multi faith event would take place at the Lord Mayors Chapel on Thursday 4th April at 7pm to which all were welcome to attend. There would be a discussion about conflict resolution.

The Lord Mayor reported that she had been impressed by the enthusiasm of all the children she had met on her schools tour of South Bristol. She was particularly supportive of Reading Recovery.

The Chamber then held a minutes silence as a mark of respect for the atrocities Christchurch, New Zealand had suffered at the hands of a terrorist attack, and also for Bristol’s Twin City of Beira in Mozambique which had been hugely affected by Cyclone Idai.

6. Public Forum (Public Petitions, Statements and Questions)

Public petitions: There were two public petitions received.

Name TitlePP01 David Beesley Introduce a Residents Parking Zone in Cheswick Village

– 161 signaturesPP02 Dr Victoria Stanford and Dr

Ellen WoodCall on Mayor Marvin Rees to clean up Bristol's unhealthy air – 70 signatures

Public statements:The Full Council received and noted the following statements (which were also referred to the Mayor for his consideration/information):

Ref No Name TitlePS01 Oliver Fortune Inclusivity, or rather a lack of itPS02 David Redgewell Light Rail around Bristol and BathPS03 Christopher Harris Unfinished building on Devonshire Rd, Westbury.PS04 Sue Archard Stoke Lodge Field

[email protected]

PS05 Lorna Crook Stoke Lodge Playing FieldPS06 John Hollyman Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS07 Sharon Parsons Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS08 John Henn Cotham School should have a duty of care to the

community.PS09 Robert Walters Stoke Lodge ParklandPS10 Keith Sheather Stoke Lodge Fence

PS11 Emma Hambert Stoke Lodge Fence

PS12 Stephanie Chadwick Petition in support of free access to Stoke Lodge FieldsPS13 R John Hall & Jill Mackley

Hall Fencing on Stoke Lodge open space

PS14 Ken Wilkinson Stoke Lodge FieldsPS15 Chris and Jane Thomas Stoke Lodge ParklandPS16 Patricia Thompson Stoke Lodge Playing Fields PetitionPS17 Amanda MacDonald Stoke Lodge playing fieldsPS18 Neil Redman Stoke Lodge Playing Fields PetitionPS19 Russell Wickens fencing at Stoke LodgePS20 P E Lemon Stoke Lodge fencePS21 Graham Donald A4018PS22 Allister Simpson Stoke Lodge Playing Fields PetitionPS23 Alan W Preece Stoke Lodge fencePS24 David Redgewell A4018 and Muller Road proposalsPS25 Alan Thompson Sense not Fence PetitionPS26 Susan J. Mayer Petition concerning Stoke Lodge Fencing IssuesPS27 Sheila Preece Stoke Lodge playing fieldsPS28 Ken Young Stoke Lodge playing fieldsPS29 Julie Wright Stoke Lodge playing fieldsPS30 Jonathan M M Johnson Sense not Fence Petition PS31 Helen Powell Sense not Fence PetitionPS32 Gill Cleverdon Stoke Lodge Playing Fields

PS33 Paul K Hayward Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS34 Vivien Johnson Stoke Lodge Playing Fields

PS35 Anni Davey STOKE LODGE PARKLANDPS36 JA Hayward Stoke Lodge playing fieldPS37 David Mayer Sense not Fence PetitionPS38 Nikki Jones In support of Motion 2 on divestment

PS39 Penelope Frances Dove Stoke Lodge petitionPS40 Tessa Garton Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS41 Brian Garton Sense not Fence petitionPS42 Andrew Varney Bristol Cycling Forum

[email protected]

PS43 David Main Fence at Stoke Lodge

PS44 Rita Doreen Thomas Sense not Fence Petition

PS45 Helen Hollick A4018

PS46 Andrew Barnes Stoke Lodge Playing Fields

PS47 Katie Fudge Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS48 Martin and Mariette

FarrellStoke Lodge Parkland

PS49 Richard Marshall Stoke LodgePS50 Guy Nason We Love Stoke Lodge petition PS51 Mark & Joanne Evans Stoke Lodge Playing Field

PS52 Ian Witherden petition regarding Stoke LodgePS53 Kathy Welham Sense not Fence PetitionPS54 Beki Trimble Stoke LodgePS55 Philippa A Nason Stoke Lodge PS56 Sally Causton Stoke Lodge grounds

