case studies undp: trowel development foundation, philippines

Upload: undpenvironment

Post on 14-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    1/13

    Equator Initiative Case StudiesLocal sustainable development solutions for people, nature, and resilient communities

    Philippines

    TROWEL DEVELOPMENTFOUNDATION

    Empowered live

    Resilient nation

    Empowered live

    Resilient nation

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    2/13

    UNDP EQUATOR INITIATIVE CASE STUDY SERIES

    Local and indigenous communities across the world are advancing innovative sustainable development solutions that wo

    or people and or nature. Few publications or case studies tell the ull story o how such initiatives evolve, the breadth

    their impacts, or how they change over time. Fewer still have undertaken to tell these stories with community practition

    themselves guiding the narrative.

    To mark its 10-year anniversary, the Equator Initiative aims to ll this gap. The ollowing case study is one in a growing ser

    that details the work o Equator Prize winners vetted and peer-reviewed best practices in community-based environmenconservation and sustainable livelihoods. These cases are intended to inspire the policy dialogue needed to take local succ

    to scale, to improve the global knowledge base on local environment and development solutions, and to serve as models

    replication. Case studies are best viewed and understood with reerence to The Power of Local Action: Lessons from 10 Years

    the Equator Prize, a compendium o lessons learned and policy guidance that draws rom the case material.

    Click on the map to visit the Equator Initiatives searchable case study database.

    EditorsEditor-in-Chief: Joseph CorcoranManaging Editor: Oliver HughesContributing Editors: Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Erin Lewis, Whitney Wilding

    Contributing WritersEdayatu Abieodun Lamptey, Erin Atwell, Toni Blackman, Jonathan Clay, Joseph Corcoran, Larissa Currado, Sarah Gordon, Oliver Hughe

    Wen-Juan Jiang, Sonal Kanabar, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Rachael Lader, Patrick Lee, Erin Lewis, Jona Liebl, Mengning Ma,

    Mary McGraw, Gabriele Orlandi, Brandon Payne, Juliana Quaresma, Peter Schecter, Martin Sommerschuh, Whitney Wilding, Luna Wu

    DesignOliver Hughes, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Amy Korngiebel, Kimberly Koserowski, Erin Lewis, John Mulqueen, Lorena de la Pa

    Brandon Payne, Mariajos Satizbal G.

    AcknowledgementsThe Equator Initiative acknowledges with gratitude Trowel Development Foundation, and in particular the guidance and inputs

    Leonardo B. Rosario. All photo credits courtesy o Trowel Development Foundation. Maps courtesy o CIA World Factbook and Wikiped

    Suggested CitationUnited Nations Development Programme. 2012. Trowel Development Foundation, Philippines. Equator Initiative Case Study Series. N

    York, NY.

    http://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=casestudysearch&Itemid=858http://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdf
  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    3/13

    PROJECT SUMMARYTrowel Development Foundation is a community-basedorganization employing climate-adapted aquaculturetechnology to replant mangroves. Mangrove reorestationeorts have ocused on planting native tree species instrategic areas, resulting in restored marine biodiversity,ood security, and protection o coastal areas.

    The initiative also works to increase local incomes andimprove livelihoods through a value-chain system to markettie-crabs. The group has established ve community-managed tie-crab arms that benet 250 subsistence

    shing households. This innovation has been implementedin idle shponds, where mangrove-riendly and climate-adapted tie-crab attening technology has been employedto double the income o shing households.

    KEY FACTS

    EQUATOR PRIZE WINNER: 2010

    FOUNDED: 2004

    LOCATION: Northern Samar province

    BENEFICIARIES: Over 250 families

    BIODIVERSITY: Mangrove ecosystems

    3

    TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATIONPhilippines

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Background and Context 4

    Key Activities and Innovations 6

    Biodiversity Impacts 9

    Socioeconomic Impacts 9

    Policy Impacts 10

    Sustainability 11

    Replication 11

    Partners 12

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    4/13

    4

    Northern Samar province is located on the eastern side o the

    hilippine Archipelago. It is bound on the north by the San Bernardino

    trait, on the east by the Pacic Ocean, on the west by the Samar Sea,

    nd on the south by the provinces o Samar and Eastern Samar. It is

    omposed o 24 municipalities and 569 barangays covering a total

    and area o 3,693 square kilometers. The province is characterized

    y a varied topography with mountains and undulating terrain that

    s exposed to wind, typhoons and rainall, with warm equatorial

    waters owing northward along the eastern coast. The province has

    complex mix o terrestrial ecosystems and habitat types, which

    nclude natural terrestrial ecosystems composed o lower mountain

    orests, agroorestry areas, lowland agricultural areas, beach orests,

    quatic ecosystems (rivers, streams, mangrove swamps, aquacultureonds and reservoirs), seagrass beds, and coral rees. Wetland orests

