chapter 5. forecasts of forest conditions · chapter 5. forecasts of forest conditions robert...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
73chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions
RobertHuggett,DavidN.Wear,RuhongLi, JohnCoulston,andShanLiu1
key FiNDiNGS
•Amongthefiveforestmanagementtypes,onlyplantedpineisexpectedtoincreaseinarea.In2010plantedpinecomprised19percentofsouthernforests.By2060,plantedpineisforecastedtocomprisesomewherebetween24and36percentofforestarea.
•Althoughpredictedratesofchangevary,allforecastsrevealthatlandusechangesandconversiontopineplantationswillresultinacontinuingdownwardtrendinnaturallyregeneratedpinetypes.
•Changesinforesttypesareinfluencedbyurbanizationandtimbermarkets:hardwoodtypesaremoststronglyinfluencedbyurbanization;softwoodtypesaremostsensitivetofuturetimbermarketconditions.
•Reversinga50-yeartrendofaccumulatingabout2.5billioncubicfeetperyear,forestbiomassisforecastedtoincreaseslightlyoverthenext10to20yearsandthendeclinegradually.
•Afteraccountingforharvests,forestgrowth,landuse,andclimatechange,thetotalcarbonpoolrepresentedbytheSouth’sforestsisforecastedtoincreaseslightlyfrom2010to2020/2030andthendecline.
•Urbanizationpatternsarethedominantdeterminatesofthesizeofthefutureforestcarbonpool,althoughstrongerforestproductmarketscanamelioratecarbonlosses.
•Becauseofincreasesintimbersupplyfrom1990to2010,removalsofforestbiomass(growingstock)areforecastedtoincreaseforallCornerstones,includingthosethatprojectdecreasingprices.Thisreflectsanoutwardshiftintimbersupplyassociatedwithforestinventoriesbetween1990and2010.
1RobertHuggettisaResearchAssistantProfessor,DepartmentofForestryandEnvironmentalResources,NorthCarolinaStateUniversity,Raleigh,NC27695.DavidN.WearistheProjectLeader,CenterforIntegratedForestScience,SouthernResearchStation,U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,Raleigh,NC27695.RuhongLiisaResearchAssociate,DepartmentofForestryandEnvironmentalResources,NorthCarolinaStateUniversity,Raleigh,NC27695.JohnCoulstonisaSupervisoryResearchForester,ForestInventoryandAnalysisResearchWorkUnit,SouthernResearchStation,U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,Knoxville,TN37919.ShanLiuisaResearchAssistant,DepartmentofForestryandEnvironmentalResources,NorthCarolinaStateUniversity,Raleigh,NC27695.
•Removalsofsoftwoodpulpwoodareresponsivetofuturesforforestplantingandproductprices.Underahighpricefuture,softwoodpulpwoodoutputwouldincreaseby56percent,roughlyequaltotheexpansionobservedbetween1950and2000.
•Althoughtheoveralllossofuplandhardwoodacreageisforecastedtobeintherangeof8to14percent,theoak-hickoryforesttyperemainsessentiallyconstantwhiletheareasofotherforesttypesdeclineathigherrates.Theyellow-poplarforesttypeisforecastedtodeclinethemost,withthehighestlossesforecastedforthePiedmont.
•Theageandspeciesstructureofsoftwoodforesttypesaremoststronglyinfluencedbyforestharvestingandmanagementtiedtotimbermarkets.Thisisnotthecaseforhardwoodforests.
•Thefuturestructureofhardwoodforestsismoststronglyaffectedbyurbanization-drivenlandusechanges(increasedpopulationgrowthandincome).
•Reductionsofnaturallyregeneratedpineforestsarenotequallydistributedamongageclasses.Mid-ageandearly-ageforestsdecline,butold-ageforestsremainrelativelyconstant.
•Thedistributionofuplandandlowlandhardwoodsshifts,withlessoftheseforestmanagementtypesclassifiedasearlyageandmoreclassifiedasolderage.
iNTRoDucTioN
TheSouth’sforestshavebeenshapedbyalonghistoryofharvesting,forestmanagement,andlanduseconversions.Europeansettlersbeganawaveoffarmingandlandclearingthatcontinuedtoexpanduntilaround1920(USDAForestService1988).Startinginthe1920s,extensivefarmabandonmentresultedinwidespreadforestestablishmentandold-fieldsuccession.Withthisperiodofforestrecovery,forestareaandforestbiomassgrewsteadilythroughmuchofthe20thcenturyandforestareapeakedinthe1960s.Inthe1970sand1980s,industrialscaleagricultureledtosomelossesinforestacreageespeciallyintheMississippiAlluvialValley,andinthe1990s,urbanizationbecamethedominantdynamicaffectingforestarea(WearandGreis2002).Despitetheselossessincethe1970s,thevolumeofgrowingstock(ameasureofstandingforestbiomass)grewbymorethan75percentwhileindustrialoutputofwoodproductsmore
Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions
![Page 2: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
74The Southern Forest Futures Project
thandoubledoverthelasthalfofthe20thcentury(Wearandothers2007).
TheexpansionoftimberharvestsintheSouthoutpacedthatofallotherregionsoftheUnitedStates.Asof2007,theSouth’stimberoutputwasmorethantwice1952levels.About60percentofalltimberproducedintheUnitedStateswasfromsouthernforests(Smithandothers2009)comparedtoabout40percentin1962,indicatingashiftingofproductioncapacitytotheregionaswellasincreasedoutput.ThisrelocationofproductiveactivityreflectstheSouth’scomparativeadvantageingrowingtimberandanewproductmixthatfavorssmallerdiametertrees.Whilesoftwoodscompriseamajorityofharvests(69percent),hardwoodharvestsarealsosubstantial.
Thischapterexplorestheongoingandpotentialfuturechangesaffectingsouthernforests.Severaluncertainties
cloudourabilitytopredictthatfuture.AstheSouth’seconomyexpands,populationandattendanturbanizationcontinuetooutpaceallotherregions.Attheendofthe20thcentury,shiftsinmarketdemandslowedthesteadyprogressionoftimberharvesting.Newpoliciespursuenewdemandsfortimbertoprovidecellulose-basedbioenergy.Anticipatedclimatechangesraisekeyquestionsaboutthefutureproductivityandcompositionofforests.Andalthoughforestsarebytheirnaturedynamic,therehavebeenbothanaccelerationandaninteractionofchangesinsouthernforeststhatcannotbeunderstoodwithoutcomprehensiveanalysis.
