chapter three talent management -...
TRANSCRIPT
CHAPTER THREE
TALENT MANAGEMENT
The term ‘Talent Management’ first emerged in 1990s to incorporate
development in human resource management, which placed more emphasis on
management of human resources or talent. The term was coined by David Watkins
of Softscape, published in a article in 1998.(1) The connection between human
resource development and organizational effectiveness has been established since
1970s. The issue of talent management with many companies put tremendous
pressure on attracting employees, but devoted meager time in developing talent and
retaining it. Talent management system needs to be worked into business strategy
and implementing in daily processes throughout company as a whole.
Usually companies leave this task over human resource department to attract
and retain employees and take the issue very lightly. In view of increasing
importance of talent management, it has become necessary to give high priority for
selection of appropriate persons for each task in the company and train them suitably
about the task to be handled with great care and make constant efforts to enhance
their capacity to maintain the quality and output at the requisite level. In most of the
industrial units the task of talented persons has become most critical to substantiate
the vision of the management through quality control.
One industry or business group has various divisions as per need and every
division has specific specialized task to be handled by workers and unit manager is
required to acclimatize the subordinates with the work culture and develop their
skills. Each manager within company should openly share the information with the
employees of other departments to gain knowledge of overall organizational
objectives. Companies focusing on talent-integrated plans remain attentive over
various steps of talent management, which is necessary for remaining in the
competitive market.
(a) Sourcing, attracting, recruiting and on boarding qualified candidates with
competitive backgrounds,
Chapter -3: Talent Management 45
(b) Managing and defining competitive salaries associated with the quality,
output, innovations in technological spheres.
(c) Providing training and development opportunities
(d) Introducing and adhering performance management processes,
(e) Remain cautious on retention of talent through various measures,
(f) Promotion and transitioning of the talent as reward for performance and
proving their capability on challenging positions.
3.1 MEANING OF TALENT MANAGEMENT:
The assets of an organization can be divided into two parts i.e., its people and
everything else. Usually the value of company is measured by its real estate, sales,
inventories, supply chains, accounts receivable, brand recognition and many other
pieces, when assembled create an organization’s physical and market presence. It
may also be termed that a company consists of human beings, who use technology to
improve the life of their fellow citizens. A dictionary definition of ‘talent’ is people,
who possess special attitude or faculty. This definition possesses the whiff of
creativity of thinking outside the box, of unique ability to solve a problem.
Present intensely competitive marketplace tolerates no automations or
robotic time card punchers, who dutifully perform the same task year after year and
hope to retire with gold watch. Large and small companies, mom-and-pop corner
store and global level company are required to be nimble, creative and ready to
abandon old reliable methods to face the challenges of new paradigms. The
performance of task by rote inevitably leads to decline and irrelevance; talent infuses
the human experience with dynamism and creativity.
In addition to tough competition, global economic crisis creates problem on
functioning of various companies, where the organizations are gripped with internal
and external challenges and existence of the companies remains quite critical and
compelled to reduce its human resources to face the crisis or face the situation with
the best practices with the help of talent have limited options. Survival of
organizations in dwindling economic environment remains quite challenging, but the
Chapter -3: Talent Management 46
organizations able to face the situation in effective manner, with swift management
policies, are able to flourish their business in later duration.
Talent management has been acknowledged to be a critical success factor for
organizations. Usually various expert institutions have addressed the theoretical
concepts of the talent management, but there are various factors, which require
application systems within organization to chalk out its own strategy to run the
company effectively. These issues are associated with effective talent management
practices and its impact on the employment relationship in terms of psychological
contracts, commitments, turnover intention, differences between generations in
terms of ideologies and innovative practices.
The experts visualize the talent management from the aspect to select the
best persons and use the available talent in most effective manner and interpreted the
terminology as per their own vision and perspectives as detailed below. Certainly
these aspects help the management to understand the conceptual framework and
interpret in their own manner, as the management is required to take long-term
policy measures and also to carry out various short-term remedial measures to
remove the problematic issues responsible for various constraints or likely to create
problem, if corrective measures are not taken timely. (2)
3.1.1 Concerns of Talent Management:
Talent management concerns the additional management processes and
opportunities; those are made available to employees in the organization, who are
considered to be talented. This means systematically attracting, identifying,
developing, engaging, retaining and deploying those individuals with high
potentials, who are of particular value to the organization. This is the ability of the
management or chief manager to select appropriate person for each problematic or
innovative area and assess the capability of selected person to derive requisite results
in desired manner. Wrong person can ruin total game plan.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 47
3.1.2 Talent Segmentation:
Talent can be segmented either from the exclusive perspective focusing
practices on any specific group in the organization such as high potentials in the
sense of an elite sub-group of future leaders or an inclusive perspective recognizing
and focusing practices on the talent of all employees in the organization. Such
decisions become inevitable, where the organization has diversified activities and
each department has to address the specific issues related to its own sphere. In
addition, talent is not limited to top level dignitaries of the organization, but middle
and subordinate persons may have solution to specific issue, which the top level
executives are not in a position to accept.
3.1.3 Psychological Contract:
In the situations, where an employee believes to be obliged to perform or
behaves in certain way and also believes that the organization has certain obligations
at the specific employee, who starts to hold psychological contract. This represents
an individual belief regarding the terms and conditions of a reciprocal exchange
agreement between individual and the organization. The psychological contract
consists of employee obligations, employer obligations and psychological contract
evaluation. Such evaluation can be measured in terms of fulfillment or violation of
the reciprocal obligations.
Psychological contract fulfillment is the degree, which a contract party is
perceived as keeping its contract terms, whereas the psychological contract is
violated, when the employee or employer perceives the other does not comply the
promised obligations and consequently has negative emotions towards the other. The
over-confidence of an employee regarding its own capability or the employer over-
faith on the person may create very embarrassing situation and things are clear,
when some opportunity arises to adjudge the capability. There is necessity to have
direct contract with such employee to adjudge its capability to prove its worthiness.
3.1.4 Generation Gap and Talent Management:
In any organization, employees working for different durations, generation
gap become an issue of ego among the employees about their capability and
Chapter -3: Talent Management 48
capacity. Talent is an intellectual property of an individual, which always vary
among the persons of same age group and qualifications. Similarly the elder staff
possesses experience of working in same task for long duration and gained
capability to derive requisite results. New person has advance knowledge of the
specific subject and may prove worthy in terms of innovative technological inputs
and quality. The management and senior executives must not be bias with pre-
conceptual thinking and interact both to understand the vision and approach.
