chapter 6 post transition: emerging trends and...

19
Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and Challenges

Upload: doannhu

Post on 20-May-2018

226 views

Category:

Documents


6 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging

Trends and Challenges

Page 2: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

118

CHAPTER - 6

POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

Basic education has been acknowledged widely as a tool of social change (Dreze & Sen, 2010) and issues related to education were the core of the Maoist strategy to fight against monarchy and ensure political changes. Maoists demanded complete reform of the education system during the “People’s War” to ensure equity in education (Acharya, 2002). Some issues, like education in the mother tongue, were part of the 40 points demand, presented by the Maoists before launching the “People’s War”. Soon after the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (2006) and the formation of the interim government, some changes were made in the education system. After the Constituent Assembly elections held in April 2008, CPN (Maoists) emerged as the single largest party and formed the government under the leadership of Prachanda followed by a short lived government led by CPN (UML). Now in 2011, CPN (Maoist) again has risen to power, under the leadership of Babu Ram Bhattarai. Some of the significant changes and emerging trends in education, after the transition, have been captured in this section.

Replacing the existing textbooks needed much more time and thus, it was not possible to do so. In 2007, a letter was sent to all the schools with details of the content, which should not be taught. A new national anthem is in place now, which is regularly sung in schools. Teaching of Sanskrit has been stopped in government schools. Teachers, who were teaching Sanskrit earlier, teach Nepali now. A new school sector reform plan has also been developed to be implemented during 2009-2015. Some initiatives have been taken up to revise the curriculum, textbooks, restructuring School Management Committees and introduction of the mother tongue in the early grades.

Page 3: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

119

6.1 No More ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’, it is ‘Nepal Sarkar’

Curriculum Development Center, Ministry of Education and Sports, Government of Nepal, issued a Government Order (see Annex) to all schools and concerned officials after announcement of House of Representatives-2063 (2007) to revise the content and the curriculum of school education with immediate effects. Following recommendations were given, by the advisory committee for curriculum, textbooks improvement, to the teachers and the education officials –

Changes Suggested in the Content of the Text Books Subject: Social Studies (Text book titled - Mero Desh) In place of ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ (Government of His Highness), Nepal Sarkar (Government of Nepal) will be used. The word ‘Shahi’ (Royal) would not be used before Nepal Airlines, Nepal Army, Ambassador of Nepal and other related terms during teaching learning process. In place of ‘Nepal Adhirajya’ (Kingdom of Nepal), Nepal Rajya (Nepal State) would be used. Hindu Adhirajya, Hindu Rajya, Hindu Rastra, Rastriya Dharm Hindu (Hindu Nation) would be changed to ‘Dharm Nirpekshya Rajya’ (Secular State). Role of the King, as per the Kingdom’s Constitution of 1991, and the provisions of his executive, legislation and judiciary power would be taught in accordance with the provisions made by the House of Representatives-in 2007. Procedures of appointing members of constitutional committees, ambassadors, Advocate General, Chief of Army as per the Kingdom’s Constitution (1991) would be replaced with provisions made by the House of Representatives (2007) while teaching these concepts. The national anthem (Sri Maan Ghambir--) and council of ministers (Rajya Parishad) would not be taught.

Page 4: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

120

Only factual and objective content related with monarchy and history of Shah Rulers will be taught. Considering the contemporary change, content would be contextualized to teach. Changes Suggested in the Curriculum

On the first and the last page of the curriculum, in place of ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ (Government of His Highness), ‘Nepal Sarkar’ (Government of Nepal) would be used.

In the curriculum, in the preface and the copy right sections, in place of ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ (Government of His Highness), ‘Nepal Sarkar’ (Government of Nepal) would be used. Civics and Moral Education (Lower Secondary Level)

In the curriculum of class 8th, page number-3 related with ‘Rastra and Rastriyata’ (Nation and Nationality),’ and on page number -12, ‘Ekata ko Prateek Shri 5’ (Symbol of Unity-the King) would not be used. Content which Must be Taught with Modification

Instead of ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ (Government of the King) mentioned on the first and the last page of the text books, ‘Nepal Sarkar’ (Government of Nepal) will be used.

