chapter 3
DESCRIPTION
The Reluctant Welfare State by Bruce JanssonTRANSCRIPT
Empowering Programs with Resources that Enhance Social
Work Education
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Counsel on Social Work Education (CSWE) Defines Educational Policy and
Accreditation Standards (EPAS) Developed Ten “Core Competencies”
and 41 related “Practice Behaviors” Every Student should master the Practice
Behaviors and Core Competencies before completing their program
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The Textbook – “Helping Hands” icon call attention to content
that relates to Practice Behaviors and Competencies.
“Competency Notes” at the end of each chapter help put the Practice Behaviors and Competencies in practical context.
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The Practice Behaviors Workbook developed with the text provides assignable exercises that assist in mastering the Practice Behaviors and Competencies.
Additional Online Resources can be found a www.cengage.com/socialwork.
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Fashioning a New SocietyFashioning a New Societyin the Wildernessin the Wilderness
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Restrictive interpretations of the Elizabethan Poor Law
Denial of civil liberties to the poor Harsh use of laws of settlement Children were often subjected to harsh
treatment Sexism was rampant with women not even
allowed to read in many places
2.14©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The founders gave the federal government the power to regulate interstate commerce, which was used in the 20th century to regulate the working conditions of workers whose companies shipped goods to other states
The founders included a clause that allowed the federal government to enact laws that furthered the nation’s “general welfare.”
This ill-defined clause was later used by social reformers to justify a range of social interventions
2.1.7©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The founders stipulated that the federal government could “make all laws that shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the fore going powers”
By allowing the Constitution to be amended, the founders provided a mechanism for change
2.1.9 ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The absence, in a rural society with small towns, of the social problems that exist in an urbanized society
The belief that the colonists were creating a society that would not have the major social problems that bedeviled Europe
The legacy of local poor law traditions and private philanthropy, which led the framers to assume that local institutions would suffice
The widespread assumption that the federal government would possess relatively scant resources. While the Constitution empowered the federal government to “raise revenue,” many framers opposed the imposition of large federal taxes
2.1.9©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
They lived within relatively restrictive boundaries with few exceptions
As the subordinate party, women were expected to be obedient, to confine themselves to household duties
It was widely assumed that women were “weaker vessels”
The economic roles of women were circumscribed
Much of the work that women undertook—as domestic servants, small retailers, spinsters, or midwives—was not organized into guilds or crafts
2.1.4
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Women had few legal protections in the medieval period
The colonists also assigned authority in families and in society to men
The Declaration of Independence and the American Constitution made no mention of “women” in their many passages
No one even thought to give women the right to vote
Women could own property and sign contracts when they were unmarried or widowed, but they could not usually retain property or sign contracts when married
2.1.4
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Women were excluded altogether from the professions of law and medicine
Women suffered extraordinary hardship because no adequate method of birth control existed
Laws existed in many colonies, as well, that forbade physical abuse of women and children and that punished rapists, although then (as now) many rapists escaped punishment by alleging that the woman had consented
2.1.5©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The settlers attempted to wrest the land from the First Americans in a manner that would make their exploitation appear to be compatible with moral codes
First Americans were made to sign under threat of coercion, while intoxicated, or in exchange for money or gifts
Violence and slaughtering of First Americans Displacement of the First Americans from their tribal lands Forceful conversion to Christianity Spread of epidemics like smallpox, cholera, and diphtheria
2 .1.5
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Slaves were a self-replenishing source of labor Slaves could be brutally disciplined without the
surveillance of local courts The Southern plantation owners had to develop
laws that circumscribed the rights of slaves and punished those whites who chose not to cooperate in maintaining slavery
Many slaveholders believed that harsh treatment of slaves helped teach them discipline and good work habits
2.1.5©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
A robust tradition of policy advocacy during the declaration of independence
Observing policy advocacy from Dr. Benjamin Rush
2.1.3
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Distinctly different approaches of liberal and conservatives to interpreting the Constitution in the 20th and 21st centuries that were present even in the colonial period
2.1.3©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/
Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Avoiding sexism and racism Address the ongoing oppression of many
vulnerable populations in contemporary society Not only is oppression of vulnerable populations
unethical; it is costly to the general public Moralistic approaches to myriad social
problems continue to impede constructive efforts to help and empower people
2.1.3
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
The Colonial era experience suggests that contemporary American public policy should help people of modest means gain access to land and homes
Existing policies often benefit current homeowners more than they help potential owners
2.1.3
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Building a welfare state in the coming centuries “from the bottom” upward
Many social problems would subsequently require a federal response due to their complexity, their prevalence across the nation, or their cost
Americans would likely develop many means-tested social programs that conditioned the receipt of benefits or services upon tests of character and income
2.1.3
©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing
Relatively harsh means-tested welfare programs even if poor houses no longer exist in contemporary society
Key provisions of the U.S. Constitution as amended by the Bill of Rights
Immigration policies that allowed many persons to enter the nation—setting in motion a society that would become an “immigrant nation” to an extent unrivaled by any other society
2.1.5 ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ ©2012, Cengage Learning, Brooks/ Cole PublishingCole Publishing