cancer options newsletter · page 14 nice calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care...

35
Page | 1 CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER www.canceroptions.co.uk www.pathwayforhealth.co.uk

Upload: others

Post on 14-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 1

CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER

www.canceroptions.co.uk

www.pathwayforhealth.co.uk

Page 2: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 2

LATEST NEWS

Hello and welcome to our newsletter for September 2010. I have been quiet

on the newsletter front as I have been updated on the communications front

and now have a blog which I update regularly and am regularly twittering with

latest news.

For those of you familiar with these, my blog is available at;

http://tinyurl.com/3adk6pf and on Twitter as Patricia Peat please sign up

and link us up with anyone you think will benefit and be interested.

NEW COLLEAGUE

I am delighted to have been joined by the wonderful Margella Salmins BSc Hons. TCM, BM (Beijing), MRCHM MBAcC MATCM

Margella is a fully qualified practitioner of Chinese Medicine, having completed

her studies and clinical training in London and Beijing. In addition she is also

trained and qualified in Macrobiotic Nutrition; Therapeutic Healing; Reiki and

Esoteric Astrology.

She is an incredibly talented practitioner who is bringing her many skills and

talents to developing the Pathway Programme into the most comprehensive

programme for anyone diagnosed with ill health. I feel very lucky to be working

with her and I am sure we will be bringing you further news of how people are

empowering themselves to good health.

Page 3: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 3

ANALYZING EFECTIVENESS

A big question with any integrative programme is always “how will I know if it

is working” In the absence of tumour markers P53 gene, protein and Bcl-2gene

expression have always given a comprehensive of how the body is dealing with

cancer. They have now been developed by Neurolab to be available as a lower

cost home finger tip blood test.

For more details contact me at [email protected]

FINANCIAL ADVICE

As many of you will know, being diagnosed with cancer does bring the practical

challenges of normal life particularly financial. A very useful chap for you to

know is George Emsden. With along background in financial services, followed

by a bout of cancer himself, he is now the most the most amazing resource for

dealing with financial matters relating to ill health. He has a web site and blog

full of good advice and is well worth consulting if financial issues crop up.

www.georgeemsden.co.uk

Page 4: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 4

COMING SOON!!!

The Yes to Life Seminar Series

Cancer: Building an Integrated Treatment Programme

It gives us great pleasure to announce the next Seminar in the Yes to Life Series.

Our top speakers

from the world of integrated cancer care include

Patricia Peat RGN - Founder, Cancer Options

Dr Nicola Hembry – Specialist in environmental and nutritional medicine

Dr Seigfried Trefzer - Medical Director, High Tree Clinic

Kristen Chick – Nutritionist, Vision of Hope Clinic

Date to be confirmed in November

To find out about Yes to Life, visit www.yestolife.org.uk.

This event is supported by

Amy Trotter

Events coordinator/Office administrator

[email protected]

YES TO LIFE EMPOWERS PEOPLE WITH CANCER WITH INFORMATION ON CAM AND SUPPORTS THEM IN

TAKING AN INTEGRATED APPROACH TO THEIR TREATMENT

Page 5: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 5

HAVING TROUBLE FITTING IT ALL IN?

One of the problems you may encounter when embarking on an integrative

regime is fitting it all in. With juicing, meditation, food preparation etc people

often complain they can’t fit in the normal household activities. Below is an

example of the sort of ingenuity and lateral thinking we have come to expect

from our wonderful clients, utilising the FIR sauna lent to him by Yes to Life,

the wonderful Derek Foot shows that it is not just women who know how to

multi task!!

Page 6: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 6

NEWSLETTER CONTENTS

Page 7 Cancer Survivors Face Tough Road Long After Treatment Ends

Page 10 New Alarm Bells About Chemicals and Cancer

Page 13 New Technique In Treating Patients With Liver Cancer Proves

Effective, Study Suggests

Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care

Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers

Page 17 Advance Toward Earlier Detection of Melanoma

Page 19 Most Patients Survive Common Thyroid Cancer Regardless of

Treatment

Page 21 Concentration, Timing and Interactions Are Key When It Comes to

Dietary Compounds

Page 22 Virtual Colonoscopy Allows Detection of Unsuspected Cancers

Beyond Colon

Page 24 Everolimus Improves Progression-Free Survival in Pancreatic

Neuroendocrine Tumours

Page 26 A Long Time Coming: New Guidance on "Normal Tissue Effects"

for Radiation Oncology

Page 29 Spicing the Meat Also Cuts the Cancer Risk, Research Suggests

Page 31 Vitamin C can curb cancer growth, say New Zealand researchers

Page 33 Aspirin cuts cancer deaths: Painkiller can boost breast cancer

survival rates by 71%

Page 7: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 7

CANCER SURVIVORS FACE TOUGH ROAD LONG AFTER

TREATMENT ENDS

Cancer survivors are more likely than their healthy peers to suffer serious

psychological distress such as anxiety and depression, even a decade after

treatment ends, new research shows.

Those who were relatively young at the time of diagnosis, unmarried, had less

than a high school education, were uninsured, had other illnesses or had

difficulty doing the activities of daily living were at the highest risk of

psychological problems.

The study appears in the July 27 issue of the Archives of Internal Medicine.

To gauge the long-term psychological impact of the disease, they analyzed

mental health and medical data on 4,636 adults who'd survived cancer and

122,220 who had never had cancer. The data was collected between 2002 and

2006 by the National Health Interview Survey, which is conducted yearly by the

U.S. Census Bureau.

During a follow-up period of at least five years and an average of 12 years,

about 5.6 percent of cancer survivors were found to have experienced severe

psychological distress within the previous month, compared with 3 percent of

those without cancer.

Dr. James Zabora, a former associate professor of oncology at Johns Hopkins

School of Medicine who has researched cancer and mental health issues, said

the study was well done but that the measure of mental health has not been

scientifically validated for use in cancer survivors. In fact, he said, he suspected

the incidence of mental health issues among cancer survivors may be higher.

