chapter 26. alarm devices
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
1/20
Chapter 26
Alarm DevicesThe purposes of an alarm are to transfer information, enhance vigilance, and warnof a potential or actual abnormal or unusual condit ion (1,2,3,4). I t is essential that
there be a means of alert ing personnel to a change or potential change in
equipment function or the patient, for there wil l always be occasions when operator
vigilance wil l be lowered or attention reduced while performing other tasks.
The number of alarms in anesthetizing areas has increased greatly. To add further
confusion, alarm sounds may come from sources o ther than from anesthesia
apparatus, including electrosurgical equipment, lasers, hearing aids, and beepers
(5,6 ,7). The J oint Commission on the Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations has
made it a goal to improve the effect iveness of alarm systems (8,9).
Standards
An internati on al stan da rd for al arm systems was pu bl ishe d in 200 3 (10 ).
Terminology (10)
Alarm Con di t ion Delay: Time from the occurrence of a tr iggering event to
when the alarm system d etermines that a n alarm condit ion exists.
Alarm Signa l Generatio n Dela y: Time from the onset of an alarm condit ion to
the generation of i ts alarm signals.
Alarm Limi t: Threshold used by an ala rm system to determine an alarm
condit ion.
Alarm Off: State of indefinite durat ion in which an alarm system or part of an
alarm system does not generate alarm signals.
Alarm Pau sed: State of l imited durat ion in which the alarm system or part of
the alarm system does not generate alarm signals.
Alarm Pres et: Set of stored configurat ion parameters, including select ion of
algorithms and init ial values for use.
Alarm Res et: Operator action that causes the cessation of an alarm signal for
which no associated alarm c ondit ion currently exists.
Alarm Setti ng s : Alarm system configurat ion, including but not l imited to alarm
limits, the characterist ics of any alarm signal inact ivat ion states, and the
values of variables or parameters that determine the function of the alarm
system.
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
2/20
Alarm Signa l: Signal generated by the alarm system to indicate the presence
of an alarm condit ion.
Alarm Sys te m: Parts of medical electrical equipment that detect alarm
condit ions and, as appropriate, generate alarm signals.
Au dio Off: State of indefinite durat ion in which the alarm system or part of
the alarm system does not generate an auditory alarm signal.
Au dio Paused: State of l imited durat ion in which the alarm system or part of
the alarm system does not generate an auditory alarm signal.
Default Alarm Preset: Alarm preset that can be act ivated by the alarm system
without operator act ion.
False-negative Alarm Condit ion : Absence of an alarm condit ion when a valid
tr iggering event has occurred.
P.829
False-positive Alarm Condition : Presence of an alarm condit ion when no
valid tr iggering event has occurred.
High Priority: Indicates that immediate operator response is required.
Information Signal: Any signal that is not an alarm signal or a reminder
signal. Examples include the tone of the pulse oximeter or
electrocardiograph, the waveform of the electrocardiograph, and the heart
rate numeric.
Intell igent Alarm System: Alarm system that makes logical decisions based
on monitored information without operator intervention. Intell igent alarm
system methodologies include analysis of trends, l imit comparisons, data
redundancy, data fusion, rules, fuzzy logic controllers, and neural networks.
Latching Alarm Signal: Alarm signal that continues to be generated after its
tr iggering event no longer exists unti l stopped by deliberate operator act ion.
Low Priority: Indicates that operator awareness is required.
Medium Priority: Indicates that prompt operator response is required.
Reminder Signal: Periodic signal that reminds the operator that the alarm
system is in an alarm signal inact ivat ion state.
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
3/20
Inhibit , silence , and suspendhave been used in past terminology for alarms.
Unfortunately, different meanings were attributed to these terms. For this reason,
these terms wil l not be used.
Alarm Prioritization
All alarms are no t eq ua ll y import an t. Th e inf orma ti on th at an alarm conveys ma y
represent an emergency, the potential for an emergency, or just an unusual
condit ion. Priorit ized alarms help to dif ferentiate l i fe-threatening si tuat ions f rom
those that are less urgent. Alarm condit ions priorit ies are shown in Table 26.1. It
may be possible to increase the prio rity of an alarm, but the priority cannot be
decreased.
