cbc investigation: who killed lebanon's rafik hariri? -

8/8/2019 CBC Investigation: Who killed Lebanon's Rafik Hariri? - http://alshahed.free-forums.org

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cbc-investigation-who-killed-lebanons-rafik-hariri-httpalshahedfree-forumsorg 1/29

dg| ~k fcge oke~he~ !|yh he~hy

Wkxy phc~ahy bkoc~gke ac ek~ ihhe h~%sh~ phc~ahy bkoc~gke

OIO @bkicb Ahcnhy Eczg`c~gke

OIO%oc•

Ehp ehp nyk| nkpe fhex •

_|ky~ |ky~ nyk| nkpe fhex •

Ycngk ycngk nyk| nkpe fhex •

^Z ~z nyk| nkpe fhex •

Fw Yh`gke nyk| nkpe fhex •

Fkyh nyk| nkpe fhex •

Pc~oa nyk| nkpe fhex •

Bg~he nyk| nkpe fhex •

_hcyoa OIO%oc _xifg~ _hcyoa _xifg~ Sxhyw

_gè X|•

Bk` Ge•

Ihgyx~ fws~hywâh Acygyg gezhs~g`c~gke

Pgbb ~ah Ocecngce `h~ ags fce;Bcs~ X|nc~hn= Fkencw" Fcyoa 9" 9<<7 r 0=80 CF H^ Okffhe~s0 Yhokffhen?> Iw Ecabca Cwhn" OIO Ehps

Pahe jkyfhy Bhicehh |ygfh fgeg~hy Ycjgd Acygyg pc fxynhyhn ge 9<<8" Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh pcge ~ah ~pgbgà~ kj c bke` ocyhhy ge Ocecnc' mx~goh w~hf% Ah pc mx~ kzhy ~pk whcy cpcw jykfyh~gyhfhe~ cen ~ah k||ky~xeg~w ~k jgecbbw |hen ag ncw hemkwge` ~ah jyxg~ kj c bke` cenng~ge`xgahn ocyhhy%

Jky Ihbbhfcyh" ~ah Acygyg ccgec~gke pc mx~ c ehp ~kyw&c yhfk~h hzhe~ ~ac~ ac||hehn zhywjcy cpcw jykf K~~cpc" pahyh ah bgzhn c~ ~ah ~gfh%

Jky Bhiceke" akphzhy" ~ac~ ccgec~gke ke c |go~xyhsxh ykcn cbke` Ihgyx~' hcjyke~ pc~ycejkyfc~gzh cen cbfk~ geokeohgzcibh%

\c`h 3 kj 1OIO Ehp & Pkybn & Pgbb ~ah Ocecngce `h~ ag fce;

9>&Ekz&3<a~~|=++ppp%oio%oc+pkybn+~kyw+9<<7+<9+90+j&yjc&cwhn%a~fb

http://www.cbc.ca/world/story/2009/02/27/f




\yk&_wgce Bhicehsh `c~ahy ke Jhi%98" 9<<7 ~k sx||ky~ ~ah yhbhcsh kj ~ayhh fhe" cyyhs~hn ge 9<<8 jkbbkpge` ~ah csscssgec~gke kj Ycjgd

Acygyg% âh ~ayhh phyh jyhhn ke icgb mxs~ ncws ihjkyh ~ah ge~hyec~gkecb ~ygixecb" ahcnhn iwOcecngce |ykshox~ky Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh" pcs ~k ih`ge fcdge` g~s ocsh% !Fcafkxn ^cpgb+Csskogc~hn \yhss

âkxà ek~ hzhywkeh bgdhn agf" eky ag c||ykcoa ~k |hcohfcdge`" Acygyg pc" ge fcew yh|ho~"Bhiceke' ahcbhy" g~ |k~&ogzgb pcy ~cbgfce%

Pac~' fkyh" ~ah fxb~gigbbgkecgyh acn ~ah ih~ |yk~ho~gke fkehw okxbn ixw% Wh~ kfhakp"kfhkeh fcec`hn ~k dgbb agf xge` 3"1<< dgbk`ycf kj Ê^% Acygyg' hhfge`bw gezgeogibh okezkwpc bhj~ c oacyyhn pyhod% ^phe~w&~ayhh |hk|bh nghn cen ~ah okxyh kj ce he~gyh ec~gke' ag~kyw pcciyx|~bw cb~hyhn%

G acn mx~ cyygzhn ge Bhiceke c jhp fke~a hcybghy% Fw kpe c|cy~fhe~" fw jgy~ ge Bhiceke" pcocxà~ x| ge ~ah hq|bkgke cen icnbw ncfc`hn% G~ pc ce ciyx|~ ge~yknxo~gke ~k Bhiceke' zgkbhe~xenhyihbbw%

Kzhy ~ah okfge` whcy" ik~a Bhiceke cen G pkxbn ih ac|hn iw ~ah hzhe~ kj ~ac~ ncyd ncw% Cen~akxà ah ngne'~ dekp g~ c~ ~ah ~gfh" k pkxbn Ihbbhfcyh%

^kncw's Ihgyx~

Jc~&jkypcyn jkxy whcy= ~kk fcew ikfi" ccgec~gke" obcah" pcy" |yk~h~ cen g~&ge% G~'ekp fh ygnge` ge c |hhnge` cyfkxyhn ocy ~aykxà ~ah ekp jcfgbgcy ~yhh~ kj nkpe~kpe Ihgyx~" c~keh' ~aykp jykf pahyh Acygyg fh~ ag jc~h%

C ~ah okezkw ocyhhyhn nkpe ~ah pgnh ikxbhzcyn" g~' acyn ek~ ~k ~aged kj pac~ ac||hehn ~k

Acygyg cen mx~ akp hcgbw g~ okxbn ac||he c`cge%







XE gezhs~g`c~ky" ekp |ykshox~ky Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh!ygà~ pg~a Bhicehsh \ygfh Fgegs~hy Jkxcn _gegkyc% !_~h|acegh Mhe}hy+OIO

Ehq~ ~k fh pc ~ah fce ~ag okezkw pc |yk~ho~ge`= ~ah XE' oaghj gezh~g`c~ky kj ~ah Acygygfxynhy" Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh%

C Sxhiho ec~gzh" Ihbbhfcyh pc keoh ~ah bke`h~ hyzge` ahcn kj Ocecnc' Jhnhycb \ykhox~gke_hyzgoh% Ah yh~gyhn ge 9<<0 cen ~ahe" mx~ c jhp fke~a bc~hy" ah cooh|~hn ~ah XE mki%

Ekp ah g kfh~age` kj c fcydhn fce agfhbj ihocxh ~ahyh cyh |hk|bh kx~ ~ahyh pak nk ek~ pce~~k hh agf xoohhn ge jgenge` ~ah |hy|h~yc~ky%

)âkh oygfh phyh ek~ okffg~~hn iw àk~ ky iw Fcy~gce") Ihbbhfcyh cw" ag acen yh~ge` kec XE&gxh ibxh ahbfh~ cen jbcd mcodh~" koocgkecbbw ~cyge` kx~ kj ~ah ~ge~hn pgenkp%

)âhyh cyh co~xcb |hk|bh pak ngn ~ac~ cen ~akh |hk|bh cyh ~gbb cykxen% _k ~ahw'yh ek~ |cy~goxbcybwjce kj kxy%)

^cy`h~ge` okezkws

Cj~hy ~ah c~~cod ke Acygyg" ~ahyh aczh ihhe 9< fkyh ikfige` cen c~~hf|~hn ccgec~gke!hzhycb xoohjxb" cbb kj pagoa phyh cnnhn ~k ~ah gezh~g`c~ge` okffggke' jgbh% Ge ~ah zc~fcmkyg~w kj och ge pagoa gengzgnxcb phyh ~cy`h~hn" ~ahw phyh ke ~ah ykcn" kj~he ge okezkw%

Ihbbhfcyh' hoxyg~w ~hcf dekp ~ac~ cbb ~kk phbb% _k ag okezkw ge Bhiceke g hoken ~k ekeh= cpcyf kj ibcod _XZ' cookf|ceghn cen nygzhe iw cyfhn" phbb&~ycgehn XE hoxyg~w |hykeehb pakxh nhoh|~gzh ~co~go ~k ~aykp kjj ~ahgy jkh% \yhngo~cigbg~w g ~ahgy hehfw%

Cyygzge` ge hcybw 9<<1" Ihbbhfcyh g ~ah ~agyn gezh~g`c~ky ~k ahcn ~ah okffggke' pkyd% _geoh~ahe" ah ac nk``hnbw |xyxhn ~ah jkxy&whcy |ykih" iyge`ge` ehp fkfhe~xf ix~" xebgdh c~ bhc~keh kj ag |yhnhohky" bcy`hbw ~cwge` sxgh~%

_~gbb" ~ah 80&whcy&kbn pc cbyhcnw zhyw phbb dekpe ahyh ~ah fkfhe~ ah ~kxoahn nkpe c~ Ihgyx~'Ycjgd Acygyg Ge~hyec~gkecb Cgy|ky~" yhecfhn cj~hy Acygyg' nhc~a%

\c`h ? kj 1OIO Ehp & Pkybn & Pgbb ~ah Ocecngce `h~ ag fce;






)G~' ~yce`h% G'f ek~ xhn ~k ~ac~") ah ~hbb fh )G'f ek~ ahyh ~k ih dekpe" G nke'~ bgdh ~k ih dekpe%_k ekp ~k ih cbpcw cookf|ceghn iw hoxyg~w cen k ke" g~' kzhypahbfge` c~ ~gfh%)

_x||ky~hys kj _ccn Acygyg" bhcnhy kj ~ah ce~g&_wygce fcmkyg~w cen ske kj sbcge Bhicehsh |ygfh fgegs~hy Ycjgd Acygyg" pczh Jx~xyh

Fkzhfhe~ jbc`s cs ~ahw pcbd ge jyke~ kj pag~h cfixbceohs ocyywge` ~ah okjjges kj sbcge ce~g&_wygcebcpfcdhy Pcbgn Hgnk cen ags ske Dacbhn pak phyh dgbbhn iw ce hq|bksgke ge Ihgyx~ ge Mxeh 9<<0%!Axsshge Fcbbc+Csskogc~hn \yhss

Ehq~ s~c`h

Pahe Ihbbhfcyh nhognhn ~k `gzh x ce ge~hyzghp" fkyh ~ace c whcy cj~hy ah jgy~ cyygzhn" g~ pc ge~ah jgecb phhd kj ag cen ~ah okffggke' ~gfh ge Ihgyx~" cen c~ ~ah ~cgb hen kj fw kpecgèfhe~ ahyh%

C kj Fcyoa 3" ~ah okffggke pgbb ih ichn ge âh Ac`xh" pahyh ~ah XE' _|hogcb ^ygixecb jky

Bhiceke kjjgogcbbw ih`ge k|hyc~ge`%

Ihbbhfcyh ~ahe oace`h ykbh cen ihokfh ~ah |hogcb ~ygixecb' oaghj |ykhox~ky" pagoa fhce ah~xye ag c~~he~gke ~k ixgbnge` c och%

Ehg~ahy Ihbbhfcyh eky G dehp Acygyg% Wh~ ph'zh ik~a okfh ~k dekp k fxoa cikx~ agf" agbgdheh" ag jcfgbw" cen hzhe pac~ ah bkkdhn bgdh ge nhc~a%

Acygyg' bh`cow „ ik~a `kkn cen icn „ g ke jxbb ng|bcw ke ~ah ~yhh~ ~ah ~pk kj x ekp ~yczhb c~agà |hhn= jykf ~ah yhjxyigahn @ycen _hycgb !~ah |ygfh fgeg~hy' kjjgoh ~k ~ah yhixgb~nkpe~kpe cen ~ah ibxh&nkfhn" kyec~h fksxh ah pc aczge` ixgb~ mx~ ihjkyh ah nghn%

)!Acygyg' ~ah yhcke paw ph'yh ahyh") Ihbbhfcyh yhjbho~% )Ix~ ke ~ah k~ahy acen" ph aczh ~k dhh|c okbn ahcn" ek~ ~k jcbb ge~k he~gfhe~cbg~w% Ph'yh ahyh ~k nk c mki cen ph aczh ~k ~cw jkoxhn%)