In the Preface and other places, wherever ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ (Government of the King) has been mentioned, it would be replaced with ‘Nepal Sarkar’ (Government of Nepal).

Picture of royal family that was added in the beginning of the textbooks would not be used.

Page 5: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

121

Class Page Number

Words/ content which will be replaced

New suggested/alternate

words/concepts 4th Mero Desh 28 ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ ‘Nepal Sarkar’ 4th Mero Desh 46 ‘Shahi’ Don’t use

4th Mero Desh 130 Rastriya Sabha ko Gathan

Prakriya (Formation of National

Assembly) Don’t Teach

4th Mero Desh 131 Karya Palika Gathan Prakriya (Formation of Excutive Body) Don’t Teach

4th Mero Desh 135 Pradhan Nayadheesh ko Niyukti

Prakriya Chapter-7, Selection of Chief

Justice Don’t Teach

5th Mero Desh 95 and 96 Karya Palika Gathan Prakriya (Formation of Executive Body) Don’t Teach

5th Mero Desh 98 and 102 ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ Nepal Sarkar 6th 4 and 6 ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ Nepal Sarkar 6th 4 Nepal Adhirajya ‘Nepal Sarkar’ 6th 32 Rastriya Dharm Hindu Nepal Dharm

Nirpekshya Rastra 6th 36 Rajmukut and Rastragaan Don’t Teach

6th 37 Activity No-2 Rajmukut

Bhayeka----- and Activity No-7 Rastriya Gaan Gayer Sunau---

Don’t Teach

7th 30,31 and 42

Terminology -Hindu Rajya, Hindu Rastra, Rastriya Dharm

Hindu Dharm Nirpekshya (Secular nation)

7th 56 ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ ‘Nepal Sarkar’ 7th 56 In first and second section-------

Nepal ko Nagrik Hune Cha. Don’t Teach 7th 59 Meaning of the word-Adhirajya Don’t Teach 8th 3 and 17 ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ ‘Nepal Sarkar’ 8th 18 and 37 Term ‘Shahi’ before Airlines etc Remove it 8th 58,59,and

94 Adhirajya Nepal Rajya

8th 62 to 68 Content related with- Karya Palika,Nayapalika, Vyvasthapika Don’t teach

Page 6: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

122

Class Page Number

Words/ content which will be replaced

New suggested/alternate

words/concepts 9th 4,6,18,21,26 ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ ‘Nepal Sarkar’ 9th 26 Nepal Adhirajya Nepal Rajya 9th Section-2 Don’t teach 9th 35 Activity No-2 Don’t teach 9th 64 and 65 Nepal ko Vartman Samvidhan

ko Viseshta Haru Don’t teach 9th 202 ‘Sahi Nepali Sena’ Nepali Sena

10th Various pages ‘Shri 5 ko Sarkar’ ‘Nepal Sarkar’

10th 62 to 67 Nepal Ma Samvaidhanik Rajtantra, Vyavasthapika,

Karyapalika related chapters Don’t teach

10th 70,71 Samvaidhanik Angaharu Don’t teach 10th 72 ‘Sri 5 Baata- Niyukti

Garibakshnch’ Don’t teach 10th 75 Nepal Adhirajya Nepal Rajya 10th 82 Pahila ra Pancho Bunda Don’t Teach

Table 6.1 : Suggestions on what not to teach

Subject: Nepali

Class-9 71 Srijanatmak Abhhyaas rahe ko Rajmukut Sirsakma Prabandh

Lekhne Kriyakalap Replace with

content on nationality

Subject-English Class 5th 164 His majesty’s Government of

Nepal Government of

Nepal 9th and 10th Pages

inside His majesty’s Government of

Nepal Government of

Nepal

Table 6.2: Replace the content

Page 7: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

6.2 National Anthem

National anthem and Rastriya geettranslating the vision of Nepali nation statnational anthem of Nepal was opposed by Maoists as it was praising the King as Almighty. So, it was replaced in August 2007 by a new national anthem, which is now incorporated in the school textbooks