A high-pri ority alarm ind icates a condit ion th at re qu ire s immedi ate ac t io n. Ex ampl es
include asystole, ventricular f ibri l lat ion, cardiac support device (intra-aort ic balloon
pump, cardiopulmonary bypass machine) fai lure, high airway pressure, extreme
hypoxemia, and sustained high-energy radiation beam.
Medium priority implies a potential ly dangerous situat ion that requires a prompt
response. Examples i nclude many cardiac arrhythmias, high or low b lood pressure,
apnea (unless prolonged or associated with extreme hypoxia), mild hypoxemia, and
high or l ow part ial pressure of carbon dioxide (pCO2).
A lo w priori ty a la rm ind ic ate s tha t on ly opera tor awa re ness is requi red. Exam ples
include failure of an i nfusion pump for maintenance intravenous f luids and failure of
an enteral feeding pump.
The object of p riorit izat ion is to minimize distract ion from less important alarms
during an emergency. It has been suggested that only the alarm sound
corresponding to the most urgent of the prevail ing alarm condit ions should be
annunciated; all other sounds s hould be temporari ly audio paused (2). Once the
most urgent alarm condit ion is resolved, the sound corresponding to the
P.830
next highest priority condit ion would then be init iated. This priority interlock should
be l imited to audible annunciat ion; lower priority visual signals need not be
suppressed because they are relat ively unobtrusive.
TABLE 26.1 Alarm Condition Priorities
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
4/20
Onset of Potential HarmaPotential Resul t of
Fai lure to
Response to the
Cause of A larm
Condition
Immediateb Promptc Delayedd
Death orirreversible
injury
HIGHPRIORITY
HIGHPRIORITY
MEDIUMPRIORITY
Reversible injury HIGH
PRIORITY
MEDIUM
PRIORITY
LOW PRIORITY
Minor injury ordiscomfort
MEDIUMPRIORITY
LOWPRIORITY
LOW PRIORITYor no alarm signal
An information signal may be used to indicate the potential for delayed minor injuryor discomfortaOnset of potential harm refers to when an injury occurs and not to when it is
manifested.bHaving the potential for the event to developed within a period of time not usually
sufficient for manual corrective action.cHaving the potential for the event to develop within a period of time that is usually
sufficient for manual corrective action.dHaving the potential for the event to develop within an unspecified time that is greater
than that given under prompt.From International Standards Organization. Medical electrical equipment-Part 18:general requirements for safety. Collateral standard: general requirements, tests andguidelines for alarm systems in medical electrical equipment and in medical electricalsystems (ISO-IEC 60601-1-8). Geneva, Switzerland: Author, 2003.
Audible Signals
The primary purpose of auditory alarm signals is to get the operator's attention. In
addit ion, they should help the operator to identify the onset of alarm condit ions, the
urgency of the required operator response and the l ocation of the device generating
alarm signals.
An aud ib le s ign al wi l l a tt ra ct at te nti on fas ter and mo re reli ab ly tha n one tha t is
visual (11). Ideally, i t should do this in a t imely, non-startl ing, and non-irr itat ing
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
5/20
fashion (12 ). Unfortunately, the qualit ies that cause sounds to attract attention also
tend to make them intrusive or s tart l ing. Some are so unpleasant that the response
may be to inappropriately disable or deactivate the alarm s ystem.
There are a number of available options in alarm sound technology, including
variat ions in pattern, pitch, tone, frequency, and loudness. The international alarm
standard specif ies the characterist ics of auditory alarm signals (10 ).
One problem associated with alarm sounds is that clinicians may not hear them.
Background noise and other alarms can i nterfere with hearing an audible alarm
signal (13). I f an a udible signal is allowed to continue to sound, other audible
signals may not be noticed (14 ,15). An anesthesia provider with a hearing deficit
may have dif f iculty determining the source of a sound. One s tudy found that many
anesthesiologists have an abnormal audiogram and that 7% had one or more alarm
intensit ies below the detectabil i ty threshold (16). Audible alarms should be a djusted
so that the si gnal wil l be perceived despite background noise.
