case re port - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak...

6
Transient in vivo selection of a constitutively cephalosporin resistant Enterobacter cloacae causing ventriculitis ARI JOFFE MD FRCPC, AMIN KABANI MD FRCPC, KARAM RAMOTAR PhD, WALLY KRULICKI RT, GISELE CADRAIN RT, TAJ JADAVJI MD FRCPC FAAP CASE REPORT Presented in part at the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons Annual Meeting, Ottawa, Ontario, September 11 to 14, 1992 as abstract N-676 Alberta Children’s Hospital and The University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta Correspondence and reprints: Dr T Jadavji, Alberta Children’s Hospital, 1820 Richmond Road SW, Calgary, Alberta T2T 5C7. Telephone (403) 229-7813, Fax (403) 229-7221 Received for publication February 14, 1994. Accepted June 14, 1994 A JOFFE, A KABANI, K RAMOTAR, W KRULICKI, G CADRAIN, T JADAVJI. Transient in vivo selection of a constitutively cephalosporin resistant Enterobacter cloacae causing ventriculitis. Can J Infect Dis 1995;6(1):44-48. A case of neonatal ventriculitis complicating a ventriculoperitoneal shunt and caused by one strain of Enterobacter cloacae (as shown on pulsed field gel electrophoresis) is presented. Daily ventricular fluid cultures from day 1 to 9 revealed induci- ble cephalosporin resistance in all isolates except on days 3, 4 and 5 of therapy when isolates were constitutively resis- tant. This emergence of resistance due to constitutive Bush class 1 beta-lactamase production is an excellent example of the rapid emergence of a predominant strain of bacteria depending on antibiotic selection pressures in vivo. The tran- sient nature of the predominant resistant phenotype may have been due to missing a dose of cefotaxime on day 5 or in vivo factors allowing persistence of sensitive organisms in antibiotic protected sites. Caution is advised in the use of cephalosporins alone for serious Enterobacter species infections. Repeat culture and sensitivity should be done in se- vere infections that are slow to respond to cephalosporin therapy. Key Words: Constitutive resistance, Enterobacter cloacae Sélection transitoire in vivo d’un Enterobacter cloacae constitutionnellement résistant à la céphalosporine et provoquant une ventriculite RÉSUMÉ : Un cas de ventriculite néonatale compliquée d’un shunt ventriculopéritonéal et causé par une souche d’En- terobacter cloacae (visualisée à l’électrophorèse sur gel par champ pulsé) est présenté ici. Des cultures de liquide ven- triculaire quotidiennes des jours 1 à 9 ont révélé une résistance inductible aux céphalosporines chez tous les isolats, à l’exception des jours 3, 4 et 5 du traitement où les isolats étaient constitutionnellement résistants. L’émergence de cette résistance due à la production d’une bêta-lactamase Bush de classe 1 constitutionnelle est un excellent exemple de l’apparition rapide d’une souche bactérienne prédominante selon les pressions de sélection de l’antibiotique in vivo. La nature passagère du phénotype à prédominance résistante peut avoir été due à l’omission d’une dose de céfotaxime au jour 5 ou à des facteurs in vivo ayant permis la persistance d’organismes sensibles dans des sites protégés de l’anti- biotique. La prudence est recommandée lors de l’emploi de céphalosporines seules dans des infections à Enterobacter graves. Il faut répéter la culture et l’antibiogramme dans les infections graves qui répondent lentement au traitement par céphalosporines. 44 CAN J INFECT DIS VOL 6 NO 1 JANUARY/FEBRUARY 1995

Upload: others

Post on 17-Mar-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CASE RE PORT - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo (1,2,5-12). The emer gence

Transient in vivo selection of a constitutively

cephalosporin resistantEnterobacter cloacaecausing ventriculitis

ARI JOFFE MD FRCPC, AMIN KABANI MD FRCPC, KARAM RAMO TAR PhD, WALLY KRU LICKI RT, GISELE CAD RAIN RT,TAJ JADAVJI MD FRCPC FAAP

CASE RE PORT

Presented in part at the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons Annual Meeting, Ottawa, Ontario, September 11 to 14, 1992 asabstract N-676