"It's a well-designed study, and the investigators document a significant issue,

that is, survivors of cancer continue to struggle well after their treatment and

recovery," said Zabora, now dean of the National Catholic School of Social

Service. "But you could argue maybe this instrument under-diagnosed

psychological distress."

Page 8: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 8

"When you are faced with a serious stressor, in order for you to respond to it,

you have to define what it means for you," Zabora said. "That process depends

on how many resources you have to manage that stressor. The younger you

are, the less experience you have dealing with stressors. The lower your

education, the more difficult it is to understand the complex nature of the

disease. If you're unmarried, you may have less support."

Getting a diagnosis of cancer and going through chemotherapy can be among

life's most trying experiences, said Kevin Stein, the American Cancer Society's

director of quality-of-life research.

The physical and emotional fallout of cancer treatment, including fatigue, pain,

nausea and vomiting, mouth sores and hair loss, can contribute to feelings of

anxiety and depression. While many of these symptoms may subside or

disappear after treatment ends, some, including fatigue, can linger for months

or years.

Chemotherapy can also cause delayed problems that aren't apparent until

months or years later, including peripheral neuropathy (nerve pain or

numbness), infertility, organ dysfunction, hearing loss, muscle atrophy and

cardiovascular disease.

"Chemotherapy is an effective treatment because it's toxic to the cancer cells,

but sometimes it does collateral damage," Stein said. Cancer can also bring

about job loss and changes to relationships, including family roles and sexual

intimacy. Survivors also may fear the cancer will recur, worries that may

contribute to psychological distress.

In the study, 9 percent of long-term cancer survivors and 6 percent of

individuals without cancer reported seeing or talking to a mental health

professional within the previous year. One-third of cancer survivors with

serious psychological distress reported using mental health services, while 18

percent said they could not afford mental health care.

Screening for psychological distress in cancer survivors by primary-care

physicians and oncologists may help direct people to services that can help

them cope, Stein said. Some may find benefit from anti-anxiety medications,

cognitive behavioral psychotherapy and stress management techniques, such

as deep breathing and progressive muscle relaxation.

Page 9: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 9

And don't underestimate the power of eating a proper diet, maintaining a

healthy weight and staying physically active, Stein said.

"All of those things impact mood in a positive way and can help manage

distress," Stein said. "And always stay in touch with your doctor. When you

recognize signs of emotional distress, discuss it."

This study highlights all the elements of diagnosis and treatment that our two

services Cancer Options and the Pathway for Health are designed to help

people with. For the most comprehensive personal service available for anyone

diagnosed with cancer; Cancer Options and the Pathway Programme are

available. www.canceroptions.co.uk www.pathwayforhealth.co.uk

Page 10: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 10

NEW ALARM BELLS ABOUT CHEMICALS AND CANCER

The President’s Cancer Panel is the Mount Everest of the medical mainstream,

so it is astonishing to learn that it is poised to join ranks with the organic food

movement and declare: chemicals threaten our bodies.

The cancer panel is releasing a landmark 200-page report, warning that our

lackadaisical approach to regulation may have far-reaching consequences for

our health.

It calls on America to rethink the way we confront cancer, including much

more rigorous regulation of chemicals.

Traditionally, we reduce cancer risks through regular doctor visits, self-

examinations and screenings such as mammograms. The President’s Cancer

Panel suggests other eye-opening steps as well, such as giving preference to

organic food, checking radon levels in the home and microwaving food in glass

containers rather than plastic.

In particular, the report warns about exposures to chemicals during pregnancy,

when risk of damage seems to be greatest. Noting that 300 contaminants have

been detected in umbilical cord blood of newborn babies, the study warns

that: “to a disturbing extent, babies are born ‘pre-polluted.’ ”

It’s striking that this report emerges not from the fringe but from the mission

control of mainstream scientific and medical thinking, the President’s Cancer

Panel. Established in 1971, this is a group of three distinguished experts who

review America’s cancer program and report directly to the president.

One of the seats is now vacant, but the panel members who joined in this

report are Dr. LaSalle Leffall Jr., an oncologist and professor of surgery at

Howard University, and Dr. Margaret Kripke, an immunologist at the M.D.

Anderson Cancer Center in Houston. Both were originally appointed to the

panel by former President George W. Bush.

“We wanted to let people know that we’re concerned, and that they should be

concerned,” Professor Leffall told me.

Page 11: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 11

The report blames weak laws, lax enforcement and fragmented authority, as

well as the existing regulatory presumption that chemicals are safe unless

strong evidence emerges to the contrary.

“Only a few hundred of the more than 80,000 chemicals in use in the United

States have been tested for safety,” the report says. It adds: “Many known or

suspected carcinogens are completely unregulated.”

Industry may howl. The food industry has already been fighting legislation in

the Senate backed by Dianne Feinstein of California that would ban bisphenol-

A, commonly found in plastics and better known as BPA, from food and

beverage containers.

Studies of BPA have raised alarm bells for decades, and the evidence is still

complex and open to debate. That’s life: In the real world, regulatory decisions

usually must be made with ambiguous and conflicting data. The panel’s point is

that we should be prudent in such situations, rather than recklessly approving

chemicals of uncertain effect.

The President’s Cancer Panel report will give a boost to Senator Feinstein’s

efforts. It may also help the prospects of the Safe Chemicals Act, backed by

Senator Frank Lautenberg and several colleagues, to improve the safety of

chemicals on the market.

Some 41 percent of Americans will be diagnosed with cancer at some point in

their lives, and they include Democrats and Republicans alike. Protecting

ourselves and our children from toxins should be an effort that both parties

can get behind — if enough members of Congress are willing to put the public

interest ahead of corporate interests.

