carlo scarpa università di brescia [email protected] · iss local public services torino, 10th...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
1
Local public firms and local utilities: ownership, regulation and competition
Carlo Scarpa
Università di Brescia
![Page 2: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
2
Municipal socialism or capitalism?
• Since the 19th century, considerable direct presence in the ownership of firms – Special services (new demand from new population)
• Now, socialism or capitalism? – Strict constraints in public finance, national and local
• Does public ownership make a difference? – And should it make a difference?
– If not, why remain among the shareholders?
![Page 3: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
3
Good management is anyway
reasonable
• The real issues are
– Set the objectives
– Find the optimal instrument • The “right” balance between market and direct
public intervention
– Verify compatibility with the budget constraint
• Objectives: a Political matter
![Page 4: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
4
Regulation and local services
• The meaning of regulatory reforms
• What is an optimal price regime?
• Local (instead of national) public services
![Page 5: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
5
A hierarchy of decisions
• Identify the services which we want citizens to have – Public services?
• Identify the maximum prices which we want customers to pay for these services
• If these prices are below cost, subsidized monopoly – How do we select the provider?
• If these prices are above costs, the market may work – Competition in the market
![Page 6: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
6
Each sector may be very complex
• The final customer only sees one end – Monopoly segments
– Segments where no economies of scale exist
• Vertical integration has its virtues – No double marginalization
• But it often preserves monopoly – High prices
– Huge inefficiencies
![Page 7: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
7
Monopoly and competition
• Unbundling creates several companies where there is one – Organizational costs
– Double marginalization
• Unbundling serves the purpose of introducing competition whenever possible – But either competition is effective, or unbundling may
worsen the situation
![Page 8: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
8
Structure: an example (energy)
Distribution
Upstream
Transmission
Natural gas extraction & regassification
Electricity generation
High pressure – High voltage
Local networks connecting final customers
Relationship with final customers, billing,
customer service Supply
Potentially
competitive
Potentially
competitive
Regulated business
(who decides?)
Natural monopoly
(not necessarily
national)
Storage Only in gas
![Page 9: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
9
Key national (?) decisions (structure)
• Do we want to preserve large national champions upstream? – If so, competition is very limited
– In gas: how effective can it be anyway if you import gas?
• Do we want transmission and production to be integrated? – If so, the monopolist will be very protected, but rivals will hardly
develop
• How large do we want the downstream market to be? – How easy to leave your historical seller? (switching)?
![Page 10: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
10
Key decisions (regulation)
• Do we want to preserve the right of the political system to decide these prices? – If so, competition is very limited
– In gas: how effective can it be anyway if you import gas?
• Do we want transmission and production to be integrated? – If so, the monopolist will be very protected, but rivals will hardly
develop
• How large do we want the downstream market to be? – How easy to leave your historical seller? (switching)?
![Page 11: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
11
Policy objectives
• Long term – Security and quality of supply
– Investment in infrastructures
• Short term – Efficient prices
– Reasonable prices (affordability)
• Others – Inflation
– Employment/salaries
– Local development …
![Page 12: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
12
Regulation and local services
• The meaning of regulatory reforms
• What is an optimal price regime?
• Local (instead of national) public services
![Page 13: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
13
The price regime
• Efficiency orientation – Cost reflective
• (Political decision not to spend public money)
• Not essential (prices may in principle be below costs)
– Concern for investments • Remuneration and incentives
• Transparency in price determination – Pre-determined criteria
– Equal for all players
– In practice…
![Page 14: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
14
Methods of price regulation
A jump in the theory…
• Cost-plus
• Rate of return regulation
• Fixed price – RPI-x
• Profit sharing
![Page 15: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
15
Cost plus: just madness?
• Non avoidable costs
• The alternative is a public subsidy, at the
expense of tax payers
• Incentive to efficiency?
• In practice…
![Page 16: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
16
Profit regulation (ROR)
/K r
• Limitations:
– Over-investment (Averch Johnson)
– Administrative difficulties
– Inefficient prices
![Page 17: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
17
Looking for perfection:
the price cap
• In a static sense: price = C’
• In a dynamic sense: fix price, or at least a
pre-determined dynamics, which the firm
cannot affect (RPI-x)
• Incentive to investments
![Page 18: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
18
RPI – x and costs
price
time
General price level (RPI)
Regulated price (RPI-x)
Cost (?)
p0
![Page 19: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
19
Problems?