Xe~gb Acygyg' nhc~a" G acn ek~ ihhe jkoxhn ke Bhiceke' okezkbx~hn |kbg~gocb pkybn" he`ykhnge~hcn ge pac~ pc ac||hege` ge Icàncn cen _cxng Cycigc% âh hq|bkgke mx~ fh~yh jykf fwehp akfh jkyohn fh ~k oace`h ~ac~ fgenh~ ge c axyyw%

\c`h > kj 1OIO Ehp & Pkybn & Pgbb ~ah Ocecngce `h~ ag fce;






Ycjgd Acygyg's jxehycb ge Jhiyxcyw 9<<8% !Csskogc~hn \yhss

C obhce sbc~h

Ihbbhfcyh' geg~gcb oxykyw dekpbhn`h cikx~ Bhiceke" Acygyg cen ~ah ogyoxf~ceoh kj ~ahccgec~gke pc co~xcbbw c |bx% Pahe ah phe~ ~k XE ahcnsxcy~hy ge Ehp Wkyd ge 9<<0 ~kngox ~ah mki" ek~ dekpge` fxoa pc ce gengoc~gke ~ac~ ah ocfh ~k ~ah ~cd pg~a ek igch%

)âh fkyh ph ~cbdhn cikx~ ~ah och" G ~akxà~ g~ pc jcogec~ge` Cj~hy c jhp akxy kj ngoxgke" Gpc akkdhn%)

Ah' ~gbb akkdhn% Cen nh|g~h cbb ~ah |kbg~gocb |yhxyh cen ki~cobh kj pkydge` ge Bhiceke"Ihbbhfcyh hhf sxg~h nh~hyfgehn ~k jgen ~ah dgbbhy cen ihbghzh ah pgbb xoohhn%

)âh yhcke G cooh|~hn !~ah mki g ~ac~ G ~aged G oce oke~ygix~h") ah cw% )Ph'yh ahyh ~k |x~ ce hen

~k gf|xeg~w" ~k ~hbb |hk|bh ~ac~ ~age` oce ih ngjjhyhe~% Gj wkx okffg~ c oygfh" oaceoh cyh wkx pgbbih gnhe~gjghn" wkx'bb ih |ykhox~hn" |hk|bh pgbb ih jkxen `xgb~w%)

Cj~hy cbb ~ac~' ac||hehn ahyh kzhy ~ah |c~ jkxy whcy „ c phbb c cbb ~ac~' ac||hehn ihjkyh „ fcew Bhicehh |hk|bh aczh bk~ ak|h%

Fcew ahyh oceek~ okeohgzh kj cewkeh ihge` ahbn cookxe~cibh jky fxynhyge` c |kbg~gogce" ckxyecbg~ ky hzhe ce kyngecyw |hyke% âhw nke'~ ihbghzh ~ac~ kjjgogcb c~ ~ah XE gezh~g`c~ge`

okffggke oce ih gffxeh ~k |kbg~gocb |yhxyh ky ~ah bxyh kj c iygih%

C Ihbbhfcyh |yh|cyhn ~k fkzh ke ~k ~ah mki kj oaghj |ykhox~ky ge ~ah Acygyg och" ah geg~ g~ g|kgibh ~k oace`h Bhicehh fgen cen ~k nk ag mki gyyh|ho~gzh kj ~ah |kbg~gocb xenhyoxyyhe~%

)Gj G okxbn iyge` c bg~~bh ig~ kj pac~ ph aczh ge Ocecnc ahyh" G pkxbn aczh fcnh c ax`hngjjhyheoh") ah cw%

Cnghx Ihgyx~

Ge hcybw Jhiyxcyw" Ihbbhfcyh cbbkphn x ce xe|yhohnhe~hn zgg~ ~k ~ah gezh~g`c~ge` okffggke'ahcnsxcy~hy ~k hh jgy~ acen akp ah cen nk}he kj k~ahy gezh~g`c~ky pkydhn cen bgzhn= gegkbc~gke" jcy cpcw jykf jcfgbw cen xenhy ~ayhc~%

Ah cen G cyh ~cenge` c~ ~ah hn`h kj ~ah fkxe~cge yhky~ okf|kxen" c zgy~xcb jky~yh"

oke~hf|bc~ge` Ihgyx~ jykf c ng~ceoh% Ah |kge~ kx~ ig~ kj ~ah oc|g~cb ~ac~ ah pgbb |ykicibw ehzhy`h~ ~k dekp%







Nh|g~h ~ah hzhyhbw yh~ygo~hn bgjh ahyh" ~ah ~ayhc~ kj ccgec~gke cen ~ah icyyc`h kj cooxc~gkecen oyg~gogf oke~ce~bw bhzhbbhn c~ agf" Ihbbhfcyh g okejbgo~hn cikx~ bhczge`%

)Keh kj fw ig``h~ yh`yh~ g ek~ ~k ih cibh ~k `k nkpe~kpe" ~k fhh~ |hk|bh" ~k ~cbd ~k ~ahf% Gokxbn bhcye k fxoa") ah cw pg~jxbbw%

)âg pgbb okfh ~k ce hen aky~bw% Hzhywiknw ge ~ah okffggke pgbb fg Bhiceke% G~' xoa c

ihcx~gjxb okxe~yw% \hk|bh cyh k ak|g~cibh4 ~ah Fgnnbh Hc~ g k ygoa% Ph'bb fg g~ jky xyh%)

Ge hzhycb ge~hyzghp kzhy ~pk ncw" Ihbbhfcyh pc ac||w ~k ngox ~ah oacbbhe`h ah jcoh cen"ge `hehycb ~hyf" akp ~ah gezh~g`c~gke g |ykohhnge`% Ix~ ah yhjxhn ~k |ykzgnh cew ~ahkygh kepak ngn g~" ky paw" ky pah~ahy ah pc hzhe obkh ~k ihge` cibh ~k ecfh ecfh%

âg ac ihhe ag ~yc~h`w jykf ~ah ~cy~" ~k hexyh ~ac~ ag gezh~g`c~gke okxbn ~cen x| ~k oyx~gew%

Ah cbk pkxbne'~ |hoxbc~h ke pahe ah pkxbn co~xcbbw fcdh ag jgenge` |xibgo%

C G ~cy~ fw jgj~a whcy ge Bhiceke" g~ pkxbn aczh ihhe `yhc~ ~k aczh ~ac~ obkxyh% âh ~xyixbheoh

kj ~ah whcy G |he~ ahyh oace`hn fw bgjh%

G aczh okfh ~k dekp Bhiceke ge~gfc~hbw% Ix~ whcy ke G cf ~gbb okejkxenhn c ~k paw Acygygnghn" paw Bhicehh akxbn xjjhy k fxoa zgkbheoh kzhy cen kzhy c`cge" whcy cj~hy ~ahw ~akxà~~ahgy pcy phyh jgecbbw kzhy%

Ihbbhfcyh ehzhy `k~ ~k dekp Bhiceke ~ah pcw ah pkxbn aczh bgdhn% Ix~ ah pcbd cpcw pg~a pac~fcw ih ~ah fk~ ge~gfc~h dekpbhn`h czcgbcibh „ czh jky ~ah |hy|h~yc~ky ~ahfhbzh „ kj pakdgbbhn Acygyg cen akp4 gejkyfc~gke ~ac~ g c~ ~ah ahcy~ kj pac~ phe~ pyke` ge Bhiceke cen pac~oke~gexh ~k `k pyke` geoh Acygyg nghn%

Ihbbhfcyh' bgjh" ~kk" ac ihhe ~ycejkyfhn% Nce`hy g ekp ag oke~ce~ okf|cegke% Yh~gyhfhe~

ekp hhf c bke` pcw ge ~ah jx~xyh%

Bhj~ ihagen" Bhiceke pcg~ jky cephy%

•

\k~ c okffhe~0 Okffhe~ aczh ihhe |k~hn

•

Yhokffhen ~ag ~kyw?>\hk|bh aczh yhokffhenhn ~ag ~kyw

_~kyw okffhe~s !0

_ky~= Fk~ yhohe~ r Jgy~ ~k bc~ r C`yhhn Ygoacyn\hcyoh pyk~h=\k~hn 9<<7+<?+<:c~ :=87 \F H^ncfe`yxf|w pyk~h=\k~hn 9<<7+<?+<?c~ 39=>7 CF H^G nk c`yhh ~ac~ ~ah Xeg~hn _~c~h g c fcmky |keky kj ~hyykygf ge ~ah ~agyn pkybn" ge jco~ ~ahw cyh ihagen c bk~ kj g~ ~aykxà ~ah OGCcen Gychb% âh jco~ g ~ah Gbfcgo ^hyykyg~ cyh jcy pkyh

666

Fgà~ wkxy oke~he~gke ~ac~ Gbcfgo ~hyykyg~ cyh jcy pkyh aczh kfh~age` ~k nk pg~a ~ah pcw ~ahgyco~gke cyh okzhyhn;

\c`h : kj 1OIO Ehp & Pkybn & Pgbb ~ah Ocecngce `h~ ag fce;






C ykodh~ jgyhn kx~ kj Gychb g cbfk~ cbpcw oacyco~hyghn c c ~hyykyg~ c~~cod" cen ycyhbw geobxnhcew~age` cikx~ pac~ okxbn aczh fk~gzc~hn ~akh yh|kegibh% Ce cgy ~ygdh ge~k @c}c xxcbbwgeobxnh c mx~gjgoc~gke jky ~ah c~~cod%

Pahe \cbh~gegce oc|~xyhn _acbg~" g~ pc ~hyfhn c dgnec||ge`" ix~ pahe ~ah GNJ oc|~xyh cfhfihy kj Acfc" g~ g ~hyfhn ce cyyh~%

Gj ~ah \cbh~gegce phyh ~k dgbb kfh fhfihy kj ~ah Gychbg `kzhyefhe~" g~ pkxbn ih ocbbhn ceccgec~gke cen ek x``h~gke ~ac~ ~ah zgo~gf nhhyzhn ~k ngh% Pahe ~ah GNJ dgbbhn fhfihy kj ~ah @c}c `kzhyefhe~" g~ pc c fxoa ngjjhyhe~ |ge

Wkx fgà~ pce~ ~k ~aged cikx~ akp ~ah okzhyc`h ac|h wkxy k|gegke%

9•

<•

9C`yhh <Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh

Ygoacyn\hcyoh pyk~h=\k~hn 9<<7+<?+<:c~ :=>9 \F H^G~ nkhe'~ yhcbbw fc~~hy akp xeigchn cen jcgy Nceghb Ihbbfcyh g" gj ~ahgezh~g`c~gke g ek~% Ge fcew kj ~ah pyke`jxb okezgo~gke och G'zh hhe" ~ah Mxn`h !cen mxyw gj |yhhe~ ocfh ~k yhckecibh zhyngo~ ichn ke pac~ hzgnheoh ~ahw `k~ ~k hh% Akphzhy" gj kfhhzgnheoh g hg~ahy |cgzhbw !bhcn ek~ jkbbkphn x|" pg~ehh ek~ sxh~gkehn" bgeh kj gesxgywgèkyhn" fk~gzh ek~ hqcfgehn ky co~gzhbw !ek~h yhpyg~~he" ~age` ek~ ngobkhn" x|ho~pg~ehh `gzhe jxbb oyhngigbg~w" oyhngibh pg~ehh gezh~g`c~hn cen yh&ge~hyzghphn xe~gb ~ahw ocehg~ahy ih ngoyhng~hn" oace`h ~ahgy ~kyw" ky cw kfh~age` fgeky ~ac~ oke~ycngo~ pac~ ~ahw|yhzgkxbw ~c~hn" ~ahe |yhxyhn ke ~ah cooxycow kj ~ahgy yhocbb" ~ah gezh~g`c~ky `h~ ~k pyg~h ~ahzhyngo~ ichn ke ~ahgy igc% G~ nkhe'~ ~cdh ce co~gzh oke|gycow" mx~ keh ky ~pk nh~hyfgehngengzgnxcb pak |yhxyh ~ah yh~ pak fcw ih yhbxo~ce~ ~k )ykod ~ah ikc~)%

Gj ~cdh ce akeh~ gezh~g`c~gke c fxoa c ce akeh~ okxy~ ~k hh mx~goh nkeh%

9•

<•

9C`yhh <Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh@yhhdKy~aknkqBhicehsh pyk~h=\k~hn 9<<7+<?+<?c~ ?=<: \F HÂhw ncfe`yxf|w" ek~ hzhywkeh ge Bhiceke g Fxbgf% Fcwih wkx akxbn nk kfhyhhcyoa cen oahod ~ah OGC jco~ ikkd% Fcwih @kk`bh;

