central electricity regulatory … · aman & diu wrts-i, ritinagar n manager, b ltd, sum...
TRANSCRIPT
Order
Date
In thApprreguof R2009to 31 AIn th
P
(A) U
1
2
3
4
5
678
9
r in Petition N
CENTR
e of Hearin
he matter oroval underlation 4 of
Regional Lo9 for WRLD1.3.2014 And
he matter oPower Grid
Vs
Users und
. Managin492013.
. ChairmaVadodar
. ChairmaBhavan,
. Managin400051.
. Chief ElGoa, Vid
. Secretar
. Secretar
. ExecutivO Uppalw
. AdditionaCorporatBhadrava
o. 92/2010
RAL ELEC
Coram:
g: 29.7.20
of: r subsectionCentral Ele
oad DespatDC Charges
of: Corporation
er the cate
g Director, n, GUVNL,
ra-390 007.n&Managin Vidyut Nag Director,
ectrical Engdyut Bhavanry(P), UT ofry , UT of De Director ,wadi, Sampal General tion of Indiaathi, Chand
TRICITY RNEW
Petition
: Dr. PraShri S.JShri V.Shri M.
010
n (4) of secectricity Retch Centre s (POSOCO
n of India L
egory of Di
CSPTCL, P
Sardar Pa
ng Director,gar, Rampu, MSEDCL,
gineer, Goan, 3rd Floor,f Dadra Naaman & Diu, WRTS-I, pritinagar NManager, Ba Ltd, Sumdrapur(Dist)
REGULATOW DELHI
No. 92/201
amod Deo, JayaramanS.Verma, M.Deena Day
ction 28 of gulatory Coand other
O Portion) f
Ltd
istribution
P.O. Sunde
atel Vidyut B
, M.P Poweur, Jabalpu, Prakashga
a Electricity, Panaji, Goagar Haveli,u, Moti DamPower Grid
Nagpur.440 Bhadravaththana Villag), Maharash
ORY COMM
10
Chairpersn, MemberMember yalan, Mem
Date of O
Electricity ommission r related mfor the con
Licensees
ernagar, Da
Bhavan, Ra
er Trading Cur-482008 ad, Bandra
y Departmeoa. , Silvassa-man. d Corporatio026 i HVDC, Poge, Bhadrahtra-442 90
MISSION
son r
mber
Order: 11.
Act 2003 r(fees and
matters) Retrol period
……Petit
s and Buye
angania, Ra
ace Course
Co.Ltd, Sha
(East), Mu
ent, Govern
396230.
on of India
ower Grid avathi(Tahs02
Pag
3.2011
read with charges gulations 1.4.2009
tioner
ers
aipur-
,
akti
umbai-
ment of
Ltd., P
il),
ge 1 of 33
Order
1
(B)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
r in Petition N
0. AdditionaCorporatSingrauli
Users und
1. General P.O.Vika
2. General Power CSidhi(Dis
3. General Power CSidhi(Dis
4. General Power CSidhi(Dis
5. General Power C
6. General Power CGujarat-
7. General of India
8. Station DCorporat504
9. Station DCorporat504
0. Station DCorporat651
1. Member(No.78, V
2. ExecutivPower PChattisga
3. General No. 397,
4. Chief ExOffice,ShAhameda
o. 92/2010
al General tion of Indiai(Dist), Mad
der the cat
Manager, Kas Bhavan, Manager, S
Corporation st),Madhya Manager, S
Corporation st),Madhya Manager, S
Corporation st),Madhya Manager,
Corporation Manager, G
Corporation 392215 Manager, SLtd, SIPATDirector, Tation of India
Director,Tartion of India
Director, Kation of India
(Power), NCVijayanagare Director, lant, Villagearh- 496 10Manager(CPhase-III,
ecutive Offhikhar, 9th abad- 380 0
Manager, Va Ltd, P.O.Vdhya Prade
tegory of G
Korba STPSJamnipali,
STAGE-I, V of India LtPradesh –
STAGE-II, Vof India LtdPradesh –
STAGE-III, of India LtdPradesh –Kawas Gasof India Lt
Gandhar Gof India Lt
SIPAT TPST, Chhattisgarapur Atoma Ltd, P.O.T
rapur Atoma Ltd, P.O.T
akrapar Atoa Ltd, Anum
CA,EMC O, Indore -45Jindal Powe & P.O:Ta07 Comml), LAUdyog Viha
ficer , AdanFloor, Near009
VindhayachVindhyanagsh-486 885
Generating
S, NationalKorba(Dist
Vindhayachd, P.O Vind486 885
Vindhayachd ,P.O Vind486 885 Vindhayac
d, P.O Vind486 885
s Power Prd , P.O.Adias Power Pd, P.O.NTP
S, National Tgarh. mic Power STAPP, Than
ic Power StTAPP, Than
omic Powermala.P.o, Vi
Office, D ¾, 52010 wer Limited,mnar, Tehs
ANCO Amarar, Gurgaoni Power Limr Mithakhal
hal HVDC, gar, P.Box.5
Stations a
Thermal Pt), Chhattisgal STPS, Ndhyanagar,
hal STPS, Nhyanagar,
chal STPS, hyanagar,
roject, Natiotya Nagar,S
Project, NatPC Townsh
Thermal Po
Station 1&2ne(Dist), Ma
tation 3&4, ne(Dist), Ma
r Station, Nia Vyara, S
Narmada C
, O.P.Jindasil:Ghargho
rkantak Pown- 122016,
mited, Regisi Road, Nav
Power Grid.No.12,
and Sellers
Power Corpgarh- 495 4
National The
National Th
National Th
onal ThermSurat- 394 tional Thermip, Bharuch
ower Corpo
2, Nuclear aharashtra-
Nuclear Paharashtra-
Nuclear Powurat, Gujara
Colony Sch
l Super Theoda, Dist: R
wer Pvt. LtdHaryana stered varangpura
Pag
d
s
oration, 450 ermal
hermal
hermal
al 516 mal h(Dist),
oration
Power - 401
Power - 401
wer at-395
eme,
ermal Raigarh,
d.,Plot
a,
ge 2 of 33
Order
(C)U2
The
12345678911111
T
beha
appr
Cent
secti
Act”)
(fees
matte
regu
(a) A
p
r in Petition N
sers unde5. Executiv
O Uppalw
following w
. Shri S.K.
. Shri U.K
. Shri N.S
. Shri Sun
. Shri M.M
. Shri Pras
. Shri R.K
. Shri Mah
. Shri S.S.0. Shri V.V.1. Shri S.R2. Shri V.K.3. Shri M.L4. Shri S.K.
This petition
alf of the
oval of th
tre(WRLDC
on (4) of S
) read with
s and char
ers) Regu
lations”). T
Approve the
ara 9 of the
o. 92/2010
r the catege Director ,wadi, Samp
were prese
.Soonee, C
.Tyagi, PGC
.Sodha, PGil Kumar, P
M.Mondal, Pshant Sharm.Gupta, PG
hesh Kuma.Raju, PGC.Sharma, N.Narasimha.Padha, NT.Jadav, NP.Meena, NH
n has been
Power Sy
e fees an
C) for the
ection 28 o
h Regulatio
rges of Re
lations 20
The petition
e charges
e petition.
gory of Inte, WRTS-I, pritinagar N
ent:
CEO,POSOCIL
GCIL PGCIL PGCIL ma, PGCIL
GCIL r, PGCIL
CIL NLDC an, WRLDCTPC PCIL HPC
O
n filed by P
ystem Ope
nd charges
control pe
of Electricity
on 4 of Ce
egional Lo
09 (herein
ner has sou
for WRLDC
er State TrPower Grid
Nagpur.440
CO
L
C
ORDER
Power Grid
ration Cor
s of Weste
riod 1.4.20
y Act 2003
entral Elect
ad Despat
nafter refer
ught the foll
C for the c
ransmissiod Corporatio026 …
d Corporati
rporation L
ern Region
009 to 31.3
(hereinafte
tricity Regu
tch Centre
rred to as
lowing relie
control peri
on Licenseon of India
… Respon
on of India
Ltd. (POSO
nal Load D
3.2014 und
er referred t
ulatory Com
and othe
s “the RL
efs:
iod 2009-1
Pag
es Ltd., P
dents
a Ltd. on
OCO) for
Despatch
der Sub-
to as “the
mmission
r related
DC fees
4 as per
ge 3 of 33
Order
(b) A
(c) A
c
d
(d) A
s
(e) A
re
2
(f) A
b
(g) A
in
p
(h) A
fo
c
(i) A
P
(j) P
a
ju
2.
India
direc
r in Petition N
Approve the
Allow the p
hange in in
uring 2009
Allow the p
eparately fr
Allow the p
evision of p
009-14 per
Allow the pe
uilding whe
Approve the
n Newspap
etition.
Allow Power
or WRLDC
ommencem
Allow petiti
POSOCO as
Pass such
ppropriate
ustice.
POSOCO
a Ltd., the
ctives of G
o. 92/2010
e CAPEX as
etitioner to
nterest rate
-14, if any.
petitioner to
rom the res
petitioner to
pay in case
riod, if any,
etitioner to
ere WRLDC
e reimburse
pers and ot
rgrid on beh
and allow
ment of bus
oner to b
s one time
other ord
in these c
O is a who
petitioner
overnment
s mentioned
o bill and a
e on accou
o bill and
spondents,
o bill and
e of non-exe
from the re
bill and adj
C and other
ement of ex
ther expen
half of POS
w POSOCO
siness of PO
bill and re
charges fro
der as the
circumstan
olly owned
herein. P
of India a
d in para 8
adjust impa
unt of floati
recover Se
if petitioner
adjust imp
ecutives w
espondents
just impact
r associated
xpenditure
nditure (if a
SOCO to ra
O to raise b
OSOCO.
ecover Pr
om the user
e Hon’ble
ces of the
subsidiary
POSOCO h
as containe
of the petit
act of inter
ng rate of
ervice Tax
r is subjecte
pact on HR
ith effect fr
s.
t on transfe
d facilities a
towards p
any) in rela
aise bills an
bills and re
re-incorpora
rs.