Photo 6.1: New National Anthem in the textbook

English translation of the Nepali National AnthemWe are hundreds of flowers, the Sovereign, spread out from Mechi to Mahakali.We are hundreds of flowers, the one garland Sovereign, spread out from Mechi to Mahakali.Amassing nature’s millions of heritageBy the blood of the brave, independent and immovablLand of knowledge, land of peace, Terai hills, mountainsUndivided this beloved, our motherland Nepal.Diverse race, language, religion, culture are so largeOur progressive nation, long live, long live Nepal.

123

Rastriya geet (national songs) played a significant role in translating the vision of Nepali nation state after 1960s (Caddell, 2007). national anthem of Nepal was opposed by Maoists as it was praising the King as Almighty. So, it was replaced in August 2007 by a new national anthem, which is now incorporated in the school textbooks.

Photo 6.1: New National Anthem in the textbook

English translation of the Nepali National Anthem-

We are hundreds of flowers, the one garland – Nepali Sovereign, spread out from Mechi to Mahakali. We are hundreds of flowers, the one garland – Nepali Sovereign, spread out from Mechi to Mahakali. Amassing nature’s millions of heritage By the blood of the brave, independent and immovable. Land of knowledge, land of peace, Terai hills, mountains Undivided this beloved, our motherland Nepal. Diverse race, language, religion, culture are so large Our progressive nation, long live, long live Nepal.

-(Retrieved from http://www.nationalanthems.info/np.htm)

(national songs) played a significant role in (Caddell, 2007). The old

national anthem of Nepal was opposed by Maoists as it was praising the King as Almighty. So, it was replaced in August 2007 by a new national anthem, which is

http://www.nationalanthems.info/np.htm)

Page 8: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

6.3 Towards Fulfilling the Promises made under the 40 Point Charter of Demand

The 40 point demand was presented before the government in February 1996, in which the Maoists asked for education in the mother tongue, a unified education system, free education up to secondary level, special support to disabled, gender equit

Free textbooks are now, being given up to 10and School Sector Reforms Plan education up to secondary levelrepresenting a changed political ideology and gender perspectives. The new textbook for Social Science for 9participation of women in development. 6.4 Politics of Photographs

The photo of the royal family was torn off during the “People’s War” and new text book of Social Science of class 10Peace Agreement of 2006. In the chapter, a photograph of Maoist leader Prachanda and the then Prime Minister, G.P. Koirala has been shown signing the peace treaty.

Photo No-6.2 Mr.G.P. Koirala and Prachanda in the textbook

124

Towards Fulfilling the Promises made under the 40 Point Charter of

The 40 point demand was presented before the government in February 1996, in which the Maoists asked for education in the mother tongue, a unified education system, free education up to secondary level, special support to disabled, gender equity, etc.

Free textbooks are now, being given up to 10th standard. An interim constitution School Sector Reforms Plan (2009)_ emphasise on the right to get free

education up to secondary level(SSRP, 2009).Text books are being revised, now a changed political ideology and gender perspectives. The new Social Science for 9th standard has a special chapter on equal

participation of women in development.

6.4 Politics of Photographs

The photo of the royal family was torn off during the “People’s War” and new text book of Social Science of class 10th has a chapter on Comprehensive Peace Agreement of 2006. In the chapter, a photograph of Maoist leader Prachanda

e Minister, G.P. Koirala has been shown signing the peace treaty.