Alberta Children’s Hospital and The University of Calgary, Calgary, AlbertaCorrespondence and reprints: Dr T Jadavji, Alberta Children’s Hospital, 1820 Richmond Road SW, Calgary, Alberta T2T 5C7. Telephone

(403) 229-7813, Fax (403) 229-7221Received for publication February 14, 1994. Accepted June 14, 1994

A JOFFE, A KABANI, K RAMO TAR, W KRU LICKI, G CAD RAIN, T JADAVJI. Tran sient in vivo se lec tion of a con sti tu tivelycepha lo sporin re sis tant En tero bac ter cloa cae caus ing ven tricu li tis. Can J In fect Dis 1995;6(1):44- 48. A case ofneo na tal ven tricu li tis com pli cat ing a ven tricu loperi to neal shunt and caused by one strain of En tero bac ter cloa cae (asshown on pulsed field gel elec tro pho re sis) is pre sented. Daily ven tricu lar fluid cul tures from day 1 to 9 re vealed in duci -ble cepha lo sporin re sis tance in all iso lates ex cept on days 3, 4 and 5 of ther apy when iso lates were con sti tu tively re sis -tant. This emer gence of re sis tance due to con sti tu tive Bush class 1 beta- lactamase pro duc tion is an ex cel lent ex am pleof the rapid emer gence of a pre domi nant strain of bac te ria de pend ing on an ti bi otic se lec tion pres sures in vivo. The tran -sient na ture of the pre domi nant re sis tant phe no type may have been due to miss ing a dose of ce fo taxime on day 5 or invivo fac tors al low ing per sis tence of sen si tive or gan isms in an ti bi otic pro tected sites. Cau tion is ad vised in the use ofcepha lo sporins alone for se ri ous En tero bac ter spe cies in fec tions. Re peat cul ture and sen si tiv ity should be done in se -vere in fec tions that are slow to re spond to cepha lo sporin ther apy.

Key Words: Con sti tu tive re sis tance, En tero bac ter cloa cae

Sélection transitoire in vivo d’un Enterobacter cloacae constitutionnellementrésistant à la céphalosporine et provoquant une ventriculiteRÉS UMÉ : Un cas de ven tricu lite néona tale com pli quée d’un shunt ven tricu lopé ri tonéal et causé par une souche d’En -tero bac ter cloa cae (visu al isée à l’é lec tro phorèse sur gel par champ pulsé) est pré senté ici. Des cul tures de liq uide ven -tricu laire quo ti di ennes des jours 1 à 9 ont révélé une résis tance in ducti ble aux cépha lo spor ines chez tous les iso lats, àl’ex cep tion des jours 3, 4 et 5 du traite ment où les iso lats étaient con sti tu tion nel le ment résis tants. L’émer gence de cetterésis tance due à la pro duc tion d’une bêta- lactamase Bush de classe 1 con sti tu tion nelle est un ex cel lent ex em ple del’ap pa ri tion rap ide d’une souche bacté ri enne prédomi nante selon les pres sions de sé lec tion de l’an ti bio tique in vivo. Lana ture pas sa gère du phé no type à prédomi nance résis tante peut avoir été due à l’omis sion d’une dose de céfo taximeau jour 5 ou à des fac teurs in vivo ay ant per mis la per sis tance d’or gan ismes sen si bles dans des sites pro té gés de l’an ti -bio tique. La pru dence est re com mandée lors de l’em ploi de cépha lo spor ines seules dans des in fec tions à En tero bac tergraves. Il faut répé ter la cul ture et l’an ti bio gramme dans les in fec tions graves qui répon dent len te ment au traite ment par cépha lo spor ines.

44 CAN J INFECT DIS VOL 6 NO 1 JANU ARY/FEB RU ARY 1995

Page 2: CASE RE PORT - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo (1,2,5-12). The emer gence