Amodelingsystemdesignedtoforecasttheinteractionsofvarioussocial,economic,andbiophysicaldriversandthestructureandextentoffutureforestsisusedinthischaptertoexploretheimplicationsofthechangesthatwillaffectsouthernforests(seetextboxonfollowingpage,table5.1,andfig.5.1).Keytothesystemisasetofscenarios,called
Table 5.1—Definition of Cornerstone Futures used in the Southern Forest Futures Project, based on two storylines from the 2010 Resources Planning Act (RPA) Assessment and three general circulation models
cornerstone Futures RPA Storylines General circulation
modelTimber prices
Planting ratesTag label label
economic growth
Population growth
A High growth/high prices A1B High Moderate MIROC Increasing BaseB High growth/low prices A1B High Moderate CSIRO Decreasing BaseC Low growth/high prices B2 Low Low CSIRO Increasing BaseD Low growth/low prices B2 Low Low Hadley Decreasing BaseE High growth/high prices/high planting A1B High Moderate MIROC Increasing HighF Low growth/low prices/low planting B2 Low Low Hadley Decreasing Low
Figure5.1—ThesixCornerstoneFuturesdefinedbypermutationsoftwo2010ResourcesPlanningAct(RPA)Assessment/IntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChangestorylinesandtwotimberpricefutures;andthenextendedbyevaluatingincreasedanddecreasedforestplantingrates.
![Page 3: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
75chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions
CornerstoneFutures,whichweredevelopedtorepresentabroadrangeofplausiblefutures(chapter2).ForeachCornerstoneFuture,themodelingsystemsimulateschangesinforestarea,shiftsamongforesttypes,theamountanddistributionofforestbiomass,harvestremovals,andchangesintheforestcarbonpool.Totheextentpossible,weexaminevariationacrossthefivesubregionsoftheSouthandfocusonthespatialdistributioninforestconditions.Thesefindingsprovideafoundationforfurtherexplorationoftimbermarkets(chapter9),bioenergyfutures(chapter10),andimpactsonwildlife,biodiversity,andforestcommunities(chapter14).
meThoDS
TheresultsexaminedinthischapterarebasedontheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystem,amodelingsystemdesignedtoforecastalternativefuturesforU.S.forests.2TheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystemisaforward-lookingadjuncttotheForestInventoryandAnalysis(FIA)ProgramoftheForestService,U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture,andwasimplementedbyresearchanddevelopmentstaffoftheForestService.TheFIAprogramprovidesnationwidemonitoringthroughrepeatedinventoriesthatprovideconsistencyovertimeandahighlevelofdetail.TheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystemaccountsforchangesdrivenbymultiplevectorsincludingbiological,physical,andhumanfactorstogenerateforecastsofforestinventories.Themodelingapproachisdesignedtoaddresschangingclimate,market-driventimberharvesting,andlandusechangesalongwithchangesdrivenbysuccessionaltransitionsinforestconditions.
Ageneralschematicofthismodelingsystem(fig.5.2)startswithasetofinternallyconsistentcombinationsofsocial,economic,andtechnologyforecastsdefinedastheCornerstoneFutures(alsocalledCornerstonesinthisbook)forthisapplicationoftheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystem.LinkedtotheCornerstonesarevariousgeneralcirculationmodels(climatemodels,orGCMs),eachselectedtodefineaclimateforecastthatisconsistentwiththeCornerstone.Alsolinkedaredatafromaforestinventoryserver,whichdefinesstartingconditionsforallplotsintheforestinventory.
Themodelingframeworkatthecenterofthissystem(middlecolumnoffig.5.2)showshowfutureforestconditionsaredrivenbybiologicaldynamics—suchasgrowthandmortality—whichinturnareaffectedbyclimatefactors.Inaddition,humanchoicesregardingallocationsamonglandusesandthedisposalofforestland,timberharvesting,andforestmanagementalsoaffectchangesinforests.Theinterplayofallofthesefactorsyieldsasetofoutputs,each
2BecauseofdatalimitationstheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystemdoesnotyetaddresschangesinforestconditionsinTexasandOklahomaoutsideoftheireasternsurveyunitsthatareheavilyforested.
The cornerstone Futures
TheSouthernForestFuturesProjectusessixCornerstoneFutures(labeledwithlettersAtoF)toprovidealternativescenariosregardingthefutureofseveralexogenousvariables(table5.1).Thesearebasedonacombinationofcounty-levelpopulation/incomeprojectionsfromtheResourcesPlanningAct(RPA)andIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange(IPCC)Assessments,assumptionsaboutfuturetimberscarcity,andassumptionsabouttreeplantingrates(seechapter2fordetails).
TwoRPA/IPCCstorylines,labeledA1BandB2areusedfortheCornerstones.B2providesalowerrateofpopulationgrowth(a40percentincreasebetween2010and2060),andA1Bprovidesasomewhathigherrateofgrowth(60percent).IncomegrowthishigherwithA1B.Bothofthesestorylinesareconnectedtodetailedglobaleconomic/demographicscenariosthataredescribedintheIPCCandRPAreports(IPCC2007a,2007b;USDAForestService2012).
Timberpricefutureseitheraddressincreasingordecreasingscarcitywithanorderlyprogressionofrealpricesfortimber:eitherincreasingordecreasinginrealtermsatonepercentperyearfromabasein2005through2060.WealsoholdtherealreturnstocropsconstantthroughouttheforecastsforallCornerstoneFutures.
AnotherelementofthestorylinesembeddedintheseCornerstonesistheclimateforecastedusinggeneralcirculationmodels(GCMs)appliedtotheassumptionsofthestorylines.Forecastvariablesincludechangesintemperature,precipitation,andderivedpotentialevapotranspirationdownscaledtocounties.WeutilizethreedifferentGCMsinconstructingtheCornerstonestoaddressthepotentialvariabilityinspatialdistributionofresultingchangestoforests.Moredetailonclimateinputstotheforecastsiscontainedinchapters2and3.
Infigure5.1,thesixCornerstoneFuturesaredisplayedinadiagramthatemphasizestheirkeyvariables.CornerstonesA-DaredefinedbythematrixformedbyintersectingRPA/IPCCstorylinesA1BandB2withincreasinganddecreasingtimberpricefuturesasdescribedabove.ThesefourCornerstonesusehistoricaltreeplantingratesfollowingharvests(byStateandforesttype)toforecastfutureplanting.CornerstonesEandFdepartfromthesefourbyeitheraugmentingplantingratesforCornerstoneA(E)orbydecreasingplantingratesforCornerstoneD(F).
![Page 4: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
76The Southern Forest Futures Project
ofwhichdescribesforestprojectionsthatareconsistentwiththeflowofforestproductsandlanduses.Changesinwater,biodiversity,andotherecosystemservicescanalsobederivedfromtheforecastedchangesinforestconditionsandlanduses.Manyofthesearedescribedinsubsequentchapters.
Theforestdynamicsmoduleofthisframeworkprovidestheoutputsdiscussedintheresultssectionofthischapter.Withinthismodulethefutureofeveryplotintheforestinventoryisprojectedinamultiplestageprocess(seeWearandothers[2013]fordetailsonmodelingapproaches).Aharvestchoicemodelassignsamanagementintensitychoice(noharvest,partialharvest,orfinalharvest)basedontimberprices(fromaforestproductsmodule)andtheconditionoftheplot(Polyakovandothers2010).Theageofeachplotisdeterminedforthenextperiod,andifharvested,theplotisdeterminedtobenaturallyregeneratedorplanted.Forecastedclimateincludingtemperatureandprecipitationisassignedandforestconditionsontheplotareinferredbasedontheharvest/noharvestdecision,age,andclimateselection.