Once an audible signal has been perceived, the next step is to identify its origin.
This is important because many monitors are not in the clinician's immediate f ield
of view, and the operator cannot always turn around to view them. Many anesthesia
providers have trouble identifying audible alarms (13 ,17 ,18,19 ). Inabil i ty to identify
an alarm may delay or prevent the appropriate remedial act ion (15,20).
Af ter an aud ibl e sign al has succee de d in cap turing atte nti on, aud io paus ing
(muting, si lencing) wil l provide t ime to correct the situat ion. The continuous
presence of an audible s ignal can degrade task p erformance and impair detect ion
of new alarm condit ions and the abil i ty to dist inguish between exist ing and new
alarm condit ions. The visual co mponent of the alarm indicator and associated
functions should stay act ivated unti l the condit ion that tr iggered the alarm is
corrected. If another alarm condition occurs while an alarm is audio paused, the
addit ional alarm should have both audible and visual indicat ions.
Most manufacturers provide a means of audio pausing. The t ime varies with the
instrument and can sometimes be varied. Some monitors i ndicate elapsed t ime. The
alarm standard requires that there be a visual indicat ion that any a larm signal has
been inactivated (10 ).
Some alarms can be turned to AUDIO OFF (defeated, disabled) for an unlimited
time. The volume of some alarms can b e decreased to a point where the audible
signal cannot be heard (21 ). Using AUDIO OFF or low volume is dangerous, as
either can lead to a false-negative alarm.
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
6/20
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
7/20
Alarm Category I ndicator Color F lashing Fr equency
HIGH PRIORITY Red 1.4 Hz to 2.8 Hz
MEDIUM PRIORITY Yellow 0.4 Hz to 0.8 Hz
LOW PRIORITY Cyan or yellow Constant
View Figure
Figure 26.1Graphic symbols for alarm systems. (FromISO IEC 60601-1-8,Medical electrical equipmentPart1-8: general requirements for safetycollateralstandard general requirements, tests and guidelines foralarm systems in medical electrical equipment and inmedical electrical systems, 2003
).
Alarm Limits
An al arm l imi t (set poin t, threshold valu e, thresho ld, sett ing ) ma y be non-
adjustable, operator-adjustable, or an algorithmically determined criterion (12). The
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
8/20
alarm standard requires that if an operator-adjustable alarm limit is provided, the
limit shall be indicated continuously or by operator act ion so that it c an be
determined if the set values are appropriate for the patient and procedure (10)
(Figs. 26.2, 26.3).
Default alarm limits can be set by the manufacturer, the health care facil i ty, or the
operator. Those set by the manufacturer may be default values or may be bracketed
around the value of a monitored variable at a point in t ime, recent values of a
monitored variable, or a current control sett ing (10 ). Most monitors allow the
operator to alter the default sett ings.
Realist ic alarm limits need to be set. Wide l imits result in fewer false alarms but
increase the risk of missing a true alarm (good specif icity but poor sensit ivity) ( 12 ).
With pressure and volume alarms during art if icial venti lat ion, a low s ett ing may
result in a part ial disconnection or small leak being missed. Constrict ions in the
breathing system that increase resistance can cause the airway pressure to remain
above a low alarm set point although a total disconnection would probably not be
missed (23).
Ensuring that an alarm is act ivated before a d angerous condit ion has occurred
without creating frequent spurious alarms requires intell igence on the part of both
the alarm system and the operator. Some operators set limits to extremes unlikely
to be encountered clinically. The farther thresholds are from normal values, the
greater the probability that a dangerous condition will occur without activating the
alarm. Others simply use the l imits se t by the last person who used the device.
Others keep the thresholds close to the manufacturer-preset l imits.
I t is good pract ice to record alarm limits on the anesthesia record. This provides
evidence that the alarms were act ivated. I t may also i ncrease the operator's
awareness of the alarms and/or make it more l ikely that appropriate values wil l be
used. I t is possible that the set alarm limits may be recorded in the electronic
record.