B AC TE RIA EX PRESS BUSH CLASS 1 CHRO MO SOME MEDIatedbeta- lactamases in two ways: low ‘b asal’ level pro duc -

tion (eg, Escheri chia coli, Sal mo nella spe cies and Shigellaspe cies) and ‘i nduc ible’ ex pres sion (1). In ducible ex pres sionoc curs tran siently in the pres ence of an in ducer an ti bi otic(eg, ce fox itin, imipe nem) in a pre dict able group of bac te ria, in -clud ing Pseu do mo nas ae rugi nosa, En tero bac ter spe cies,Citro bac ter spe cies, indole- positive Pro teus spe cies, Provi -den cia spe cies, Mor gan ella mor ganii and Ser ra tia spe cies(1,2). These bac te ria with in duci ble ex pres sion also have asig nificant number (10-6 to 10-7 wild- type cells) of mu tant ‘st -able dere pressed’ cells that pro duce con sti tu tively largeamounts of beta- lactamase (1,2). These re sis tant vari antscan be quickly se lected as the pre domi nant bac te ria by la bileweak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo(1,2,5-12). The emer gence of re sis tance by this mecha nismdur ing ther apy has been well de scribed and has re sulted in ahigh rate of treat ment fail ures (1).

We de scribe a case of neo na tal men in gi tis due to En tero -bac ter cloa cae that de vel oped re sis tance to beta- lactam an ti -bi ot ics dur ing ther apy and again be came sus cep ti ble whilethe pa tient was still on ther apy. This is the first case of whichwe are aware of tran sient se lec tion of a dere pressed mu tanten tero bac ter de scribed in the lit era ture.

CASE PRES EN TA TIONThis eight- day- old Cau ca sian fe male was seen by the in -

fec tious dis ease con sult ant for ir ri ta bil ity and fe ver of oneday’s du ra tion. She was de liv ered by cae sar ean sec tion (forfail ure to prog ress) with birth weight 3800 g to a well mother af -ter a nor mal full- term preg nancy; mem branes were rup turedfor 5 h with out evi dence of cho rioam nioni tis, and Ap gars were 9 and 9 at 1 and 5 mins, re spec tively. At birth she was found to have a sac ral mye lo men in go cele and hy dro cepha lus; sur gi -cal re pair and ven tricu loperi to neal shunt in ser tion were doneon day 2 of life. She was trans ferred out of the in ten sive careunit to the neo na tal ward on day 4 of life.

On ex ami na tion the neo nate was very ir ri ta ble. Vi tal signsshowed a heart rate of 160/min, res pi ra tory rate 45/min, blood pres sure 84/42 mmHg and tem pera ture 38.6°C tym panic.Head cir cum fer ence was 38.7 cm (greater than 90th per cen -tile) and weight 3740 g. The an te rior and pos te rior fon tan elleswere large and full, and the skin over the en tire ven tricu loperi -to neal shunt res er voir and tub ing was ery the ma tous, tenderand swol len. She was he mo dy nami cally sta ble, and the spi -nal wound was heal ing well. The rest of the ex ami na tion wasnon con tribu tory. Labo ra tory in ves ti ga tions re vealed a whiteblood cell count of 7.9x109/L with 14% poly mor pho nu clearleu ko cytes, 52% band forms and 27% lym pho cytes, he mo -glo bin 105 g/L and plate let count 444x109/L. Elec tro lytes,urea, cre ati nine, glu cose, liver en zymes and uri naly sis wereall nor mal. Af ter blood, urine and cere bro spi nal fluid (CSF) cul -tures were drawn she was started on in tra ve nous ce fo taxime(150 mg/kg/day di vided every 8 h) and van co my cin (45mg/kg/day di vided every 12 h), and op er ated for re moval ofthe ven tricu loperi to neal shunt and in ser tion of an ex ter nal ized ven tricu lar drain. CSF from the shunt res er voir showed a white

blood cell count of 45,900/mm3, red blood cell count50,000/mm3, glu cose less than 0.62 mmol/L and pro tein 1400 mg/L with Gram- negative ba cilli on Gram stain. Cul ture of CSF

and blood (both sets) grew E cloa cae, urine was ster ile, ab -domi nal ul tra sound was nor mal, and com puted to mo gra phy(CT) scan of the head showed evi dence of hy dro cepha lus andven tricu li tis.