39•

3•

39C`yhh 3Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh ncfe`yxf|w pyk~h=\k~hn 9<<7+<?+<?c~ 39=>7 CF H^Paw g g~ ek fc~~hy pac~ ~ah |ykibhf" ph aczh |hk|bh pak oce kebw |kge~ ~kCfhygoc ky Gychb; G nk c`yhh ~ac~ ~ah Xeg~hn _~c~h g c fcmky |keky kj ~hyykygf ge ~ah ~agyn pkybn" ge jco~ ~ahw cyh ihagen c bk~ kj g~ ~aykxà ~ah OGCcen Gychb% âh jco~ g ~ah Gbfcgo ^hyykyg~ cyh jcy pkyh" ~ah ek~ kebw aczh~ahgy |kbg~go ~ahw cyh ikxen x| ge jxencfhe~cbg~ yhbg`gke ~ac~ ge jco~ ng~ky~ ~ah jcg~a fk~Fxbgf aczh%âh |ykibhf c G hh g~ g ~ag" ~ah Fxbgf pkybn" g icgocbbw ~ygicb ge ec~xyh cen ~ah ph~ gj

kogh~cb% Ph oceek~ hqg~ ~k`h~ahy jky cew bhe`~a kj ~gfh cen~ah ~pk zggke kj kogh~w pgbb xb~gfc~hbw hen x| ge hygkx okejbgo~ ih~phhe~ah yh`gke kj ~ah pkybn ge ~ah ek~ ~kk ng~ce~ jx~xyh%







0 •

99•

0 C`yhh 99Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh \cxb C% pyk~h=\k~hn 9<<7+<?+<9c~ 9=>3 \F H^cjcng9<< pyk~h=)Wkx dekp" Gychbg cen ~ah X_ okffg~~hn ~ah fk~ oygfh cen ccgec~gke ge ~ah pkybn" pawcyh ~ahw ek~ ihge` gezh~g`c~hn cen |ykhox~hn;)&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

âh Bhicehh aczh xjjhyhn c bk~ cen ~ahw nhhyzh mx~goh% âg ac ek~age` ~k nk pg~a ~ahCfhygoce ky ~ah Gychbg% âhyh g ek yhcke ~k ihbghzh ~ac~ Fy Ihbbfcyh g igchn keh pcw kycek~ahy%

?8•

3<•

?8C`yhh 3<Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh

\yhzgkx•

3•

9•

Ehq~•

\ks~ wkxy okffhe~

Ek~h= âh OIO nkh ek~ ehohcygbw henkyh cew kj ~ah zghp |k~hn% Iw xifg~~ge` wkxyokffhe~" wkx codekpbhn`h ~ac~ OIO ac ~ah ygà~ ~k yh|yknxoh" iykcnoc~ cen |xibgog}h ~akhokffhe~ ky cew |cy~ ~ahyhkj ge cew fceehy pac~khzhy% \bhch ek~h ~ac~ okffhe~ cyh |yh&

fknhyc~hn+yhzghphn cen |xibgahn cookynge` ~k kxy xifggke ̀ xgnhbgeh%

Wkx fx~ ih bk``hn ge ~k bhczh c okffhe~% Bk` ge r _gè x|Okffhe~=

\ks~\ks~ _xifggke |kbgow







_\HOGCB YH\KYÊhgb Fconkecbn

OIO Gezhs~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke'sYcjgd Acygyg;Bcs~ X|nc~hn= _xencw" Ekzhfihy 93" 9<3< r 3<=8> \F H^ Okffhe~s><3Yhokffhen:<: Iw Ehgb Fconkecbn OIO Ehps

Obgod ahyh ~k |bcw \cy~ 9 kj ~ah nkoxfhe~cyw r Yh|bcw \cy~ 3

G~ pcse'~ xe~gb bc~h 9<<0 ~ac~ ~ah cpdpcynbw ~g~bhn XE Ge~hyec~gkecb Genh|henhe~ Gezh~g`c~gkeOkffggke co~xcbbw `k~ cykxen ~k kfh hygkx gezh~g`c~ge`%

Iw ~ahe" ehcybw ~ayhh whcy acn |chn geoh ~ah |ho~coxbcy |xibgo fxynhy kj Bhiceke' jkyfhy|ygfh fgeg~hy Ycjgd Acygyg%

Acygyg" ~ah ixgbnhy% âh igbbgkecgyh ~wokke pak'n yhobcgfhn Ihgyx~' cyoag~ho~xycb ahyg~c`h jykf ~ah

ac~~hyhn og~woc|h kj c ogzgb pcy cen fcnh g~ ag fggke ~k yh~kyh Bhiceke' fhyoce~gbhbhcnhyag|%

Acygyg" ~ah ec~gkecbg~ pak'n acn ~ah okxyc`h ~k ~cen c`cge~ _wygc" Bhiceke' bke`~gfh koox|ghy4cen ge ag ncw pc ~ah fk~ gf|ky~ce~ yhjkyfhy ge ~ah Fgnnbh Hc~%

âh fcgzh nh~kec~gke ~ac~ dgbbhn agf ke Jhi% 3>" 9<<8 xebhcahn jkyoh ek keh dehp phyh~ahyh% Cbb kj Bhiceke hhfhn ~k ygh x| ge ~ah fxynhy' cj~hyfc~a" jxygkxbw |kge~ge` c~ ~ahokxe~yw' _wygce kzhybkyn%







Pak dgbbhn Ycjgd Acygyg; Ags csscssgec~gkege Jhiyxcyw 9<<8 ykodhn ~ah |kphy cyyce`hfhe~s ge ~ah Fgnnbh Hcs~ cen ~xyehn agf ge~k cekzhycyoage` swfikb kj hzhyw~age` ~ac~ pcs pyke` ge Bhiceke% !Fkacfhn C}cdgy+Yhx~hys

âh ek~ xeyhckecibh cxf|~gke pc ~ac~ Acygyg acn nghn jky k||kge` Ncfcox%

Bhiceke' jxyw sxgodbw cookf|bgahn pac~ ~ah ccgec~hn bhcnhy acn jcgbhn ~k coaghzh ge agbgjh~gfh%

âh fxynhy `czh ygh ~k ~ah k&ocbbhn Ohncy Yhzkbx~gke" c ycyh Bhicehh |kbg~gocb okehex%_wygc" okphn iw ~ah okbbho~gzh ce`hy" pg~anyhp g~ ~ykk|%

C~ ~ah XE" Jyceoh cen ~ah X%_% |xahn ~ah _hoxyg~w Okxeogb ge~k ng|c~oage` c |hogcbgezh~g`c~gzh okffggke%

Jky c ~gfh" g~ co~xcbbw hhfhn ~ac~ Bhiceke pc fkzge` ~kpcyn ~ah yxbh kj bcp cen ~yxhnhfkoycow%

Ix~" iw ~ah hen kj 9<<0" cbb ~ac~ acn hiihn% âh dgbbhy yhfcgehn xeocxà~% _wygc pc `ycnxcbbwyhchy~ge` g~ gejbxheoh% Cen ccgec~gke kj k~ahy |ykfgehe~ Bhicehh oke~gexhn%

Ge ~ah Pag~h Akxh" hegky cnfgeg~yc~gke kjjgogcb ih`ce ~k okeobxnh ~ac~ ~ah XE' jcfkx obcwjhh~ phyh |bknnge` ~kpcyn ek~age`%

G~ ~xyehn kx~ ~ahw phyh ygà~%

C fke~a&bke` OIO gezh~g`c~gke" yhbwge` ke ge~hyzghp pg~a fxb~g|bh kxyoh jykf gegnh ~ah XEgesxgyw cen kfh kj ~ah okffggke' kpe yhokyn" jkxen hqcf|bh kj ~gfgng~w" ixyhcxoyc~gogehy~gc cen geokf|h~heoh ikynhyge` ke `yk eh`bg`heoh%

\c`h ? kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






Cfke` k~ahy ~age`" OIO Ehp ac bhcyehn ~ac~=

Hzgnheoh `c~ahyhn iw Bhicehh |kbgoh cen" fxoa bc~hy" ~ah XE" |kge~ kzhypahbfge`bw ~k~ah jco~ ~ac~ ~ah ccge phyh jykf Ah}ikbbca" ~ah fgbg~ce~ \cy~w kj @kn ~ac~ g bcy`hbw|kekyhn iw _wygc cen Gyce% OIO Ehp ac ki~cgehn ohbb|akeh cen k~ahy~hbhokffxegoc~gke hzgnheoh ~ac~ g c~ ~ah okyh kj ~ah och%

•

XE gezh~g`c~ky ocfh ~k ihbghzh ~ahgy gesxgyw pc |heh~yc~hn hcybw iw Ah}ikbbca cen ~ac~~ac~ ~ah okffggke' bcq hoxyg~w bgdhbw bhn ~k ~ah fxynhy kj c wkxe`" nhngoc~hn Bhicehh|kbgohfce pak acn bcy`hbw oycodhn ~ah och ke ag kpe cen pc ok&k|hyc~ge` pg~a ~ahge~hyec~gkecb gesxgyw%

•

XE okffggke gegnhy cbk x|ho~hn Acygyg' kpe oaghj kj |yk~kokb c~ ~ah ~gfh" c fcepak ekp ahcn Bhiceke' ge~hbbg`heoh hyzgoh" kj okbbxnge` pg~a Ah}ikbbca% Ix~ ~akhx|gogke" bcgn kx~ ge ce hq~hegzh ge~hyecb fhfk" phyh ek~ |xyxhn" icgocbbw jkyng|bkfc~go yhcke%

•

|cy~ 3 r |cy~ 9 r |cy~ ? r |cy~ >

Ge g~ jgy~ fke~a" ~ah XE gesxgyw acn co~xcbbw c||hcyhn |ykfgge`% ^ah jgy~ okffggkehy" c@hyfce mxn`h ecfhn Nh~bhz Fhabg" sxgodbw nhbgzhyhn c ibg~hyge` yh|ky~ x``h~ge` _wygc acnkynhyhn" gj ek~ co~xcbbw ocyyghn kx~" ~ah ag~%

Xe|hogjghn c`he~" Fhabg oke~henhn" acn nkeh ~ah nhhn%

Ix~ Fhabg' xoohky" c Ihb`gce |ykhox~ky ecfhn _hy`h Iycffhy~}" hhfhn ~k ih fkyhge~hyh~hn ge czkgnge` oke~ykzhyw ~ace ge |xyxge` cew ky~ kj hygkx gezh~g`c~gke" c~ bhc~cookynge` ~k |hk|bh pak pkydhn jky agf%

Nh~bhz Fhabgs" ~ah @hyfce mxn`h pak pcs~ah XE okffgssgke's jgys~ oaghj gezhs~g`c~ky" akbns x| c |ak~k ge Mxeh 9<<8 kj c pag~h Fg~sxigsag~yxod" bgdh ~ah keh ~ac~ akxshn ~ah 3"<<< d` ikfi ~ac~ dgbbhn Acygyg% !Mcfcb _cgng+Yhx~hys

Xenhy ag bhcnhyag|" ~ah okffggke |he~ fk~ kj g~ ~gfh oacge` pac~ ~xyehn kx~ ~k ih jcbhbhcn cen ng|ykzge` pgbn oke|gycow ~ahkygh%

^ac~ ge'~ ~k cw ~ah okffggke ngne'~ aczh kfh `kkn gezh~g`c~ky% G~ ngn% Ge jco~" g~ acn cacenjxb kj ~ah ih~ ~ac~ Ph~hye |kbgoh c`heogh acn ~k kjjhy%

Ix~ Iycffhy~} okxbn ek~ ih |hyxcnhn ~k cx~akyg}h ~ah keh ~hoaegsxh ~ac~ ~akh gezh~g`c~ky

pce~hn cikzh cbb ~k nh|bkw= ~hbhokffxegoc~gke cecbwg" |ykicibw ~ah ge`bh fk~ gf|ky~ce~ge~hbbg`heoh&`c~ahyge` ~kkb ge fknhye ~gfh%