PS57 Ewen MacLeod Stoke Lodge ParkPS58 JACKIE HAWKEN A4018PS59 Chris Prior Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS60 Ivete Hunt Stoke Lodge Playing Fields

PS61 Mike Whitworth Stoke Lodge Playing FieldPS62 Reg Hunt Stoke Lodge Playing FieldsPS63 Judith Brant Stoke Lodge Playing Fields

PS64 Reginald K. Davey STOKE LODGE PARKLAND

PS65 Paul Spellward Stoke Lodge Playing Fields

PS66 Jayne Youngs Stoke LodgePS67 Martin Bennett Stoke LodgePS68 Graham Wright Stoke Lodge

PS69 Judith Young Stoke Lodge

PS70 David Faulkner Stoke LodgePS71 Martin Garrett Bus Franchising

PS72 Andrew Brown Bus Franchising PS73 Catherine Barnes Stoke LodgePS74 Rachel Austin Stoke Lodge

[email protected]

PS75 Helen Faulkner Stoke LodgePS76 Tony Jones Avon Pension Fund - Disinvestment and DiversificationPS77 Margaret & Andrew

HilesStoke Lodge

PS78 Nigel Muntz Stoke LodgePS79 Chris Anderson Stoke LodgePS80 Simon & Della Hooper Stoke LodgePS81 Max Langer Bus FranchisingPS82 Charles Elderton Stoke LodgePS83 Carol Andrews- Wrong

Road GroupRing Road

PS84 Michael Sheehan Stoke LodgePS85 Larissa and Robert

WiltonStoke Lodge

PS86 We Love Stoke Lodge Stoke LodgePS87 Rowan Ruggles Stoke LodgePS88 Michael Waddington Stoke LodgePS89 Shirley Brown Stoke LodgePS90 Christine Aston A4018PS91 Geoff Causton Stoke LodgePS92 Emma Burgess Stoke LodgePS93 Peter and Rosemary

WrightStoke Lodge

PS94 Kevin Tozer Stoke LodgePS95 Vivien Gellett Stoke Lodge

Within the time available, statements were presented by individuals present at the meeting. The Lord Mayor selected a variety of topics and nominated representatives from those who submitted statements about Stoke Lodge Playing Fields. These were PS01, PS02, PS23, PS24, PS26, PS42, PS76, PS71,

Public Questions:The Full Council noted that the following questions had been submitted:

Ref No Name TitlePQ01 Dr Victoria Stanford and Dr

Ellen WoodAir Quality

PQ02 Judith Brown Air QualityPQ03 & PQ04

Oliver Fortune Inclusivity, or rather a lack of it & New Community Hub, Knowle

PQ05 Alan Taylor Elmlea Avenue/ Rylestone GrovePQ06 Barry Cash Waitrose and Partners GrantPQ07 & PQ08

Bristol Tree Forum Protection of TPO and Conservation Area trees & Tree Canopy Cover

PQ09 Nicholas Coombes Meads Reach cycle bridgePQ10 Nicholas Coombes St Georges Park

[email protected]

PQ11 & PQ12

Christine Townsend Secondary School preferences/offers

PQ13 Graham Donald A4018 Road ProposalsPQ14 & PQ15

Ruth Campbell Education and Bristol Schools

PQ16 & PQ17

Cumberland Basin Stakeholder Group

Western Harbour Development Area

PQ18 Christopher Harris A4018 Road ProposalsPQ19 Jonathan Hucker Western Drive Business ParkPQ20 James Cox Care for Homeless PeoplePQ21 Tracy Sockett The Hengrove MoundsPQ22 Alex Morss (OneByOne

Bristol)Single Use Plastic Petition

PQ23 Helen Powell Stoke Lodge Playing Fields – Equalities ImpactPQ24 Helen Powell Stoke Lodge Playing Fields – Public Rights of WayPQ25 Michael Knight Hengrove ParkPQ26 Andy Nairn Elmlea Avenue and Rylestone Grove

Within the time available, the Mayor responded verbally to questions PQ01, PQ03, PQ04, PQ06, PQ11, PQ12 and PQ13 and PQ25 also responding to supplementary questions.

7. Petitions Notified by Councillors

There were none.