The fol low ing day the pa tient looked well, was afeb rile,and the skin along the pre vi ous shunt tub ing ap peared nor -mal and non tender. Ce fo taxime was con tin ued and gen ta -mi cin was added (7.5 mg/kg/day di vided every 8 h).Van co my cin was dis con tin ued. Daily CSF cul tures weredone (twice on day 7), which be came ster ile on day 10 ofther apy. Blood cul ture was ster ile when first re peated on day5. CT scan of the head with con trast on day 6 and day 10 ofther apy showed no change. In view of the re sis tant iso late(see be low), ther apy was changed to in tra ve nous gen ta mi cinand trimethoprim- sulfamethoxazole (TMP-SMX) (20 mg/kg/ daydi vided every 6 h) on day 7 and con tin ued un til day 40. In tra -ven tricu lar gen ta mi cin (1 mg every 24 h) was given from day12 to 16 (CSF gen ta mi cin lev els 3 h post- dose were 19.2 mg/Land 12 h post- dose were 14.0 mg/L). The CSF bac te ri cidal ti tre on day 25 was 1:64.

The pa ti ent’s re cov ery was un event ful apart from gen er al -ized sei zures on day 6. In ret ro spect, it was found that on day5 the in tra ve nous line was out and ther apy held for 13 h 20mins un til one dose of in tra mus cu lar cef tri ax one (50 mg/kg)was given. Ce fo taxime was re started in tra ve nously 18 h af terthe last dose.

MI CRO BI OL OGYThe sus cep ti bili ties of the E cloa cae iso lates in CSF are

shown in Ta ble 1; the day 3, 4 and 5 iso lates were re sis tant tosec ond- and third- generation ce pahlo sporins and ti car cil lin,

TA BLE 1Sus cep ti bil ity of daily ven tricu lar fluid En tero bac ter cloa -cae iso lates by the Vitek Auto- Microbic Sys tem

Sus cep ti bil ity (MIC µg/mL)An ti bi otic Day 1-2 Day 3-5 Day 6-9Ampicil lin ≥ 32 R ≥ 32 R ≥ 32 RCe fa zolin ≥ 32 R ≥ 32 R ≥ 32 RCef tazidime ≤ 8 S ≥ 32 R ≤ 8 SCef tri ax one ≤ 8 S ≥ 64 R ≤ 8 SCe fo taxime ≤ 8 S ≥ 64 R ≤ 8 SCe fu rox ime 16 MS ≥ 64 R 16 MSGen ta mi cin ≤ 0.5 S ≤ 0.5 S ≤ 0.5 STo bra my cin ≤ 0.5 S ≤ 0.5 S ≤ 0.5 STi car cil lin ≤ 16 S ≥ 256 R ≤ 16 S†

TMP- SMX ≤ 10 S ≤ 10 S ≤ 10 SAmox icil lin,

cla vu lanic acid≥ 16/8 ≥ 16/8 ≥ 16/8

M Mod er ately sen si tive; MIC Mini mal in hibi tory con cen tra tion (µg/mL); R Re -sis tant; S Sen si tive; TMP- SMX Trimethoprim- sulfamethoxazole. *Con firmed by the Scep tor Mi cro di lu tion method and the agar di lu tion method for ce fo taxime,cef tazidime and gen ta mi cin. †On day 5 the MIC was 128 R

CAN J INFECT DIS VOL 6 NO 1 JANU ARY/FEB RU ARY 1995 45

Tran sient in vivo se lec tion of a re sis tant E cloa cae

Page 3: CASE RE PORT - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo (1,2,5-12). The emer gence

whereas all other initial and later isolates were susceptible.

Each day at least four colonies were ‘picked’ from the culture

plate to use for sensitivity testing; however, from day 6 to 9

there were very few colonies on the culture plate to ‘pick’

(day 7: one colony; day 8: one colony; day 9: three colonies)

for sensitivity testing.

The results of the inducible beta-lactamase disk approxi-

mation test are shown in Figure 1. As described by others (8),

the ceftriaxone and imipenem disks were placed on the

Meuler-Hinton agar such that they were separated by exactly

one half the sum of the zone size around each disk when

used alone. The day 3, 4 and 5 isolates had constitutive resis-

tance to ceftriaxone, whereas all other isolates (including the

initial blood cultures) had only inducible (with imipenem and

cefoxitin) resistance. The nitrocefin assay was positive on all

isolates. Clavulanic acid did not change the sensitivity to

ampicillin (Table 1) and thus did not inhibit beta-lactamase.

Disk-diffusion sensitivity testing showed sensitivity of all isolates

to imipenem (diameter 25 mm) and resistance of all isolates

to cefoxitin (diameter 6 mm).

