ce 59700: laser scanning - purdue university · 2020-01-09 · laser scanning 3 ayman f. habib...

49
Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib 1 CE 59700: LASER SCANNING Ayman F. Habib Digital Photogrammetry Research Group – DPRG Lyles School of Civil Engineering Purdue University, USA Webpage: http://purdue.edu/CE/DPRG Email: [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib1

CE 59700: LASER SCANNING

Ayman F. HabibDigital Photogrammetry Research Group – DPRGLyles School of Civil EngineeringPurdue University, USAWebpage: http://purdue.edu/CE/DPRGEmail: [email protected]

Page 2: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib2

Contact Information• Instructor:

– Ayman F. Habib– Office: HAMP 4108– Tel: (765) 496-0173– E-mail: [email protected]– Lectures (HAMP 2117):

• Monday (3:30 p.m. – 6:20 p.m.)– Office Hours:

• Flexible (upon e-mail request for setting up an appointment)

• Course webpage:– http://purdue.edu/CE/DPRG

Page 3: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib3

Course Objectives• Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR

mapping.• Emphasis:

– Data acquisition,– Georeferencing of mobile mapping systems,– System calibration,– Quality control of point cloud coordinates,– Registration of overlapping point clouds,– Data characterization,– Data processing,– Quality control of the data processing results, and– Integration of point cloud and image data.

Page 4: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib4

Course Notes and Textbooks• Material presented in class, as well as supplemental notes,

will be available through the course webpage.– Contains all the required material for the course work and

exams.• Supplementary References (optional):

– Selected research papers will be made available throughout the semester.

Page 5: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib5

Grading Scheme• Class participation: 5%• Midterm exam: 15%• Project presentations and final report: 50%

– Some suggested project topics are provided later.– Midterm presentation– Final presentation & technical report

• Final exam: 30%• Exams are open book/notes.

Page 6: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib6

Course Contents• Principles of Photogrammetric Mapping• Photogrammetric and LiDAR Georeferencing• LiDAR Mapping Principles• Quality Assurance and Quality Control of LiDAR

Mapping• Registration of Laser Scanning Point Clouds• Adaptive Processing of LiDAR Data for Extracting Planar

and Linear Features• Occlusion-based Procedure for True Orthophoto

Generation and LiDAR Data Classification• Automatic Detection and Reconstruction of Right-

Angled-Corner Buildings

Page 7: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib7

Chapter 1: Overview• Principles of Photogrammetric Mapping• Photogrammetry: Definition and applications• Photogrammetric tools:

– Rotation matrices– Photogrammetric orientation: interior and exterior orientation

• Photogrammetric point positioning– Collinearity equations/conditions (single camera systems)– GNSS/INS-assisted photogrammetric systems– Multi-camera photogrammetric systems

• Photogrammetric bundle adjustment– Structure of the design and normal matrices

Page 8: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib8

Photogrammetry• Objective: Derive the positions and shapes of objects

from imagery

Page 9: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib9

Photogrammetric Reconstruction

Object Point (A)

Conjugate Points

• The interior orientation parameters of the involved cameras have to be known.• The position and the orientation of the camera stations have to be known.

a a´

Camera Calibration (IOP) Georeferencing (EOP)

Camera

Page 10: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib10

Chapter 2: Overview• Photogrammetric and LiDAR Georeferencing• Introduction• Georeferencing Alternatives:

– Indirect georeferencing– Integrated Sensor Orientation (ISO)– Direct georeferencing

• Direct Georeferencing: Operational Example– Terrestrial Mobile Mapping Systems (MMS)

• Accuracy Analysis of Different GeoreferencingTechniques

• Concluding Remarks

Page 11: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib11

c-frame

m-frame

)(trmc

)(tRmc

Georeferencing• Exterior Orientation Parameters (EOP) define the

position and orientation of the camera/LiDAR coordinate system relative to the mapping reference frame at the moment of exposure.

Page 12: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib12

Direct Georeferencing: Airborne System

GNSS Antenna

Camera

INS PC

Two Base Stations

GNSS Receiver

Page 13: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib13

Direct Georeferencing: Land-based System

Digital camera

GNSS antenna

INS

Direct georeferencing in practice

Page 14: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib14

Direct Georeferencing

c-frame

m-frame

GNSS antenna

IMU b-frame

bcr

bc

mb

mb

mc rtRtrtr )()()( +=

CalibrationGNSS/INS attitudeGNSS/INS positionCamera position

bc

mb

mc RtRtR )()( =

CalibrationGNSS/INS attitudeCamera attitude

bcR

)( tr mc

)(trmb

)(tRmb

)(tRmc

Page 15: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib15

Airborne LiDAR Mapping• Three Measurement Systems

– GNSS– IMU– Laser scanner emits laser beams with high frequency and

collects the reflections.

