btp report phase i jasmeet

Upload: jasmeet-singh-sethi

Post on 06-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    1/54

    Exploring Multiple Intelligence for Kids through Play

    By

    Jasmeet Singh Sethi

    07020509

    Under the guidance of

    Prof. Avinash Shende

    Department of Design

    INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI

    Bachelors Thesis Project Tinkerable

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    2/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    2

    Certificate

    This is to certify that the project entitled :

    Exploring Multiple Intelligence for kids through Play done by

    Mr. Jasmeet Singh Sethi (07020519) is an authentic work carried out by

    him at IIT Guwahati under my guidance.

    The matter embodied in this project work has not been submitted earlier

    for award of any degree to the best of my knowledge and belief.

    Examiner 1

    Examiner 2 .

    Guide..

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    3/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    3

    IPR DeclarationI, the undersigned student, declare that in accordance to the IPR norms

    generally followed in Academics, I have acknowledged appropriately all

    sources of material / content including visuals / designs / copyrights

    accessed from other authors / sources / references and used in this

    project as part of our academic reporting.

    I declare that the contents of this project report including

    visuals/designs other than those whose origin / source has been

    appropriately acknowledged, are a result of my original efforts.

    Signature:

    Jasmeet Singh Sethi

    07020509

    IIT Guwahati.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    4/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    4

    Acknowledgement

    I would like to thank my guide Mr. Avinash Shende for the amount oftrust he put into me and my thoughts, no matter how farfetched they

    seem. The project had always been very ambitious and his support was

    all that was needed.

    Secondly, I would like to thank Vivek and Adarsh for all the time they

    invested. A special thanks to my friends, juniors and teachers for their

    co-operation.

    Special thanks to Asst. Librarian Mr. Rajbanshi for his enthusiasm and

    knowledge.

    Lastly, I would like to dedicated this project to the spirit of education

    and its lost meaning.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    5/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    5

    Abstract

    There seems to be a need to understand a childs abilities and focus

    so as to provide a better education and his development to a fully

    realized individual.

    The traditional notion of intelligence, based on I.Q. testing is limited

    in terms of judging an individual and leads to stereotypes. The project is

    an exploration based on the theory of M.I. by Dr. Howard Gardener,

    using the theme of play.

    .

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    6/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    6

    Contents

    1.Introduction

    1.1 Objective1.2 Aim1.3 Motivation1.4 Methodology

    2. Literature Review

    2.1 Intelligence2.1.1 Multiple Intelligence

    2.2 Education in India2.2.1 Introduction2.2.2 Historical Overview

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    7/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    7

    2.2.3 Children and play2.2.4 Technology and Education-Critique

    3. Analysis

    3.1 Analysis of M.I.3.2 Case Example Lego blocks3.3 Intervention

    4. Hypothesis

    4.1 Intelligence4.2 Experiential Learning4.3 Guidelines

    5. Product Concept

    5.1 Concept5.2 Visualization5.3 Initial Draft

    6. References

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    8/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    8

    1. Introduction

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    9/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    9

    " Once upon a time the animals decided they must do something

    decisive to meet the increasing complexity of their society. They held a

    meeting and finally decided to organize a school. The curriculumconsisted of running, swimming and flying. Since these were the basic

    behaviors of most animals, they decided that all the students should take

    all of the subjects.

    The duck proved to be excellent at swimming, better in fact than his

    teacher. He also did well in flying, but he proved to be very poor in

    running. Since he was poor in this subject he was made to stay after

    school to practice it and even had to drop swimming in order to get more

    time in which to practice running. He was kept at this poorest subject

    until his webbed feet were so badly damaged that he became onlyaverage at swimming. But average was acceptable in the school so

    nobody worried about that except the duck.

    The rabbit started at the top of his class in running, but finally had a

    nervous breakdown because of so much make-up time in swimming a

    subject he hated.

