case studies undp: il ngwesi group ranch, kenya

Upload: undpenvironment

Post on 14-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    1/12

    Equator Initiative Case StudiesLocal sustainable development solutions for people, nature, and resilient communities

    KenyaIL NGWESI GROUP RANCH

    Empowered live

    Resilient nation

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    2/12

    UNDP EQUATOR INITIATIVE CASE STUDY SERIES

    Local and indigenous communities across the world are advancing innovative sustainable development solutions that wo

    or people and or nature. Few publications or case studies tell the ull story o how such initiatives evolve, the breadth

    their impacts, or how they change over time. Fewer still have undertaken to tell these stories with community practition

    themselves guiding the narrative.

    To mark its 10-year anniversary, the Equator Initiative aims to ll this gap. The ollowing case study is one in a growing ser

    that details the work o Equator Prize winners vetted and peer-reviewed best practices in community-based environmenconservation and sustainable livelihoods. These cases are intended to inspire the policy dialogue needed to take local succ

    to scale, to improve the global knowledge base on local environment and development solutions, and to serve as models

    replication. Case studies are best viewed and understood with reerence to The Power o Local Action: Lessons rom 10 Years

    the Equator Initiative, a compendium o lessons learned and policy guidance that draws rom the case material.

    Click on the map to visit the Equator Initiatives searchable case study database.

    EditorsEditor-in-Chie: Joseph CorcoranManaging Editor: Oliver Hughes

    Contributing Editors: Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Erin Lewis, Whitney Wilding

    Contributing WritersEdayatu Abieodun Lamptey, Erin Atwell, Toni Blackman, Jonathan Clay, Joseph Corcoran, Larissa Currado, Sarah Gordon, Oliver Hughe

    Wen-Juan Jiang, Sonal Kanabar, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Rachael Lader, Patrick Lee, Erin Lewis, Jona Liebl, Mengning Ma,

    Mary McGraw, Gabriele Orlandi, Brandon Payne, Juliana Quaresma, Peter Schecter, Martin Sommerschuh, Whitney Wilding, Luna Wu

    DesignOliver Hughes, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Amy Korngiebel, Kimberly Koserowski, Erin Lewis, John Mulqueen, Lorena de la Pa

    Brandon Payne, Mariajos Satizbal G.

    AcknowledgementsThe Equator Initiative acknowledges with gratitude the Il Ngwesi Group Ranch, and in particular the guidance and inputs o James Ka

    and Caroline Karimi. All photo credits courtesy o I l Ngwesi Group Ranch. Maps courtesy o CIA World Factbook and Wikipedia.

    Suggested Citation

    United Nations Development Programme. 2012. Il Ngwesi Group Ranch, Kenya. Equator Initiative Case Study Series. New York, NY.

    http://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=casestudysearch&Itemid=858http://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdf
  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    3/12

    PROJECT SUMMARYThis Maasai group ranch in the central Kenyan district oLaikipia has established an 8,645-hectare community-conserved area that balances the needs o local pastoralistswith wildlie conservation and the operation o a lucrativeeco-lodge. One o the pioneering and most successul oKenyas Maasai-owned ecotourism initiatives, Il Ngwesihas served as a model or replication across the country.Its sanctuary rangers ensure a high level o security or theconserved area, which has played a key role in a network oconnected wildlie protected areas and corridors in central

    Kenya.In addition to the areas o reshwater management andeducation, ecotourism revenues have been invested intargeted health interventions. The group is a lead partner ina health campaign which oers awareness-raising, testingand counseling, or HIV/AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis, thecampaign has targeted thirteen local group ranches or acombined population o 40,000 people.

