Cattle Lot Beef Vs. Pasture Beef“The Debate”

By: Jordan Cress

The Debate

• There has been an ongoing debate on whether cattle lot beef or pasture beef is a better option.

• To make a decision on which one is for you, middle ground must be found.

Cattle Lots…

• 97% of beef in the market is grain-fed• It takes cattle that are fed corn about 12-15

months to make weight. Produced more frequently.

• Feed lot cattle are protected from predators• Any animal that is sick is removed from pens

and treated by the vet

Cattle Lots…(continued)

• Cattle lots are kept as clean as possible for the cow’s and worker’s health

• $2.50/lb• Average cattle lot is 25-80 acres depending on

how many cows there are

Feed lots are kept clean and animals are fed twice a day.

Pasture Beef…

• 3% of beef in the market is pasture fed• It takes cattle that are fed grass about 20-24

months to make weight • Higher nutritional value• Less fat• $9/lb• Average size of pasture needed is 2.5-30 acres

depending on the quality of land

Pasture raised cattle are kept on a vast array of grassland.

What They Agree On…

• Feed the world• Produce good quality meat • Keeping animals healthy• Reduce emissions from cattle farming• Feed cows forage• A lot of land is needed

Middle Grounds…

• Create a diet that is both forage and corn fed• Keep a safe environment that will protect

cattle from both predators and weather• Produce quality beef products for consumers

at a reasonable price• Composting manure to better environment

Sources…

• FAO.org• USDA.gov• About.com/Animal Rights • MagnumFeedyard.com• Cartoonstock.com

Questions?

Excellent Good Fair Needs Work

Context

Purpose: perceptive definition of central question, visual & verbal; scope is narrow, question consistent throughout

x

Substance

Development: sufficient summary & insight; slides focused & yet fully developed; mix of verbal & visual information

x

Sources: appropriate for topic, pertinent in placement, and accurately cited; quotations & data introduced correctly

x

Organization

Thesis: a thesis, early or late, that clearly states both sides of question & its mediation x

Introduction and Conclusion: overview of organization given at the beginning; conclusion sums up key points

x

Relationship: relationship of ideas clear; coherent; visual cues guide us through presentation x

Style

Visual Style: clear & to-the-point text on-screen; same for data on-screen; the verbal component fits the visual

x

Verbal & Sonic elements: engaging presence, name given, neither too colloquial nor too formal; no mumbling; any other use of sound (music, video) fitting

x

Conventions & Correctness free from data errors free from word errors (SP, etc.)

x

Response Team

Response: Questions in class & written responses demonstrate understanding; response helps enhance presentation (rated “Excellent,” “Good,” or “Fair.”)

x