Pulsed field gel electrophoresis: Genomic DNA in agar plugs

from one blood isolate and the nine CSF isolates from day 2 to

9 were prepared essentially as described by Haertl and Band-

low (13). Restriction endonuclease digestion of genomic DNA

was done with Xba I (New England Biolabs, Massachusetts)

using a 4 mm slice of the agarose plug incubated with 20

units of enzyme in a total volume of 225 µL at 25⊃C overnight.

Digested DNA was electrophoresed in a 1% agarose gel

(Fastlane agarose, FMC Bioproducts, Maine) in 0.5 x TBE buffer

(0.05 M Tris, 0.05 M boric acid, 1 mM EDTA) with the use of the

contour-clamped homogeneous electric field apparatus

(CHEF Mapper, BioRad, California). Lambda concatemers

(New England Biolabs) were run as size controls. Electropho-

resis was carried out for 27 h using ramped pulse-time begin-

ning with 3 s and ending with 40 s at an applied voltage of 6

V/cm. The gels were stained with ethidium bromide and

destained with distilled water for up to 12 h and photo-

graphed under ultraviolet irradiation. Identical banding pat-

terns were found for all the isolates, with 17 bands ranging

from approximately 50 to 700 kb size (Figure 2).

DISCUSSIONSelection of Gram-negative rods with constitutive Bush

class 1 beta-lactamase production has resulted in emer-

gence of resistance on therapy (with labile weak inducer an-

tibiotics) in 14 to 56% of cases, with treatment failure or

relapse in 25 to 75% of these (1). Emergence of resistance is

thus recognized as a significant problem. The potentially

causative bacteria accounted for 22% of all nosocomial iso-

lates and 11% of all nosocomial bloodstream isolates in the

United States in 1986-1989 (14). There have been reports of

nosocomial outbreaks of resistance in a cystic fibrosis centre

(15) and in neonatal intensive care units (5,11) shortly after in-

troduction of broad spectrum cephalosporins. There are also

increasing reports correlating use of broad spectrum cepha-

losporins to decreased susceptibility of P aeruginosa, Entero-

bacter species and Citrobacter species to ceftazidime,

cefotaxime and piperacillin in the United States (16), in indi-

vidual hosptals (17) and in individual patients (18). It has also

been reported that cefotaxime use in a neonatal intensive

care unit resulted in increased colonization with enterobac-

ter strains and decreased susceptibility of these strains to

cephalosporins (19). Re-emergence of sensitive strains of en-

terobacter has been shown hospital-wide with changes in

antibiotic use (16,17).

Emergence of resistance while on therapy in neonates

with E cloacae meningitis and ventriculitis has been recog-

nized in the past (8,11). The present case adds to the number

of documented cases of emergence of resistance while on

Figure 2) Xba I digested Enterobacter cloacae genomic DNA afterpulsed field gel electrophoresis and ethidium bromide staining. Lane1: blood isolate day 1; lanes 2 to 10: cerebrospinal fluid isolates fromday 2 to 9. Identical banding is shown for all isolates, indicating a sin-gle clone

Figure 1) The inducible beta-lactamase disk approximation test. ADay 1, 2 and 6 to 9 isolates. Imipenem (I) induces beta-lactamaseproduction and thus a zone of consequent ceftriaxone (C) resistance,shown as growth around the C disk only in closest proximity to the I disk. BDay 2 to 5 isolates. There is constitutive resistance to ceftriaxone shownas growth all around the C disk, regardless of any proximity to the I disk

JOFFE et al

46 CAN J INFECT DIS VOL 6 NO 1 JANUARY/FEBRUARY 1995

Page 4: CASE RE PORT - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo (1,2,5-12). The emer gence

ther apy with ce fo taxime in neo nates with se ri ous in fec tionsdue to E cloa cae. It clearly dem on strates the ra pid ity with which the re sis tant phenotype can be se lected as the pre domi nantor gan ism in vivo. This case is un usual in that the re sis tantphe no type was pre domi nant for only three days.