Commissi
e case and
of Power
has been c
ed in letter
tion.
rest on loa
interest a
on RLDC
ed to such
R expenses
rom 1.1.200
er of buildin
are located
ublishing o
ation to the
d receive p
eceive paym
ation expe
on deems
d in the in
Grid Corpo
created as
No-41/20/
Pag
n due to
applicable
charges
tax.
s due to
07 during
ng/part of
of notices
e filing of
payments
ments on
enses of
s fit and
nterest of
oration of
s per the
2005-PG
ge 4 of 33
Order
dated
Desp
per t
funct
3.
centr
territ
exerc
RLD
estab
the C
Regi
r in Petition N
d 4.7.2008
patch Centr
the said le
tions:
(a) To sup
manpo
executi
POSOC
(b) To act
NLDC a
(c) To ens
smooth
(d) To coo
(e) To adv
special
(f) To perf
Section 2
re for each
orial jurisdi
cising the
Cs shall be
blished or c
Commissio
onal Load
o. 92/2010
8 for indep
re (NLDC) a
etter dated
pervise and
wer require
ives workin
CO.
as the ape
and RLDCs
sure plannin
h operation
rdinate the
vise and as
ized trainin
form any ot
27 of the A
region to b
iction as de
powers an
e operated
constituted
on. Sectio
Despatch C
pendent sy
and Region
4.7.2008,
d control,
ement of R
ng with RLD
ex organiza
s,
ng and imp
and develo
functioning
ssist state
ng etc.
ther functio
Act provides
be known a
etermined
nd discharg
by Governm
by or und
on 28 of th
Centre whic
ystem ope
nal Load De
POSOCO
all aspect
RLDCs and
DCs and NL
ation for hu
plementatio
opment of N
g of NLDC a
level Load
n entrusted
s that the C
s Regional
by the Cen
ging the fu
ment comp
er any cen
he Act dea
ch is extract
eration of
espatch Ce
shall disch
s concerni
NLDC. All
LDC will be
uman resou
n of infrast
NLDC and R
and RLDCs
d Despatch
d to it by the
Central Go
Load Desp
ntral Govt.
unctions un
pany or auth
ntral Act as
als with th
ted as unde
the Nation
entres (RLD
harge the
ing operati
the employ
e from the c
urce requir
tructure req
RLDCs,
s,
h Centres
e Ministry o
vt. shall es
patch Centr
for the pur
nder the A
hority or co
may be no
he function
er:
Pag
nal Load
DCs). As
following
ions and
yees and
cadres of
ement of
quired for
including
of Power.
stablish a
re having
rposes of
Act. The
orporation
otified by
ns of the
ge 5 of 33
Order
4.
to e
WRL
and
stabi
effici
respo
of el
and t
5.
a uni
proje
r in Petition N
“Section 2Load Desppower sys (2) The Reand methoof electrici (3) The Re (a) be resregion, in generating (b) monitor (c) keep ac (d) exercis (e) be respof electricigrid in acc (4) The Refrom the gelectricity a Wester
nsure inte
LDC is emp
exercise a
ility of grid
ency of th
onsible for
ectricity ov
the Grid Co
Establish
ified projec
ect. Under
o. 92/2010
28. (Functionpatch Centre tem in the con
egional Load odologies in rty as the Cen
egional Load D
sponsible for accordance
g companies o
r grid operatio
ccounts of qu
se supervision
ponsible for city within the cordance with
egional Load generating coas may be sp
rn Regiona
grated ope
powered un
and supervi
d operation
he power s
carrying ou
ver inter-reg
ode.
hment of RL
t under the
this projec
ns of Regionshall be the
ncerned regio
Despatch Cerespect of thentral Commiss
Despatch Ce
r optimum scwith the co
operating in th
ons;
uantity of elec
n and control
carrying out rregion througthe Grid Stan
Despatch Ceompanies or lpecified by the
l Load Des
eration of
nder Sectio
ision and c
n and for
system in
ut real time
gional links
LDCs and S
Unified Lo
ct, Remote
nal Load Desapex body to
on.
entre shall come wheeling ansion may spec
ntre shall –
cheduling andontracts entehe region;
ctricity transmi
over the inter
real time opergh secure andndards and th
entre may levlicensees enge Central Com
spatch Cen
the Weste
n 29(1) of t
control as
achieving
the Weste
e operations
s in accord
SLDCs was
oad Despatc
Terminal
spatch Centro ensure inte
mply with sucnd optimum sccify in the Gri
d despatch ored into with
itted through
r-State transm
rations for grid economic ohe Grid Code.
vy and collecgaged in inte
mmission.”
tre (WRLD
ern Region
the Act to g
may be re
the maxim
ern Region
s for grid co
ance with
s taken up
ch and com
Units (RTU
re): --- (1) Thegrated opera
ch principles, cheduling andid Code.
of electricity h the license
the regional g
mission system
rid control andoperation of th.
ct such fee aner-State trans
C) is the ap
nal Power
give such d
equired for
mum econo
. WRLDC
ontrol and d
the Grid S
by the peti
mmunication
Us) and as
Pag
e Regional ation of the
guidelines d despatch
within the ees or the
grid;
m; and
d despatch he regional
nd charges smission of
pex body
System.
directions
ensuring
omy and
C is also
despatch
Standards
itioner as
n (ULDC)
ssociated
ge 6 of 33
Order
equip
were
for d
ULD
effec
sect
6.
r in Petition N
pments we
e installed a
ata/speech
C scheme
ct from 1.2
tor portion
The scop
(i) Es
Su
M
Co
Ce
(ii) Re
su
(iii) Ad
th
(iv) As
op
se
(v) Au
Su
co
ce
o. 92/2010
re installed
at control c
h communic
of WRLD
2.2006 at a
n of ` 1057
pe of work u
stablishmen
upervisory
anagemen
oordination
entre and S
emote Term
ubstations a
daptation w
e requirem
ssociated d
ptic, microw
ector.
uxiliary pow
upply (UPS
ontrol centr
entres for co
at the sub
centres. Co
cation betw
C was dec
a cost of `
76 lakh.
under ULD
nt of Contro
Control an
t System (
n Centre
State Load
minal Units
and genera
work at sub
ent of data
dedicated c
wave and
wer supply
S) and 48 V
res at som
ommunicat
bstations, ha
ommunicatio
ween substa
clared und
` 17703
C scheme w
ol Centres
d Data Acq
(EMS) whi
(RSCC), C
Despatch C
(RTUs) at
ating station
bstation an
acquisition
communica
PLCC ter
system co
V DC power
me wideban
tion equipm
ardware an
on network
ations and c
er comme
lakh inclu
was as und
at Regiona
quisition (S
ch includes
Central Pr
Centres and
various 400
ns.
d generatin
n through R
ation netwo
rminals for
omprising U
r supply are
nd location
ment.
nd software
k systems w
control cen
rcial opera
uding the
der:
al and State
SCADA) and
s Regional
roject Coo
d sub LDCs
0 kV/220 kV
ng stations
RTUs.
ork compris
r state and
Uninterrupte
e provided
ns including
Pag
systems
were laid
tres. The
ation with
central
e level for
d Energy
l System
ordination
s.
V/132 kV
s to meet
sing fibre
d central
ed Power
at all the
g control
ge 7 of 33
Order
7.
by th
The
the t
How
imple
short
sche
Task
Finan
augm
emol
recom
ment
r in Petition N
(vi) Ot
fig
Tariff for
he Commis
petitioner h
time of co
ever, in v
ementation
ter life spa
eme. It has
k Force un
nce Corpo
mentation a
luments f
mmendatio
tioned over
(a) Ow
pr
of
st
an
Ho
ac
o. 92/2010
ther infras
ghting, cons
r the WR-U
ssion vide
has submit
mmissionin
view of the
of ABT an
an of the
s been furth
nder the ch
ration of I
and upgrada
for perso
ons of the T
rleaf.
wnership o
remises the
f existing a
ations and
nd STUs/SE
owever, in
ctual entitie
structural f
struction/re
ULDC for th
its order d
ted that the
ng was con
e fast cha
nd fast obs
SCADA/E
her submitte
hairmanshi
ndia Limite
ation of Loa
onnel eng
Task Force
of new RTU
ese RTUs w
as well as w
state secto
EBs respec
due cours
es can be pl
facilities su
novation of
he period u
ated 7.11.2
e SCADA/E
nsidered to
anging pow
solescence
EMS system
ed that Gov
p of Shri
ed to look
ad Despatc
gaged in
regarding
Us should r
would be lo
work-in-pro
or stations,
ctively as p
e of time,
lanned by m
uch as ai
f buildings,
up to 31.3.2
2008 in Pe
EMS system
o be havin
wer sector
of technol
m installed
vernment o
Satnam S
into the f
ch Centre a
System
ownership
rest with th
ocated. Re
ogress RTU
these coul
per the prev
modalities
mutual cons
r-conditioni
etc.
2009 was a
etition No.
m commiss
ng life of 1
scenario
ogy has re
d under th
f India cons
Singh, CMD
financial as
and issues r
Operatio
of ULDC a
he entities i
egarding o
US in centr
d rest with
vailing arran
for their tr
sent.