    KEY FACTS

    EQUATOR PRIZE WINNER: 2002

    FOUNDED: 1995

    LOCATION: Laikipia District, Kenya

    BENEFICIARIES: 7,000 Laikipiak Maasai pastoralists

    BIODIVERSITY: Lewa Wildlife Sanctuary

    3

    IL NGWESI GROUP RANCHKenya

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Background and Context 4

    Key Activities and Innovations 6

    Biodiversity Impacts 7

    Socioeconomic Impacts 7

    Policy Impacts 9

    Sustainability 10

    Replication 11

    Partners 11

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    4/12

    4

    Ngwesi Group Ranch consists o 8,645 hectares o community-

    managed land located in Mukogodo Division, Laikipia District, north

    Mount Kenya. It sits next to the Ngare Ndare River, on the edge

    the Mukogodo Hills, and consists predominantly o semi-arid and

    rid savannah land. The ranch is owned and managed by the local

    opulation o almost 7,000 Laikipiak Maasai pastoralists. Key species

    ound in the area include the white rhino (Ceratotherium simum),

    Arican elephant (Loxodonta aricana), Arican wild dog (Lycaon

    ictus) and Grevys zebra (Equus grevyi), while the area is also a

    anctuary or the critically endangered black rhino (Diceros bicornis).

    he Group Ranch has been able to promote conservation and

    enerate income-generating opportunities or its members through

    he conservation o around 80% o the ranch area, a reductionn the Maasais dependence on livestock, and the promotion o

    onservation-riendly ecotourism.

    A context o environmental, social and economic threats

    ollowing the end o commercial hunting in the area during the

    970s, local people used rearms purchased rom Somali reugees

    o poach wildlie indiscriminately. By the late 1980s, elephant

    opulations had been signicantly reduced and rhinos had

    isappeared rom the area. The Il Ngwesi land remained an important

    wildlie corridor between Laikipia and Samburu, but the ecosystem

    was simultaneously coming under threat rom deorestation, with

    ections o the Mukogodo orest being cleared or timber, uel wood,nd or agriculture. As well as contributing to widespread land

    egradation, this also increased local tensions between pastoralists

    nd armers. Human development indicators were low, meanwhile:

    here were ew schools in the area, contributing to low levels o

    ducational attainment, while the entire district was served by one

    overnment-run hospital, with a doctor-to-patient ratio o 1:44,000.

    Over-reliance on livestock, the decline o traditional grazing

    management systems, and human-wildlie conict meant that the

    Maasai tribes livelihoods were under threat. The poverty o the area

    in turn threatened the security o Lewa Downs, a privately-ow

    wildlie conservancy directly to the south o Il Ngwesi. In respo

    the management team at Lewa, with support rom Kenya Wi

    Service, encouraged the ormation o a community conserved

    within Il Ngwesi, and the creation o an ecotourism attractio

    generate revenue. They engaged Maasai elders and comm

    leaders in the process, trained local people as rangers, and overc

    initial skepticism within the communities to establish the Il Ng

    Group Ranch in 1995.

    A community-owned conservation initiative

    Lewa Conservancy has been a constant partner in Il Ngwconservation work since 1995. The chie means through which

    group has sought to encourage sustainable land management

    development o a community-owned ecotourism enterprise, cen

    on the construction o a luxury eco-lodge and conservation o

    areas agship wildlie species. Il Ngwesi Lodge was opened in 1

    and caters to the high-end Kenyan tourism market. The lodge i

    by Il Ngwesi Company Ltd. and has stimulated the developme

    various other conservation-based enterprises, such as cultural bo

    (villages), artisanal handicrat production, and community-run c

    sites. The revenues generated by these initiatives are reinvest

    inrastructural projects that are prioritized by the Maasai comm

    at annual general meetings. To date, revenues have been use

    water inrastructure projects, schools, educational scholarshipsextensive health outreach services.

    Holistic land management is central to Il Ngwesis strategie

    conservation and development. Management o the group r

    land area has involved its division into settlement and conserv

    areas. The latter is urther divided into a relatively small core z

    measuring 5km2 (500 hectares) and a larger buer zone o 6

    hectares. Within this buer zone, pastoralists are permitted to g

    livestock during dry periods, making it an important strateg

    reducing the impacts o droughts. Meanwhile, various inrastruc

    Background and Context

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    5/12

    55

    rojects within the ranch area help to prevent soil erosion and

    maintain paths, while access to water has been improved or local

    ommunities. The Maasai group ranch members play a participatory

    ole in all land-use decisions.

