business audit paper - buview
TRANSCRIPT
BuView Business Audit
Elijah Clark
2016
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Abstract
Marketing is known as the process of executing and planning the conception, promotion, pricing,
and distribution of goods, ideas, and services to create exchanges and satisfy individual and
business goals (Jankovic, 2012). Drawing from a series of interviews with the current marketing
manager of BuView LLC., an assessment was conducted to determine the state of the firm's
strategic marketing efforts. Performing a marketing audit is essential within hostile and complex
competitive business environments such as BuView (Jankovic, 2012). Hundreds of internal and
external factors often affect profitable businesses that need evaluation in order to achieve success
(Tyagi & Sawhney, 2010). The purpose of this marketing audit is to gain an analysis of the
firms’ primary marketing and promotional initiatives. The key element of this paper is the
framing and identification of the firms’ problems that relate to macro environment, task
environment, marketing function, and marketing strategy. The knowledge gained from this
research and marketing audit leads to identifying problems and recommending various solutions
to those problems.
2
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Abstract............................................................................................................................................................... 2Executive Summary........................................................................................................................................ 5Business Mission.............................................................................................................................................. 6Macro Environment........................................................................................................................................ 6Markets............................................................................................................................................................... 7Customers.......................................................................................................................................................... 7Distribution and Dealers............................................................................................................................... 8Marketing Tools............................................................................................................................................... 9Facilitators and Marketing Firms...............................................................................................................9General Force Analysis.................................................................................................................................. 9
Economics........................................................................................................................................................................... 9Technology....................................................................................................................................................................... 10Demographics / social / culture.............................................................................................................................10Government / legal / military..................................................................................................................................11Physical environment..................................................................................................................................................12
Industry Analysis.......................................................................................................................................... 12Matrix Analysis.............................................................................................................................................. 12
Barriers to entry............................................................................................................................................................13Substitutes........................................................................................................................................................................13Bargaining power of suppliers................................................................................................................................13Bargaining power of buyers.....................................................................................................................................13Competitive rivalry.......................................................................................................................................................14
Inbound Marketing Tool............................................................................................................................. 14Detailed Value Chain Analysis: Internal Environment.....................................................................15Customized Value Chain of Activities in Table Form........................................................................15
Table 1: Value Chain Analysis..................................................................................................................................15Implications of Competitive Analysis.....................................................................................................16
Strengths........................................................................................................................................................................... 16Weaknesses......................................................................................................................................................................16Skills.................................................................................................................................................................................... 16Capabilities.......................................................................................................................................................................17
Detailed SWOT Analysis..............................................................................................................................17SWOT Factor Matrix..................................................................................................................................... 18
SO strategies.................................................................................................................................................................... 18ST strategies.................................................................................................................................................................... 18WO strategies.................................................................................................................................................................. 18WT strategies.................................................................................................................................................................. 19
Key Success Factor Analysis...................................................................................................................... 19Marketing Function...................................................................................................................................... 20Products........................................................................................................................................................... 20Place of Distribution.................................................................................................................................... 21Integrated Marketing Communications................................................................................................21How BuView Works...................................................................................................................................... 22Insights............................................................................................................................................................. 22Marketing Strategy....................................................................................................................................... 23Marketing Objectives and Goals...............................................................................................................24Strategy............................................................................................................................................................. 24Action Plan Analysis..................................................................................................................................... 25
Drive Web Traffic..........................................................................................................................................................26Improve Brand Awareness.......................................................................................................................................26
3
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Increase Market Share and Profits........................................................................................................................26Conclusion....................................................................................................................................................... 28
4
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
BuView Business Strategy
BuView LLC is an Internet platform that provides businesses with the opportunity to
network with demographically segmented users within an online focus group environment.
Focus groups allow for marketers and businesses to observe how and why consumers react to
certain concepts and ideas (Kotler & Keller, 2012). The benefits of online focus groups include
cost savings, geographically diverse participants, and fast results (Kotler & Keller, 2012). The
BuView platform provides a focus group based approach, designed for businesses to use for
providing free products to targeted users based on the users’ geographical location, race, gender,
age, religion, political view, education, income level, social hangouts, and product interest. In
exchange for free products, the user is responsible for generating product awareness through
social reviews and feedback.
Online focus groups are a growing market and organizations are developing an increasing
interest in the service and the results that it generates (Kotler & Keller, 2012). In evaluating the
impact of consumer generated feedback and reviews, Jabr & Zhiqiang (2014) found that
endorsed opinions and homogeneity in reviewer impression improves the sales of products and
services. Online focus group organizations such as BuView help businesses and marketers
observe the reactions of consumers regarding particular concepts and ideas. Unlike local focus
groups, online focus groups give businesses the opportunity to determine product and service
cost based on the opinion of geographically diverse participants (Kotler & Keller, 2012).
Executive Summary
BuView (bue – view) is an online platform provided for businesses that desire reviews
and feedback about their product or service. BuView has a network of product testers and
reviewers that work together with registered business owners and marketers to assist in
5
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
enhancing products and producing effective marketing strategies targeted at demographically
segmented consumers. Focus groups are beneficial for businesses seeking honest feedback,
business reviews, and beta testing. An active list of businesses registered with BuView include:
marketing professionals, authors, inventors, and businesses of all types. Products offered by
these businesses include: Electronics, Beauty Products, Consumer Goods, Accessories, Clothing,
Software, Food, Home Goods, Toys, Retail, and many others.