The iso lates from each day were tested by: the VitekAuto- Microbic Sys tem (Vitek Sys tems, BioMer ieux, Mis souri); the Scep tor Mi cro di lu tion method (Becton- Dickinson Di ag -nos tic In stru ment Sys tems, Mary land); and the agar di lu tionmethod for cef tazidime, ce fo taxime and gen ta mi cin (Da lynnLabo ra tory Prod ucts). These were re peated for all the CSF iso -lates. Fail ure to rec og nize re sis tance in the ini tial or later iso -lates is thus a very un likely ex pla na tion for the tran sientna ture of the re sis tant phe no type (20). It is also un likely thatfrom day 3 to 5 iso la tion of the re sis tant phe no type was a‘chance’ in vi tro find ing. A chance oc cur rence of a re sis tantmu tant is ex pected in about 1x10-6 colo nies (1,2); thus, withfour colo nies ‘picked’ for sen si tiv ity test ing each day, thechance of de tect ing this for three days is: (4 colo nies) x(1x10-6) x (3 days) = 9x10-6. Simi larly, since from day 6 to 9(for five sepa rate cul tures) vir tu ally all colo nies grow ing were‘picked’ for sen si tiv ity test ing, it is rea son able to as sume thatthe sen si tive phe no type was truly pre domi nant again.

There are very strong data to show that the mecha nism ofre sis tance in these iso lates was Bush class 1 beta- lactamase. The ni tro ce fin test showed that beta- lactamasewas pro duced. Cla vu lanic acid did not in hibit the en zyme (Ta -ble 1), ce fox itin was a strong in ducer of and sus cep ti ble to theen zyme, and imi pe nem was a strong in ducer of and re sis tantto the en zyme (Fig ure 1). Thus, se lec tion by ce fo taxime of asta ble dere pressed mu tant on day 3 is the most likely ex pla -na tion for the emer gence of re sis tance.

An other po ten tial ex pla na tion for the re sis tant pheno type isthat there were two dif fer ent strains of E cloa cae with dif fer entsen si tivi ties. Al though iden ti cal mor pho types and bio types(on Vitek iden ti fi ca tion) for all iso lates are not ade quate toprove strain iden tity, pulsed field gel elec tro pho re sis (PFGE)(Fig ure 2) does ar gue very strongly that the in fec tion wascaused by only one strain of E cloa cae. PFGE us ing Xba I to di -gest ge nomic DNA has been used suc cess fully to dis crimi nateclearly ge netic re lat ed ness of E cloa cae strains (13). Be cause of the Xba I low G-C rare rec og ni tion site TCTAGA, a PFGE gelwith up to 20 bands was ex pected (21), pro vid ing a dis crimi -nat ing easy to read gel. This was in deed the case, and theiden ti cal band ing pat tern on PFGE for all the E cloa cae iso lates very strongly sug gests a sin gle clone (13). There fore, the re- emergence of the sen si tive phe no type on day 6 must be ex -plained.

One po ten tial ex pla na tion is that the lack of a se lec tive ad -van tage for the re sis tant mu tant when one dose of ce fo taxime was missed for 18 h on day 5 al lowed re- emergence of thesen si tive phe no type. How ever, the cef tri ax one dose given at13 h 20 mins makes this ex pla na tion less likely; cef tri ax one(like ce fo taxime) is quite la bile to beta- lactamase and of fers ase lec tive ad van tage to re sis tant mu tants. Per haps a morelikely ex pla na tion is that in vivo fac tors al lowed some anti -biotic sen si tive or gan isms, es tab lished with the ini tial in fec -

tion, to per sist in a rela tively an ti bi otic pro tected site and becul tured from day 6 to 9. An ti bi otic pro tected sites such as inven tricu li tis or shunt tub ing would of fer lit tle ad van tage for re -sis tant mu tants, and would be ex pected to take longer toeradi cate. Thus, the re sis tant mu tant may have been eradi -cated with gen ta mi cin by day 5, and then the com bi na tion of amissed ce fo taxime dose on day 5 and in vivo pro tected sitescon trib uted to the iso la tion of the sen si tive phe no type fromday 6 to 9. Fi nally, the change in ther apy to TMP-SMX and gen -ta mi cin on day 7 may have con trib uted to the lack of re- emergence of a re sis tant phe no type a sec ond time.