One reason for concern is that some cancers are becoming more common,

particularly in children. We don’t know why that is, but the proliferation of

chemicals in water, foods, air and household products is widely suspected as a

factor. I’m hoping the President’s Cancer Panel report will shine a stronger

spotlight on environmental causes of health problems — not only cancer, but

perhaps also diabetes, obesity and autism.

This is not to say that chemicals are evil, and in many cases the evidence

against a particular substance is balanced by other studies that are

Page 12: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 12

exonerating. To help people manage the uncertainty prudently, the report has

a section of recommendations for individuals:

· Particularly when pregnant and when children are small, choose foods, toys

and garden products with fewer endocrine disruptors or other toxins.

· For those whose jobs may expose them to chemicals, remove shoes when

entering the house and wash work clothes separately from the rest of the

laundry.

· Filter drinking water.

· Store water in glass or stainless steel containers, or in plastics that don’t

contain BPA or phthalates (chemicals used to soften plastics). Microwave

food in ceramic or glass

· Give preference to food grown without pesticides, chemical fertilizers and

growth hormones. Avoid meats that are cooked well-done.

· Check radon levels in your home. Radon is a natural source of radiation linked

to cancer.

By Nicholas D. Kristof

Page 13: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 13

NEW TECHNIQUE IN TREATING PATIENTS WITH LIVER

CANCER PROVES EFFECTIVE, STUDY SUGGESTS

Use of multipolar radiofrequency ablation in the treatment of colorectal liver

metastases is effective and has a relatively low recurrence rate, according to a

recent study conducted by researchers at Charité, Campus Benjamin Franklin

in Berlin, Germany.

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) has become a widely used treatment option for

patients with primary liver cancer and liver metastases from some primary

tumors, if surgery is not an option. However, because of limited sizes of the

ablation zones the technique has been limited to tumors smaller than four

centimeters," said Bernd Frericks, MD, lead author of the study. "This long-

term study (four years) was performed using a new multipolar radiofrequency

(RF)-device allowing for up to six ablation probes to be used simultaneously,

thus providing larger ablation zones. We evaluated this new technique

prospectively regarding ablation zone size, technical effectiveness,

complications and clinical outcome in patients with colorectal liver

metastases," he said.

The study evaluated 27 patients with 67 colorectal liver metastases that were

treated using multipolar RF ablation. According to the study, complete tumor

destruction occurred in 66 of 67 cases. Of the 67 metastases, eight required

reablation. After a mean of nine months, 16 patients developed new

metastases in the liver and the lung, eight of which were successfully

reablated. After four years, 52% of the patients are now tumor-free and 78%

are still living.

"Using this new device, the rate of local tumor progressions was not influenced

by the size of the tumor to be treated," said Dr. Frericks.

The full results of this study will be presented on Wednesday, April 16, 2008

during the American Roentgen Ray Society's annual meeting in Washington,

DC.

Page 14: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 14

NICE CALLS FOR SPECIALIST CANCER TEAMS TO BOOST PATIENT CARE

THIS IS GOOD NEWS AS PEOPLE WITH UNKNOWN

PRIMARIES CAN BE LEFT WITHOUT PROPER SUPPORT

Specialist cancer teams should be set up to improve the care and treatment of

patients whose cancer has spread to other parts of the body from an unknown

primary location, NICE says.

Around 10,000 people are diagnosed with cancer of unknown primary origin

(CUP) in England and Wales every year, making the disease one of the most

common causes of cancer death. However, current levels of care for patients

with CUP are patchy, with many patients missing out on the high-standards of

care on offer to patients with site-specific cancers such as breast and bowel.

This latest guidance calls for a re-organisation of cancer services to boost care

for this group of patients, and has received the support of the National Cancer

Peer Review Programme in England, which is developing a number of peer

review quality measures,

Hospitals will be expected to follow the measures and are assessed against

them with the aim of improving care for cancer patients and their families.

Under the plans, all hospitals with a cancer centre or unit should set up

specialist CUP teams to support and manage the care of patients with this

diagnosis. This team will be responsible for guiding patients’ care until they are

referred to a consultant with expertise in a particular type of cancer, referred

for palliative care alone or are finally diagnosed with confirmed CUP.

Specialist CUP Multi Disciplinary Teams should be set up at a Network level to

review the treatment and care of patients with confirmed CUP, or with

complex diagnostic issues.

Professor Peter Littlejohns, NICE Clinical and Public Health Director, said: “We

are pleased that the National Cancer Peer Review Programme in England is

taking note of our guideline and looking to use it to improve services.

Page 15: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 15

“It is important that patients with this form of cancer receive the same level of

care that other cancer patients experience. This guideline seeks to provide a

consistent, national approach to the diagnosis and management of this

condition.”

Dr Andrew Fowell, Guideline Development Group (GDG) Chair and a Macmillan

Consultant in Palliative Medicine at Eryri Hospital, North Wales, said: “Just as

specialised teams help care for patients with a site-specific cancer such as

breast, prostate, bowel or liver, the same needs to exist for those with CUP.

These teams can provide great support for cancer patients and better one-on-

one care.

"We expect some oncologists to become CUP specialists, alongside their more

conventional site-specific activities. They will be supported by CUP Nurse

Specialists, Palliative Care physicians, and other core diagnostic staff. These

teams should be supported by their hospitals to ensure they are given

sufficient time in their job plans for this specialist role and any training that

may be needed."

Dr David Brooks, a member of the GDG and Macmillan Consultant in Palliative

Medicine at Chesterfield Royal Hospital, helped to establish a specialist CUP

team earlier this year.

He said: “Our Unknown Primary Team consists of existing members of the

Upper GI Cancer and Palliative Care teams. We see one or two patients per

week in a Cancer Unit that covers a population of just over 300,000 so the

workload is not onerous.