    Governance and organizational structure

    he Il Ngwesi Community Trust committee (or Natural ResourceManagement committee) consists o ourteen representatives rom

    he seven Maasai communities. The committee meets three times

    year to hear proposals rom the community representatives and

    ebate decisions concerning the management o the group ranch

    r particular land-use regulations. The Community Trust committee

    as a legal advisor to review proposals; once agreed upon, these

    roposals are taken to the Group Ranch committee.

    he Group Ranch committee consists wholly o Maasai community

    members, although they also seek advice rom government

    epartments and other partners in specic areas o expertise,

    ncluding issues such as land acquisition, updating the members

    egister, and nancial management. The Group Ranch committees led by a Board o Directors, comprised o six elected members o

    he community and three external experts. Decisions are reerred

    o the Group Ranch committee or a vote, beore being outlined

    t an Annual General Meeting or Special General Meeting to gain

    he approval o the entire community. Elections are also held at

    he Annual General Meetings, as well as audited accounts being

    resented to the members.

    o solidiy this management structure, the Group Ranch developed a

    onstitution to establish clear decision-making and implementation

    rocesses. This includes the objectives, duties and powers o

    ommittees, ofce bearers, members, and non-member residents;

    rocedures or nancial management, conict resolution, andmeetings; and a description o the areas, rules and sanctions or

    ierent activities, such as grazing, conservation, and camp sites.

    he Group Ranch also has provisions or a salaried secretariat,

    ncluding a Programme Manager, responsible or carrying out

    he operations o the Group Ranch. Other innovative provisions

    nclude a commitment to retire 50% o all committee members

    t each election (elections are held every ve years or the Group

    Ranch Committee and every two years or the Community T

    Committee), so that newly acquired skills gained through tra

    are retained, but a reasonable turnover o personnel is ensured

    The lodge itsel is run as an independent limited company w

    majority shareholding owned by the Group Ranch, and is gove

    by a board made up o our community members, representa

    rom Lewa and Borana conservancies, and the local MembeParliament. The project typically employs around 32 sta; 24

    employed ull-time, with 15 working at the lodge and nine ull-

    guards, while casual workers are hired on a regular basis.

    Il Ngwesi has been very sensitive to the effects of climate change. Sources of income have

    shifted from pastoralism to agriculture to reduce the impact of a drought as a result of the

    unpredictable rain patterns. Il Ngwesi was also severely affected by the drought of 2008-9 (75%

    of buffaloes died as a result), and this has influenced the plan to make the area 100% conserved

    Youth are also being targeted to use alternative fuel sources for fires in communities, and to

    acquire solar panels as a source of energy, to minimize the rate of deforestation

    James Kasoo, Il Ngwesi Group Ranch

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    6/12

    6

    Key Activities and Innovations

    Ngwesis work has ocused on ensuring the ecological integrity

    o its conservation area while delivering tangible economic and

    ocial gains or its Maasai members. Conservation strategies have

    ncluded employing armed rangers to maintain security within the

    onservation area and enorce its prohibitions. Alternative livelihood

    ctivities have been encouraged to decrease the Maasais reliance

    on livestock and increase household incomes. Inrastructural

    projects, alongside health and education programs, have improved

    he wellbeing o the group ranchs communities.

    Conservation regulations

    he by-laws established to protect the ranchs 6,500 hectares o

    onserved land include the outlawing o tree-elling, poaching orilling o animals, and starting o res in the conservation area. Il

    Ngwesi is not enced, so nine security personnel are employed, and

    ave been given training and weapons by the governments reserve

    police orce to enorce these by-laws. The security personnel control

    he number o local people crossing the conservation area; they

    ave also banned pangas (machetes), dogs, and matchboxes rom

    being taken into the conservation area.