3.1.5 Organizational Commitment:
Organizational commitment describes the strength of an individual’s
identification with and an attachment to an organization. It has been conceptualized
as having three main dimensions: affective, continuance and normative. The
effective commitment is the situation, where employee intends to transcribe the task
into practice, while maintaining the quality and cost effectiveness. The continuance
is reflected in the situation, where the employee is loyal to its work and honesty, but
continuance is possible through similar reciprocation through encouragements and
enhanced salary or promotion.
3.1.6 Turnover Intention:
Relationship between management and employee is of master and servant in
real terms, where the top most dignitaries are subordinate to the organization
owners. The terms in between the two remain coordinating or confrontation with
mutual sides and management need to take care of the employees, who express their
loyalty and remain honest in their work and behaviour. The management and
employee remain well aware of the views of each other and decide their future
course of action in response to the relationships. Employees take their decision to
leave organization quite consciously and deliberately.
3.1.7 Talent Management and Accenture:
Talent management is the capability to create and continuously optimize the
talent resources needed to execute business strategy, attracting and developing them,
guiding their performance towards optimal productivity in the light of strategic goals
and finding new sources of value in their performance through innovation and
continuous improvement. Talent powerful organization is intended to truly compete
to create accenture cells, which compels to do something more by adding people to
fill in the gap.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 49
The organization must be capable to multiply talent by recombining skills,
knowledge and organizational processes, thereby increasing contribution of
individuals, teams, work-groups and entire workforce to increase capability,
learning, flexibility, innovation and performance, as such to create extra-ordinary
value through people. Talent powered organizations can create sustainable long-term
competitive advantage by multiplying talent and significantly more likely to achieve
high performance. Alignment of people and performance to business strategy is
improved, employees are more engaged and their productivity is increased. Core
accenture offerings talent management is detailed below:
(a) Talent Strategy: Articulating strategic goals and defining talent needs, multi-
polar world impacts, workforce strategies, segmentation etc.
(b) Talent Resourcing: Discovery and deploying talent sourcing, recruiting and
workforce planning.
(c) Learning and Collaboration: Defining new ways of working and learning in a
technology savvy, geographically dispersed, ever-changing world.
(d) Performance and Reward: Measuring and managing performance, aligning
rewards with results- objectives, assessments, incentives and recognition.
(e) Work-force Solutions: Identifying organization’s most critical work forces
and defining the capabilities required to increase engagement, productivity
skills and retention.
Relationship in talent management and accenture is helpful in multiplying
the organization performance reflected to added production and productivity and the
organization can accentuate in befitted manner. Accenture offers solutions that
build the components for talent multiplication. Above features have been
incorporated in Figure 3.1 for visual approach.
3.1.8 Effect of Segmentation on Perceived Employment Relationships:
An organization can chose two talent management approaches in case of
segmentation, viz., inclusive and exclusive. Inclusive approach focuses on talent
management practices on specific group in the organization, for instance on high
potentials, in the sense of elite sub-group of future leaders. The inclusive approach
recognizes and focuses talent management practices on the talent of all employees in
Chapter -3: Talent Management 50
the organization. An exclusive talent segmentation approach results in significant
differences in the way, employees experience their employment relationships.
Psychological contract violation stands out, when an exclusive approach is
being used in an organization. This means that employees experience more breech of
promises made by the organization. Since the previous research has established a
high correlation between breech of employer promises and behavioural aspects of
employee performance, this is an important aspect to consider. Talents experience
less psychological contract violation and non-talent experience more psychological
contract violation. The differences in percentages between talents and others are
smaller, when the segmentation approach is exclusive. (2)
These results show that organization should include the effect on
employment relationship, while defining their segment approach. The segmentation
approach may create high differences in the organization, which can result in
frustration in other non-
Figure 3.1
Talent Management and Accenture
Chapter -3: Talent Management 51
Included employees and they start thinking in opposite direction.
Consequences of no segmentation and segmentation approach are given in Figure
3.2 and 3.3
3.2 PROCESSES OF TALENT MANAGEMENT
Talent management has become most important buzzwords in corporate
sector, where human resource department has been recognized as separate entity. In
addition training of the personnel recruited has become essential to acquaint the
employees about the specific features of the task to be handled. In addition, the
competitive market has necessitated the quality and cost aspects most requisite
issues. Selection and training of personnel was earlier handled by personnel
department, but organizations had realized the importance of human resource
function has much larger role.
Recruitment of right persons, training, helping design job roles and
organizational structure have become most critical factors for retention of the
personnel. Necessity has arisen to develop total compensation package, which
Figure 3.2
Consequences of no segmentation (the inclusive strategy)
Chapter -3: Talent Management 52
Figure 3.3
Consequences of no segmentation (the exclusive strategy)
Figure 3.4
Evolution of the HR function
include Benefits, stock options and bonuses, as well as serving at central point of
communication for employee’s health and happiness. Head of personnel has now
become key functionary of human resource and has much important role in business
strategy and execution. The system has been built to support new role including
recruiting and applicants tracking, portals, total compensation system and learning
management systems.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 53
In this role, human resource department has become more than a business
function, rather business partner reaching out to support lines of business. Evolution
of the Human Resources Function is given in Figure 3.4, which is evident that talent
management has emerged into new era of business management, where human
resource and leadership development organizations are on new set of strategic
issues, which have intensive approach in following issues:
(a) To make recruitment process more efficient and more effective by using
competency-based recruitment rather than sorting through resumes or one at
a time approach.
(b) Develop managers and leaders to reinforce culture, instill values and create
sustainable leadership pipeline.
(c) Quickly identify competency gaps to deliver training, e-learning or
development programmes to fill identified gaps, through most appropriate
persons.
(d) Measure people in consistent and measurable way, where everyone is
aligned, help accountable for lapses and paid fairly.
(e) To identify high performers and successors to key positions throughout the
organization to make highly flexible and responsive organization.
(f) To assess that learning provided to functionaries is relevant, flexible,
convenient and timely.
These new and more challenging problems require new processes and
systems. There is immense need for higher integration between different human
resource silos and direct integration into line of business management processes.