“It is early days but we are already seeing benefits in both providing early

supportive and palliative care, more effective targeting of investigations to

confirm treatable disease and, in those who are not fit for treatment, stopping

inappropriate tests and re-focusing care towards arranging appropriate

support and palliation to enable the patient to get home.”

Dr Richard Osborne, GDG lead clinician and Consultant in Medical Oncology,

Dorset Cancer Centre, added:“This guideline will provide a sound basis for

healthcare professionals to ensure patients are informed and their care is

centred around their needs and wishes.”

Page 16: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 16

SCIENTISTS FIND GENE THAT CAUSES LUNG CANCER IN NON-SMOKERS

A gene that can cause lung cancer in people who have never smoked has been

pinpointed by scientists.

Mutations in the gene - known as GPC5 - could lead to a 'significantly higher

risk' of lung cancer among those who have never touched tobacco.

The research suggests that targetting the gene could lead to new treatments

for the disease and identify high risk patients earlier.

Mutations: A gene that can cause lung cancer in people who have never

smoked has been pinpointed by scientists. A quarter of people who die from

lung cancer each year globally have never smoked.

An international team of scientists, led by Ping Yang from the Mayo Clinic

College of Medicine in Rochester, New York, studied people who have smoked

less than 100 cigarettes in their lifetime. They examined DNA samples from

754 non-smokers to find the genetic variations most likely to lead to lung

cancer.

Tests showed that GPC5 expression levels were 50 per cent lower in

adenocarcinoma - the most common form of lung cancer - than in matched

normal lung tissue.

This indicates that reduced GPC5 expression could be specific for

adenocarcinoma in people who have never smoked.

The research is published in The Lancet Oncology journal.

But Dr Ramaswamy Govindan, of Washington University, warned: 'Even though

this study reports a two-fold reduction in GPC5 expression in adenocarcinoma

tissues compared to matched normal controls, it is far from clear how reduced

GPC5 expression could predispose individuals to lung cancer.

'More studies are needed to confirm these preliminary observations in the

tumour samples from those with no history of tobacco smoking.'

Page 17: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 17

ADVANCE TOWARD EARLIER DETECTION OF MELANOMA

Melanoma is one of the less common types of skin cancer but it accounts for

the majority of the skin cancer deaths (about 75 percent).

The five-year survival rate for early stage melanoma is very high (98 percent),

but the rate drops precipitously if the cancer is detected late or there is

recurrence. So a great deal rides on the accuracy of the initial surgery, where

the goal is to remove as little tissue as possible while obtaining "clean margins"

all around the tumor.

So far no imaging technique has been up to the task of defining the

melanoma's boundaries accurately enough to guide surgery. Instead surgeons

tend to cut well beyond the visible margins of the lesion in order to be certain

they remove all the malignant tissue.

Two scientists at Washington University in St. Louis have developed

technologies that together promise to solve this difficult problem.

Their solution, described in the July issue of ACS Nano, combines an imaging

technique developed by Lihong Wang, PhD, the Gene K. Beare Distinguished

Professor of Biomedical Engineering, and a contrast agent developed by

Younan Xia, PhD, the James M. McKelvey Professor of Biomedical Engineering.

Together the imaging technique and contrast agent produce images of startling

three-dimensional clarity.

Photoacoustic tomography (PAT) can detect deep structures that strongly

absorb light because sound scatters much less than light in tissue.

"PAT improves tissue transparency by two to three orders of magnitude," says

Wang.

Moreover, it's a lot safer than other means of deep imaging. It uses photons

whose energy is only a couple of electron-volts, whereas X-rays have energies

in the thousands of electron-volts. Positron emission tomography (PET) also

requires high-energy photons, Wang says.

Page 18: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 18

Photoacoustic images of biological tissue can be made without the use of

contrast agents, particularly if tissues are pigmented by molecules like

hemoglobin or melanin.

Still, photoacoustic images of melanomas are fuzzy and vague around the

edges. To improve the contrast between the malignant and normal tissue, Xia

loads the malignant tissue with gold.

"Gold is much better at scattering and absorbing light than biological

materials," Xia says. "One gold nanocage absorbs as much light as a million

melanin molecules," says Xia.

The molecule is alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone, slightly altered to

make it more stable in the body. This hormone normally stimulates the

production and release of the brown pigment melanin in the skin and hair.

As is true in many types of cancers, this hormone seems to stimulate the

growth of cancerous cells, which produce more hormone receptors than

normal cells.

Page 19: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 19

MOST PATIENTS SURVIVE COMMON THYROID CANCER REGARDLESS OF TREATMENT

Individuals with papillary thyroid cancer that has not spread beyond the

thyroid gland appear to have favorable outcomes regardless of whether they

receive treatment within the first year after diagnosis, according to a report in

the May issue of Archives of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, one of the

JAMA/Archives journals.

Papillary thyroid cancer is commonly found on autopsy among individuals who

died of other causes, according to background information in the article.

"Studies published as early as 1947 demonstrated it, and more recently, a

report has shown that nearly every thyroid gland might be found to have a

cancer if examined closely enough," the authors write. "The advent of

ultrasonography and fine-needle aspiration biopsy has allowed many

previously undetected cancers to be identified, changing the epidemiology of

the disease. Over the past 30 years, the detected incidence of thyroid cancer

has increased three-fold, the entire increase attributable to papillary thyroid

cancer and 87% of the increase attributable to tumors measuring less than 2

centimeters."

Louise Davies, M.D., M.S., of Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, N.H. and

Gilbert Welch, M.D., M.P.H., both also of Department of Veterans Affairs

Medical Center, White River Junction, Vt., and The Dartmouth Institute for

Health Policy and Clinical Practice, Hanover, studied cancer cases and

individual treatment data from National Cancer Institute registries. They then

tracked cause of death through the National Vital Statistics System.