Mr.G.P. Koirala and Prachanda in the textbook

Towards Fulfilling the Promises made under the 40 Point Charter of

The 40 point demand was presented before the government in February 1996, in which the Maoists asked for education in the mother tongue, a unified education system, free education up to secondary level, special support to orphans and

An interim constitution emphasise on the right to get free

Text books are being revised, now a changed political ideology and gender perspectives. The new

standard has a special chapter on equal

The photo of the royal family was torn off during the “People’s War” and now the has a chapter on Comprehensive

Peace Agreement of 2006. In the chapter, a photograph of Maoist leader Prachanda e Minister, G.P. Koirala has been shown signing the peace treaty.

Page 9: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

125

6.5 New Provisions for School Management Committee (SMC) SMCs are being constituted for a three years term. An executive committee comprising of ten members take decisions. This committee includes representatives of women and different communities. Head master works as the secretary. Now School Management Committees are more empowered and are functioning in a decentralized manner. Earlier, members of the committee were appointed by the district officials on the basis of connections with Panchayat representatives or personnel of the royal government. But now, majority of the members are elected by the parents and local community. 6.6 Education Provision in the Interim Constitution, 2007

The Provision of Education in the Interim Constitution, 2007 (Section-3, Article 18 of Democratic Republic of Nepal includes: • Right to education and culture of each citizen has been provisioned as a

fundamental right. • Each community has a right to protect its own language, script and

culture. • Each community can operate primary schools with mother tongue as the

medium of instruction. • Provisions will be made to ensure free education up to Secondary Level.

6.7 Integrated School System

Integrated school system has been proposed and is being implemented gradually, as schools are being upgraded from primary to elementary and so on. The senior secondary is being integrated with the school system, which was part of higher education earlier. Structural integration of classes 1st to 5th with 6th to 8th in schools is believed to improve students’ performance with introduction of a

Page 10: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

126

competency-based learning programme. The integrated structure will minimize cases of dropouts, as it providing inter-linkages which were not their earlier. The School Management Committee (SMC) can also play an effective role, with an integrated school system, in planning and monitoring.

Integration of art and craft skills from 6th standard onwards has also been proposed under the School Sector Reform Plan, 2009. 6.8 Recruitment of Teachers

The Department of Education has estimated a shortage of about 60,000 teachers in the school system (SSRP, 2009). Now the teacher recruitment will be done through a centralized process and only candidates having teacher’s licenses will be recruited. SMCs have been given a significant role in teacher management. Provisions have been made to give a budget to the SMC, so that they can send school teachers for need based in service-training.

The minimum qualifications of teachers for basic education will be higher secondary in place of secondary school. In teacher recruitment, females, Dalits, and other disadvantaged groups will be given a priority to address issues of gender and social exclusion (SSRP, 2009).

“The National Centre for Educational Development (NCED) is conducting certification and recurrent training courses for primary and secondary level teachers through Education Training Centers (ETCs) located at different places in the country and through other allied training-providers. Completion of a professional teacher training course has been made mandatory, prior to entering the teaching profession”- SSRP, 2009, p. 37). 6.9 Addressing the Issues of Language

In Nepal, leading political parties have been promising to do justice with the regional languages and representation of the other languages along with Nepali

Page 11: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

127

in the textbooks. After the departure of monarchy, some efforts are being made to develop textbooks in the local languages. Awadhi has been incorporated as an optional subject in the early grades. A text book in Awadhi for standard-1(Hamar Bhasha) was introduced during the academic session of 2009-2010. The initiative received appreciation at international forums, especially by Multi Lingual Education groups. However, during my field visits to the schools of an Awadhi speaking area, I found that the Awadhi text book is not being used by the teachers. In the current academic session (2010-2011), the Awadhi text book did not reach the school, so English is being taught as an optional subject in standard-1. Many parents prefer English to Awadhi. They believe English will provide better opportunities to their children. 6.10 Framework for Schools as Zones of Peace

Recognizing education as a the fundamental right of the child and responsibility of the government, In May, 2011, the Ministry of Education presented a framework for Schools as Zones of Peace, which was approved by the cabinet. Code of conduct is being developed to ensure smooth functioning of the schools in an inclusive and non threatening manner. Photo No-6.3. Schools as Zones of peace campaign

Page 12: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

128

6.11 Provisions of Scholarships for Children of Martyrs

The School Sector Reform Plan of 2009, Ministry of Education, Government of Nepal (2009) has proposed scholarship for the children of martyrs’ families (who sacrificed their life during the “People’s War”) along with girl students, Dalits, disabled and girls of the Karnali region. Dalit students will be getting Nepali Rupia -350 per year and children of martyrs will be given Nepali Rupia-1000 per year.