BuView presents a unique value proposition by providing businesses with full and
complete access to the demographics of the focus group participants. The demographics include:
geographical location, race, gender, age, political view, religion, education, income level,
product interest, and social hangouts. BuView is currently in its beta phase and has registered
over 900 businesses and 10,000 users since its beta launch in March of 2015. The management
team has a combined 35 years of business experience, 10 years of digital marketing experience,
and 12 years of web development and programming experience. This experience has provided
BuView with the necessary resources to build its platform and brand with a budget of only $300.
Business Mission
In evaluating the mission of BuView, the organization's mission is clear and in market-
oriented terms. The organization seeks to create a network of businesses and users that work
together to enhance products and generate effective marketing strategies aimed at
demographically segmented users.
Macro Environment
The macro environment section of an audit includes topics related to consumer
demographic, economic environment, technological impact, and social-cultural forces that affect
sales and profits (Kotler & Keller, 2012). The macro environment is a significant factor in
6
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
understanding the key forces and influences that affect the organization’s ability to earn profits
(Kotler & Keller, 2012). Furthermore, the macro environment assists with describing important
changes in the organization's target market.
Markets
Based on market research provided by Chevalier & Mayzlin (2006), businesses of all
sizes are in search of product reviews and feedback. Justifiably, positive reviews and product
recommendations typically signify a quality product and higher sales for the vendor (Chevalier
& Mayzlin 2006; Hu, Zhang, & Pavlou, 2009). In addition to culture and social factors, reviews
and social recommendations influence consumer purchases (Kotler & Keller, 2012; Šalkovska &
Ogsta, 2014).
Businesses are aware that giving away free product can stimulate brand awareness and
generate sales. BuView’s targeted market segments include product review networks and local
focus group organizations. Within these markets, consumer awareness and growth are trending
upward because of the positive influence of product reviews on electronic commerce sites like
Amazon.com. Consequently, businesses are seeking to build their brand by reaching out to
organizations such as BuView for consumer reviews and feedback.
Customers
Defining and recognizing the consumers' needs are paramount in all aspects of business,
including sales, price, and customer support (Daj, 2012). Kotler and Keller (2012) suggest that
consumers value price and quality over their brand loyalty. In analyzing consumer segments,
BuView has evaluated its support databases and additionally reached out to a few of its active
users for qualitative feedback regarding its services and support. This method has helped produce
7
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
valuable and effective insight for measuring the consumers’ overview, behavior, and reactions
toward the organization in comparison to its competitors. The results of BuView’s analysis
agreed with Kotler and Keller (2012), which determined that businesses are likely to make their
purchase decisions based on value, quality, and price, while users value incentives and support.
BuView has customer segments of both users (BuViewers) and businesses. The
BuViewer segment consists of mostly influential females between the ages of 25-45 who are
technically keen and socially active. The business segments are generally small to medium-sized
start-up businesses that are seeking product feedback and reviews to help promote their brand
and build social awareness. BuView believes its services and platform are highly rated against
the competition, and both businesses and users are satisfied with the service and results. Of the
over 900 registered businesses on the website, more than half created multiple projects. There are
over 10,000 registered users on BuView, and most all are active and have subscribed to multiple
projects.
In regards to price, businesses value BuView over the competitors because of its free
offering. BuViewers value BuView’s service because it provides access to free products that they
would otherwise have to pay for. Appropriately, one of BuView’s unique value proposition is its
free offering. The purchasing decisions of these groups vary and are essentially determined by
peer and colleague referrals, social engagement, and website content that influences trust.
Distribution and Dealers
Businesses have the responsibility of getting their products to registered users. BuView
promotes its services to consumers through its website, electronic mail, and social networks.
BuView could use distribution channels more efficiently if the organization ever intends to
manage the projects for businesses. With BuView managing the projects, the organization would
8
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
be responsible for distributing the products and working with outside vendors. Whether BuView
will ever manage business projects is undetermined.
Marketing Tools
The services in which BuView uses includes Mailchimp for electronic mail newsletters,
Mandrill for electronic mail monitoring, Buffer for generating social engagement, and Zapier for
producing automated network building task. There are no noticeable trends occurring amongst
these suppliers.
Facilitators and Marketing Firms
BuView’s co-founders are currently managing and facilitating the organization's
marketing efforts and strategies. The results of their efforts have been satisfactory, and the
leaders produced over 10,000 registered users and over 900 registered businesses with a budget
of less than $300. Nearly a quarter of the registered businesses and users were hand selected by
the company in order to influence maximum social outreach and awareness.
General Force Analysis
The General Force Analysis (GFA) assists organizations with analyzing threats and
opportunities. The analysis focuses on identifying organizational threats and weaknesses by
analyzing (a) political/ legal/ government/ military, (b) economic, (c) social/ demographic/
cultural, (d) physical environment, and (e) technology influences. The analysis is used to forecast
relevant trends relating to organizations such as BuView and its business structure and activities.
Economics. The economy plays an important role in the growth of BuView. Innovative
technology and mobile platforms have seen a tremendous market growth (Haag & Cummings,
2008). Considering BuView offers online solutions, the company can benefit from the expected
9
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
e-retail growth. Considering this, BuView has an immediate opportunity for growth by
enhancing its online marketing efforts and mobile presence for online consumers.
Economic macro environments provide an in-depth view of the organization's industry.