Pag
ing, fire-
approved
11/2007.
sioned at
5 years.
in India,
esulted in
e ULDC
stituted a
D, Power
spects of
related to
on. The
assets as
in whose
wnership
ral sector
the CTU
ngement.
ansfer to
ge 8 of 33
Order
8.
recom
years
Main
Janu
upto
optim
have
9. T
Task
EMS
other
its st
be tr
r in Petition N
(b) Th
sy
be
ST
LD
sy
(c) Th
lo
SL
m
The pet
mmended
s for norm
ntenance C
uary 2013, i
2014 wit
mization in t
e to undergo
The petition
k Force, the
S functions
r infrastruct
tatutory fun
ransferred,
o. 92/2010
he respons
ystem from
etween con
TUs/SEBs.
DCs can as
ystem from
he comput
cated in t
LDC/Sub-L
anaging the
titioner ha
a life span
mal IT syst
Contract w
t would be
th some u
terms of res
o a major u
ner has sub
e control ce
alongwith
ture facilitie
nctions out
committee
sibility of ow
substation
ntrol centre
However,
ssess, plan
other telec
ter system
the control
LDCs shou
ese LDCs.
s further
of 5 to 7
tems. Sinc
with the O
just possib
upgradation
sources, an
upgradation
bmitted tha
entre at the
the associ
es would be
of the scop
s comprisin
wning and
n to the nea
es should c
, in case of
n and take
com service
m along w
centre bu
ld be tran
submitted
years for t
e the pres
Original Equ
ble to meet
ns in the
nd beyond t
n/replaceme
t in line wit
e regional le
iated powe
e transferre
pe of ULDC
ng the mem
providing
arest contro
continue to
f any specia
on lease s
e providers
ith softwar
uilding of
sferred to
that the
the system
sent system
uipment M
the grid op
present s
that, the pr
ent.
th the recom
evel (RSCC
er supply, a
ed to the RL
C. For iden
mbers of Ce
the comm
ol centre a
be that of
al requirem
such comm
also.
re and pe
NLDC/RLD
respective
Task Fo
in operatio
m is unde
Manufacture
peration req
system an
esent syste
mmendatio
C) with SCA
air conditio
LDC for dis
tifying the a
entral Tran
Pag
unication
s well as
f CTU or
ments, the
unication
eripherals
DCs and
e entities
rce also
on and 3
r Annual
er up to
quirement
nd some
em would
ons of the
ADA and
ning and
scharging
assets to
nsmission
ge 9 of 33
Order
Utility
comm
ident
1.4.2
15.4
POS
on 3
the a
subm
are b
value
fees
31.3
place
Acco
asse
abov
10.
WRL
r in Petition N
y and RL
mittees, the
tified and b
2009 were f
.2010 app
SOCO as o
1.3.2009 w
actual trans
mitted vide
being main
e as on 1.4
and char
.2014. The
ed on recor
ountant sho
ets in ER-W
ve Affidavit.
The petit
LDC in its a
Depreciation Interest on LoReturn on equInterest on WO & M ExpenHuman ResoHuman ResoNLDC ChargeOffice Expens
o. 92/2010
DCs were
e assets fo
book value
finalized. T
roved the
n 1.4.2009
would be fu
sfer to be
its affidavit
tained as p
4.2009. Ac
rges of W
e petitioner
rd a copy o
owing the s
WULDC as
tioner has c
ffidavit date
oan uity
Working Capital ses Excludingurce Expensesurce Expenseses and Corporases
Total
constitute
or transfer
s of the as
The Board o
book valu
and it was
urther upda
effected fro
t dated 26.
per the RLD
cordingly, t
WRLDC for
r, vide its re
of the certif
segregation
on 1.4.200
claimed the
ed 12.7.201
200947
318
8g s
32
s 109ate 80
299
ed and ba
r to POSO
ssets (gros
of Power G
ue of the
s also deci
ated to 31.3
om 1.4.201
.8.2010 tha
DC fees reg
the petition
r the cont
eply under
ficate dated
n of assets
09 which is
e following f
10:
9-10 2010-14.04 485.5.86 20.1.03 184.3.72 105.4.02 546.
2.49 1332.0.89 1050.
2.04 3725.
ased on th
CO(NLDC
ss block an
Grid in its 23
assets to
ded that bo
3.2010 befo
10. The pe
at separate
gulations b
has been
trol period
affidavit da
d 4.7.2010
s and open
placed as
fees and ch
11 2011-1208 531.5642 19.8792 224.1898 124.9387 658.25
20 1576.5948 1244.09
95 4379.48
he report
and RLDC
nd net bloc
35th meeting
be transf
ook value o
ore proceed
etitioner ha
e books of
based on th
filed for ap
from 1.4
ated 12.7.2
from the C
ning capita
Annexure-
harges in re
(` in lakh2012-13
6 838.07 7 30.14 8 303.81 3 152.87 5 793.60
9 1893.35 9 1421.35
8 5433.19
Page
of these
Cs) were
ck) as on
g held on
ferred to
of assets
ding with
as further
accounts
he assets
pproval of
.2009 to
2010, has
Chartered
al cost of
-III to the
espect of
h) 2013-14 1022.27
35.97 403.32 175.58 961.27
2198.48 1482.19
6279.07
e 10 of 33
Order
11.
capit
NLO HRHuRe
RaInt
12.
13.
proce
14.
trans
for th
the
regu
Regi
the tr
CAP
15.
r in Petition N
The peti
tal:
LDC charges & M expense
R expenses)uman Resoureceivable
Toate of Interestterest
None of
Having h
eed to disp
Consider
sition, we h
he tariff per
petitions fi
lations. Ho
on upto th
ransfer, bill
PITAL COS
Regulatio
“(1) Capitaincurred oDuring CoForeign EExpenditur
Provided th
o. 92/2010
tioner has
es (excluding
rce expenses
otal t
the respond
heard the p
pose of the
ring the fac
have decide
riod 2009-1
iled in acc
owever, PG
e date of t
ing shall be
T
n 6 of the R
al cost for a Ror projected onstruction (IDExchange Rare During Con
hat the value
also claim
2009-10
66.7427.00
91.04498.67683.46
12.25%83.72
dents have
parties and
petition.
ct that the s
ed that cha
4 shall be d
cordance w
GCIL shall
transfer of
e made on
RLDC fees
Regional Loato be incurreDC) and finaate Variationnstruction (IE
of the assets
med the foll
0 2010-11
4 87.540 45.57
4 111.027 620.996 865.12
% 12.25%2 105.98
e filed any re
d examined
separation
rges of PO
determined
with the p
bill the b
assets to P
the benefic
regulations
ad Despatch Cred during thancing chargen (FERV) d
EDC) in line wi
s not in use sh
owing as I
2011-12
103.6754.85
131.38729.91
1019.82 112.25% 1
124.93
eply to the
d the mate
of POSOC
OSOCO i.e.
d by the Co
provisions o
eneficiaries
POSOCO (
ciaries/user
s provides
Centre shall ihe control pees, any gain
during constrwith the CAPEX
hall not form p
nterest on
(` in lakh2012-13 20
118.45 1266.13 8
157.78 18905.53 104
1247.89 14312.25% 12.152.87 17
petition.
erial on rec
CO from PG
NLDC and
ommission b
of the RL
s/users of
(WRLDC) a
rs by WRLD
as under:
include the eeriod, includin
or loss on ruction, and
EX plan:
part of capita
Page
Working
h) 013-14
23.52 80.11
83.21 46.51 33.34 .25% 75.58
cords, we
GCIL is in
d RLDCs
based on
DC fees
Western
and after
DC.
expenditure ng Interest account of Incidental
l cost.
e 11 of 33
Order
16.
contr
Expenupto
31.3.22556.
17.
supp
`255
of fe
petiti
19.
inclu
asse
with
The
RLD
the fe
r in Petition N
(2) The cabasis for d
Provided tcapital exprun and timthe Comm Provided fSystem OpNational LCAPEX pla
The peti
rol period 2
nditure
2009 200995
The petitio
port of its
56.95lakh,
ees and ch
ioner has b
It is not
des cost o
ets not in us
proviso to
petitioner is
C fees regu
ees and ch
o. 92/2010
apital cost admdetermination
that prudencpenditure, finame over-run,
mission:
further that thperation Com
Load Dispatchan for the con
tioner has
2009-14:
Balance e
9-10 2016.00
oner has
s claim o
which has
arges of W
been consid
ticed that t
of replacem
se has not
Regulation
s directed t
ulations and
arges allow
mitted by the of charges:
e check mayancing plan, Iand such oth
e capital costmpany for theh Centre as ntrol period sh
claimed the
estimated exp
0-11 201101.00
submitted
of capital
s been con
WRLDC. C
dered under
the capital
ment of cer
been remo
n 6(1) of R
to comply w
d file the ne
wed under t
Commission
y include scrIDC, IEDC, uher matters a
t appearing ine respective Ron the date hall be the ba
e following
enditure durin
11-12 20979.00
Auditor’s
cost as
sidered for
CAPEX of
r additional
expenditu
rtain assets
oved from t
RLDC fees
with the req
ecessary de
this order.
n after pruden
rutiny of the use of efficiens may be con
n the books oRegional Loaof transfer al
asis for determ
capital exp
ng 2009-14
012-13 201211.00
certificate
on 1.4.20
r the purpo
` 3823 lak
capital exp
re projecte
s. Howeve
the capital
regulations
quirement o
etails at the
nce check sha
reasonablent technology,nsidered app
f accounts of ad Dispatch Clong with the
mination of ch
penditure d
(`Tee
013-14 31526.00 6
dated 4.7
009 amou
se of deter
kh projecte
penditure.
ed by the p
er, the valu
base in acc
s as quote
of Regulatio
e time of tru
Page
all form the
ess of the cost over-ropriate by
f the Power Centre and e approved harges.”
uring the
` in lakh) Total estimated expenditure31.3.2014 6379.95
.2010 in
unting to
rmination
ed by the
petitioner
ue of the
cordance
d above.
on 6(1) of
uing up of
e 12 of 33
Order
ADD
20.