    From pastoralism to agriculture

    Conservation has been strengthened by the purchase o land outside

    he Il Ngwesi Group Ranch or agriculture: 2,000 acres were acquired

    or wheat planting using USD 30,000 rom the UNDP Equator Prize002. Community members have also been encouraged to diversiy

    rom livestock to agricultural activities, including the irrigation o

    and on the slopes o Mount Kenya. This acet o Il Ngwesis holistic

    pproach to land use is complemented by the controlled use o

    onservation land or pastoral grazing, and the requent relocation

    o the rhino sanctuary to allow the regeneration o depleted grass

    nd bushes. Action has been taken to reduce the eects o trodden

    paths in the conservation area by planting Rhodesian grasses;

    ocal people have also been employed to build gabions along

    oadsides to reduce water run-o and topsoil erosion rom hillsides.

    nrastructural investments have also been made in constructing

    water systems, connecting group ranch communities to rivers u

    pipes.

    Investments in community wellbeing

    This holistic approach to land use management has

    underpinned by Il Ngwesis extensive health and education prog

    Income generated through tourism has been used in construc

    new school classrooms, providing salaries or teachers, and crea

    bursaries or children to attend both secondary and ter

    education. In 2006, Il Ngwesi instituted an HIV/AIDS program

    using unding rom the Institute o Cultural Aairs (ICA) in Can

    which provides awareness, testing, counseling, and medical sup

    services to local communities. Training people within these villas counsellors and community care workers has been a key

    o this work. As o 2010, over 4,000 people had been tested

    within Il Ngwesi and outside the group ranch. Construction is

    underway on a health clinic, while mobile health services have

    delivered to communities in partnership with Lewa Conservanc

    National and international recognition

    Various strategies have helped to raise Il Ngwesis prole

    as an ecotourism destination and as a model or community

    conservation in Kenya and East Arica. The our-star eco-lodge

    been successully marketed via a website maintained by Il Ng

    sta based in the nearby town o Nanyuki. Il Ngwesi was awathe British Airways Best Ecotourism Destination Award in 1

    and also won in the Best Small Lodge category at the 2006 G

    Responsible Travel Awards. Its high prole has also been boo

    by its rhino sanctuary. The conservation area received a single b

    rhino in 2002, with assistance rom Lewa Wildlie Conservancy

    the approval o Kenya Wildlie Service. Ongoing conservation o

    species, along with two white rhino specimens, is testament to

    high level o security within the group ranch area. The nine ar

    rangers communicate via radio, using a radio channel requ

    purchased rom Kenyas Communication Commission.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    7/12

    7

    Impacts

    BIODIVERSITY IMPACTS Ngwesi was historically home to abundant populations o

    everal species, beore poaching in the 1970s and 1980s severely

    depleted wildlie numbers. Black rhinos in particular were heavily

    ected, while Il Ngwesis importance as an elephant corridor

    ttracted poachers rom eastern Kenya and Somalia. The land-use

    ystem implemented by the Group Ranch since 1995, however,

    has rehabilitated wildlie species numbers, and has made the re-

    ntroduction o numbers o black rhinos a genuine possibility.

    Much o the conservation work within Il Ngwesi should be seen in

    he context o coordinated eorts within Laikipia District as a whole,

    nd in the network o community-conserved areas and privateonservancies surrounding Lewa Downs Wildlie Conservancy. This

    network is now coordinated by the Northern Rangelands Trust. Il

    Ngwesi is a crucial partner in these eorts, and has been a pioneer in

    ommunity conservation. Many o its successes are based on having

    diversied income sources or its pastoralist communities, as well as

    ensuring the security o the conservation area.