PlantingprobabilitiesarebasedonthefrequencyofplantingonharvestedplotsbasedontheforesttypeandStateforthe
mostrecentinventoryperiod.Giventhehighplantinglevelsobservedoverthisperiod,forecastedrateswereadjusteddownwardby50percentforCornerstoneFuturesA-D.Thehigh-plantingCornerstoneFuture(E)uses75percentofthehistoricalplantingrateswhilethelow-plantingCornerstoneFuture(F)uses25percent.
Toincorporateforestmarketdata,weadoptedasimplifiedprocessthatspecifiesapricetrajectoryforeachCornerstoneFutureandprovidesinputbothonindividualplot-harvestdecisionsandontheoverallsupplyoftimber.Consistentwiththeory,higherpricesyieldmoreharvestingandlargertimbersupplies;lowerpricesyieldsmallertimbersupplies.Harvestchoicemodelsarebasedonempiricalanalysisandareconsistentwithharvestingbehaviorobservedinthelate1990sandearly2000s.
Thelandusemodule(fig.5.2)describedinchapter3(seealsoWear2011)simulateschangesinallusesoflandandisdrivenbypopulationandincomegrowthalongwiththepricesoftimberproducts.Projectionsofforestareafromthelandusemodulefeedintotheforestdynamicsmoduleandtheprojectionoffuturemarketconditions.Changesforecastedatthecountylevelfornon-FederallandarebasedonNational
Figure5.2—SchematicoftheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystem.
![Page 5: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
77chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions
ResourcesInventorydata(chapter3)andareusedtorescalethearearepresentedbyeachplotinthecounty(alsoknownasplotexpansionfactors).
Theassignmentoffutureplotconditionsusesaresamplingofhistoricalplotrecordscalledwhole-plotimputation(Wearandothers2013),whichinvolvestheselectionofahistoricalplotwithcomparableconditionstorepresenteachplotlocationinthefuture.Theselectedhistoricalplotisascloseaspossibletotheoriginalplotlocationtoallowfororderlychangesinconditions,e.g.,ifplotconditionsareforecastedtobewarmer,theresamplingalgorithmwouldfirstlookwithinthesamesurveyunittofindahistoricalplotwithsimilartemperatureincreases.Findingnone,thealgorithmwouldextendthesearchtoadjacentunitsuntilanappropriatematchisfound.Thisprocessisrepeatedforeverytimestep(orintervalbetweenmeasurementsorprojections)togenerateplotforecastsovertime.Theinventoryforecastiscompletedbycouplingtheplotforecastwiththelanduseforecasts,whichareappliedtoadjustthearearepresentedbyeachnon-Federalplotwithineachcounty(throughtheplotexpansionfactordescribedabove).
Theforestdynamicsmodelisbasedonseveralprobabilities,includingprobabilisticharvestchoice,forestinvestment,andforesttransitionmodelsthatareimplementedwithrandomdrawsfromprobabilitydistributions,andawhole-plotimputationthatisbasedonarandomselectionofasubsetofhistoricalplotswithreplacement.Forecaststhereforemayvarybetweenrunsofthemodel.Theforecastsforthe50-yearsimulationinthischapterarebasedon26runs,oneofwhichwasselectedasrepresentativebasedoncentraltendencyacrossseveralvariables.Thefullsuiteof26runsoffersinformationabouttheuncertaintyoftheforecastsandisusedwheneverconfidenceintervalsareneeded.
ThetimestepofthesimulationdependsontheFIAinventoriesthatunderliemuchofthemodeling(Wearandothers2013).BecausestartingyearsandtimestepvaryfromStatetoState,theforecastperiodsarestaggeredacrosstheregion,e.g.,aStatemighthaveatimestepof6yearsstartingin2007,whileanotherStatemighthaveatimestepof6yearsstartingin2008.Forreportingacrosstheregion,weselected10-yearintervals,eachbeginningwithazero-endingyear,e.g.,1990,andthenattachedforecastsfromthenearestyeartothereferenceddecade—identicaltohowFIAassignsyearsforaggregateinventories(Smithandothers2007).
Thereportsandmapsinthischaptershowchangingforestconditionsfortheforecastperiod(2010to2060)inenoughdetailtodepictacompleteforestinventoryforeachStateintheSouth.Wefocusedonforecastingthevolumeofforestbiomass,theareaofforestsbytypeandageclass,thecarboncontainedinabove-andbelowgroundpools,andremovalsfromforestsdeterminedbyforestproductharvestsandland
usechanges.OurapproachwastosummarizetotalchangesfortheSouthandtheirdistributionacrosssubregions.
DATA SouRceS
ForeachState,FIAplotrecordswereavailabletopopulatetheforestdynamicsmodelandconducttheresampling.Werequiredatleasttwoinventorypanelsofmatchedplots,ideallywithbothderivedfromthecontinuousinventorydesignthatwasimplementedin1998toreplacecomplete-but-periodicinventoriesofthepastwithannualupdates.Becauseofchangesintheplotmeasurementapproach,wedeterminedthatitwasimportanttousetwopanelsofcomparabledesigntoconstructtransitionmodelsforkeyvariables.Sowhenfacedwiththedilemmaofonlyoneavailablecontinuousinventory,weoptedforpanelsfromtwoolder(periodic)inventoriesratherthanrelyontwodifferentdesigns.
FrompubliclyavailableplottableslocatedontheFIAWebsite,weextractedrawdataonplotcharacteristics,discretelandscapefeatures,andmeasurementsoftreeslargerthan1-inchd.b.h.Wewerealsograntedaccesstoconfidentialplotlocationdata,allowingustoconducttheplotmatchingneededtoevaluatetransitionsovertime.Expansionfactors,theareaassociatedwitheachplot,wereattachedtotheplotswiththeappropriatetables.Eachplot’scountylinksittothelandusemodel(seechapter3).
BecausetheFIAinventoryisextensive,weperformedsomemanipulationsontherawdatatoallowustosummarizevaluesforanalysis.Biomassvariables,suchasthevolumeandnumberofgrowing-stocktrees,werecalculatedonaperacrebasisusingalgorithmsderivedfromMilesandothers(2001)toaccountforchangesinsurveymethodologyovertheyears.Forexample,plotsintheannualinventorypanelsweredividedintocomponentstocapturecondition-leveldetailssuchasforesttype.AsavalidationstepwegeneratedtotalvaluesforStatesandsurveyunits,whichcouldthenbecomparedwithpublishedreportsandconfirmtheaccuracyofthealgorithms.
Changesinalgorithms,recording,andmeasurementtechniquescreateddataanomaliesinmanyinventories.WecomparedattributesacrossinventoriesineachStatetodeterminewheredataadjustmentswererequired.Thiswasespeciallycrucialwhenconductingtheanalysisoftransitions.
