budget briefing booklet, volume 2
DESCRIPTION
Volume #2 of our Budget Briefing Book series dives into the major drivers of our debt.TRANSCRIPT
your one-stop-shop for our greatest products
VOL 2
WHAT’S INSIDE
MEDICARE & SOCIAL SECURITYDrivers of Our Debt
IN THE SPOTLIGHT: MEDICAREAn In Depth Overview of Its Financial Future
IN THE SPOTLIGHT: SOCIAL SECURITYAn In Depth Overview of Its Financial Future
DEFENSE How Bloated Spending is Hurting our Nation’s Security
6
13
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
STATE FACT SHEETS How Does Your State’s Budget Fare? [click the state to find out]
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
18
20
MEDICARE &
SOCIAL SECURITY:drivers of our debt
On May 13, 2011, the Medicare and Social Security Boards of Trustees
released their annual reports on the financial status of both programs.
These reports made it clear that the government must address the grow-
ing costs associated with the two largest federal programs. Recently, the
President estimated in his budget that Medicare and Social Security spend-
ing will consume 33-percent1 of all federal government spending for the
government’s next Fiscal Year, which begins on October 1, 2012. With
Americans living longer lives, 10,000 babyboomers retiring a day2, lower
birthrates, and the ever increasing cost of healthcare, the costs of these
programs will continue to grow.
Documented in this budget briefing book, Medicare and Social Security
face an unfunded liability of $38.3 trillion over the next 75-years. To put
this number in perspective, in 2010 the United States government collected
$2.2 trillion3 in taxes.
TRUSTEES LEAN TOWARDS REFORM4
As the nation’s financial condition continues to hamper the American people,
government programs, such as Medicare and Social Security, are no excep-
tion. According to the trustees, these programs are now challenged with
costs that are not sustainable under current government financing; thus, in
order to avoid an added burden to both beneficiaries and taxpayers, modifi-
cations are required without having significant disruptions to the programs.
WHAT ARE THE DRIVERS OF DEBT FOR THESE PROGRAMS?
The growing number of babyboomers entering retirement in comparison with the lower-birth-rate of younger generations.
The rapid increase in healthcare costs per person.
Medicare and Social Security worked fine in previous years when there were
many more workers on the bottom of the pyramid than retirees on top. As
the pyramid begins to flip in the opposite direction, with more and more
retirees being added on top of the pyramid and fewer workers entering the
workforce due to lower birthrates, added with the increased costs of health-
care and the impacts of individuals living longer lives than they did when the
programs were created, it’s easy to see why there are problems.
1 http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget
2 http://pewresearch.org/databank/dailynumber/?NumberID=1150
3 CBO. An Analysis of the President’s Budgetary Proposals for Fiscal Year 2012. Pp. 2. http://www.cbo.gov/
ftpdocs/121xx/doc12130/04-15-AnalysisPresidentsBudget.pdf
4 Status of the Social Security and Medicare Programs, A Summary of the 2011 Annual Reports. Social Security and Medi-
care Board of Trustees. http://www.ssa.gov/oact/trsum/index.html
OVERVIEW
Just the Facts: A Summery of Findings
Medicare 101: What is Medicare
Medicare Hospital Coverage Going Broke
Medicare 201: What’s the Real Story with Medicare’s Other Finances
IN THE SPOTLIGHT:medicare
JUST THE FACTS: A SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
Medicare’s primary trust fund, which collects Medicare payroll taxes and
only funds in-patient hospital care and related hospital costs, will run out of
funds in thirteen years—five years sooner than was projected in last year’s
trustees report. Over the next 75-years, this trust fund faces an unfunded
liability of $3.0 trillion—meaning the money is not in the trust fund to cover
benefits over this timeframe.
Medicare’s other services, such as general doctor visits and prescription drug
coverage, are primarily funded by the general taxes collected by the United
States government. To be clear, they are not financed by the Medicare
payroll tax. Since this percentage of federal funding happens automati-
cally each year, the trustees found these parts of Medicare to be actuarially
sound. However, this is misleading when put in context because over the
next 75-years, these parts of Medicare face an unfunded liability of $28.8
trillion—meaning the federal government has to find a way to pay $28.8
trillion out of its general fund over this timeframe.
MEDICARE 101:
WHAT IS MEDICARE1
Medicare, which was created in 1965, provides healthcare coverage for
individuals in the United States who are 65 and older until their death. In
1972, the program was expanded to provide healthcare for the disabled
who are under 65 years old. In 2006, the program was expanded for a
third time to provide prescription drug coverage for eligible participants (Pp.
249-250).
In 2010, 47.5 million individuals were covered by Medicare (P. 4). According
to the 2010 Census, the U.S. population stands at 308 million2. This means
that over 15% of the U.S. population is currently covered by Medicare.
MEDICARE IS MADE UP OF FOUR KEY PARTS:
A B DC
MEDICARE PART A
funded by federal payroll taxes3 on earnings, Medicare Part A
provides in-patient hospital care and other related services. Funds collected
from taxes go into the Medicare Hospital Trust Fund. For retired individuals
who paid into the system4, there are no premium costs for this service. Cur-
rently, the Medicare payroll tax taxes earnings at “…1.45 percent for em-
ployees and employers, each. The self-employed pay 2.9 percent (P. 257).
“According to the trustees, this “…fund is not adequately financed over the
next 10 years” (P. 4).
MEDICARE PART B
funded by healthcare premiums—monthly payments of the individ-
uals enrolled in the program—and government money (in 2010, nearly 73%
of the total funding came from government money collected from general
federal taxes). Covers doctor appointment costs and other related services.
In 2011, the Part B monthly premium for most beneficiaries is approximately
$1005.
Medicare Parts A and B are considered “traditional” and “fee-for-service”
Medicare.
MEDICARE PART C (i.e., “Medicare Advantage”)
funded by money from Medicare Parts A and B, Medicare Part C
is private insurance approved by Medicare that is contracted “…to provide
Part A and Part B health services” (P. 4). These plans may include prescrip-
tion drug coverage as well. The premiums vary greatly based upon the plan
selected. There are many different options to choose from. For example,
some Medicare Advantage plans may have the cost of a gym membership
included while others may not. In general, such features are reflected in the
price6.
A
B
C
If you have Medicare Part C, you do not have Medicare Part A or B but you
may have Medicare Part D.
MEDICARE PART D
funded by healthcare premiums and government money (in 2010,
nearly 83% of the total funding came from government money collected from
general federal taxes). The plan “pays private plans to provide prescription
drug coverage” (P. 253). Like Medicare Part C, there are many different
options to choose from. In 2011, the average Part D monthly premium is
approximately $407.
MEDICARE HOSPITAL COVERAGE is Medicare Part A. It receives funds
from the Medicare payroll tax (and trust fund reserves), which are used to
pay for in-patient hospital care and other related services (P. 252).
What is a trust fund? A trust fund is a separate account maintained by the
Department of Treasury, which “…may be used only for a specified purpose”
(P. 259). For the Medicare Trust Fund, money that is not used for current
benefits and administrative costs are invested in basic government bonds,
which earn interest for the trust fund (P. 259).
If changes are not made to the program, there will be significant disruptions
in care because not enough money will exist in the program. According to
the trustees, this “…fund is not adequately financed over the next 10 years”
(P. 4). The trustees now estimate that this trust fund will run out of funds in
13-years, five-years earlier than was projected in last year’s report (P. 4).
What happens if the fund goes insolvent? No one knows for sure. “Neither
the Social Security Trust Fund nor the Medicare Trust Fund has ever run out of
money and there are no provisions…governing what would happen in such
event9.”
D
Here are just the facts: in 2010, there were about 3.4 workers paying into
the Medicare Part A system for every beneficiary. In 2030, projections are
there will be 2.3 workers paying into the system for every beneficiary. By
2085, there is expected to be only 2.0 workers per beneficiary (P. 80).
According to the trustees, the current unfunded obligation for Medicare Part
A over the next 75-years is $3 trillion (P. 83).