    The squirrel was excellent in climbing until he developed

    psychological blocking in flying class when the teacher insisted he start

    from the ground instead of from the tops of the trees. He was kept at

    attempting to fly until he became muscle bound and received a C in

    climbing and a D in running.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    10/54

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    11/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    11

    1.1. Objectives

    Development of possible design guidelines and solutions to act as a

    medium to foster exploration in terms of different individuals abilities.The desired characteristics will be as follows:

    Child centered Add-on to the current education system Blends easily in a play environmentThe focus will be on kids ( age group 6-10 yrs).

    1.2. Aim

    Development of a min. of 3 activities and one product based on the

    observations and proposed guidelines.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    12/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    12

    1.3. Motivation

    The need for education is an issue that needs not a debate. There are

    many organizations and individuals who are working to make educationreachable to more and more areas. This particularly shows our concern

    towards development of education in terms of quantity.

    On the other hand we also need to focus on the quality of

    education. I mean so in terms of the types of education that can be made

    available not only on the basis of the needs of the industry, but also on

    the requirements and abilities of an individual.

    A good degree of polarization is seen towards individual pertaining

    used to or can be made used to general schooling where they areaccustomed to take paper-pencil tests featuring clearly delineated

    answers.

    The primary motivation can safely be assumed to be the alternative

    schools in operation, which are trying their best to make education

    available to children in a way that they feel to be at the centre of it.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    13/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    13

    1.4. Methodology

    The process this project will follow cannot be linear due to the

    vastness of the issue concerned and at the same time, has to providetangible results at the end of the provided short time of a year. The

    diagram above shows the process that will be followed.

    It consists of two identifiable parts; first being divergent in nature,

    will try to explore the realms that overlap with the concerned, through

    the stated means, followed by the second phase which by its nature is

    convergent, so as to make this fruitful in the form of a design-output.

    Process Map [1.4]

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    14/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    14

    2. Review/Study

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    15/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    15

    The project demanded an exhaustive study of prevalent methods and

    research. The domain of the study lied heavily in psychology and partly in

    understanding norms which have been practiced since years and

    therefore required a thorough understanding of the same if it was to becritically analyzed and challenged.

    The study can be broadly divided into following parts-

    Intelligence Child Psychology Education in India Technology and Education Play

    2.1 Intelligence

    Numerous definitions and hypothesis about intelligence have been

    proposed, with no consensus reached by scholars. Intelligence has been

    a topic of thorough study in psychology. It started from ability to

    differentiate between sensory inputs, to mental processing and

    abstraction. But being a science, it has a tendency to approach an issue

    empirically. And thus started the works on trying to measure and

    compare an individuals so called intelligence. This has led to formulationof tests, largely based upon logical and linguistic nature.

    It lacks view of process, of how one goes about solving a problem. As

    stated by Dr. Gardener, they rely heavily upon language and upon a

    persons skill in defining words, in knowing facts about the world, in

    finding connections (and differences) among verbal concepts.[2]

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    16/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    16

    There are many views and approaches towards intelligence; for

    reference they have been explained briefly:

    Piagetian

    Piaget's work mainly concerned cognitive psychology. He says that an individual is continually constructing hypothesisand thereby attempting to generate knowledge. He talks about various stages of development of intelligence varyingfrom age group.

    Informationprocessing

    Briefly put, this is a step by step model of how intelligence can be considered from the point of view of informationprocessing. It talks about a horizontal approach, notion of a single-general problem solving approach.

    The theory seems limited in terms of finding any biological basis. There seems to be no emphasis or explanation as suchon creativity.

    Symbol

    systems

    This particular approach lays emphasis on human use of various symbolic vehichles in expressing and communicatingmeaning. The use of symbols has been at the core in various creative domains, such as, art, science, mythology, etc.

    It lays views upon cultural backing of these symbols. It taks about domains, namely, universal and unique, elaboration

    of which would deem unnecessary.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    17/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    17

    2.1. 1. Multiple Intelligence

    The theory of Multiple Intelligences was developed by Dr. HowardGardner, a psychologist, and professor of neuroscience from Harvard

    University.

    Traditionally individuals were viewed as possessing degrees of

    intelligence, as measured by IQ or some test scores, usually made in

    schoolcontexts, about school performance(the Piagetian view).