    urround the reshwater swamps and coastal orest. The cultivated

    rea, which covers 171,000 hectares o the province, or roughly

    8 percent o the land, is used or coconut (140,212 hectares), rice

    26,737 hectares), root crop (1,710 hectares), banana (679 hectares),

    nd corn (542 hectares) production.

    Environmental threats to an area of mega-biodiversity

    he waters o the coast o Northern Samar are inhabited by

    ommercially important sh and marine species. The provinces

    ch abundance o biological diversity helps to account or the

    hilippines classication as one o the worlds 18 areas o mega-iodiversity. Thirteen o the Philippines orty indigenous mangrove

    pecies are ound in Northern Samar, as are twenty-our ree-based

    sh amilies, thirty economically important sh species, two

    ndigenous seagrass species, and several endemic seaweed varieties.

    mportantly, Northern Samar supplies 60 percent o the countrys

    rablets. This diversity and abundance o sh, coral and mangrove

    esources, however, has been severely degraded due to illegal

    shing and destructive activities such as dynamite shing, coral

    arvesting, and mangrove deorestation. In the case o the latter, a

    ubstantial proportion o the provinces mangrove orests have been

    systematically deorested to convert land into settlement are

    or shpond use. Hundreds o hectares o sh ponds, previo

    used or milk sh and prawn cultivation, have been abandoned

    now sit idle and unproductive.

    Root causes of poverty in Northern Samar

    Northern Samar is also an economically marginalized provin

    recent survey o the region ound that 14 o 24 municipalities

    poverty rates higher than 50 percent, making it the seventh po

    among the countrys 79 provinces. Roughly 50,000 househol

    Northern Samar suer rom extreme poverty.

    The economy is largely dependent on the agriculture and sh

    sectors. Small-hold armers are the norm, with the average a

    tending to less than ve hectares o land to cultivate coconut,

    corn, bananas, abaca, pineapple, ginger and vegetables. Copra

    root crops provide the primary sources o rural income. Small-

    production also predominates in the shing sector, where

    shermen use traditional shing techniques and equipment

    as hook and line, sh netting, and small-scale aquaculture. S

    scale shing operations cultivate Spanish mackerel, grouper,

    big-eyed scad, round scad, herring, anchovies and salmon. O

    marine resources include cuttlesh, crabs, shrimp, squid and lob

    As shing incomes have plummeted, so has the ability o s

    amilies to provide or basic ood security, health, education, houor other economic needs.

    Growing levels o poverty can be linked, to a certain exten

    diminishing outputs rom the provinces sheries. According

    Fishery Resources Management Conerence in 2006, the decl

    trend in the provinces sh production stems rom dwind

    productivity due to overshing, destructive shing methods,

    o strong sheries regulation and enorcement, lack o sh

    inormation, inaccessible credit acilities, lack o post-ha

    acilities, and weak institutions and organizations. So too, pov

    Background and Context

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    5/13

    55

    n Northern Samar has been exacerbated by the negative impacts

    climate change. It is particularly vulnerable to tropical cyclones,

    ooding and coastal erosion, which introduce insecurity and

    ncertainty or an already vulnerable rural population.

    nnovative technologies for local livelihoods

    ince 2004, the Trowel Development Foundation has worked to

    trengthen the adaptive capacities o coastal villages to the impacts climate change by securing the livelihoods o subsistence shing

    ouseholds. The project ocus was and remains the productive

    tilization o idle shponds, namely through the introduction and

    mainstreaming o mangrove-riendly, biodiversity-enhancing, and

    isaster-resilient tie-crab attening technology. The tie-crab attening

    pproach tying individual crabs to bamboo poles has helped to

    ouble the income o shing households. The Trowel Development

    oundation has also ocused on mangrove reorestation, planting

    ative tree species in abandoned sh ponds to restore aquatic

    iodiversity, improve ood security and enhance the protection o

    oastal ecosystems.