8. Senior Executive Remuneration Review - Audit for the year ended 31st March 2018

The Full Council agreed to suspend standing orders relating to the presentation of items and CPR10.3a which related to the altered deadline for questions pertaining to the item.

An officer from BDO presented the external auditors report in relation to the review of the senior executive remuneration, including references to points of clarification raised in writing prior to the meeting.

Public StatementsThe Full Council noted the following statements submitted by members of the public:

Ref No NamePS01 Graham Donald

Public Questions: The Full Council noted the following questions submitted by members of the public. Answers had been provided in writing prior to the meeting and verbal supplementary questions invited of each:

[email protected]

NamePQ001 Graham DonaldPQ01 & PQ02 Mary PagePQ03 & PQ04 Barry Cash

Councillor Statements:The Full Council noted the following statements submitted by Councillors:

Ref No NameCS01 Cllr Gary HopkinsCS02 Cllr Richard EddyCS03 Cllr Anthony NegusCS04 Cllr Paula O’Rourke

Councillor Questions:The Full Council noted the following questions submitted by Councillors. Answers had been provided in writing prior to the meeting and verbal supplementary questions invited. Supplementary questions were asked by Councillors Clark, Hopkins, Don Alexander, Hance, O’Rourke, Gollop and Eddy.

NamePQ05 & PQ06 Councillor CloughPQ07 Councillor DaviesPQ08 & PQ09 Councillor Jos ClarkPQ10 & PQ11 Councillor HopkinsPQ12 & PQ13 Councillor KentPQ14 & PQ15 Councillor NegusPQ16 & PQ17 Councillor WrightPQ18 Councillor Don AlexanderPQ19 Councillor BreckelsPQ20 & PQ21 Councillor HickmanPQ22 & PQ23 Councillor HancePQ24 & PQ25 Councillor O’RourkePQ26 & PQ27 Councillor ThomasPQ28 & PQ29 Councillor GollopPQ30 & PQ31 Councillor EddyPQ32 & PQ33 Councillor GoulandrisPQ34 & PQ35 Councillor JonesPQ36 & PQ37 Councillor RadfordPQ38 & PQ39 Councillor Weston

[email protected]

A debate followed during which an amendment to recommendation three was moved by Councillor Eddy and seconded by Councillor Weston.

Amended Recommendation (iii) to read:- (iii) that Full Council requests that the Head of Paid Service provides a written update to be debated at the next Ordinary Meeting of Full Council after Annual Council having first been considered by the Council’s Audit and HR Committees with their input provided as part of the written update.

Upon being put to the vote, the amendment was CARRIED(32 voting FOR, 32 voting AGAINST, Lord Mayor casting vote FOR)

Following the debate, the three substantive recommendations were then put to the vote and it was RESOLVED:

i) That Full Council accepts the recommendations from the Council’s external auditors, BDO;(64 voting FOR, 0 AGAINST)

ii) that Full Council approves the action plan in response to the recommendations from the Council’s external auditors, BDO; (45 voting FOR, 16 AGAINST, 3 ABSTAIN)

(iii) that Full Council requests that the Head of Paid Service provide a written update to be debated at the next Ordinary Meeting of Full Council after Annual Council having first been considered by the Council’s Audit and HR Committees with their input provided as part of the written update.(34 voting FOR, 30 AGAINST)

An adjournment for 20 minutes then followed.

9. Pay Policy Statement 2019-20

Following the adjournment, it was moved by the Lord Mayor that standing orders be suspended(i) CPR9.1 to allow the meeting to go past the 2 hrs 30 time limit until 10pm. (ii) CPR9.2 that the motions on the agenda that would be deferred, to be carried over to the next

ordinary meeting.

The motion was seconded and upon putting to a vote, it was AGREED.

The Full Council considered a report which proposed adoption of the Pay Policy Statement for the year 2019/20.

Councillor Wellington moved the report and the recommendations contained therein. Councillor O’Rourke seconded the report.

[email protected]

During debate, it was proposed by Councillor Gollop and seconded by Councillor Eddy (with reference to CPR9.4) that the report be withdrawn. When put to the vote the motion was LOST.

Following debate, it was:

RESOLVED:That the Pay Policy Statement for 2019/20 be adopted.

10. Making of Hengrove and Whitchurch Park Neighbourhood Development Plan

The Full Council considered a report which noted the outcome of the referendum on the Hengrove and Whitchurch Park Neighbourhood Development Plan held on 14th February 2019.