The pres ent case was not an ex am ple of treat ment fail ure.In simi lar pa tients with out re sis tant strains CSF has also beenculture- positive for 7.2±5.0 days (22). Al though ce fo taxime for Gram- negative men in gi tis has not been evalu ated in a pro -spec tive fash ion, avail able data sug gest its safety and ef fi -cacy to be very good (22- 24). How ever, cau tion must beex er cised in the use of third- generation cepha lo sporins totreat se ri ous in fec tions due to or gan isms such as E cloa caewhere emer gence of re sis tance has been a prob lem; this istrue both in in di vid ual pa tients and hospital- wide. In pa tientsslow to re spond, or in treat ment fail ure, emer gence of re sis -tance must be looked for with re peat cul ture and sen si tiv itytest ing. Con comi tant use of gen ta mi cin has not been shownto re duce emer gence of re sis tance (1) – in this case re sis -tance to cepha lo sporins de vel oped while on com bined gen ta -mi cin and ce fo taxime ther apy.

CON CLU SIONSWe re port a case of neo na tal ven tricu li tis due to E cloa -

cae that had rapid but tran sient emer gence of a sta ble dere -pressed re sis tant mu tant on ther apy as a re sult of chang ingan ti bi otic se lec tion pres sures and in vivo fac tors. This is anex cel lent in vivo ex am ple of the mecha nism of emerg ing re -sis tance in Gram- negative rods that is be com ing an in creas -ing prob lem (25). We ad vise cau tion in the use ofthird- generation cepha lo sporins alone for these in fec tions.Re peat cul ture and sen si tiv ity test ing should be done in se -vere in fec tions with these bac te ria that are slow to re spond tocephalo sporin ther apy.

AC KNOW LEDGE MENTS: We thank Dr Pam Kib sey at the Uni ver sityof Al berta Mi cro bi ol ogy Labo ra tory for as sist ing with the in duci blebeta- lactamase disk ap proxi ma tion test meth od ol ogy, and Stepha nieHow ard RT for do ing all of the sen si tiv ity test ing on our iso lates. Wealso thank Mar ilyn Dorozio for in valu able sec re tar ial as sis tance.

REF ER ENCES1. Sanders WE Jr, Sanders CC. Inducible b-lactamases: clinical

and epidemiologic implications for use of newer cephalosporins. Rev Infect Dis 1988;10:830-8.

2. Livermore DM. Clinical significance of beta-lactamase inductionand stable derepression in Gram negative rods. Eur J ClinMicrobiol 1987;6:439-45.

3. Marchou B, Michea-Hamzehpour M, Lucain C, Pechere JC.Development of b-lactam-resistant Enterobacter cloacae inmice. J Infect Dis 1987;156:369-73.

4. Michea-Hamzehpour M, Pechere JC. How predictable isdevelopment of resistance after b-lactam therapy in

CAN J INFECT DIS VOL 6 NO 1 JANU ARY/FEB RU ARY 1995 47

Tran sient in vivo se lec tion of a re sis tant E cloa cae

Page 5: CASE RE PORT - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo (1,2,5-12). The emer gence

Enterobacter cloacae infection? J Antimicrob Chemother1989;24:387-95.

5. Bryan CS, John JF Jr, Pai MS, Austin TL. Gentamicin vscefotaxime for therapy of neonatal sepsis: relationship to drugresistance. Am J Dis Child 1985;139:1086-9.

6. Eng RHK, Cherubin CE, Pechere JC, Beam TR. Treatmentfailures of cefotaxime and latamoxef in meningitis caused byEnterobacter and Serratia spp. J Antimicrob Chemother 1987;20:904-11.

7. Follath F, Costa E, Thommen A, Frei R, Burdeska A, Meyer J.Clinical consequences of development of resistance to thirdgeneration cephalosporins. Eur J Clin Microbiol 1987;6:446-50.

8. Heusser MF, Patterson JE, Kuritza AP, Edberg SC, BaltimoreRS. Emergence of resistance to multiple beta-lactams inEnterobacter cloacae during treatment for neonatal meningitiswith cefotaxime. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1990;5:509-12.

9. Johnson MP, Ramphal R. b-lactam resistant enterobacterbacteremia in febrile neutropenic patients receivingmonotherapy. J Infect Dis 1990;162:981-3.