• Is it true that the incentive to invest is not
distorted?
• Who bears the risk if input prices increase?
• Price review: how are prices reviewed?
• Credibility
![Page 20: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
20
Profit sharing: just demagogy?
• In period t, x increases to x’ if profit in t-1 goes
beyond a threshold
• Lesser pressures from the public opinion
lesser regulatory risk
• Greater efficiency in the distribution of surplus
• Incentive to invest? Profit sharing intervenes
only if things go well …
![Page 21: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
21
Price regulation from theory to practice
• (Italy) price cap system (law 481/95)
– Initial price (p0)
– Dynamic adjustment (x etc.)
• How is the initial price determined ?
• What happens within the regulatory
period?
![Page 22: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
22
The price at the beginning
of the regulatory period
RAB x
WACC*
Operational costs
* Regulatory asset base (RAB), remunerated through WACC
Total allowed costs
/
The price contains a pre-determined remuneration of
capital
Element of rate of return regulation
Output = price
![Page 23: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
23
Within a regulatory period
• Price cap is sometimes applied only to
“avoidable” costs (personnel)
• Price increases if input prices increase
• The new price shares efficiency gains
50-50 between firms and consumers
– cost plus
– profit sharing
![Page 24: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
24
Theory and practice
• Called price cap
• In practice it combines elements of
– Price cap (possibly limited to avoidable costs)
– ROR in the cost of capital
– Cost plus for some inputs (especially wholesale prices)
– Profit sharing at the end of the regulatory period
![Page 25: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
25
The investment regime
• In theory: left to the firms
– Direct incentives (ROR)
– Indirect incentives (privileged access to newly build infrastrucures)
• In practice, even more intervention:
– For activities given in concession, minimum obligations are defined
– Guidance by the Ministry
![Page 26: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
26
Rules or discretion?
• In practice, regulation is not fully transparent
• Discretionary intervention takes place – On price
• How to translate costs into prices
• Price reviews
– On investments (guidance by the Ministry)
– Through a heavy public presence in firms
• Within EU Directives and general competition principles
![Page 27: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
27
Price regulation v. revenue regulation
• Revenue is p x q
– Regulating revenues (revenue caps) is equivalent to
regulating prices if q is perfectly predictable
• When q is risky, with price regulation the firm
bears output risk
– May be good or bad depending on demand dynamics
• Water: falling demand
• Others: sensitive to business cycles
![Page 28: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
28
Problem: prices may be below cost
• Some services may be subsidised if they produce positive externalities – Public transport (environment)
– Social services?
• Even optimal contracts entail a transfer – With asymmetric information (from Baron-Myerson
1982 onwards)
![Page 29: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
29
A dangerous game
• Good excuse to mix efficiency and equity – Why do welfare policy through prices?
• Good excuse to hide inefficiencies – When losses are expected, how do we measure
success?
• Good excuse to hide deficits – Delay the payment to hide the loss out of the budget
• Not surprising that the EU requires prices which cover costs…
![Page 30: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
30
Even subsidies can be designed well
• Subsidies such as “full cost
reimbursement” give bad incentives
• Subsidies which do not bluntly follow costs
may be smarter
– Subsidy caps
– Subsidies may be designed to induce the firm
to cut costs or improve service quality…
![Page 31: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
31
Net cost and gross cost transfer
• Definitions:
– T = total subsidy
– R = revenue (= p×q)
– C = total cost
– Π = profit
– M = subsidy cap
– The apex e indicates expectations
![Page 32: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
32
Net cost contracts
eee RCT
The transfer T is given ex ante, only based on
expectations
The firm
• bears the whole risk (industrial and commercial)
• keeps the extra-profits
• bears the losses
![Page 33: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
33
Gross cost contracts
RMT
0 TMR
• The municipality guarantees a minimum revenue M
(set ex ante), and thus bears the commercial risk
• The actual transfer T is known ex post
• Advance payment + ex-post adjustments
• The firm bears the industrial risk (cost)
• Profits and losses remain with the firm
So that
![Page 34: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
34
Comparison gross cost - net cost
• Service quality/revenues – NC is a high powered incentive scheme on service
quality;
– GC provides almost no incentive to increase revenues;
• Manageability – GC is easier to manage if different operators share
meighbouring services
– Integrated transport systems
• GC is compatible with a fully free service;
• GC may fall into a sheer cost plus contract
![Page 35: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
35
Regulation and local services
• The meaning of regulatory reforms
• What is an optimal price regime?
