broward county's medical examiner's office and bso's … · finn name alan cohen dr....

Scoring Sheet Final Evaluation Meeting

RFP No. S2115731 P1 Consultant Services for Broward County's Medical Examiner's and Broward Sheriff's Office Crime Laboratory Combined

Facility May 7, 2018

Broward County Governmental Center 115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301

Finn Name Alan Cohen Dr. Craig Mallak Ariadna Musarra Leonard Colonel John D.

Total Ranking Vialpando "Jack" Dale

ARCADD, Inc. 63 38 49 36 20 206 6

Bermello Ajamll & Partners, 89 74 93 92 77 425 3 Inc.

Cartaya and Associates 92 73 83 80 74 402 4 Architects, P.A.

Leo A Daly Company 95 77 90 87 86 435 1

MOBIO Architecture, Inc. 84 65 78 82 73 382 5

Saltz Michelson Architects, 94 78 86 82 90 430 2 Inc.


RFP No. S2115731 P1 Consultant Services for Broward County's Medical Examiner's and

Broward Sheriff's Office Crime Laboratory Combined Facility May 7, 2018

115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301

Evaluation Criteria - Project Specific Crite ria Maximum Bermello Ajamil Cartaya and

Leo A Daly ARCAOO, Inc. Associates

(Complete text of questions provided separa tely) Points & Partners, Inc. Architects, P.A .

Company

ABILITY OF PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL (Total Maximum 25 Points)

See Evaluation Criteria • question 1.a 10 h q 9 lo bSee Evaluation Criteria • ques tion 1.b 5 3 ) f) 5" See Evaluation Cr iter ia • question 1.c 5 ~ ) ) )

See Evaluation Criter ia ·ques tion 1.d 5 L( ) ) s-PROJECT APPROACH

(Total Maximum 20 Points)

See Evaluation Criteria • question 2.a 10 ~ er 9 [0 See Evaluation Criteria · question 2.b 10 ~ <1 9 to

PAST PERFORMANCE (Total Maximum 30 Points)

See Evaluation Criteria · question 3.a 15 1 IS- I ;;i. IS-See Evaluation Criteria • question 3.b 15 /0 15"" I) IS'

SPECIALIZED EXPERIENCE, KNOWLEDGE AND CAPABILITIES


See Evaluation Criteria • question 4.a 5 L/ ) J )

See Evaluation Criteria • question 4.b 5 '3 5"" ~ S" WORKLOAD OF FIRM

See Evaluation Criteria· question 5 5 0 t-/ t./ s-POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS

LOCATION ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

See Evaluation Crtterta - question 6 5 0 0 5 0

WILLINGNESS TO MEET TIME AND BUDGET POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS

REQUIREMENTS ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

See Evaluation Crtterta • question 7 2 2 2 2 2

POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY

PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

See Evaluation Crtterta - question 8 3 3 1 2 3

TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY


TOTAL SCORE WILL BE ENTERED BY Max 100 PURCHASING One Hundred

Alan Cohen Name

MOBIO Saltz Michelson

Architecture, Inc.

Architects, Inc.

'8 Cf

) 5' :) 5-' J -j

7 er 3" 9

I :S l .3

IS- IS-

q s-s-- s-

q £-/ POINTS POINTS

ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING

0 5

POINTS POINTS ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING

2 2

POINTS POINTS ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING

3 3

TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY

PURCHASING PURCHASING

o/~ By signing th is docum ent I certify that I have abided by the Cone of Silence Ordinance and have not

Signature r been influenced or coerced by anyone in the assignment o f the points by me ror this procu rement.

,


RFP No. S2115731 P1 Consultant Services for Broward County's Medical Examiner's and

Broward Sheriff's Office Crime Laboratory Combined Facil ity May 7, 2018


B ermell o Ca rtaya a nd

Evaluation Cri teria - Project Specific Criteria Maximum A R CADD, Inc. Ajamil &

Associates Leo A Da ly

{Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Partners , Inc.

Arc hitects, Company

P .A .