Economic audit research includes industry facts, market size, market demand, market trends, and
growth potential and opportunities (Kotler & Keller, 2012). In response to economic
developments and trends, BuView is seeking financing from investors and website advertisers.
The organization is determined to build positive brand awareness to help generate website traffic
and investor interest.
Technology. Information technology has an enormous impact on business sectors
(Dasgupta, Gupta, & Sahay, 2011; Kotler & Keller, 2012). Technology is used by organizations
to help improve logistical operations and strengthen communication and partnerships. Online and
traditional retailing continues to evolve at a fast pace, which presents BuView with an
opportunity to attract new consumers using the latest technological trends and marketing
techniques.
Demographics / social / culture. Demographics are used as a determining factor in
understanding organizational threats and weaknesses. By evaluating the consumers’
demographics, organizations can develop an effective strategy targeted toward growing the
organization and increasing profitability (Kaplan & Norton, 2008). An important demographic
for BuView is the organizations size, user age group, and income level of its targeted businesses
and users.
Demographic profile-based marketing formulates an assessment of the consumer and is
generated to serve the consumers' needs and wants (Kotler, 2011). Understanding the consumer
10
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
helps in identifying the targeted and ideal consumer, their characteristics, and their geographical
locations.
Based on feedback from registered businesses and users, the overall attitude toward
BuView as a company is positive. However, because of its youth, the organization still lacks
complete trust from its users. Furthermore, by being a free service, businesses and users are
skeptical of the quality level of the service.
The demographic developments and trends, which pose a threat to the organization, is the
lack of registered male users. The original goal of the organization was to build a network of
females as the company believed females would influence social engagement quicker. This
theory developed based on monitoring social user engagements of the organization’s
competitors. Although there are many more females than male registered users, the
organization’s theory that women would influence brand awareness was successfully accurate as
the organization did experience tremendous growth by focusing on a female audience.
However, the lack of males on the site is likely to cause future concerns for registered
businesses seeking male participants for their BuView projects. BuView believes that the
organization can gain male participants by targeting and promoting more technology driven
products.
Government / legal / military. Government agencies and institutions are often
overlooked within the technology retail industry. Government agencies offer many growth
opportunities and benefits for BuView. Additionally, BuView needs to remain aware and within
the standards of the countries in which it does business. Not only does BuView need to study
international policies and laws, but the organization must also consider currency exchange rates
11
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
and property right laws that could damage the organization's success abroad (Ross, Westerfield,
& Jaffe, 2013).
BuView is a free service and is within third-party guidelines and regulations, which
prohibit the use of businesses paying for positive product reviews. BuView is not, and does not
intend to violate any United States codes, which prohibit the distribution of illegal drugs and
services.
Physical environment. Physical environmental concerns may consist of conservation,
resources, products and materials, and recycling. The physical environment trends that are likely
to impact BuView’s industry include product waste and recycling. The physical environment for
BuView does not seem to be a concern of the organization. However, BuView should remain
current and aware of its physical environmental habits. As an Internet-based company, BuView
has no real environmental concerns. Registered users and businesses are responsible for product
exchanges, which may require knowledge of cost and availability of natural resources and
energy.
Industry Analysis
Matrix Analysis
Porter's Five Forces is used by organizations to determine their industry relevance and
profit opportunities (Porter, 2008). Additionally, Porter's Five Forces evaluates direct forces
relating to the organization. Porter's Five Forces are considered a micro-view point model,
instead of a macro-view point like the General Force Analysis model. BuView should use
Porters Five Forces analysis to develop a better understanding of its industry and competition.
Porter’s Five Forces include barriers to entry, availability of substitutes, bargaining power of
suppliers, bargaining power of buyers, and competitive rivalry (Porter, 2008). The analysis
12
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
should be used to discover trends and forecast threats and opportunities within the industry. If
opportunity does exist, BuView should enhance their position based on the forecasted threats
(Mentzer, Myers, & Stank, 2007). Based on the results of the forces, availability of substitutes,
and competitive rivalry may impact BuView’s profitability.
Barriers to entry. Barriers of entry present obstacles for competitors to enter into the
industry. The problem that often prevents organizations from entering an industry is the need for
capital. Considering online marketing and awareness often requires creative talent, marketing
knowledge, and programming needs, it is an expensive industry for potential competitors.
Substitutes. The availability of substitute products should offer value and quality within
the industry (Porter, 2008). To achieve success, BuView may need to develop a unique value
proposition from its competitors. A unique value may include BuView developing a better
customer experience, more product offerings, better quality customer service, or products and
services with a better value (Petersen, Ragatz, & Monczka, 2005). A substitution benefit of
BuView is that the organization has positioned itself to match not only traditional focus group
based brick-and-mortar competitor prices, but also online competitor prices.
Bargaining power of suppliers. Bargaining power of suppliers of BuView are low
considering BuView focuses on maintaining strong and healthy long-term relationships with its
suppliers. BuView does have purchasing power over suppliers because of its large user-base and
organizational value. Consequently, this force is a low external threat.
Bargaining power of buyers. The bargaining power of businesses at BuView differ in
that consumers receive access to the platform free of charge. Additionally, because competitors
such as Tomoson and its vendors offer consumers multiple packages and price tiers, it presents a
threat to BuView's growth and potential profitability. Because BuView is a platform, its products
13
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
are often not unique to its platform and consumers can go elsewhere to purchase products and
services offered by the organization.