21.
for W
recom
Satn
a CA
2009
CAPES. No.1
2 3 4
22.
by th
and w
r in Petition N
DITIONAL C
Regulatio
“7. Additibe incurreby the Com Provided tand tacklewashing mof commedeterminat
The petit
WRLDC has
mmendatio
am Singh.
APEX of ` 7
9-14 with ye
EX AS PER TH. Item
Control upgradationOff-line sysInfrastructuTotal
The petit
he manage
would be in
(a) Re
ATC/TTC
expansio
(b) Pr
system o. 92/2010
CAPITAL E
on 7 of the
ional Capitald after the dammission, sub
that any expees, furniture, amachines, heaercial operatiotion of fees an
tioner in its
s been plan
ons of G B
It has bee
74.35 crore
ear-wise bre
E RECOMMEN200
Centre n tem re
tioner has
ment keepi
ncurred for
eplacemen
C estimati
on involving
rocurement
involving
EXPENDITU
RLDC fees
lisation. - (1)ate of commebject to prude
enditure on aair-conditioneat convectorson shall not nd charges.”
s affidavit 1
nned in line
B Pradhan
en submitte
s for a typic
eak up und
NDATIONS OF09-10 2010
920 12
310 450 2
1680 1
submitted
ing in view
the followin
t of SCA
on, integr
g an estima
t of server
an estima
URE
s regulation
) The capital ercial operatioence check:
cquiring the mrs, voltage st
s, mattressest be conside
2.7.2010 h
e with the R
Committee
ed that the T
cal load dis
der the follow
F SATNAM SIN0-11 2011-200 26
85 280 1565 28
that its CA
the recom
ng:
ADA/EMS,
ration of
ted expend
rs and othe
ated expe
ns provides
expenditure ion may, in its
minor items otabilizers, refrs, carpets etcred for addi
has submitt
RLDC fees
e and Task
Task Force
spatch cent
wing major
NGH REPORT-12 2012-13650 350
85 14545 185
880 680
APEX plan
mendations
web bas
WAMS w
diture of ` 3
er Hardwa
nditure of
as under:
incurred or ps discretion, b
or the assetsrigerators, coo. brought afteitional capital
ted that the
regulations
k Force un
e has recom
tre during th
r heads as u
(` in T 3 2013-14 0 350
5 125 5 155 0 630
has been a
s of the Ta
sed applic
with EMS,
3200 lakh;
re items fo
` 423 lPage
rojected to be admitted
s like tools olers, fans, er the date lization for
e CAPEX
s and the
nder Shri
mmended
he period
under:
lakh)
Total 5470
750 1215 7435
approved
ask Force
cation of
WAMS
or the IT
lakh. for e 13 of 33
Order
23.
DescInfrasOff-linHardwContrupgra
Total
24.
subm
appli
25.
the l
addu
RLD
analy
r in Petition N
customis
data bas
(c) Ci
in a ph
manpow
The deta
ription
structure (civilne software ware rol adation(EMS?
Subsequ
mitted the
icable for th
We hav
light of the
uced in su
Cs under t
ysis of the C
(a) EM
and also
o. 92/2010
sed develo
sed manage
ivil works a
hased man
er augmen
ails of CAPE
works) and nece
C?SCADA/TTC
uently, the
detailed br
he CAPEX
ve conside
e provision
pport of th
the Act and
CAPEX pla
MS/SCADA
o there wa
pment of s
ement, wea
at an estima
nner for c
tation as pe
EX plan pro
2009-1
0 ssary 6
Centre C/ATC
0
6
petitioner
reak-up of
projected fo
red the CA
s of the R
he claim a
d various r
an submitted
A: Since th
as a proble
systems fo
ather foreca
ated cost of
reating ex
er Pradhan
ojected by t
10 2010-11
0 29
72
101
vide its
hardware
or the contr
APEX plan
RLDC fees
and the res
regulations
d by the pe
here is fast
em in gett
or market o
asting, syste
f ` 200 lak
xtra office
Committee
the petitione
2011-12 201
0 10259 96
720 10
979 12
affidavit da
and softw
rol period 2
submitted
regulation
sponsibilitie
of the Com
etitioner is a
t obsolesce
ing the AM
operation,
em analysis
kh, to be ca
space con
e report.
er are as un
(` in lakh12-13 2013-1
0 100 33
15 1393
11 1526
ated 3.1.2
ware compo
2009-14.
by the pet
ns, the just
es entruste
mmission.
as under:
ence of te
MC suppor
Page
common
s;
arried out
nsidering
nder:
h) 4 Total
200 423
3200
3823
011 has
onent as
titioner in
tifications
ed to the
Detailed
chnology
rt for the
e 14 of 33
Orderr in Petition N
existing
SCADA,
(b) IT
crime w
emphasi
system a
is allowe
not allow
Sub-hea
Firewall (
(c) De
is not allo
(d) Co
submitte
Open Ac
of Loca
Commiss
services
already
emerging
(e) Co
expansio
252/2009
o. 92/2010
EMS/SCAD
based on t
T security sy
world-wide,
s. These
and Firewa
ed. Howeve
wed due to t
ds of Ant
(hardware)
esktop PCs
owed as Re
ost of Inte
d that the a
ccess (STO
tion Margi
sion has a
and LMP M
in service
g requireme
ost of Inte
on: The Co
9 filed by
DA system
the budgeta
ystem: In th
importance
consist of
ll (hardwar
er, an amou
the fact tha
tivirus soft
.
s: An amou
egulation 7
egration o
amount is r
OA), adminis
inal Partic
allowed on
Method. Sin
e may nee
ent, an amo
egration of
ommission,
WRLDC h
m, ` 25 Cr
ary support
he present
e of IT S
Antivirus
re). Accordi
unt of ` 2
at “cyber se
tware, Intr
unt of ` 50
(1) does n
f EMS &
required for
stration of a
cipation (LM
ly STOA t
nce operatio
ed upgrad
ount of ` 50
f EMS &
in order da
has sanctio
rore for rep
t of the vend
day scenar
ystem sec
software,
ingly, an am
Lakh unde
ecurity” gets
usion dete
0 lakh claim
ot provide f
MMS: T
r implemen
ancillary se
MP) Metho
transactions
onal STOA
ation in fu
0 lakh has b
WAMS an
ated 15.2.2
oned one-t
placement
dors is allow
rio of growi
curity hardl
Intrusion d
mount of `
r “cyber se
s covered u
ection syst
med under t
for the sam
The petitio
ntation of S
ervices and
od. Prese
s and not
A software w
uture to m
been allowe
nd Cost of
2010 in Pet
ime expen
Page
of EMS/
wed.
ing cyber
ly needs
detection
31 Lakh
ecurity” is
under the
tem and
this head
me.
oner has
hort-term
adoption
ntly, the
ancillary
which are
meet the
ed.
f WAMS
tition No.
nditure of
e 15 of 33
Orderr in Petition N
` 1097 la
lakh tow
WRPC)
project f
project is
WAMS e
until and
of ` 40 la
the year
complete
(f) M
would be
informati
MIS is al
(g) Da
capital e
the succe
requirem
Southern
received
Analytics
WRLDC
amount o
o. 92/2010
akh (` 876
wards the c
from the
for the We
s 3 years. W
expansion
unless the
akh is allow
r 2013-14,
ed.
anagemen
e utilized fo
on, project
lowed.
ata mining
xpenditure
essful oper
ment for ` 2
n Regional
a minimum
s which app
handles a
of ` 150 la
lakh towar
cost for ma
UI Surplus
estern Reg
We do not f
and of inte
e Pilot Proje
wed for integ
by which t
t Informati
or generat
ted amount
and Data
for this pu
ration of the
250 lakh in
Load Des
m quotation
pears to be
much bigg
akh will be
rds the part
aking data
s fund for
gion. The
find any jus
egration of
ect is comp
gration of W
time the P
ion System
ing valuabl
t of ` 50 la
Analytics: A
urpose as d
e real-time
n this rega
spatch Cen
n of ` 100 l
e prevalent
ger system
appropriate
t cost of the
available t
developme
scheduled
stification fo
WAMS wit
pleted. Acco
WAMS with
Pilot Project
m (MIS): S
le system
akh for the
All the RLD
data reposit
grid. WRLD
ard. It is ho
ntre (SRLD
lakh for Da
market rat
than SRLD
e for WRLD
e project a
to constitue
ent of Pilo
completio
or implemen
th the EMS
ordingly, an
h the EMS s
t is expect
Since MIS
and marke
developme
DCs have p
tory is impo
DC has proj
owever not
DC), Banga
ata mining a
te for such
DC, we fee
DC for deve
Page
nd ` 221
ents and
t WAMS
n of the
ntation of
S system
n amount
system in
ed to be
S system
et related
ent of the
proposed
ortant for
jected its
ticed that
alore has
and Data
jobs. As
el that an
elopment
e 16 of 33
Order
r in Petition N
of this s
capitalise
(h) W
requirem
job.
(i) W
the func
allowed.
(j) Ex
WRLDC
requirem
is allowe
(k) Ba
of the ele
backup c
is allowe
(l) W
projected
(m) Ph
strengthe
assessm
o. 92/2010
system and
ed.