Currently, the trust fund has $272 billion in funds (P. 4). In 2010, since less
was taken in from Medicare taxes than was paid in benefits, Medicare was
forced to redeem $32.3 billion from its trust fund. In past years, when there
was excess Medicare taxes not used to paid benefits, the remaining funds
were invested in special U.S. government bonds. Like the Social Security
Trust fund, the money from the Medicare Trust fund was used by the govern-
ment for whatever expenses it had at the time. In other words, this means
that the government spent the ‘surplus’ money as soon as it received the
money for general government operations and Medicare, in return, received
a U.S. government bond that earns interest.
MEDICARE 201:
WHAT’S THE REAL STORY WITH MEDICARE’S OTHER FINANCES10
According to the trustees, Medicare Parts B and D are “…adequately fi-
nanced over the next 10 years and beyond…” (Pp. 4–5).
However, this statement is misleading when put in context. In 2010,
73-percent of the costs of Part B came directly from funds the United
States collects in general taxes (109). Likewise in 2010, 83-percent
of the costs of Part D came directly from funds the United States
collects in general taxes (P. 134). Exactly how the government funds
Parts B and D are complex formulas; however, the federal govern
ment is the primary contributor for the costs and will continue to be
so in the future if the law remains unchanged. Therefore, to conclude
that Parts B and D are actuarially strong would be a grave mistake.
Unlike Medicare Part A, which collects the Medicare payroll tax and
has a trust fund for the excess funds it does not spend on benefits,
Medicare Parts B and D rely every year on general federal govern
ment funding, which is not tied to the Medicare payroll tax.
In 2010, general government funds contributed $153.5
billion for Part B (p. 109). According to the trustees, the
current cost for Part B for the next 75-years is $18.9 trillion
(P. 130). In this calculation, the trustees assumed that 73
percent of Part B will be paid for by the federal government
for the indefinite future.
In 2010, general government funds contributed $51.1
billion for Part D (p. 134). According to the trustees, the
current cost for Part D over the next 75-years is $9.9 trillion
(P. 146). In this calculation, the trustees assumed that 75
percent of Part D will be paid for by the federal government
for the indefinite future.
This equals $24.2 trillion in unfunded federal government
liabilities for Medicare over the next 75-years.
Additionally, the Trustees report is flawed because it does not take
into account the blocking of the sustainable growth rate (“SGR”) formula.
The sustainable growth rate formula was enacted to control
Medicare spending in the Balanced Budget Act of 1997. If fully
implemented, SGR would ‘control’ Medicare spending by ‘control
ling’ what doctors are paid for certain Medicare services (Pp. 212-213).
Congress routinely blocks the sustainable growth rate formula on a
“temporary basis.” The current block last until January 1, 2012.
Why temporary? Because it “costs” so much to eliminate the SGR
on a permanent basis. Therefore, Congress prefers blocking it on a
short-term basis.
If enacted in 2012, payments to doctors for certain Medicare services
would immediately fall by 29.4 percent (P. 213). If this were to hap-
pen, many believe that a large amount of doctors would stop seeing
Medicare patients altogether.
Because it is almost certain to be “temporarily extended” beyond
January 1, 2012, the trustees note that the future costs for Medicare
are likely to surpass those shown by the current estimates in the report
(P. 17).
Medicare Part C is funded by Part A and Part B trust funds (P. 192). Medi-
care Part C is private insurance that is contracted “…to provide Part A and
Part B health services” (P. 4). Of the 47.5 million individuals were covered
by Medicare in 2010, 25 percent, chose Part C (P. 4). In 2010, Part A paid
$60.7 billion and Part B paid $55.2 for Medicare Part C (P. 199).
1 In general, unless otherwise noted, information in this section is found in the 2011 Annual Report of the Boards of Trustees
of the Federal Hospital Insurance Fund and Federal Supplemental Medical Insurance Trust Funds. https://www.cms.gov/
ReportsTrustFunds/downloads/tr2011.pdf
2 http://2010.census.gov/news/releases/operations/cb10-cn93.html
3 For the purposes of this document, “payroll tax” also includes Medicare self-employment taxes, which are triggered if you
work for yourself instead of an employer.
4 In general, for the purposes of being “paid into the system,” it means working 10 or more years. https://questions.medi-
care.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/2305/~/medicare-premiums-and-coinsurance-rates-for-2011
5 https://questions.medicare.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/2306
6 This information was found by researching various Medicare Part C policies on the internet.
7 Kaiser Family Foundation. “Medicare Part D Spotlight.” http://www.kff.org/medicare/upload/8107.pdf
8 In general, unless otherwise noted, information in this section is found in the 2011 Annual Report of the Boards of Trustees
of the Federal Hospital Insurance Fund and Federal Supplemental Medical Insurance Trust Funds. https://www.cms.gov/
ReportsTrustFunds/downloads/tr2011.pdf
9 CRS. “Medicare: History of Part A Trust Fund Insolvency Projections.” May 2009. Pg. 3. http://aging.senate.gov/crs/
medicare14.pdf
10 In general, unless otherwise noted, information in this section is found in the 2011 Annual Report of the Boards of Trustees
of the Federal Hospital Insurance Fund and Federal Supplemental Medical Insurance Trust Funds. https://www.cms.gov/
ReportsTrustFunds/downloads/tr2011.pdf
OVERVIEW
Just the Facts: A Summary of Findings
Social Security 101: What is Social Security
Social Security 201: The Truth about its Finances
Two Prominent Views on the State of Social Security
JUST THE FACTS: A SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
Social Security’s retiree income trust fund, which collects Social Security pay-
roll taxes1 and pays for retirees’ income, will run out of funds in 2036, which
is one-year earlier than was projected in last year’s trustees report.
Social Security’s disability income trust fund, which pays disabled workers a
supplemental income, will run out of funds in seven years.
According to the trustees, the current unfunded obligation for Social Security
over the next 75 years is $6.5 trillion.
SOCIAL SECURITY 101: WHAT IS SOCIAL SECURITY2
Social Security was created in 1935. In general, the program creates a
“basic level of monthly income” once an individual reaches normal retirement
IN THE SPOTLIGHT:social security
age until their death. In 2011, the average Social Security payment for a
retired person is $1,177 per month3. In 1939, the program was extended
to give certain benefits for family members when a parent or spouse who
works dies. In 1956, the program was extended again to provide income
for disabled workers (and their dependents) who are unable, or partly un-
able, to work due to a disability.
In 2010, 54 million individuals were covered by Social Security4. Accord-
ing to the 2010 Census, the U.S. population stands at 308 million5. This
means that nearly 18-percent of the U.S. population is currently covered
by Social Security. Since the program has more retirees being added to
the system and less and less workers paying into it, legislative changes are
required to keep Social Security operating without substantial disruptions to
the program6.
Here are the facts: from 1974 – 2008, there were between 3.2 and 3.4
workers paying Social Security taxes for every beneficiary. In 2010, there
were 2.9 workers paying Social Security taxes for every beneficiary. By
2035, projections are there will be 2.1 workers for every beneficiary7. With
individuals living longer lives than they did in 1935 when the program was
created, and with fewer workers paying into the system due to lower birth-
rates, the system is going broke.
An individual qualifies for Social Security retirement benefits if they work
at least 10-years while contributing to the program with Social Security
payroll taxes. Currently, the Social Security taxes earnings at 6.2 percent
for employees and employers, each. The self-employed pay 12.4 percent8.
The Social Security payroll tax only taxes earnings up to $106,8009. Social
Security also is financed by income taxes on Social Security benefits and in-
terest income earned from the trust fund. To get full Social Security benefits,
you have to reach the normal retirement age. For those born in 1937
or earlier, the normal retirement age in 65. This age is gradually increasing
over time to 67, which will apply for those born in 1960 and the proceeding
years. Individuals can opt to get early retirement benefits at 62; however,
their benefits are permanently reduced. Exact benefits are calculated by
using a complex benefit formula. The benefit formula provides more benefits
relative to wages for low-income earners while providing high-income earn-
ers a degree of equity since they have higher lifetime earning.