False Alarms
Actu al al arm ma lfu nction s are rare (24 ,25). The anesthesia provider can reduce the
number of false-posit ive and false-negative alarms by carefully preparing the
patient interface, securely a ttaching probes, select ing monitors with art ifact
reject ion capabil i t ies, using wider l imi ts, increasing the alarm signal generation
delay, and tailoring the alarms to the patient or operat ion (25 ,26 ,27,28 ,29 ).
Posit ioning the pulse oximeter probe away from electrosurgery
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
9/20
P.833
wires may also help, as may locating the electrosurgery grounding pad far away
from the pulse oximeter probe and electrocardiogram electrodes (30).
View Figure
Figure 26.2Alarms limits are displayed continuously to theright of the values for the parameters. (Picture courtesy ofDraeger Medical, Inc.)
View Figure
Figure 26.3The complete set of alarm values is displayed.
To display the alarm limits menu, the alarm limits soft key(1)is pressed. The menu (2)lists the parameters, their
current measured values (larger numbers), and the currentlow and high alarm limits. The alarm limits also appear on
the curves as dashed lines (3). (Picture courtesy of DraegerMedical, Inc.)
Fa ls e - p o s i t i v e A l a rm s
Many alarms are spurious. Only a small number indicate actual r isk
(31,32,33,34 ,35 ,36,37 ,38 ,39,40 ).
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
10/20
An al arm ac tivated wi th ou t prop er cause requi res t ime an d eff ort to chec k the
actual condit ions. This wil l result in less attention to other tasks and may lead to an
inappropriate act ion. False-posit ive alarms are a source of irr i tat ion and distract ion
and are a threat to patient care, because the anesthesia provider becomes
increasingly l ikely to ignore the signals, lower the alarm volume, turn OFF the
entire alarm system, use the AUDIO OFF or AUDIO PAUSE without looking for the
cause, or set the alarm limits at such extremes that the ala rm system is effect ively
disabled (12 ,41 ,42 ,43,44,45 ). False-posit ive alarms may fr ighten patients and
relat ives.
False-posit ive alarms a re a fact of l i fe. While there are s trategies for minimizing
them, they cannot be entirely eliminated.
False-posit ive alarms may be caused by alarm malfunction, art ifacts, extraneous
sounds being mistaken for a larm signals, and inappropriate set points.
The start-up sequence on equipment can prevent false-posit ive alarms. Medical
equipment that automatically enables the alarm system when a patient is connected
to the equipment when a valid physiologic signal is f irst detected, or through an
admit new patient function act ivated by the operator wil l decrease the number of
such alarms.
False alarms may be reduced by changing alarm limits at certain t imes, since
clinical ranges vary during dif ferent phases of anesthesia (46 ). For example, the
high heart rate alarm limit might be set higher during intubation than during
maintenance.
The ALARM PAUSED state can be used to avoid nuisance alarm signals before
performing an act ion that is l ikely to cause an alarm condit ion (10 ,38). Examples of
such act ions are intentional breathing system disconnection to perform airway
suctioning, opening a transducer to air for zero cal ibrat ion, intubation, and trying to
restore spontaneous breathing at the end of a case.
Monitors with art ifact reject ion such as pulse oximeters with motion-resistant
algorithms can decrease the
P.834
number of false-posit ive alarms (47,48 ,49 ,50 ). Filtering in the algorithm that is
monitoring for an alarm condit ion often causes alarm condit ion delay (10). For
instance, a heart rate monitor can average the R-R interval f or several heartbeats.
An ab rupt cha nge in R-R interv al s wi l l no t im me dia te ly cause an alarm condi ti on,
because it wil l take several consecutive heartbeats for the calculated heart rate to
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
11/20
exceed the alarm limit. Some electrocardiogram monitors have automatic lead
switching so that monitoring can continue even if one or two electrodes come OFF.
This can d ecrease false-posit ive alarms.