Web based
ment of the W
Web based
ctional requ
xtra office
more per
ment of extra
d.
ackup cont
ectrical grid
control cen
d for the cr
Website De
d by the pet
hysical Se
ening and r
ment, only `
d the said
scheduling
WRLDC, an
system stu
uirement of
space: As
rsonnel are
a office spa
trol centre:
d. In view o
tre is allow
reation of B
velopment:
titioner for w
curity: The
ring fencing
10 lakh is a
d amount
g/ accountin
n amount o
udies, ATC
f WRLDC,
s per the f
e required
ace. Accord
RLDC ma
of the secu
wed. Accord
Backup cont
: An amo
website dev
e petitioner
g of compo
allowed for
is accordin
ng: Consid
of ` 20 Lak
C/TTC estim
an amou
functional
over the
dingly an a
anages the
rity reason
dingly an a
trol centre.
unt of `10
velopment.
r has claim
ound wall W
the purpos
ngly allowe
ering the f
kh is allowe
mation: Con
nt of ` 20
requiremen
years, res
mount of `
real-time o
s, expendit
mount of `
0 lakh is
med ` 30
WRLDC. As
e.
Page
ed to be
functional
ed for this
nsidering
0 lakh is
nt of the
sulting in
100 lakh
operation
ture for a
`100 lakh
allowed,
lakh for
s per our
e 17 of 33
Order
26.
to W
Detail
GrossAdditiexpenCapita
DEB
27. R
28.
the p
r in Petition N
In view o
Western Reg
ls
s Block onal Cap
nditure alloweal cost allowe
BT- EQUITY
Regulation 8
“8. Debt-Eaccounts aNational Lo (2) For andeployed treated as Provided tactual equ Provided fIndian rupe Explanatiowhile issuireserve, foDevelopmecapital for and interna
The follo
petitioner ha
o. 92/2010
of the abov
gional Load
As 31.3.202556.95
pital ed
ed
Y RATIO
8 of the RL
Equity Ratio.as on the dateoad Despatch
n investment is more thannormative loa
that where equity shall be co
further that thees on the da
on.- The preming share capor the fundingent Fund as the purpose al resources a
owing detail
ave been co
Particula
DebtEquityTotal
ve, the capit
Despatch
on 009
2009-10
5 2556.91.0
2557.9
LDC fees re
. - (1) The ace of transfer sh Centre and
made on or n 30% of thean:
quity actually onsidered for
he equity invate of each in
mium, if any, pital and invesg of the capita
approved byof computingare actually u
ls of debt-e
onsidered a
arsAmount
Finan
tal expendi
Centre are
0 2010-11
95 2557.9500 31.00
95 2588.95
egulations p
ctual debt: eqshall be consRegional Loa
r after the dae capital cost
deployed is ler determinatio
vested in forevestment.
raised by thestment of inteal expenditurey the Commisg return on equtilised for me
equity of as
as on the d
t (` lakh)1811.00
745.952556.95
ncial Package01.04.2009
iture includ
as under:
2011-12
5 2588.950 669.00
5 3257.95
provides as
quity ratio appidered for thead Despatch
ate of transfet, equity in e
ess than 30%on of charges:
eign currency
e Power Systeernal resourcere, and funds ssion shall b
quity, providedeeting the cap
set as on 1
ate of trans
%70.83%29.17%
100.00%
e as on 9
ing CAPEX
(` 2012-13
3257.95 990.00
4247.95
under:
pearing in the opening capCentres.
er, if the equiexcess of 30%
% of the capita:
y shall be des
em Operationes created oucreated out o
be reckoned ad such premiupital expenditu
1.4.2009 cla
sfer:-
Page
X allowed
in lakh) 2013-14
4247.951400.00
5647.95
e books of pital cost of
ity actually % shall be
al cost, the
signated in
n Company ut of its free of the LDC as paid up um amount ure.”
aimed by
e 18 of 33
Order
29.
expe
has b
RET
30. R
31.
the a
as un
r in Petition N
Debt-equ
enditure and
been determ
URN ON E
Regulation
“12. Returequity bas (2) Return as per the (3) The rathe normaOperation Provided tPower SysActs of thecontrol per (4) Rate ocomputed Rate of pre Where t is
The petit
above regu
nder:
Financial YROE
o. 92/2010
ity ratio of
d according
mined.
EQUITY
12 of the R
rn on equityse determined
on equity shsub-clause (3
te of return oal tax rate for
Company:
that return onstem Operatioe respective yriod.
of return on as per the for
e-tax return o
the applicabl
tioner has
lation @ 2
Year 200
1
70:30 has
gly equity b
RLDC fees r
y. - (1) Returnd in accordanc
all be compu3) of this regu
on equity shalr the financia
n equity withon Company year during c
equity shall rmula given b
on equity = Ba
le tax rate in a
calculated
4.239% pe
09-10 201081.03 184
s been ado
base for diff
regulations
n on equity sce with Regul
ted on pre-taxulation.
ll be computeal year 2009-
respect to tin line with th
control period
be rounded below:-
ase rate / (1-t)
accordance w
the return
er annum o
0-11 2011-14.92 224.1
opted for th
ferent year
provides th
shall be complation 8 of the
x base rate o
ed by grossin-10 applicable
the actual taxhe provisions d shall be true
off to three
)
with sub claus
on equity
n the equit
(` in l12 2012-118 303.8
he additiona
s of the tar
hat,-
puted in Rupeese regulation
of 16% to be g
ng up the base to the Pow
x rate applicaof the releva
ed up at the
decimal poin
se (3).”
in accorda
ty amount d
akh) 3 2013-14
81 403.32
Page
al capital
riff period
ee term on ns.
grossed up
se rate with wer System
able to the ant Finance
end of the
nts and be
ance with
deployed
e 19 of 33
Order
32.
acco
INTE
33. R
intere
OpeninAdditioClosingAveragReturn
Tax raRate ofReturn
r in Petition N
Return on
ordance with
EREST ON
Regulation
est on loan
“13. InterRegulationloan.
(2) The nothe cumulagross norm (3) The reequal to th (4) The rathe basis orespective Provided toutstandin Provided floan, thenCompany (5) The intby applying (6) The Poloan as loassociatedshall be shthe case m
ng Equity n due to additiong Equity ge Equity
on Equity (Base
ate for the year 20f Return on Equit
n on Equity (Pre
o. 92/2010
n equity has
h Regulatio
LOAN
13 of the
as under:
rest on loann 8 shall be co
ormative loan ative repaymmative loan.
epayment for he depreciatio
ate of interestof the actual Regional Loa
that if there isng, the last av
further that ifn the weighteas a whole sh
terest on loang the weighte
ower System ong as it resd with such rhared betwee
may be, in the
nal capital expen
e Rate )
009-10 ty (Pre Tax )
e Tax)
s been calc
on 12 of RL
RLDC fee
n capital. -onsidered as
outstanding ent as admitt
respective yon allowed for
t shall be theloan portfolio
ad Despatch
s no actual lovailable weigh
f the Regioned average rhall be consid
n shall be calced average ra
Operation Csults in net sre-financing sen the users
e ratio of 2:1.
74diture
30
culated at th
DC fees re
es regulatio
(1) The loagross norma
as on 1.4.20ted by the Co
year of the cor that year.
e weighted avo at the beginCentre:
oan for a parthted average r
al Load Desprate of interedered.
culated on theate of interest.
Company shalsavings on inshall be borne
and the Pow
2009-1045.95 745.9
0.3746.2746.1
16.00%
.00% 33.990%24.239%
180.8
he normal/c
gulations a
ons provide
ns determinetive loan for c
09 shall be wommission up
ontrol period
verage rate onning of each
ticular year burate of interes
patch Centreest of the Po
e normative a.
ll make everynterest and ie by the use
wer System O
0 2010-11 95 746.25 30 9.30 25 755.55 0 750.90
% 16.00%
% 33.990% % 24.239% 85 182.01
corporate ta
as under:
(`
es for calcu
ed in accordcalculation of
worked out byp to 31.3.200
shall be dee
of interest calh year applica
ut normative st shall be con
e does not hower System
average loan
y effort to re-fin that eventers and the nOperation Co
2011-12 20755.55 200.70 956.25 1855.90 1
16.00%
33.990% 324.239% 2
207.46
Page
ax rate in
` in lakh)
ulation of
dance with interest on
y deducting 09 from the
emed to be
lculated on able to the
loan is still nsidered:
ave actual Operation
of the year
finance the t the costs net savings ompany, as
012-13 2013956.25 125297.00 42
1253.25 1671104.75 14616.00% 16.0
3.990% 33.994.239% 24.23267.78 35
e 20 of 33
3-14 3.25 0.00 3.25 3.25 00%
90% 39% 4.68
Order
34. T
preva
intere
may
the u
docu
intere
as p
dated
have
from
will c
petiti
conv
trans
liabil
made
repay
r in Petition N
(7) The chdate of suc (8) In casethe Centra1999, as settlement Provided tclaimed bpendency of loan.”