Competitive rivalry. One of BuView’s largest competitors within the online focus group
market is tomoson.com (Tomoson). Tomoson offers its users more products because of its
affiliation with the online retailer Amazon. However, Tomoson charges businesses $250 to
register to use its platform while BuView offers the same service for free to businesses.
BuView’s main competitors are Tomoson and influenster.com (Influenster). BuView faces
identifiable threats from its competitors, primarily dealing with brand awareness. Tomoson
targets businesses to purchase access to its platform, and Influenster targets mainly users to sign
up on its website. It is highly probable that both competitors have a business sales team in charge
of generating sales and registering new businesses and products. In regards to the competitors’
platforms, BuView’s offering is similar in structure and process, with the exception that BuView
provides businesses with complete access to user demographics including geographical location,
race, gender, age, religion, political view, education, income level, social hangouts, and product
interest. Unlike Tomoson, which only offers a product review platform, and Influenster, which
primarily target users, BuView is in the process of building both peer-to-peer and business-to-
user segments into its platform. The new structure is designed to promote further user
engagement along with satisfying businesses by having more active users.
The market has room for growth, and neither of BuView’s competitors is immensely
successful. Based on the size and strength of the market and its competitors, BuView has room to
grow and become a market leader by implementing a strategy, collaborating with established
product corporations, and strengthening its social impact.
Inbound Marketing Tool
14
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Stepping beyond the simplistic review model tool, BuView has the capability to be
capitalized by brands as an inbound marketing tool. Pre and post review shout outs by bloggers
opportune:
• Brand imprint
• Drive consumers to a website
• Commence brand conversations
Detailed Value Chain Analysis: Internal Environment
The value chain is a system used by companies to assist in building competitive
advantages and shareholder value (NetMBA, 2010). The system creates what is known as a value
chain that is developed based on a series of value-generated activities. The goal of value-
generated activities is to offer consumers value that generates higher profit margins for the
organization (NetMBA, 2010). Organizational activities are sustained by the firm’s framework,
technology development, human resource management, and procurement. Determining the most
effective activities is decided by whether the profit margins generate high returns (NetMBA,
2010).
Customized Value Chain of Activities in Table Form
Table 1: Value Chain Analysis
Business Process BuView Tomoson Influenster
Management Management engages centralized
and decentralized.
Management structure is similar
to BuView in structure but lack
the industry knowledge and
education level of BuView.
Management is active and has a good
industry understanding and social media
knowledge.
Logistics BuView has no distribution
centers or products for
distribution.
Same as BuView. Online based
and no distribution center.
Businesses are responsible for
Located in New York and distributes
products from its location. Businesses send
to Influenster and Influenster sends to
15
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
shipping to the user. users.
Service Online focus group platform that
offers businesses the benefit of
receiving demographically
segmented feedback and
reviews.
Similar to BuView but does not
offer as many demographics for
businesses to select from. Also,
cost businesses for access.
Similar to BuView but does not offer as
many demographics for businesses to
select from. Cost businesses per project.
Sales Offers a free service to
businesses and consumers. No
sales data.
Has a high-profit rate because of
its partnered relationship with
Amazon and other large
organizations.
Maintains high profits because of its social
presence and consumer engagement.
Partners with brands including Sony,
Coca-Cola, and Shell.
Customer Service Lacks sufficient employees to
fully satisfy customer request
and concerns. However, no
known negative reviews.
Businesses rate the company
weak considering it lacks having
a variety of reviewers.
Receives low user satisfaction because of
the lack of products. Too many users and
not enough products for distribution.
Implications of Competitive Analysis
Strengths. BuView believes that its organization has an advantage over competitors
considering it has built on the success of offering demographic information of its users.
Additionally, the company has invested in enhancing its platform by offering users the
opportunity to connect with one another in a community. The company believes that its unique
value strength and market knowledge give it a competitive edge.
Weaknesses. A disadvantage of using the value chain is that it is a very extensive process
and takes a huge amount of time to complete a full analysis of the organization and its
competitors. BuView currently isolates its cost drivers for its activities and identifies its value
chain linkages by continuing to monitor potential profit margins and technology trends.
Skills. Activities within a company should be optimally run in order for the company to
gain a real competitive advantage. Technological changes can generate competitive advantages
16
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
by adjusting activities or the value chain (NetMBA, 2010). An advantage of using the value
chain is that its allows for BuView to evaluate its organization, competitors, and industry value.
The value chain is used to create competitive advantages by focusing on activities that help in
delivering a unique value proposition (Millar & Porter, 1985).
Capabilities. With the use of innovative technology, organizations such as BuView can
benefit within their industry and produce a competitive advantage (Dasgupta, Gupta, & Sahay,
2011). Technology allows for organizations to reduce cost while increasing productivity. With
the use of technology, organizations can easily share information throughout their supply chain
and generate faster results and product availability. In regards to BuView, technology is used to
evaluate trends patterns and relationships to improve business risk selection. Additionally,
technology has changed the online industry as users desire immediate access to services and
products through the Internet. Considering this, BuView plans to attract new customer segments
and remain competitive by staying current with consumer trends and technology advancements.
Detailed SWOT Analysis
Table 2: Summary of BuView SWOT Analysis
Strengths
User demographic offering.
Leadership with online marketing knowledge and backgrounds.
Free tier plan for businesses.
Full project control for businesses.
Weaknesses
Lack of strong brand recognition and reputation.
Low level of partnerships with organizations that can provide businesses and users.