False alarms can be reduced by integrat ing monitors (38,51 ). An example is
synchronizing the pulse oximeter and noninvasive blood pressure monitor. I f the
oximeter probe is on the same arm as the blood pressure cuff, no alarm wil l sound
if no pulse is detected when the cuff is inf lated. Another example is the pulse
oximeter and electrocardiogram (ECG). SpO 2values are rejected unless the pulse
rate measured on the oximeter matches that on the ECG.
Fa ls e - n e ga t iv e A l a rms
I f an alarm s ystem fails to generate a signal when it should (false negative), the
patient 's s afety may be threatened. An alarm condit ion may be rejected or missed
because of spurious information produced by the patient, the patient-equipment
interface, other equipment, or the equipment itself.
Another cau se is the alarm be ing turn ed OFF . Su bseq uen t users may no t be aware
that it has been turned OFF. Automatic enabling is present on many newer
monitors. Once a monitored parameter is s ensed, the alarm becomes active. This
eliminates the problem of forgetting to turn an alarm ON or not being aware that an
alarm has been turned OFF by a previous user. Appropriate application of reminder
signals should reduce the chance that the alarm system is unintentionally left in an
alarm signal inact ivat ion state (10).
Speaker failure, sett ing the audible volume too low, and sett ing the alarm limits too
widely may also cause false-negative alarms (52).
False-negative alarms may be reduced by not s ett ing the l imits too widely, using
the AUDIO PAUSE rather than the AUDIO OFF state, and checking alarm systems
at regular intervals to detect problems such as a faulty loudspeaker or low audible
volume that can result in a n audible signal not being heard.
Intelligent Alarm Systems
An inte ll ige nt (s ma rt, ex pert ) alarm system may do one or mo re of th e fol lowi ng
without operator intervention: determine an alarm co ndit ion on the basis of t ime,
weightings, mult iple variables, or other advanced processing; generate alarm
signals for two or more alarm condit ions of equal priority; change the previously
assigned priority or relat ive priorit izat ion of a part icular alarm condit ion; change the
alarm signal generation delay or alarm condit ion delay; change the characterist ics
of the generated alarm signals (e.g., to indicate a change in urgency); provide the
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
12/20
operator with a l ist of c ondit ions that could have tr iggered the alarm(s); a nd present
information that is helpful in dealing with the c ondit ion that tr iggered the alarm
(36,46,53,54 ,55 ,56,57 ,58 ,59,60 ).
Smart alarms can reduce the number of false alarms by discriminating between
art ifacts and truly threatening condit ions. Human response t imes are longer and
have greater variabil i ty with c onventional alarms than intell igent alarms (61 ).
Alarm Condition Logging
Many modern monitors and l i fe-support ing equipment are equipped with alarm
condit ion logging. Logging can be used to determine the cause of a transient alarm
condit ion, for quality assurance purposes, to s tudy crit ical incidents, and to
determine when an alarm condit ion occurred. The log should include the value of
the variable that caused the alarm condit ion, the alarm limits, and the alarm status
(ON, Audio Paused, Paused, Audio Off, etc). This information can then be made
available if a problem occurs.
References
1. Beneken JEW, van der Aa JJ. Alarms and their l imits in monitoring. J Clin Monit
1 989 ;5 :2 052 10 .
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
2. Schreiber PJ, Schreiber J. Structured alarm systems for the operating room. J
Cl in Monit 1989;5:201204.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
3. Quinn ML. Semipractical a larms. A parable. J Cl in Monit 1989;5:196200.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
4. Weinger MB, Smith NT. Vigilance, alarms, and integrated monitoring systems. In:Ehrenwerth J, Eisenkraft J B, eds. Anesthesia equipment, principles and
applicat ions. St . Louis: CV Mosby, 1993:350384.
5. Ell iott B, Chestnut J. Dangers of alarms. Anaesthesia 1996;51:799800.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
6. Zmyslowski WP, Ravi VS, Chua M, et al. Spurious anesthesia alarm in an
anesthet ized pat ient . Anesthesiology 1993;79:11501151.
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
13/20
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
7. Taylor S, Wandless J, Harrup K. A false a larm with the oxygen failure warning
device. Anaesthesia 1995;40:210.