The interes
ailing as o
est rate du
be allowed
users. The
uments for
est of prop
er Bond XX
d 26.8.2010
e been fund
the World
continue to
ioner has p
veying its n
sfer of the
ity to the W
e back to
yment of p
o. 92/2010
hanges to thech re-financin
e of dispute, aal Electricity amended frot of the disput
that the userby the usersof any disput
st on loan
on 1.4.200
ue to floatin
d to be clai
e petitioner
verification
posed loans
XX for the
0 has furthe
ded by the W
Bank for t
repay the lo
placed on
no objectio
assets to
World Bank
back arra
principal an
e terms and cng.
any of the parRegulatory C
om time to timte:
rs shall not ws and the Pte arising out
has been
9. The p
ng rate of i
med or adj
r in its affid
n of actual
s as shown
rate of int
er submitte
World Bank
transfer of
oans on ba
record a l
on to the a
POSOCO
as specifie
angement
nd interest
conditions of t
rties may maCommission me, including
withhold any Power Systemof refinancing
calculated
petitioner h
nterest app
justed for t
davit dated
loan detai
n in Form 5
erest only.
d that as th
k, POWER
assets on t
ack to back
etter dated
arrangeme
O would no
ed in the Lo
with POW
on loan. T
the loans sha
ke an applica(Conduct of g statutory re
payment on m Operation g
on the ba
as submitt
plicable, if
the control
d 26.5.2010
ils. It is se
5B have be
The petit
he assets o
RGRID has
the ground
recovery fr
d 22.6.2010
nt on the
ot relieve P
an Agreem
WERGRID t
The petitio
all be reflecte
ation in accorBusiness) R
e-enactment
account of thCompany d
asis of inte
ted that ch
any, for th
period dire
0 has furni
een that the
een taken n
tioner in its
f NLDC and
sought no
that POW
rom POSOC
0 from Wo
understand
POWERGR
ment. POSO
to pay the
ner has co
Page
ed from the
rdance with egulations, thereof for
he interest during the
erest rate
hange in
e project
ectly from
shed the
e rate of
notionally
s affidavit
d RLDCs
objection
WERGRID
CO. The
orld Bank
ding that
RID of its
OCO has
e annual
onsidered
e 21 of 33
Order
actua
rate
35.
the fo
36.
r in Petition N
al loans an
of interest f
In our cal
ollowing:
(a) G
interest a
have bee
(b) Th
to be equ
(c) Re
commerc
deprecia
(d) W
per (a) a
year to a
(e) Th
interest r
subsequ
Details of
Gross Notional Addition due to Gross NormativCumulative RepNet Loan-OpenAddition due to Repayment durNet Loan-ClosinAverage LoanWeighted AveraInterest
o. 92/2010
d the propo
for calculat
lculations, i
ross amou
and weight
en consider
he repayme
ual to the d
epayment
cial operati
tion allowe
Weighted av
bove has b
arrive at the
he interest
rate prevai
ent to 1.4.2
the interes
Loan additional capita
ve Loan payment upto Pr
ning additional capita
ring the year ng
age Rate of Inter
osed loans
ion of intere
interest on
unt of loan
ted average
red as per t
ent for the c
epreciation
of loan sh
on of the p
d.
verage rate
been applie
e interest on
on Loan h
ling as on
2009 will be
st on loans h
al expenditure
revious Year
al expenditure
rest on Loan
for the com
est on loan
loan has be
, repaymen
e rate of in
the petition
control peri
n allowed fo
all be con
project and
of interest
d on the no
n loan.
has been c
1.4.2009. A
e considere
have been
21811.00
0.00 1811.00
mputation o
.
een worked
nt of insta
nterest on a
.
iod 2009-14
or that perio
sidered fro
d shall be e
t on actual
otional aver
calculated o
Any change
d at the tim
worked out
2009-10 201
1811.00 18592.88 10
1218.12 70.70
476.08 4742.74 2980.43 5
3.6400% 3.635.69
of weighted
d out on the
lments and
actual aver
4 has been
od.
om the first
equal to th
loan worke
rage loan d
on the bas
e in rate o
me of truing
t as under:
10-11 2011-1
811.70 1833.068.96 1549.742.74 284.
21.70 468.480.13 558.284.31 193.513.52 239.6400% 3.6400
18.69 8.
Page
average
e basis of
d rate of
rage loan
n deemed
t year of
e annual
ed out as
during the
sis of the
f Interest
up.
(` in lak12 2012-13
40 2301.7009 2107.7631 193.9430 693.0067 735.1194 151.8312 172.88
0% 3.6400%.70 6.29
e 22 of 33
kh) 2013-14
2994.70 2842.87
151.83 980.00 994.40 137.42 144.63
3.6400% 5.26
Order
DEP 37.
of de
3
M
p
c
c
m
th
a
h
r in Petition N
RECIATIO
Regulatio
epreciation
“14. Deprcapital cos (2) The saconsideredcapital cosconsidered (3) Land scapital cos (4) Deprecrates specLoad Desp (5) Assets (6) Value capital cos (7) The badeducting appearing respectiveon the date
8. Depre
Method and
etitioner v
omputing th
ivil works
machinery, w
he deprecia
ssociated c
as been co
o. 92/2010
N
on 14 of th
in the follow
reciation. - (1st of the asset
alvage value od as 10% andst of the assetd as NIL and
shall not be st while comp
ciation shall bcified in Apppatch Centre.
fully deprecia
of the assetsst for the purp
alance deprecthe cumulativin the books Regional Loe of transfer”.
eciation ha
d at rates s
vide affidav
he charges
under item
was taken
ation rates f
calculations
onsidered in
he RLDC fe
wing manne
1) The value t admitted by
of the asset (ed depreciationt. The salvag100% value o
a depreciableuting depreci
be calculatedendix-III to t
ated shall be
s not in use opose of calcul
ciable value ave depreciatioof accounts
oad Despatch.
as been cal
specified in
vit dated
s, inadverte
m no. A-2
@ 1.63%.
for this item
s at their en
n our calcul
ees regulat
er, namely:
base for the the Commiss
(excluding IT n shall be alle value for ITof the assets
e asset and iable value of
d annually bathese regulat
shown separ
or declared olation of depre
as on the daton from the gof the Power
h Centre and
lculated an
Appendix-
10.02.201
ently the de
in Form 6
The petitio
m @ 3.34%
nd. Therefo
lations.
tions provid
:
purpose of dsion.
equipments alowed up to m
T equipments shall be cons
its cost shalf the capital co
sed on Straigtions for the
rately
obsolete shalleciation.
te of transfer gross depreciar System Ope
d National Loa
nnually bas
-III as per
1 has su
preciation r
-B, which
oner has req
% as per the
ore, depreci
des for com
depreciation s
and Softwaremaximum of 9and Software
sidered depre
ll be excludedost of the ass
ght Line Methassets of the
ll be taken ou
shall be worable value of eration Compad Despatch
ed on Stra
Regulation
bmitted th
rate for buil
includes p
quested to
e regulation
iation rate @
Page
mputation
shall be the
’s) shall be 90% of the e’s shall be
eciable.
d from the set.
hod and at e Regional
ut from the
rked out by f the assets any for the Centre as
aight Line
14. The
hat while
lding and
plant and
consider
n and the
@ 3.34%
e 23 of 33
Order
39.
OPE
40.
meth
41.
Expe
SCA
supp
r in Petition N
Details o
Rate of DeprecDepreciable Vaand softwares) Depreciable vasoftwares Total DepreciabRemaining DepDepreciation
ERATION &
Regulatio
hodology fo
“15. Opeexpenses) (1) Operashall be deyears 2004shall be ndonation, provisions, (2) The nothe years 2normalizedrespectivemaintenanaverage nobe escalaexpenses (3) The opfurther at maintenan The pet
enses the
ADA/EMS sy
ply, housek
o. 92/2010
of the depre
ciation alue (excluding IT
lue of IT equipm
ble Value preciable Value
& MAINTEN
on 15 of th
or computat
eration and ). -
tion and maerived on the4-05 to 2008-
normalized byloss-in-stock,, etc, if any, a
ormalised ope2004-05 to 20d operation ly and then
nce expensesormalized ope
ated at the rfor year 2009
peration and mthe rate of
nce expenses
titioner has
expenditur
ystem, AC
keeping etc
eciation hav
T equipments
ents and
NANCE EXP
he RLDC f
ion of oper
Maintenan
aintenance exe basis of act-09, based ony excluding a, prior-period
after prudence
eration and m008-09, shall and mainteaveraged to
s for the 20eration and mrate of 5.72%9-10.
maintenance 5.72% per
s for the subse
s consider
re to be in
Plant, DG
c. and adm
ve been wo
2009- 18.61 72
175
247 188 47
PENSES
fees regula
ation and m
nce Expense
xpenses (exctual operationn the audited abnormal oped adjustmentse check by th
maintenance ebe escalated
enance expeo arrive at
004-05 to 20maintenance e% to arrive
expenses forannum to a
equent years
red under
ncurred on
set, other
ministrative
rked out as
-10 2010-1154% 18.65714.64 724.6
52.30 1768.3
76.94 2492.984.06 1423.976.08 480.1
ations presc
maintenanc
es (excludi
cluding human and maintenbalance sheeeration and ms, claims ande Commissio
expenses, afd at the rate oenses at thenormalized a
008-09 at 20expenses at 2at the opera
r the year 200arrive at perm
of the tariff p
Operation
n repair an
charges tow
and gene
s under:
(`1 2011-12 % 19.1100%64 729.14
30 2113.30
94 2842.4497 1293.3413 558.67
cribes the
e expenses
ing human
an resource nance expensets. The O&Mmaintenance d advances
on.
fter prudence of 5.17% to ae 2008-09 paverage ope08-09 price 2008-09 priceation and ma
09-10 shall bemissible opeeriod.”
and Main
nd mainten
wards wate
eral expens
Page
` in lakh) 2012-13
% 19.5875% 4 778.64
0 2887.80
4 3666.44 4 1558.67 7 735.11
following
s:
resource
expenses) ses for the
M expenses expenses, written off,
check, for rrive at the price level ration and level. The
e level shall aintenance
e escalated ration and
ntenance
nance of
er, power
ses.
e 24 of 33
2013-1420.0973%
823.64
4032.80
4856.44 2013.56
994.40
Order
The
ItemsRepaAdminTotal
42.
subm
Reso
expe
Regu
7D in
and
asse
for S
43.
be co
been
basis
AMC
durin
expe
PartiR& Mof SCExpeTotal
r in Petition N
petitioner h
irs and maintenistrative and
The peti
mitted that
ource Expe
enses for 2
ulation 15 o
n the petitio
maintenan
ets have als
SCADA/EMS
As there
ompleted in
n approved
s of actual e
C of EMS/ S
ng 2010-11
enditure dur
culars M Expenses (noCADA enditure for AMl
o. 92/2010
has claimed
enance expe general expe
itioner in i
Operation
enses) for
2009-10 to
of the RLD
on. It has
ce expense
so been con
S system w
e is a propo
n year 201
upto year
expenditure
SCADA inc
to 2013-1
ring 2009-1
ormalised) with
C of EMS/SCA
d the followi
20nses 1enses 1
3
its affidavit
n and Mai
2004-05
2013-14 h
DC fees reg
also been
es, Annual
nsidered in
which came
osal for mo
3-14, the e
2013-14.
es during 2
curred durin
14, have be
0 to 2013-1
2hout AMC
ADA
ing O & M e
009-10 201141.56 35182.45 19324.02 54
ts dated 2
intenance
to 2008-0
ave been
gulations an
submitted
l Maintenan
addition to
into effect
odernization
expenditure
The norma
2004-05 to 2
ng 2009-10
een consid
14 as per th
2009-10 2
40.46
100.5 140.96
expenses a
0-11 2011-53.98 454.92.89 203.46.87 658.