    Developments in psychological theories have caused the

    advancement of otherconceptions of intelligence. Modern theories of

    intelligence have allowed for a dynamic and multidimensional view ofintellectualpossession. Models of intelligence that combine cognitive

    processing interacting with contexts have allowed for these multiple

    forms ofintelligence. For example, Sternberg (1994) has presented a

    Triarchic theory of intelligence as that which encompasses attributes of

    practical problem solving, verbal ability, and social competence.

    Although the definition has expanded the Piagetian view, it continues to

    place an emphasis on logical competence and verbal facility.

    When Gardner was first asked to define intelligence in 1983, he

    wrote: "To my mind, a human intellectual competence must entail a setof skills of problem solvingenabling the individual to resolve genuine

    problems or difficulties that he or she encounters and, when

    appropriate, to create an effective productand must also entail the

    potential for finding or creating problems, thereby laying the

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    18/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    18

    groundwork for the acquisition of new knowledge." These prerequisites

    represented his effort to focus on the strengths and abilities people

    posses that are important in a particular cultural context. He believes

    intelligence is a biopsychological potential.

    CriteriaWhen considering evidence to support the existence of a new

    intelligence Gardner looks for the following eight criteria. These are

    merely brief excerpts from the more specific details that Gardner

    provides in his text.

    1. Potential Isolation by Brain Damage To the extent that, as aresult of brain damage, a particular faculty can be destroyed or spared in

    isolation, its relative autonomy from other human faculties seem likely.

    2. The existence of idiot savants, prodigies and other exceptionalindividuals To the extent that the condition of the prodigy or the idiot

    savant can be linked to genetic factors or to specific neural regions, the

    claim upon a specific intelligence is enhanced.

    3. An identifiable core operation or set of operations One mighteven go so far as to define a human intelligence as a neural mechanism

    or computational system that is genetically programmed to be activated

    or "triggered" by certain kinds of internally or externally presented

    information.

    4. A distinctive developmental history, along with a definable set ofexpert "End-State" performances The existence of one or more basic

    information-processing operations or mechanisms, which can deal with

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    19/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    19

    specific kinds of input.

    5. An evolutionary history and evolutionary plausibility A specificintelligence becomes more plausible to the extent that one can locate its

    evolutionary antecedents, including capacities (like bird-song or primate

    social organization) that are shared with other organisms.

    6. Support from experimental psychological tasks Especiallysuggestive are studies of tasks that interfere (or fail to interfere) with

    one another; tasks that transfer (and those that do not) across different

    contexts; and the identification of forms of memory, attention or

    perception that may be peculiar to one kind of input.

    7. Support from psychometric findings To the extent that thetasks that purportedly assess ones intelligence correlate highly with one

    another, and less highly with those that purportedly assess otherintelligences, his formulation enhances its credibility.

    8. Susceptibility to encoding in a symbol system One of thefeatures that makes a raw computational capacity useful (and

    exploitable) by human beings is its susceptibility to marshaling by a

    cultural symbols systems. These would include culturally contrived

    systems of meaning that capture important forms of information.

    TypesGardner has identified nine intelligences although he has also been

    considering the possibility of a tentha Spiritual Intelligence. The latter,

    when brought up under the context of spiritual feeling or a gift for

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    20/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    20

    religion, mysticism or the transcendent, usually generates a great deal of

    controversy with the science. The nine intelligences all human beings

    possess and their primary distinguishing characteristics are as follows:

    1. Verbal/LinguisticIntelligence: the capacity to use languageyour native language and perhaps other languagesto express what's onyour mind and to understand other people. Poets really specialize in

    linguistic intelligence, but any kind of writer, orator, speaker, lawyer or

    other person for whom language is an important stock in trade highlights

    linguistic intelligence.

    2. Logical/Mathematical Intelligence: the ability to understand theunderlying principles of some kind of a causal systemthe way a

    scientist or a logician does; or can manipulate numbers, quantities and

    operationsthe way a mathematician does.