\c`h > kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






^hbhokffxegoc~gke cecbw~ xh |kphyjxb okf|x~hy cen agàbw k|ag~goc~hn kj~pcyh ~k gj~~aykxà fgbbgke kj |akeh ocbb" hhdge` |c~~hye" yhjhyheoge` cen oyk&yhjhyheoge`" gnhe~gjwgeèh~pkyd cen ckogc~gke%

\kbgoh jkyoh ocbb g~ )~hbhokff%) _|w c`heogh ocbb g~ )g`ge~%) G~ bhcn ~k okezgo~gke ge okxy~ cenfggbh ~ygdh ge |bcoh bgdh Cjàceg~ce cen Whfhe%

Xeihbghzcibw" ~akxà" ~ah XE okffggke ge Bhiceke ngn ek ~hbhokf cecbwg c~ cbb jky fk~ kj g~ jgy~ ~ayhh whcy kj hqg~heoh% G~ pce'~ xe~gb Iycffhy~} pc ehcyge` ~ah hen kj ag ~hyf ~ac~ keh|cy~goxbcybw nk``hn nh~ho~gzh |yknnhn agf ge~k bh~~ge` ~ah gesxgyw ~cy~ hqcfgege` |akeh yhokyn%

âh iyhcd~aykxà

C~ ~ac~ |kge~" ge Ko~kihy kj 9<<0" ~age` ih`ce fkzge` jc~% Okffggke ~cjj co~xcbbw fcec`hn~k ki~cge ~ah yhokyn kj hzhyw ge`bh |akeh ocbb fcnh ge Bhiceke ~ah whcy kj Acygyg' fxynhy „ c~xeege` cfkxe~ kj nc~c „ cen iykxà~ ge c Iyg~ga jgyf ocbbhn J^_ ~k ocyyw kx~ ~ah |hogcbg}hncecbwg%

Jkbbkp ~ah eh~pkyd% Gezh~g`c~ky oyhc~hn c oacy~ ~ac~ akphn ~ah hzhy hq|cenge` okeeho~gkeih~phhe ~ah x|ho~hn ag~ ~hcf cen k~ahy ohbb|akeh ocyyghy% !K|he ge c h|cyc~h pgenkp%

XE obhyd pkydhn ncw cen egà~ ge|x~~ge` nc~c ge~k c |yk`ycf ocbbhn GIch% âhe" ge Nhohfihy" c|hogcbg~ jykf J^_ ih`ce hqcfgege` pac~ ~ah okf|x~hy pc |g~~ge` kx~%

Pg~age ~pk ncw" ah ocbbhn ~ah XE gezh~g`c~ky ~k`h~ahy% Ah acn gnhe~gjghn c fcbb eh~pkyd kj fkigbh |akeh" hgà~ ge cbb" ~ac~ acn ihhe acnkpge` Acygyg ge ~ah phhd |ygky ~k ag nhc~a%

G~ pc ~ah ge`bh ig``h~ iyhcd~aykxà ~ah okffggke acn cookf|bgahn geoh g~ jkyfc~gke „ )hcy~a&ac~~hyge`") ge ~ah pkyn kj keh kj ~ah |hk|bh ge ~ah ykkf ~ah ncw ~ah eh~pkyd pc

gnhe~gjghn%

Pac~ ~ah Iyg~ga cecbw~ akphn ~ahf pc ek~age` bh ~ace ~ah ag~ sxcn ~ac~ acn ocyyghn kx~ ~ahfxynhy" ky c~ bhc~ ~ah |akeh ~ahw'n ihhe ocyywge` c~ ~ah ~gfh%

Jky ~ah jgy~ ~gfh" okffggke gezh~g`c~ky phyh ~cyge` c~ ~ahgy sxcyyw% âh ~ykxibh pc" ~ah~ycoh phyh ekp ehcybw ~ayhh whcy kbn" bke` |c~ ~ah )`kbnhe akxy) jky acyzh~ge` ~ah ih~ obxh%

_~gbb" g~ pc kfh~age`% Cen pahe ~ah gezh~g`c~ky ih`ce ~ahgy nxh ngbg`heoh" nkxibh&oahodge`~ahgy pkyd" ~ahyh pc cek~ahy yhzhbc~gke" ~ag keh hzhe fkyh hcy~a&ac~~hyge`%

_kfhkeh ng``ge` ~akxà ~ah okffggke' yhokyn ~xyehn x| c yh|ky~ jykf c fgn&ycedge`

Bhicehh |kbgohfce ~ac~ acn ihhe he~ kzhy ~k ~ah XE kjjgoh ehcybw c whcy cen c acbj hcybghy" ge~ah jgy~ fke~a kj 9<<:%







\yknxohy's ibk`

Yhcn ~ah OIO' Bwee Ixy`h' |ghoh ke ~ah oacbbhe`h kj okejgnhe~gcb kxyoh%

Ek~ kebw acn ~ah |kbgohfce gnhe~gjghn pac~ ~ah XE pkxbn hzhe~xcbbw nxi ~ah )yhn eh~pkyd) „ ~ahag~ ~hcf „ ah acn ngokzhyhn fxoa fkyh% Ah acn jkxen ~ah eh~pkyd ihagen ~ah eh~pkyd%

Ge jco~" ah'n xeokzhyhn c okf|bhq" ngog|bgehn |bk~ ~ac~ acn ihhe c~ bhc~ c whcy ge ~ah |bceege`"cen ah acn cbyhcnw sxh~gkehn x|ho~%

Pac~' fkyh" hzhyw~age` ah'n ngokzhyhn |kge~hn ~k keh oxb|yg~= Ah}ikbbca" ~ah \cy~w kj @kn%

Cbb kj ~ag pc ge ~ah |kbgohfce' yh|ky~" pagoa ah acn nx~gjxbbw he~ ~k ~ah XE kjjgogcb pg~apakf ah pc x||khn ~k ih |cy~ehyge`%

Cen ~ah XE okffggke acn |ykf|~bw bk~ g~%

|cy~ 3 r |cy~ 9 r |cy~ ? r |cy~ >

Ihjkyh ag zgkbhe~ nhc~a ge 9<<1" Pgcf Hgn pc ce xexxcb jg`xyh ge ~ah fxydw" kj~he okyyx|~pkybn kj Cyci |kbgoge`%

Ah acn ehzhy co~xcbbw pce~hn ~k ih c |kbgohfce" ky ce ge~hbbg`heoh kjjgohy% Ge cx~akyg~cygce Cycikogh~w" ah acn ek ge~hyh~ ge ihokfge` ce cx~akyg~w jg`xyh% Cen wh~" ah'n acn ek oakgoh%

Bhicehsh |kbgohfhe iyhcd nkpe c~ ~ah jxehycb kj Oc|~% Pgsscf Hgn" ?3" keh kj ~ah okxe~yw's ~k| ~hyykygsf gezhs~g`c~kys% Hgn pcsdgbbhn iw c ocy ikfi ke Mce% 98" 9<<1" cbke` pg~a ags iknw`xcyn cen ~ayhh k~ahys" saky~bw cj~hy

c`yhhge` ~k ahb| XE gezhs~g`c~kys% !Axsshge Fcbbc+Csskogc~hn \yhss

\c`h : kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;

9>&Ekz&3<a~~|=++ppp%oio%oc+pkybn+~kyw+9<3<+33+37+j &yjc&fconkecbn&bhiceke&acygyg%a~fb





Pahe ah pc nkge` ag fgbg~cyw hyzgoh ge ~ah 377<" ~ah G_J" Bhiceke' cbb&heokf|cge`hoxyg~w jkyoh" ek~gohn Hgn' nh`yhh ge okf|x~hy he`gehhyge`%

âh hoxyg~w hyzgoh pc ~ahe ~ywge` ~k ixgbn ce gejkyfc~gke ~hoaekbk`w nh|cy~fhe~% Cen ~ac~ pc~ac~%

)Ah pc c |c~ygk~") cw ag jc~ahy Fcafkxn" g~~ge` ge ~ah bgzge` ykkf kj ~ah jcfgbw akfh ge Nhgy

Cffcy" ke ~ah kx~dgy~ kj ^yg|kbg%

âh ohe~hy|ghoh kj ~ah ykkf g" ge ~ah Cyci pcw" c aygeh ~k ~ahgy ke% âh wkxe` fce' ge~heh"oaghbbhn okxe~heceoh ~cyh icod c~ zgg~ky kzhy okffhenc~gke cen ~h~gfkegcb%

Ag fk~ahy _cfgyc" c |go~xyh kj Gbcfgo ngèg~w" g c yhbg`gkx |hyke% G~ ahb| pg~a ~ah `yghj%

âh yh~ kj ahy jcfgbw g ek~ |cy~goxbcybw kihyzce~% Ix~ ~ahw cbb xenhy~cen ~ah czc`h yhcbg~gh kj ~ahgy okxe~yw cen akp ~akh yhcbg~gh obcahn pg~a Hgn' xewghbnge` |xyxg~ kj kfh kj ~ah fk~nce`hykx |hk|bh ge ~ah pkybn%

Iw ~ah ~gfh Acygyg pc dgbbhn ge 9<<8" Hgn pc c oc|~cge ge ~ah G_J% Ag ik" B~%&Okb% _cfhy_ahacnha" iykxà~ agf ge~k ~ah gezh~g`c~gke%

G~ pc c Bhicehh gezh~g`c~gke" Hgn pc ~kbn" ix~ g~ pc cbk c XE keh% Hgn pc ~k ok&k|hyc~hpg~a ~ah jkyhgèhy pkydge` kx~ kj ~ah kbn cicenkehn ak~hb ge ~ah agbb cikzh Ihgyx~%

\ykohss kj hbgfgec~gke

Oc|~% Hgn" ~akxà" pce'~ ge~hyh~hn ge nhbzge` ge~k kfh kj ~ah pgbnhy ~ahkygh fcdge` ~ah ykxenge Bhiceke%

Ah yhckehn ~ac~ jgenge` ~ah jgy~ ~ycoh kj ~ah dgbbhy pc c |ykoh kj hbgfgec~gke%

XE hfcgb

Yhcn ce hfcgb jykf _~h|ahe Fc~agc" Xeg~hn Ec~gke Kjjgoh kj Bh`cb Cjjcgy" ~k Ehgb Fconkecbnyh`cynge` XEGGO nkoxfhe~ ge ag |khgke%

Jykf Bhiceke' |akeh okf|cegh" ah ki~cgehn ~ah ocbb yhokyn kj cbb ~ah ohbb|akeh ~ac~ acnyh`g~hyhn pg~a ~ah ohbb ~kphy ge ~ah gffhngc~h zgogeg~w kj ~ah Ak~hb _~% @hky`h" pahyh ~ahfcgzh ibc~ acn ~kye c nhh| oyc~hy%

Keoh Hgn acn ~akh yhokyn" ah ih`ce ~ageege` kx~ ~ah axenyhn kj |akeh ge ~ah cyhc ~ac~fkyege`" xi~yco~ge` ~akh ahbn iw hcoa kj ~ah 99 nhcn" ~ahe ~akh ge Acygyg' he~kxyc`h" ~ahe ~akhkj |hk|bh ehcyiw pak acn ihhe ge~hyzghphn cen acn cbgig%

_kke hekxà" ah acn jkxen ~ah )yhn) |akeh ~ah ag~ ~hcf acn xhn%

Ix~ ah ngne'~ ~k| ~ahyh% Hqacx~gzhbw ~ycodge` pagoa ~kphy ~ah yhn |akeh acn )acdhe acenpg~a) ge ~ah ncw ihjkyh ~ah ccgec~gke" cen okf|cyge` ~akh yhokyn ~k Acygyg' oahnxbh" ahngokzhyhn ~ac~ ~ag eh~pkyd acn ihhe acnkpge` ~ah jkyfhy \F%

âh yhn&|akeh ocyyghy phyh obhcybw c ngog|bgehn `ykx|% âhw okffxegoc~hn pg~a keh cek~ahy cencbfk~ ehzhy pg~a ce kx~gnh |akeh% Cen ngyho~bw cj~hy ~ah ccgec~gke" ~ah yhn eh~pkyd phe~nhcn jkyhzhy%