CarbonestimatesareattachedtoeachhistoricalplotusingmodelsdevelopedandappliedbyFIAusingtheU.S.ForestCarbonCalculationTool(Smithandothers2007).ThistoolincorporatesestimatesderivedfromfieldmeasuresintotheFORCARB2modeltoprovidecarboninventoriesthatareconsistentwithstandardsdevelopedbythe
![Page 6: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
![Page 7: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
79chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions
populationgrowthismoderatebutincomegrowthisstrong(resultinginhighurbanization),andtimberpricesarefalling(resultinginshiftsofforestlandtoagriculturaluses).Figure5.3alsoshowsthatpriceeffectsdominatetheprojectionofforestarea,withthehighestforestlossassociatedwithCornerstonesthathavedecreasingprices(B,D,andF);thethreeCornerstoneswiththelowestforestlosshaveincreasingprices(A,C,andE).
ForestlossesareespeciallyhighinafewareasoftheSouth(fig.5.4).ForallCornerstoneFuturesforestlossesareconcentratedinthePiedmontfromnorthernGeorgiathoughNorthCarolinaandpartsofVirginia,theAtlanticandGulfofMexicocoastalareas,andtheareasurroundingHouston.Theincome-fueledurbanizationinCornerstonesAandBspreadslowintensityforestlossesacrossabroaderareaoftheSouth(chapter3).ForallCornerstones,thenumberofacreslostislargestintheCoastalPlainandsmallestintheMississippiAlluvialValleyandtheMid-South.ThepercentofacreslostislargestinthePiedmontfollowedbytheAppalachian-CumberlandhighlandsandtheCoastalPlain.
Forestareachangealsovariesacrossthefiveforestmanagementtypes:plantedpine,naturalpine,oak-pine,uplandhardwood,andlowlandhardwood.Theuplandandlowlandhardwoodtypesareforecastedtocomprisebetween51and53percentofallforestsin2060,adeclinefromabout54percentin2010(fig.5.5).Thegreatestchangeshoweverarefoundamongthesoftwoodtypes(plantedpine,naturalpine,andoak-pine).Theseforestdynamicsareheavilyinfluencedbymanagementforforestproducts,whichinturnisdrivenbytimbermarketconditions,andbytherateofforestplanting.
Planted pine–OfthefiveforestmanagementtypesintheSouth,onlyplantedpineisforecastedtoincreaseinspiteofoveralldeclinesinforestedarea.TheSouthnowcontains39millionacresofplantedpine(about19percentoftotalforestarea),theculminationofanupwardtrendthatstartedinthe1950s.Ourprojectionsofplantedpinearedrivenbyurbanization,timberprices,andplantingrates(fig.5.6).CornerstoneE,characterizedbyarelativelyhighlevelofurbanizationaswellashightimberpricesandplantingrates,producesthelargestexpansioninplantedpine(thoughatrateslowerthanthoseexperiencedinthe1990s)andyieldsanincreaseof28.2millionacresby2060(about560,000acresperyear).UnderthisCornerstone,34percentofforestswouldbeplantedpinein2060.Conversely,CornerstoneF,characterizedbyarelativelylowlevelofurbanizationaswellaslowtimberpricesandplantingrates,yieldsthesmallestgaininplantedpineareawithanincreaseof7.8millionacresby2060(24percentofforestarea).TheremainingCornerstoneshaveprojectionsthatareintermediatetotheseresults.TheyclusteraroundtheforecastforCornerstoneDwithitslowertimberpricesandslowerurbanization:againof16.8million
acres(about0.3millionacresperyear)withplantedpinecomprising28percentoftheforestacreagein2060.
Natural pine—Forecastedlossesintheareaofnaturallyregeneratedpineforesttypesmirrorthegainsinplantedpineforestsandarethereforerelated,albeitinversely,totheconditionofforestproductsmarkets(fig.5.6).Thelargestdecreaseinnaturalpine—alossof58percentfrom31.5millionacresin2010to13.5millionacresin2060—isassociatedwithCornerstoneE,whichhasthehighestplantingrates.ThesmallestdeclineoccurswithCornerstoneF,withitslowertimberpricesandplantingrates,butlossesarestillsubstantial—7.6millionacresor25percentfrom2010to2060.RegardlessoftheCornerstoneevaluated,naturallyregeneratedpinetypesareforecastedtodecline,continuingatrendthathasdominatedforesttypedynamicssincethe1960s.
Oak-pine—Theareaoftheoak-pineforestmanagementtypealsodeclinesforallCornerstoneFutures,withasimilarpatternofchangebutsmalleracreageandpercentchangesthanisforecastedfornaturalpines(fig.5.6).Aswithnaturalpine,oak-pineismoreheavilyinfluencedbytimbermarketconditionsthanbyurbanizationrates.Oak-pinedeclinesrangefrom8.5millionacres(38percent)to3.9millionacres(17percent)bytheyear2060.
Upland hardwood—Atmorethan80millionacresin2010,uplandhardwoodsarethepredominantforesttypeintheSouth,morethandoubletheareaofthenextlargestforesttype.UplandhardwoodsareforecastedtodeclineforallCornerstoneFutures(fig.5.6),andvariationsinforecastsareassociatedmorewiththerateofurbanizationthanwithtimbermarketfutures.ThethreeCornerstoneswiththelowestuplandforestlossareassociatedwithlowerurbanization(CornerstonesC,D,andF),andthethreewiththehighestlossareassociatedwiththehigherurbanizationforecasts(CornerstonesA,B,andE).Lossofuplandhardwoodforestsrangesfrom5.9millionacres(about8percent)forCornerstoneCto11.2millionacres(14percent)forCornerstoneB.ForCornerstoneE,whichisalsocharacterizedbyhightimberpricesbutwithevenhigherratesofplanting,theprojectedtotalareaofplantedpineforestwouldbenearlyequaltouplandhardwoodforestsin2060,asthestimulatingeffectsofpriceandplantingonthepinetypecombineswiththedepressingeffectsofurbanizationonthehardwoodtype.
Lowland hardwood—Theareaoflowlandhardwoodforestsisalsomoresensitivetotherateofurbanizationandlesssensitivetoforestproductsmarketsthanthesoftwoodtypes.Forthisforestmanagementtype(fig.5.6),forecastsindicatelossesrangingfrom1.7millionacres(5percent)to4millionacres(12percent)by2060fromabaseof32millionacresin2010.Therelativerankingofchange
![Page 8: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
![Page 9: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
![Page 10: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
82The Southern Forest Futures Project
acrossCornerstoneFuturesisidenticaltotheforecastsforuplandhardwoodtypes.Lowlandforestsloseproportionallylessareathantheotherforesttypesthatexperiencelosses.