Organizations have started to buy, build and stitch together performance
management systems, succession planning systems and competency management
systems. The human resource function has become integrated with the business in a
real-time fashion. In this type of business process, no organization intends to lag
behind, which may lead to be failure of the business group.
Process of talent management has been depicted in Figure 3.5, where total
cycle is inter-connected with each other with the objective to implement business
Chapter -3: Talent Management 54
plan into performance management. Starting from workforce planning and
concludes on critical skills and gap analysis, as detailed below:
Figure 3.5
Talent Management : A Process
(a) Workforce Planning: This is integrated with business plan and this process
establishes workforce plans, hiring plans, compensation budgets and hiring
targets for total year duration.
(b) Recruiting: This is integrated process of recruitment assessment, evaluation
and hiring the business brings people into the organization.
(c) On boarding: The organization must train and enable employees to become
productive and integrated into the company more quickly, as long time need
not be encouraged.
(d) Performance Management: This can be achieved with the help of business
plan, where the organization establishes its own processes to measure and
manage employees. This is a complex process in itself require careful
handling.
(e) Training and Performance Support: This is most important and critical
function, which envisages providing, learning and development programme
Chapter -3: Talent Management 55
to all levels of the organization. Training and performance support is
required to be separate to different functionaries keeping in view their tasks
and expectations of the organization from functionaries at different levels
and required to evolve continuous support function.
(f) Succession Planning: There is continuous need to move personnel into new
positions to evolve changes in the organizational system. Succession
planning enables managers and individuals to identify right candidate for any
position. This function need to be aligned with the business plan to
understand and meet requirements for key positions on three to five yearly
basis. Such process is deemed necessary for managers and executives, but
application to all the functionary of business is also essential.
(g) Compensation and Benefits: This is an integral part of human resource
management, where organization is required to tie compensation plan
directly associated with performance management. The compensation,
incentives and benefits align with business goals and execution is necessary.
(h) Critical Skills Gap Analysis: Such functions are generally over-looked in
various industries and organizations, but such analysis is necessary to
identify the skill gaps for making the performance more elaborative and
taking early measures after identification of requisite gaps. Positions likely to
be vacant through retirement, attrition needs to be suitably addressed at the
earliest.
In the centre of total process, there is immense need to identify job roles,
description, competency and learning, where no ambiguity is left behind. Adjudging
the performance is possible, when the roles and descriptions are fully defined with
daily, monthly or annual performance indicators to be complied with. Such
indicators serve as yardstick before the personnel of each categories and base for
additional benefits. The top-level executive has to take decision to quantify the
performance indicators, as a line to decide as eligibility for benefits or promotion.
The success of the company remains on maintaining transparency in
performance indicators and to leave it open to all the functionaries of same
discipline. The criteria for promotion need to be maintained on the basis of
Chapter -3: Talent Management 56
performance in specific area, where discrimination in any form should not be
encouraged. The incompetent or under-competent person cannot be better leader and
posing such person by suppressing the interest can ruin the human resource
management. Talented person can handle all the problems effectively and explicitly.
In addition, such person needs to be preserved and protected for remaining with the
organization. (3)
3.3 TALENT MANAGEMENT STRATEGY:
Talent management is natural evolution of human resource and also series of
business process. It is neither product nor solution to be procured and inserted into
business system. Organizations are focused on different elements, driven by their
maturity and urgent business problem being handled by different organizations. Few
mature organizations handle their inherent problems cautiously and effectively;
other few focus on several key elements and develop their own integrated approach,
while understanding their problems. Talent management is forward looking
function, where it improves with flexibility and performance.
Talent management requires integration and communication between human
resource and leadership development functions. In this situation, training cannot be
left on island and leadership development organization must align with performance
management and recruitment process more closely. Training programmes need to be
developed and updated continuously addressing new problems faced by
organization. New recruits for certain competencies need to be offered training with
complement and reinforce these competencies. Compensation programme need to be
tied with performance management process.
Competency management is most critical component of training and human
resource development. Leadership development, recruitment and succession
planning share Job description, roles and competencies used for performance
management. There are various techniques for effective use of competencies and
many are described as performance management system. A simple best practice is to
develop small set of consistent, easy to understand and easy to be adopted in the
Chapter -3: Talent Management 57
organization. The personnel undergoing training need to understand their roles and
responsibilities in easy and accessible manner.
Easiest mode developed in the present is the software solution, but need to be
applied by understanding requirement of the organization and make corrections and
revisions as per requirement of the organization. Such software packages can be
taken as base to develop its own strategy keeping in view of specific requirements of
individual organization, as vendors are also not perfect to put appropriate solution to
the specific requirements of the organization, which may be most crucial for
adoption as part of training and performance indicators of specific group of
personnel.
3.3.1 Performance Management:
Performance management is ongoing communication process undertaken in
partnership between an employee and immediate supervisor, which involves
establishing clear expectations and understanding about job functions, employees
contributions to goals of organization, where job means in concrete terms in between
employee and supervisor working together to sustain and build on existing
performance. Performance management is strategic, linking organizational
objectives to individual performance and development. Initial stage in developing
performance management system is to identify missions and strategic goals with
following stages:
(a) Formulate goals at departmental level with their integration at strategic
levels.
(b) Managers and employees meet to agree on individual goals aligned with
departmental and strategic goals
(c) Identification of individual requirement is to prepare personal development
plan.
(d) Put the planning stage into practice
(e) Continue monitoring and feedback of identified goals and achieved by an
individual
(f) Formal and review feedback, identifying the reasons of shortfalls and
efficiency above the identified level.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 58
(g) Rating of individual performance comparing with previous stage and
reasons for deviations on both sides.
In increasing competitive environment, performance of employees is widely
recognized as leading influence on organizational effectiveness. Increasing
recognition has been reflected in gradual development of performance management.
Contemporary performance features wide range of models, tools and strategies,
which enables setting up of objectives and measuring of outcomes. Information
gathered on individuals from themselves, their customers, peers, subordinates
normally by means of anonymous questionnaires usually address competencies.
Use of balanced scorecard is also typical in performance oriented
organizations, where organization’s strategic objectives are translated into a set of
performance indicators. Organizational performance is measured in four key areas,
viz., financial, customer, internal business process and learning and growth, which
are assigned quantitative measures to analyze the information across the
organization. A notable trend has been widespread implementation of competency
based performance, which seeks to reward people for achieved results.