Oc|~% Hgn" c~ pkyd c~ ags G_J kjjgoh" jykf c zgnhk~c|h ags iyk~ahy fcnh% C okf|x~hy s|hogcbgs~" ah acn ~ah dgen kj fgen ~ac~ okxbn shh

ge~ygoc~h |c~~hyes% !Okxy~hsw Hgn jcfgbw+OIO

Ix~ Hgn acn jkxen cek~ahy okeeho~gke% Ah hzhe~xcbbw gnhe~gjghn hgà~ k~ahy |akeh ~ac~ acn jkyfke~a gfxb~cehkxbw xhn ~ah cfh ohbb ~kphy c ~ah yhn |akeh%

_gècb ge~hbbg`heoh |ykjhgkecb ocbb ~ahh )ok&bkoc~gke) |akeh%

Pac~ Oc|~% Hgn acn ngokzhyhn pc ~ac~ hzhywkeh ke ~ah ag~ ~hcf acn ocyyghn c hoken |akeh" cen~ac~ ~ah ~hcf fhfihy acn xhn ~ahgy hoken |akeh ~k okffxegoc~h pg~a c fxoa bcy`hy x||ky~eh~pkyd ~ac~ acn ihhe ge hqg~heoh jky c~ bhc~ c whcy%

Hzhe~xcbbw" ~ah XE pkxbn bcihb ~ac~ `ykx| ~ah )ibxh) eh~pkyd%

Fkyh eh~pkyds

âh ibxh eh~pkyd cbk hqhyoghn okegnhycibh ngog|bgeh% G~" ~kk" yhfcgehn c )obkhn) eh~pkyd% Ek~keoh ngn cew ibxh&eh~pkyd fhfihy fcdh ~ah ky~ kj bg| ~ac~ ~hbhokf bhx~a bkkd jky%

Ix~ ~ahh |hk|bh cbk ocyyghn ok&bkoc~gke |akeh cen Hgn dh|~ jkbbkpge` ~ah hzhy&pgnhege` ~ycgb kj oyxfi%

âh ig` iyhcd ocfh pahe ~ah ibxh eh~pkyd pc obkhn nkpe cen ~ah |akeh phyh okbbho~hn iw cfgeky hbho~ykego |hogcbg~ pak pkydhn jky Ah}ikbbca" Cin cb Fcmgn cb @acfbkxa%

@acfbkxa pc" ge ~ah pkyn kj keh jkyfhy XE gezh~g`c~ky" )ce gngk~%)

@gzhe ~ah mki kj okbbho~ge` cen ng|kge` kj ~ah ibxh |akeh" ah ek~gohn kfh ~gbb acn ~gfhyhfcgege` ke ~ahf cen xhn keh ~k ocbb ag `gybjyghen" _cpce" ge ~ah |ykoh icgocbbw gnhe~gjwgeàgfhbj ~k Oc|~% Hgn% Ah fgà~ c phbb aczh pyg~~he ag ecfh ke c pag~hikcyn cen ahbn g~ x|kx~gnh G_J ahcnsxcy~hy%

@acfbkxa' ~x|gng~w hzhe~xcbbw bhn Hgn ~k c |cgy kj iyk~ahy ecfhn Axhge cen Fkxge Dayhg"ik~a Ah}ikbbca k|hyc~gzh% Keh kj ~ahf acn co~xcbbw ihhe c~ ~ah g~h kj ~ah ibc~%

Oc|~% Hgn dh|~ `kge`" gnhe~gjwge` fkyh cen fkyh |akeh ngyho~bw ky gengyho~bw ckogc~hn pg~a ~ahag~ ~hcf% Ah jkxen ~ah okyh kj c ~agyn eh~pkyd" c bke`hy&~hyf xyzhgbbceoh ~hcf ~ac~ pkxbnhzhe~xcbbw ih nxiihn ~ah )whbbkp%)







Hgn' pkyd pkxbn cbk bhcn ~k cek~ahy ngokzhyw= Hzhyw~age` okeeho~hn" akphzhy hbbg|~gocbbw" ~kbcen bgeh gegnh Ah}ikbbca' @yhc~ \yk|ah~ Ak|g~cb ge _kx~a Ihgyx~" c ho~ky kj ~ah og~w he~gyhbwoke~ykbbhn iw ~ah \cy~w kj @kn%

Bhicehsh kjjgogcbs ges|ho~ ~ah cj~hyfc~a kj ce

c~~hf|~ ke ~ah bgjh kj B~%&Okb% _cfhy _ahncaha" Hgn's ikss c~ ~ah G_J% _ahncaha sxyzgzhn ~ah ocy ikfi c~~cod" ehcy _gnke" ge _h|~hfihy 9<<: cen pcs she~ ~k Ocecnc jky ~yhc~fhe~ cen yhsh~~bhfhe~% !Dcfhb Mcih+Yhx~hys

G~ ac bke` ihhe cgn ~ac~ ~ah jxencfhe~cbg~ jgà~hy k|hyc~h c okffcen ohe~yh ge ~ah ak|g~cb%

Hzhe~xcbbw" ~hbhokf bhx~a pkxbn gnhe~gjw cek~ahy eh~pkyd kj jkxy k&ocbbhn )|ged |akeh) ~ac~acn ihhe okffxegoc~ge` ik~a pg~a ~ah ak|g~cb cen" gengyho~bw" pg~a ~ah k~ahy eh~pkyd%

âhh |akeh ~xyehn kx~ ~k ih ~yhfhenkxbw gf|ky~ce~% G~ ~xyehn kx~ ~ahw acn ihhe gxhn iw ~ahBhicehh `kzhyefhe~ g~hbj cen pahe ~ah fgeg~yw kj okffxegoc~gke pc sxhyghn cikx~ pak

~ahw acn ihhe gxhn ~k" ~ah cephy ocfh icod ge ~ah jkyf kj c ibcen `kzhyefhe~ yhokyn%

OIO ac ki~cgehn c ok|w kj ~ag yhokyn |ykzgnhn ~k ~ah okffggke% Ke g~" kfhkeh acagàbgà~hn jkxy he~ygh ge c bke` okbxfe kj gq&ng`g~ exfihy% Ihgnh ~ah agàbgà~hn exfihy" geCycigo" pc ~ah pkyn )Ah}ikbbca%)

Ah}ikbbca ac hzhycb hc~ ge ~ah Bhicehh bh`gbc~xyh cen c~ ~ah ~gfh acn ihhe |cy~ kj c`kzhyege` okcbg~gke" aheoh ~ah `kzhyefhe~&gxhn |akeh%

Jgecbbw" Hgn pc acenhn c obxh jykf ~ah ih~ kxyoh |kgibh= Ah pc oke~co~hn iw Ah}ikbbcag~hbj cen ~kbn ~ac~ kfh kj ~ah |akeh ah pc oacge` phyh ihge` xhn iw Ah}ikbbca c`he~okenxo~ge` c okxe~hy&h|gkec`h k|hyc~gke c`cge~ Gychb' Fkcn |w c`heow cen ~ac~ ah ehhnhn

~k icod kjj%

âh pcyege` okxbn ek~ aczh ihhe fkyh obhcy%







C ~akxà ~k xenhyokyh g~" Hgn' ik" B~%&Okb% _ahacnha" pc ~cy`h~hn iw ikfihy ge _h|~hfihy9<<:% âh ibc~ dgbbhn jkxy kj ag iknw`xcyn cen ehcybw dgbbhn _ahacnha" pak pc he~ ~k Sxhihojky fhngocb ~yhc~fhe~ cen yhh~~bhfhe~%

Iw ~ac~ ~gfh" Oc|~% Hgn acn he~ ag yh|ky~ ~k ~ah XE gesxgyw cen fkzhn ke ~k cek~ahy k|hyc~gke%

âh Hgn yh|ky~ pc he~hyhn ge~k ~ah XE' nc~cich iw kfhkeh pak hg~ahy ngne'~ xenhy~cen g~ ky

ngne'~ ocyh hekxà ~k iyge` g~ jkypcyn% G~ ngc||hcyhn%

Fgqhn pg~a sacfh

C whcy cen c acbj bc~hy" ge Nhohfihy 9<<0" pahe ~ah Hgn yh|ky~ jgecbbw yhxyjcohn" ~ah gffhngc~hyhco~gke kj ~ah XE ~hbhokf ~hcf pc hficyycfhe~% Cen ~ahe x|gogke%

Hgn obcgfhn ~k aczh |hyjkyfhn ag cecbwg xge` ek~age` ix~ Hqohb |yhcnahh~ cen ~ac~" cgn ~ahIyg~ga |hogcbg~" pc gf|kgibh%

Ek keh" ah nhobcyhn" okxbn cookf|bga xoa c ~age` pg~akx~ |kphyjxb okf|x~hy cg~ceoh cen ~ah

yhsxgg~h ~ycgege`% Ek cfc~hxy" pagoa g akp ~ah |hogcbg~ yh`cynhn Hgn" okxbn |kgibw aczhpcnhn ~aykxà ~ah fgbbgke kj |kgibh |hyfx~c~gke |khn iw ~ah |akeh yhokyn cen hq~yco~hngengzgnxcb eh~pkyd%

Csscssgec~gke ohe~ycb

âh ocy&ikfige` kj Ycjgd Acygyg ge 9<<8 pc iw ek fhce ce gkbc~hn geognhe~ ge Bhiceke'~ykxibhn ag~kyw% _geoh 3700" c~ bhc~ c nk}he |ykfgehe~ |kbg~gocb bhcnhy aczh ihhe ccgec~hn"geobxnge` |yhgnhe~ Icagy @hfcwhb ge 3719 cen |ygfh fgeg~hy Ycagn Dcycfg ge 3710%

@hfcwhb' eh|ahp" \ghyyh @hfcwhb" c bhcnhy ge ~ah Oayg~gce \acbce`g~ |cy~w cen ~ah fgeg~hy kj genx~yw c~ ~ah ~gfh" pc ak~ cen dgbbhn pagbh nygzge` ge ag ocy ge Ekzhfihy 9<<:" c whcy cenacbj cj~hy Acygyg cen pahe Ah}ikbbca pc ge ~ah fgn~ kj sxg~~ge` ~ah |yk&xeg~w `kzhyefhe~ ge c|yk~h~ c`cge~ ~ah XE |hogcb ~ygixecb%

âh fk~ yhohe~ kx~iyhcd kj bcy`h&ocbh ho~cygce zgkbheoh pc ge Mcexcyw cen Jhiyxcyw 9<<1

pahe cyfhn fgbg~gc" fcnh x| kj ~akh bgdh ~ah |yk&`kzhyefhe~ _xeeg `xefce |go~xyhn cikzh"jkxà~ ge ~ah ~yhh~ kj ^yg|kbg cen k~ahy bcy`h ohe~yh%

\c`h 3< kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






âg Oc|~% Hgn fx~ aczh acn ahb|" ~akxà~ ~ah ~hbhokf hq|hy~% _kfhkeh fx~ aczh `gzhe agf~ag gejkyfc~gke% \hyac| ah pc gezkbzhn kfhakp;

Iw ekp g~ pc Mcexcyw 9<<1% C ehp XE okffggkehy pc ge oacy`h" c Ocecngce mx~goh kjjgogcbecfhn Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh% Gezh~g`c~ky phyh jgecbbw ih`geege` ~k ihbghzh ~ahw phyh `h~~ge`kfhpahyh%

C nh|x~c~gke kj ~hbhokf hq|hy~ pc ng|c~oahn ~k fhh~ Hgn% âhw sxh~gkehn agf cen yh~xyehnokezgeohn ~ac~" kfhakp" ah acn genhhn gnhe~gjghn ~ah eh~pkyd agfhbj%

Hgn c||hcyhn ~k ih keh kj ~akh |hk|bh pak okxbn ge~xg~ fc~ahfc~gocb |c~~hye" ~ah ky~ pak ~agedhzhycb fkzh cahcn ge oah% Hzhe ih~~hy" ah pc pgbbge` ~k ahb| ngyho~bw% Ah pce~hn Acygyg'dgbbhy ~k jcoh mx~goh" Ah}ikbbca' pcyege` ih ncfehn%

G~ pc ce hqog~ge` |yk|ho~ jky ~ah XE ~hcf% Ahyh pc ce co~xcb Bhicehh gezh~g`c~ky" pg~agegà~ cen oke~co~ ~ah XE jkyhgèhy okxbn ehzhy fc~oa%