• Local (instead of national) public services
![Page 36: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
36
Local public services:
a meaningful concept?
• Public services
– The most complicated ones to provide
through a market, not the most important
ones
– Political definition (unavoidable)
• National or local?
– Who decides?
– Why?
![Page 37: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
37
Factors favouring local
responsibility • Some services exhaust their relevance locally, others
are appendices of a larger system – Water
– Local transport
– Gas distribution
• Costs: Economies of scale – Institutional scale economies?
• A national common framework may favour competition
• Demand: When do local preferences really make a difference?
![Page 38: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
38
Local economic policy
• Local authorities have an increasing
relevance in economic policy
– Institutional reforms
– Withdrawal of the State
– Industrial districts
– Competition among areas to attract
investments
• Regional marketing
![Page 39: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
39
Independent authority?
• Local regulation
– At local level, particularly strong and direct link
between the administration which sets the rules and a
possible local public firm
• Are there experiences of independent local
authorities?
• Effectiveness of local competition for the market
![Page 40: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
40
Local public services in practice (Italy)
• Energy distribution: supplied locally, with national rules
• Water services: national principles, significant freedom locally
• Local transport: greater local freedom
• Waste: total freedom
• A category or a set of different problems?
![Page 41: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
41
Competition and public services
• In monopoly segments, only competition for the market – Effective?
– Who manages the selection?
• The definition of the size of the market affects competition – Unduly small market definitions: inefficient where there are
economies of scale
– Unduly large market definitions: possible ways to limit participation & competition
– Unduly large market definitions: possible ways to deny competition among sub-markets
![Page 42: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
42
Competition for the market and local choices
• (Italy) Great institutional confusion
• EU principles apply, many possibilities are open
– direct management (unusual)
– “in house” providing
– outsourcing to private or public firms (tender)
– non-competitive outsourcing to mixed firms if the
private partner is chosen on the basis of an open
procedure (quasi-tender)
![Page 43: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
43
Local authorities have contractual freedom
• Once the provider is selected, the contract
is largely a local choice as for
– Price/cost reimbursement rules
• Structure
• Review
– Investment requirements
– Enforcement mechanisms
– Control bodies
– …
![Page 44: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
44
Local public firms
• From local champions to national ones
– Local firms expand their operations
• Local protection helps, to some extent
– Engage in huge projects
• Nuclear plants
– Profit seeking local authorities?
• Looking for private capital
• Listing in stock markets
![Page 45: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
45
Development of local firms
• From multi-utilities to sectoral champions?
– Maybe…
• France, Germany…
• Profit oriented or empire builders ?
– In any case, what is the role of municipal
ownership?
– And its future? …
![Page 46: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
46
Local public firms
are not totally public…
• Mixed firms
– Reluctant privatization?
– Way to get entrepreneurial know-how
– Way to raise finance (short in the public
sector)
– Genuine partnership from the beginning
![Page 47: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
47
The role of private shareholders
• No guarantee that firms behave like private ones – No guarantee that political inteference will not take place
• Significant constraint that managers can use to counter political pressures – Could financial markets play a similar role even if
private capital provides debt and not equity?
• Significant constraint that politicians can use to counter their voters’ requests (including employees) – Public shareholders may be as greedy as private
ones…
![Page 48: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
48
How do local public firms perform?
• Does a correct indicator of performance exist?
– Depends on the objective function
– On sector… • Large amount of (unavailable) information
• However, two models emerge
– Service providers
– Entrepreneurs (firms as ways of raising money)
![Page 49: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
49
Do competition and ownership matter?