17
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Opportunities
Growth in online feedback and review
influence.
Growth in online spending on review-
based commerce websites.
Organizations seeking feedback from
global consumers.
Threats
Technological drawbacks of distributing
digital products and services.
Distribution concerns with shipping
products to users.
Competition has large partnerships with
huge organizations.
SWOT Factor Matrix
SO strategies. To fortify BuView's opportunities, the organization needs to keep on
building brand value through promoting and extended operations to surpass Tomoson. BuView
should find avenues to build its presence through broad statistical surveying that would
incorporate social networking, client benefit, the value chain and current operations. BuView
needs to build group relationships through social engagement, online networking, and
communication building.
ST strategies. With a goal to combat threats, BuView needs to implement complex,
versatile frameworks into their strategic methods. The execution would permit BuView to keep
on being dexterous, adaptable, and versatile to any environmental changes. BuView must stay
focused through reinforcing of their core capabilities, development, and continuing to search for
better approaches to adding unique value.
WO strategies. BuView must focus on alleviating their shortcomings and take advantage
of opportunities to reinforce those shortcomings to stay relevant. All internal leaders from the
CEO to the most minimal level representative should be acclimated with all item areas inside of
18
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
the organization. Additionally, BuView should focus on satisfying its users by providing
excellent customer support and competitive service quality.
WT strategies. Weaknesses and threats are significant for BuView. To guarantee those
concerns are reduced, BuView should focus on building its brand recognition and reputation.
Additionally, to combat the current direct and indirect market contenders, BuView should
expand its strategic alliance with partners, producers, and suppliers. Linking with partners should
help the organization achieve trust and reliability through the referred source.
Key Success Factor Analysis
Market personalization covers execution, advertising yield, purchaser quality, and
advertiser value (Vesanen, 2007). Marketing personalization is a strategy utilized by numerous
organizations to improve consumer engagements. Furthermore, promoting personalization
comprises of customizing procedures based on the individual demographics, conduct, verifiable
information, and way of life subtle elements (Cudmore & Patton, 2007).
The key elements for BuView to focus on to enhance sustainability are development,
growth, innovative advancement, online networking engagement, and consumer loyalty.
BuView's capacity to profit by these areas are vital to the continued success of the organization.
The implementation of the community system gives BuView a chance to build its brand
notoriety and awareness. Social networking can improve customer satisfaction, expand customer
base and help BuView build its marketing strategies (Porter, 2008). Online social media requires
minimal effort marketing contrasted with conventional radio, newspaper, and television
promotions. Social media is likewise a system that BuView can use to improve their users'
experience and enhance client relationships (Porter, 2008). BuView can enhance consumer
loyalty through technological advances and online networking. Garnering expanded consumer
19
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
loyalty helps in expanded sustainability for BuView now and in the future. Consumer loyalty
helps in enhancing reliability and improve BuView probability of growth and sustainability.
Marketing Function
The marketing function audit is a study used to determine the marketing functions in
relation to the product or service offered. The marketing function audit evaluates the marketing
mix of the company, which includes the product, price, place of distribution, and promotion (four
P components) (Kotler & Keller, 2012). A marketing mix includes tactics that support the four P
components and uses them to develop an understanding of the requirements necessary to produce
an effective marketing strategy (Kotler & Keller, 2012).
Products
Developing a product line objective gives the organization an outline to determine which
products and services are meeting their objectives and which should phase out (Kotler & Keller,
2012). Within BuView, projects are posted on the website, and users request the projects in
which they are most interested. Based on the user request rate for projects, users prefer feminine
products, accessories, and home improvement items. The least requested project based on this
same standard are books. Considering BuView is a young company, the product line objectives
are still within its original evaluation stage.
BuView’s product line objective is to provide businesses with a way to gain brand
awareness and product feedback. To accomplish the objective, BuView requires that its users
engage in social discussions about business products, and provide detailed feedback to
businesses for market research and product improvements.
Areas of improvement for product and brand strategy include implementing an effective
method to build the number of registered users. With time and further evaluation, the
20
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
organization will have a better understanding of which projects and services registered users and
businesses desire most. As the evaluations conclude, BuView will have the ability to determine
the types of businesses it should market toward based on the request rate of its users.
Place of Distribution
BuView currently distributes its service directly on its company website. Registered
businesses are responsible for distributing their products or services to the requested users at the
expense of the business. Methods used by registered businesses on BuView to distribute their
products include: online retails, direct mail, electronic mail, and virtual file downloads.
Integrated Marketing Communications
BuView’s distribution objective and strategy is to promote its services by utilizing online
marketing strategies in addition to influencing registered users to promote the brand. BuView
plans to collaborate with local focus groups and marketing firms with customers in need of
building their brand reputation and awareness. BuView further intends to promote its services
directly to businesses by using traditional sales channels such as newspaper advertisements,
magazines, flyers, and through distributing business cards during networking events. BuView’s
advertising objective is to influence user registrations and generate business leads. Marketing
and advertising efforts in which BuView has previously used include paid social campaigns, and
gift card giveaways for peer referrals.
BuView has yet to implement marketing methods fully by using direct, online, and
database marketing. With the completion of a marketing strategy, the company intends to
promote and advertise its brand online through social inbound channels, paid campaigns, and
electronic mail campaigns.
21
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
How BuView Works
When a vendor posts a project, that vendor specifies a product interest plus social
hangout sites. Each project goes through a hand review process to ensure that the project adheres
to BuView’s Terms of Service. Upon approval, BuViewers are notified of said project via email.