    ive community-managed tie-crab arms have been established,

    which together benet more than 250 subsistence shing

    ouseholds. Aquatic biodiversity has recovered, as evidenced by the

    rolieration o native sh, crustaceans, and mollusks which are now

    arvestable in the tie-crab arms and neighboring areas. Stocks o

    mud crabs have increased substantially due to the release o gravid

    mud crabs into the wild or spawning. Over 20 hectares o mangrove

    orest have been replanted and maintained.

    he Trowel Development Foundation is guided in its work by our

    ey objectives:

    . Increase by 80 percent the ood security and income o 1,000subsistence shing households through the establishment o

    community-managed tie-crab arms.

    . Restore local aquatic biodiversity and enhance the protection o

    10 barangays through mangrove reorestation in idle shponds.

    . Enhance the economic productivity o subsistence shing

    households by building mutually-benecial market supply

    chains in the local mud crab industry.

    . Develop viable value chains or crab-attening and marketing.

    As crosscutting issues, the Trowel Development Foundation aims to

    nhance the local economy, ensure environmental sustainability, and

    improve local governance. To bolster the local economy, the initi

    works through community-managed tie-crab arms to increase

    supplies o mature mud crabs. Market supply chains are not

    developed or tie-crabs, but or a range o locally harvested ma

    resources and products. The benets are ound not only in impr

    livelihoods and incomes, but also in improved ood security athousehold level. On the environment side, the initiative has oc

    on the restoration and recovery o degraded mangrove ecosyst

    Targeting previously idle sh ponds, mangrove reorestation

    helped to reduce shore erosion, buer against climate-rel

    natural disasters, and has promoted the regeneration o se

    marine species. Local governance eorts have ocused on

    institutionalization o co-management systems which encou

    the active participation o local shermen, and partnership

    cooperation with womens sel-help groups, national governm

    agencies and line ministries, local government units, acad

    institutions, civil society, and other community-based organizat

    The coastal communities in Northern Samar, Philippines continue to face the threat of sea-lev

    rise and strong storms due to climate change. As an adaptive response, the small-scale fishers in th

    province developed an integrated strategy that involves disaster-resilient aquaculture, ecologic

    mangrove restoration and value-chain development in tie-crab fattening and marketing.

    Leonardo B. Rosario, Trowel Development Foundation

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    6/13

    6

    Key Activities and Innovations

    he Trowel Development Foundation was born in 2004, ollowing

    n Integrated Support or Local Actions Towards Coastal Resources

    Amelioration and Augmentation o Livelihoods program unded

    by New Zealand Aid. This program was implemented in twenty

    oastal barangays. The ounders o what would become the Trowel

    Development Foundation were asked to implement the program

    n Lavezares. As in the other barangays, the traditional shing

    ommunities in Lavezares were suering rom low incomes due

    o dwindling sh catches resulting rom illegal shing, a lack o

    ppropriate shing gear and equipment, and an absence o viable

    lternative livelihood options.

    Transition to a community-owned initiative

    When the project ended in 2007, the Trowel Development

    oundation developed a continuity strategy to sustain advances

    nd gains made during the course o the program. Specically, the

    trategy ocused on the local aquaculture industry and the gap in

    ppropriate technologies or small-scale armers and shermen.

    ollowing a gap analysis based on several key considerations

    ncluding potential t with coastal and marine and environments,

    vailability o necessary raw materials, and market demand priority

    was given to mud crab and seaweed cultivation, as these were seen

    o have the highest enterprise potential. Trowel Development

    oundation began by undertaking a comprehensive inventory a

    ocial mapping o local technologies and practices in mud crab andeaweed cultivation. A viable, transerable crab-attening technique

    was identied that involved tying crabs to individual bamboo poles.

    o test the approach, a two-hectare demonstration arm and training

    acility or tie-crab attening was established. On- and o-site training

    was oered to small-scale shermen. Mangrove restoration and

    eorestation were instituted as a central conservation dimension

    o the strategy. Supply-chain and marketing support or attened

    ie-crabs was also provided, closing the loop on market access and

    business development.