6.12 Ray of Hope

The new era demands a new social contract to emerge, as the forces that fought against the State now lead the State. The political parties mistrust each other, and are struggling with fractions within the party, which lead not only to political instability but uncertainty on finalizing the constitution of the country. If the political parties fail to form solidarity on issues of national importance, the country managing with limited resources and high aspirations may fail to address issues of development, welfare and essential services and would go into chaos. The past experiences have proved that ‘where the transitions remained disputed, the State lost its capacity to enforce the rule of law, even if it managed to hang on to power’ (Mungiu-Pippidi, 2010, pp. 120-127).

Evidences gathered from primary and secondary sources, reveal that certain groups were deprived from resources and were denied opportunities in an organized manner at various levels. It is not limited to stray instances of depriving and denying opportunities, but apparently has a long history of biased practices. The nature of the exploitative cycle was interlinked and distinct at the same time. The country was a proclaimed Hindu nation having 80 percent believers of Hinduism. This religious identity of the nation, not only helped the monarch and elites to protect their privileged position, but also to maintain the opportunity gaps. The privileged groups legitimized many of the exclusionary practices through religion. Any act or criticism against the King was not only unacceptable

Page 13: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

129

in the country during their rule, but was also banned by constitutional provisions. As mentioned in chapter -5, the caste based social structure got sanctioned by the religious identity of the nation and helped Bahun and Chetri communities to exploit the educational services and opportunities in their favor.

Tumin (1985) rightly articulated that ‘when religion is the dominant institution- as in medieval church and modern fundamentalist states such as Iran- the highest rewards, power, prestige as well as property, are likely to be awarded to the chief religious specialists such as bishops, cardinals, caliphs and imams’ ( Tumin,1985,p. 39). In the case of Nepal, the Kings were Chetri by caste and enjoyed the supreme religious position as the living form of Lord Vishnu. They enjoyed the highest rewards, power, prestige and property. The Bahuns, being the priest class, also benefited with rewards, power, prestige and property.

Though the upper caste supremacy is very much evident, it was further combined with regional identity, so the most beneficial groups of these castes were from the hill region rather than the Terai. The Bahun and Chetri of the Terai only received benefits and opportunities in their region that were relatively less attractive or were given up by Bahun and Chetri of the hill, in the absence of options available within their own clan. People of the Terai, who constitute 35 percent of the population, had a feeling of being second class citizens, as their representation in the Royal Nepal Army and the civil services had been minimal. In contrast, Newars who accounted for only 5.6 percent of the total population and highly concentrated in and around Kathmandu had occupied as much as 36 percent of the civil service positions in the 1990s (Rana, 1998).

School norms were made on the basis of regions and raised many questions. Before 2007, the pupil-teacher ratio (PTR) stipulated for mountain and for the Terai region was not equal.

Page 14: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

130

Along with regional discrimination, social mobility was limited even after the abolition of the Panchayat System and the restoration of Multi-Party Democracy under monarchy. In 2006, at the primary school (Prathmik) level, only 3 percent teachers were from the Dalit communities and 2 percent were from the marginalized Janjati groups. At the lower secondary level (Nimn Madhyamik), the representation of Dalits and Janjatis stood at 2 percent and 1 percent respectively (TRSE-3, 2007). Few Muslim teachers were part of the teaching community in the Terai and some were appointed as Sanskrit teachers and now teach Nepali after 2007.