    Endangered wildlie species conservation

    One milestone was in 2002, when an orphaned black rhino was

    elocated rom Lewa Conservancy to Il Ngwesi. Such an increase

    n the potential carrying capacity or black rhino in the area has

    made a direct contribution to the Kenya Wildlie Services national

    goal o improving the conservation o this species in Kenya. To

    date, however, this one specimen and two white rhinos delivered at

    he same time remain the only rhinos in Il Ngwesi. It is still unclear

    whether Kenya Wildlie Service will increase this number; ongoing

    ecurity eorts have demonstrated that the conservancy has the

    potential to protect this species.

    Ngwesis eorts have also benetted biodiversity and ecosystems

    n surrounding areas. The ranch provides critical security support

    o the no-mans land directly north o Lewa Wildlie Conservancy.

    This security has signicant implications or the survival oendangered Grevys zebra, which migrate between Lewa and

    government-run National Reserves o Samburu, Bualo Springs

    Shaba.

    Other species numbers are thriving. The conservation area is h

    to viable populations o large herbivores such as elephants, gir

    impalas, gerenuks, zebras, greater kudus, waterbucks, dik-diks

    warthogs. This reects broader improvements in ecosystem qu

    in 2002, over twice as many tree and herbaceous plant sp

    were counted in the conservancy compared to outside it. Ove

    bird species are also testament to a healthier ecosystem, resu

    rom decreased dependence on a pastoralist liestyle. Addit

    initiatives have included cutting back o acacia trees, oil rom w

    contributes to soil acidity, and planting o grasses to rehabi

    pathways.

    Research has been conducted by various institutions, inclu

    Kenya Forest Research Institute, Kenya Wildlie Service, the Unive

    o Nairobi, Ministry o Tourism, and private researchers such a

    International Centre o Insect Physiology and Ecology (icipe),

    have looked at the eects o ticks on wildlie and livestock num

    Il Ngwesi rangers also assist in monitoring eorts, dividing

    conservation area into blocks or occasional species counting.

    SOCIOECONOMIC IMPACTS

    Il Ngwesis community development projects are unded

    revenues rom ecotourism and seek to increase the wellbeing o

    group ranchs communities. Partnerships with international d

    organizations are also leveraged or this purpose. 40% o the net p

    rom the eco-lodge is reinvested in community development, w

    the remaining 60% is used to cover the lodges operational costs

    lodge generates approximately nine million Kenyan Shillings

    86,500) gross income annually, with the net prot usually ran

    between KSh 1.5-2 million (USD 14,400 to USD 19,200.)

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    8/12

    Job creation

    The group ranch has been able to create job opportunities primarily

    hrough the eco-lodge. The lodge employs teen ull-time sta, with

    a urther nine working as conservancy rangers. Temporary positions

    are created by ongoing inrastructural projects. These have included

    oad maintenance, water systems, and construction o schools and

    health clinics.

    i. Related sustainable livelihoodsncome generation associated with ecotourism has been seen

    hrough the development o artisanal handicrat-making by a

    womens group, while Il Ngwesi has also explored the possibility

    o purchasing and marketing locally-produced honey or tourists.

    n conjunction with Voluntary Service Overseas (VSO), the Group

    Ranch has initiated a our-year programme targeting womens

    groups in crat making. The programme trains women in quality

    beadwork skills and enables access to micro-credit acilities to allow

    hem to purchase raw materials or production. Training has also

    been given in leadership and governance, business development,

    and identiying markets or their products. Plans are in place to

    establish a rural bank in the Il Ngwesi community with assistance

    rom K-Rep, a Kenyan bank. Small loans will be made available atow interest rates (around 5%) or uture business development

    activities and sustainable enterprises within the community. The

    ustainability o both handicrats and honey as income sources

    depends on successul marketing, however, or which Il Ngwesi is

    eliant on external assistance.

    ii. Benefts to livelihoods rom holistic land-use

    The group ranch has also been able to boost household incomes

    hrough traditional sources. Improved land use management has

    had substantial benets or livestock and agriculture. During the

    2008-9 droughts, Il Ngwesis livestock were able to graze within

    he buer zone portion o the conservancy area. This helped to

    ubstantially mitigate the loss o cattle compared to other areas. The

    buer zone supplied approximately three months worth o grass or

    he herds, with total livestock losses estimated at around 60%; the

    communities bordering the conservancy experienced losses around

    40%. This compared with livestock losses o up to 90% in other areas

    o Kenya. The use o grass reserves in the conservancy is a local

    nnovation that could help to oset the eects o unpredictable

    weather patterns, and is thereore a valuable strategy or community-

    based adaptation to climate change.