10. McCracken GH Jr. Use of third generation cephalosporins fortreatment of neonatal infections. Am J Dis Child1985;139:1079-80. (Edit)

11. Modi N, Damjanovic V, Cooke RWI. Outbreak of cephalosporinresistant Enterobacter cloacae infection in a neonatal intensivecare unit. Arch Dis Child 1987;62:148-51.

12. Olson B, Weinstein RA, Nathan C, Kabins SA. Broad spectrumb-lactam resistance in Enterobacter: emergence duringtreatment and mechanisms of resistance. J Antimicrob Chemother 1983;11:299-310.

13. Haertl R, Bandlow G. Epidemiologic fingerprinting ofEnterobacter cloacae by small fragment restrictionendonuclease analysis and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis ofgenomic restriction fragments. J Clin Microbiol 1993;31:128-33.

14. Schaberg DR, Culver DH, Gaynes RP. Major trends in themicrobial etiology of nosocomial infection. Am J Med1991;91(Suppl 3B):72S-5S.

15. Pedersen SS, Koch C, Hoiby N, Rosendal K. An epidemicspread of multiresistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa in a cystic

fibrosis centre. J Antimicrob Chemother 1986;17:505-16.16. Jones RN. Type I b-lactamase resistance: an emerging problem.

In: Jones R, ed. Emerging Trends in Gram Negative Resistance: A New Concern for Critical Care Medicine. Wayne: LederleLaboratories, 1990:7-11.

17. Koontz FP, Jones RN, Wenzel RP. Antibiotic resistance:experience at the University of Iowa hospitals and clinics. In:Jones R, ed. Emerging Trends in Gram Negative Resistance: ANew Concern for Critical Care Medicine. Wayne: LederleLaboratories, 1990:16-9.

18. Cohen SH, King JH, Morita MM, Mahackian KA, Bradford M,Willits NH. The relationship between enterobacter isolatesresistant to extended spectrum cephalosporins and antecedentantibiotic use. Program and Abstracts of the 29th InterscienceConference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy.Houston, September 17-20, 1989. (Abst 654)

19. Spritzer R, Kamp HJ, Dzoljic G, Sauer P. Five years ofcefotaxime use in a neonatal intensive care unit. Pediatr InfectDis J 1990;9:92-6.

20. Washington JA, Knapp CC, Sanders CC. Accuracy ofmicrodilution and the automicrobic system in detection ofb-lactam resistance in Gram negative bacterial mutants withderepressed b-lactamase. Rev Infect Dis 1988;10:824-9.

21. Maslow JN, Slutsky AM, Arbeit RD. Application of pulsed-fieldgel electrophoresis to molecular epidemiology. In: Persing DH,Smith TF, Tenover FC, White TJ, eds. Diagnostic MolecularMicrobiology Principles and Applications. Rochester: MayoFoundation, 1993:563-72.

22. Kaplan SL, Patrick CC. Cefotaxime and aminoglycosidetreatment of meningitis caused by Gram negative entericorganisms. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1990;9:810-4.

23. Jacobs RF. Cefotaxime treatment of Gram negative entericmeningitis in infants and children. Drugs 1988;35(Suppl2):185-9.

24. Naqvi SH, Maxwell MA, Dunkle LM. Cefotaxime therapy ofneonatal Gram negative bacillary meningitis. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1985;4:499-502.

25. Sanders CC. b-lactamases of Gram negative bacteria: newchallenges for new drugs. Clin Infect Dis 1992;14:1089-99.

JOFFE et al

48 CAN J INFECT DIS VOL 6 NO 1 JANU ARY/FEB RU ARY 1995

Page 6: CASE RE PORT - downloads.hindawi.comdownloads.hindawi.com/journals/cjidmm/1995/539351.pdf · weak in ducer an ti bi ot ics both in vi tro (3,4) and in vivo (1,2,5-12). The emer gence

Submit your manuscripts athttp://www.hindawi.com

Stem CellsInternational

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

MEDIATORSINFLAMMATION

of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Behavioural Neurology

EndocrinologyInternational Journal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Disease Markers

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

BioMed Research International

OncologyJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

PPAR Research

The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Immunology ResearchHindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Journal of

ObesityJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine

OphthalmologyJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Diabetes ResearchJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Research and TreatmentAIDS

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Gastroenterology Research and Practice

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Parkinson’s Disease

Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Volume 2014Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com