SOCIAL SECURITY 201: THE TRUTH ABOUT ITS FINANCES10
Social Security receives its funding from the Social Security payroll tax.
These payroll taxes are deposited into separate trust fund accounts in the De-
partment of Treasury. For excess funds not immediately spent to pay bene-
fits, these funds are invested in special U.S. government bonds (P. 221). From
1984 until 2010, the Social Security payroll tax made a surplus, meaning
more money was taken in through taxes than was paid out in benefits (Pp.
142-143). By law, when the program was running a surplus, the surplus
was “…credited to the Social Security trust funds in the form of U.S. govern-
ment securities. The money itself, however, [was] used to pay for whatever
other expenses the government…” had at the time11. In other words, this
means that the government spent the ‘surplus’ money as soon as it received it
for general government operations and Social Security, in return, received a
U.S. government bond that earns interest.
SOCIAL SECURITY HAS TWO SEPARATE TRUST FUNDS:
OLD-AGE AND SURVIVORS INSURANCE TRUST FUND (com-
monly referred to in the public as the “Social Security
Trust Fund”)—pays retirement income for qualified
retirees (and their dependents) (Pp. 222). Is expected to
run out of funds by 2036, one-year earlier than originally
projected in last year’s trustees report.
1
DISABILITY INSURANCE TRUST FUND—pays income for dis-
abled workers (and their dependents) who are unable, or
partly unable, to work due to a disability (Pp. 222). This
fund is expected to drain its fund by the year 2018.
At the end of 2010, the balance of both Social Security Trust Funds is $2.6
trillion. According to the trustees, the current unfunded obligation for Social
Security over the next 75 years is $6.5 trillion (P. 12).
TWO PROMINENT VIEWS ON THE STATE OF SOCIAL SECURITY12
How bad is the financial situation with Social Security? Is the money in the
trust fund really there? Well, it depends how you view the situation. Here are
two different takes:
Senator Sanders of Vermont: “…We keep hearing that the Social Security
trust fund has a pile of worthless IOUs. The fact is, Social Security invests the
surplus money it receives from workers, from the payroll tax, into U.S. Gov-
ernment bonds, the same bonds China or anybody else purchases. These
bonds are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. Government. And
in our entire history—and many of us want to make sure this continues—the
U.S. Government has never defaulted on its debt obligations. The point is,
to say these are worthless IOUs is not dissimilar to saying: Guess what. Be-
cause we have a deep deficit and a deep national debt, we don’t have any
money to fund equipment for soldiers who are in the field in Afghanistan
or Iraq. They are just worthless IOUs, and we can’t fund them. That is, of
course, nonsense.”
Senator Coburn of Oklahoma: “…The flaw in the argument given by my col-
league from Vermont (Senator Sanders) is the assumption that the IOU at the
Treasury for Social Security is good. It is good as long as people will loan
2
us money. It is not any good if they will not. …And having looked at every
aspect of Social Security, I can tell you if we are not able to borrow the $2.6
trillion, the benefits will not be there. The money has been stolen. There is
no trust fund. There is no money there. Congresses, under both Republi-
can and Democratic control, both Republican and Democratic Presidencies,
have stolen money from Social Security and spent it. The money is gone.
…The question is, does this Congress owe… [it] back to Social Security?
Yes. But where do we get the money to repay it?”
1 For the purposes of this document, “payroll tax” also includes Social Security self-employment taxes, which are triggered if you work for yourself instead of an employer.
2 In general, unless otherwise noted, information in this section is found in the GAO Social Security Reform Answers to Key Ques-tions. May 2005. http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05193sp.pdf
3 http://ssa-custhelp.ssa.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/13/~/average-monthly-social-security-benefit-for-a-retired-worker
4 2011 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Funds. P. 2. http://www.ssa.gov/oact/tr/2011/tr2011.pdf.
5 http://2010.census.gov/news/releases/operations/cb10-cn93.html
6 Status of the Social Security and Medicare Programs, A Summary of the 2011 Annual Reports. Social Security and Medicare Board of Trustees. http://www.ssa.gov/oact/trsum/index.html
7 2011 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Funds. P. 10. http://www.ssa.gov/oact/tr/2011/tr2011.pdf.
8 http://www.ssa.gov/oact/progdata/taxRates.html
9 http://www.ssa.gov/oact/COLA/cbb.html#Series
10 In general, unless otherwise noted, information in this section is found in 2011 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Fed-eral Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Funds. http://www.ssa.gov/oact/tr/2011/tr2011.pdf.10 In general, unless otherwise noted, the information contained in this section is found in the Status of the Social Security and Medi-care Programs, A Summary of the 2011 Annual Reports. http://www.ssa.gov/oact/tr/2011/tr2011.pdf.
11 CRS. “Social Security: Trust Fund Investment Practices.” October 2010. http://aging.senate.gov/crs/ss5.pdf
12 Congressional Record – Senate. March 16, 2011. Accessible by searching http://thomas.loc.gov/home/LegislativeData.php?&n=Record.
“The biggest threat to our national security is our debt.” – Admiral Mike Mullen, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff1
“It is no secret that the United States faces a serious fiscal predicament that
could turn into a crisis—of credit, of confidence, of our position in the world
– if not addressed soon…as a matter of simple arithmetic and political real-
ity, the Department of Defense must at least be part of the solution.” – Robert
Gates, Secretary of Defense (2006-2011)2
Washington’s unsustainable spending threatens the economy, the nation’s
credit standing in the world3, and is making the country less secure over
time. The fact is that as the U.S. debt continues to grow, it makes the United
States more beholden to foreign countries, such as China, that finance the
United States’ growing appetite for spending.
DEFENSE: A DRIVER OF FEDERAL DEBT
If President Obama’s 2012 budget for defense is enacted into law, next year’s
national defense spending would consume 20-percent of total government
spending4. Since 2001, funding for defense programs has doubled5. Cur-
rently, no other nation comes close to matching the United States in defense
capabilities or spending.
4 5
DEFENSE SPENDING:How Bloated Spending is Hurting our Nation’s Security
DEFENSE SPENDING:How Bloated Spending is Hurting our Nation’s Security
Last year, Washington spent $700 billion on defense, which represents
43-percent of total defense spending among all countries in the world.6
For government spending in 2011 that is not automatically funded (such as
Social Security spending), many areas of government saw a modest spend-
ing decrease. This was not so for defense spending. In fact, Congress
raised the defense budget by approximately $5.7 billion dollars. 7
THE CONFLICT
While no one questions the need to protect and support our troops in con-
flict, the question arises: should Washington pursue further military commit-
ments and projects, or focus on the level of current debt so that tomorrow’s
troops will have the tools they need?
The U.S. has overstretched itself with defense spending commitments. Currently,
the United States is fighting two major conflicts in foreign countries, retains
troops in countries throughout the world, and is involved in peacekeeping
and nation building missions across the globe. The simple fact is that the
U.S. level of debt is so heavy, it cannot afford to keep defense spending off
the table when it comes to debt reduction8. “The U.S. Government’s ambi-
tions now outstrip its capacities… abroad” in respect to defense spending9.