    The group ranch has also encouraged diversication o income

    hrough agricultural projects on the higher slopes o the group

    anch. The majority o the Maasai remain pastoralists, but most nowend household plots or agriculture.

    v. Investments in education

    One area o investment that has yielded substantial socioeconomic

    benets is education. 500,000 Kenyan Shillings (almost USD 6,000)

    s allocated annually or an educational bursaries scheme, whereby

    community youth members are unded to attend secondary school

    and universities. This has targeted girls, aiming to reduce the rate

    o early marriages in Il Ngwesi communities. The Group Ranch

    also benetted local primary schools through the building o ho

    or teachers at Sanga Primary School, and sinking a boreho

    Enakishomi Primary School. Donor support has been sought to

    teachers salaries.

    v. Water systems inrastructure

    In 2008, with support rom Kansas City Zoo, Reid Park Zoo (

    USA) and the Northern Rangelands Trust, the Ngare Ndare pipwas repaired ater being damaged in 2006. This has ensured a w

    supply or the lodge and or livestock. This water system has b

    extended to schools and communities in 20% o the group r

    area through pipes. Communities have also benetted rom

    Sanga water project, which was rehabilitated with the suppo

    the Lewa Education Trust. In total, seven water systems have b

    put in place, carrying water rom river sources to villages.

    vi. Health acilities and outreach

    Investments in health have come through the building o a he

    clinic at Nadungoro, or which Il Ngwesi is in the process o see

    approval rom the government to operate. They have also wo

    closely with Lewa Conservancy in a mobile health project, ensuthat seven local communities are visited once a week by he

    workers.

    The greatest impact on the health o local people has come thro

    Il Ngwesis Aya II program, however. This project took its

    rom the USAID-led, country-wide AIDS, Population, and H

    Integrated Assistance (APHIA II) program, and in particular

    Family Health International (FHIs) work in Rit Valley provinc

    2006, in partnership with Canadas Institute o Cultural Aairs (

    Il Ngwesi undertook a baseline survey to assess awareness o

    AIDS issues among local communities. These results led to

    initiation o a campaign on awareness, testing, and counselin

    the disease, as well as on Malaria and Tuberculosis, through tra

    community volunteers and outreach events. The target popula

    extended beyond Il Ngwesi Group Ranch to a total o thirteen

    group ranches; to date, ten o these groups have been reached,

    a combined population o approximately 40,000.

    The two group ranches initially covered by the program we

    Ngwesi and Makurian, with 5,000 targeted or counseling

    testing, and 20,000 targeted or increasing prevention aware

    in 2007/8. In subsequent years the scope has been expanded,

    3,000 targeted or counseling and testing in both 2009 and 2

    A University o Toronto study in 2009 is indicative o the prog

    that has been made. They ound that over 8,000 tests had bconducted (including repeat tests). The incidence rate was u

    5%, while those that had tested positive were receiving

    Contraception use was more prevalent, and was cited as a r

    o the success o outreach activities. Approximately 70% o t

    surveyed had attended at least one HIV/AIDS awareness ses

    56% had been tested in Il Ngwesis mobile tent; 80% had receiv

    home visit rom a program volunteer; and over 80% had volunte

    with the project or knew someone who had.

