choosing the qualities of student leaders: a matching of student voting preference and election...

10
 Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com | Volume 2, No. 4, August 2014 _______________________________________________ 159 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.c om Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference and Election Results as a Basis for Policy Formulation NOEL M. CAPULONG Office of Student Affairs, City College of Calamba, Calamba City, Laguna, PHILIPPINES [email protected]  Date Rec eived: Ju ly 15, 201 4; Date Pub lished: Augus t 15, 2014  Abs t ract    The qualities of student-leaders in the 21  st  century cannot be underrated. The ability to influence individuals in the context of boundless territories and worldwide integration is of paramount importance to education. Research has revealed that the crux of student leadership in this century is on achieving the right pace and qualities in the changing landscape of borderless society. Choosing the qualities of leaders helps the administrators and students come up with a collaborative policy formulation in the attainment of institutional mission and goals. The research utilized the mixed methods using the qualitative key informant interview, focus group discussions  , and researcher’s experience to choose the qualities of student leaders among the students of City College of Calamba. The perceptions of student council leaders from the different schools of Calamba were also surveyed. The student voting preference was matched with the results of Student Council election. The results obtained were recorded and compared to the results of the interview from the experts in the field of educational leadership. K e yw ords   student-leaders, perception, leadership, policy I. INTRODUCTION Leadership for the 21 st  century is an inseparable component of the holistic development of students. The idea of serving the constituents cannot be rated as a less important parameter in determining the academic excellence of students. Acting as a student-leader in an academic institution involved the entire praxis of being a student. The practices and activities being done by student-leaders are actually manifestations of the students’ selected field of academic discipline. The abundance of leadership theories (Rice, 2011) in many books and other publications does not manifest a concise description of leadership qualities, more so, of the native Filipino qualities of student-leaders. The  perceptions of the qualities of student-lea ders based on the voters criterion and candidates in a student-election remain particularly elusive due to mismatch of orientation and philosophies in life. For this century, the need for collaboration and collective relationship among the student-leaders, students, and administrators must be enhanced in order to facilitate change and create a global understanding for better learning and proactive education. Leadership activities manifested by student-leaders must be centered on communal participation of the group rather than on the individual work of a single leader (Mullen, 2010). At any rate, even with the collective leadership of the students, there is a need to enhance or even develop the potentials of the individual leaders so that they can give more to the organization which is really important especially when the student-leader is leading hundreds or thousands of students in an academic institution. Even in educational leadership, the individual dispositions which are the foundations of leadership skills, characteristics, and abilities are given attention. The assessment and development of core beliefs, attitudes, and values are said to have an important role in leadership effectivenes s (Allen et al., 2014).  In the context of qualities possessed by student- leaders, the administrators of every educational institution especially those offices handling student affairs services must always be mindful on how to develop the potentials of their student-leaders. Being at the forefront of student engagement, the programs and  policies of student affairs must be aligned not only in the realm of the regular programs of the institution but also with the present and unending evolution of needs, strengths, and weaknesses of student-leaders. More than ever before, the offices of student affairs must respond

Upload: asia-pacific-journal-of-multidisciplinary-research

Post on 11-Oct-2015

16 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

The qualities of student-leaders in the 21st century cannot be underrated. The ability to influence individuals in the context of boundless territories and worldwide integration is of paramount importance to education. Research has revealed that the crux of student leadership in this century is on achieving the right pace and qualities in the changing landscape of borderless society. Choosing the qualities of leaders helps the administrators and students come up with a collaborative policy formulation in the attainment of institutional mission and goals. The research utilized the mixed methods using the qualitative key informant interview, focus group discussions, and researcher’s experience to choose the qualities of student leaders among the students of City College of Calamba. The perceptions of student council leaders from the different schools of Calamba were also surveyed. The student voting preference was matched with the results of Student Council election. The results obtained were recorded and compared to the results of the interview from the experts in the field of educational leadership.