1 Joint Chiefs of Staff: National Debt Poses Security Threat, Mullen Says. http://www.jcs.mil/newsarticle.aspx?ID=360
2 The American: Gates at AEI: Strategy Must Drive Budget Decisions. May 24, 2011. http://blog.american.com/2011/05/
gates-at-aei-strategy-must-drive-budget-decisions/
3 Foreign Affairs: A Leaner, Meaner Defense. January/February 2011. http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/67145/
gordon-adams-and-matthew-leatherman/a-leaner-and-meaner-defense
4 OMB: President’s FY12 Budget. February 2011. http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/Overview/
5 Foreign Affairs: A Leaner, Meaner Defense. January/February 2011. http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/67145/
gordon-adams-and-matthew-leatherman/a-leaner-and-meaner-defense
6 Stockholm International Peace Research Institute: Military Expenditure Database. http://www.sipri.org/databases/milex
7 OMB: President’s FY12 Budget. February 2011. http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/Overview/
CQ Weekly: 2012 Appropriations – Defense: Parties Unite to Increase Pentagon Budget. May 30, 2011. http://www.cq.com/
doc/weeklyreport-3879408?wr=U2ZyOGV0Ymg1TTNTcnVnN2hZdip0Zw
8 Foreign Affairs: A Leaner, Meaner Defense. January/February 2011. http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/67145/
gordon-adams-and-matthew-leatherman/a-leaner-and-meaner-defense
9 Foreign Affairs: A Leaner, Meaner Defense. January/February 2011. http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/67145/
gordon-adams-and-matthew-leatherman/a-leaner-and-meaner-defense
STATE FACT SHEETS:How Does Your State’s Budget Fare?
STATE FACT SHEETS:How Does Your State’s Budget Fare?
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.2 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $3,659,407,996
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
The Natural Resources Conservation Service received $145 million
for watershed operations and flood protection in financially dis
tressed counties. Instead, $59 million went to counties with unem-
ployment below the national average. Montgomery received $2
million to investigate converting the city’s garbage into gas.
ALABAMA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $24.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $586 million, or 8.3% of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $979 million, or 13.9% of the budget
Pension Liability & % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $41,634,55, 74% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,433 houses
F ISCAL PROMISES
GOV. ROBERT BENTLEY (R)
“We are in challenging economic times and state govern-
ment must do what every Alabama family is doing right
now and that is find ways to cut back on spending. The
Alabama Commission on Improving State Government will
take an in-depth look at the current cost structure of every
state agency and look for new and effective ways to cut
costs without cutting essential services.”
ALASKA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $9.7 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): No state sales tax
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: No deficit
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: No deficit projected
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$15,347,768, 61% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 3.5 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.4 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,710 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3.2 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,190,583,809
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The Federal Aviation Administration allocated $15 million to re-
place Ouzinkie Airport, which averages less than 2 flights a day.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. SEAN PARNELL (R)
“I have already met with legislative leadership and many
members here to express my willingness to work together to
restrain government spending. I have asked the leaders, gath-
ered in these chambers, to establish a spending limit with me
early in session so together we can avoid the spending frenzy
at the end of session.”
ARIZONA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $27.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 4.54 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 9.3 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $3.1 billion, or 36.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit:
$974 million, or 11.5 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$44,078,394, 78% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.9 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.1 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 210 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $6,419,642,484
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
$1.5 million was slated to change 400 road signs from kilometers to
miles. Residents in the relatively unpopulated southern corridor think
the change will cause confusion.
Researchers at the University of Arizona received $314,964 to
examine what happened after the Big Bang and to develop a course
in astronomy for non- astronomy majors at the University of Cape
Coast in Ghana.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JAN BREWER (R)
“[W]e intend to leave Arizona with a budget that is balanced; fueled
by private enterprise, unencumbered by heavy regulations and un-
necessary rules.”
ARKANSAS
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $20.2 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 7 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: No deficit
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: No deficit projected
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$22,698,906, 78% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 0.6 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.8 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 907 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $7.1 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,335,526,961
Example of Stimulus Spending: The federal government spent
$1,047 to purchase a riding mower from the Toro Company to
cut the grass at the Fayetteville National Cemetery.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. MIKE BEEBE (D)
“If we are to retain the enviable national position we now
hold, we must remain cautious and conservative. … We will
balance our budget and serve as a model for fiscal responsibility in
difficult times. We will take the steps necessary to make our govern-
ment more efficient and more cost-effective.”
CALIFORNIA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $217.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 9.3 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 8.25 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $17.9 billion, or 20.7 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit:
$25.4 billion1, or 29.3 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$490,585,000, 81% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 11.7 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 259 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $95.4 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $30,098,137,607
Example of Stimulus Spending: The National Institute of Health re-
ceived $823,200 to study the effects of a genital-washing program
in Orange Farm, South Africa.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JERRY BROWN (D)
“When dealing with a budget gap in the tens of billions, I must point
out that it is far more than waste and inefficiency that we have to
take out. Yes, government wastes money—and I will be doing a lot
about that.”
COLORADO
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $29 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 4.63 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 2.9 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1.5 billion, or 21.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit:
$988 million, or 13.8 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$54,536,549, 69% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -0.9 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.7 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 518 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $8.9 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $5,474,644,414
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
Colorado liquor distilleries, breweries, and wineries received $5 million
in loans. Over a one year period, Colorado spent $247,000 on
road signs to designate which construction projects were funded by
the stimulus. An effort to prevent the state from posting more signs failed.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JOHN HICKENLOOPER (D)
“We view our task in three parts: making the hard decisions to
balance the annual budget; improving how we spend the money
we have; and restoring structural balance to our spending and tax
rules. We cannot fix all of these items this year or even in this build-
ing. But a long-term plan is critical to Colorado’s future.”
CONNECTICUTBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $26.1 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6.5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $5.1 billion, or 28.8 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $3.2 billion, or 18 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $41,311,400,
62% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.1 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,130 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3.1 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,489,621,777
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
The Mohegan Tribe of Indians will get $54 million in rural develop-
ment loans to build a four-story tribal government center, which will
include a new community center and a practice facility for the Con-
necticut Sun, the state’s WNBA team.
Perry Hill School in Shelton received $176,000 for a “green” cool-
ing system even though renovations are $1.5 million over budget
and dozens of employees, including 27 teachers, have been laid off.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. DAN MALLOY (D)
“In the coming weeks and months, you will hear a lot about reduc-
ing the size of government, from the size of my office, to the number
of state agencies. And not just cutting for cutting sake, but re-conceiving
government so that better decisions are made and implemented faster.”
DELAWAREBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $8.7 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6.95 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): No state sales tax
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit:
$377 million, or 11.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit:
$208 million, or 6.3 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$7,615,166, 94% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.8 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 609 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $1.6 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,003,466,721
Example of Stimulus Spending:
A juice importer received $15.5 million to build new apple juice
storage tanks.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JACK MARKELL (D)
“[W]hile next year’s budget requires our immediate attention, we
must not govern only for the short term. We are here to make our
State better for generations to come. Many of the most important
budget savings – the type that last – require action this year but will
not produce significant savings for the next budget. To reduce the
size of government in a thoughtful way, we will look past the next
fiscal year.”
FLORIDABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $66.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $4.7 billion, or 19.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $3.6 billion, or 14.9 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $141,485,280,
84% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.4 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 10.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 461 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $22.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $11,039,520,913
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
Florida received $3.4 million to build a tunnel for turtles to pass
under a highway.
Dry Tortugas National Park received $13.3 million to repair its
main above-water attraction, Fort Jefferson, which is located 70
miles off shore, almost entirely underwater, and accessible only by
airplane, private boat, or ferry.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. RICK SCOTT (R)
“[W]e’ve got to reduce state spending and we’ve got to weed out
unnecessary regulations that hinder job growth. … I took the first of
many steps to reduce government spending by taking steps to sell
the two state owned and operated airplanes that currently cost us
$2.4 million a year to operate. We are creating the best climate for
job creation by making the government smaller and less intrusive.”
GEORGIABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $38.6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $4.2 billion, or 25.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.3 billion, or 7.9 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009):
$79,898,410, 87% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.8 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 387 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $13.1 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $6,701,811,083
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Atlanta received $47.6 million for a $72 million, 2.62-mile streetcar
project in downtown. The Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Author-
ity already covers the area.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. NATHAN DEAL (R)
“I am proposing that State Agencies reduce their spending on an
average of 4 percent. ... We are now entering a new era of smaller
government and greater personal responsibility. Government must
pull back, but Georgians and our strong communities, big and
small, have what it takes to fill the gap. Our State’s fortunes do not
rise and fall with the size of government.”