INS

GNSS

GNSS

IMU

Page 16: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib16

Kinematic Terrestrial Laser Scanning• Three Measurement Systems

– GNSS– IMU– Laser scanner emits laser beams with high frequency and

collects the reflections.

LiDAR Sensors

IMU

GNSS Antenna

DMI

Page 17: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib17

Chapter 3: Overview• LiDAR Mapping Principles• Passive versus active sensors• LASER principles• LiDAR principles• LiDAR equation• Error sources (systematic and random errors) & their

impact• LiDAR vs. photogrammetric mapping

Page 18: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib18

Source: seaice.acecrc.au

Airborne Laser Scanning Static Terrestrial Laser Scanning

Source:www.cage.curtain.edy.au

Kinematic Terrestrial Laser Scanning

Source:www.optech.ca/lynx.htm

LiDAR Principles

Page 19: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib19

LiDAR Principles

Page 20: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib20

LiDAR Data Applications

Heritage Documentation

Source: www.nytimes.com

Transportation Planning

Source: www.isgs.uiuc.edu

Power Line Mapping

Source: www.merrick.com

Flood Plain Mapping

Source: www.maritimejournal.com

3D City Modeling

Source: www.trimble.com

We need to understand the underlying principles of LiDAR point

positioning and the factors that affect the quality of derived points.

LiDAR Principles

Page 21: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib21

Chapter 4: Overview• Quality Assurance and Quality Control of LiDAR

Mapping• Motivation• Quality Assurance (QA) and Quality Control (QC)

– Introduction– Prerequisites

• QA/QC of Photogrammetric Mapping• QA/QC of LiDAR Mapping:

– LiDAR system calibration– Geometric validation of LiDAR data

• Concluding Remarks

Page 22: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib22

LiDAR Quality Assurance• QA activities/measures include:

– Optimum mission time– Distance to GNSS base station – Flying height– Pulse repetition rate– Beam divergence angle– Scan angle– Percentage of overlap– System calibration

Laser scanner

Page 23: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib23

xlb

ylbzlb

xlu

zlu

xb

ybzb

ylu

XG

ZG

YG

2. IMU body frame

1. Mapping Reference Frame Object point (I)

Laser beam

3. Laser unit

4. Laser beam

)t(r mb

)t(R m

b

blur

bluR

l ( )lubR t

),(lbI)S,S(

lulb),,(

blu

mb)Z,Y,X(

blu

mb

mb

mI rRR)t(Rr)t(R)t(rr ρΔρββαακΔϕΔωΔΔΔΔ ++=

mIr

( )lbIr t ρ=

LiDAR QA: System Calibration

Page 24: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib24

LiDAR QA: System Calibration

Error Sources Analysis /

Error Modeling

Recoverability Analysis

Flight Configuration

Sampling Density

Correspondence

Primitives

Aspects Involved

Page 25: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib25

LiDAR Internal QC

Page 26: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib26

LiDAR QA/QC• Profile: AA'

1m

1mBefore

After

Page 27: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib27

Chapter 5: Overview• Registration of Laser Scanning Point Clouds• Introduction: Terrestrial Laser Scanners (TLS) and

applications• Prior work: Registration paradigm, point-based

registration, feature-based registration• Methodology: Linear features extraction, parameter

estimation alternatives, matching process, and parameter refinement

• Experimental results: Segmentation and registration results

• Conclusions and future work

Page 28: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib28

TLS Registration

Page 29: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib29

Chapter 6: Overview• Adaptive Processing of LiDAR Data for Extracting

Planar and Linear Features• LiDAR Mapping Principles• LiDAR Data Characterization

– Local Point Density (LPD) Estimation• Planar & Linear Feature Segmentation

– Spatial-Domain Segmentation– Parameter-Domain Segmentation– Quality Control of the Segmentation Outcome

• Concluding Remarks• Current & Future Work

Page 30: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib30

LiDAR Data Applications

Heritage Documentation

Source: www.nytimes.com

Transportation Planning

Source: www.isgs.uiuc.edu

Power–Line Mapping

Source: www.merrick.com

Flood Plain Mapping

Source: www.maritimejournal.com

3D City Modeling

Source: www.trimble.com

LiDAR mapping should have reliable QA/QC guidelines and the

data should be carefully processed to extract useful information

for these applications.