Email contains project announcement with link to project. It is up to the BuViewer to request
interest. Default pooling life span is 120 hours; however, project owner has an override ability to
close the project prior.
Once a project is closed, the project owner has the ability to select interested BuViewers
that applied. The project owner can view unabridged demographics to make certain that a
particular BuViewer aligns with desired traits. Once a BuViewer is selected, it is up to the
BuViewer to respond to the acceptance email. Because of that, the double opt-in acts as a
safeguard.
Insights
Brands that know their consumer spending habits have the ability to leverage over brands
that turn a blind eye. BuView’s messaging to brands must communicate that its platform offers
the ability to scoop into consumer tiered subsets. Moreover, B2B messaging correctness falls on
magnifying how brands can mine known subsets, clarity tiered subset messaging, and check
market products using BuView’s demographic filtering capabilities. U.S. Department of Labor
(2013) reported that 57.3% of women with infants and 74.7% of women with children ages 6-17
were part of the workforce. BuView’s demographic filters support this type of audience
segmentation potential.
BuView must be aware of consumer segment life events and stages as well. Its pool of
reviewers needs to be recognizably broad for brands to segment users when applying valuable
22
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
insight using industry and demographic filters. This ability to filter earmarks BuView from
analogous businesses.
The vendor selects demographics. Demographics can be selected during signup and with
each product evaluation. The Vendor’s and BuViewer’s personal identity remains private and
only available to BuView’s agents. Each BuViewer will be required to supply to BuView a
scanned digital copy of a valid state ID, or U.S. passport. This is to verify legal age and accuracy
of address as well as race, gender and other measurements of identity to help better categorize
demographics. Demographics are private and available only to BuView agents. BuView strictly
complies with COPLA, and minimum age to become a BuViewer is 18.
Some vendors may require that the selected BuViewer sign a nondisclosure agreement
prior to beginning the review. BuView does not get involved with such agreements or disputes
when a vendor requests such. BuView and its employees are released from any liability due to a
BuViewer not abiding by the terms of a nondisclosure agreement, and neither the vendor nor
BuViewer can hold BuView liable or bring civil litigation against BuView and its employees.
BuView manually reviews all BuView profiles to verify authenticity. BuView also
read’s all requested reviews to make sure they are in compliance with vendor’s request. All
projects have a deadline. Failure to comply with a vendor’s deadline may disqualify a BuViewer
from future participation. A BuViewer’s deadline is at minimum 10 days before vendor due date.
This will allow BuView agents to review BuViews and select a new BuViewer if necessary to
complete the vendors request.
Marketing Strategy
The ideal marketing strategy builds consumer trust, generates brand awareness, and
influences sales and investor wealth (Tyagi & Sawhney, 2010). The marketing strategy evaluates
23
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
the organization's underlying needs, targets the consumers, and discovers the strategies necessary
to influence the consumers’ purchasing decision (Daj, 2012).
Marketing Objectives and Goals
BuView’s marketing objectives and goals need improvements if it desires to affect the
market positively. The objectives lack credible research and direction. The organization has a
solid understanding of its market based only on assumptions and minor research. However,
BuView does have the means necessary to create effective goals and objectives. With further
research and proper planning, BuView can determine the approach necessary to maximize its
organizational growth.
Considering the co-founders of BuView are professional Internet marketing consultants,
the digital marketing aspect of the marketing objectives and goals are clear and directed at
measuring performance. However, the individuals lack the necessary knowledge for producing a
complete and effective marketing strategy outside of the digital environment. With the assistance
of an outside business consultant, advisory board, and with further marketing research, BuView
believes it will have the resources necessary for creating an appropriate and effective business
plan and strategy for success.
Strategy
In creating a marketing strategy, BuView should use a qualitative and quantitative
approach for gathering necessary consumer information (Varadarajan, 2010). In regards to the
current state of BuView’s marketing strategy, the organization has minimally researched its
targeted segments of businesses and users and currently has a digital marketing strategy in place.
BuView’s current strategic goal is to connect emotionally with users, provide excellent customer
24
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
support, and keep the website busy with projects and user generated content and activities. This
method, as stated by Kotler & Keller (2012), should help the organization achieve its marketing
goals. The organizations marketing strategy aims to build brand loyalty, trust, and awareness.
Furthermore, the organizations current and future digital marketing strategy positively affects the
organization's marketing mix for its target segments.
Action Plan Analysis
The action plan is a report that starts with key objectives and recognizes all the steps
needed to accomplish them. For an action plan to have value, an assessment process must
distinguish estimations of success, and those measures must be distinguished as benchmarks.
When an action plan is finished an organization should consistently screen and contrast the
advancement accomplished with pre-established benchmarks. The examination of
accomplishments to benchmarks gives confirmation of achievement.
Actions Department Timeline/ Month
Benchmarks & Goals Potential Barriers Communications
Step 1:Increase Web Traffic
ManagementEmployees
2016-2017
Increase customer satisfaction and build social community on the platform to influence users to return to the website.
Finances and time needed to update and enhance website features.
Daily through the use of internal emails. Phone and chat could be used for immediate needs.
Step 2:Improve Brand Awareness
ManagementEmployees
2017-2018
Improve awareness through the use of social media, email marketing, and other online and offline marketing techniques including referral rewards.