Competence describes behaviour of employee completing his role as well as
demonstrable activities that make the employee valuable to overall success of
organization. It is expected from the organization to recognize competencies that fit
its culture, context and performance requirements. Given the recent advances in
technologies, performance appraisal and management systems are widely available
online. Automating the process of performance appraisal and adding collaborative,
online capabilities, productivity should improve and employees need to be
empowered by taking active role in developing their career.
Employees and supervisors are able to create documents and gather
comments and approval from manages and incharge of human resources division.
Ideally, performance appraisal software streamlines the evaluation process, reduces
paperwork and encourages objectivity and organizations need to tailor online
systems to meet their own needs. Applying any tools, approach is expected to carry
Chapter -3: Talent Management 59
out business, where performance management processes are part of holistic
approach to managing for performance, which is concern of everyone in the
organization.
In implementing performance management tools the organization needs to
consider its culture, structure, technology and people involved to ensure the best fit
has been achieved. Best practices can be developed, but stating their research
identified number of qualities that represent good practices among the organization.
Following specific issues are helpful in identifying performance related aspects in
the organization.
(a) Clear understanding of aims, e.g., enhancing performance, improving
customer services, changing culture, providing support for individuals;
(b) Principles i.e., focus on changing behaviour rather than paperwork, being
driven by corporate purpose and values, developing a management tool to
help managers to undertake their responsibilities in realistic manner,
(c) Develop the process through maximum involvement of staff, recognizing
diversity, using line managers to facilitate implementation,
(d) Evaluation: the widespread use of attitude surveys and focus groups,
(e) Clarity in objectives without being stringent in laying down specific features
of the tasks in management and such objects are to be associated with
performance indicators,
(f) Competence: need to develop organizational role for identifying the level of
competency as performance benchmark.
3.3.2 Organizational Design and Structure:
Organizational design is defined as process of managing the organizational
structure, having important implications for competitiveness and survival of the
organization. The structure of the organization is not a tool for managing the
workforce, but also a means of communicating priorities and responsibilities
enabling management to focus employees and stakeholders attention on particular
aspects of the business. Organizational design need to support strategy
implementation, facilitate flow of work, permit effective managerial control and
create reasonable and measurable jobs.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 60
In determining the design of organization, management team needs to
consider competencies, seeking to exploit competitive advantage while achieving a
balanced trade-off between cost, control and access to markets. Managers are
required to diagnose organization situation and implement most appropriate design.
Need for potentially changing the organizational structure and considering the
organizational design as partly driven by the desire for greater financial security,
technological innovation, globalization and pronounced customer volatility along
with the current shift towards softer core competencies such as speed in the market,
reputation and services, which reflect the emergence of knowledge based economy.
The existing structure of organization impedes its ability to implement new
strategies or disrupt workflow of business processes, than restructuring can be
considered. In earlier times, the organizational design was initially based on the
principles of scientific management, where organizations mechanistic and heavily
centralized, with tall hierarchies and narrowly defined tasks. Before three decades, it
was deemed proper to decentralize structure with more organic, holstered
innovations and added customer services.
More recent research has focused on design of organization to improve
effectiveness in terms of strategy, size and innovations. Features of movement
towards decentralization have included flattening of organization, downsizing, re-
engineering of business process, sub-contracting outsourcing, multi-functional
project teams, empowerment of employees, increasing workforce flexibility,
expanding externalized workforce and development of multipurpose information
systems. Results of these trends are increasingly flexible and firms, which are able
to respond rapidly to changes in competitive environment, wider distribution of
expertise within the organization.
This has further necessitated a shift towards collective entrepreneurship and
social creatibility, where self-management is fostered. Increasing popularity of
decentralization has been recognized in forecast of key strategies and supported by
self-management paradigm. In determining organizational design, three frameworks
Chapter -3: Talent Management 61
have been identified, which provide decision rules that enable organization to assess
the trade-off between disparate corporate objectives:
(a) Adaptation of the balanced scorecard, which assesses the trade-offs
associated with centralizing or decentralizing functions;
(b) Tests for design alternatives, which examines the prospective outcomes of
the organizational design; and
(c) Natural business units, where companies identify business units with distinct
core competencies and markets as well as target for decentralization.
Instead of operating under one extreme or another, most companies maintain
hybrid structures, relying on shared services to exploit economies of scale, while
allowing customer facing entrepreneurial functions to be decentralized. Companies,
which decide to alter their structure in search of operational effectiveness, it is likely
to face a period of upheaval and employees dissatisfaction. Most common changes
of such type were related to merger and acquisition, takeovers, bankruptcy or
relocation of business. It is pertinent that restructuring and downsizing cannot
achieve desired results and organizations through this process can survive with well
thought system of causes and consequences.
There is no universal way to design an organization, the structure flow from
missions and strategies of organizations itself, with each organization adapting its
structure, systems, skills and style to its specific circumstances, but the design of an
organization centred around its need can survive and prosper The basic proposition
is that greater uncertainty leads to strategic processing by decision makers to come
out of ambiguity. Thus, variations in organizational form are strategic issues vary
according to work culture and objectives, where it is envisaged to consider:
(a) Increase their ability to pre-plan
(b) Increase their flexibility to adapt their inability to pre-plan, and
(c) Decrease the level of performance required for continual viability.
The problem of organizational design occurs, when there are many
employees in a number of specialist groups, which need to be integrated around
completion of global task. The organizational needs to create a mechanism that
Chapter -3: Talent Management 62
permits coordinated action across a number of independent roles, while increasing
the information processing capabilities. This task is quite critical, but can be
achieved through well-set coordinated rules and programmes, hierarchy and well-set
goals and targets. It is deemed necessary to involve employers and employees to
have amicable approach to design the changed pattern.
3.3.3 Culture:
Corporate culture are far ranging and numerous, which are broadly termed as
beliefs, values and behavioural patterns that characterize an organization. Some core
aspects of culture include contact and context, cultural manifestations, interpretation
of meaning and patterns of interpretation. Interest of corporate culture is driven by
increased competition and acknowledgements that scientific and rational
explanations of organizations are insufficient. Importance of culture has been
recognized for suggesting strong corporate culture to foster high performance.