    Evolution of project goals based on local demand

    The initial objectives o the project were to increase the incom

    200 subsistence shing households by 50 percent, to protect

    enhance local biodiversity in nine mangrove sites, and to aci

    co-management arrangements or the conservation and sustain

    use o aquatic and mangrove resources. These objectives

    later expanded to cover incomes and ood security or a tot

    1,000 households, mangrove reorestation in idle shponds,

    market supply-chain development. Growth in the number o ta

    beneciaries was quite simply a unction o local interest

    demand rom small-scale shermen. The issue o ood security

    introduced in acknowledgment that tie-crab attening could alsused or consumption, and to directly address an existing decie

    Lastly, supply-chains were prioritized based on a perceived ga

    avorable markets or locally produced products.

    Planning, mobilization, and evaluation

    To date, Trowel Development Foundation activities have

    delivered through three phases: assessment and planning, educa

    and mobilization, and evaluation. The rst phase on assessm

    and planning had two stages. The rst stage was an exerci

    institution-building, scoping and visioning. Project orient

    assemblies were held to raise awareness and understandin

    the various aspects o Trowel Development Foundation objecand proposed activities, to mobilize relevant stakeholders, an

    secure needed commitments. During this stage, the projec

    management council was ormed, project operation and investm

    plans were ormulated, and an MOU was signed between the proj

    stakeholders regarding partner responsibilities and commitm

    o resources. The second stage involved community assessm

    denition o project priorities, and crab industry scoping. In the

    instance, local consultations and site inspections were undert

    to identiy and select idle shponds that could useully be inclu

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    7/13

    7

    n the project. This was complemented by participatory resource

    ppraisals, which gathered data on community and household

    ssets in the target villages, easible cooperation guidelines and

    riority areas, and potential project collaborators. Lastly, a crab

    ector study and value-chain analysis was conducted on the linkages

    etween members o the tie-crab association and other industry

    takeholders. Based on the ndings o this study, an industry

    rotocol was drated to ensure a steady supply o quality lean crabs,

    eliable market outlets that oer air prices to local shermen, andccessible business development services.

    he second phase on education and mobilization had three stages.

    he rst stage ocused on awareness-raising within the local crab

    ndustry, using the ndings o the sector study and value-chain

    nalysis. A standard protocol on crab attening was developed,

    long with a trading plan. Training on the tie-crab attening

    was provided to project participants. The second stage invo

    mangrove reorestation and restoration in strategic portions o

    and abandoned shponds. Community members were involve

    documentation o mangrove species as well as replanting e

    Fattening sites were identied, arm areas were demarcated, bam

    poles were set up, a eed area and guard house were establis

    lean crabs were procured and distributed, and harvesting

    marketing was acilitated. The nal stage in this phase was a

    parade and mangrove estival, where wholesale and retail markesupport was provided and market agreements between

    armers and buyers negotiated. These public events also serve

    a means o exchanging best practices in tie-crab attening betw

    stakeholders. The third phase o Trowel Development Founda

    development involved mid-term assessments and pro

    evaluations, where the net benets and costs to participa

    communities were determined.

    Support local adaptation strategies because the negative impacts of climate change hit loc

    communities the hardest.

    Leonardo B. Rosario, Trowel Development Foundation

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    8/13

    8

    Innovations in technology, value-chains, and governance

    The most noteworthy innovation o this project is the disaster-

    esilient tie-crab attening technique, which involves tying individual

    rabs, each with a buoy, to bamboo poles staked two meters apart.

    As a consequence, crabs do not easily escape during arm ooding

    a regular occurrence), as they are securely astened to the bamboo

    poles. In the event that the poles break during oods, the crabs can be

    ecovered, as the buoys are easily visible rom above the oodwater.When aced with more severe storms, armers can quickly collect

    he crabs, place them in a secure shelter, and then return them

    o the arms ater the storm has passed. Individual eeding allows

    or regulation and rationing based on the consumption capacity

    o individual crabs, meaning that there is less wasting o ood as

    ompared to grow-out methods o crab cultivation. In addition to

    being an easily transerred technology, tie-crab attening adds to

    ease o harvesting, greater selection in harvesting based on weight

    nd maturity, and a higher return on investment, as prots are 50

    percent higher over a 15 to 20 day period as compared with the

    grow-out method.