TheforecastsofforesttypedynamicsvaryacrosstheFuturesProjectsubregions(figs.5.7,5.8,and5.9).Forestlosses,especiallyconcentratedinthePiedmontandAppalachian-Cumberlandregions(figs.5.7),andintensivemanagementintheCoastalPlaininfluenceforesttypesdifferently.TheCoastalPlain,with82percentofplantedpinein2010,experiencesthegreatestgrowthinplantedpinearea,from32millionacresto43millionacres.DeclinesinnaturallyregeneratedpinearegreatestintheCoastalPlainaswell.UplandhardwoodlossesaregreatestinthePiedmontandintheAppalachian-Cumberlandsubregionreflectingtheinfluenceofurbanizationonthesetypes.ChangesinlowlandhardwoodtypesaremoreevenlyspreadacrosstheSouth.
Forest Biomass Forecasts
Ofthevariousmetricsavailableformeasuringbiomasschangesforasiteinaforestinventory,weoptedtofocusonthevolumeofgrowingstockbecauseitisausefulindexbothfortimberanalysisandformeasuringotherecosystemservices.Totalgrowingstockvolumesareforecastedtochangeinresponsetobothlandusechangesandtimberharvestinglevels(fig.5.10).Fromabaseofabout292billioncubicfeetin2010,inventoriesincreaseatmostbyabout11percentin2060underthelow-urbanization/low-timber-priceCornerstoneD.Thesmallestincreaseintotalgrowingstockinventoriesisfoundwiththehigh-urbanization/high-timber-priceCornerstoneA,withanincreaseinvolumeto2030andthenadeclineovertheremainderoftheforecastperiod.UnderthisCornerstone,thevolumein2060isabout1percenthigherthanvaluesobservedin2010.
Patternsofchangedifferbetweenhardwoodandsoftwoodcomponentsoftheinventoryandgenerategenerallycountervailingchanges.UnderallCornerstones,softwoodgrowingstockinventoriesincrease(fig.5.11).Forthelow-urbanization/low-timber-priceCornerstoneD,softwoodinventoriesincreasefromabaseofabout121billioncubicfeetin2010toasmuchas148billioncubicfeet(37billioncubicfeetor22percent).Thesmallestincreaseis15percent(18billioncubicfeet)forthehigh-urbanization/high-timber-pricesCornerstoneA.
Hardwoodgrowingstockinventoriesrevealdifferentpatternsofchange.Startingfromabout171billioncubicfeetin2010,hardwoodgrowingstockvolumespeaksomewherebetween2020and2040forallCornerstonesandthendeclinetotheyear2060(fig.5.11).ThemostpronounceddeclinesareforCornerstonesAandE,bothofwhichhavehighratesofurbanizationandhightimberprices.DeclinesfortheseCornerstonesareintherangeof15billioncubicfeet
(9percent)from2010to2060.CornerstonesFandDresultinincreasesof3billioncubicfeet(2percent)forthesameperiod.
ThesechangesingrowingstockvolumedepartfromhistoricalpatternsofvolumeaccumulationintheSouth.Between1963and2010southernforestsaccumulatedabout2.5billioncubicfeetperyearorroughly70percent.Hardwoodforestsaccountedformostofthisbiomassaccumulation(61percent).Althoughgrowthisprojectedtocontinueoveratleastthenext10years,growingstockvolumereachesamaximumandthendeclinessomewhatoverthefollowing40years(fig.5.12),withhardwoodgrowingstocksdeclining,especiallyinresponsetourbanization(CornerstoneA),whilesoftwoodvolumesincreaseonlyslightly.
Figures5.13,5.14,and5.15showcounty-levelchangesingrowingstockvolumefrom2010to2060forthehigh-urbanization/high-timber-pricesCornerstoneA.Whilesoftwoodgrowingstockincreasesoverall,areaswithlargeincreasesinplantedpine(fig.5.8)showdeclinesinsoftwoodgrowingstockvolumesasoldernaturallyregeneratedpineforestsarereplacedbyyoungerplantedpineforests(fig.5.14).Declinesinhardwoodgrowingstockvolumesbetween2010and2060aremorewidespreadandgenerallyorganizedbyurbanizationpatterns(fig.5.15).EasternKentuckyandfarwesternVirginiashowthegreatestgainsinhardwoodgrowingstockvolumes.
Forest carbon Forecasts
Weestimatethecarbonstoredinsouthernforestsin2010atabout12.4billiontons,includingcarbonstoredineightpools:downtrees,standingdeadtrees,litter,soilorganiccarbon,livetreesabovegroundandbelowground,andunderstoryplantsabovegroundandbelowground.Abovegroundlivetreesandsoilorganicmaterialcomprise80percentofthetotalcarbonstock.Forecastsoffutureforestcarbonstocksreflectchangesintheamountofforestareaandthecompositionoftheforestinventory.However,themodeltracksonlythecarbonpoolinforestsanddoesnotaccountforcarbontransferstoagriculturalandotherlandusepools.Likewise,themodeldoesnotaccountforcarbonthatleavesforestsasproductsandmayremainsequesteredforlongperiodsoftimeinhousingorotherenduses(e.g.,Heathandothers2011).
Changesinforestcarbonpoolsreflectbothchangesingrowingstockvolumesandchangesinforestarea(figs.5.16and5.17).UndermostCornerstones,treecarbonpeaksin2020andthenlevelsoffordeclines;theexceptionisthelow-urbanization/high-timber-pricesCornerstoneCwhoseforecastpeaksin2030.Atmost,theforestcarbonpoolin2060is5percentsmallerthanthepoolin2010(anetemissionofabout600milliontons).Carbonaccumulatesasaresultofnetbiomassgrowthonforestedlands(fig.5.17.F),but
![Page 11: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
![Page 12: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
![Page 13: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
![Page 14: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
86The Southern Forest Futures Project
Figure5.10—Totalgrowingstockvolume,2010to2060,byCornerstoneFuture.
thesegainsareoffsetbythelossofforestedlandthroughurbanizations(i.e.,thelossofsoilcarbonshowninfig.5.17.D).
TheclusteringofcarbonforecastsinFigure5.16revealstheinterplayofurbanizationandtimberprices.Theforecastswiththehighestamountofcarbonin2060areforthelow-urbanizationCornerstones(C,D,andF).Thelowestcarbonforecastedisforthehigh-urbanizationCornerstones(A,B,andE).However,withineachofthesetripletsthelowestamountofcarbonisassociatedwithlowtimberprices(CornerstonesB,D,andF)whilehighertimberpricesandresultingintensiveforestmanagementleadtohighercarbonsequesteredintheforestpool.Thissuggeststhaturbanizationpatternsdominatetheforecastsofcarbonstoragewhilestrongerforestproductmarketscanamelioratecarbonlosses.