TRANSCRIPT

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com | Volume 2, No. 4, August 2014

    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    159

    P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student

    Voting Preference and Election Results as a

    Basis for Policy Formulation

    NOEL M. CAPULONG

    Office of Student Affairs, City College of Calamba, Calamba City, Laguna, PHILIPPINES

    [email protected]

    Date Received: July 15, 2014; Date Published: August 15, 2014

    Abstract The qualities of student-leaders in the 21st century cannot be underrated. The ability to influence individuals in the context of boundless territories and worldwide integration is of paramount

    importance to education. Research has revealed that the crux of student leadership in this century is on

    achieving the right pace and qualities in the changing landscape of borderless society. Choosing the

    qualities of leaders helps the administrators and students come up with a collaborative policy formulation in

    the attainment of institutional mission and goals. The research utilized the mixed methods using the

    qualitative key informant interview, focus group discussions, and researchers experience to choose the qualities of student leaders among the students of City College of Calamba. The perceptions of student

    council leaders from the different schools of Calamba were also surveyed. The student voting preference was

    matched with the results of Student Council election. The results obtained were recorded and compared to

    the results of the interview from the experts in the field of educational leadership.

    Keywords student-leaders, perception, leadership, policy

    I. INTRODUCTION

    Leadership for the 21st century is an inseparable

    component of the holistic development of students. The

    idea of serving the constituents cannot be rated as a less

    important parameter in determining the academic

    excellence of students. Acting as a student-leader in an

    academic institution involved the entire praxis of being

    a student. The practices and activities being done by

    student-leaders are actually manifestations of the

    students selected field of academic discipline. The abundance of leadership theories (Rice, 2011)

    in many books and other publications does not manifest

    a concise description of leadership qualities, more so, of

    the native Filipino qualities of student-leaders. The

    perceptions of the qualities of student-leaders based on

    the voters criterion and candidates in a student-election

    remain particularly elusive due to mismatch of

    orientation and philosophies in life.

    For this century, the need for collaboration and

    collective relationship among the student-leaders,

    students, and administrators must be enhanced in order

    to facilitate change and create a global understanding

    for better learning and proactive education. Leadership

    activities manifested by student-leaders must be

    centered on communal participation of the group rather

    than on the individual work of a single leader (Mullen,

    2010).

    At any rate, even with the collective leadership of

    the students, there is a need to enhance or even develop

    the potentials of the individual leaders so that they can

    give more to the organization which is really important

    especially when the student-leader is leading hundreds

    or thousands of students in an academic institution.

    Even in educational leadership, the individual

    dispositions which are the foundations of leadership

    skills, characteristics, and abilities are given attention.

    The assessment and development of core beliefs,

    attitudes, and values are said to have an important role

    in leadership effectiveness (Allen et al., 2014).

    In the context of qualities possessed by student-

    leaders, the administrators of every educational

    institution especially those offices handling student

    affairs services must always be mindful on how to

    develop the potentials of their student-leaders. Being at

    the forefront of student engagement, the programs and

    policies of student affairs must be aligned not only in

    the realm of the regular programs of the institution but

    also with the present and unending evolution of needs,

    strengths, and weaknesses of student-leaders. More than

    ever before, the offices of student affairs must respond

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    160 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    to those pressing needs and issues to assist other

    stakeholders like teachers in the formulation of policies

    and activities in targeting the best environment for

    students (Pomerantz, 2006).

    II. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

    This research presents the qualities of student-

    leaders as matched to the perceptions of voters, student-

    leaders, and experts in the field of educational

    leadership. The results of the study shall then be utilized

    in determining the policies in terms of programs and

    activities of the Office of Student Affairs of the City

    College of Calamba in developing the qualities of its

    student-leaders.

    III. THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES

    The idea of leadership qualities can be traced back

    from the different theories of leadership. Some of those

    theories are anchored on the personality of individual

    leaders while some considered leadership as a thematic

    approach in dealing with subordinates. Other theories

    suggest that leadership traits may differ based from the

    situation that arose in the environment while others

    would contend that reward and punishment obliged a

    person to lead expectedly. These theories would

    sometimes harmonize with other theories while some

    considered these as sources of debates among scholar

    individuals. The study will focus on some of the

    following most influential theories of leadership:

    Contingency Theory. This theory emphasizes that

    one can improve the organization by replacing the

    leader to fit a particular event or scenario or changing

    the scenario or event in order to fit the leader (Fiedler,

    1967 as cited in Christie & Bob, 2001). The

    organization like the Student Council may be developed

    depending on the leader or the environment. Changing

    one of them to fit the other may bring success to the

    Student Council.

    Exchange Theory. This theory states that social

    behaviour is based on the rewards and costs that affect

    relationships (Blau, 1964; Ritzer, 1988 as cited in

    Wettersten, 1994). The quality of relationship of two

    persons including between a leader and a subordinate

    can be determined by what they give and what they

    take.