    Additionally, the Trowel Development Foundation has created a

    uccessul value-chain or crab attening and marketing. The process

    ocuses on consolidation within the existing tie-crab association

    o improve its collective productivity, to set standards, and to

    enhance collective bargaining capacity when negotiating with

    mainstream markets. Industry orums and training in marketing and

    negotiation help to strengthen armer engagement with industry

    takeholders. Industry protocols have been enhanced, and in some

    ases pioneered, to advance investments in crab research, crab

    nursery establishment, crablet collection, crab attening, and crab

    marketing. Negotiations between crab growers and buyers are

    acilitated in advance o the attened crabs being ready or market

    n order to establish mutually benecial outcomes and to bolsterhe bargaining power o local crab growers who are otherwise in a

    ompromised position.

    Another project innovation has been the co-management approach

    o mangrove restoration, which brings together a range o relevant

    takeholders, including civil society organizations, government,

    nd the business sector. Cooperating organizations are equal and

    ctive participants in decision-making, and each perorms a distinct

    developmental unction that complements the work o other players.

    Similarly, benet-sharing is at the heart o the co-management

    rrangement.

    Multifaceted service delivery and capacity building

    Above and beyond its work in tie-crab arming, mangrove

    eorestation and market supply-chain development, Trowel

    Development Foundation is actively involved in integrated service

    delivery to the local community, including credit and savings

    ervices. These services are provided or small-scale armer activities

    nd enterprise development in the orest, agriculture, and shery

    ectors. The initiative also provides technical support and guidance

    o local armers on organic agriculture, orest management and

    agro-orestry techniques, community-based coastal resou

    management and conservation, and community mobiliza

    Further still, Trowel Development Foundation oers training

    community members on project management, bookkee

    accounting, and gender sensitivity.

    Organizational structure

    On an organizational level, the Trowel Development Foundaretains our technical sta members, including a project t

    leader, an aquaculture ofcer, a orestry ofcer, and a develop

    ofcer. Administrative support is provided by a nance o

    and a bookkeeper. Technical support is provided by consult

    with expertise, respectively, in the areas o aquaculture, or

    and value-chain development. Project management is a sh

    responsibility between the Project Management Council, the

    Crab Industry Association, the Project Technical Team, and a num

    o barangay sherolk and armers organizations.

    The Project Management Council is a multi-stakeho

    interdisciplinary governance unit. It is variously composed o

    representatives rom sherolk, armers and womens ederat

    a municipal agricultural ofcer and municipal councilor rom

    Committee on Agriculture and Fisheries; the chairperson o

    University o Eastern Philippines, Department o Fisheries;

    provincial ofcer o the Bureau o Fisheries and Aquatic Resou

    and the Executive Director o Trowel Development Foundation

    decision-making body is charged with overall strategic dire

    and policy guidance or the organization. Its members deter

    resource requirements, ensure a avorable policy environm

    through local government unit advocacy, provide technical

    nancial assistance through line ministries, and set criteria o

    selection o project beneciaries. Overall coordination o the Tr

    Development Foundation is undertaken at the community levthe Tie Crab Industry Association, with assistance rom the Pro

    Technical Team the project team leader, aquaculture ofcer, s

    ofcer, and community development ofcer.

    To coordinate Trowel Development Foundation work, our unct

    committees have been established. A sanctuary committee

    charge o the development and management o the crab sanct

    including monitoring and enorcement. A production comm

    ensures the steady production o mud crabs, the developme

    tie-crab arm plans, the monitoring o mud crab production

    tie-crab arm, and reporting on perormance and obstacles. A c

    committee sets organizational policies or credit availability and

    monitors the use o credit unds by community members, ensthat credit unds are paid on time, and monitors adherence to c

    policies. Lastly, a marketing committee lays the oundation or ai

    equitable market supply-chains through price negotiation sup

    and industry meetings. Fisherolk, armers and womens edera

    provide volunteer labor and resources or the implementatio

    project activities at the barangay level. These communities

    directly involved in coordination o the tie-crab arms and the

    sanctuary, as well as the credit and marketing aspects o the pro

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    9/13

    9

    Impacts

    BIODIVERSITY IMPACTS

    The municipalities o Lavezares and Rosario in which the Trowel

    Development Foundation is currently active have a combined

    ggregate coastline o 102 kilometers, comprised mainly o coastal

    nd marine ecosystems and wetlands that include mangrove

    wamps, aquaculture ponds, reservoirs, coral rees, and seagrass

    beds. The regions mangrove orest contains thirteen mangrove

    pecies o seven amilies, the most dominant o which are

    Rhizophora mucronata and R. apiculata, which are ound in all Trowel

    Development Foundation project sites. Due to ongoing degradation,

    mangrove orest densities are low and increasingly shrinking, with

    n average o 6,000 stems per hectare. It is this trend that the TrowelDevelopment Foundation is working to reverse.