Forest Removals Forecasts
RemovalsfromgrowingstockareforecastedtoincreaseforallCornerstoneFuturesreflectingbothlandusechangesandtimberharvesting(fig.5.18).From2010to2060,removalsareforecastedtoincreasebyasmuchas85percent(thehigh-urbanization/high-timber-price/more-plantingCornerstoneE)
andaslittleas35percent(thelow-urbanization/low-timber-price/low-plantingCornerstoneF).ThedominantfactorthataffectsthenumberofremovalsisthepriceprojectionfortimberthatisassociatedwitheachCornerstone.ThemostremovalsareassociatedwithhighpriceCornerstones(A,C,andE)whilethelowestremovalsareassociatedwithlowpriceCornerstones(B,D,andF).Evenwithdecliningprices,harvestsareprojectedtoincrease,reflectingpreviousforestinvestments,maturationofforestinventories,andremovalsassociatedwithforestlosses.
Theforecastsgeneratedistinctlydifferentremovalpatternsforhardwoodsandsoftwoods(fig.5.19).Softwoodremovalsareforecastedtoincreasesteadilyovertheprojectionperiodandatratescomparabletorecenthistory.Forhardwoods,forecastedremovalsincreasefrom2010to2020andthenleveloffformostCornerstones.Theincreaseinthefirstdecadereflectstherecoveryfromsuppressedremovalsleadinguptoandduringthe“greatrecession”(2005to2010).Trendsinlaterdecadesreflectadeclineinhardwoodgrowingstockinventories,mostespeciallyinthepulpwoodsizeclasses.
Amongproducts,softwoodpulpwoodremovalsarethemostvariableacrossCornerstones,withforecastsranging
![Page 15: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
![Page 16: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
88The Southern Forest Futures Project
between2,800millioncubicfeetforthelow-plantingfutureofCornerstoneFand3,900millioncubicfeetforthehigh-plantingfutureofCornerstoneEby2060(seechapter9foradiscussionoftimbersupplyandtimbermarketforecastsrelatedtotheCornerstoneFutures).Historically,becausethepinesarethedominantplantationspecies,pinepulpwoodhasbeenthemostprice-responsivetimberproductintheSouth.5Overthelongrun,thehigh-pricefuturesofCornerstonesAandCproducemorepulpwoodthanthelow-pricefuturesofCornerstonesBandD,andthehigh-prices/more-plantingfutureofCornerstoneEproducesthemostsubstantialincreaseinsoftwoodpulpwoodoutput(about56percent).
SoftwoodsawtimberremovalsalsoshowstronggrowthpotentialacrosstheCornerstonesandarealsostronglyaffectedbypriceforecasts(fig5.19).Incontrasttopulpwoodhowever,sawtimberoutputlevelsoffovertimeandisnotstronglyinfluencedbyplantingrates.NaturallyregeneratedsitesarematuringintheSouth,resultingingrowth-inducedsupplyincreases.Thisexplainswhyitispossibleforsoftwoodsawtimberoutputtoremainstableorincreasewith
5Econometricstudiesshowthatsawtimberproductsarethemostprice-responsiveintheshortrun.However,inthelongrun,investmentsinnewpineplantationshaveledtosubstantialincreasesinpulpwoodproduction.
decreasingprices.Softwoodsawtimberoutputeventuallylevelsoffastheareaofnaturalpinedeclinesovertime.
WhilestillseparatedbylowandhighpriceCornerstones,hardwoodremovalforecastsvarymuchlessthansoftwoodremovals(figs.5.20).Afterincreasingfrom2010to2020,hardwoodremovalsareforecastedtodeclineforthelowpriceCornerstones(B,D,andF).ForthehighpriceCornerstones(A,C,andE),removalsincreaseuntil2030,whentheybegintoleveloff.Incontrasttothesoftwoods,directinvestmentinsouthernhardwoodforestshasbeennegligible,andnoneisprojectedforthefuture.Theresultisasteadydropinhardwoodforestareaandinhardwoodgrowingstockinventories.
Whenconsideredtogether,growingstockandremovalforecastsindicateacontinuationofsomeimportanthistoricaltrends.Removalsareforecastedtoincreasesubstantiallyinspiteofalevelingoffofinventories(fig.5.21).Thisreflectsanongoingtransitionfromaforestminingapproachtoanagriculturalmodelofforestproduction.Plantedpinemanagementallowsformoreproductionfromasmallerlandbasewithamorefrequentcaptureofforestgrowth.Thismeanslowerinventoriesonthegroundcomparedtonaturallyregeneratedforests.
Figure5.12—Historical(1962to1999)andforecasted(2020to2060)hardwoodandsoftwoodgrowingstockinventories,forCornerstonesAandD.
![Page 17: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
![Page 18: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
![Page 19: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
![Page 20: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
92The Southern Forest Futures Project
Forest condition Forecasts
TheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystemisdesignedtoreplicateinventoriesacrossbroadareas—e.g.,aggregatesofatleastseveralcounties—andforbroadforesttypegroupings.However,theresampling/imputationapproachdoesprovidesomeinsightsintohowdriversofchangemayalterforestcompositionatafinerscale,e.g.,figure5.22showsforestforecastsofhardwoodtypesforthehigh-urbanization/low-timber-priceCornerstoneB,whichleadstheotherCornerstonesindeclinesofforestarea.ForthisCornerstone,allhardwoodtypesareforecastedtolose16millionacres(14percent)butnotalloftheforesttypesloseareaatthesamerate.Oak-hickorylosesabout1percentcomparedto10percentormoreforallotherforesttypes.Themostsubstantiallossesarefortheotherhardwoodandyellow-poplartypes,whichlose26percent(6millionand4millionacres,respectively).Diggingabitdeeper,lossesoftheyellow-poplarforesttypeareexpectedtobeabout25percentintheCoastalPlain(1.4millionacres)andtheAppalachian-Cumberlandsubregion(1millionacres),comparedtoamoresubstantiallossof34percentinthePiedmont(1.6millionacres).
Theforecastedareaofsoftwoodtypesisshowninfigure5.23.Loblolly-shortleafpineisthedominanttypeanditsareastaysroughlylevelthroughtheforecastperiod.Althoughoverallforestareaisexpectedtodeclineandsoftwoodremovalsareforecasttoincrease,continuedinvestmentinplantationsenablesthistypetomaintainitsarea.Longleaf-slashpineisforecastedtoincreaseslightlywhileoak-pineisexpectedtodecline.Allothertypesexhibitverylittlechange.
Anotherelementofforestconditionsthatmaybeespeciallyimportantforwildlifeistheageclassdistributionofforesttypes(chapter6).Figure5.24showsforecastsofageclassesforbroadforesttypesforthehigh-urbanization/high-timber-prices/more-plantingCornerstoneE.Early-ageforestsarethosethatarelessthan20yearsold,mid-ageforestsarebetween20and70yearsold,andold-ageforestsaregreaterthan70yearsold.BecauseCornerstoneEhasthelargestchangeinforestmanagementtypes(fig.5.5)andthemostharvesting(fig.5.18),itisa“best”casefortheproductionofearly-ageforests.
Figure5.16—Totalforestcarbonstock,2010to2060,byCornerstoneFuture.
![Page 21: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
![Page 22: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
94The Southern Forest Futures Project
Figure5.18—Forecastsoftotalremovalsfromgrowingstock,2010to2060,byCornerstoneFuture.