HAWAIIBUDGET :
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $10.9 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 11 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $594 million, or 11.8 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $410 million, or 8.2 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $16,549,069,
69% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.5 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 573 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $2.4 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,466,657,631
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The University of Hawaii received $210,000 to study how honey-
bees learn.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. NEIL ABERCROMBIE (D)
“We will forge understandings, develop creative solutions and make
changes to the budget in ways that reflect our common values and
best serve the people of Hawaii. It won’t be easy. There will be nec-
essary sacrifices that all of us must share to move us all forward.”
IDAHOBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $7.1 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 7.8 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $84 million, or 3.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $92 million, or 3.9 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $12,057,500,
74% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.4 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 460 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,698,994,560
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Heyburn State Park rented 540 goats, at a price tag of $4,950, for
invasive weed management.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BUTCH OTTER (R)
“It all begins with us – the individual – and how we decide to fulfill
the role of being our brother’s keeper … along with responsibly
balancing our budget, there is no task before us more important
than improving Idaho’s economy. That does not mean government
spending. It means stability. It means predictability. And it means
keeping more money in the hands of the people whose innovation
and enterprise actually creates those career opportunities.”
I LL INOISBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $47.4 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.25 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $13.5 billion, or 40.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $4.9 billion, or 14.6 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $126,435,510,
51% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.4 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.9 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 500 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $14.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $11,522,709,068
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Northwestern University received $712,883 to develop a model of
machine-generated humor. The project will “create intelligent come-
dic performance agents and deploy them both on- and off-line for
the enjoyment and illumination of everyday citizens.”
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. PAT QUINN (D)
“We will strengthen our economy. We will do that and we will do
that very, very soon. I command all of both parties to work together
to reach a point where I believe we can enact very quickly a sound
budget, a balanced budget, that pays the bills of the stay Illinois,
that pays our obligations and also makes sure that our economy is
strong for today and in the future.”
INDIANABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $26.7 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 3.4 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 7 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1.3 billion, or 9.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $270 million, or 2 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $36,924,845,
67% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.6 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.2 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 887 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.3 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $4,559,536,417
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The Purdue University Airport in West Lafayette received $665,000
to replace its eight-foot perimeter fence with an 11-foot fence to
prevent animal strike incidents. The airport has reported only 14
such incidents since 1990.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. MITCH DANIELS (R)
“We will take the actions necessary to limit state spending to the
funds available. We will protect struggling taxpayers against the
additional burden of higher taxes. We will continue improving our
jobs climate by holding the line on taxes as our competitors take the
easy way and let theirs rise. We say tonight, whatever course others
may choose, here in Indiana we live within our means, we put the
private sector ahead of government, the taxpayer ahead of every-
one, and we will stay in the black, whatever it takes.”
IOWABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $18.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 8.98 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1.1 billion, or 20.3 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $186 million, or 3.5 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $26,602,516,
81% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -0.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 878 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $6.6 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,157,248,244
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Iowa state legislators used $11 million to buy new cars for the state
vehicle fleet even though nearly four dozen of the state’s existing
cars haven’t even been used.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. TERRY BRANSTAD (R)
“[W]e have too much government—state, county, city, school, lo-
cal—and it must be reduced. For too long, we have papered over
the fact that our appetite for government exceeds our pocket book
to pay for it. As my 86-year-old dad, Edward, who is with us today
would say, ‘Our eyes are bigger than our wallet.’ Our auditor tells
us that at least 15% must be permanently eliminated from govern-
ment to make our books balance once and for all. And I aim to
make sure we do it and do it now. We will all share in the sacrifice,
while protecting those who need our help. But we will remove the
lead boots of excess government from our economy. And without
that burden, we will be able to run like the wind in the race to
prosperity.”
KANSASBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $14.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6.45 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.3 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $510 million, or 9.1 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $492 million, or 8.8 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $21,138,206,
64% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,473 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $4.5 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,405,519,187
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The Kansas legislature authorized $39.7 million in Build America
Bonds for the statehouse renovation, which includes upgraded office
space and indoor parking for Kansas politicians.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. SAM BROWNBACK (R)
“Growing the Kansas economy is my first priority. We must take
bold steps today to create economic growth tomorrow. In saying
this, however, let me be clear; we cannot government-program or
borrow our way into a stronger state economy. We cannot hope for
the best and paper over the worst.”
KENTUCKYBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $25.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $780 million, or 9.1 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $780 million2, or 9.1 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $35,686,737,
58% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.8 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.8 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,777 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.5 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $3,493,455,387
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$357,710 was used to repair the Fitchburg Furnace stonework and
allow historians to conduct research.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. STEVE BESHEAR (D)
“I’ve cut more than a billion dollars in state spending in three years
and shrunk the state workforce to the smallest it’s been in a genera-
tion. And I’ve balanced this budget eight times without raising any
broad-based taxes on Kentucky families and businesses.”
LOUISIANABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $29.6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1 billion, or 12.9 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.6 billion, or 20.7 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $39,657,924,
60% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 2.5 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.2 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,070 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $14.8 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $3,364,665,037
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The city of Shreveport used $1.5 million on mold remediation for a
housing complex it was considering for demolition.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BOBBY J INDAL (R)
“In Washington, the answer always seems to be more borrowing,
more spending, and higher taxes. ... In Louisiana, we’re doing
more with less…. By working to right-size state government, we’ve
reduced the number of government positions by more than 6,300
since entering office. The budget for the current fiscal year is $4.2
billion less than the last fiscal year … we cannot hide from the
challenges we face. That’s why our budget challenges will require
sacrifice, and no government agency or program is off limits when
it comes to reducing the size of government.”
MAINEBUDGET :
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $8.3 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 8.5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $940 million, or 34.7 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $436 million, or 16.1 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $14,410,000,
73% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.3 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.7 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 2,649 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING :
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3.2 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,373,641,613
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$102 million in funds was used to pay down hospital debt stemming
from services provided to Medicaid patients.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. PAUL LEPAGE (R)
“The taxpayers tired of footing the bill for a bloated establishment
in Augusta. It is time to make state government accountable. It is
time to deliver value. It is time to put people first. … While we have
a generous spirit in Maine, we do not have limitless resources. Our
programs have to be focused on Maine residents, we must make
every effort to move people from dependency to self-sufficiency and
we must have a tiered system that rewards work and progress.”
MARYLANDBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $33.4 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5.5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $2 billion, or 15.3 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.4 billion, or 10.7 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $53,054,565,
65% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 0 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.8 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,301 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $9.8 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $6,260,568,791
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$30,000 has been granted to University of Maryland researchers to
study the effects of methamphetamine on the sex drives of female rats.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. MARTIN O’MALLEY (D)
“With tough but fiscally responsible choices, we cut $5.6 billion in
state spending and reduced the size of our government. As we look
ahead, we know these next four years will not be easy. Unemploy-
ment and foreclosures remain unacceptably high, wages remain
stagnant, and our national recovery has only just begun. We have a
long way to go. None of us has all the answers, but you and I rightly
sense what is at stake right now.”
MASSACHUSETTSBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $53.4 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5.3 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.25 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $2.7 billion, or 8.6 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.8 billion, or 5.7 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $61,140,335,
68% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.6 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,124 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING :
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $5.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $7,050,752,553
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
The Federal Emergency Management Agency provided a tour boat
company with a $43,214 terrorism prevention grant.
The Massachusetts Institute of Technology was awarded $435,271 to
develop iPod Touch or smartphone apps to teach introductory biol-
ogy to high school students.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. DEVAL PATRICK (D)
“Our budget reflects the difficult economic times. Already during this
recession, we have solved a budget gap of more than $12 billion.
That has meant that we have cut many worthy programs and ser-
vices, eliminated over 2600 state jobs, frozen or cut wages, negoti-
ated concessions from state employee unions, squeezed efficiencies
out of every corner of government, and passed important reforms to
save millions.”
MICHIGANBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $45.7 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 4.35 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $2 billion, or 9.3 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.3 billion, or 5.9 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $72,911,900,
79% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -5.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 10.3 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 311 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $19.2 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $8,646,112,562
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
$3.8 million was appropriated for the Old Tiger Stadium Con-
servancy – a group dedicated to finding a new use for the Detroit
Tigers’ former stadium.
$7.5 million was used to construct a new terminal with stone fire-
places and exposed log beams in a tiny northern Michigan airport.
The airport serves an average of only 72 departing passengers a
day.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. RICK SNYDER (R)
“What we’re talking about today should have happened decades
ago, generations ago. It’s absolutely critical that we have transpar-
ency and accountability in financial information. … This is not about
cutting yourself to prosperity. It’s not the time to cry ... to whine
about it. It’s time to go to work.”
MINNESOTABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $31.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 7.85 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.88 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $4 billion, or 25 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $3.8 billion, or 23.6 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $60,835,351,
77% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.3 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 829 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.4 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $4,027,997,387
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
Jefferson Lines received $2.85 million to purchase several new
luxury buses.
The city of Eagan matched a $1.34 million award for a ground
source heat pump system, which will serve the ice rink in the city’s
civic arena.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. MARK DAYTON (DFL)
“My second, urgent priority is to clean up the state’s financial mess,
a responsibility I will share with the new Legislature and, ultimately,
with all of you. Some people think eliminating a $6.2 billion deficit,
almost 20% of expected revenues, will be simple and easy. I don’t.
As my friend and former colleague, Senator Tom Harkin of Iowa,
likes to say, “For every complex problem, there’s almost always a
simple solution. And it’s almost always wrong. … My proposed
budget solution will be reasonable, balanced – and painful – be-
cause I see no easy alternative.”
MISSISSIPPIBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $19.4 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 7 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $716 million, or 15.9 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $634 million, or 14.1 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $31,386,747,
67% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -0.9 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 10.3 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 6,930 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $8.8 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,792,833,646
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Choctaw Central High School used $190,000 to paint a metal
canopy at the school’s baseball field and to repair and replace a
retaining wall behind the school’s concession stand.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. HALEY BARBOUR (R)
“Despite the worst recession in generations and a steep drop in
revenue, we’ve kept our budget balanced by cutting spending and
without depleting all our reserves. ... I realize this is an election
year, and every penny of appropriated spending has a constitu-
ency. You will get pressure to spend more for this and spend more
for that. As Governor I have cut the budget by a total of about
$700 million in just the last two years. Just as our constituents have
cut back, they expect state government to cut back. They know the
alternative is raising taxes, because government has no money
except what it takes from taxpayers.”
MISSOURIBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $24.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4.23 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $730 million, or 9.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $704 million, or 9.1 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $55,314,996,
79% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.9 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,037 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $8.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $4,813,473,888
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The scientists at the University of Missouri received $180,935 to
develop freezing protocols for epididymal rat sperm.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JAY NIXON (D)
“[I] won’t be satisfied until all Missourians can provide for their
families. How will we do it? By fighting hard every day for every
job. By making government smarter and more efficient. By invest-
ing in strong communities to attract and keep good jobs, and by
balancing our budget without raising taxes. ... We will continue to
be aggressive and relentless, fighting every day for every job. And
we’ll continue to be aggressive and relentless in making government
smarter and more efficient. We’ve kept our fiscal house in order with
prudent financial controls, rigorous cost reductions, and smarter,
more efficient government … fiscal responsibility is a value we share
here in the Show-Me State. ... These decisions are never easy, but
they are necessary.”
MONTANABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6.9 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): No state sales tax
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: No deficit
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: No deficit projected
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $10,271,027,
74% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 0 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.3 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,919 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $2.9 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,544,976,466
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$260,112 went to New York artist Jason Middlebrook to construct a
public sculpture outside a not-yet-built federal courthouse in Billings,
Montana.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BRIAN SCHWEITZER (D)
“Montana expects us to get a few things and to get them right. First,
they expect you, this Legislature, to get a balanced budget back to
my office in 90 days. Second, this is important, they expect you to
reform a bloated, unworkable workers compensation system that is
fair for workers and helps small business start and grow in Mon-
tana. Third and this might be your most important task and if you
get it right it will create thousands of jobs in Montana, if you get it
wrong or you don’t finish it there will be pink slips that go to work-
ers across Montana.”
NEBRASKA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $9.6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6.84 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5.5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $329 million, or 9.7 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $314 million, or 9.2 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $9,427,370,
88% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 0.3 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 4.1 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 2,788 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,344,833,653
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$7 million in funds is being used to build a bridge in Thedford, a
town of 168 residents, to help avoid a 30 second wait at a local
train crossing.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. DAVE HEINEMAN (R)
“We wisely built up our cash reserve as a hedge against the slowing
national economy. We worked together to control the growth of
state spending and to pass balanced budgets without raising taxes.
We did this in spite of the fact that revenues in fiscal years 2009
and 2010 were less than fiscal year 2008. Now Nebraska is in bet-
ter shape than most of America. Together we built a strong founda-
tion for the future because we didn’t spend money we didn’t have
and while three-fourths of the states have raised taxes since 2008,
Nebraska has not.”
NEVADABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $7.9 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.85 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1.8 billion, or 54.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.5 billion, or 45.2 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $33,148,347,
72% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -6.4 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 12.1 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 103 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $2.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,215,052,864
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$2 million went to a fire station, which doesn’t actually have any
firefighters.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BRIAN SANDOVAL (R)
“I am calling on all branches of government to achieve efficiencies
at every turn so that we might spend less and serve more.”
NEW HAMPSHIREBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $5.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): State income tax limited to 5 perecent on
dividends and interest income only
Sales Tax Rate (2011): No state sales tax
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $365 million, or 27.2 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: Size unknown
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $8,475,062,
58% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 4.8 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 930 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $2.1 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $978,605,056
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$150,045 was used to preserve and resurface a bridge built in
1860 that doesn’t connect to any roads and ends with an eight-foot
dropoff.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JOHN LYNCH (D)
“To balance the budget, we must continue assessing how we pro-
vide every state government service – and decide what services we
should provide. But our reductions should not come at the expense
of our most vulnerable citizens. An important part of reaching that
goal will be continuing to reform state government and improve ef-
ficiency.”
NEW JERSEY:
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $49 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 8.97 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 7 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $10.7 billion, or 38.2 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $10.5 billion, or 37.4 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $134,928,225,
66% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.4 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.4 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 3,509 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $14 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $5,430,131,727
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Atlantic city used $276,000 to purchase playground equipment.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. CHRIS CHRISTIE (R)
“When I talk of controlling spending, I am doing it for a reason. I
am not proposing to cut spending just for cutting’s sake. I am fight-
ing this fight because we have to be truthful about what we can’t
afford—whether it is health and pension benefits, which are out
of line with the rest of the country, or a tunnel, which we can’t pay
for. I am asking for shared sacrifice so that when we leave here,
New Jersey will be more fiscally sound than when we got here. I am
asking for shared sacrifice in cutting what we don’t need so that we
can invest in what we absolutely do need.”
NEW MEXICOBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $14.4 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 4.9 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5.13 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $333 million, or 6.1 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $450 million, or 8.3 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $29,003362,
76% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.9 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,394 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $5.6 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,728,693,953
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$212 million will be used to finance a demolition project at the
Alamos National Laboratory.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. SUSANA MARTINEZ (R)
“We must tell New Mexicans the truth: our financial house is a mess
and it’s time we clean it up. ... In the past, New Mexico’s serious
budget problems have been papered over with unrealistic projec-
tions and temporary infusions of Federal stimulus dollars. This
allowed politicians to shirk responsibility and avoid tough decisions.