26.5.2010 a
expenses
09 and the
calculated
nd submitte
that for ca
nce Contra
o Annual Ma
during 200
n of EMS/S
for AMC o
alized R&M
2008-09 an
0 and estim
dered for c
he details g
2010-11 20
42.78
300.5 343.28
as under:
(`-12 2012-1.33 578.0.92 215.5.25 793.6
and 12.7.2
(excluding
e normalize
in accorda
ed as Form
alculating th
act for CAP
aintenance
09-10.
SCADA whi
of EMS/SCA
expenditur
nd the actua
mated to be
alculating t
given as und
(` 011-12 201
45.23
300.5 345.73 3
Page
` in lakh) 3 2013-141 733.359 227.920 961.27
2011 has
g Human
ed O&M
ance with
m 7C and
he repair
PEX plan
Contract
ch would
ADA has
re on the
al cost of
incurred
the R&M
der:
in lakh) 12-13 2013
47.81 5
300.5 3348.31 35
e 25 of 33
3-14
50.55
300.5 51.05
Order
44.
subm
on th
has b
detai
perio
Parti
Admi
45.
perio
Repa
Adm
HUM
46.
expe
follow
r in Petition N
Regardin
mitted that t
he audited
been norma
ils of appr
od 2009 - 20
culars
inistrative and
Based on
od from 200
Parti
airs and mainte
inistrative and
O&M E
MAN RESO
Regulatio
enses in re
wing metho
“16. Humaon the basbased on normalizedexpenses,if any, afte (2) The no2004-05 tnormalizedthen avera2004-05 to
o. 92/2010
ng Adminis
the expend
expenditure
alized as p
roved Adm
014 are as
General Expen
the above
09-10 to 20
iculars
enance expens
general expen
Expenses
URCE EXP
on 16 of th
espect of H
odology:
an Resourcesis of actual h
the auditedd by exclud prior-period
er prudence ch
ormalised humto 2008-09, d human resaged to arrivo 2008-09 at
strative and
diture indica
e for the pe
er Regulati
ministrative
follows:
2009
nses 182.45
e, the follow
13-14 are g
200
ses 1
ses, 1
3
PENSES
he RLDC f
Human Re
e Expenses. human resou
d balance shding abnorma
adjustments,heck by the C
man resourceshall be esc
source expenve at normali2008-09 price
d General
ated in Form
eriod 2004-
ion 15 of th
and Gene
9-10 2010
5 192.8
wing O&M
given as un
09-10 2010
40.96 34
82.45 19
323.42 53
fees regula
sources sh
- (1) Human urce expenseheets. The hal Human re claims and a
Commission.
e expenses, calated at thses at the 2ized averagee level. The a
Expenses,
m 7D of the
-05 to 2008
he RLDC fe
eral Expens
0-11 2011
9 203.92
Expenses
nder:
0-11 2011
43.28 34
92.89 20
36.17 54
ations prov
hall be cal
resource exps for the yeauman resouresource expeadvances wri
after prudenche rate of 52008-09 price human resoaverage norm
the petitio
e petition a
8-09 and t
ees regulati
ses for the
(` -12 2012-
2 215.59
, is allowed
(` -12 2012-
45.73 348
03.92 215
49.65 563
vides that t
culated as
penses shall ars 2004-05 torce expensesenses, ex-gritten-off, prov
ce check, for5.17% to arre level respecource expensmalized huma
Page
oner has
are based
the same
ons. The
e control
in lakh) -13 2013-14
9 227.92
d for the
in lakh) -13 2013-14
8.31 351.0
5.59 227.9
3.90 578.9
the O&M
s per the
be derived o 2008-09, s shall be ratia, VRS
visions, etc,
r the years rive at the ctively and ses for the n resource
e 26 of 33
4
4
05
92
97
Order
47.
WRL
(CTC
RLD
been
G.B.
to dis
r in Petition N
expenses the operati Provided rationalizethe emplooperation a (3) The huthe rate ofthe subseqtariff period
The pet
LDC have b
C) and esca
C fees reg
n increased
Pradhan C
scharge the
(a) facilit
(b) expan
term
(c) collec
(d) ancill
(e) institu
(f) capac
(g) integr
(h) any o
to tim
o. 92/2010
at 2008-09 pion and main
that human d considering
oyees of theand maintena
uman resourcf 5.72% per aquent years od.”
titioner has
been calcul
alating it @
gulations.
d progressi
Committee
e following
ating the re
nding mark
open acces
ction and di
ary service
utional build
city building
ration of ren
other functio
me
price level shtenance expe
resource exg 50% increase Public Secance expense
ce expenses fannum to arr
of the
s submitted
lated taking
@ 5.72% for
It has bee
vely to me
Report and
functions e
eform proce
ket option
ss, medium
isbursemen
es
ding
g of SLDCs
newable en
ons assigne
all be escalaenses for yea
xpenses for se in employector Undertakes for the yea
for the year 2rive at permis
d that Hum
g the prese
r the subseq
en further s
eet the sho
d for meetin
entrusted to
ess in the In
functions u
m term contr
nt of large f
s
nergy sourc
ed by Govt
ted at the ratr 2009-10:
the year 20ee cost on ackings to arrir 2009-10.
2009-10 shallssible human
man Reso
ent employe
quent years
submitted t
ortfall which
ng the func
RLDCs:
ndian Powe
under pow
racts, long
funds
ces
. of India a
te of 5.72% t
009-10 shall ccount of pay rive at the p
l be escalated resource ex
urce Expe
ee cost to c
s as provid
that manpo
h is in line
ctional requ
er Sector
er exchang
term contra
nd CERC f
Page
to arrive at
be further revision of
permissible
d further at xpenses for
enses for
company
ded in the
ower has
with the
uirements
ge, short
acts
from time
e 27 of 33
Order
48. T
unde
49. T
Hum
of th
acco
50.
same
prop
requ
51.
the c
r in Petition N
The petition
er:
Financial YeaHR Cost
The petitio
man Resour
he said da
ordance with
As regard
e in the RL
osed increa
irement for
“3.1 round-Operaacquisestablireport.surveyprevailassessplacedbody wby othFurthebackgrwould a typic
We do ap
context of R
o. 92/2010
ner has cla
ar
ner in its a
rce expense
ata, Huma
h the Regu
ds the augm
LDC fees re
ase is in lin
r skilled ma
Manpower r-the-clock wittion, resear
sition, Energishment servi. A literature y were doneiling work loasment of the d at Annex-IXwith people prher faculties ser, additional round would be seen that
cal LDC.”
ppreciate th
RLDC/NLD
aimed the p
2009-10 21092.49 1
affidavit da
es for the p
n Resourc
lation 16 of
mentation o
egulations.
ne with G.B
npower has
requirementth suitably srch, analysisgy Managemices to carry survey and a
e to assess d and the likestaffing requ
X. The commiredominantly such as Elecpersons withalso be requon an averag
he significa
DC. In this
projected h
010-11 201332.20 157
ated 12.7.20
period 2004
ce Expense
f 2009 regu
of manpowe
However,
B. Pradhan
s been reco
:The Load skilled manpos, regulatory
ment, commuout the funct
a reality checthe manpow
ely responsibuirement for aittee perceive
y from the fieldtronics Enginh Commerce,uired to look ge 60 to 70 sk
ance of the
connection
human reso
11-12 201276.59 189
010 has su
4-05 to 200
es have b
ulations.
er, there is
it has been
n Committe
ommended
Despatch Ceower for Sysy affairs, lounication, IT tions discusseck of all the Lwer requirembilities that wia typical LDC es the LDC ad of Electricalneering, Inform, Economics,after financia
killed executiv
human res
n, the follow
ources expe
( ` in lakh2-13 2013.35 219
ubmitted th
08-09. On t
been norma
no provisio
n submitted
e Report w
as under:
entres have tstem Operatioogistics (sys
T systems) ed in Section LDCs with thements. Consiill arise in the
has been ms an executivl Engineeringmation Techn Humanities al and legal ves might be
source esp
wing observ
Page
enses as
h) 3-14
98.48
he actual
the basis
alized in
on for the
d that the
where the
to function on, Market stem data and other 2.3 of this
e help of a dering the
e future, an ade and is ve oriented g supported nology etc. and Legal aspects. It required in
pecially in
vation by
e 28 of 33
Order
the C
regu
52.