Corporate culture includes ideological relations impacted on work
performance, influenced to improve the performance of organization. Culture
reflects common values, shapes employee behaviour and affects to attain identified
goals. It is effective to align vision, mission, strategies, goals and external
environment of the organization. There are number of considerations for companies
seeking to create a culture comprising of:
(a) Discover and articulate distinctive ideologies,
(b) Recruit like-minded personnel,
(c) Device and use cultural forms,
(d) Specialize and instill and sustain ideologies,
(e) Structure to influence sub-cultural formation,
(f) Remain flexible enough to adapt,
(g) Support innovative leadership, and
(h) Go gracefully
The culture tended to be centred on belief that strong corporate culture
creates enhanced business performance and institutional practices can produce best
results, while others undermine ability of organization to adapt requisite changes in
Chapter -3: Talent Management 63
successful manner. In is observed that contextual and strategically appropriate
culture, which fit in the organizational strategy and business context, need to
facilitate adoption of strategies that respond to changing markets. It is also envisaged
that effective leadership is necessary to bring the desired results, as disguised
approach is not advisable in corporate culture.
3.3.4 Training, Learning and Development:
Proliferation of job websites and low unemployment levels have compelled
employers to find new ways of retaining their staff, employee training and
development is widely thought to be an important means of attracting and holding
on staff. Performance of best companies is evident that most of employees have
commitment to do their best to address their intellectual needs. The employees are
recognizing their responsibility to develop their skills and respond to employer
retention measures. Traditional trainings have been superceded by multi-faceted,
multi-sourced and customized development with forward-looking appraisals.
Many corporates have developed and implemented their individual
development plans, which enable very specific training plans for each employee,
often as part of team goals and activities. Impacts of these training programmes have
been found to be very high and employees have responded through increased
production and productivity, witnessing loyalty to the work and company. Further
trend is on-the-job competency development, which is cost efficient and direct
applicable means of training staff while working continuously.
Virtually, all descriptions of high performing management practices
emphasize training, suggesting as essential component of high performance work
system, when the systems rely on the skills of front line employees. Usually training
is treated as expenditure like salary or wages and treated as the decreased amount
from net income or profits of the company. Contrary to this approach, most
companies have realized the importance of training as increased potential of
workers, resulted into more income and profit. This fact has been well recognized to
be beneficial to employer and employee in following manner:
Chapter -3: Talent Management 64
Benefits to Employer include Benefits to Employee include
1. Cost savings: higher retention results
in a decreased need for recruitment
1. Performing meaningful work and
possessing marketable skills.
2. Greater depth of experience, and 2. Increased mobility in the company,
and
3. Better return on investment of
education and training programmes
as employees posses a clear
understanding of their learning
needs
3. Better prepared to seize new
opportunities
In the field of training, prototype system has been substituted by classic
techniques of training needs analysis. While analyzing development needs
effectively, the employers ensure informed decisions for resource allocation and
performance of individuals to improve for overall gain to organization performance.
One approach to analysis of development needs is investors in people, which seeks
to analyze training and development needs at all levels, i.e., organizational, group
and individual. The approach focuses on developing a framework to enable training
and development activities to be tied directly with business objectives.
The balanced scorecard approach focuses on four key indicators viz.,
financial, customer, internal business process, learning and growth, of which latter is
concerned with development needs and divided into three categories i.e., employee
capabilities, information system capabilities, motivation, empowerment and
alignment. Benchmarking enables to determine relative position in other
organizations and gain new ideas. Some organizations focus on competencies, which
enable assessment of individual contribution. Assessment of returns from training
has been made into following factors:
(a) Returns from training investment are nearly positive and can be very high,
depending on the nature of training and its relevance to business needs of the
organization.
(b) Returns accrue in many forms, not just labour productivity and profitability,
but also value addition activities, which may arise as a result of greater skills
Chapter -3: Talent Management 65
of employees, increased flexibility, reduced overheads and greater potential
to innovate.
(c) Immediate returns from training are highest, when it is highly focused on
clear business problems.
(d) Measuring returns is not always easy and may be achieved through
productivity studies or cost benefit analysis.
(e) Training acts as mechanism for various changes in organization and does not
act alone to improve performance but allows organization to introduce
identified changes successfully.
(f) Return from training can be enhanced by human resource policies that
encourage employees to remain with the organization after skill
improvement.
3.3.5 Leadership:
Traditionally, leadership has its root in the military and in corporate field
successful leaders need to forge their way along very different lines. In the
contemporary competitive environment, organizations are increasingly decentralized
and flexible, the leadership is no longer the authoritarian, once it was. The
organizational structure is increasingly decentralized, where decisions are made at
the lowest levels, resulting in the traditional hierarchy being turned upside down.
Following organizational characteristics have been identified to operate leadership:
(a) Alignment: Organizations are increasingly focused on a sense of shared
objectives and goals.
(b) Empowerment: Employees increasing believe that they can make a
difference in the organization.
(c) Learning Culture: In the new leaning and inquiry-based organizations, ideas
must flow unhampered.
Approach of leadership in business concerns relates to change and features
transactional and transformational leadership. Transactional leadership motivates
followers by clarifying their roles, meeting their social needs and providing them
with appropriate rewards. The transformational leadership focuses on vision of
organization and values as a means of motivating staff and encouraging them to fork
Chapter -3: Talent Management 66
for the best interest of the organization. Leadership becomes more effective by
encouraging subordinates to take appropriate decisions.
Leadership approach is shifting significantly from hard issues to softer issues
encouraging leaders to encourage and empower subordinates to remain open-
minded, relax, control, learn from mistakes and intuitive. It is also fact that talented
ideas are not limited to top level business owners, high executives and managers, but
the issue is related with the intellectual property, which can rest with any sub-
ordinate and benefit the organization to great extent. Encouraging subordinates is
one of the essential features of the successful and result-oriented approach.
3.3.6 Human Resource Metrics:
Metric is accountability tool that enables to produce results while facilitating
competitive human resource department in building business and economic
conditions of work. The metrics include measurements of quality, quantity, time,
money, satisfaction and benchmark comparison that are measured through return on
investment, which enables human resource department to define as business partner
and place it on path of continuous improvement. The escalating interest in human
resource metrics have vitally developed as a result of companies becoming
increasingly cost conscious, particularly of staff functions.