But I am here to tell the people of New Mexico that the days of kick-
ing the can down the road are over. … During difficult economic
times, balancing the budget is not easy, but how we choose to go
about the task is critical because our budget blueprint is a statement
about our values ... the truth is, the waste is there and it must be
eliminated …”
NEW YORKBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $130.9 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 8.97 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $8.5 billion, or 15.9 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $10 billion, or 18.7 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $146,733,000,
101% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -4.3 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.9 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 3,367 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $44.8 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $16,062,312,915
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
Columbia University received $112,437 to provide summer re-
search opportunities to three high school students and three college
students.
The Department of Health and Human Services used $25.8 million
for a contract with Ketchum, Inc. to help build consumer confidence
regarding electronic medical records.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. ANDREW CUOMO (D)
“We need to transform our budget…. We need to hold the line
on taxes, we need a state-spending cap and we need to close this
$10 billion gap without any borrowing. We need to transform the
budget process that we use in this state.”
N. CAROLINABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $31.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 7.75 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5.75 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $5.8 billion, or 30.6 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $2.4 billion, or 12.7 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $76,976,542,
97% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.7 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,584 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.5 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $7,597,408,120
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
The University of North Carolina at Charlotte received $762,372
to create a program called “Dance Draw” where UNCC dance
students wear wireless computer mice on their chests and wrists to
“draw” abstract geometric shapes on computers.The North Carolina
State University Insect Museum, which averages 44 visitors daily,
received $253,123.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BEVERLY PERDUE (D)
“My short session budget adjustments reflect a state facing con-
tinued fiscal challenges. Even as our economy is showing signs of
recovery, families across our state still worry about what the future
holds. Like businesses and families statewide, North Carolina
government is doing what it must do in these tough economic times
-- tightening its belt, scrutinizing every expenditure, and taking
care of the basics.”
N. DAKOTA :
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $4.7 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 4.86 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: No deficit
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: No deficit projected
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $4,475,800,
81% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 3.9 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 3.2 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 9,589 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $1.8 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,092,718,801
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The Audubon National Wildlife refuge received $6.1 million to
build a new administration and visitor center. The refuge averages
80 visitors a day.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JACK DALRYMPLE (R)
“I don’t mean to suggest that we are somehow immune to the na-
tion’s economic woes. It reaches us all, and as a state, we will have
174 million fewer dollars in federal funding in human services
alone. But in North Dakota — unlike most other states — we are
setting our own course and reaping the rewards of our hard work,
our careful fiscal management, our pro-business climate, and our
diversified economy.”
OHIOBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $57.6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5.925 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5.5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $3 billion3, or 11 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $3 billion4, or 11 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $171,194,371, 66% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.7 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 608 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $13 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $8,859,793,533
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Cincinnati’s John Weld Peck Federal Building received $34 million
for a “window makeover.”
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JOHN KASICH (R)
“First of all, you need to balance a budget and we’re cutting taxes
out here. We had a tax cut that went into place on January 1. We
will preserve it. We will balance the budget, and we will do it with
a reform-oriented restructuring attitude, number one. Number two,
regulatory reform. We’re going to get rid of silly rules and regula-
tions, involve the big, you know, the chambers of commerce, the
small business community and all of my cabinet directors know,
number one, it is jobs. So therefore, eliminate regulations.”
OKLAHOMABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $21.6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5.5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4.5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $725 million, or 13.7 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $500 million, or 9.4 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $34,815,244,
57% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 6.6 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 5.3 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 821 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.9 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $3,190,809,977
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The town of Boynton was given $89,298 to replace a quarter-mile
stretch of sidewalk that was replaced only five years ago.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. MARY FALLIN (R)
“Our state is now confronting yet another challenging budget year.
But with that challenge comes the opportunity to seriously examine
how we conduct the people’s business. It is time to ask the probing
questions, the “why” questions – why have we done it like this for
years and why can’t we consider a different approach – a new
approach – a modern approach. And, yes, we must be coura-
geous and willing to move forward each time we find a better way,
a better solution for the benefit of the people of Oklahoma. ... My
administration will be focused on creating jobs and growing our
state economy, not our state government.”
OREGONBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $27.9 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 11 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): No state sales tax
Total FY 2010 and 2011 Budget Deficit: $4.77 billion5
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.8 billion6, or 25 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $56,810,600,
86% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.4 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.3 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 756 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $8.3 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $3,297,752,294
Examples of Sti mulus Spending:
Eugene used $78,979 to add a last-minute public art installation
to a bridge project. Portland spent $900,000 on new bike signs,
despite having similar signs already in place.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. JOHN KITZHABER (D)
“[T]his is the legislative session when we stop kicking the
can down the road and start reshaping Oregon’s state
government. Instead of creating a budget that does less of
the same in the hopes that we will later be able to do more
of the same, I will be proposing a budget and structural
reforms that will do things differently….”
PENNSYLVANIABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $70.4 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 3.07 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $4.1 billion, or 16.2 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $4.2 billion, or 16.4 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $111,317,700,
81% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.4 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,849 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $29.4 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $9,467,557,136
Example of Stimulus Spending:
A local ice rink received $1 million for refurbishment.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. TOM CORBETT (R)
“We need good government. The people now demand it. And they
deserve it. We will lead the way toward a government that under-
stands that, just as families have found a way to live within their
means, it too must budget in a way that is responsible and honest, a
government that has the courage to find fiscal strength in restraint, a
government that shows compassion for those most in need and rec-
ognizes its citizens’ great investment, a government that must yield
them a hopeful, realistic return.”
RHODE ISLANDBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $8.2 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5.99 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 7 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $395 million, or 13.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $331 million, or 11.3 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $11,500,425,
59% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.8 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 10.9 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 802 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3.1 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,191,375,724
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$550,000 went to build a skateboard park, tennis courts, and bas-
ketball courts in Pawtucket.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. L INCOLN CHAFEE ( I )
“Our goal is a budget that provides adequate investments in state
services, fosters realistic expectations on the part of taxpayers, and
ensures fiscal stability that will allow existing businesses to thrive
and attract outside employers to bring good, high-paying jobs to
our state. Fiscal stability is essential for job creation and economic
growth.”
S. CAROLINABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $22.6 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 7 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1.3 billion, or 26.1 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $877 million, or 17.4 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $42,050,701,
69% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.5 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 10.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 703 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $10.1 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $4,637,467,676
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The South Carolina Department of Natural Resources received $1.7
million to improve the quality of an oyster habitat.
F ISCAL PROMISES
GOV. NIKKI HALEY (R)
“I believe that in order for the public to trust us, as we make deci-
sions that may be seen by some as unfair or even callous, we must
be honest with them: this budget year is going to hurt … we will
never again have such an opportunity to reform and correct the
spending habits and processes that have brought us to this dire
situation. This year has to be the year we make the tough but right
decisions so that, going forward, this process doesn’t hurt as much
as it does today.”
S. DAKOTABUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $3.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $102 million, or 8.8 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $127 million, or 10.9 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $7,494,895,
92% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 2.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 4.8 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 3,974 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $1.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,423,716,739
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Gavins Point National Fish Hatchery received $20,000 to be spent,
in part, on a new freezer to store fish sperm.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. DENNIS DAUGAARD (R)
“My budget proposal will clearly demonstrate, to you and to the
people of South Dakota, that if we truly want to balance our budget
without raising taxes, as I do, we must be prepared to make some
very difficult decisions. I intend to lead by example. The agencies
under the control of the governor will be cut by at least ten percent.
The governor’s office will be cut ten percent overall. Every member
of my cabinet has agreed to cut his or her salary by at least ten
percent. And I will be cutting my own salary by fifteen percent.”
TENNESSEEBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $29.1 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): State income tax of 6 percent on divi-
dends and interest income only
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 7 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1 billion, or 9.4 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: Size unknown
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $35,198,741,
90% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -3.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.7 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,170 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $12.9 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $5,968,095,821
Example of Stimulus Spending:
A $38.6 million construction project on Highway 66 forced busi-
nesses to lay off workers and trim operating hours. Rubble and
concrete barricades from the project were blocking business doors.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BILL HASLAM (R)
“As we slowly reverse the negative trends of the economic downturn
that gripped our state and nation, we will be diligent in watching
the weight of state government, going on a diet of efficiency and ef-
fectiveness. State government will live within its financial means, and
a Top to Bottom review will set priorities and establish measurable
goals. We face few easy alternatives in closing the budget gap and
balancing the budget – difficult choices face us. We will make the
right decisions that point us toward the future – while doing so with
a measure of compassion.”