    Trait Theory. This theory focuses on the individual

    traits of the leader and not on the followers and the

    situation. As a more straightforward theory, this

    approach posits that certain set of traits must be

    possessed by the leader which are considered to be of

    crucial importance to effective leadership (Germain,

    2008).

    The qualities that must be possessed by the student-

    leaders are important in the regular performance of their

    basic duties and responsibilities. Absence of important

    qualities may lead to the deterioration of the

    organization.

    IV. MATERIALS AND METHODS

    Research Design

    The design of the study utilized the mixed method

    of descriptive research using the quantitative and

    qualitative approaches.

    Participants

    Participants were grouped into 3 sets of

    respondents. The first group of respondents were the

    student-voters during the last Student Council election

    for SY 2014-2015 comprising about 311 students from

    different courses of the college namely the Bachelor in

    Secondary Education, Bachelor in Elementary

    Education, Bachelor of Science in Information

    Technology, Bachelor of Science in Computer Science,

    and Bachelor of Science in Accountancy.

    The second set of respondents was the 10 Student

    Council Officers of the college for the positions of

    President, Vice President, Secretary, Treasurer, Auditor,

    and 5 PROs.

    The third set of respondents was Student Council

    officers of selected schools from Calamba City and

    some officers of the Student Council from the

    University of the Philippines Los Baos, Laguna.

    Instrument

    The data gathering instrument was a self-made

    questionnaire to gather information on the perceptions

    of the three sets of respondents on the qualities of

    student-leaders collected from the election results and

    survey. The self-made questionnaire was based from the

    interpretation of the Student Manual of the college,

    references from the DIY Committee Guide, Survey on

    Youth Perceptions of Elections and Good Governance

    undertaken by the Communication Foundation for Asia,

    and article from Emeagwali (2011).

    For the qualitative interpretation, the researcher

    utilized the interview protocol in soliciting information

    from the respondents as well as from the experts in the

    field.

    To ensure its validity, the researcher validated the

    questionnaire from the expert in the field of education

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    161 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    and through the assistance of a statistician. Interviews

    were also done by the researcher to determine the need

    for further improvement and modification of the

    instrument.

    Procedures

    The researcher distributed the questionnaires among

    the respondents and conducted interviews with some

    persons involved in handling student organizations and

    activities. Through the permission of the Division Head,

    the researcher was able to conduct interviews and focus

    group discussions. The researcher assured the

    confidentiality of the data gathered in the study.

    Data Analysis

    The gathered data were tallied, tabulated, encoded, and

    analyzed using the following statistical tools:

    1. Average Composite Rank was used to in order to determine the average ranks of qualities perceived

    by the respondents per position in the Student

    Council. The combined composite ranks were then

    used in order to the find the average rank of the

    three sets of respondents.

    2. One-Way ANOVA was used in order to compare the means of the three sets of respondents using the

    F-distribution

    V. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

    The following tables reflected the perceptions of the

    three sets of respondents based from the ranking of

    qualities. The different positions that were given the set

    of qualities were tabulated and analyzed for better

    appreciation. Below are the summary results of the

    questionnaire:

    Table1. Description of Student Leaders Quality for President Position in SSC

    Descriptions Group A Group B Group C Combined

    The President should ACR* Final Rank ACR* Rank ACR* Rank ACR* Rank a. exercise good communication

    skills 3.54 5 4.00 4 2.75 2 3.43 3

    b. have a vision for the students 3.14 4 3.00 3 4.25 4 3.46 4 c. be dedicated in his duties and

    responsibilities 2.54 1 1.00 1 1.50 1 1.68 1

    d. be fair in making decisions 2.65 2 2.00 2 4.25 4 2.97 2 e. possess openness that would

    enable him/her to listen to

    new ideas

    3.12 3 5.00 5 4.25 4 4.12 5

    * Average Composite Rank, SSC-Supreme Student Council

    Table 1 suggests that for the position of President,

    all the three sets of respondents agreed that the most

    important quality for the President is that he/she must

    be dedicated in his duties and responsibilities. The least

    important qualities as implied is openness.

