cgfoa western slope coalition public funds opt .pdffiduciary • an individual or institution that...
TRANSCRIPT
Chandler Asset Management | [email protected] | chandlerasset.com | 800.317.4747
CGFOA Western Slope Coalition
Investing Public Funds
April 29, 2016
Ned Connolly, CCM SVP, Relationship Manager
Key Components of Investment Program
• Fiduciary Duty
• Decision-Making Process
• Investment Policy and Procedures
• Cash Flows
• Documentation and Reporting
2
Fiduciary Duty
3
Fiduciary
• An individual or institution that has a special relationship of trust with another person or group legally responsible for their assets. Examples include: v Treasurers v Finance Directors, v Investment Personnel, v Oversight Boards, v Investment Advisers. v Brokers are NOT fiduciaries at this time.
• By law a fiduciary must: 1. Make decisions in the best interest of the beneficiary; 2. Always put the beneficiaries’ interests before their own; and, 3. Act prudently.
4
Prudence Standard
1. Prudent Person
2. Prudent Investor
3. Prudent Expert
Prudence language typically includes statement similar to:
“…shall act with care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing…that a prudent person acting in a like capacity and familiarity with those matters would use…”
5
Compliance with Fiduciary Duty
• Test of fiduciary duty compliance is one of conduct, not performance
• Measures for evaluating compliance v Establishment of formalized investment policy v Compliance with policy v Prudent investment decisions v Best price trade executions v Diversification of risk v Strict avoidance of conflicts of interest
6
Developing a Decision-Making Process
Importance of an Investment Plan
8
• Provides discipline in managing risk
• Helps manage return expectations
• Establishes accountability
• Promotes communication
Portfolio Management Considerations
9
• What are the objectives of the investment program
• What are the investment constraints v Government Code v Investment Policy v Agency risk tolerances v Investment staff experience
• What strategies can be implemented that achieve stated objectives and are compliant with constraints
Determining Portfolio Structure
1. Cash flow analysis a. Identifies near-term (6-12 months) funding needs, trends for high
and low balances and seasonal patterns
2. Liquidity portfolio a. Often expressed as percentage (e.g.10-20%) of total portfolio b. Typically invested in:
I. Liquidity accounts: LGIPs, MMMFs, Bank Accounts II. Money market instruments: T-Bills, Discount Notes,
Commercial Paper
3. Core/Reserve portfolio(s) a. Invested longer-term and more diversified for potential for higher
earnings and principal growth
10
Determining Appropriate Strategies
1. Passive or Active 2. Interest rate exposure
a. Maximum maturity b. Weighted average maturity c. Weighted average duration
3. Credit exposure (asset classes) a. Treasuries, agencies, corporate securities, municipal
securities, etc.
4. Benchmark selection a. Total return market benchmarks b. Similar risk profile to investment style selected
11
Managing Risk
1. Interest rate/market risk a. Portfolio duration
i. Equal to; longer than; shorter than benchmark duration b. Maturity structure
i. Ladder; Barbell; Bullet
2. Credit risk a. Allocation limits to asset classes and issuers b. Minimum credit ratings c. Ongoing credit analysis and monitoring
3. Prepayment risk a. Callable securities b. Amortizing securities
4. Liquidity risk 12
External Factors
1. Economic environment
a. Expanding/contracting b. Employment c. Inflation d. Monetary Policy e. Fiscal Policy
13
2. Market environment a. Shape of yield curve b. Interest rate expectations c. Spread analysis
3. Global environment a. Economic b. Markets c. Geo-political
Oversight, Evaluation, Rebalancing
1. Ongoing compliance monitoring
2. Reporting a. Monthly accounting for investments b. Performance
i. Weighted average yield ii. Total return iii. Comparison to benchmark total return
3. Rebalancing a. Bring back in line with duration target b. Reallocate sector percentages
14
Comprehensive Investment Program
Statutes &
Investment Policy
Disciplined Management
Process
Optimal Investment
Program
Cash Flow
Modeling
Reporting &
Review
Compliance Monitoring
Investment Style
& Benchmark
15
Investment Policy &
Investment Procedures
16
Governance of Public Funds
• State Statutes specify: v Investment types v Maximum maturity v Potential partners v Credit criteria v Reporting v Safekeeping
• Entity’s Investment Policy
• Bond Indentures
17
Why an Investment Policy?