This low representation of socially excluded groups comes from the access and participation at school level. The challenges before the children were not only in access to schools in the neighborhood but also poverty and discrimination in the schools. It was confirmed by many respondents, that upper caste people (including teachers) preferred to send their children to private schools, and now consider government schools for children of ‘nanh jaati’ (lower caste). A fifth of children in Nepal now attend private schools and the proportion of children getting enrolled in private schools is increasing .

Language was another dimension of exclusion, as previously Sanskrit and later Nepali, were medium of instruction. Since learning Sanskrit was of professional significance to Bahuns to perform religious rituals, they capitalized opportunities in literacy and education as well. Both Sanskrit and Nepali were not in practice among a sizeable number of Nepali people, so they accepted their poor education attainment as a failure of individuals, rather than being victims of a discriminatory system. Bourdieu (1986) reminds of the ‘cultural capital’ which is a must to acquire for the students uniformly. So, the working class children find success harder, as they have to learn new culture, practices and language.

Political scenario was a reflection of the stratified society of Nepal. In most of the cases, political competition was between the leaders of the upper caste. Majority

Page 15: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

131

of senior leaders of political parties are either Bahun or Chetri and therefore, it was a real challenge for the Dalits to claim their rightful political space (Gellner, 2007). Though the state claims to serve all citizens, in reality only the interests of the powerful groups get protected while the marginalized groups get symbolic space, instead of actual power positions (Sears, 2008).

Though primary education was free but 15 percent of the total teachers working in primary schools were dependent on the resources generated by the schools, so students were bound to pay fee, which contributed funds for the salaries of the Niji Srot teachers. Therefore, the choice was clear, either have only one or two teachers, or be ready to pay for the additional teachers.

Quality of teaching and commitment of teachers were also a concern. In 2006, only 47 percent teachers had the necessary training. Since the remuneration of the contract teachers were not very attractive, they were engaged in doing other assignments. In 2011, some contract teachers revealed that they get Nepali Rupee1,200 /- as remuneration.

Timely supply of the text books to all the schools of the country was an issue earlier. For example, 65 percent schools did not get a full set of text books at the beginning of the academic session of 2005-2006. Very often, students got text books in the middle of the session. Teachers revealed that the money allocated for textbooks by the government to the schools was often not enough (33 percent less than required) to ensure a full set of text books for all the enrolled students (TRSE-3, 2007). A volatile political situation also affected foreign aid to education in the country during the “People’s War”. As stated in the earlier chapter, the European Commission withdrew financial aid to education (The Kathmandu Post, 2005).

As has been stated earlier, the schools have been used by various groups to promote and challenge the visions of national identity. Earlier the textbooks and the national anthem were used to perpetuate supremacy of the monarchy. After

Page 16: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

132

the end of the “People’s War” and restoration of Multi-Party Democracy, political parties agreed to reform the agenda of education. Through a Government Order of 2007, teachers were asked not to teach certain lessons, contents and words (related with monarchy) in the text books (see annex).

As mentioned before, out of the 40 demands presented by the Maoists before the Prime Minister Sher Bhadur Deuba, in February 2006, eight demands were closely linked with education (Muni, 2004). Some of the demands were– making Nepal a secular State, end of gender based discrimination in property, end of region based and caste based discrimination and prejudices, ensuring mother tongue based education till higher secondary level etc. By putting these demands on the party agenda, Maoists successfully mobilized support of the youth and the excluded communities. Social division and Maoists’ success reflects anger against the denial of equal opportunities for the excluded groups. Davies (2004) rightly pointed out that conflict that looks of a religious or ethnic origin can also have background of economic divisions.

With the hope to get better future prospects and make Nepal a self-reliant country, a substantial number of teachers and children also supported the vision of “New Nepal”.

Informal Sector Service Centre (INSEC), estimated that at least 141 teachers were killed during the “People’s War”, 84 by the Maoists and the rest by the security forces (IRINnews, 2006). 475 children were also killed in which 205 were girls (CWIN, 2009).