TEXAS
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $97.9 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.25 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $4.6 billion, or 10.8 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $13.4 billion, or 31.5 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $155,679,204,
84% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -1.5 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 1,074 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $38 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $16,723,827,903
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The city of Euless received $454,200 in funds to replace lighting at
its Softball World facility.
F ISCAL PROMISES
GOV. RICK PERRY (R)
“[F]or the good of the 25 million pioneers we call Texans, for a
people who work hard to get ahead – we must balance our budget
without raising their taxes … We will protect them, support them
and empower them, but cannot risk the future of millions of taxpay-
ers in the process. We must cut spending to keep our economic
engine on track. As legislators do the hard work of trimming agency
budgets, the headlines will be dominated by impacted constituen-
cies, but these tough times dictate government doing more with less.
If we cannot exercise fiscal discipline in governing Texas, I doubt it
can be achieved anywhere least of all in Washington.”
UTAHBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $12.9 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5.95 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $700 million, or 14.7 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $390 million, or 8.2 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $24,299,183,
86% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -0.9 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.3 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 365 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $3.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $2,219,016,692
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Salt Lake City will use $1 million to give iPod Touches to 1,600
students at Kearns High School.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. GARY HERBERT (R)
“As a state, we will continue to make government more responsive,
more efficient and more taxpayer friendly … as a state, we will do
all that we can to support and keep our focus on the private sec-
tor to promote economic expansion and job creation. And let me
underscore: America’s traditional system of free enterprise is the
only means to long-term job security and economic prosperity …
Utah has demonstrated the innovation, the fiscal restraint and the
problem-solving skills that can play an important role in providing
solutions to the problems that confront America. And, as we lead
by example, we will continue to exercise fiscal responsibility and
budget discipline.”
VERMONTBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $5.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 8.95 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $338 million, or 31.3 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $176 million, or 16.3 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $4,012,955,
73% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -0.7 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 5.4 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 39,281 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $1.8 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $992,821,539
Example of Stimulus Spending:
Mt. Snow received $25 million to replace chairlifts, construct a
120-million-gallon storage pond for snowmaking, and install ad-
ditional snowmaking guns.
F ISCAL PROMISES
GOV. PETER SHUMLIN (D)
“I stand here today to present a budget that is as sobering as it is
necessary, matching state spending with our state revenues, in keep-
ing with the long tradition of frugality and common sense that is the
lifeblood of Vermonters. My budget puts Vermont on a solid and
sustainable path to fiscal responsibility. Facing our fourth consecu-
tive year of budget shortfalls, I am committed to making the painful
choices today that will help ensure that we are not back here next
year making drastic cuts.”
V IRGINIA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $40.8 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 5.75 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $1.3 billion, or 8.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $2 billion7, or 13.1 percent of the budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $69,135,000,
80% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 0.2 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 766 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $9.3 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $6,179,530,415
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$98,000 was allotted to develop a walking tour of the town of Boy-
dton, which is less than one square mile.
F ISCAL PROMISES
GOV. BOB MCDONNELL (R)
“We will also continue our efforts to fundamentally reform and
restructure Virginia’s state government. Over the past three years
we have cut billions from our state budget. Our budget had nearly
doubled in a decade, growing 28% faster than the growth in
population and inflation. When we make government smaller and
smarter, we make our economy stronger. Just like families and busi-
nesses regularly do, we must look at what doesn’t work well and
what wastes money, and fix it.”
WASHINGTONBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $32.5 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6.5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $3.5 billion, or 22.5 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $2.5 billion, or 16.2 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $57,754,700,
99% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -0.7 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 9.1 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 781 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $8.7 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $8,244,555,200
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
The Puget Sound Regional Council spent $260,000 building a
pedestrian bridge across the North Creek, just 20 paces from an
existing sidewalk that crosses the river.
$10,000 was used to purchase “fish art” for the beautification of
Canal Drive’s median.
FISCAL PROMISES GOV.
CHRISTINE GREGOIRE (D)
“We need to use this economic crisis to get control of spending in
two critical areas — pensions and health care costs. In the past
decade our health care costs doubled to more than $5 billion. In the
next biennium alone our pension costs will double. Every dollar we
spend on health care and pensions means we have one fewer dollar
to educate our children.”
WEST VIRGINIA
BUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $20.2 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 6.5 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 6 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $134 million, or 3.6 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: No deficit projected
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $14,266,419,
56% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 0.7 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 8.6 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 8,052 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $4.4 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $1,841,687,846
Example of Stimulus Spending:
The Army Corps of Engineers will spend $650,000 to have an
Ohio-based company, Air Maids LLC, clean bathrooms, offices, and
campgrounds at Burnsville Dam.
F ISCAL PROMISES
GOV. EARL RAY TOMBLIN (D)
“In all of my years in the Senate, I am most proud of the fact that we
always kept a watchful and cautious eye over the State’s finances. In
acting as Governor, I pledge to continue to do so.”
WISCONSINBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $40.1 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): 7.75 percent
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 5 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $3.4 billion, or 23.9 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: $1.8 billion, or 12.8 percent of the
budget
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $79,104,600,
100% funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): -2.1 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 7.4 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 555 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $11.5 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $4,081,659,780
Examples of Stimulus Spending:
The village of Twin Lakes received $899,853 to implement a
“streetscaping” project.
A nursing home in Chetek received $2.8 million for renovations.
The nursing home was already on track to receive funding from the
USDA.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. SCOTT WALKER (R)
“Creating a more vibrant economy; however, will not happen with-
out a return to frugality in government – returning to our fundamen-
tal constitutional principles. Soon, we will lay out our plans for the
next state budget and we will successfully tackle the three billion
dollar deficit. We will do it without raids on segregated funds, or
excessive borrowing. Let me be clear on one thing: Increasing taxes
is off the table—as it will counter our efforts to provide economic
growth. Instead, we will make tough, but compassionate decisions
to balance the next state budget in a way that will get Wisconsin
working again.”
WYOMINGBUDGET:
Total State Expenditures (FY 2010 estimated): $7.7 billion
Income Tax Rate (Tax Year 2011): No state income tax
Sales Tax Rate (2011): 4 percent
Total FY 2011 Budget Deficit: $147 million, or 10.3 percent of the budget
Projected FY 2012 Budget Deficit: No deficit projected
Pension Liability and % of Liability Funded (FY 2009): $7,401,614, 89%
funded
ECONOMY:
Economic Growth (2008 to 2009): 5.4 percent
Unemployment Rate (May 2011): 6.0 percent
Foreclosure Rate (May 2011): 1 in every 2,331 houses
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SPENDING:
Total Federal Funds Received (FY 2010 estimated): $1.4 billion
Stimulus Money Awarded: $658,542,993
Example of Stimulus Spending:
$140 million was awarded to Wyoming for road and bridge proj-
ects. Half of the money was awarded to out-of-state contractors, who
underbid local companies.
FISCAL PROMISES
GOV. MATT MEAD (R)
“With our communities still feeling the effects of the economic
downturn, we need to provide an additional source of revenue
to our cities, towns and counties. It is good that we do not face a
repeat of last year’s fiscal austerity — with 10 percent budget cuts
and revenue shortfalls that affected everyone in the chain — from
the state on down. It is good that we have an unexpected amount
of money for a supplemental budget. But, the last few years have
provided a wake-up call. We need responsible growth, growth that’s
right for the times and our needs, growth that does not compromise
our values.”
For more information on the facts that affect your pocketbook, visit us at:
thepublicnotice.org
[published June, 2011]