LiDAR Mapping

Page 31: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib31

LiDAR Mapping: Ultimate Goal

Airborne scan

Terrestrial scan Combined and segmented scans

Page 32: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib32

LiDAR Mapping: Ultimate GoalAirborne ScanTerrestrial Scan ATerrestrial Scan BIntegrated Scans A rooftop profile

Noise level

Density variations

Top view

We need a data characterization step to take into account the varying natures of the input

point clouds.

Page 33: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib33

Chapter 7: Overview• Occlusion-based Procedure for True Orthophoto

Generation and LiDAR Data Classification• Introduction• Orthophoto generation

– Literature review– Procedure

• LiDAR data classification– Literature review– Procedure– Experimental results

• Concluding remarks

Page 34: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib34

Perspective Image

Page 35: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib35

Orthophoto

Page 36: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib36

LiDAR Classification

Original Image LiDAR DSM

Page 37: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib37

LiDAR Classification

Original DSM Off-ground Points

Page 38: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib38

LiDAR Classification

Original DSM Derived DTM

Page 39: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib39

Chapter 8: Overview• Automatic Detection and Reconstruction of Right-

Angled-Corner Buildings• Introduction• Existing DBM Generation Methodologies• Research Objectives• Proposed Methodology• Experimental Results• Concluding Remarks• Current & Future Work

Page 40: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib40

• Orthophoto over the test area

DBM Generation

Page 41: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib41

• Original LiDAR data

DBM Generation

Page 42: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib42

Realistic 3D Modeling / Visualization

Page 43: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib43

Suggested Project Topics• Structuring/organization/query of point cloud data:

– Kd-tree data structure– Octree data structure– Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search (ANN)

• LiDAR point positioning:– Pulse-based Time-of-Flight (ToF) systems– Phase-shift-based Time-of-Flight (ToF) systems– Triangulation-based systems

• LiDAR system calibration:– Airborne system calibration– Mobile terrestrial system calibration– Static terrestrial system calibration

Page 44: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib44

Suggested Project Topics• Quality control of the LiDAR point positioning

– Point-based QC procedures– Feature-based QC procedures– Internal versus external QC procedures

• Classification of point cloud data:– Terrain/off-terrain classification– Planar, pole-like, and rough feature (local neighborhood)

classification• Segmentation of point cloud data:

– Spatial-domain segmentation– Parameter-domain segmentation– Hybrid segmentation approaches– Quality control of the segmentation outcome

Page 45: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib45

Suggested Project Topics• LiDAR data characterization:

– Local point density estimation– Noise level evaluation

• Down-sampling LiDAR data:– Random down-sampling– Distance-based down-sampling– Adaptive down-sampling

• Registration of LiDAR data:– Coarse-based registration– Fine-based registration– Point-based registration– Feature-based registration– Heterogeneous data registration

Page 46: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib46

Suggested Project Topics• Integration of LiDAR and image data:

– True orthophoto generation– Point-based color-coding of LiDAR data– Feature-based texturing of LiDAR data– Object detection and extraction (e.g., Digital Building Model –

DBM – generation)• LiDAR versus 3D range cameras• LiDAR systems:

– Discrete systems– Waveform LiDAR– Photon-counting LiDAR– Flash LiDAR

Page 47: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib47

Suggested Project Topics• LiDAR applications:

– Flood plain mapping– Heritage documentation– 3D-city modeling– Power-line mapping– Transportation planning

• LiDAR versus photogrammetric mapping:– Operational principles– Point-positioning alternatives– Characteristics– System calibration alternatives– Quality control procedures– Pros/cons

Page 48: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib48

Suggested Project Topics• Unique point extraction from LiDAR data:

– 3D point descriptors– 3D SIFT– Spin images

• Note: The above list is just provided as suggested topics.– Other related topics are welcome.

Page 49: CE 59700: LASER SCANNING - Purdue University · 2020-01-09 · Laser Scanning 3 Ayman F. Habib Course Objectives •Gain familiarity with the basic principles of LiDAR mapping. •Emphasis:

Laser Scanning Ayman F. Habib49

Suggested Project Topics• The project should have a good balance between literature

review and implementation.• For each of the suggested topics, group projects are

permitted. If applicable, the following should be discussed.– Technical details of the individual approaches– Pros/cons of the individual approaches– Comparative evaluation of the performance of the different

approaches• The project (team, if applicable) selection should be

finalized by Friday, January 24th.