    In one of the document articles of Hyde as

    published by Gary North (2006), in explaining the

    mechanics of the proliferation of Communism in the

    previous decades, he explained that commitment in an

    organization can be expounded more when the

    organization demands a bigger commitment. When organizations make minimal demands on their

    members, they would get minimal commitment. When

    they make big demands, they get big commitment. Based from this article, it can be well interpreted that

    the perceptions of the three sets of respondents posit

    that dedication which is tantamount commitment is the

    most important thing in the organization to work. This

    quality should be exemplified by the President of the

    organization since he/she is considered to be the head

    and the direction-setter of the organization.

    This is also supported by the coded responses of

    some of the respondents as illustrated in Table 2.

    Table 2. Coded Responses of the Respondents on the Qualities of President for Student Council Position CODES/CATEGORIES TRANSCRIPTION

    Commitment and Dedication They must be committed and dedicated

    Dedication in the Organization Must be dedicated in the organization

    Active part of student movement Must be active part of student movement with dedication and

    commitment

    Commitment and dedication for student rights Must be committed and dedicated in serving the student rights

    Dedication in duties Kailangan ay may dedikasyon sa Gawain

    Person of Integrity Must be a person of integrity

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    162 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    Based on responses from the respondents, most of

    the item/categories pertaining to Presidential

    qualifications are deemed to be related to dedication

    and commitment. The chat to respondents also supports

    dedication and commitment as the main basis of voting

    their candidate for the Student Council Election. It was

    revealed that the college deserves a Student Council

    President who has a sense of direction bound by

    commitment and dedication. Due to numerous academic

    and non-academic activities of the college, coupled by

    academic requirements and scholastic pressures, it is

    quite difficult to find a student who will be devoted to

    become a President both managing his/her individual

    academic performance and effectuating leadership for

    the welfare of the students.

    Karns and McGee (2011) in their journal abstract

    article, Everyday Heroes, mentioned that heroes are everywhere in education. Those who are in charge of creating learning organizations through their efforts,

    commitment, and dedication are really worth telling.

    The Academy for Educational Development (2011) also

    illustrated some stories of dedication of some young

    people in constructing positive learning environment for

    student engagement.

    Indeed, dedication and commitment proved to be a

    baseline quality that must be characterized by the

    President of the Council.

    Table 3. Description of Student Leaders Quality for Vice President Position in SSC

    Descriptions Group A Group B Group C Combined

    The Vice President should ACR Final

    Rank

    ACR Rank ACR Rank ACR Rank

    a. exercise good communication skills

    3.63 5 4.00 4 3.75 5 3.79 5

    b. have good understanding about

    the nature of different

    organizations in the

    campus

    2.84 2 5.00 5 3.00 3 3.61 4

    c. be dedicated in his duties and

    responsibilities

    2.30 1 1.00 1 2.25 1 1.85 1

    d. be flexible 3.35 4 3.00 3 2.75 2 3.03 3 e. possess openness that

    would enable him/her

    to listen to new ideas

    2.88 3 2.00 2 3.25 4 2.71 2

    The table showed congruity between the quality

    choices of respondents being dedicated to the duties and

    responsibilities as the most important quality.

    Respondents agreed that the responsibilities of the Vice

    President should also be of the same quality as the

    President since the former position acted as a

    replacement of the President in case of replacement

    through resignation, death, disqualification, and/or

    impeachment. This can also be gleaned from the

    responses in table 4.

    Table 4. Coded Responses of the Respondents on the Qualities of Vice President for Student Council Position

    CODES/CATEGORIES TRANSCRIPTION

    Commitment and Dedication They must be committed and dedicated

    Spare tire of the President He/She must be a good spare tire for the President

    Possess same qualifications Must possess same qualifications as the President

    Qualities of the President Must maintain all the qualities of the President

    Sharing of the same characteristics Since he/she is the Vice President, they must share same

    characteristics

    Assist the President Should do the best to assist the President

    Based from the coded responses, the qualifications

    of the Vice President must be in harmony with the

    qualifications of the President. Most of the respondents

    agreed that since the Vice President shares the same

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    163 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    features as of the President, they must be able to share

    the same qualities. In this case, the respondents also

    posit that dedication to duties is considered to be the

    most important quality.

    Experience (as Director of OSA and Student

    Council adviser for around eight years) has shown that

    the duty of the Vice President is of paramount

    importance to the Student Council. Being equally

    committed and dedicated to his/her duty is an important

    task especially when the President cannot effectively

    perform his duty or has lost the commitment and

    dedication to the job. The Vice President as the alter

    ego of the President should complement the President in

    times of weakness like when the President has

    experienced emotional and social downturn.