• GFOA’s Best Practice on “Creating an Investment Policy” starts with: “A written investment policy is the single most important element in a public funds investment program.”
• Why? v It improves the quality of decisions v It demonstrates a commitment to the fiduciary care of
public funds, with emphasis on balancing safety of principal and liquidity with yield.
v It signals to rating agencies, the capital markets, and the public that a government entity is well managed and is earning interest income suitable to its situation and economic environment. 18
What Does an Investment Policy Do?
• Defines the investment program v Legal and permitted activities and investments v Who’s in charge v Measurement of results v Relationship to counterparties
• Provides protection for the agency
• Addresses the dynamic nature of the investment process
19
Policy Components - 1
1. Introduction and Statement of Intent v Overview of entity v Sound fiscal management v Adoption of policy v Approval by governing board
2. Scope v Funds covered by policy
3. Objectives v Safety, liquidity, yield/return (SLY) & others
4. Delegation of Authority
5. Statement of Prudence, Indemnification & Ethics 20
Policy Components - 2
5. Authorized Investments & Transactions v Research state statutes v Risk tolerance v Types of securities & transactions v Maximum maturities & weighted average maturities v Credit criteria v Repurchase agreement criteria
6. Collateralization v Repurchase Agreements v Bank deposits
21
Policy Components - 3
7. Local Government Investment Pools/Mutual Funds v Criteria for evaluating pools and mutual funds
8. Authorized Financial Institutions, Depositories & Broker/Dealers v Criteria for selection v Competitive trade executions
9. Delivery, Safekeeping and Custody v Criteria for selecting custodian v Delivery versus payment (DVP) settlement
§ Fed wire § Depository Trust Company (DTC)
22
Policy Components - 4
10. Risk Management and Diversification v Addresses how market and credit risk will be managed v Maximum maturities, weighted average maturities, weighted
average duration v Diversification among asset classes and issuers v Liquidity targets v Prohibited investments and practices
11. Reporting v Disclosure of activities & holdings v Methods for calculations v Frequency of reports & who receives them
23
Policy Components - 5
12. Performance Benchmarks v Criteria for selecting benchmarks v Minimum yield standards v Methods of calculation
• Policies will often have a “Glossary of Terms” that follow the body of the Policy
24
Additional Policy Thoughts
• Start by v Examining State Statutes v Review sample investment policies, but don’t just copy
• The Policy is an internal document v Involve staff responsible for investments v Prepare draft of new policy and anytime making revisions v Have the right parties review the drafts
• The Policy is an external document v Distribute to outside parties
• Get governing body approval v As resolution, ordinance, etc.
• Perform annual reviews & updates 25
Investment Policy Resources
• Government Finance Officers Association v “Sample Investment Policy” v (312) 977-9700 www.gfoa.org
• Association of Public Treasurers v “Model Investment Policy” v (202) 737-0660 www.aptusc.org v Policy certification program
26
Investment Procedures
• An Investment Procedures Manual assists the staff in day-to-day operations of the investment program
• It should include explicit delegation of authority for executing transactions and investment decisions and include reference to procedures like: v Review of daily cash balances v Process for selecting investments v Steps for purchasing an investment v Settlement and safekeeping process v Wire transfer agreements v Banking service contracts v Collateral/depository agreements
27
Internal Controls
• Internal controls are designed to ensure assets are protected from loss, theft or misuse and should address the following areas:
v Control of collusion v Separation of investment transaction authority from
accounting and recordkeeping v Third-party safekeeping of assets v Clear delegation of authority to subordinate staff members v Staff training v Dual authorization of wire transfers v Written confirmation of telephone transactions for investments
and wire transfers
28
Cash Flow Forecasting
What is a Cash Flow Forecast
• Projection of anticipated cash receipts
• Projection of anticipated cash disbursements
• To create an estimate of investable cash balances v Liquid funds v Reserve funds
• “Cash” is the operative word in “cash flow forecasting”. v It is not accruals or budgeted funds v Only cash is spendable or investable!