Figure5.19—Forecastedremovalsfromsoftwoodgrowingstock,2010to2060,byCornerstoneFuture.
mill
ion
cubi
c fe
et
![Page 23: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
![Page 24: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
![Page 25: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
![Page 26: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
98The Southern Forest Futures Project
Withtheexceptionofplantedpine,allforesttypesareforecastedtoexperienceadeclineinearly-ageforeststhroughouttheforecastperiodforCornerstoneE.Plantedpineforestsareforecastedtoshifttheirage-classdistributionstowardmoremid-ageforestsastherateofplantingdeclinesfromitspeakinthelate1990s.Mid-ageforestareaincreasesstrongly,whileearly-ageforestareaincreasesatamoremoderaterate.Therearepracticallynoacresofold-ageforestintheplantedpineforesttype.
HighharvestratesandconversiontoplantedpineinCornerstoneEshiftstheage-classdistributionofthenaturallyregeneratedpinetypes.Theareaofold-agenaturalpinestaysrelativelyconstantwhilemid-ageforestsdeclineby13millionacres(about64percent)andearly-ageforestsdeclinebyabout4.5millionacres(58percent).Oak-pineshowsasimilarpatternofageclasschanges.
Incontrasttothesoftwoods,hardwoodforecastsshowanincreaseinold-ageforests.Foruplandhardwoods,theareaofmid-ageforestsisforecastedtodeclineby14millionacres(downfrom59percentin2010to47percentin2060).Overthissameperiod,old-ageforestsareforecastedtoincreaseby12millionacres(upfrom20to40percent)andearly-ageforestsdecreaseby8millionacres(downfrom21to13percent).Overall,theshiftamongageclassesrevealsthattheearly-agecomponentoftheuplandhardwoodtypedeclinesby44percentatthesametimethattheold-agecomponentincreasesby71percent.
Thepatternofchangeforlowlandhardwoodforesttypesissimilartochangesinuplandhardwoodforesttypes,butchangesoccuratdifferentrates.Themid-agecomponentoflowlandhardwoodforestsdeclinesbyabout5millionacres(26percent),theold-agecomponentincreasesbyabout4millionacres(77percent),andtheearly-agecomponentdeclinesbyabout2millionacres(33percent).Aswiththeuplandforesttypes,whilethetotalareaoftheforesttypedeclines,theaverageageoftheforesttypeincreases.
ContrarytoCornerstoneE,CornerstoneF(fig.5.25)ischaracterizedbylessplantingandalowerharvestrate(fig.5.18).TheresultsforCornerstonesEandFthereforebrackettheage-classresultsforallCornerstones.ForCornerstoneF,theareaofearly-ageplantedpinedeclinesovertime(incontrasttoincreasessimulatedunderCornerstoneE),andtheageclassdistributionapproachesastasis.
CornerstoneFalsoresultsinlessdramaticchangesinareaofnaturalpinewhencomparedtoCornerstoneE,withmorestabilityintheearly-ageclass,increasesintheold-ageclass,anda33-percentreductionindeclinesofthemid-agedclass.Thispatternismirroredintheoak-pineageclasses.Forhardwoodforesttypes,however,thereislittledifferencebetweenCornerstonesEandF.Thisindicatesthat
managementchangesstronglyinfluencetheagestructuresofthesoftwoodforesttypesbuthavelittleinfluenceontheagestructuresofhardwoodforesttypes.
DiScuSSioN AND coNcluSioNS
Anumberofforcesofchangewillaffectthedevelopmentofforestsoverthenext50years.TheU.S.ForestAssessmentSystem,whichaccountsforlandusechanges,climatechange,andforestmanagement,isusedheretoforecastforestconditionsforsixCornerstoneFutures.EachCornerstonedescribesthefutureintermsofhumanpopulation,personalincome,climate,andthemarketsforproductsfromrurallanduses.AcrossalloftheseCornerstones,totalforestareadeclinesandchangesamongbroadforestmanagementtypesaresubstantial.Amongthefiveforestmanagementtypes,onlyplantedpineisexpectedtoincreaseinareafrom2010to2060.In2010,plantedpinecomprised19percentofsouthernforests.By2060plantedpineisforecastedtocomprisesomewherebetween24and36percentofforestarea.Themidpointofthisrangeofgrowth(20-72percent)isconsistentwitharecentstudybyZhangandPolyakov(2010)thatforecastsa40percentexpansioninplantedpineintheSouth.
Foresttypesareinfluenceddifferentiallybyurbanizationandtimbermarketdynamics.Ingeneral,hardwoodsaremorestronglyinfluencedbyurbanization,andsoftwoodsaremorestronglyinfluencedbyforestmanagement.Althoughpredictedratesofchangevary,allforecastsrevealthatlandusechangesandconversiontopineplantationswillresultinacontinuingdownwardtrendinnaturallyregeneratedpinetypes.HardwoodtypesaremoststronglyinfluencedbyurbanizationandallCornerstoneFuturesshowdeclinesinhardwoodareathatvaryindirectproportiontoratesofurbanization.
NearlyallforestsintheSouthhavebeenharvestedatleastonceandmuchoftheregion’sforestsaretheresultofreforestationandanaccumulationofbiomass.Afteralongperiodofaccumulatingbiomass,theSouth’sforestsareforecastedtoreachamaximumby2030andthentoeitherleveloffordecline.
Southernforestsalsodefinealargepoolofterrestrialcarbonamountingto12.3billiontons.Mirroringchangesingrowingstockvolumessomewhat,thispoolofcarbonisforecastedtoreachapeakfrom2020to2030,andthendeclineovertime.Urbanizationpatternsarethedominantdeterminatesofthesizeofthefutureforestcarbonpool,althoughstrongerforestproductmarketscanamelioratecarbonlosses.
Forestforecastsaddresschangeinclimatevariablesbyassociatingforecasted,multipleyearaveragesoftemperatures,precipitation,andpotentialevapotranspiration
![Page 27: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
![Page 28: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
100The Southern Forest Futures Project
withhistoricalconditions.Thepotentialeffectsofotherchanges,mostnotablyCO2enrichmentdonotentertheanalysis.ControlledexperimentsshowincreasedproductivitywithCO2fertilizationbutalsohighlighttheimportantinteractionwithnitrogen,precipitation,andotherclimateandsitevariablesindeterminingresponse(McCarthyandothers2011).Thesetypesofimpactsonproductivityarerelativelysubtlecomparedtothevariabilityoffieldinventorymeasurementsandcouldnotbefactoredintotheforecasts.Thepotentialeffectsofatmosphericcarbononforestbiomassataregionalscaleremainsanimportantuncertainty.