Finances and time needed to create and place promotional advertisements space could present a barrier.
Daily through the use of internal emails. Phone and chat could be used for immediate needs.
Step 3:Increase Market Share and Profits
ManagementEmployees
2018-2019
Increase market share so that the organization can ultimately increase advertisement profits.
To assist with increasing market share, the company should also merge with business partners to produce more users.
Finances and lack of resources to gain partners.
Low profits may not be attractive to potential partners.
Daily through the use of internal emails. Phone and chat could be used for immediate needs.
Table 3: BuView 3 Year Action Plan
25
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Drive Web Traffic. To drive web traffic, BuView needs to increase customer
satisfaction and build on its marketing and social networking platforms. The goal of the process
is to influence new users to register on the website and current users to continually visit the
website. To increase traffic, BuView's planned development of an integrated community should
influence users to remain on the site to network with other users. Barriers that prevent an
increase in web traffic include a lack of finances and time needed to complete the task. With a
low level of employees and resources being used elsewhere, the organization could have a hard
time focusing on the process.
Improve Brand Awareness. To improve awareness for the brand, BuView should use
social media to build its customer satisfaction, which should help influence conversation and
referrals. Additionally, the company should implement marketing strategies that include online
promotions, advertisements, campaigns, newsletter, and reward its current users for referring a
friend to join the platform and community. Barriers that may prevent BuView from achieving its
goal to improve brand awareness include a lack of finances to purchase advertisement space and
promotional material.
Increase Market Share and Profits. To generate profits and increase market share,
BuView needs to link with business partners that can provide the company with users and
businesses with products to offer. Additionally, the benchmark should help generate profits by
offering businesses advertisement space and potential tiered packages ranging from free to paid.
Barriers that could prevent BuView from reaching this benchmark include a lack of resources
necessary to gain partners. Additionally, partners may not be interested in the service unless
there are high profits.
26
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Twice throughout each year, the organization's management should meet to discuss
progress on the benchmarks. Additionally, the organization’s leaders should communicate daily
through emails, chat, and teleconferences to discuss setbacks and concerns. Benchmarks that
have not met their goals, should be re-evaluated and given priority of resources and employees
so that the goals are met by the end of the year.
BuView should generate sales through an internal sales team. Cold calling and
prospecting consumer based product companies, start-ups and eventually local businesses. We
will also generate and increase sales through lead generation.
Potential BuView price points
Level Product Value BuViews Completed
Vendor Cost BuViewer Reward
BuView Reward
Level 1 -$100 -25 $50 $25 $25
Level 2 $100 - $500 25-50 $75 $50 $25
Level 3 $500 - $1000 51-100 $100 $75 $25
Level 4 $1001 + 101+ $125 $100 $25
Marketing:
Marketing methods that could be used include heavy Social Media, SEO, SEM,
Retargeting Ads, and Behavioral Display. We will also market to popular bloggers and
influential online users on YouTube, Instagram, Twitter, etc.
Expense for marketing will be budgeted but most of the buzz will be created from key
influencers and BuViewers’ word of mouth.
Markets targeted will include major metro cities with the largest populations,
demographics and potential for quick word of mouth growth. BuView’s strength will be in its
27
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
list. The larger our database and demographics the easier it will be to penetrate the product
industry.
BuView will market nationally. There is huge potential to service the local business
market as well. 73% of searches performed are local. We will start national with a focus on
consumer products (i.e. books) and branch out over time.
Conclusion
Organizations develop marketing audits to identify associated organizational market
strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and risk (Rădulescu & Cruceru, 2013). Audits are
performed in order to satisfy the organizational mission, and vision. Furthermore, the audit is
necessary to discover the value of products offered, and the effectiveness of current and future
marketing efforts (Rădulescu & Cruceru, 2013). As a start-up organization still in beta, BuView
has seen an adequate amount of success within the growing online focus group market.
BuView’s unique value proposition is its free service and availability of user demographical
information that is accessible for businesses registered on the website. The knowledge gained
from consumer evaluations, business surveys, and market research recommends that BuView
expand its marketing and advertising efforts by utilizing the information gathered within this
audit to create and implement a marketing strategy.
28
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
References
Chevalier, J. A., & Mayzlin, D. (2006). The effect of word of mouth on sales: Online book
reviews. Journal of Marketing Research (43:3), pp. 345-354. doi:10.1509/jmkr.43.3.345
Cudmore, B. A., & Patton, J. R. (2007). The intimate marketer: Personalized direct marketing
strategies in a wireless environment. Journal Of Internet Commerce, 6(4), 73-96.
doi:10.1080/15332860802086243
Daj, A. (2012). Contemporary marketing trends: From one-to-one marketing and the service-
dominant logic to m2m communications and netnography. Bulletin of the Transilvania
University of Brasov. Series V: Economic Sciences, 5(1), 37-40. Retrieved
from http://jourlib.org
Daj, A. (2012). Contemporary marketing trends: From one-to-one marketing and the service-
dominant logic to m2m communications and netnography. Bulletin of the Transilvania
University of Brasov. Series V: Economic Sciences, 5(1), 37-40. Retrieved from
http://jourlib.org
Dasgupta, M., Gupta, R. K., & Sahay, A. (2011). Linking technological innovation, technology
strategy and organizational factors: A review. Global Business Review, 12(2), 257–277.