Some organizations information required gauging human resource impact on
the bottom line and decision-making models. The human resource has evolved from
support function to strategic business partner. In this new role, investment in human
resource is measured in comparison to investment, finance, marketing etc. The
human resource function is also experiencing increasing business pressure to
achieve cost containment, place greater emphasis on employee’s well-being and use
employee as a source of competitive advantage. It suggests that function must
develop a comprehensive range of strategic business objectives and translate them
into a set of workforce related implications to be managed.
If human resource is unable to quantify its contribution on the bottom line, it
need to be viewed by a remainder of organization as an overhead, implying that it
Chapter -3: Talent Management 67
utilizes resources rather than adding value. If human resource function succeeds in
implementing effective metrics, human resource professionals become result-orient
leaders moving away from creating programme to creating deliverables. In the
corporate sector, employees are most creating component of business and measure
source to turning business prospects, if handled perfectly. Other reasons for
quantifying human resource impact on the organization includes:
(a) Labour costs are frequently most controllable cost of the organization.
(b) Managers also recognize that employees make a difference between success
and failure of organization.
(c) Measuring and benchmarking human resource activities result in continuous
improvements.
(d) Audits bring human resource function closer to line functions of the
organization
One of the human resource metrics relates to balanced scorecard, which
highlights measures for driving performance. The metrics used by human resource
need to convey organization’s values, priorities and standard framework to be based
on centric vision and key objectives should invariably include:
(a) Create a centralized metrics group, where employees are assigned centres of
expertise, where they alone are responsible for measuring human resource
effectiveness and strategic compliance.
(b) Create an alignment between human resources and the overall corporate
strategy.
(c) Align human resource strategy with the corporate defined goals.
In developing human resource metrics, the organization must ensure that
they are tied into key goals and development initiatives and focus on the external
implications of internal operations. There is need to define value in human capital in
production or financial terms continuously track the metrics and adopt standard
reporting structure to ensure transparency of metrics. Financial implications of
human resources have widespread impact linked with business element, which
display considerable variability or seek to focus on key issue or problem.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 68
3.3.7 Human Resource Strategy and Policy:
Human resources of any organization have changed from supportive
administrative function to consultative strategic business partner, which have
significant implications on strategies and policies. Human resources are now
operating in leadership position and largely influenced by escalating importance of
knowledge and its distribution through the management of human capital, viewed by
many organizations in similar realm to finance and technology, as a source of
competitive advantage. In order to capitalize on competitive advantage, human
resource must be able to scan and respond to business environment with excellent
knowledge of employee needs.
It is widely acknowledged that in more than half of the organizations, human
resource managers are involved in the development of corporate strategy from
outset, while they are consulted in one-third of organizations. In order to human
resources to become true strategic business partner, human resource initiatives need
to be aligned with overall business objectives and strategy. In turbulent business
environment, business objectives are ever-changing and human resource function
attempting to aim for moving target and having a balance of multitude of roles,
including business partner, internal consultant, operational and administrative expert
and employer’s advocate.
The transformation has been further complicated by disregard for strategy by
many organizations in recent years. In the face of turbulent change, organizations
have turned away from premise that a strategy is necessary to succeed and have
instead focused on competitiveness and rapid response. Despite these complications,
future is bleak for human resource function, unless it is able to become strategic,
becoming an enabling factor in the delivery of general business strategy. The
strategic change in the role of human resource in business needs cautious approach.
Human resource functions seeking to become strategic, identifies two
normative models and one of which is the ‘best fit’ school, which argues that human
resource strategy to become more effective, when it is appropriately integrated with
its specific organizational and environmental context. The second universal model
Chapter -3: Talent Management 69
recommends the use of best practices in the management of employees. In both the
models, there are compelling needs of casual link between management of
employees and performance of the organization. For successful role, it is necessary
to ensure following strategic functions:
(a) Mission definition: role and purpose.
(b) Business alignment: alignment with overall business strategy.
(c) Functional expertise: strength of human resources.
(d) Role clarity and customer service: response of various stakeholders about
human resource department.
(e) Clever structure and smart processes: design of human resource and its
surrounding organizational structure.
(f) Adequate resources: required for the success of the business.
(g) Internal marketing: define and promote role of human resources.
(h) Human resource metrics: measures for assessment of the contribution of
human resources,
(i) Personal impact: assessment of competencies of human resource professional
to meet needs of business.
Aims of human resource function need to include the conditions necessary to
become partner in execution of business become an expert in execution of strategy
of business, becoming a champion for all the employees in the organization and
become an agent of continual change. Human resource management becomes
critical in effectiveness of organization in taking strategic role. It must concern with
strategic choices associated with use of labour in organization. Human resource
strategy of an organization suggests that human resource director should concentrate
on:
(a) Assessment of strategic choices in human resource management, which are
critical in the performance of the firm.
(b) Mode of determining choices by different stakeholders in the firm and expect
to be materialized through human resources.
(c) Measures required for human resource management to become effective tool
of the firm.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 70
In order to excel in the new strategic role, human resource professional need
also consider their own competencies to ensure that they are able to deliver required
services to the firm. Role of human resource from servant to business partner is quite
challenging in the environment, where business strategies continuously change in
view of market conditions and expectations from human resources are maximum.
The expectations from human resources are many, which need to meet the
challenges comprising of:
(a) Business knowledge: strategic, technological and financial.
(b) Change management capabilities: innovation, problem solving attitude and
commitment to work.
(c) Knowledge of procedural human resource practices such as remuneration,
rewards, appraisals etc.
(d) Knowledge of strategic human resource practices: organizational design, role
design, reporting system design etc.
3.3.8 Human Resource Function:
Traditional human resource function was merely support service and
programme delivery mechanism supplying to the rest of the organization. In the
present context, the human resource function has moved away from that focus,
becoming altogether more involved with successful human resource executives
expanding their responsibilities to participate in executive committee meeting of
organization. The change in focus is broad, away from an administrative, facilitative,
consultative, developmental role as strategic business partner.
It is also pertinent that business companies cannot operate effectively under a
common set of human resource programme and need to evolve its own strategy to
influence growing scarcity of skilled workers, particularly knowledge workers,
which have changed employer/employee relationship, resulting in human resource
seeking ways to make organization appear attractive to potential employees and
finding means of retaining them, once they are employed. Impact of new
technologies has resulted in fundamental business changes.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 71
Human resources function tend to be centralized unit, encompassing
specialist areas such as compensation, benefits etc. Responsibility of human
resource representatives was to inform managers about policies and programmes for
handling employee relations and hence serving as conduit to human resource and
line management. This was subsequently gradual realization that different business
needed different programmes and benefits, which led to decentralization to human
resource structure with following three commands:
(a) Shared human resource services for administrative and transactional
functions.