• Claim/hope that competition help select the best
provider
– If so, firms selected through a competitive procedure
should be more efficient than those directly appointed
• Fear that public ownership is associated to
greater managerial slack (see above)
– If so, private firms should be more efficient
– Mixed firms? Maybe…
![Page 50: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
50
Different models
• In some areas, local governments use public firms to provide services, create employment
• In other regions, they use public firms to raise money (while providing services and creating employment)
• This goes through the management of firms
• …and through the choice of the sector of activity – Take account of the “composition effect”
![Page 51: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
51
Summing-up: are “local” public services
and public firms really different ?
1. Limited resources
2. Size of jurisdiction
3. Access to capital markets
4. Proximity to citizens
![Page 52: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
52
1. Limited resources (a)
• For some services, national funding (health,
some local transports)
• For others (waste,…) there may be local taxes
• For others local supply within a national
framework
– Energy, in detail
– Water, in principles
![Page 53: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
53
1. Limited resources (b)
• Limited possibility to run services at a loss
– The freedom to set local taxes is crucial
– Use of firms to bypass constraints and
postpone funding
• “Need” to use some services to fund
others
– “Improper” taxation (cross subsidies)
![Page 54: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
54
Income from municipal firms
for some Italian cities, 2001 (in Euro)
Net profits from
firms Total income %
Bologna 20,020,714 640,031,748 3.13
Brescia 31,658,424 292,443,110 10.83
Como 1,069,079 111,983,429 0.95
Genova 2,903,664 1,292,210,599 0.22
Milano 60,220,375 9,291,479,888 0.65
Modena 5,669,758 310,698,345 1.82
Padova 5,671,165 303,966,266 1.87
Ravenna 2,500,601 181,328,372 1.38
Rimini 1,128,552 212,599,045 0.53
Roma 32,318,854 4,274,439,739 0.76
Torino 17,979,298 1,929,386,230 0.93
Trieste 7,956,025 704,467,352 1.13
Net of cross subsidies
within multiutility firms
![Page 55: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
55
Income from privatisations
for some Italian cities, 2001 (in Mil Euro)
Total incomes
of the local
government % sold
Value of the
sale
(revenue) Year
Revenue as %
of total income
ACEA Roma 5,725 49.0 787 1999 13.7
ACSM Como 129 25.0 18 1999 14.0
144 24.0 43 2000 29.9
AEM Milano 6,378 49.0 689 1998 10.8
8.8 268 2004
AMGA Genova 1,150 49.0 102 1996 8.9
AEM Torino 2,073 26.0 279 2000 13.5
Hera (Bologna et al.) 640 38.7 368 2003* 57.5
Meta (Modena et al.) 311 24.0 57 2003* 18.3
Acegas -Aps (PD-TS) 1,008 41.9 154 2001 15.3
![Page 56: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
56
2. Size of jurisdiction
• The control activity is a fixed cost:
economies of scale
• Local Authorities ? (independent ones?)
– Necessary a separation between
management and control
– Width of competence of the authority?
– Efficiency of the municipal dimension?
![Page 57: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
57
3. Access to capital markets
• How large is the national stock market?
– In Italy, a stock market only for large firms
• Several LPF are listed, but the transparency
requires an elimination of cross subsidies
– The governance of LPF is now even less
transparent than the one of large national firms
• Should one favour/incentivate/force greater
access to the stock market?
![Page 58: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
58
4. Proximity to citizens
• Advantage in terms of capacity to interpret
preferences
• Disadvantage in terms of exposure to
even small local pressure groups
– Transportation infrastructures
• Local concentration of potential costs and
benefits to the workforce
– Protection of workers
![Page 59: Carlo Scarpa Università di Brescia cscarpa@eco.unibs · ISS Local public services Torino, 10th Sept 2012 2 Municipal socialism or capitalism? • Since the 19th century, considerable](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041300/5e0fdc2c2bcabd49a85ed6a9/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
ISS Local public services Torino,
10th Sept 2012
59
Conclusions
• Local public services are not very different
from national ones
– But control activities display economies of scale
– Local public services may be a key reason for re-
election
• Funding mechanisms are crucial
– Financial constraints induce profit seeking
– Access to funding may be limited
– Dedicated (earmarked) funds are vulnerable to
local interest groups