    The Student Manual (2006) of the college stated

    that the Vice President should perform other duties and

    responsibilities as directed or advised by the President.

    In the normal course of Student Councils operation, it is the Vice President who is acting as the Chairman of

    the Council of Student Leaders (CSL), the

    confederation of all heads/presidents of all recognized

    student organizations of the college. As Vice President,

    he/she also acts as the President or Head of the CSL

    performing delegative and supervisory functions. As

    such, commitment and dedication is also a primary

    concern quality for the position of the Vice President.

    Table 5. Description of Student Leaders Quality for Secretary Position in SSC

    Descriptions Group A Group B Group C Combined

    The Secretary must be ACR Final

    Rank

    ACR Rank ACR Rank ACR Rank

    a. Organized 2.54 1 3.00 3 1.75 1 2.43 2 b. good in written skills 3.79 5 1.00 1 4.75 5 3.18 3 c. responsible in

    keeping the minutes

    of meetings

    2.75 2 2.00 2 2.25 2 2.33 1

    d. objective in making correspondence and

    minutes of meetings

    3.03 4 5.00 5 2.50 3 3.51 4

    e. punctual in doing his/her assigned

    tasks

    2.90 3 4.00 4 3.75 4 3.55 5

    Table 5 suggests that for the position of Secretary,

    all the respondents agreed that the most important

    quality is to be responsible in keeping the minutes of

    the meeting. Referring to the Student Manual (2006) of

    the college, it was laid down that the main duty and

    responsibility of the Secretary is to keep the record of

    the meetings of the Council. It is in this concept that the

    perception of the Student Council officer, voters, other

    officers from other schools view this quality as the

    foremost quality that a Secretary must be able to

    possess.

    Table 6. Coded Responses of the Respondents on the Qualities of Secretary for Student Council Position

    CODES/CATEGORIES TRANSCRIPTION

    Record Management The Secretary must be good in record management

    especially minutes of meetings

    Responsible for minutes of meetings He/She must be responsible for minutes of meetings

    Recording the minutes of meeting Must be good in recording the minutes of meeting

    Ability to record minutes of meeting The best quality should be related to his/her ability

    to record the minutes of meetings well

    Preparing minutes of meeting Be good in preparing minutes of meeting

    Present the minutes of meeting Present the minutes of meeting well

    Most of the coded responses of the respondents are

    aligned with the quality pertaining to record

    management, recording of the minutes of meetings,

    preparing, and presenting the minutes of meeting. All of

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    164 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    those responses are in consonance with the perceived

    most important quality which is to keep the record of

    the meetings of the Council.

    Chat and experience confirm that most often than

    not, the Secretary plays a vital role in the

    documentation of the minutes of the meeting as

    compared to other special roles given to him/her by the

    President or by the Council itself. The record of all the

    meetings of the Council is kept with the Secretary. The

    success of the Journal of Accomplishment published by

    the Student Council and the Office of Student Affairs

    every year depends on the quality of the Secretary to

    record the minutes of the meeting as accurately as

    possible. Some voters perceived that the Secretary

    whom they will vote is the one who can really conserve

    or keep the records of the meetings of the Council for

    they will be able to publicly the things being done by

    the Student Council during their meetings.

    Table 7. Description of Student Leaders Quality for Treasurer Position in SSC

    Descriptions Group A Group B Group C Combined

    The Treasurer must be ACR Final Rank ACR Rank ACR Rank ACR Rank

    a. be capable of handling figures and

    cash

    3.08 3 4.00 4 2.50 2 3.19 4

    b. have a methodological way

    of thinking

    3.35 4 2.00 2 3.75 4 3.03 3

    c. have experience in financial control and

    budgeting

    2.87 2 3.00 3 3.00 3 2.96 2

    d. be trustworthy and honest

    2.01 1 5.00 5 1.75 1 2.92 1

    e. be willing to explain figures if asked

    3.68 5 1.00 1 4.00 5 2.89 5

    Table 7 suggests that the most important quality for

    the position of Treasurer according to the respondents,

    is the quality of being trustworthy and honest. It is of

    this perception that a person of integrity with high

    moral values is considered as the best quality being

    perceived for this position.