(b) Centres of excellence: centralized units responsible for programme
development and consulting to business in highly specialized areas.
(c) Decentralized human resource business partners to undertake responsibility
to understand business issues and act as member of business team,
identifying human resource implications and coordinating assistance from
centres of excellence.
It is generally accepted fact that human resource is moving away from the
transactional, paper-pushing, hiring and firing support function to become a bottom
line business decision maker. It was also observed that strategic partner is one of the
most utilized catchphrases. Despite these changes, the structure remains too
administrative, expensive and unable to deal with strategic issue of people. It has
been observed that human resource practisoners are focused on administrative and
transactional-based business. The human resource function is being practiced in its
strategic capacity. It is continuously used by employees for low-level support such
as vacation time or clarifying company policy.
New trend is distributive human resource to design and delivery of human
resource function is completed through multiple channels. In many cases, all the
administrative activities are outsourced, key element of people management are
returned to line management, employees are expected to take more responsibility for
their own human resource management and small teams of specialists are assembled
to focus on specific business needs. In these situations, human resource function
need change the way, where organization makes human capital decisions, aiming to
spread the responsibility for human capital issues.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 72
3.3.9 Recruitment:
Recruitment related issues are major challenge to business organizations and
many organizations find it difficult to get appropriate persons to suffice their
business needs. There remains quite disguised view in organizations to get
experienced persons or new entrants and both the category persons have advantages
and disadvantages. In recruitment notice, the organization need to quote attractive
salary and other incentives to get employees of their liking. . Job descriptions are
widely thought of as tool for publicizing vacant positions indicating following
details for attracting potential candidates
(a) Appropriately assigned professional codes, titles and pay levels,
(b) Clearly establishing performance requirements.
(c) Making decision on job restructuring.
(d) Successfully training new employees in their job duties.
There are number of complexities in writing and maintaining job
descriptions, including large number of employees in an organization, inefficient job
description processes, different responsibilities and duties of every job and legal
issues, which have significant impact on the format and content of description. It is
also pertinent to specifically mention about training to be provided to recruited
candidates in the form of business writing, external resource seminars, structural
assessment training and new manager and performance training.
Core competency based questions are used at all stages of recruitment
including application, assessments and interviews. Competency based interview are
used while hiring externally or promoting internally and are helpful in adjudging the
employee to fit in with values and culture of the organization. Competency based
interviews include behavioural and situational, where behavioural interviews are
structural assessment of qualities, which company believe to be important for
particular position. It is assumed that past performance is best predictor of future
success.
In situational interviews, hypothetical and future oriented questions are asked
believing the candidate stating actions are indicator of good behaviour. Situational
Chapter -3: Talent Management 73
interviews also offer case of comparing information from large number of
candidates. It is suggested to companies to frame questions to assess competency of
candidates in desired spheres comprising of analytical or problem based solution
skills, collaboration and teamwork, leadership and creativity. The selection board
needs to firm up in mind to continue search for candidates suited to the organization
and can continue to work for longer duration.
There are various methods of sourcing, selection and assessment and it is the
responsibility of the selection board to recruit appropriate persons and ensuring their
aptitude to work as part of elite group. Online capacity assessment is also treated as
one of the criteria for short-listing appropriate candidates for interview. It is also
pertinent that good employment brand creates an image of well managed firm,
where workers are continually growing and learning the minds of targeted candidate
pool. The candidates must feel that company has challenging, prestigious and
rewarding place to work.
3.3.10 Remuneration and Rewards:
Remuneration is significant issue in management of human resource, as the
organization pays employees impact on its capacity to attract and retain high
performing personnel. In order to achieve maximum return, the remuneration system
needs to be integrating with business and human resource practices and focus on
critical business objectives. Human resource contend with continual pressure in
increase salaries or at least keep them competitive, while often suffering slashed
budgets, where compensation and benefits are frequent key targets.
Usually organizations remain conscious about the hike in the remunerations
in the fear to develop feeling to leave the organization and search better avenues in
their own interest. Now human resources are increasingly operating in strategic
business role, remuneration is potentially one of key tools at the disposal of
management. Now, human capital is viewed, as an important source of competitive
advantage with capability and commitment of employees are greatest influencing
factors on performance. Employees also remain careful and conscious over
remunerations and rewards of their dedicated work.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 74
Companies remain conscious about the capability of employees to face the
challenges of competition in terms of cost and quality and realize that employees
work performance is helpful in enhancement of income and benefits in most
competitive market conditions. In this manner the companies need not to pay
employees from its limited income and profits, but earn suitably through increased
production and lowering down cost of the produce. In such conducive environment,
companies need to realize enlisted issues:
(a) Understand that human capabilities are essential to the success of business.
(b) Ensure that all employees are committed to the success of the organization
through better combined performance.
(c) Design programmes and measures that link employees to short and long term
business success, such as effective goal setting and performance
management systems.
(d) Develop total reward systems that deliver strong value to employees
addressing their values and commitments rather than focusing narrowly on
monetary rewards.
Remunerations and rewards are believed to be important influence on output
and performance. If remunerations and benefits are linked to and aligned with
overall corporate or business strategy, employees individually and collectively focus
on delivering unit and organizational goals. One of key trend developed of variable
pay schemes, which reward employees for their performance. There are many
options of variable pay schemes, but such practices are not justified in group or team
work. In addition trust of employees is dwindled at the management, may not be in
the long term interest of the organization.
This system is perfect, where work and performance is related to individual
work and others have similar opportunities to adhere to their commitment also. In
addition, remuneration with performance need to be kept as one portion of additional
production, benefit or profit. Any system introduced by the management in deciding
remuneration and rewards need to be transparent and open with no discrimination to
any individual. Such fair practices create enthusiasm in all the employees to remain
dedicated and trustworthy to the management.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 75
3.3.11 Human Resource Outsourcing:
Outsourcing essentially involves the undertaking of human resource
functions by specialized external company, which offers whole or partial
outsourcing depending on the client’s requirements. Company management
identifies a range of human resource functions to be outsourced, including
recruitment, selection and assessment processes comprising of psychological
assessment, skills testing, reference checking, performance and compensation
management, organizational development, industrial-employee relations,
occupational health, safety and work cover administration, outplacement services
and employee assistance programme.
