centimeter and millimeter observations of very young binary and multiple systems -orbital motions...

44
Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks -The OMC1S Region in Orion Luis F. Rodríguez CRyA, UNAM

Post on 21-Dec-2015

217 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple

Systems

-Orbital Motions and Mass Determination

-Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

-The OMC1S Region in Orion

Luis F. Rodríguez CRyA, UNAM

Page 2: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

ORBITAL MOTIONS IN BINARY AND MULTIPLE PROTOSTARS

L. Loinard, M. Rodríguez, & P. D’Alessio (CRyAUNAM, Morelia)

S. Curiel, J. Cantó, & A. C. Raga (IAUNAM, México City)

J. M. Torrelles (IEEC, Spain), J. M. Girart (U. Barcelona, Spain)

David J. Wilner & Paul T. P. Ho (CfA, USA)

High angular resolution (0.1”) Very Large Array observations of young stellar systems that allow measurement of orbital proper motions and estimate of stellar masses.

Page 3: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

BACKGROUND

• Most information on stellar masses comes from studies of orbital motions

• Work at optical band toward visible stars has been going on for 200 years

• In the last decade, near-IR speckle and adaptive optics has been used to investigate T Tauri binaries

• What about heavily obscured protostars, not detectable even at near-IR wavelengths?

Page 4: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

RADIO OBSERVATIONS

• Remarkably, protostars can be tracked at radio wavelengths due to three processes:

1. Gyrosynchrotron from active stellar magnetosphere

2. Free-free emission from ionized outflows

3. Thermal emission from circumstellar disks

No extinction. However, processes (2) and (3) produce extended sources. These emissions are not always present.

Page 5: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Very Large Array

0.1” resolution at 2 cm

Page 6: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

HEAVILY OBSCURED SOURCES:

• L1551 IRS5

• YLW 15

• L1527 (= IRAS 04368+2557)

• IRAS 16293-2422

Page 7: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

H

[SII]

Cont.

Reipurth & Bally 2001

ESO NTT

L1551 IRS5

Page 8: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Free-free from ionized outflow dominates cm range, while thermal emission from dust in disk dominates mm range

Page 9: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks
Page 10: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

L1551 IRS5 VLA-A 2 cm

Page 11: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks
Page 12: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Proper Motions

• Large proper motions due to large scale motion of region with respect to Sun and agree very well with Jones & Herbig (1979)

• However, proper motions not identical for N and S components, indicating relative (orbital) motions

Page 13: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks
Page 14: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Orbital Proper Motions

• Observed changes in separation and position angle imply relative velocity in the plane of the sky of 2.3+-0.5 km/s

• A (very) conservative lower limit to the total mass can be derived from (M/Msun)>0.5 (V/30 km/s)^2 (R/AU)

• We obtain (M/Msun)>0.1

Page 15: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

An attempt to correct for projection effects...

• Assume plane of orbit parallel to plane of disks (Bate et al. 2000)

• Circular orbit

• => M = 1.2 Msun; P = 260 yr

• In the main sequence, luminosity will be of order 1 solar luminosity, while now Lbol is of order 30 Lsun => accretion main source of luminosity

Page 16: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

YLW 15 VLA-A 3.5 cm

1990.41

Page 17: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

2002.18

Page 18: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

YLW 15

Page 19: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

YLW 15

• Relative velocity in the plane of the sky of 6.4+-1.8 km/s, implying:

• M > 1.7 Msun

• Assuming observed separation is close to true separation, P < 360 yr

• Lbol = 13 Lsun

Page 20: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

L1527 VLA-A 7 mm

Page 21: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Relative Velocity in Plane of the Sky = 4+-2 km/s

M > 0.1 Msun, most likely 0.5 Msun

Lbol about 2.5 Lsun

Page 22: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Up to now, binary systems, what about multiples (i. e. triples)?

• IRAS 16293-2422

Page 23: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

IRAS 16293-2422, VLA-A, 3.5 cm, average proper motion subtracted

Page 24: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

IRAS 16293-2422

• Relative velocity of about 15 km/s and separation of about 30 AU between components A1 and A2, implies relatively large mass of about 4 Msun

• However, A1 has been proposed in the past to be shock with ambient medium

Page 25: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

CONCLUSIONS OF ORBITAL MOTIONS

• Orbital motions in protostars will provide important constraints on the early phases of stellar evolution

• We are getting reasonable results, but must follow “strange” cases such as IRAS 16293-2422

Page 26: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

What do we know about protoplanetary disks?

• Radii of 100s of AU in T Tauri stars.

• They last between 2 and 10 million years.

• But little is known about their formation, about their earliest stages.

• It can be argued theoretically that the disks should start small and grow with time…

Page 27: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

The binary disks in L1551 IRS5 are much smaller than the disks found around T Tauri stars, but their small size is most likely due to tidal truncation.

Other small disks found are also part of binary systems…

Page 28: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Anglada et al. (2004)

Page 29: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

IRAS 04368+2557 = L1527

VLA-A 7 mm

Page 30: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

VLA 7 mm

Page 31: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Detailed modeling of disk allows estimate of parameters:

Disk Mass= 0.3-0.4 solar masses.

Disk Radius = 26 AU.

Page 32: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

But…B

A

Page 33: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Conclusions on Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

• Given multiplicity in star formation it will be hard to find truly isolated protoplanetary disks to study their evolution, without the effects of companion stars.

Page 34: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

OMC-1S: A Cluster in Formation

• SMA and VLA observations of OMC1S: part of Ph. D. Thesis of Luis Zapata (see his poster).

Page 35: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Optical image of O´Dell & Doi (2003).

OMC-1S is a region with bolometric luminosity of 10,000 solar luminosities from which many optical outflows emanate.

Page 36: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

VLA-A 3.6 cm

Zapata et al. (2004)

Page 37: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

VLA-B 1.3 cm

Hypercompact HII Regions Ionized by Early B-type stars?

Page 38: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Higher angular resolution VLA-A observations at 7-mm reveal that at least two of the sources are close binaries: 139-409 and 134-411.

Page 39: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks
Page 40: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks
Page 41: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks
Page 42: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

SMA SiO (5-4)

Page 43: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

Molecular Outflows in OMC-1S

• Highly collimated, young CO outflow.

• Multiple SiO outflows.

• CO and SiO observations complementary: the CO outflow is not evident in SiO and viceversa.

Page 44: Centimeter and Millimeter Observations of Very Young Binary and Multiple Systems -Orbital Motions and Mass Determination -Truncated Protoplanetary Disks

The Next Frontiers in Star Formation

• With the availability of the SMA and the future construction of other interferometers we will start to study star formation with new frontiers:

• Binary and multiple star formation• Star formation in the extremes (very massive stars

and brown dwarfs)• Starbursts and cosmological star formation (the

first stars)