case study 55 mw new rotor and overhaul - … · the turbine was shut down. ... around of new rotor...
TRANSCRIPT
Case Study55 MW new rotor and overhaul
• During start up in the
process of opening
extraction there was a
increase in vibration and
the turbine was shut down.
• On opening and inspection
rotor bend found
• After due diligence
customer decided to come
to us due to quick turn
around of new rotor
Status report
As inspected by TTL at customer site
• Customer was unable to define exactly the
reason for the damage.
• Customer had explored many repair options by
then including number of OEM’s
• Requested them to send the rotor to our works
for inspection and engineering
• Invited customer to visit our works and review
our capabilities which they did and based on the
same entrusted us with the work
Further inputs
Blade drawing for manufacture by reverse engineering
As received
Blade lock pin hole drill
Blading Rotor machining
Shroud machining High speed balancing
Process
• Confidence by interaction with our
Engineering team at Bangalore on
procedures.
• Complete engineering process flow
discussed and given confidence
• Completed the reverse engineering
without any liability to the customer
Challenges Confidence building • To complete the reverse engineering
• Ship in 6 months from order to enable
customer save Insurance costs of shut
down.
• Find special materials at short notice to
match original rotor specs
• Blades with pre twist and to establish the
process for the same.
Post completion process• Shipped out 10 days before the
deadline making us eligible fora large bonus as per agreement
• The quality parametersadhered to during manufactureof rotor built confidence andcustomer asked us to take upthe overhauling andcommissioning of turbine aswell
Customer speak Current Status
• Operating for the past 2years satisfactorily.
“We are pleased to confirm theturbine is operating is much betterthan we had expected and we areachieving 8% improvement over thedesign parameters”
WE CARE
Overhaul at site
Final checks and operationalised
Customer speak Current Status
• Operational for the pastyear.
The ….. Team thanks the Triveniteam of Lindon and Matharu forworking efficiently andunderstanding the system to ensurethat the turbine was commissionedright and we appreciate theconfidence with which they workedfor standards including thevibrations of the HP rotor and gave anumber of suggestions for improvingthe operations. We are happy withour decision to go with Triveni asour partner for the project andrecommend them for future projectstoo
WE CARE
Efficiency improvement projects completed
Triveni turnkey expertise services for retrofitting of turbo-visory systems likeGoverning machinery management & power management systems
Retrofitting of Turbo visory Systems
Integration of existing water operated control system with electronic governor and retrofitting of vibration monitoring system
Electronic Governor Retro fitment of a 37 MW Turbine
Retrofitted with hydro mechanical actuator
Customer Perception
ExpectationsOverall Triveni Competitor 1 Competitor 2
% Mean % Mean % Mean % Mean
Service support 30.5 5.74 28.0 5.77 28.9 5.66 26.9 5.14
Product Performance
16.7 5.79 16.4 5.77 25.6 6.03 23.1 5.67
Commercial Terms 11.7 5.70 13.2 5.73 8.3 5.40 3.8 5.00
Maintenance 11.4 5.78 11.0 5.84 13.2 5.63 15.4 5.75
Quality of turbine 9.2 5.96 10.1 6.02 4.1 5.60 15.4 5.50
Product features 8.5 5.89 9.2 5.96 9.1 5.36 7.7 6.00
Delivery/ Supply 5.5 5.62 5.9 5.51 3.3 6.50 3.8 7.00
Others 2.0 6.16 2.1 6.20 1.7 6.00 . .
Customer PerceptionMean scores on 7 point scale
% Relative impact onOverall
After sales support
Competition Customers
Competitor 1 Competitor 2Competitor
3
16.6 5.83 5.23 6.00
15.9 5.75 5.40 -
12.8 5.17 5.30 5.40
11.2 5.75 5.40 -
7.8 6.25 5.40 -
5.4 6.50 5.80 -
5.1 5.83 5.43 6.00
4.8 5.50 5.10 5.00
4.3 5.50 5.07 5.40
3.1 6.00 5.37 6.00
2.4 5.50 5.40 -
2.2 5.50 5.60 -
2.2 5.50 5.33 5.80
1.9 5.17 5.40 6.00
1.8 7.00 5.80 -
1.5 6.00 5.80 -
0.9 5.50 5.60 5.60
0.0 5.50 5.40 -
- 5.67 5.36 5.40
< 5.67 > 5.82Based on quartile analysis
Mean scores on 7 point scale
Customer Perception
” I will admit that there were times when I doubted whether we could pull this off, but we did succeed, and I amespecially pleased because this validated our decision to award the contract to Triveni in the face of some doubt”
The first TG set was supplied over 7 years ago and the last one in 2010. The 30 MW turbine was commissioned in 2010 and willcomplete 2 years of operations. The 30 MW TG which we have understood is among the first one supplied by Triveni isperforming well above our expectation with consumption of 3.87 kg/KWWe are pleased to inform you that we are happy about having taken the decision of going with Triveni Turbines. All turbines areperforming as per the performance curves provided”
”The overhauling job of STG and the auxiliaries was carried out under the guidance and supervision of Mr CK Taneja . Weappreciate Mr Taneja and whole TTL team for their relentless efforts in completing the overhauling job in time to our satisfaction”
We have in operation 4 TG sets supplied by you : 5 MW back pressure , 15 MW back pressure, 16 MWextraction condensing , 30 MW extraction condensing and very satisfied with the performance
“During this job M/s TTL have supplied & rectified turbine rotor, casing, diaphragm and its accessories. They have modified theoil piping & hydraulic governing system and after completion of all modification job, TG set commissioned successfullyPresently, TG set is running satisfactorily on load. We appreciate entire team of TTL for their best efforts in completing therefurbishment, overhauling & commissioning job in time to our satisfaction”
Thanks so much for organising Ashok to visit us. We were impressed with his knowledge and were able to get the turbineserviced adequately
“Hello Mr Matharu, how are you doing?Our "baby" is going well here, and I'm sending this email to you because the STG project won a prize, the "Award for
Excellence". As you worked with us during the commissioning, you received a certificate (Siva & Dipak as well)”
Customer Speak