    Competencies regarding numbers are only next

    qualities being considered by the respondents.

    Regardless of the course being taken up by the student,

    whether the course is related to numbers, (ie. BS

    Accountancy or BSE major in Math), what was

    perceived is the ability of the candidate/officer to

    become trustworthy and honest. Students are looking

    for someone whom they can entrust their money. For

    instance in the City College, the Student Fund collected

    from each student by the Student Council every

    semester amounting to P50.00 is entrusted to the

    Treasurer of the Council. With this, students perceived

    that regardless of the capability (but without necessarily

    disregarding it) of the Treasurer, what was the most

    important factor is that the Treasurer will become

    honest and trustworthy in the faithful disposition of the

    fund.

    This perception is supported by the coded responses

    of the respondents as shown by table 8.

    Table 8. Some of the Coded Responses of the Respondents on the Qualities of Treasurer for Student Council

    Position

    CODES/CATEGORIES TRANSCRIPTION

    Transparent in handling funds He/She must be transparent in handling the funds

    Honest in making financial statements The Treasurer must be honest in making financial statements

    Sense of honesty The position of Treasurer must be with sense of honesty

    Integrity and honesty The best quality has something to do with integrity and

    honesty

    Truthful in handling funds Be truthful in handling the funds

    Honest and truthful Must be honest and truthful

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    165 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    Table 8 shows the responses of some respondents

    pertaining to the qualities of the Treasurer position.

    They mentioned that for this position, the council

    officer must be transparent in handling funds, honest in

    making financial statements, with sense of honesty and

    integrity, and truthful. All of these points to the most

    important quality which is trustworthy and honest.

    Glaser and Bingham (2009) pointed out that one

    behaviour being valued by students that increased their

    sense of connectedness with one another is honesty. As

    Treasurer, he/she is a student-leader bound by moral

    obligations to faithfully perform his duty and

    responsibility in making sure that all his/her financial

    activities are deemed to be honest and trustworthy.

    Table 9. Description of Student Leaders Quality for Auditor Position in SSC

    Descriptions Group A Group B Group C Combined

    The Auditor must ACR Final Rank ACR Rank ACR Final Rank ACR Rank

    have a methodological

    way of thinking 3.40 5 3.00 3 4.25 5 3.55 4

    have experience in

    financial control and

    budgeting

    2.92 3 2.00 2 2.50 2 2.47 2

    have background in

    Accounting 3.02 4 5.00 5 3.00 3 3.67 5

    be able to identify and

    analyze financial risks 2.80 1 4.00 4 3.50 4 3.43 3

    be impartial in dealing

    with funds and with the

    Treasurer

    2.88 2 1.00 1 1.75 1 1.88 1

    * Average Composite Rank

    Table 9 shows that the most important quality for the position of Auditor based from the respondents is the

    quality of being impartial in dealing with funds and with the Treasurer. In an article written by Anderson (2012), he

    mentioned that being an Auditor is beyond learning the debits and credits. It also involves solid ethical foundation

    alongside with sound technical ability. An Auditor must be able to avoid any temptation to let errors or fraud things

    to pass.

    Being impartial with funds and with the Treasurer has something to do with how an Auditor must be able to

    give an honest auditing activity of the funds handled by the Treasurer. Errors, if committed by the Treasurer, must

    be revealed in order to make the financial statement more sound and transparent. This ability requires excellent

    interpersonal relationship with the Treasurer and other officers of the Council.

    Table 10. Coded Responses of the Respondents on the Qualities of Auditor for Student Council Position

    CODES/CATEGORIES TRANSCRIPTION

    Honest The Auditor must be honest just like the Treasurer.

    Impartial in dealing with Treasurer The Auditor must be impartial in dealing with the Treasurer

    Handle funds openly He/She should handle the funds openly and with

    transparency

    Openness and Transparency The Auditor must audit the funds with openness and

    transparency

    Free from internal influence Must be free from internal influence

    With sense of fairness Should be a good Auditor with sense of fairness

    Based from the coded responses, the Auditor must be honest, impartial in dealing with Treasurer, must handle

    funds openly, be free from internal influence, and with sense of fairness. All of these responses point to the quality

    of the Auditor to be impartial in dealing with funds and with the Treasurer.