8. Wil l iams JS. Meeting the challenge: how hospitals complied with the new clinical
a larms requirement. B iomed Instrum Technol 2003;37:319328.
[Medline Link]
9. Anonymous. Joint Commission announces f ive new goals in i ts 2005 national
pat ient safety goals. Health Devices Alerts 2004;28:14.
10. International Standards Organization. Medical electrical equipmentPart 18:
general requirements for safety. Collateral standard: general requirements, tests
and guidelines for alarm systems in medical electrical equipment and in medical
e lectr ical systems ( ISO-IEC 60601-1-8). Geneva, Switzer land: Author, 2003.
11. Morris RW, Montang SR. Response t imes to visual and auditory alarms during
anaesthesia. Anaesth Intens Care 1996;24:682684.
[Medline Link]
12. Block FE, Nuutinen L, Ballast B. Op timization of alarms: a study on alarm limits,
alarm sounds, and false alarms, intended to reduce annoyance. J Clin Monit
Comput 1999 ;15:7583 .
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
13. Momtahan K, Hetu R, Tansley B. Audibil i ty and identif icat ion of auditory alarms
in the operating room and intensive care unit . Ergonomics 1993;36:11591176.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
14. Chui PT, Gin T. False alarms and integrated alarm system: report of a potential
hazard. Anesth Analg 1994;68:193199.
15. Jones D, Lawson A, Holland R. Case reports. Integrated alarms and alarm
overload. Anaesth Intens Care 1991;19:101102.
[Medline Link]
16. Wallace MS, Ashman MN, Matjasko MJ. Hearing acuity of anesthesiologists and
alarm detect ion. Anesthesio logy 1994;81:1328.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
P.835
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
14/20
17. Finley GA, Cohen AJ. Perceived urgency and the anaesthetist: responses to
common operating room monitor alarms. Can J Anaesth 1991;38:958964.
[Medline Link]
18. Grif f i th RL, Raciot BM. A survey of pract icing anesthesiologists on auditory
alarms in the operating room. In: Hedley-Whyte J, ed. Operating room and intensive
care alarms and information transfer (STP 1152). Philadelphia: American Society
for Test ing and Mater ia ls, 1992:1018.
19. Loeb RG, Jones BR, Leonard RA, et al . Recognit ion accuracy of current
operat ing room alarms. Anesth Analg 1992;75:499505.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
20. Andrzejowski J, Freeman R. Oxygen failure alarms on modern anaesthetic
machines. Anaesthesia 2002;57:931932.
[Fulltext Link]
[Medline Link]
21. Anonymous. Crit ical alarms: patients as risk. Technol Anesth 1996;16(10):1
6.
22. Morris RW, Montano SR. Response t imes to visual and auditory alarms during
anaesthesia. Anaesth Intens Care 1996;24:682684.
[Medline Link]
23. Anonymous. Mini-set venti lator alarms can be lethal. Technol Anesth
1 999 ;20 :1 2 .
24. Anonymous. Why alarm-related problems really happen. Technol Anesth
2 002 ;23 :1 8 .
25. Watson MO, Sanderson PM, Russell WJ. Tailoring reveals information
requirements: the case of anaesthesia alarms. Interact Comput 2004;16:271293.
[CrossRef]
26. Anonymous. Delay circuit may reduce pulse oximetry false alarms. Biomed Safe
Stand 1992;22:162163.
27. Anonymous. Noise pollut ion in the operating room from monitor alarms. Technol
Anesth 1993;13 (10 ):3 .
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
15/20
28. Ahlborn V, Bohnhorst B, Peter CS, et al. False a larms in the neonatal intensive
care unit : comparison between 3 modular monitoring systems. Acta P aediatr
2000;89 :571576 .
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
29. Seagull FJ, Sanderson PM. Anesthesia alarms in context: an observational
study. Hum Factors 2001;43:6678.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
30. Block FE, Detko GJ . Minimizing interference and false alarms from
electrocautery in the Nellcor N-100 pulse oximeter. J Clin Monit 1986;2:203205.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
31. Koski EMJ, Makivirta A, Sukuvaara T, et al. Frequency and reliabil i ty of alarms
in the monitoring of cardiac postoperative patients. Int J Clin Monit Comput 1990;7:
129133.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
32. Schaaf C, Block FE. Evaluation of alarm sounds in the operating room. J Clin
Mon i t 1989 ;5 :300301.