    3. Visual/SpatialIntelligence: the ability to represent the spatialworld internally (in your mind)the way a sailor or airplane pilot

    navigates the large spatial world; or the way a chess player or sculptor

    represents a more circumscribed spatial world.

    4. Musical/RhythmicIntelligence: the capacities to think in music,to be able to hear patterns, recognize them and perhaps manipulate

    them.

    5. Bodily/Kinesthetic Intelligence: the capacity to use your wholebody or parts of your body (your hands, your fingers, your arms) to solvea problem, make something or put on some kind of production.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    21/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    21

    6. Naturalist Intelligence: the human ability to discriminate amongliving things (plants, animals) as well as sensitivity to other features of

    the natural world (clouds, rock configurations).

    7. IntrapersonalIntelligence: having an understanding of yourself,of knowing who you are, what you can do, what you want to do, howyou react to things, which things to avoid and which things to gravitate

    toward.

    8. Interpersonal Intelligence: a person's capacity to understandthe intentions, motivations and desires of other people and,

    consequently, to work effectively with others.

    9. Existential Intelligence: the proclivity to pose (and ponder)questions about life, death and ultimate realities.

    The reason I go into this much detail of the particular theory is

    because it will be extensively used in the process throughout this project

    and therefore becomes a perquisite for further understanding of work.

    Lastly, it should be kept in mind that, the theory of multiple

    intelligences is nothing but a tool to understand the notion of

    intelligence and abilities of an individual. It gives us a basis of

    segmentation.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    22/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    22

    2.2. Education in India

    "Education in the true sense is helping the individual to be matureand free, to flower greatly in love and goodness"

    - J. Krishnamurthi

    2.2.1. Introduction

    Each generation, since the beginning of human existence, has sought

    to pass on cultural and social values, traditions, morality, religion and

    skills to the next generation. The passing on of culture is also known asenculturation and the learning of social values and behaviors is

    socialization. The history of the curricula of such education reflects

    human history itself, the history of knowledge, beliefs, skills and cultures

    of humanity.

    In pre-literate societies, education was achieved orally and through

    observation and imitation. The young learned informally from their

    parents, extended family and grandparents. At later stages of their lives,

    they received instruction of a more structured and formal nature,

    imparted by people not necessarily related, in the context of initiation,religion or ritual.

    As the customs and knowledge of ancient civilizations became more

    complex, many skills would have been learned from an experienced

    person on the job, in animal husbandry, agriculture, fishing, preparation

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    23/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    23

    and preservation of food, construction, stone work, metal work, boat

    building, the making of weapons and defenses, the military skills and

    many other occupations.

    With the development of writing, it became possible for stories,

    poetry, knowledge, beliefs, and customs to be recorded and passed onmore accurately to people out of earshot and to future generations. In

    many societies, the spread of literacy was slow; orality and illiteracy

    remained predominant for much of the population for centuries and

    even millennia. Literacy in preindustrial societies was associated with

    civil administration, law, long distance trade or commerce, and religion.

    A formal schooling in literacy was often only available to a small part of

    the population, either at religious institutions or for the wealthy who

    could afford to pay for their tutors. The earliest known universities, or

    places of higher education, started teaching a millennium or more ago.

    Universal education of all children in literacy has been a recent

    development, not occurring in many countries until after 1850 CE. Even

    today, in some parts of the world, literacy rates are below 60 per cent

    (for example, in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh). Schools, colleges

    and universities have not been the only methods of formal education

    and training. Many professions have additional training requirements,

    and in Europe, from the Middle Ages until recent times, the skills of a

    trade were not generally learnt in a classroom, but rather by serving an

    apprenticeship.