30
Identify Liquid & Reserve Balances
• Total balances are trending higher
• But balances fluctuate throughout the year
• The “Liquid Balances" are established to meet cash needs
• The “Reserve Balances" are generally stable and available for longer-term more diversified investing
Reserve Balances
Liquid Balances
Entity’s Balances 5 Year Period
31
Objectives Of Cash Flow Forecasting
• Ensure sufficient liquidity for 6-12 month disbursements
• Improve investment earnings by v Matching sources and uses of funds v Investing reserve/core funds longer-term and more diversified v Managing investment risks
§ Liquidity risk § Market risk
• Identify Short-term Cash Deficits
• Warn of Impending Budget Problems 32
Annual Cash Flow Forecasts
• Estimates monthly cash position
• Determines cash available for investments of more than 30 days
• Provides a useful monthly overview for investment decision-making
• Prepared for this fiscal year and next one to three fiscal years
33
Creating Annual Cash Flow Forecast
• Beginning balance of cash and investments
• Monthly revenue projections
• Monthly expenditure projections
• Projected net change
• Projected cumulative balance of cash and investments
• Schedule of current investments and coupon payments
34
Identify Revenues and Expenditures
Major revenues
v Property tax
v Sales and use tax
v User fees
v Shared revenues
v Non-recurring § Bond proceeds
v Other
Major expenditures
v Payroll and benefits
v Operating expenses
v Debt service
v Capital projects § Draw-down schedule
v Non-recurring
v Other
35
Sources of Information
• Historical Data from General Ledger
• Historical Data from Bank and Pool Statements
• Current Year Budget
• Capital Project Spending Projections
• Schedule of Investment Maturities and Coupon Payments
36
Annual Cash Flow - Example
Beg.Balance Jan-15 Feb-15 Mar-15 Apr-15 May-15Liquid Fund Balances 95,542,961 94,422,259 93,301,557 92,180,855 91,060,153 89,939,451
InflowSales Tax Collections 3,516,116 3,516,116 3,516,116 3,516,116 3,516,116Property Tax Collections 10,507,259 10,507,259 10,507,259 10,507,259 10,507,259Intergovernmental 10,264,623 10,264,623 10,264,623 10,264,623 10,264,623Other Revenues 7,919,282 7,919,282 7,919,282 7,919,282 7,919,282
OutflowsPersonnel (12,778,319) (12,778,319) (12,778,319) (12,778,319) (12,778,319)Operating & Maintenance (1,199,030) (1,199,030) (1,199,030) (1,199,030) (1,199,030)Charges for Services (11,597,717) (11,597,717) (11,597,717) (11,597,717) (11,597,717)Debt Service (1,093,706) (1,093,706) (1,093,706) (1,093,706) (1,093,706)Other Expenses (6,659,210) (6,659,210) (6,659,210) (6,659,210) (6,659,210)
Actual/Projected Net Change (1,120,702) (1,120,702) (1,120,702) (1,120,702) (1,120,702)
Projected Liquid Balance 94,422,259 93,301,557 92,180,855 91,060,153 89,939,451Projected Invested Balance 141,565,000 141,565,000 141,565,000 141,565,000 141,565,000Total Projected Balance 285,268,483 285,268,483 285,268,483 285,268,483 285,268,483
Actual Liquid Balance 85,862,465 203,231,573 124,216,038 201,625,430 150,181,434Acutal Invested Balance 141,565,000 146,645,000 146,645,000 146,645,000 149,645,000Total Actual Balance 227,427,465 349,876,573 270,861,038 348,270,430 299,826,434Difference (57,841,018) 64,608,090 (14,407,445) 63,001,947 14,557,951
37
Funds Balance Cash Flow
Month Beg.Balance CashInflows CashOutflows NetChangeJanuary-15 95,542,961 243,572,384 -253,257,765 -9,685,381February-15 85,857,580 143,962,217 -26,607,427 117,354,790March-15 203,212,370 41,584,603 -119,098,784 -77,514,181April-15 125,698,189 94,526,488 -17,116,990 77,409,497May-15 203,107,686 33,277,738 -84,727,349 -51,449,611June-15 151,658,075 102,278,132 -76,404,216 25,873,915July-15 177,531,991 2,747,874 -36,416,262 -33,668,388
August-15 143,863,603 32,888,804 -39,493,932 -6,605,128September-15 137,258,475 251,833,487 -251,697,780 135,707October-15 137,394,182 242,834,825 -242,187,729 647,095
November-15 138,041,277 232,485,117 -239,719,807 -7,234,690
LowBalance $85,857,580HighBalance $259,994,231
Prior12Months $155,641,677Prior36Months $159,324,198
AverageBalance
ForPeriod