33. O'Carroll TM. Survey of alarms in an intensive therapy unit . Anaesthesia
1986;41 :742744 .
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
34. Kestin IG, Miller BR, Lockhart CH. Auditory alarms during anesthesia
monitor ing. Anesthesio logy 1988;69:106109.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
35. Lawless ST. Crying wolf: false alarms in a pediatric intensive care unit . Crit
Care Med 1994;22:981985.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
36. Tsien CL, Fackler JC. Poor prognosis for exis t ing monitors in the intensive care
unit . Cr i t Care Med 1997;25:614619.
[Fulltext Link]
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
16/20
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
37. Chambrin M-C, Ravaux P, Calvelo-Aros D, et al. Mult icentric study of
monitoring alarms in the adult intensive care unit (ICU): a descript ive analysis.
Intensive Care Med 1999;25:13601366.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
38. Block FE, Schaaf C. Auditory alarms during anesthesia monitoring with an
integrated monitoring system. Int J Cl in Monit Comput 1996;13:8184.
[Medline Link]
39. Wiklung LM, Hok B, Stahl K , et al. Post anesthesia monitoring revisited:
frequency of true and false alarms from dif ferent monitoring devices. J Clin Anesth
1 994 ;6 : 18 218 8.
40. Yasumoto M, Sakuragi T, Maruta S, et al. Activation of apnea alarm by a
surgical theater light during ophthalmological surgery. Anesth Analg 1997;85:1414
1415.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
41. McIntyre JWR. Ergonomics. Anaesthetists' use of auditory a larms in the
operat ing room. Int J Cl in Monit Comput 1985;2:4755.
[Medline Link]
42. Anonymous. Crit ical alarms: patients at risk. Technol Anesth 1987;7(10):16.
43. Geddes LA. Some examples of hazards in the operating room. J Clin Eng
1999;24 :175186 .
44. Lofsky AS. TURN YOUR ALARMS ON! APSF Newslett 20042005;19(4):43.
45. Norton RN. Silenced alarm results in near-miss. APSF Newslett 2005;20:42.
46. Mylrea KC, Orr JA, Westenskow DR. Integrat ion of monitoring for intell igent
alarms in anesthesia: neural networkscan they help? J Clin Monit 1993;9:3137.
47. Miyasaka K. Pulse oximetry in the management of children in the PICU. Anesth
Analg 20 02 ;9 4:S44S46.
[Medline Link]
48. Ahlborn V, Bohnhorst B, Peter CS, et al. False a larms in the neonatal intensive
care unit : comparison between 3 modular monitoring systems. Acta P aediatr
2000;89 :571576 .
[CrossRef]
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
17/20
[Medline Link]
49. Hay WW, Rodden DJ, Coll ins SM, et al. Reliabil i ty of conv entional and new
pulse oximetry in neonatal pat ients. J Per inato l 2002;22:360366.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
50. Malviya S, Reynolds PI, Voepel-Lewis T, et al. False alarms and sensit ivity of
conventional pulse oximetry versus the Maximo SET t echnology in the pediatric
postanesthesia care unit . Anesth Analg 2000;90:13361340.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
51. Navabi MJ, Watt RC, Hameroff SR, et al. Integrated monitoring can detect
cr i t ica l events and improve alarm accuracy. J Cl in Eng 1991;16:295306.
[Medline Link]
52. Anonymous. Nellcor-Various pulse oximeters: audio alarm failure. Health
Devices Alerts 2004;28:56.
53. Anonymous. Alarms in the operating room. Can J Anaesth 1991;38:951.
[Medline Link]
54. Fukui Y, Masuzawa T. Knowlege-based approach to intelligent alarms. J Clin
Mon i t 1989 ;5 :211216.