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    166 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    Table 11. Description of Student Leaders Quality for PRO* Position in SSC

    Descriptions Group A Group B Group C Combined

    The PRO must be ACR Final Rank ACR Rank ACR Rank ACR Rank

    a. have good interpersonal

    relationship with

    others.

    2.37 1 2.00 1 2.25 1.5 2.21 1

    b. be hardworking 2.74 3 2.67 2.5 3.00 3 2.80 3 c. have good

    communication skills

    for information

    dissemination

    2.46 2 2.67 2.5 2.25 1.5 2.46 2

    d. possess pleasing personality

    3.57 4 3.00 4 3.25 4 3.27 4

    e. have experience in public speaking

    3.86 5 4.67 5 4.25 5 4.26 5

    * PRO- Public Relations Officer

    Table 11 revealed that the most important

    quality for the position of PRO based from the

    perceptions of respondents is good interpersonal

    relationship with others. The Student Manual (2006) of

    the college places the importance of PRO as the

    information disseminator of all the information

    pertaining to all the projects, programs, and activities of

    the Student Council. It is in this context that the PRO

    must be able to handle feelings and emotions properly

    in order to have meaningful relationship with their

    constituents. This is supported by the Exchange

    Theory which states that a long lasting relationship can

    be quite reciprocated by what we give and what we

    take. Based from the personal experience of the

    researcher, the inability of a PRO to have good

    interpersonal relationship with other students has a

    rippling effect to the entire Student Council for it failed

    to substantiate and properly inform its constituents

    about the current programs and activities of the group.

    The disconnection between the Student Council and the

    students become so glaring due to this failure.

    Table 12. Coded Responses of the Respondents on the Qualities of PRO for Student Council Position

    CODES/CATEGORIES TRANSCRIPTION

    Connect with his subordinates The PRO must be able to connect with his subordinates.

    Friendly The PRO should be friendly.

    Jolly and humorous to the students The PRO must possess the qualities of being jolly and

    humorous to the students.

    Share good relationships The PRO must be able to share good relationships with his

    members.

    Good relationship skills The PRO must possess good relationship skills.

    Respectful to his clients The PRO must be respectful to his clients.

    The coded responses indicate that the PRO must be

    able to connect with his subordinates, should be

    friendly, must possess the qualities of being jolly and

    humorous to the students, must be able to share good

    relationships with his members, and must be respectful

    to his clients. The mentioned responses support the

    quantitative findings that the most important quality for

    the position of PRO is that he/she must have good

    interpersonal relationship with others. Interviewed

    respondents mentioned that while experience in public

    speaking is also a quality that must be possessed by the

    PRO, it is a must that he/she must be able to connect

    with the students in such a way that he/she would use

    words and speeches that would not be alien or

    intimidating with the students. A good rapport with

    students is the most important quality that a PRO must

    possess.

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    167 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    Table 13. Differences of Perceptions Among the Respondents on the Different Qualities of Student-Leaders for the

    Different Positions of the Student Council*

    Critical Value F-ratio Decision Interpretation

    All positions for

    the Student

    Council

    3.89 1 Failed to Reject Not Significant

    *based from the actual summary of sources of variations between groups and within groups at P>0.05

    It can be seen from table 13 that there are no

    significant differences of perceptions among the

    respondents in terms of their assessment of qualities for

    all the positions of the Student Council.

    VI. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

    Choosing the qualities of student-leaders is of

    paramount importance in formulating policies for

    student affairs. The different positions of the Council

    starting from the President up to the PROs were

    subjected to respondents perceptions on the best qualities that they should possess. For the positions of

    President and Vice President, the most important

    quality is dedication and commitment. The Secretary,

    on the other hand, must be responsible in keeping the

    minutes of the meeting of the Student Council. The

    Treasurers most important quality is being trustworthy and honest. In the same vein, the Auditor of the Council

    must be impartial and dealing with the funds and with

    the Treasurer, and lastly, the PRO must able to have

    good interpersonal relationship with others.

    There were no significant differences of

    perceptions among the respondents based on statistical

    analysis. This means that the student-voters perceptions have no difference with the perceptions of

    the incumbent Student Council officers which are

    considered to be the results of the recently concluded

    Student Council election.

