chapter 8 new wave research: contemporary applied approaches
TRANSCRIPT
Chapter 8New Wave Research:
Contemporary Applied Approaches
Action Research
• The systematic collection & analysis of data for the purpose of taking action & making
change
Participatory Action Research
• A subset of action research
• Three elements:research, adult education, sociopolitical action
Steps in Action Research
• Entry into the community
• Assessment of the situation
• Planning for research and action
• Implementation of plan and reflection
• Evaluation of the implementation
• Report and reassessment
• Planning future action
Evaluation Research
• A systematic appraisal using the methods of social research for the purpose of generating knowledge that can be used for decision making
• Also referred to as outcomes research
Purpose of Evaluation Research
• Needs assessment
• Formative evaluation
• Summative evaluation
Steps in Evaluation Research
• Identification of program objectives
• Measurement of program objectives
• Collection of data
• Analysis & interpretation of data
Pluralistic Approaches to Evaluation Research
• Approach selected depends upon the purpose of the evaluation
• Classic experiment (RCT)
• Evaluation case study
Health Promotion Research
• Systematic investigation into the processes and substance of health promotion action
• A broad range of studies including health policy, lifestyle, socioepidemiology
• Some include anthropology of health & community participation studies
Scope of Health Promotion Research
• Individual
• Family
• Community
Methods for Health Promotion Research
• Debate re traditional public health measures vs nontraditional methods
• Use a multiplicity of methods
• Question and objectives should guide design
Feminist Research
• valuing of women & their experiences
• seeing phenomenon from the perspective of women
• recognizing conditions that oppress women
• a desire to change conditions through criticism & political action
Feminist Methods
• Use a variety of quantitative & qualitative methods
• Most emphasis is on qualitative with in-depth interviews
Feminist Research (Harding)• Core purpose is to create social change to benefit
women
• a variety of methods are used to collect data but data are always analyzed within the context of women’s lives
• relationship b/w the researcher & participant is horizontal
• participant is a legitimate knower of the experience-an expert
F.R. - Philosophical Tenets
• Similar to critical social theory
• Acknowledges oppresive nature of social structures
• Universal role of systematic patriarchy in society
• Places gender centrally within research
• Promotes equality within the research team
Method/methodology
• Multiplicity of methods
• Select a method appropriate to the question
• Method ( technique for collecting evidence)
• Methodology (how the methods should be used)
• Methodology should be consistent with feminist epistemology
Feminist Methodology
• Values women’s subjective experiences
• Values importance of context in women’s lives. Method should provide a rich description of the context
• Values relationship of researcher & participant
• Values inclusion of diverse women
F.R.- Question
• Issues that are of primary concern to women
• requires women to report their experiences in their own voices
• allows for a structural analysis of the conditions of women’s lives & should lead to an improvement of it
• e.g. accessing health care, women’s work, women’s health, poverty, motherhood
F.R. - Role of the Researcher
• Nonhierarchical, reciprocal relationship
• Views self as a partner with participants
• Vulnerable one, shares experiences & emotions with participants as team member
• Reflexivity is expected of the researcher
F.R. - Sample
• Purposive
• Embrace diversity of women’s lives
• Include women of diverse social class, ethnic groups, cultures, etc
• Critical of ethnocentric bias in nursing studies
F.R. - Data Collection
• Oral history interviewing
• Multiple in-depth interviews
• Participant observation
• Focus group interviews
• Structured/ semi-structured interview guides
• Documents such a diaries, letters, photos
• Questionnaires and indexes
F.R. - Data Analysis
• Content is analyzed in terms of artifacts produced by women, about women, for women
• Patriarchy & ethnocentric bias are major themes examined in the analysis
• Participants are active partners in the data analysis process
F.R. - Findings
• Use descriptive, non-sexist language • Portray women’s voices• Structural analysis of everyday lives of
women• User friendly, accessible to all not just
intellectuals• Includes an analysis of the role of the
researcher