    8

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    9/12

    POLICY IMPACTS

    Ngwesi has had an impact on Kenyas wildlie policies through

    ts association with Lewa Conservancy, the Northern Rangelands

    rust, and its partnership with Kenya Wildlie Service (the owner

    nd ounder o Lewas private conservancy, who was instrumental

    n encouraging community conservation in Il Ngwesi, served on the

    oard o KWS rom 2008-2011.) This relationship initially led to IlNgwesi being granted its black rhino in 2002. The signicance o this

    hould not be understated: KWS policy had been that communal

    onservancies could not be given endangered rhino specimens due

    o security concerns. Ater an assessment o Il Ngwesi, however, it

    was deemed a sufciently sae environment. Il Ngwesi can be seen

    s a test case or community conservation, thereore.

    Since 2002, however, the group ranch has not been awarded a se

    individual, as KWS remain unconvinced o the ranchs security

    Rhino Sanctuarys sole inhabitant is now an eight year-old m

    but has not been given a mate. Il Ngwesi maintain that their ar

    rangers guarantee a sufcient level o security. This has ca

    rustration on the part o Il Ngwesis wardens, with bureaucracy

    policy changes also cited as a reason or the ongoing situation.

    Despite this, Il Ngwesi is undoubtedly regarded as a mode

    community-based conservation and tourism within Kenya,

    has been inuential in advising replication eorts. In particula

    governance structure and method o benets distribution

    inormed other community conservancies in Kenya and Tanzan

    9

    Policy decisions should consider the negative and positive impacts for communities. Polic

    details must be defined and communities must be educated on their effects. Government dono

    should know that communities do not always benefit as they would hope from donations improve

    monitoring of their impacts and better systems of governance are needed

    James Kasoo, Il Ngwesi Group Ranch

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    10/12

    10

    Sustainability and Replication

    SUSTAINABILITYhe Group Ranch is nancially sustainable, with average annual

    evenues rom the eco-lodge o around USD 86,500. This adequately

    overs the lodges operational costs, while 40% is invested in

    ommunity development projects. The lodge has operated without

    xternal unding since 2004. In addition to lodge revenue, a

    onservation ee is also payable or entry into the area, at USD 40

    er person, per day, while groups o visitors pay USD 300 per night

    o stay in the lodges campsites. Associated ecotourism attractions

    lso generate revenue or the Group Ranch. The cultural boma (a

    raditional Maasai village) promotes indigenous traditions and

    Maasai culture. Tourists can visit the village without staying at theodge, with prots going directly to the villagers themselves itsel.

    Hiring out conservancy vehicles provides an additional source o

    evenue, while womens groups have developed artisanal handicrat-

    making to capitalize on ecotourism.

    Strategic partnerships and investments

    xternal unding is sought where Il Ngwesis own revenues cannot

    over its community development projects. International partners

    ave also contributed in the orm o technical assistance, or instance

    n Il Ngwesis health and enterprise development schemes. FHI and

    CA have played key roles in the Aya II program, which is wholly

    unded by external sources, while VSO volunteers have given trainingnd marketing advice to the women producing artisanal handicrats.

    eachers salaries are paid by Il Ngwesi, the government, and specic

    onors. On the other hand, the maintenance o water systems and

    ecurity in the conservancy are unded wholly by Il Ngwesi.

    A strategy to enhance the long-term nancial autonomy o the

    Group Ranch is the purchase o land to build residential property in

    he local town o Timau, which will then be leased to generate extra

    ncome. This decision was taken by the Group Ranch Committee

    with the acquiescence o the Il Ngwesi Community Trust. Pr

    rom the eco-lodge that would otherwise have been paid out to

    Maasai community member shareholders in the orm o divid

    were instead used to purchase the land plot. A nance comm

    has been appointed to come up with quotations and seek ext

    unding or the construction.

    Social and ecological sustainability

    Community participation through Il Ngwesis governance stru

    is undamental to its long-term sustainability. By giving the g

    ranch inhabitants a voice and a vote, the initiative has ensur

    strong degree o local ownership. Its tangible socioeconomic imphave also gained it the support o the community. This suppo

    not assured, however, and external land acquisitions have also

    used to ease pressures within the conservation area. Popula

    growth and unpredictable weather patterns have increased ten

    over land use or wildlie conservation versus livestock grazing

    Group Ranch Committee has thereore proposed relocating

    various communities to external sites. 100% o the group r

    would then be used or conservation, although there are ears

    this could lead to the land being managed by Kenya Wildlie Se

    as a government-run conservancy.