TheSouthproducesthemajorityoftimberproductsintheUnitedStates(morethan60percent)includingadiversityofbothhardwoodandsoftwoodoutputs.ForestmanagementhasincreasedharvestingthroughouttheSouthsincethe1960s,andtheoutputperunitofgrowingstockhasincreasedasmanagementhasintensified.Themostimportantfactorinchangingtheproductivityofsouthernforestsistheexpansionintheamountofplantedpineforests.Becauseofincreasesintimbersupplyfrom1990to2010,removalsofforestbiomass(growingstock)areforecastedtoincreaseforallCornerstones,eventhosethatprojectdecreasingprices.Removalsofsoftwoodpulpwoodareresponsivetofuturesforforestplantingandproductprices.Underahighpricefuture,softwoodpulpwoodoutputwouldincreaseby56percent,roughlyequaltotheexpansioninoutputobservedbetween1950and2000.TheseprojectionsofremovalsarebasedonthepriceassumptionsoftheCornerstoneFuturesandnotonforecastsofdemand.TimberharvestforecastsundervariousmarketconditionslinkedtotheCornerstonesarediscussedinchapters9and10.
Thecombinationoflandusechange,managementintensities,andclimateresultinanumberofchangesinthecompositionandstructureoftheregion’sforests.Theforesttypecompositionofthebroadforestmanagementgroupsareforecastedtochangeandtheagestructureoftheseforestsarealsoaltered.Althoughtheoveralllossofuplandhardwoodacreageisforecastedtobeintherangeof8to14percent,theoak-hickoryforesttyperemainsessentiallyconstant.Theyellow-poplarforesttypeisforecastedtodeclinethemost,withthehighestlossesforecastedforthePiedmont.Theageandspeciesstructureofsoftwoodforesttypesismoststronglyinfluencedbyforestharvestingandmanagementtiedtotimbermarkets,whilethefuturestructureofhardwoodforestsismoststronglyaffectedbyurbanization-drivenlandusechanges(increasedpopulationgrowthandincome).Reductionsofnaturallyregeneratedpineforestsarenotequallydistributedamongageclasses:mid-ageandearly-ageforestsdeclinebutold-ageforestsremainrelativelyconstant.Forhardwoods,theagedistributionofbothuplandandlowlandhardwoodtypesshift,withlessoftheseforesttypesclassifiedasearlyageandmoreclassifiedasolderage.
liTeRATuRe ciTeD
Coulson,D.P.;JoyceL.A.;Price,D.T.[andothers].2010.Climatescenarios fortheconterminousUnitedStatesatthecountyspatialscaleusingSRESscenariosA1BandA2andPRISMclimatology.FortCollins,CO:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation.http://www.fs.fed.us/rm/data_archive/dataaccess/US_ClimateScenarios_county_A1B_A2_PRISM.shtml.[Dateaccessed:January10,2011].
Heath,L.S.;Smith,J.E.;Skog,K.E.[andothers].2011.ManagedforestcarbonestimatesfortheU.S.greenhousegasinventory,1990-2008.JournalofForestry.109(3):167-173.
IntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange(IPCC).2007a.Climatechange2007:synthesisreport.Geneva,Switzerland.http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/syr/en/contents.html.[Dateaccessed:January24,2012].
IntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange(IPCC).2007b.Generalguidelinesontheuseofscenariodataforclimateimpactandadaptationassessment.http://www.ipcc-data.org/guidelines/TGICA_guidance_sdciaa_v2_final.pdf.[Dateaccessed:January24,2012].
Linacre,E.T.1977.Asimpleformulaforestimatingevaporationratesinvariousclimates,usingtemperaturedataalone.AgriculturalMeteorology:409-424.Vol.18.
McCarthy,H.R.;Oren,R.;Johnsen,K.H.[andothers].2011.Re-assessmentofplantcarbondynamicsattheDukefree-airCO2enrichmentsite:interactionsofatmospheric[CO2]withnitrogenandwateravailabilityoverstanddevelopment.NewPhytologist.185(2):343-589.
Miles,P.D.;Brand,G.J.;Alerich,C.L.[andothers].2001.TheForestInventoryandAnalysisdatabase:databasedescriptionandusersmanual.Version1.0.Gen.Tech.Rep.NC–218.St.Paul,MN:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,NorthCentralResearchStation.130p.
Penman,J.;Gytarsky,M.;Hiraishi,T.[andothers],eds.2003.Goodpracticeguidanceforlanduse,landusechange,andforestry.Hayama,Kanagawa,Japan:InstituteforGlobalEnvironmentalStrategiesfortheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange.502p.http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/gpglulucf/gpglulucf.htm.[Dateaccessed:April13,2010].
Poylakov,M.;Wear,D.N.;Huggett,R.2010.Harvestchoiceandtimbersupplymodelsforforestforecasting.ForestScience.56(4):344-355.
Smith,J.E.;Heath,L.S.;Nichols,M.C.2007.U.S.forestcarboncalculationtool:forest-landcarbonstocksandnetannualstockchange.GenTech.Rep.NRS-13.NewtownSquare,PA:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,NorthernResearchStation.28p.
Smith,W.B.;Miles,P.D.;Perry,C.H.;Pugh,S.A.2009.ForestresourcesoftheUnitedStates,2007.Gen.Tech.Rep.WO-78.Washington,DC:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService.336p.
U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture(USDA)ForestService.2012.Futurescenarios:atechnicaldocumentsupportingtheForestService2010RPAassessment.Gen.Tech.Rep.RMRS-GTR-272.FortCollins,CO:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation.34p.
U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture(USDA)ForestService.1988.TheSouth’sFourthForest:alternativesforthefuture.For.Res.Rep.24.Washington,DC:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService.512p.
Wear,D.N.;Carter,D.R.;Prestemon,J.2007.TheU.S.South’stimbersectorin2005:aprospectiveanalysisofrecentchange.Gen.Tech.Rep.SRS-99.Asheville,NC:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,SouthernResearchStation.29p.
Wear,D.N.2011.Forecastsofcounty-levellandusesunderthreefuturescenarios:atechnicaldocumentsupportingtheForestService2010RPAassessment.Gen.Tech.Rep.SRS-141.Asheville,NC:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,SouthernResearchStation.41p.
![Page 29: Chapter 5. Forecasts of Forest conditions · chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions Robert Huggett, David N. Wear, Ruhong Li, John Coulston, and Shan Liu1 key FiNDiNGS • Among](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070808/5f06f70c7e708231d41a9ec2/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
101chAPTeR 5. Forecasts of Forest Conditions
Wear,D.N.;Greis,J.G.2002.SouthernForestResourceAssessment:summaryreport.Gen.Tech.Rep.SRS-54.Asheville,NC:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService.SouthernResearchStation103p.
Wear,D.N.;Huggett,R.;Li,R.[andothers].2013.ForecastsofforestconditionsinU.S.regionsunderfuturescenarios:atechnicaldocumentsupportingtheForestService2010RPAassessment.Gen.Tech.Rep.SRS-170.Asheville,NC:U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureForestService,SouthernResearchStation.101p.
Zhang,D.;Polyakov,M.2010.ThegeographicaldistributionofplantationforestsandlandresourcespotentiallyavailableforpineplantationsintheU.S.South.BiomassandBioenergy.34(12):1643-1654.