The Mayor moved the report and it was seconded by Councillor Kent.

Following debate it was;

RESOLVED: 1. That Council noted the outcome of the referendum on the Hengrove and Whitchurch Park Neighbourhood Development Plan held on 14th February 2019.2. That Council noted that the Hengrove and Whitchurch Park Neighbourhood Development Plan now forms part of the statutory development plan for Bristol.3. That the Council approved the Hengrove and Whitchurch Park Neighbourhood Development Plan.

11. Report of change to Licensing Committee membership/chair

The Full Council considered the appointment of Councillor Goggin and Hickman to the Licensing Committee.

The Lord Mayor moved the report and the Deputy Lord Mayor seconded the report.

There was no further debate it was:

RESOLVED that Councillors Goggin and Hickman be appointed to the Licensing Committee.

12. Motions

This item fell due to lack of time. It was agreed that the golden and silver motion would be deferred to the agenda of the next ordinary meeting.

[email protected]

Meeting ended at 9.55 pm

CHAIR __________________

Meeting Title: Meeting of the Full Council 19th March 2019

1/14

Item 12 - vote iii) as amended33 For 32 Against – Casting Vote (Lord Mayor) For

Wright Mark Liberal Democrat ForKent Tim Liberal Democrat ForDavies Chris Liberal Democrat ForKent Tim Liberal Democrat ForHopkins Gary Liberal Democrat ForNegus Anthony Liberal Democrat ForClark Jos Liberal Democrat ForClough Harriet Liberal Democrat ForLangley Mike Labour AgainstHolland Helen Labour AgainstGodwin Helen Labour AgainstJohnson Carole Labour AgainstBradley Harriet Labour AgainstAlexander Donald Labour AgainstCraig Asher Labour AgainstHickman Margaret Labour AgainstBeech Nicola Labour AgainstMassey Brenda Labour AgainstThrelfal Mhairi Labour AgainstBowden-Jones Nicola Labour AgainstShah Afzal Labour AgainstKirk Gill Labour AgainstWhittle Lucy Labour AgainstMead Olly Labour AgainstLovell Jeff Labour AgainstSmith Paul Labour AgainstTincknell Estella Labour AgainstPhipps Celia Labour AgainstPickersgill Ruth Labour AgainstWellington Jon Labour AgainstDudd Kye Labour AgainstBrain Mark Labour ForPearce Steve Labour AgainstKeen Anna Labour AgainstBrook Tom Labour AgainstBreckels Fabian Labour AgainstJama Hibaq Labour AgainstSergeant Jo Labour AgainstRees Marvin Labour AgainstClark Barry Labour AgainstJackson Christopher Labour AgainstEnglish Jude Green ForStevens Clive Green ForThomas Jerome Green ForDenyer Carla Green ForFodor Martin Green ForCombley Eleanor Green ForHance Fi Green ForBolton Charles Green For

Minute Item 332


2/14

O'Rourke Paula Green ForClarke Stephen Green ForWeston Mark Conservative ForQuartley Kevin Conservative ForCarey Tony Conservative ForMorris Graham Conservative ForAbraham Peter Conservative ForRadford Liz Conservative ForHiscott Claire Conservative ForMelias Matt Conservative ForSmith Steve Conservative ForEddy Richard Conservative ForAlexander Lesley Conservative ForGollop Geoff Conservative ForJones Steve Conservative ForGoulandris John Conservative ForLake Cleo Green For (casting vote)Bradshaw Mark LabourKhan Sultan LabourDavies Mike LabourCheney Craig LabourGoggin Paul LabourWindows Chris Conservative