C phhd bc~hy" c bcy`hy XE ~hcf fh~ pg~a Oc|~% Hgn cen" c`cge" cbb phe~ phbb%

âhe" ~ah ehq~ ncw" Mce% 98" 9<<1" hgà~ ncw cj~hy ag jgy~ fhh~ge` pg~a ~ah XE gezh~g`c~ky"Oc|~% Pgcf Hgn fh~ |yhoghbw ~ah cfh jc~h c Acygyg% âh ikfi ~ac~ yg||hn c|cy~ ag jkxy&pahhb&nygzh zhagobh cbk dgbbhn ag iknw`xcyn cen ~ayhh geekohe~ iw~cenhy%

Bhiceke `czh Hgn c ~hbhzghn jxehycb cen" c~ ~ah XE gesxgyw" ~ahyh pc kx~yc`h c phbb% Ix~ fgqhnpg~a acfh%

Ihocxh ~ahyh pc ek nkxi~ ge ~ah fgen kj cew fhfihy kj ~ah ~hbhokf ~hcf paw Hgn acn nghn=Ah}ikbbca" ~ahw nhnxohn" acn jkxen kx~ ~ac~ Oc|~% Hgn' yh|ky~ acn ihhe ngokzhyhn" ~ac~ ah'n fh~pg~a ~ah XE gezh~g`c~ky cen ~ac~ ah acn c`yhhn ~k pkyd pg~a ~ahf%

Gffhngc~hbw" ~ah ~hbhokf ~hcf acn ~ah yhokyn kj ~ah ohbb ~kphy ehcy ~ah Hgn ibc~ g~h okbbho~hn"yhckege` ~ah dgbbhy fgà~ keoh c`cge aczh bhj~ ng`g~cb jkk~|yge~ ~ahw okxbn jkbbkp%

Ek~ ~ag ~gfh" ~akxà% âhyh pc ek~age`% âg ~gfh ~ah dgbbhy ngn pac~ ~ahw akxbn aczh ihhenkge` cbb cbke`= âhw'n xhn ycngk" ek~ ohbb|akeh% Ycngk nke'~ bhczh c ~ycoh%

âc~ bhj~ ~ah XE ~hcf pg~a ~ah kizgkx |ykibhf% âhgy cnzhycyw kizgkxbw dehp ek~ kebw pac~~ah XE gezh~g`c~ky phyh nkge`" ix~ dehp ge okegnhycibh nh~cgb%

Cen ~ah fkyh ~ah XE gezh~g`c~ky ~akxà~ cikx~ g~" ~ah fkyh ~ahw jkoxhn ke keh fce= Okb%Pgcf cb Acce" ~ah ehp ahcn kj Bhicehh ge~hbbg`heoh%

|cy~ 3 r |cy~ 9 r |cy~ ? r |cy~ >

Ge ~ah ~ycng~gke kj Fgnnbh Hc~hye ge~hbbg`heoh oaghj" Okb% Acce g c |x}}bge`" hzhe jhcyhn jg`xyhge ag kpe okxe~yw%

Ah pc ke ~ah XE ycncy jykf ~ah ih`geege`" jky ~pk yhcke= Ah sxgodbw ihocfh keh kj ~ahgesxgyw' fcge bgcgke pg~a ~ah G_J4 |bx ah pc ge oacy`h kj Acygyg' hoxyg~w c~ ~ah ~gfh kj ~ahccgec~gke%

Hqoh|~ ah acne'~ ihhe ge ~ah okezkw ~ah ncw kj ~ah ibc~% Cen ag cbgig pc jbgfw" ~k |x~ g~ fgbnbw%







Okb% Pgsscf Acssce" ~ah G_J ge~hbbg`heohoaghj pak pcs Acygyg's oaghj kj |yk~kokb c~ ~ah ~gfh kj ~ah ikfige`% !OIO

Ke Mxbw 7" 9<<8" Okb% Acce ~kbn XE gezh~g`c~ky ~ac~ ah pc heykbbhn ge c okf|x~hy okxyh"

Fcec`hfhe~ _kogcb h~ Axfcgeh" c~ Bhicehh Xegzhyg~w%

Ah cgn ~ac~ ke ~ah ncw ihjkyh ~ah ccgec~gke" Jhi% 3?" ah acn yhohgzhn c ocbb jykf ag |ykjhky"Wcawc Yciga" gejkyfge` agf ah pc yhsxgyhn ~k g~ jky ce hqcf ~ah ehq~ ncw%

^phe~w fgex~h bc~hy" ah ~kbn gezh~g`c~ky" Acygyg acn |akehn" xffkege` agf% Okb% Acce cgnah cyygzhn c~ Acygyg' yhgnheoh c~ 7=?< ~ac~ hzhege` cen ki~cgehn ag ik' |hyfggke ~k c~~hen~ah hqcf ~ah ehq~ ncw%

Ah |he~ ~ah he~gyh ehq~ fkyege` ~xnwge` jky ~ah hqcf" ah ~kbn ~ah XE" cen ~xyehn kjj ag |akehpahe ah he~hyhn ~ah xegzhyg~w" pagoa pc c~ mx~ cikx~ ~ah ~gfh Acygyg nghn%

)Gj G pce'~ g~~ge` jky ~ac~ hqcf") Acce ~kbn gezh~g`c~ky" )G pkxbn aczh ihhe pg~a Fy% Acygyg)pahe ah nghn%

C ngjjhyhe~ s~kyw

Ix~ Acce' |akeh yhokyn ~kbn cek~ahy ~kyw he~gyhbw%

Ge jco~" g~ pc Okb% Acce pak ocbbhn ~ah |ykjhky" ek~ ~ah k~ahy pcw cykxen% Cen Acce |bcohn~ah ocbb acbj ce akxy cj~hy ah acn fh~ Acygyg hcybghy ge ~ah hzhege`%

XE gezh~g`c~ky |yh|cyhn c yh|ky~ ke Okb% Acce ge bc~h 9<<1 ~ac~ oacbbhe`hn ag cbgig cenyhokffhenhn ~ac~ ah ih iykxà~ ge jky nh~cgbhn sxh~gkege`% !Yh|ky~ k|he ge c h|cyc~h pgenkp%

âh ohbb ~kphy cykxen Acce' akfh cbk akphn ~ac~ ~ah ehq~ ncw Okb% Acce |he~ ~ah akxyihjkyh Acygyg' ccgec~gke" ~ah ~gfh ah pc x||khnbw ~xnwge`" ke ~ah |akeh%

Ah fcnh 9> ocbb" ce czhyc`h kj keh hzhyw egeh fgex~h%

Pac~ pc cbk ng~xyige` ~ah XE gezh~g`c~ky pc ~ac~ agà hoxyg~w kjjgogcb ge Bhiceke nke'~ekyfcbbw g~ jky hqcf%

)Ag cbgig g phcd cen geokeg~he~") cw c okejgnhe~gcb XE yh|ky~ ~ac~ bcihb Acce c )|kgibh

x|ho~ ge ~ah Acygyg fxynhy%)

âc~ yh|ky~" ki~cgehn iw OIO Ehp" pc |yh|cyhn ge bc~h 9<<1 jky @cyyw Bkh||dw" c jkyfhyhegky YOF\ kjjgogcb pak acn ~cdhe kzhy c ~ah XE' oaghj gezh~g`c~ky ~ac~ xffhy%







Acce' cbgig" cgn ~ah nkoxfhe~" )nkh ek~ c||hcy ~k aczh ihhe genh|henhe~bw zhygjghn%)

âc~ acne'~ ihhe jky bcod kj nhgyh ke ~ah |cy~ kj XE gezh~g`c~ky% âhw'n pce~hn ~k oahod kx~Acce' cbgig" ~k )`h~ ge ag jcoh") ge ~ah pkyn kj keh jkyfhy nh~ho~gzh" cen |god c|cy~ ag ~kyw%

Hqgbh pg~akx~ hen

Bhiceke' zgogkx ho~cygce ~ygjh geoh ~ah hen kj ~ah _hoken Pkybn Pcy oceek~ ih jxbbwxenhy~kkn pg~akx~ yhjhyheoh ~k ~ah gejbxq kj \cbh~gegce yhjx`hh pak jbkknhn ge~k ~ah okxe~ywjkbbkpge` ~ah oyhc~gke kj Gychb ge 37>1 cen ~ah Cyci&Gychbg Pcy ge 37:0%

Yhohe~bw" ~ah OIO' Ecabca Cwhn cen okbbhc`xh jykf Ycngk&Ocecnc |he~ kfh okegnhycibh~gfh ge Bhiceke nkoxfhe~ge` ~ah ag~kyw cen |bgà~ kj ~ahh yhjx`hh cen pac~ ~ahw yh|yhhe~ jky~ah jx~xyh kj ~ah yh`gke%

âhgy ~kygh oce ih yhcn cen zghphn ge kxy |hogcb yh|ky~= Hqgbh pg~akx~ hen= \cbhs~gegces ge Bhiceke%

C~ ~ah zhyw bhc~" ~ahw pce~hn ~k oke~co~ Yciga" ~ah |ykjhky%

Ix~ Iycffhy~}" ~ah hoken XE okffggkehy" jbc~bw yxbhn ~ac~ kx~% Ah okegnhyhn Acce ~kkzcbxcibh c oke~co~ cen cew xoa gezh~g`c~gke c ~kk ngyx|~gzh%

'Fgà~ ncfc`h yhbc~gkes'

âh okejgnhe~gcb yh|ky~ okeohnh ~ac~ gezh~g`c~ge` Acce okxbn aczh g~ nycpicod= )G~ fcw

ncfc`h ~ah okffggke' yhbc~gke pg~a ~ah G_J" cen gj ah pc kfhakp gezkbzhn ge ~ah Acygygfxynhy" ~ah eh~pkyd fgà~ yhkbzh ~k hbgfgec~h agf%)

Ekeh~ahbh" ~ah yh|ky~ ~c~h ~ac~ Okb% Acce )g c dhw ge~hybkox~ky jky ~ah okffggke% Ah g ge cxegsxh |kg~gke ~k gejbxheoh kxy gezh~g`c~gke% C xoa" sxh~gke yh`cynge` ag bkwcb~w cenge~he~gke akxbn ih yhkbzhn%

)âhyhjkyh" g~ g yhokffhenhn ~ac~ PCA ih gezh~g`c~hn sxgh~bw%)

Ix~ hzhe ~ac~ pce'~ nkeh% âh XE okffggke' fcec`hfhe~ gèkyhn ~ah yhokffhenc~gke%

Jkyfhy XE gezh~g`c~ky yhfcge x|gogkx ~k ~ag ncw kj Acce" pak" ~ahw ek~h" pc hzhe~xcbbwox~ kx~ kj ~ah gesxgyw' bkk|%

\c`h 3? kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






Ix~ Acce ngn ihokfh Oc|~% Hgn' ik cj~hy ~ah Acygyg ccgec~gke% Ah ohy~cgebw pkxbn aczhdekpe cikx~ ~ah xnnhe ge~hyh~ ge ~ah Hgn yh|ky~" cen ~ah fhh~ge`%

)Ah pc ce xeczkyw oacyco~hy") c jkyfhy hegky XE kjjgogcb cgn% )G nke'~ ~aged ah |cy~gog|c~hn ge~ah fxynhy" ix~ ~ahyh' ek pcw kj ~hbbge` pac~ ah dehp%)

)Ah ykh" c~ ~ah zhyw bhc~" ~k ~ah bhzhb kj c |hyke kj ge~hyh~") cgn cek~ahy%

Yhcoahn ge Bhiceke ~kncw" cb Acce yh|hc~hnbw nhobgehn okffhe~%

Fkyh ocbbs

âkxà ~kbn ~k icod kjj" XE gezh~g`c~ky ehzhy~ahbh acn fcec`hn ~k okbbho~ Acce' |akehyhokyn jky bc~h 9<<> cen cbb kj 9<<8%

Ah}ikbbca bhcnhy _ahgda Ecsycbbca

!bhj~ cen ags ~k| cgnh" Axsshge Dacbgb !shoken jykf bhj~" |yhshe~ c `gj~ ygjbh ~k ~ah ahcn kj ~ah_wygce ge~hbbg`heoh shyzgoh ~k Bhiceke" Yxs~kf @ac}cbg !jcy ygà~ ge C|ygb 9<<8" ~pk fke~as cj~hy ~ah Acygyg fxynhy cen kebw ncws ihjkyh _wygc pkxbn |xbb ~ah bcs~ kj g~s ~ykk|s jykf Bhiceke%