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
55. Pan PH. False alarms distr ibut ion in intraoperative pulse oximetry.
Anesthes iolog y 1992 ;77 :A 494.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
56. Farrell RM, Orr JA, Kuck K, et al. Dif ferential features for a neutral network
based anesthesia a larm system. Biomed Sciences 1992;28:99104.
57. Orr JA, Westenskow DR. A breathing circuit alarm system based on neural
networks. J Cl in Monit 1994;10:101109.
[Medline Link]
58. Watt RC, Maslana ES, Mylrea KC. Alarms and anesthesia challenges in the
design of intell igent systems for patient monitoring. IEEE Eng Med Biol Mag
1993; (Dec) :3441 .
[CrossRef]
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
18/20
59. Oberli C, Urzua J, Saez C, et al . An expert system for monitor alarm
integrat ion. J Cl in Monit 1999;15:2935.
60. Imhoff M, Kuhls S. Alarm algorithms in c rit ical care monitoring. Anesth Analg
2006;102:15251537.
[Fulltext Link]
[CrossRef]
[Medline Link]
61. Westenskow DR, Orr JA, Simon FH, et a l. Intell igent alarms reduce
anesthesiologist 's response t ime to crit ical faults. Anesthesiology 1992;77:1074
1079.
[Medline Link]
P.836
QuestionsFor the following questions, answer
i f A, B, and C are correct
i f A and C a re correct
i f B and D a re correct
is D is correct
i f A, B, C, and D are correct.
1. Purposes of an alarm include
A. Warning of a potenti al or actu al abn orma l or un us ua l condi ti on
B. Gett ing attention
C. Transferring information
D. Transferring legal responsibil i ty from the manufacturer to the user
View Answer2. Problems associated with determining the source of an
alarm include
A. Th e hearin g of th e anes the sia prov id er
B. Dif f iculty in recognizing tone patterns
C. Noise levels in the operating room
D. Audible signals that do not sound continuously
View Answer3. Visual signals
A. Give less specif ic inf ormat ion than audi bl e s ig nals
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
19/20
B. May go unrecognized for a longer period of t ime than audible signals
C. Use continuous l ights for more crucial information
D. Require the anesthesia provider to be looking at the monitor instead of the
patient
View Answer4. Causes of false-positive alarms include
A. Ac tivat ion by an inapp ro pri ate dev ice
B. Extraneous sounds that sound l ike an alarm signal
C. Alarm malfunction
D. Widely set l imits
View Answer5. Means to reduce the incidence of the false-positive alarms
include
A. Alteri ng al arm l im its duri ng the proced ure
B. Synchronizing monitors
C. Delaying the t ime between detect ion of an alarm condit ion and alarm ac tivat ion
D. Decreasing the averaging time
View Answer6. Concerning alarm prioritization, which of the following
are true?
A. Low-pri ori ty v is ua l s igna ls ne ed not be suppre ssed
B. With mult iple alarm condit ions, all alarms wil l be annunciated
C. All alarms are not equally important
D. Alarm priorit ies may be increased or decreased.
View Answer7. The purpose(s) of alarm signals include(s)
A. Gaini ng atte ntion
B. Notifying the operator of the alarm urgency
C. Identifying the onset of an alarm condit ion
D. Identifying the device that provides the alarm
View Answer8. The characteristics of a false-negative alarm include
A. Automa ti c enabling
B. The alarm may be turned OFF
C. Narrow alarm limit range
D. Failure to generate a signal when there is a threat to patient safety
View Answer9. Which are some of the functions that a smart alarm may
perform?
A. De termin in g th e alarm condi ti on on the bas is of mu lti pl e vari abl es
B. Changing the alarm s ignal generation delay
C. Presenting a l ist of condit ions that may have generated the alarm
-
8/11/2019 Chapter 26. Alarm Devices
20/20
D. Changing the alarm priority
View Answer10. Alarm condition logging
A. Shou ld inc lu de th e val ue of the varia ble th at caused the alarm condi t io n
B. Can help to determine the cause of transient alarm condit ions
C. Is useful for quality assurance
D. Can d etermine when an alarm condit ion occurred
View Answer