ConsolidatedCashFlowFundsBalance
38
Graphing Balances Over Time
0
50,000,000
100,000,000
150,000,000
200,000,000
250,000,000
300,000,000
Liquidity+ReserveFundsBalance
Beg.Balance
39
Challenges to Developing Forecasts
• Systems v Limitations of computer systems for historical data or data
management
• Physical structure v Locations of people
• Political v Elected officials agenda
• Inter-departmental communications v Departments not understanding importance of information
40
Review and Maintain Cash Flow Forecast
• Compare actual versus forecast • Identify reasons for variances • Adjust assumptions if warranted • Follow up with department heads on capital project
slippage • Update database for accurate future projection
• Retain documentation for future reference
41
Documentation and Reporting
Documentation, Disclosure, Evaluation
• Trade documentation is important for internal accounting and controls against potential errors, loss and theft v Trade ticket v Broker confirmation v Custodian statements
• Comprehensive monthly reports v Summary of portfolio characteristics v Accounting of investments
• Performance results – GIPS standards v How is risk being managed versus benchmark
43
Trade Ticket
44
Broker/Dealer Confirmation
45
Custodian Holdings Report
46
Importance of Reporting
• Investment reports disclose information needed for effective oversight in monitoring compliance with constraints and objectives v Security description: par amount, issuer, coupon, maturity,
yield, cost, credit rating, market value, v Risk diversification v Yield and total return measurements v Compliance with investment constraints v Transaction ledger
• Reports help instill a sense of disclosure and openness and serve to keep stakeholders informed about the entity’s investment program
47
48
Portfolio Summary
48
49
Monthly Compliance Report
49
50
Holdings Report
50
51
Transaction Ledger
51
52
Income Earned
52
53
Cash Flow Report
53
54
Issuer Report
54
Accounting Considerations
• Book value vs. cost v Will you amortize premiums and accrete discounts or carry at
original cost?
• Yield vs. total return v Yield - measures income v Total return - measures outcomes of investment strategies
• Calculating weighted average maturity (WAM), weighted average duration (WAD) and weighted average yield (WAY)
• Accruing interest v Purchased interest v Monthly accrual
55
Evaluating Results
• Portfolio management is risk management v Market/interest rate risk v Credit risk v Liquidity risk v Prepayment risk
• How well is investment risk being managed? v Is liquidity sufficient to fund disbursements for the next 6-12
months? v What is the appropriate market (total return) benchmark
based on the entity’s investment objectives and constraints? v Is there appropriate duration distribution and credit
diversification versus the benchmark given the current market and economic environment?
v What is the current and historic total return and yield versus the benchmark? 56
Portfolio Characteristics
57
Sector Distribution
58
Duration Distribution
59
Investment Performance
60
Biography
61
Ned Connolly Senior Vice President, Relationship Manager
Ned Connolly is Senior Vice President of client service. He is a member of the firm’s Client Service team which develops client relationships and coordinates the delivery of services related to the review and implementation of recommended practices. Ned works with public agencies in writing and revising investment policies and procedures, developing cash flow projections and providing investment education for finance staff. Ned joined the firm in 2004. He has 33 years of experience in the investment industry in the areas of institutional fixed-income investing and portfolio management. Ned has been a member of the Government Finance Officers Association’s (GFOA) Committee on Treasury and Investment Management. He has spoken on a variety of investment topics before numerous regional and national organizations. Ned received his B.A. from Boston College and holds the designation of permanent Certified Cash Manager (CCM) through the Association for Financial Professionals.