While the “People’s War” was on the rise in 2002, Seventh Amendment on Education Act (Ministry of Education and Sports, 2004) was enforced with provisions of adoption of community schools as a system of education, free education at the community primary school, teacher training and teacher licensing, de-politicization of teaching force, regulation of private schools, free

Page 17: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

133

education and incentives for Dalit children. Through the new amendment, the government attempted to encounter the Maoists allegations of injustice and the denial of rights and tried to attract the marginalized sections in their favor. This way, both the parties at war against each other, kept education at the center of their strategy, to influence communities and mobilize them to their side. Maoists also introduced their own calendar in 20-25 schools, and asked teachers to declare holidays on Labour Day, on the birthday of Mao (Basnet, 2005).

People of Nepal had dreamt of better life opportunities and better governance, but due to the instability of the government and lack of consensus among political parties things have not improved much. Bringing a change in the schooling, Ministry of Education has been working on school sector reforms. Favoring multilingual education, it is working for producing a new set of text books. It also has provisions for incentives for marginalized children and for teacher training. But, as there is hardly any restructuring of the old administrative system, it is unlikely that there will be many positive changes to benefit the learners studying in the government schools.

Enrollment, retention and quality of learning are the major challenges in addition to generation of faith, among the parents; in the education system with more than 50 percent untrained, poorly paid and politicized teachers. Restructuring of the bureaucracy is an imperative, keeping the issues of social exclusion and the need to ensure equal opportunity for all in perspective. For such a restructuring to take place, a stable government is required, with enough resources. However, the political leadership of all the leading parties is still in the hands of Bahun and Chetri/Thakuri. Some changes have been proposed in education, but on the whole, it seems like power has got transferred from one group of elite to another within the clan. (Both the prime ministers of CPN (Maoist), Prachnada and Babu Ram Bhattarai are ‘Bahun’, like G. P. Koirala, who served as Prime Minister in Nepal for the longest period of time. This is a case of ‘circulation of elites’ as

Page 18: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

134

stated by Pareto, which is the clue to maintain equilibrium in the society as well (Delaney, 1971).

Provisions have been made for the reservation and promotion of Dalits, Janjati groups and women in administration and education services. But relative instability and high expectations from the government are the major challenges on the political front. In a society with a complex social structure, it would always be a test for the government to justify actions and decide who is the entitled to enjoy the biggest share of property and power (Melvin, 1985).

In education, ensuring equal opportunities for all the social groups and establishing forward institutional linkages, should be the priority for the government. As education plays a crucial role in developing the human capital, which results in economic growth and individual benefits (Judson, 1998). National Framework for Capacity Development has been prepared and recognized as an essential means of ensuring quality education through School Sector Reform Plan for 2009 (SSRP,2009).

Tawil (2002) warns at this stage, that educational policy-making, in the context of uncertain peace and instability, is a challenge and high unemployment could be a threat to sustainable peace, particularly in post-conflict situations.

A new constitution has not been finalized yet and the country is being governed by the constitution enforced in 1990, with some changes approved by the Constituent Assembly. The anger of the youth groups, students and ordinary people in general is rising, with political uncertainty and frequent calls for ‘Bandh’.

The economic condition of the country cannot be improved without political stability. The issue of unemployment, if not tackled quickly, could be a threat to sustainable peace, particularly in the post-conflict phase (Tawil, 2002).Educational policy-making in the context of uncertain peace and relative instability is a big task for the government in power.

Page 19: Chapter 6 Post Transition: Emerging Trends and …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/13642/12/12_chapter 6.pdf118 CHAPTER - 6 POST TRANSITION: EMERGING TRENDS AND CHALLENGES

135

On the issues of ethnic representation and language, Nepal must project and protect a common identity internally and externally. If Nepal fails to do so, formation of a new social contract would be difficult to achieve, and it would collapse like all the other three post-communist federations — the USSR, Yugoslavia, and Czechoslovakia -- collapsed (Mungiu-Pippidi, 2010).