Bkkdge` ke gs @he% Jcwhn cb&Acjjcy% Cookynge` ~k XE gezhs~g`c~kys" Dacbgb cen Okb% Acsscehqoace`hn exfhykxs |akeh ocbbs ge 9<<> cen 9<<8% !Yhx~hys |ak~k

Ge ~ac~ ~gfh" ah acn 907 ngoxgke pg~a Axhge Dacbgb" ~ah |ygeog|cb nh|x~w kj Ah}ikbbcaoaghj~cge Acce Ecycbbca% Dacbgb ge ~xye |kdh :<9 ~gfh ~k Pcjgd _cjc" pak g dekpe gege~hbbg`heoh ogyobh c ~ah acyn fce pak yxe Ah}ikbbca' ge~hyecb hoxyg~w nh|cy~fhe~%

Ek keh cdhn Acce cikx~ ~akh ocbb" hg~ahy%

Acce" ~akxà" cbk ac ag nhjhenhy% Ah yhfcge c obkh cbbw kj Acygyg' ke _ccn" ~ah oxyyhe~Bhicehh |ygfh fgeg~hy%

Cbk" jkyfhy X%_% kjjgogcb" kfh kj pakf phyh ge ~ah Kzcb Kjjgoh pahe ~ahe |yhgnhe~ @hky`hP% Ixa zhe~hn ag jyx~yc~gke pg~a ~ah okffggke' c||cyhe~ geokf|h~heoh" fcge~cge ~ac~Acce g ge jco~ c ig~~hy hehfw kj Ah}ikbbca" cen oc~ge` x|gogke ke agf fhyhbw |bcw ge~k ~ah`ykx|' acen%

âc~ ~ag |cy~goxbcy XE fhfk cikx~ Acce pc hzhy pyg~~he" cw keh jkyfhy Cfhygoce hoxyg~wkjjgogcb" g hzgnheoh ~ac~ ~ah okffggke acne'~ ~ah bgà~h~ gnhc pac~ g~ pc nkge`%

_hzhycb jkyfhy XE gezh~g`c~ky" ~akxà" cyh xecegfkx% âhw ihbghzh Ah}ikbbca gejgb~yc~hn ~ahokffggke cen xhn Acce ge ~ah |ykoh%

\c`h 3> kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






)Ah bghn ~k x ke ~ah cbgig") cw keh% )Ah akxbn aczh nghn ge ~ah okezkw% âc~' ~ah sxh~gkefcyd%)

|cy~ 3 r |cy~ 9 r |cy~ ? r |cy~ >

Ehcybw gq whcy aczh ekp |chn geoh Acygyg' ccgec~gke% âh XE fcenc~h pc hzhe~xcbbwhq|cenhn ~k geobxnh egeh xe~cy`h~hn |xibgo ikfige` cen 33 ~cy`h~hn c~~cod cen ccgec~gke"geobxnge` ~ac~ kj Oc|~% Hgn%

Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh kzhycp ~ah okffggke' ~ycejkyfc~gke ge~k ~ah _|hogcb ^ygixecb jky Bhiceke"yhgnge` ge âh Ac`xh" cen g ekp g~ oaghj |ykhox~ky%

^k nc~h" ~ah XE gesxgyw ac yh|ky~hnbw |he~ ge ~ah yce`h kj .9<< fgbbgke cen ~ahyh ac ihhe ~cbd jky kfh ~gfh ekp ~ac~ g~ g |yh|cyge` ~k iyge` nkpe gengo~fhe~" |kgibw bc~h ~ag whcy ky ge hcybw9<33%

Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh" ~ah Ocecngce |ykshox~ky pakahcns ~ah _|hogcb ^ygixecb jky Bhiceke" c~~hens g~s k|hege` ohyhfkew ge âh Ac`xh ge Fcyoa9<<7% !Fgoachb Dkkyhe+Yhx~hys

âh ~ygixecb oxyyhe~bw ac ce ceexcb ixn`h~ ge hqoh kj .>< fgbbgke cen fkyh ~ace ?<< hf|bkwhhjykf :3 okxe~ygh% G~ ac c ahcnsxcy~hy" c ~hcf kj |ykhox~ky" c nhjheoh kjjgoh" mxn`h" obhyd"gezh~g`c~ky cen yhhcyoa ~cjj" hzhe cooh ~k nh~he~gke jcogbg~gh" ix~ ek~ c ge`bh cooxhn%

Ihbbhfcyh g ge`xbcybw xeokffxegoc~gzh cikx~ pac~hzhy |yk`yh ac ihhe fcnh" c pc

Iycffhy~}% Jykf ~gfh ~k ~gfh" Ihbbhfcyh ac cxyhn ~ah Bhicehh fhngc ~ac~ mx~goh g|ykohhnge`" fx~ yhfcge okejgnhe~gcb cen akxbne'~ ih yxahn%

Ihbbhfcyh yhjxhn yh|hc~hn yhsxh~ ~k |hcd ~k OIO Ehp cikx~ ~ag yh|ky~%







âh okffggke' ~hbhokf ~hcf hzhe~xcbbw |yknxohn c xoohgke kj k|ag~goc~hn oacy~nh|go~ge` ~ah |akeh eh~pkyd ihagen ~ah Acygyg dgbbge`% OIO Ehp ac ki~cgehn c jcgybw yhohe~g~hyc~gke%

Ge yhohe~ fke~a" gezh~g`c~ky hzhe c~~coahn ecfh ~k kfh kj ~ah yhn |akeh ocyyghn iw ~ahAcygyg ag~ sxcn%

Ix~ ~ah ig``h~ |ykibhf" cookynge` ~k hzhycb kxyoh" ac ihhe okezhy~ge` ~ah~hbhokffxegoc~gke cecbwg ge~k hzgnheoh ~ac~ pgbb ~cen x| ge c okxy~ kj bcp%

Pgbb ~ah Ocecngce `h~ ag fce; âh OIO' Ecabca Cwhn ge~hyzghphn Nceghb Ihbbhfcyh ge Fcyoa9<<7% Ahy yh|ky~ oce ih yhcn cen zghphn ahyh%

âc~ fhce kfhkeh ac ~k jgen jgeceogcb yhokyn" ky pg~ehh ky k~ahy hzgnheoh" ~k co~xcbbw |bcoh~ah |akeh ge ~ah acen kj ~ah cbbh`hn |hy|h~yc~ky%

C kj fgn&9<<7" kxyoh cw" ~ah okffggke acn ek~ nkeh k%

)âhyh pc ek Tokyykikyc~ge`V hzgnheoh pac~khzhy") cw keh jkyfhy gegnhy% )Cen ~ahyh pc ekak|h kj `h~~ge` cew hzgnheoh% Ihocxh pak cyh wkx `kge` ~k |x~ ke ~ah `ykxen ge kx~ahye Ihgyx~~k `k ng``ge` cykxen; Wkx oce'~ |x~ cewkeh ke ~ah `ykxen% G~' ek~ |kgibh%)

Pac~' fkyh" ~ah okffggke ehzhy xhn pgyh~c|" hzhe cj~hy g~ gnhe~gjghn ohy~cge |akeh geeh~pkyd ~ac~ acne'~ `keh nhcn%

Ge cbb bgdhbgakkn" cew jkyfcb yhsxh~ ~k ~ah Bhicehh cx~akyg~gh jky c |akeh ~c| pkxbn aczhihokfh dekpe ge aky~ kynhy ~k Ah}ikbbca" `gzhe g~ okeeho~gke% Cen Ihbbhfcyh pkxbne'~ cbbkpag gezh~g`c~ky ~k ixw cen xh hczhnyk||ge` ~hoaekbk`w ke ~ahgy kpe%

Ah acn" ~akxà" `keh oc|&ge&acen ~k Pcage`~ke" bkkdge` jky ahb| jykf g~ ge~hbbg`heoh c`heogh%

âhyh" ah fh~ pg~a Ixa' ec~gkecb hoxyg~w cnzghy" _~h|ahe Acnbhw" cen pg~a ~ahe hoyh~cyw kj ~c~h Okenkbhh}}c Ygoh%

Ix~ ah pc yhixjjhn% Ihbbhfcyh acn ek~ ihhe Pcage`~ke' oakgoh jky ~ah mki cen X%_% kjjgogcbngn ek~ akbn agf ge ~hyygibw agà yh`cyn% âhw phyh cpcyh ah acn ihhe |henge` fxoa kj ag ~gfhkihge` kzhy ~ah ~yc||ge` kj ag XE kjjgoh" kynhyge` ge ~cgbkyhn obk~ah" ikc~ge` cikx~ ag|ykhox~kygcb |ykph cen nhgège` c |hykecb okc~ kj cyf%

Ag xenhybge` acn pc~oahn" ihfxhn" c ah ng|c~oahn hoxyg~w ~cjj ~k Ihgyx~' fkyh jcagkecibhak||ge` ng~ygo~ ~k gesxgyh cikx~ aczge` ~ah jcfgbw oyh~ hfikhn ke |ghoh kj mhphbyw%

)Gj G pc `gzhe ~k oke|gycow ~ahkygh") cgn keh kj Ihbbhfcyh' jkyfhy kjjgogcb" )G'n ~aged ah pcnhbgihyc~hbw |x~ ge ~ahyh k c ek~ ~k coaghzh cew~age`%)

_hoyh~ ge~hyoh|~ jykf ge~hbbg`heoh c`heogh bgdh ~ah OGC ky Ec~gkecb _hoxyg~w C`heow cyh ek~xhcibh ge c okxy~ xoa c ~ah XE _|hogcb ^ygixecb% Cen" dekpge` kj ~ah bhcd cen k~ahy |ykibhfc~ ~ah XE okffggke" ek ge~hbbg`heoh c`heow ge ~ah Ph~ pc |yh|cyhn ~k acen kzhy xoaheg~gzh fc~hygcb%

\c`h 3: kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






X%_% _hoyh~cyw kj _~c~h Agbbcyw Obge~ke fhh~s pg~a Bhicehsh \ygfh Fgegs~hy _ccn Acygyg !~ah ske kj Ycjgd ge C|ygb 9<<7" ge cnzceoh kj c oyg~gocbhbho~gke% _ccn Acygyg acs yh~yco~hn skfh kj ags hcybghy okffhe~s cikx~ _wygce gezkbzhfhe~ ge ags

jc~ahy's nhc~a ix~ ~ah Phs~ gs s~gbb c||bwge` |yhssxyh% !Igbcb Axsshge+Csskogc~hn \yhss

Pahe Acnbhw |kbg~hbw gesxgyhn c ~k pac~ Ihbbhfcyh pkxbn okegnhy c xooh „ gengo~fhe~"co~xcb cyyh~" nhobcyc~gke kj kjjgogcb x|gogke; „ ~ah Ocecngce pcjjbhn" xecibh ky xepgbbge` ~k|ykzgnh c |yhogh cephy%

Fhcepagbh" icod ge Bhiceke" Ah}ikbbca acn ih`xe fkxe~ge` c ocf|cg`e ~k hexyh ~ac~ `c~ahyge`x||ky~ge` hzgnheoh pkxbn yhfcge ehq~ ~k gf|kgibh%

C yxfkxy ih`ce xyjcoge` ge ~ah Bhicehh |yh ~ac~ ~ah XE ~ygixecb pc `h~~ge` obkh ~kgxge` gengo~fhe~" Ecycbbca" ~ah Ah}ikbbca oaghj" ih`ce pcyege` ~ac~ ah pgbb gf|bw ek~ ~kbhyc~h

cyyh~ kj cew kj ag |hk|bh%

^ac~' ek gnbh ~ayhc~% Ecycbbca k|hyc~h c |ygzc~h fgbg~gc okegnhycibw fkyh |kphyjxb ~ace ~ahBhicehh cyfw% Cen ah cbk nhfcenhn ~ac~ ~ah XE ~ygixecb" pagoa g |cy~gcbbw jxenhn iwBhiceke" ih ngkbzhn%

Ge yhohe~ fke~a" Ecycbbca ac ~cdhe ~k obcgfge` ~ac~ g~ pc co~xcbbw Gychb ~ac~ dgbbhn Acygyg%