Item 12 - Vote i)64 For 0 Abstain 0 Against

Clough Harriet Labour ForClark Jos Labour ForNegus Anthony Labour ForHopkins Gary Labour ForDavies Chris Labour ForKent Tim Labour ForWright Mark Labour ForJackson Christopher Labour ForClark Barry Labour ForRees Marvin Labour ForSergeant Jo Labour ForJama Hibaq Labour ForBreckels Fabian Labour ForBrook Tom Labour ForKeen Anna Labour ForPearce Steve Labour ForBrain Mark Labour ForDudd Kye Labour ForWellington Jon Labour ForPickersgill Ruth Labour ForPhipps Celia Labou

rFor

Tincknell Estella Labour

ForSmtih Paul Labou

rFor

Lovell Jeff Labour

For


3/14

Mead Olly Labour

ForWhittle Lucy Labour ForKirk Gill Labour ForShah Afzal Labour ForBowden-Jones Nicola Labour ForThrelfal Mhairi Labour ForMassey Brenda Labour ForBeech Nicola Labour ForHickman Margaret Labour ForCraig Asher Labour ForAlexander Donald Labour ForBradley Harriet Labour ForJohnson Carole Labour ForGodwin Helen Labour ForHolland Helen Labour ForLangley Mike Labour ForClarke Stephen Green ForO'Rourke Paula Green ForBolton Charles Green ForHance Fi Green ForCombley Eleanor Green ForFodor Martin Green ForDenyer Carla Green ForThomas Jerome Green ForStevens Clive Green ForEnglish Jude Green ForGoulandris John Conservative ForJones Steve Conservative ForGollop Geoff Conservative ForAlexander Lesley Conservative ForEddy Richard Conservative ForSmith Steve Conservative ForMelias Matt Conservative ForHiscott Claire Conservative ForRadford Liz Conservative ForAbraham Peter Conservative ForMorris Graham Conservative ForCarey Tony Conservative ForQuartley Kevin Conservative ForWeston Mark Conservative ForLake Cleo Green Lord Mayor – didn’t vote.

Bradshaw Mark LabourWindows Chris ConservativeCheney Craig LabourDavies Mike LabourGoggin Paul LabourKhan Sultan Labour


4/14

Item 12 - Vote ii)45 For 3 Abstain 16 Against

Name First name Group Vote result Clough Harriet Liberal Democrat AbstainClark Jos Liberal Democrat ForNegus Anthony Liberal Democrat AgainstHopkins Gary Liberal Democrat AbstainDavies Chris Liberal Democrat ForKent Tim Liberal Democrat AbstainWright Mark Liberal Democrat ForJackson Christopher Labour ForClark Barry Labour ForRees Marvin Labour ForSergeant Jo Labour ForJama Hibaq Labour ForBreckels Fabian Labour ForBrook Tom Labour ForKeen Anna Labour ForPearce Steve Labour ForBrain Mark Labour ForDudd Kye Labour ForWellington Jon Labour ForPickersgill Ruth Labour ForPhipps Celia Labour ForTincknell Estella Labour ForSmith Paul Labour ForLovell Jeff Labour ForMead Olly Labour ForWhittle Lucy Labour ForKirk Gill Labour ForShah Afzal Labour ForBowden-Jones Nicola Labour ForThrelfal Mhairi Labour ForMassey Brenda Labour ForBeech Nicola Labour ForHickman Margaret Labour ForCraig Asher Labour ForAlexander Donald Labour ForBradley Harriet Labour ForJohnson Carole Labour ForGodwin Helen Labour ForHolland Helen Labour ForLangley Mike Labour ForClarke Stephen Green ForO'Rourke Paula Green ForBolton Charles Green ForHance Fi Green ForCombley Eleanor Green For


5/14

Fodor Martin Green ForDenyer Carla Green ForThomas Jerome Green ForStevens Clive Green AgainstEnglish Jude Green ForGoulandris John Conservative AgainstJones Steve Conservative AgainstGollop Geoff Conservative AgainstAlexander Lesley Conservative AgainstEddy Richard Conservative AgainstSmith Steve Conservative AgainstMelias Matt Conservative AgainstHiscott Claire Conservative AgainstRadford Liz Conservative AgainstAbraham Peter Conservative AgainstMorris Graham Conservative AgainstCarey Tony Conservative AgainstQuartley Kevin Conservative AgainstWeston Mark Conservative AgainstLake Cleo Green Lord Mayor – didn’t voteCheney Craig LabourDavies Mike LabourGoggin Paul LabourBradshaw Mark LabourWindows Chris ConservativeKhan Sultan Labour