See Evaluation Criter ia · question 1.a 10 L,/ q 7 9 bSee Evaluation Criteri a - question 1.b 5 ;3 t-( f-,/ l See Evaluation Cri teria - question 1.c 5 H ") ~ 4 See Evaluation Criteria - question 1.d 5 '2 L.j lj -

~ PROJECT APPROACH


See Evaluation Cri teria - question 2.a 10 '1 7 ?' 9 See Evaluation Criteria - question 2.b 10 Li ~ ~ Q

PAST PERFORMANCE I - -(Total Maximum 30 Points)

See Evaluation Criteria - question 3.a 15 s f [) /{? /0 See Evaluation Criteria - ques tion 3.b 15 2-J rD JO 10


(Total Maximum 10 Po ints)

See Evaluation Criteri a - question 4.a 5 ?, Ly J--/ ~/

See Evaluation Cri teria - question 4.b 5 -z ~ 4 1/ WORKLOAD OF FIRM

See Evaluation Criteria - question 5 5 l Q 3 :y POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS

LOCATION ENTERE.DBY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASlNG PURCHASING

See Evaluation Crtterla • question 6 5 0 0 5 0

WILLINGNESS TO MEET TIME AND BUDGET POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS

REQUIREMENTS ENTERED BY ENTEREO BY ENTERED BY ENTEREOBY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

See Evaluation Criteria - question 7 2 2 2 2 2 POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS

VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

See Evaluation Crtterla ·question 8 3 3 1 2 3 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE

CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

TOTAL SCORE Wil l BE ENTERED BY Max 100 PURCHASING One Hundred

Dr. Craig Mallak -

Name

MOBIO Saltz

Architecture, Miche ls on

Inc. Architects, Inc.

y ~ t-._/ ~t( L( L/ 'V

rl I .--..

'~

6 R p a

v .

Cl ff] '?( A?

y

:5 <.. ? _ _:\ t/

ti ~ POINTS POINTS

ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASlNG

0 5 POINTS POINTS


2 2 POINTS POINTS

ENTEREOBY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING

3 3 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE

CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING

/! ~ By signing this document I certify that I have abided by the Cone of Silence Ordinance and have not

Signature - /' been influenced or coerced b y anyone in the assignment o f the points b y m e for this procurement.

Scoring Sheet

Final Evaluation Meeting

RFP No. S2115731 P1

Consultant Services for Broward County's Medica l Examiner's and

Broward Sheriff' s Office Crime Laboratory Combined Facility

May 7 , 2018


Evaluation Criter ia - Project Spec ific Criteria Maximum

(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points


See Evaluation Criteria - question 1.a

bSee Evaluation Criteria • question 1.b

See Evaluation Criteria - question 1.c

See Evaluation Criteria - question 1.d

PROJECT APPROACH (Total Maximum 20 Points)


See Evaluation Criteria - question 2.b








WORKLOAD OF FIRM

See Evaluation Criteria - question 5

LOCATION

See Evaluation Crtterta - question 6

WILLINGNESS TO MEET TIME AND BUDGET REQUIREMENTS


VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK


10

5

5

5

10

10

15

15

5

5

5

5

2

3

Bermello

ARCADD, Inc . Ajamil &

z 2

J

POINTS ENTERED BY PURCHASING

0 POINTS

ENTERED BY PURCHASING

2 POINTS


3

Partners, Inc.

5

lo LO

lS 15

5

5 POINTS


0 POINTS


2 POINTS


1

Cartaya and

Associates Architects,

P.A.

7 4 4 4

B

(3

l4

4 4

4 POINTS


5 POINTS


2 POINTS

ENTERED BY PURCHASlNG

2

Leo A Daly Company

lO

(O

l4 l4

s

4 POINTS


0 POINTS


2 POINTS


3

MOBIO Saltz Architecture, Michelson

Inc. Architects, Inc.

4 4 4

7 8

IB

s 5

POINTS ENTERED BY PURCHASING

0 POINTS


2 POINTS


3

8

4 4

7

l4 lS

5

5 POINTS


5 POINTS


2 POINTS


3 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE

CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASlNG PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASlNG


Ariadna Musarra Name

_.,,4 ~ _A~~" A _ _A' ..I~ A/\ (Lu _ - - . --~ 5 . 1 . \ fi) By signing this document I certi fy that I have abided by the Cone of Silence Ordinance and have not t-S-ig_n_a-tu_r_e--------------------- been influenced or coerced by anyone 1n the assignment o f the points by me for this procurement.

Scoring S h ee t

Fina l Evaluation Meeting

RFP No. S2115731 P1

Consultant Services for Browa rd Cou nty's Medical E xamine r 's and

Broward Sheriff' s Office Crime L aboratory Combined F acility

May 7 , 201 8

115 S . A n drews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort L a ude rd a le , FL 33301

Bermello Cartaya and

Evaluation Criteria - Project Specific Criteria Maximum ARCADD, Inc . Ajami l &

Ass oc iates Leo A Da ly (Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Partners, Inc.