The researchers identified 35,663 patients with papillary thyroid cancer that

had not spread to the lymph nodes or other areas at diagnosis. Of these, 440

(1.2 percent) did not undergo immediate, definitive treatment. Over an

average of six years of follow-up, six of these patients died of their cancer. This

was not significantly different from the rate of cancer death among the 35,223

individuals who did undergo treatment (161 over an average of 7.6 years of

follow-up).

The 20-year survival rate from cancer was estimated to be 97 percent for those

Page 20: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 20

who did not receive treatment and 99 percent for those who did. "These data

help put management decisions about localized papillary thyroid cancer in

perspective: papillary thyroid cancers of any size that are confined to the

thyroid gland, have no lymph node metastases at presentation and do not

show extraglandular extension [reach beyond the thyroid gland] are unlikely to

result in death due to the cancer," the authors write.

"Thus, clinicians and patients should feel comfortable considering the option to

observe for a year or longer cancers that fall into this category," they conclude.

"When treatment is elected, the cancers in this category can be managed with

either hemithyroidectomy [removal of part of the thyroid] or total

thyroidectomy [removal of the complete gland], and the prognosis will be the

same

Page 21: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 21

CONCENTRATION, TIMING AND INTERACTIONS ARE KEY WHEN IT COMES TO DIETARY COMPOUNDS

Agricultural Research Service (ARS) chemist Thomas Wang, who specializes in

cancer prevention research, has reported evidence that for some dietary

compounds, length of exposure over time may be key to whether or not

ingestion leads to a beneficial, or detrimental, effect.

Scientists do not know exactly why one person develops cancer and another

does not. But they do know that certain nutrients might increase or decrease

cancer risk. There are "layers" of factors involved in the development of

cancer, and Wang is studying the layers involving peoples' diet complexity and

gene expression.

Wang works at the ARS Diet, Genomics and Immunology Laboratory, part of

the Beltsville (Md.) Human Nutrition Research Center. He published a

complementary cell-culture and animal-model study showing that

concentrations of resveratrol -- a highly bioactive compound found in grapes

and other plant foods -- actually turned out to be a double-edged sword when

it came to mitigating cancer risk.

First, Wang exposed human prostate cancer cells to resveratrol and found that

it inhibited the cells' growth. He further tested the cells' gene expression. Then

Wang tested the effects of resveratrol on a group of laboratory animals that

had sex-hormone-dependent tumor cells.

Half of those animals were fed a daily diet that included 3 to 6 milligrams of

purified resveratrol (equal to roughly the amount in five glasses of wine or

grape juice). At first, the tumor cells in the resveratrol-fed lab animals grew

slower. But as the animals continued to consume resveratrol, there was an

increase in blood vessels developing around the tumors of the resveratrol-fed

animals, effectively setting up a system of feeding the tumors.

The study, published in the journal Carcinogenesis, showed that the

concentration of the plant compound is important, but so is length of

exposure, according to the authors.

Page 22: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 22

VIRTUAL COLONOSCOPY ALLOWS DETECTION OF

UNSUSPECTED CANCERS BEYOND COLON

A new, large-scale study of more than 10,000 adults found that more than one

in every 200 asymptomatic people screened with CT colonography, or virtual

colonoscopy, had clinically unsuspected malignant cancer and more than half

of the cancers were located outside the colon. The findings were published in

the April issue of the journal Radiology.

We are finding that virtual colonoscopy screening actually identifies more

unsuspected cancers outside of the colon than within it," said lead author

Perry J. Pickhardt, M.D., professor of radiology and chief of GI Imaging, at the

University of Wisconsin School of Medicine & Public Health. "As with

asymptomatic colorectal cancers identified by virtual colonoscopy screening,

these cancers are often detected at an early, curable stage."

Colorectal cancer remains the second leading cause of cancer death in the U.S.,

and the National Cancer Institute estimated that there would be 146,970 new

cases diagnosed in 2009 and 49,920 deaths. The disease is largely preventable

through screening for colon polyps, which are benign growths that may

develop into cancer if not removed. The American Cancer Society recommends

that people at average risk for colorectal cancer begin regular colorectal cancer

screening at age 50, but current compliance with this recommendation is

below 50 percent. Many people resist screening because of the discomfort and

inconvenience caused by the conventional optical colonoscopy test.

Virtual colonoscopy is less invasive than optical colonoscopy and produces

precise and detailed "fly-through" images of the entire colon's interior without

having to insert a scope. With virtual colonoscopy screening, there is

essentially no risk of bleeding or of perforating the colon. There is no need for

intravenous sedation, and the procedure is less costly than conventional

optical colonoscopy. It also is more convenient, typically taking 10 minutes or

less. Virtual colonoscopy also allows for limited assessment of structures

outside the colon (extracolonic), including the abdomen, pelvis and portions of

the lungs. Additional diagnostic tests for unsuspected extracolonic findings are

performed in about 6 percent of cases, nearly half of which ultimately prove to

be clinically relevant.

Page 23: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 23

"Optical colonoscopy cannot provide for any assessment beyond the colon

itself, whereas virtual colonoscopy can detect a wide array of unsuspected

extracolonic diseases, most notably cancers and aortic aneurysms," Dr.

Pickhardt said.

For the study, Dr. Pickhardt and colleagues set out to determine the detection

rate and clinical outcome of unsuspected malignancies detected with virtual

colonoscopy in an asymptomatic screening population. The researchers

retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 10,286 adults (5,388 men and

4,898 women) with a mean age of 59.8 years who were evaluated at either the

University of Wisconsin or National Naval Medical Center. All of the adults had

undergone colorectal cancer screening with virtual colonoscopy at the two

centers between April 2004 and March 2008. The mean time for follow-up was

30.2 months.

Unsuspected cancer was confirmed in 58 patients, including 33 women and 25

men. Invasive colorectal cancer was found in 22 patients, and extracolonic

cancer was found in 36 patients. Cancers in 31 patients (53.4 percent) were

stage 1 or localized cancers.