6/14

Item 12 - vote iii) substantive

34 For 0 Abstain 30 Against

Clough Harriet Liberal Democrat ForClark Jos Liberal Democrat ForNegus Anthony Liberal Democrat ForHopkins Gary Liberal Democrat ForDavies Chris Liberal Democrat ForKent Tim Liberal Democrat ForWright Mark Liberal Democrat ForJackson Christopher Labour AgainstClark Barry Labour AgainstRees Marvin Labour AgainstSergeant Jo Labour AgainstJama Hibaq Labour ForBreckels Fabian Labour AgainstBrook Tom Labour AgainstKeen Anna Labour AgainstPearce Steve Labour AgainstBrain Mark Labour AgainstDudd Kye Labour AgainstWellington Jon Labour AgainstPickersgill Ruth Labour AgainstPhipps Celia Labour AgainstTincknell Estella Labour ForSmith Paul Labour AgainstLovell Jeff Labour AgainstMead Olly Labour AgainstWhittle Lucy Labour AgainstKirk Gill Labour AgainstShah Afzal Labour ForBowden-Jones Nicola Labour AgainstThrelfal Mhairi Labour AgainstMassey Brenda Labour AgainstBeech Nicola Labour AgainstHickman Margaret Labour AgainstCraig Asher Labour AgainstAlexander Donald Labour AgainstBradley Harriet Labour AgainstJohnson Carole Labour AgainstGodwin Helen Labour AgainstHolland Helen Labour AgainstLangley Mike Labour AgainstClarke Stephen Green ForO'Rourke Paula Green ForBolton Charles Green ForHance Fi Green ForCombley Eleanor Green ForFodor Martin Green ForDenyer Carla Green ForThomas Jerome Green ForStevens Clive Green For


7/14

English Jude Green ForGoulandris John Conservative ForJones Steve Conservative ForGollop Geoff Conservative ForAlexander Lesley Conservative ForEddy Richard Conservative ForSmith Steve Conservative ForMelias Matt Conservative ForHiscott Claire Conservative ForRadford Liz Conservative ForAbraham Peter Conservative ForMorris Graham Conservative ForCarey Tony Conservative ForQuartley Kevin Conservative ForWeston Mark Conservative ForLake Cleo Green Lord Mayor – didn’t voteWindows Chris ConservativeKhan Sultan LabourCheney Craig LabourDavies Mike LabourBradshaw Mark Labour


8/14

Item 8 Vote to defer18 For 2 Abstain 36 Against

Name Wright Kent Davies Hopkins Negus Clark Clough Langley Holland Godwin Johnson Bradley Alexander Craig Hickman Beech Massey Threlfal Davies CheneyBowden-JonesShah Kirk Whittle Mead Lovell Khan Smith Tincknell Phipps Bradshaw PickersgillWellingtonDudd Brain Pearce Goggin Keen Brook Breckels

First name Mark Tim Chris Gary Anthony Jos Harriet Mike Helen Helen Carole Harriet Donald AsherMargaret Nicola Brenda Mhairi Mike Craig Nicola AfzalGill Lucy Olly Jeff Sultan Paul Estella Celia Mark Ruth Jon Kye Mark Steve Paul Anna Tom Fabian

Group Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat LabourLabour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour

Vote resFor For For For For For ForAgainst Against Against

Against Against Against Against

AgainstAgainst

Against Against Against

AgainstAgainst


Against Against Against Against Against



9/14

Jama Hibaq Labour AgainstSergeant Jo LabourRees Marvin Labour AgainstClark Barry Labour AgainstJackson Christopher Labour AgainstEnglish Jude GreenStevens Clive Green AbstainThomas Jerome Green AgainstDenyer Carla Green AgainstFodor Martin Green AgainstLake Cleo GreenCombley Eleanor Green AbstainHance Fi Green AgainstBolton Charles Green AgainstO'Rourke Paula Green AgainstClarke Stephen Green AgainstWeston Mark Conservative ForQuartley Kevin Conservative ForCarey Tony Conservative ForMorris Graham Conservative ForWindows Chris ConservativeAbraham Peter Conservative ForRadford Liz Conservative ForHiscott Claire ConservativeMelias Matt Conservative ForSmith Steve Conservative ForEddy Richard ConservativeAlexander Lesley Conservative ForGollop Geoff Conservative ForJones Steve ConservativeGoulandris John Conservative For