    The long-term ecological sustainability within the Laikipia Dist

    aided by Il Ngwesis relationship with neighbouring conservathrough the Northern Rangelands Trust. I the Maasai popula

    are resettled elsewhere in the next ve years, the conserv

    will be utilized entirely or wildlie management. Wildlie sp

    will be translocated rom Lewa Wildlie Conservancy to b

    existing wildlie populations in Il Ngwesi. Increasing the black r

    conservation potential o Il Ngwesi is also a major ocus o the u

    while discussions are being held with Lewa Wildlie Conserva

    Lekurruki Group Ranch, and Borana Ranch to establish a l

    combined conservation area between the our properties.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    11/12

    Biodiversity concerns everyone; it is the responsibility of everyone to take care of the

    ecosystems. Everyone must contribute

    James Kasoo, Il Ngwesi Group Ranch

    1111

    Challenges to Il Ngwesis sustainability

    ompetition with other ecotourism ventures: marketing o Il Ngwesi

    will be crucial to this, as will urther improving the road inrastructure.

    eaching Il Ngwesi rom the main road rom Isiolo is currently a

    hallenge in bad weather.

    limate change: rain patterns have changed considerably in recent

    ears, and impose hardship on pastoralists that in turn increasesuman pressures on the conservation area.

    Ownership o newly-acquired land: questions exist over the

    wnership structure or any potential expanded conservation areas

    nd residential plots.

    ecurity: urther strengthening security operations within the

    onservancy could be key to Il Ngwesi receiving more black rhino

    ndividuals or other at-risk species, which in turn would improve its

    cotourism potential.

    REPLICATION

    Ngwesi has been used as a model or community conserved

    reas in Kenya, as well as in Tanzania, Uganda and Southern Sudan.

    Exchange visits have been hosted at Il Ngwesi, while elders ro

    Ngwesi have also been invited by Kenya Wildlie Service to s

    lessons on governance processes with other communities. M

    o the replication o Il Ngwesis model has taken place locally,

    as the establishment and development o Naibunga Conserva

    which covers over 17,000 hectares, while Shompole Commu

    Trust, rom near Magadi in southern Kenya, has also replicat

    Ngwesis eco-lodge model.

    PARTNERS

    Lewa Wildlie Conservancy

    Northern Rangelands Trust

    Laikipia Wildlie Forum

    Arica Wildlie Foundation

    Kenya Wildlie Service

    University o Nairobi

    Kenya Forestry Research Institute

    Voluntary Service Overseas (two ull-time volunteers or

    next two years to cover range o activities)

    Borana Ranch

    Family Health International

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: IL NGWESI GROUP RANCH, Kenya

    12/12

    Click the thumbnails below to read more case studies like this:

    Equator Initiative

    Environment and Energy GroupUnited Nations Development Programme (UNDP)

    304 East 45th Street, 6th Floor

    New York, NY 10017

    Tel: +1 646 781-4023

    www.equatorinitiative.org

    The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is the UNs global development network, advocating or change

    onnecting countries to knowledge, experience and resources to help people build a better lie.

    The Equator Initiative brings together the United Nations, governments, civil society, businesses and grassroots organizati

    o recognize and advance local sustainable development solutions or people, nature and resilient communities.

    2012 by Equator Initiative

    All rights reserved

    FURTHER REFERENCE

    Il Ngwesi Group Ranch website: ilngwesi.com

    Il Ngwesi Group Ranch PhotoStory (Vimeo) vimeo.com/27016070 (English) vimeo.com/15750010 (Swahili)

    http://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348161880.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348260928.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348161612.pdf