    The projects positive biodiversity impacts have stemmed largely

    rom the reorestation and restoration o mangrove ecosystems.

    These activities have resulted in the recovery, reappearance and

    prolieration o sh species, as well as other endemic marine auna.

    Reorestation eorts have ocused primarily on idle and abandoned

    shponds.

    Beyond mangrove replantation, the act o tie-crab arming itsel

    has proven to have a number o biodiversity benets. The tie-crab

    pproach allows or more targeted and less destructive harvesting,

    nd the demarcation o tie-crab arms has in many case (whetherdeliberately or otherwise) created de facto marine sanctuaries where

    quatic species have been able to regenerate and thrive. Tie-crab

    armers have reported the reappearance o native sh species in arm

    ites and in adjacent areas. Specically, wild milk sh, rabbit sh and

    hrimp can now be ound and caught, both inside the arms and on

    heir peripheries. Farmers have also been supported to strategically

    elease attened and matured crabs or spawning in the wild. This

    has led to a dramatic increase in crablet stocks, which, according to

    egg production numbers oered by the South East Asian Fisheries

    Development Centre, have grown by over 12 million individuals.

    SOCIOECONOMIC IMPACTS

    Trowel Development Foundation has improved the quality o

    o over 250 amilies, who can now meet basic needs as a resu

    increased incomes and diversied livelihood options. On ave

    participating amilies have seen an increase in monthly earnin

    USD 69. This revenue is reported to have been invested into sc

    ees and meeting the subsistence needs o local households. Pr

    activities have also resulted in greater ood security, through

    reliable and regular production o attened, mature crabs, as w

    the reappearance o wild sh in the crab sanctuaries. Where ar

    had no reliable source o sh previously, they now report an ave

    weekly take o three kilograms o wild milk sh, rabbit shshrimp. The sh caught is equivalent to an additional USD 32

    month.

    For tie-crab attening, the cost o land averages USD 313 per he

    per year. Since tie-crab armers only require about 100 sq

    meters or a unctioning small-scale arm, the cost o the pond

    is very low. The time required to develop a unctioning tie-crab

    is also minimal, taking between 15 and 20 days or crabs to atte

    which point they are harvestable. There is a strong market and

    demand or tie-crabs, both locally and or export. Tie-crab ar

    can make gross average revenue o USD 161 per attening cycle

    Within the over 1,000 small-scale shermen amilies engagetie-crab arm management, women have been a primary ta

    o capacity building and support. Specically, local wo

    are supported to engage in the buying and selling o lean

    robust crabs, each earning USD 5 or a hal day o trading. Tr

    Development Foundation has also promoted a Passing on the

    approach, whereby primary project beneciaries are encour

    to transer and share the original assistance they received to o

    amilies in need o capacity building support.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    10/13

    POLICY IMPACTS

    Trowel Development Foundation actively advocates at the local

    and provincial levels or community- rights and entitlements, and

    he delineation o mangrove orests or both tie-crab arming and

    community co-management. At the time o this study (2011), a

    municipal tie-crab ordinance was still being negotiated in order

    o ormally establish mud crab sanctuaries in the mangroves o

    wo municipalities. At the provincial level, Trowel Development

    Foundation has succeeded in introducing a mud crab ordinanc

    all o Northern Samar. Tie-crab armers help enorce the ordin

    by reporting violators who export y-size or undersized cra

    outside the province, thereby diminishing the sustainable

    reproductive capacity o local crab populations and ecosystems

    organization is also in conversation with the Provincial Govern

    Environment and Natural Resource Ofce regarding the alloca

    o unds or mangrove reorestation eorts in two municipalitie

    10

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    11/13

    11

    Sustainability and Replication

    SUSTAINABILITYn terms o nancial sustainability, the capital requirements o the

    roject are relatively small. Material and labor inputs are minimal.