WRL
durin
as pe
DetaNormof RLHR CRequ
TotaNumexec
INTE
53. R
r in Petition N
Commission
lation is rel
“3.77 The over the yterm openrecent opegrid wouldservices. IEnergy Cechallenge.human resalready bRLDCs/NL
Consid
LDC has be
ng 2009-14
er the table
ails malised HR-CosLDC fees regulCost for Additiouirement
l HR Expenseber of employeutive)
EREST ON
Regulation
“17. Intere(i) ex (ii) (iii) (ivan
o. 92/2010
n in the Sta
evant:
Commissionyears startingn access in ineration of muld only becomeIntegration oertificates (R The RLDCs/source to und
been envisagLDC would fa
dering the
een consid
. The follo
e given as u
st as per Reguations onal Man-Powe
s ees (executive
WORKING
17 of the R
est on WorkiOperation
xpenses for on
) Human reso
i) NLDC charg
v) Receivablend market ope
atement of
n recognizes g with implemnter-State traltiple Power Ee more and mf renewable
RECs) and its/NLDC would dertake theseged by the ctor these req
above, th
ered for ca
wing huma
under:
2ulations 16
er
and non
G CAPITAL
RLDC fees r
ing Capital.-and mainte
ne month;
ource expense
ges for one m
es equivalent eration charge
Objects an
the increasementation of Aansmission, inExchanges. Tmore complexenergy sour
s entire admd have to be se additional r
Pradhan coquirements su
he addition
alculation o
an resource
009-10 2010
860.30 909
0.00 81
860.30 991
81
L
regulations
(1) The workienance expe
es for one mo
month; and
to two montes as approve
nd Reasons
e in responsibAvailability Bantegration of
The operationx necessitatin
rces and introministration wstrengthened cresponsibilitiesommittee. It uitably.”
al manpow
of Human R
e expenses
0-11 2011-1
9.51 961.5
1.75 141.7
1.27 1103.2
89 9
provides a
king capital shenses exclud
onth;
ths of the sysed by the Com
s for the RL
bilities of RLDased Tariff (Af regional gridn of the Indianng demand fooduction of R
would be anoconsiderably s. Such a sitis expected
wer require
Resource E
have been
(` in lakh
12 2012-13
54 1016.54
70 232.35
24 1248.89
95 105
as under:
hall cover : ding human
stem operatiommission.
Page
LDC fees
DCs/NLDC ABT), short ds and the n electricity or ancillary Renewable ther major in terms of
tuation has d that the
ement of
Expenses
n allowed
h) 2013-14
1074.68
290.45
1365.14
111
resource
on charges
e 29 of 33
Order
54.
55.
of In
cons
regu
notw
outsi
r in Petition N
(2) Rate oto the shor (3) Interesthat the Pcapital from
Interest on
(a) O
allowed
pro-rata
(b) Hu
allowed
pro-rata
(c) N
month of
Petition N
(d) Re
operation
Regulatio
While cal
ndia Prime
sidered. It
lations, int
withstanding
ide agency
o. 92/2010
of interest on rtterm Prime L
st on working Power Systemm any outside
n working ca
&M expen
under para
basis.
uman Res
under para
basis.
LDC Charg
f NLDC ch
No. 83/2010
eceivables:
n charges a
on 20 of RL
culating the
e Lending
t is clarifie
terest on
g the fact th
for working
working capitLending Rate
capital shall m Operation e agency.”
apital has b
nses excep
a 48 above
source Exp
a 55 above
ges for on
harges appr
0 has been
: Receivab
and market
LDC fees re
e rate of in
Rate as
ed that as
working c
hat the pet
g capital.
tal shall be one of State Ban
be payable oCompany h
been calcul
pt HR exp
e has been
pense: Hu
e has been
ne month:
roved vide
n considere
bles equiva
t operation
egulations.
terest on w
on 1.4.200
s per Reg
capital is
titioner has
n normative bnk of India as
on normativeas not taken
ated based
penses: O
considered
uman reso
considered
Charges
our order
d.
alent to two
charges a
working cap
09 @ of
gulation 17
payable o
s not taken
basis and shaon 1.4.2009.
e basis notwin any loan fo
d on the foll
O&M expe
d for one m
urce expe
d for one m
equivalen
dated 14.2
o months o
s determin
pital, the St
12.25% h
7(3) of RL
n normativ
any loan f
Page
all be equal
withstanding for working
owing:
enses as
month on
enses as
month on
t to one
2.2011 in
of system
ed under
ate Bank
as been
DC fees
ve basis
from any
e 30 of 33
Order
56.
NLO &ReHuReTotRaInt
NLD
57.
appo
the R
58.
vide
amon
their
RLD
59.
allow
DeInteReInteO &ReHuNLexpTot
r in Petition N
Accordin
DC Charges & M Expenses Esource Expenseman Resource Eceivables tal te of interest erest
C CHARG
Regulatio
ortionment
RLDCs as u
“(3) NLDCRegional Lregion.”
In accord
our order d
ng the five
fees and c
C FEES AN
Fees an
wed during t
preciation erest on Loan turn on Equity erest on Working& M Expenses ( source Expenseman Resource EDC Charges & Cpenses tal
o. 92/2010
ngly, interes
Excluding Humanes Expenses
ES
on 18 (3
of the NLD
under:
C charges aLoad Despatc
dance with
dated 14.2.2
Regional L
charges.
ND CHARG
nd charges
the control
g Capital excluding Huma
es) Expenses Corporate Office
st on workin
2009-159.6
n 26.9
71.6444.3
602.512.25%
73.8
) of the
DC charges
and corporatech Centre on
h the above
2011 in Pet
Load Desp
GES
s for Wes
period 200
2009-476.
35.180.
73.n 323.
860.715.
2665.
ng capital h
10 2010-1164 77.8295 44.68
69 82.6130 538.8758 743.97% 12.25%82 91.14
RLDC fe
s and corp
e office expethe basis of t
e provision
tition No. 83
patch Centr
stern Regi
09-14 are su
-10 2010.08 480.69 18.85 182.82 91.42 536
.30 991
.63 933
.79 3233
as been wo
1 2011-12 2 91.21 8 45.80
1 91.94 7 604.05 7 833.00
% 12.25%4 102.04
es regulat
porate office
enses shall the demand s
, NLDC ch
3/2010 hav
res to be re
onal Load
ummarized
-11 2011-.13 558.6.69 8.7.01 207.4.14 102.0.17 549.6
.27 1103.2
.80 1094.5
3.21 3624.2
orked out a
(`2012-13
103.41 46.99
104.07 696.57
951.05 12.25% 116.50
tions prov
e expense
be apportionserved in the
harges as a
ve been app
ecovered a
Despatch
as under:
(`12 2012-1367 735.1170 6.2946 267.7804 116.5065 563.90
24 1248.8951 1240.97
28 4179.44
Page
as under:
` in lakh) 2013-14
110.14 48.25
113.76 791.74
1,063.88 12.25%
130.33
vides for
s among
ned to the respective
approved
portioned
long with
h Centre
` in lakh) 3 2013-14 994.40
9 5.268 354.680 130.33 0 578.97
9 1365.147 1321.65
4 4750.43
e 31 of 33
Order
PRE
60.
incor
have
users
prop
PUB
61.
expe
other
incur
reimb
basis
SER
62.
recov
respo
oper
prem
TRA
63.
trans
likes
r in Petition N
-INCORPO
The peti
rporation ex
e already a
s in our dat
ortionately
BLICATION
The pet
enditure in c
r expenditu
rred for
bursement
s.
RVICE TAX
The peti
ver the S
ondents, if
ation is not
mature.
ANSFER OF
The petit
sfer of build
staff quar
o. 92/2010
ORATION E
tioner has
xpenses of
pproved re
ted 14.2.20
recovered
EXPENSE
titioner ha
connection
ure relating
meeting a
of these
tioner has
Service tax
the petition
t subject to
F BUILDING
tioner has
ding/part o
rters from C
EXPENSES
prayed to
f POSOCO
eimburseme
011 in Petiti
by the RLD
ES
as sought
with the pu
to filing the
a statutory
expenses
made a s
x on Trans
ner is subje
service tax
G
prayed to
f building o
Central Ele
S
be allowe
as onetim
ent of pre-i
ion No. 83/
DCs from th
approval
ublication of
e petition. S
y requirem
by the us
specific pra
smission c
ected to se
x. Therefore
be allowed
of WRLDC
ectricity Au
d to bill an
e charges
ncorporatio
/2010. The
heir users.
for the
f notices in
Since the ex
ment, we
sers/benefi
ayer to be
charges se
ervice tax.
e, the praye
d to bill an
and other
uthority dur
nd recover
from the u
on expense
e expenditu
reimburse
the newsp
xpenditure h
allow th
ciaries on
allowed to
eparately f
At present
er of the pe
nd adjust im
r associate
ring 2009-1
Page
the pre-
sers. We
es by the
re will be
ment of
aper and
has been
e direct
pro-rata
o bill and
from the
t, system
titioner is
mpact on
facilities
4 period
e 32 of 33
Order
from
in the
the c
64.
petiti
fees
65.
M.De
r in Petition N
the respon
e CAPEX p
control perio
The fees
ioner on m
regulations
This orde
Sd/‐
eena DayalaMember
o. 92/2010
ndents. W
plan for 200
od.
and charge
monthly bas
s.
er disposes
an V.S Me
We notice th
09-14 and
es allowed
sis in accor
s of Petition
Sd/‐
.Verma ember
at the expe
accordingly
in this ord
rdance with
n No. 92/20
Sd
S.JayaMem
enditure ha
y cannot be
der shall b
h Regulatio
10.
/‐
raman mber
s not been
e considere
e recovere
on 26 of th
Sd/
Dr. Pramo Chairpe
Page
included
ed during
ed by the
he RLDC
/‐
od Deo erson
e 33 of 33