chasingoxygen ccas 2020jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. we are made of star...

19
Chasing Oxygen CCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23 Chasing Oxygen Prof. Richard Pogge The Ohio State University Department of Astronomy 1 Where does all this stuff come from? 2

Upload: others

Post on 09-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Chasing Oxygen

Prof. Richard PoggeThe Ohio State UniversityDepartment of Astronomy

1

Where does all this stuff come from?

2

Page 2: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Graphic created by Prof. Jennifer Johnsonwww.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/~jaj/nucleo

3

All the universe’s hydrogen and most of its helium was made during the first 15 minutes after the Big Bang

4

Page 3: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Dying Low-Mass Stars

Red: Nitrogen

Green: Oxygen

Blue: HeliumNASA Hubble Space Telescope

Make N & C plussome O & He andtraces of heavyelements

5

Exploding Massive Stars

NASA Hubble Space Telescope

Red: Oxygen

Green: Sulfur

Blue: hot electrons

Make O thru Ironup through Rb,some C & N

6

Page 4: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Exploding White Dwarfs

NASA Chandra X-Ray Telescope

Make most ofthe Iron & Nickelgroup elements

7

Merging Neutron Stars

LIGO artist’s impression

Make heaviest elements up to Uranium & Plutonium (?)

8

Page 5: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

“The nitrogen in our DNA, the calcium in our teeth, the iron in our blood, the carbon in our apple pies were made in the interiors of collapsing stars.We are made of star stuff.”

Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars)

9

10

Page 6: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

H

He

O

C

OthersH

73.9%

He24.7%

What is the Sun made of?

NASA

O - 0.63%C - 0.22%

11

Si

Fe

O

Mg

S

Ni

Ca

Al

Others

O30.1%

Si15.1%

What is the Earth made of (in bulk)?

NASA “Blue Marble” West

Fe32.1%

Mg13.9%

SNiCa Al

12

Page 7: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Al

Si

O

Fe

Ca

K

Na

Mg

Others

O46.6%

Si27.7%

What is Earth’s crust made of?

NASA “Blue Marble” West

Si27.7%

Al8.1%

FeCa

K Na Mg

13

H

C

O

N

Ca

P

Others

O65%

C18.5%

H9.5%

What are we made of?

N

Ca

14

Page 8: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Measuring cosmic oxygenis surprisingly difficult...

Expectation:Typically a few parts in 1000 to a few parts in 100,000

Hard to measure in stars:Solar value good to ~40%(!)Often have to use proxies

Needed: a tracer that works on cosmic scales…

15

Young cluster of hotmassive stars

Surrounding gas isionized by UV lightfrom the hot stars

European Southern Observatory

HII Regions

16

Page 9: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Spiral galaxies are filled with 100sof HII regions…

NASA Hubble Space Telescope17

Hydrogen

Helium

Oxygen

Neon

Iron

18

Page 10: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

HydrogenHelium

UV

Near

-IR

19

OxygenNitrogen

Sulfur

Argon

Neon

UV

Near

-IR

20

Page 11: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

UV

Near-IR

Green Red

Red

Green

21

CHemical Abundances Of Spirals(CHAOS)

Joint Ohio State – Univ of Minnesota projectfunded by the National Science Foundation

22

Page 12: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

23

The Multi-Object Double Spectrographs (MODS)on the Large Binocular Telescope

MODS1Installed August 2010

MODS2Installed April 2014

24

Page 13: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

MODS1 on the LBT(August 2010)

25

Collimator MirrorsRedCamera

BlueCamera

RedGrating

BlueGrating

Red/Blue DichroicBeam Splitter

MODS Optics

Starlight

26

Page 14: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

LBT+MODS1 Spectrum of the Crab Nebula

27

H SO

N

28

Page 15: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Spiral Galaxy M101

NASA Hubble Space Telescope29

The M101 Campaign

Spring 2015 at the LBT

13 observations:7 multi-slit masks6 single-slit masks28 hours of observing

Yield:109 HII regions

Croxall et al. 2016, ApJ, 830, 4

30

Page 16: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Oxygen-Rich

Oxygen-Poor

O/H

Rat

io

31

Young-star Nitrogen

production dominates

Supernova Nitrogenproduction dominated

N/O

Rat

io

32

Page 17: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

A recent CHAOS finding:

The N/O distribution ingalaxies follows a nearlyuniversal pattern.

The starting N/O ratio is setby initial star formation:A strong start makes more Oahead of N, depressing N/O.

33

What about Carbon?

34

Page 18: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

Leo PFaint dwarf galaxy ~15 Million light years away.

35

Leo P is an extremely metal-deficient galaxy…

Skillman et al. 2013, AJ, 146, 3

UV Near

-IR

36

Page 19: ChasingOxygen CCAS 2020Jan23 slides...in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of star stuff.” Carl Sagan (Cosmos, 1980 Episode 9: The Lives of the Stars) 9 10 Chasing Oxygen

Chasing OxygenCCAS Presentation – 2020 Jan 23

M101

Leo P

Skillman et al. 2013, AJ, 146, 3

O/H

Rat

io

J0811+4730Izotov et al. 2017

37

PIs: Prof. Evan Skillman (Minnesota) & Prof. Rick Pogge (OSU)Dr. Danielle Berg (OSU postdoc)Ness Mayker (OSU graduate student)Noah Rogers (Minnesota graduate student)Dr. Kevin Croxall (OSU & Expeed Software LLC)Prof. John Moustakas (Sienna College)

The CHAOS Team

US National Science FoundationCollaborative Grants AST-1108693 & AST-1715284

38