    Materials needed, including lean crabs, bamboo poles and crab

    eeds are widely available in project sites. Also, tie-crab attening as

    technique requires only modest levels o expertise and knowledge,

    most o which is already widely abundant amongst the local

    opulation.

    he nancial sustainability and viability o the Trowel Development

    oundation is provided or by partners and collaborators, who

    er in-kind support, sot loans, grants, the use o laboratoryacilities and manpower. The organization is engaged in ongoing

    utreach eorts to make connections and linkages with relevant

    takeholders capable o contributing support and resources.

    artners such as the Philippine Social Enterprise Network (value-

    hain development), the University o Eastern Philippines (technical

    upport on coastal resource management), and the Southeast Asian

    isheries Development Center (aquaculture scientists) all bolster the

    nitiatives sustainability.

    he Passing on the Gits approach has been institutionalized

    nd contributes to project growth and sustainability. The original

    ecipients o project assistance are required to transer an equal

    measure o assistance to a selected recipient amily. The approachs still in the process o being socially embedded amongst the small-

    cale shers in the coastal communities, but has a high degree o

    otential or expanding the number o participating armers and

    roject beneciaries.

    REPLICATION

    or the Trowel Development Foundation, success has bred interest

    n other communities. As is oten the case with biodiversity

    onservation initiatives, it has been necessary to communicate

    the incentives and benets possible rom thoughtul, sustain

    resource management. Neighboring communities and municipa

    have been able to see rst-hand the positive, transormative e

    Trowel Development Foundation activities have had on the

    economy, on household-level ood security, and on mangrove

    coastal ecosystems. Equally attractive to communities is how e

    transerred the project model is to other sites, and the relat

    low levels o capital investment and resource inputs needed

    organization has also provided an instructive model o how to

    start-up unds or crab arming through micro-nance loans.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    12/13

    1212

    he project model is currently being promoted among local

    overnment units or integration into local development plans. For

    xample, the municipality o Calauag invited Trowel Development

    oundation to share its tie-crab attening technique with

    overnment ofcials in 2009. The technique was also eatured in

    he national aquaculture conerence Fishlink 2010, which brought

    ogether shpond owners, aquaculture scientists, ofcials o national

    overnment agencies, and local government units rom all over the

    ountry.

    PARTNERS

    robust partnership makes the Trowel Development Foundation

    ossible. Dierent partners make dierent contributions, depending

    n their expertise and respective value-add. Several partners

    rovide technical support and guidance in project implementation

    and management. Other partners (mostly in government) pro

    a conducive policy environment, demarcating zones or pro

    implementation. Some partners support with the publicatio

    manuals on ecological mangrove. Others still help to establish

    tie-crab arms and construct the necessary acilities guard ho

    molting pens, eed areas, and pole areas.

    The main stakeholders in this partnership are:

    The College o Science and Fisheries Department o

    University o Eastern Philippines

    Bureau o Fisheries and Aquatic Resources

    Local Governments o the Municipalities o Lavezares

    Rosario

    Municipal ederations o shers and armers organization

    Lavezares, and their member organizations

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: TROWEL DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, Philippines

    13/13

    FURTHER REFERENCE

    Trowel Development Foundation website trowelsamar.weebly.com/

    Trowel Development Foundation Photo Story (Vimeo) vimeo.com/15746250

    Equator Initiative

    Environment and Energy GroupUnited Nations Development Programme (UNDP)

    304 East 45th Street, 6th Floor

    New York, NY 10017

    Tel: +1 646 781 4023

    www.equatorinitiative.org

    The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is the UNs global development network, advocating or change and

    necting countries to knowledge, experience and resources to help people build a better lie.

    The Equator Initiative brings together the United Nations, governments, civil society, businesses and grassroots organizati

    o recognize and advance local sustainable development solutions or people, nature and resilient communities.

    2012 by Equator Initiative

    All rights reserved

    Click the thumbnails below to read more case studies like this:

    http://vimeo.com/15746250http://vimeo.com/15746250http://vimeo.com/15746250http://vimeo.com/15746250http://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348160384.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348151578.pdf