    Nowadays, formal education consists of systematic instruction,

    teaching and training by professional teachers. This consists of the

    application of pedagogy and the development of curricula.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    24/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    24

    2.2.2. Historical Overview

    The present mainstream educational system was inaugurated in India

    in the mid-nineteenth century. Over the next century, it almostcompletely supplanted earlier educational institutions. There had, earlier

    been wide network of small village schools- pathshalas, gurukuls and

    madarsas. 'One village -one school' was the norm in various parts of the

    country, up to the early nineteenth century. A large number of such

    schools - reportedly 100,000 in just Bihar and Bengal around 1835 - were

    kept alive by local support (William Adam 1835, in Dharampal 2000).They

    played an important social role and 'were, in fact, the watering holes of

    the culture of traditional communities' (Dharampal 2000). Students from

    various castes studied in these schools. In schools, subjects included

    literature, philosophy, lexicology, religion and grammar. Instruction wasimparted in local languages. Harking back to the tradition of monastries

    and ashrams, schools interspersed training in practical life skills with

    academic education.

    Within the overall context of decline of local economies, these

    schools went into decline and decay under the colonial rule. Deliberate

    policy was employed to wipe out this community-based system of

    schooling, and replace it with an alien model.

    In 1931, Gandhi alleged that 'today India is more illiterate than it was50 or a 100 years ago' (M.K. Gandhi 1931, in Dharampal 2000). He added

    that British administrators had '...scratched the soil and begun to look at

    the root, and left the root like that and the beautiful tree perished.'

    Indigenous education was replaced by an alien rootless system,

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    25/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    25

    deliberately set up, as articulated by Lord Macaulay (1835), to 'form a

    class who interprets between us and the millions we govern; a class of

    persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English in taste, in opinions, in

    morals and in intellect'.

    Despite the transfer of power in 1947, Indian schools continued inthe same mold. Some changes were introduced: the government

    expanded its network of schools in both rural and urban areas, and local

    languages were accepted as the medium of instruction in these schools.

    Today, we have a vast network of government schools in the country,

    and a growing number of privately run institutions. Yet, the basic format

    remained unchanged; a large number of our schools today are based on

    a derivative, mechanistic model. They are designed to produce

    individuals who fit into modern society and it's (consumerist,

    competitive) values, and are easy to govern since they learn to be highly

    disciplined within hierarchical, centrally administered institutions.Schooling thus tends to reinforce social inequalities - class, gender and

    caste.

    Despite vital differences in facilities and funding, all these schools

    share a similar ethos. Mostly competitive, many of them emphasize

    external discipline at the expense of inner responsibility. Further, the

    accent is on absorbing information rather than on original thinking and

    imagination. The setup is centralized and bureaucratic, teachers

    distanced from students and most merely doing a job, while the schools

    act as delivery points for a set curriculum and content. Few students whopass out of these schools love to learn, since they associate learning with

    boredom and pressure.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    26/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    26

    2.3. Children and Play

    Less known is Vygotsky's research on play, or children's games, as a

    psychological phenomenon and its role in the child's development.Through play the child develops abstract meaning separate from the

    objects in the world, which is a critical feature in the development of

    higher mental functions.[3]

    The famous example Vygotsky gives is of a child who wants to ride a

    horse but cannot. If the child were under three, he would perhaps cry

    and be angry, but around the age of three the child's relationship with

    the world changes: "Henceforth play is such that the explanation for it

    must always be that it is the imaginary, illusory realization of unrealizable

    desires. Imagination is a new formation that is not present in theconsciousness of the very raw young child, is totally absent in animals,

    and represents a specifically human form of conscious activity. Like all

    functions of consciousness, it originally arises from action." (Vygotsky,

    1978)

    The child wishes to ride a horse but cannot, so he picks up a stick and

    stands astride of it, thus pretending he is riding a horse. The stick is

    apivot. "Action according to rules begins to be determined by ideas, not

    by objects.... It is terribly difficult for a child to sever thought (the

    meaning of a word) from object. Play is a transitional stage in thisdirection. At that critical moment when a stick i.e., an object

    becomes a pivot for severing the meaning of horse from a real horse,

    one of the basic psychological structures determining the childs

    relationship to reality is radically altered".

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    27/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    27

    As children get older, their reliance on pivots such as sticks, dolls and

    other toys diminishes. They have internalizedthese pivots as imagination

    and abstract concepts through which they can understand the world.