    From the mentioned qualities of student-

    leaders, the Office of Student Affairs should be able to

    come up with policies that would suit up to the resultant

    qualities. From the different theoretical perspectives,

    the administrators should be able to come up with a

    training program that would enhance and develop the

    different qualities of student-leaders. Regular meetings

    and exposures should be done to help the officers in

    reflecting their strengths and weaknesses for a better

    Student Council. Participation in different seminars and

    conferences shall be of great significance in enhancing

    the needs of the student-leaders for better student

    engagement and leadership.

    The administrators of the college should be able

    to support student developmental programs in order to

    attain its vision, mission, and goals of quality and

    holistic education for students.

    REFERENCES

    Academy for Educational Development (2011) written

    by Joselowsky, Francine and Elyshia Aseltine.

    Students as Co-Constructors of the Learning

    Environment: Building Systemic Approaches for

    Youth Engagement. retrieved from:

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED520110.pdf

    Allen, J. G., Wasicsko, M. M.; Chirichello, M. (2014).

    The Missing Link: Teaching the Dispositions to

    Lead. International Journal of Educational

    Leadership Preparation, 9(1). retrieved from:

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1024114.pdf .

    Anderson, Alan W. (2012). The Characteristics of

    Successful Auditor. Andersons Audit Express. Published by Society of CPAs & Educational

    Foundation. retrieved from:

    http://www.kscpa.org/writable/files/Self-

    Study/AAE/12._aae_self-study.pdf

    Christie, P., & Lingard, B. (2001). Capturing

    Complexity in Educational Leadership. Paper

    presented at the Annual Meeting of the American

    Educational Research Association. 27p. citing

    Fiedler, F. E. (1967). A Theory of Leadership

    Effectiveness. New York: McGraw-Hil. retrieved

    from: http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED461930.pdf

    Communication Foundation for Asia with Affiliated

    Network for Social Accountability. Survey on Youth

    Perceptions of Elections and Good Governance.

    Philippines.

    DIY Committee Guide. (by Volunteer Now) licensed

    under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-

    Commercial Share Alike 2.0. retrieved from:

    http://www.diycommitteeguide.org

    Emeagwali, N. Susan. (2011). Millennials: Leading the

    Charge for Change Techniques: Connecting

    Education and Careers (J1), 86(5), 22-26. retrieved

    from: http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ925286.pdf

    Germain, Marie-Line. (2008). Traits and Skills Theories

    as the Nexus between Leadership and Expertise:

    Reality or Fallacy? (Online Submission). Paper

  • Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research | Vol. 2, No. 4| August 2014 Capulong, N. M., Choosing the Qualities of Student Leaders: A Matching of Student Voting Preference

    168 P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com

    presented at the Academy of Human Resource

    Development International Research Conference in

    the Americas.

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED501636.pdf

    Glaser, Hollis F.; Bingham, Shereen. (2009). Students'

    Perceptions of Their Connectedness in the

    Community College Basic Public Speaking Course.

    Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and

    Learning, 9(2), 57-69.

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ854898.pdf

    Hyde, D. (2006; First published, 1956). Dedication and

    Leadership Techniques. University of Notre Dame

    Press in 1992. Published by Gary North. Retrieved

    from: http://www.garynorth.com/Hyde.pdf.

    Karns, M. & McGee, B. (2011). Everyday Heroes.

    Leadership, 40(3), 28-32. Retrieved from:

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ965901.pdf.

    Mullen, C. A. (2010). 21st-Century Priorities for

    Leadership Education and Prospective School

    Leaders. Scholar-Practitioner Quarterly. v4 n4: 331-

    333. Retrieved from:

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ942994.pdf.

    Pomerantz, N. K. (2006). Student Engagement: A New

    Paradigm for Student Affairs. College Student

    Affairs Journal., 25(2), 176-85 Spr.

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ902794.pdf

    Power, R. L. (2013). Leader-Member Exchange Theory

    in Higher and Distance Education. International

    Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,

    14(4) p277-284.

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1017531.pdf

    Student Manual. (2006). City College of Calamba. (as

    written by Madrigal, et al) Calamba City, Laguna.

    City Government of Calamba.

    Wetersten, J. A. (1994). Low Profile, High Impact: Four

    Case Studies of High School Department Chairs

    Whose Transactions "Transform" Teachers and

    Administrators. Paper presented at the Annual

    Meeting of the American Educational Research

    Association, 43p. citing Blau, P. (1964). Exchange

    and power in social life. New York:

    Wiley & Ritzer, G. (1988). Contemporary sociological

    theory. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

    http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED376604.pdf