"To our knowledge, none of the patients who presented with stage 1, stage 2

or localized disease at diagnosis has progressed to a higher stage," Dr.

Pickhardt said. "The fact that so many of the cancers in our study were

localized or detected at an early stage appears to have positively affected

survival."

Extracolonic malignancies, which outnumbered cases of invasive colorectal

cancer, included renal cell carcinoma, lung cancer and non-Hodgkin lymphoma,

among others.

"Although extracolonic evaluation at screening CT colonography does carry

some disadvantages, such as patient anxiety, inconvenience, or the potential

for benign biopsy, our results suggest that early detection of asymptomatic

extracolonic cancer represents an additional benefit of screening CT

colonography that is not available with optical colonoscopy," Dr. Pickhardt

said.

"Virtual colonoscopy is an accurate, safe and convenient screening test that

could potentially be a life-saving examination," he added.

Page 24: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 24

EVEROLIMUS IMPROVES PROGRESSION-FREE SURVIVAL IN PANCREATIC NEUROENDOCRINE TUMORS

THIS IS GOOD NEWS FOR A CANCER THAT HAS FEW VIABLE OPTIONS

AVAILABLE, LETS HOPE NICE AGREES!

Another targeted therapy has had a major impact on pancreatic

neuroendocrine tumors in a phase 3 clinical trial, so now everolimus (Afinitor,

Novartis) and sunitinib (Sutent, Pfizer) are set to offer new treatment options

in these patients.

Both drugs are already marketed for use in kidney cancer and for other

indications. The new data for pancreatic neuroendocrine tumors have already

been filed with regulatory authorities for sunitinib, and there are plans to file

for everolimus for this new indication.

Pancreatic neuroendocrine tumors affect the hormone-producing tissues

within the pancreas, and are relatively rare, affecting annually only 2 to 4

people per million worldwide. However, the incidence is rising, and has

quadrupled in the past 30 years, according to data from the National Cancer

Institute. The most common treatment is surgery, which can be curative, but

patients who are not suitable candidates have been treated with

chemotherapy. Targeted agents now stand to offer a new treatment option,

with lower toxicity and the convenience of oral dosing.

New Data With Everolimus

The latest results, reported at the 12th World Congress on Gastrointestinal

Cancer in Barcelona, Spain, show that everolimus significantly increased

progression-free survival in a placebo-controlled phase 3 trial of 410 patients,

the largest study ever conducted in this tumor type.

The results, presented at the meeting by James Yao, MD, from the University

of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, showed that everolimus

increased progression-free survival to 11 months, compared with 4.6 months

for placebo and best supportive care (hazard ratio [HR], 0.35; P < .0001).

This is similar to the improvement in progression-free survival seen with

sunitinib in a phase 3 trial reported earlier this year, which was stopped early

because of the benefit seen. That trial involved 171 patients, and sunitinib

Page 25: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 25

improved progression-free survival to 11.4 months, compared with 5.5 months

for placebo and best supportive care (HR, 0.418; P = .0001).

New data from that trial, including results for overall survival, were reported at

the Barcelona meeting by the principal investigator, Eric Raymond, MD,

professor of medical oncology at Beaujon University Hospital in Clichy, France.

The 1-year median overall survival was 90% in the sunitinib group and 70% in

the placebo group, Dr. Raymond reported. The latest data, at 20 months, show

that the benefit in the sunitinib group was sustained, with overall survival

remaining at 90%, but it fell to below 60% in the placebo group (HR, 0.409; P =

.0204).

"In my opinion, it's great news, as tolerance can be different in patients" and it

is useful to have more than 1 agent to choose from, he added.

"Pancreatic neuroendocrine tumors are generally felt to be indolent, although

the majority do present at an advanced stage," Dr. Saif said. "In the past,

treatment options have been limited, with hormonal treatment with

octreotide being the primary therapeutic approach. Chemotherapeutic agents

have been used with limited efficacy; [they are] less effective in well-

differentiated tumors," he explained, adding that "targeted therapy has a clear

Page 26: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 26

A LONG TIME COMING: NEW GUIDANCE ON "NORMAL

TISSUE EFFECTS" FOR RADIATION ONCOLOGY WHO THOUGHT ONCOLOGY ALWAYS WORKED FROM AN

EVIDENCE BASE!

A group of international experts has published a new set of recommendations

for the irradiation of 16 different organs that are sites of potential collateral

damage from radiation therapy for cancers.

The recommendations, known as the Quantitative Analysis of Normal Tissue

Effects in the Clinic (QUANTEC), address a fundamental challenge in radiation

oncology treatment: the competing needs to limit normal tissue damage and

to deliver a therapeutic dose to the cancer.

QUANTEC is the first such set of comprehensive recommendations published in

radiation oncology in 19 years — since the study by Emami et al in 1991 (Int J

Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1991;21:109–122).

Why has it taken so long?

"There have been many reports on individual organs since 1991, so the field

has not been stuck using the 1991 data/report," said Lawrence B. Marks, MD,

from the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill, and one of the editors of

QUANTEC. But he did admit that a QUANTEC-like report could have been done

earlier.

Mary Martel, PhD, also a QUANTEC editor, said the new report is a great leap

forward from the Emami work, in which recommendations were largely based

on a survey of clinicians' experiences.

QUANTEC is unprecedented in our literature because these are evidence-

based guidelines.

"QUANTEC is unprecedented in our literature because these are evidence-

based guidelines to limit the dose to normal tissue as much as possible," said

Dr. Martel, from the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in

Houston, in an interview with Medscape Oncology.

QUANTEC features individual chapters or reviews on 16 organs, including the

Page 27: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 27

brain, ear, parotid, heart, bladder, rectum, and lung.