Architects, Company P.A .


See Evaluation Criteria • question 1.a 10 s 9 1 'i

bSee Evaluation Criteria - question 1.b 5 ~ s ~ , See Evaluation Criteria . question 1.c 5 ~ 5 "\ s See Evaluation Cr iter ia - question 1.d 5 I s 5 s

PROJECT APPROACH (Total Maximum 20 Points)

See Evaluation Criteria - question 2.a 10 d / t:> ~ g See Evaluation Criteria - question 2.b 10 d 10 ' Io


See Evaluation Criteria - quest ion 3.a 15 s \ 'l \;} \1 See Evaluation Criteria - question 3.b 15 s \ s \~ \J



See Evaluation Cri teria - question 4.a 5 \ c; ""

s See Evaluation Criteria - question 4.b 5 I s ".l s

WORKLOAD OF FIRM

See Evaluation Criteria - question 5 5 c; 5 5 s POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS

LOCATION ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING

See Evaluation Criteria - question 6 5 0 0 5 0

WILLINGNESS TO MEET TIME AND BUDGET POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY

REQUIREMENTS PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING



See Evaluation Criteria - question 8 3 3 1 2 3 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE



Leonard Vialpando Name

MOBIO Sal tz Architecture, Michelson

Inc. Arch itects, Inc.

'8 I ~ '-1

"-t '1

5 5

S' 7 I o i

)l \}.

\ J. ,~

~ "1 s l.f

s s POINTS POINTS


0 5 POINTS POINTS


2 2 POINTS POINTS




~~- {/~ By signing this document I certify that I have abided by the Cone of Silence Ordinance and have not -~-,

Signat#' /' been innuenced or coerced by anyone in the assignment o f the points by me for this procurem ent.

//


RFP No. S21 15731 P1 Consultant Services for Broward County's Medical Examiner's and

Broward Sheriff's Office Crime Laboratory Combined Facility May 7, 2018

115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderda le, FL 33301

Bermello Cartaya and

Evaluation Criteria - Project Specific Criteria Maximum ARCADD, Inc. Ajamil &

Associates Leo A Daly

(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Partne rs, Inc. Arch itects, Company

P.A.


See Evaluation Criteria · question 1.a 10 7-- ~ ·1 9 bSce Evaluation Criteria· question 1.b 5 I '-i --! '-/ See Evaluation Criteria · question 1.c 5 \ '-/- </ {

5 I ,..

See Evaluation Criteria • question 1.d '.;> .e " PROJECT APPROACH (Total Maximum 20 Points)

See Evaluation Cri teria • question 2.a 10 l ? j, 21 See Evaluation Criteria · question 2.b 10 ·v- ? h 7


See Evaluation Criteria ·question 3.a 15 "3 IL-- tD { <{ See Evaluation Criteria ·question 3.b 15 '2.....-

\S l I I <f SPECIALIZED EXPERIENCE, KNOWLEDGE AND

CAPABILITIES (Total Maximum 10 Points)

See Evaluation Criteria • quest ion 4.a 5 l 4 4 y See Evaluation Cri teria • question 4.b 5 0 1 l/. 5

WORKLOAD OF FIRM

See Evaluation Cri teria • question 5 5 1 '-{ z/ t;;

POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS LOCATION ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY


See Evaluation Criteria · question 6 5 0 0 5 0

WILLINGNESS TO MEET TIME AND BUDGET POINTS POINTS POINTS POINTS ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY

REQUIREMENTS PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING



See Evaluatlon Criteria - question 8 3 3 1 2 3 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE



Colonel John D. " Jack" Dale Name

MOBIO Sa ltz

Architecture, M ichelson

Inc. Archi tects, Inc.

c 9 J ~"'

1 :5 ..:> g

7 q ·7 ff

12' {t{

(/ I <-/

<-/ 4 ../ ~

'I v POINTS POINTS


0 5 POINTS POINTS


2 2 POINTS POINTS




~ ~ -·f2__- By signing this document I certi fy tha t I have abided by the Cone of S ilence Ordinance and have not I / Signature / been influenced or coerced by anyone in the assignment of the points by me for this procurem ent.

/ \..

broward county's medical examiner's office and bso's … · finn name alan cohen dr....

Documents