can big data yield big insights for depression?...can big data yield big insights for depression?...

16
Can big data yield big insights for depression? www.gillanlab.com AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology and MQ Fellow Trinity College Dublin @clairegillanTCD

Upload: others

Post on 03-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Can big data yield big

insights for depression?

www.gillanlab.com

AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019

Claire Gillan, PhD

Assistant Professor of Psychology and MQ Fellow

Trinity College Dublin

@clairegillanTCD

Page 2: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology
Page 3: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

OCD

Bipolar

Schizophrenia

Depression

Page 4: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

***

0

20

40

60

80

100

Resp

on

ses (

%)

Contr

ol

OC

D

Gillan et al., American Journal of Psychiatry, 2011

Habit

Same goes for schizophrenia!

And social anxiety…

And cocaine addiction…

…and binge-eating disorder, alcohol use disorder,

mixed results in anorexia…

OCD

Page 5: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

OCD

Bipolar

Schizophrenia

Depression

Page 6: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

OCD

BipolarDepression

Schizophrenia

Page 7: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

*p<.05 ** p<.01 ***p<.001

Co

ntr

ol o

ver

hab

it

**** ***

p >.14

1,413 participants

(general population)

Eating D

isord

ers

Imp

uls

ivity

OC

D

Alc

ohol A

ddic

tion

Schiz

oty

py

Depre

ssio

n

Tra

it A

nxie

ty

Apath

y

Socia

l Anxie

ty

Gillan et al., eLife, 2016

Habits forming, trans-diagnostically

Page 8: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Anxious-Depression

Co

mp

uls

ivit

y

Social Withdrawal

0.5

0.0

0.5

0.0

-

0.5

0.0

0.5 -

0.5

-1

-0.8

-0.6

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Inter-correlation of 209

individual self-report

questionnaire items

Gillan et al., eLife, 2016

Contr

ol over

habit

***

Page 9: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

**

Dimension or Disorder?

Gillan et al., JAMA Psychiatry, 2019

Contr

ol over

habit

Contr

ol over

habit (

beta

)

N=285 diagnosed patients

GAD OCD GAD

+

OCD

This is interesting, but is this

valuable?

Page 10: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

33% remission rate

47% response rateTrivedi et al., 2006

Antidepressants work!

They just don’t work for everyone.

Several candidate predictors of treatments response

But :

• Non-specific

• Weak, one-dimensional predictors

• Impractical (too expensive)

None are in clinical use

www.AntidepressantResearch.com

Can we use big data to make psychiatry’s first

objective tests?

Page 11: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Precision Treatment

Several candidate predictors of treatments response

But :

• Non-specific

• Weak, one-dimensional predictors

• Impractical (too expensive)

None are in clinical use

Our Objective:

• Specific – which treatment will work for you?

• Strong, multidimensional predictors

• Scalable, cheap and easy to access

Make this tool available

www.AntidepressantResearch.com

Page 12: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

A novel method to achieve these goals

www.AntidepressantResearch.com

• Scalable: We want to recruit as we mean to implement

• Strong: We need a large sample (N=1000) to use machine

learning to capture multidimensional space

• Specific: We need to test comparative treatments

Page 13: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Early Identification

• Prevention is better than treatment.

• Can we detect an episode before it happens?

• Network theories suggest we might be able to pin it

down to a matter of weeks

anxietysleep motivation

self-esteem

moodappetite

Are tightly connected

networks are more

vulnerable?

Borsboom & Kramer, 2008

Page 14: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Weakly connected(‘resilient’)

Strongly connected(‘vulnerable’)

Baseline Network

Future diagnoses

Future treatments

freq

uenc

y

A BLow Disability OCD Patients (N=102)

High Disability OCD Patients (N=101)

Weakly connected(‘resilient’)

Strongly connected(‘vulnerable’)

Baseline Network

Future diagnoses

Future treatments

freq

uen

cy

A BLow Disability OCD Patients (N=102)

High Disability OCD Patients (N=101)

Kelley, …., & Gillan, in preparation

Early Identification

N=200 patients

Higher ImpairmentLower Impairment

episode

begins

weeks

co

nnectivity

@use_mybrain

Can we use signals like this to predict the future?

Page 15: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Want to help?

VISIT: www.AntidepressantResearch.com

Seeking:

• GPs

• Pharmacists

• Individuals +/- 2 days of starting antidepressants

@use_mybrain

Page 16: Can big data yield big insights for depression?...Can big data yield big insights for depression? AWARE Conference, Dublin 2019 Claire Gillan, PhD Assistant Professor of Psychology

Gillan LabTricia Seow

Andrew Pringle

Kevin Lynch

Eoghan Gallagher

Sean Kelley

Thank You

www.AntidepressantResearch.com

@use_mybrain