    "The old adage that 'childrens play is imagination in action' can bereversed: we can say that imagination in adolescents and schoolchildren

    is play without action" (Vygotsky, 1978).

    Another aspect of play that Vygotsky referred to was the

    development of social rules that develop, for example, when children

    play house and adopt the roles of different family members. Vygotsky

    cites an example of two sisters playing at being sisters. The rules of

    behaviour between them that go unnoticed in daily life are consciously

    acquired through play. As well as social rules, the child acquires what we

    now refer to as self-regulation. For example, when a child stands at thestarting line of a running race, she may well desire to run immediately so

    as to reach the finish line first, but her knowledge of the social rules

    surrounding the game and her desire to enjoy the game enable her to

    regulate her initial impulse and wait for the start signal.

    2.4. Technology and Education[4] - a critique

    Technologys role in imparting education is increasing day by day. It isused in the form of presentations, applications and other multimedia

    content. It aids in the form of a strong visual medium. Dictionary

    searches, accumulating data and knowledge from encyclopedia had

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    28/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    28

    never been easier. The content is presented through use of pictures,

    images, graphic organizers, mind-maps, videos, etc.

    All said and done, it seems quite unfair to teach a child about a plant

    through only using books or the above stated multimedia content, if he

    has a choice to see the plant for real, to touch it, feel it and observe itclosely, to plant a seed and see the plant grow in his supervision. This

    process should be finally aided with the use of books or any other

    technology medium.

    Technology needs to be used as an aid, rather itself being the primary

    medium in question. How can an online feedback system incorporate the

    notion of a teacher, who is always there to guide, not just in the sense of

    the subject a student is struggling in? How can an interactive chat system

    make a child strong socially, if he is too afraid to even come out of his

    room?

    The primary modes and methods of helping a child to learn, needs to

    be further developed before we can have independent technology

    intervene. To teach him about a squirrel, why not let him play with a

    stuffed toy in its form. It seems fitting that the appreciation of its shape

    and form would dramatically increase; also would show a further jump

    when aided with technology as an aiding tool.

    What needs to be regained is the physicality, at least for domains

    that demand it; if possible, a link to the real world around the kid isneeded, so as they can themselves make connections. As said above, the

    process can rightfully be aided by technology, but technology should not

    be used as a replacement for it.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    29/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    29

    The media-aids, help in terms of visual and auditory sensory

    experiences, but they fail to incorporate rest of the senses. The full

    sensory experience needs to be communicated through its respective

    sense and not always linguistically or through visually dominant media.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    30/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    30

    3. Analysis

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    31/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    31

    3.1. Analysis of M.I.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    32/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    32

    3.2. Case Example LEGO Blocks

    Lego building blocks utilize to the core, the understanding of spatial

    relationships, to build structures. Children try their best to make figuresthat they find attractive. Not to forget the limitless possibility if offers for

    kids to make things purely thorugh imagination. Interpersonal aspect is

    touched, when kids try try to work in groups and teams to create the full

    arsenal of their fantasy world.

    No. of children invloved - atleast 1

    Nature of tasks additive, constructive

    Nature of solutions open-ended, no solution in particular

    Motivation factor Stated examples; house, robots, etc.

    Intelligences involved Visual/Spatial, Interpersonal, Intrapersonal

    3.3. Intervention

    IIT Guwahati has weekend art classes, hosted in Technology

    Complex. This setup was chosen for the intervention. The classes start

    from 9 a.m. to 10.30 a.m. every Sunday, having 3 groups of students,from classes 1

    st, 2

    ndand 3

    rdrespectively. Total strength of around 40 is

    generally seen.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    33/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    33

    Activity Zero - Mute Observers

    For the zero session, we chose to be mute observers. The wholesession was overseen and documented. Two coordinators were available,

    who conducted the whole session of around 40 kids. The general mode of

    teaching was passive. Room had 3 blackboards, on which a certain scene

    or object had been drawn by the coordinators/instructors. This was

    supposed to be copied and colored in individual drawing books.The

    classes consist of basically 2D drawings and coloring. Students try to

    imitate what is drawn on the board as much as possible in their

    sketchbooks.