The 16 are "normal" organs and are not organs from which cancers arise, such

as the prostate or breast, Dr. Marks told Medscape Oncology. "The rectum and

bladder chapters are largely about patients with prostate cancer in whom

there is a risk of injury to the bladder and rectum," he explained.

One of the goals of QUANTEC is to provide "practical guidance allowing the

clinician to reasonably (although not necessarily precisely) categorize toxicity

risk based on dose/volume parameters or model results," according to one of

the essays that introduce the 16 chapters on individual organs.

But Bahman Emami, MD, lead author of the seminal 1991 paper, thinks that

QUANTEC fails in a key matter of practicality — the all-important summary

tables.

"The practicing community-based radiation oncologist needs something

simpler, a table that says, for each organ, 'don't go beyond this dose'," said Dr.

Emami, who is from the Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine in

Illinois.

That's why my tables became so famous.

QUANTEC's dose/volume/outcome tables present information in a graded

manner and are missing this simple and emphatic message, Dr. Emami told

Medscape Oncology. "That's why my tables became so famous," he said,

referring to the clearly stated limits in his paper's summary tables.

Page 28: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 28

The QUANTEC report is published at a time when the field of radiation

oncology has been scrutinized by the media and regulators. A recent feature in

the New York Times exposed how software and operator errors in radiotherapy

have resulted in serious injuries and patient death, and the US Food and Drug

Administration has recently notified manufacturers of radiotherapy equipment

that the speedy, streamlined review processes of their products may no longer

be available to them

"It's definitely a coincidence," said Dr. Martel about the timing of the issuance

of QUANTEC and the eruption of negative publicity surrounding radiation

oncology.

But she also said that the aggressive marketing and rapid implementation of

new radiotherapy technologies have gotten "out of control."

Dr. Marks circumspectly acknowledged the tumultuous business environment.

"We are in an evolving field and we need to be careful to apply the new

technology in a reasonable manner," he said.

For all of the fancy technologies, one is always left with the same set of

issues.

But he returned his attention to QUANTEC. "For all of the fancy technologies,

one is always left with the same set of issues: How much can I give to the

tumor safely? What are the normal tissues at risk? What are the trade-offs?

For these questions, one needs good data on dose/volume/outcome."

Another prominent radiation oncologist believes that professionals in the field

need to be reminded that treatment with radiation, effective as it may be, has

inherent dangers for normal tissue.

We need to move beyond 'tolerance doses' and recognize that radiation

treats large anatomic segments of normal tissues.

"We need to move beyond 'tolerance doses' and recognize that radiation

treats large anatomic segments of normal tissues while concentrating, shaping,

and conforming the high-dose volume to the cancer," said Philip Rubin, MD,

from the University of Rochester Medical Center in New York. "There is total

body scatter radiation beyond the treated segments housing the cancer. Any

Page 29: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 29

radiation or chemotherapy dose, even well below tolerance doses, can leave

an imprint on any cell in the body. A point mutation in a cell can result decades

later in very late carcinogenesis and a second malignancy," he told Medscape

Oncology.

"Cancer treatment is like life in general — there are no free lunches. The price

of being a long-term cancer survivor may very well be an adverse late effect,"

said Dr. Rubin.

Written by Nick Mulcahy

Page 30: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 30

SPICING THE MEAT ALSO CUTS THE CANCER RISK,

RESEARCH SUGGESTS

MIGHT JUST BE BETTER TO AVOID THE BEEF!

Spices will do more than just enhance the taste of ground beef. They may also

cut down on the risk of compounds that can cause cancer.

J. Scott Smith, a Kansas State University food chemistry professor, has pursued

different projects in recent years seeking ways to reduce heterocyclic amines

(HCAs). HCAs are the carcinogenic compounds that are produced when muscle

foods, such as ground beef patties, are barbecued, grilled, boiled or fried.

Consuming HCAs through meat increases risk factors for colorectal, stomach,

lung, pancreatic, mammary and prostate cancers.

Smith, in research supported by the Food Safety Consortium, found that

certain spices containing natural antioxidants would reduce HCA levels by 40

percent when applied to beef patties during cooking.

"Cooked beef tends to develop more HCAs than other kinds of cooked meats

such as pork and chicken," Smith said. "Cooked beef patties appear to be the

cooked meat with the highest mutagenic activity and may be the most

important source of HCAs in the human diet."

Previous studies have shown that meat products cooked below 352 degrees

Fahrenheit for less than four minutes had low or undetectable levels of HCAs,

with HCAs increasing with higher temperatures and added cooking time. It's

not a good idea to lower cooking temperatures too much, so antioxidant spices

with phenolic compounds can block HCAs before they form during heating and

still allow high temperatures to be maintained.

Smith's research team investigated six spices -- cumin, coriander seeds,

galangal, fingerroot, rosemary and tumeric -- and found that the latter three

had the highest levels of antioxidant activity toward inhibiting the formation of

HCAs, with rosemary as the most effective.

Consumers can take advantage of the spices by integrating them into their

Page 31: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 31

cooking regimen. Previous research in his laboratory has demonstrated that

some commercial rosemary extracts, available for purchase on the Internet,

can inhibit HCA formation by 61 to 79 percent. Smith's earlier work also

showed that Thai spices can inhibit HCA formation by 40 to 43 percent.

Smith said future research in this area will investigate what some marinades or

powders can do to inhibit HCAs when applied to a cooked patties. His earlier

project showed that marinating steaks with certain herbs, rosemary and other

antioxidant spices also reduces HCAs.

VITAMIN C CAN CURB CANCER GROWTH, SAY NEW

ZEALAND RESEARCHERS

PROGRESS TOWARDS REAL EVIDENCE FOR VIT C IS BEING

MADE, GREAT NEWS ON IT HELPING CHEMO!

Wellington (dpa) - Vitamin C can help curb the growth of cancer cells,

according to New Zealand scientists who claim breakthrough research to

provide the first real evidence of a connection between the vitamin and the

development of tumours.