10/14

Item O8 - Pay Policy Statement39 For 0 Abstain 19 Against

Clough Harriet Liberal Democrat AgainstClark Jos Liberal Democrat AgainstNegus Anthony Liberal Democrat AgainstHopkins Gary Liberal Democrat AgainstDavies Chris Liberal Democrat AgainstKent Tim Liberal Democrat AgainstWright Mark Liberal Democrat AgainstJackson Christopher Labour ForClark Barry Labour ForRees Marvin Labour ForSergeant Jo Labour ForJama Hibaq Labour ForBreckels Fabian Labour ForBrook Tom Labour ForKeen Anna Labour ForGoggin Paul LabourPearce Steve Labour ForBrain Mark Labour ForDudd Kye Labour ForWellington Jon Labour ForPickersgill Ruth Labour ForBradshaw Mark LabourPhipps Celia Labour ForTincknell Estella Labour ForSmith Paul Labour ForKhan Sultan LabourLovell Jeff Labour ForMead Olly Labour ForWhittle Lucy LabourKirk Gill Labour ForShah Afzal Labour ForBowden-Jones Nicola Labour ForCheney Craig LabourDavies Mike LabourThrelfal Mhairi Labour ForMassey Brenda Labour ForBeech Nicola LabourHickman Margaret Labour ForCraig Asher Labour ForAlexander Donald Labour ForBradley Harriet Labour ForJohnson Carole LabourGodwin Helen Labour ForHolland Helen Labour ForLangley Mike Labour ForClarke Stephen Green ForO'Rourke Paula Green ForBolton Charles Green ForHance Fi Green ForCombley Eleanor Green ForLake Cleo Green


11/14

Name Clough Clark Negus Hopkins Davies Kent Wright Jackson Clark Rees Sergeant Jama Breckels Brook Keen Goggin Pearce Brain DuddWellingtonPickersgill

First name Harriet Jos Anthony Gary Chris Tim MarkChristopher Barry MarvinJo Hibaq Fabian Tom Anna Paul Steve Mark Kye Jon Ruth

Group Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat Liberal Democrat LabourLabour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour Labour

VotFor For For For For For For For For For For For For

For

For

ForForFor

Fodor Martin Green ForDenyer Carla Green ForThomas Jerome Green ForStevens Clive Green ForGoulandris John Conservative AgainstGollop Geoff Conservative AgainstAlexander Lesley Conservative AgainstEddy Richard Conservative AgainstSmith Steve Conservative AgainstMelias Matt Conservative AgainstRadford Liz Conservative AgainstAbraham Peter Conservative AgainstMorris Graham Conservative AgainstCarey Tony Conservative AgainstQuartley Kevin Conservative AgainstWeston Mark Conservative AgainstWindows Chris ConservativeHiscott Claire ConservativeEnglish Jude GreenJones Steve Conservative

Agenda item856 For 0 Abstain 0 Against

Item 09 - Making of Hengrove and Whitchurch Park Neighbourhood Development Plan


12/14

Bradshaw Mark LabourPhipps Celia Labour ForTincknell Estella Labour ForSmith Paul Labour ForKhan Sultan LabourLovell Jeff Labour ForMead Olly Labour ForWhittle Lucy LabourKirk Gill Labour ForShah Afzal Labour ForBowden-Jones Nicola Labour ForCheney Craig LabourDavies Mike LabourThrelfal Mhairi Labour ForMassey Brenda Labour ForBeech Nicola LabourHickman Margaret Labour ForCraig Asher Labour ForAlexander Donald Labour ForBradley Harriet Labour ForJohnson Carole LabourGodwin Helen Labour ForHolland Helen Labour ForLangley Mike Labour ForClarke Stephen Green ForO'Rourke Paula Green ForBolton Charles Green ForHance Fi Green ForCombley Eleanor Green ForLake Cleo GreenFodor Martin Green ForDenyer Carla Green ForThomas Jerome Green ForStevens Clive Green ForEnglish Jude GreenGoulandris John Conservative ForJones Steve ConservativeGollop Geoff Conservative ForAlexander Lesley Conservative ForEddy Richard Conservative ForSmith Steve Conservative ForMelias Matt Conservative ForHiscott Claire ConservativeRadford Liz Conservative ForAbraham Peter Conservative ForWindows Chris ConservativeMorris Graham Conservative ForCarey Tony Conservative ForQuartley Kevin Conservative ForWeston Mark Conservative For

bristol city council jon wellington, mark weston, lucy ... · paula o'rourke, steve pearce,...

Documents