    Child/ Coordinator ratio20:1Nature of taskPassive

    Nature of solutionSingle solution

    Motivation factorOn board example

    Intelligences InvolvedVisual/Spatial

    Discussion

    The session managed with a ratio of 20 students per coordinator,

    lacks in the possible individual attention a child may need. The singlesolution approach helps in developing drawing skills but lacks in inviting

    creativity as a major element.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    34/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    34

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    35/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    35

    Activity One Rocket Launch

    The children consisted in 3 groups; 1st, 2nd and 3rd standard

    respectively.1st standard children were given the two small sizedcardboard pieces along-with 2nd standard ones. Seniors were given

    some small pieces and many larger ones. The tools available were

    pencils, cutters and duct tapes. Use of colors was left optional.

    The children working on 2d structures, finished fast and moved on to

    make larger objects, like 2D monsters or to 3D objects. Children were

    getting inspired by other children around them. This seemed to be a

    good example of how children learn things, while doing things in groups.

    Child/ Coordinator ratio8:1

    Nature of taskActiveNature of solutionOpen-ended

    Motivation factorScrap build structures

    Intelligences InvolvedVisual/Spatial, Intrapersonal, Interpersonal,

    Bodily-Kinesthetic

    Discussion

    Initial ideas kids had, concerned mainly box like objects. Any specific

    use didnt really concern them. Buildings and rockets were the common

    ideas. A fix with 2D forms was also observed amongst many children,which can be traced back to being seasoned through these art classes

    held weekly.

    This one session also boosted up the interactivity. It was observed

    that 3rd standard students worked better in terms of teamwork; also

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    36/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    36

    they showed the tendency to think before doing. Some preferred to

    sketch before actually making anything.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    37/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    37

    Activity Two Salad Monsters

    We prepared a list of vegetables and condiments to suit children. The

    vegetables were sliced, diced and grated.The kids were first of all introduced to the festival of Holi and the

    respective mythology. The session turned to be the initial icebreaker.

    The activity required them to use plates as canvases and the salad

    vegetables as the colour. They were to think about their fears the so

    called monsters. The plan was to let them make their monsters, than

    to swap them with their friends, so as they can help each other eat their

    monsters off using the condiments. The activity went as planned except

    for the swapping part.

    The task ended with introducing condiments for kids to eat off their

    monsters, after being photographed.

    Child/ Coordinator ratio8:1

    Nature of taskActive

    Nature of solutionOpen-ended

    Motivation factorMonster/Fear

    Intelligences InvolvedVisual/Spatial, Intrapersonal, Interpersonal,

    Naturalistic

    Discussion

    The different cut shapes were used as basic elements to create the

    monsters. Children made monsters inspired from their reservations and

    fears. Some had no clear idea of how their monsters looked, while some

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    38/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    38

    chose to discover the form in the process of making. Kids showed a great

    affinity towards ketchup. Some preferred honey and tamarind sauce.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    39/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    39

    Activity Three Wally

    The wall of the TC room was covered with A2 sheets this time. The

    raw materials were; newspaper cutouts in variety of shapes and sizes,

    cardboard stencils to be used on walls and glue.

    At first kids were given the newspaper cutouts and glue to stick

    shapes on walls. This was done for around 30 minutes. After this, they

    were handed wax crayons and cardboard stencils. The use of more

    newspaper cutouts was kept optional.

    Child/ Coordinator ratio8:1

    Nature of taskActiveNature of solutionOpen-ended

    Motivation factorCommon Giant Canvas

    Intelligences InvolvedVisual/Spatial, Intrapersonal, Interpersonal

    Discussion

    Kids showed a tendency to stick to their own working regions as their

    personal canvas. To limit this, kids were instructed to change positions

    midway in session.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    40/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    40

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    41/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    41

    4. Hypothesis

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    42/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    42

    4.1. Intelligence

    A characteristic oflive beings, which due to its very nature, aids insurvival through understanding and/or utilization ofresources

    presented to the being.