"Our results offer a promising and simple intervention to help in our fight

against cancer at the level of both prevention and cure," Associate Professor

Margreet Vissers, of the University of Otago's Free Radical Research Group,

said recently.

She said the role of vitamin C in cancer treatment had been the subject of

debate for years, with many anecdotal accounts of the vitamin's beneficial

role.

While her previous research had demonstrated the vitamin's importance in

maintaining cell health and hinted at its potential for limiting diseases such as

cancer, the latest study looked at whether vitamin C levels were lowered in

patients with endometrial tumours.

Page 32: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 32

She said the study found that tumours were less able to accumulate vitamin C

compared with normal healthy tissue and that this related to the ability of the

tumour to survive and grow.

"Tumours with low vitamin C levels had more of a protein called HIF-1 which

allows them to thrive in conditions of stress," she said.

"The findings are significant as they show, for the first time, a direct

relationship between HIF-1 and vitamin C levels in tumours and suggest it

would be beneficial for people with cancer cells to have more vitamin C."

"This could help limit the rate of tumour growth, increase the responsiveness

to chemotherapy and may prevent the formation of solid tumours."

Details of the research are published in the latest edition of the Cancer

Research journal

Deutsche Presse-Agentur (dpa)

Page 33: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 33

ASPIRIN CUTS CANCER DEATHS: PAINKILLER CAN BOOST BREAST CANCER SURVIVAL RATES BY 71%

GREAT, BUT NO PLANS FOR LARGE TRIALS — NO MONEY = NO EVIDENCE, ISN’T IT ABOUT TIME WE HAD MORE CLINICAL STUDIES OUTSIDE OF

THE CONTROL OF DRUG COMPANIES?

Women in the study who took two to five aspirins a week were far less likely to

die from breast cancer or for the cancer to spread

Women with breast cancer who take aspirin at least twice a week can more

than double their chance of surviving, researchers say. The greatest protection

comes from taking the drug two, three, four or five times a week, a study has

found.

They cut the risk of dying by 71 per cent and the risk of the cancer spreading by

60 per cent. Taking aspirin on six or seven days cut the death risk by 64 per

cent, but the risk of spreading fell only 43 per cent.

The findings of the U.S. study provide the most compelling evidence yet of the

power of the cheap painkiller. Previous research has suggested that aspirin can

protect against bowel cancer, although results for other cancers, such as breast

and prostate, were less clear-cut.

The latest dramatic results came from a 30-year project tracking the health of

238,000 nurses.

Lead researcher Dr Michelle Holmes, of Harvard Medical School, said: 'This is

the first study to find that aspirin can significantly reduce the risk of cancer

spread and death for women who have been treated for early-stage breast

cancer.

'If these findings are confirmed in other clinical trials, taking aspirin may

become another simple, low-cost and relatively safe tool to help women with

breast cancer live longer, healthier lives.'

Drugs in the same class as aspirin, including ibuprofen and naproxen, also

lowered the risks, but paracetamol did not.

Experts warned, however, that aspirin can have serious side effects, including

stomach irritation that can lead to ulcers and even fatal bleeding.

Page 34: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 34

For some people the risk of harm is greater than potential benefits.

Women newly diagnosed with breast cancer are advised not to take aspirin for

the first 12 months as it can cause side effects while they undergo

chemotherapy or radiation. Researchers are uncertain exactly how aspirin

affects tumours but it could be by lowering inflammation. The study found that

there were no beneficial effects for people who took aspirin only once a week.

Despite its benefits, many cancer sufferers could also find themselves

struggling with severe side effects if they take aspirin regularly. Dr Holmes said:

'Aspirin cannot be considered a substitute for conventional cancer treatments,

and taking aspirin does have negative effects in some.

'More study is definitely needed to establish the cause and effect of aspirin on

breast cancer. But for now, if a woman has breast cancer and is taking aspirin,

she may take some comfort in knowing she might be doing something to help

prevent her breast cancer from recurring.'

Millions of people in the UK already take low-dose aspirin every day on

doctor's advice to reduce the chance of a repeat heart attack or stroke. Others

take it of their own accord for 'health insurance'. Most of the women in the

new study, published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, were taking aspirin to

prevent heart disease.

The Harvard team identified 4,000 breast cancer patients between 1976 and

2002 and followed them until their deaths or the end of the study in June

2006.

Altogether 341 women died from the cancer.

The Harvard study falls short of the research 'gold standard', however,

because the women reported their aspirin use in questionnaires, rather than

going through a controlled clinical trial.

The next stage of drug development would normally be a large randomised

study, but this may never happen.

Not only is aspirin so cheap it will not make any money for drug firms, it could

be hard to find a group of women with breast cancer who were prepared

never to take aspirin during a trial.

Page 35: CANCER OPTIONS NEWSLETTER · Page 14 NICE calls for specialist cancer teams to boost patient care Page 16 Scientists find gene that causes lung cancer in non-smokers Page 17 Advance

Page | 35

Nick Henderson of the European Aspirin Foundation, which represents the

industry, said: 'The best evidence for aspirin in protecting against cancer has

been from studies on bowel cancer. 'But this latest report adds to growing

evidence that aspirin appears to have special effects in reducing cancer risk

through a mechanism which has yet to be scientifically explained.

'However, I doubt it will be possible to carry out a proper clinical trial because

everyone has heard aspirin may be useful. We're going to hold a conference to

plan the way forward.'

Ed Yong, head of health information at Cancer Research UK, said: 'Several

studies have found that taking aspirin and related drugs is associated with a

lower risk of breast cancer, and this new study suggests that they might also

help to stop cancer from spreading and improve a woman's chances of

survival. 'But aspirin has risks as well as benefits, so we need large clinical

trials to see if it can really save lives from breast cancer, and, if so, to work out

what doses to use and how long to use the drugs for.' By Jenny Hope