doi:10.1177/097215091101200206
Freeman, R. E., & McVea, J. A. (2001). Stakeholder Approach to Strategic
Management. Darden Graduate School of Business Administration, University of
Virginia. Working Paper No. 01-02. doi: 10.2139/ssrn.263511
Haag, S., & Cummings, M. (2008). Management information systems for the information
age (Laureate Education, Inc., custom ed.). Boston: McGraw-Hill/Irwin
Haag, S., & Cummings, M. (2008). Management information systems for the information
29
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
age (Laureate Education, Inc., custom ed.). Boston: McGraw-Hill/Irwin
Hamel, G., & Prahalad, C. K. (2005, July-August). Strategic intent. Harvard Business Review,
83(7/8), 148-161. Retrieved from https://hbr.org
Hu, N., Zhang, J., & Pavlou, P. A. (2009). Overcoming the j- shaped distribution of product
reviews. Communications of the ACM (52:10), pp. 144-147.
doi:10.1145/1562764.1562800
Jabr, W., & Zhiqiang, Z. (2014). Know yourself and know your enemy: An analysis of firm
recommendations and consumer reviews in a competitive environment. MIS Quarterly,
38(3), 635-A10. Retrieved from http://misq.org
Jabr, W., & Zhiqiang, Z. (2014). Know yourself and know your enemy: An analysis of firm
recommendations and consumer reviews in a competitive environment. MIS Quarterly,
38(3), 635-A10. Retrieved from http://misq.org
Jankovic, M. (2012). Integrated marketing communications and brand identity development.
Management Journal for Theory and Practice, 63, 91-100.
doi:10.7595/management.fon.2012.0015
Kahn, R.L. (2000). The effect of technological innovation on organizational structure: Two case
studies of the effects of the introduction of a new technology on informal organizational
structures. Journal of Business and Technical Communication,
14(3). doi:10.1177/105065190001400305
Kaplan, R. S. & Norton, D. P. (2008). Mastering the management system. Harvard Business
Review, 86(1), 62–77. Retrieved from http://hbr.org
Kotler, P. (2011). Reinventing marketing to manage the environmental imperative. Journal of
Marketing, 75(4), 132–135. doi:10.1509/jmkg.75.4.132
30
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. (2012). Marketing management (14 ed.). Upper Saddle River, New
Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. (2012). Marketing management (14 ed.). Upper Saddle River, New
Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Mentzer, J. T., Myers, M. B., & Stank, T. P. (Eds.). (2007). Handbook of global supply chain
management. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Millar, V.E. & Porter, M. E. (1985, July–August). How information gives you competitive
advantage. Harvard Business Review, 63(149–160). Retrieved from http://hbr.org
Mintzberg, H. (1994, January-February). The fall and rise of strategic planning. Harvard
Business Review, 107-114. Retrieved from https://hbr.org
NetMBA. (2010). The value chain. Retrieved August 6, 2013, from
http://www.netmba.com/strategy/value-chain
Petersen, K. J., Ragatz, G. L., & Monczka, R. M. (2005). An examination of collaborative
planning effectiveness and supply chain performance. The Journal of Supply Chain
Management, 41(2). doi:10.1111/j.1055-6001.2005.04102002.x
Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review,
86(1), 78–93. Retrieved from http://hbr.org
Rădulescu, V., & Cruceru, A. F. (2013). The significance of the audit of distribution and
communication policy in increasing organizational performance. Romanian Journal Of
Marketing, (3), 46-50. Retrieved from http://romaniajournal.ro
Ross, S. A., Westerfield, R. W., & Jaffe, J. (2013). Corporate finance (10th ed.). New York:
McGraw-Hill Irwin.
Šalkovska, J., & Ogsta, E. (2014). Quantitative and qualitative measurement methods of
31
BUVIEW BUSINESS AUDIT
companies’ marketing efficiency. Management of Organizations: Systematic Research,
(70), 91–105. doi:10.7220/mosr.1392.1142.2014.70.7
Tyagi, R. K., & Sawhney, M. S. (2010). High-performance product management: The impact of
structure, process, competencies, and role definition. Journal of Product Innovation
Management, 27, 83-96. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5885.2009.00701.x
Tyagi, R. K., & Sawhney, M. S. (2010). High-performance product management: The impact of
structure, process, competencies, and role definition. Journal of Product Innovation
Management, 27, 83-96. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5885.2009.00701.x
Tyagi, R. K., & Sawhney, M. S. (2010). High-performance product management: The impact of
structure, process, competencies, and role definition. Journal of Product Innovation
Management, 27, 83-96. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5885.2009.00701.x
Van Heerde, H. J., Gijsenberg, M. J., Dekimpe, M. G., & Steenkamp, J. M. (2013). Price and
advertising effectiveness over the business cycle. Journal of Marketing Research (JMR),
50(2), 177-193. doi:10.1509/jmr.10.0414
Varadarajan, R. (2010). Strategic marketing and marketing strategy: Domain, definition,
fundamental issues and foundational premises. Academy of Marketing Science Journal,
38(2), 119-140. doi:10.1007/s11747-009-0176-7
Vesanen, J. (2007). What is personalization: A conceptual framework. European Journal of
Marketing, 41(5/6), 409-418. doi:10.1108/03090560710737534
White, S., & Red, R. (2001). Stop and smell the what now? Floral arranging for beginners
(Research Report No. 40-921). Retrieved from University of Wooded Glen, Center for
Aesthetic Improvements in Fairy Tales website: http://www.uwg.caift/~40_921.pdf
32