Fkyh ~ace keh jkyfhy XE gezh~g`c~ky ihbghzh ~ac~ akxbn ~ah ~hbhokffxegoc~gke hzgnheoh hzhyih |x~ ihjkyh ~ah Bhicehh |xibgo" Ecycbbca pgbb codekpbhn`h ~ac~ ag k|hyc~gzh phyh ke ~ah~yhh~ pahe Acygyg nghn" ix~ obcgf ~ac~ ~ahw phyh ~ahyh oacge` Gychbg ccge%

Ek~age` ~ah XE ac xeokzhyhn |kge~ yhfk~hbw c~ Gychb% Hzhyw~age` |kge~ c~ Ah}ikbbca% Ix~gezkdge` Gychb cbpcw `cge ~yco~gke ge ~ah Cyci pkybn%







Icodge` kjj

Keh jkyfhybw hegky kjjgogcb pg~a ~ah okffggke cw )okegnhycibh |yk`yh) pc fcnh nxyge`~ah fk~ yhohe~ fke~a kj Ihbbhfcyh' ~hyf ge `c~ahyge` hzgnheoh ~k x||ky~ ~ah~hbhokffxegoc~gke pkyd% Ix~" ah okeohnh" ~ah hzgnheoh g ~gbb bcy`hbw ogyoxf~ce~gcb%

âc~ fcw ih cbb ~ah hqoxh ~ac~ \ygfh Fgeg~hy _ccn Acygyg cen ag |kbg~gocb cbbgh ehhn ~k bh~ ~agokffggke ngh%

_ccn Acygyg cen ag x||ky~hy kyg`gecbbw ibcfhn _wygc jky ~ah ccgec~gke% Ix~ ~ahw'zh ihheicod|hncbge` ge yhohe~ fke~a% Acygyg yhohe~bw hqkehyc~hn _wygc" yh|xngc~ge` ag kpe pkye~c~hfhe~ ~k XE gezh~g`c~ky ge 9<<8%

Ah ac cbk ocbbhn jky ce gezh~g`c~gke kj Ecycbbca' obcgf ~ac~ Gychb dgbbhn ag jc~ahy%

Nh~bhz Fhabg" ~ah jgy~ XE okffggkehy" ~kbn OIO Ehp yhohe~bw ~ac~ g~ ac cbpcw ihhekizgkx _wygc kynhyhn ~ah Acygyg ag~% âc~ g~ pkxbn xh Ah}ikbbca" g~ bke`&~gfh |ykqw" ah cw" gkebw bk`gocb%

âh hbnhy Acygyg" Fhabg ek~hn" acn |xahn ek~ mx~ jky c _wygce pg~anycpcb ix~ cbk jky ~ahngcyfge` kj Ah}ikbbca' jhcyhn fgbg~gc%

_ok~~ Ocy|he~hy" c jkyfhy Ixa cnfgeg~yc~gke kjjgogcb ng|c~oahn iw ~ah Pag~h Akxh ~k Bhicekege ~ah pcdh kj Acygyg' nhc~a" cbk cw ~ah yhcbg~w g kizgkx%

Ix~" ah cnn= )G Ah}ikbbca `kge` ~k `h~ cpcw pg~a g~; Wh% Jhphy ~yczh~gh pgbb ih `yhc~hy" ix~ Gnke'~ hh pahyh ~ah ge~hyec~gkecb pgbb g ~k ~cdh ~ag ke" cen G ohy~cgebw nke'~ hh" cihe~ ~ac~ge~hyec~gkecb pgbb" akp ~ah Bhicehh |hk|bh oce ~cdh g~ ke%)

C fcy~wy yhfhfihyhn

Oc|~% Hgn" pak pc |k~axfkxbw |ykfk~hn ~k ~ah yced kj fcmky" bgh ge c `yczh ek~ jcy jykf ~ahjcfgbw akfh ge Nhgy Cffcy%

Ag |go~xyh g hzhywpahyh ge ~ah og~w" bkkdge` nkpe x|ke ~yhh~" ocjh cen yh~cxyce~% Ah gxegjkyfbw nhoygihn c c fcy~wy ~k ag okxe~yw%

Ag jcfgbw ac |yhogkx bg~~bh iw pagoa ~k yhfhfihy agf% C jhp |ak~k" c oyc|ikkd kj ehp~kygh cikx~ ag nhc~a" cen c jhp fgex~h kj cfc~hxy zgnhk%







Oc|~% Pgsscf Hgn pg~a ags fk~ahy"_cfgyc" jykf c zgnhk ags iyk~ahy fcnh pahe ~ah ~pk iyk~ahys sheshn ags ncws fg`a~ ih exfihyhn%!OIO

Fkacffhn Hgn cw ~ac~ iw bc~h 9<<0" ag kbnhy iyk~ahy acn ih`xe bgzge` ge ag kjjgoh" okezgeohnah |ykicibw ngne'~ aczh fxoa bke`hy ~k bgzh%

Ah cdhn Fkacffhn ~k fcdh ~ah zgnhk" pagoa nh|go~ agf pkydge` c~ ag nhd ge ~ah G_J' Ihgyx~ahcnsxcy~hy% Ge g~" ah ice~hy pg~a |hk|bh kjj&oyhhe4 g~ g xeyhfcydcibh jkk~c`h" ix~ acxe~ge` ~kcewkeh pak dekp ag ~kyw%

Hgn' fk~ahy" _cfgyc" cw ahy ke pc c `gj~ ~k ~ahgy okxe~yw cen ihbghzh ~ac~" c c fcy~wy" ahyhfcge pg~a ahy h~hyecbbw%

)Gj ph aczh c jhp k~ahy Pgcf ge Bhiceke" ~ah okxe~yw pgbb ih mx~ jgeh") ah cw% Ahy axicen

x~ ~cyh cnbw ge~k |coh%

_ah cen ahy axicen cen ~ahgy ~ayhh xyzgzge` ke dekp cbfk~ ohy~cgebw pak dgbbhn Pgcf%

Ix~ ~ag g Bhiceke" cen ~ahw xenhy~cen ~ah okehsxheoh kj ~cbdge` cikx~ ~ac~%

)G oceek~ k|he fw fkx~a") ah cw" )ihocxh ph aczh k~ahy wkxe` fhe ~k |yk~ho~%)

Fkacffhn Hgn cw ~ah jcfgbw ac hzhe okfh ~k yhcbg}h ~ac~ Bhiceke okxbn |cw c ibkknw |ygoh gj ag iyk~ahy' fxynhyhy cyh hzhy oacy`hn% )O'h~ |c bh fkfhe~") ah cw" ge ~ah jcfgbw' hokenbce`xc`h%

Ix~ kj ag iyk~ahy' gezh~g`c~gzh dgbb" ~ah jcfgbw ac ek nkxi~%

Ge 9<<7" ihjkyh ~ah XE gesxgyw |codhn x| cen bhj~ jky ^ah Ac`xh" ce Cx~ycbgce |ykhox~ky ecfhnYchbheh _acy|" pak'n ihhe pkydge` jky ~ah okffggke" |cgn ~ah Hgn jcfgbw c xy|ygh zgg~%

_ah ph|~" c ah ~kbn ~ahf ~ac~ pg~akx~ ~ahgy ke" ~ah okffggke pkxbn ih ekpahyh%

•

\k~ c okffhe~><3Okffhe~ aczh ihhe |k~hn

•

Yhokffhen ~ag ~kyw:<: \hk|bh aczh yhokffhenhn ~ag ~kyw







_~kyw okffhe~s ! ><3

_ky~= Fk~ yhohe~ r Jgy~ ~k bc~ r C`yhhn Yki _hc pyk~h=\k~hn 9<3<+33+9>c~ 7=99 CF H^G c||bcxn Ehgb FcoNkecbn jky iyge`ge` ~k bgà~ pac~ g `kge` c~ ~ah XE% âg ~w|hkj yh|ky~ge` pgbb hzhe~xcbbw bhcn ~k ~ah ~yx~a gj g~ ace'~ cbyhcnw%

<•

<•

<C`yhh <Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh^KMcod pyk~h=\k~hn 9<3<+33+9>c~ 7=37 CF H^G~ g genhhn ygà~ cen |yk|hy ~k sxh~gke ~ah fk~gzh kj kfh kj ~ah fkyh zkogjhykx|k~hy pak cyh geohce~ ge ~ahgy oyg~gogf kj FcoNkecbn' okeobxgke cen pak oke~gexcbbw hhd ~k nhjbho~ cooxc~gke cpcw jykf Ah}ikbbca ke~k Gychb% Obhcybw ph cyh pg~ehge` c \Ynggejkyfc~gke ocf|cgè iw Ah}ikbbca

3•

<•

3C`yhh <Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh^KMcod pyk~h=\k~hn 9<3<+33+9>c~ 7=3> CF H^Pcb~hy??" Dheehnw' ccgec~gke g cikx~ c yhbhzce~ ~k ~ah Ocecnc kj ~kncw cAcygyg'%

<•

3•

<C`yhh 3Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh

^KMcod pyk~h=\k~hn 9<3<+33+9>c~ 7=39 CF H^Pac~' jcogec~ge` cikx~ ~ah |yk&Ah}ikbbca |k~hy g ~ac~ ~ahw cbb hhf ~k aczhcooh ~k fxoa fkyh gejkyfc~gke ~ace cewkeh hbh" geobxnge` Ehgb FcoNkecbn ke ~ah `ykxen geIhgyx~% Akp g ~ac~ |kgibh" keh fgà~ cd;

âh k~ahy ge~hyh~ge` okffkecbg~w ~ahw aczh g ~ac~ ~ahw cbb nhjbho~ ~ah cooxc~gke kj Acygyg'fxynhy cpcw jykf Ah}ikbbca ke~k Gychb% Ge ~ah Fgnnbh Hc~ hzhyw~age` cbpcw hhf ~k hen x| geoyg~gogf kj Gychb% Ek keh hzhy ~cdh yh|kegigbg~w jky cew~age`% Ek pkenhy Bhiceke g xoa cicdh~&och%

âh bc~ ~gfh ph cp ce Cyci bhcnhy ~cdh yh|kegigbg~w ah pc kke ccgec~hn% _cnc~' fxynhypc c pcyege`" mx~ c Acygyg' g%

?•

?•

?C`yhh ?Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixhPcb~hy?<? pyk~h=\k~hn 9<3<+33+9>c~ 9=9> CF H^Pagbh ah g ge ~ah fkkn ah akxbn jgen kx~ pak dgbbhn Dheehnw% G~ g obkhy ~kakfh cen fkyh yhbhzce~ ~k x ge Ocecnc

3<•

3?•

3<C`yhh 3?Ngc`yhh\kbgow Yh|ky~ cixh

Jgy~•

\c`h 9< kj 93OIO Ehp & Pkybn & OIO Gezh~g`c~gke= Pak dgbbhn Bhiceke' Ycjgd Acygyg;






\yhzgkx•

3•

9•

?•

>•

8•

:•

0•

1•

7•

3<•

Ehq~•

Bc~•

Okffhe~ ke ~ag ~kyw cyh |yh&fknhyc~hn% Ihjkyh ~ahw c||hcy" okffhe~ cyh yhzghphn iwfknhyc~ky ~k hexyh ~ahw fhh~ kxy xifggke `xgnhbgeh%

Okffhe~ cyh k|he cen phbokfh xe~gb Jygncw" Ekzhfihy 9:" 9<3< c~ 33=87 |%f% H^%

Ph yhhyzh ~ah ygà~ ~k obkh okffhe~ ihjkyh ~ahe%

\ks~ wkxy okffhe~

Ek~h= âh OIO nkh ek~ ehohcygbw henkyh cew kj ~ah zghp |k~hn% Iw xifg~~ge` wkxyokffhe~" wkx codekpbhn`h ~ac~ OIO ac ~ah ygà~ ~k yh|yknxoh" iykcnoc~ cen |xibgog}h ~akhokffhe~ ky cew |cy~ ~ahyhkj ge cew fceehy pac~khzhy% \bhch ek~h ~ac~ okffhe~ cyh |yh&fknhyc~hn+yhzghphn cen |xibgahn cookynge` ~k kxy xifggke `xgnhbgeh%

Wkx fx~ ih bk``hn ge ~k bhczh c okffhe~% Bk` ge r _gè x|Okffhe~=

\ks~\ks~ _xifggke |kbgow


cbc investigation: who killed lebanon's rafik hariri? -

Documents