    Intelligence is a characteristic of lifeforms Lifeforms aim at survival

    and this is the property that lets them. What does this property do? It

    gives them the ability to utilize resources for their survival; how much

    they understand this, is a matter of how developed that intelligence is.

    The intelligence can be very well governed by the cultural influence.

    For that reason, there arises the case of selective exposure.Like father,like son syndrome, talks about high tendency of exposure to same set

    of skills as the parents, or peer group [cultural group]. This makes way

    for so called polarity, and reduces the chances of full mental

    development.

    It is supposed that one intelligence can be nurtured, using the other

    as a base.

    To get an idea of the same, a subject was asked to perform a task.

    SubjectMathematically dominant, not confident in visual skills

    Task Using math as an inspiration to draw illustrations.

    Time1 hour

    The illustrations so made, are shown on the left side.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    43/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    43

    Play Experience Learn

    4.2. Experiential Learning

    The learning can be attributed to the experiences that we have. The

    human brain works by making connections between differentinformation. The process demands constant influx of new information

    and at the same time old information connections need to be reaffirmed

    by exposure to similar experiences. All and all, kids are experience

    hungry machines when they are in the learning phase.

    The activities and environment should be able to provide different

    possible experiences to aid the process. The project lies around

    suggesting, play as an experience stimuli. Children have a tendency to

    involve in play as a means to indulge them, and the above stated

    behavior starts subconsciously.

    The reasons that can be thought of for explaining the pros of play are

    as follows-

    Incorporates a sense of discovery Removes inhibitions Attributes to group behavior/ imitation of social groups Learn by doing approach Recreational Feeling of independence

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    44/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    44

    4.3. Guidelines

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    45/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    45

    5.Product Concept

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    46/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    46

    5.1. Concept

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    47/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    47

    The concept consists ofglass canvas, which will be painted/ colored,

    using rolling stencil sheet as an aid. The movable sheet provides

    freedom to draw at different parts of canvas. The rolling action provides

    flexibility in terms of trying to use the full stencil.

    The concept derives heavily from Visual/Spatial and Interpersonal

    Intelligences. The use of stencils as aid (Activity three), helps children to

    easily draw elements they like. Stencils can be of different types based

    on content they carry. The stencils can aid as a means of visual

    inspiration.

    The integration of this module in a space can lead to a collaborative

    approach amongst kids, due to the large size of the canvas and flexibility

    of use from both the sides.

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    48/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    48

    5.2. Visualization

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    49/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    49

    Stencil Sheet Graphics

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    50/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    50

    Social Collaboration

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    51/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    51

    5.3. Initial Draft

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    52/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    52

    6. References

  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    53/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    53

    [1]www.janebluestein.com/handouts/animal.html

    [2]Frames of Mind Howard Gardener

    [3]Paul Tough, Can the right kinds of play teach self-control?, New York Times, 2009/09/27 (reviewing the Tools of

    the Mind curriculum based on Vygotskys research

    [4]Carlson-Pickering, Jane. 1999. "Multiple Intelligencesand Technology: A Winning Combination"

    Rhode Island Teachers in Technology Initiative - (RITTI)

    Web:(http://www.ri.net/RITTI_Fellows/Carlson-Pickering/MI_Tech.htm)

    [5]Teaching mixed media to children Karla Cikanova

    [6]Muiltimodal teaching and learning Kress, Jewitt,

    Ogborn and Tsatsarelis

    [7]Alternative Schooling in India Vittachi Raghavan

    http://www.janebluestein.com/handouts/animal.htmlhttp://www.janebluestein.com/handouts/animal.htmlhttp://www.janebluestein.com/handouts/animal.htmlhttp://www.ri.net/RITTI_Fellows/Carlson-http://www.ri.net/RITTI_Fellows/Carlson-http://www.ri.net/RITTI_Fellows/Carlson-http://www.ri.net/RITTI_Fellows/Carlson-http://www.janebluestein.com/handouts/animal.html
  • 8/3/2019 BTP Report Phase I Jasmeet

    54/54

    Bachelors Thesis Project - Tinkerable

    54