Purpose of outsourcing is multi-fold and includes corporate aims of lowering
costs, increased flexibility in capability, increased to best practices methodologies
and solutions, freeing up of internal human resource staff to concentrate on strategic
and core business issues. Usually all sizes of organizations choose to outsource some
or all of their human resource activities, there is large range of situations, which
need to be considered for outsourcing. This issue is also related with the decision
making process to get the work done by organization itself or outsource in view of
various benefits listed below:
(a) Organization is very large and must sustain a level of quality and consistency
in obtaining better services at lower costs.
(b) Small organizations do not possess critical mass that may necessitate an in-
house human resource function.
(c) Organization is new and need to keep people focused on core business
processes, which may not include human resource.
(d) Organization needs to work more strategically and keep free human resource
professionals to think strategically and concentrate on central role in business
strategy planning.
(e) Need to be sure of legal compliances in certain areas, as legal complications
may create serious problem in functional arrangement.
(f) Having faith in specialized services available at reasonable cost and keeping
free from all botherations.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 76
(g) Need to manage ongoing change or a period of turbulence, while keeping
human resource processes rock solid.
Outsourcing is also practiced for very specific reasons related to need to
access invention, innovation and best practices, where human resource capability
can be supplemented improved or upgraded. Such facilities are also necessary in
case of bulk task beyond the capacity of organization and increasing staff is not
justified for such short-term activities. Such services are also eminent in case of
skills provided by personnel who are not directly involved in value addition to
services or product. Outsourcing is a facility available to all such organization and
availing such services is usually cost effective.
3.3.12 Workforce Planning:
Workforce planning is the process of getting right persons with right
competencies, in the right job at a right time. It envisages that company is capable to
tackle labour market pressures, respond to fast changing business environment and
addresses staffing shortages. Workforce planning transforms staffing function from
vacancy filling role to continually ensuring alignment between human capital and
strategic goals of the organization. Workforce planning is not mechanistic or static
process and there are number of steps to be adhered to ensure successful
implementation. Usually call centres have commercial workforce management
system in place.
First step of the task is analysis of current workforce, with minimum data for
analysis including job title and job description, location and length of services,
personal employee details, vacancies, turnover and wastage, reasons for leaving and
destination of previous employees, qualifications and skills of workforce. Second
step is to forecast the competencies required in future at the existing level and
expansion strategies. Subsequent stage undertakes to identify gap between two
situations to determine skill surpluses and deficiencies. Following strategies are
suggested to proceed further:
(a) Review transfer policies to facilitate relocation as source of recruitment and
outplacement.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 77
(b) Review recruitment, selection and remuneration strategies.
(c) Improve selection methodologies, particularly for emerging skill
requirements.
(d) Improve selection methodologies in relation to the assessment of team based
work skills.
(e) Develop ‘at-risk’ based remuneration strategies for senior positions to meet
performance culture in commercial environment.
(f) Review strategies in relation to rewards for team based work.
3.4 RELEVANCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT IN
PHARMACEUTICAL SECTOR:
Pharmaceutical industry is one of the fastest growing businesses in the world
and largely associated with the expansion of health facilities. The demand of
medicines is created with the expansion of health facilities and still about 40 percent
of the population of the world is still uncovered with the health facilities. In India,
the expansion of health facilities has been made in systematic manner after
independence and start of planned era. Still 30 percent of the country population is
residing at far distant places from health facilities. The demand of medicines is
created with the coverage of population with health facilities and doctors are the
main stakeholders to create demand by examining the patents, who reach for cure of
specific disease.
The demand and supply are two basic factors for relevance of pharmaceutical
industries and demand of medicines is possible to be met by medicines produced in
the country or imported from other countries. Even in India, demand of 97 percent
of medicines is met by pharmaceutical industries functional in the country and 3
percent medicines are imported from other countries, which are mainly related to
lifeline and strategic diseases. The country is capable to export medicines in
developed and developing countries, wherever possible. Still health facilities are not
in access to 30 percent of population and demand of medicines in the country would
start with coverage such unconnected areas.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 78
The problem of developing countries is quite critical in view of slow
coverage of country population with health facilities mainly for lack of resources.
The gap between demand of medicines and supply of medicines is the base of
expansion of pharmaceutical industries. India is capable to manufacture medicines at
cheaper rate and of global standard, the expansion of pharmaceutical industries is
certain. Global market is most competitive in medicines sphere also and India has
advantage in view of capability to manufacture medicines of global standard at
cheaper rate to compete with global companies. Even developed countries avail
outsourcing facilities for manufacturing of medicines. Developed countries offer
such services to India after close assessment of the processing system and contents
used in the process.
The pharmaceutical industry has mainly three main tasks viz., research for
patent of new medicines, process of manufacturing of the medicines and marketing
of the medicines through their own personnel. These activities are most challenging
tasks requiring talented personnel to handle to task in result oriented manner. The
talent is essential to adhere on the strategic issues of quality and production. In the
sphere of research, the firm can provide al requisite facilities but the personnel
working for invention of new medicines need to prove their worthiness in time and
cost parameters. The marketing is most challenging task, as convincing the doctor
for boosting the medicines of specific company is most critical task, while the
personnel of the firm have to prove their proficiency in the task.
Thus total pharmaceutical sector is based on some presumptions, which the
personnel engaged in different spheres heed to manage the tasks in the requisite
manner within time and cost limits. The talented personnel engaged in research,
manufacturing process and marketing have attained specialization in their respective
spheres, which is possible with their training and working experience. The caliber
such talented personnel possess is helpful in prospering the firm engaged in the task
and expansion of the activities of the firm is possible with the active role of such
personnel. Usually the business firm rewards them suitably in the form of increased
salary, promotion and holding the task of foreign trade. The talented personnel are
the backbone of pharmaceutical industry.
Chapter -3: Talent Management 79
REFERENCES
(1) http//www/watsonwyatt.com / research/resrender.asp?id=W-488&page=1
(2) Tilburg University in Cooperation with Accenture (2009) How Effective are
Talent Management Practices
(3) John Bersin (2006) Hay Acquisition Company